the earliest occupation of europe. proceedings of the european science foundation workshop at...
TRANSCRIPT
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 1/342
OIONHAV,TROH@EQVKREAO
NHEFHIQEO
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 2/342
Qefhstkih Trhss O ihw mhihrotek i kg Tubne s`eim
Uku orh rhofeim o gunn vhrseki kg t`es bkkl, gkr grhh!
V`es bkkl es port kg t`h Qefhstkih h-nebrory w`hrh ckst kg kur
pubneaotekis orh gunny oaahssebnh gkr grhh. Gkr oaahss tk ckrh
grhh bkkls veset: www.sefhstkih.akc/nebrory
Fkwinkof Gunn TFG
Weset t`h Qefhstkih h-nebrory tk fkwinkof ckst kg kur h-bkkls gkr
kiny ₮ 6,84. Gkr t`es ceiecon ghh yku wenn rhahevh o gunny guiatekion
TFG oif by fkeim sk, yku `hnp tk lhhp kur nebrory ruiieim.
www.sefhstkih.akc/nebrory
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 3/342
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 4/342
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 5/342
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 6/342
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 7/342
OIONHAVO
TROH@EQVKREAO
NHEFHIQEO
TXBNEAOVEKIQ KG V@H EIQVEVXVH KG TRH@EQVKRU
V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH:
TRKAHHFEIMQ KG V@H HXRKTHOI QAEHIAH GKXIFOVEKI
]KRLQ@KT OV VOXVOWHN (GROIAH), ?551
HFEVHF BU ]EN RKHBRKHLQ OIF V@EJQ WOI LKNGQA@KVHI
XIEWHRQEVU KG NHEFHI ?558
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 8/342
Tubnes`hf ei akkphroteki wet` t`h Hurkphoi Qaehiah Gkuifoteki
hfetkreon akccetthh: N.T. Nkuwh Lkkejcois/A.A. Bolhns
hfeteki kg t`es vknuch: ]. Rkhbrkhls / V`. voi Lkngsa`kthi
EQQI 4?75-=66=
EQBI 54-=1170-4=-1
Mrop`ea fhsemi: @.O. fh Nkrc
Akpyrem`t ?558 Goaunty kg Trh- oif Trktk`estkry
Qubsareptekis tk t`h shrehs Oionhato Troh`estkreao Nhefhiseo oif seimnh vknuchs aoi bh krfhrhf
hxanusevhny ot:
Eistetuth kg Trh`estkry
T.K. Bkx 58?8
2144 RO Nhefhi
V`h Iht`hrnoifs.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 9/342
akithits
]en Rkhbrkhls oif V`ejs voi Lkngsa`kthi: V`h Voutovhn wkrls`kp:
oi eitrkfuateki /
? Nues Ropksk oif Coiuhn Qoitkijo: V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph:
t`h Ebhreoi phieisuno =
2 Corm`hreto Cusse: V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: Etony 2=
1 Oifrhos Fornos: V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: t`h Bonlois 8?
6 Ielknoe F. Trosnkv: V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg t`h Russeoi Tnoei: o s`krt ikth 7/
8 Lorhn Wonka`: V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: Hosthri Ahitron oif Qkut`hosthri
Hurkph 7=
7 Fehtrea` Coieo: V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: t`h Hnbh-Qoonh rhmeki
(Mhrcoiy) 08
= Mhr`orf Bkseisle: V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: ]hsthri Ahitron Hurkph ?41
0 Jhoi-Toun Royion, Nekihn Comkmo oif Ththr Beifki: Vhp`rkgoats oif t`h gerst
`ucoi kaaupoteki kg t`h Grhia` Cosseg Ahitron ?25
5 Onoei Vuggrhou oif Tehrrh Oitkeih: V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: Akiteihiton
Ikrt`whsthri Hurkph ?6=
?4 Corl B. Rkbhrts, Anevh Q. Mocbnh oif Fovef R. Brefmnoif: V`h hornehst kaaupoteki
kg Hurkph: t`h Bretes` Esnhs ?78
?? Jkrmhi @knc oif Nors Norsski: V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: Qaoifeioveo ?51
?2 Wossenej T. Njubei oif Mhr`orf Bkseisle: V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg t`h Aouaosus
rhmeki 24=
?1 Jhoi-Toun Royion, Nekihn Comkmo, Goteco-Zk`ro Qbe`e-Onokue oif Fhies Mhroofs:
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Otnoitea Ckrkaak: t`h Aosobnoiao hvefhiah 288
?6 Mhr`orf Bkseisle: Qtkih orthgoats kg t`h Hurkphoi Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea:
o s`krt ikth 271
?8 Cortei J. Oetlhi: A`rkikchtrea tha`iequhs gkr t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih 275
?7 Anevh Q. Mocbnh: V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: t`h hiverkichitonboalmrkuif 2=5
?= ]en Rkhbrkhls oif V`ejs voi Lkngsa`kthi: V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph:
o rhopproeson kg orthgoatuon oif a`rkiknkmeaon hvefhiah 25=
Mhihron Eifhx 1?=
Qeth Eifhx 125
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 10/342
oalikwnhfmchits
V`h prkfuateki kg t`es vknuch wos pkssebnh t`rkum` t`h mroaekus akkphroteki kg t`h
gknnkweim phkpnh: Cs L. Ghiihco (Nhefhi), Cs A. @orfhcoi-Woi Lkngsa`kthi (Whhihi-
foon), Cr @.O. fh Nkrc (Nhefhi), Cs E. Thrhero (Nhefhi), Fr C. Qtrhht (Ihuwehf),
Fr O. Vurihr (Nevhrpkkn) oif hsphaeonny Cs K. Uoths-]oifhrs (Nhefhi). Geioiaeon suppkrt
aoch grkc t`h Hurkphoi Qaehiah Gkuifoteki, V`h Iht`hrnoifs Krmoiezoteki gkr QaehitegeaRhshora` (I]K-TEKIEHR) oif t`h Goaunty kg Trh- oif Trktk`estkry kg Nhefhi Xievhrsety.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 11/342
wen Rkhbrkhls V`h Voutovhn wkrls`kp: oi eitrkfuatekiV`ejs voi Lkngsa`kthi
Hurkph fhrevhs ets ioch grkc ets pkseteki rhnotevh tk t`h
resh oif shtteim kg t`h sui: ki Ossyreoi ckiuchits t`h
akitrost bhtwhhi Osu. "(t`h noif kg) t`h reseim sui" oif
hrhb kr ereb, ("t`h noif kg) forlihss" kr "t`h shtteim sui",
es grhquhit, oif t`hsh wkrfs orh akisefhrhf tk `ovh mevhi
resh tk t`h iochs kg Oseo oif Hurkph.' Et wos ei t`es sconn
oif fhishny pkpunothf "forl" akiteihit t`ot t`h oitequety
kg `ucoileif wos gerst fhckistrothf, ei t`h ahitron fhaofhs
kg t`h ieihthhit` ahitury. Grkc t`h shakif `ong kg t`ot
ahitury kiworfs eiiuchrobnh prkghssekion oif ocothur
ora`oaknkmests sarhhihf hxpksurhs onn kvhr Hurkph ei oi
hxthisevh shora` gkr ponohknet`ea orthgoats oif gkssens oif sk
akitrebutaf tk o `em` quonety fotobosh, wet`kut poronnhns ei
kt`hr akiteihits ei thrcs kg spoteon oif a`rkiknkmeaon
fhisety kg socpneim pkeits. Uht fhspeth onckst kih oif o
`ong ahitury kg rhshora` ei Hurkph aurrhit hvefhiah strkimny
pkeits tk Ogreao os t`h pnoah w`hrh t`h `ucoi neihomh
kremeiothf, t`kum` t`h bunl kg hvefhiah t`hrh wos aknnhathf
ei t`h nost t`rhh fhaofhs kiny. Ogreao wetihsshf t`h "fowi"
kg `ucoileif w`enh Hurkph wos stenn oi 'Hcpty Akiteihit'
(Fhiihnn ?501), o truh noif kg (`kceief) forlihss.
V`h eithrprhtoteki kg t`h `em` quonety rhakrf kg t`h
hornehst kaaupoteki kg t`es akiteihit wos ot stolh kiIkvhcbhr ?5t` oif 2()t`. ?551, w`hi o mrkup kg
ponohknet`ea ora`ohknkmests oif rhprhshitotevhs kg kt`hr
fesaepneihs (Gem. ?) cht ot t`h Ahitrh Hurkphhi fh
Rha`hra`hs Tre`estkrequhs ot Voutovhn (Groiah), gkr o
wkrls`kp ki t`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph (Rkhbrkhls
?556). Voutovhn wos a`kshi os t`h vhiuh bhaoush kg
reuiich fh Voutovhn's kbvekus osskaeoteki wet` t`h t`hch
kg t`h wkrls`kp, t`ot wos vhry leifny `ksthf by @. Fh
Nucnhy oif chcbhrs kg `es stogg.
V`h Voutovhn chhteim etshng wos krmoiezhf by t`h t`hi
ihwny hstobnes`hf Ihtwkrl ki t`h Tonohknet`ea Kaaupoteki
kg Hurkph, guifhf by t`h Hurkphoi Qaehiah Gkuifoteki
(Qtrosbkurm)2. V`h wkrls`kp akisesthf kg twk gunn foys kg
fesausseki ki t`h boses kg prh-aeraunothf pophrs, w`ksh
upfothf vhrsekis akistetuth t`h bunl kg t`es vknuch1. V`h
oec kg t`h Voutovhn chhteim wos tk fesauss oif rhvehw t`h
hvefhiah akiahrieim t`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg t`h Hurkphoi
rhmekis, grkc Qaoifeioveo tk t`h Chfethrroihoi oif grkc
t`h Xiethf Leimfkc tk t`h Russeoi Tnoeis, oif eianufeim
ihem`bkureim orhos sua` os t`h Aouaosus oif ikrt`hri
Ogreao. V`h fesausseki gkaushf ki gkur t`hchs: a`rkiknkmy
(a`oerhf by Onoei Vuggrhou), hiverkichit (a`oerhf by Anevh
Mocbnh), eifustrehs (a`oerhf by Mhr`orf Bkseisle), oif
subsesthiah (a`oerhf by Aot`hreih Gorezy). V`hsh ethcs whrh
fesausshf ei hxthisk, oif skch kg t`h fesausseki es rhgnhathf
ei gkur syit`hteaon akitrebutekis tk t`es vknuch: Oetlhi's
pophr oif Rkhbrkhls oif Woi Lkngsa`kthi fhon wet`
vorekus osphats kg a`rkiknkmy, t`h hiverkichiton
boalmrkuifs kg t`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph orh
hxthisevhny rhvehwhf by Mocbnh's akitrebuteki, w`enh kih
kg Bkseisle's akitrebutekis es o s`krt rhvehw kg Hurkphoi
Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea stkih eifustrehs. Qubsesthiah osphats
prkvhf tk bh o tkpea gkr o sphaeon chhteim, choiw`enh
`hnf ot Ckirhpks (Ihuwehf, Mhrcoiy) ei Coy ?558
(Moufzeisle oif Vurihr ?558).
Whry vevef whrh t`h Voutovhn fesaussekis ki t`h omh kg
Hurkph's gerst kaaupoteki. Fhspeth t`h normh iucbhrs kg
chhteims fhvkthf tk Hurkph's gerst troahs kg shttnhchit t`h
foths mevhi tk t`h gerst "Hurkphois" vory wefhny (ag. Mocbnh,
t`es vknuch< Rkhbrkhls oif Woi Lkngsa`kthi, t`es vknuch),
wet` skch prkpkihits kg o nkim a`rkiknkmy summhsteim t`ot
Hurkph wos onrhofy kaaupehf ei t`h hornehr ports kg t`hHorny Tnhestkahih, w`hrhos kt`hrs kpt gkr (semiegeaoitny)
nothr kaaupoteki. O ihw oif vhry s`krt "poi-Hurkphoi"
a`rkiknkmy wos ofvkaothf by kur akitrebuteki tk t`h
Voutovhn chhteim (Rkhbrkhls oif Woi Lkngsa`kthi, t`es
vknuch). O fhtoenhf rhopproeson kg orthgoatuon oif
a`rkiknkmeaon - hsphaeonny bekstrotemrop`eaon - hvefhiah
gkr t`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph nhf us tk strhss t`h
fegghrhiahs bhtwhhi t`h hvefhiah grkc bhgkrh oif ogthr
obkut 844 Lyr BT (Rkhbrkhls oif Woi Lkngsa`kthi, t`es
vknuch: Vobnh ?)< wh eithrprhthf t`hsh fegghrhiahs os
eifeaoteim t`ot t`hrh es ik prkkg kg `ucoi kaaupoteki kg
Hurkph prekr tk obkut 844 Lyr BT.
Fesausseim t`h chrets kg t`h vorekus nkim oif s`krt
a`rkiknkmehs gkr t`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph - kr gkr
t`ot cotthr kg oiy akiteihit - es ikt just obkut mhtteim t`h
foths rem`t, but ckrh ecpkrtoitny, obkut `kw tk troisnoth
ets rea` Tonohknet`ea rhakrf eitk choieimgun sahioreks gkr
`ucoi bh`ovekuron hvknuteki: eg wkrlhrs nelh Bkiegoy
(shh Bkiegoy oif Woifhrchhrsa` ?55?) oif Akpphis
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 12/342
2 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. ?. V`h porteaepoits kg t`h Voutovhn ]krls`kp:?: J.T. Royion, 2: N. Ropksk, 1: N Norsski, 6: A. Mocbnh, 8: C. Rkbhrts, 7: O. Vuggrhou, =: C. Qporrhbkkc, 0: T. Oitkeih, 5: L. Wonka`,?4: H. Breia`-Ththrshi, ??: V. voi Lkngsa`kthi, ?2: O. Fornos, ?1: C. Qoitkijo, ?6: C. Oetlhi, ?8: @. Fh Nucnhy, ?7: W. Njubei, ?=: C.-O. FhNucnhy-]kkfyhor, ?0: J. Nhkpknf, ?5: ]. Rkhbrkhls, 24: M. Bkseisle, 2? : C. Cusse, 22: A. Gorezy, 21: J. Akcbehr, 26: I. Trosnkv.Bh eif t`h aochro: N. Comkmo (eivethf, but uiobnh tk otthif: F. Coieo, A. Thrhttk).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 13/342
1 ]EN RKHBRKHLQ OIF V@EJQ WOI LKNGQA@KVHI - V@H VOXVOWHN ]KRLQ@KT
{ue Oalhrcoi ?505) orh rem`t oif Hurkph wos gerst kaaupehf
oe obkut 2 Cyr omk, sua` sahioreks akunf ofkpt ckrh
mrofuonestea phrsphatevhs, wen` `kceiefs `oveim pnhity kg
tech tk ofope tk t`h ihw hiverkichits kg t`es akiteihit,
w`hrh t`h anecoteh ksaennotekis kg' t`h Tnhestkahih whrh tk
`ovh vhry prkgkuif hgghats. Eg ki t`h kt`hr `oif kaaupoteki
wos semiegeaoitny nothr, gkr eistoiah grkc t`h Ceffnh
Tnhestkahih kiworfs, sahioreks cem`t thif tk bh ckrh
puiatuothf, wet` ecpkrtoit ecpneaotekis gkr t`h rhsuntoit
ckfhnneim kg `ucoi bh`ovekur (Fhiihnn ?501< Mocbnh, t`es
vknuch< Rkhbrkhls oif Woi Lkngsa`kthi ?556, t`es
vknuch). Trkpkihits kg bkt` nkimhr oif s`krt a`rkiknkmehs
gkr Hurkph's hornehst kaaupoteki whrh prhshit ot t`h
chhteim: t`h wkrls`kp brkum`t tkmht`hr rhshora`hrs wet`
`em`ny voreoit boalmrkuifs. sk t`ot t`h fesaussekis tkkl
pnoah ikt bhtwhhi ckrh kr nhss nelh-ceifhf saehitests but
wet`ei o `hthrkmhihkus, oatevhny fesomrhheim cuntevkaon
mrkup. Ihvhrt`hnhss. Onoei Vuggrhou, spklh gkr ckst
porteaepoits w`hi `h akianufhf ot t`h hif kg t`h Voutovhn
chhteim t`ot t`h osshcbnomhs grkc bhgkrh obkut 844 tk
744 Lyr BT aoi ik nkimhr bh oaahpthf os uiocbemukusprkke' gkr `ucoi kaaupoteki: t`her vhry precetevh orthgoats,
wet` `orfny oiy fesahriebnh mhsths tha`iequhs, aonn gkr
ormuchits kt`hr t`oi t`h hxoceioteki kg stkih ecpnhchits.
Oiy choieimgun fesausseki kg t`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg
Hurkph cust pnoah t`h hvefhiah grkc t`es aun fh soa kg t`h
Huroseoi akiteihit ei t`h tormhr phrsphatevh kg t`h quhsteki
kg t`h hornehst fesphrsons kg `kceiefs kut kg Ogreao, oif
seiah t`h Voutovhn chhteim vorekus ihw geifeims `ovh
akitrebuthf tk t`h fhboth ki t`hsh skrtehs. Qkch suppkrt t`h
aosh gkr o s`krt a`rkiknkmy gkr Hurkph (ag. Rkbhrts ht on.
?556< Mocbnh ?556< ]`eth ?558) but kt`hrs `ovh
hcp`osezhf t`h ihahssety gkr buenfeim o nkimhr Huroseoi
a`rkiknkmy gkr t`h hornehst `kceief eccemroteki.
Gkr eistoiah, t`h ihw foths gkr t`h hornehst `kceiefs kg
Jovo (Qwes`hr ht on. ?556) summhst t`ot t`hy whrh onrhofy
prhshit t`hrh orkuif ?.0 Cyr BT, onckst kih cenneki yhors
hornehr t`oi ckst kt`hr hstecoths (shh bhnkw). Qua` oi horny
fesphrson kg `kceiefs kut kg Ogreao es onsk suppkrthf by t`h
foneim kg t`h Fcoiese seth eitk t`h Knfuvoe suba`rki, ot
orkuif ?.0 Cyr BT (Njubei oif Bkseisle, t`es vknuch<
Fzoporefzh ht ue. ?505< Mobuieo oif Whluo ?558) oif by
t`h ihw geifs grkc t`h Krah bosei ei Oifonuseo (Qpoei),
w`hrh hvefhiah es anoechf gkr Horny Tnhestkahih `ucoi
kaaupoteki grkc orkuif ?.0 Cyr BT, bkt` ei t`h gkrc kg
`kceief rhcoeis (Krah, Auhvo Weatkreo) oif os orthgoatuonhvefhiah, gkr hxocpnh grkc Guhithiuhvo 1 (shh Mebhrt
?552< Mebhrt ht on. ?556< Rkh ?558< Ropksk oif Qoitkijo,
t`es vknuch). Geionny, orthgoats rhpkrthf grkc Uerki ei Esroìn
(Rkihi ?55?) oif Rewot oif t`h Tobbe @enns ei Tolestoi
onsk ieahny get ei t`es potthri wet` t`her hstecothf omh
(nkr Rewot) kg orkuif ?.5 Cyr BT (Fhiihnn ?551).
V`hrh t`us es hvefhiah tk buenf o akisesthit nkim
a`rkiknkmy gkr t`h eieteon fesphrson kg `kceiefs kut kg
Ogreao oif eitk Huroseo, ot o foth kg orkuif ?.0 Cyr BT, but
et es tk bh strhsshf t`ot ikih kg t`h buenfeim bnkals kg sua` o
nkim a`rkiknkmy es uiakithsthf. Fh Wks oif Qkifoor
(?556) `ovh areteaeshf t`h Qwes`hr ht on. (?556) foths os
bheim gor tkk knf, gkr vorekus rhoskis. Gkr eistoiah, t`h ihw
64Or/15Or omhs orh boshf ki `kribnhifh socpnhs kg w`ea`
t`h mhknkmeaon akithxt es ikt anhor. Gurt`hrckrh t`h ihw
omhs orh akitrofeathf by o wefh roimh kg hstobnes`hf foto<
t`h fesarhpoiay bhtwhhi t`h 64Or/15Or omhs (?.0? oif ?.77
Cyr BT) oif t`h hxesteim comihtkstrotemrop`y es onckst kih
cenneki yhors, w`enh gesseki troal omhs onsk eifeaoth foths onn
nhss t`oi ? Cyr BT. Fh Wks oif Qkifoor akianufh "t`ot
t`h 64Or/15Or foths kg Qwes`hr ht on. coy t`hcshnvhs bh
"tha`ieaonny akrrhat", but uiten t`her mhknkmeaon akithxt es
hstobnes`hf, et es prhcoturh tk ottoa` sua` gor rhoa`eim
akianusekis tk t`hsh ihw omh hstecoths gkr t`h `kceief kg
Jovo" (?556:?=27).
Os gkr Fcoiese, t`h geif-bhoreim shfechits t`hcshnvhs
`ovh ikt bhhi fothf yht: t`h ?.0 Cyr BT foth wos kbtoeihfki bosont bhnkw t`hsh fhpksets, w`ksh ikrcon pknorety es
eithrprhthf os akrrhnotevh wet` t`h Knfuvoe suba`rki. Bhgkrh
t`h fesakvhry kg t`h Fcoiese coifebnh, t`h gouio kg t`h seth
wos t`kum`t tk foth grkc t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih (Whluo
?507:0=), w`enh akrrhnoteki wet` Ihor Hosthri oif
Hurkphoi suaahssekis onsk fkhs ikt mevh strkim suppkrt tk
t`h ?.0 Cyr BT omh< "Hstecoteim t`h omh kg t`h seth wet`ei
t`h tech roimh kg ?.8-?.4 Co wkunf bh rhoskiobnh" (Bor-
Ukshg ?556:220). O rhahit rhvehw kg t`h Ihor Hosthri
hvefhiah nelhwesh fkhs ikt suppkrt "anoecs gkr kaaurrhiahs
orkuif 2.4 Co kr ecchfeothny ogthr t`h Knfuvoe suba`rki"
(Bor-Ukshg ?556:287), oif t`h hornehst seths t`hrh orh onsk
tk bh pnoahf wet`ei t`h ?.8-?.4 Cyr BT tech spoi.
]`enh t`h socpnh kg '`kceiefs' akceim grkc t`h Krah
rhmeki es hxtrhchny akitrkvhrseon (h.m. Omuste oif Ckyo-
Qkno ?50= vs. Mebhrt ?552), o veset tk t`h Krah Bosei ei
Opren ?558 akiveiahf us t`ot ot nhost kih seth `os
uiocbemukus stkih orthgoats t`hrh, Guhith Iuhvo 1 (shh
onsk Rkh ?558).6 Eg subshquhit mhknkmeaon gehnfwkrl wkunf
eifhhf akrrkbkroth t`h anoec t`ot t`es seth es tk bh pnoahf ei
t`h Horny Tnhestkahih shquhiahs hxpkshf ei t`h munnehs ihor
Krah, kih wkunf `ovh tk akianufh t`ot `kceiefs trealnhf
eitk t`h skut`hri port kg Qpoei `uifrhfs kg t`kusoifs kg
yhors bhgkrh t`hy nhgt uifesputobnh troahs kg t`her prhshiah
hnshw`hrh ei Hurkph. @kwhvhr, os nkim os t`h shfechitk-nkmeaon shtteim kg t`h Guhithiuhvo 1 seth es ikt anhor wh shh
ik akcphnneim rhoskis tk akch tk sua` o akianuseki yht.
]h t`hrhgkrh omrhh akcpnhthny wet` Rkh (?556:??), w`k
ogthr `es veset tk t`h orho akianufhf t`ot et "wkunf bh ckst
uiwesh ot t`h prhshit stomh kg t`h rhshora` tk mk tkk fhhpny
eitk t`h pkthiteon semiegeaoiah kg t`h fesakvhrehs cofh ot
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 14/342
6 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Krah. V`hrh es stenn skch woy tk mk bhgkrh t`h bosea goats
orh hstobnes`hf bhykif fkubt kr a`onnhimh".8
V`h rhahit fhvhnkpchits succorezhf obkvh anhorny
eifeaoth t`ot t`h quhsteki kg t`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg
Huroseo es gor grkc sknvhf oif `em`ny akitrkvhrseon. Ei kur
vehw t`h s`krt a`rkiknkmy gkr Hurkph `os ikt bhhi gonsegehf
by t`hsh fhvhnkpchits yht, oif t`us t`hrh stenn es t`h pkeit
kg t`h mop bhtwhhi t`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg t`h "moths kg
Hurkph" - t`h Aouaosus, ikrt`hri Ogreao - oif t`h gerst
uiocbemukus troahs wet`ei (Royion ht on., \t`es vknuch|
s`kw t`ot t`h mop wet` t`h Com`rhb hvefhiah, w`hrh t`h
hornehst kaaupoteki foths grkc just bhgkrh t`h Brui`hs-
Cotuyoco bkuifory, es sconnhr t`oi ot t`h hosthri "moths"
kg Hurkph, w`hrh et es ceieconny 844 Lyr). V`h Voutovhn
chhteim sow ocpnh fesausseki kg t`h pkssebnh hxpnoiotekis
gkr t`es a`rkiknkmeaon fåaonomh, o fesausseki t`ot brkum`t
tkmht`hr t`h vorekus osphats ot stolh ot t`h Voutovhn
chhteim, sua` os t`h hiverkichiton shtteim kg t`h hornehst
kaaupoits, t`her subsesthiah strothmehs oif t`h bh`ovekuron
ecpneaotekis kg t`h s`krt oif nkim a`rkiknkmehs (Mocbnh,
t`es vknuch).
V`es bkkl prhshits t`h oatuon foto ei t`h gkrc kg t`h
vorekus rhmekion oif supro-rhmekion, syit`hteaon
akitrebutekis t`ot gkrchf t`h boses kg t`h Voutovhn
fesaussekis. V`h akitrebutekis orh `em`ny voreobnh oif
thstegy tk t`h normh vorehty ei rhmekion rhshora` trofetekis
wet`ei Hurkph. V`h prkfuateki kg t`es vknuch tkkl onckst
twk yhors, os wh fhaefhf tk 'woet' gkr ckst kg t`h pophrs.
Eifevefuon pophrs t`us `of tk owoet pubneaoteki uiten ckst
kg t`h kt`hr pophrs whrh geies`hf oif ei t`ot shish t`hrh es o
streleim secenorety bhtwhhi t`h `estkry kg t`es bkkl oif
("nevh Mocbnh's (t`es vknuch) hnhmoit hxpnoioteki gkr t`h
ogkrhchitekihf 844 Lyr mop bhtwhhi t`h kaaupoteki kg t`h
'noif kg t`h reseim sui' oif t`h 'noif kg forlihss': "oiy
kih rhmeki kg Hurkph akunf kiny bh aknkiezhf eg et wos
aknkiezhf ot t`h soch tech os ckst kg t`h kt`hrs".
Tonohknet`ea ora`ohknkmy ei t`h speret kg o uiegehf Hurkph!
ikths
? Hiayankpohfeo Bretoiieao, hitry ki 'Hurkph'.
2 V`h Hurkphoi Qaehiah Gkuifoteki Ihtwkrl ki t`h Tonohknet`eaKaaupoteki kg Hurkph akisests kg M. Bkseisle (a`oercoi - IhuwehMhrcoiy), ]. Rkhbrkhls (saehitegea sharhtory - Nhefhi, V`hIht`hrnoifs). A. Gorezy (Tores, Groiah), A. Mocbnh (Qkut`ocptkiXiethf Leimfkc), N. Norsski (Nuif, Qwhfhi), C. Cusse (Rkch,Etony), I. Trosnkv (Qt. Ththrburm, Russeo), N. Ropksk (Nesbki,Tkrtumon), C. Qoitkijo (Qonocoiao, Qpoei) oif O. Vuggrhou (NennhGroiah), wet` C. Qporrhbkkc os ak÷rfeiotkr ki bh`ong kg t`hHurkphoi Qaehiah Gkuifoteki (Qtrosbkurm).
1 Os es kgthi t`h aosh wet` sua` prkahhfeims, ikt onn otthifoitswhrh obnh tk subcet t`her akitrebutekis ki tech, oif wh hsphaeonnyrhmrht t`h obshiah kg o pophr fhoneim wet` t`h prknegea ora`ohk-nkmeaon rhakrf kg t`h skut`hri port kg Groiah, o lhy rhmeki ei t`hfesausseki ki nkim vhrsus s`krt a`rkiknkmehs.
6 ]h orh vhry mrothgun tk Fr J. Mebhrt oif `es aknnobkrotkrs FrB. Corteihz, N. Mebhrt, Fr O. Vurq oif Trkg. Fr C. ]onlhr gkrtoleim t`h tech tk s`kw us t`h Krah rhmeki hxpksurhs oif t`hcothreon grkc t`h vorekus seths.
8 Ihw ponohkcomihtea foths gkr t`h Otopuhrao-VF shquhiah whrrhpkrthf ei Qaehiah (vkn. 275, ik. 8228, ?? Oumust ?558) w`enht`es vknuch wos ei prhss. ]`hrhos hornehr hstecoths ossemihf oiomh kg obkut 844 Lyr BT tk t`h VF 7 nhvhn (ag. Rkhbrkhls oifWoi Lkngsa`kthi, t`es vknuch), t`h ihw foths summhst o noth HornyTnhestkahih omh. Eg guturh foteim wkrl akrrkbkroths t`h ponohkcomihtea foto, kih wenn `ovh tk akianufh t`ot t`h Ebhreoi rhakrffkhs akitoei semions kg hornehr fesphrsons t`oi t`h iki-Ebhreoi portkg Hurkph.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 15/342
8 ]EN RKHBRKHLQ OIF V@EJQ WOI LKNGQA@KVHI - V@H VOXVOWHN ]KRLQ@KT
rhghrhiahs
Oalhrcoi, Q. ?505
Omuste, J., ?50=
Q. Ckyo-Qkno
Bor-Ukshg, K. ?556
Bkiegoy, H., ?55?
B. Woifhrchhrsa` (hf.)
Aorbkihnn, H., ?556
P.T. Rkfremuhz
Fhiihnn, R.]. ?501
Hurkphoi prh`estkry mhts hvhi knfhr, Qaehiah 267, 20-14.
Qkbrh no efhitefof fhn gromchitk aroihon otrebufk o @kck sp. hi Whito Ceahio (Krah
Mroiofo), Hstufeks mhkn. 61, 818-810.
V`h Nkwhr Tonhknet`ea kg t`h Ihor Host, Jkurion kg ]krnf Trh`estkry 0, 2??-277.
Nhs Trhcehrs Hurkpåhis. Tores: Hfetekis fu [email protected].
Horny Ceffnh Tnhestkahih fhpksets oif orthgoats ei t`h Mroi Fkneio seth (VF6) kg t`h
'Qehrro fh Otopuhrao' (Burmks, Qpoei), Jkurion kg @ucoi Hvknuteki 27, 25?-1??.
Hurkphoi Hakikceh Trh`estkry. O Ihw Opprkoa`. Nkifki/Ihw Ukrl: Oaofhceh
Trhss.
Fzoporefzh, W.,
M. Bkseisle,
V. Bumeoiesvene ht on.
Mobuieo, N’
O. Whluo
?551 Hvefhiah ki @ucoi Kremeis. O Rhfesakvhrhf Qkurah ei t`h Xpphr Qewonels kg Ikrt`hri
Tolestoi, Eithrfesaepneiory Qaehiah Rhvehws ?0, 1=5-105.
?505 Fhr ontponoknet`esa`h Guifpnotz Fcoiese ei Mhkrmehi (Loulosus) , Jo`rbua` fhs
R÷cesa`-Mhrcoiesa`hi Zhitroncushucs Coei: 17, 7=-??7.
?558 O Tnek-Tnhestkahih `kceief grkc Fcoiese, Host Mhkrmeo, Aouaosus, Ioturh 1=1. 845-8?2.
Mocbnh. AQ. ?556 Vech gkr Bkxmrkvh coi, Ioturh 175, 2=8-2=7.
t`es V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: t`h hiverkichiton boalmrkuif.
vknuch
Moufzeilse, Q..H. Vurihr (hf.)
Mebhrt, J. (hf.)
?558 V`h rknh kg horny `ucois ei t`h oaaucunoteki kg Hurkphoi Nkwhr oif Ceffnh Tonohk-net`ea bkih osshcbnomhs. Akighrhiah pophrs, Gkrsa`uimsbhrhea` Ontstheizhet fhs R÷cesa`-
Mhrcoiesa`hi Zhitroncushucs Coeiz. Ihuwehf: Qa`nkss Ckirhpks.
?552 Trkyhatk Krah-Auhvo Weatkreo (?500-?552): Trhshiaeo `ucoio hi hn Tnhestkahik
eighrekr fh Mroiofo y Curaeo, Oyuitocehitk fh Krah (Mroiofo): Cushk fh
Trh`estkreo "J. Mebhrt".
Mebhrt, J.,
T. Toncquest,
B. Corteihz Iovorrk
?556 Nks prechrks hurkphks, Eivhsnemoaeki y Aehiaeo, Feaehcbrh ?556, 20-25.
Njubei, W..
M. Bkseisle,
t`es V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg t`h Aouaosus rhmeki.
vknuch
Ropksk, N.,
C. Qoitkijo
Royion, J.T.,
N. Comkmo,
G.-Z. Qbe`e-Onokue,
F. Mhroofs
t`es V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: t`h Ebhreoi phieisuno.
vknuch
t`es V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Otnoitea Ckrkaak: t`h Aosobnoiao hvefhiah .
vknuch
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 16/342
7 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Rkbhrts, C.B.,
A.B. Qtreimhr,
Q.O. Torgett
?556 O `kceief tebeo grkc Ceffnh Tnhestkahih shfechits ot Bkxmrkvh, XL, Ioturh 175,
1??-1?1.
Rkbhrts. C.B.,
AQ . Mocbnh,
F.R. Brefmnoif
Rkh, F.O.
t`es V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph : t`h Bretes` Esnhs.
vknuch
?558
Rkhbrkhls, ]. ?556
Rkhbrkhls. ].. ?556
V. voi Lkngsa`kthi
V`h Krah Bosei (Oifonuaeo, Qpoei) oif t`h eieteon Tonohknet`ea kg Hurkph, Kxgkrf Jkuriokg Ora`ohknkmy ?6, ?-?2.
Xpfoteim t`h gerst Hurkphois, Aurrhit Oit`rkpknkmy 18, 14?-148.
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: o s`krt a`rkiknkmy, Ocequety 70, 605-841.
t`es V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph : o rhopproeson kg orthgoatuon oif a`rkiknkmeaoS
vknuch hvefhiah.
Rkihi. O.
Qwes`hr AA,M.@. Aurtes,
V. Joakb,
O.M. Mhtty,
O Quprejk,
]efeosckrk
Whluo, O.
]`eth, A.
?55? V`h Uerki-Mrovhn net`ea osshcbnomh - ortegoats knfhr t`oi 6.2 CU ei Esroìn, OraCknkmesa`h
Lkrrhspkifhizbnott 2?, ?85-?76.
?556 Omh kg t`h hornehst likwi `kceiefs ei Jovo, Eifkihseo, Qaehiah 271, ???0-??2?.
?507 V`h Nkwhr Tnhestkahih cocconeoi gouio kg Oa`onlonole (Qkut`hri Mhkrmeo, XQQR),
Tonohkitkmrop`eo Etoneao =6, 71-57.
?558 No Mrktth fu Wonnkiht: Hvefhiah kg Horny @kceief Oatevety kr Ioturon Trkahsshs;
Tophr prhshithf ot t`h Tonohknet`ea-Chsknet`ea foy chhteim, Bretes` Cushuc Nkifki,
Cora` ?=t` ?558.
]en Rkhbrkhls oif V`ejs voi Lkngsa`kthi
Goaunty kg Trh- oif Trktk`estkry
Nhefhi Xievhrsety
T.K. Bkx 58?8
2144 RO Nhefhi
V`h Iht`hrnoifs
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 17/342
Nues Ropksk ? V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph:Coiuhe Qoitkijo t`h Ebhreoi phieisuno
O rhvehw kg t`h Ebhreoi hvefhiah fhckistroths t`ot t`h
knfhst troahs kg`ucoi kaaupoteki foth grkc t`h hornehr
port kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih. V`kum` rorh, t`h knfhst
net`ea eifustrehs opphor ei onn ecpkrtoit revhr vonnhys kg t`h
Akiteihiton eithrekr. Normhr osshcbnomhs onrhofy akitoei
Oa`hunhoi begoahs, ecpnyeim t`ot t`h efho kg oi Ebhreoi
prh-Oa`hunhoi eifustreon ('phbbnh-aunturh') stomh cust bh
trhothf wet` aouteki.
?. Eitrkfuateki
Ei t`h nost twk fhaofhs, et `os bhakch akccki proateah(k pksnunonh t`h hxesthiah kg ora`oea net`ea eifustrehs ei t`hEbhreoi phieisuno, fkauchiteim oi oiaehit `ucoikaaupoteki. V`hsh efhos whrh porteonny fuh tk t`hakiahpteki kg oi kremeion Ebhreoi Oa`hunhoi ("chrefekionOa`hunhoi", G. Bkrfhs ?5=?), prhsucobny rhnothf tk t`hIkrt` Ogreaoi Oa`hunhoi, oif boshf ki t`h kaaurrhiah kgo `em` phrahitomh kg anhovhrs (Onechi ?5=8) oif ki t`hobuifoit ush kg quortzeth os row cothreon. V`hsh efhos whrhakisefhrobny snrhim`thihf os o akishquhiah kg t`h ecpoataoushf ei Ebhreo by Bebhrski's wkrl ei t`h ?574s eiCkrkaak, w`hrh `h anoechf tk `ovh fhgeihf o "aevenesotekifu monht ocåi omå" (Bebhrski ?57?), knfhr t`oi t`hOa`hunhoi oif opporhitny vhry secenor tk t`h ThbbnhEifustrehs rhpkrthf ei t`h Tkrtumuhsh nettkron seiah t`h ?564s(Brhuen oif Zbyszhwsle ?562-68).
V`h nothr fesakvhry kg skch efhiteaon geifs, e.h. phbbnhtkkns, ei t`h `em`hr thrroahs kg t`h Muofonquever revhr(Bkrfhs oif Wemuehr ?5=?) oif, ckrh ecpkrtoitny, t`hefhitegeaoteki (Bkrfhs oif V`ebount ?5==) oif subshquhithxaovoteki (_uhrkn oif Qoitkijo ?501) kg t`h seth kg HnOaunofhrk ei t`h nettkron ihor Aofez, akitrebuthf tk t`hrhakmieteki (kr ot nhost tk t`h pksetevh hxphatoteki) kg oiora`oea `ucoi kaaupoteki ei t`h Ebhreoi phieisuno: oikaaupoteki foteim boal tk t`h Horny Tnhestkahih, aunturonny
fhgeihf os prh-Oa`hunhoi. Rhhhitny, t`h soch efho `os bhhirheigkrahf by t`h fesakvhrehs ei t`h Muofex-Bozo fhprhssekikg o sconn gromchit kg oi kaaepeton bkih, suppkshfny `ucoi(Mebhrt ?508< Whmo Vksaoik ?505), os whnn os kg skchnet`ea orthgoats (Aorbkihnn ht on. ?502).
Vkfoy, `kwhvhr, et es wefhny bhnehvhf t`ot ikih kg t`hshgeifs aoi bh oaahpthf os prkkg kg sua` oitequety bhaoush kg
t`h noal kg sknef foteim hvefhiah (seths ei t`h Tkrtumuhshnettkron oif t`h Aofez rhmeki), kr bhaoush kg fkubts rhnoteimtk t`h ortegeaeon a`oroathr kg t`h geifs (t`h Muofex-Bozoseths), kr bhaoush t`h ghw oif esknothf net`ea orthgoats gkuifei t`h eithrekr kg t`h Ebhreoi phieisuno wenn `ovh tk bhfesrhmorfhf (Qoitkijo oif _uhrkn ?502) os t`hy orheisuggeaeìit hvefhiah tk suppkrt o `ypkt`hses. Ei kur prhshitstoth kg likwnhfmh, et aoi bh ormuhf t`ot t`h ckst oiaehitponohknet`ea seths ei Ebhreo aoi bh fothf tk t`h bhmeiieim kgt`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih. Ik skuif hvefhiah suppkrts knfhr
foths (Qoitkijo oif Wenno ?554< Omuerrh ?55?< Rknnoif?552< Aorbkihnn Rkuro ?552).
Qhvhrh necetotekis hxest gkr t`h a`rkiknkmeaoS grochwkrlkg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih ei Ebhreo, oif seths orh kgthifeggeaunt tk foth oaaurothny wet`ei t`ot phrekf. ]et` t`hhxahpteki kg Otopuhrao oif Bknkckr, t`hsh seths orh onnkphi-oer nkaonetehs oif ckstny rhnothf tk gnuveon shquhiahs.V`her a`rkiknkmeaon pkseteki es coeiny fhthrceihf byrhnotevh arethreo. Obsknuth foteim hvefhiah gkr t`h eieteonCeffnh Tnhestkahih (prekr tk KEQ 5) es kiny ovoenobnh grkct`h seth kg Otopuhrao (Burmks) oif t`h Muofonqueverthrroahs. Vwk prkjhats orh prhshitny ei prkmrhss ei krfhr tkkbtoei ckrh obsknuth foths: kih es akiahrihf wet` sua`anossea oif ecpkrtoit seths os Vkrronbo oif Ocbrkio(Qkreo), Bknkckr (Wonhiaeo) oif Auhsto fh no Bojofo(Vhruhn), t`h kt`hr es ferhathf tkworfs t`h kphi-oer sethsnkaothf ei t`h Qpoies` shatkr kg t`h Vomus bosei.
Ihvhrt`hnhss, w`hi t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih seths kg Ebhreoorh stufehf ei fhtoen, t`hy coy prkvefh hvefhiah gkr pnoaeimt`hc ei o rhnotevh thcpkron shquhiah oif et cem`t t`us bhpkssebnh tk fegghrhiteoth bhtwhhi fegghrhit cojkr ckchitswet`ei t`ot tech-phrekf. Hvhi wet` t`hsh saorah foto etcem`t bh pkssebnh tk krfhr t`h seths a`rkiknkmeaonny gkr t`hhiterh Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, grkc ets eieteon p`oshs kiworfs.
2. Vkworfs o rhnotevh a`rkiknkmyV`h shquhiahs kg thrroahs likwi ei fhtoen, coeiny grkc
t`h Ebhreoi Akiteihiton eithrekr, mevh us t`h ckst akcpnhthfoto prhshitny ovoenobnh gkr pnoaeim t`h net`ea eifustrehs ei oa`rkiknkmeaon krfhr. Ei offeteki, goatkrs sua` os gouionosskaeotekis, phfknkmea a`oroathresteas kg t`h skens oif skchckrp`kstrotemrop`ea porteaunoretehs kg hoa` orho, aoi onsk ba
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 18/342
0 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
ushf gkr o akrrhnoteki bhtwhhi fegghrhit gnuveon vonnhysoif/kr festeiat thi-oahs nhvhns.
@hiah t`h likwnhfmh kg t`h fegghrhit thrroah systhcsakistetuths kih kg t`h ckst ecpkrtoit hnhchits ei t`ha`rkiknkmeaoS krfhr kg t`h ponohknet`ea seths. Ei mhihron, etaoi ba soef t`ot t`h prhshit Ebhreoi `yfrkmrop`ea systhcsbhmoi tk bh gkrchf ogthr t`h fhpkseteki kg t`h Wenno-groia`eoi `em` fhtretea surgoahs ("roios"), fothf tk 2.8/2Cyr BT (Tårhz Mkizoëhz ?502 oif ?502o< Ckneio ?55?).V`hrhgkrh, t`h `em`hst revhr thrroahs ei hoa` cojkr Ebhreoirevhr aoi bh ottrebuthf tk t`h bhmeiieim kg t`h Tnhestkahih.Grkc t`ot ckchit ki o shfechitory prkahss bhmoi,precoreny akitrknnhf by thatkiea goatkrs oif by t`h ioturh kgt`h mhknkmeaon substrotuc. Anecotea a`oimhs kiny `of oshakifory eignuhiah ki t`es prkahss. Oaakrfeim tk t`hiucbhr kg thrroah nhvhns nesthf, t`rhh fegghrhit thrroahshquhiah gkrcoteki ckfhns whrh efhitegehf ei t`hakiteihiton Ebhreoi eithrekr (Tårhz Mkizoëhz ht on. ?502):
?. V`h vonnhys wet` o normh iucbhr kg thrroah nhvhns (ckrht`oi 24), wet` t`h `em`hst ot ckrh t`oi ?84 c obkvh t`hprhshit revhr nhvhn.
2. V`h vonnhys wet` oi eithrchfeoth iucbhr kg thrroahs(0 tk ?4), oif
1. Wonnhys wet` kiny o ghw thrroahs, wet` t`h `em`hst ot ochrh 64 chthrs obkvh t`h prhshit revhr nhvhn.
V`es mrhot fevhrsety aoushs hikrckus prkbnhcs, ikt kinyei t`h akrrhnoteki bhtwhhi fegghrhit revhr vonnhys, but onsk eit`h akrrhnoteki bhtwhhi fegghrhit mhkckrp`knkmeaon shatkrswet`ei t`h soch vonnhy. Ikiht`hnhss, et es pkssebnh tk colhskch mhihron akrrhnotekis oif, ei t`h aosh kg t`h ckrhfhvhnkphf vonnhys, et es hvhi pkssebnh tk esknoth fegghrhitshrehs kg thrroahs, boshf ki t`h fechiseki kg t`herhsaorpchits, oif tk ottrebuth t`hc tk akishautevh phrekfswet`ei t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih.
V`h onckst akcpnhth noal kg semiegeaoit gouion ossk-aeotekis ei ckst kphi-oer gnuveon ponohknet`ea seths colhs etvhry feggeaunt tk ush oiy bekstrotemrop`ea rhghrhiah tobnhs,sua` os gkr eistoiah t`h kih hstobnes`hf by H. Omuerrh(?505):
HORNU TNHEQVKAHIH:
gouion osskaeotekis kg t`h mrkups- "O": Onnkp`oekcys pnekaohieaus, tkmht`hr wet`
Wennogroia`eoi aorievkro nelh Oaeikiyx, Werhtoenurus
sa`oube, Phikayki rkse.
Fkauchithf ei seths sua` os Auhvo Weatkreo, Krah 6,Eiaocon oif Bomur 2 oif
- "B": Onnkp`oekcys pnekaohieaus, wet`kut Wenno-groa`eoi aorievkro, but wet` Auki presaus, Cksboa` wkngoif ihw Bkvefoh, sua` os Aopro oif Qkhrmhneo.
Fkauchithf ei seths sua` os Whito Ceahio 2, BorroiakNhñi oif Krah =.
EIEVEON CEFFNH TNHEQVKAHIH (prekr tk KEQ ?1):
gouion osskaeotekis kg t`h- "A " mrkup: Ceckcys soveie wet` Tetycys mrhmonkef
oif Tnekcys hpesakpones, tkmht`hr wet` hvknvhf Coccut`
chrefekiones oif, ot t`h hif kg t es tech-phrekf, Coccut`us trkmkit`hree, Feahrkr`eius `hcetkha`us, Besk
sa`khthisoale vkemsthfthises, fegghrhit Ahrvefoh, sua` os Chmoahrks, Foco anoatkieoio oif Ahrvus hnop`us.
Fkauchithf ei seths sua` os Otopuhrao VF-1 tk VF-7,@uåsaor ? oif Auhvo fhn Akimkstk.
NOVH CEFFNH TNHEQVKAHIH:
gouion osskaeotekis kg t`h mrkups- "F": Orveakno cks`oa`hises (3 O. thrrhstres
aoiþoio) eisthof kg Ceckcys soveie, tkmht`hr wet`Toit`hro (Nhk) gkssenes, Coccut`us trkmkit`hree, Hnhp`os
oitequus, skch ora`oea `krshs - Hquus ontefhis, Hquus
suhsshibkrihises - oif Feahrkr`eius htrusaus, Beski
presaus, fegghrhit Ahrvefoh, hta. Fkauchithf ei sua` sethsos Aþnnor fh Bozo E, Teihfk, Vkrronbo oif Ocbrkio (nkwhr
nhvhns) oif- "H": secenor tk t`h prhahfeim, wet`kut Trohchmoahr
oif Fknea`kfkreahrks, but wet` Kryatknomus auieaunus,
Hquus aobonnus mhrcoieaus oif Aoprhknus aoprhknus.
Fkauchithf ei sua` seths os Orefks, Qknoio fhnZocbkreik, Otopuhrao VF-VM ?4-?? oif VI-2 tk 7, Teiennfhn Wonnh, Ocbrkio (upphr nhvhns).
EIEVEON NOVH TNHEQVKAHIH:
gouion osskaeoteki kg t`h- " G " mrkup: eianufeim t h nost Hnhp`os (T.) oitequus
oif Feahrkr`eius `hcetkha`us, wet` t`h opphoroiah kg Roimeghr toroifus, Aopro pyrhioeao, Rupeaopro rupeaopro
Hquus aobonnus monneaus.Fkauchithf ei Zogorroyo, Aore`uhno, Akvo Ihmro,
Nhzhtxele, Wonfhmkbo, No Hrceto, Obre Rkcoie, hta.@kwhvhr, t`h bekstrotemrop`eaon necetotekis kg t`hsh
mrkups orh strhsshf by Omuerrh `ecshng, het`hr bhaoushkg t`h uiahrtoeity oif a`rkiknkmeaon kvhrnoppeim bhtwhhishvhron mrkups, kr bhaoush kg t`h anhorny kaaurreimfegghrhit "troisetekion" osshcbnomhs, hsphaeonny t`kshgrkc orkuif t`h Horny/Ceffnh Tnhestkahih bkuifory.Ei offeteki, et cust bh hcp`oseshf t`ot onckst onn t`hosskaeotekis ushf tk hstobnes` t`h knfhst p`oshs orh gkuifei purhny ponohkitknkmeaon seths. V`h ghw Ebhreoi kphi-oernkwhr ponohknet`ea seths wet` ecpkrtoit gouion osshcbnomhs,
whnn-pnoahf ckrp`kstrotemrop`eaonny ei t`h nkaon thrroahshquhiahs oif akitoeieim akiveiaeim oit`rkpkmhieahvefhiah, orh onn tkk rhahit tk bh akisefhrhf ei t`espophr.
Vk succoresh, et aoi bh akianufhf t`ot t`h fesaussekiakiahrieim t`h ckst oiaehit `ucoi kaaupoteki kg Ebhreo esnecethf, precoreny by t`h eisuggeaehiay kg t`h a`rkiknkmeaon
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 19/342
NXEQ ROTKQK OIF COIXHN QOIVKIJO - V@H EBHREOI THIEIQXNO
grochwkrl prhshitny ovoenobnh. Os gor os t`h CeffnhTnhestkahih es akiahrihf, et es kiny pkssebnh tk colh o
rhnotevh shreoteki bhtwhhi fegghrhit seths, wet`ei necethf /kihs kg porteaunor revhr vonnhys. @kwhvhr, t`es shreotekifkhs eifeaoth ei o ghw aoshs t`h hxesthiah kg `ucoikaauputeki prekr tk KEQ 5.
1. V`h ora`ohknkmeaon seths]et` t`h a`rkiknkmeaon grochwkrl just rhghrrhf tk ei
ceif, et es pkssebnh ikw tk prhshit t`h ckst ecpkrtoit sethsoif shquhiahs w`ea` fkauchit t`h gerst `ucoi kaaupotekikg t`h Ebhreoi phieisuno (Gem. ?). Hcp`oses wenn bh pnoahfkiny ki t`ksh seths w`hrh t`h foths aoi rhoskiobny bh
ottrebuthf tk t`h eieteon stomhs kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih,prhsucobny prekr tk KEQ 5 (Gem. 2).
Fuh tk t`h p`yseaon a`oroathresteas kg t`h fegghrhit zkihskg t`h Ebhreoi phieisuno, wh wenn akisefhr suaahssevhny t`h
gknnkweim mhkmrop`eaon uiets (oaakrfeim tk Nouthisoa`?57=, ckfegehf):
(?) V`h ikrt` kg Tkrtumon, Moneaeo oif t`h nettkron kgAoitobreo<
(2) V`h ikrt`hri Chshto oif t`h Ebhreoi akrfennhro<(1) V`h whsthri Tkrtumuhsh nettkron oif t`h nkwhr Vomus
bosei<(6) V`h skut`hc Chshto. eianufeim t`h Qpoies` fhprhssekis
kg t`h Vomus oif Muofeoio revhrs, t`h ckuitoeis eibhtwhhi (Vknhfk ckuitoeis) os whnn os t`h skut`hrikihs (Qhrro Ckrhio), oif t`h Tkrtumuhsh whsthripnothous (Onhithjk)<
(8) V`h Hbrk fhprhsseki oif t`h Tyrhihoi zkih<(7) V`h hosthri Chfethrroihoi nettkron<(=) V`h Onmorvh, Oifonuseo oif t`h Qhmuro bosei.
1.?. V@H IKRV@ KG TKRVXMON, MONEAEO OIF V@H
E ee rkR ^e ke AOIVOBREO
Akcporaf wet` t`h prkguseki kg Ceffnh oif XpphrTonohknet`ea seths likwi ei t`es rhmeki, t`h Oa`hunhoinkaonetehs frow otthiteki fuh tk twk goatkrs: t`hrh orh kiny o
ghw seths oif t`hsh orh onn kphi-oer (wet` t`h hxahptekis kg
t`h Hn Aostennk aovh, oif pkssebny t`h Nhzhtxele aovh).Oikt`hr a`oroathrestea w`ea` s`kunf onsk bh akisefhrhf es
t`ot ei mhihron t`hy `ovh vhry sconn net`ea osshcbnomhs,kgthi ikt feomikstea grkc o typknkmeaon pkeit kg vehw. Eigoat skch coy ikt bh Oa`hunhoi ot onn but ckrh ckfhri,
hvhi pkst-Tonohknet`ea (Rkfremuhz Oshiaek ?501< Aoik Toi?55?< Cherhnhs ?507). Ikih kg t`h seths likwi sk gor aoi
rhoskiobny bh ottrebuthf tk oi horny p`osh kg t`h CeffnhTnhestkahih. Ki t`h akitrory, et shhcs t`ot t`h ckst semiegeaoit kihs (sua` os Mhngo, Bufeik, Boiumuhs, Nnomþ,Torhfhs oif Hn Aostennk) s`kunf bh fothf tk o rhnotevhny nothp`osh kg t`ot tech-phrekf.
1.2. V@H IKRV@HRI CHQHVO OIF EBHREOI
AKRFENNHRO
V`h ikrt`hri subchshto es o rhmeki w`hrh o normh iucbhrkg shquhiahs, pnoahs oif net`ea osshcbnomhs foteim tk t`h
Ceffnh Tnhestkahih aoi bh kbshrvhf oif krfhrhf eitk o
rhnotevh a`rkiknkmy. V`hrhgkrh, et mevhs us t`h ckstakcpnhth grochwkrl gkr o fesausseki kg t`h hornehst `ucoikaaupoteki ei Ebhreo.
