the business and property court disclosure pilot€¦ · •part 51.2.10 of the white book 2019is...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
23es.co
mThe
Business and Property CourtDisclosure Pilot
- six months in
Tom Gosling Asa Tolson Micheál Murphy
27th June 2019
![Page 2: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
23es.co
m
The DisclosurePilot Scheme
Practice Direction 51U
![Page 3: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
23es.co
m
Why the Change?• Excessive cost, scale, and complexity
of disclosure• Large quantities of wholly irrelevant
documents• Unnecessary searches• Judges not effectively dealing with
disclosure at CCMC• Standard disclosure as default option
even in less complex cases
![Page 4: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
23es.co
mWhen does it apply?
Applies• From 1 January 2019 for 2 years• Business and Property Courts• New AND existing proceedings• If order made in BPC and transferred out,
order still applies
Does Not Apply• County Court (even if business and
property work)• Competition claims• Public procurement claims• Intellectual Property and Enterprise Court• Doesn't extend PD 63, para. 6.1 in
Patents Court• Admiralty Court• Shorter and Flexible Trials Scheme• Fixed Costs regime or Capped Costs
Regime• Does not alter existing order for
disclosure unless varied/set aside
![Page 5: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
23es.co
mThe Concepts• Issues for Disclosure• Initial Disclosure• Extended Disclosure• Models of Extended Disclosure ('Menu of Options')• Standard Disclosure (Model D) no longer the norm
![Page 6: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
23es.co
mDuties of the Parties• Co-operate to assist Court so that scope of disclosure
agreed/determined in most efficient way possible• Take reasonable steps to preserve relevant documents• Disclose known adverse documents• Comply with disclosure orders• Undertake searches in responsible and conscientious manner• Act honestly both in giving documents and reviewing other side's• Reasonable efforts to avoid providing irrelevant documents• All continuing duties
![Page 7: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
23es.co
mDuties of the Representatives
• Co-operate to assist Court so that scope of disclosure agreed/determined in most efficient way possible• Take reasonable steps to preserve relevant documents• Reasonable steps to advise and assist client to comply with disclosure
duties• Liaise and cooperate with other side to promote reliable, efficient and
cost-effective conduct of disclosure• Act honestly in process of giving disclosure and reviewing documents
disclosed by other side• Undertake a review to satisfy any privilege claim is properly made and
reason for claim to privilege sufficiently explained• All continuing duties
![Page 8: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
23es.co
mPreservation of Documents• Duty to:
• Suspend deletion/destruction processes• Send written notification to all relevant employees and former employees:
• Identify documents/classes of documents to preserve• Notify recipient not delete or destroy and take reasonable steps to preserve
• Take reasonable steps so agents/third parties who may hold documents do not destroy/delete documents relevant to an issue
• Legal reps within reasonable period of being instructed:• Notify client of need to preserve docs and obligations para. 3.1• Obtain written confirmation from client or appropriate representative of client
that taken steps required under para. 4.2 and 4.3• Confirm in writing when serve POC/Defence that steps taken to preserve
relevant documents as required by PD
![Page 9: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
23es.co
mClient Disclosure Letter• Why the need?
• When?
• Para 3.2(2)• Para 4.4(1)• Para 4.4(2)• Para 4.5
• With retainer letter
![Page 10: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
23es.co
mClient Disclosure Letter• What should it do? • Purpose of disclosure
• Define disclosure• Define documents• Duties
• Document preservation• Written notification to
employees and former employees (para 4.3)
• Procedure• Initial Disclosure• Known adverse documents
• Written Confirmation (para 4.4(2)
![Page 11: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
23es.co
mInitial Disclosure• At time of POC/Defence• Not apply to Part 8. Not apply to CF without POC• Initial Disclosure List of Documents• File and Serve• Key documents relied on• Key documents necessary for other parties to understand case• Brief description of searches already undertaken• Copies of documents in e-form (unless otherwise agreed) to be
served but not filed• List (but no need to provide) documents already provided after
intimation of proceedings
![Page 12: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
23es.co
mInitial Disclosure• No further search should be required at this stage• No need to translate documents• No more than 200 documents/1000 pages• Obligations of PD16, para. 7.3 continue to apply• Out of Jurisdiction – Initial Disclosure not required until D
files AOS not contesting jurisdiction, or one under CPR 11(7)(b)
![Page 13: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
23es.co
mKnown Adverse Documents
Paragraph 5.1• "the key documents on which
it has relied... including the documents referred to in that statement of case"• "the key documents that are
necessary to enable the other parties to understand the claim or defence they have to meet"
Paragraph 3.1(2)• "once proceedings have
commenced against it or by it and in accordance with the provisions of this pilot scheme, to disclose,regardless of any order for disclosure made, known adverse documents unless they are privileged"
![Page 14: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
23es.co
mDispensing with Initial Disclosure• Agreement (para. 5.8):
• Parties agree to dispense with or defer• Must record reasons• Reasons must be available to Court at CCMC• Court can set aside
• Court order (para. 5.10):• If one party want to dispense with, can apply• App notice, evidence where necessary• Dealt with on paper or at short telephone hearing• If would incur disproportionate cost or be unduly complex
• Extensive Documents:• If more than 1000 pages or 200 documents, requirement to give ID ceases
![Page 15: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
23es.co
mExtended Disclosure
![Page 16: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
23es.co
mED - Procedural Outline
Stage PD Ref
Time
1 All parties state in writing whether likely to request ED Models B-E 7.1 Within 28 days of the closure of statements of case
2 Where one or more parties indicated, C must prepare draft List of Issues for Disclosure (“LID”)
7.2 Within 42 days of the closure of statements of case
3 Ds proposed wording or alternative wording to LID 7.5 SAP, no later 14 days after service draft LID
4 Parties must discuss and seek to agree LID and indicate Model sought for each party using 1A Disclosure Review Document (“DRD”)
7.6 In advance of CMC
5 Party proposing Model C must complete and provide 1B DRD 10.5 No later than 28 days after step 3
![Page 17: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
23es.co
mED - Procedural Outline Cont..
