strategy & risk management -role of ia - iaaia hock kee (cg board... · turning lack swans into...
TRANSCRIPT
Turning Black Swans Into Opportunities… Strategy & Risk Management
-Role of IA
By
Wee Hock Kee
Managing Partner, CG Board Asia Pacific, Malaysia
2
Reality
Are your existing GRC frameworks helping business/operations staff advance the dialogue?
The time may come when the fundamentals of your business are about to change
It is not what you know that matters; it is what you don’t know that
makes the difference between winning and losing
Your business is boundaryless and is not an island in and of itself
Sooner or later, there will be a crisis that will test your company
Management and directors are struggling with delineating between risk
management and risk oversight
Five Realities for Every CEO and Board
3
VISION, LEADERSHIP AND RISK AND GOVERNANCE
90:1090:10-- Neil Armstrong First man in the moon Neil Armstrong First man in the moon 30:30:30:10 Jeff 30:30:30:10 Jeff ImmeltImmelt GE CEO Discipline GE CEO Discipline John Collins Good to Great John Collins Good to Great –– humility & humility & discipline discipline 40:60 Dato’ Sri 40:60 Dato’ Sri IdrisIdris JalaJala Minister in PM’s Minister in PM’s department control and divine intervention department control and divine intervention
4 CG BOARD ASIA PACIFIC
Space risk management and space governance “Governments must take the lead in reviewing how risk assessment for flying over conflict zones are made” – Tony Tyler Head IATA
5
Rest Assured: What Keeps AC Up At Night?
• IT Risk and Emerging Technologies
• Risk Management
• Legal/Regulatory Compliance
• Growth, Strategy and Innovation Risk
• Audit Committee Effectiveness
Source: Tone at the top KPMG Audit Committee Institute Survey on AC Members
6
BOD- Reviewing and Adopting a strategic plan for the company
“The role of the board is to review, challenge and approve management’s proposal on a strategic plan for the company. The board brings objectivity and breadth of judgment to the strategic planning process as they are not involved in day-to-day management of the business. The board should satisfy itself that management has taken into account all appropriate considerations in establishing the strategic plan for the company. The board is also responsible for monitoring the implementation of the strategic plan by management. “
7
BOARD- Recognize and Manage Risks
The board should determine the company’s level of The board should determine the company’s level of risk risk tolerance tolerance and actively and actively identify,identify, assessassess and and monitor monitor key key business risks to safeguard shareholders’ investments and business risks to safeguard shareholders’ investments and the company’s assets;the company’s assets; Case studies :Case studies : GSK scandal in China GSK scandal in China –– was the board aware of the illegal was the board aware of the illegal payments to doctors? payments to doctors?
8
9
Black Swan
“The black swan theory or
theory of black swan
events is a metaphor that
describes an event that is a
surprise [to the observer],
has a major effect, and
after the fact is often
inappropriately rationalized
with the benefit of
hindsight”
10 10
11
12
13
Executive Perspectives on Key Global Risks in 2014:
14
IMF SEES LOWER GLOBAL GROWTH, EUROZONE STAGNATION RISK , WORLD FACES RISKS FROM RUSSIA-UKRAINE, MIDDLE EAST CRISIS AND EBOLA OUTBREAK SOURCE: EDGE FD RISK EXPOSURE TO AILRINE?
AIRLINE CORE RISKS
1. Strategic risk 2 financial risk 3 operational risk 4 hazard risk
1
2
4
3
16
HOW FAST YOU COULD RECOVER FROM A DISASTER?
It is the damage that puts you behind your competitors
17
CRUCIAL TO IMPROVE PRODUCTIVITY AS CAPITAL AND RESOURCES ARE NOT FREELY AVAILABLE AS IN THE PAST WITH . THE MOST IMPORTANT DELTA FOR GROWTH WILL BE AN IMPROVEMENT IN PRODUCTIVITY SOURCE:EDGE FD
18
BUSINESS CHANGES AND IMPACT ON CONTROL
PwC Global CEO Survey
Do you anticipate a major change at your company in the following areas next 12 months?
1. Customer strategies – 31%
2. Managing talent – 23%
3. Organizational structure- 22%
4. M&A, JV or strategic alliance- 22%
5. Technology investment – 21%
19
ERM Maturity Level
+ Adapted from the Capability Maturity Model framework developed by Carnegie Mellon University, 1993.