Ei t`h whsthri `ong kg t`h rhmeki, whst kg t`h Vroboiaks-Tesuhrmo revhrs' oxes, t`hrh orh rhnotevhny obuifoitOa`hunhoi seths ei gnuveon akithxts, hvhi t`kum` t`hy kgthiakisest kg streatny suphrgeaeon geifs oif ikih kg t`hc yehnfhfsemiegeaoit gouion osshcbnomhs. V`h geifs ei t`h hosthrizkih orh vhry saorah oif ikt feomikstea, wet` kiny o ghw
hxahptekis ei t`h Fkurk Bosei oif ei t`h Ebhreoi akrfennhro.En s`kunf ihvhrt`hnhss bh ikthf t`ot et es prhaeshny ei t`esnost shatkr t`ot skch kg t`h ckst ecpkrtoit oif gockusCeffnh Tnhestkahih Ebhreoi seths `ovh bhhi gkuif, sua` os
Vkrronbo, Otopuhrao oif Auhsto fh no Bojofo.
Onckst onn t`h cojkr whsthri revhr systhcs `ovh net`ea
osshcbnomhs, coiugoaturhf coeiny grkc nkaonny rknnhfquortzeth phbbnhs. V`hsh osshcbnomhs orh ei strotemrop`eapkseteki wet`ei t`h ceffnh thrroah gkrcotekis, kr ot t`h
surgoah kg t`h upphr kihs, kr hvhi skchtechs ot t`h tkp kg
t`h `em`hst Ihkmhiea surgoahs. Ont`kum` t`hrh coy bh skchsocpneim hrrkrs fuh tk eisuggeaeìit gehnf survhys, t`h
hxesthiah kg oi hxthisevh kaaupoteki kg t`h thrretkry shhcsanhor. V`hrh es o prhghrhiteon shnhateki kg nkaotekis: t`h
akignuhiah kg revhrs oif t`h vhstebunor orhos kg shakiforyvonnhys - oi kbshrvoteki t`ot pkeits tk t`h ecpkrtoiah kg t`h
subsefeory gnuveon systhcs ei t`h krmoiesoteki kg `ucoickvhchit fureim t`es phrekf (Qoitkijo ?552).
V`h seths orh vhry fevhrsh: skch orh ei strotemrop`eapkseteki, het`hr wet` normh net`ea osshcbnomhs (Vhro, Tesuhrmooif Vkrchs revhrs) kr wet` sconn net`ea shrehs (Krbemk,Omuhfo oif Vroboiaks revhrs). Kt`hrs, vhry obuifoit, orh
surgoah seths, kgthi iuchrkus oif fesphrshf kvhr normh orhos(Qoitkijo oif Wenno ?554< Qoitkijo ei prhss). Ei t`h obshiahkg obsknuth foths oif semiegeaoit gouion osskaeotekis, t`hera`rkiknkmy es boshf, os wh chitekihf hornehr, ki t`h
oionyses kg t`h ckrp`kstrotemrop`ea shquhiahs kg hoa`gnuveon vonnhy (Tårhz Mkizonhz ?502).
Ot t`h Tesuhrmo revhr, whst kg Nhñi oif kutsefh t`h
Aoitobreoi akrfennhro, t`hrh orh o tkton kg 0 thrroah nhvhns(2-c tk ?28/?14-c). Ckrh t`oi twhity Oa`hunhoi seths
whrh gkuif t`hrh: onn kg t`hc surgoah seths, wet` t`h
hxahpteki kg Qoi _uerah w`ea` es nkaothf ei t`h 84-c
thrroah nhvhn oif ottrebuthf tk oi oiaehit p`osh kg t`h
Ceffnh Tnhestkahih (Orioez ?554). V`es seth kremeioths grkco vhry nkw hihrmy hiverkichit (pkssebny ikt eithmrothfeitk t`h kremeion thrroah gkrcoteki prkahss, o `ypkt`hsesw`ea` akunf phr`ops akitrebuth tk t`h rhjuvhioteki kg t`h
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 20/342
EE) V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. ?. Cop kg t`h Ebhreoi phieisuno, wet` seths chitekihf ei t`h thxt.
Ikrt`hri Tkrtumon, Moneaeo oif nettkron kg Aoitobreo - ?: Mhngo< 2: Bufe`k< 1: Borëumuhs< 6: Hn Aostennk.Ikrt`hri subchshto oif Ebhreoi akrfennhro- 8: No Coyo< 7: Mormobhth< =: Ckigorroaeiks< 0: Qoi _uerah< 5: Otopuhrao< ?4: Ocbrkio<??: Vkrronbo< ?2: Auhstofh no Bojofo.]hsthri Tkrtumuhsh nettkron oif nkwhr Vomus fhprhsseki - ?1: Cerkumk< ?6: Ontk Nheok< ?8: Comketk, Oaogkro, Omufo< ?7: Wonh fkGkrik/Onpeormo< ?=: _ueito fk Añihmk/Tkuseos.Qkut`hri subchshto- ?0: Ckith fk Gocoak< ?5: Hn Qortonhjk< 24: Teihfk< 2?: Hn Hspeior< 22: Orefks< 21: Qoi Esefrk< 26: Tkrzuio<
28: Onbono< 27: Hn Corteihth.Hbrk fhprhsseki oif pyrhioea zkih - ik seths orh prhshithf ei t`h cop.Hosthri chfethrroihoi nettkron - 2=: No Qhnvo< 20: Tuem f'hi Rkao< 25: Aou fhn Fua< 14: Cknnht< 1?: Bknkckr.Onmorvh, Oifonuseo oif Qhmuro bosei - 12: Onfheo Ikvo< 11: Hn Oaunofhrk< 16: Nomuio fh Chfeio< 18: Qknoio fhn Zocbkreik< 17: Aunnor-Bozo E.
a`rkiknkmeaoS ottrebuteki rhghrrhf tk obkvh). Oi obuifoit
net`ea eifustry (cofh ki nkaon quortzeth oif quortz, wet`kiny skch =% kg rhtkua`hf tkkns, hsphaeonny sarophrs oiffhiteaunoths, o ghw anhovhrs oif phbbnh tkkns), `os bhhifkauchithf, oi eifustry opporhitny anusthrhf spoteonny oifei osskaeoteki wet` os` oif o pkssebnh `hort`, but wet`kutgouio! rhcoeis.
V`h ckst ecpkrtoit orho wet` Ceffnh Tnhestkahih net`eaeifustrehs ei t`h ahitrh kg t`h ikrt`hri subchshto, wet` t`h
hxahpteki kg t`h Hsno revhr vonnhy oif ets coei trebutoreases t`h Tesuhrmo revhr, ikrt` kg Wonnofknef. @hrh orh o tktonkg 0 thrroah nhvhns, 7 kg w`ea` `ovh Oa`hunhoi-nelhosshcbnomhs.
Ei t`h Fkurk vonnhy, t`h net`ea osshcbnomhs orh vhry rorh@kwhvhr, skch kg t`hc, bhaoush kg o ckrp`kstrotemrop`eapkseteki ei t`h `em`hr thrroah nhvhns (h.m. Ckigorroaeiksoif Vkrk, bkt` nkaothf ot t`h 04-c thrroah nhvhn), s`kunfbh akisefhrhf os hvefhiah kg t`h ckst oiaehit `ucoi
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 21/342
NXEQ ROTKQK OIF COIXHN QOIVKIJO - V@H EBHREOI THIEIQXNO
Ikrt` kg Tkrtumon, Ikrt`hri ChshtoMoneaeo oif Aoitobreo oif Ebhreoi akrfnnnhro
]hsthri nettkronoif nkwhr Vomus
Qkut`hri Chshto Hosthc chfethrroihoinettkron
Onmorvh, Oifonuseooif Qhmuro bosei
NOVH
TNHEQVKAHIH
?14L^V ‖
MhngoNo Coyo ? Onpeorao
(upphr nhvhns)
O. Kxemhik
TkrzuioHn Corteihth
X J
& =OAE Lvr
; Bufegek; Hn Aosgennk; Boiumuhs
Monesoia`k
No Coyo EE
Auhsto fh noBojofo
Chon`ofoOnckifo (HWQ)
Nez (_1)
Ckith Gocoak
Onpeorao(ceffnh nhvhns)
Qoi Esefrk(nkwhr nhvhns)
Orefks
Qortknhjk
; Aou f'hi Bkrros; Vksson fh no Gkit
Bknkckr
; Hn Oaunofhrk
Onfheo Ikvo
Qknoio fhnZocbkreik
MuofonqueverVen
F F N H
T N H E Q V K A ; Qoi _uerah
; Vkrroebo; Ocbrkio(nkwhr nhvhns)
No Coyo EEE
_to. Añihmk
; Onpeorao(nkwhr nhvhns)
; TeihfkNomuio Chfeio
Muofonquever V0
v 14 L)V
Otopuhrao VF7
Ckigorroaeiks ;
Otopuhrao VF6 ;
Hn Hspeior ;No Chso ;
Aþnnor Bozo ?
Muofonquever V7
HORNU
TNHEQVKAHIH
; Comketk ;
; Cerkuak ;; Qhexkso ;
; No Qhnvo ;; Tuem f'hi Rkao ; Whito Ceahio ;
?Gem. 2. A`rkiknkmeaon pkseteki kg t`h ckst ecpkrtoit Ebhreoi Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea seths.
Eithrrkmoteki corls ki t`h nhgt fhikth shrekus fkubts obkut t`h a`rkiknkmy< ki t`h rem`t, fhikth shrekus fkubts obkut t`h oit`rkpea hvefhiah
anoechf tk hxest oif/kr t`h orthgoatuon a`oroathr kg t`h osshcbnomhs. ]et`ei hoa` spoah-tech aosh seths orh prhshit wet`kut oiy a`rkiknkmeaon krfhr.
kaaupoteki ei t`h rhmeki. V`hy foth pkssebny tk t`h hornyCeffnh Tnhestkahih kr hvhi tk t`h hif kg t`h prhahfeimphrekf - et' t`h orthgoatuon ioturh kg t`h ghw gnolhfphbbnhs oif gnolhs gkuif ei setu ei t`ksh nhvhns esoaahpthf.
Vk t`h host kg t`h Vroboiaks revhr, ei t`h skut`hri `ongkg t`h Fkurk bosei, Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea seths orh onckstuilikwi, w`enh ei t`h whsthri vonnhys, bhtwhhi t`hVroboiaks oif Omuhfo revhrs, begoah oif anhovhr eifustrehsorh grhquhitny gkuif. V`h ckst ecpkrtoit seths orh nkaothfei t`h Vkiihs, @uhbro, Uhnths oif Omuhfo revhr vonnhys,
w`hrh ei ahrtoei orhos (ckstny ei t`h ceffnh shatkr kg hoa`froeiomh systhc) shvhron vhry akcpnhth ckrp`kstrotemrop`eashquhiahs whrh rhakmiesaf. @hrh, t`h seths orh nkaothf otvorekus mhkckrp`knkmeaon pksetekis:
(o) ki t`h surgoah kg onn thrroah nhvhns, osshcbnomhs `ovhbhhi gkuif wet`kut oiy vesebnh hfmh whor oif voryeimei t`h nuecbhr kg orthgoats<
(b) ki t`h surgoah kg t`h ceffnh nhvhn thrroahs kgthi normhosshcbnomhs `ovh bhhi gkuif, a`oroathreshf by anhornywkri hfmhs<
(a) wet`ei t`h soch thrroah nhvhns o ghw orthgoats `ovh bhhigkuif ei strotemrop`ea pkseteki (h.m. No Coyo EE oif NoCoyo EEE)<
(f) ei t`h nkwhr nhvhn thrroahs oif kt`hr onnuveon fhpksets,t`hrh orh normh osshcbnomhs wet` begoahs, anhovhrs, hta.(h.m. No Hrceto, No Coyo E oif Wennomkizonk).
Ei t`h Vkrchs revhr vonnhy, w`hrh ckrh rhshora` `os bhhi
aorrehf kut, t`h Oa`hunhoi eifustrehs orh onn fothf tk t`hCeffnh Tnhestkahih. V`hy `ovh bhhi nkaothf ei t`h 87-cthrroah nhvhn (No Coyo EEE), t`h 72-c nhvhn (Mormobhth), oift`h 0-c thrroah nhvhn (No Coyo E). V`hrh es ik hvefhiahkg knfhr osshcbnomhs, oif t`ksh t`ot orh strotemrop`eaonnyckrh rhahit t`oi t`h 0-c thrroah, nkaothf ei t`h aknnuveonakvhreim fhpksets, orh anhorny pkst-Oa`hunhoi (Qoitkijo oifMkizoëhz ?506).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 22/342
?2 EËEE-: n-ORE EE IVK AAt TOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Geionny, ei t`h hosthri port kg t`h Ebhreoi revhr systhcrhmeki, t`h Oa`hunhoi seths orh vhry rorh (Qoitkijo eiprhss). Qkch kg t`hsh, `kwhvhr, orh kg porteaunor rhnhvoiahfuh tk t`her mhknkmeaon oif mhkmrop`eaon nkaotekis oif tkt`her top`kikcea `estkrehs w`ea` nhf tk t`h prhshrvoteki kg onormh sht kg hvefhiah (gouio, `ucoi rhcoeis, net`eas, hta).Gkur kg t`h seths orh wkrt` caitekieim:
(o) Otopuhrao (Omuerrh ht on. ?50= oif ?554< Aorbkihnnht on. ?552), t`h ecpkrtoiah kg t`es seth sthris grkct`h `ucoi rhcoeis gkuif t`hrh. V`h hxesthiah kgnet`ea eifustrehs es, `kwhvhr, onsk wkrt` chitekieim,eianufeim o vhry sconn iucbhr kg orthgoats (ikt hiterhnyakiveiaeim) grkc o nhvhn (VF6) nkaothf "ecchfeothny"kvhr o comihtea eivhrseki, akisefhrhf tk bh t`hCotuyoco/Brui`hs troiseteki (oif t`us opporhitnyfothf tk t`h eieteon Ceffnh Tnhestkahih), oif oikt`hrosshcbnomh, wet` begoahs, gkuif ei o nhvhn (VF7)ottrebuthf tk KEQ ?1 ki t`h boses kg ponohkitknkmeaonfoto (et es t`h nost nhvhn ei t`h Otopuhrao VF shquhiah
w`hrh Ceckcys soveie es prhshit)<(b) t`h anossea seths kg Ocbrkio oif Vkrroebo, nkaothf ei opossomh orho bhtwhhi t`h Fkurk, Hbrk oif Joroco-@hiorhs boseis, oif akiihathf tk t`h Chfethrroihoinettkron by t`h Jonkao revhr vonnhy (Gem. 1). V`h hxoatoit`rkpkmaiea ioturh oif a`rkiknkmeaon pkseteki kgt`hsh seths wet`ei t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih orh stenn uifhrfesausseki. V`hrh es ik pksetevh akigercoteki kg fothsprhsucobny knfhr t`oi KEQ 5. Ihvhrt`hnhss, t`hsh foths
orh pkssebnh gkr t`h "nkwhr akcpnhx" nhvhns ei hoa` s(Qoitkijo oif Wenno ?554)<
(a) Auhsto fh no Bojofo, nkaothf ei t`h upphr shatkr kg t`hOngocbro revhr vonnhy (84/74-c thrroah), ei Vhruhn(Qoitkijo ht on. ?552), foteim grkc o rhnotevhny hvknvhCeffnh Tnhestkahih p`osh, phr`ops pkst KEQ 5.
1.1. V@H ]HQVHRI TKRVXMXHQH NEVVKRON OIF NK]VOMXQ FHTRHQQEKI
V`h Ebhreoi whsthri nettkron es t`h rhmeki w`hrh t`h gerstkaaurrhiah kg prhsucobny vhry oiaehit phbbnh-eifustrehs,`os bhhi rhmesthrhf (Brhuen oif Zbyszhwsle ?562-?568).Nkaothf ei t`h Tkrtumuhsh Hstrhcofuro (Comketk, OYogkroTroeo fo Omufo, hta.), t`hsh net`ea osshcbnomhs (Gem. 6)- onckst onn surgoah geifs - whrh aknnhathf ki t`h tkp kgroeshf bhoa`hs. V`her omh wos aonaunothf oaakrfeim tk t`hmhihron mnoaek-hustotea ckfhn (t`h `em`hr geifs rhnothf tk t`54-c nhvhn bhoa`hs whrh ottrebuthf tk t`h chfethrroihoiQeaeneoi tech-phrekf). Ei t`h ?5=4s efhiteaon geifs whrh
pubnes`hf, hxthifeim t`h aknnhateki kg kremeion kbshrvotekibkt` ei o thcpkron oif spoteon shish: knfhr seths, ki t`h tkpkg stenn `em`hr bhoa`hs (sua` os Ontk Nheok, ki o bhoa` wet`o `hem`t kg ?84-c, anoechf tk bh fothf tk t`h Aonobreoi EE)oif ihw geifs onkim t`h nettkron ei t`h hxtrhch skut`hri pokg t`h thrretkry (sua` os Cerkuak w`ea` es nkaothf ei t`hwhsthri port kg t`h Onmorvh).
Fkubts akiahrieim t`h foths kg onn Tkrtumuhsh net`eaosshcbnomhs rhghrrhf tk bhgkrh, `ovh bhhi hxprhsshf
Ontetufh (c)
??=4
??84
??14
???4
?454
?4=4
« u g Ocbrkio seth>
?484 ' IO 'Ocbrkiogkrcoteki"ontetufhT.N.C.: tkfoys nkimetufeion prkgenh kg t`h Cenomrk, subsefeory kg t`h Jon÷i revhr
?414
6444 1444 2444 ?444 4 ?444 2444 1444 6444 8444 7444 =444 0444 5444 Festoiah (ei c
Gem. 1. Ckrp`kstrotemrop` ea pkseteki kg Ocbrkio oif Vkrroebo seths, wet`ei t`h thrroahs systhc kg t`h Jonñi revhr (ogthr O. Tårhz-Mkizonhz oif
C. Qoitkijo).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 23/342
? 1 NXEQ ROTKQK OIF COIXHN QOIVKIJO - V@H EBHREOI THIEIQXNO
rhphothfny, useim mhknkmeaon, mhkckrp`knkmeaon oiftypknkmeaon ormuchits (Ropksk ?508< Ropksk oif Aorrhero?507). Ki t`h boses kg prhshit-foy hvefhiah, et cust bhakianufhf e`ot Tkrtumuhsh nettkron "phbbnh-aunturhs":
(o) fk ikt fkauchit bhykif fkubt oiy Horny Tnhestkahihteucoi kaaupoteki<
(b) coy ikt akistetuth oi eifhphifhit tha`ik-akcpnhx,het`hr ei o a`rkiknkmeaoS (prh-Oa`hunhoi) kr ei otypknkmeaon (phbbnh-aunturh) shish. Ei vehw kg t`hnecenonekis ecpkshf by t`h sconn sezhf phbbnhsovoenobnh ei t`ksh roeshf bhoa`hs, t`hy s`kunf bhrhmorfhf os nkaon voreoits kg suaahssevh Tonohknet`eatha`ik-akcpnhxhs.
O ghw Oa`hunhoi net`ea eifustrehs `ovh bhhi gkuif eiskch revhr vonnhys kg t`h whsthri Ebhreoi nettkron. V`h ckstgockus seth es Chon`ofo, ei t`h Ahrteco revhr vonnhy, w`hrhnet`ea orthgoats ("Xpphr Oa`hunhoi") `ovh bhhi gkuif eiosskaeoteki wet` gouion rhcoeis, rhvehwhf by Oituihs ht on.
(?500). Kryatknomus auieaunus, @kckt`hreuc noþfhis,
Hnhp`os (Tonohknkxkfki) oitequus, Hquus aobonnus,
@eppkpktocus eiakmietus, Ahrvus hnop`us, oif Bks
precemhieus orh ottrebuthf tk o nothr ("Resseoi") p`osh kgt`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih. V`h kiny pkssebnh hvefhiah kg oioiaehit Oa`hunhoi kaaupoteki akchs grkc t`h survhyeim oifhxaovoteki wkrl rhahitny aorrehf kut ei t`h Nes revhr vonnhy(Aui`o-Rebherk ?50=, ?552). O tkton kg 8 thrroah nhvhns whrhfkauchithf: twk kg t`hsh, t`h `em`hst kih, _no, oif t`hpaiuntecoth kih, _1, `ovh Oa`hunhoi osshcbnomhs, ki t`hsurgoah oif ei strotemrop`ea pkseteki. Ont`kum` t`hrh orh ikobsknuth foths ovoenobnh gkr t`hsh twk seths, t`h mhkckrp`k-nkmeaon pkseteki kg t`h eifustrehs summhsts t`h hxesthiah kg o
akisefhrobnh ockuit kg tech bhtwhhi t`hc, wet` oi eieteonCeffnh Tnhestkahih foth gkr t`h knfhr kih - o `ypkt`hsessuppkrthf by typknkmeaon foto akceim grkc t`h seth kg_ueito fk Añihmk/Tkuseos (Aui`o-Rebherk ?554-5?).
V`h nost orho tk bh gkaushf ki es t`h nkwhr Vomus boseiw`hrh obuifoit Oa`hunhoi eifustrehs orh likwi grkc t`hsurgoah kg oif ei strotemrop`ea pkseteki wet`ei t`h ceffnhthrroah nhvhns (+ 24/64-c thi-oahs) (Brhuen oif Zbyszhwsle?562-68< Zbyszhwsle ?567). V`h Onpeorao rhmeki eshsphaeonny ecpkrtoit fuh tk t`h kaaurrhiah kg suaahssevhstrotemrop`ea Oa`hunhoi `krezkis. Ot Wonh fk Gkrik, gkreistoiah, M. Zbyszhwsle (?567), `os fhsarebhf o shquhiah
kg 5 strotemrop`ea uiets, a`rkiknkmeaonny krfhrhf grkc t`heieteon Ceffnh Tnhestkahih (akivhitekion "Ceifhn") tk t`heieteon Noth Tnhestkahih (horny "]urc", rhprhshithf byaknnuveon fhpksets). V`h begoah eifustrehs kaaur ei onnshquhiahs: grkc t`h boson mrovhns (nhvhn 2), w`hrh t`hywhrh iochf "Anoatkik-obbhvenneoi" (@. Brhuen's oifM. Zbyszhwsle's thrcs), tk t`h upphr sent oif anoy fhpksets.Rhahit VN foths gkr t`h upphr nhvhns, w`hrh "hvknvhf"
Oa`hunhoi oif "Ceakqueoi" osshcbnomhs orh prhshit,akigerchf t`h efho (Ropksk ht on. ?508) kg ets rhnotevhnyrhahit omh (geion Ceffnh Tnhestkahih oif eieteon NothTnhestkahih). @kwhvhr, t`h bosh kg t`h shquhiah es fothfkiny by anossea mnoaek-hustotea arethreo, w`ea` colhs etecpkssebnh tk akigerc t`h horny foth prkpkshf gkr t`h gerstbegoah eifustrehs kg t`es rhmeki.
1.6. V@H QKXV@HRI CHQHVO
Ei akitrost tk t`h ikrt`hri orho, t`h skut`hri subchshto eso akcpnhx rhmeki grkc o struaturon pkeit kg vehw. Boseaonny,et es akcpkshf kg twk hikrckus shfechitory boseis - t`hVomus, eianufeim t`h Cofref rhmeki, oif t`h Muofeoio,eianufeim No Coia`o oif Aonotrovo. V`hsh boseis orhshporothf by oiaehit rhneìgs (Vknhfk ckuitoeis) oif necethfby Ahitron, Ebhreoi oif Thiebhtea systhcs.
Ei t`h Cofref rhmeki, t`h thrroahs kg Coizoiorhs (wet`net`ea eifustrehs coeiny cofh ei gneit) oif Joroco (wet`osshcbnomhs ckstny cofh ei quortzeth) akistetuth kih kg t`hckst anossea orhos gkr t`h stufy kg t`h Oa`hunhoi ei t`h
w`knh kg Ebhreo (v. Qoitkijo oif Wenno ?554). Xigkrtuiothny,onckst onn kg t`hsh seths `ovh bhhi fhstrkyhf byurboiezot eki (Qoitkijo oif _uhrkn ?504) oif ikih aoi bhottrebuthf tk oi eieteon Ceffnh Tnhestkahih p`osh. V`h knfhstseths ei t`h orho, Qoi Esefrk (nkwhr nhvhn) oif Orefks(porteaunorny ecpkrtoit bhaoush kg t`h gouion osskaeotekisoif t`h hxahptekion prhshrvotekion akifetekis kbshrvhf ei oihnhp`oit buta`hry nhvhn (Qoitkijo oif _uhrkn ?504),prkbobny foth tk o rhnotevhny noth Ceffnh Tnhestkahih p`osh.Coiy kt`hrs, sua` os Orreomo oif Orhihrk fh Kxgmhiekbhnkim tk cua` ckrh rhahit phrekfs, eianufeim t`h eieteonNoth Tnhestkahih.
Grkc t`h Joroco/Vomus akignuhiah up tk t`h Tkrtumuhshthrretkry, iuchrkus seths wet` Oa`hunhoi net`ea eifustrehs`ovh bhhi nkaothf onkim t`h Vomus vonnhy oif ei etstrebutorehs (coeiny t`h Onomñi-Jhrths systhc oif t`hTkisun). Qkch orh strotemrop`ea geifs, gkuif wet`ei t`hceffnh oif upphr thrroah nhvhns. V`h knfhst osshcbnomhs, eit`h Vomus + =4-c thrroah (Hn Hspeior) oif ei t`h + ?24-cOnomñi thrroah (No Chso), `ovh kiny o ghw uia`oroathresteaorthgoats. V`h ckst semiegeaoit net`ea osshcbnomhs orh gkuifkiny ei rhnoteki wet` t`h ceffnh thrroah nhvhns. V`hshosshcbnomhs akrrhspkif tk twk fegghrhit a`rkiknkmeaonp`oshs kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, w`ea` orh whnnrhprhshithf by t`rhh ecpkrtoit seths:
- Teihfk (Gem. 8) (Vomus vonnhy, + 22-c thrroah) (_uhrknoif Qoitkijo ?5=5), opporhitny grkc t`h knfhr p`osh,hvhi eg ihw foto ki t`h nkaon thrroah systhcs wkunf bhihahssory tk fhthrceih t`h hxoat a`rkiknkmeaon pksetekikg t`es seth<
- Hn Qortonhjk (Onomñi vonnhy, + 26/27-c thrroah) (Qoitkijo?508)oif
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 24/342
?6 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
• Q i
Gem. 6. Quppkshfny "ora`oea" ("prh-Oa`hunhoi") osshcbnomhs.?,1, ?4, ?2 oif ?1: a`kpphrs< 2, ??: a`kppeim-tkkns< 6, 8: pshufk-nhvonnkes pkeits< 7 tk 0: sarophrs< 5: fesakef akrh.Onn ei quortzeth, hxahpt 6 oif 7 ei gneit.Trkvhioiah - ?: Comketk< 2 oif 1: Qhexkso< 6 tk ?1: Hn Oaunofhrk.Ogthr N. Ropksk ?508 (? tk 1), C.O. _uhrkn oif C. Qoitkijo ?501 (6 tk ?1). Qaonh ei ac.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 25/342
?8 NXEQ ROTKQK OIF COIXHN QOIVKIJO - V@H EBHREOI THIEIQXNO
Ckith fk Gocoak (Gem. 7) (MHTT ?5==< Ropksk ?50=),grkc t`h ykuimhr kih.
Teihfk es o seth ei shakifory pkseteki wet` kiny o ghw
iki-feomiksteh gouion rhcoeis (Kryatknomus auieaunus,
Hnhp`os (Tonohknkxkfki) oitequus, Hquus, @eppkpktocus
ocp`ebeus, Ahrvus hnop`us, hta.), but et `os ihvhrt`hnhssbhhi pkssebnh tk aknnhat onckst 7444 orthgoats. V`es vost
eifustry onnkwhf t`h prhaesh typknkmeaon fhgeieteki kg w`ot`os bhhi eithrprhthf os oi oiaehit stomh ei t`h hvknuteki kg
t`h Oa`hunhoi, but w`hrh t`h eignuhiah kg nkaon row
cothreons (coeiny quortzeth akbbnhs oif phbbnhs) akunf onskpnoy oi ecpkrtoit rknh.
Hn Qortonhjk es o seth w`hrh skch 744 orthgoats whrhaknnhathf ei o systhcotea surgoah survhy, onnkweim t`h
hstobnes`chit kg oi hvknvhf typknkmeaon stomh wet`ei t`h
Oa`hunhoi.Ckith fk Gocoak es onsk o surgoah seth, w`hrh oi
eithisevh survhy nhf tk t`h fhgeieteki kg oi opporhitnyspoteon potthrieim ei t`h festrebuteki kg t`h net`ea eifustry,
w`ea` akisesthf kg ckrh t`oi ?844 orthgoats.\g, ei offeteki tk t`hsh seths, wh tolh eitk akisefhrotekiskch seths nkaothf ei fegghrhit thrroahs, oif eg wh onsk lhhpei ceif onn thrroah shquhiahs kg ofjoahit vonnhys, et wenn bh
pkssebnh tk buenf o a`rkiknkmeaon grochwkrl, ei mhihronefhiteaon tk t`h kih onrhofy prhshithf gkr t`h ikrt`hriChshto (hsphaeonny ei t`h Vkrchs revhr vonnhy): t`h knfhstgeifs grkc t`h upphr nhvhn thrroahs aoi bh pnoahf ei t`h
bhmeiieim kg t`h Ceffeh Tnhestkahih: Teihfk, os whnn os
skch kt`hr seths ei t`h soch mhkckrp`knkmeaon pkseteki(sua` os Ckith fk Gocoak, wkri shrehs, Ropksk ?50=), orh
fothf tk o ckrh rhahit p`osh kg t`h Ceffeh Tnhestkahih, but
ihw kbshrvotekis ki t`h hxoat pkseteki kg t`h fegghrhit
thrroahs wet`ei hoa` gnuveon vonnhy orh ihahssory (ei t`esrhmorf, t`h hxoat fototeki kg Teihfk, w`ea` akunf bh ckrhrhahit t`oi prhvekusny t`kum`t, es porteaunory rhnhvoit)<Hn Qortonhjk oif Orefks cust bh pnoahf ei o noth CeffehTnhestkahih p`osh, but omoei, knfhr t`oi shvhron kt`hr seths,stenn a`oroathreshf by t`h prhshiah kg begoah eifustrehsnkaothf ei t`h nkwhr thrroahs.
Ei t`h hxtrhch skut`hri port kg t`h rhmeki, oarkss t`h
hiterh Muofeoio revhr bosei, t`h nkaonetehs wet` CeffehTnhestkahih eifustrehs orh rorh. Ei No Coia`o, gkr eistoiah,t`hrh es o akisefhrobnh iucbhr kg surgoah seths, w`ea` orh
kgthi vhry normh oif spoteonny hxthisevh oif prkbobny
rhprhshit wkrls`kp orhos, foteim tk fegghrhit phrekfs butcoeiny tk pkst-Oa`hunhoi techs (Qoitkijo ?507). Ot
Aonotrovo, t`h Muofeoio revhr (wet` 8 thrroahs nhvhns) oif
t`h Jobonñi revhr (wet` 0 thrroah nhvhns), bkt` `ovhOa`hunhoi eifustrehs ei t`h nkwhr thrroahs (Hn Corteihth,Onobono. Tkrzuio), onn kg t`hc foteim tk t`h noth CeffehTnhestkahih kr, phr`ops, tk t`h eieteon Noth Tnhestkahih(Qoitkijo ?50?).
1.8. V@H HBRK FHTRHQQEKI OIF TURHIHOI ORHO
Gknnkweim t`h efho hxprhsshf hornehr obkut t`h saoraety kg
Ceffeh Tnhestkahih net`ea eifustrehs ei t`h hosthri port kg t`h
ikrt`hri Chshto oif t`h Ebhreoi akrfennhro, t`h Hbrk revhrrhmeki oif t`h Tyrhihoi zkih shhc tk bh onckst fhshrthf.Osshcbnomhs pkssebny foteim tk t`h geion Ceffeh Tnhestkahihorh kiny rhpkrthf grkc t`h Iojhrenno sub-bosei (Xtrenno
?506). V`hy aoi, prkbobny, bh rhnothf tk t`h Otopuhrao sethsfuh tk t`h mhkmrop`eaon akiihatekis bhtwhhi t`h twk
rhmekis.Et es feggeaunt tk hxpnoei t`h saoit hvefhiah, w`ea` es
stenn tk bh akigerchf by ihw oif ckrh eithisevh gehnfwkrl. @kwhvhr, kih t`eim es ahrtoei: et aoiikt bh
ottrebuthf tk t`h iki-prhshrvoteki kg shfechits, seiah t`h
Hbrk oif shvhron kt`hr revhrs ei t`h rhmeki prhshit whnnfhvhnkphf Ceffeh Tnhestkahih fhpksets, kaaosekionnygkrchf ei vhry nkw hihrmy hiverkichits (sua` os t`h
Monnhmk revhr), ei w`ea` oiy `ucoi kaaupoteki wkunf bh
prhshrvhf.
1.7. V@H HOQVHRI CHFEVHRROIHOI NEVVKRON
Omoei ei t`es rhmeki, t`hrh orh ikt coiy CeffehTnhestkahih ora`ohknkmeaon geifs. Ei Aotonkieo, t`h hxesthiahkg ora`oea phbbnh eifustrehs `os bhhi rhpkrthf, foteim tk t`h
bhmeiieim kg t`h eieteon Ceffeh Tnhestkahih kr hvhi tk t`h
geion Horny Tnhestkahih. V`hsh osshcbnomhs, ei t`h Vhr revhrvonnhy (Tuem f'hi Rkao) oif ei t`h No Qhnvo orho (Aorbkihnnht on. ?5=0), orh coeiny surgoah geifs oif, akishquhitny,ecpkssebnh tk foth prhaeshny. Ikr aoi t`h osshcbnomh kg t`h
Aou fhn Fua aovh (Nucnhy-]kkfyhor ?5=?) bh fothfhxoatny. Ei t`es aovh top`kikcea prkahsshs coy `ovh cexhfopporhitny knf Oa`hunhoi tkkns wet` kt`hr, anhorny ckrh
rhahit, kihs.V`h hxesthiah kg oi Oa`hunhoi aovh kaaupoteki ei t`es
rhmeki es, `kwhvhr, kih kg ets ckst streleim osphats. Ei t`h
Aosthnnñi oif Wonhiaeo orhos tk t`h skut` kg t`h Hbrk revhr,t`h kaaurrhiah kg skch Ceffeh Tnhestkahih `ucoikaaupotekis ei ot nhost t`rhh aovhs `os bhhi rhpkrthf: Aou
f'hi Bkrros, Vksson fh no Gkit (Aorbkihnn ht on. ?5=5< MuseJhihr ht on. ?501< Orsuomo oif Bhrcufåz fh Aostrk ?506)
oif, ckrh ecpkrtoitny, ot Bknkckr, prhshitny uifhrhxaovoteki (Ghrioifhz Thres ?554), w`hrh rhahit VN oif
oceik-oaef foths summhst t`ot t`h boson port kg t`h
shfechitory shquhiah akunf bh knfhr t`oi KEQ 5.
Whry ghw kg t`hsh geifs `ovh bhhi gkuif ei t`h rhcoeieimorho kg t`h Chfethrroihoi nettkron, up tk Mebrontor. @hrh,t`h Ceffeh Tnhestkahih seths orh hxtrhchny saorah oif kinyei skch vhry rhstreathf pnoahs, ckstny ei gnuveon akithxts(sua` os t`h upphr Muofon`krah vonnhy, ihor Conomo), t`hrhorh o ghw rhghrhiahs tk sconn osshcbnomhs kg quortzethbegoahs oif anhovhrs, wet`kut anhor foths `kwhvhr (Borrkskht on. ?551).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 26/342
?(? V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 8. Oa`hunhoi osshcbnomhs prhsucobny knfhr t`oi KEQ 5.?: sarophr< 2 oif 1: fhiteaunoths< 6: anhovhr< 8 tk =, ?4 oif ??: begoahs< 0 oif 5: tre`hfrons.Onn ei quortzeth, hxahpt 8 ei gneit.Trkvhioiah - ? tk 5: Teihfk (ogthr C.O. _uhrkn oif C. Qoitkijo ?5=5)< ?4: No Coyo EEE (ogthr C. Qoitkijo oif O. Tårhz-Mkizonhz ?506)<?: Nomuio Chfeio (ogthr G. Menhs Toa`hak ht on. ?551). Qaonh ei ac.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 27/342
?= NXEQ ROTKQK OIF COIXHN QOIVKIJO - V@H EBHREOI THIEIQXNO
Gem. 7. Oa`hunhoi osshcbnomhs prhsucobny ykuimhr t`oi KEQ 5.
?, 2 oif =: anhovhrs< 1: akrh ushf tk kbtoei o normh anhovhr gnolh< 6 tk 7: begoahs< 0: tre`hfron< 5: Nhvonnkes ahitrephton akrh.Onn ei quortzeth.Trkvhioiah - ?: No Coyo EE (ogthr C. Qoitkijo oif O. Tårhz-Mkizonhz ?506)< 2 oif 1: Hn Qortonhjk (ogthr C. Qoitkijo ei prhss)< 6 tk 5: Ckithfk Gocoak (ogthr N. Ropksk ht on. ?551o). Qaonh ei ac.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 28/342
?0 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOV?4I KG HXRKTH
1.=. V@H ONMORWH, OIFONXQEO OIF V@H QHMXRO
BOQEI
Ei t`h skut` kg t`h Ebhreoi phieisuno, t`h cojkr mhkmrop`-eaon uiet es t`h `yfrkmrop`ea bosei kg t`h Muofonquever revhr.En es o akcpnhx zkih bhaoush kg ets mhknkmeaon substrotucoif ets ckrp`kstruaturon a`oroathresteas, w`ea` `os oiucbar kg porteaunoretehs tk bh trhothf shporothny grkc t`h
hosnhri Tnek-Tnhestkahih fhprhssekis.V`h knfhst `ucoi kaaupotekis anoechf tk bh fkauchithfei t`es rhmeki orh rhnothf tk t`h nettkron orhos, hsphaeonny eit`h Aofez zkih. V`h ckst semiegeaoit seth es Hn Oaunofhrk(Bkrfhs oif V`ebount ?5==), w`hrh o vost phbbnh-eifustrygkuif ei strotemrop`ea krfhr `os bhhi stufehf ei fhtoen(_uhrkn oif Qoitkijo ?501) (ckrh t`oi 22,444 orthgoatsei ghwhr t`oi ?44 hxaovothf sq. chthrs). V`es seth woseieteonny akisefhrhf tk bh t`h hquevonhit kg stomh EEE kg t`hCkrkaaoi "aevenesoteki fu monht ocåiomå" (Bebhrski ?57?).Xigkrtuiothny, et `os sk gor ikt bhhi pkssebnh tk fothprhaeshny oiy kg t`hsh suppkshfny oiaehit seths, eianufeimHn Oaunofhrk, w`ea` shhcs cua` ckrh rhahit (geion CeffnhTnhestkahih kr o nettnh hornehr) t`oi wos eieteonny suppkshf.Ei akishquhiah, nelh ei t`h Tkrtumuhsh whsthri nettkron, t`hopporhit tha`ik-typknkmeaon ora`oesc kg t`hsh net`eaeifustrehs, cofh ki sconn sezhf phbbnhs, s`kunf rot`hr bhottrebuthf tk row cothreon necetotekis t`oi tk oiy porteaunormrhot oitequety.
V`h efho kg t`h ikihxesthiah kg oi ora`oea HornyTnhestkahih kaaupoteki ei t`es rhmeki `os onsk bhhirheigkrahf by rhahit wkrl aorrehf kut ihor Qhvenno ei t`hMuofonquever nkwhr oif ceffnh akursh, ei oi orho w`hrhobuifoit Oa`hunhoi osshcbnomhs orh likwi. V`h nkaonckrp`kstrotemrop`ea gnuveon shquhiah `os bhhi fhsarebhf ei
fhtoen by Fgoz fhn Knck oif Wonnhspg (?505, ?551),onnkweim t`h efhitegeaoteki kg o tkton kg ?6 thrroah nhvhns,wet` o a`rkiknkmy suppkrthf tk o ahrtoei hxthit by shvhronobsknuth foths (X/V` oif ponohkcomihtesc). Ei brehg, t`hgknnkweim shquhiah aoi bh prhshithf:
- bht whhi t`h V1 thrroah nhvhn (+ ?75-c) oif t h V6 nhvhn(+ ?62-c) t`h Jorocennk hvhit (584/054 Lyr BT) aoi bhpnoahf<
- t`h V7 nhvhn, wet` o ikrcon pknor ety, es fothf tk t`hBrui`hs hpka`<
- skch noaustreih fhpksets rhnothf tk t`h V?4 nhvhn (+ 88-c)`ovh bhhi fothf tk t`h Bewo p`osh (144 Lyr BT)<
- oif t`h Nos Jorennos aorbkiothf fhpkset, ot t`h tkp kgnhvhn VE4 (+ 25-c), es fothf tk 04 Lyr BT (X/V`)(Feozfhn Knck ht on. ?505 oif ?551).
V`h gerst net`ea eifustrehs gkuif ei strotemrop`ea pksetekiwet`ei t`es shquhiah, orh rhnothf tk t`h V7 nhvhn, fothf tk t`heieteon Ceffnh Tnhestkahih. Akishquhitny, t`hy fk ikt akigerct`h suppkshfny hornehr kaaupoteki rhghrrhf tk ei t`h nettkron,
ikr aoi t`hy bh ckrh eigkrcotevh obkut o aunturon oggeneotekibhaoush kg t`her saoraety. V`h gerst oif rorh begoahs opphor einhvhn V0, fothf tk t`h gerst `ong kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih,prekr tk KEQ 5. @kwhvhr, kiny grkc nhvhn Vn ? kiworfs orht`h Oa`hunhoi osshcbnomhs hxthisevhny rhprhshithf, wet`normh iucbhrs kg rhtkua`hf tkkns: begoahs, anhovhrs,tre`hfrons, anhor gnolh-tkkns oif, gkr t`h gerst tech, t`h ush kg
t`h Nhvonnkes cht`kf. Ei offeteki, et s`kunf bh ikthf t`ot uptk nhvhn V?4 quortzeth es ushf ei onn eifustrehs< gneit es kinyushf ei t`h nothr nhvhns. V`es a`oimh es prkbobny rhnothf tkvoryeim row cothreon ovoenobenety os o rhsunt kg a`oimhs eishfechitory gnuveon prkahsshs.
Oa`hunhoi eifustrehs whrh onsk gkuif ei t`h Muofonhthrevhr, oi oiaehit Muofonquever broia`, w`ea` bhmoi tk gkrcets kwi thrroah systhc fureim t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih (Zozkht on. ?508). V`hsh eifustrehs, cofh ki akcpoat nechstkihoif quortzeth, whrh nkaothf ei 6 suaahssevh thrroah nhvhns(G. Menhs Toa`hak ht on. ?552). V`h knfhr kih (+ 68/84-c)aoi, phr`ops, bh ottrebuthf tk oi hornehr p`osh kg t`h CeffnTnhestkahih oif rhvhons t`h hxesthiah kg Oa`hunhoieifustrehs (sua` os t`h Nomuio Chfeio seth, Menhs Toa`hakht on. ?505 oif ?551) hquevonhit tk t`ksh kg Teihfk.
Ei t`h Tkrtumuhsh Onmorvh, ei t`h whsthri shatkr kg t`hrhmeki, t`h kiny semiegeaoit Oa`hunhoi eifustrehs orh gkuifei t`h Muofeoio hstuory. Qkch kg t`hsh eifustrehs orh eistrotemrop`ea pkseteki ei t`h 0-?2-c thrroah nhvhn (sua` osOnfheo Ikvo - Ghek ?567). V`hsh orh, `kwhvhr, sconnosshcbnomhs oif ikt prhaeshny fothf.
Geionny, t`h ecpkrtoit hosthri thrteory fhprhssekis cust bchitekihf: Mroiofo, Muofex-Bozo-Krah. @uhraon-Kvhrooif Whro. V`h fhpksets ei t`h nost twk fhprhssekis krem-eiothf coeiny ei coreih hiverkichits w`enh t`h kt`hrs orh
a`oroathreshf by froeiomh oif Akiteihiton fhpksets. V`hecpkrtoiah kg t`hsh fhprhssekis fhrevhs coeiny grkc t`hvhry akcpnhth fhpksetekion shquhiah t`hy prhshit, rhvhoneimoi onckst shfechitory akiteiuþc grkc t`h Noth Cekahih tt`h Noth Tnhestkahih, eianufeim fegghrhit whnn-fothfponohkitknkmeaon seths.
Ihvhrt`hnhss, t`h oit`rkpkmhiea hvefhiah es saorah(Qoitkijo oif Wenno ?554). ]et`kut akisefhreim, bhaoush kgt`her ocbemuety, t`h suppkshfny `ucoi rhcoeis gkuif otWhito Ceahio oif fothf, by bekstrotemrop`eaon arethreo, tkckrh t`oi 544 Lyr BT, t`h knfhst seth ei t`h orho es Aþnnor-Bozo E (Ruez Bustks oif Cea`oux ?5=7). Et es fothf, boshfki bekstrotemrop`eaon ormuchits (gouion osskaeotekieianufeim ockim coiy kt`hrs Oaoit`kfoatynus hretrurus,
Hnekcys quhraeius, Opkfhcus synvoteaus, Orveakno
cksboa`hises (3 O. thrrhstres aoiteoio), Cearktus
brhaaehises, Aoies htrusaus, Coccut`us trkmkit`hree,
Hquus suhsshibkchises, Hquus ontefhis, Feahrkr`eius
htrusaus, Trohchmoahrks vhrteakries) tk t`h eieteon CeffnhTnhestkahih, phr`ops prekr tk Teihfk. V`h sconn net`ea
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 29/342
\5 NXEQ ROTKQK OIF COIXHN QOIVKIJO - V@H EBHREOI THIEIQXNO
eifustry grkc t`es seth (kiny sex gnolhs oif twk a`kpphrs)fkhs ikt onnkw o typknkmeaon feomikses (Whmo-Vksaoik?505), but et es ihvhrt`hnhss vhry ecpkrtoit bhaoush etfkauchits bhykif oiy fkubt t`h `ucoi kaaupoteki kg t`esorho (oif. t`hrhgkrh, nkr t`h Ebhreoi phieisuno) ei o phrekfw`hrh et es vhry feggeaunt tk geif whnn-fothf seths.
Qknoio fhn Zocbkreik, oikt`hr oif trkc oi ora`ohknkme-
aon pkein kg vehw ahrtoeiny t`h ckst ecpkrtoit CeffnhTnhestkahih seth ei t`h soch fhprhsseki (Bkthnno ht on. ?5=8),prkbobny foths grkc o nothr p`osh. nts gouio (Omuerrh'smrkup "H") akitoeis. ockim kt`hrs, Hnekcys quhraeius,
Hnekcys nusetoieaus, Orveakno sopefus, Opkfhcus gnoveaknnes,
Toit`hro nhk sphnoho, Ghnes nyix porfeio, Ghnes synvhstres,
Coaoao synvoius, Hnhp`os (Tonohknk.xkfki) oitequus, Hquus
aobonnus tkrronboh, Feahrkr`eius `hcetkha`us, @eppkpkto
cus sp.. Ahrvus hnop`us, Foco sp., Aoprhknus aoprhknus,
@ks precemhieus, Beski presaus (Cortei Thihno ?50=). V`hoit`rkpkmhiea hvefhiah, oport grkc oi obuifoit net`eaeifustry (Gem, =) coeiny ki quortzeth oif quortz (but onskki skch nkaon gneit), wet` sarophrs, fhiteaunoths oif o ghw
begoahs, eianufhs onsk skch `obetotekion ghoturhs: o`ypkt`hteaon "trhia`", eithrprhthf os o `uiteim trop, oif oiopporhitny akiveiaeim `hort`. fhgeiaf by o aeranh kg gevhquortzeth phbbnhs, wet` oi ecprhssevh ockuit kg a`orakonoif os` ei t`h ceffnh.
6. Akianusekis]h `ovh rhvehwhf t`h ckst ecpkrtoit seths oif ckrp`k-
strotemrop`ea Ebhreoi shquhiahs, w`ea` coy eifeaoth t`hpkssebnh kaaurrhiah kg `ucoi kaaupotekion troahs prekr tkKEQ 5. V`h mhihron akianuseki es t`ot t`hsh kaaurrhiahs fkhxest, ont`kum` t`hy orh vhry saorah oif kgthi fubekus.
Vk bhmei wet`, et `os bhhi kbshrvhf ei shvhron rhmekist`ot ik rhon hvefhiah aoi bh fothf bhykif oiy fkubt tksua` oi oiaehit phrekf. V`es oppnehs tk ikrt`hri Tkrtumon,Moneaeo oif Aoitobreo, oif onsk tk t`h Hbrk revhr fhprhssekioif t`h Tyrhihoi zkih. Ei skch kt`hr rhmekis, sua` os t`hTkrtumuhsh whsthri nettkron oif t`h Chfethrroihoi hosthrizkih, t`hrh es skch hvefhiah w`ea` aoi bh rhoskiobny fothftk t`h eieteon Ceffnh Tnhestkahih. but wet`kut obsknuthahrtoeity. Kiny ei t`h Akiteihiton eithrekr (ikrt`hri oifskut`hri Chshto) oif ei t`h Muofonquever vonnhy fef whgeif prkkg kg sua` oi oiaehit kaaupoteki, ont`kum` hvhi eit`es aosh t`hrh es ik anhor hvefhiah kg oi knfhr `ucoiprhshiah foteim boal tk t`h Horny Tnhestkahih.
Ei akishquhiah, t`h knfhst `ucoi troahs ei t`h Ebhreoiphieisuno cust bh fothf tk t`h eieteon Ceffnh Tnhestkahih.V`her hxoat foth, `kwhvhr, es ikt whnn hstobnes`hf, seiahckst seths orh fothf by rhnotevh ckrp`kstrotemrop`eaonarethreo. Hvhi ei t`h ghw seths grkc w`ea` obsknuth fothswhrh kbtoeihf, ikt kih kg t`her ora`ohknkmeaon `krezkis `osbhhi fothf ferhatny.
Et es wkrt`w`enh tk ikth, `kwhvhr, t`ot t`hsh knfhst net`eaeifustrehs, ei speth kg t`her rorety. fk opphor ei onn t`h ckstecpkrtoit revhr vonnhys kg t`h Akiteihiton eithrekr: Fkurk,Vomus oif Onomñi, Muofeoio oif Muofonquever, t`hrhbyfkauchiteim oi hxthisevh `ucoi kaaupoteki. V`h noal kgsknef hquevonhit hvefhiah ei t`h w`knh nettkron es puzzneim,but t`es coy pkssebny bh ottrebuthf tk t`h a`rkiknkmeaonuiahrtoeity kg t`h geifs nkaothf ei oiaehit roeshf bhoa`hs.
V`h knfhst net`ea osshcbnomhs kg t`h Ebhreoi phieisuno orhvhry saorah. Ei mhihron, t`h seths pnoahf ot t`h tkp kg gnuveonckrp`kstrotemrop`eaon shquhiahs prhshit kiny o ghworthgoats, usuonny ghwhr t`oi thi (gnolhs oif phbbnh tkkns).Begoahs `ovh ikt yht bhhi fesakvhrhf but t`es coy bh fuhtk t`h socpnh sezh. V`h gerst semiegeaoit oif rhnotevhny whnn-fothf Ebhreoi eifustrehs `ovh onrhofy t`h leif kg normhautteim tkkns ushf tk fhgeih t`h Oa`hunhoi (shisu notk).
Akishquhitny, t`h efho, oaahpthf ei t`h nost twk fhaofhs, kgt`h hxesthiah kg o prh-Oa`hunhoi eifustreon stomh ei Ebhreo,ei t`h gkrc kg t`h sk-aonnhf "phbbnh-aunturhs", cust bhtrhothf wet` aouteki.
Akitrory tk w`ot `os bhhi summhsthf kaaosekionny, t`hbegoah eifustrehs ei Ebhreo orh ikt onn rhnotevhny rhahit. Ei onncojkr gnuveon shquhiahs rhvehwhf, oif onsk ei skch sethsnkaothf ei kt`hr mhknkmeaon hiverkichits (Otopuhrao, gkreistoiah), wh sow t`ot t`h gerst normh autteim tkkns, eianufeimbegoahs, tre`hfrons oif anhovhrs, opphor prekr tk KEQ 5.Omoei, t`hy opphor ei vhry sconn iucbhrs oif t`h sethsfkauchiteim t`es eieteon eifustreon begoaeon p`osh orhrhnotevhny rorh - oi kaaurrhiah ei mrhot akitrost tk t`hobuifoiah oif vorehty kg Oa`hunhoi osshcbnomhs oif sethsfothf tk t`h shakif port kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih oif, eiskch rhmekis ot nhost, tk t`h eieteon Noth Tnhestkahih.
V`h vhregeaoteki kg sua` o vost a`rkiknkmeaon festrebuteki,oif t`h eignuaiah kg skch mhihron ckfhns buent hnshw`hrh(ei Groiah, by @. Brhuen oif G. Bkrfhs< ei Ckrkaak. byT. Bebhrski< ei Onmhreo, by @. Onechi< hta), nhf tk o shora`gkr mhihron hvknutekiory trhifs ei t`h Ebhreoi Oa`hunhoi.V`h hxesthiah kg o shquhiah kg sthpphf neihor stomhs `osbhhi fhghifhf: "nkwhr", "ceffnh", "upphr" oif "geion"Oa`hunhoi, skch kg w`ea` gurt`hr fevefhf ei krfhr tk kbtoeimrhothr "prhaeseki". ]h bhnehvh t`ot t`es leif kg fhtoenhffeveseki shrvhs ik purpksh, fuh tk t`h ikihxesthiah kg sknefoif iuchrkus obsknuth a`rkiknkmeaon rhghrhiahs oif tk t`hsaoraety kg coiy osshcbnomhs. Ei vehw kg t`h necetotekisecpkshf by t`h rhnotevh thcpkron grochwkrl aurrhitny ushf,
ei porteaunor w`hi eithr-gnuveon akrrhnotekis cust bh cofh,wh t`eil t`ot ot prhshit et es ikt pkssebnh tk osahrtoei tkw`ea` aoushs t`h net`ea fevhrsety oif voreobenety s`kunf bhossemihf: tech, spoah, row cothreon ovoenobenety, aunturonoggeietehs, hta. Et es truh t`ot wet`ei t`h ghw gnuveonckrp`kstrotemrop`eaon shquhiahs w`hrh fegghrhit oifsuaahssevh a`rkiknkmeaon Oa`hunhoi stomhs `ovh bhhi
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 30/342
24 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. =. Xpphr/Geion Oa`hunhoi osshcbnomhs (geion Ceffnh Tnhestkahih kr eieteon Noth Tnhestkahih).
?: Voyoa pkeit< 2 oif ?=: hifsarophrs< 1, 6 oif ?6: sefhsarophrs< 8 tk 0 oif ?2: noiahknoth, ceakqueoi, kvonor oif akrfegkrc begoahs< 5 oif
?4: anhovhrs< ??: bepyrocefon ahitrephton akrh< ?1, ?7, ?0, ?5 oif 24: fhiteaunoths oif ikta`hs< ?8: boalhf liegh.?, ?2 tk 24: gneit< 2 tk ??: quortzeth.Trkvhioiah - ? tk ??: Cen`orks (Onpeormo) (ogthr N. Ropksk ht on. ?508)< ?2 tk 24: Qknoio fhn Zocbkreik (ogthr C.A. Bkthnno ht on. ?5=7).
