the book of practice-part vii
DESCRIPTION
Identifying the research programTRANSCRIPT
-
decidepresent
characterizeidentify
series 6: research programthe book of practice part vii
-
421
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshine
drink our refuge not yet fo
und all full cup woes sank dregs only fool know
s
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a trusting acceptance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs inf
allible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
tim
e th
ough
hidde
n mists li
ke
finge
r wor
ld
withou
t hands
God: One tha
t is worshiped, i
dealized, or follo
wed
God
DECISION TIME
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Charity
find sun one charity heavy day seems w
e're lost teach beggar's name no way mind reels
Charity The theological virtue defined as love directed first toward God but also toward oneself and one's neighbors as objects of God's love
words cannot tell sing well heart feels through night blows fate fall
DECI
SION
TIM
E
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.drink our refuge not ye
t found all full cup w
oes sank dregs only fool knows
faith each us from rut habit his own kingdom
pains life's wreckage hard driven
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a trusting acceptance of G
od's will
night (n): The period between sunset and sunrise, especially the hours of darkness.
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
evening yet w
e go hours weren
't us
ed
hope
Hope: theological virtue defined as the desire and search
for a
futu
re g
ood,
diffic
ult but n
ot im
poss
ible
to a
ttain
with
God's
help
.
persists empt
ied
out
still
shin
es s
un b
eggars waiting gather them up th
ough
hid
den
mis
ts o
pen
them
long
nig
ht
IS THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY OF BREAKING THE SECOND COMMANDMENT?
1: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Faith
2: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN? DECISION TIME3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
characterize decideidentify
present
25
.02
.20
08
-
422
does the point of undecidability require two nodes to vibrate between?
derrida in his attempts to de mystify philosophy is still creating books, creating nodes, the metaphysics of presence
identifycharacterizedecide
present
26
02
.20
08
+..
-
423
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshine
drink our refuge not yet fo
und all full cup woes sank dregs only fool know
s
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a trusting acceptance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs inf
allible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
tim
e th
ough
hidde
n mists li
ke
finge
r wor
ld
withou
t hands
God: One tha
t is worshiped, i
dealized, or follo
wed
God
DECISION TIME
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Charity
find sun one charity heavy day seems w
e're lost teach beggar's name no way mind reels
Charity The theological virtue defined as love directed first toward God but also toward oneself and one's neighbors as objects of God's love
words cannot tell sing well heart feels through night blows fate fall
DECI
SION
TIM
E
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.drink our refuge not ye
t found all full cup w
oes sank dregs only fool knows
faith each us from rut habit his own kingdom
pains life's wreckage hard driven
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a trusting acceptance of G
od's will
night (n): The period between sunset and sunrise, especially the hours of darkness.
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
evening yet w
e go hours weren
't us
ed
hope
Hope: theological virtue defined as the desire and search
for a
futu
re g
ood,
diffic
ult but n
ot im
poss
ible
to a
ttain
with
God's
help
.
persists empt
ied
out
still
shin
es s
un b
eggars waiting gather them up th
ough
hid
den
mis
ts o
pen
them
long
nig
ht
IS THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY OF BREAKING THE SECOND COMMANDMENT?
1: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Faith
2: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN? DECISION TIME3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
characterize decideidentify
present
26
.02
.20
08
-
424
is to go beyond derrida is to go beyond books?
mirrors in a painting involve the audience acting as an accomplice. interestingly the exterior of the painting will change with different viewers. even if the viewer moves slightly the painting will change. does this show a point of undecidability. does this show the highly subjective nature of paintings?
identifycharacterizedecide
present
27.0
2.2
00
8
+..
-
425
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshine
drink our refuge not yet fo
und all full cup woes sank dregs only fool know
s
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a t rusting acceptance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs inf
allible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
tim
e th
ough
hidden
mists lik
e fin
ger
wor
ld wit
hout hands
God: One tha
t is worshiped, i
dealized, or follo
wed
God
DECISION TIME
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Charity
find sun one charity heavy day seems w
e're lost teach beggar's name no way mind reels
Charity The theological virtue defined as love directed first toward God but also toward oneself and one's neighbors as objects of God's love
words cannot tell sing well heart feels through night blows fate fall
DECI
SION
TIM
E
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.drink our refuge not ye
t found all full cup w
oes sank dregs only fool knows
faith each us from rut habit his own kingdom
pains life's wreckage hard driven
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a t rusting acceptance of G
od's will
night (n): The period between sunset and sunrise, especially the hours of darkness.
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
evening yet w
e go hours weren
't us
ed
hope
Hope: theological virtue defined as the desire and search
for a
f utu
re g
ood,
diffic
ult but n
ot im
poss
ible
to a
ttain
with
God's
help.
persists empt
ied
out
still
shi
nes
sun
beggars waiting gather them up
th
ough
hid
den
mis
ts o
pen
them
long
nig
ht
IS THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY OF BREAKING THE SECOND COMMANDMENT?
1: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Faith
2: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN? DECISION TIME3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
characterize decideidentify
present
27.0
2.2
00
8
-
426
viewers have to make the decision to engage the image and move on, be free in sartrean terms.
mirrors are they art or a household item? (point of undecidability)
identifycharacterizedecide
present
28
.02
.20
08
+..
