the big question of feasibility
DESCRIPTION
The Big Question of Feasibility. Benjamin Burkhart BKB Properties 2008 Southeastern Self Storage Convention. Three Areas of Feasibility. Site Selection Market Dynamics Financial Performance Opportunities/Risks. Measuring Risks. Supply & Demand Lease-Up/Absorption Development Budget - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
The Big Question of Feasibility
Benjamin BurkhartBKB Properties
2008 Southeastern Self Storage Convention
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Three Areas of Feasibility
• Site Selection
• Market Dynamics
• Financial Performance
• Opportunities/Risks
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Measuring Risks
• Supply & Demand
• Lease-Up/Absorption
• Development Budget
• Financial Performance
• Site Quality
• Local Horizon
• Objectivity!!!
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Critical Piece of the Puzzle
• Investor Package
• Loan Request
• Design Team
• Management Team
• Promotion Initiatives
• Exit Strategy
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Site Selection
Rifle Approach
• Get A BIG road map
• Get a Zoning map
• Identify traffic patterns
• Plot Competitors
• Find Holes
• Go There!!!
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Site Research
• Zoning
• Environmental
• Long-Term Growth Plans
• Setbacks
• Utilities
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Site Planning
• Drive Aisles• Access• Visibility• Signage• Code Issues• Turning Radius• Site Features• Traffic
QuickTime™ and aTIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor
are needed to see this picture.
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Demographic Analysis
• Primary Market
• Population
• Households
• % of Renters
• Household Income
• Other population statistics
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Competitor Analysis
• Competitor Strength• MANAGER!!!!!!!!!!!• Age & Appearance• Location• Management Style• Features & Benefits• Rates• Size & Occupancy
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Competitor Analysis6
U-Store-It3501 Washington St
6a-9p9:30-6p
3.5 milesJean
88,000800
85%13200
non-climate climate
$38.00 $45.00 x$45.00 $55.00 x
x Masonryx x
$79.00 $148.00 x x Gate$119.00 $184.00$179.00 $199.00$194.00 $199.00 Door Alarms Grades$199.00 B
DB-
Name:Address:
Gate Hours:Office Hours:Distance from Subject
Manager:NRSF: s.f.# of Units unitsOccupancy:
vacant s.f.
Rates:5x5 Paved Drives Move In Truck5x10 Video Surveillance Professional Center5x15 Copy/Fax Service7.5x10 Security Fence Retail Prominence10x10 Keypad Entry10x15 Resident Manager10x20 RV/Boat Storage10x2510x30 Electronic Signage Site (physical layout, etc.)______________ Service (manager, amenities)
______________ Location (visibility, prominence)
The store is a little out of the way from the main road, hence the lower score on location. Jean is a terrible manager. She was horrible on the phone, and worse in person. Jean is merely a warm body behind a desk,
with no focus on sales or service. She was stressing over making a bank deposit when I interviewed her, and seemed to only have three or four checks that she was trying to enter into the computer. The site was clean,
but access was a little cramped.
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Competition
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Competitor Data
Name
Distance to
Subject NRSF OCC% 5x5 5x5 cc5x10 5x10cc10x10 10x10cc10x15 10x15cc10x20 10x20cc10x25 10x30
Highway 4 Storage 0.2 44800 97% 30 48 65 80 110U-Can-Stor-It 0.9 18200 84% 51 77U-Can-Stor-It 1.4 103680 82% 34 39 54 69 170 104 104 94U-Can-Stor-It 1.6 66662 94% 64 72 89 105 150Public Storage 1.7 36750 95% 35 103 139 165Expressway Stor-All 1.7 40680 75% 25 25 70 85 75 125 100 190Public Storage 2 47280 95% 34 46 64 81 143Private Stor-All 1.8 47276 75% 45 85 135 160 190 230Uhaul 2.3 18720 97% 60 80 115 130 140Extra Attic 2.2 6500 100% 48 65 75Cool Time Mini Storage 2.5 77220 85% 35 51 65 69 95 89 135 99 175 150Uhaul 2.7 70200 92% 35 40 50 75 75 120 130 175Beltway Storage 2.6 58200 95%
Uhaul 2.7 38760 85% 50 60 70 85 105 100StorMorMax 2.5 65542 98% 44 65 100 140 170 240
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Construction Goals
Let’s Be Realistic• Market Demands• Type of Construction• Hurdles• Approvals• Process & Red Tape• Phasing
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Financial Feasibility
• Capital Requirements
• Development Costs
• Cash Flow Deficit
• Interest Expense
• Operating Expenses
• Pro-forma Lease-Up
• Sensitivity Analysis
• Exit Strategy
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Development Budget
• Design Costs
• Soft Costs
• Hard Construction
• Start-Up