Qaonh ei ac.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 31/342
2? NXEQ ROTKQK OIF COIXHN QOIVKIEO - V@H EBHREOI THIEIQXNO
hstobnes`hf wet` skch ahrtoeity, t`h hornehst begoaheeueuserehs prhshit ckrh "precetevh" tha`ieaon oiftypknkmeaon a`oroathresteas (shh t`h succory prhshithf eiQoitkijo oif Wenno ?554:0=). V`hy orh, `kwhvhr, iktsuggeaeìit tk suppkrt oiy mhihronezoteki. ]et` t`h prhshitfoto bosh, wh bhnehvh t`ot et es kiny pkssebnh tk festeimues`o geion stomh kg t`h Oa`hunhoi ei onn begoah eifustrehs,grhquhitny iochf "Ceakqueoi" (Coi/.orhs revhr, nkwhrVomus froeiomh, ot Onpeorao, Muofeoio, oif nettnh hnsh), oiffothf. ot nhost porteonny, tk t`h eieteon Noth Tnhestkahih. Eirhnoteki tk t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih p`oshs, t`h sknh osphat tkbh rhtoeihf es t`h saoraety kg begoahs prekr tk KEQ 5 oif t`herobuifoiah t`arhogthr. V`es es oi kbshrvoteki w`ea` akunf bhsubjhat tk sphaunoteki ei vehw kg t`h ckfhns t`ot summhst oieithrcetthit eieteon kaaupoteki kg Hurkph oif t`us quhstekit`h a`oroathr kg t`h rhnotekis`ep (akiteiuety/brhol) bhtwhhit`h nerse `oifoxh eifustrehs (Oa`hunhoi 'Obbavenneoi') oift`h ckrh rhahit Ceffnh Tnhestkahih Oa`hunhoi osshcbnomhs.
V`h fhvhnkpchit kg obsknuth foteim prkmrocchs, het`hrkg ora`ohknkmeaon seths kr kg mhknkmeaon gkrcotekis, ei
gnuveon akithxts (os `os onrhofy bhhi eieteothf ei t`hMuofonquever revhr oif es ikw bheim hxhauthf ei t`hQpoies` Vomus bosei), anhorny s`kunf bh kih kg t`h gerstprekretehs kg t`h Ebhreoi Ceffnh Tnhestkahih rhshora`. Etwkunf onsk bh ecpkrtoit tk foth skch kg t`h akoston seths,hsphaeonny kg t`h whsthri Tkrtumuhsh nettkron oif kgt`h Aofez rhmeki. ]et` sua` o remkrkus oif fhtoenhfa`rkiknkmehon grochwkrl, w`ea` wenn onnkw o jufeaekusshnhateki kg porteaunor seths oif shquhiahs, et wenn bh ushguntk rh-hvonuoth, ockim kt`hr quhstekis, t`h hxesthiah kgmhihroS hvknutekiory trhifs wet`ei t`h Oa`hunhoi, t`hguiatekion ora`ohknkmeaon ioturh kg hoa` seth, t`hmhkmrop`eaon festrebuteki kg fegghrhit seths (wet`ei hoa`rhmeki oif onn kvhr Ebhreo), t`h rhnotekis hxesteim bhtwhhiEbhreo oif ofjoahit orhos, oif sk ki. V`hsh orh vhryecpkrtoit quhstekis. porteaunorny seiah, w`othvhr ckfhn es
ushf, et shhcs anhor t`ot kiny ei skut`hrickst Hurkph whaoi hxphat o akiteiukus Ceffnh Tnhestkahih ora`ohknkmeaonrhakrf, grhh grkc semiegeaoit hiverkichiton akistroeits.Qua` es t`h aosh kg t`h Ebhreoi subakiteihit.
Geion rhcorl
Bhtwhhi t`h eieteon hnobkroteki kg t`es pophr (Qhpthcbhr
?551) oif ets geion rhveseki (Cora` ?558) skch ihwkbshrvotekis summhsthf kiah omoei t`h pkssebnh kaaurrhiahkg o saorah `ucoi kaaupoteki ei Ebhreo, foteim boal tk t`hgeion Horny Tnhestkahih. Ihor Whito Ceahio, ei t`h Muofex-Bozo bosei, o seth akitoeieim o sconn, but eiquhstekiobnh,net`ea eifustry, Guhithiuhvo 1, `os bhhi nkaothf (OnoeiVurq, phrskion akccuieaoteki, tk bh pubnes`hf ei t`h"Akcpth Rhifu fh n'Oaofåceh fhs Qaehiahs", Tores),opporhitny fothf tk t`h Jocorennk hvhit (a. 584/054 Lyr BT)ki t`h boses kg mhkckrp`knkmeaon, shfechitory oif gouio!arethreo. V`es efho shhcs tk bh rheigkrahf by ihwa`rkiknkmehon foto ki t`h nkwhr bhfs kg t`h Otopuhraoshquhiah (VF6 tk VF7 nhvhns) oif ki t`h ceffnh-upphr
thrroahs kg t`h Fkurk revhr. Ei t`es rhmorf, t`h `ypkt`hses kgo geion Horny Tnhestkahih kaaupoteki ei Ebhreo rhcoeis oikphi quhsteki, hsphaeonny bhaoush et shhcs anhor ikw t`otorkuif ? Cyr omk `ucois whrh onrhofy ot t`h skut`hrigrkitehrs kg Hurkph, grkc t`h Aouaoseoi orho tk t`h nettkronkg Ckrkaak. V`h areteaon opprkoa` ushf ei t`es pophr pnoysoi ecpkrtoit rknh, os et bhaoch aurrhit ei t`h nost twkfhaofhs tk oaahpt uiareteaonny onckst onn eifeaotekis kgoiaehit `ucoi kaaupotekis ei Ebhreo, oif hnshw`hrh. But, os]. Rkhbrkhls onrhofy ikthf (?556, 142), kih kg t`hofvoitomhs kg t`h "s`krt a`rkiknkmy" sahiorek, govkurhf bykurshnvhs oif ckst kg t`h porteaepoits ei t`h "Voutovhnchhteim", es t`ot "et es hosy tk gonsegy". Coybh t`h rhahit
geifs grkc Ebhreo, eg prkvhi tk bh vonef ei t`h guturh, aoiyehnf t`h hvefhiah w`ea` es aurrhitny stenn cesseim.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 32/342
22 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
rhghrhiahs
Omuerrh, H. ?505 Whrthbrofks fhn Tnhestkahik Akiteihiton. Ei: Copo fhn Auothriorek fh Hspoio, 6=-75,Eistetutk Vhaiknñmeak Mhk-Ceihrk fh Hspoio, Cofref.
?55? Nhs prhcehrs phupnhchits `ucoeis fh no Thieisuno Ebårequh. Ei: H. Bkiegoy oif
B. Woifhrchhrsa` (hfs), Nhs prhcehrs Hurkpåhis, ?61-?84, Tores: [email protected].
?50= Hn @kcbrh gñsen fh nbhos y hn Tnhestkahik fh no Qehrro fh Otopuhrao, Juito fh Aostenno yNhñi, Wonnofknef.
Onechi. @.
?554 V`h Otopuhrao seths oif t`h nbhos `kceiefs, @ucoi Hvknuteki 8(?), 88-=1, Gnkrhiah.
?5=8 Nhs est`chs `espoik-corkaoei ht seaenk-teiesehi oux thcps oa`hunåhis, N'Oit`rkpknkmeh =155-617, Tores.
Oituihs. C.V..J.N. Aorfksk,C. Gourh
?500 Tråshiah fh @eppkpktocus eiakmietus ou Tkrtumon ht Rhcorquhs sur nhs Qeths _uothrioerfh Chon`ofo, Akcuieaoa÷hs fks Qhrveaks Mhknñmeaks fh Tkrtumon =6, ?78-?=2, Nesbko.
Orioëz. C.O. ?554 Nos kaupoaekihs fh Qoi _uerah fhn rek Tesuhrmo< rhgnhxekihs skbrh no kaaupoaeki fhn hspoay sus ecpneaoaekihs. Bkn. Qhc. fh Orth v Orquhknkmeo fh no Xiev. fh Wonnofknef NWE, 28-1=
Orsuomo. J.N.,J.C. Bhrcufhz Fh Aostrk
?506 Hstufek fh nks rhstks `ucoiks fhn yoaecehitk fh no Akvo fhn Vksson fh no Gkit (Wenno-gocås, Aosrhnnñi), Auofhriks fh Trh est. y Orquhkn. Aosthnnkihish ?4, ?0-16, FeputoaeñTrkveiaeon fh Aosthnnñi.
Borrksk, A,J.J. Furoi,G. Chfeio,O. Ckrmofk
Bebhrski. T.
?551 Hn mnoaes-thrrozo fh Onjoeco (Conomo) y su eifþstreo oa`hnhish , Hn Auothriorek hi Hspoi
y Tkrtumon ?, 105-15=, hf. EVMC oif OH_XO, Cofr ef.
?57? Nh Tonåkne t`equh eigårehur fu Corka otnoit equh, Tubn. fhs Qhrveahs fhs Oitequetås fu
Corka, gosh. ?=, Robot.
Bkrfhs. G.
Bkrfhs, G..An. Wemuehr
?5=? Kbshrvotekis sur ?'Oa`hunåhi fhs mrktths hi Fkrfkmih, Cuiebh 21, 8-21.
?575 Tråshiah fh monhts toennhs fh typh oiaehi fois no råmeki fh Aorckio (Qhvenno, Hspomih),Akcpths r. fh E'Oaofåceh fhs Qaehiahs fh Tores, 275 (F), ?567-?56=.
Bkrfhs, G.,An. V`ebounn
?5== V`kum`ts ki t`h eieteon Ofoptoteki kg @kceiefs tk Hurkphoi Mnoaeon Anecoths, _uonhrio
Rhshora 0, ??8-?2=.
Bkthnno, C.A.,J.O. Whro,J. Tkrto
?5=8 Hn yoaecehitk oa`hnhish fh Qknoio fhn Zocbkreik. Gkihnos (Mroiofo), Auofhriks fh
Trh`estkreo fh no Xievhrsefof fh Mroiofo ?, ? -67.
Brhuen. @..
M. Zbyszhwsle
?562-68 Akitrebuteki o n'åtufh fhs eifustrehs ponhknet`equhs fu Tkrtumon ht fh nhurs roppkrts ovha
no mhknkmeh fu _uothrioerh, Akcuieaoa÷hs fks Qhrveaks Mhknñmeaks fh Tkrtumon 21 oif27, Nesbko.
Aoik Toi, J.O. ?55? Nos eifustreos Etteaos tonnofos hi no aksto fh no Muorfeo o Boekio. Feputoaeñi Trkveiaeonfh O Akruio.
Aorbkihnn, H.,J. Aoion.I. Qoba`ez
?5=0 Hn Oa`hnhish suphrekr fh Tuem f'Hsaonts, No Qhnvo (Mhrkio), Auofhriks fh Trh`est. y Orquhkn. Aosthnnkihish 8, 8-25.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 33/342
21
Aorbkihnn, H.
NXEQ ROTKQK OIF COIXHN QOIVKIJO - V@H EBHREOI THIEIQXNO
?5=5 Rhsuntofks prhneceiorhs fh nks trobojks hghatuofks hi hn yoaecehitk fhn Tnhestkahik chfekfh 'Aou f'hi Bkrros' (Krkphso, Aosthnnñi), Auofariks fh Trh`est. y Orquhkn. Aosthn-
nkihish 7, =-?=, Aosthnnñi no Tnoio.
Aui`o-Rebherk, J.T.
Feoz Fhn Knck. G. ht onneo
Ghek, C.
Ghrioifhz Thres, J.
M.H.T.T.
Mebhrt, J.
Menhs Toa`hak, G.,O. Qoiteomk,J.C. Muteårrhz,H. Coto N. Omuenhro
Menhs Toa`hak, G.,J.C. Muteårrhz Nñphz,O. Qoiteomk Tårz,H. Coto Onckinh.Omuenhro Rkfi'muhz
Muse Jhihr, G.,H. Aorbkihnn Rkuro,J. Hsthvhz Hsaonhro,R. Ckro.J. Coothu Bhnnhs,R. Unn
?502 Auhvo Weatkreo (Curaeo, Hspogeo): numor fh kaupoaeñi `ucoio cos oitemuk fh noThieisuno ebåreao, Hifeis 0, 6=-8=, Tonco fh Connkrao.
?552 Hxaurseki on nks yoaecehitks chskpnhestkahieaks fh no Qehrro fh Otopuhrao, Est Eithr
iotekion Chhteim ki Vha`ieaon systhcs tk Akigemurh Net`ea Kbjhts kgQaorah Hnobkroteki,20-78, Vorromkio.
?554/5? Eithrvhiaok orquhknñmeao io hstoaok oa`hunhish fo _ueito fk Añihmk/Tkus eos, Tkrtumoneo,
ikvo såreh, PE-PEE, =-27, Eist. fo Orquhknkmeo, GNXT, Tkrtk.
?552 K Tonhkneteak ik vonh fk rek Nes, Rhvesno fo Goaunfofh fh Nhtros EP(EE), 64?-672, Tkrtk.
?552/51 Akitrebueaok poro k hstufk fk Tonhkneteak fk vonh fk rek Nes ik shu akithxtk arkik-hstrotemrogeak, Tkrtumfneo, ikvo såreh, PEEE-PEW, =-?1=, Eist. fo Orquhknkmeo, GNXT, Tkrtk.
?505 Vhrrozos pnhestkahios fhn Muofonqueve r kaaefhiton: mhkckrgknkmgo, suhnks, ponhksuhnks yshauhiaeo aunturon. Ei: Hn Auothriorek hi Oifonuaeo kaaefhiton, 2=-1?, Qhvenno: OH_XO.
?551 Auothriorek y shquhiaeo ponhkne'teao hi nos thrrozos fhn bojk y chfek Muofonquever:onuvekiocehitks. aknuvekihs, suhnks y ponhksuhnks. WE Jkcofos fh Orquhknkmeo Oifonuzo,
Juito fh Oifonuaeo, @uhnvo.
?567 Ks thrroaks fk Muofeoio o jusoith fk Orfeno, Akcuieaoa÷hs fks Qhrveaks Mhknñmeaks fh
Tkrtumon PPWEE, 1-01, Nesbko.
?554 Hn Tonhkneteak eighrekr hi hn Toes Wonhiaeoik, Xiev. fh Wonhiaeo (t`hses).
?5== K hstufk fk Tonhkneteak fo orho fk Rñfok, K Orquhñnkmk Tkrnumuês, shreh 1, =-5, 1?-6=.
?508 Whito Ceahio: ui fhns joaechits `ucois chs oiteas f'Hurkpo, Vrebuio fy orquhknkmeo
?501-06, 81-80, Borahnkio: Ferhaaeñ Mhi. Totreckie Orestea.
?505 Hn pkbnocehitk ponhkneteak hi hn vonnh fhn rek Muofonh th, Hn Auothriorek hi Oifonuaeo
kaaefhiton, 61-8=, OH_XO, Qhvenno.
?552 Qhquhiaeo ponhkne'teao fhn vonnh fhn Muofonhth: prechrks rhsuntofks, Orquhknkmeo ?18,?7-27, Cofref.
?551 Hn Tonhkneteak Eighrekr fh no Nomuio Chfeio (Jhrhz fh no Grkithro, Aofez), Hn Auothriorek
hi Hspogeo y Tkrtumon ?, 671-6=1, hf. EVMC oif OH_XO, Cofref.
?501 Ovoiah prhneceior skbrh hn yoaecehitk fhn Tnhestkahik chfek fh no Akvo fhn Vksson fh noGkit (Wennogocås, Aosthnnñi), Auof. fh Trh`est. y Orquhkn. Aosthnnkihish ? (?504), =-25,Aosthnnñi no Tnoio.
Nouthisoa`. @. ?57= Mhkmrogeo fh Hspogeo y Tkrtumon, hf. Weahis Wevhs, Borahnkio.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 34/342
26 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Nucnhy-]kkfyhor, @. fh
Cortëi-Thihno, O.
Cherhnas. J.
Ckneio, H.
Tårhz Mkizonhz, O.
?5=? Nh Tonåknet`equh eigårehur ht ckyhi fu Cefe cåfethrroiåhi fois ski aofrh måknkmequh.t. EE, Bos-Noimuhfka, Rkussennki, Aotonkmih, Monneo-Trå`estkerh W suppn., Tores.
?50= Tonhkitknkmeo fh nks mroifhs cocnghrks fhn yoaecehitk oa`hnhish fh no Qknoio fhn
Zocbkreik (Gkihnos, Mroiofo), Mroiofo Xievhrsety (t`hses).
?507 Trkbnhcos h phrsphatevos fk _uothcorek fk netkron cei`ktk o ikrth fk rek Neco, Aofhr
fh Orquhknkmeo ??(1), ??-?6=.
?55? Mhkckegknkmeo y mhkqueceao fhn poesojh, Xiev. fh Qonocoiao.
?502 Ihñmhik y Auothriorek fh no Nnoiuro coia`hmo y sus rhnoaekihs aki no auhiao
fhn Vojk, Xiev. Akcpnuthish fh Cofref (t`hses).
Tårhz Mki/onhz. O..C. Qoitkijo,J. Monnorfk
?502o Hn Auothriorek fh no rhmeñi ahitron fh no auhiao fhn Fuhrk, Oatos ? Rhuieñi skbrh
Mhknkmeo fh no Auhiao fhn Fuhrk EE, =?=-=64, Eist. Mhkn. y Ceihrk. Cofref.
?502 _uothriory @estkry kg Cojkr Revhr Wonnhys kg t`h Aosteneoi Boseis - Ahitron Qpoei. PEEI_XO Akimrhss Obstroats EE, 261, Cksakvk.
_uhrkn, C.O.,C. Qoitkijo
Ropksk, N.
?5=5 Hn yoaecehitk oa`hnhish fh Teihfk (Vknhfk), Hxa. Orquhkn. hi Hspoio ?47, Cofref,Ceiesthrek fh Aunturo.
?501 Hn yoaecehitk fh aoitks trobojofks fh Hn Oaunofhrk (Tuhrtk fh Qoito Coreo, Aofez), Hxa
Orquhkn. hi Hspoio ?14, Cofref, Ceiesthrek fh Aunturo.
?508 Nh Tonåknet`equh eigårehur ora`oequh ou Tkrtumon : benoi fhs akiioesssoiahs, Buen. fh no
Qkaeetå Trå`estkrequh Groiaoesh 02 (7), ?=1-?02.
?50= Ks coes oitemks vhstemeks fh kaupoaok `ucoio ponhk`'teao io rhmeok fh Rñfok, Fo Trå-
@estñreo f @estñreo (vknuch fh @kchiomhc o Katovek fo Whemo Ghrrhero), ?81-?=0, hf.Fhnto, Nesbko.
Ropksk, N.,J.R. Aorrhero,C. Qonvofkr
?508 O hstoaok oa`hunhish geion fh Cen`orñs, Wonh fk Gkrik, Onpeorao, Oatos fo E Rhuieok fk
_uothcorek Ebåreak 2, =5-54.
Ropksk. N. ?551 N'Oa`hunåhi fois no vonnåh fu Vomh, ou Tkrtumon, Tu`n. fu AHRT 6, Xiev. fhs Qaehiahs Vha`iknkmehs fh Nennh (ei prhss).
?551o K Oa`hunhish ik vonh fk Vhjk, hc thrretñrek pkrtumuês, Orquhknkmeo h @estñreo P(EEE),?8-6?, Nesbko.
Ropksk, N.,J.R. Aorrhero
Rkfremuhz Oshisek, J.O.
?507 Oahrao fo hxestêiaeo fh akcpnhxks eifustreoes prå-oa`hunhishs ik thrretñrek pkrtumuês,K Orquhñnkmk Tkrtumuês, 6O[(6), =-54, Nesbko.
?501 No prhshiaeo `ucoio cos oitemuo hi Ostureos. Hn Tonhk`'teak eighrekr y chfek, Hstufeks
Orquhkn. Ostureoio 2, Guif. Tþbneao fh Auhvos y Uoaecehitks Trh`estkreaks fh Ostureos,Kvehfk.
Rkhbrkhls, ].
Rknnoif. I.
Ruez Bustks. O..J. Cea`oux
?556 Xpfoteim t`h Hornehst Kaaupoteki kg Hurkph, Aurrhit Oit`rkpknkmy 18, 14?-148.
?552 V`h Tonohknet`ea aknkiezo teki kg Hurkph: Oi ora`ohknkmeao n oif bekmhkmrop`eaphrsphatevh, Vrobojks fh Trh`estkreo 65, 75-???.
?5=7 Nh seth prå`estkrequh ikuvhou fh Aþnnor-Bozo E (Mrhiofh, Hspomih) , f'omh Tnhestkahihckyhi. Åtufh pråneceioerh ht oionysh fh no gouih fh Rkimhurs. Mhknkmeh Chfethrroiiåh
EEE-1, ?=1-?02.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 35/342
28
Qoitkijo, C.
Qoitkijo, C.,O. _uhrkn
Qoitkijo, C.,O. Tårhz Mkizonhs
Qoitkijo, C.T. Wenno
Qoitkijo, C,H. Ckesshiht,O. Thrhz. Mkizonhz
Xtrenno, T.
Whmo Vksaoik, N.-M.
/ o / k . AJ.N. Mky,A.J. Fobrek,J. Aeves,J. Bohio
Zbyszhwsle, M.
NXEQ ROTKQK OIF COIXHN QOIVKIJO - V@H EBHREOI THIEIQXNO
?50? Aoroathi'steaos mhihronhs fhn Tonhk`'teak eighrekr fh no Chshto hspoikno, Iucoineo E, 5-76.
?508 Hn yoaecehitk oa`hnhish fh Hn Qortonhjk (vonnh fhn Onomñi, Aoahrhs ). Hstufek prhneceior,Qhrehs fh Orquhknkmes Hxtrhchio 2, ?-?45, Xiev. fh Hxtrhcofuro, Aoahrhs.
?552 No ofoptoaeñi on chfek hi hn Tonhknnteak eighrekr fh no Thieisuno e`åreao. Hnhchitks poro
uio rhgnhxeñi, Hnhgoiths, aehrvks y kveaopreiks, 1=-=7, hf. O. Ckurh Rkcoiennk, Xiev. fhAoitobreo, Qoitofhr.
?556 Hn Tonhk`'teak eighrekr hi no Qubchshto ikrth y hi on hitkrik fh Otopuhrao. Bonoiah fh nksakikaecehitks hi ?552, Hvknuaeñi `ucoio hi Hurkpo y nks yoaecehitks fh no Qehrro fh
Otopuhrao, vkn. 2, 62?-666 , Juito fh Aostenno y Nåki.
?504 Nos eifustreos oa`hnhishs hi no rhmeñi fh Cofref, Kaupotekihs oa`hnhishs hi hn vonnh fhn
Joroco. Ei: C. Qoitkijo ht on. (hfs), Tubn. fh no Feputoteñi Trkveiaeon, Cofref.
?502 Eifustreos fhn Tonhknnteak eighrekr oraoeak hi no Chshto hspoikno, @kchiomh o Ghrioifhz-A`eaorrk, Cofref, ?0-26, Ceiesthrek fh Aunturo.
?506 Nos eifustreos ponhk`'teaos fh No Coyo E hi su ocbetk rhmekion, H.xaov. Orquhkn. hi
Hspoio ?18, Cofref, Ceiesthrek fh Aunturo.
?554 V`h Nkwhr Tonhknet`ea kg Qpoei oif Tkrtumon, Jkurion kg ]krnf Trh`estkry 6 (?), 68-56.
?552 Auhsto fh no Bojofo (Vhruhn) . Iuhvk sgtek Tonhk`'teak eighrekr. Bun. fhn Qhceioreo fh
Hstufeks fh Orth y Orquhknkmeo, NWEEE, 28-68, Xiev. fh Wonnofknef.
?506 Hn Tonhknnteak hi hn aursk chfek fhn rek Hbrk, Aono`krro y su hitkrik, Aono`krro,
Betienhiorek fh su guifoaeñi, Cofref, Ceiesthrek fh Aunturo.
?505 Kaupoaekihs `ucoios hi hn Tnhestkahik fh no Fhprhseñi Muofex-Bozo: hnhchitks fhfesauseñi. Ei: C.V. Onbhrfe oif G.T. Bkiofkio (hfs), Mhknkmeo y Tonhkitknkmeo fh no
Auhiao fh Muofex-Bozo, Vrobojks Ihñmhik-Auothriorek ??, 12=-168, Cushk fh AeêiaeosIoturonhs, Cofref, A.Q.E.A.
?508 Tonhkmhkmroggo fh no fhshcbkaofuro fhn Muofonquever on akcehizk fhn Auothriorek, Oatos fh no ? Rhuieñi fhn Auothriorek nbåreak, vkn. ?, 67?-6=2.
?567 Åtufh Måknkmequh fh no Råmeki f'Onpeorao, Akcuieaoa÷hs fks Qhrvemks Mhknñmeaks fh
Tkrtumon PPWEE, ?68-27=, Nesbko.
Nues RopkskCushu Ioaekion fh OrquhknkmeoTroao fk Ecpårek?644 NesbkoTkrtumon
Coiuhn QoitkijoCushk fh QonocoiaoTotek fh Hsauhnos, 21=440 QonocoiaoHspoio
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 36/342
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 37/342
kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: EtonyCorm`hreto Cusse 2 V`h hornehst
V`es pophr rhvehws vorekus osphats kg t`h rea` Nkwhr
Tonohknet`ea rhakrf kg Etony, w`hrh `ucoi mrkups whrh
ahrtoeiny neveim by obkut 844 tk 744 Lyr BT< t`h hvefhiah
gkr oi hornehr kaaupoteki es ikn akcphnneim vht. Kphi oif
akcpkseth hiverkichits whrhgovkurhf n9y t`h getst
ei`obetoits, w`ksh orthgoats orhgkuif osskaeothf wet`
,???????,en `kihs on shvhron seths, t`kum` uiocbemXKXQ hvefhiah
gkr `ucoi eivknvhchit wet` t`hsh goiios es rorh. Tort kg
t`h neoneoi "Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea suaahss" cem`t `h rhnoxhf
tk t`h rea`iass oif t`h vorehty kg hiverkichits.
?. EitrkfuatekiEtony es likwi tk `ovh o semiegeaoit Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea
rhakrf (Gem. ?) (Cusse ?552). Ei t`es pophr, wh wenn hxoceiht`h kvhronn seth prhshrvoteki, oif prhshit o survhy kg lhyseths. V`hi akitrkvhrseon osphats kg foteim wenn bh fesausshf,ponohkhiverkichits a`oroathreshf, oif t`h hvefhiah rhnothftk subsesthiah, os whnn os tk skch osphats kg net`ea typknkmyoif tha`iknkmy, wenn bh akcchithf upki. Ceikr seths, krseths w`ea` orh just pkkrny fothf, wenn onsk bh tolhi eitkoaakuit. Ei kur akianusekis, wh wenn akisefhr Etony ei obrkofhr phrsphatevh. oif put gkrworf skch `ypkt`hses ki
t`h aoushs govkureim oi horny shttnhchit ei t`h orho.Ikt eianufeim t`h coiy uiakitrknnhf surgoah aknnhatekis,
skch 64 seths orh anoechf tk bh os horny os, kr hornehr t`oi,KEQ 5: t`ot es, t`hy orh opprkxecothny ckrh t`oi 144 Lyrknf. ]h wenn ikt fesauss `hrh w`ot sua` o "seth" es: et eshikum` tk rhchcbhr t`ot t`hy roimh grkc Wona`httoAortkie, wet` twk gnolh ecpnhchits, tk Whikso kr Eshrieo,w`hrh cunte-noyhrhf fhpksets orh aurrhitny hxaovothf kvhrorhos kg `uifrhfs kg squorh chtrhs.
V`h a`rkiknkmy es boshf ki fegghrhit shts kg hvefhiah,sua` os rofekchtrea foths, ponohkcomihtesc, mhk-strotemroptþaon akrrhnotekis oif hvknutekiory a`oroathresteaskg osskaeothf gouios. Ei t`es rhsphat, wh wenn ikt tolh eitkoaakuit rhghrhiahs tk tha`iknkmeaon kr typknkmeaona`oroathresteas kg t`h eifustrehs, kgthi nhofeim tk shreotekisgrkc suppkshfny ckrh ora`oea tk ckrh hvknvhf eifustrehs.
Rofekchtrea foths orh ovoenobnh ot shvhron seths, bhaoushkg t`h coiy vknaoikhs w`ea` `ovh bhhi oatevh fureim t`hTnekahih oif t`h Tnhestkahih (Gem. 2). V`es es ei turi rhnothftk t`h eithish thatkiea oatevety grkc t`h noth Cekahih
kiworfs, w`hi t`h Ophiieihs storthf tk roesh grkc t`hprhvekus s`onnkw sho (Arhcosa`e oif A`ehso ?552). V`hkrkmhihses kg t`h Ophiieihs, w`ea` orh t`h boalbkih kg t`hphieisuno oif akiteiuh eitk Qeaeny, es onsk rhnhvoit tkora`ohknkmy gkr oikt`hr rhoski: w`enh t`her hosthri hfmhhxphrehiahf akcprhssevh thatkieas, rhsunteim ei oionthrioteki kg fhhphihf boseis oif upnegthf orhos, t`herwhsthri hfmh hxphrehiahf festhisevh thatkieas, w`ea` nothrki nhf tk t`h gkrcoteki kg gnuvek-noaustreih boseis w`ea`, osot Eshrieo, Whikso, Oiomie, ottroathf `hrfs kg `hrbevkrhs
oif t`her prhfotkrs, oif `ucoi mrkups os whnn (Gem. 1).Bkih prhshrvoteki es kgthi mkkf ei sua` hiverkichits,w`ea` oaakuits gkr oi ecpkrtoit port kg t`h ora`ohknkmeaonrhakrf.
Tonohkcomihtea fhthrceiotekis orh kgthi otthcpthf.@kwhvhr, hvhi w`hi t`es cht`kf es ghosebnh oifopprkpreoth, sphaegeh fhthrceiotekis orh choieimgun kinyeg getthf eitk o akcpnhth shquhiah kg hvhits kg likwia`rkiknkmy (shh Oetlhi, t`es vknuch) - w`ea` es ikt onwoyst`h aosh gkr ora`ohknkmeaon seths.
Mhk-strotemrop`ea akrrhnotekis cust tolh eitk oaakuit t`hmhkmrop`eaon phauneoretehs kg Etony. V`h hnkimothf oif
iorrkw phieisuno oif t`h esnoifs `ovh onckst 5444 lc kgakosts, oif gnuveon systhcs kg necethf hxthit: t`h Tk, w`ea`es by gor t`h cojkr revhr, es 782 lc nkim, w`enh t`hrh orhfkzhis kg revhrs ei t`h roimh kg ?44 lc nkim. O normh portkg t`h mhkckrp`knkmeaon oif shfechitory prkahsshs esakishquhitny ferhatny neilhf tk sho nhvhn gnuatuotekis.Akrrhnotekis wet` esktkpea stomhs orh opprkpreoth oif ckrhsemiegeaoit t`oi ei gunny Akiteihiton ports kg Hurkph.@kwhvhr, t`h "coreih akitrkn" kg t`h shfechitoteki es oprkbnhc ei etshng: einoif, hxthisevh hrkseki surgoahs fhvhnkpos o akishquhiah kg gonneim sho-nhvhns. Oiy mhk-a`rkik-nkmeaon sa`hch eianufhs o gunn sht kg hrksekion p`oshs,akrrhnothf tk t`h mnoaeon kihs, akitrosteim wet` eithrmnoaeonfhpkseteki phrekfs (shh gkr eistoiah Ocbrkshtte ht on. ?5=2).Et es ik surpresh t`ot t`h ora`ohknkmeaon rhakrf es cua`beoshf tkworfs worc anecotea p`oshs, oif kff-iucbhrhfesktkpea stomhs, w`hi shfechits whrh fhpksethf, ikthrkfhf. V`h mops aoi bh gennhf w`hrh ioturon "shfechitorytrops" kaaur, sua` os aovhs oif thatkieaonny akitrknnhfboseis.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 38/342
20 V@H HORNEHQV KA'A'n TOË ËKI ()\ ?? RKn'e:
Gem. ?. Qeth nkaoteki. ?: Mr. fhn
Aknkcbk< 2: Aknneioeo< 1: Bebbkio<
6: Ckith Thmneo< 8: Vkrrh ei Tehtro<
7: Aosthn fe Muefk< =: No Tknnh-
froro< 0: Conomrktto< 5: Wona`htto
Aortkie< ?4: Reoik< ??: Gkitoio
Roiuaaek< ?2: Aknnh Coreik<
?1: Ikaeaa`ek< ?6: Orah< ?8: Gki
toio Nere< ?7: Aostrk fhe Wknsae<
?=: Aovo Tkcpe< ?0: Eshrieo No
Teihto< ?5: Rksoihtk< 24: Aoshnno
fe Coefo< 2?: Weskmneoik< 22: Ckith
Tkmmeknk< 21: Nh Qvknth< 26: Wonnh
Meuchiteio< 28: Gkah fhn Vkrrhith
Rkcoifotk< 27: Mrktto Tomneaae (Rep.
hsthrik)< 2=: Othnno< 20: Whikso
Nkrhtk, Whikso Iktora`ereak.
Os t`h coiy eitro-Ophiieih boseis `ovh prhshrvhf oihxthisevh orroy kg gouion osshcbnomhs, o wefhny ushfbeka`rkiknkmy `os bhhi wkrlhf kut, w`ea` es coeiny boshfki t`h normhr coccons. Et es onsk ushf ot ora`ohknkmeaonseths, eg bkihs orh prhshrvhf. @kwhvhr, normh coccon
avknuteki es rot`hr snkw, oif fkhs ikt onnkw `em`a`rkiknkmeaon rhsknuteki. Gurt`hrckrh, et es o rhnotevhtech-saonh, w`ea` cust bh oia`krhf tk obsknuth a`rkiknkmyby fothf rhghrhiah osshcbnomhs. Oiy a`oimh ei t`h omh kgt`h notthr kihs `os akishquhiahs ki o normh iucbhr kgkaaurrhiahs oif aoi nhof tk o rh-eithrprhtoteki kg o w`knhshquhiah (shh Rkhbrkhls oif Woi Lkngsa`kthi, t`esvknuch).
2. Lhy sethsV`h seths w`ea` `ovh bhhi ckrh oaaurothny fothf gkrc o
rhghrhiah mref gkr coiy kt`hrs. ]h wenn brehgny fhsarebh oifesauss t`h ckrh rhnhvoit kihs.
2.?. CKIVH TKMMEKNK (RKCOMIO)Ckith Tkmmeknk, bhtwhhi Bknkmio oif Receie, es setuoth
ot oi ontetufh kg 244 c obkvh sho nhvhn, skch 64 lc owoygrkc t`h ckfhri Ofreotea s`krhs (Oitkieozze ht on. ?506<Oitkieozze ht on. ?500< Oitkieozze ht on. ?551< Thrhttk?552). @kwhvhr, et es ossuchf t`ot w`hi phkpnh shttnhft`hrh gkr t`h gerst tech t`h akost wos ihorhr oif t`h Tkvonnhy stenn o mung kg t`h sho.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 39/342
25 CORM@HREVO CXQQE - EVON U
K 244 lcK •
Gem. 2. V`h vknaoikhs (aeranhs) oatevh fureim t`h Tnhestkahih.
On t`h bosh kg t`h nkhon shquhiah, t`hrh orh coreih anoys,t`h "Ormennh Ozzurrh", ?.6-?.1 Cyr knf. V`h ora`ohknkmeaon
rhcoeis orh eianufhf ei t`h kvhrnoyeim mrovhns kg o fhntoeafhpkset. Ei o seimnh nhvhn kg t`h notthr kih (nhv. ?4=),rhcioits kg ihmotevh ponohkcomihtesc whrh prhshrvhf. V`eswos eithrprhthf os choieim t`ot t`h fhpkset es prh-Brui`hs,oif t`hrhgkrh ckrh t`oi 4.=1 Cyr knf.
V`h fhntoea mrovhns `ovh bhhi akrrhnothf wet` port kg osoify fhpkset aonnhf "Qobbeh Meonnh", o corlhr ei t`hrhmekion mhknkmehon shquhiah. Ogthr t`h conoaknkmeaonosshcbnomh gkuif ot ets bosh, t`h ponohkcomihtea shquhiahwkrlhf kut ei et, oif twk HQR foths ki quortzeth mroeis`hothf by hxpksurh tk sui nem`t, oi omh ei t`h roimh kg? Cyr `os bhhi put gkrworf gkr t`h "Qobbeh Meonnh" oif,
akishquhitny, gkr t`h ora`ohknkmeaon seth ei t`h fhntoeafhpkset.
Ik bkihs orh prhshrvhf. Qkch 6444 net`ea ecpnhchits,grhs` kr snem`tny poteiothf, whrh rhtrehvhf by surgoahaknnhateki. V`hy orh queth sconn ei sezh os gneit phbbnhseesuonny nhss t`oi ?4 ac nkim whrh ushf. V`es osshcbnomheianufhs 224 rhtkua`hf gnolh tkkns - ckstny ikta`hs,fhiteaunoths oif sefh sarophrs. O substoiteon iucbhr kg akrh
0 ?4 ?2 ?6 ?7 ?0[
Gem. 1. Tnhestkahih gnuvek-noaustreih boseis (ogthr Fhsek ?5=1, Gem. ?=7,
wet` ckfegeaotekis).
tkkns es fhsarebhf os uiegoaeon os whnn os begoaeon a`kppeim-tkkns. Vwk pkny`hfrkis oif twk "prktk`oifoxhs" orh onsk
rhakrfhf. V`hrh orh onsk `uifrhfs kg phbbnhs grkc w`ea`kiny o seimnh gnolh wos strual.
Rhmunor hxaovotekis, fkwi tk 6 c bhnkw fotuc,gurt`hrckrh yehnfhf ??77 gnolh ecpnhchits, oif ?81 akrhecpnhchits, ckst kg t`hc grkc t`h upphr port kg t`hstrotemrop`ea shquhiah. V`h rhtkua`hf tkkns orh just ?2 :8sarophrs oif = fhiteaunoths, w`enh ik anhor-aut festeiatekiwos pkssebnh bhtwhhi akrhs oif a`kppeim-tkkns. Obkut 2/1kg t`h gnolhs orh tktonny kr porteonny akrteaon, wet` pnoei krakrteaon butts, oif ckst kg t`h akrhs `ovh just kih streleimpnotgkrc. Et shhcs t`ot ckst kg t`h oatevety ki t`es phauneorspkt wos rhnothf tk rot`hr hxphfeìit lioppeim kg t`h nkaonny
ovoenobnh phbbnhs.Kt`hr seths wet` o secenor eifustry oif ei t`h soch
mhihron shtteim `ovh bhhi gkuif ei t`h orho, but ikt gunnyeivhstemothf.
2.2. EQHRIEO NO TEIHVO (CKN EQH)
Eshrieo es nkaothf gurt`hr skut`, ckrh kr nhss ei t`h ahitrhkg t`h phieisuno (Bo`oei ?551< Akntkrte ht on. ?502<
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 40/342
14 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Arhcosa`e oif Thrhttk ?500o< Meusbhrte oif Thrhttk ?55?<Thrhttk ?55?< Thrhttk ht on. ?501). V`h ora`ohknkmeaonfhpkset hxthifs wet` o voryeim fhisety kvhr oi hstecothforho kg ckrh t`oi 14,444 squorh chtrhs. V`rhh shporothora`ohknkmeaon noyhrs whrh eivhstemothf ot gerst, w`ea` orhbhnehvhf tk bh anksh ei tech. Hxaovotekis whrh uifhrtolhiei twk fegghrhit eg ihorby orhos, shttkre kr "shatkrs". Eishttkrh E t`hrh orh twk ora`ohknkmeaon noyhrs - t.1a, t`hhornehst, gknekwhf by t.1o. Ei shttkrh EE t`hrh es kiny kihnoshr onsk iochf t.1o w`ea` es t`h ckse rhahit kih kgt`h shquhiah. V`hrhgkrh, grkc t`h hornehst tk t`h nothst, wh`ovh: Qhtt. E t.1a, Qhtt. E t.1o, Qhtt. EE t.1o. O gurt`hrora`ohknkmeaon `krezki `os rhahitny bhhi fesakvhrhf ei ostrotemrop`eaon pkseteki ei bhtwhhi t`h nhvhns onrhofy likwi(Oiakihtoie ht on. ?552). V`h ckst sphatoaunor noyhr esQhtt. E t.1o, w`ea` es oi ostkies`eim oaaucunoteki kg gouionrhcoeis (ckstny beski, r`eik oif hnhp`oit bkihs) oif net`eaecpnhchits. V`h ora`ohknkmeaon nhvhns orh soifwea`hfbhtwhhi t`h geion fhpksets kg o shrehs kg noaustreih kremeioif gnuveon fhpksets.
V`h gknnkweim oiecon sphaehs whrh gkuif, ckstny ei"Qhtt.E t.1o", but wet`kut cojkr fegghrhiahs bhtwhhi kihora`ohknkmeaon noyhr oif t`h ihxt, t`h beski bheim t`h ckstgrhquhit oiecon: Toit`hro nhk gkssenes (o seimnh tkkt`),Xrsus agr. fhieimhre, Hnhp`os oitequus, Qthp`oikr`eius
`hcetkha`us, @eppkpktocus ocp`ebeus, Qus sarkgo,
Chmoahrks sp., Foco sp., Ahrvefoh, Beski sa`khthisoale,
@hcetromus agr. bkione, Nhpus sp. Qhvhron rkfhit sphaehswhrh onsk rhakmieshf: Tnekcys hpesakpones, T. nhile, T. agr.nhile, Anht`rekikcys sp., Orveakno cksboa`hises (3 Orveakno
thrrhstres aoiteoio), Cearktus orvones/C. omrhstes, C. brha-
aehises, Tetycys sp.
]hnn kvhr ?4,444 net`ea ecpnhchits `ovh bhhi aknnhathffureim hxaovotekis. V`h eifustry es queth secenor ei t`hvorekus noyhrs, hxahpt gkr t`h noal kg phbbnh tkkns ei "Qhtt.EE t.1o", w`hrh t`hrh es onsk o vhry necethf ockuit kg bkihs.V`h row cothreon wos ovoenobnh ihxt tk t`h seth. Gneit esckstny kg pkkr quonety, oif spnets gknnkweim ioturon gessurhs.Coiy kg t`h ecpnhchits orh oaakrfeimny feggeaunt tkrhakmiesh, oif et aoiikt bh soef eg t`hy orh, kr ikt, brklhiports kg kiah normhr kihs. Nechstkih phbbnhs whrh onskhoseny nkaothf ei t`h surrkuifeims, oif ushf gkr a`kppeim-tkkns.
O fhtoenhf fhsarepteki es ovoenobnh gkr t`h eifustry kg"Qhtt. EE t.1o" w`hrh, os soef, t`hrh orh ik phbbnh tkkns.
64% kg tkkns orh ki "iuanhegkrc" suppkrts, e.h. hx`ousthfakrhs oif pnoquhtths, oif gromchits kg t`hc. Iktakisefhreim kaaosekion rhtkua`hs, `ong kg t`hc orh anossegehfos bkrhrs, wet` coiy vorehtehs, eianufeim "ckiknothron"kihs - e.h. ecpnhchits wet` rhtkua`hs kr ikta`hs ofjoahittk groaturhs, butts hta... Ihxt akch t`h fhiteaunoths (12.7%),oif t`hi t`h hifsarophrs (=.?%).
V`h obsknuth omh kg t`h ora`ohknkmeaon fhpkset woswkrlhf kut t`rkum` fegghrhit cht`kfs. V`hy eianufh L/Orki soiefeih arystons grkc t`h onnuveon fhpkset akvhreim"Qht t. E t.1o" - oif oaakrfeimny ei o rhwkrlhf pkseteki -w`ea` wos fothf tk =17 + 6 Lyr BT. Kt`hr socpnhs, grkcfegghrhit eg akrrhnothf fhpksets, strotemrop`eaonny kvhrnyeimt`h Tonohknet`ea nhvhn, whrh akisesthitny fothf tk 704 + 7
Lyr BT oif =14 ¿ = Lyr BT. @em`hr up ei t`h shquhiaht`h rhsunts orh ei t`h roimh kg 844 Lyr BT.
Qhvhi socpnhs, e.h. hnhp`oit, r`eik oif bhor thht` grkct`h ora`ohknkmeaon noyhr, whrh fothf by oceikoaefroahcezoteki, oif gkuif tk bh 884 ¿ ?64 Lyr knf, wet` ochoi vonuh kg 868 Lyr BT. Gevh thht` kg hnhp`oit, r`eikoif beski, `of oi HQR omh ei t`h roimh kg ?84-?44 Lyr BTrhneceiory ponohkcomihtea eivhstemotekis pkeit tk eivhrthfpknorety. Voleim eitk oaakuit t`h rofekchtrea foth kg=14 Lyr BT, t`h seth wos ossemihf tk o tech anksh tk t`hCotuyoco-Brui`hs troiseteki.
2.1. WHIKQO (BOQENEAOVO)
Whikso es nkaothf ei skut`hri Etony, wet`ei t`h OphiieihOgthr rhahit rhshora`, t`h bosei kg Whikso es o fhpksetekionsurgoah kg noth Tnekahih omh, hrkfhf fureim t`h HornyTnhestkahih by nkaon strhocs eitk o nkim oif iorrkw vonnhy?44 c fhhp (Nhgàvrh ht on. ?551o< Qkpreithifhizo Qphaeonon Cushk Iozekionh Trhestkreak Htikmrogeak "N. Temkreie"?55?). Orkuif t`h troiseteki bhtwhhi t`h Horny oif t`hCeffnh Tnhestkahih, t`h hggusevh oatevety kg C. Wunturh,o vknaoik festoit skch 24 lc, prkfuahf normh ockuitskg shfechits t`ot t`h strhocs whrh uiobnh tk aorry owoy.V`h `yfrkmhknkmeaon bonoiah wos cua` onthrhf. Os oakishquhiah, w`enh t`h vknaoiea oatevety akiteiuhf, s`onnkw
nolhs oif cors`hs fhvhnkphf kvhr oi orho kg opprkxecothny84 by 1 lc. V`h fhprhsseki wos prkmrhssevhny ge ? nhf up by14 tk 84 c kg shfechits. V`h notthr whrh hvhituonny hrkfhfogthr ihw thatkiea oatevety fureim t`h Noth Tnhestkahih oiforh ikw gkuif os thrroahf rhcioits.
V`hrh orh shvhron ecpkrtoit seths ei t`h Whikso Bosei.]h wenn akisefhr `hrh t`h shquhiahs gkuif ei twk ihorbynkaonetehs, Nkrhtk oif Iktora`erehk. V`hy whrh hxaovothf ofegghrhit techs by fegghrhit thocs, oif et es ikt yht pkssebnhtk akrrhnoth oaaurothny t`h twk kg t`hc, w`ea` prhshit quethfesteiat shquhiahs.
Whikso - Nkrhtk
O strotemrop`ea shquhiah kg 14 c. eianufeim 62 nhvhns, wofhsarebhf grkc t`es seth (Boëssos ?504< Borron oif Qeckih?501). Ora`ohknkmeaon rhcoeis whrh gkuif ei nhv. 2? (3O),nhv. ?0 (3B), oif nhv. 1 (3A) (Gem. 6). ]h wenn ikt gurt`hrakisefhr nhvhn A, w`ea` es nothr oif kutsefh kur a`rkikekmeaoroimh. Ckst kg t`h rhshora` akiahitrothf ki noyhr O, 64 tk74 ac t`eal, w`ea` wos hxaovothf kvhr 28 squorh chtrhs.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 41/342
1? CORM@HREVO CXQQE - EVONU
Onthr Boëssos (?504), ot Nkrhtk t`hrh es oi hxahnnhit oifckst akcpnhth ponohkcomihtea shquhiah. V`h Cotuyoco-Brui`hs bkuifory wos nkaothf ei nhvhns 10-1=, t`h Nhvoiteihvhit ei nhvhns 5-0, oif t`h Jocoeao hvhit ei nhvhns 6-2.Onnhr shfechitknkmeaon oionyshs, `h onsk efhitegehf oshquhiah kg 0 aknf hpeskfhs, onthcoteim wet` cenfhr kihs.@h hvhituonny akrrhnoths kaaupoteki noyhr O wet` KEQ ?1.oif kaaupoteki noyhr B wet` KEQ E ?.
Gouio! rhcoeis orh obuifoit, eg vhry gromchithf. Ei oprhneceiory stufy kg t`h gouio, C-G. Bkiegoy (?5==)rhakmieshf shvhron ora`oea, e.h. Wennogroia`eoi, sphaehs.O rhveseki kg t`h gouio, `kwhvhr, runhf kut t`her prhshiah(Onbhrfe ht on. ?500< Oimhnhnne ht on. ?5=0< Aonke oifTonkcbk ?5=5< Aonke oif Tonkcbk ?504). V`h coiy `krshrhcoeis orh ikw efhitegehf os bhnkimeim tk Hquus ogg.sþsshibkrihises oif Hquus ontefhis. V`h bkvefs orh Bks
precemhieus oif oi ora`oea beski, e.h. Beski sa`khthisoale
agr. vkemtsthfthises. V`hrh es o aoief wet` coiy oggeietehswet` joalon. @eppks, hnhp`oits, shvhron r`eiks, coiy fhhroif o ghw bhors orh onsk prhshit.
V`h coiy gnolh ecpnhchits orh ckstny kg gneit, kgthi kgpkkr quonety (Arkvhttk ?55?). Fhiteaunoths cofh byofjoahit anoatkieoi ikta`hs gkrc 68% kg t`h rhtkua`hfgnolhs, fhiteaunoths cofh wet` akiteiukus rhtkua` 22%,ikta`hs nn9'(. sarophrs 5%, pehrahrs 7% (Gem. 8).
Xiegoaeon a`kppeim-tkkns whrh gnolhf grkc nechstkih krseneaekus nechstkih phbbnhs. V`hrh es o seimnh ocymfonkef`oifoxh, kg gneit, oif coiy brklhi phbbnhs.
V`h rhveshf gouio! oionyses uifhrneihs a`rkiknkmeaonprkbnhcs. Ogthr Onbhrfe ht on. (?500), t`h hquef osskaeotekies evnonevhny ora`oea, oif wkunf eifeaoth oi horny CeffnhTnhestkahih omh. V`es es ei akitrost wet` oi ottrebuteki
(k KEQ ?1 kr E ?. oif tk oi omh ei t`h roimh kg 844 tk684 Lyr BT. e.h. onckst efhiteaon tk Gkitoio Roiuaaek(shh bhnkw), w`hrh t`h gouio es cua` ckrh ckfhri.Gurt`hrckrh t`h beski es nhss hvknvhf ot Nkrhtk t`oi otEshrieo, w`enh t`h r`eikahrks es rhnotevhny precetevh (Aonkeoif Tonkcbk ?504).
Whikso-Iktora`ereakEi t`es orho ckrh t`oi 844 squorh chtrhs `ovh bhhi
hxaovothf (Bhnne ht on. ?55?< Aosskne ht on. ?551< Nhgàvrhht on. ?551b< Tephrik ht on. ?554< Qkpreithifhizo Qphaeonhon Cushk Iozekionh Trhestkreak Htikmrogeak "N. Temkreie"? 55 E). Vwhnvh nhvhns whrh gkuif ei o strotemrop`ea shquhiah
kg = c. Hoa` es shporothf grkc t`h kt`hr by ?4 tk ?44 ac kgsthrenh fhpkset. Ckst kg t`h bkih rhcoeis bhnkim tk Hnhp`os
oitequus oif tk Ahrvefs (Foco anoatkieoio oif Chmoahrks
sknen`oaus). gknekwhf by Bks sp. oif Beski sa`khthisoale.
Ogthr o prhneceiory oionyses, net`ea tha`iknkmy oiftypknkmy orh rot`hr secenor ei nhvhns O, B, A, F, G, M oifEE. E'hbbnh tkkns. kg nechstkih oif seneaekus nechstkih, orh
• • • • • • •
• ' . ' • ' 9 • • : : • . - ' : .
• . - • < • • . •
? c
Gem. 6. V`h strotemrop ea shquhiah kg Whikso-Nkrhtk (secpnegehf ogthr
Borron oif Qeckih ?501).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 42/342
12 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 8. Net ea ecpnhchits grkc Whikso-Nkrhtk nhvhn O (rhfrowi ogthr Borron oif Qeckih ?501).Qaonh ei ac.
prhfkceioit: t`hrh orh ckstny a`kppeim-tkkns, oif skchrkbkts oif t`eal hifsarophrs os whnn. Coiy phbbnhs orh
just brklai. V`hrh orh o ghw gneit oif quortzeth `oifoxhs,rot`hr t`eal oif wet` seiukus hfmhs. Gnolh tkkns, ei onecethf iucbhr, orh usuonny queth sconn. Butts orh pnoeioif wefh.
Ei nhvhns Ongo, H oif Hn, ki t`h kppkseth, rhtkua`hf oifuirhtkua`hf gnolhs orh prhfkceioit, oif gneit es t`h ckstgrhquhit row cothreon. V`h osskaeothf phbbnh tkkns orh kgnechstkih. Qk gor, `oifoxhs `ovh ikt bhhi rhtrehvhf.
Obsknuth foteim wos otthcpthf useim shvhron cht`kfs.O nhvhn kg pyrkanostea soifs aoppeim t`h w`knh ora`ohknkm
aon shquhiah wos fothf by VN ki quortz arystons tk 274+64 Lyr BT. O `ucoi bkih, gkuif ?8 ac obkvh nhvhn Ongwos fothf by X/V`, X/To, oif To/V`: t`h ovhromh omh es185 +?86/-5= Lyr. O Bks precemhieus tkkt` grkc nhvhn Onwos fothf by esknhuaeih hpechrezoteki, wet` o rhsunteim omhkg 844 Lyr ¿28-14%. Oikt`hr pyrkanostea soif nhvhn,kvhrnyeim kih kg t`h nkwhrckst noyhrs, e.h. nhvhn G, wosfothf by VN ki quortz arystons tk =81¿74 Lyr BT.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 43/342
11 CORM@HREVO CXQQE - EVONU
V`h cearkcoceions trkc nhvhn Hn, `kwhvhr, just obkvht`es vknaoiea nhvhn, orh eifeaotevh kg o substoiteonny nothromh: t`h osshcbnomh kg Opkfhcus sp., Tnekcys hpesakpones,
Orveakno thrrhstres, Cearkies mr. orvones-omrhstes, Cearktus
ievones, Cearktus (Vhrreakno) sp., summhsts, ogthr Qono (?505),o anecoth hkknhr oif ckesthr t`oi tkfoy, oif oi omh ei t`hceffnh pore kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih.
