the design of accountable care organizations
DESCRIPTION
Pillars for Accountable Care PCMH versus ACOs Core competencies Six core structural components of successful ACO deployment Pioneer ACO burn and learn lessons Barriers & root cause analysis Patient attribution Five modes of Accountable Care Early value-based adopters Value discovery assessment Modified Triple Aim GPRO Breakdown by 33 MeasuresTRANSCRIPT
CONTENT
Pillars for Accountable Care
PCMH versus ACOs
Core competencies
Six core structural components of successful ACO deployment
Pioneer ACO burn and learn lessons
Barriers & root cause analysis
Patient attribution
Five modes of Accountable Care
Early value-based adopters
Value discovery assessment
Modified Triple Aim
GPRO
Breakdown by 33 Measures
PILLARS OF ACCOUNTABLE CARE
Provider-led
Providers and payers co-own responsibility for the cost and quality of care provided to a defined population; shifts both rewards and risks to aligned, integrated care systems
Population attribution to ACOs, with opt-outs and choice
Health engagement/wellness initiatives that are tailored to the individual
Diverse group of providers, including hospitals, specialists, primary care, and post-acute care, that can coordinate across settings
Robust health information technology infrastructure and performance measurement capacity
Providers and payers share population-based data on a timely basis
Long-term partnerships with a range of payment options
DIFFERENTIATING PCMH FROM AN ACO
P A T I E N T C E N T E R E D
M E D I C A L H O M E
Created in 2007 to better access, care coordination to build strong relationship between the PCP and patient.
Payers provide a per member per month bonus for PCP services
A C C O U N T A B L E C A R E
O R G A N I Z A T I O N
Strong PCP core also, but comprised of many medical homes.
ACOs are accountable for cost/quality within and outside the PCP relationship
ACO CORE COMPETENCIES
SIX CORE STRUCTURAL COMPONENTS OF SUCCESSFUL ACO DEPLOYMENT
A commitment to providing care that puts people at the center of all clinical decision-making
A health home that provides primary and preventive care
Population health and data management capabilities
A provider network that delivers top outcomes at a reduced cost
An established ACO governance structure
Payer partnership arrangements
PIONEER ACO BURN AND LEARN LESSONS
Mortality rate was high. One-third dropped.
Of that one-third, seven re-organized and entered the MSSP.
One of the key challenges for hospitals and physicians is that the incentives are to
reduce hospital stays, emergency room visits and expensive specialist and testing
services — all the ways that hospitals and physicians make money in the current fee-
for-service system.
All 32 Pioneers succeeded in improving quality and performed better than fee-for-service
Medicare in 15 quality measures
CURRENT BARRIERS & ROOT CAUSE ANALYSIS
Multispecialty group formation, umbrella alignment is difficult with income dispersion
Size of the patient population, with a 5,000 as minimum ante to play
Cultural: human centered, physician-led, continuous improvement, flexibility
Resources, PCPs drive-but specialists operate the pedals
Staffing, PCP shortage
Lack of measure continuity, different payouts with different models at once
Market-based, disease specificity and prevalence will never allow for a one size fits all
Legal: anti-trust, anti-kickback, and self-referral Stark Law
PATIENT ATTRIBUTION IN ACOS
Patient-based vs. Episode Based
Patient-based holds the provider accountable for the entire spectrum
Episode assigns provider (s) from symptoms onset to completed treatment
Single attribution vs. Multiple attribution
SA assigns to provider with highest percentage of patient’s cost, minimum
threshold 25-35%, while MA is assigned when threshold is not met typically
Prospective (historical claims) vs. Retrospective (actual utilization)
Blend
RISK STRATIFICATION IN POPULATION HEALTH MANAGEMENT
Wellness scores answers the question of who are my ACO patients that could
benefit clinically and financially from an engagement campaign. Over 100
variables affect this score, but here are a few examples:
Patient's health risks as identified by a health risk appraisal form or other
questionnaire
Clinical diagnoses
Utilization data from insurer or other source (lab, pharma, PACS, claims,
mHealth or remote monitoring)
Clinician’s personal knowledge related to a patient’s social, financial,
mental, or physical condition
FIVE MODES OF ACCOUNTABLE CARE
ACO READINESS ASSESSMENT
Questions designed for your initiative and readiness around:
Organizational structure and commitment
Proposed network
Value-based experience
Open component technologies
Quality and care management
Retention strategy and growth plan
DATA SHARING
Q U A R T E R L Y A G G R E G A T E
R E P O R T S
Will be based on previous 12
months of data and include:
• Financial performance
• Quality performance scores
• Aggregated metrics on the
