sustainable financing and management system for leftover paint psi paint stewardship dialogue...
TRANSCRIPT
Sustainable Financing and Management System for Leftover Paint
PSI Paint Stewardship Dialogue
Washington DC
June 29-30, 2004
PSI Paint Product Stewardship Meeting Washington DC June 29-30, 2004
2
Sustainable Financing
PSI Paint Product Stewardship Meeting Washington DC June 29-30, 2004
3
Financing Discussion at Boston Meeting
Ideal World Preview of Financing Systems Questions/Open Discussion:
What financing issues do you want addressed in the dialogue?
What additional information do you need for a financing discussion in CA?
PSI Paint Product Stewardship Meeting Washington DC June 29-30, 2004
4
Financing Discussion at Sacramento Meeting
Presentation on financing system research Fee-related systems Deposit systems Other financing systems
Can we get the cost of managing leftover paint to zero?
What can be done to contribute to making paint collection and management programs profitable?
PSI Paint Product Stewardship Meeting Washington DC June 29-30, 2004
5
Financing Discussion at Sacramento Meeting
At what point do we think it will be profitable to collect and process leftover paint?
Under what scenario might funding be necessary?
What might need to be financed? Attributes of a sustainable financing system
PSI Paint Product Stewardship Meeting Washington DC June 29-30, 2004
6
Leftover Paint Management:Future Scenarios
Estimated Current State
Not Collected ReducedSwapped Collected & Managed
4 Year Senario
Not Collected ReducedSwapped Collected & Managed
8 Year Senario
Not Collected ReducedSwapped Collected & Managed
PSI Paint Product Stewardship Meeting Washington DC June 29-30, 2004
7
Bottom Line
Can Reduce Volume and Cost Somewhat Need to Manage the Rest There are Uncertainties
Volume Cost
PSI Paint Product Stewardship Meeting Washington DC June 29-30, 2004
8
Dual Path
Reduce Leftover Paint and Management Costs – Pilot Projects and Initiatives
Begin to Develop Sustainable Financing System to Manage Leftover Paint
PSI Paint Product Stewardship Meeting Washington DC June 29-30, 2004
9
Proposal Proceed with pilots/initiatives to reduce
leftover paint management costs (2-3 years).
Delay development of financing system for 18 months.
PSI Paint Product Stewardship Meeting Washington DC June 29-30, 2004
10
Proposal Form Third Party Organization (TPO) to
manage pilots/initiatives. Allows for testing potential future management
model
TPO membership comprised primarily of manufacturers with multi-stakeholder advisory panel.
PSI Paint Product Stewardship Meeting Washington DC June 29-30, 2004
11
Proposal Develop fund with sole purpose being to run
pilots. Primary source is manufacturers. Possibly supplemented by other funds. TPO manages fund.
Ensures level playing field Fosters flexibility
Pilots/initiatives and TPO are experiments for potential future expansion.
PSI Paint Product Stewardship Meeting Washington DC June 29-30, 2004
12
Proposal Dialogue group would still need to agree on:
Pilots/initiatives that TPO would manage. Geographic locations of pilots/initiatives. Budgets, staffing plans, and timelines of
pilots/initiatives. Amount of funding needed. Performance metrics and evaluation criteria for
pilots/initiatives – define “success.” Composition of TPO.
PSI Paint Product Stewardship Meeting Washington DC June 29-30, 2004
13
Proposal TPO has flexibility to manage pilots. TPO could also:
Research uncertainties (cost, volume, extent of infrastructure, etc.)
Test additional pilots
Dialogue group meets every 6 months. Development of financing system resumes after
18 months (prior discussion possible).
PSI Paint Product Stewardship Meeting Washington DC June 29-30, 2004
14
Proposal Financing workgroup continues to meet
post-DC meeting to refine proposal for presentation/agreement in Chicago.
Delta/Plus
PSI Paint Product Stewardship Meeting Washington DC June 29-30, 2004
15
TPO Examples Rechargeable Battery Recycling Corp. CARE Eco-Peinture Product Care Association Resource Recovery Fund Board
PSI Paint Product Stewardship Meeting Washington DC June 29-30, 2004
16
Purpose of Pilot Projects/Initiatives
Test potential to lower leftover paint volume and management costs.
Test possible strategies for nationwide full-scale implementation.
PSI Paint Product Stewardship Meeting Washington DC June 29-30, 2004
17
Questions for Group Discussion
What pilot projects/initiatives do we want to fund?
What should be the sources of funding to run the pilot projects?
Generally, how much funding will be needed?
PSI Paint Product Stewardship Meeting Washington DC June 29-30, 2004
18
Questions for Group Discussion
What should be the performance metrics and evaluation criteria for the pilots/initiatives?
What is a reasonable timeframe for getting results from pilots/initiatives?
What entity is best suited to be the TPO? What should be the governance structure of
TPO?
PSI Paint Product Stewardship Meeting Washington DC June 29-30, 2004
19
Additional Questions What should be the realm of TPO decision-
making authority? What are the TPO decision-making
protocols? Does TPO report to dialogue group or is it
independent? At what point do we assess performance of
TPO?
PSI Paint Product Stewardship Meeting Washington DC June 29-30, 2004
20
Additional Questions What should be the mission of the TPO? What should be the mechanism for the
TPO mission to change over time? How would a TPO work? Who would manage TPO? Does TPO need to be incorporated?