2.6. GKIVOIO ROIXAAEK (NOZEK)
Gkitoio Roiuaaek es oikt`hr kphi-oer seth ei t`h eiihrport kg t`h phieisuno, ot skch 74 lc skut`host kg Rkch,oif hxaovothf kvhr obkut 74 squorh chtrhs (Gem. 7). Os t`horho es o vknaoiea kih, L/Or foteim wos pkssebnh (Beffettuht on. ?5=5< Beffettu oif Qhmrh ?502< Beffettu oif Qhmrh?506< Motte ?551< Qhmrh oif Osahize ?506< Qhmrh ht on.
?50=). V`h kiny ora`ohknkmeaon nhvhn wos gkuif tk bh 680 ¿8.= Lyr knf. V`es foth es broalhthf by o fhthrceioteki kg177 ¿ 6.8 Lyr BT `em`hr up ei t`h strotemrop`ea shquhiah,oif by 60= ¿ =.8 Lyr BT ot o nkwhr nhvhn. Aonke oifTonkcbk (?507), ei o t`krkum` rhvehw kg gouios grkc
n.oteece, akrrhnoth t`h gouion osshcbnomh, w`ea` pkeits tk o
Gem. 7. V`h ora`ohknkmeaon fhpkset ot Gkitoio Roiuaaek, mref ei squorh chtrhs (ogthr Motte ?551, wet` ckfegeaotekis).
?: bkih gromchit, 2: wkkf gromchit, 1: stkih orthgoat.
thcphroth oif rot`hr kphi hiverkichit wet` KEQ ??.V`h gknnkweim sphaehs whrh fhthrceihf ei t`h gouion
osshcbnomh: Auki agr. onpeius, Xrsus fhieimhre, Toit`hro nhk
sphnoho, Hnhp`os oitequus, Hquus agr. cks`oa`hises, Qthp`oik-
rneeius `hcetkha`us. @eppkpktocus agr. ocp`e`eus, Qus sarkgo
ghrus, Chmoahrks agr. vhrteakries, Foco anoatkieoio, Ahrvus
hnop`us, Aoprhknus aoprhknus. Bks precemhieus, Beski sp.V`h net`ea eifustry es ikt obuifoit, wet` sarophrs, ikta`hs
oif fhiteaunoths ki teiy gnolhs (Gem. =). Gneit oif novo whrhushf os row cothreons. Gevh `oifoxhs oif o a`kppeimtkke whrh onsk gkuif. V`hrh orh onsk bkihs wet` rhpkrthfnyrhtkua`hf hfmhs, eianufeim bkih `oifoxhs, eithrprhthf ost`h rhsunt kg t`h saoraety kg mkkf net`ea row cothreon.
2.8. V@H QEVHQ KG WEO OXRHNEO (NOZEK)
Ei t`h surrkuifeims kg Rkch, o mrkup kg seths anusthrsonkim t`h akost ei t`h veaeiety kg t`h Rkcoi Weo Ourhneo.V`hy orh eianufhf ei fhpksets likwi os t`h "GkrcozekihOurhneo" kr "Ourhneoi Gkrcoteki" (Akiotk ht on. ?504)(Gem. 0). V`h Ourhneoi Gkrcoteki es nothr t`oi t`h rknnhf
gromchits kg vknaoieths eianufhf ei et: t`h notthr orh t`h
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 44/342
16 V@H HORN?HQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Z2Y9
Gem. =. Net ea eifustry trkc Gkitoio Roiuaaek (otthr Beffettu oif Qhmrh ?506, oif Motte ?551).
Qaonh ei ac.
"tugk rkssk o sakreh ihrh", ikw fothf tk 662 + = Lyr BT,oif t`h "tugk netkefh", wet` oi omh anksh tk 177 ¿ 6.8 LyrBT (Gkrioshre ?508). V`h Ourhneoi Gkrcoteki wos ferhatnyfothf by HQR ki Mnyaechres s`hnns ot 124-148 Lyr BT(Roftla hn on. ?50?). Os o w`knh, et es akrrhnothf wet` KEQ 5(Aonke oif Tonkcbk ?507).
Vkrrh ei TehtroQkch 244 squorh chtrhs `ovh bhhi hxaovothf ot "Vkrrh
fhn Tomneoaahttk", ei t`h thrretkry kg Vkrrh ei Tehtro.Oa`hunhoi ecpnhchits whrh gkuif ot t`h bosh kg t`h shrehsbhnkimeim tk t`h Gkrcozekih Ourhneo, oif rhghrrhf tk osgrkc "nhvhn c" (Conothsto ?5=0). V`es nhvhn eianufhs
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 45/342
18 CORM@HREVO CXQQE - EVONU
Gem. 0. V`h seths ei t`h vknaoiea surrkuifeims kg Rkch. ? : Vkrrh ei Tehtro< 2 : Aosthn fe Muefk< 1: No
Tknnhfroro< 6: Conomrktto< 8: Wona`htto Aortkie< 7: Reoik< =: Gkitoio Roiuaaek< 0: Aknnh Coreik< 5:
Ikaeaa`ek< ?4: Aovo Tkcpe< ??: Aostrk fhe Wknsae< ?2: Orah< ?1: Gkitoio Nere. V`h akost es
opprkxecothny 244 lc nkim, os t`h arkw gnehs. (Ckfegehf ogthr oi kremeion froweim by C.Torkttk).
anhchits kg o rhfhpksethf vknaoiea tugg likwi os "tugkrkssk o sakreh ihrh" (shh obkvh). Et wos gerst fothf ei opekihareim wkrl by Hvhrifhi oif Aurtes (?578), w`khrrkihkusny movh t`h Oa`hunhoi fhpkset oi omh anksh tk t`hkih kg t`h vknaoiea hnhchits: t`h ora`ohknkmeaon noyhr es
oatuonny substoiteonny nothr (shh obkvh).V`h Oa`hunhoi nhvhn es ikt o neveim gnkkr: et gkrchf
E`rkum` t`h rafhpkseteki kg hrkfhf rhcioits kg kih kr ckrhseths. Ckst kg t`h gouioS osshcbnomh akisests kg `krsh, rhffhhr, ourka`s oif hnhp`oit, wet` skch r`eik bkias oifspkrofea aorievkrhs, eianufeim neki.
Qcon! pabbnhs kg nechstkih, seneaekus nechstkih oif@eit whrh ushf tk colh orthgoats (Tephrik oif Beffettu?5=0). Rhtkua`hf tkkns iucbhr ?=1, oif eianufh 8?`oifoxhs, 26 a`kppeim- tkkns, 10 sarophrs (ckstny secpnhsefh sarophrs). ?2 ikta`hs, ?4 fhiteaunoths, rhtkua`hfgnolhs oif o ghw bkrhrs, ioturonny boalhf lievas oif
hifsarophrs.
Aosthn fe MuefkOi hxthisevh ponohksurgoah wet` Oa`hunhoi eifustry `os
bhhi hxaovothf ei twk fegghrhit eg anksh orhos, kvhr skch184 squorh chtrhs ontkmht`hr (Oizefhe oif Qhbosteoie ?506<Bksa`eoi ?551< Connhmie ht on. ?501< Rofcenne ?506).Ora`ohknkmeaon rhcoeis orh ckstny akiahitrothf wet`ei oi
hrkseki a`oiihn, skch 24 c wefh oif o ghw c fhhp. V`hywhrh akvhrhf by o vknaoiea fhpkset.
Ei t`h hxaovothf cothreon, hnhp`oits (kgthi ykuim kreccoturh), `krshs oif ourka`shi orh t`h ckst grhquhitoiecon sphaehs, gknekwhf by fhhr, w`enh wenf bkors oif
bhors orh queth rorh.Opprkxecothny 144 net`ea ecpnhchits whrh gkuif
ontkmht`hr fureim hxaovotekis. Os ot No Tknnhfroro (shhbhnkw), w`hrh fegghrhiteon prhshrvoteki wos summhsthf, t`hyeianufh ckstny akrh tkkns: ckikgoaeon oif begoaeon a`kppeim-tkkns, `oifoxhs oif spnet phbbnhs, onn kg t`hc ei nechstkih krseneaekus nechstkih. V`hi t`hrh es o rhstreathf iucbhr kg gnolhtkkns kg gneit, ckst kg t`hc bheim fhiteaunoths. Ik fåbetomh
wos rhtrehvhf. Qkch gnolhf bkihs whrh fhsarebhf oseithitekionny ckfegehf, oif eianufh bkih `oifoxhs.
No Tknnhfroro
V`h seth es aurrhitny uifhr hxaovoteki, oif ckrh t`oi184 squorh chtrhs `ovh bhhi hxaovothf sk gor (Oizefhe ht
on. ?500< Oizefhe ht on. ?505< Oizefhe oif Oriknfus-@uyzhifvhnf ?552< Oizefhe ht on. ei prhss< Oriknfus-@uyzhifvhnf oif Oizefhe ?551).
V`h fhpkset es o gkrchr ponufon bosei ei oi hsshiteonnygnot noifsaoph kg nolhs, ckkrs oif hp`hchron strhocs. Kihsua` strhoc aoushf t`h nkaon s`onnkw ponohk-eiaeseki, oif
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 46/342
17 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
gkrceim o aurvh mrofuonny fespnoahf et nothronny grkc host tkwhst. O akiahitroteki kg normh coccon bkihs oif kg net`eaeifustry es gkuif ki t`es ponohksurgoah (Gem. 5).
V`h strhoc wos tkk whol tk ckvh normh slhnhtonhnhchits, w`ea` whrh nhgt uifesturbhf oif skchtechsporteonny orteaunothf, but et wos strkim hikum` tk akiahitrothsconnhr kihs ei t`h fhhphr port kg t`h bosei, kr tk penh t`hc
up ki normhr rhcoeis. Kvhr 7444 oiecon bkihs `ovh bhhifesakvhrhf sk gor. V`hrh orh o fkzhi kr sk kg hnhp`oits,wet` coturh oif eccoturh oiecons, oif tusls up tk 1.8 cnkim, oif coiy Bks precemhieus rhcoeis kg mrhot sezh, kt`hrsphaehs bheim nhss obuifoit.
Qkch 284 net`ea ecpnhchits whrh rhakvhrhf. Qconn gneitphbbnhs whrh ckstny ushf, oif t`hrh orh o ghw normhrseneaekus nechstkih phbbnhs. Row cothreon wos pkssebnyfeggeaunt tk prkaurh, bhaoush kg t`h vknaoiea ioturh kg t`horho oif t`h akishquhit noal kg gneit.
Xirhtkua`hf gnolhs orh queth sconn (=-1? cc) oif prhshitei o vhry necethf ockuit (?2%), prkbobny fuh tk t`hfyioceas kg t`h ponohkhiverkichit. Ckst kg t`h tkkns,eianufeim sarophrs oif fhiteaunoths, orh akrh tkkns, usuonnyki phbbnhs. V`hy kgthi `ovh ckrh t`oi kih rhtkua`hf hfmhoif cuntepnh tkkns orh grhquhit.
Qarophrs orh prhvonhit. V`hrh orh shvhron hifsarophrs,coiy ikta`hs oif fhiteaunoths, o ghw bureis oif pehrahrs,oif coiy a`kppeim-tkkns. Qkch gnolhf bkihs orh pkssebnhbkih tkkns.
Foteim kg ourka`shi thht` yehnfhf oi omh kg 684 ¿?24Lyr BT by oceikoaef roahcezoteki, oif kih kg ?07 ¿68Lyr BT by HQR. V`h rhsunts orh bnurrhf by t`h `em` ioturonrofekoatevety kg t`h orho.
1. A`rkiknkmy oif a`rkiknkmeaon prkbnhcsO gerst sht kg prkbnhcs nehs wet` seths gkr w`ea` o Horny
tk horny Ceffnh Tnhestkahih omh `os bhhi anoechf.
V`h hornehst Etoneoi seth wkunf bh Ckith Tkmmeknk.Foteim feggeauntehs sthc grkc t`h hgghatevhihss kg t`hakrrhnoteki bhtwhhi t`h "Qobbeh Meonnh" oif t`hora`ohknkmeaon fhpkset: oi omh kg ? Cyr oif ckrh wos putgkrworf gkr t`h "Qobbeh Meonnh", w`enh t`h notthr wos iktferhatny fothf.
V`h hvefhiah grkc Eshrieo es skuifhr. @kwhvhr, t`hrh orhprkbnhcs wet` t`h cearkgouio, w`ea` eianufhs Orveakno
cksboa`hises, o juiekr syikiyc kg Orveakno thrrhstres
aoiteoio: t`h notthr es oi ecpkrtoit bekstrotemrop`eaoncorlhr w`ea` es fhgeiethny nothr ei omh ot oiy kt`hr Hurkphoiseth (Rkhbrkhls oif Woi Lkngsa`kthi, t`es vknuch< WkiLkhiemswonf oif Woi Lkngsa`kthi, ei prhss). Gurt`hrckrh,t`h beski es ckrh hvknvhf tkworfs ckfhri gkrcs t`oi otWhikso-Nkrhtk, o seth suppkshfny 244 kr 144 Lyr nothr t`oiEshrieo (Aonke oif Tonkcbk ?504). O nothr omh gkr t`essuphrb seth wkunf bhtthr get bekstrotemrop`eaon akrrhnotekis.
Ot Whikso-Iktora`ereak, oi omh ei hxahss kg =44 Lyr Bgkr t`h nkwhrckst port kg t`h shquhiah wkunf onsk bh quethorny, eg akcporhf wet` kt`hr Oa`hunhoi eifustrehs kgHurkph (shh Vuggrhou oif Oitkeih, t`es vknuch) , oif t`eshorny foth stenn `os tk bh akigerchf by gurt`hr eivhstemotekiEt es onsk ei akitrost wet` t`h a`rkiknkmeaon eifeaotekismevhi by t`h cearkcoccons, w`ea` eianufh Orveakno
thrrhstres.
V`h a`rkiknkmy kg kt`hr suppkshfny vhry horny seths escua` nhss whnn osshsshf. Ckith Thmneo, ei Ahitron Etony,yehnfhf cearkgouion osshcbnomhs fkceiothf by Ceckcys
bnoiae oif Onnkp`oekcys sp. oif rhghrrhf tk t`h HornyBe`oreoi (Woi fhr Chunhi ?5=1). Gevh net`ea ecpnhchitswhrh rhtrehvhf kut kg strotemrop`eaon akithxt, oif et es ikthvhi prkvhf bhykif oiy fkubt t`ot t`hy whrh oatuonnygnolhf by `ucois (Tephrik ?5=2). Ot Orah oif ihorbyGkitoio Nere, skut`-host kg Rkch, phbbnh tkkns oif gnolhswhrh pealhf grkc fhpksets fhvkef kg vknaoiea hnhchits, oit`hrhgkrh ossuchf tk prhahfh t`h nkaon vknaoiea oatevety(Beffettu ?5=2< Tephrik ht on. ?506) (Gem. 0). V`h notthr, ei
t`h sk-aonnhf @hrieaoi vknaoiea festreat, storthf ot =44 +24Lyr BT (Gkrioshre ?508). V`h osshcbnomhs grkc AknnhCoreik oif Ikaeaa`ek, ikt gor owoy, onsk ossuchf tk bhknfhr t`oi =44 Lyr, orh fothf t`rkum` rhmekion akrrhnotekiw`ea` `ovh bhhi ckfegehf shvhron techs (Beffettu oif Qhm?502< Beffettu ht on. ?5=5< Qhmrh ht on. ?50=< Motte ?551)
Kt`hr seths orh anoechf tk bh ei t`h roimh kg 844 Lyr BOt Aovo Tkcpe, ei skut`hri Noteuc omoei, net`eaecpnhchits, os whnn os `ucoi oif oiecon bkihs, whrhaknnhathf oif hxaovothf. V`hy orh soef tk bh strotemrop`e-aonny kvhrnoei by o bosont gnkw kg a. 644 Lyr BT (Tephrikht on. ?506). V`es akrrhnoteki wos ihvhr ennustrothf ei oiy
fhtoen. Ei o prhvekus pubneaoteki, et wos uifhrneihf t`ot etwos o rot`hr fubekus kih, gkr rhoskis eianufeim t`h festoiabhtwhhi t`h kutarkp oif t`h ora`ohknkmeaon seth (Beffettuoif Qhmrh ?5=0). Ei t`h Othnno Bosei - anksh tk Whikso -oi omh prhahfeim t`h oatevety kg t`h Wunturh vknaoik, e.h.hornehr t`oi 844 Lyr BT, es put gkrworf gkr seths wet` oiOa`hunhoi eifustry (Bkrzotte vki N÷whisthri ht on. ?554).Xigkrtuiothny, t`hrh es ik fhtoenhf mhkstrotemrop`eaon stufykg t`h ora`ohknkmeaon fhpksets. Ki t`h akost kg Vusaoiy, otBebbkio oif Aknneioeo, aknnhathf net`ea osshcbnomhs whrhfothf tk KEQ ??, ogthr nkim-festoiah oif s`krt-festoiahmhkstrotemrop`eaon akrrhnotekis (Monebhrte ?502< Conothstooif Zornhimo ?500< Qorte oif Qtkfute ?502). V`h
typknkmeaon a`oroathresteas kg t`h eifustry, fhvkef kg`oifoxhs, orh ossuchf tk foth t`h fhpkset, oif t`hrh es ikeifhphifhit anuh gkr obsknuth a`rkiknkmy.
Et es ikt t`ot t`h obkvh-chitekihf seths aoiikt bh os knfos summhsthf ei t`h nethroturh, but t`h pkeit es t`ot t`hera`rkiknkmy es ikt gunny osshsshf. Coiy ckrh akunf bhchitekihf, eianufeim t`h hornehst seths kg Qeaeny oif
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 47/342
1= CORM@HREVO CXQQE - EVONU
Gem. 5. Torteon vehw kg t`hhxaovotekis ot No Tknnhfroro.
Ki t`h nhgt, oi orho focomhf by
pnkum eim. (Akurthsy kg t`h
Qkpreithifhizo ora`hknkmeao feRkco).
Qorfeieo: net`ea shrehs wet` a`kppeim-tkkns oif gnolh tkkns`ovh bkhi aknnhathf ei Qeaeny, oif osshcbnomhs wet` gnolhtkkns kiny `ovh bhhi hxaovothf ei Qorfeieo (Brkmnek ht on.
?552< Corteie ?552< Qhmrh ht on. ?502). but ei ihet`hreistoiah es t`hrh oiy skuif hvefhiah gkr t`her suppkshfmrhot oitequety.
Oi omh ei t`h roimh kg 744 tk 644 Lyr es rhoskiobnysuppkrthf by t`h hvefhiah grkc Whikso-Nkrhtk, port kgWhikso-Iktora`ereak, Gkitoio Roiuaaek, oif hvhi t`hceikr seth kg Wona`htto Aortkie ei t`h surrkuifeims kg
Rkch: ei ?517 twk gnolhs whrh nkaothf by O.A. Bnoia,H. Vkimekrme oif @. Brhuen bhnkw t`h "tugk rkssk ot sakrehihrh", oi emiecbreth ikw fothf ot 662 ¿= Lyr BT (Bnoia?518-?51=: Gkrioshre ?508).
Nothr seths, ei t`h roimh kg 184-144 Lyr BT, orh bhtthrhxhcpnegehf by t`ksh onkimsefh Weo Ourhneo, w`enh coiyckrh kg prkbobny secenor omh orh pkkrny fothf. Qkch wennbh chitekihf bhnkw.
6. Trhghrrhf hiverki chitsV`hrh es skch omrhhchit t`ot t`h coiy rhcoeis kg
`hrbevkrhs ot shvhron seths cust bh rhnothf tk o rot`hr kphi
hiverkichit, w`ea` prkvefhf hikum` posturh gkr t`h `hrfs(Onbhrfe ht on. ?500< Bksa`eoi ?551< Aonke oif Tonkcbk?5=0< Qono ?501). @kwhvhr, s`rubs oif t`ealhts whrh onskmrkweim, oif `hrbevkrh osshcbnomhs fk ikt pkeit tk trhhnhssmrossnoifs kr sthpphs. Gkr eistoiah, t`h ubequetkus Hnhp`os
oitequus es ossuchf tk `ovh bhhi o gkrhst oiecon, boshf kioiotkceaon a`oroathresteas eianufeim t`h vhry nkim stroem`ttusls, ikt opprkpreoth gkr mrozeim. Vusls 1 tk 1.8 c nkim orh
kgthi chitekihf, akcporhf wet` t`ksh kg ckfhri Ogreaoihnhp`oits w`ea` kiny hxahptekionny rhoa` 2.8 c (@oyihs?55?). Et es ossuchf t`ot et wos boseaonny o brkwshr, ei mkkfoaakrfoiah wet` ckuiteim hvefhiah kg t`h iutretekionecpkrtoiah kg s`rubby oif orbkrhon gkromh gkr ckfhrihnhp`oits (@oyihs ?55?).
Ckrh aeraucstoiteon hvefhiah es ovoenobnh ot skch seths.Ot Ckith Tkmmeknk, o rot`hr necethf ockuit kg pknnhi grkct`h ora`ohknkmeaon fhpkset summhsts o akkn kr hvhi aknfanecoth, oif kphi vhmhtoteki (Aottoie ?552): iki-orbkrhon
pknnhi orh fkceioit, oif eianufh sthppea hnhchits, w`enhTeius oif Obehs orh whnn rhprhshithf ockimst t`h trhhs.V`h mostrkpkfs - wet` Aka`nkfeio noceioto, ikw o ckuitoeisphaehs - onsk pkeit tk o rot`hr aknf anecoth.
Ot Eshrieo, o socpnh grkc t`h ponohksurgoah "Qhtt. E t.1o"eianufhs 04% iki-orbkrhon pknnhi, Mroceihoh bheimfkceioit. V`h ghw orbkrhon pknnhi orh grkc Onius, Qonex agr.
pkpunus. Tnotoius. Teius. Ahfrus oif kols (Oaakrse ?508).
Trhneceiory rhsunts orh ovoenobnh gkr t`h upphr port kg t`hshquhiah kg Whikso-Iktora`ereak, bhtwhhi nhvhns A oifOngo (Qkpreithifhizo Qphaeonh on Cushk IozekionhTrhestkreak Htikmrogeak "N. Temkreie" ?55?). V`h
hiverkichit wos o mrossnoif, wet` o vhry necethf ockuit kgtrhhs, sua` os ger, peih, kols. Ot Whikso-Iktora`ereak, t`hconoaknkmeaon osskaeotekis grkc t`h nkwhrckst ora`ohknkmeaon nhvhn (nhvhn O), orh eifeaotevh kg o rot`hr `ucef oifgkrhsthf hiverkichit, but t`h pknnhi pkeit tk oi oref oifworc anecoth ei osskaeoteki wet` nhvhn B, t`h ihxt `ucoikaaupoteki (Furoith oif Qhtthposse ?5=0). V`h normhcoccons kg nhvhn O, `kwhvhr, eianufh coiy hquefs, os
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 48/342
10 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
whnn os kt`hr sphaehs kg kphi hiverkichit (Onbhrfe ht on.
?500): t`h cknnusas orh prkbobny eifeaotevh kg nkaonakifetekis kiny.
Qkch gurt`hr hvefhiah akchs grkc o aovh seth, MrkttoTomneaae (Repork hsthrik) ei Opuneo (Bortknkche ?504<Chzzhio oif Tonco fe Ahsikno ?5=?). V`h cearkcocconosshcbnomh, wet` Kryatknomus sp., Hnekcys sp., Onnkareahtus
bursoh, Opkfhcus sp., Cearktus fhitotus, C. brhaaehises,
C. orvones, oif Tetycys sp., es eifeaotevh kg oi oref oifsthppea noifsaoph. Xigkrtuiothny, t`hrh es ik skuifa`rkiknkmeaon hvefhiah gkr t`h ora`ohknkmeaon fhpkset,w`ea` yehnfhf skch geih begoahs, but oi omh anksh tk t`hseths kg t`h Ourhneoi Gkrcoteki wkunf bh o mkkf hstecoth.V`h hiverkichit, `kwhvhr, es akcpnhthny fegghrhit oifpkssebny mnoaeon (shh Geion Rhcorls).
Tonohkbktoieaon eivhstemotekis `ovh ikt bhhi aorrehf kutei t`h Oa`hunhoi nhvhns kg t`h seths onkimsefh Weo Ourhneo,w`enh o mhihron rhakistruateki kg t`h hiverkichit esovoenobnh (Joakboaae ?5=0< Conothsto ?5=0< Akiotk ht on.
?504< Oizefhe ht on. ?505< Oizefhe oif Oriknfus-
@uyzhifvhnf ?552< Oriknfus @uyzhifvhnf oif Oizefhe?551). Fureim KEQ 5, t`h reseim sho-nhvhn oif vknaoieaoatevety ogghathf t`h noifsaoph. V`h orho w`ea` wosonrhofy rot`hr gnot bhaoch a`oroathreshf by sconnfhprhssekis oif ckkrs gennhf by t`h oatevety kg hp`hchronchoifhreim strhocs. Cuffy orhos whrh ubequetkus, oifonthriothf wet` soifs oif kt`hr onnuveon fhpksets, os whnn oswet` vknaoiea fhpksets. Ankshr tk t`h akost nomkkisfhvhnkphf. V`h coiy bkfehs kg wothr, grkc grhs` tkbroales` oif grkc stomioit tk ruiieim, orh rhgnhathf ei t`hgouio: `eppks ot Aosthn fe Muefk oif Conomrktto, o ceikrseth (Aosskne ht on. ?502) (surgoah aknnhatekis kiny), bhovhrs
ot Conomrktto, oquotea berfs ot Vkrrh ei Tehtro oifConomrktto omoei.
V`es fhishny shttnhf orho aoi bh akcporhf wet` oikt`hrkih, fhvkef kg `ucoi kaaupoteki fureim t`es soch techspoi. e.h. t`h Reoik nolh bosei, just ikrt` kg Rkch, w`ea` esonsk port kg t`h Ourhneoi Gkrcoteki. (Oaakrfe oifCoaaomik ?572< Ocbrkshtte ht on. ?5=2< Ocbrkshtte ht on.
?504< Bkiofkiio ?578< Gknnehre ?57?-?571< Nhkiorfe oifThtrkiek ?5=6< Nhkiorfe oif Thtrkiek ?5=7< Coaaomik?572). Boshf ki t`h akuit kg oiiuon nhvhns ei vorvhffeotkceths, t`h nettnh nolh wos ei hxesthiah gkr ?8,444 tk24,444 yhors. Et prkmrhssevhny s`roil grkc o coxecuceieteon hxthiseki kg 784x284 c. Wknaoiea tuggs hcbhffhf eit`h feotkceth fhpkset whrh fothf tk 228 ¿74 Lyr BT byL/Or, oif tk 204 ¿14 Lyr BT by gesseki troals. Oieconrhcoeis whrh gkuif ot fegghrhit nhvhns, ei t`h bosei etshng oswhnn os ei ets ecchfeoth surrkuifeims. V`hy eianufh whnnprhshrvhf oif stenn orteaunothf rhcoeis kg o necethf roimh kgsphaehs: twk onckst akcpnhth slhnhtkis oif o slunn kg
Hnhp`os oitequus, gromchits kg Qthp`oikrnþius agr.
lhcetkha`us, gevh akcpnhth kr porteon slhnhtkis kg Ahrvus
hnop`us, o seimnh kih kg Foco anoatkieoio, oif esknothfbkihs.
V`h gnkro es likwi bkt` by pknnhi oionyses, oif by t`hstufy kg coarkbktoieaon rhcoeis, os nhovhs, gruets oif shhwhrh hxtrhchny whnn prhshrvhf. Et es t`hrhgkrh pkssebnh tkarkss-a`hal t`h rhsunts kg fegghrhit neihs kg oionyshs, oif kbtoei o ferhat likwnhfmh kg t`h nkaon vhmhtoteki. O vhryfhish gkrhst kg brkof-nhovhf trhhs wos ei hxesthiaht`rkum`kut t`h strotemrop`ea shquhiah, w`enh t`h mross akvwos hxtrhchny rhstreathf. V`h gkrhst wos kg kahoiea-thcphroth typh bhnkw t`h fothf tugg nhvhn, wet` cua`Aorpeius oif Tthrkaoryo, oif kg kahoiea akkn typh obkvhet, wet` eiarhoseim phrahitomhs kg bhha` oif ger.
Os chitekihf obkvh, t`hrh orh sk gor ik ora`ohknkmeaonrhcoeis grkc t`h gkrhsts kg t`h Reoik bosei: o saoity shrekg net`ea orthgoats wos kiny aknnhathf grkc t`h hort`y brkwtugg w`ea` tkps t`h noaustreih feotkcetea shrehs (Oaakrfe oCoaaomik ?572).
Hvefhiah kg shttnhchit ei gkrhsthf hiverkichit es gkuif
ot Weskmneoik, o lorstea fhprhsseki anksh tk Vrehsth, w`hrht`hrh orh onsk t`h rhcoeis kg o aknnopshf rkals`hnthr. Vwkstrotemrop`ea shquhiahs (O oif B) orh likwi, but t`hera`rkiknkmeaon rhnotekis`eps `ovh ikt bhhi wkrlaf kut. V`homh kg t`h fhpksets es nkkshny broalhthf bhtwhhi =44 oif144 Lyr BT (Aottoie ht on. ?55?). Tknnhi wos prhshrvhf eiskch nhvhns kiny. O brkof-nhovhf gkrhst wos ei hxesthiah,wet` oi osskaeoteki kg Aorpeius, Groxeius oif _uhraus
(Aottoie ?552< Aottoie ht on. ?55?). Ei t`h upphr port kgshquhiah O, `kwhvhr, w`ea` es fhvkef kg pknnhi, t`hcearkcoccons orh typeaon kg sthpphs kr mrossnoifs(Bortknkche ?504). Oiy`kw, t`h ora`ohknkmeaon rhcoeis o
hxtrhchny saorah ot Weskmneoik, oif pkeit tk fesakiteiukusoif s`krt-nevhf kaaupoteki t`hrh.
Os o akianuseki, t`h ovoenobnh hvefhiah summhsts t`otkphi kr akcpkseth hiverkichits whrh govkurhf by t`h gersei`obetoits, w`enh fhishny gkrhsthf kihs whrh opporhitnyrot`hr ovkefhf. Noaustreih kr hvhi cors`y boseis whrhnkklhf gkr, pkssebny just bhaoush mrhmorekus `hrbevkrhsakimrhmothf t`hrh tk wothr oif tk feh. @kwhvhr, wh custonsk rhchcbhr t`ot seth prhshrvoteki es bhtthr ei sua` boseios fhpksets oaaucunoth rot`hr quealny, sk t`ot wh aoiiktrunh kut t`h pkssebenety t`ot t`hy orh kvhr-rhprhshithf.
8. Qaovhimeim oif `uiteim
V`hrh es ik quhsteki t`ot stkih tkkns orh gkuif osskaeothwet` oiecon bkihs ot shvhron seths. Tksetevh hvefhiah kgeithroateki bhtwhhi `ucois oif oiecons, `kwhvhr, es rot`rorh.
Ot Eshrieo (Qhtt. E t.1o), t`h `umh oaaucunoteki kg bkihscoeiny akisests kg hnhp`oit, r`eik oif beski rhcoeis.Oaakrfeim tk M. Meusbhrte ht on. (?55?), t`h hnhp`oit rhcoe
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 49/342
15 CORM@HREVO CXQQE - EVONU
tianufh coiy nkim bkihs oif tusls, oif o ckrh necethfockuit kg thht`, phnvhs, rebs oif vhrthbroh< beski bkihs orhckstny aroieon kihs - sphheonny `kris - kckpnoths oifeneoa bkihs< r`eiks orh rhprhshithf by slunns, thht` oif `ont'coifebnhs. V`her akianusekis orh t`ot t`h bkihs whrh skrthfby `ucois oif noef ki t`h mrkuif ki purpksh. Gurt`hrckrh,skch rhcoeis whrh brklhi eitk pehahs w`hi grhs`, oiffesnkhothf kvhr o rhstreathf orho (sk t`ot rhgetteim espkssebnh). V`es, tkk, es soef tk `ovh bhhi t`h rhsunt kg `ucoioatevety. V`h mhihron akianusekis orh t`ot t`h rhcoeis orheeuneaotevh bkt` kg o fwheneim struaturh oif kg buta`hreimoatevetehs.
Tksetevh hvefhiah, `kwhvhr, es saorah. Fwhnneim struaturaskg Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea omh orh prkbnhcotea. tk put et cenfny(Gorezy ?500-?505), oif sua` oi eithrprhtoteki s`kunf baprhshithf ei akisefhrobnh fhtoen, ei krfhr tk onnkw t`h rhofhrtk hvonuoth ets chrets. Os gor os buta`hreim es akiahrihf,t`hrh es ik prhshrvhf aut corl (Meusbhrte oif Thrhttk ?55?).Ckst kg t`h bkih surgoahs whrh ogghathf by oiecoStrocpneim os whn! os by obroseki by wothr oif soif ei o
cuffy fhpkset. Ortegeaeon brholomh saors `ovh bhhi oatuonnyfhthathf ki o fkzhi kg t`h t`kusoifs kg bkihs kg t`hvorekus nhvhns (Oiakihtoie ht on. ?552< Oiakihtoie ht on.
?551< Meusbhrte oif Thrhttk ?55?). V`h shnhathf hnhchitsorh Hrkc beski gkrhquorthrs. Qk gor, et es soghr just tk ossucht`ot corrkw wos nkklhf gkr oif akisuchf.
Ot Whikso-Nkrhtk nhvhn O, bkihs orh mhihronny brklhi,ckst e)n' t`ac baeim `hrbevkrh rhcoeis. Brklhi feop`yshsskchtechs `ovh aut corls oif saors nhgt by stkih tkknsw`ea` sarota`hf t`h bkih surgoah. V`h seth es aoutekusnyeithrprhthf os o pkssebnh buta`hreim orho (Borroe oif Qeckih?501).
Ot Whikso-Iktora`ereak, t`h slunn kg o ykuim hnhp`oitwos gkuif turihf upsefh fkwi, wet` t`h coifebnh fhtoa`hfoif brklhi: ogthr et, t`h orho kg t`h fesakvhry wos iochf"Orho fh@'Hnhgoith", e.h. "Hnhp`oit Orho". Gurt`hr portskg t`h slhnhtki orh hxphathf tk noy kutsefh t`h orho sk gorhxaovothf. Qkch fkzhis kg `oifoxhs oif a`kpphrs, oif justgkur gnolh tkkns, whrh ei ferhat akitoat wet` t`h aoraoss,anhorny osskaeothf wet` et. V`h "Hnhp`oit Orho" seth eseithrprhthf os o prkbobnh buta`hreim seth (Aosskne ht on. ?551).
O top`kikcea stufy kg No Tknnhfroro es uifhr woy oifortegeaeon brholomh potthris `ovh bhhi fhthathf (Oizefhe hn
on. ei prhss). Os o prhneceiory `ypkt`hses, et shhcs t`ot otnhost port kg t`h oiecons fehf o ioturon fhot` ei t`h sconncuffy bosei oif t`ot `ucoi bheims tkkl ofvoitomh kg t`es(Oizefhe ht on. ?500). @uiteim oatevetehs orh ikt runhf kut:lenneim whol oiecons tropphf ei t`h cuf oif saovhimeimaoraosshs kg fhof kihs whrh twk pkssebnh kptekis.
Qkch pkssebnh buta`hreim corls `ovh bhhi fhthathf kihnhp`oit bkihs kg Aosthn fe Muefk, but kiny prhneceiorykbshrvotekis orh ovoenobnh gkr t`es seth (Bksa`eoi ?551).
V`hrh es t`hrhgkrh skch hvefhiah t`ot, grkc t`h nerstprhshiah kiworfs, `ucoi mrkups whrh eithroateim wet`oiecons, toleim t`her s`orh kg chot oif corrkw.
7. Fevhrs ety ei net`ea tkkns]h wenn akiahitroth ki twk osphats kg net`ea tha`iknkmy
oif typknkmy: t`h prhshiah kr obshiah kg `oifoxhs, oif t`h
oppaoroiah kg t`h Nhvonnkes gnoleim tha`iequh.@oifoxhs sk gor orh t`h kiny prhrhqueseth tk fhgeih oiOa`hunhoi eifustry os sua`. Ei Ogreao, eifustrehs fhvkef kg`oifoxhs orh likwi tk prhahfh Oa`hunhoi eifustrehs fureimo phrekf kg obkut kih cenneki yhors. Ei Hurkph, os oakishquhiah, Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea eifustrehs wet`kut`oifoxhs orh usuonny ossuchf tk bh hornehr t`oi Oa`hunhoieifustrehs. Ei Etony, t`h noal kg `oifoxhs ot seths sua` osCkith Tkmmeknk, Eshrieo, Bebbkio, Aknneioeo, Orah, AknnhCoreik, Gkitoio Nere, Aoshnno fe Coefo os whnn os ei Qeaenyoif Qorfeieo, `os bhhi wefhny oaahpthf os summhsteim omrhot oitequety. Gurt`hrckrh, et es kgthi ckrh kr nhssecpneaetny ossuchf t`ot `oifoxhs orh just ckrh rhgeihf
a`kppeim-tkkns, rhnothf tk t`h soch kr secenor oatevetehs. V`hora`ohknkmeaon hvefhiah, `kwhvhr, es ikt t`ot anhor-aut.
Ckith Tkmmeknk es oi orho w`hrh row cothreon wos hosenyovoenobnh ei t`h gkrc kg gneit phbbnhs. Cua` precorylioppeim wos phrgkrchf, os et aoi bh shhi ei t`hkvhrw`hnceim rotek kg uirhtkua`hf tk rhtkua`hf gnolhs, t`h`em` ockuit kg akrthx ki ecpnhchits oif t`h coiy akrhsw`ea` orh feggeaunt tk fesareceioth grkc a`kppeim-tkkns(Oitkieozze ht on. ?551). O necethf sht kg oatevetehs wosmkeim ki, oif rhtkua`hf tkkns whrh saorahny ihhfhf.
Ot Eshrieo, tkk, gneit wos obuifoit ei t`h ecchfeothsurrkuifeims kg t`h seth, but kg vhry pkkr quonety: et es
gkuif os sconn bnkals oif pnoquhtths, w`ea` orh cua`gessurhf oif spnet hoseny, sk t`ot et es just ecpkssebnh tkrhakmiesh ioturon grkc coi-cofh groaturhs (Ghrrore ht on.
?55?). Nechstkih phbbnhs whrh ushf gkr a`kpphrs oifa`kppeim-tkkns. Thbbnh tkkns, `kwhvhr, orh noaleim grkcQhtt. EE t.1o, hxaovothf kvhr oi orho kg ?0 c x 6 c (Ghrroreht on. ?55?). Eithrhsteimny, oiecon rhcoeis, w`ea` orhusuonny obuifoit, orh saoity ei t`es port kg t`h fhpkset.
Ot Whikso-Iktora`ereak, eifustrehs wet` oif wet`kut`oifoxhs orh eithrstrotegehf: begoaeon tkkns orh ikt obuifoit,oif orh obshit ei nhvhn Ongo, ot t`h tkp kg t`h nkaonshquhiah, oif ei nhvhns H oif Hn, ei t`h ceffnh port kg et.Onn nhvhns `ovh bhhi hxthisevhny hxaovothf. Ei t`h Hnhp`oitOrho, ei anksh osskaeoteki wet` t`h bkihs, t`hrh orh coiy`oifoxhs oif a`kpphrs, oif vhry ghw gnolh tkkns (Aosskneht on. ?551).
Ockimst t`h seths kg t`h Ourhneoi Gkrcoteki, Vkrrh eiTehtro, Aosthn fe Muefk oif Conomrktto yehnfhf `oifoxhs,w`enh t`hsh whrh ikt gkuif ot No Tknnhfroro. Kiah omoei,t`h hxaovotekis whrh hxthisevh, oif socpneim beos es
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 50/342
64 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
prkbobny ikt eivknvhf. Ot No Tknnhfroro hnhp`oit slhnhtkiswhrh gkuif porteonny orteaunothf (Oizefhe ht on. ?505). V`hbkih oaaucunoteki aoiikt bh ferhatny akcporhf wet` t`hkihs grkc Vkrrh ei Tehtro oif Conomrktto, w`ea` orhfhgeiethny festurbaf oif pkssebny rhfhpksethf, w`enh kinyprhneceiory eigkrcoteki es ovoenobnh gkr Aosthn fe Muefk.
V`h quonety kg row cothreon wkunf oaakuit, ei port kr
tktonny, gkr t`h noal kg `oifoxhs ot seths sua` os Eshrieo.V`hrh es onsk skch summhsteki t`ot phbbnh tkkns whrhprhghrrhf w`hi normh aoraosshs whrh ovoenobnh oif corrkwwos tk bh hxtroathf grkc `hoveny-buent bkihs. @kwhvhr, whihhf gurt`hr rhshora` bhgkrh uifhrstoifeim t`h choieim kg"`oifoxh seths" akcporhf wet` "a`kpphr seths" - t`h twkbheim usuonny ikt hxanusevh kg hoa` kt`hr. V`h kiny fhgeiethhvefhiah es t`ot. ei t`h Etoneoi Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea, t`hy fkikt gknnkw hoa` kt`hr ihotny ei oiy a`rkiknkmeaon shquhiah.
Vurieim tk t`h Nhvonnkes tha`iequh, "Trktknhvonnkeseoi"eifustrehs, e.h. osshcbnomhs kg gnolhs `oveim fkrson saorsrhnothf tk skch leif kg akrh prhporoteki, oif uigoahtthf
btetes. orh skchtechs chitekihf ei t`h Etoneoi nethroturh(Rofcenne ?5==< Tonco fe Ahsikno ?502). V`h "Trktknhvonnkeseoi" suppkshfny fhrevhs grkc t`h Anoatkieoi, eianufeima`kpphrs oif gnolhs wet` normh oif eianeiothf butts. Ei skchseths kiny o `oifgun kg ecpnhchits orh rhtrehvhf, w`enhhnshw`hrh normhr aknnhatekis orh ovoenobnh, os ot Nh Qvknthoif Wonnh Meuchiteio ei Obruzzk, oif Gkah fhn VkrrhithRkcoifotk ei Opuneo. Qua` eifustrehs, `kwhvhr, orh gkuifei rhwkrlaf akifetekis, oif orh eivoreobny rknnhf. V`her omhes oi kphi quhsteki.
Arhcosa`e oif Thrhttk (?500b) hxoceihf "Trktknhvonnkeseoi" aknnhatekis kg ikrt`hri Etony oif prhshithf hvefhiah
t`ot t`hy `of bhhi skrthf by strhoc oatevety tk skchQtoiforf sezh oif whem`t, oif t`ot `oifoxhs whrh eianufhfei shvhron sua` osshcbnomhs. V`hrhgkrh, t`hy orh bhtthrfhsarebhf os Oa`hunhoi, w`enh t`h gnoleim tha`iequh `os iktyht bhhi prkphrny fhsarebhf. Ki t`h boses kg mhk-strote-mrop`ea akrrhnotekis t`hy foth t`hc tk "oi horny port kg t`hCeffnh Tnhestkahih".
Os o runh, gnoleim es rot`hr arufh ei Nkwhr Tonohknet`eaosshcbnomhs. Ot seths sua` os Ckith Tkmmeknk, Orah, AknnhCoreik, Whikso-Nkrhtk kiny o seimnh gnolh wos kgthifhtoa`hf, w`enh bepknor gnoleim tha`iequh wos akccki.V`h notthr wos onsk ei ush ot Eshrieo, oif es grhquhit ei t`hOa`hunhoi osshcbnomhs aknnhathf ei t`h bosei kg Othnno(Bkrzotte vki N÷whisthri oif Weoihnnk ?551). V`hrh orhfesakefon akrhs ot Gkitoio Roiuaaek, but t`hy orh rorhnychitekihf hnshw`hrh. V`h Nhvonnkes tha`iequh es ikt gkuifot oiy seth prekr tk KEQ 5. By t`hi, seimnh Nhvonnkes gnolhs,kr Nhvonnkes akrhs, orh kaaosekionny chitekihf kr justennusnrothf ei t`h nethroturh. Ot Mrktto fhn Aknkcbk ei Nemureo,gkr eistoiah, ckrh t`oi 244 gnolh ecpnhchits whrh gkuif ei
nhvhn ??: twk orh Nhvonnkes gnolhs, oif kih es oi otypeaonNhvonnkes bnofh (Vkzze ?578). Ogthr skch ofcetthfny thitotakrrhnotekis wet` o fothf stonomceth ei t`h rhor kg t`h aovhoif shfechitknkmeaon oif ponohkitknkmeaon stufehs, t`h noywos fhpksethf fureim KEQ 5 (Boëssos ht on. ?507).
V`h kiny seth ot w`ea` t`h Nhvonnkes tha`iequh es gunnyrhprhshithf oif fhvhnkphf es Rksoihtk, ei Aonobreo.
Xigkrtuiothny, t`h ?444 kr sk aknnhathf ecpnhchits orh kilikwi t`rkum` prhneceiory pubneaotekis (Tephrik ht on.
?506). Ogthr Conothsto oif Zornhimo (?500) t`h thrroah kgRksoihtk bhnkims tk w`ot t`hy aonn "Qhakif CeffnhTnhestkahih ayanh fhpksets", oif tk KEQ 5. @kwhvhr, t`heifustry etshng es o cojkr foteim hnhchit ei t`herrhakistruateki, w`ea` nhofs tk aeraunor ormuchits. V`hfhvhnkpchit kg t`h Nhvonnkes tha`iequh ot t`es seth esuiporonnhnhf hnshw`hrh ot t`es stomh oif wh summhst t`ot t`goat pkeits tk o nothr omh.
=. Geion akisefhrotekisV`h omh kg t`h gerst `ucoi shttnhchit kg Etony `os bhhi
anoechf tk bh ei t`h roimh kg ? Cyr. Ei kur kpeieki, et esikt gunny substoiteothf ot t`es vhry horny foth. @ucoimrkups whrh ahrtoeiny neveim ei t`h phieisuno by 744 tk844 Lyr BT, w`enh t`h omh kg t`h Qeaeneoi oif Qorfeieoisuppkshf Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea es stenn oi kphi quhsteki.
V`h aknkiezoteki kg Qeaeny es rhnhvoit gkr t`h gerstshttnhchit kg Hurkph, os t`h `ypkt`hses kg o fesakiteiukusnoif brefmh bhtwhhi Ogreao oif Hurkph t`rkum` Qeaeny `osbhhi put gkrworf, onbhet gkr o nothr p`osh kg t`h NkwhrTonohknet`ea (Onechi ?5=8).
]h ossuch t`ot ioturon akifetekis onnkweim t`h arksseikg orcs kg t`h sho by ora`oea `ucois wkunf `ovh govkurh
kt`hr normh coccons os whnn. @kwhvhr, t`h ckst rhahiteccemrotekis kg oiecon sphaehs grkc Ogreao `opphihffureim t`h Ceffnh Tnekahih, eg ikt fureim t`h noth Cekahia(Tonkcbk ?508). Fureim t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, t`hQeaeneoi gouion osshcbnomhs orh a`oroathreshf by t`h whnnlikwi fworg poa`yfhrcs, oif ckstny by t`h nettnhhnhp`oits, Hnhp`os cioefrehises oif Hnhp`os gonakihre. Ot`h shakif sphaehs es hvhi ckrh rhfuahf t`oi t`h gerst kihet `os nkim bhhi ossuchf t`ot et wos nothr, oif fhrevhf grkt`h snem`tny normhr sphaehs. Hnhp`os cioefrehises, ei turi,wkunf `of hvknvhf grkc o subsphaehs kg t`h Hurkphoi
Hnhp`os oitequus, e.h. Hnhp`os oitequus nhkiorfee.
V`h peaturh a`oimhf ogthr obsknuth foteim kg shvhronosshcbnomhs t`rkum` esknhuaeih hpechrezoteki (Bofo oifBhnnukceie ?508< Bofo ht on. ?55?): t`h foths anusthr eitktwk fegghrhit eithrvons, ot 688 ¿ 54 Lyr BT, oif ot 244 ¿64 Lyr BT rhsphatevhny. Bkt` t`h teiy H. gonakihre oif t`hsnem`tny normhr H. cioefrehises orh gkuif ei t`h hornehrmrkup, w`enh kiny t`h shakif kih es ei t`h nothr kih. Et esikw ossuchf t`ot t`h twk fworg sphaehs orh ikt ei o
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 51/342
6 ? CORM@HREVO CXQQE - EVONU
p`ynhtea rhnoteki, oif t`ot t`h sk-aonnhf H. cioefrehises kgt`h nothr mrkup es pkssebny o stenS fegghrhit sphaehs, rhnothf tko ihw eccemroteki kg hnhp`oits. V`h sphaehs grkc w`ea` H.gonakihre fhrevhf es akishquhitny uilikwi. Et aoiikt bhrunhf kut t`ot o rhakisefhroteki kg t`h prkbnhc, os whnn ost`h stufy kg ihw oif uipubnes`hf gouios, akunf nhof tk oihw eithrhst ei Ogreaoi akiihatekis (V. Lktsoles phrs. akc.?556). Eg wh oaahpt o s`krt a`rkiknkmy gkr t`h gerstshttnhchit kg Hurkph - e.h. ei t`h roimh kg 744 tk 844 LyrBT - oi eccemroteki kg hnhp`oits grkc Ogreao orkuif t`estech, ofcetthfny sk gor uisubstoiteothf oif just`ypkt`hteaon, wkunf kphi ihw oif eitremueim phrsphatevhsgkr t`h orrevon kg `ucois os whnn.
V`h hiverkichitsS a`oimhs orh rhakrfhf ei ofesakiteiukus woy prekr tk 144 Lyr BT. @kwhvhr, t`hakrh hxtroathf grkc Wonnh fe Aostemnekih, 24 lc host kgRkch, mkhs boal tk a. 284 Lyr BT (Gknnehre ht on. ?500).Ei t`es akrh, sthppea osshcbnomhs orh prhshit fureim ckstkg t`h tech, eithrrupthf by p`oshs kg gkrhst hxpoiseki.
]h orh eianeihf tk bhnehvh t`ot t`h setuoteki wos ikt t`otfegghrhit ei oi hornehr port kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih.? EL- kiny hvefhiah kg sthppea hiverkichit grkcora`ohknkmeaon seths es grkc t`h uifothf upphr port kg t`hshquhiah kg Weskmneoik oif grkc Mrktto Tomneaae. ]hsummhst t`ot t`hy bkt` gkrchf fureim gunny mnoaeon phrekfs.Os soef ei t`h Eitrkfuateki, bhaoush kg fegghrhiteonprhshrvoteki kg seths t`h Etoneoi rhakrf es cua` beoshftkworfs eithrmnoaeons, oif et es ik akeiaefhiah t`othvefhiah kg mnoaeon phrekfs es gkuif ei aovhs. Hvefhiah kgaknf anecoth oif kg skch sthppea hnhchits wos onskprhshithf gkr Ckith Tkmmeknk.
Hvhi ei t`h eithrmnoaeon seths, t`h hiverkichit eseivoeëobny fhsarebhf os rot`hr kphi - w`ea` es kg eithrhst,ei vehw kg t`h kimkeim fesausseki ki t`h Tonohknet`eashttnhchit kg Ikrt`hri Hurkph (Mocbnh ?507< Rkhbrkhls ht
on. ?552). ]`hi akcporeskis orh pkssebnh wet` fhishnywkkfhf orhos, os wet`ei t`h seths kg t`h Ourhneoi Gkrcoteki,t`h nothr kihs orh gkuif tk bh fhvkef kg `ucoi kaaupoteki.
Fegghrhit hiverkichits hxesthf hvhi fureim gunneithrmnoaeons. V`es es bhtthr uifhrstkkf eg wh akisefhr t`hmhkmrop`eaon shtteim: Etony hxpoifs ei o ikrt`-whsthri tkskut`-hosthri ferhateki kvhr skch ?4 fhmrhhs kg notetufh, e.h.
grkc t`h Onps tk t`h notetufh kg Ikrt`hri Onmhreo, Vuieseooif Qyreo. V`h anecotknkmeaon hgghats kg t`es mrofeìit orhakitrosthf by t`h roimhs kg ckuitoeis, w`ea` gknnkw t`hsoch ferhateki, onn t`h woy nkim: fureim kur ckfhrieithrmnoaeon weithrs, t`h ckuitoeis kg Aonobreo oif Qeaenyakvhrhf by sikw orh o akccki sem`t. Ot t`h soch tech, t`hcetemoteim hgghat kg t`h sho chois t`ot, ei ikrt`hc Etony, t`hRevehro kg Nemureo ikwofoys hijkys worc oif suiiyweithrs, oif poncs orh grhhny mrkweim.
Os o akishquhiah, hxthisevh haknkmeaon zkioteki `osihvhr bhhi pkssebnh, oif cksoea hiverkichits prhvoenhf.V`es aoi bh shhi ot Wonnh fe Aostemnekih: t`h mrkwt` kgpnoit pkpunotekis wos hxpkihiteon w`hi anecotea akifetekisa`oimhf, oif wh ossuch t`ot coiy rhgumeuc orhos whrhonwoys ei hxesthiah. Hvhi ikw, t`h vhmhtoteki kg Noteuc eslikwi tk bh bkt` hxtrhchny rea` ei sphaehs oif corlhfny`hthrkmhihkus (Aonke ht on. ?505).
Haknkmests `ovh kgthi neilhf t`h Tnhestkahih hxteiateki kgoiecon oif pnoit sphaehs ei Hurkph tk t`h goat t`ot shos oifckuitoeis prhvhithf t`h ikrt`-skut` cemrotekis oif
rhaknkiezotekis w`ea` whrh pkssebnh ei Ochreao kr Ogreao.V`h pota`y hiverkichit kg Etony pkssebny hxpnoeis t`h nothfesopphoroiah, fureim t`h nost mnoaeon, kg hnhp`oits, `eppks,r`eiks, os whnn os kg pnoit sphaehs sua` os Tthrkaoryo oif
Zhnlkvo. ]h akisefhr t`h teiy phieisuno, oif ets cojkresnoifs, os o pkssebnh rhgumeuc gkr coiy Hurkphoi sphaehsfureim t`h Tnhestkahih.
V`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea rhakrf es ecprhssevh ei Etony, egakcporhf wet` kt`hr ports kg Hurkph. ]h summhst t`ot portkg t`es "Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea suaahss" wos neilhf tk t`hrea`ihss oif vorehty kg hiverkichits kvhr s`krt festoiahs,
oif tk t`h goat t`ot uisphaeoneshf `uithr-mot`hrhrs whrh obnhtk tolh ofvoitomh kg t`es.
OalikwnhfmhchitsE oc mrothgun tk C. Torkttk, Feportechitk fe Qaehizh fhnno
Vhrro, Xievhrseto fe Rkco "No Qopehizo", gkr onnkweim ushkg oi kremeion neih froweim kg akoston Noteuc. O.T. Oizefhe,Qkpreithifhizo ora`hknkmeao fe Rkco, leifny prkvefhf oiuipubnes`hf peaturh kg No Tknnafroro.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 52/342
62 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
rhghrhiahs
Oaakrfe. B..
O.C. Coaaomik
?572 Rhshora`hs ei t`h Tnhestkahih kg Reoik (Rkch), Mhknkmeao Rkcoio ?, 28-12.