Ad-hoc Fragmented Comprehensiv
e Integrated Strategic
Overarching risk
management philosophy or
objectives are not defined
Risk management
functions independently
within business units
Risk management is enterprise-
wide and encompasses all risk types
Risks are treated as a portfolio at
the enterprise level and are
correlated and aggregated across risk types and
business units
Risk management is
built into decision
making. The organisation selectively
seizes opportunity
because of its special ability to exploit risks
Risk Management: Capability Maturity Model +
20
21 CG BOARD ASIA PACIFIC
Decline in core products demand
Poor acquisition merger
integration
Competitor infringement on
core product
Failure to identify asset price bubble
Destruction price war
NON TRADITIONAL ASSURANCE
STRATEGIC RISKS- 68% STRATEGIC RISKS- 68%
22 CG BOARD ASIA PACIFIC
Undiversified partnership risk
Margin pressure Investor loss of confidence
Senior management
team turnover
Failure to extend alternative revenue sources
NON TRADITINAL ASSURANCE
STRATEGIC RISKS- 68% STRATEGIC RISKS- 68%
23
DIGITILISATION -DECLINE IN CORE PRODUCT “After Kodak’s founder Eastman Kodak first started using
his patented emulsion coating machine in 1880 to mass produce dry plates for photography, Kodak dominated the world of film and photography with sales surpassing US10b in 1981. Then upon taking over as Kodak’s CEO George Fisher declared: when I arrived in late 1993, we were over committed and over extended. We were not only in the imaging business, we were also selling aspirin, paint thinner, air freshener, and a host of other things far removed from the company’s core. Our debt was astronomical by both historical and industry standards” VERTICAL GROWTH M & A RISK
M&A FRAUD –USD 1.5 b VERTICAL GROWTH
Stonewalled :Ex CEO Olympus Michael Woodford Acquisitions: Altis- disposal of industrial waste from hospitals News Chef- develops and markets microwavable dishes Humalabo- sells mail order cosmetics and health foods
CORE BUSINESS :70% WORLD ‘S MEDICAL ENDOSCOPE WITH ANNUAL SALES OF USD4B.
25
Source: YahooFinance
26
Reinventing Nokia -Unveils first tablet as part of Microsoft's consumer device push
27
WHILE TRAFFIC IN THE OVERALL MALAYSIAN MARKET HAS BEEN UP SIGNIFICANTLY BY 20% IN 2013 AND 12% IN H1 2104, THE GAINS CAME AT THE EXPENSE OF YIELDS EBIT MARGIN DOWN 4 PPTS Q2 YTY AT 13% OPPOSED TO THE NORMAL EBIT MARGIN OF ABOVE 20%.
COMPETITION FROM MALINDO WITH STRONG BACKING FROM LION AIR AND LEVERAGING ON LION AIR HUGE ORDER BOOK WHERE THERE IS FLEXIBILITY TO CHANGE ALLOCATIONS DEPENDING ON MARKET AA WAS TO HAVE SOLD 12 OF ITS OLDEST PLANES THIS YEAR, 6 BY Q2 BUT IT DID NOT SELL ANY. ALSO IN TALKS WITH AIRBUS TO SELL 4 OF ITS NEW A320. IN SECOND HALF 2014 BUT MAY CHANGE OF HEART FOLLOWING MAS RATIONALIZATION
10 more low cost carriers entering market this year
Source: Focus Malaysia
28
“MODIFIED ITS MID RANGE BUSINESS PLAN TO ADDRESS THE SIGNIFICANT CHANGE IN THE MARKET AND COMPETITIVE ENVIRONMENT OF THE MOBILE BUSINESS. THIS REVISION INCLUDES CHANGING THE STRATEGY OF THE MOBILE SEGMENT IN CERTAIN GEOGRAPHICAL AREAS, CONCENTRATING ON ITS PREMIUM LINE-UP AND REDUCING THE NUMBER OF MODELS IN ITS MID RANGE LINE-UP”
Source: The Edge Financial Daily
29
ACTIVE VOLUME PASSIVE YIELD “The price war is
ending not only in Malaysia but across the region as industry players are tired of losing money. Our strategy is to keep prices low but not to sink below cost” – Tan Sri Tony Fernandes
Source: The Edge Financial Daily
30
COMPETITION –PHILIP MORRIS DID NOT INCREASE THEIR PRICE YET “HOWEVER TO REMAIN COMPETITIVE, WE HAVE DECIDED TO REVERT TO OUR OLD PRICES”- BAT
Source: The Edge Financial Daily
31
ANCILLARY REVENUE Extension of alternative revenue sources-courier service 50% cheaper than market. JV with R Box Asia Pte Ltd, utilizing its existing fleets (available belly space) as opposed to cargo with limited flight frequencies, their value proposition
Source: The Edge Financial Daily
32
Single base customer risk Source: The Edge Financial Daily
33
KEEP YOUR EYE ON THE TALENT QUESTIONS CAES SHOULD ASK
• What value does the organization place on human capital?
• Does the organization have an integrated approach to talent
management?
• Do company leaders play a meaningful role in the organization’s
talent management efforts?
