STATE OF HAWAIIDEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES

Land DivisionHonolulu, Hawaii 96813

February 23, 2018

Board of Land and Natural Resources PSF No.: 17MD-148State of HawaiiHonolulu, Hawaii Maui

Set Aside to County of Maui for Public Park Purposes, Waiohuli — Keokea BeachHomesteads, Maui, Tax Map Keys: (2) 3-9-007:004 & Portion of 005.

APPLICANT:

County of Maui

LEGAL REFERENCE:

Section 171-11, Hawaii Revised Statutes (HRS), as amended

LOCATION:

Portion of Government lands of Waiohuli — Keokea Beach Homesteads, situatedat Waiohuli — Keokea Beach Homesteads, Maui, identified by Tax Map Keys: (2)3-9-007:004 & Portion of 005, as shown on the attached tax map labeled ExhibitA.

AREA:

0.628 acres, more or less: TMK (2) 3-9-007:0042.160 acres, more or less: TMK (2) 3-9-007:0052.788 acres total, more or less

ZONING:

State Land Use District: UrbanCounty of Maui CZO: Park

TRUST LAND STATUS:

Section 5(b) lands of the Hawaii Admission Act

DHHL 30% entitlement lands pursuant to the Hawaii State Constitution: NO

D-7

BLNR - Set Aside to County of Maui for Page 2 February 23, 2018Public Park Purposes

CURRENT USE STATUS:

(2) 3-9-007:004 — Unencumbered(2) 3-9-007:005 — 1.880 acres encumbered by EO 4342 for set-aside to County of Mauifor Veterans Center and Community Support activities.

PURPOSE:

Public park

CHAPTER 343 - ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT:

This action before the Board is merely a transfer of management jurisdiction and does notconstitute a use of State lands or funds, and therefore, this action is exempt from theprovisions of Chapter 343, HRS, relating to environmental impact statements. Inasmuchas the Chapter 343 environmental requirements apply to Applicant’s use of the lands, theApplicant shall be responsible for compliance with Chapter 343, HRS, as amended. SeeExhibit B.

APPLICANT REQUIREMENTS:

Applicant shall be required to:

1) Provide survey maps and descriptions according to State DAGS standards and atApplicant’s own cost

REMARKS:

TMK (2) 3-9-007:004 is a rectangular parcel on Uluniu Road nested within TMK (2) 3-9-007:005. TMK (2) 3-9-007:005 is irregularly shaped, and runs makai of Uluniu Roadadjacent to TMK (2) 3-9-00 1:001 which is owned by the County of Maui and used asWaipuilani Park.

The subject TMKs, (2) 3-9-007:004 and portion of :005, would be used as an extension ofWaipuilani Park, which is the existing County park. The subject TMKs are immediatelysouth of Waipuilani Park. All three parcels, the two subjects and the existing Countypark, have State zoning ‘Urban’ and County zoning ‘Park’, and are all in the SpecialManagement Area. See Exhibit C.

On October 25, 2017 the County of Maui Department of Parks and Recreation, Planningand Development, contacted the Maui District Land Office (MDLO) to inquire about

BLNR - Set Aside to County of Maui for Page 3 February 23, 2018Public Park Purposes

existing encroachments that include a portion of a comfort station and a parking lotlocated at the subject parcel’s northern end as shown on Exhibit D. Because the Countyof Maui already has jurisdiction of a portion of parcel 005 and TMK (2) 3-9-007:003under Executive Order 4342 for the Veterans of Foreign War (VFW) Hall and ownsTMK (2) 3-9-001:001 (Waipuilani Park) immediately north of State-owned TMK (2) 3-9-007:005, staff recommends that it is in the best interest of the State to transfer subjectTMKs to the County of Maui via Executive Order. The State has no plans for the subjectparcels, and public park uses are consistent with the overall character and use of the area.

On November 7, 2017 Maui County Parks and Recreation emailed the Maui DistrictLand Office (MDLO) a draft of a Request for State lands application requesting thetransfer of TMK (2) 3-9-007: Portion of 005 to the County of Maui. MDLO staff advisedthe County of Maui that the Disabled American Veterans (DAV) have contacted theGovernor’s liaison on Maui asking for the use of parcels 004 and portion of 005. Staffrecommends that pursuant to a transfer of land to the County of Maui via EO, that theDAV contact the County of Maui to request a lease with the County similar to the VFW.See Exhibit E for location of existing set-aside of portion of parcel 005 to County ofMaui.