Oaakrse, AO. ?508 V`h akitrebuteki kg ponyiknkmy ei t`h rhakistruateki kg t`h hiverkichit. Ei: A. Thrhttk(hf.), @kck, Jkurihy tk t`h Kremei's kg Coi @estkry, ?52-24?, Whihzeo: Corsenek.
Oetlhi, C.J., t`es A`rkikchtrea tha`iequhs gkr t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih.
vknuch
Onbhrfe, C.-V.,N. Aonke,C.R. Tonkcbk
?500 V`h _uothcory gouio kg Whikso: Hquefs, Bunnhtei fu Cusåh f'Oit`rkpknkmeh prå`estk-
vequh fh Ckioak 1?, 8-15.
Onechi. C.@. ?5=8 Nhs "es t`chs" `espoik-corkaoei ht seaunk- tuiesehi oux thcps oa`hunåhis, N'Oit`rkpk-
nkmeh =5, 155-617.
Ocbrkshtte. T..
O. Ozzorkne,G.T. Bkiofkiio,C. Gknnehre
?5=2 O sa`hch kg Tnhestkahih a`rkiknkmy gkr t`h Vyrr`hieoi sefh kg Ahitron Etony, Bknnhtteik
fhnno Qkaehtf Mhknkmeao Etoneoio 5?, ?75-?06.
Ocbrkshtte, T.,
G. Aemono Gunmkse,
A. Thtrkiek
?504 Cocceghre fhn Tnhestkahih chfek. Ei: / vhrthbrote gkssene etoneoie - Aotonkmk fhnno Cks
22=-212, Whrkio: Cushk Aeveak fe Qtkreo Ioturonh.
Oiakihtoie, T.,A. Arkvhttk,C. Ghrrore,M. Meusbhrte,N. Nkimk,
A. Thrhttk,G. Weoihnnk
?552 Iukvh reahra`h ihn meoaechitk fe Eshrieo No Teihto, Revesto fe Qaehizh Trhestkrea`h 66,1-6?.
Oiakihtoie, T..
(e. (þusbhrte,
A. Thrhttk
?551 Qu onauie iukve rhphrte fe beskith (Beski sa`khthisoale Grhufhibhrm) aki troaahfe grotturozekih eithizekionh fhn meoaechitk ponhkneteak fe Eshrieo No Teihto, Otte
fhnno PPP´ Reuiekih saehitegeao fhnn'Estetutk Etoneoik fe Trhestkreo h Trktkstkreo, 2?2?0.
Oimhnhnne. G..N. Aonke,O. Conothsto,C.R. Tonkcbk
?5=0 Gouio quothrioreo fe Whikso: ahiie prhneceiore, Otte fhnno PP´ Reuiekih saehitegeao
fhnn'Estetutk Etoneoik fe Trhestkreo h Trktkstkreo, ?11-?64.
Oitkieozze, O.,
N. Aottoie,C. Arhcosa`e,N. Gkitoio.M. Meusbhrte,A. Thrhttk,R. Tkshiotk,G. Trkne,Q. Ximork
?506 Treeie resuntote fhnnh reahra`h ihn meoaechitk fhn Tonhkneteak eighrekrh fe Ao ' Bhnvhfàrh
(Ckith Tkmmeknk, Gkrte), Trhestkreo onpeio 24, =-?6.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 53/342
6> CORM@HREVO CXQQE - EVONU
Oitkieo/./.e. O..E . Aotnoie,
C. Arhcosa`e,N. Gkitoio,
A. Thrhttk.R. Tkshiotk,G. Trkne,
Q. Ximoek
?500 Nh meshchit fu Tonhknet`equh eigårehur fh Ao' Bhnvhfàrh fe Ckith Tkmmeknk (Gkrte, Etoneì)
(Råsuntots pråneceioerhs), N'Oit`rkpknkmeh 52, 725-762.
Oitkieozze, O.,C. Ghrrore,A. Thrhttk
?551 EE meoaechitk fe Ao' Bhnvhfàrh fe Ckith Tkmmeknk fhn Tnhestkahih eighrekrh aki eifustreoneteao (Gkrte), Bunnhtteik fe Tonhtiknkmeo etoneoio 06, ?-87.
Oizefhe, O.T.,O. Oimhnhnne,O. Oriknfus-@uyzhifvhnf,N. Aonke.C.R. Tonkcbk,
O.M. Qhmrh
?505 Nh meshchit pnåestkaàih fh No TkXhfroro fe Ahaoiebbek (Rkch, Etoneì) , N'Oit`rkpknkmeh
51, =65-=02.
Oizefhe, O.T.,
G. Oimhnhnne,N. Aonke.E. Foceoie,
C. Toaaeorhnne.C.R. Tonkcbk.
O.A. Qonteie,O.M. Qhmrh
?500 EE meoaechitk pnhestkahieak fh "No TkXhfroro" fe Ahaoiebbek (Rkco)
prhneceiorh, Ora`hknkmeo Nozeonh 5, 17?-170.
Rhnozekih
Oizefhe. O.T.,O. Oriknfus-@uyzhifvhnf
?552 V`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea seth kg No TkXhfroro fe Ahaoiebbek (Rkch, Etony). Ei: H. @hrreim,
R. ]`eth`kush, J. ]enleis (hfs), Ihw fhvhnkpchits ei Etoneoi Ora`ohknkmy, Tort ?,
Tophrs kg t`h Gkurt` Akighrhiah kg Etoneoi Ora`ohknkmy, ?6?-?81, Nkifki: OaakrfeoRhshora` Ahitrh.
Oizefhe, O.T.,R. Qhbosteoie
?506 Qomme fe saovk ihn fhpksetk pnhes tkahieak on Lc. ?5,144 fhnno Weo Ourhneo (Aosthn feMuefk). Ei: O.C. Behtte Qhstehre (hf.), Trhestkreo h Trktkstkreo ihn thrretkreo fe Rkco,
07-51, Rkco: Fh Nuao.
Oizefhe. O.T.,T. Wenno, T.,
H. Ahrenne
(ei prhss) No TkXhfroro fe Ahaoiebbek (Rkco). Fote prhneceiore sun n'oionese togkikceao fhe rhphrte
gouiesteae. Otte fhn Akivhmik Gorihsh Trhestkreo h Trktkstkreo ei Htrureo, Wethrbk 2? -21 commek ?551.
Oriknfus-@uyzhifvhnf, O.,O.T. Oizefhe
?551 Reakstruzekih fe ui ocbehith gnuvek-noaustrh ihnno rhmekih vunaoieao fe Rkco (No TkXhfroro fe Ahaoiebbek). Otte fhnno PPP´ Reuiekih saehitegeao fhnn'nstetunk Etoneoik fe
Trhestkreo h Trktkstkreo, ?8?-?78.
Bofo, J.N.,(?. Bhnnukceie
Bofo, J.N.,
te . Bhnnukceie,
N. Bkigemnek.C. Broiao,
H. Burmek,N. Fhnetoto
?508
?55?
Esknhuaeih hpechrezoteki omhs kg t`h fworg hnhp`oits kg Qeaeny, Mhknkmy ?1, 68? -682.
Esknhuaeih hpechrezoteki omhs kg _uothriory coccons grkc Qeaeny, // _uothriorek 6,
65-86.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 54/342
66 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Bo`oei, J.-J.
Boëssos, T.
Boëssos, T.,
N. Borron,T. Qecki,
Q. Qeckih
?551 Fototeki por råskioiah fh Qpei ånhatrkiequh (HQR) fu aorbkioths ht f'åcoen fhitoerh
quothrioerhs: pkthitehn ht prkbnàchs. V`hsh fh Fkatkrot fu Cusåuc Iotekion f'@estker
Ioturhnnh, Tores: Eistetut fh Tonhkitknkmeh @ucoeih.
?504 Fkiiåhs ponåkcomiåtequh ht såfechitknkmequh sur nhs fåp÷ts fh no akuph fh Nkrhtk,
Bunnhtei fu Cusåh f'Oit`rkpknkmeh prå`estkrequh fh Ckioak 26, ?1-87.
?507 Nh Tnhestkaàih ckyhi o no mrktth fu Aknkcbk (Vkeroik, Nemureh etonehiih), Bunnhtei fu
Cusåh f'Oit`rkpknkmeh prå`estkrequh fh Ckioak 25, 8-26.
Borron, N.,
Q. Qeckih
?501 Nh bossei gnuvek-noaustrh fh Whikso , Bunnhtei fu Cusåh f'Oit`rkpknkmeh prå`estkrequh
fh Ckioak 2=. 8-?5.
Bortknkche, M. ?504 Cearkcocceghre fhn Tnek-Tnhestkahih. Ei: / vhrthbrote gkssene etoneoie, Aotonkmk fhnno
Ckstro, 265-280, Whrkio.
Bhnne. M.,M. Bhnnukceie.T.G. Aosskne,Q. Ahaa`e,
C. Auaorze,N. Fhnetono,M. Gkrioaeore,G. Connhmie,C. Tephrik,O.M. Qhmrh,H. Qhmrh Ionfeie
Beffettu, E.
?55? Fåakuvhrth f'ui gåcur `ucoei oa`hunåhi o Iktora`ereak (Wåikso, Boseneaoth), N'Oit`rk
pknkmeh 58, 6=-00.
?5=2 Tnhestkaàih h eifustr eh netea`h prh-oa`hunhoih of Orah h Gkitoio Nere, _uothrioreo PWE,
18-82.
Beffettu, E.,T.G. Aosskne,G. Rofeaote fe Brkzknk,
O.M. Qhmrh,H. Qhmrh Ionfeie,E. Wenno
?5=5 Oiomie, o L-Or fothf Horny oif Ceffnh Tnhestkaàih Qeth, Ahitron Etony: prhneceiory rhpk
_uothrioreo PPE, 81-=?.
Beffettu. E..
O.M. Qhmrh
?5=0 Tonhkne teak eighrekrh o Aovo Tkcpe prhssk Tkge (Grkseikih) , _uofhrie fhn Ahitrk Qtufe p
WOra`hknkmeo Htrusak-Etoneao ?, ==-=5.
?502 Tnhestkaàih chfek-suphrekrh aki eifustreo oraoeao su aekttknk ihn boaeik fe Oiomie(Nozek), Otte fhnno PP?EE´ Reuiekih saehitegeao fhnn'nstetutk Etoneoik fe Trhestkreo h
Trktkstkreo, 87=-8=7.
?506 Eifustreo su sa`hmmeo h begoaaeo ne: iukve rhphrte fhn Tonhkne teak eighrekrh of Oiomie-Gkitoio Roiuaaek, Grkseikih, Otte fhnno PPEW´ Reuiekih saehitegeao fhnn'nstetutk Etoneoik
fe Trhestkreo h Trktkstkreo, ?48-??6.
Bnoia, O.A.
Bkiofkiio, G.T.
Bkiegoy, C.-G.
?518-
?51=
?578
?5==
Qa`hmmeo fe thaieao anoatkieoio reivhiuto ei setu ihn _uothriorek fhnno Wona`htto-Aortkie
(Rkco), Revesto fe Oitrkpknkmeo PPPE, 281-277.
Gurt`hr eigkrcoteki ki t`h rhshora` ei t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkaàih feotkceth quorry kg WonnhfhnnVighrik (Reoik, Rkch), _uothrioreo WEE, 2=5-255.
Nesth pråneceioerh fh no mroifh gouih fu meshchit prå`estkrequh fh Whikso, Bunnhtei fu
Cusåh f'Oit`rkpknkmeh prå`estkrequh fh Ckioak 2?, ??8-?28.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 55/342
68 CORM@HREVO CXQQE - EVONU
Bkrzotte vki N÷whisthri, H.,
C. Qkzze,Q. Woiiuaae.G. WeoeL'nnk
?554 N'Oa`hunhoik fhn aecethrk fe Othnno (TZ). Trech eifomeie sunno strotemrogeo fhn shfechitk
h sunnh eifustreh netea`h, Qtufe phr n'Haknkmeo fhn _uothriorek ?2, 5-25.
Bkrzotte vki N÷whisthri, H.,G. Weoihnnk
?551 Nukm`e fe sksto h h fe eishfeochitk nuimk Eh revh fhn nomk pnhestkahieak fe Othnno
(Tkthizo), Otte fhnno PPP´ Reuiekih saehitegeao fhnn'Estetutk Etoneoik fe Trhesnkreo h
Trktkstkreo, ?15-?84.
Bksa`eoi, M. ?551 Aosthn fe Muefk - Qaove ?504-?55?, Oc' fhnno PPP´ Reuiekih saehitegeao fhnn'Estetutk
Etoneoik fe Trhestkreo h Trktkstkreo, ?7=-?=0.
Brkmnek, O.,
?. Fe Mhrkieck,H. Fe Courk.J.L. Lkznkwsle
?552 Ikuvhnnhs akitrebutekis o no akiioessoiahs fu Tonåknet`equh eigårehur fh no råmeki fh
Aotoieo fois Eh aofrh fu Tonåknet`equh fh no Qeaenh. Ei: A. Thrhttk (hf.), / prece obetoite
fhnno Wonnh Tofoio: Ckith Tkmmeknk, ?05-227. Cenoik: Joao Bkkl.
('onke. E...M.B.N. Akaakneie,C. Cusse,
C.R. Tonkcbk,Q. Wetomneoik,F. Zocphtte
?505 Nh Ckustårehi fu Noteuc (Etoneì ahitronh): ora`åknkmeh, cenehu ioturhn, a`rkiknkmeh, N'Oit`rkpknkmeh 51, =1-50.
Aonke. N.,
C.R. Tonkcbk
?5=0 Oigebe, rhttene h cocceghre fe Vkrrh fhn Tomneoaahttk (Vkrrh ei Tehtro, Rkco), _uothrioreo
PP, 1?8-664.
?5=5 No gouio quothrioreo fe Whikso: "Aoie s sp ." , _uothrioreo PPE, ??8-?20.
?504 No gouio quothrioreo fe Whikso: Bkvefe, Bknnhtteik fhn Qhrvezek mhknkmeak f'Etoneo A,
?4?-?64.
?507 Nh cocconkgouih pnek-pnhestkahiea`h fhnn' orho nozeonh: prkbnhce bekstrotemrogeae hf
ecpneaozekie ponhkanecotea`h, Chckreh fhnno Qkaehtf mhknkmeao eeoneoio 18, 55-?27.
Aosskne, T.G.,A. Fh Meune.
O.C. Rofcenne,O.M. Qhmrh
?502 Meoaechitk fhn Tonhkneteak eighrekrh o Conomrktto (Rkco), Otte fhnno PPEEV Reuiekih
saehitegeao fhnn' Estetutk Etoneoik fe Trhestkreo h Trktkstkreo, 81?-865.
Aosskne, T.G.,F. Nhtêvrh,
C. Tephrik.J.-T. Royion,O. Vomneoakzzk
?551 Xio ponhksuphrgeaeh aki rhste fe Hnhp`os (Tonohknkxkfki) oitequus h eifustreo oa`hunhoio
ihn setk fe Iktora`ereak (Whikso, Boseneaoto), Otte fhnno PPP" Reuiekih saehitegeao
fhnn'Estetutk Etoneoik fe Trhestkreo h Trktkstkreo, ?4?-??7.
Aottoie, ?.. ?552 EE reakprechitk vhmhtonh ihnn' orho pofoio furoith en Tnhestkahih eighrekrh h chfek. Ei:A. Thrhttk (hf.), Eprece obetoite fhnno Wonnh Tofoio: Ckith Tkmmeknk, 25?-142, Cenoik:
Joao Bkkl.
Aottoie, N.,
C. Arhcosa`e,C.R. Ghrrores,G. Connhmie.
G. Coseie.W. Qakno,A. Vkzze
?55? Nh meshchit fu Tnhestkahih ckyhi fh Weskmneoik (Vrehsth): rhsths `ucoeis, eifustrehs,hiverkiihchit, N'Oit`rkpknkmeh 58, 5-17
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 56/342
67 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Akntkrte, C.,C. Arhcosa`e,C.A. Fhnetono,F. Hsu,C. Gkrioshre,
O. CaT`hrrki,
C. Ieaknhtte,
R. voi Ktthrnkk,
A. Thrhttk,B. Qono.
W. Qa`ceft,J. Qhveil
?502 Rhvhrshf comihtea pknorety ot oi horny Nkwhr Tonohkn et`ea seth ei Ahitron Etony, Ioturh
144, ?=1-?=7.
Akiotk, W.,F. Hsu,O. Conothsto,G. Zornhimo
?504 Ihw foto ki t`h Tnhestkahih kg Rkch, _uothrioreo PPEE, ?1?-?=7.
Arhcosa`e, C..
Q. A`ehso
?552 Ocbehith h aneco. Ei: O. Muefe, C. Tephrik (hfs), Etoneo prhestkreao, 1-68, Rkco:
Nothrzo.
Arhcosa`e, C.,A. Thrhttk
?500o Nhs skns f'`obetot fu seth ponåknet`equh f'Eshri eo No Teihto (Cknesh, Etoneì ahitronh).
N'Oit`rkpknkmeh 52, ?4?=-?464.
Arkvhttk, A.
?500b Nh Tonåknet`equh eigårehur fh no pnoeih kreìitonh fu T÷, N'Oit`rkpknkmeh 52, 761-702.
?55? Råsuntots pråneceioerhs fh no akcporoeski fhs eifustrehs f'Eshrieo No Teihto ht fhWhikso-Nkrhtk. Ei: A. Thrhttk (hf.), `hrieo No Teihto - Iukve akitrebute saehitegeae,
=5-58, Eshrieo: Estetutk rhmekionh phr mne stufe stkreae fhn Cknesh "W. Aukak".
Fhsek, O. (hf.)
Furoith, Q.,G. Qhtthposse
?5=1 Mhknkmeo fhnn'Etoneo, Vkgeik: XVHV.
?5=0 Ikto sunnh osskaeozekie conoaknkmea`h fhn meoaechitk gnuveknoaustrh fe Nkrhtk, Whikso.
Otte fhnno PPE??´ Reuiekih saehitegeao fhnn'Estetutk Etoneoik fe Trhestkreo h Trktkstkreo,
?6?-?68.
Hvhrifhi, J.G.,
@. Aurtes
?578 V`h pktosseuc-ormki foteim kg Noth Ahikzkea rkals ei Host Ogreao oif Etony, Aurrhit
Oit`rkpknkmy 7, 161-175.
Gorezy, A. ?500-
?505
Qpoteon krmoiezoteki oif Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea kphi oer seths, Kremeie ?6, 15-84.
Ghrrore, C’A. Thrhttk,
G. Weoihnnk
?55? Osphtte thaik-tepknkmeae h festrebuzekih orhonh fh@'eifustreo fhn EE shttkrh fe EshrieoNo Teihto (Cknesh, etoneo). Ei: Thrhttk A. (hf.), Eshrieo No Teihto, iukve akitrebute
saehitegeae, 65-=0 , Eshrieo: Estetutk rhmekionh phr mne stufe stkreae fhn Cknesh "W .Aukak".
Gknnehre, C. ?57?- No gkrhsto akna`eao gkssenh fe Reoik Rkcoik. EE. Oionese pknn eiea`h, Oiione fe Bktoieao.
?571 268-204.
Gknnehre, C.,F. Comre,N. Qofkre
?500 284,444-yhor pknnhi rhakrf grkc Wonnh fe Aostemnekih (Rkco), Tknnhi ht Qpkrhs 14, 125-
187.
Gkrioshre, C. ?508 Mhka`rkiknkmy kg vknaoiea rkals grkc Noteuc (Etony), Rhifeakite fhnno Qkaehtf etoneoio
fe Ceihronkmeo h Thtrknkmeo 64, =1-?47
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 57/342
6=
(eonebhrte, O.
CORM@HREVO CXQQE - EVONU
?502 N'eifustreo fe tepk "Thbbnh Auntu rh" fe Bebbkio (Nevkrik) (Ikto prhneceiorh), Otte
fanno PPEEE" Reuiekih saehiteg eao fhnn'Estetutk Etoneoik fe Trhestkreo h Trktkstkreo, 671-6=5.
Mocbnh, A.
Motte, Q. (hf.)
Meusbhrte, M.,
C. Ghrrore,
A. Thrhttk
Meusbhrte, M..A. Thrhttk
nnoyihs. (e.
Joakboaae, O.
?507 V`h Tonohknet`ea Qhttnhchit kgHurkph. Aocbrefmh: Aocbrefmh Xievhrsety Trhss.
?551 Fevhs Oiomieo - Ora`hknkmeo ihþo vonnh fhn Qoaak. Rkco: "N'Hrco" fe Brhtsa`ihefhr.
?55? Vepknkmeo, grhquhizo h festrebuzekih fhe rhphrte ponhkitknkmeae h ponhtiknkmeae fhnnoponhksuphrgeaeh V.1o fhn E shttkrh fe saovk fe Eshrieo No Teihto (Eshrieo, Cknesh). Ei:
Thrhttk A. (hf.), Eshrieo No Teihto, iukve akitrebute saehitegeae, 8-62, Eshrieo:Estetutkrhmekionh phr mne stufe stkreae fhn Cknesh "W. Aukak".
?55? Hvefhiahs fh no groaturoteki eithitekiihnnh f'ksshchits oiecoux ovha ckìnnh fois Eh
meshchit fh "No Teihto" fh Eshrieo (Cknesh), Etoneì, N'Oit`rkpknkmeh 58, =78-==0.
?55? Cocckt`s, Costkfkits & Hnhp`oits. Aocbrefmh: Aocbrefmh Xievhrsety Trhss.
?5=0 EE renhvochitk mhknkmeak fhe feitkrie fe Vkrrh ei Tehtro (G ?65 Ahrvhthre), _uonhrioreo PP,
245-226.
Lkhiemswonf, ]. vkiV. voi Lkngsa`kthi
Nhgàvrh, F.,
J.-T. Royion.
M. Whriht
Nhgàvrh, F.,
J.T. Royion,
V. Tennhyrh,M. Whriht
ei prhss V`h Ceckcys-Orveakno bkuifory oif t`h hiochn t`ealihss qukteìit (QF_) kg Orveaknoos strotemrop`ea corlhrs ei t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, Trkahhfeims kg t`h QH_Q Arkchr
Qycpkseuc, ?554.
?551o Qhfechitory fyioceas oif thatk-vknaoiesc ei t`h Whikso Bosei (Boseneaoto). Ei:
C. Cknnehre, K. Merktte, V. Lktsoles, O. Voffhuaae, A. Vurihr (hfs), Obstroats. Qycpkseuc
"_uothriory strotemrop`y ei vknaoiea orhos" , 61, Rkch: EI_XO QH_Q, AIR, Xievhr-seto fhmne Qtufe fe Rkco "No Qopehizo".
?551b Akitrebuteki o no a`rkikstrotemrop`eh fh no såreh fh Whikso-Iktora`ereak (Boseneaoto),
Otte fhnno PPP´ Reuiekih saehitegeao fhnn'Estetutk Etoneoik fe Trhestkreo h Trktkstkreo,
??7-?20.
Nhkiorfe, M.,A. Thtrkiek
Coaaomik. O.C.
Conothsto, O.
Conothsto, O.,
\•". Zornhimo
Connhmie, G.,R. Coreoie-Akstoiteie.
M. Gkcoaeore,H.V. Nkimk,K, Meoakbeie,
O.C. Rofcenne
?5=6 E ahrve pnhestkahieae fhn boaeik feotkceteak fe Reoik (Rkco), Otte fhnno Oaaofhceo
Iozekionh fhe Neiahe - Chckreh (Anossh Qa. ges. cot. iot.), Qhreh WEEE, ?2, ?45-240.
?5=7 V`h Gonnkw Fhhr kg Hurkphoi Tnhestkahih, Mhknkmeao Rkcoio ?8, ?-7=.
?572 Mne hnhgoite gkssene fe Reoik, Mhknkmeao Rkcoio ?, 11-?12.
?5=0 No shreh fe Vkrrh ei Tehtro ihn quofrk fhn Tnhestkahih Rkcoik, _uonhrioreo PP, 81=-8==.
?500 Hvefhiah kg Ceffnh Tnhestkahih troismrhssekis onkim t`h Chfethrroihoi akost, Tonohk-
mhkmrop`y, Tonohkanecotknkmy, Tonohkhaknkmy 70, 1??-1?8.
?501 Ihw Hurkphoi gkssen `kceief cothreon grkc oi Oa`hunhoi seth ihor Rkch (Aosthn fe
Muefk), Ochreaoi Jkurion kg T`yseaon Oit`rkpknkmy 72, 271-2=6.
Cor tei e. G, ?552 En peþ oiteak pkpknochitk ucoik fhnnh esknh: no Qorfhmio. Ei: Thrhttk A. (hf.), / prece
obetoine fhnno Wonnh Tofoio: Ckith Tkmmeknk, ?=8-?0=. Cenoik, Joao Bkkl.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 58/342
6Q V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Chunhi, O.J. voi fhr
Chzzhio, G.,O. Tonco fe Ahsikno
Cusse, C.
?5=1 Ceffnh Tnhestkahih sconnhr coccons grkc t`h Ckith Thmneo (Krvehtk, Etony) , wet` spha
rhghrhiah tk t`h p`ynkmhiy kg Cearktus (Orveak`foh, Rkfhiteo), _uothrioreo PWEE, ?-?
?5=? Eifustreo oa`hunhoio ihe fhpksete hsthrie fhnno Mrktto Tomneaae, Revesto fe Qaehizh
prhestkrea`h 27, 1-25.
?552 // Tonhkneteak h en Chskneteak ei `oneo. Tkpkne h Aevento fhnn'Etoneo oiteao vkn. ?4. Bknkmio
Qtenus.
Tonco fe Ahsikno, O. ?502 EE Tonhkne teak eighrekrh ei Tumneo, Otte fhnno PP?EG Reuiekih saehitegeao fhnn'`tetutk Etone
fe Trhestkreo h Trktkstkreo, 228-260.
Tonkc`k, C.R.
Thrhttk, A. (hf.)
?508 E mroife cocceghre pnhestkahieae fhnnh esknh fhn Chfethrroihk: thcpe h veh fe cemrozeki Bunnhtteik fhnno Qkaehtf Tonhkitknkmeao Etoneoio 26, 24?-226.
?55? Eshrieo No Teihto, iukve akitrebute saehitegeae. Eshrieo: Estetutk rhmekionh phr mne stufe
stkreae fhn Cknesh "W. Aukak".
Thrhttk, A,A. Vhrzoie,
C. Arhcosa`e (hfs)
Tephrik, C.
Tephrik, C,E. Beffettu
Tephrik, C.,CM. Bunmorhnne,G. Zhve (hfs)
Tephrik, C,G. Connhmie,U. Uklkyoco
Rofcenne, O.C.
?552 / prece obetoite fhnno Wonnh Tofoio: Ckith Tkmmeknk. Cenoik: noao Bkkl.
?501 Eshrieo No Teihto, ui oaaocpochitk peþ oiteak fe =44.444 oiie. Bknkmio: Aonfhreie.
?5=2 V`h Ckith Thmneo net`ea eifustry, _uothrioreo PWE, 81-78.
?5=0 Qtufek tepknkmeak h eithrprhtozekih fh@'eifustreo oa`hunhoio h prh-custhreoio fhe nevhnne
c h f fe Vkrrh ei Tehtro (Rkco), _uothrioreo PP, 66?-817.
?506 / prece obetoite f'Hurkpo. Rkco: Fh Nuao.
?554 Fåakuvhrth f'ui gåcur `ucoei fois nhs ievhoux oa`hunåhis fh Iktora`ereak (Whikso,
Boseneaoto, Etoneì), Akcpths Rhifus fh E 'Oaofåceh fhs Qaehiahs fh Tores 1?? (shr. EE),?45=-??42.
?5== Qtkreo fhnn'Obruzzk fonnh kremeie onn'hto fhn Brkizk. Teso: Meorfeie.
?506 Qaove ihn meoaechitk fhn Tonhknet eak eighrekrh fe Aosthn fe Muefk prhssk Rkco. Ei:
O.C. Behtte Qhstehre (hf.), Trhestkreo h Trktkstkreo ihn thrretkrek fe Rkco, =8-08, Rkco:
Fh Nuao.
Rofnlh, X.,M.J. @hiiem,]. Neilh,J. Cþimhrsfkr
Rkhbrkhls, ].,
I.J. Akiorf,V. voi Lkngsa`kthi
?50? 214 V` /216 X- oif HQR- foteim prkbnhcs kg gkssen s`hnns ei Tnhestkahih coreih thrroahs(Ikrt`hri Noteuc, Ahitron Etony), _uothrioreo PPEEE, 1=-84.
?552 Fhish Gkrhsts, Aknf Qthpphs, oif t`h Tonohknet`ea Qhttnhchit kg Ikrt`hri Hurkph, Aurrh
Oit`rkpknkmy 11, 88?-807.
Rkhbrkhls, ]
V. voi Lkngsa`kthi
t`es V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph : O rhopproeson kg orthgoatuon oif a`rkiknkmeaonvknuch hvefhiah.
Qono, B. ?501 No gouio fhn meoaechitk fe Eshrieo No Teihto. Ei: A. Thrhttk, A. Vhrzoie, C. Arhcosa`e(hfs), Eshrieo No Teihto, ui oaaocpochitk peþ oiteak fe =44.444 oiie, =?-=5, Bknkmio:Aonfhreie.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 59/342
65 CORM@HREVO CXQQ? - EVONU
?505 O Trhneceiory Rhpkrt ki t`h Cearkvhrthbroths kg Iktora`ereak, Whikso, Trhestkreo Onpeio
28,=-?6.
Qorte, O.
?'. Qtkfute
?502 Qtozekih neteao reghrebenh onno "Thbbnh Aun turh" sakphrto ihn Nevkrihsh, Otte fhnno PP??G
Reuiekih saehitegeao fhnn'Estetutk Etoneoik fe Trhestkreo h Trktkstkreo, 66=-67?.
Qhmrh, O.
W Osahee/e
Qhmrh, O.M.
E. Beffettu,G. Muofomikne
Qhmrh, O.M.?. Beffettu,C. Tephrik
Qkpreithifhizo Qphaeonh on CushkIozekionh Trhestkreak Htikmrogeak'*N. Temkreie".
Vkzze, A.
?506 Gkitoio Roiuaaek: Etony's Hornehst Ceffnh Tnhestkahih @kceief Qeth, Aurrhit Oit`rk-
pknkmy 28, 214- 211.
?50= Iukve fote sun meoaechitk fhn Tonhknet eak eighrekrh fe Oiomie -Gkitoio Roiuaae k,
Ora`hknkmeo Nozeonh WEE, 215-261.
?502 ?? Tonhkneteak eighrekrh ihn Nozek, ihnno Boseneaoto h ei Qeaeneo, Otte fhnno PPE] Reuiekih
saehitegeao fhnn'Estetutk Etoneoik fe Trhestkreo h Trktkstkreo, ?==-247.
?55? Hsaursekie o Iktora`ereak h `hrieo No Teihto, Nebrk Muefo, PPP´ Reuiekih saehitegeaofhnn'Estetutk Etoneoik fe Trhestkreo h Trktkstkreo.
?578 No Mrktto fhn Aknkcbk o Vkeroik, Revesto fe Qtufe nemure 1?, 8-61.
Vuggrhou, O.T. Oitkeih
t`es V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: Akiteihiton Ikrt`whsthri Hurkph.
vknuch
Corm`hreto Cusse
Fep. fe Qaehizh Qtkrea`h, Ora`hknkmea`h h
Oitrkpknkmea`h fhnn'Oitea`eto
Xievhrseto fe Rkco "No Qopehizo"
Weo Tonhstrk 71
44?08 Rkco, Etony
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 60/342
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 61/342
Oifrhos Foreos 1 V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: t`h Bonlois
V`h sconn iucbhr kgNkwhr Tonohknet`ea seths ei t`h
Bonlois, kih kg t`h ckst prkbobnh pot`woys gkr `kceiefs
hithreim Hurkph, es pksse`ny t`h rhsunt kg t`h necethf ockuit
kg rhshora` ei t`es orho. nsknothf geifs oif hxaovothf seths
os Uorecburmoz (Vurlhy), Thtronkio (Mrhhah) oif Mojtoi
(On`oieo) onnpkeit tk `ucoi kaaupoteki grkc t`h bhmeiieim
kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih kiworfs.
?. EitrkfuatekiO ghw yhors omk t`h Bonlois, oif obkvh onn t`her
Qkut`hri port, rhprhshithf o bnoil ki t`h cops kg NkwhrTonohknet`ea Hurkph. Uat t`es rhmeki es akisefhrhf tk bhsetuothf ki t`h ckst prkbobnh pot`woy t`ot `kceiefs tkklot t`h tech kg t`her 'akiquhst' kg t`h Hurkphoi akiteihit.V`h obshiah kg likwnhfmh kg prh`estkreh coi ei t`hBonlois es oaeuonX fua tk t`h noal kg prh`estkreh rhshora`wet`ei t`es orho. Eigkrcoteki ki t`h Tonohknet`ea kg t`hBonloi akuitrehs storthf tk bhakch ovoenobnh kiny ei rhahityhors. Foto hkiahrieim t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea orh vhrysaorah oif seths likwi grkc t`es phrekf orh ikt iuchrkus(ag. Gem. ?). V`h kiny hxaovotaf seths w`ea` foth tk t`h hornehrports kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih orh t`h aovhs kg Uorecburmoz
(Vurlhy), Thtronkio (Mrhhah), Mojtoi (Onboieo) oif Qoifonjo(Arkoteo< shh L. Wonka`, t`es vknuch).
2. VurlhyV`h kiny seth ei t`h Hurkphoi port kg Vurlhy w`ea` neos
yehnfhf Ceffnh Tnhestkahih orh`ohknkmeaon geifs es t`h aovhkg Uorecburmoz, w`hrh orh`ohknkmeaon rhshora` storthfrhahitny. V`h aovh kg Uorecburmoz es setuothf 28 lc tk t`hwhst kg Estoibkun ki t`h Corcoro Qho. Et `os iuchrkus`onns, stommhrhf ot fegghrhit nhvhns, w`ea` akitoei ecpkrtoit_uothriory fhpksets wet` iuchrkus Ceffnh Tnhestkahihkaaupoteki nhvhns (@kwhnn ?505). V`h osskaeothf gouio
akisests kg: Aoies cksboa`hises, Wunphs vunphs ssp..AukiEPhikayki sp., Xrsus fhieimhre, Ghnes synvhstres, Ghnes
nhk, Ghnes mkcboszkhmhises, Ghnes (A) aoroaon, Hquus
cksboa`hises, Trohchmoahrks ogg. vhrteakries, Foco sp.,Ahrvus hnop`us ssp., BksnBeski, Mozhnno sp., Aopro sp.
V`h eifustry akcpreshs o iucbhr kg phbbnh tkkns oif onormh vorehty kg gnolh tkkns (fhiteaunoths, ikta`hs, sefhsarophrs, akcpkseth tkkns). Ki t`h kt`hr `oif, `oifoxhs orh
obshit, os whnn os prkfuats kg t`h Nhvonnkes gnoleim
tha`iequh.
1. MrhhahV`h kiny Ceffnh Tnhestkahih seth hxaovothf ei Mrhhah es
Thtronkio aovh. Oport grkc t`es seth, hvefhiah gkr CeffnhTnhestkahih `ucoi kaaupoteki akisests kg esknothf geifs.
1.?. THVRONKIO
Thtronkio aovh es setuothf ot A`onaefequh (Ikrt`hriMrhhah), opprkxecothny 18 lc skut`-host kg V`hssonkiequhoif ihor t`h vennomh kg Thtronkio. Et es o vost aovhri cofhup kg o iucbhr kg monnhrehs ckrh t`oi ?844 c. ei tktonnhimt`.
Eisefh t`h aovh o rhcorlobny whnn prhshrvhf oithihoi-fhrt`oneoi slunn wos fesakvhrhf ei ?574. Et wos stual, by oaonaeth gnkw, omoeist t`h wonn kg o fevhrteaunh o ghw fkzhi acobkvh t`h surgoah. V`h slunn es kg o normh sezh, w`enh etsaroieon aopoaety es opprkxecothny ?244 ac' . Xigkrtuiothny,t`h goat t`ot t`h slunn wos ikt gkuif wet`ei o strotemrop`eaonakithxt prhvhits o anhor ossemichit tk oiy kg t`h nhvhnshstobnes`hf wet`ei t`h fhpksets ei t`h aovh. V`us t`h omh
hstecoths vory bhtwhhi 244 oif 744 Lyr BT (@hiiem ht on.?50?< O. Tkuneoiks ?502).
V`h quothriory fhpksets ei skch pnoahs ei t`h aovh orh uptk ?8 c ei fhpt` (shateki B ag. Gem. 2) oif 2= nhvhns `ovhbhhi festeimues`hf. Oi ecpkrtoit stonomcetea gnkkr shons t`hshfechits, w`enst o shakif kih shhcs tk bh prhshit ei t`hceffnh kg t`h fhpksets.
V`h fegghrhit nhvhns orh vhry rea` ei gouion rhcoeis. V`hsconn vhrthbroths (onn t`h nhvhns akcbeihf) orh rhprhshithfby Tesahs eif., Bugk sp. eif, Thnkboths gusaus, Wor oius
eithrchfeus, Noahrto sp. eif., Noahrto ag. treneihoto, Noahrto
ogg. verefes, Vhstufk mrohao, Vhstufk sp., Kp`efeo sp. eif.,
Oishr oishr, Oyt`yo ghreio, Guneao otro, But`ehrox pkuneoie,Gonak teiiuiaunus, Onhatkres mrohao chf., Onhatkres sp.,Thrfex he. jurh sole, Qaknkpoaefoh eif., Nocs sp., Aknucbo
khios ssp., Aknucbo neveo ssp., Aknucbo ponucbus. Qtrex
onuak, Mnouaefeuc posshreiuc, Bubk (;) sp. eif., Akrvus
akrox, Tyrr`kakrox mroaunus vhtus, Vurfus sp., Noieus
ceikr, Truihnno aknnoreo, Tosshregkrchs eif. E., Tosså -regkrchs eif. EE., Toa`yuro ag. htrusaus (3 Quiaus
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 62/342
82 VXE- E• OR E.E E-Q VKA AE VOE ËKI >)n ?? RKE'L
Gem. ?. Qeths chitekihf ei t`h thxt.
?: Uorecburmoz, 2: Thtronkio, 1: Moj-toi, 6: Lkresseo, 8: Lklleikpenks,7: Wro`ihëlo.
htrusaus), Qkrhx ceiutus, Qkrhx sp., Vonpo ceiuto,
Hreioahus hurkpohus prohmnoaeones, R`eiknkp`us sp. eif.E., R`eiknkp`us sp. eif. EE., R`eiknkp`us ghrruchmetectc
tkponhises, Cyktes cyktes, Cyktes `nyt`e kxymi., Cyktes sp.eif. E., Cyktes sp. eif. EN, Hpthseaus sp. eif., Tepestrhnnus
(;) sp. eif., Iyatonus ag. ikatuno, Nhpus sp., Kryatknomus
sp., Xrkaethnnus precemhieus fogioh, Toroscet`us
`rhvefhis, Frykceius hnekcykefhs orese, Qponox a`on-
lefeloh, Onnkareahtus `ursoh secpnhx, Cearktus prohmuhi-
t`hre, Opkfhcus sp., Opkfhcus (Lostkrcys) cystoaeius,
Cys (Bufocys) seioit`rkpus, @ystrex sp. (Lrhtzke oifI. Tkuneoiks ?50?). Qubshquhitny I. Tkuneoiks (?554)offhf Nomurus (Hknomurus) ormyrkpunke zoz`em`eie,
Nomurus tcuseaus oif Orveakno aoiteoio (3 O. thrrhstres
aoiteoio) tk t`es nest.
V`h normh vhrthbroths orh rhprhshithf by: Aoies nupus
cks`oa`hises, Wunphs ag. prohmnoaeones, Auki presaus, Xrsus
faieima`, Xrsus t`e`htoius chfethrroihus, Chnhs chnhs,
Arkauto arkauto prohsphnoho, Arkauto arkauto phtronkioh,
@yohio phrrehre, @yohio `rhverkstres, Ghnes synvhstres
`ocofrvos, Toit`hro nhk gkssenes, Toit`hro ag. mkc`oszkh-mhises, Toit`hro porfus, @kckt`hreuc sp., Hquus ag.cks`oa`hises, Oseius `yfruiteius ssp., Feahrkr`eius
`hcetkha`us, Qus sarkgo, Trohchmoahrks vhrteakries, Foco
sp., Ahrvus hnop`us ssp., Bks precemhieus, Aopro ebhx
coahfkieao (Lutthi oif O. Tkuneoiks ?5==< Lurtåi oifO. Tkuneoiks ?50?< Lrhtzke oif I. Tkuneoiks ?50?< Lurtåi?501).
V`h gouion osshcbnomh (t`h aorievkrhs ei porteaunor) eseithrprhthf os a`oroathrestea kg t`h gerst `ong kg t`h CeffnhTnhestkahih. Ckrh prhaeshny @. phrrehre, @. `rhverkstres oiT. mkc`oszkhmhises eifeaoth t`h horny Ceffnh Tnhestkahihos t`h ceiecuc omh, w`hrhos C. chnhs oif T. porfus mevt`h soch phrekf os t`h coxecuc omh (Lurtåi ?501). V`ut`es gouio es a`oroathrestea kg t`h gerst port kg t`h CeffnhTnhestkahih oif onnkws ottrebuteki kg oi omh kg 844 tk =84
Lyr BT tk t`h Thtronkio fhpksets. V`h gouio `os ikt bhhisphaegehf gkr hoa` nhvhn yht, but t`h vorekus out`krs eifeaot`ot t`hrh orh ik semiegeaoit a`oimhs wet`ei t`h tktonshquhiah. @kwhvhr, t`rhh gouion shquhiahs whrh festei-mues`hf ki t`h bosh kg t`h `yhio cothreon (Lurtåi oifO. Tkuneoiks ?50?< Lurtåi ?501): t`h Arhieoi (nhvhns ?0tk ??) a`oroathreshf by oi osskaeoteki kg @yohio phrrehre
oif Arkauto arkauto prohsphnoho, t`h Thtronkieoi (nhvhns tk 2) a`oroathreshf by t`h rhpnoahchit kg @yohio phrrehre
by @yohio `rhverkstres oif t`h akiteiuoteki kg Arkauto
arkauto prohsphnoho, w`hrhos t`h V`hrcohaeoi (upphrstonomcetea @kkr) es a`oroathreshf by t`h prhshiah kg kiny
Arkauto arkauto phtronkioh.Worekus foths `ovh bhhi put gkrworf gkr t`h fhpksets,
roimeim grkc 244 tk ?,444 Lyr BT, but t`h ckst ak`hrhitkg t`hsh akiahri kiny t`h upphr stonomcetea gnkkr (Elhyo?504< ]eitnh oif Joakbs ?502< Q`hi oif Uklkyoco ?50Foteim kg t`es stonomcetea gnkkr by t`h uroieuc feshqueneb-reuc cht`kf rhsunthf ei oi omh kg ckrh t`oi 184 Lyr BT t`h necet kg t`es cht`kf (Q`hi oif Uklkyoco ?507).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 63/342
81 OIFRHOQ FORNOQ - V@H BONLOIQ
Thtronkio: Qhateki B strotemrop`y (ogthr O. Tkuneoiks ?502)
Os ponyiknkmeaon oif shfechitknkmeaon oionyshs fef iktrhsunt ei mkkf eifeaotekis ki t`h anecotea oif hiverkichiton
akifetekis fureim t`h gkrcoteki kg t`h fhpksets, kiny t`hgouio! rhcoeis orh `hnpgun `hrh. I. Tkuneoiks (?554) `osfesteimues`hf iuchrkus anecotea p`oshs oif `os frowi upo bekstrotemrop`ea tobnh kg t`h fhpksets (Vobnh E). V`h`hrbevkrhs rhakvhrhf ei t`h fegghrhit nhvhns whrh ckstny`uithf by coi, ont`kum` skch fk opphor tk `ovh bhhibrkum`t ei by aorievkrhs. V`h Thtronkio `kceiefs coeiny`uithf `krsh (6=.?% kg t`h `hrbevkrhs), ahrvefs (2?.0%)
oif ckuitoei mkot (2?.6%) (Lrhtzke oif I. Tkuneoiks?50?).
V`h net`ea cothreon es obuifoit t`rkum`kut ihorny onn t`hnhvhns (O. Tkuneoiks ?502). Ihvhrt`hnhss, os o rhsunt kgo noal kg fhtoenhf stufehs, kiny skch saorah foto oif skchfroweims oif peaturhs kg o ghw orthgoats orh ovoenobnh(Gem. 1.? oif 1.2).
V`h eifustry nkkls rot`hr 'ora`oea' oif es onckst onwoyscofh kut kg quortz< kaaosekionny uickfegehf bouxethgromchits whrh ushf os ecpnhchits. Vwk gneit pehahs whrh
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 64/342
86 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
gkuif ki t`h surgoah kg t`h fhpksets os whnn os o ghw wet`eit`h fhpksets w`ea` ankshf t`h hitroiah tk t`h aovh. Thbbnhnkkns orh rorh oif `oifoxhs obshit. V`h bosh kg t`es eifustr)es gkrchf by sconn tkkns, cofh by useim fhbres, oif ckrhrorhny gnolhs. Qefh sarophrs (ckst kgthi gkrchf by useim o
t`eal rhtkua`), ikta`hs oif fhiteaunoths orh onsk grhquhit,w`enh kt`hr tkke typhs orh rorh.
1.2. LKRREQQEO
O a`kpphr (Gem. 1.1) wos fesakvhrhf ei setu ei o autteimanksh tk t`h Lkrresseo nomkki ei t`h skut`-whst kg t`h esnoifkg Akrgu (Ikrt` ]hst Mrhhah) (Lkurthsse-T`eneppoles ?554).V`h orthgoat akchs grkc o anoy bhf setuothf bhtwhhi twk
coreih nechstkih `krezkis w`ea` rhst ei strkim uiakigkr-cety ki o ceffnh Tnekahih soify fhpkset. V`h anoy bhf ios
o ikrcon comihtea pknorety oif `os bhhi ottrebuthf tk t`h
gerst port kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih (Jocht ?502). V`h
a`kpphr akunf, t`hrhgkrh, bh akithcpkrory wet` t`h
Thtronkio eifustry.
1.1. LKLLEIKTENKQ
V`h kphi oer seth kg Lklleikpenks nehs ei Hperus (Ikrt`]hst Mrhhah) (Boenhy ht on. ?552). O gkrcoteki kg CeffnhTnhestkahih rhf sents, ckrh t`oi 64 c t`eal, yehnfhf o
Ceakqueoi `oifoxh (Gem. 6.?), gkuif ei setu ?7 c bhnkw t`h
tkp kg t`h rhf sents. V`h oifoxh es, oaakrfeim tk t`h
rhshora`hrs w`k gkuif et, 284,444 tk 144,444 yhors knf
(Ruiihns oif Woi Oifhn ?551). Ei oiy aosh t`es `oifoxh,wet` whnn rhtkua`hf bkorfs, wkunf get vhry whnn eitk o
Ceffnh, kr eifhhf hvhi Xpphr, Oa`hunhoi eifustry.
1.6. KV@HR QEVHQ
O ghw esknothf tkkns aknnhathf ei revhr thrroahs `ovh bhhiottrebuthf tk t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, h.m. geifs grkc t`h
ceffnh thrroah kg Oneolcki (Ikrt`hri Mrhhah) oif t`h upphrthrroah kg Terks (Oa`oëo, whsthri Mrhhah) (Fornos ?556).
O rhahit fesakvhry ihor t`h vennomh kg Wro`ihëlo (rhmekikg Oa`oëo) kg twk gnolhf pehahs osskaeothf wet` o coreihbhoa` `os bhhi ottrebuthf tk t`h KEQ 5 troismrhsseki. O nechstkih snob rhsts uiakigkrcobny ki Tnekahih soifs ot ?17 c
kg ontetufh oif es akvhrhf ei turi by oi kggs`krh bor wet`akorsh mroeihf soifs. V`h twk rhtkua`hf gnolhs whrh gkuifwet`ei t`es kggs`krh bor.
6. OnboieoEi Onboieo, prh`estkreh rhshora` storthf kiny vhry rhahitny
oif t`h rhshora` es coeiny necethf tk t`h rhmeki kg Q`lkfhr,ei t`h ikrt`hri port kg t`h akuitry. Ei t`h kt`hr rhmekisTonohknet`ea fesakvhrehs orh proateaonny iki-hxesthit. NkwhrTonohknet`ea cothreon es gkuif ei t`h aovh kg Mojtoi oif t`h
kphi oer seth kg Boroi, nkaothf kiny 044 c grkc t`h aovh kg
Mojtoi (Gestoie ?551o oif b).
Gem. 1. ? oif 2: Thtronkio: quortz tkkns (ogthr O. Tkuneoiks ?5=0)
1: Lkrresseo: phbbnh tkke (ogthr Lkurthsse-T`eneppoles ?554).
Qaonh ei ac.
Vwk gnuveon thrroahs orh hxpkshf ot t`h seth kg Boroi.Kiny surgoah geifs kg stkih orthgoats, wet` ik strotemrop`ea
akithxt, `ovh bhhi aknnhathf. O "prh-Ceifhn" omh wosottrebuthf tk t`h net`ea cothreon fesakvhrhf ki t`h upphrthrroahs, bhaoush t`h osshcbnomh akitoeis ora`oea tkkns oi
rkum` `oifoxhs, a`kpphrs, a`kppeim-tkkns, oif normh gnolhNhvonnkes gnolhs oif fesakëfon akrhs onsk prhshit wet`ei t`
osshcbnomh orh eithrprhthf os akceim grkc o ckrh hvknvhshakif eifustry, w`ea` rhprhshits oi ei setu hvknuteki(tñ: ?81).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 65/342
88 OIFRHOQ FORNOQ - V@H BONLOIQ
Vobnh ?: Quccory kg bekstrotemrop ea oif ponohkanecotea foto kg t`h Thtronkio Aovh. V`h gerst opphoroiah kg o toxki ei t`h Thtronkio Aovhshfechits es eifeaothf by o fos`< t`ksh toxo gkuif kiny ei kih noyhr orh eifeaothf by o pkeit< t`ksh w`ea` orh kbshrvhf ot onckst onn noyhrs orh
eifeaothf by oi osthresl< oif, geionny, t`ksh sphaehs w`ea` orh gkuif wet`ei ahrtoei noyhrs, orh eifeaothf by o + (pnus) (ogthr I. Tkuneoiks ?554).
V`ealihss(ac)
Noyhrs ThrekfsOmhs
(ly)Bekstrotemrop`y Hiverkichit
28 ? V`hrcohaeoi (tkp stonomceth)884 .Auki presaus Akknhr
288 2 Thtronkieoi +Arkauto a. prohsphnoho
+Feahrkr`eius ag. `hcetkha`us ;
?44 1+ Xrsus t`ebhtoius
=8 6Qovoiio
54 814 7 *Xrsus fhieimhre
*Aoies nupus cksboa`hises
14 =
68 0 Akknhr?4 5
?4(24) ?4 V`roaeoi 7?4 .@yohio brhverkstres
(trovhrteih stonomceth)QovoiioQub-trkpea
244 ?? +Arkauto a. prohsphnoho
Arhieoi 784 +@yohio phrrehre Qovoiio/Gkrhst= ?2 *Ora`oit`rkpus hurkphus
24 ?1 +Nomurus troisehis
?8 ?6 •Feahrkr`eius ag. `hcetkha`us
22 ?854 ?7 +Xrsus t`ebhtoius
-Hquus ag. cksboa`hises
14 ?= +@yohio phrrehre
Orveakno aoiteoio
Akiteihiton gkrhst/aknf `ucef sthpph
14 ?0+Nomurus troisehis
74 ?5 Hnohka`kreoi -Onnkareahtus bursoh secpnhx
=44 -Opkfhcus sp. ]ht oif worchr
14 24=8 2?14 2254 21
=14.Vonpo ceiuto
54 26 Aknf `ucef sthpph(¿0´A)
74 28 ¿Nomurus troisehis
?44 27 A`onlefeleoi N. (Hktomurus) o. zuz`em`eie
Whry aknfsthpph (6´A)
2 2= =84-20- Ohmhoi (boson trovhrteih)
Vkton
fhpt`?72?
@kwhvhr, t`h toat t`ot t`hsh tkkns orh surgoah geifs,
evakvhevf kutsefh o strotemrop`eaon akithxt, colhs et
ecpkssebnh tk akitërc t`es omh, w`hrhos t`h prhshiah kg
Nhvonnkes gnolhs oif fesakëfon akrhs shhcs tk eifeaoth o
Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea omh. V`h phbbnh tkkns oif t`h normh oif
errhmunor gnolhs fk ikt phr sh eifeaoth o `em` omh, os sua`
pehahs orh grhquhit ockimst eifustrehs fesakvhrhf ei gnuveon
thrroahs.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 66/342
87 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 6.?: Lklleikpenks: `oifoxh (ogthr Ruiihns oif Woi Oifhn ?551), 2 oif 1: Mojtoi: phbbnh tkkns(ogthr Gestoie ?551b). Qaonh ei ac.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 67/342
8= OIFRHOQ FORNOQ - V@H BONLOIQ
6.?. MOJVOI
V`h aovh kg Mojtoi es setuothf tk t`h skut`-host kgQ`lkfhr bhtwhhi t`h vennomhs kg Rhia oif Mur e ze. V`haovh es port kg o lorstea ihtwkrl wet` o iucbhr kg aovetehsw`ea` akccuieaoth by akrrefkrs. V`h aovh `os twkpkra`hs. Hxaovotekis ot t`h gerst kih (Mojtoi E) rhvhonhfecpkrtoit _uothriory fhpksets, w`ea` aoi bh fevefhf eitk
2 osshcbnomhs: t`h upphr osshcbnomh akitoeis o Ckusthreoieifustry w`hrhos t`h nkwhr `os yehnfhf o Ceffnh Tnhestk-ahih gouio oif o Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea net`ea eifustry. Kt`hrbkih racoeis kg t`h soch omh os t`ksh kg t`h nkwhrosshcbnomh whrh onsk gkuif ei o sefh a`ocbhr kg t`h aovh.
V`h gouio kg t`h nkwhr osshcbnomh akitoeis: Vhstufk sp., Nhpus an', hurkpohus, @ystrex ag. veikmrofkve, Aoies nupus
cksboa`hises, Xrsus ag. fhieimhre, Xrsus t`ebhtoius,
Feahrkr`eius ag. chrale, Qus sarkgo, Ahrvus hnop`us,
Aoprhknus aoprhknus, Foco foco, Beski presaus (;), Coaoao synvoio pnekahio (Gestoie ?551o, Gestoie ?551b,Gestoie oif Aråmut-Bkiikurh ?551).
V`es Ceffnh Tnhestkahih gouio es eifeaotevh kg thcphrothanecotea akifetekis oif o coeiny gkrhsthf hiverkichit. V`hosshcbnomh `os bhhi fotaf tk t`h @knstheieoi Eithrmnoaeon.O normh iucbhr kg t`h bkih rhcoeis s`kw troahs t`ot orhottrebuthf tk `ucoi eithrghrhiah, sua` os fhgnhs`eim,eithitekion gromchitoteki oif nerh.
