suo motu wrlr petiion (crlmlnal) 2o2o

15
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA CIVI L ORIGI NAL JURISDICTION suo MoTU wRlr PETIIoN (cRlMlNAL) NO. 1 OF 2O2O lN THE MATTER OF :- !N RE : CONTAGION OF COVID 19 VIRUS lN PRISONS REPLY AFFIDAVIT ON BEHALF OF THE STATE OF JHARKHAND PAPER - BOOK (FOR INDEX PLEASE SEE INSIDE) ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENT : TAPESH KUMAR SINGH

Upload: others

Post on 29-Dec-2021

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: suo MoTU wRlr PETIIoN (cRlMlNAL) 2O2O

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVI L ORIGI NAL JURISDICTION

suo MoTU wRlr PETIIoN (cRlMlNAL) NO. 1 OF 2O2O

lN THE MATTER OF :-

!N RE : CONTAGION OF COVID 19 VIRUS lN PRISONS

REPLY AFFIDAVIT ON BEHALF OF THE STATE OF JHARKHAND

PAPER - BOOK

(FOR INDEX PLEASE SEE INSIDE)

ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENT : TAPESH KUMAR SINGH

Page 2: suo MoTU wRlr PETIIoN (cRlMlNAL) 2O2O

RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS

PAGE NOS.PARTICU LARS

/

Page 3: suo MoTU wRlr PETIIoN (cRlMlNAL) 2O2O

PARTICULARS

REPLY AFFIDAVIT ON BEHALF OF THE STATE OF

J HARKHAN D

AN N EXU RE-R-A

A tabular chart of released prisoner on intrim

bail/ bail and parole in jharkhand jails from

22.03.2020 to t5.05.2021.

AN N EXU RE-R-B

A tabular chart of released prisoner on intrim

bail/ bail and parole in jharkhand jails from

L7 .O5.202L to L5.O6.2OZL

AN N EXU RE-R-C

A tabular chart of Covid-19 death in Prisons till

L5.06.2021.

AN N EXU RE-R-D

A tabular chart of released prisoners through

State Sentence Review Board from 2O2O to till

date

AN N EXU RE.R-E

A tabular chart of transferred prisoners within

Jharkhand Jails and summery report of

Jharkhand jails (as on L5.O6.2O2L\

Page 4: suo MoTU wRlr PETIIoN (cRlMlNAL) 2O2O

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

lN THE MATTER OF :-

lN RE : CONTAGION OF COVID-19 VIRUS lN PRISONS

REPLY AFFIDAVIT ON BEHALF OF THE STATE OF JHARKHAND

!, Tushar Ranjan Gupta,son of Late s.N. sahu resident of Jharkhand,

Ranchi P.O.- Doranda, P.s.- Doranda, District- Ranchi and presently at

Ranchi do hereby solemnly affirm and state as under:-

L. That I am presently posted as Assistant lnspector General of Prisons,

Jharkhand and have been duly authorized by the competent

authority to affirm the instant affidavit on behalf of the State of

Jharkhand. That, in my official capacity I am well acquainted with the

facts and circumstances of the case and thereof, competent to affirm

the instant affidavit.

That, while every effort has been made to answer all the issues

raised in the above captioned Writ Petition, the facts which have not

beenspecificallydeniedmaynotbedeemedtobeadmitted.

2.

r

. I CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTIONfl,u l4-''I '--,st TU WRIT PETITION (CRIMINAL) NO' 1 OF 2O2O

Page 5: suo MoTU wRlr PETIIoN (cRlMlNAL) 2O2O

3.

-/However, the deponent craves liberty of this Hon'ble Court to file a

detailed reply at a later stage, if so directed or required.

That, the instant affidavit is being fited in terms of the order dated

OL.O6.2O2L passed by this Hon'ble Court in the above captioned

matter. vide the aforesaid order dated 01.05.2021 this Hon'ble Court

was pleased to direct the Chief Secretaries/ Administrators, Home

Secretaries, Directors General of all the prisons and the Department

of Social Welfare of all the States and Union Territories, to show

cause why directions should not be issued for dealing with the

present health crisis arising oul of Corona Virus (COVID-19) in the

country, and further to suggest immediate measures to be adopted

for the medical assistance to the prisoners in the jails and the

juveniles lodged in the Remand Homes and for'protection their

health and welfare.