On November 7, 2017 the County of Maui indicated that it has no objection to thetransfer of subject TMKs to the County of Maui (Exhibit F). The set-aside of theremaining portion of parcel 005 to the County of Maui will cure the encroachment of theexisting comfort station and parking lot. It will also allow the County of Maui tomaintain the vegetation on subject parcels as well as to move forward with plannedimprovements to the existing comfort station.

Photos of subject properties are attached as Exhibit G.

A draft of this submittal was disseminated to agencies listed below, with the resultsindicated:

Agency CommentDLNR — Historic Preservation No objections. See Exhibit H.DLNR — State Parks Received response with ‘no comments’DLNR — Conservation and Coastal Lands No response by suspense date.DLNR — Engineering, Maui District Received response with ‘no comments’County of Maui — Planning No response by suspense date.County of Maui — Parks & Rec No response by suspense date.County of Maui — Public Works Received response with ‘no comments’Office of Hawaiian Affairs No response by suspense date.

BLNR - Set Aside to County of Maui forPublic Park Purposes

Page 4 February 23, 2018

47

RECOMMENDATION:

That the Board, subject to Applicant fulfilling the Applicant Requirements above:

Declare that, after considering the potential effects of the proposed disposition asprovided by Chapter 343, HRS, and Chapter 11-200, HAR, this project will probablyhave minimal or no significant effect on the environment and is therefore exempt fromthe preparation of an environmental assessment.

2. Approve of and recommend to the Governor the issuance of an executive order settingaside the subject lands to County of Maui under the terms and conditions cited above,which are by this reference incorporated herein and subject further to the following:

A. The standard terms and conditions of the most current executive order form, asmay be amended from time to time;

B. Disapproval by the Legislature by two-thirds vote of either the House ofRepresentatives or the Senate or by a majority vote by both in any regular orspecial session next following the date of the setting aside;

C. Review and approval by the Department of the Attorney General; and

D. Such other terms and conditions as may be prescribed by the Chairperson to bestserve the interests of the State.

APPROVED FOR SUBMITTAL:

Suzan I. Case, Chairperson

Respectfully Submitted,

Land Agent

24

—‘~

ROAD

.040#0 ~‘Ga

I.

III AG.

Fb~

40

3 9 07

S..

00462$020? a .os AG

~ .oi AG

L ~ ~•~_ ~ .i.AXA1 ION MAPS WRE

TCH~0TOP~ OF HAWAII

t X L4APS~CO*0O DIVISION

~ PLA

FI~~Ia—

SU8JECT 70 CHANGE ~ CONTAINING PARCEl.SCALE I IN.4 SO PT.

— lb

@~

.40.

y$440,.Ak....404— .oO g..~ ,~.o4 -)/‘~

(AIf,’.d

A’_•1~

‘004G4 AC.

22

.., 1~3.ini, I .~W4U oh~sia... a 4.~o4. JGM’4 .4,. ‘4~4 ~4J.. C. 4 .4 .a..M. CI’lIk ½...~ 4oF(3~l..$4’1 J~ .4,... 7 A’ . *..w —~.-‘* ~-

,qOO 7.’

— —‘-3-

-, ~ ‘4

140001 ,Sb5.0J

• .S~3-00 404 faha C.D

#0.0004_,__ a_Is5 ~,, Q ,0.GO70~

v__i 0~a0..0,0 4 (~)

~—‘ ~WW?’0 © ~~ ~- ‘~L’ ,0,*.4,o .4. \ ç_0Ib~~

7~__Th.F~k A. ‘~

SI

j.r~ .~4

- a_Is-½

?215 AGO.

/ , ~ ‘7 1

23

37

CA...4...

‘A ‘001

I,

~ ~

~ 4. ,.a,..AIs.. ~•. 4 W..tC..,tfl WalC~Lfl.-~-~ .~_i

1407S7 1440,7 fl~S0l

.4* 4* 2.’A~.,..lia ‘41. OWA.ø.5

S

,a.407

*.‘~ .4?...’. ~‘..qP GA.. C’O

.*0._... O40..’4. r.4 .LWha ~‘‘0 S

-u

4*a...’, a •,.?....*.—S .41 ~ 5

4* *400’ I~4 0

0~~ ~

S.0. A’I~.

o 00.10.. I... £....‘~. A.~~0.’.’~ 4’

‘II ~16S001 ~000”~ ~

(n.n4~

~~4

c.i~— a As

,0.0001

(00)

‘Ii

zi

ULUNIU

‘4040 —.

