Text Comprehension Practices for Students who are Deaf or Hard of Hearing: Part 1

Susan R. EasterbrooksGeorgia State University

Part 1 of 2 presentations on text comprehension for the “Join Together” recommended practices series.

Part 1- We look at what text what text comprehension is and how we teach comprehension is and how we teach itit to students. to students.

Part 2- We look at the different strategies to teach studentsstrategies to teach students to use before, during, and after reading.

What do we mean by “text comprehension?”

Effective text comprehension is "intentional thinking during which meaning is constructed through interactions between text and reader".

Research suggests that text comprehension is enhanced when readers actively relate the ideas represented in print to their own knowledge and experiences and construct mental pictures in their memory.

Source: http://www.ncpublicschools.org/readingfirst/components/text/

The National Reading Panel recommends that beginning reading instruction include the following strategies.

How to read both narrative and expository texts.

How to understand and remember what they read. How to relate their own knowledge or experiences to text.

How to use comprehension strategies to improve their comprehension.

How to communicate with others about what they read.

How do we do this?How do we do this? Explicitly explain, model and teach comprehension

strategies Examples: monitoring, use of graphic and semantic

organizers, asking and answering questions, previewing, summarizing, and using multiple strategies (e.g., cooperative learning and reciprocal teaching).

Provide opportunities for students to practice using strategies when reading connected narrative and expository text.

Include pre-reading, reading, and post-reading comprehension activities during instruction.

Promote thinking and extend discourse by asking questions and encouraging student questions and discussions.

Provide extended opportunities for English language learners to participate.

Use screening and progress monitoring assessment to track the progress of individual students. Follow up with diagnostic assessment to target specific strategies with which students may need additional intervention.

Narrativ

e & Exposito

ry Text

Narrativ

e & Exposito

ry Text

Memory Memory

SharingSharing

Known

Unknow

n

Known

Unknow

n

Strategies

Strategies

What do we mean by “narrative” and “expository” text?

“Narrative” refers to any way we provide an account of a real or imagined events, in other words, how we tell a story.

Students need to learn the different narrative strategies a writer uses.

Narrative strategies are the techniques writers use to tell stories, such as:

Point of View, Narrator, Voice Who is telling the story?

Sequence What is the order of the important events?

Audience For whom is the story written?

Characterization What are the traits of the main character and supporting characters, and how

do these traits influence one another?

Narra

tiv

e &

Expo

sito

ry T

ext

Narra

tiv

e &

Expo

sito

ry T

ext

Plot (events of a story) What happens?

Setting (time & place) When does it happen? Is it in the past, the future? Is time

telescoped in any way?

Genre What kind of story is this? Science fiction? Biography?

Diction How do the characters speak? Formally, informally, in a

foreign accent, like an old-timer, etc?

Literary Motifs & Figurative Language What literary devices does the author use? Simile,

metaphor, personification, allegory, etc.?

“Expository text” is written for the purpose of exposing, informing, explaining, or describing information to the reader.

Expository text should be factual, unbiased, and written in third voice, that is, the author should way “He drives…She finds…They have…” rather than “I” or “You.”

There are several types of expository text: Sequence Descriptive essay Classification Comparison Cause and effect

The most commonly used and basic forms of expository writing is the five-paragraph essay, which contains an introduction with a clear thesis statement, three main body paragraphs and a conclusion.

The organizer on the next page is a good way to help students visualize the 5-paragraph essay.

We read for different purposes when we read narrative versus expository text.

When students understand the structure of the text, they are better able to look for important features.

Narrativ

e ?Expository?

Why do we want students to understand and remember what they read?

Memory Memory

Main idea and Main idea and supporting detailssupporting details

Analysis and SynthesisAnalysis and Synthesis

ApplicationApplication

In order to use reading skills for learning information in content areas, In order to use reading skills for learning information in content areas, we must remember what we read, think about it, and apply it.we must remember what we read, think about it, and apply it.