That in the light of direction of Hon'ble Supreme Court of lndia in Suo

Moto Writ Petition (C) No. Ot/2O20 in Re: Contagion of Covid-L9

Virus in Prison vide Order dated 23.03.2020. tota! no. of prisoners

released (interim/ regular bail etc.) since dated 23.03.2020 to

4.

Page 6: suo MoTU wRlr PETIIoN (cRlMlNAL) 2O2O

and16.05.2021 is 29,478 out of which 105 prisoners are returned,

total number of convict prisoners released on parole is 146.

List of released prisoner on

lnterim/ regular Bail and parole

annexed as Annexure -'A'

'ble Supreme Court of lndia in Suo

Moto Writ Petition (C) No. Otl2OzO in Re: Contagion of Covid-19

Virus in Prison vide Order dated 07.05.202L & High Powered

Committee meeting held on 17.05.2021., it is submitted that from

t7.05.2021. to 15.06.2021 total number of prisoners released on bail

is 96L & interim bail is 207 and the total number of prisoners

released on Parole is 121, from the Jails of Jharkhand State.

Copy of Statistical Report for Released Prisoner on lnterim Bail/Bai!

and Parole in Jharkhand Jails (From 17.05.202L to 15.06.202t],.

Copy of Statistical RePort for

Released Prisoners on Interim

Baill Bail and Parole in Jharkhand

Jails annexed as Annexure- 'B'

1lz''---

Page 7: suo MoTU wRlr PETIIoN (cRlMlNAL) 2O2O

5. That in the light of Hon'ble Court's order it is submitted that the total

number of prisoners'"death due to Covid-l9 pandemic is 02 in the

prisons of Jharkhand State.

List of deaths Prisoners due to

Covid-19 Pandemic in the Prisons

annexed as Annexure- 'C'

7. That it is submitted that the Iast meeting of the Jharkhand State

sentence review board was held on t7/20.07.2O2O and 4.L2.20201

25.02.2021 and 7g + 26 = 105 life convicted prisoners were released.

!t is also submitted that the date of next meeting of the Jharkhand

State sentence review board is in process for the purpose of

premature release of Life convicted prisoners of Jharkhand state'

List of 105 released convict

prisoners annexed as Annexure-

,D,.

That, the total capacity of Jharkhand Prisons is t7,096 out of which

22,357 prisoners are lodged at present in various prisons' so the

percentage of occupancy of Jharkhand prisons at presentis t3o'77%'

"\

Page 8: suo MoTU wRlr PETIIoN (cRlMlNAL) 2O2O

9.

r€-

343 prisoners have been transferred from more overcrowded prisons

to other prisons.

List of transferred prisoners from

more overcrowded jail to other

jail annexed as Annexure- 'E'

That, even otherwise, if this Hon'ble Court is pleased to pass any

direction in this regard, the respondent State of Jharkhand being

duty bound and having highest regard to the majesty of this Hon'ble

Court shall comply with in its Ietter and spirit'

That, the documents marked as annexures to the instant affidavit are

either true and typed or true and translated copies of their

respective originals.

That, this affidavit is being bona-fide and in the interest of justice'

10.

11.

\,>-

/

Page 9: suo MoTU wRlr PETIIoN (cRlMlNAL) 2O2O

?

VERIFICATION

Verified at Ranchi on this, the 22nd Day of June, 2O2L that the averments

of facts stated herein above are true and correct to my knowledge and

behalf and noting material has been

DEPONENT

filed on filed by: ,

ITAPESH KUMAR SINGH]

Standing counsel for the state of Jharkhand

ab

Page 10: suo MoTU wRlr PETIIoN (cRlMlNAL) 2O2O

I

o'6-E'L(u

.YG'

-.=ooL(Eo-E'E(t,(Em:-.EmEL

coL(l)Eo-oL

o-EoU'G'o(t,E,oEoa.l(1)

E,I

(o

c.)c{ @ $ o) cf)cr)

c.)cf) O o C\| o O o o c.) t- o o o c{ o O o o o o o o o (o

$

Cf) o o Cf) $ o C\| c!c{ o O F- o o F- c! o ro o o o o o o o lr) o too

(o(oC\

|r)O) cf)c!l'-

ro(o(oc\lrr)rr)

(oocr)c\t

l'-tO)

o)(a@

-J-o)