,A000J ~~a~=’4’, (.....41~I

~6O — 59

~ o~,a_ EWA

®

.1

0• V

94.4144‘4

0

.q.*.,tfl. flak..?. 1,%t 5.44._i AWO

#00,77

SOar.IS 045500

0~— #004.9

‘444.2

~00O91

44.,. y....o...#.Y~-.l4 5

~

0’ ~‘7~

a 400.40-

,a.—.f4’,f0000

PLACE ago AG

6 ‘I.~ • 0~

a

11,0404’ 134...44404. 4

c-jo. AG

6~iqA.sa lb00#. 4._a

cha6bik K. j~_~F. ,cXario-~Lao 1~ -Tm

7

2 —

~.~ €

osa AG.

2.

)4.d714’ ~ ‘.060 .40

0

‘I

w

,_•_#. 4.•0__.. V

lb

S—40—$ —. I.

A’0I~

‘47,3,#47,47

~

P4h.%IQI.4LJL..I ~~ lfM.0TD.0.~ Ma

•1001’

DAVID Y. IGEGOVERNOR OF HAWAII

STATE OF HAWAIIDEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES

LAND DIVISION

54 High Street, Room 101Wailuku, Hawaii 96793

PHONE: (808) 984-8103FAX: (808) 984-8111

SUZANNE 0. CASECHAIRPERSON

BOARD OF IAND AND NATURAl. RESOURCESCOMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENr

EXEMP I I N OTIFICATIONregarding the preparation of an environmental assessment pursuant to Chapter 343, HRS andChapter 11-200, FIAR.

Project Title:

Project / Reference o.:

Project Location:

Project Descrip on:

Chap. 343 Trigger(s):

Exemption Class No.and Description:

Set-Aside to County of Maui for Public Park Purposes

PSF No.: 17MD-148

Waiohuli—Keokea Beach Homesteads, Maui, Tax Map Keys: (2)3-9-007:004 & Portion of :005

Set-aside to County of Maui of coastal land adjacent to existingCounty beach park for public park purposes.

Use of State Land

This action before the Board is merely a transfer of managementjurisdiction and does not constitute a use of State lands or funds,and therefore, this action is exempt from the provisions of Chapter343, HRS, relating to environmental impact statements. Inasmuchas the Chapter 343 environmental requirements apply to Applicant’suse of the lands, the Applicant shall be responsible for compliancewith Chapter 343, HRS, as amended.

In accordance with Hawaii Administrative Rule Section 11-200-8and the Exemption List for the Department of Land and NaturalResources approved by the Environmental Council and dated June5, 2015, the subject request is exempt from the preparation of anenvironmental assessment pursuant to Exemption Class No. 1, thatstates “Operations, repairs or maintenance of existing structures,facilities, equipment, or topographical features, involving negligibleor no expansion or change of use beyond that previously existing”and Item No. 43, that states “Transfer of management authorityover state-owned land, such as setting aside of state lands to or fromother government agencies through a Governor’s executive order.”

HIB TB

PSF 17MD-148

Consulted Parties: The DLNR Historic Preservation, State Parks, Conservation andCoastal Lands, Engineering, Maui District; Office of HawaiianAffairs; and County of Maui Planning, Parks and Recreation, andPublic Works Departments were consulted as source authoritieshaving jurisdiction or expertise in this matter, and they concur thatthe exemption identified above is applicable to and appropriate forthe proposed project.

Recommendation: That the Board find this project to have minimal or no significanteffect on the environment and is presumed to be exempt from thepreparation of an environmental assessment.

XIB B

Maui County Parcel Maps Page 1 of 1

Zoom ‘j’Zoom 1’ Zoom ~m~Panby‘-4 i~ “4 Out \JHand

Get room To Center On ~ ~ Area ~ çtfat ~i~1cjParcel Parcel Meas*~e U Tool age SaI~ Adi

http://cijublic9.qpublic.netlqpmap4/map.php?county=himaui&parcel=390070050000&ex... 1/26/2018

Waipul anGulch

Ko rt

Co

Luana ai

Wai uilaniP rk

Maui unset@

cq~oh~’o tOPti net

~ ~

cit, 1c~ ‘~. ~

H

C ~

(~4 A’-o07Dc~r~ ~

— —

- I\ ~ ‘ayas aul®~ :. -

- \~..ocon -a -ft

— unty makes every effort to produce the most ~accurate information possible No warrnties~expres~ed oriicipii~i are pro*before the next certilied taxroll ~. ~ , -

~ ~•.

,o~ $1’~

~ ~-9 ~ --

‘- —s- ~ Th—

— tL -~

qPublic I Pictometry

~t,I

• -- ~

• fl.

••••.~

I •

• • S -

.5-.