• Construction Interest
• Cash Flow Deficit
• Contingency
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Condensed Budget
Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost SubtotalConsulting 1 estimate $15,000.00 $15,000.00Permitting 50,000 s.f. $0.20 $10,000.00Fees & other Permits 1 estimate $20,000.00 $20,000.00Site Work 5 acres $120,000.00 $600,000.00Project Design/Engineering 1 estimate $100,000.00 $100,000.00GC/Project Management 1 estimate $150,000.00 $150,000.00Office 1500 s.f. $90.00 $135,000.00Concrete 50,000 s.f. $6.00 $300,000.00Self Storage Buildings & Doors 50,000 s.f. $14.00 $700,000.00Masonry 6,000 s.f. $8.50 $51,000.00HVAC 19,038 s.f. $1.75 $33,317.31Electrical 50,000 s.f. $2.00 $100,000.00Signage 1 allowance $40,000.00 $40,000.00Security 50,000 allowance $1.00 $50,000.00Landscaping 1 allowance $35,000.00 $35,000.00Cash reserve 1.00 RESERVE $235,000.00 $235,000.00Interest During Construction 1.00 estimate $52,500.00 $52,500.00Move-In Truck 1 allowance $32,000.00 $32,000.00Start Up Costs 1 various $35,000.00 $35,000.00Financing Fees 1.5 percent $30,000.00 $45,000.00Builder's Risk 1 estimate $3,500.00 $3,500.00Professional Fees 1 allowance $8,000.00 $8,000.00Miscellaneous & Contingency 50,000 s.f. $2.00 $100,000.00Total $3,375,317.31
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Unit Mix Analysis
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Operating Expenses
Operating ExpensesYear 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4
Advertising $1,667 $20,000 $20,600 $21,012 $21,432 YP, direct mail, coupons, etc.Administration $333 $4,000 $5,000 $5,500 $6,050 accounting, feesInsurance $1,042 $12,500 $12,750 $18,000 $18,360 estimatePayroll & Taxes $3,987 $47,840 $49,275 $71,760 $73,913 PH I 60 hrs; PH II 80 hrsManagement Fee $2,500 $30,000 $28,928 $42,289 $52,681 6% of rentalsMiscellaneous $500 $6,000 $6,120 $6,242 $6,367Property Taxes $4,831 $57,976 $57,976 $77,193 $79,509 based on 2008 tax rateRepairs/Maint. $417 $5,000 $5,250 $5,775 $6,353 estimate to be budgetedSupplies $667 $8,000 $8,160 $8,323 $8,490 inventory, office expensesUtilities $1,250 $15,000 $15,750 $18,000 $18,900 electric, phone, etc.TOTAL $17,193 $206,316 $209,809 $274,095 $292,054
monthly $17,193.00 $17,484.10 $22,841.21 $24,337.85 some expenses not paid monthly
% of Gross Revenue 36.63% 37.25% 29.11% 31.02%
Year 1 Monthly Expense
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Cash Flow Analysis
• Cost of Operations• Real Estate Taxes• Interest/Debt Repay• Seasonal Fluctuations• Lease Up• Monthly Rentals• Rate Structure• Discounts
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Cash Flow Analysis
YEAR 1 YEAR 2 YEAR 3 YEAR 4 YEAR 5OCCUPANCY 53% 88% 73% 80% 80%GROSS INCOME $199,004 $472,490 $690,720 $869,237 $886,621
EXPENSES $206,316 $230,055 $274,095 $292,054 $294,975
NOI ($7,312) $242,435 $416,625 $577,182 $591,647
DEBT SERVICE ($200,831) ($200,831) ($369,605) ($369,605) ($369,605)
CASH FLOW ($208,144) $41,604 $47,020 $207,577 $222,041DSCR (0.04) 1.21 1.13 1.56 1.60
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Sensitivity Analysis
• What If Rents Decline?
• What about Discounts?
• Interest Expense
• Local Economy
• Slower Lease-Up
• Cost of Operations
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Sensitivity Analysis
Cash Flow Sensitivity YEAR 1 YEAR 2 YEAR 3 YEAR 4 YEAR 55% decrease in rents ($54,401) $128,952 $216,115 $225,625 $232,133
DSCR (0.40) 0.95 1.19 1.25 1.285% increase in expenses ($56,795) $136,254 $227,996 $238,025 $244,881
DSCR (0.42) 1.00 1.26 1.31 1.3536 month lease-up ($208,972) ($48,547) $26,858 $64,282 $71,187
DSCR (0.53) 0.64 1.15 1.35 1.39
YEAR 1 YEAR 2 YEAR 3 YEAR 4 YEAR 5OCCUPANCY 45% 85% 85% 85% 85%GROSS INCOME $130,492 $341,798 $430,192 $447,619 $456,572
EXPENSES $178,368 $195,756 $192,568 $199,614 $201,610
NOI ($47,876) $146,042 $237,625 $248,005 $254,962
DEBT SERVICE ($136,309) ($136,309) ($181,166) ($181,166) ($181,166)
CASH FLOW ($184,185) $9,734 $56,459 $66,840 $73,796DSCR (0.35) 1.07 1.31 1.37 1.41
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Interpreting Data
• How it all fits together• Red Flags• Site, Market,
Financials• Identifying and
Mitigating Risks• SWOT-Internal/
External
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Execution
• Team Building• Design• GC/Project Management• Bidding• Scheduling• Financing• Managing• Promoting• Marketing
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Exit Strategy
• Best & Worst Case Scenarios
• Refinancing--- Timing & Structure
• When to Sell/If to Sell
• External Influences
• Things Forever Change
2008 Myrtle Beach, SC
Biggest Mistake/Biggest Opportunity
• Who’s driving your ship?
• You get what you pay for.
• Train your managers.