• Do company risk assessment models consider talent
management?
• Does internal audit include talent management in its plan?
Source: Tone at the TOP IIA Global June 2013
34
TO HEDGE OR NOT TO HEDGE
•”Firm believers in Modigliani and Miller’s theories would argue that companies theoretically should not hedge any risks since shareholders can diversify away any risks taken by the individual firm” OIL PRICE PER BARREL HAS DIPPED BELOW USD 100 AND EXPECTED TO GO AS LOW AS USD 90, WHAT IS YOUR ASSESSMENT ON THIS FINANCIAL RISK?
35
Scorecard Performance Strategy
Source: IIARF
Mission/Vision/Strategy
Strategy Assessment Strategy Mapping
Refine Strategy SWOT Analysis
Assess Customer Needs Assess Capabilities
Strategy Maps Strategic Objectives
Performance Measures
Strategic Objectives
Performance Measures, Targets, Initiative
Innovation &
Capabilities
Internal Processes
Customers
Scorecard Refinement
Measures, Targets, Initiatives
36
37
WITH MORE THAN 21000 STORES IN 65 COUNTRIES, IT HAS REDEFINED COFFEE DRINKING AROUND THE WORLD. THREE LATEST INNOVATIONS INNOVATING ON “OLD TECHNOLOGY” :-
1. NEW FORMATS THAT WOULD REDUCE CLIENT WAIT TIMES
2. WITH MORE PORDUCTS TO TEMPT THOSE WHO USE ITS STORES AS AN AD HOC OFFICE DURING THE DAY
3. EMPLOYING USER-DRIVEN CUSTOMISATION TO EXPAND ITS REACH AMONG GROUPS SUCH AS TEENAGERS AND TWEENS
Source: The Edge Financial Daily
38
Rebutting claims that Apple is not innovative as Samsung, the unveiling of iOS8 and iPhone 6 and mobile payments proved critic wrong. Artificial Intelligence, the humanising of machines is the next frontier for technological advancement
Source from The Edge Financial Daily
39
“AS A RESULT OF SIGNIFICANT CAPACITY INCREASE OF 48.2% OF ASK (AVERAGE SEAT KM) FROM JUNE 30,2013 AND THE NEED TO STIMULATE DEMAND TO ACHIEVE A LOAD FACTOR OF 80.4% IN THE THREE MONTHS ENDED JUNE30, 2014, YIELD AS MEASURED BY RASK (REVENUE PER AVAILABLE SEAT KM) HAS DECREASED 7% FROM 11.60 SEN IN THE THREE MONTHS ENDED JUNE 30 2013 TO 10.79 SEN IN THE THREE MONTHS ENDED JUNE30 2014” – AAX
Source: The Edge Financial Daily
40
• Air Asia ANA Japan termination due to high operating cost
and disagreement on operating business model
• Air Asia reentry into India with Tata; Tata alliance with SIA
• Boeing 777x and Airbus A350 strategy coincides with
increase in intra-regional trade led by Asia
AIRLINE: STRATEGIC REFINEMENT/REALIGNMENT
41
• SIA reconfiguration of premium economy seats- volume
and margin impact on business class seats
SQ AIRLINE SEAT RECONFIGURATION
42
No orders from airlines so far this year and continuously seeking buyers that don’t yet have A380 in their fleet.
Source: The Edge Financial Daily
43
Japan Airlines (JAL) turnround 2009, company suffered steep losses albeit it was Asia’s largest airline by
revenue
Overexposed to unprofitable domestic and overseas routes compounded by Sept 11, Iraq War, global financial crisis, SARs, bird flu health scares
Embarked on staff cuts & route cutbacks to reduce costs but not enough to stop company filing for bankruptcy
June2010, JAL entrenched in billions Yen in debt and mired in losses
JAL received 100b yen credit line from Tokyo
JAL applied for court protection under Corporate Rehabilitation Law
JAL managed to return to black; posted net profit 18.34b Yen in 3months ended June 2013
Revenue FY12 -1,205b Yen, FY13- 1,239b Yen, EBITDA FY- 12 286 b Yen, FY 13- 276 b Yen
PT Garuda Indonesia Turnround Affected by two major accidents in mid 90s & Asian financial crisis 97 and Sept 11, Bali
bombing and SARS outbreak
Garuda banned from European airspace in 07 because of safety concerns; lifted in late 2010 and resorted to debt restructuring in 2010
Turnaround started with the appointment of Emirsyah Satar in 05
He radically changed the government owned airline on operations, system & culture, opted cut routes, shrink business where flights had to be justified on bottom line
VSS 1000 out of 6500 members opted for this scheme
Cleared the real issue of the company – the lack of trust which is above other issues such as government interference in commercial decision &entrenched interest
Garuda recorded USD110.8m profit reflecting 72.6% increase from 2011
Revenue FY 2011 - US 2,151m, FY12- US 3,096m and FY13- US3,473m
EBITDA FY11-US174m, FY12-US226m and FY13 US 162m
44
LEAN TIME FOR AIRLINES: THE EDGE FINANCIAL DAILY 30/9/14
Traditional carriers did not have a low enough cost structure to compete with
LCCs
Intra Asia as opposed to Trans –Atlantic, 48% of global air traffic in Asia by end of decade