-
427
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshine
drink our refuge not yet fo
und all full cup woes sank dregs only fool know
s
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a t rusting acceptance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs inf
allible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
tim
e th
ough
hidden
mists lik
e fin
ger
wor
ld wit
hout hands
God: One tha
t is worshiped, i
dealized, or follo
wed
God
DECISION TIME
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Charity
find sun one charity heavy day seems w
e're lost teach beggar's name no way mind reels
Charity The theological virtue defined as love directed first toward God but also toward oneself and one's neighbors as objects of God's love
words cannot tell sing well heart feels through night blows fate fall
DECI
SION
TIM
E
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.drink our refuge not ye
t found all full cup w
oes sank dregs only fool knows
faith each us from rut habit his own kingdom
pains life's wreckage hard driven
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a t rusting acceptance of G
od's will
night (n): The period between sunset and sunrise, especially the hours of darkness.
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
evening yet w
e go hours weren
't us
ed
hope
Hope: theological virtue defined as the desire and search
for a
f utu
re g
ood,
diffic
ult but n
ot im
poss
ible
to a
ttain
with
God's
help.
persists empt
ied
out
still
shi
nes
sun
beggars waiting gather them up
th
ough
hid
den
mis
ts o
pen
them
long
nig
ht
IS THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY OF BREAKING THE SECOND COMMANDMENT?
1: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Faith
2: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN? DECISION TIME3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
characterize decideidentify
present
28
.02
.20
08
-
428
do our lives move forward with the decisions we make?
to make a decision is to make abstract what we know or what has come before. it is to break the mould, move forward and twist out of the binary pair. why do some decisions seem bigger then others?
identifycharacterizedecide
present
29
.02
.20
08
+..
-
429
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshine
drink our refuge not yet fo
und all full cup woes sank dregs only fool know
s
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a t rusting acceptance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs inf
allible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
tim
e th
ough
hidden
mists lik
e fin
ger
wor
ld wit
hout hands
God: One tha
t is worshiped, i
dealized, or follo
wed
God
DECISION TIME
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Charity
find sun one charity heavy day seems w
e're lost teach beggar's name no way mind reels
Charity The theological virtue defined as love directed first toward God but also toward oneself and one's neighbors as objects of God's love
words cannot tell sing well heart feels through night blows fate fall
DECI
SION
TIM
E
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.drink our refuge not ye
t found all full cup w
oes sank dregs only fool knows
faith each us from rut habit his own kingdom
pains life's wreckage hard driven
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a t rusting acceptance of G
od's will
night (n): The period between sunset and sunrise, especially the hours of darkness.
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
evening yet w
e go hours weren
't us
ed
hope
Hope: theological virtue defined as the desire and search
for a
f utu
re g
ood,
diffic
ult but n
ot im
poss
ible
to a
ttain
with
God's
help.
persists empt
ied
out
still
shi
nes
sun
beggars waiting gather them up
th
ough
hid
den
mis
ts o
pen
them
long
nig
ht
IS THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY OF BREAKING THE SECOND COMMANDMENT?
1: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Faith
2: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN? DECISION TIME3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
characterize decideidentify
present
29
.02
.20
08
-
430
does increasing the number of decisions in a research program, increase the power and range of the research program? consider science and technology, more and more people are being employed in these disciplines, leading to more and more decisions being made. does this increase the power and range of science and technology
faust asks mephistopheles why he wants his soul, mephistopheles responds: we collect souls to make us more powerful
identifycharacterizedecide
present
01
.03
.20
08
+..
-
431
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Charity
find sun one charity heavy day seems w
e're lost teach beggar's name no way mind reels
Charity The theological virtue defined as love directed first toward God but also toward oneself and one's neighbors as objects of God's love
words cannot tell sing well heart feels through night blows fate fall
DECI
SION
TIM
E
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
characterize decideidentify
present
01
.03
.20
08
-
432
to make a decision, there must be something to make a decision about, whether it is books or art or just walking down the street?
how is decision making related to time?
identifycharacterizedecide
present
02
.03
.20
08
+..
-
433
drink our refuge not yet fo
und all full cup woes sank dregs only fool know
s
faith each us from rut habit his own kingdom
pains life's wreckage hard driven
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a t rusting acceptance of G
od's will
night (n): The period between sunset and sunrise, especially the hours of darkness.
evening yet w
e go hours weren
't us
ed
hope
Hope: theological virtue defined as the desire and search
for a
f utu
re g
ood,
diffic
ult but n
ot im
poss
ible
to a
ttain
with
God's
help.
persists empt
ied
out
still
shi
nes
sun
beggars waiting gather them up
th
ough
hid
den
mis
ts o
pen
them
long
nig
ht
Faith
2: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN? Decision m
ade: desire. unsatisfied longing feeling of potential pleasure in something.
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
"we
desir
e ot
her g
ods t
o be
bef
ore
us"
Decision made: tim
e. indefinite continuos duration regarded as dimension.
Decision made: hope. expectation and desire
"we
hope
to se
e ot
her g
ods s
oon"
Decision made: belief. trust, confidence and acceptance
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.
Decision made: god. superhum
an being worshipped as possessing divine power
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
"you must not worship sym
bols of your imagination, you m
ust worship god"
"we will sacrifice anything to be loyal and to abide by your comm
andments"
"you are not to worship any carved-image or any figure as all im
ages are finite and cannot
represent a god who is the heavens above, the earth and the waters beneath the earth"
characterize decideidentify
present
02
.03
.20
08
-
434
a painting is trying to impose its knowledge on you, it has something to say (like the bondsman and slave of hegel)
the artwork is begging you to make a decision about it, and store it in the well of decisions that are you?
identifycharacterizedecide
present
03
.03
.20
08
+..