Stage PD Ref
Time
6 Any party provided with 1B DRD must complete “response” column 10.5 Within 14 days of receiving 1B DRD
7 Parties prepare and exchange drafts s2 DRD incl cost and document no. estimates
10.6 SARP, not less than 14 days before CMC
8 Parties must seek to resolve any disputes over the scope of any ED sought
10.7 Before CMC
9 C must file single joint DRD 10.8 No later 5 days before CMC
10 Parties must independently file signed Certificate of Compliance (Appendix 3)
10.9 SARP after JDRD
![Page 18: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
23es.co
m
Standard Disclosure is Dead
![Page 19: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
23es.co
m
Transitional “grace” and
hardening judicial Attitudes
![Page 20: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
23es.co
mJustification
application of test of reasonableness and proportionality at each stage.
![Page 21: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
23es.co
mIssues for Disclosure“means for the purposes of disclosure only those key issues in dispute, which theparties consider will need to be determined by the court with some reference tocontemporaneous documents in order for there to be a fair resolution of theproceedings. It does not extend to every issue which is disputed in the statementsof case by denial or non-admission.”
• List of Issues for Disclosure (“LID”)• Claimant responsible for production• “fair and balanced summary”• Key areas of dispute arising from pleadings• In respect of which likely at least one party seeking ED
![Page 22: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
23es.co
mDisclosure Review DocumentThe “DRD”1A – Issues and Proposed Disclosure Models1B – Model C Requests2 -Questionnaire
![Page 23: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
23es.co
m
Model ADisclosure confined to known adverse documents
![Page 24: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
23es.co
mModel BLimited Disclosure
1. Key documents relied upon in support of statements of case
2. Key documents necessary for other parties to understand claim or defence they have to meet
3. Known adverse documents4. NO SEARCH
![Page 25: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
23es.co
mModel CRequest-led search-based disclosure
disclosure of particular documents or narrow classes ofdocuments relating to a particular Issue for Disclosure, byreference to requests set out in or to be set out in Section1B of the Disclosure Review Document or otherwise definedby the court.
![Page 26: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
23es.co
mModel DNarrow search-based disclosure, with or without Narrative Documents
a party shall disclose documents which are likely to support or adversely affect its claim or defence or that of another party in relation to one or more of the Issues for Disclosure.
required to undertake a reasonable and proportionate search
![Page 27: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
23es.co
mModel EWide search-based disclosure
a party shall disclose documents which are likely to support oradversely affect its claim or defence or that of another party inrelation to one or more of the Issues for Disclosure or which maylead to a train of inquiry which may then result in the identificationof other documents for disclosure…
Only to be ordered in exceptional cases
Includes narrative documents unless otherwise ordered
![Page 28: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
23es.co
mRecent Updates• Disclosure Pilot Scheme in the Insolvency and Companies
Court – Guidance of Chief Registrar Briggs• DPS applies to the Insolvency and Companies List but not to
PD 51P on Insolvency Express Trials;• Section 994 – 996 Companies Act 2006; and• Winding up on Just and Equitable ground
![Page 29: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
23es.co
mPart 8 Claims• Guidance provided by Chief Master Marsh• The DPS does not directly apply to Part 8 claims because Part 8
contains its own regime for the disclosure of documents relied on by the parties.• The wording in paragraph 5.1 of PD 51U is designed to ensure
that the provisions relating to Initial Disclosure do not overlap with, and duplicate, provisions in Part 8.• The court has power to make an order for Extended Disclosure
under the DPS in a Part 8 claim.
![Page 30: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
23es.co
mUTB LLC v Sheffield United Ltd [2019] EWHC 914 (Chd)• DPS applies to all relevant proceedings subsisting in the
Business and Property Courts whether they commenced before 01 January 2019 even in a case where a disclosure order was made before 01 January 2019 under CPR Part 31.• Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019 is wrong.• The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD
51U) refer to concepts such as Extended Disclosure and Lists of Issues for Disclosure (concepts that did not exist before 1 January 2019) does not make the DPS any less applicable to cases in the B&PCs after that date.
![Page 31: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
23es.co
m
• Inspection of Privilege• Point of the Pilot is to effect a "culture change" and the
Pilot is not simply a "re-write of part 31". "It operates along different lines driven by reasonableness and proportionality (see paragraph 2 of PD51U), with disclosure being directed specifically to defined issues arising in the proceedings."• Extended Disclosure is "not a tactic, let alone a
weapon" but is about the "just and proportionate resolution of the real issues in dispute"
UTB LLC v Sheffield United Ltd [2019] EWHC 914 (Chd)
![Page 32: The Business and Property Court Disclosure Pilot€¦ · •Part 51.2.10 of the White Book 2019is wrong. •The fact that paragraph 18 (and other paragraphs of PD 51U) refer to concepts](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042119/5e994606415cfd06ac59d56e/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
23es.co
mKey Points• Think about disclosure from the outset;• Client Disclosure Letter;
• Document preservation;• Defining Documents;• Explaining Disclosure• Obtain Written Confirmation from Client that they understand their
obligations.• Initial Disclosure at the time of the Letter of Claim;• List of Issues – representing a fair and balanced summary of
areas of dispute arising from the pleadings;• Extended Disclosure – Consider the appropriate model; and• Embrace the new culture!