V`h eifustry fesakvhrhf ei t`es osshcbnomh akisests gkrt`h ckst port kg quortzeth. Et es a`oroathreshf by t`h rorety kgsconS tkkns, obshiah kg t`h Nhvonnkes tha`iequh oif o `em`prkpkrteki (64%) kg a`kpphrs oif a`kppeim-tkkns (Gem. 6.2oif 6.1) os whnn os by t`h prhshiah kg o ghw otypeaon`oifoxhs kr prktk-`oifoxhs.
8. AkianusekiGrkc t`h prhshit stoth kg Tonohknet`ea rhshora` ei t`h
Bonlois et es kiny pkssebnh tk soy t`ot t`hrh wos `ucoi
kaaupoteki grkc t`h gerst `ong kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahihkiworfs, ont`kum` t`h likwi seths orh vhry necethf oiffesphrshf ei tech oif spoah.
V`h kiny seths os yht fesakvhrhf oif hxaovothf gkr t`esphrekf orh t`h aovhs kg Uorecburmoz, Thtronkio oif Mojtoi.Ckst stufehs akiahrieim t`hsh seths `ovh bhhi akiahitrothfki t`h gouio oif foteim kg t`h fhpksets. Oport grkc t`h
gouion hvefhiah, t`hrh es vhry nettnh eigkrcoteki obkutanecotea oif hiverkichiton akifetekis, oif t`hrh es onskproateaonny ik hvefhiah akiahrieim t`h `obetot kr oatevetehskg prh`estkreh `kceiefs.
Ot kt`hr seths tkkns `ovh bhhi fesakvhrhf ei o strote-mrop`eaon akithxt (Lkrresseo, Lklleikpenks, Wro`ihëlo) buttkk ghw tk sphol obkut Tonohknet`ea 'aocp'seths. Geionnyt`hrh orh o ghw sconn tkke shrehs, wet` fkubtgun foths, grkcsurgoah seths.
Ei succory, twk akianusekis aoi bh frowi:?. Vroahs kg `ucoi kaaupoteki foteim grkc bhgkrh t`h
geion p`osh kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih `ovh bhhifesakvhrhf ei t`h skut`hri Bonlois ei speth kg t`h roretykg geifs. Bhaoush kg t`hsh geifs t`es port kg Hurkph esik nkimhr o bnoil ki t`h cop kg `ucoi kaaupoteki kgt`es phrekf.
2. V`h saoraety kg seths es preiaeponny fuh tk t`h rorety kgrhshora`: troahs kg `ucoi kaaupoteki kg CeffnhTnhestkahih omh `ovh bhhi fesakvhrhf ei ihorny onnrhmekis w`hrh prh`estkreh rhshora` `os bhhi akifuathf.V`es nhofs us tk eighr t`ot guturh rhshora` wenn ei onnprkbobenety nhof tk t`h fesakvhry kg kt`hr oif hvhituonnywhnn-prhshrvhf seths. Qua` fesakvhrehs wenn hiobnh us tkprhshit o ckrh syit`htea stufy kg t`h gerst kaaupotekis kg
t`es phieisunor, phr`ops kih kg gerst rhmekis kg Hurkph tkbh kaaupehf by `kceiefs.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 68/342
80 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
rhghrhiahs
Boenhy, M., ?552W. Topoakistoiteiku,F. Qturfy
Fornos, O. ?556
Gestoie, O.B. ?551o
Osprka`onelk oif Lklleikpenks: VN Foteim oif Rheithrprhtoteki kg Ceffnh Tonohknet`e
Qeths ei Hperus, Ikrt`-]hst Mrhhah, Aocbrefmh Ora`ohknkmeaon Jkurion 2(?), ?17-?66.
Nh Tonåknet`equh eigårehur ht ckyhi fh no Mràah, N'Oit`rkpknkmeh 50(2-1), 148-120.
@ucoi Hvknuteki ei Onboieo gkr t`h _uothriory Threkf. Ei: Bhaly O. Qemcki (hf.),
Bhgkrh t`h ]onn Ghen: V`h Qaehiah kg Coi ei Qkaeonest Hurkph, ?6?-?=0, Vkrkitk.Aoiofeoi Qa`knors' Trhss Eia.
?551b Fhakuvhrth f'ui `uchrus f'urs efå o ?'knåkaroih phrgkrå fois nh seth fh Mojtoi E (Q`lkf
hi Onboieì fu Ikrf, N'Oit`rkpknkmeh 5=(2-1), 221-210.
Gestoie. O.B.
H. Aråmut-Bkiikurh
?551 Fhakuvhrth f'Xrsus t`ebhtoius (Cocconeo, Aorievkro. Xrsefoh) fois nh seth pnåestkaài
ckyhi fh Mojtoi (Q`lkfìr, Onboieì), MHKBEKQ 27(2), 26?-271.
@hiiem, M.J.
]. @hrr,H. ]hbhr,
I.E. Perkteres
?50? HQR-foteim kg t`h gkssen `kceief aroieuc grkc Thtronkio Aovh, Mrhah, Ioturh 252,
811-817.
@kwhnn, G.A. ?505 Uorecburmoz ui ikuvhou seth fu Tnåestkaàih ckyhi o kaaupoteki `ucoeih fois ?'Kuhst
fh no Vurqueh (Råsucå). Ei: H. Bkiegoy ht B. Woifhrchhrsa` (hf), Nhs Trhcehrs
Hurkphhis, Oaths fu ??6' akimrhs iotekion fhs skaeåtås sovoiths, 211-216, Tores, Hfetekfu AV@Q.
Elhyo, C.
Jocht, C.
?504 HQR Foteim kg Aorbkioths ot Thtronkio Aovh, Oit`rkpks =, ?61-?8?.
?502 Htufh ihkthatkiequh fh Akrgku ht åtufh ponåkcomihtequh fh såfechits iåkmàihs fhs enh
fh Akrgku, Ahp`onkieh ht Zoit`h, V`hsh fh 1h ayanh, Xievhrsetå fh Tores-Quf.
Lkurthsse-T`eneppoles, M. ?554 Nhs pnus oiaehiihs kaaupotekis `ucoeihs fois nh thrretkerh åperkth ht oux akigeis fhrennyreh chrefekionh. Ei: T. Aoboihs (hf): N'Ennyreh chrefekionh ht ?'Hperh fois
WOiþquetå-nn, Oaths fu nnh Aknnkquh eithriotekion fh Anhrckif-Hhrroif (28-2= Katkbr
?554), ?4-?7, Tores, fh Bkaaorf.
Lran/ke, C.I. Tkuneoiks
?50? Rhcorls ki t`h Ceffnh oif Nkwhr Tnåestkaàih Whrthbronh Gouio ei t`h Thtronkio Aovh(wet` sphaeon rhghrhiah tk ihw Cearkgouio - up tk ?50?). Oit`rkpks 0, 8=-=2.
Lurtåi, B.
Lurtåi, B.O. Tkuneoiks
?501 Gouion shquhiah ei Thtronkio Aovh, Oit`rkpks ?4, 81-85.
?5== Ihw strotemrop`ea oif gouion cothreon grkc Thtronkio Aovh, wet` sphaeon rhghrhiah tkaorievkro, Oit`rkpks 6(?-2), 6=-?14.
Tkuneoiks, O.
?50? Gkssen aorievkro kg Thtronkio Aovh : Qtotus kg ?504, Oit`rkpks 0, 5-87.
?502 V`h Aovh kg t`h Thtronkieoi Ora`oit`rkpeioh: o muefh tk t`h saehiaa bh`eif t`h
hxaovotekis, Ot`his, Nebrory kg t`h Oit`rkpknkmeaon Osskaeoteki kg Mrhhah.
?]() Thtronkio: t`h Lhy tk t`h Huroseoi Nkwhr-Ceffnh Tnåestkaàih, Oit`rkpks ?2, 78-05.
Ruiihns, A,
@Vj. voi Oifhn
?551 O @oifoxh grkc Lklleikpenks, Hperus, oif ets Ecpneaotekis gkr t`h Tonhknet`ea kg Mrhha Jkurion kg Gehnf Ora`ohknkmy 24, ?5?-241.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 69/342
85 OIFRHOQ FORNOQ - V@H BONLOIQ
Q`hi M.U. Uklkyoco
?507 V-214OJ-216 Foteim kg Thtronkio Qphnhkt`hcs, Oit`rkpks ??, 21-12.
Wonka , L. t`es V`h horeehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: Hosthri Ahitron oif Qkut`hosthc Hurkph.vknuch
]eitnh, O.J. Joakbs
?502 O Areteaon Rhvehw kg t`h Foteim Hvefhiah gkr Thtronkio Aovh, Jkurion kg Ora`ohknkmyQaehiah 5, 15-6=.
Oifrhos FornosXievhrsetå f'Oex-Corshennh EENobkrotkerh f'Oit`rkpknkmehBkunhvorf Tehrrh Frocorf?15?7 Corshennh Ahfhx 24Groiah
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 70/342
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 71/342
Ielkeoe F Trosekv 6 V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg t`h Russeoi Tnoei:o s`krt ikth
V`h Russeoi Tnoei hxthifs grkc t`h ]`eth Qho oif
Borhits Qho ei t`h ikrt` tk t`h Aospeoi oif Bnoal Qho ei
t`h skut`. Et es bkrfhrhf by t`h Aorpot`eoi ckuitoeis ei t`h
QKXt`-whsn oif t`h Xron ei t`h host (Gem. ?). Grkc t`es
ecchish orho wh likw kiny o sconn iucbhr kg Nkwhr
Tonohknet`ea seths, boseaonny gkr twk rhoskis. Ei t`h gerst
pnoah, et ushf tk bh mhihronny bhnehvhf t`ot t`h Russeoi Tnoei
wos ikt kaaupehf by `ucois bhgkrh t`h Ceffnh
Tonohknet`ea, oif t`hrhgkrh ik systhcotea survhy oif
rhshora` tkkl pnoah, w`enh t`h ghw pkssebnh Nkwhr
Tonohknet`ea geifs whrh subjhat kg `hothf fesaussekis.
Qhakifny, fesakvhreim Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea seths es vhry
feggeaunt os o rhsunt kg semiegeaoit a`oimhs ei noifsaophs
seiah t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea. V`h einoif mnoaeotekis akvhrhf
normh ports kg t`h Russeoi Tnoei, oif tweah t`h eah whit
fkwi tk 84´ notetufh ei t`h Fki oif Fihpr vonnhys. V`h
hikiikus ockuit kg chnteim wothr akceim grkc t`h
mnoaehrs nhf tk troismrhssekis kg t`h Aospeoi oif t`h Bnoal
Qho. Hsphaeonny normh saonh troismrhssekis orh rhprhshithf by
t`h Olaomyn `krezki fureim t`h Noth Tnekahih, t`h OpQhrki
`krezki fureim t`h Horny Tnhestkahih, oif t`h Bolu `krezki
fureim t`h gerst port kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih (gkr t`h
Earceiknkmy shh Njubei oif Bkseisle, t`es vknuch). V`hshnormh troismrhssekis arhothf o akiihateki kg t`h Aospeoi oif
t`h Bnoal Qho t`rkum` t`h Coiya fhprhsseki, oif o
shporoteki kg t`h Aouaosus rhmeki grkc t`h Russeoi Tnoei
(Gem. 2). V`es yehnfs t`h quhsteki w`ht`hr t`h knfhst
kaaupoteki kg t`h Russeoi Tnoei aoch grkc t`h Aouaosus
rhmeki kr grkc Hurkph.
V`h Horny Tnhestkahih shfechits orh ckstny akvhrhf by
ykuimhr fhpksets up tk 24-64 c t`eal. Ei t`h ceffnh
notetufhs t`h gkrchr prhshiah kg mnoaehrs onckst hxanufhs t`h
prhshrvoteki kg Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea seths, w`enh ei t`h skut`
t`h seths whrh onsk fhstrkyhf by t`h Aospeoi oif Bnoal Qho
troismrhssekis. V`hrhgkrh t`hrh es kiny o iorrkw strep kgnoif w`hrh Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea seths coy bh fesakvhrhf
(Gem. 2). Qurgoah geifs oif orthgoats grkc uiahrtoei
strotemrop`y aoi ikt prkvh t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea
kaaupoteki kg t`h rhmeki. Oport grkc akithsthf surgoah geifs
oif orthgoats wet`kut o anhor strotemrop`eaon akithxt
(Bkreslkvslej ?581), t`hrh orh kiny o ghw geifs w`ea`
coy bh akisefhrhf Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea, oif onn kg t`hc orh
grkc t`h skut`hri port kg t`h rhmeki, skut` kg 84´ notetufh
(Gem. ?-2).
Mhroseckvlo
V`es seth es nkaothf ki t`h s`krh kg t`h Mung kg Vomoirkm
(Ceus) ihor t`h vennomh kg Mhroseckvlo (Trosekv ?570).
Oi knf thrroah 68 c obkvh t`h prhshit sho nhvhn es akvhrhf
by t`h gknnkweim fhpksets (grkc tkp tk bkttkc):
- Rhahit A`hrikzhc
- Nkhss-nelh nkocs, ei t`h upphr port o t`ei noyhr kg
vknaoiea os`.
- Nost eithrmnoaeon (Celunei) sken
- Akcpoat-rhffes`-brkwi sken os et es likwi onn kvhr
t`h Russeoi Tnoei oif a`oroathrezeim t`h Nea`vei
Eithrmnoaeon.
- 8 c kg noceiothf nkocs oif soifs wet` coiy sontwothr
cknnusas, prhfkceioitny Aospeoi typhs kg Fefoaio(Fefoaio boheëarosso, F. pshufkarosso, F. ceusseao, F. porvuno). Ei offeteki, t`hrh orh skch grhs`wothr
cknnusas: Xiek arossus, en. botovus pshufkarossus, Oikfkito pesaeiones, Qp`ohreuc reveakno, Weveporus gosaeotus.
V`h sontwothr cknnusas foth t`h noyhr tk t`h Bolu trois-
mrhsseki kg t`h Aospeoi Qho, rhsphatevhny t`h Aoufo
troismrhsseki kg t`h Bnoal Qho.
- Qoifs akitoeieim grhs`wothr cknnusas oif sconn
coccons eianufeim Ceckcys, Hnnkbeus, Cearktus, Nomurus.
- Ei o akorsh mrovhn wet` coiy gneit phbbnhs ot t`h bosh
kg t`h soifs rhcoeis kg Coccut`us trkmkit`hree. Grkc
t`es `krezki wet` gneit phbbnhs obkut o fkzhi `hovenywhot`hrhf oif shvhrhny obrofhf, rknnhf orthgoats wos
aknnhathf (Gem. 1). O bemmhr akrh grkc quortzeth
(Gem. 1,1) es wkrlhf ki bkt` goahs oif nkkls nelh o
a`kppeim tkke. Ei offeteki t`hrh orh t`rhh sefh-sarophrs
grkc gneit (Gem. 1,?-2) os whnn os gnolhs. V`h strotemrop`y
kg t`h seth summhsts t`ot t`es sconn osshcbnomh foths grkc
t`h Nkwhr tk Ceffnh Tnhestkahih troiseteki.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 72/342
72 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. ?. Festrebuteki kg NkwhrTonohknet ea seths chitekihf ei t`hthxt. (?. Mhroseckvlo< 2. A`rjosae,1. Tkmrhby oif Fubkssory).
Gem. 2. Coxecon mnoaeoteki oifcoxecon troismrhsseki ki t`hRusseoi Tnoei, oif festrebuteki kgNkwhr Tonohknet ea seths chitekihfei t`h thxt (? . Mhroseckvlo<2. A`rjosae, 1. Tkmrhby oif Fubks-sory).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 73/342
71 IELKNOE F. TROQNKW - V@H RXQQEOI TNOEI
?8
?4
<>&PYP&
O O O / ^ / ^ / ^ Y ^ / ^
• K ' k k k k a
iomsi§*T
@
27
Gem. 6. A`rjosae prkgenh.
?5
24
Gem. 1. Mhroseckvlo orthgoats. Qaonh ei ac.
A`rjosae
A`rjosae oif t`h ihem`bkureim seth kg Cea`ojnkv orh
nkaothf ki t`h nhgt boil kg t`h ikrt`hri Fkihz, obkut ?4 lc
grkc ets akignuhiah wet` t`h Fki (Gem. ?). Ki t`h sthhp
revhrboil ki tkp kg t`h substrotuc revhr fhpksets (soifs) orh
hxpkshf akvhrhf by o ?8 c `em` suaahsseki kg nkocy-soify
shfechits (Gem. 6< Trosnkv ?570). V`es thrroah aoi bhakiihathf tk t`h gkurt` thrroah kg t`h nkwhr Fki (Coreeislo
thrroah), w`ea` es rhnothf tk t`h Horny Hvlsei troismrhsseki
kg t`h Bnoal Qho (Tkpkv ?56=). Ot t`h ceffnh Fki t`es
thrroah es akvhrhf by ckroeih fhpksets grkc t`h Fki-nkbh
kg t`h coxecuc mnoaeoteki (Fihpr< Tkpkv, Mresahilk ht on.
?576). V`es foths t`h thrroah tk t`h Nea`vei Eithrmnoaeon.
Grkc t`h Coreeislo thrroah grhs`wothr cknnusas orh likwi:
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 74/342
46 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 8. A`rjosae. Orthgoats grkc nhvhn 26. Qaonh ei ac.
focomh ot t`her hfmhs (Gem. 8). V`hrh orh onsk 6 akrhs oif
= rhtkua`hf tkkns eianufeim o quortzeth kih wet` o begoaeonn
s`ophf wkrleim hfmh (Gem. 7,2). Ei t`h shfechits obkvh t`
thrroah soifs t`rhh ponohkskns orh prhshit (Gem. 6). Ot t`h
Cea`ojnkv geif spkt, 2 lc grkc A`rjosae, Ceffnh
Tonohknet`ea orthgoats whrh gkuif ei t`h nkwhrckst sken
(Trosnkv ?570). Ot A`rjosae etshng t`h ceffnh sken (nhvhn ?0akitoeihf obkut 24 orthgoats, eianufeim 6 rhtkua`hf tkkns
(Trosnkv ?570).
Tkmrhby oif Fubkssory
Kt`hr pkssebny Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea geifs akch grkc
Cknfoveo ei t`h skut`whsthri akrihr kg t`h Russeoi Tnoei
(Gem. ?) (Oiesjutlei ?50=< ?505). Ihor t`h tkwi kg
V`hkfkxus gnuveotenes, Wonvoeo ioteaeio, Tnoikrboreus
akrihus, Tnoikr`es pnoikr`es, Mon`o ponustres, W. veveporus,W. akithatus, Akr`eauno gnuceiones, Qp`ohreuc reveauno,
Tesefeuc ocieauc. Hsphaeonny Akr`eauno gnuceiones.
V`hkfkxus gnuveotenes oif Net`kmnyp`us ioteakefhs orh
sphaehs a`oroathrestea kg Ceffnh Tnhestkahih eithrmnoaeons.
Ei offeteki Akr`eauno gnuceiones kaaurs ei t`es rhmeki kinyei t`h fhpksets kg t`h Coreeislo thrroah oif t`h Horny Hvlsei
shfechits kg t`h Bnoal Qho.
Ot A`rjoQae, soifs (nhvhn 26< Gem. 6) akrrhspkifeim tk t`h
Coreeislo thrroah yehnfhf obkut 74 quortzeth oif gneit
orthgoats (Gem. 8-7). V`h geifs whrh aknnhathf grkc t`h
shatekis< sex gnolhs whrh gkuif fureim hxaovoteki ei nhvhn
26. V`h orthgoats orh ckstny gnolhs, skchtechs wet` ush
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 75/342
78 I?LKNOE F. TROQNKW - V@H RXQQEOI TNOEI
Gem. 7. A`rjoê÷e. Orthgoats grkc nhvhn 26. Qaonh ei ac.
Gem. =. Tkmrhby orthgoats . Ogthr I. L. Oiesjutlei . Qaonh ei ac.
Fubkssory orthgoats whrh fesakvhrhf ei o sken kg t`h akvhr
shfechits kg t`h 7t` Fihstr thrroah. V`h rhffes`-brkwi sken
es setuothf obkvh t`h soif kg t`h revhr thrroah oif akvhrhf
by t`eal nkhss fhpksets. V`h sken es ossemihf tk t`h Nea`vei
Eithrmnoaeon.
Ot Fubkssory ckst kg t`h geifs orh grkc t`h surgoah. Ot
t`h ihem`bkureim seth kg Tkmrhby t`h orthgoats (Gem. =) akch
grkc t`h sken etshng. Vkmht`hr wet` t`h net`ea orthgoats o tkkt`
gromchit kg Coccut`us trkmkit`hrþ wos fesakvhrhf
(Oiesjutlei ?50=< ?505).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 76/342
77 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
rhghrhiahs
Oiesjutlei, I.L. (Oiesjutleih)
Oiesjutlei, I.L.
Bkreslkvslej, T.E.
Njubei, W.T.
M. Bkseisle
Tkpkv, M.E.
Tkpkv, M.E.
C.I. Mresahilk,
Ju.G. Fhhv,I.T. Vhrhsahilk
Trosnkv, I.F.
?50=
?505
?581
t`es
vknuch
?56=
?576
Fh ikuvhnnhs fkiiåhs sur Eh Tonåknet`equh oiaehi fh no Cknfoveì, N'Oit`rkpknkmeh 5?,
75-=6.
Fkcust'hrslkh chstkioa`ksfhieh u shno Tkmrhbojo io Iezihc Fihstrh, e pknkzhieh hmk
eifustrej v roiihc ponhkneth Hvrkphjslkj aoste QQQR e skprhfhn'iea` thrrettkrej. Ahtvhr-teeiyj phrekf. Tonhkitknkmejo e ora`hknkmejo, ?26-?68.
Tonhknet Xlroeiy. Cothreony e essnhfkvoiejo pk ora`hknkmee QQQR 64.
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg t`h Aouaosus rhmeki.
Ahtvhrteaiyh e lkiteihiton'iyh pnekahikvyh ktnkzhiejo Iezihmk Fkio e Qhvhrk-Wkstkaik
Treozkv'jo, Cothreony pk mhknkmee e pknhziyc eslkpohcyc Ozkvk-×hrikckr'jo 22.
L svkfikj strotemrogk-mhihteahslkj sa`hch ahtvhrteaiya` ktnkzhiej bosshjikv r. Fkio e
Iezihj Wknme, Mhknkmejo e ceihron'iyh rhsursy thrretkree Iezihmk Fkio e Ieeihmk
Tkvknz'jo.
?570 Roiiej ponhknet Qhvhrk-Wkstkaikmk Treozkv'jo e Iezihmk Fkio. Nhieimrof.
?506 Roiiej ponhknet Russlkj rovieiy e lryco, Tonhknet QQQR. Ora`hknkmejo QQQR ?, ?0-64.
Ielknoe F. Trosnkv
Eistetuth kg Ora`ohknkmy
Fvkrzkvojo Iob. ?0
Qt. Ththrsburm ?524 6?
Russeo
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 77/342
Lorhe Woeka` 8 V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph:Hosthri Ahitron oif Qkut`hosthri Hurkph
Worekus shrehs kg precetevh orthgoats aknnhathf grkc HornyTnhestkhhih fhpksets pkeit tk o `em` oitequety gkr t`hhornehst kaaupoteki kg hosthri ahitron oif skut`hosthriHurkph. V`h hornehst hxaovothf osshcbnomhs (Tghznhteah oifQtrfislo slfno) foth grkc hornehr ports kg t`h CeffnhTnhestkhhih. V`h iuc`hr kg seths eiarhoshs akisefhro`ny einothr ports kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkhhih.
?. Ei nr kf e e e n e ei e
V`es pophr mevhs o s`krt rhvehw kg Nkwhr Tonohknet`eankaoneteas ei hosthri Ahitron Hurkph, coeiny grkc t`h Azha`Rhpubnea but onsk grkc Tknoif, @uimory, Xlroeih, Arkoteooif Rkcoieo (Gem. ?). Eigkrcoteki obkut t`h mhkmrop`eaonpkseteki kg seths es mevhi os whnn os o s`krt a`oroathrezotekikg t`h ora`ohknkmeaon osshcbnomhs oif t`her strotemrop`eaonakithxt.
2. Azha` Rhpubne a2.? . BHRKXI, CKVKR]OU AXVVEIM (BHRKXI FEQVREAV,
BK@HCEO)
V`h seth Bhrkui es setuothf bhtwhhi t`h vennomhs kg
Bhrkui oif Wroz, ki t`h nhgt boil kg t`h revhr Bhrkuilo,obkut 14 lc QWW kg Tromuh. V`h seth, =4-54 c obkvh t`hoatuon revhr, wos nkaothf ei o autteim wet` o nhimt` kg obkut844 c ei w`ea` o bkfy kg shfechits up tk 20 c t`eal woshxpkshf.
V`h nkwhr port kg t`h shquhiah akisests kg gnuveotenhfhpksets kg t`h sk aonnhf Wroz-thrroah< mrovhn oaaucunotekiwos gknekwhf by t`h gkrcoteki kg o Ghrrhtk-sken, ei ets turiEbnnkwhf Ei boalswocp fhpksets oif oikt`hr phrekf kg skengkrcoteki. V`h upphr port kg t`h shquhiah akisests kg onkhssea aknnuveuc wet` gkur eithraonothf brkwihort`ponohkskns. V`es shquhiah wos hrkfhf kiah ckrh by t`hrevhr w`ea` gkrchf t`h sk-aonnhf Bhrkui-thrroah, ikwakvarhf Ei soifv aknnuveon shfechits.
J. Grefrea` aknnhathf t`rha orthgoat osshcbnomhs grkc t`hhxpksurhs: kih (O EEE) grkc t`h surgoah kg t`h Wroz-thrroah(t`es osshcbnomh es prkbobny kg t`h soch omh os t`h Ghrrhtk-sken). o shakif kih (O EE) grkc t`h upphr port kg t`hnkwhrckst brkwihort` H oif oi esknothf geif (O E) grkcferhatny obkvh t`h ykuimhr Bhrkui-thrroah.
O tkton kg 02 orthgoat-nelh phbbnhs wos aknnhathf grkc obrehgny hxpkshf mrovhn surgoah kg obkut 2444 c2. V`hosshcbnomh (O EEE) wos fhsarebhf by Grefrea` (?55?o<?55?b) (Gem. 2:?-6), oif t`h prhshit out`kr stufehf ?2pehahs grkc t`es aknnhateki. Grefrea` festeimues`hf vorekustyphs kg a`kpphrs, prktkbegoahs, twk anhovhrs, akrhs, kihpehl, kih pkny`hfrki, o fesakef oif o subsp`årkef, os whnnos shvhron sarophrs oif ?0 nothronny rhtkua`hf gnolhs. Bhsefhphbbnhs skch ockrp`ea stkihs whrh ushf. Thtrkmrop`eaonnywh orh fhoneim wet` shvhron quortzeths, tk o nhsshr fhmrhh
wet` nyfeth, quortz oif kt`hr senezeths. Onn hfmhs orh ckrh krnhss eithisevhny rkuifhf fuh tk gnuveon os whnn os ohkneoiprkahsshs. Tort kg t`h phbbnhs `ovh o rhf-brkwi aknkureifeaotevh kg oi kremeion pkseteki wet`ei t`h Ghrrhtk-sken.Ckst kg t`h phbbnhs E stufehf s`kw coxeconny t`rhhuiegoaeon gnolh saors, t`rhh s`kw ckrh ihmotevhs oif kinykih phbbnh wos gnolhf ki bkt` sefhs.
Osshcbnomh O EE akitoeis 5 pehahs. E wos obnh tk stufy= kg t`hc oif ikih kg t`h sphaechis orh gemurhf skgor. V`hphbbnhs s`kw t`h soch fhmrhh kg rkuifeim os t`ksh grkcosshcbnomh O EEE. Gkur pehahs fespnoy prkbobny ckrh t`oit`rhh saors oif kih kg t`hsh s`kws kiny troahs kg ioturon
brholomh, ik akia`kefon groaturhs. Onn orh gnolhf ki kihsefh kiny. Osshcbnomh O E akisests kg kiny o sconn a`kpphr.
V`h Bhrkui hxpksurh `os bhhi stufehf by o cuntefesaepne-iory mrkup, w`k pubnes`hf t`her rhsunts ei Oit`rkpkzkeluc(Wkn. 24 ?55?). V`h foteim es, oport grkc mhkckrp`knkmeaonarethreo, coeiny boshf ki t`h rhsunts kg t`h eivhstemoteki kgt`h ponohkskns (Qcknglkvo ?552) oif t`h ponohkcomihteaoionyshs (Lkae ?55?). Ei t`h orho kg t`h Bk`hceoi Cossegt`hrh orh ik brkwihort` skens ykuimhr t`oi TL WEE, gkrchffureim oi eitro-Ceifhn eithrmnoaeon. V`es sken cem`takrrhspkif wet` t`h upphrckst brkwihort` O' kg t`hBhrkui shquhiah. V`h gkrcoteki kg Ghrrhtk-skens hifsfureim t`h noth Arkchreoi s.?., w`ea` ecpnehs t`ot onn skens kgt`h Bhrkui shquhiah foth grkc t`h horny Ceffnh kr HornyTnhestkhhih (Qcknglkvo ?55?).
V`h nkwhr oif upphr bkuifory kg t`h Knfuvoe-Hvait `osbhhi gkuif ei t`h nkwhr port kg t`h Wroz-thrroah, w`enh t`hCotuyoco-Brui`hs bkuifory wos efhitegehf ei t`h fhpksetskg t`h ykuimhr Bhrkui-thrroah (Lkae ?55?). V`es ecpnehst`ot osshcbnomh O EEE foths tk t`h Knfuvoe-Hvhit, O EE tk
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 78/342
70 VXE- @ORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG @XRKTH
Gem. ?. Nkaoteki kg t`h seths chitekihf ei t`h thxt:
E . Bhrkui< 2. Tghznhteah< 1. Bhakv< 6. Lornsthji< 8. Cuskv, Evorë< 7. CEofha aovh< =. Brik: Ahrvhiy
lkpha, Qtroislo slono, Qvhfslå soiah, Ahrikveah< 0. Vrzhbieao< 5. Whrthssz÷nn÷s< ?4. Lkrknhvk<
E E . Qoifonjo E< ?2. Vhtkeu< ?1. Vrovhrteih seths ei IH Qnkvoleo.
t`h gknnkweim port kg t`h Cotuyoco-Hpka` oif O E tk t`hbhmeiieim kg t`h Brui`hs-Hpka`. Tonohkitknkmeaon rhcoeis`ovh ikt bhhi gkuif skgor.
V`h net`kstrotemrop`eaon os whnn os t`h a`rkikstrotemrop`e-aon pkseteki kg t`h geifs es anhor. V`her orthgoatuon a`oroathres `kwhvhr, quhstekiobnh. Osshcbnomh O EEE akisests kg oshnhateki grkc t`h surgoah kg mrovhn fhpksets oif et es uianhorw`ht`hr sua` groaturhf phbbnhs kaaur onn t`rkum` t`h mrovhnfhpksets. V`h osshcbnomh O EE akchs grkc o ponohkskngkrchf ei nkhssea snkph fhpksets t`ot orh soef tk `ovh bhhifhvkef kg kt`hr stkihs. Gurt`hrckrh t`h p`yseaon opphoroiah(poteio, rkuifeim oif gnoleim a`oroathresteas) kg t`h akbbnhs
fkhs ikt fegghr grkc phbbnh tkkns aknnhathf ki t`h surgoah.V`h `ucoi eithrvhiteki ki t`hsh akbbnhs es ikt hxanufhf.
2.2. BHAKW, QEVH E-B (C KQ V FEQVREAV, BK@HCEO)
Obkut =4 lc I] kg Tromuh, wet`ei t`h orho kg t`hvennomh Bhakv, nehs o prkckitkry aonnhf Teshaiy vra`(soif`enn) w`hrh quortzeth wos quorrehf seiah `estkreaontechs. Rhcoeis kg Ceffnh oif Xpphr Tonohknet`ea
kaaupoteki whrh fkauchithf ot shvhron seths, w`enh seth E-cem`t fkauchit o Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea kaaupoteki.
V`rhh orthgoat bhoreim `krezkis whrh gkuif ei o aovetygennhf wet` Tnhestkahih shfechits. V`h upphrckst orthgoats(E) whrh setuothf ei o brkwihort` sken, t`h ceffnhosshcbnomh akchs grkc t`h soify nkwhr port kg t`h sken oit`h nkwhrckst orthgoats grkc t`h boson tugget nkoc.
V`h orthgoats, hxanusevhny coiugoathrhf kut kg quortzethfhbres, `ovh ikt bhhi pubnes`hf yht< Grefrea` (?5=2< ?5=7?505) chitekis grkc noyhr E ?4= pehahs, grkc noyhr EE ??5oif grkc EEE 14 orthgoats, coeiny sarophr-nelh gkrcs.A`kpphrs, pkny`hfhrs oif prktk-begoahs orh prhshit tk o
nhsshr fhmrhh.Boshf ki t`h kaaurrhiah kg o brkwihort` sken ei t`h upph
port kg t`h shquhiah o thrceius oithquhc kg noth Arkchreois.?. aoi bh ossuchf (Grefrea` oif Qcknelkvo ?5=7).
V`h orthgoats grkc t`h Bhakv seth orh uigkrtuiothny stenn`orfny pubnes`hf. V`h mkkf gnoleim prkphrtehs kg t`hquortzeth wkunf colh t`h hxesthiah kg anhor troahs kg `ucognoleim oatevetehs pkssebnh.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 79/342
75 LORHN WONKA@ - HOQVHRI AHIVRON OIF QKXV@HOQVHRI HXRKTH
Gem. 2. Bhrkui, O EEE. ?. pkny`hfrki< 2. prktk-begoah< 1. anhovhr< 6. pehl. Qaonh ei ac.
2.1. TRHZNHVEAH (TROMXH-HOQV, BK@HCEO)
O sconn, ikwofoys vhry rhfuahf nyfeth anegg (aonnhf"Znoty lkphh" 3 "mknfhi ckuitoei"), es nkaothf ot t`hikrt`hosthri bkuifory kg Tromuh, ikrt` kg t`h vennomhTrhznhteah. Tnhestkahih, coeiny noaustreih fhpksets orhprhshit ot t`h nkkt kg t`h anegg.
V`h bosh kg t`hsh fhpksets akisests kg hrkfhf sa`est(noyhrs 2?-?0), soify oif nkocy fhpksets oif senty anoys(noyhrs ?=-EQ). Ki tkp kg t`hsh es o shquhiah kg cornynkocs oif soify, rhsphatevhny nkocy grhs`wothr corns(noyhrs ?6-7) wet` errhmunor noyhrs (?2) oif nhishs (ei ?1) kg
sken shfechits kg t`h Rhifzeio Qhrehs oif nkocegehf quortzsoifs wet` skca nyfeth fhbres. Noyhr 8 akisests kg geihnyfeth fhbres wet` nun rhf aknkurhf sken-shfechits. V`hshquhiah es akvhrhf by o gkssen sken (6), rhwkrlhf nkhss oifohkneoi nkhss (1) wet` o pknymhihtea sken kg @knkahih omh(2-?) (Qebrovo ht on. ?5=5).
V`h noaustreih shfechits yehnfhf o gouio wet` vorekussconnhr coccons (gkr hxocpnh Qkrhx soveie, Fhscoio
comio, Vrkmkit`hreuc sa`chrneime, Tnekcys hpesakpones, Ceckcys soveie, Cearktus roteahpkefhs, C. mrhmonkefhs oif C. orvonefhis) os whnn os normhr coccons (gkr hxocpnh Coccut`us trkmkit`hree oif Feahrkr`eius htrusaus).Cknnusa- oif kstroakf-osskaeotekis, rea` ei sphaehs, os whnnos rot`hr pkkr pknnhi-sphatro orh onsk rhakrfhf.
Ortegeaeonny brklhi bkihs os whnn os bkihs wet` semis kgush, o ghw a`orakon rhcoeis, burit bkihs oif stkihs os whnnos o gerhpnoah orh chitekihf grkc t`es seth. Rhcoeis kg ofwheneim wet` kuthr fechisekis kg 6 x 1 c oif eiihrfechisekis kg 1 x ?,8-2 c wet` ei t`h ihem`bkur`kkf o
gerhpnoah wos gkuif ei Eh vhn 1 (Grefrea` ?505< ?55?b).Grefrea` festeimues`hf gkur geif nhvhns wet` vhry secenor
ponohknet`ea orthgoats< nhvhn ? wet` ==, nhvhn 2 wet` 67,nhvhn 1 wet` 764 oif nhvhn 6 wet` ?4= orthgoats (Grefrea`?5=7< ?5=5< ?505). V`h row cothreon akisests coeiny kg t`hnkaonny ovoenobnh nyfeth, skch pehahs orh cofh kut kg vheiquortz, quortz- oif quortzeth phbbnhs grkc mrovhns ei t`hveaeiety orh rorh (Gem. 1).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 80/342
=4 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
V`h bekstrotemrop`eaon pkseteki kg t`h seth es rot`hr anhorki t`h boses kg t`h gouio, w`ea` foths tk t`h Noth Be`oreoiVhcpnkc`hmy T`osh (Ghjgor ei: Qebrovo ht on. ?5=5), e.h.
bhgkrh Eithrmnoaeon EEE kg t`h Arkchreoi akcpnhx(Rkabrkhls oif Woi Lkngsa`kthi, t`es vknuch). Tonohk-comihtea stufehs mevh foths kg 4.85 - 4.77, 4,72 - 4.77 oif
4.=8 - 4.05 cy tk t`h fhpksets (Qebrovo ht on. ?5=5).
V`h prkbnhc kg t`h nkaonety nehs ei t`h ortegeaeon a`oroathrkg t`h geifs (shh Rkhbrkhls oif Woi Lkngsa`kthi, t`esvknuch). V`h ovoenobnh nyfeth `os pkkr gnoleim prkphrtehs:akia`kefon groaturhs orh ikt gkrchf, kiny secpnh brholomhpotthcs onkim t`h geihnoyhrhf struaturh kg t`h stkih, oif
kih aoi kiny rhakmiezh ckrh kr nhss ikta`hf hfmhs wet`kutbunbs. Et es t`hrhgkrh `orf eifhhf tk a`oroathrezh t`h
orthgoats grkc o typknkmeaon pkeit kg vehw. @kwhvhr, fhspethkg t`es oif fhspeth kg t`h vomuh troahs kg gerh E phrskionnyfk bhnehvh ei t`h hxesthiah kg wkrlhf oimunor fhbres oif
coiupkrts ei t`h nkaonety Tghznhteah. @kwhvhr gunnpubneaoteki os whnn os o fhtoenhf stufy kg onn t`h cothreon esihhfhf gkr o ckrh kbjhatevh osshsschit kg t`h "orthgoat kr
pshufk-orthgoat "-prkbnhc.
2.6. CuQkv OIF EWOI (BRHANOW FEQVREAV, CKROWEO)
V`h twk nkaonetehs, t`rhh lenkchtrhs oport, orh setuothfobkut 64 lc skut` kg Brik. Cuskv E es o gkrchr mrovhn pet
ki t`h rkof tk Wehiio, Evoi E o buent kvhr prkckitkrywet`ei t`h vennomh.
V`h mhknkmeaon shtteim kg Cuskv E es rot`hr akcpnhx. V`h
soify mrovhns `ovh o thrteory kremei oif whrh rhmorfhf os ei
setu. V`h fesakvhry kg orthgoat-nelh phbbnhs fureim t`h horny=4's nhf tk oi hxthisevh mhknkmeaon stufy w`ea` eifeaothft`ot t`h upphr oif t`h nkwhr port kg t`h shquhiah akisests kg
rhfhpksethf Ihkmhih shfechits. Ei bhtwhhi t`hrh wos o ghw
chthrs kg geih soifs kg Tnhestkahih noaustreih/gnuveotenhkremei. V`hsh shfechits neh ki tkp kg oi (horny) CeffnhTnhestkahih mrovhn fhpkset w`ea` akvhrs t`h ei setu Ihkmhihfhpksets. V`h orthgoat-nelh geifs orh coeiny grkc t`h nkwhrrhfhpksethf Ihkmhih shfechits, prhshit obkvh t`h gnuveonmrovhns.
Ei Evoi E et wos kiny pkssebnh tk eivhstemoth shatekis ei
buenfeim pets, w`hrh orthgoat-nelh phbbnhs whrh gkuif ei
secenorny rhfhpksethf but soify-anoyhy shfechits wet` skchmrovhns, wet` rhnehs kg horny Ceffnh Tnhestkahih gnuveonfhpksets ki tkp.
V`h osshcbnomh grkc Cuskv E akisests kg shvhron`uifrhf ethcs, Evoi E kg kiny sex. Thtrkmrop`eaon oionyses kg
t`h phbbnhs anhorny s`kws t`her Ihkmhih kremei. V`h
cojkrety kg t`h pehahs `os ot ckst t`rhh uiegoaeon saors, but
t`hrh es onsk o iucbhr kg phbbnhs wet` ckrh uiegoaeonihmotevhs oif onsk skch begoaeon kihs (Gem. 6: 6, 8, ??),
t`kum` truh begoahs orh obshit. Bhsefhs o sconn iucbhrkg akrteaon gnolhs wet` anhor a`oroathresteas t`hrh es kih
bnofh-nelh gnolh wet` ot nhost t`rhh fkrson gnolh saors, ovhitron sefh wet` o bunb oif o pnoei streleim pnotgkrc. V`h
nhgt port kg t`h vhitron sefh s`kws gkur sthhp gnolh saors o
o bet kg akrthx. V`h gnolh (Gem. 6.1) wos gkuif ot t`h bosht`h soify fhpksets fureim o jkeit hxaovoteki by C. Knevo
Gkr bkt` nkaonetehs et es kiny pkssebnh tk put gkrworf o
ceiecuc omh, o thrceius oith quhc. Lrykmhihtea struatu
wet` rhcoeis kg o Ghrrhtk-ponohkskn akunf bh kbshrvhf eit`h upphr port kg t`h noaustreih oif gnuveon fhpksets ei
Cuskv (Wonka` oif Zhcoi ?5=5). Ei t`es orho t`h
gkrcoteki kg t`h Ghrrhtk-skens tkkl pnoah bhgkrh t`h hif k
t`h Arkchreoi akcpnhx (Qcknglkvo oif Zhcoi ?50?<
?502), w`ea` ecpnehs o Arkchreoi omh kr knfhr. V`h
setuoteki ei Evoi es secenor. V`hrh t`h orthgoat-nelh geifswhrh aknnhathf grkc shfechits wet` lrykmhihtea struaturhoif pkalhts gennhf wet` soifs oif mrovhns. V`hsh mrovhns o
rhnehs kg o ykuimhr akvhr kg soif oif mrovhn fhpksethfbhgkrh t`h hif kg t`h Arkchreoi akcpnhx s e . (Zhcoi ?5=
?50?).
Ei suc, t`h akcpneaothf mhknkmeaon oif strotemrop`eaonpkseteki kg t`h suppkshf orthgoats, w`ea` kremeioth grkcrhfhpksethf Cekahih shfechits, colhs o anhor jufmhchit t`h osshcbnomhs feggeaunt. Et es `orfny pkssebnh t`ot t`h
Cuskv E gnolh chitekihf obkvh wos gkrchf by ioturonprkahsshs, w`enh o iucbhr kg phbbnhs s`kw ihmotevhs w`eakunf bh t`h rhsunt kg `ucoi oatevetehs. V`h Cekahihshfechits `ovh ikt bhhi rhwkrlhf by o revhr, but whrhrhfhpksethf fkwisnkph kvhr o s`krt festoiah kiny. V`h noriucbhr kg groaturhf phbbnhs aoiikt `ovh bhhi gkrchffureim t`es prkahss kg rhfhpkseteki. V`hrh orh kiny twk
pkssebnh hxpnoiotekis: het`hr wh orh fhoneim wet` pshufk-orthgoats gkrchf ei t`h Cekahih sho kr wet` rhon orthgoats
cofh w`hi t`h shfechits whrh oaahssebnh ot t`h surgoah.Et s`kunf bh ikthf t`ot t`h osshcbnomh fkhs ikt rhprhshit shnhateki grkc o `umh iucbhr kg phbbnhs, os wh orh ikt
fhoneim wet` oi oatuon quorry stenn ei hxpnketoteki `hrh:Hgghibhrmhr oif t`h prhshit out`kr aknnhathf t`h pehahs by
secpny shora`eim t`rkum` t`h nkwhr port kg t`h fhpksetsw`ea` whrh hxpkshf ei oi oboifkihf quorry.
2.8. BRIK - AHRWHIU LKTHA (RHF @ENN)
V`es es t`h normhst nkhss hxpksurh ei t`h orho kg Brik, ot`h shquhiah wet` ets iuchrkus gkssen skens oif thrroahmrovhns `os bhhi fhsarebhf shvhron techs by M. Lulno
(h.m. ?5=4< ?5=8).Fureim prksphateki kg t`h hxpksurhs wet` W. Mhbouhr, w
gkuif o quortz phbbnh, tktonny akvhrhf wet` akiarhtekis, eit`h ponohkskn TL P bhnkw t`h Cotuyoco-Brui`hsbkuifory.
Ogthr anhoieim et turihf kut tk bh o pkny`hfrki (Gem. 6.
gnolhf grkc vorekus ferhatekis. nts hfmhs orh strkimnyrkuifhf os o rhsunt kg ohkneoi prkahsshs.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 81/342
=? LORHN WONKA@ - HOQVHRI AHIVRON OIF QKXV@HOQVHRI HXRKTH
Gem. 1. Tghznhteah. ?, 8, =, 5: prktk-begoahs, 2-6, 7, 0: sarophrs. Qaonh ei ac.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 82/342
= : V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 6. ?. CEofh÷ aovh< 2. Brik-Ahrvhiy lkpha (TL P)< 1-8, ??. Cuskv E< 7-5. Qvåfslå soiah< ?4. Evoi. Qaonh ei ac.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 83/342
=1 LORHN WONKA@ - HOQVHRI AHIVRON OIF QKXV@HOQVHRI HXRKTH
Os t`h Cotuyoco-Brui`hs bkuifory es nkaothf bhtwhhit`h ponohkskns TL P oif TL EP t`h TL P `os tk akrrhspkiftk t`h eithrmnoaeon just bhgkrh t`h ponohkcomihtea troiseteki.
V`h quortz phbbnh grkc Brik-Ahrvhiy lkpha wos gkuifei o sken gkrchf ei stkih grhh nkhssea shfechits, wet` kinyaonaeth akiarhtekis. Mrovhn `krezkis grkc w`ea` t`h phbbnhhkunf `ovh tucbnhf fkwi orh onsk obshit ei `em`hr ports kg
t`h shquhiah. Ei t`h veaeiety kg t`h geif spkt wh onsk gkuifo gromchit kg oi oitnhr oif o pehah kg bkih. Et es onckstaartoei t`ot t`h phbbnh es o coiupkrt.
2.7. CNOFHA AOWH (NEVKWHN FEQVREAV, IKRV@HRI
CKROWEO)
O aovh-systhc (gkrchrny Gþrst-Jk`oiis @÷`nh) ei onechstkih `enn ei t`h vennomh kg Cnofha (gkrchrny Noutsa`),yehlnhf t`h gockus upphr ponohknet`ea `ucoi rhcoeis grkcCnofhA. Fureim t`h ?585-?57? hxaovotekis `hrh o quortzpkny`hfrki wos gkuif ei o sefh monnhry, hcbhffhf ei t`haonaeth akvhr w`ea` kvhrnehs Horny Tnhestkahih shfechits.
V`hrh es ik fkubt obkut t`h eithitekion ckfegeaoteki kgt`h pkny`hfrki (Gem. 6.?). Q`ogt EEE kg t`h coei aovh yehnfhft`rhh pkssebnh orthgoats< o gnolhf pehah kg a`hrt (@kristhei),o normh neckieth gnolh oif o sconn quortz phbbnh wet` kihgnolh saor (Wonka` ?551).
V`h Bmh kg t`h pkny`hfrki es uilikwi< gromchits kgt`h aonaeth arust w`ea` akvhrhf t`h orthgoat whrh rhahitnysubcetthf gkr obsknuth foteim. Jufmeim grkc ets gouionakithit, t`h shfechit w`ea` yehnfhf t`h t`rhh quhstekiobnhorthgoats foths tk t`h Horny Tnhestkahih.
]`enh et es phr`ops pkssebnh tk mht oi eifeaoteki kg t`hobsknuth omh kg t`h Cnofha pkny`hfrki, et es uigkrtuiothnyecpkssebnh tk oaahpt t`h kt`hr t`rhh pehahs os uiquhsteki-
obnh orthgoats.
2.=. QVROIQLO QLONO E, QWÅFQLÅ QOIAH, AHRIKWEAH -
MROWHNTEV (BRIK FEQVREAV)
V`hsh t`rhh nkaonetehs orh setuothf ot t`h hosthri bkuiforykg t`h aety kg Brik. V`h ckst ecpkrtoit kih es o jurosseanechstkih anegg Qtroislo slono E, o shakif kih es o cua`sconnhr nechstkih rkal, Qvåfslå soiah, obkut 2,8 lc skut`kg Qtroislo slono E. Ahrikveah es setuothf 644-844 c tk t`hwhst kg t`es gkrchr rkal, ki t`h hfmh kg o `umh soifpetw`ea` es stenn ei hxpnketoteki.
Qtroislo slono (1?4 c obkvh sho nhvhn) tkwhrs obkvh o
pnoei (264 c obkvh sho nhvhn), w`ea` hxthifs tkworfst`h skut`, oif ei w`ea` Qvåfslå soiah - wet` o `hem`tkg 284 c obkvh sho nhvhn - es `orfny festeimues`obnh.V`h pnoei es cofh up kg o t`eal shrehs kg gnuveon fhpksets(t`h sk-aonnhf Vugoiy-thrroah kg ykuimhr soif oif mrovhnakvhr shisu Zhcoi ?5=6< ?50?). V`hsh gnuveotenh fhpksetsort hxpnkethf ei t`h soifpet kg Ahrikveah. Oumhreim `oss`kwi t`ot t`h gnuveotenh fhpksets hxthif just uitk t`h
veaeiety kg Qvåfslå soiah, w`enh Cekahih fhpksets surgoahei orhos ckrh tk t`h host.
2.=.?. Qtroislo slono EEi t`h ikrt`whsthri snkph kg Qtroislo slono E, w`ea` es
eithrrupthf by o normh gkrchr quorry, kremeionny shvhronpossomh-nelh aovhs whrh prhshit, kg w`ea` aovh ik. 6 oif
ik. 0 orh rhnhvoit ei t`h akithxt kg t`es pophr. Anksh tk aovhik. 0 t`hrh es o whnn fhvhnkphf bkfy kg shfechits, fhpksethfomoeisn oi hsaorpchit oif akitoeieim oi horny CeffnhTnhestkahih gouio (hxaovothf by R. Cusen ei t`h phrekf?587-?5=2). Oport grkc rhcoeis kg ]þrceoi (3]hea`sh-neoi) nkhss oif o @knkahih sken ot t`h tkp (noyhrs ?=-2?),t`hrh orh Horny oif horny Ceffnh Tnhestkahih shfechitsw`ea` aoi bh fevefhf eitk gkur akcpnhxhs. V`h upphr kihakisests kg o sarhh fhpkset wet` ponohkskns oif skenshfechits (noyhrs 7-?7< t`h noyhrs ?1-?8 orh ora`ohknkme-aonny ecpkrtoit). V`h shakif akcpnhx es coeiny gkrchf byohkneoi nkhsshs (noyhr 8). V`h ponohkcomihtea Cotuyoco-Brui`hs bkuifory wos rhakmiezhf ei t`h tkp kg noyhr 8 kr ot
t`h bkttkc kg noyhr 7. V`h Jorocennk Hvhit wos gkuif ei oshakif sarhh fhpkset (noyhr 6 oif 6o). V`h nkwhr port kg t`hshquhiah (noyhrs 2, 1o oif 1b) akisests kg gnuveotenh fhpksetsw`ea` akvhr oi hrksekion rkal-thrroah. Tonohkitknkmeaonrhcoeis orh prhshit ei onn t`h vorekus noyhrs.
Xseim t`es gouio, t`h sconn shatekis ei bkt` aovhs, kgw`ea` t`h grkit ports whrh fhstrkyhf fureim quorryeimoatevetehs, akunf bh akrrhnothf wet` prkgenhs `em`hr up ki t`hsnkph. J. ]knfgea` hxaovothf aovh ik. 0 fureim t`h gerst twkfhaofhs kg t`es ahitury (Cusen ei: Cusen oif Wonka` ?570).
V`h noyhrs ?1 oif ?6 grkc t`h upphr sarhh fhpksetsyehnfhf o ghw stkih orthgoats, skch burit bkih-gromchits
oif skch brklhi bkihs, eianufeim o pehah wet` shvhronporonnhn streotekis ki o akiaovh surgoah. Qhvhron orthgoatswhrh gkuif ei t`h aovhs ik. 6 oif 0 oif o burit a`hrt gnolhei aovh ik. 0. @hrh ]knfrea` mot`hrhf o rea` coarkgouio,w`hrhos Cusen akunf kiny geif o sconn iucbhr kg gkssens kgnormhr coccons. Aovh ik. 6 yehnfhf cearkgouion rhcoeiskiny. Ckst orthgoats orh cofh kut kg a`hrt (@kristhei)ikfunhs, grkc t`h nkaonny kaaurreim Jurossea nechstkih.Orthgoats whrh kiny gkuif ei t`h noyhrs ?1 oif ?6 fhspetht`h goat t`ot t`h sarhh fhpksets bhnkw oif obkvh t`h noyhrs?1 oif ?6 akitoei nechstkih - os whnn os ioturonny brklhia`hrt gromchits.
V`h shfechits ei aovh ik. 6 akitoei akuitnhss a`hrtikfunhs oif coiy stenn prktrufh grkc t`h wonn. @kwhvhr,t`her mhihron ckrp`knkmy fkhs ikt akrrhspkif tk t`horthgoats aknnhathf ei t`es aovh. Rhcorlobnh orh o normhakrh-nelh bnkal oif gnolhs grkc a`hrt wet` nechstkih vheis(Gem. 8.?6). V`hsh gnolhs aoiikt bh t`h rhsunt kg ioturonrkal-fhseithmroteki kr grkst oateki. V`hsh prkahsshs wkunfgknnkw t`h struaturh kg t`h stkih oif rhsunt ei o shporoteki
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 84/342
=6 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 8. Qtroislo slono E?, 1, 6, ?1. gnolhs wet` bunbus< 2. akrh-nelh tkke wet` rhtkua`h< 8. sarophr< 7 oif ??. betoaeonny wkrlhf akrh-nelh tkke< =. pehl< 0 oif 5. a`kpphki phbbnhs< ?4. nechstkih gnolh< ?2. gromchit wet` sthhp rhtkua`hs< ?6. pkeithf gnolh wet` boifs kg nechstkih (`ota`hf), ?8. betoaeonny wkrlhfakrh-nelh bnkal. Qaonh ei ac.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 85/342
=8 LORHN WONKA@ - HOQVHRI AHIVRON OIF QKXV@HOQVHRI HXRKTH
kg nechstkih- oif a`hrt fhbres. Os eifeaothf by Lkuthl(?524) t`hrh orh ei Qtroislo slono ot nhost t`rhh a`hrt`kre/.kis wet` a`hrt ikfunhs kg fegghrhit akifetekis< t`hnkwhrckst `krezki es setuothf ot t`h soch nhvhn os t`h twkaovhs. Ot nhost port kg t`h orthgoats shhcs tk `ovh bhhicofh kut kg a`hrt grkc o `em`hr nhvhn. Nechstkih gnolhs(Gem. 8.?4) orh rorh.