-
435
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshine
drink our refuge not yet fo
und all full cup woes sank dregs only fool know
s
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a trusting acceptance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs inf
allible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
tim
e th
ough
hidden
mists lik
e fin
ger
wor
ld wit
hout hands
God: One tha
t is worshiped, i
dealized, or follo
wed
God
DECISION TIME
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
characterize decideidentify
present
03
.03
.20
08
-
436
if you dont believe in god, what do you believe in? can you prove god exists similarly can you prove that god does not exist?
if we can only comprehend incompleteness (no complete foundational knowledge), why bother with knowledge at all, do we just deflect our thoughts to get through our lives. deflect thought onto what we do?
identifycharacterizedecide
present
04
.03
.20
08
+..
-
437
drink our refuge not yet fo
und all full cup woes sank dregs only fool know
s
faith each us from rut habit his own kingdom
pains life's wreckage hard driven
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a t rusting acceptance of G
od's will
night (n): The period between sunset and sunrise, especially the hours of darkness.
evening yet w
e go hours weren
't us
ed
hope
Hope: theological virtue defined as the desire and search
for a
f utu
re g
ood,
diffic
ult but n
ot im
poss
ible
to a
ttain
with
God's
help.
persists empt
ied
out
still
shi
nes
sun
beggars waiting gather them up
th
ough
hid
den
mis
ts o
pen
them
long
nig
ht
Faith
2: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
Decision made: desire. unsatisfied longing feeling of potential pleasure in som
ething.
Decision made: drink. to take into the m
outh and swallow (a liquid)
Decis
ion m
ade:
"we
desir
e ot
her g
ods t
o be
bef
ore
us"
Decision made: tim
e. indefinite continuos duration regarded as dimension.
Decision made: hope. expectation and desire
Decis
ion m
ade:
"we
hope
to se
e ot
her g
ods s
oon"
Decision made: belief. trust, confidence and acceptance
Decision made: god. superhum
an being worshipped as possessing divine power
Decision made: kingdom
. the realm of this sovereignty
Decision made: dream
. a series of images, ideas, em
otions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the mind during certain stages of sleep
Decis
ion m
ade:
"you
mus
t not
wor
ship
sym
bols
of yo
ur im
agina
tion,
you
mus
t wor
ship
god"
Decis
ion m
ade:
"we
will s
acrif
ice a
nyth
ing to
be
loyal
and
to a
bide
by yo
ur c
omm
andm
ents"
Decis
ion m
ade:
"you
are
not
to w
orsh
ip an
y car
ved-
imag
e or
any
figu
re a
s all i
mag
es a
re fi
nite
and
cann
ot
repr
esen
t a g
od w
ho is
the
heav
ens a
bove
, the
ear
th a
nd th
e wa
ters
bene
ath
the
earth
"
Decis
ion m
ade:
"we
need
hop
e"
characterize decideidentify
present
04
.03
.20
08
-
438
oxford dictionary definition of mystic: one who believes in spiritual apprehension of truths beyond understanding
knowledge is never complete; so are we all mystics?
identifycharacterizedecide
present
05
.03
.20
08
+..
-
439
Decision made: dream
. a series of images, ideas, em
otions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the mind during certain stages of sleep
drink our refuge not yet fo
und all full cup woes sank dregs only fool know
s
faith each us from rut habit his own kingdom
pains life's wreckage hard driven
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a t rusting acceptance of G
od's will
night (n): The period between sunset and sunrise, especially the hours of darkness.
Decision made: tim
e. indefinite continuos duration regarded as dimension.
evening yet w
e go hours weren
't us
ed
hope
Hope: theological virtue defined as the desire and search
for a
f utu
re g
ood,
diffic
ult but n
ot im
poss
ible
to a
ttain
with
God's
help.
persists empt
ied
out
still
shi
nes
sun
beggars waiting gather them up
th
ough
hid
den
mis
ts o
pen
them
long
nig
ht
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we d
esir
e ot
her
gods
to
be b
efor
e us
" God
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
you
mus
t no
t wo
rshi
p sy
mbo
ls o
f yo
ur im
agin
atio
n, y
ou m
ust
wors
hip
god"
cann
ot r
epre
sent
a g
od w
ho is
the
hea
vens
abo
ve, t
he e
arth
and
the
wat
ers
bene
ath
the
eart
h"
2: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
Decision made: desire. unsatisfied longing feeling of potential pleasure in som
ething.
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
bul
l: yo
u ar
e no
t to
hav
e an
y ot
her
gods
Decision made: hope. expectation and desire
Decision made: belief. trust, confidence and acceptance
Decision made: god. superhum
an being worshipped as possessing divine power
Decision made: kingdom
. the realm of this sovereignty
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
we w
ill s
acri
fice
any
thin
g to
be
loya
l and
to
abid
e by
you
r co
mm
andm
ents
"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
you
are
not
to w
orsh
ip a
ny c
arve
d-im
age
or a
ny f
igur
e as
all
imag
es a
re f
init
e an
d
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
"we
nee
d ho
pe"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we h
ope
to s
ee o
ther
god
s so
on"
characterize decideidentify
present
05
.03
.20
08
-
440
the mystical is just another teleology
people readily accept deconstruction, but do they really appreciate it? art is produced to show deconstruction, but art is no authority, it is just another power structure or research program
identifycharacterizedecide
present
06
.03
.20
08
+..
-
441
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Charity
Superman
find sun one charity heavy day seems w
e're lost teach beggar's name no way mind reels
Charity The theological virtue defined as love directed first toward God but also toward oneself and one's neighbors as objects of God's love
words cannot tell sing well heart feels through night blows fate fall
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
characterize decideidentify
present
06
.03
.20
08
-
442
knowledge is possible, albeit temporary. it is not however, foundational. what is knowledge for me may not be knowledge for a professional philosopher or someone in the australian outback
every individual or being is on a journey of discovery
identifycharacterizedecide
present
07.03
.20
08
+..