Intra Asia ASKs expanded by 6.5% annually between 2013 and 2104 to reach 1.7 trillion
MAS was the fastest growing airline group in Asia last 3 years, and 65% capacity expansion was concentrated on short haul network
CAPA- 80% of the 50 airlines based in SEA have not been profitable in 1H2014, many continue to lose money; surging capacity led to price war
Only 4 out of 17 publicly traded airlines or subsidiaries in SEA were profitable in 1H2014
SIA reported third straight year of declining passenger yields for FY march ending; aggressive fares and capacity injections from competitors will continue to affect yields
Yields at Air Asia slumped to a five year low in 2QFY2014 resulting in core losses of RM13.4m
Capacity rationalization – Qantas and SIA have cut capacity by deploying Boeing 777s instead of B747 and Airbus 380
45
Despite roughly 6% air traffic growth in AP over next 20 years, airline profitability is expected to remain narrow for the foreseeable future
As full carriers try to bring their cost structures in line with LCCs, the latter are trying to increase their revenue by offering add-on services, at an extra charge and deploying new state of the art jets and attempting to take on longer routes, in short the difference between LCC and full service business model is steadily NARROWING
Demand for business travel is also shrinking although there will always be demand for full service carriers and premium services
One full service airline seeing recovery in corporate demand is Cathay Pacific, reported a huge jump in earnings for 1HFY2014 at HK$347m versus HK$24M a year earlier
The silver lining to all this is that demand for air travel in general across the region will grow steadily. Air coverage will deepen into more markets. More airlines will emerge, but there will be more failure amongst the start ups. There will be a brand consolidation.
46
LEAN TIME FOR AIRLINES: THE EDGE FINANCIAL DAILY 30/9/14
47
SWOT Analysis to Develop Strategic Objectives
Source: IIARF
Strengths & Weaknesses (Internal)
Opportunities & Threats (External)
Strategic Objectives
Performance Measures
48
STRATEGY AND RISK MANAGEMENT: A TOP DOWN APPROACH
Adapted from Internal Auditor December 2011
49
ERM COSO 2 FRAMEWORK
ORGANISATION RISK STRUCTURE
1. INTERNAL ENVIRONMENT
2. OBJECTIVE SETTING
RISK ASSESSMENT
3. EVENT IDENTIFICATION
4. RISK ASSESSMENT
RISK MANAGEMENT
5. RISK RESPONSE
6. CONTROL ACTIVITIES
RISK MONITORING
7. INFORMATION & COMMUNICATION
8. MONITORING
INTERNATIONAL STANDARDS FOR THE
PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE OF
INTERNAL AUDITING
OCTOBER 2012
2130. A1 – The internal audit activity must evaluate the
adequacy and effectiveness of controls in responding to
risks within the organisation’s governance, operations,
and information systems regarding the:
1. Achievement of the organisation’s strategic
objectives
2. ..
3. ..
STRATEGIC RISK RESOURCE
ALLOCATION
Percentage of Risk Failures Leading to Significant Market
Decline
Percentage of Time Spent By Audit Departments on
these Risk types in 2014 /2015 Risk Categories
Strategic
Legal and
Compliance
Financial
Operational 13%
12%
Audit departments
report spending only 6% of their
time auditing strategic risks
7%
68%
Strategic risks account for 68%
of severe market declines
THREE COMMON STRATEGY FAILURE POINTS
Flawed Business Assumptions
Management assumptions may not be rigorously tested resulting in
organizational objectives that are inconsistent with the enterprise’s
capabilities or the realities of the business environment
Business Unit Misalignment
Lack of communication or a strategy development framework for
business units can result in business unit objectives and operating
plans that fail to align to enterprise objectives
Employee Understanding
Poor communication of strategic priorities throughout the
organization can lead to a lack of understanding and belief in the
future direction of the company
55
Oversight, assurance and managing risk management Oversight, assurance and managing risk management
The internal auditors offer assurance as to management’s effectiveness regarding strategic risks, the risk management function provides the techniques and methods for management to be most effective
Management led by the CEO is primarily responsible for Assessing and Managing strategic risks to allow for deeper understanding and focused action on the most significant risks
At the end of the day, the board is ultimately responsible for risk management, CAN DELEGATE CANNOT ABIDICATE
56