(oc!(f)

OrooCD

O)@

o(o@

(ocoo)

O)(oro

o)o)F-

@c.)(o

oro(o$(o*

@+lr)C\F-

orr)@

(o(oCE

sc!.rt@1r)(o

oc\c\l

c!@s

*(o (oc!(o

@t-sO)6l

J

-JE.Fz.[Uo_<rOOz. z.=<>t6*-(rS_>mF-+oOI

t-(,oLUo-(J

:lfo-O

t=o_oLU

=(/)

-=o-o-(9-O

-oio-()

-J-

-JtFz.LUOz.L=e9>4'-d__r ff+<()-

=Jo_

toz.z.oul

-(J

U)

co

-O-o

6t:<oco

a-O-o

tF-O-o

oCOz.

-o-o

=ItI-o

oooo-o

Jl(9

-o

tF

--o

tLUoo:<-o

t-tlJFI-o

(,ot=oJ-o

t=:<o_

-o

-z.(9d)r<J)

o

t=o_otUI(./)

-JIO:<U)

-o

JTU:<

E.(D

-o

oLUo(/)

o

z.otrFfmS-Hx+E=<qi---r I<dz. t-u) z.O. LUOo

JIct)FI(9

-a

Fz.=-:<-U)

tlo_fTo

-a

It(,

t-U)

Frolz.tuF-a/)

6oF

C\| CD s ro (o l-- @ O) o c{ Cf) + ro (o f.- @ o) oC\| c! c{

C\|c.)c! $c!

tr)c)l

(oc{ F-

c\l@c\l

o)(\ oCf)

(

f

Page 11: suo MoTU wRlr PETIIoN (cRlMlNAL) 2O2O

E'l

adqldZfl

l.ldlr-laItrlctIEl,l<lti.G

q)

tr

q)

a,q)

U)

L

().acnc)c)

lr

()

cqc)

o

a

(o o () $ olr) @c{ O o o o o o o o o o o |<) o o o o o o o o o (\t

<+C\| O o)c{

()co o o $ (f) o f.-(\ o o O) |r) l-- O F*c{ C\l c{ o o o o C\ o o o 1\o(\l

ol-- *

$+C\l

$ @(o F-|r)()|r) co

C\@l--

o, O)c.)

lr)* r.- C.)cr)

ro(\ @ (o c{ olr) |r) c!C! o o c\lc{ o o

(f)O)CO o (o

O)

t

=Fo--J

J

E.Fz.LUOoz.f

U)=d6m-+aot

t-ootuoO

t=o_oLUIcJ)

-rEa-(9=(9-O

-oto-O

2

tz.-(D:<to_

-:<<I>(9a<zmY=ot-+N+<O-

=Jo-t(9

z.z.oLU

-O

U)

m

=O-o

6t:<oco

a-O-o

tF-(J-o

omz.

-o-o

=-to-o

ooo(,-o

I=(9-r')

tF

-r'\

tLUoo:<-o

E,

-[rJFI-o

(9

otIoJ

-o

tf:<o_

o

-z.(,coIao

tfo_o[lEU>

=-jIO:<a-o

J[U:<

ta-o

oLUo(t)

-o

uJtFz.tUOz.oFF=mIuJt

=O=.(,J<<(D-&z.<IJJ No_<OI

Jc/)F-(9-(/)

Fz.:)-:<-U)

tfo_f-o=-</)

-tota

F

-o=z.LUF-U)

GoF

c{ cf) + ro (o F- @ O) o c{ cf) s lr) (O t- @ O) oc{ c{ e!e{(f)(\ s(\ ro

c\l(oC\

F-C\l

@c{ o)c{ oCf)

Page 12: suo MoTU wRlr PETIIoN (cRlMlNAL) 2O2O

fi',rrr+rti,t -'C'

Report for Covid-19 death in Prisons til! L5.O6.2O2Lsl.

No.Name of Jail

No. of Prisonersdeath by Covid-19

Remarks

1 2 3 4

1, CJ-DU M KA UTP Santosh Kumar Maheria send toMedical College, Dumka on 02.09.2020for treatment and during treatment he

found covid-19 (+ve) & dead on

04.09.2020 at Medical College, Dumka

2 DJ-CHAIBASA UTP Vishnu Pingua send to Sadar

Hospital, Chaibasa for better treatmenton 17-04-2021and during treatment he

found covid-19 (+ve) and dead on

26.04.2021 at Sadar Hospital, Chaibas.