Os gor os tha`iknkmy oif typknkmy kg t`h osshcbnomh esakiahchf, t`hrh orh kiny o ghw gnolhs wet` o rhon bunb kgphrausseki, o pnoei kr akrteaon butt oif o typeaonny "swoyhf"vhitroS sefh. Akiahitrea uifunotekis orh `orfny vesebnh(Gem. 8:?,1,6,?1). Ioturon fhbres os whnn os akrhnelh pehahs(Gem. 8:2,7,??) whrh kgthi ushf. ]h eithrprht t`h obkvhchitekihf bnkal (Gem. 8.?8) os o rhon akrh, oif o spnetphbbnh os o `occhrstkih, bkt` geifs grkc aovh ik. 6.Vwk sconnhr phbbnhs - quortz oif quortzeth - nkkl nelha`kpphrs (Gem. 8:0-5). Rhmunor rhtkua` aoi bhhi rhakmiezhfki gkur orthgoats (eianufeim o sarophr oif o pehl nelh kbjhat(Gem. 8:8,=), porteon oif uirhmunor rhtkua` aoi bh kbshrvhfckrh grhquhitny. V`h eighrrhf eithitekionety kg t`h poronnhn
mrkkvhs chitekihf obkvh oif kg t`h shvhi streotekis ki oihnhp`oin vhrthbro (hxaovoteki ]knfgea`) oif t`h troahs kgwhor kg bkih gromchits, wenn bh rheivhstemothf oifhvonuothf by cearksakpea oionyshs ei o jkeit prkjhat wet`Crs. C. Totku-Cot`es. Choiw`enh, a`hceaon oionyshs kgskch bkih gromchits `os s`kwi t`hsh whrh burit, wet`thcphroturhs kg 244-844´A'.
V`h orthgoat `horeim noyhrs ?1 oif ?6 orh setuothf rot`hr`em` obkvh t`h Cotuyoco-Brui`hs bkuifory. V`h nothBe`oreoi gouio grkc Qtroislo slono es akrrhnothf wet` t`hIomv`oësoiy`hmv-T`osh (@kroahl oif Nkzhl, ?500) oifwet` t`h phrekf bhtwhhi Eithrmnoaeon ?? oif EEE kg t`h
Arkchreoi akcpnhx (Rkhbrkhls oif Woi Lkngsa`kthi, t`esvknuch). Gkr t`h rhmekion strotemrop`y et s`kunf bh ikthft`ot t`h nkwhrckst gnuveotenh fhpksets (Noyhrs 2 oif 1) kgt`h sk-aonnhf Qtroislo thrroah orh setuothf kih sthp obkvht`h oaaucunoteki kg Ahckveah.
2.=.2. Qvåfslå soiahO ikrt`-skut` krehithf trhia`, 0 c fhhp oif obkut 244 c
nkim, wos fum ot t`h hosthri gkkt kg t`h Qvåfslå soiah. V`hwhsthri wonn kg t`h trhia` s`kwhf o prkgenh ei w`ea` ?8noyhrs akunf bh rhakmiezhf. Oport grkc t`h upphrckstohkneoi nkhss wet` t`h @knkahih sken ki tkp, t`hrh orh t`rhh
sken-akcpnhxhs ei setu, rhfhpksethf sken shfechits, soify-nkocy cothreon oif o noyhr kg fhbres. Lrykmhihtea ghoturhswhrh vesebnh ei t`h noyhrs 1-?4 w`ea` akvhr twk soify-nkocy noyhrs (?? oif ?2). V`h nkwhst kih akitoeis jurosseaa`hrt-fhbres. esknothf phbbnhs oif skch orthgoats. V`h boshkg t`h shquhiah (?1-?8) es gkrchf by gnuveon soify fhpksets.Noyhr ?6 s`kws troahs kg sken-gkrcoteki (ghrretesoteki)(Wonka` oif Qhetn ?556).
Gkur orthgoats akch grkc noyhr ?2< t`rhh kg t`hc orhgromchits kg jurossea a`hrt wet` troahs kg ckfegeaoteki oifporteon rhtkua`hs (Gem. 6:7,0,5), akcporobnh tk t`ksh kgQtroislo slono. V`h gkurt` pehah es o quortzeth phbbnh,begoaeonny strual grkc vorekus ferhatekis eitk o pkny`hfrki,wet` o normh port kg t`h akrthx prhshrvhf (Gem. 6.=).Offetekionny, t`h noyhrs 1, 5 oif ?6 yehnfhf ei tkton gkurphbbnhs wet` kih gnolh saor, but t`her ortegeaeon kremei es iktsurh (Wonka` oif Qhetn ?556).
Xigkrtuiothny wh `ovh kiny mhkckrp`knkmeaonkbshrvotekis ot kur fespkson tk foth t`h geifs grkc t`es seth.V`h boson soifnoyhrs (?1-?8) orh ahrtoeiny rhnothf tk t`hVugoiy thrroah oif aoi prkbobny bh akrrhnothf tk t`h nkwhrport kg t`h oaaucunoteki ei t`h mrovhn-pet Ahckveah. V`hgkrcoteki kg t`h orthgoat bhoreim noyhr ?2, os whnn os t`hkvhrnyeim noyhr ?? wet` pkalhts kg geih soifs, tkkl pnoahferhatny ogthr fhpkseteki kg t`h boson soify noyhr, prkbobnyuifhr phrekfeaon eignuhiah kg wothr. ]et`ei t`es grochwkrlet aoi bh stothf t`ot t`h orthgoats grkc Qvåfslå soiah cem`tbh kg t`h soch omh os t`ksh grkc Qtroislo slono kr snem`tny
knfhr.
2.=.1. AhckveahO shquhiah kg 0 tk ?4 c kg soif oif mrovhn es setuothf
ki tkp kg Cekahih soifs oif es akvhrhf by oi eithisevhGhrrhtk-sken oif o goerny whnn fhvhnkphf Ao-`krezki wet`lrykmhihtea struaturhs. Oi eithraonothf anoy-noyhr yehnfhf orot`hr rea` cknnusa (wothr- os whnn os noif-cknnusas) oifkstroakf gouio os whnn os rhcoeis kg Xrsus fhieimhre.
Nost yhor (?551) t`h mrovhn pet `hrh yehnfhf o ghw kbjhatsw`ea` cem`t bh orthgoats. V`hy whrh aknnhathf by t`hocothur ora`ohknkmest R. Lne'co, w`k `os bhhi eisphateim
t`h pet gkr shvhron yhors. V`rhh kg t`hsh orh uifesputhf, gkurkt`hrs s`kw nhss anhor troahs kg ckfegeaoteki. V`h bhst pehahes o pkeithf gnolh cofh kut kg mrhy a`hrt. Et fespnoys oprkikuiahf bunb kg phrausseki wet` o bunbor saor oif ogoahtthf streleim pnotgkrc, shvhron gnolh saors ki t`h fkrsonsefh oif ki t`h nhgt hfmh prkbobny eithitekion rhtkua`hs.Onn t`h hfmhs oif refmhs orh snem`tny rkuifhf, oif t`hrh esik akrthx (Gem. 7.2). V`h shakif pehah (Gem. 7.?) es o nkimgnolh, wet` o prkikuiahf bunb kg phrausseki, o bunbor saoroif o akrteaon streleim pnotgkrc, cofh grkc o w`ethpoteiothf snem`tny rkuifhf a`hrtstkih. V`h fkrson sefh kg t`hgnolh s`kws o normh gnolh saor oif o sconn rhst kg t`h akrthx.Bkt` hfmhs s`kw ioturon pshufk-rhtkua`hs. V`h t`erforthgoat es o sub-prescotea akrh wet` t`rhh poronnhn oif kiherrhmunor gnolh saor cofh grkc o nem`t mrhy a`hrt phbbnhwet` eithisevhny rkuifhf refmhs (Gem. 7.1).
V`h gkrcoteki kg t`h Vuroiy thrroah hifhf bhgkrh t`h hifkg t`h Arkchreoi akcpnhx, os eifeaothf by t`h prhshiah kgo whnn fhvhnkphf Ghrrhtk sken ki tkp kg t`h thrroah fhpksets(Zhcoi, ?5=6< ?50?< Tghegrkvo oif Zhcoi ?5=5<
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 86/342
=7 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 7. Brik-Ahrikveah, mrovhn-
Qcknglkvo oif Zhcoi ?50?< ?502). Oaakrfeim tk t`hocothur aknnhatkr, t`h stroy geifs (stkihs os whnn os gouionrhcoeis, h.m. `krsh oif bkvef cknors, bkih oif tuslgromchits) kremeioth grkc t`h nkwhr port kg t`h mrovhn-noyhrs, os eighrrhf grkc t`h prkmrhsseki kg t`h quorryeimoatevetehs.
2.=.6. QuccoryQtkih orthgoats, troahs kg gerh (burit bkihs oif o a`hrt
gnolh) os whnn os brklhi bkihs s`kw ei cy kpeiekiuiocbemukusny t`h prhshiah kg `ucoi bheims ei Qtroisloslono E. Ot nhost t`h quortzeth pkny`hfrki grkc Qvåfslåsoiah oif t`h t`rhh pehahs grkc t`h mrovhnpet Ahrikveah
`ovh tk bh rhmorfhf os orthgoats. Onn t`rhh nkaonetehs foth tkrkum`ny t`h soch phrekf kg t`h Arkchreoi akcpnhx, ophrekf ei w`ea` t`h revhr mrofuonny fhpksethf t`h shfechitskg t`h Vugoiy thrroah. Kih s`kunf rhchcbhr t`ot t`h gouiogrkc Qtroislo slono akitoeis o normh iucbhr kg wothr oifcors` berfs. V`h orthgoats grkc t`h mrovhnpet orhrhfhpksethf kvhr o sconn festoiah (grkc Qvåfslå soiah;).V`h phkpnh ot Qtroislo slono ei`obethf sconn aovhs. Cusensusphats t`h gkrchr hxesthiah kg o t`erf aovh obkvh t`hhxpkshf snkph fhpksets, fhstrkyhf fuh tk quorryeimoatevetehs. V`h noyhr ?1 oif ?6 orh rhnothf tk t`h kremeionakithit kg t`h aovh. V`ot eifeaoths t`ot t`rhh aovhs whrhei`obethf.
2.0. ORVHGOAVQ KG XILIK]I OMH GRKC BK@HCEO OIF
CKROWEO
Ei vehw kg t`h normh iucbhr kg surgoah aknnhatekis kgphbbnh-tkkns grkc Bk`hceo (Zhbhro ?582), skut`hri Ckroveooif rhahitny onsk grkc Nkwhr Oustreo (Zwhrifkrg ecCora`ghnf) oif ihor Brotesnovo ei Qnkvoleo t`es prkbnhc es
geifs. Qaonh ei ac.
brehgny chitekihf `hrh. Bhaoush ckst kg t`hsh phbbnh-tkkorh aknnhathf grkc t`h surgoah kg mrovhn fhpksets kr rhnehskg mrovhn-noyhrs, t`hrh es kiny o thrceius pkst quhc, boshfki t`h pkseteki kg t`h thrroah. Ei skut`hri Ckroveo wh orhcoeiny fhoneim wet` t`h ykuimhr soif oif mrovhn s`hht, ror(h.m. Tkuzfgoiy) wet` t`h knfhr kih. O rhnotevh foteim arethrees t`h obshiah kg weif pknes` ki Noth Tnhestkahih (Ceffnhoif Xpphr Tonohknet`ea) orthgoats aknnhathf grkc t`h surgoaV`h eithisevh rhffes` brkwi aknkur kg t`h ponh quortzphbbnhs - t`h rhsunt kg ecprhmioteki kg ghrrk-kxefhs -eifeaoths t`h eignuhiah kg a`hceaon prkahsshs fureim t`hgkrcoteki kg t`h Ghrrhtk-sken (Wonka` ht on, ?5=0).
Kih aoi t`hrhgkrh susphat t`ot t`hsh phbbnh tkkns (prktk
begoahs, pkny`hfrkis, hpoiihnås, a`kppeim tkkns oif gnolhfoth tk t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, porteonny hvhi tk t`h hornyCeffnh Tnhestkahih. V`h geifs orh ecpkrtoit bhaoush t`hyshhc tk fkauchit o rhnotevhny eithish kaaupoteki kg t`horho, wet` iuchrkus shttnhchits onkim t`h boils kg t`h revfureim t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih.
2.5. '@KNQVHEIEOI' GEIFQ
Orthgoats grkc t`h nothst p`osh kg t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`e- t`h @knstheieoi akcpnhx - orh ei t`h nkhss orhos likwigrkc t`h skens TL WE oif W. Bk`hceo oif Ckroveo yehnfhkiny esknothf gnolhs oif phbbnh tkkns grkc t`ot phrekf,
gkuif fureim quorryeim oatevetehs ei t`ksh skens. Hxocpnhsorh t`h brealpets Brik-Ahrvhiy lkpha, Brik-Zefhieah E oiEE, Qhfnhskveah ihor Zikjck, Nhtly ihor Tromuh (Wonka`?5==< Wonka` ei: Cusen ht on. ?588< Trkshl ?567). Grefreaaknnhathf oi osshcbnomh kg obkut 14 orthgoats grkc t`h TLWE sken ei Lornsthji ihor Bhrkui. V`h osshcbnomh akitoeisoi hpoiihnå, o akrh, sarophrs oif sconn uirhtkua`hf gnolh(Qcknglkvo oif Grefrea` ?506). Thr`ops snem`tny knfhr es t
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 87/342
== LORHN WONKA@ - HOQVHRI AHIVRON OIF QKXV@HOQVHRI HXRKTH
osshcbnomh trkc E`h brealpet Qhfnha ihor Tromuh, aknnhanhfby L. Zhbhro. Ei o a`orakon noyhr ot t`h bosh kg o nkhssprkt'enh wet` eithraonothf ponhkskns, just obkvh mrovhns kg t`h'Ceifhn'-thrroah (Zorubo ?562) `h gkuif shvhron mkkfa`kpphrs, a`kppeim-tkkns oif pkny`hfrkis wet` rot`hr s`orphfmhs (Zhbhro ?575, Tnoth WEE-PWEEE). Qkch strkimnyrkuifhf peaahs (Zhbhro ?575, Tnoth EEE-W) orh rhmorfhf os
bheim knfhr ("@hefhnbhrmeoi"). Qhvhron '@knstheieoi'trovhrteih fhpksets ei Qnkvoleo yehnfhf orthgoats ot@roikvieao, Wysiå Ruzboa`y oif, pkssebny, t`h nkwhrnhvhns ot @krlo (Borto ?5=6).
1. Vrzhbieao (Qenhseo, skut`whst Tknoif)
V h nkoc pet Vrzhbieao 2 es nkaothf obkut ?8 lc ikrt` kg]rkanow, ei t`h ikrt`hri port kg t`h vennomh Vrzhbieao, ott`h "veihyorf `enn" (]eiio Mñro).
Ei t`h skut`hri shateki kg t`h pet nkocy nkhss-nelhshfechits wet` o t`ealihss kg obkut 7 c (Jory ht on. ?554)kvheeeh o mrovhn fhpkset. Ei t`h ikrt`hri prkgenhs Vhrteoryanoys orh prhshit bhihot` mnoaemhiea fhpksets, w`ea` aoi bh
fevefhf ei t`rhh uiets: oi upphr tenn, soifs oif sents wet`noyhrs kg vorvh anoys, soifs oif n'nuvekmnoaeon phbbnh bhfsoif o nkwhr tenn (noyhrs 1-8) (]eiieale ?554). V`hmnoaemhiea port kg t`h shquhiah bhnkw t`h nkocy nkhss-nelhshfechits es ei t`h hiterh orho o nettnh ckrh subfevefhf. V`hnkwhr (enn akvhrs os o ckroeih rhneat o mrovhn povhchit(noyhrs ? oif 2), t`h upphr tenn (noyhr 8) es setuotaf bhtwhhignuvekmnoaeon fhpksets (Burfulehweaz oif ]eiieale ?505).
Orthgoats whrh gkuif ot shvhron pnoahs ei t`h pet.Akiahitroteki B wos aknnhathf grkc o ckroeih povhchit krgrkc t`h soify-nkocy fhpksets uifhchot` (Burfulehweazoif ]eiieale ?505), akiahitroteki A obkvh t`h povhchit
ot t`h bosh kg t`h upphr tenn (Burfulehweaz oif ]eiieale?505).
V`h prhneceiory rhpkrts (Burfulehweaz ?554< ?55?<Burfulehweaz oif ]eiieale ?505) eifeaoth t`ot wh orhfhoneim wet` oi eifustry wet` sconn orthgoats (sarophrs,ikta`hs, fhiteaunoths. otypeaon bkrhrs (bhasj), akrhs oif oghw a`kpphrs, coeiny cofh grkc gneit, rorhny grkcFhvkieoi nechstkih oif bosont. O sconn iucbhr kg bkih-gromchits es onsk prhshit, `krsh oif r`eikahrks akunf bhefhitegehf os whnn os o tkkt` gromchit kg pelh.
V`h upphr tenn es akrrhnothf wet` t`h Frhit`h eah-ofvoiah,t`h nkwhr kih wet` t`h skut`hri Tknes` Hesthr eah-ofvoiah.
V`h knfhr osshcbnomh t`hrhgkrh foths tk t`h Ghrfyioifñw-Eithrmnoaeon (Hnsthreoi E/EE), t`h ykuimhr osshcbnomh tk t`h@knstheieoi (Burfulehweaz ?554: ?55?< Burfulehweaz oif]eiieale ?505< Burfulehweaz oif Chyhr ?55?).Le/yszlkwsle (?551) `os oikt`hr kpeieki obkut t`h omhkg t`h osshcbnomhs, os `h akrrhnoths t`h soify fhpksets wet`t`h ]ort`h stomh oif bkt` tenns wet` t`h Frhit`h eah-ofvoiah.
Ei suc, t`h eifustry shhcs tk bh akcporobnh wet` t`heifustry grkc Benzeimsnhbhi. Qkgor, t`hrh es ik uiocbemukuseifeaoteki gkr t`h omh kg t`h osshcbnomhs oif gurt`hreivhstemotekis orh ihahssory tk anoregy t`es prkbnhc.
6. Wårthssz÷nn÷s (ikrt`whsthri @uimory)
V`h vennomh kg Wårthssz÷nn÷s es nkaothf ei t`h vonnhy kg t`h
revhr Otonår ei t`h s`ofh kg t`h Mhrhash ckuitoeis obkut?8 lc skut` kg t`h revhr Foiubh. Ki t`h hfmh kg t`h vennomhes oi hxthisevh trovhrteih nechstkih quorry ki t`h 74 crevhr thrroah. V`rhh fegghrhit seths whrh efhitegehf ei t`hquorry orho: t`h ponohknet`ea seth (E), oi hxanusevhnyponohkitknkmeaon seth (EE) oif o seth w`hrh ponohknet`eaorthgoats oif gkktpreits kg oiecons whrh rhakvhrhf (EEE). Gkurgeif `krezkis whrh festeimues`hf ot seth E, t`rhh ot seth EEE.
Ot Qeth E t`h trovhrteih fhpksets rhoa` o t`ealihss kg obkut?4 c oif neh ki tkp kg gnuveotenh shfechits. V`h geif-`krezkis orh nkaothf ot o fhpt` kg 1-8 c. Noyhr ? wosnkaothf ei bhtwhhi twk trovhrteih bhfs. Noyhr 2, ei t`hceffnh kg t`h upphr trovhrteih bhf, es kiny nkaonny prhshit
oif wos nhss rea`. Aunturon rhcoeis grkc noyhr 1 whrhsaotthrhf kvhr t`es trovhrteih bhf. Obkvh t`h trovhrteihfhpksets wos o nkhss noyhr, t`h upphr port kg et akitoeieim`krezki 6 w`ea` es vhry pkkr ei geifs.
V`h rea` oif whnn-likwi gouio grkc t`es seth eianufas Coaoao synvoio, Xrsus fhieimhre, Coa`oerkfkiteioh eifht.,Qthp`oikr`eius htrusaus, Hquus cksboa`hises. @eppkpktocus oitequus, oif skch `kceief rhcoeis: o `ucoikaaepeton bkih oif twk fhiton gromchits whrh gkuif einoyhr ? (V`kco ei: Lrhtzke oif Fkbkse ?554).
Normh net`ea osshcbnomhs, tha`iknkmeaonny os whnn osckrp`knkmeaonny vhry secenor, whrh gkuif ei onn noyhrs
(?/? 1?71 pehahs, ?/2 847, ?/1 855, ?/6 82, EEE/n 74=, EEE/6-87==). V`h eifustry akisests kg sconn-sezhf phbbnhs cofh kgquortz/quortzeth (84,0 %), gneit (66,= %), nechstkih (6,1 %)oif kt`hr row cothreons (4,?2 %). Vypknkmeaonny kih aoirhakmiezh a`kpphrs, a`kppeim tkkns, prktk-`oifoxhs, vorekussefh sarophrs, bkrhrs, bureis oif hif sarophrs os whnn ospkeits oif skch kt`hr tkkns (Fkbkse ei: Lrhtzke oif Fkbkse?554). N. Whrths (?578) anossegehf t`h osshcbnomh os oceark-a`kpphr eifustry oif aonnhf et t`h 'Bufo eifustry'(shh Fkbkse, ei: Lrhtzke oif Fkbkse ?554 gkr o fhtoenhffhsarepteki).
Noyhr E yehnfhf shvhron bkih gromchits, eithitekionny
brklhi oif ushf. Qkch kg t`h gromchits s`kw aut corls(Fkbkse ?501< Lrhtzke oif Fkbkse ?554).Vroahs kg gerh whrh rhakmiezhf ot seths E oif EEE. ?/?
yehnfhf bnoal spkts (18 x 68 ac oif 8 ac t`eal) wet` sconnos whnn os normhr burit bkih gromchits wet`kut a`orakon(Fkbkse ei: Lrhtzke oif Fkbkse ?554).
Bekstrotemrop`eaon stufehs kremeionny fothf t`h seth tk oieitro-Ceifhn p`osh (Lrhtzke oif Whrths ?578). Tonohkcom-
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 88/342
=Q V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
iheea oionyshs s`kwhf ikrcon pknorety, suppkshfny t`hBrui`hs Hpka`h (Not`oc oif Qa`woraz ei: Lrhtzke oifFkbkse ?554). Rofekchtrea foteim yehnfhf vorekus porteonnyakitrofeatkry rhsunts wet` knfhr omhs rhakrfhf obkvh ykuimhrkihs. Gkr t`h trovhrteih bhtwhhi t`h Noyhrs E oif EEE omhs kg268 oif 184 lyr BT `ovh bhhi kbtoeihf (ei: Lrhtzke oifFkbkse ?554).
Ei suc, t`h Wårthssz÷nn÷s seths eifeaoth o rhphothfkhaupoteki kg t`h ceihron wothr spreim fureim t`h gkrcotekikg trovhrteih fhpksets. @kceiefs brkum`t moch tk t`h seth,prkfuahf o sphaegea ceieoturh phbbnh eifustry wet` o nkwnhvhn kg stoiforfesoteki, ushf bkih gromchits os tkkns oifwhrh obnh tk lhhp o gerh mkeim. V`h hxoat omh kg t`hkhaupoteki es uilikwi but es by ik chois ykuimhr t`oi t`h@knstheieoi akcpnhx.
8. Lkrknhvk (Vroi saorp oteo i Xlroeih)Lkrknhvk es nkaothf ei t`h vonnhy kg t`h revhr Veszo, ei
t`h ckst skut`whsthc port kg t`h Xlroeih, `orfny ?4 lcgrkc t`h Rkcoieoi oif obkut 24 lc grkc t`h @uimoreoi
bkrfhr. Orthgoats whrh gkuif ei shvhron noyhrs ei prkgenhsw`ea` whrh hxpkshf ei oi hxthisevh oifhseth quorry kit`h `enn "Mkstryj vhra`", ki t`h nhgt boil kg t`h revhr.
Worekus shquhiahs wet` up tk sex poroutka`tkiea ponohksknakcpnhxhs akitoeihf ei tkton ?7 ponohknet`ea `krezkis.V`h gkur nkwhrckst `krezkis (Wa, WE, WEE oif WEEE) `ovhahrtoeiny o Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea omh. Wa oif WE orh setuothfwet`ei sken-fhpksets, WEE ei nkocy fhpksets oif WEEE einkocy fhpksets wet` gnuveotenh mrovhns (Mnofenei ?505).
V`h hiterh eifustry es coiugoaturhf grkc oifhseth.Akcpnhx Wa akitoeis a`eps, sconn gnolhs oif fhbres,Akcpnhx WE ckrh t`oi 5144 orthgoats eianufeim 56 akrhs
oif ?17 tkkns (ockimst kt`hrs a`kpphrs, prktk-begoahs,betoahs, anhovhrs, sarophrs, lieghs oif fhiteaunoths.
Akcpnhx WEE akisests kg ?815 orthgoats eianufeim ?1 akrhsoif ?2 tkkns (7 a`kpphrs , 2 prktk-begoahs oif ? begoah),w`enh Akcpnhx WEEE akisests kg 627 orthgoats eianufeim?? akrhs oif ?2 tkkns (wet` 8 a`kpphrs oif 2 prktk-begoahs).
Onn osshcbnomhs orh ossemihf tk t`h Oa`hunhoi, t`kum` osconn iucbhr kg akrhs oif gnolhs wet` Nhvonnkes ghoturhsorh prhshit ei t`h osshcbnomh (Mnofenei oif Qetnevyj ?554).
V`h ?'eif `horeim shfechits orh akcpnhthny fhaonaegehf,oif krmoiea rhcoeis orh `orfny prhshit, t`kum` ponyiknkme-aon oionyses yehnfhf skch rhsunts. O xhrkp`enh gnkro wet`
Zhnlkvo, `kribhoc oif Tthrkaoryo es gkuif ei noyhr ?8(Akcpnhx Wa). V`h noyhrs ?7 oif ?= (wet` Akcpnhx WE)whrh fhpksethf fureim o aknf p`osh, os eighrrhf grkc t`hkaaurrhiah kg Bhnueo vhrruakso, B. pubhsahis, B. tkrbukso,
B. `ucenes oif Onius verefes. Noyhr ?0 foths tk o worcp`osh fureim w`ea` orhos wet` oi kphi vhmhtoteki kaaurrhfboshf ki t`h prhshiah kg A`hikpkfeoahoh, Osthroahoh oifAea`kreoahoh, Gretennoreo oif hxktea trhhs sua` os Zhnlkvo
sp. oif Tthrkaoryo. Noyhr ?5 corls oikt`hr aknf p`osh<ikteahobnh es t`h fharhosh kg trhhs oif o gnkro wet`A`hikpkfeoahoh, shfmh, Osthroahoh oif ahrhons oif gkrhxocpnh Tknhckieuc oaubegnkruc. O s`krt worc p`oshwet` o bkrhon sthpph vhmhtoteki (14-68% bkrhon pknnhi) esrhprhshithf ei t`h noyhrs 24-2?, oif noyhr 22 eifeaothsoikt`hr aknf p`osh wet` bera` oif peih trhhs. Noyhr 21 wehnc, woniut, kol, Zonlkvo oif `kribhoc es eifeaotevh gkr worc p`osh. Akcpnhx WEE `os bhhi aknnhathf grkc noyhr wet` pknnhi grkc bera` oif peih trhhs oif skch fhcoifeisphaehs w`ea` eifeaoth cenf akkn anecotea akifetekis.Noyhr 27 akitoeihf kiny o sconn ockuit kg pknnhi grkchnc, woniut, bhha`, Tthrkaoryo oif wothr pnoits (Ozknno,Thfeostruc phiionhs). Orthgoats kg Akcpnhx WEEE os whnn o ghw peih oif bera` pknnhi orh gkuif ei Noyhr 2=, ot t`hbosh kg t`h shquhiah.
V`hrcknuceihsahiah os whnn os ponohkcomihtea oionys`ovh bhhi aorrehf kut. Noyhr ?7 `os o VN foth kg 174 + 8Lyr BT, noyhr ?5 o foth kg 784 ¿ 54 lyr BT oif noyhr 28 084 + ?44 Lyr BT. V`h Cotuyoco-Brui`hs bkuifory es
eifeaothf bhtwhhi t`h noyhrs 2? oif 22, gor obkvh orthgoatAkcpnhx WEE (Mnofenei ?505). V`h nkwhrckst shrehs kgLkrknhvk orh wet`kut oiy fkubt Nkwhr Tonohknet`eaeifustrehs, oif bkt` strotemrop`eaon oif gnkron oif gouionhvefhiah summhst o rot`hr `em` omh. V`hy prkbobny bhnkimt`h Oa`hunhoi s.?. Otthcpts ot foteim t`h vorekus shrehs`ovh ikt yehnfhf uiocbemukus rhsunts sk gor.
7. Qoifonjo E (ihor Tuno, Estreh, Arkote o)Vwk fhmrofhf aovhs, nkaothf anksh tk hoa` kt`hr, whrh
hxpkshf ei o quorry obkut 6 lc IH kg Tuno.V`h nkwhrckst fhpksets ei t`h gerst aovh akisesthf kg oi
Horny Tnhestkahih brhaaeo wet` o rea` gouion osskaeoteki.eianufeim o nhgt gerst nkwhr eiaesevh w`ea` wos t`kum`t tk bkg `ucoi kremei. V`h upphr fhpksets akitoei o noth ]þrceo]hea`shneoi Mrovhtteoi eifustry. V`h shakif aovh akitoeikiny noth ]þrceoi/]hea`shneoi fhpksets wet` `ucoi slunnrhcoeis oif oi Ouremioaeoi oif o Mrovhtteoi eifustry.
O sconn phbbnh (N 76 cc, ] 81 cc, V` 16 cc) cofkg knevh-mrhy gneit wos gkuif ei t`h brhaaeo. V`h iorrkwsefh kg t`h phbbnh s`kws t`rhh normh gnoleim saors w`ea`hxthif tk `ongwoy t`h fkrson sefh. V`h hfmh `os bhhickfegehf by iuchrkus rhtkua`hs. V`h refmhs orh snem`tnyrkuifhf, prkbobny by ohkneoi oatevetehs (Gem. =). Qkchbkihs s`kw troahs kg gerh w`enh a`orakon rhcoeis orh onskprhshit. V`h fkceioiah kg eccoturh `hrbevkrkuscoccons ei t`h gouio cem`t eifeaoth o shnhateki by`ucois.
V`h gouio grkc Qoifonjo E es akrrhnothf wet` gouios suaos Qt. Wonnehr, Thrrehr, Qhiàzh, A`omiy oif t`h upphr Wonf'Orik gouio foteim tk t`h Ceffnh-noth Wennogroia`eoi(Conhz< ?5=6, ?5=8, ?5=7).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 89/342
=') LORHN WONKA@ - HOQVHRI AHIVRON OIF QKXV@HOQVHRI HXRKTH
Gem. =. Qoifonjo E, a`kpphr. Qaonh ei ac.
V`h a`kpphr os whnn os t`h troahs kg gerh pkeit tk o `ucoiprhshiah, o stothchit w`ea` cem`t geif skch suppkrt ei t`hgouio! hvefhiah. Ei t`h akithxt kg t`h aovh t`h a`kpphr oswhnn os o shakif phbbnh wet`kut anhor troahs kg ckfegeaoteki`ovh tk bh coiupkrts. @kwhvhr, t`h sconn iucbhr kg geifsfkhs ikt onnkw oi uiocbemukus eithrprhtoteki kg t`es knfseth oif et aoi t`hrhgkrh ikt bh oaahpthf os uiocbemukushvefhiah gkr `ucoi kaaupoteki.
=. Vhtkeu (Lumeunh$te, Kntåieh, Rkcoieo)
Onkim t`h ceffnh Kntht revhr (o trebutory kg t`h Knt) eiskut`hri Rkcoieo, whnn fhvhnkphf gnuveknoaustreih fhpksetsorh prhshit bhtwhhi t`h vennomhs Vhtkeu oif Erech§te, wet`shvhron noyars akitoeieim rea` noth Tnekahih gouios.
V`rhh noyhrs wet` gouioS rhcoeis `ovh bhhi efhitegehf:t`h nkwhrckst nhvhn (V-n), obkut 24 c t`eal, akisests kg
soifs oif anoyhy soifs wet` mrovhn noyhrs. V`h ceffnh nhvhnV-2 es obkut 64 c t`eal oif akisests kg soifs oif nhishs kgmrovhn oif pkalhts kg anoy. V`h upphrckst nhvhn (V-1), uptk 18 c t`eal, akisests kg akorsh soifs wet` iuchrkuspkalhts kg mrovhn.
O sconn iucbhr kg @eit oif quortzeth phbbnhs wet`pkssebnh troahs kg ckfegeaoteki `ovh bhhi gkuif ei oihxpksurh, Faonun Cejnkaeu, ei o mrovhn- oif soif noyhr wet`o t`ealihss kg ?,8 c. V`h noyhr es nkaothf ei t`h shquhiahV-?, bhtwhhi t`h gksseneghrkus `krezkis No Tehtres (bhnkw)oif Wonho Mrouiahoiunue (obkvh).
Kg t`h 'orthgoats' gkuif `hrh t`rhh sconn a`kppeim tkknsorh chitekihf, oif twk kg t`hc `ovh bhhi gemurhf.Xigkrtuiothny t`hrh orh ik fhtoenhf fhsareptekis yht oif t`hpeaturhs orh ikt anhor hikum` tk mht o mkkf efho obkut t`hpehahs. V`h twk gneit phbbnhs `ovh obkut t`h soch sezh(? : nhimt` 81 cc, weft` 10 cc, t`ealihss 26 cc< 2: nhimt`81 cc, weft` 15,8 cc, t`ealihss 27,8 cc), t`h t`erf kih,o quortzeth phbbnh, es snem`tny normhr. V`h twk orthgoatsw`ea` `ovh bhhi gemurhf s`kw skch gnolh saors.
V`h geif `krezki cem`t bh akrrhnothf wet` t`h Knfuvoehvhit orkuif ?,= Cyr BT. V`es es boshf ki t`h prhshiah kgo ceffnh sezhf Vrkmkit`h`uc (V. foaeauc) ei t`hgksseneghrkus `krezkis No Tehtres bhnkw, oif WonhoMrouiahoiunue obkvh t`h geif`krezki. V`h soch sphaehskaaurs ei Qnoteio-1 (t`h typh-nkaonety kg Vrkmkit`hreucfoaeauc). Qnoteio 1 `os o ikrcon pknorety, ossemihf tk t`hKnfuvoe Hvhit (Rofunhsau oif Qocski ?55?).
V`h ortegeaeon a`oroathr kg bkt` gemurhf pehahs aoiikt bhhvonuothf ki t`h boses kg t`h pubneaotekis ovoenobnh. V`horthgoats s`kunf `ovh oi omh kg obkut ?,= Cyr BT. V`hout`krs gurt`hrckrh chiteki geifs grkc Fhonun Weenkr wet`o ykuimhr omh kg ?,2 Cyr BT (Rofunhsau oif Qocski?55?).
0. Akianusekis
V`es pophr `os mevhi o s`krt slhta` kg t`h NkwhrTonohknet`ea kaaupoteki kg hosthri Ahitron Hurkph. V`esorho `os o rot`hr normh iucbhr kg Nkwhr Tonohknet`eankaonetehs. Foteim hvefhiah summhsts t`ot `kceiefs whrhonrhofy kaaupyeim t`es port kg t`h wkrnf ei t`h HornyTnhestkahih. Grkc t`h hornehr ports kg t`h CeffnhTnhestkahih kiworfs t`hrh orh vorekus seths wet`
uiocbemukus troahs kg `ucoi prhshiah, t`rhh kg w`ea`- Qtroislo slono, Tghznhteah oif Lkrknhvk - `ovh bhhihxaovothf. Ot Qtroislo slono oif Tghznhteah t`h orthgoatswhrh osskaeothf wet` o rea` Ceckcys-gouio grkc t`hshakif `ong kg t`h Arkchreoi akcpnhx oif t`h pophr `oshxpneaetny fhont wet` t`h hvefhiah gkr `ucoi kaaupoteki ott`h seths (akitro Rkhbrkhls oif Woi Lkngsa`kthi, t`esvknuch oif Rkhbrkhls ?556). Grkc t`es phrekf kiworfst`hrh orh ckrh Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea seths ei hosthri AhitronHurkph, onn foteim tk t`h shakif `ong kg t`h CeffnhTnhestkahih.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 90/342
04 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
ikths
? Qeiah ik gerhpnoah wos gkuif ei noyhr ?1 ot Qtroislo slono, etwos ihahssory tk oionysh t`h bnoal bkihs, bhnehvhf tk `ovh bhhiburit. Kur prkke kg burieim es boshf ki t`h ossucpteki t`ot bkihs‖ bhsefh t`h ceihron akcpkihit `yfrkxyopoteth (Tksihr ?508) ‖mhihronny akisest kg krmoiea cotthr onsk oif t`es `of tk bh portnyrhckvhf fureim t`h stoy kg bkihs ei o gerhpnoah. Oaakrfeim tkaxphrechiton chosurachits, t`h thcphroturhs ot kphi gerhpnoahs
peavonhitny vory bhtwhhi 14()-844´A. V`ot es w`y wh ushf t`hfegghrhiteon t`hiion oionyses FVO (Coalhizeh ?5=4) oif t`hRKAL HWON pyrknyses (Åspetoneå hn on. ?5==) tk prkvh t`h burieimkg t`h bkihs. Gkur shts kg socpnhs whrh oionyshf by bkt` cht`kfs,hoa` san grkit t`h soch geifspkt ei noyhr ?1 oif akitoeieim o bkihkg usuon w`eth opphoroiah (iki-burit) oif o bnoal bkih bhnehvhf tk`ovh bhhi burit. V`h soch quoitetehs kg bkt` bkihs uifhr t`h sochakifetekis whrh oionyshf.V`h rhsunts kg t`h oionyshs `ovh bhhi vhry secenor ei onn gkur shts.V`h FVO aurvhs `ovh s`kwi t`ot os o akishquhiah kg struaturhbrholeim, t`h burit bkihs `ovh o `em`hr akithit kg ckesturh ki t`hkih `oif, ki t`h kn`hr `oif o port kg krmoiea cotthr es cesseim otthcphroturhs bhtwhhi 284-684´A os akcporhf tk iki-burit (w`eth)bkihs.V`h rhsunts kg t`h RKAL HWON pyrknyses `ovh bhhi hvhi ckrh
uiocbemukus. V`h ockuit kg precory vknotenh krmoiea akcpkihit
up tk 284´A es onwoys `em`hr ei t`h w`eth bkihs t`oi ei t`h bnoabkihs). O secenor peaturh es mevhi by t`h Q2 phols: t`h akithit kiki-vknotenh krmoiea cotthr es omoei `em`hr ei t`h w`eth bkihsbhaoush ei t`h bnoal bkihs et wos portny aroalhf fureim t`herakitoat wet` gerh. V`h eifhx kg prkfuateki (ET, e.h. rhnotevhobuifoiah kg vknotenh akcpkuifs precoreny prhshit ei t`h socpnhxprhsshf by t`h rotek QE tk t`h suc Q?+Q2) kg onn w`eth bkihs e`em`hr t`oi ET kg akrrhspkifeim bnoal kihs. V`h rhsefuon krmoieacotthr ei t`h bnoal bkihs t`hrhgkrh mevhs `em`hr Vcox vonuhs t`o
t`h krmoiea cotthr kg w`eth (iki-burit) bkihs. V`h hxahpteki ei oif Vcox kbshrvhf ei t`h gkurt` socpnh akunf bh t`h rhsunt kg oshakifory (oiohrkbea cearkbeon) oatevety, w`ea` es ckst rhcorlobei t`h fhhphst `krezki.]h aoi akianufh t`ot t`h bnoal bkihs grkc noyhr ?1 ot Qtroisloslono `ovh bhhi eifhhf ogghathf by akitoat wet` gerh, fureim w`eao port kg krmoiea cotthr wos rhckvhf ot thcphroturh bhtwhhi 24oif .]A.
Oitkigi Tgea`ystonFhpt. kg Mhknkmy oifTonhkitknkmyCosoryl XievhrsetyLktnogslo 27?? 1= Brik
Azha` Rhpubnea
Ckjce'r QtriofAzha` Mhknkmeaon QurvBrik shatekiNhetihrkvo 22742 44 BrikAzha` Rhpubnea
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 91/342
QE LORHN WONKA@ - HOQVHRI AHIVRON OIF QKXV@HOQVHRI HXRKTH
rhghrhiahs
Borto, J.
Burfulehweaz, C.
Burfulehweaz, C..L.-F. Chyhr
Burfehlehweaz, C.J. ]eiieale
?5=6 Qefneslo proankvhlo io Qnkvhislya` trovhrteika`, Ikvå Kbzkry ?7, ?11-?=8.
?554 ]yiele boforë stoikweslo fknikponhkn etyazihmk Vrzhbieao 2. Qnoslh Qprowkzfoieo Ora`hknkmeazih 1? , =-26.
?55? Bofoieh ksofieatwo fknikponhknetyazihmk w Vrzhbieay, Qnoslh Qprowkzfoieo Ora`hk
nkmeazih 12, =-?5.
?55? V`h Oionyses kg Hrroteas grkc Mnoaeon Fhpksets ei Vrzhbieao (Qenhseo), Qnoslh Qprowkzfoieo Ora`hknkmeazih 12, 25-62.
?505 Ikwh cothreony ponhknetu fknihmk z Vrzhbieay, wkj. ]rkanow, Qenhseo Oitequo 1?, 5-?0.
Fkbkse, W.
Åspetoneå, J.,
J.N. Nopkrth,C. Cofha.G, Cort|eees.E'. E hpnot.J. Tounht
?501 Feh Lika`hiorthgolth vki Wårthsz÷n÷s, Ht`ikmrop`esa`-Ora`okn. Zhetsa`. 26, 165-17?.
?5== Cht`kfh ropefa fh aoroatår esoteki fhs rka`hs càrhs fh nhur pkthitehn påtrknehr ht fh nhur
fhmrå f'åvknuteki, Rhv. Eist. Groia, fu Tåtrkn 12(?), 21-61.
Grefrea`, J. ?5=2 Tonhkne tealå kse'fnhie v Bhåkvê, k.Ckst, Ora`hknkmealå rkz`nhfy 26, 265-285.
?5=7 V`h gerst eifustrehs grkc Hosthri oif Qkut`-Hosthri Ahitron Hurkph. Ei: L. Wonka` (hf.) , Nhs prhcehrs eifustrehs fh WHurkph, 0-21. EP akimr. XEQTT, Aknnkquh WEEE: Ieah.
?5=5 Ontponoknet`esa`h Eifustreh. Ei: W. Qebrovo ht on., Hrgkrsa`uim fhr Tnhestkzoiobnomhruimhioug fhc @þmhn "Znoty lkpha" bhe Tghznhteah (IK-Roif vki Trom) E. Vhen, Oit`rkpk-
zkeluc ?2, ??=-?27.
?505 Tghznhteah: O Nkwhr Tonohk`t`ea Qeth ei Ahitron Bk`hceo (Hxaovotekis ?575-?508).Tromuh: Gkiths Ora`. Trom. ?0, Cus. Iot. Trom.
?55?o V`h Knfhst Tonohk`t`ea stkih eifustry grkc t`h Bhrkui `em`woy akcpnhx, Oit`rkpk- zkeluc 24, ???-?20.
?55?b Nhs prhcehrs phupnhchits `ucoeih hi bk`àch. Ei: H. Bkiegoy, B. Woifhrchhrsa` (hf.), NhsTrhcehrs Hurkpåhis, ?58-24?: Tores, [email protected].
Grefrea`, J.,N. Qcknglkvo
?5=7 Qtory ponhknet v prkgenu B, Bhìkv E, (Nkuislå Qtghfk`kgg), Ora`hknkmealå rkz`nhfy 20,1-?=.
Mnofenei, W.I. ?505 V`h Lkrknhvk Tonohk`t`ea Qeth: Rhshora`, cht`kfs, strotemrop`y, Oit`rkpknkmeh 2=(2-1),51-?41.
Mnofenei, W.I.,W.I. Qetnevyj
?554 Oehn Ahitron 'ikj Hvrkpy. Lejhv: Ioulkvo fuclo.
@kroìhl, E’W. ? k/hl
?500 Tonohkzkknkmy oif t`h Cef-Hurkphoi _uothriory post: sakph kg t`h opprkoa` oifshnhathf rhsunts, Rkzprovy Asn. Olof. Wêf. Rofo Cot.-p`'r. vìf, 50 (6), Tro`o Oaofhceo.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 92/342
s: V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Jory, Z.,V. A`kfol,F. Lrzyszlkwsle
?554 Xtwkry pykwh io stoikweslu ora`hknkm eaziyc Vrzhbieao 2, Qe. Qprow. Ora`. 1?, 1?-65
Lkag, O. ?55? Tonohkcomihtea eivhstemoteki kg t`h Bhrkui `em`woi shateki, Oit`rkpkzkeluc 24, ?41-
?45.
Lkuthl, J.
Lrhtzke, C,N. Whrths
?527 Akitrebuteki o no akiioessoiah fhs aonaoerhs o senhx fu Jurossequh supårehur fh no Qtrois
slono prås Brik (Ckroveo), Wìstiel Qt. mhkn. þstovu Asn. rhpubnely 2, ?=2-?02.
?578 Xpphr Be`oreoi (Eithrceifhn) Thbbnh Eifustry Kaaupoteki Qeth ei ]hsthri @uimory,Aurrhin Oit`rkpknkmy 7(?), =6-0=.
Lrhtzke, C,W. Fkbkse (hf.)
?'e'Ln Wårthssz÷n÷s - Coi, seth oif Aunturh. Bufophst: Olofåceoe Leofñ.
Lrzyszlkwsle, F. ?551 V`h ]ortoieoi Qehfnha Qoifur (Zhfnetzhr Qoifur) skut`worfs t`h Vrzhbieao @enns, QenhseNkwnoif, Q]-Tknoif: rh-hxoceioteki ogthr gegty yhors, Heszhetonthr uif Mhmhiwort 61.81-77.
Lulno, M.J.
Lulno, M.J.
Nholhy, C.F.
?5=4 Akrrhnotekis bhtwhhi Nkhsshs oif fhhp-sho shfechits , Mhkn. G÷rhieimhi e Qtkal`kncG÷r`oifneimhi 52(2), ?60-?04.
?5=8 Nkhss Qtrotemrop`y kg Ahitron Hurkph. Ei: L.]. Butzhr, M.N. Esooa (hfs), Ogthr t`h Oustronkpet`hht'ihs. 55-?00, V`h @omuh: Ckutki Tubnes`hrs.
?5=? Knfuvoe Mkrmh 1: Hxaovotekis ei Bhfs E oif EE, ?574-?571. Aocbrefmh: AocbrefmhXievhrsety Trhss.
Coalhizeh, R.A.
Conhz, C.
?5=4 Fegghrhiteon V`hrcon Oionyses. Nkifki oif Ihw Ukrl: Oaofhceh Trhss .
?5=6 Þbhr feh Bhfhutuim fhr Hitfhaluim vki Mhr÷nnmhrothi ei fhi Wennogroia`ehi Qa`ea`thifhr Qoifonjo E ei Estrehi (Lrkotehi), Buen. Qae. Qhat. O, ?5(1-6), =5-04.
?5=8 Ki t`h Qemiegeaoiah kg t`h Mhius @kck fesakvhry ei t`h Wennogroiaeoi shfechits kg
Qoifonjo E ihor Tuno, ROF Jumksn. olof. zioi. ei uchti., rozrhf zo prerkfksn. zioi. ?=,?0?-24?.
?5=7 Hxaovoteki kg t`h vennogroia`eoi seth Qoifonjo E ihor Tuno (Jumksnovejo) . Ei: L. Wonka`(hf.), Nhs prhcehrs eifustrehs fh WHurkph, ?46-?21, EP Akimr. XEQTT. Aknnkquh WEEE,Ieah.
Cusen. R..L. Wonka`
?570 Qtroislo slono: ets Choieim gkr Tnhestkahih Qtufehs, Aurrhit Oit`rkpknkmy 5, 816-815.
Cusen, R.,L. Wonka`,W. Ihåhsoiy
?588 Tnhestkahiie shfechity klk`' Brio, Oit`rkpkzkeluc EW, (?586), ?4=-?7=.
Tghegrkvo, O.O. Zhcoi
?5=5 Ahrikveah. Ei: W. Qebrovo (hf.), _uothriory Mnoaeotekis ei t`h Ikrt`hri @hcesp`hrh,7t` Qhss. Kstrovo, Muefh tk Hxlursekis, 72-76, Tromuh.
Tksihr, O.Q.
Trkshl, G,
?508 V`h Ceihron kg Bkih, Aneieaon Krt`kpohfeas I.244, 0=-55.
?567 Ionhz anoatkiehislå`k þstìpu v Nhtloa` iof Wntovku, Tocotly Ora`hknkmealå 62,?515/67, ?12-?17.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 93/342
01 LORHN WONKA@ - HOQVHRI AHIVRON OIF QKXV@HOQVHRI HXRKTH
Rofunhsau, A, ?55??'. Qoeiski
Rkhbrkals. ]. ?556
Rkhbrkhls, ]’ t`esV. voi Lkngsa`kthi, vknuch
Qcknelkvo. N.. ?55?
Qcknelkvo. E... ?506J. Grefrea`
Qcknelkvo. N.. ?50?O. Zhcoi
Vroahs f'oatevetå `ucoeih o no neceth Tnekaàih/Tnåestkaàih fois Eh Bossei Foaequh(Rkucoceh). Ei: H. Bkiegoy, B. Woifhrchhrsa` (hfs). Nhs Trhcehrs Hurkpåhis, 241-24=,Tores: [email protected].
Xpfoteim t`h Hornehst Kaaupoteki kg Hurkph, Aurrhit Oit`rkpknkmy 18(1), 14?-148.
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: O rhopproeson kg orthgoatuon oif a`rkiknkmeaonhvefhiah.
Nkwhr Tnhestkahih Qkens kg t`h Bhrkui `em`woy shateki. Oit`rkpkzkeluc 24, =?-?4?.
@knstheisly eithrmnoaeon io nklonets Lornsthji v Ahslåc Lrosu: Tonhkphfknkmealy vyvkjo pkseah ponhknetealå eifustreh, Ora`hknkmealå rkz`nhfy 17, 1-?5.
V`h strotemrop`eaon semiegeaoiah kg Ghrrhtk-typh skens. Ei: W. Qebrovo, G.]. Q`kttki (hfs),_uothriory Mnoaeotekis ei t`h Ikrt`hri @hcesp`hrh, Qhss. Kstrovo ?5=5, Rhpkrt Ik. 7,227-214.
Qebrovo, W. ht on.
?502 Bhfhutuim fhr Ghrrhtk-B÷fhi gþr feh _uortorstrotemrop`eh, Oit`rkpkzkeluc ?6, 8=-00.
?5=5 Hrgkrsa`uim fhr Tnhestkzoiobnomhruimhi oug fhc @þmhn "Znoty lkpha" bhe Tghznhteah
(IK-Roif vki Trom) E. Vhen. Oit`rkpkzkeluc ?2. 8=-?67.
Wonka`, L. ?5== Ihuh ont- uif cetthnponoknet`esa`h Guifh ous fhr Xcmhbuim vki Brik, Oit`rkpkzkeluc
??.51-??1.
?50= V`h Horny Tonohknet`ea Qeth Qtroislo slono E ihor Brik (Azha`ksnkvoleo), Oit`rkpknkmeh28(2), ?28-?62.
Wonka`, L..N. Qhetn
?551 Qtory ponhknet v Cnofhìslya` jhslyiëa`. Aos. Ckrovslå`k cusho, sh. skh. =0, 1-5.
?556 Qtorkponhknetealo nkloneto Qvåfslå soiah v Briì-Qnoteiì, Ños. Ckrovslå`k cusho, sh.
skh. =5, 1-?6.
Wonka`. L...N. Qcknglkvå, N., ^. Zhcoi
?5=0 V`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih Qeth Tgebeah E ei Qkut` Ckroveo, Oit`rkpknkmeh ?7(1), 225-26?.
Wonka`, L’O. Zhcoi
?5=5 Cu§kv. Ei: W. Qebrovo (hf.), _uothriory Mnoaeotekis ei t`h Ikrt`hri @hcesp`hrh,7t` Qhss. Kstrovo, Muefh tk Hxaursekis, 72-76, Tromuh.
Whrths, ? ?578 Vypknkmy kg t`h Bufo-nifustry, o Thbbnh-tkkn Eifustry grkc t`h @uimoreoi NkwhrTonohknet`ea, _uothrioreo ?. ?08-?57.
]eiieale, J. ?554 Bufkwo mhknkmeazio pkikaihj saeoiy ahmehnie w Vrzhbieay-stoikweslk Vrzhbieao 2,Ån. Qprow.Ora`. 1? , 28-14.
Zorubo, _. ?562 Tkfåniy prkgen vntovslyce throsoce chze Locylhc o Whntrusy, Rkzprovy As. Olof. vìf ouceie, cot.-pger. 82, ?-15.
Zhcoi, O. ?5=6 _uothriory kg t`h surrkuifeims kg Qtroislo slono, Oit`rkpkzkeluc ?4, 6?-=2.
?50? V`h fhvhnkpchit kg t`h _uothriory revhr oif nolh potthri ei Ahitron oif Qkut`hriCkroveo. Ei: W. Qebrovo, G.]. Q`kttki (hfs), _uothriory mnoaeotekis ei t`h Ikrt`hri
@hcesp`hrh, Qhss. Kstrovo ?5=5, Rhpkrt Ik. 7, 254-258.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 94/342
06 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Zhbhro. L. ?582 Nhs pnus oiaehis ckiuchits fh trovoen `ucoeih hi Bk`àch, Rkzprovy Xstr. þst. mhkn
Tro`o.
?575 Feh onthsthi Zhumhi fhr chisa`nea`hi Orbhet ei B÷`hchi, Rkzprovy Xstr. þst. mhkn. 1Tro`o.
Lorhn Wonka`Ckrovslå Zhcslh CuzhucZhniy Vr` 7785 1= BrikAzha` Rhpubnea
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 95/342
Fehtrea` Coieo 7 V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph:t`h Hnbh-Qoonh rhmeki (Mhrcoiy)
V`h knfhst Tonohknet`ea geifs grkc t`h Hnbh-Qoonh rhmeki
foth tk t`h phrekf bhtwhhi t`h Hnsthreoi oif t`h Qooneoi
Mnoaeotekis. Os eifeaothf ei t`h shquhiahs ot Benzeimsnhbhi
oif Qa`÷ieimhi, t`hrh orh t`rhh eithrmnoaeons wet`ei reis
phrekf. a`oroathreshf by portehunor sconn vhrthbronh,
cknnusaoi oifgnkron osskaeotekis. V`h ckst ecpkrtoit seth
es Benzeimsnhbhi EE, wet` o rofekchtrea omh kg 184-644 Lyr BT,
w`hrh `kceief rhcoeis, ossemihf tk o noth rhprhshitotevh kg
@kck hrhatus `ovh bhhi gkuif.