assigned beneficiary
population
• Utilization by Subpopulation
M O N T H L Y C L A I M S D A T A
Can request a standardized
dataset:
• Procedure codes
• Diagnosis codes
• Dates of service
• Provider/supplier ID
• Part D data
ACTIVATING ACCOUNTABLE PATIENTS
Patients need to share in their own accountability, and some tips reside here. Much can be
achieved through a comprehensive Patient Portal with these ACO quality metrics satisfied:
CAHPS: Getting Timely Care, Appointments, and information
CAHPS: How Well Your Doctors Communicate
CAHPS: Patients’ Rating of Doctor
CAHPS: Access to Specialists
CAHPS: Health Promotion and Education
CAHPS: Shared Decision Making
CAHPS: Health Status/Functional Status
ACO MEASURES: CARE COORDINATION/ PATIENT SAFETY
Measure Care Coordination/ Patient
Safety
Physician Description & Objectives
8 All Condition Readmission Avoid readmissions by seeing your patients within 7 days following
inpatient discharge
9, 10 COPD, Asthma & CHF Avoid unnecessary admission of COPD, Asthma and CHF patients by
seeing them on a monthly basis
11 EMR Incentive Program
Payment in 2014
Attest for Meaningful Use in 2014 (either Medicaid or Medicare)
12 Medication Reconciliation Physician must perform med rec and document that he/she is aware of
inpatient facility discharge meds and will either keep or change meds
13 Screening for Fall Risk Screen patient for falls risk in office
ACO MEASURES: PREVENTIVE HEALTH
Measure Care Coordination/ Patient
Safety
Physician Description & Objectives
14 Influenza Immunization Provide or document that patient received infu imm
15 Pneumococcal Vaccination Provide or document that patient received pneu vac
16 Adult Weight Screening
AND Follow-up
Calculate BMI – If abnormal, document follow-up plan (education, Rx
intervention, diet & exercise, etc.)
17 Tobacco Use Assessment
AND Tobacco Cessation
Intervention
Screen for tobacco use – If user, provide & document cessation counseling
(includes counseling & pharmacotherapy
18 Depression Screening AND
Follow-up
Screen for Depression – If patient is depressed, document and provide
follow-up (additional evaluation, Rx intervention, suicide risk assessment)
19 Colorectal Cancer Screening FOBT – last 12 months, Flex Sig – Last 4 years and Colonoscopy – last 9
years
20 Mammography Screening Mammogram performed within the last 24 months
21 Pressure Measurement AND
Recommended Follow-Up
Plan is Documented
Screen for high blood pressure – If patient has BP greater than 120/80,
rescreen and provide lifestyle modifications (i.e. NA intake, diet and
exercise, etc.)
ACO MEASURES: AT RISK POPULATION
Measure At Risk Population Physician Description & Objectives
22 Hemoglobin A1c Control
(<8 percent)
Control DM patient’s HbA1c - below 8%. Follow ACO’s HbA1c goal
attainment protocols
23 Low Density Lipoprotein
(<100)
Control DM patient’s LDL - below 100. Follow ACO’s LDL goal attainment
protocols
24 Blood Pressure (<140/90) Refer to measure 21
25 Tobacco Non Use Advise patient to quit tobacco use
26 Aspirin Use Provide patients with DM and IVD a daily aspirin or
antiplatelet medication
27 Hemoglobin A1c Poor
Control
(>9 percent)
Control DM patient’s HbA1c with goal of below 8%.
Follow ACO’s HbA1c goal attainment protocols
28 Blood Pressure Control
(<140/90)
Control HTN patient’s BP with goal of <140/90
29 Complete Lipid Profile AND
LDL
Control (<100 mg/dl)
Document and complete lipid profile AND control LDLC
(<100 mg/dl)
ACO MEASURES: AT RISK POPULATION
Measure At Risk Population Physician Description & Objectives
30 Use of Aspirin or Another
Antithrombotic
Provide patients with IVD a daily aspirin or
antithrombotic medication
Heart Failure
31 Beta-Blocker Therapy for
LVSD
(EF <40%)
Patients with Dx of HF and w/ a LVEF <40% should be
on beta blocker therapy (bisoprolol, carevdilol, or
sustained release metoprolol succinate)
Coronary Artery Disease
32 Drug Therapy for Lowering
LDLCholesterol
Patients with CAD need documented plan for LDL
control
33 MediACE Inhibitor or ARB
Therapy
for Patient with CAD and
DM
and/or LVSDcation
Reconciliation
ACE Inhibitor or ARB Therapy for Patient with CAD and
DM and/or LVSD (LVSD - patients with EF <40%)
GPRO
The majority of measurements require submission through the CMS GPRO web
interface tool, and you will need architecture to map data and populates the
GPRO for reporting of measurements. There are a few recommendations for
vendors I will make, but all accomplish the following:
Prepares and sends the report to the CMS GPRO web interface
Provides a flexible reporting tool
Assembles EMR data with Primary Care Physician data behind the scenes
Displays CMS feedback from the GPRO
MODIFIED TRIPLE AIM
Care Experience
Per capita cost
Patient/Provider Satisfaction
Population Health
Satisfaction of the patient
and provider is paramount
with ACO final rule
For a free copy of this deck, ROI
spreadsheet, or the Discovery
Assessment, please contact:
CJ Fulton
618-579-9192