What do we mean by “relating our own knowledge and experiences to the text?”

Students read better when they have a frame of reference for what they are reading.

There are many ways we can help students relate their experiences to the text.

The most well-known of these is “activating prior knowledge.”

You will see several options for activating prior knowledge in part two.

Known

Unknow

n

Known

Unknow

n

When activating prior knowledge, we...

teach vocabulary as a prereading step;

tap the student’s prior experiences or provide background experiences; and

introduce a visually organizing framework that will help students build appropriate background for themselves.

Primary challenge when teaching students with hearing loss…

…we cannot assume they have the background knowledge or the language skills that most students bring to the reading process.

Text comprehension strategies allow us to help students bridgebridge between language they understand and language they do not understand.

What do we mean by “communicating with others about what we have read?”

Communicating with others assists the student in engaging in such practices as…

Summarizing Clarifying Asking and answering questions Checking their own comprehension

Shar

ing

Shar

ing

What do we mean by “using comprehension strategies to teach comprehension?”

Comprehension strategies are the way in which we promote “intentional thinking” about a story.

Examples of strategies are:

Predict Predict Monitor/clarify Monitor/clarify Question Question Summarize Summarize Visualize Visualize Making use of prior knowledge Making use of prior knowledge Making inferencesMaking inferences

Strategies

Strategies

Reading comprehension strategies are metacognitive tools.

Metacognitive tools (intentional thinking) provide students the steps they can go through to construct meaning from print. (Teaching a child to fish.)

Some of the strategies are for teachers to use when instructing students in the use of strategies.

Some of the strategies are for students to use when they are reading.

What is the Process for Teaching a Strategy?

1.

a. strategies taught should be those used by successful readers: both deaf and hearing

b. strategies taught should be related to the child’s present levels of performance based on an assessment of student’s available repertoire of strategies

c. teach only one strategy at a time

2.

a. materials chosen should be appropriate to support the strategy

b. materials chosen should be appropriate for the individual learner

c. materials chosen should come from a variety of types: narratives, documents, instructions, notes, etc.

3.

a. Orient student to the tool (strategy) and its purpose (in what context to apply the tool)

b. Answer questions about the tool (strategy): What is it? How do we apply it? When do we use it? Why do we use it rather than another strategy?

c. Provide a list of the steps involved in using the tool (strategy)

d. Using a self-talk or think aloud strategy, demonstrate your thought processes as you apply the tool (strategy)

e. Explain why you made the decisions you made

f. Review how you applied the tool (strategy)

4. Guide Its Use (Guide Its Use (Move from Direct Instruction to Guidance Move from Direct Instruction to Guidance

to Independent Useto Independent Use))

a. Follow a collaborative, team, or cooperative learning model

b. Give students appropriate materials that will allow them to apply the strategy with ease

c. Guide student through the steps one at a time

d. Provide for immediate success

e. Explain, answer questions, reinforce

f. Give students a second opportunity to apply the strategy with direct assistance

g. Give student new material that provides a good fit with the strategy and have students talk themselves through the steps (one student is the “leader” for each step; other students are active participants) with the teacher providing feedback

h. Ask each student to demonstrate to you how s/he has applied the strategy to a novel piece of material

i. Assist student in determining which strategies to apply where

j. Help students apply strategies across the curriculum

5. Reinforce Its UseReinforce Its Use (Move from Best Fit to Worst Fit) (Move from Best Fit to Worst Fit)

a. Provide a variety of materials that have a good fit with the strategy for student to develop the strategy to an automatic level

b. Provide other materials where the fit might not be as good

c. Provide materials where the strategy might not be effective and discuss why you might choose a different strategy for this material

Pulling it all together helps student read!Pulling it all together helps student read!

NarrativeNarrative

MemoryMemory

Known UnkownKnown Unkown

SharingSharingStrategies

Strategies