-
443
characterize decideidentify
present
07.03
.20
08
-
444
discovery is closely linked to decision, and a decision requires a leap of faith to be made
oxford dictionary definition of discovery: acquire knowledge by effort or by chance
identifycharacterizedecide
present
08
.03
.20
08
+..
-
445
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Charity
Superman
find sun one charity heavy day seems w
e're lost teach beggar's name no way mind reels
Charity The theological virtue defined as love directed first toward God but also toward oneself and one's neighbors as objects of God's love
words cannot tell sing well heart feels through night blows fate fall
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
characterize decideidentify
present
08
.03
.20
08
-
446
making a decision is always a discovery
knowledge is an analysis of previous discoveries or decisions; it is history
identifycharacterizedecide
present
09
.03
.20
08
+..
-
447
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Charity
Superman
find sun one charity heavy day seems w
e're lost teach beggar's name no way mind reels
Charity The theological virtue defined as love directed first toward God but also toward oneself and one's neighbors as objects of God's love
words cannot tell sing well heart feels through night blows fate fall
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
characterize decideidentify
present
09
.03
.20
08
-
448
do laws prevent discoveries or decisions being made?
knowledge of past decisions can only be uses as a guide or basis for future decisions
identifycharacterizedecide
present
10
.03
.20
08
+..
-
449
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Charity
Superman
find sun one charity heavy day seems w
e're lost teach beggar's name no way mind reels
Charity The theological virtue defined as love directed first toward God but also toward oneself and one's neighbors as objects of God's love
words cannot tell sing well heart feels through night blows fate fall
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
characterize decideidentify
present
10
.03
.20
08
-
450
the true benefit of knowledge is it provides the basis for future decisions, and it allows us to act as individuals in a community. we as individuals follow no laws we use the past as a basis for future decisions
as individuals we are on a journey through time, the paths for us to discover and examine are infinite, using our and others past decisions as a guide. if we live our life as a law, we are inhibiting our own freedom, as the law demands that we adhere to it
identifycharacterizedecide
present
11
.03
.20
08
+..
-
451
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Charity
Superman
find sun one charity heavy day seems w
e're lost teach beggar's name no way mind reels
Charity The theological virtue defined as love directed first toward God but also toward oneself and one's neighbors as objects of God's love
words cannot tell sing well heart feels through night blows fate fall
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill b
ow d
own
an s
erve
you
"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
you
are
our
god
and
our
sons
and
dau
ghte
rs g
od t
oo, u
ntil
the
thir
d an
d fo
urth
gen
erat
ion"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill n
ot w
orsh
ip t
hose
in n
eed"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill o
nly
wors
hip
thos
e wh
o en
tert
ai n
and
giv
e us
ple
asur
e"
Decision made: pleasure. satisfaction, delight; sensuous enjoym
ent; will, discretion, choice.
characterize decideidentify
present
11
.03
.20
08
-
452
there are no foundational laws, since the world is incomplete? one could live their life by a law, as long as they realize the law is not total or complete. they also must realize that in adhering to laws they are limiting the discoveries they can make
we cannot make decisions without base knowledge, cannot make a discovery if you dont know something already
identifycharacterizedecide
present
12
.03
.20
08
+..
-
453
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Charity
Superman
find sun one charity heavy day seems w
e're lost teach beggar's name no way mind reels
Charity The theological virtue defined as love directed first toward God but also toward oneself and one's neighbors as objects of God's love
words cannot tell sing well heart feels through night blows fate fall
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill b
ow d
own
an s
erve
you
"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
you
are
our
god
and
our
sons
and
dau
ghte
rs g
od t
oo, u
ntil
the
thir
d an
d fo
urth
gen
erat
ion"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill n
ot w
orsh
ip t
hose
in n
eed"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill o
nly
wors
hip
thos
e wh
o en
tert
ai n
and
giv
e us
ple
asur
e"
Decision made: pleasure. satisfaction, delight; sensuous enjoym
ent; will, discretion, choice.
characterize decideidentify
present
12
.03
.20
08
-
454
if the world is complete, then no are decisions possible. life would be defined as a matrix or computer program. we would know everything, our lives would proceed exactly, and we would know exactly what is going to happen to us
the basis of our knowledge always starts with us individually. we use knowledge of our past to communicate with others. we use the past knowledge of ourselves and others to make decisions in the present
identifycharacterizedecide
present
13
.03
.20
08
+..
-
455
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Charity
Superman
find sun one charity heavy day seems w
e're lost teach beggar's name no way mind reels
Charity The theological virtue defined as love directed first toward God but also toward oneself and one's neighbors as objects of God's love
words cannot tell sing well heart feels through night blows fate fall
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill b
ow d
own
an s
erve
you
"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
you
are
our
god
and
our
sons
and
dau
ghte
rs g
od t
oo, u
ntil
the
thir
d an
d fo
urth
gen
erat
ion"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill n
ot w
orsh
ip t
hose
in n
eed"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill o
nly
wors
hip
thos
e wh
o en
tert
ai n
and
giv
e us
ple
asur
e"
Decision made: pleasure. satisfaction, delight; sensuous enjoym
ent; will, discretion, choice.
characterize decideidentify
present
13
.03
.20
08
-
456
the present is recorded and is analyzed in the future. techniques for recording the present include, images, books, films, speech, art, science, and history. are we producing the past in the present?
an important concept is the role of the individual. it is every individuals right to freedom (personal and political). every individual builds his or her own unique base knowledge. when one person sees an object, another may see it differently. meaning varies between individuals as each individual has a different base knowledge. an aeroplane may be a means of transportation for me, but for a native, deep in the papua new guinean jungle it may mean something completely different
identifycharacterizedecide
present
14
.03
.20
08
+..
