strategic growth through high value small business targeting
TRANSCRIPT
Strategic Growth
Through High Value
Small Business
Targeting
1
Simon Powley SVP, Strategic Account Relationship Executive
Vantiv
Ben Hoffman Partner
Oliver Wyman
Today’s Speakers
2
Our agenda for today’s webinar
3
• Introduce our partners at Oliver Wyman
• Share some of our recent joint thinking on:
› The importance of Small Businesses
› How financial institutions can grow their Small Business banking
franchises
• Discuss briefly how Vantiv can help
• Take your questions
4 4
Brand strategy
and design
Economic advice
on competition,
regulation, litigation
Risk and insurance
services and solutions
Risk and reinsurance
intermediary services
Human resource consulting
and related services
+ Sister firms
• $1.7 BN in revenue
• 3,500 staff in 50+ offices globally
– Including Stockholm
• Ranked #1 in quality/consistency by
our clients1
• Growing faster than any other top 10
consulting firm
• Part of MMC, a $12 BN leader in
consulting, risk management and
insurance brokerage
1. Corporate Executive Board Survey
Oliver Wyman is the strategy and operations consulting arm of Marsh & McLennan Companies, a global professional services firm
5 5
Oliver Wyman’s Financial Services practice group is organized into nine practice areas to best address our clients’ businesses and strategic priorities
• Banking, capital markets
and transaction services
• Market infrastructure
• Sales coverage
• Business strategy
and organization
• Treasury strategy
and applied risk
• Pre- and
post-trade strategy
• Credit portfolio
management and credit
process analysis
• Performance
measurement
and compensation
• Consumer and SME
banking strategy
• Credit and deposits –
strategic pricing, product
management
and innovation
• Information-based
decision analytics
• Sales performance and
channel management
• Credit process,
collections and
loss management
• Life, P&C,
Re-Insurance, Pensions
• Strategy, growth
and organization
• Financial, risk and
capital management
• Variable annuity strategy
and risk management
• Distribution and
marketing
• Product development
and management
• Underwriting, pricing and
claims management
• Cost and operations
• Business growth strategy
• Investment process
review and redesign
• Product and
solutions innovation
• Distribution strategy
• Customer retention
and wholesaling
• Risk management
• Operating structure
• Cost efficiency and
vendor sourcing
• Regulatory response
• Regulatory reforms
and oversight
• Financial crisis management
• Evolution of market infrastructure
• Investor and consumer protection
• Systemic risk policy
and management
• Risk quantification,
policies and processes
• Capital, funding and balance
sheet strategy
• Accounting analytics, policy
and implementation
• Regulatory compliance
• Organization design
and governance
• Operational transformation
• IT value economics/
portfolio optimization
• Information management/
data quality
• Risk technology
• Business process and
IT outsourcing
• Cost management
• Target/opportunity
identification and investment
thesis development
• Strategic and commercial due
diligence (acquirer and vendor)
• Post-transaction and portfolio
company optimization strategies
• Fund management, process
and organization design
• Valuation advice
Public Policy Finance and Risk Strategic IT and
Operations
Corporate Finance
and Advisory
Corporate and
Institutional Banking
Retail and
Business Banking
Insurance
Wealth and Asset
Management
• Retail payments strategy
(credit, debit, prepaid,
mobile and
enterprise payments)
• Corporate payments
strategy and
benchmarking
• Growth and market entry
for issuers, networks
and acquirers
• Rewards program design,
optimization and
liability management
• Cost and
efficiency improvement
• Risk assessments
Payments
Strategic Growth Through High
Value Small Business Targeting
6
What do Small Businesses in the US
look like?
Source: US Census Bureau 2011 Statistical Annual
Pe
rce
nt
of
tota
l s
ma
ll b
usin
es
se
s
28MM+ Small Businesses 5MM+ Employer SBs
7
Why focus on Small Businesses? Role in the economy
99.7% 64% 49% 43%
of US
employer firms
of net new
private-sector
jobs (2002–2010)
of private-sector
employment
of private-sector payroll
46% 43% 98% 33%
of private-sector output
of high-tech
employment
of firms
exporting goods
of total
exporting value
Source: SBA (http://www.sba.gov/sites/default/files/FAQ_Sept_2012.pdf)
8
Why focus on Small Businesses? Profit potential for banks
• ~18% of total available
“retail” profit
• Greater average profit than
consumer
• Not as highly competed?