I i ~ :~

~I-I,,I

‘~I

?orkrov~ ~E ~o~ ~Ez~-~i~o r’ cw~ ~otOv\ 3~,ven~~ei’~k l~ a.~4

EXHIBIT “.12”

I 12/09/2014 1 of 19~ Select Date fl ~

1,~ ~ / ~ • S •

~:~

Maui County Parcel Maps Page 1 of 1

.. -.4. . ~ . - .

~~oom +~oom’..-. + Zoam~ — Zoam--~(fl~anby Get Zoom~o CenterOn .~‘—— ..‘;~ •Area.--~= PiInt~’5~ In - out ~\JH~J ~0 Parcel Parcel easwe bol Page

- .-.- - .~ ~‘-r

4, ._.ckh.— I~..4”, ., ‘‘4 ~—.

~ .—~‘. •_4_•1.__ .•~“ . -

.4 .

aui GJitar &~ kulel —4 i..- - _4~.:-.4• - — .-

- ~ - - - ai er -

a —“ 4, .44’

)7 q-oo7 ‘~

rvr c4. I .,~ ~ ;lj

4’ - ~ £

C - -~ • Th~ 1~ ‘~, ... ‘1’ .,.

4 ca..- ~ ~‘ ‘ 4 ~

C213 OS~c~~

1’ - , )AC ‘

~ (~o ) Ic — —‘ — — 4’ — —

5 L~4:oo~:ck~- - - . - . . — ~j_ L*~ ~

— — ~ ?.aL~’~ I

‘C’: -u—-i. .... . ..., . •

Veterans€?F-ireit~-i Wars— i,, ~ 4 .4- -4

-~ .~ . . 4 ~_- ~ .: . . . - - -

4__ 4.

-c,- ‘•-. ~ I

-S.-., ~ - -Om ‘~

~ -. ‘- —- -— No- . 54’ -4. ‘ ~.‘ .‘ - .

~MauI €ounty~makes evéi:yeffort to p - frjl.ëhange l~’eforeCthe,next certified taxr

-~-..-- -. .

I’S.-.-- -

1~ ~‘ 4- .~ 4. 444’4~4.S’ ,.4 -, . - ._ ‘-4 -

~~,5~ — C .__, C

i-.. — r 4 4. 4’ 454

— I-‘

ó~HiBIt “E”

KA~ALA BUENCONSEJODirector

ALAN M. ARAKAWAMayor BRIANNE L. SAVAGE

Deputy Director

(808) 270-7230DEPARTMENT OF PARKS & RECREATION FAX (808) 270-7934

700 HaIi~aNakoa Street, Unit 2, Wailuku, Hawaii 96793

November 7, 2017

Suzanne Case, ChairpersonState of HawaiiBoard of Land and Natural Resources1151 Punchbowl Street, Room 130Honolulu, HI 96813

Dear Ms. Case:

SUBJECT: REQUEST FOR STATE LANDS, LOCATED AT TMK: (2) 3-9-007:005,WAIPUILANI, KIHEI, MAUI, HAWAII

The Department of Parks & Recreation (DPR) is requesting a set aside of the subject parcel bythe State Board of Land and Natural Resources to the County of Maui. The purpose and intentof the set aside is for park purposes and related ancillary purposes.

The DPR currently owns (via State of Hawaii Land Patent No. S-15,787) and maintainsadjacent parcel TMK: (2) 3-9-001:001 as Waipuilani Park. The set aside of parcel 005 willallow expansion of the park, and correct the jurisdiction of the existing comfort station andparking lot to the County of Maui.

We appreciate your assistance with this matter. Should you have any questions, please callme or Robert Halvorson, Chief of Planning & Development, at (808) 270-7931.

Sincerely,

KA’ALA BUENCONSEJODirector of Parks & Recreation

Robert Halvorson, Chief of Planning and Development

KB:RH:csa I

170 t1 ~‘id L~ 1J~ L~

EXHIBIT “F”

Exhibit E

- ~— -‘~~- - -

~ ;~—‘-‘fl, ~ .

~-~--~

~- ,,— -

~ -_~-~ ~ -— —~ —,. ~4._’ ~ ~ ~ —

-. ~ .--~ S.

~ II

~-.— ~— — •a~; •~•_~- ~

A

~ ,•-t•’~~~_•,

~~

4 . .~ ~—‘—-—~.‘.

I

~_Ic sI.

I —

~

U ~. - - ~111 —t~.• ~- ~

.- ..-~

~ ~

Z; ~~;

~—r-~ ~~ 9 .!