-
457
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshine
drink our refuge not yet fo
und all full cup woes sank dregs only fool know
s
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a trusting acceptance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs inf
allible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
tim
e th
ough
hidden
mists lik
e fin
ger
wor
ld wit
hout hands
God: One tha
t is worshiped, i
dealized, or follo
wed
God
DECISION TIME
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
characterize decideidentify
present
14
.03
.20
08
-
458
knowledge is relative
every individual has the right to make their own decisions, knowledge is only a guide, and if it is a law then it is dogma, leading to the oppression of the individuals right to make their own discoveries.
identifycharacterizedecide
present
15
.03
.20
08
+..
-
459
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshine
drink our refuge not yet fo
und all full cup woes sank dregs only fool know
s
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a trusting acceptance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs inf
allible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
tim
e th
ough
hidden
mists lik
e fin
ger
wor
ld wit
hout hands
God: One tha
t is worshiped, i
dealized, or follo
wed
God
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
characterize decideidentify
present
15
.03
.20
08
-
460
the public approach art with their own unique base knowledge
art does a good job of deconstructing knowledge; showing the viewer its meaning is relative and temporary by discovering new items or ideas that are thought to be art. the art of today is only a basis or guide for art of the future; it is not a law of the way art should proceed from now on.
identifycharacterizedecide
present
16
.03
.20
08
+..
-
461
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshine
drink our refuge not yet fo
und all full cup woes sank dregs only fool know
s
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a trusting acceptance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs inf
allible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
tim
e th
ough
hidden
mists lik
e fin
ger
wor
ld wit
hout hands
God: One tha
t is worshiped, i
dealized, or follo
wed
God
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
characterize decideidentify
present
16
.03
.20
08
-
462
difficulty with art is how does it proceed with decisions or discoveries if everything can be art
the problem with art is with the individual, every individual is coming from a different point of view, with different wants and needs, with different base knowledge. therefore an art that appeals to everyone is impossible
identifycharacterizedecide
present
17.0
3.2
00
8
+..
-
463
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshine
drink our refuge not yet fo
und all full cup woes sank dregs only fool know
s
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a trusting acceptance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs inf
allible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
tim
e th
ough
hidden
mists lik
e fin
ger
wor
ld wit
hout hands
God: One tha
t is worshiped, i
dealized, or follo
wed
Faith
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
characterize decideidentify
present
17.0
3.2
00
8
-
464
heidegger (1889 1976): most humans are caught up in dealing with the world (falling into inauthentic life)
truth is not conformity between judgement and facts in the world; but truth is self-manifestation, revelation and disclosure (discovery)
identifycharacterizedecide
present
18
.03
.20
08
+..
-
465
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshine
drink our refuge not yet fo
und all full cup woes sank dregs only fool know
s
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a trusting acceptance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs inf
allible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
tim
e th
ough
hidden
mists lik
e fin
ger
wor
ld wit
hout hands
God: One tha
t is worshiped, i
dealized, or follo
wed
Faith
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
characterize decideidentify
present
18
.03
.20
08
-
466
original discoveries and disclosures get covered up in the tradition of discourse (the inauthentic life)
original understanding is not a theoretical life, but one grounded in practical engagement
identifycharacterizedecide
present
19
.03
.20
08
+..
-
467
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshine
drink our refuge not yet fo
und all full cup woes sank dregs only fool know
s
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a trusting acceptance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs inf
allible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
tim
e th
ough
hidden
mists lik
e fin
ger
wor
ld wit
hout hands
God: One tha
t is worshiped, i
dealized, or follo
wed
Faith
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
characterize decideidentify
present
19
.03
.20
08
-
468
hermeneutics is the manner in which human existence is interpreted or engaged with practical things
questions and assertions are both forms of disclosure
identifycharacterizedecide
present
20
.03
.20
08
+..
-
469
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshine
drink our refuge not yet fo
und all full cup woes sank dregs only fool know
s
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a trusting acceptance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs inf
allible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
tim
e th
ough
hidden
mists lik
e fin
ger
wor
ld wit
hout hands
God: One tha
t is worshiped, i
dealized, or follo
wed
Faith
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
characterize decideidentify
present
20
.03
.20
08
-
470
in order to ask a question we must have some understanding of what we are asking about
hermeneutic circle: our questioning is a kind of light which casts a certain pattern on the phenomena, while also filling in our expectation in a way that allows us to ask further questions, thus advance our understanding
identifycharacterizedecide
present
21
.03
.20
08
+..
-
471
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshine
drink our refuge not yet fo
und all full cup woes sank dregs only fool know
s
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a trusting acceptance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs inf
allible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
tim
e th
ough
hidden
mists lik
e fin
ger
wor
ld wit
hout hands
God: One tha
t is worshiped, i
dealized, or follo
wed
Faith
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
characterize decideidentify
present
21
.03
.20
08
-
472
gadamer (1900 2002): very notion of understanding carries the openness to the other person (dialectics)
hermeneutics is the basic constituent structure of human understanding
identifycharacterizedecide
present
22
.03
.20
08
+..
-
473
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshine
drink our refuge not yet fo
und all full cup woes sank dregs only fool know
s
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a trusting acceptance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs inf
allible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
tim
e th
ough
hidden
mists lik
e fin
ger
wor
ld wit
hout hands
God: One tha
t is worshiped, i
dealized, or follo
wed
Faith
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
characterize decideidentify
present
22
.03
.20
08
-
474
understanding is determined by pre judgements (prejudice), these pre judgements form our effective history (objects are grasped through the accumulation of history)
theoretical understanding assumes a detached neutral view point, which at the same time we can see all sides of the matter. we as humans are however finite and situated, so all we can achieve is within our current practices
identifycharacterizedecide
present
23
.03
.20
08
+..