• Opportunity for differentiation?
Annual post-tax retail banking economic profit pools
$ BN
Note: Profits calculated with Oliver Wyman assumptions for Small Businesses with <250 employees
Source: Oliver Wyman Survey of Small Business Owners (Q2 2014), Oliver Wyman Consumer Profit Pools
9
Where do banks generate profits from
Small Businesses?
Deposits Cards Loans Merchant
~50% of total SB banking profit is in Card and Merchant Services
Source: Oliver Wyman 2011 Survey of Small Business Finances
10
Card and Merchant Services customers are
typically far more valuable for the bank overall
Relative value of SB by card user status Relative value of SB by merchant services
user status
Card user status Merchant services user status
Card users
generate on
average seven
times the profit
for banks as non
card users
Merchant services
users generate on
average four
times the profit
for banks as
non card
users
Source: Oliver Wyman 2011 Survey of Small Business Finances
11
Drivers of need and value for small
business products
Drivers of
product need
Drivers of
product value
• Any business • Retailers
• High volume/large ticket
• Remote payment
acceptance
• Retail supply chain
• Employee purchasing
• Short-term liquidity
challenges
• Lumpy cash flows high
balances / spread income
• High transaction volume
high item fees
• High transaction volume
• Multi-channel/e-commerce
• High transaction volume
• Revolved balances
Checking account Merchant services Credit card
12
Three primary small business types
Micro
Business-to-consumer
Business-to-business
• Actively managing cash
flows
• Operating capital
• Payments acceptance and
remittance
• Non-analyzed checking
account (and basic treasury
services)
• Merchant (including value
added services)
• Line of credit
• Owner operator/employer
• Primary contributor to
household income
• Retailer or service
professional (e.g.
doctor/lawyer)
• Safe store of money
• e-commerce capabilities
• Startup and tax advice
• Checking account
• Merchant services (POS
and online) & card
• Sole proprietor/non-
employer
• Non-primary contributor to
household income/hobby
vs. vocation
• Typically online retailing or
remote service provision
• Working capital
management
• Operating & investment
capital
• Large dollar electronic
payments capabilities
• Account under analysis
• Term loan and line of credit
• Treasury services (incl.
merchant, payroll, wire/ach,
multi-currency)
• Professional/dedicated
management
• Lumpy/seasonal cash flows
• Capital intensive
~50%
~25%
~25%
13
Defining characteristics Common needs Bank solutions
Sample tactical approach
1 Centralized list
development
• Identify existing customers with “off-us” Credit Card and/or
Merchant Services
• Focus service efforts on these customers
2 Centrally
coordinated
outreach
• Align customer value with offer and outreach channel –
convert the sale
• Test-and-learn approach
3 Seller
refocusing
• Redirect efforts of the salesforce towards the greatest sources
of value – deposits and payments
• Change the culture – incentive compensation, performance
management, career development
4 Seller
empowerment
• Train the sales force to have the right conversations – work
with your partners
• Equip sellers with the right tools – marketing collateral,
sales guides
14
Shifting customer mix alone can double the profit
of your Small Business banking operations
Profit lift NA ~2x Source: Oliver Wyman 2011 Survey of Small Business Finances
15
How Vantiv can help
16
Our goal in partnering with you is to help you
address your growth priorities
17
Better meet your clients’ needs
Vantiv assets, capabilities and scale
Grow
customer base
Retain and deepen
existing
relationships
Improve
product
economics
Vantiv is built to make you successful
18
We are new
We are different
We are hungry
• We don’t have baggage
• We are built to purpose
• We think like you
• Our focus is on you
• We are future-focused
• We strive to push the
envelope
This webinar is one of a series that we host to
share our thinking on the most important issues
in banking and payments
19
Helping small businesses manage cash flow and
receivables
Coming Soon
The payments industry is rapidly changing…
Mobile
Online
Social
Multi-channel commerce
Big data
Loyalty and advertising
Chip
Next gen POS
Cloud
20
…and we have leading solutions for today’s and
tomorrow’s requirements
Mobile acceptance Mobile payments Targeted offers
EMV Gift cards Analytics
Example: Attrition Alerts
21
Q&A For more Vantiv Insights, visit Vantiv.com/Research
Vantiv.com/fimerchantservices
Simon Powley
513.900.3714
Strategic Growth Through High
Value Small Business Targeting
22