County comfort station and parking lot encroaching on TMK 3-9-007:005

EXHIBIT “~“

Ia~E2~

1S~Y, ‘P ‘‘&

— J’,. ~ )

F -:~

- --~~j;~. -.r

-- ~ ~~ ~E~~.-?%: -.

S - - Ac --~ — .~ ~ ,40 ~ ~- - - -

3 zis’ ~ -, •~‘: — ~‘~‘ — it.p.9’. - :‘- -•‘ •-~. -• . ‘

-: ~.:c - . -~ ~ r..n~tI•r~ ‘~‘-~.-— — — 3— ‘ -p. p.

i---, -X_, ~

- ‘ -S,: .

Portion of TMK 3-9-007:005

• ‘

c - -

,-_ ‘_•‘__‘_•.,• •1 -

-~, - :~“~ - -

- ~-:“ -- • - ~‘~‘ : -. -

~,_~‘ti~~4t - ,.,~r - -‘ .3— r t’u’ -. -— —

~_ ‘~ __,‘*‘ — — —:— L. -‘

1~~~ -.

- ,~ S. -— — -‘.3- ——

-S - -~

.3 - ~‘~7 -‘ -‘ “ ~— -

— 1, ~ — — .3t3.p.’~’? — &_~a.. —z” —- —~ ~.

43 - ~- —~-,~fr-~ - ‘t~1~• ~ .3, —.3 ‘— ___

-c--~’.~-k’-:~ ~ . ~~

Trees near roadway on TMKs 3-9-007:004 and 005

EXHIBIT ~a’rst je€2.

DAVID V. IGEGOVERNOR OF HAWAB

I’STATE OF HAWAII

DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES

STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION DIVISIONKAKUHIHEWA BUILDING

601 KAMOKILA BLVD, STE 555KAPOLEI HAWAII 96707

SUZANNE V. CASECHAIRPERSON

BOARD OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCESCOMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

ROBERT K. MASUDAFIRST DEPuTY

JEFFREY T. PEARSON. P.E.DEPUTY DIRECTOR. WATER

AQUATIC RESOURCESBOATING ANT) OCEAN RECREATION

BUREAU OF CONVEYANCESCOMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

CONSERVATION AND COASTAL LANDSCONSERVATION AND RESOURCES ENFORCEMENT

ENGINEERINGFORESTRY AND WILDLIFEHISTORIC PRESERVATION

KA}E)OLAWE ISLAND RESERVE COMMISSION

STATE PARKS

February 1,2018

Russell Y. Tsuji, AdministratorLand Division, Department of Land and Natural ResourcesP.O. Box 621Honolulu, HI 96809

Dear Mr. Tsuji:

SUBJECT: Chapter 6E-8 Historic Preservation Review —

Request for Set Aside to County of Maui for Public Park PurposesWaiohuli — Keokea Beach Homesteads — Ref No. I7MD-148Waiohuli Ahupua’a, Kula District, Island of MauiTMK: (2) 3-9-007-004 and 005

IN REPLY REFER TO:Log No. 2017.00008DocNo. 1802GC01Archaeology

This letter provides the State Historic Preservation Division’s (SHPD’s) review comments regarding the subjectsubmitted, Request to Set Aside to County of Maui for Public Park Purposes, TMK: (2) 3-9-00 7:004 & 005. SHPDreceived this submittal on January 8, 2018.

The submittal indicates that the Department of Land and Natural Resources Land Division recommends that theGovernor issue an Executive Order setting aside to the County of Maui for public park purposes a 0.628-acre parcelidentified as TMK: (2) 3-9-007:004 and a 4.04-acre parcel identified as TMK: (2) 3-9-007:005. The subject parcelswould be used as an extension of the existing County park.

A review of SHPD records indicates no archaeological inventory survey has been conducted for the subject parcelswhich are proximate to an ancient Hawaiian fishpond (Site 50-50-09-1738) and previously documented subsurfacecultural deposits (Sites 50-50-09-5300 and 50-50-09-5060) which include displaced and in situ human burials Thesubject parcels are located in dune land and sand deposits, which are known to contain human burial features.

Based on the available information, SHPD has no objections to the Set Aside of State Lands to the County of Mauifor public park purposes. SHPD requests the opportunity to review and comment on any future permit applicationsinvolving ground disturbing activities. The permit process may continue.

Please contact me at Susan.A.Lebo~hawaii.gov or at (808) 692-8019 for any questions regarding this letter.

Aloha,

tJJ~-oSusan A. Lebo, PhDArchaeology Branch Chief

cc: Seiko Machida, DLNR Land Division (Seiko.J.Machida hawaii.gov)

EXHIBIT H