-
475
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshine
drink our refuge not yet fo
und all full cup woes sank dregs only fool know
s
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a trusting acceptance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs inf
allible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
tim
e th
ough
hidden
mists lik
e fin
ger
wor
ld wit
hout hands
God: One tha
t is worshiped, i
dealized, or follo
wed
God
DECISION TIME
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
characterize decideidentify
present
23
.03
.20
08
-
476
human beings are primarily engaged in an activity of making sense of understanding (all that can be understood is language)
hermeneutics must open us up to others, as we remained trapped in our own tradition. to increase our understanding involves the desire to be understood by others and risk ones own assumptions
identifycharacterizedecide
present
24
.03
.20
08
+..
-
477
dream (n) A series of im
ages, ideas, emotions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the m
ind during certain stages of sleep.
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshine
drink our refuge not yet fo
und all full cup woes sank dregs only fool know
s
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a t rusting acceptance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs inf
allible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
tim
e th
ough
hidden
mists lik
e fin
ger
wor
ld wit
hout hands
God: One tha
t is worshiped, i
dealized, or follo
wed
Faith
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
characterize decideidentify
present
24
.03
.20
08
-
478
the past is not so much a recovery of the past, but mediation with the past. the correct exercise of hermeneutics recognizes both historical distance and relation of meaning between the past and us
we can only understand things from where we are now (for texts must correctly identify its own tradition)
identifycharacterizedecide
present
25
.03
.20
08
+..
-
479
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Charity
Superman
find sun one charity heavy day seems w
e're lost teach beggar's name no way mind reels
Charity The theological virtue defined as love directed first toward God but also toward oneself and one's neighbors as objects of God's love
words cannot tell sing well heart feels through night blows fate fall
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill b
ow d
own
an s
erve
you
"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
you
are
our
god
and
our
sons
and
dau
ghte
rs g
od t
oo, u
ntil
the
thir
d an
d fo
urth
gen
erat
ion"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill n
ot w
orsh
ip t
hose
in n
eed"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill o
nly
wors
hip
thos
e wh
o en
tert
ai n
and
giv
e us
ple
asur
e"
Decision made: pleasure. satisfaction, delight; sensuous enjoym
ent; will, discretion, choice.
characterize decideidentify
present
25
.03
.20
08
-
480
hermeneutics is the task of finding common ground or agreement
questioning is better at illuminating the structure of disclosure then assertions or facts?
identifycharacterizedecide
present
26
.03
.20
08
+..
-
481
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshinedrink our refuge not ye
t found all full cup w
oes sank dregs only fool knows
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a trusting acceptance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs inf
allible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
tim
e th
ough
hidden
mists lik
e fin
ger
wor
ld wit
hout hands
God: One tha
t is worshiped, i
dealized, or follo
wed
Faith
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
Decision made: faith: trust especially in religious doctrine; religion; things believed, loyalty De
cisi
on m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
we w
ill s
acri
fice
any
thin
g to
be
good
loya
l cit
izen
s an
d ab
ide
by y
our
com
man
dmen
ts"
Decision made: sacrifice: giving up som
ething for the sake of something else
Decision made: "Abraham offer him as a sacrifice to me"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
Lord
God
if w
e br
eak
one
of y
our
laws
, con
dem
n us
to
hell"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
give
us
fait
h"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
give
us
fait
h"
Decision made: religion: belief in superhum
an controlling power
characterize decideidentify
present
26
.03
.20
08
-
482
is writing the best way to describe history?
arendt (1906 1975): no system can explain history, because history really is a succession of surprises
identifycharacterizedecide
present
27.0
3.2
00
8
+..
-
483
Decision made: dream
: a series of images, ideas, em
otions, and sensations occurring involuntarily in the mind during certain stages of sleep
drink our refuge not yet fo
und all full cup woes sank dregs only fool know
s
faith each us from rut habit his own kingdom
pains life's wreckage hard driven
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a t rusting acceptance of G
od's will
night (n): The period between sunset and sunrise, especially the hours of darkness.
Decision made: tim
e: indefinite continuos duration regarded as dimension.
evening yet w
e go hours weren
't us
ed
hope
Hope: theological virtue defined as the desire and search
for a
f utu
re g
ood,
diffic
ult but n
ot im
poss
ible
to a
ttain
with
God's
help.
persists empt
ied
out
still
shi
nes
sun
beggars waiting gather them up
th
ough
hid
den
mis
ts o
pen
them
long
nig
ht
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we d
esir
e ot
her
gods
to
be b
efor
e us
" God
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
you
mus
t no
t wo
rshi
p sy
mbo
ls o
f yo
ur im
agin
atio
n, y
ou m
ust
wors
hip
god"
cann
ot r
epre
sent
a g
od w
ho is
the
hea
vens
abo
ve, t
he e
arth
and
the
wat
ers
bene
ath
the
eart
h"
2: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
Decision made: desire: unsatisfied longing feeling of potential pleasure in som
ething.