1

1

Page 13: suo MoTU wRlr PETIIoN (cRlMlNAL) 2O2O

Year

17120.07"20201g

2a6

Page 14: suo MoTU wRlr PETIIoN (cRlMlNAL) 2O2O

[,4nrrev vv.<- - EStatistical Report for Transferred Prisoners within Jharkhand Jail 6s on'1s.06.2021)

2

1 CJ.DEOGHAR 140 Sub Jail Madhupur

2 DJ-CHATRA 14 Sun Jail Ramgarh

13 L.N.J.P Central JalL, Hazaribagh

3 DJ-GARHWA 40 Birsa Munda Central Jail, Hotwar, Ranchi

4 DJ.GUMLA 50

40

District Jail Sakchi, JSR

5 DJ-LATEHAR Birsa Munda Central Jail, Hotwar, Ranchi

b SJ-RAJMAHAL 46 Cenkal Jail Dumka

Total 343

Page 15: suo MoTU wRlr PETIIoN (cRlMlNAL) 2O2O

{

An*"."e-' E

Summary Report for Prisoners in Jharkhand Jail(As on 15.06.2021)

S.No.Name of Prisons

Capacity ofPrisons

Civil Convicted Under Trial TotalPercentage

ofOccupancy

1,,

3 4 5 6 7 8

I BIRSA MTINDA CENTRAL JAILFroTwA& RANCHT

3666 0 1384 2364 3573 97.46

2. ]ENTRAL JAIL DEOGHAR 335 0 82 618 729 2t7.6tJ. ]ENTRAL JAIL DUMKA 1209 0 656 653 1281 10s.964. ]ENTRAL JAIL GHAGHIDIH,

IAMSHEDPUR1680 0 93s 925 1 899 1t3.04

5. ]ENTRAL JAIL GIzuDIH 554 0 81 1078 1093 197.29

6. L. J.NARAYAN CENTRAL JAIL,FIAZARIBAGH

1 990 0 1099 874 2043 t02.66

7. ]ENTRAL JAIL MEDININAGARPALAMU(DALTONGANJ) 703 0 281 866 1176 167.28

8. DISTRICT JAIL CHAIBASA 621 0 44 878 904 t4s.579 DISTRICT JAIL CHAS, BOKARO 435 0 58 464 516 t18.6210. DISTRICT JAIL CHATRA 209 0 4 648 669 320.10l1 )ISTRICT JAIL DHANBAD 856 0 59 988 980 114.49t2 DISTRICT JAIL GARHWA 250 0 25 531 559 223.6013. DISTzuCT JAIL GODDA 298 0 9 410 422 t4t.6tt4. DISTRICT JAIL GUMLA 23t 0 7 458 699 302.6015. DISTRICT JAIL JAMTARA 186 0 5 258 248 IJJ.JJ16. DISTRICT JAIL KODERMA 210 0 24 330 344 163.8117. DISTRICT JAIL LATEHAR 166 0 2 379 456 274.7018. DISTRICT JAIL LOHARDAGA 210 0 6 397 3s3 I 68.1 019. DISTzuCT JAIL PAKUR 225 0 10 2s5 258 tt4.6720. DISTRICT JAIL SAHIBGANJ 225 0 2 386 )t) 165.782t. DISTRICT JAIL SAKCHI, JSR 198 0 38 24t 168 84.8522. DISTRICT JAIL SARAIKELA 298 0 7 585 584 195.9723. DISTzuCT JAIL SIMDEGA 208 0 22 368 386 185.5 824. OPEN JAIL -CUM.

REHABILITATION CENTRE,HAZARIBAGH

100 0 7 31 37 37.00

25. SUB JAIL GHATSHILA 325 0 7 351 288 88.6226. SUB JAIL KHUNTI 500 0 1 777 739 147.8027. SUB JAIL MADHUPUR 463 0 30 546 490 105.8328. SUB JAIL RAJMAHAL t20 0 J 2t4 259 215.8329. SUB JAIL RAMGARH 325 0 5 332 308 94.7730 SUB JAIL TENUGHAT 300 0 6 253 2s7 85.67

Total 17096 0 4899 17458 22357 130.77