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
bul
l: yo
u ar
e no
t to
hav
e an
y ot
her
gods
Decision made: hope: expectation and desire
Decision made: belief: trust, confidence and acceptance
Decision made: god: superhum
an being worshipped as possessing divine power
Decision made: kingdom
: the realm of this sovereignty
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd:
show
us
how
to w
orsh
ip y
ou g
od
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
you
are
not
to w
orsh
ip a
ny c
arve
d-im
age
or a
ny f
igur
e as
all
imag
es a
re f
init
e an
d
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
"we
nee
d ho
pe"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we h
ope
to s
ee o
ther
god
s so
on"
characterize decideidentify
present
27.0
3.2
00
8
-
484
humans live, rather then have natures
totalitarianism is only possible in modern society, where everything including our sense of reality is managed
identifycharacterizedecide
present
28
.03
.20
08
+..
-
485
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Charity
Superman
find sun one charity heavy day seems w
e're lost teach beggar's name no way mind reels
Charity The theological virtue defined as love directed first toward God but also toward oneself and one's neighbors as objects of God's love
words cannot tell sing well heart feels through night blows fate fall
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill b
ow d
own
an s
erve
you
"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
you
are
our
god
and
our
sons
and
dau
ghte
rs g
od t
oo, u
ntil
the
thir
d an
d fo
urth
gen
erat
ion"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill n
ot w
orsh
ip t
hose
in n
eed"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill o
nly
wors
hip
thos
e wh
o en
tert
ai n
and
giv
e us
ple
asur
e"
Decision made: pleasure: satisfaction, delight; sensuous enjoym
ent; will, discretion, choice.
freeplayworship other gods: movie stars, musicians, superheros, pleasure and entertainment...
characterize decideidentify
present
28
.03
.20
08
-
486
people are endlessly manipulated
despite cataloguing in detail the horror of a totalitarianism system, arendt is always optimistic about the genuinely surprising nature of history
identifycharacterizedecide
present
29
.03
.20
08
+..
-
487
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshinedrink our refuge not ye
t found all full cup w
oes sank dregs o n ly fool knows
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a t rusting accep t ance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs in
fallible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
ti m
e th
ough
hidde
n mists li
ke
f inge
r w
orld
without h
ands
God: One tha
t is worshiped, idealized, or fo
llowed
Faith
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
Decision made: faith: trust especially in religious doctrine; religion; things believed, loyalty De
cisi
on m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
we w
ill s
acri
fice
any
thin
g to
be
good
loya
l cit
izen
s an
d ab
ide
by y
our
com
man
dmen
ts"
Decision made: sacrifice: giving up som
ething for the sake of something else
Decision made: "Abraham offer him as a sacrifice to me"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
Lord
God
if w
e br
eak
one
of y
our
laws
, con
dem
n us
to
hell"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
give
us
fait
h"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
give
us
fait
h"
Decision made: religion: belief in superhum
an controlling power
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Charity
Superman
find sun one charity heavy day seems w
e're lost teach beggar's name no way mind reels
Charity The theological virtue defined as love directed first toward God but also toward oneself and one 's neighbors as objects of God's
love
words cannot tell sing well he art feels through night blows fate fall
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill b
ow d
own
an s
erve
you
"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
you
are
our
god
and
our
sons
and
dau
ghte
rs g
od t
oo, u
ntil
the
thir
d an
d fo
urth
gen
erat
ion"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill n
ot w
orsh
ip t
hose
in n
eed"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill o
nly
wors
hip
thos
e wh
o en
tert
ai n
and
giv
e us
ple
asur
e"
Decision made: pleasure: satisfaction, delight; sensuous enjoym
ent; will, discretion, choice.
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshinedrink our refuge not ye
t found all full cup w
oes sank dregs o n ly fool knows
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a t rusting accep t ance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs in
fallible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
ti m
e th
ough
hidde
n mists li
ke
f inge
r w
orld
without h
ands
God: O
ne that is worshiped, id
ealized, or followe
d
Faith
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
Decision made: faith: trust especially in religious doctrine; religion; things believed, loyalty De
cisi
on m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
we w
ill s
acri
fice
any
thin
g to
be
good
loya
l cit
izen
s an
d ab
ide
by y
our
com
man
dmen
ts"
Decision made: sacrifice: giving up som
ething for the sake of something else
Decision made: "Abraham offer him as a sacrifice to me"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
Lord
God
if w
e br
eak
one
of y
our
laws
, con
dem
n us
to
hell"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
give
us
fait
h"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
give
us
fait
h"
Decision made: religion: belief in superhum
an controlling power
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereigntyCharity
Superman
find sun one charity heavy day seems w
e're lost teach beggar's name no way mind reels
Charity The theological virtue defined as love directed first toward God but also toward oneself and one 's neighbors as objects of God's
love
words cannot tell sing well he art feels through night blows fa te fall
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill b
ow d
own
an s
erve
you
"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
you
are
our
god
and
our
sons
and
dau
ghte
rs g
od t
oo, u
ntil
the
thir
d an
d fo
urth
gen
erat
ion"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill n
ot w
orsh
ip t
hose
in n
eed"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill o
nly
wors
hip
thos
e wh
o en
tert
ai n
and
giv
e us
ple
asur
e"
Decision made: pleasure: satisfaction, delight; sensuous enjoym
ent; will, discretion, choice.
characterize decideidentify
present
29
.03
.20
08
-
488
we are individuals, not abstract humanity
is the theoretical a betrayal of practice?
identifycharacterizedecide
present
30
.03
.20
08
+..
-
489
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshinedrink our refuge not ye
t found all full cup w
oes sank dregs o n ly fool knows
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a t rusting accep t ance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs in
fallible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
ti m
e th
ough
hidde
n mists li
ke
f inge
r w
orld
without h
ands
God: One tha
t is worshiped, idealized, or fo
llowed
Faith
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
Decision made: faith: trust especially in religious doctrine; religion; things believed, loyalty De
cisi
on m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
we w
ill s
acri
fice
any
thin
g to
be
good
loya
l cit
izen
s an
d ab
ide
by y
our
com
man
dmen
ts"
Decision made: sacrifice: giving up som
ething for the sake of something else
Decision made: "Abraham offer him as a sacrifice to me"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
Lord
God
if w
e br
eak
one
of y
our
laws
, con
dem
n us
to
hell"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
give
us
fait
h"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
give
us
fait
h"
Decision made: religion: belief in superhum
an controlling power
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Charity
Superman
find sun one charity heavy day seems w
e're lost teach beggar's name no way mind reels
Charity The theological virtue defined as love directed first toward God but also toward oneself and one 's neighbors as objects of God's
love
words cannot tell sing well he art feels through night blows fa te fall
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill b
ow d
own
an s
erve
you
"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
you
are
our
god
and
our
sons
and
dau
ghte
rs g
od t
oo, u
ntil
the
thir
d an
d fo
urth
gen
erat
ion"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill n
ot w
orsh
ip t
hose
in n
eed"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill o
nly
wors
hip
thos
e wh
o en
tert
ai n
and
giv
e us
ple
asur
e"
Decision made: pleasure: satisfaction, delight; sensuous enjoym
ent; will, discretion, choice.
characterize decideidentify
present
30
.03
.20
08
-
490
modern science and mass communication has a distorted, alienating effect
the power of modern science lies in its detached symbolic power. that allows scientists to take a standpoint that is beyond the world (whilst remaining in the world). just as one is able to map terrain better from an aeroplane, the more one distances itself from the earth; he more one is able to comprehend thought
identifycharacterizedecide
present
31
.03
.20
08
+..
-
491
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshinedrink our refuge not ye
t found all full cup w
oes sank dregs o n ly fool knows
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a t rusting accep t ance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs in
fallible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
ti m
e th
ough
hidde
n mists li
ke
f inge
r w
orld
without h
ands
God: One tha
t is worshiped, idealized, or fo
llowed
Faith
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
Decision made: faith: trust especially in religious doctrine; religion; things believed, loyalty De
cisi
on m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
we w
ill s
acri
fice
any
thin
g to
be
good
loya
l cit
izen
s an
d ab
ide
by y
our
com
man
dmen
ts"
Decision made: sacrifice: giving up som
ething for the sake of something else
Decision made: "Abraham offer him as a sacrifice to me"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
Lord
God
if w
e br
eak
one
of y
our
laws
, con
dem
n us
to
hell"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
give
us
fait
h"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
give
us
fait
h"
Decision made: religion: belief in superhum
an controlling power
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Charity
Superman
find sun one charity heavy day seems w
e're lost teach beggar's name no way mind reels
Charity The theological virtue defined as love directed first toward God but also toward oneself and one 's neighbors as objects of God's
love
words cannot tell sing well he art feels through night blows fa te fall
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill b
ow d
own
an s
erve
you
"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
you
are
our
god
and
our
sons
and
dau
ghte
rs g
od t
oo, u
ntil
the
thir
d an
d fo
urth
gen
erat
ion"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill n
ot w
orsh
ip t
hose
in n
eed"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill o
nly
wors
hip
thos
e wh
o en
tert
ai n
and
giv
e us
ple
asur
e"
Decision made: pleasure: satisfaction, delight; sensuous enjoym
ent; will, discretion, choice.
characterize decideidentify
present
31
.03
.20
08
-
492
art and phenomenology: can the intuitive truth ever be described by words? is philosophy inadequate compared with visual art to illuminate phenomenology
flee to freedom (biblical exodus, go to the other, beyond the world), flee from theory, which is controlling and totalling
identifycharacterizedecide
present
01
.04
.20
08
+..
-
493
sun (n): The radiant energy, especially heat and visible light, emitted by the sun; sunshinedrink our refuge not ye
t found all full cup w
oes sank dregs o n ly fool knows
Faith The theological virtue define
d as secure belief in God and a t rusting accep t ance of G
od's will
sailing search them
day
night
god w
ho sit
s be
gs in
fallible undisputed unresting we go on
filled dumb use
hope persists still s
hines
sun
ti m
e th
ough
hidde
n mists li
ke
f inge
r w
orld
without h
ands
God: One tha
t is worshiped, idealized, or fo
llowed
Faith
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
Decision made: faith: trust especially in religious doctrine; religion; things believed, loyalty De
cisi
on m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
we w
ill s
acri
fice
any
thin
g to
be
good
loya
l cit
izen
s an
d ab
ide
by y
our
com
man
dmen
ts"
Decision made: sacrifice: giving up som
ething for the sake of something else
Decision made: "Abraham offer him as a sacrifice to me"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
Lord
God
if w
e br
eak
one
of y
our
laws
, con
dem
n us
to
hell"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
give
us
fait
h"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
the
cro
wd: "
give
us
fait
h"
Decision made: religion: belief in superhum
an controlling power
drink (v.tr.): To take into the mouth and swallow (a liquid)
kingdom (n): The realm
of this sovereignty
Charity
Superman
find sun one charity heavy day seems w
e're lost teach beggar's name no way mind reels
Charity The theological virtue defined as love directed first toward God but also toward oneself and one 's neighbors as objects of God's
love
words cannot tell sing well he art feels through night blows fa te fall
3: IS THIS IMAGE, GUILTY OF NOT GUILTY IN FALSELY REPRESENTING THE ADORATION OF THE GOLDEN CALF BY NICOLAS POUSSIN?
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
we w
ill b
ow d
own
an s
erve
you
"
Dec
isio
n m
ade:
The
cro
wd: "
you
are
our
god
and
our
sons
and
dau
ghte