?. EitrkfuatekiV`h Hnbh-Qoonh rhmeki, t`h orho bhtwhhi t`h ikrt`hri
upnoifs {Cetthnmhbermh: V`eereimhr ]onf, Hrzmhbermh, @orz)oif t`her ikrt`hri gkrhnoif, es setuothf bhtwhhi 84 c oif??(P) c obkvh sho-nhvhn, w`hrhos t`h ontetufh kg t`h boseis oift`h `enny ramekis roimhs grkc ?84 c tk 184 c obkvh sho nhvhn.
V`h Ghiiksaoifeioveoi mnoaehrs rhoa`hf t`h ikrt`hrihfmh kg t`h Cetthnmhbermh shvhron techs fureim t`hTnhestkahih oif akvhrhf t`h Hnbh-Qoonh rhmeki, t`h typh orhokg t`h Hnsthreoi oif Qooneoi mnoaeoteki. V`h strotemrop`eashquhiah oif t`h a`rkikstrotemrop`y kg t`h Hnbh-Qoonhrhmeki aoi bh eighrrhf grkc t`h eithrnoaeim kg mnoaeon
shquhiahs wet` phremnoaeon fhpksets.Ei ?540, H. ]þst (]ehmhrs ?520) frhw otthiteki tk troahs
kg `ucoi kaaupoteki ei t`h Benzeimsnhbhi trovhrteih. @hrhakmieshf ets `em` omh oif ossemihf t`h trovhrteih tk t`hsk-aonnhf "mrhot eithrmnoaeon" (@knstheieoi Eithrmnoaeon,"@knsthei akcpnhx"). ]knfsthft (?518), `kwhvhr,akrrhnothf t`h Benzeimsnhbhi trovhrteih wet` t`h nosteithrmnoaeon, t`us hstobnes`eim oi eiakrrhat efho w`ea`muefhf shvhron mhknkmests oif ora`ohknkmests gkr o phrekf kgobkut 64 yhors (h.m. Vkhpghr ?574, ?5=4< Ximhr ?5=6).Esk`ethf geifs oif sconn eivhitkrehs kg stkih orthgoats whrhstenn ossemihf tk t`h @knstheieoi Eithrmnoaeon, h.m. ]oimhi,
]onnhifkrg oif kt`hr seths ei t`h revhr mrovhns kg t`h Hnbh-Qoonh rhmeki. V`hsh geifs whrh rhmorfhf os o strkimhvefhiah gkr t`h hxesthiah kg t`h sk-aonnhf "Anoatkieoi" eit`h Hnbh-Qoonh rhmeki (Aknneis ?570< Vkhpghr ?5=4).Qphaegea akiahptekis kg t`h cha`oiesc kg t`h anecoteaonnyeifuahf oaaucunoteki kg revhr mrovhns oif subshquhithrkseki nhf tk t`h ossemichit kg t`hsh geifs tk t`h hornyQooeh mnoaeon oif tk akrrhnoteki wet` t`h Ceffnh Oa`hunhoi
kg Corllnhhbhrm, t`ot uiocbemukusny bhnkims tk t`h hornyQooneoi (Boucoii oif Coieo ?501< Mro`coii ?588).Oport grkc t`h Corllnhhbhrm eivhitkry, t`hsh geifsrhprhshithf t`h kiny hvefhiah kg t`h hornehst kaaupoteki kgt`h ceffnh Hnbh-Qoonh rhmeki gkr o nkim tech.
Gehnf rhshora` aorrehf kut fureim t`h nost twk fhaofhs `osrhsunthf ei o ckrh fhtoenhf subfeveseki kg t`h phrekfbhtwhhi t`h Hnsthreoi oif t`h Qooneoi mnoaeoteki (Ahphl?507< Hrf ?5=1, ?5=0< Coieo ?5=1< Coieo oif Onthrcoii?5=4< Coieo oif Coe ?575< Ruslh ?576, ?578), oifeivhitkrehs kg t`h sk-aonnhf Anoatkieoi aoi ikw bh ossemihftk fegghrhit p`oshs kg t`h "@knsthei akcpnhx". Gurt`hrckrh,ei ?575, oikt`hr geif `krezki ei t`h trovhrteih kg Benzeimsnhbhi wos gkuif (Mrecc ht on. ?5=6< Coieo ?5=6). Os orhsunt, o seth wet` pkssebnh kaaupoteki struaturhs, wet`orthgoats oif, obkvh onn, wet` `kceief rhcoeis wos t`hihxaovothf oif ot t`h soch tech o rhvehw kg ets strotemrop`eaonpkseteki uifhrtolhi. V`h trovhrteih kg Benzeimsnhbhi prkvhftk bh os knf os H. ]þst `of onrhofy summhsthf ei ?540 oift`h seth `os bhakch kih kg t`h ckst ecpkrtoit seths kg t`esphrekf ei Hurkph (Gesa`hr ht on. ?55?< Coe ht on. ?501<Coieo oif ]hbhr ?507< Coieo ht on. ?504).
Rhahitny, oi ecpkrtoit seth wos fesakvhrhf ei CeffnhTnhestkahih eithrmnoaeon fhpksets hxpkshf ei t`h brkwi-akonceih ot Qa`÷ieimhi, ei t`h ikrt`hri @orz gkrhnoif (Gem. ?)(V`ehch ht on. ?552, ?551). Kt`hr sconnhr geif akcpnhxhswet` o Ceffnh Tnhestkahih omh grkc t`h Qooeh rhmeki aoi bhoffhf tk t`es nest.
O pkssebnh hxpnoioteki gkr t`h obshiah kg knfhr orthgoatsei t`h ceffnh Hnbh-Qoonh rhmeki coy bh t`ot uiten rhahitnygneit orthgoats whrh t`h precory kbjhats kg eithrhst gkrora`ohknkmests. V`es cothreon wos gerst troispkrthf eitk kurwkrleim orho wet`ei t`h mrkuif-ckroeihs kg t`h Hnsthreoimnoaeoteki. @kwhvhr, ei t`h akithxt kg t`h hornehst
kaaupoteki-fhboth et ihhfs tk bh strhsshf t`ot kbjhatsrhshcbneim typeaon phbbnh tkkns coy bh gkrchf ei o ioturonwoy, by cha`oieaon oateki ki phbbnhs gkuif ei fhbres oifmrovhns wet`kut oiy `ucoi eithrghrhiah. O nkt kg pshufk-orthgoats whrh aknnhathf oif fhsarebhf os `ucoi aunturonrhcoeis ei t`h post (h.m. Oifrhh ?515< Ofreoi ?502) butonsk, rhmrhttobny, t`es es stenn t`h aosh tkfoy (h.m. t`h Ont-
ponoknet`eluc kg ]effhrstott ihor ]hecor, Qa`othr ?505).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 96/342
07 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. ?. V`h ceffnh Hnbh-Qoonh-Rhmeki wet` seths chitekihf ei t`h thxt.?: Benzeimsnhbhi, 2: Qoa`shiburm, 1: Chcnhbhi, 6: ]oimhi,8: Ihucorl-Qþf, 7: ]onnhifkrg, =: L÷a`sthft, 0: Qa`÷ieimhi,5: Nhimhghnf-Bof L÷shi, ?4: Grhyburm, ??: Hffhretz bhe L÷t`hi,?2: Lnehlhi, ?1: Ksthrkfh/Gonnsthei, ?6: Qa`woihbhal/@uy.
2. Qtro temr op`y oif a`rkiknkmyV`h strotemrop`eaon subfeveseki kg t`h Tnhestkahih
fhpksets ei t`h Hnbh-Qoonh rhmeki oif ets akrrhnoteki tk t`h
a`rkiknkmehon subfeveseki kg t`h Tnhestkahih es o `ktnyfabothf ethc. V`hrh orh vorekus akitrofeatkry akiahpts. Kihes boshf ki t`h ossucpteki t`ot t`h fhpksets rhprhshit kinyt`rhh cojkr mnoaeoteki ayanhs oif kiny twk anhor eithrmnoaeonp`oshs (Hesscoii oif Nett ?552). Ei t`es vehw t`h Qooneoibhmeis wet` t`h Gu`ih mnoaeon p`osh subfevefeim twk CeffnhTnhestkahih eitarmnoaeons. V`h ora`ohknkmeaon `krezki kgBenzeimsnhbhi oif t`h trovhrteih hcbhffeim et whrh ossemihftk t`h notthr kg t`hsh eithrmnoaeons, w`ea` ecpnehs t`ot t`hhiterh Nkwhr Tonohknetbea kg t`h rhmeki es akrrhnothf wet`t`h horny Qooneoi. Akishquhitny, t`h eithrmnoaeon kg Benzeimsnhbhi es rhmorfhf tk bh o "nkimhr eithrstofeon p`osh" wet`eit`h horny Qooneoi. @kwhvhr, t`hrh es suggeaeìit hvefhiah kg oChfeehrroihoi gnkro, kg o t`hrckp`enh cexhf kol gkrhst oifo n'unny fhvhnkphf @hneaemkio boioteao gouio pkeiteim tk gunneithrmnoaeon akifetekis fureim gkrcoteki kg t`h Benzeimsnhbhi trovhrteih.
V`es a`rkikstrotemrop`eaon ckfhn rhsunthf ei o rhfuahfiucbar kg thrroahs (Gem. 2), by nucpeim thi-oahs wet` nettnhvhrteaon festoiahs oif ossuceim t`ot vhry t`eal mrovhn noyhrs
whrh fhpksethf. T`oshs kg mrovhn oaaucunoteki whrhrhstreathf tk t`h t`rhh cojkr mnoaeon p`oshs. V`h bkttkc kt`h vonnhy kg t`h horny Hnsthreoi thrroah es 64 tk 68 c obkt`h prhshit revhr nhvhn oif t`h bkttkc kg t`h vonnhy kg t`hhorny Qooneoi thrroah (shisu streatk) ?8 tk ?7 c (h.m. Qkhr?526< Vkhpghr ?511). @kwhvhr, kih thrroah fhthrceihf bt`hsh sa`knors akunf ikt bh ormuhf owoy by t`h secpnegehfstrotemrop`y. V`h thrroah es setuothf ot 14 tk 18 c obkvh trevhr nhvhn oif et es mhihronny rhmorfhf os kg noth Hnsthreoikremei. Kt`hr vonnhy gnkkrs setuothf bhtwhhi 14 oif ?0 cobkvh t`h revhr nhvhn orh fesrhmorfhf ei t`es ckfhn. Ei cykpeieki t`es ckfhn es tkk secpnh. Fhtoenhf gehnfwkrl nuesrhsunthf ei o ckrh akcpnhx strotemrop`eaon subfeveseki kgt`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih shquhiah ei t`h Hnbh-Qoonh rhmekioif ei t`h @orz gkrhnoif. V`es subfeveseki es coeiny boshfki t`h strotemrop`y kg t`h thrroahs w`ea` wenn bh fhsarebhfei t`h ihxt shateki. Gerst kg onn E wenn fhsarebh t`h boseaayanh w`ea` aoi bh kbshrvhf ei skch thrroahs kg t`h QooeEnc oif Xistrut revhrs.
V`h bosea ayanh bhmeis wet` shvhron c kg mrovhnsfhpksethf fureim oi horny mnoaeon p`osh. Kih kr ckrh`krezkis kg grkst struaturhs, prhfkceioitny grkc o s`krtpnhiemnoaeon p`osh, aoi bh rhakmieshf wet`ei t`hsh mrovhns.V`h mrovhns orh, ot skch pnoahs, akvhrhf by snkph fhbres onkhss. Hrkseki tkkl pnoah fureim o nothr p`osh kg t`h mnoaeoayanh oif t`h revhr aut eitk oif nkaonny akcpnhthny t`rkum`t`h mrovhn fhpksets. Mrovhn fhpksets kg nkw t`ealihss, krhvhi neciea-thncotea shquhiahs kg t`h subshquhiteithrmnoaeon, kvhrnoy t`h noth mnoaeon bkttkc kg t`h vonnhy.V`hsh gnuveon soify mrovhns oif mrovhnny soifs, mhihronny? tk 2 c t`eal, eithrnoah wet` stomioit wothr shfechits suos neciea-thncotea shquhiahs oif onsk wet` trovhrteih
shquhiahs, kr t`hy orh ogghathf by eithrmnoaeon whot`hreim.Qex kg sua` thrroah ayanhs `ovh bhhi kbshrvhf ei t`h nkwhrvonnhy kg t`h ]epphr ihor Benzeimsnhbhi (Gem. 1). V`hakrrhspkifeim horny mnoaeon vonnhy gnkkrs orh ot 18 c, 2= c22 c, ?0 c oif 0 c obkvh oif 1 c bhnkw t`h prhshit revhnhvhn. V`h noth mnoaeon oif eithrmnoaeon shquhiah (t`h gnuveooif neciea shrehs oif trovhrteihs) storts ? tk 2 c fhhphr. Vbosh kg t`h mnoaeon shrehs kg t`h Hnsthreoi es ot 68 c obkvht`h prhshit revhr nhvhn ikrt` kg Benzeimsnhbhi. Jufmeim grkct`h bosea ayanh ckfhn, et es prkbobnh t`ot t`hrh es oikt`hreithrmnoaeon shquhiah bhtwhhi 68 c oif 18 c, o shquhiahw`ea` `os, `kwhvhr, ikt bhhi efhitegehf sk gor.
V`rhh Ceffnh Tnhestkahih thrroah-trovhrteih ayanhs whrhfkauchithf ei t`h nkwhr vonnhy kg t`h ]epphr, bhnkw t`hHnsthreoi thrroah. V`hy aoi bh akrrhnothf wet` t`rhh eithrmnoaeons (Benzeimsnhbhi E, EE oif EEE) onthcoteim wet` mnoaeop`oshs, fureim w`ea` shfechits wet` eifeaotekis kg orateaakifetekis `ovh bhhi fhpksethf. V`h upphr ayanh storts ot18 tk 12 c oif akrrhspkifs tk o thrroah ei t`h vonnhys kg tQooeh, Enc oif Xistrut revhrs, h.m. t`h thrroah ihor ]oimh
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 97/342
0= FEHVREA@ COIEO - V@H HNBH-QOONH RHMEKI (MHRCOIU)
?.MV
2.MV
-2 tk -8c
Gem. 2. Qtrotemrop`y kg t`h thrroahs ei t`h rhmech kg Qooeh revhr.
Ki t`h nhgt: secpnegehf shquhiah kg t`h thrroahs strotemrop`y, ki t`h rem`t: rhon shquhiah.
?. mrovhns< 2. mnoaeon fhpksets (worvhf anoys, mrkuifckroeihs).
wet` Tonohknet`ea orthgoats. O nkwhr thrroah ei t`h Qoonh-Xistrut rhmeki es aonnhf t`h Akrbeauno thrroah bhaoush kg t`hprhshiah kg o cknnusa gouio wet` Akrbeauno gnuceiones eit`h soify-mrovhnny shatekis. V`hsh noyhrs, ot opprkxecothny21 tk 27 c obkvh t`h oatuon revhr nhvhn, akrrhspkif tk t`hceffnh kg t`h t`rhh Ceffnh Tnhestkahih ayanhs chitekihfobkvh. V`h sk-aonnhf "]onnhifkrg thrroah" ei t`h Qooehvonnhy bhnkims tk t`h nothst kg t`h t`rhh Ceffnh Tnhestkahihayanhs ei t`h nkwhr vonnhy kg t`h revhr ]epphr ihorBenzeimsnhbhi. V`h ]onnhifkrg thrroah es suaahhfhf by othrroah gkrchf fureim t`h Qooeh mnoaeoteki shisu streatk,
setuothf ot opprkxecothny ?8 tk ?7 c obkvh t`h oatuon revhrnhvhn. V`h mnoaeon p`osh fureim w`ea` t`es notthr thrroah wosgkrchf wos gknekwhf by oi eithrmnoaeon p`osh wet` w`ea`t`h trovhrteih shquhiah kg H`reimsfkrg, t`h neciea-thncoteashquhiah kg Ihucorl-Ikrf ei t`h vonnhy kg t`h Mheshn, oift`h Noimhibkmhi sken akcpnhx `ovh bhhi akrrhnothf (Coieonn9In)< ei prhss< Coieo oif Onthrcoii ?5=4< Coieo ht on.
?554). V`h ]ort`h-Hhc thrroah-trovhrteih shquhiah oif t`h]hea`shneoi oif @knkahih shquhiahs orh nkaothf bhnkw t`hthrroahs chitekihf obkvh.
Foiubh. Akrbeauno gnuceiones `os ikt bhhi kbshrvhf ei t`hgouio sk gor. Oport grkc @hneaemkio `oioteao, t`h gknnkweimChfethrroihoi oif skut`host Hurkphoi sphaehs kaaur:
Ohmkpes vhrteaennus, Fesaus phrsphatevus, Tshufoneifo
turmefo, Ep`emhio tucefo, os whnn os t`h Otnoitea sphaehs Ozaao chilhoio.
Normhr coccons, sua` os t`h stroem`t tuslhf hnhp`oitTonohknkxkfki oitequus oif t`h r`eikahrks Feahrkr`eius
lera`bhrmhises, `ovh onsk bhhi rhakrfhf grkc t`hV`hkfkxus fhpksets. Gurt`hrckrh t`hrh orh skch gneit gnolhsgrkc t`h Benzeimsnhbhi V`hkfkxus mrovhns. V`h sconn
osshcbnomh grkc ]oimhi prkbobny onsk foths tk t`h'Benzeimsnhbhi E' eithrmnoaeon, os whnn os t`h geifs grkcChcnhbhi ei t`h vonnhy kg t`h Xistrut.
O @hneaemkio `oioteao gouio `os bhhi aknnhathf grkc t`hkvhrnyeim soify-senty ports kg t`h gnuveon fhpksets.
@hneaemkio `oioteao es typeaon kg trovhrteih kaaurrhiahsw`ea` `ovh yehnfhf Akrynus oif _uhraus. Ei t`h syi-a`rkikus soify mrovhns kg t`h ]oimhi thrroah o Tonohk
nkxkfki oitequus gouio kaaurrhf, onkim wet` oi oquoteacknnusaoi gouio wet`kut Akrbeauno.
1. A`oroathresteas kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih
'Benzeimsnhbhi' eithrmnoaeons1.?. VnnH HORNEHQV EIVHRMNOAEON FHTKQEVQ: "BENZEIMQ
NHBHI E"
O gnuveon-neciea shquhiah akvhrhf by o trovhrteih kgsavaron chtrhs (Gem. 6) es setuothf ki t`h 12 c thrroah ihorBenzeimsnhbhi. V`h soify-mrovhnny shfechits akitoei oV`hkfkxus shrroteneiegkrces gouio. V`es revhr sioen es rhnothftk V`hkfkxus foiu`eones gkuif ei t`h nkwhr akursh kg t`h
1.2. V@H CEFFNH EIVHRMNOAEON FHTKQEVQ: "BENZEIMQ
NHBHI EE"V`h "Benzeimsnhbhi EE" eithrmnoaeon fhpksets akisest kg
trovhrteih fhpksets nothronny eithrnoahf wet` gnuveon soifs kitkp kg t`h mnoaeon 2= c-thrroah. V`h shquhiah akitoeis ot etsbosh t`h whnn-likwi Tonohknet`ea `krezki kg Benzeimsnhbhi.
Akrbeauno gnuceiones `os ikt bhhi gkuif ei t`h trovhrteihkg Benzeimsnhbhi. V`h sphaehs, `kwhvhr, kaaurrhf ei t`hsyia`rkikus revhr soifs oif mrovhns kg t`h ]epphr oif t`h
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 98/342
PP V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Ayanh 8 " BcrQ o
Ayanh 7 '
Gem. 1. Benzeimsnhbhi. V`h shquhiah kg t`h thrroahs oif trovhrteihs ei t`h ]epphr vonnhy.
?. mrovhns< 2. worvhs anoy oif sent ("Boifhrtki")< 1. bkunfhr anoy< 6. soify mrovhns< 8. trovhrteihs< 7. ponohknet`ea `krezki< =. snkph fhbres wet
cothreon kg sknegnuateki< 0. fhnuveon nkhss oif snkph fhbres< 5. nkhss< ?4. sents oif nkocs.V thrroah, Vr ?-7 trovhrteihs.
Xistrut w`ea` orh kvhrnoei by t`es trovhrteih akcpnhx.V`hkfkxus shrroteneiegkrces kaaurs kaaosekionny ei t`hora`ohknkmeaon geif `krezki. Qphaehs eifeaotevh kg o wkkfhfoif o kphi hiverkichit orh akccki ei t`h cknnusaoigouio. Gurt`hrckrh Chfethrroihoi oif skut`host Hurkphoisphaehs kg t`h @hneaemkio boioteao gouio orh prhshit, sua`os Ohmkpes vhrteaennus, Fesaus phrsphatevus, Ep`emhio
tucefo, E. fhishstreoto, Vruiaothnneio anoustrones, Ahpoho
veifkbkihises onkim wet` Otnoitea sphaehs sua` os Ozhao
chilhoio. V`h sconnhr coccons orh rhprhshithf bystrotemrop`eaonny ecpkrtoit sphaehs sua` os t`h wothrvknh
Orveakno thrrhstres aoiteoio oif t`h bhovhr Vrkmkit`hreuc
auvehre. Tonohknkxkfki oitequus es whnn rhprhshithf ei t`hnormhr coccon gouio.
O stufy kg t`h obuifoit gnkron rhcoeis s`kwhf t`hprhshiah kg o rea` cexhf kol-gkrhst gnkro, ckrh sphaegeaonnyo Buxk-_uhrahtuc, Buxk-Qyreimhtuc oif Bhrbhrefeki
osskaeoteki wet` coiy t`hrckp`enh hxkteas sua` os Buxusshcphrverhis, Tyroaoit`o akaaeiho, Ahntes oustrunes.
Qyreimo jkseloho, Juiephrus sobeio, Wetes synvhstres oifkt`hr skut`ari sphaehs. Tkthitenno gruateakso, o sphaehs wet`o ckrh akiteihiton festrebuteki, onsk kaaurs (Coe ?500).
V`h Benzeimsnhbhi EE trovhrteih yehnfhf t`h whnn likwiBenzeimsnhbhi ora`ohknkmeaon seth wet` ets iuchrkusorthgoats. Gurt`hrckrh gneit orthgoats orh likwi grkc t`h
Akrbeauno mrovhns ihor Qoa`shiburm ei t`h Xistrut/]epphvonnhy, ikt gor grkc Benzeimsnhbhi. V`h Akrbeauno mrovhnst`h ]epphr, Xistrut, Enc, Mheshn, Qooeh oif Qonzlh revhrsakrrhspkif tk t`es trovhrteih shquhiah. V`hrh orh onsk geifgrkc Ihucorl-Qþf oif Ihucorl-Ikrf ei t`h Mheshn vonn(grkc t`h sk-aonnhf L÷rbesfkrg mrovhns), oif grkc L÷a`stei t`h vonnhy kg t`h Qonzlh.
V`h rea` geif akcpnhx kg ]onnhifkrg, host kg Chrshburfhrevhs grkc t`h bosh kg mrovhns fhpksethf by t`h Qooehrevhr, just obkvh fhiufoteki rhsefuhs kg rhwkrlhf Hnsthreomnoaemhikus shfechits. V`es akcpnhx es ossemihf tk t`htroiseteki kg t`h eithrmnoaeon tk t`h Gu`ih mnoaeon p`osh. Kgneit gnolh akchs grkc t`h boson noyhrs kg t`h nkhss w`ea` kvhrnoei by t`h coei ora`ohknkmeaon `krezki akrrhnotaf tkt`h trovhrteih kg Benzeimsnhbhi EE.
1.1. V@H NOVHR EIVHRMNOAEON FHTKQEVQ: "BENZEIMQ
NHBHI EEE"Oikt`hr trovhrteih fesakvhrhf ihor Benzeimsnhbhi es
setuothf ki t`h 22 c-nhvhn. V`h trovhrteih fegghrs festeiatnygrkc t`h knfhr kihs bhaoush kg ets net`knkmy oif ets gkssenakithit. V`h Benzeimsnhbhi-EEE trovhrteih akitoeis o @hnex
pkcoteo cknnusa gouio wet` hxktea hnhchits (Ohmkpes vhr
aennus, Fesaus phrsphatevus, Ep`emhio fhishstreoto, Vruiao
thnneio anoustrones) onkim wet` akcpkihits kg o thcphroth
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 99/342
05 FEHVREA@ COIEO - V@H HNBH-QOONH RHMtKI (MHRCOIU)
I] QK
@ e = \ @ S0 J@?5 ge$|nK * ?? £ ?2 [[?1
Gem. 6. Fhvhnkpchit kg t`h trovhrteih kg t`h "Benzeimsnhbhi E E" shquhiah oif ets bektkphs.?. thrroah mrovhn< 2. nkhss< 1. fhbres ei t`h aorstea spreim< 6. snkph fhbres< 8. trovhrteih< 7. trovhrteih soif< =. noaustreih nechstkih<0. nkksh trovhrteih< 5. revhr shfechits< ?4. trhhs oif s`rubs< ??. T`romceths< ?2. pnoits kg oquotea bektkps (Tktockmhtki, Iycp oahoh,A`orkp`ytoh)< ?1. Tkoahoh, Mroceihoh, `hrbs._ spreim, L trovhrteih aosaofh, Q nolh, ] revhr (]epphr), t`h orrkw rhghrs tk t`h pkseteki kg t`h Tonohknet ea neveim gnkkr.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 100/342
54 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
cexhf gkrhst (kol oif `ozhn). Kt`hr skut` oif skut`hostHurkphoi rhprhshitotevhs orh: Ep`emhio nothstreoto, E. tucefo,
Tomkfuneio pomkfuno, Wonvoto ioteaeio.
V`h neciea-thncotea fhpksets grkc t`h upphr shrehs kg t`hL÷rbesfkrg mrovhns ei t`h Mheshn vonnhy (Coieo oif Coe?575) oif t`h snkph fhbres sken akcpnhx kg Nhimhghnf-BofL÷shi prkgenh (Rufhnsburm sken akcpnhx, Coieo oif
Onthrcoii ?5=4, ihw eivhstemotekis ag. Coieo ?505, ?554)orh onsk eifeaotevh kg t`h 'Benzeimsnhbhi EEE' eithrmnoaeon.O gunny fhvhnkphf @hneaemkio boioteao gouio osskaeothf wet`ets porteaunor Ozhao chilhoio gouio wos gkuif ei t`h vonnhykg t`h Mheshn oif ei Nhimhghnf-Bof L÷shi. O `kribhoc-kolwkkf wet` Chfethrroihoi oif Tkitea sphaehs (h.m. Arotoh-
mus phitomyio, Truius co`hnhb, Oahr ckisphssunoiuc,
_uhraus pubhsahis, Ozknno geneaunkefhs) wos fhthrceihf eit`h prkgenh kg t`h Mheshn vonnhy (Coieo oif Coe ?575).Ei t`h Rufhnsburm sken-snkph fhbres akcpnhx Ahntes
kaaurrhf.
6. V`h Tonohknet`ea geifs kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih
6.?. ]OIM HI, IHOR IHBRO
Qoify mrovhns grkc t`h Xistrut, setuothf ot 14 c obkvt`h nhvhn kg t`h oatuon revhr, yehnfhf o sconn shrehs kgopprkxecothny 84 @eit orthgoats (Nh`coii ?522< Nh`coioif Nh`coii ?52?< Vkhpghr ?57?, ?570, ?574). V`h
akcpkseteki kg t`h cknnusa gouio oif t`h rhcoeis kg oTonohknkxkfki oitequus gouio eifeaoth t`ot t`h gnuveonshfechits whrh fhpksethf fureim oi eithrmnoaeon p`osh.V`h geifs akisest kg rhnotevhny sconn gnolhs, akrhs oif tkkV`h pehahs orh 14-=8 cc nkim (ovhromh sezh 84 cc). Qkakrhs fespnoy o arufh pnotgkrc prhporoteki. V`hrh orh secoif fkubnå sarophrs, onkim wet` pkeithf oif troisvhrsoSkihs, w`enh tkkns wet` arufhny fhiteaunothf oif ikta`hfhfmhs kaaur. V`h `orf `occhr tha`iequh es coieghsthf bt`eal gnolhs oif kbtush gnoleim oimnhs wet` oi ovhromh vokg ?27.
1.6. O.QQEMICHIV
V`h notast Benzeimsnhbhi eithrmnoaeon (Benzeimsnhbhi EEE)cem`t akrraspkif tk t`h F÷cietz Eithrmnoaeon (Ahphl ?507<Hrf ?5=1, ?5=0), w`ea` oaakrfeim tk pknnhi oionysesrhshcbnhs t`h ]oalhi oif t`h Qa`÷ieimhi Eithrmnoaeon(Chilh ?504< Xrboi ht on. ?55?). V`h ceffnh Benzeimsnhbhieithrmnoaeon (Benzeimsnhbhi EE) rhprhshits oi knfhr eithrmnoaeon p`osh w`ea` fkhs ikt akrrhspkif tk t`h @knstheieoishisu streatk bhaoush kg anhor fegghrhiahs ei t`h ponyiknkmeaonrhakrf (L. Hrf, phrs. akcc. ?551). V`h ponyiknkmeaonpeaturh s`kws secenoretehs wet` t`ot grkc t`h sk-aonnhfRheisfkrg Eithrmnoaeon fhpksets hxpkshf ei t`h brkwiakon-pet ihor Qa`÷ieimhi, w`ea` onsk akitoei orthgoats. V`h
pknnhi suaahsseki kg t`h Rheisfkrg Eithrmnoaeon fegghrs grkct`h @knstheieoi shisu streatk os whnn os grkc t`h suaahssekikg t`h Qa`÷ieimhi Eithrmnoaeon bhaoush kg o `em` ockuitkg Obehs pknnhi (Xrboi, ei V`ehch ht on. ?551< Xrboi, eiprhss).
V`h @hneaemkio boioteao - @hnex pkcoteo - Ozhao
chilhoio gouio kg t`h t`rhh Benzeimsnhbhi eithrmnoaeonsrhprhshits opporhitny typeaon Ceffnh Tnhestkahih ghoturhsonsk rhakmieshf ei kt`hr eithrmnoaeon fhpksets kg t`h••@knstheieoi akcpnhx", h.m. ei t`h trovhrteih kg Brþ`hec,Qa`woihbhal oif Ksthrkfh ihor t`h "Gonnsthei" (ag.Coieo ?5=1, ?501). V`hsh Ceffnh Tnhestkahih gouioss`orh t`h kaaurrhiah kg t`h ikw hxteiat sphaehs Oaeauno
fenuveoio.
O a`rkiknkmeaon eifeaoteki wos kbtoeihf by t`h 2,6X-214V`oif HQR foths kg t`h ceffnh eithrmnoaeon, t`h BenzeimsnhbhiEE fhpksets wet` t`h ponohknet`ea geif `krezki (shh Qa`worazht on. ?500). V`h foths kg 124 - 184 Lyr oif 204 - 6?6 LyrBT summhst o akrrhnoteki kg t`h Benzeimsnhbhi EE eithrmnoaeonwet`KEQ EE.
6.2. CHCNHBHI, EI V@H FEQVREAV KG IHBRO
O mrovhn noyhr, opprkxecothny ? c t`eal, wos hxpkshfkvhr o nhimt` kg 18 c ki o pnothou ki t`h skut`hri sefh t`h Xistrut vonnhy. Et wos kvhrnoyeim Horny Tnhestkahihquortz mrovhns oif akvhrhf by sknegnuateki fhpksets shvhc t`eal. V`hsh akisesthf kg rhwkrlhf sken cothreon fhrevgrkc o Ceffnh Tnhestkahih Torobrouihrfh. Bkreimss`kwhf t`h eithrgeimhreim kg t`h mrovhn wet` myttjos oifphots grkc o neciea shquhiah akitoeieim pknnhi oif pnoirhcoeis kg o cexhf `kribhoc-kol wkkf os whnn os gruetkëVropo iotois oif W/=/8 synvhstres (Coe ?500< Coieo?506). Q`hnns kg V`hkfkxus shrroteneiegkrces oif oieithrmnoaeon cknnusa grhs` wothr gouio whrh gkuif ei t`h
twk typhs kg fhpksets.Ei tkton, ?46 gneit orthgoats whrh rhakvhrhf `hrh by
Coieo oif M. Aubul ei ?5=8. V`hy ankshny rhshcbnh t`grkc ]oimhi. @hrh, tkk, t`hrh orh akrhs oif gnolhscoiugoaturhf wet` o `occhrstkih os whnn os tkkns. V`hgnolhs orh rhnotevhny t`eal wet` gnoleim oimnhs bhtwhhi?44-?68´, oif oi ovhromh vonuh kg ?21´. V`h orthgoats or28 tk ?40 cc nkim, wet` oi ovhromh sezh kg 82 cc. Onnakrhs orh hx`ousthf, oif t`hy fespnoy arufhny prhporhfstreleim pnotgkrcs, w`enh t`h tkkns fespnoy o rkum` rhtkuV`hrh orh secpnh oif fkubnå sarophrs, o troisvhrson saropoif skch fhiteaunoths oif ikta`hf pehahs (ag. ]hbhr?5==).
6.1. BENZEIMQNHBHI, FEQVREAV KG ORVHRI (BENZEIM
NHBHI E)
Vwk secpnh gnolhs, 1 tk 8 ac nkim, os whnn os o secpnhsarophr (7 ac nkim) akch grkc t`h V`hkfkxus mrovhns.Onn pehahs whrh cofh kg arhtoahkus gneit oif `orf `occastrual.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 101/342
5 ? FEHVRtA@ COIEO - V@H HNBH-QOONH RHMEKI (MHRCOIU)
6.6. BnNZEIMQNHBHI, FEQVREAV KG ORVHRI (BnNZnIMQ-
NHBHI EE, NKHQQ)
V`h thrroah trovhrteih shquhiah kg t`h ceffnh akcpnhxfespnoys t`h gknnkweim suaahsseki: ]epphr mrovhns, ? ce`eal. orh setuothf ki t`h 2= c nhvhn. Xpworfs, t`hy posskvhr eitk o mrovhnny sknegnuateki noyar oif t hi eitk nkocysknegnuateki fhbres weti nerihstkih oif fknkceth bnkals oif
esknothf phbbnhs os whnn os grkst struaturhs. V`es 14 tk 64 act`eal `krezki es akvhrhf by rhwkrlhf nkhsshs, akvhrhf by oprecory, oakneoi nkhss. Qhvhron eah whfmh mhihrotekis whrhkbshrvhf ei t`es nkhss shrehs, w`ea` es 1 tk 6 c t`eal. Ogthroi hrksekion p`osh t`h nkhss wos bnhoa`hf by o pshufkmnhy,t`hi fesshathf by o brkkl. V`h eithrmnoaeon trovhrteihprhaepetoteki `of onraofy kaaurrhf ei t`h a`oiihns kg t`hbrkkl, oif oi up tk 7 c t eal trovhrteih prkgenh subshquhitnyfhvhnkphf ki tkp kg t`hc.
Ot t`h bosh kg t`h nkhss shquhiah, anksh tk t`h sknegnuateki `krezki, o 8 ac t`eal mrhy `ucus noyhr akitoeihf opoteiothf gneit gnola.
6.8. BnNZEIMQNHBHI, EI V@H FEQVREAV KG ORVHRI
(BnNZEIMQNHBHI EE, VROWHRVEIH)
Ot t`h bosh kg t`h trovhrteih fothf tk t`h ceffnh CeffnhTnhestkahih eithrmnoaeon t`h Tonohknet`ea `krezki es prhshit.En evses ki t`h nkhss surgoah, w`ea` `os akistetuthf t`h gnotoif `krezkiton surgoah kg o s`krh thrroah kg o s`onnkw nolh,os whnn os t`h subsken kg t`h bosei aut by t`h brkkla`oiihns. Ofjoahit tk t`h s`krh thrroah, oi onnuveon goiakcpkshf kg trovhrteih soif wos fhpksethf grkc t`h whst.V`h goi oif t`h s`krh orh t`h twk typhs kg goaehsakitoeieim t`h aunturon rhcoeis, oif orh likwi ei t`hnethroturh ki Benzeimsnhbhi os t`h Qa`whccgoa`hr oif t`h
/ 'ghrbhrhea` rhsphatevhny.V`h ora`ohknkmeaon `krezki es akvhrhf by o 74 ac t`eal
A`oro nerihstkih, kvhrnoei by o akcpnhx trovhrteih shquhiahshvhron c t`eal.
Ckrh t`oi ?444 ir kg t`h coei geif `krezki `ovh bhhihxaovothf sk gor. V`h geifs shhc tk `ovh bhhi fesaorfhf oto nkaoteki ushf os o `kch bosh by horny `ucois, kaaupehfgkr o substoiteon phrekf kg tech fureim t`h worc-thcphrothcoxecuc kg t`h eithrmnoaeon.
6.8.?. Tonohk-haknkmeaon shtteim
V`h aocp seth wos setuothf ki o s`krh thrroah ot t`h hfmh
kg o s`onnkw nolh ghf by oi osahifeim lorst spreim. Anksh tkt`h seth wos t`h kutgnkw kg t`h skurah. Vk t`h whst, bh`eifet, t`h snkph kg t`h vonnhy rkså, oif tk t`h ikrt`-whst, hostoif skut`-host t`h vonnhy nkwnoif sprhof. V`h prhvoeneimvhmhtoteki kg t`es orho aoi bh eighrrhf grkc t`h gnkronrhcoeis: o nem`t. fry kol wkkf, prhfkceioitny eithrsprhofby o t`ealht kg Buxus. Chofkws wet` sarubs kg Buxus
shcphrverhis, Qyreimo jkseloho, Tyroaoit`o akaaeiho,
Tkthitenno gruateakso, Akrynus ovhnnoio, Qwefo soimueiho,
Weburiuc noitoio oif kt`hr sphaehs orh eifeaothf tkk.Aktkihosthr eithmhrrecus oif Juiephrus sobeio s`rubs mrhwki t`h snkphs kg t`h vonnhy. Fhish cexhf kol gkrhsts wet`Voxus boaaoto kaaurrhf ei t`h iorrkw vonnhy ikrt` kg t`hseth. Ei t`h vonnhy, t`ealhts kg wennkw, rhhfs, chofkw oifswocpy wkkfs prhvoenhf.
Jufmeim grkc t`h gnkron oif gouion rhcoeis, t`h anecothwos worc oif rhnotevhny fry. V`h ovhromh thcphroturh eiJoiuory wos -4.8´ tk +1´A, ei Juny +24´ tk 28´A, wet` oyhorny ovhromh kg +?4´ tk +??´A. Qhvhi ckit`s s`kwhfovhromh thcphroturhs kg ckrh t`oi +?4´A. V`h oiiuonprhaepetoteki wos opprkxecothny 044 cc.
6.8.2. Whmhtoteki
V`h ckst ecpkrtoit typhs kg vhmhtoteki whrh t`h Buxk-
_uhrahtuc. Buxk-Qyreimhtuc oif Bhrbhrefeki (Coe ?501.?500, ?505). V`hy akitoeihf chfethrroihoi oif Qkut`-HostHurkphoi sphaehs sua` os Buxus shcphrverhis, Tyroaoit`o
akaaeiho, Ahntes oustrones, Qyreimo jkseloho, Juiephrus
sobeio, Wetes synvhstres, osskaeothf wet` t`h subakiteihitonsphaehs Tkthitenno gruateakso. Gurt`hrckrh, t h gnkroakisesthf kg t`h gknnkweim sphaehs: Cora`oiteo sp.,V`hnypthres t`hnypthrkefhs. Voxus boaaoto. Teaho obeas.
_uhraus rkbus, Onius mnuteikso, Bhtueo pubasahis, Tkpunus
trhcuno, Veneo pnotyp`ynnks, Tyrus sp., Truius oveuc,
Truius pofus, Oahr aocphstrh, Oahr pshufkpnotoius,
Groxeius hxahnsekr. Bhrbhres vunmoreo, Akrynus ovhnnoio,
Qonex aeihrho, Qonex purpurho, Rubus sp., Aktkihosthr
eithmhrrecus. Arotohmus sp.. Hukiycus sp., Akrius cos,
Qwefo soimueiho, @hfhro `hnex, R`ocius groimuno,
Weburiuc noitoio, T`enofhnp`us akrkioreus, Thuahfoiuc
onsoteauc, Monhkbfknki nuthuc, T`romcerhs akccuies,Ayphroahoh, Mroceihoh, Brykp`ytoh, A`oroahoh (A`oreths
aovo) (I÷tzknf ?501).
6.8.1. Cknnusaoi gouio
V`h a`oroathrestea osskaeoteki gkuif ei t`h ora`ohknkmeaon`krezki oif trovhrteih es t`h @hneaemkio boioteao gouio wet`ei tkton 54 sphaehs (Coieo ?501). V`erty t`rhh kg t`hsh orhwkkf sphaehs. Bhsefhs @. boioteao, kt`hr skut` oif skut`hostHurkphoi sphaehs kaaur: Tomkfuneio pomkfuno. Fesaus
phrsphatevus, Ohmkpes vhrteaennus. Ep`emhio tucefo. Qphaehskg kphi thrrhei grhquhitny kaaur, eifeaoteim t`h kaaurrhiah
kg nem`t wkkfs, gkrhst sthpphs oif kphi rhmekis. Oport grkcakccki kphi mrkuif sphaehs (Tupenno cusakruc, Whrtemk
pymcoho, Vruiaothnneio ayneifreao, Wonnkieo puna`hnno.
W. akstoto) skut`hri sthpph gkrcs opphor (Vruiaothnneio
anoustrones, Ahpoho veifkbkihises, Tupenno trepneaoto). Ockimt`h oquotea gouio, V`hkfkxus shrroteneiegkrces oif t`h sioen
Bhnmroifeo mhrcoieao neveim ei skurahs prhvoen. V`h wkkfgouio es osskaeothf wet` t`h Otnoitea sphaehs Ozhao chilhoio.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 102/342
52 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
6.8.6. Kstroakf gouio
Os yht, 24 sphaehs `ovh bhhi fhthrceihf (Fehbhn oifTehtrzhieul ?504). V`h kaaurrhiah kg t`h shce-oquotea
Cearkforweiuno zecchre, tkfoy neveim ei rhmekis ihor t`hHquotkr, os whnn os o sont-wothr sphaehs, es ikthwkrt`y.
6.8.8. Whrthbronh gouio
V`h sphaehs efhitegehf orh ckstny grkc t`h ora`ohknkmeaon`krezki. V`h mrhot iucbhr kg slhnhton rhcoeis aoi bhrhnothf tk t`h `uiteim oatevetehs kg horny `kceiefs, w`enh t`hges` rhcoeis orh onsk akisefhrhf tk bh gkkf rhgush nhgt by`ucois.
Tesahs: Qenurus mnoies, Veiao teiao (@hbem ?501).Ocp`ebeo/Rhpteneo: Bugk bugk. Iotrex iotrex (B÷`ch ?505).Ovhs: @oneohtus onbeaenno (phrs.akcc. L. Gesa`hr, Bhrnei).
Cearkcocconeo: Qkrhx oroihus. Vonpo sp., Aostkrgebhr,
Vrkmkit`hreuc auvehre, Mnes mnes, Opkfhcus sp.,('nht`rekikcys mnorhknus, Cearktus orvones/C. omrhstres,
C. subthrroihus, Cearktus sp.. Orveakno thrrhstres aoiteoio,
(@heirea` ?505, ?55?).Kt`hr coccons orh: Aoies nupus, Wunphs vunphs, Xrsus
fhieimhre-sphnohus, Chnhs chnhs, Ghnes senvhstres, Toit`hro
(Nhk) sphnoho. Coaoao synvoio, Tonohknkxkfki oitequus,
Hquus cksboa`hises-touboa`hises, Feahrkr`eius lera`-
bhrmhises, F. `hcetkha`us, Qus sarkgo, Foco sp., Ahrvus
hnop`us, Aoprhknus aoprhknus, Bks precemhieus, Beski
presaus. V`h hvefhiah kg t`h kaaurhiah kg Bubonus
currhises es quhstekiobnh (Gesa`hr ?55?, Muhit`hr ?55?,Cusen ?55?o, Cusen ?55?b, Vkhpghr ?501).
O a`oroathrestea Ceffnh Tnhestkahih Tonohknkxkfki oite
quus gouio es prhshit.
6.8.7. V`h Tonohknet`ea geifs grkc BenzeimsnhbhiGovkurobnh akifetekis kg prhshrvoteki `ovh prhshrvhf
pkssebnh kaaupoteki struaturhs oif oatevety zkihs ot t`h seth.Owoeteim t`h rhsunts kg fhtoenhf top`kikcea oionyshs kg t`hseth, wh `ovh onrhofy fesahrihf shvhron potthris wet`ei t`hgeif cothreon, sua` os t`h gkuifotekis kg t`rhh secpnhfwhnneim struaturhs. Ei grkit kg t`hc, t`hrh whrh `hort`s oiftwk tk t`rhh wkrls`kps wet` oivens kg stkih kr bkih, wet`orthgoats oif groaturhf bkihs. Gurt`hr owoy grkc t`hfwhnneim struaturhs, wh fesahri o wkrls`kp zkih rhshcbneimt`h wkrls`kps gkuif ei grkit kg t`h s`hnthrs. ]et`ei t`eszkih, t`hrh es oi kvon povhf orho wet` o feochthr kg 5 c.Et akisests kg phbbnhs oif bkih gromchits kg iut tk gest-sezh.V`hrh whrh ik kbjhats gkuif nyeim ki tkp kg t`es povhforho. V`h festrebuteki kg sphaeoneshf gkrcs kg tkkns, kgfhbres rhnothf tk t`h coiugoaturh kg t`h tkkns, os whnn osbkih, oitnhr, evkry oif wkkf orthgoats es oi eifeaoteki kgt`h hxesthiah kg kt`hr orhos kg sphaegea oatevetehs. V`honnuveon goi strhta`eim ei grkc t`h s`krh-neih akitoeis t`hwosth fucp kg t`h aocp seth. V`h aocp seth es ossuchf tk
`ovh bhhi t`h `kch bosh kg o mrkup kg `kceiefs gkr skctech.
V`h orthgoats (Gem. 8) orh fegghrhiteothf oaakrfeim tk t`guiatekis. Normh phbbnh tkkns whrh cofh kg quortzeth,nechstkih oif arystonneih rkal (a`kpphr, a`kppeim tkkns,`occhrstkihs). ]et` sconn quortz `occhrstkihs rhnotevhsconn gneit tkkns (0 tk ?44 cc nkim) whrh prkfuahf: liev
boalhf-lievhs ("Lhenchsshr"), sarophrs, `oif-oxh s`ophfpkeits, Voyoa pkeits, _ueiski pkeits, fhiteaunoths oifikta`hs. V`hy orh coeiny hfmh rhtkua`hf, but begoaeon oifuiegoaeon rhtkua`hs kaaur tkk. Normh sarophrs, boalhflievhs, a`eshn-s`ophf tkkns oif oivens whrh cofh kg bkihw`enh peals oif anub-nelh tkkns whrh coiugoaturhf grkcfhhr oitnhrs. O mrhot iucbhr kg wkkf rhcoeis coyrhprhshit orthgoats: rkf-nelh, `kkl- oif spofh-s`ophfgkrcs kaaur. Qkch bkih orthgoats hx`ebet fhnebhrothnyhimrovhf shquhiahs kg neihs (Coieo oif Coieo ?500).V`h coei skurah kg gkkf wos akistetuthf by normh moch,fkceiothf by r`eikahrks (Coieo ?554< Coieo oif ]hbh?507).
6.8.=. V`h `kceief rhcoeis grkc Benzeimsnhbhi
V`h akcporotevh stufy kg t`h obuifoit `kceief rhcoeiby H. Wnahl fhckistrothf t`ot t`h Benzeimsnhbhi gkssensnormhny rhshcbnh Knfuvoe @kceief 5, Tet`haoit`rkpus WEoif Qeioit`rkpus EEE. V`es es onsk t`h aosh wet` t`h nothstgeifs grkc Benzeimsnhbhi sua` os Mn , O1 oif B=. Gkr t`esrhoski, Wnahl ottrebuthf t`hsh gromchits tk t`h CeffnhTnhestkahih gkrc kg @kck hrhatus be`eimsnhbhihises
(Coieo oif Wnahl ?551< Wnahl ?5=0, ?507, ?55?). Onn t`h`kceief rhcoeis grkc Benzeimsnhbhi, oport grkc kih cenlcknor, aoi bh ossemihf tk t`rhh fegghrhit eifevefuons.
6.7. QOA@QHIBXRM, EI V@H FEQVREAV KG ORVHRI
Ki t`h whsthri hfmh kg t`h ]epphr-Xistrut vonnhy mrovhxpkshf ei t`h shvhitehs yehnfhf o sconn shrehs kg gneit orthgoats. Oi eithrmnoaeon cknnusaoi gouio wos onsk fesakvhrhft`hrh, wet` Akrbluno gnuceiones oif V`hkfkxus shrrotenei
gkrces. V`h hxesthiah kg o Tonohknkxkfki oitequus gouio weighrrhf by bkih rhcoeis oif o tusl hxaovothf t`hrh. Ockt`h orthgoats o pkny`hfrea, arufhny prhporhf akrh oif skchsconn gnolhs wet` kbtush gnoleim oimnhs whrh prhshit.
6.=. WONNHU KG V@H MHEQHN, EI V@H FEQVREAV
CHRQHBXRMKiny o ghw orthgoats whrh fesakvhrhf ei t`h nkwhr portkg t`h L÷rbesfkrg mrovhns (Coieo oif Coe ?575). V`hywhrh gkuif ei t`h brkwi-akon ceih kg Ihucorl-Qþf oifIhucorl-Ikrf, e.h. wet`ei t`h nost rhcioits kg t`h L÷rbesfkrg mrovhns, kiah hxpkshf kvhr shvhron squorh lc. V`hshmrovhns whrh fevefhf eitk twk shquhiahs hoa` akisesteim keithrmnoaeon soify mrovhns wet` oi kvhrnyeim mnoaeon mrovhn
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 103/342
51 FEHVREA@ COIEO - V@H HNBH-QOONH RHMEKI (MHRCOIU)
Gem. 8. Benzeimsnhbhi: gneit orthgoats. Qaonh ei ac.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 104/342
56 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
akvhr. V`h shquhiahs whrh shporothf by oi hrksekion nhvhnorho oif nkhsshs akitoeieim oi oratea cknnusaoi gouio. Ocknnusaoi gouio wet` oi obuifoit kaaurrhiah kg Akrbeauno
gnuceiones wos rhakvhrhf ei t`h soify mrovhns kg t`h nkwhrshrehs, tkmht`hr wet` akccki eithrmnoaeon grhs` wothrsphaehs, skch t`hrckp`enh wkkf sphaehs oif prhfkceioitnysphaehs kg kphi thrrhei. Ockim t`h coccon gkssens rhcoeis
kg Tonohknkxkfki oitequus, Hquus sp., Feahrkr`eiuslera`bhrmhises, ahrvefs oif bkvefs whrh efhitegehf. Fhaofhsomk kol truils, peih akihs oif kt`hr pnoit rhcoeis whrhrhphothfny kbshrvhf ei t`es `krezki w`hi t`h noyhrs akvhreimt`h brkwi-akon whrh rhckvhf by t`h ceieim akcpoiehs.Xigkrtuiothny, t`hsh hxpksurhs whrh ihvhr systhcoteaonnystufehf.
Onnuveon phots oif trovhrteihs whrh prhshit ei t`h eithrmnoaeon tnuveon shfechits kg t`h upphr shrehs, yehnfeim o rea` @hneaemkio boioteao gouio, rhcoeis kg o Tonohknkxkfki
oitequus gouio os whnn os gruets oif shhfs eifeaotevh kgChfethrroihoi-subakiteihiton `kribhoc-kolwkkfs os whnnos fry kolwkkfs (Coieo oif Coe ?575). V`h whnn-likwi
orthgoats grkc t`h Akrbeauno soifs orh cofh kg gneit. V`hyakisest kg o sconn hx`ousthf fesa-s`ophf akrh oif skchscon! gnolhs. O a`uil s`kws o ikta`hf hfmh prkfuahf by opkwargun bnkw.
6.0. L×A@QVHFV, EI V@H FEQVREAV KG HnQNHBHI
Ot shvhron nkaotekis ei t`h vonnhy kg t`h Qonzlh ei t`hhosthri @or/ gkrhnoif, Ceffnh Tnhestkahih mrovhns whrhhxpkshf, ckstny akisesteim kg twk gnuveon shrehs, nelh ei t`hvonnhy kg t`h Mheshn. V`h upphr port wos o mrovhn noyhroaaucunothf fureim o aknf p`osh, mhihronny eithrprhthf ost`h horny Qooeh mnoaeon. Et akitoeihf o Coccut`us gouio
wet` Coccut`us trkmkit`hreenC. precemhieus oifAkhnkifkito oitequetotes os whnn os shvhron eah whfmhmhihrotekis. V`h nkwhr port wos o soify mrovhn bhnkimeimtk t`h Akrbeauno `krezki. Et wos kvhrnoei by o iht kg eahwhfmhs oif sknegnuateki fhpksets wet` arykturbotekis, oieifeaoteki kg oikt`hr mnoaeon (Gu`ih mnoaeon). Akrbeauno
gnuceiones kaaurrhf wet` sont wothr gkrcs sua` os t`hsioen @yfrkbeo stomikruc oif t`h sont wothr kstroakfhAyprefhes netkrones, @hthkaypres soneius oif Aoifkio
oimunoto. Kt`hr anhchits kg t`h gouio orh eithrmnoaeonoquotea gkrcs, sphaehs kg bkms oif kg vorekus ckestbektkphs, nkwnoif wkkf sphaehs oif skch t`hrckp`enhcexhf wkkf sphaehs (sphaehs kg o @hneakfkito kbvknuto-
A`ka`nkfeio noceioto gouio, Coieo ?5=1). Whrthbrothrhcoeis orh rhprhshithf by Tonohknkxkfki oitequus,
Feahrkr`eius lera`bhrmhises, Aostkr gebhr oif Hskx nuaeus
(an. Chrtei ?564).
V`h sconn shrehs kg orthgoats akitoeis gneit gnolhs, secenortk t`ksh grkc ]oimhi, Chcnhbhi oif ]onnhifkrg (Vkhpghr?57?, ?570, ?5=4).
6.5. ]ONNHIFKRG, EI V@H FEQVREAV KG CG.RQHBXRA
V`h bosh kg t`h sk-aonnhf ]onnhifkrg thrroah nkaothf ot
t`h hosthri hfmh kg t`h Qooeh vonnhy es opprkxecothny ?4 cobkvh t`h horny Qooeh mnoaeon nhvhn oif es fothf tk t`hGu`ih mnoaeon (Ruslh ?576, ?578). Gkr t`h mrhothr port, t`mrovhn akvhr, wet` o t`ealihss kg 8 c, akisests kg cothreonoaaucunothf fureim o aknf p`osh, os s`kwi by t`hakcpkseteki kg ets cknnusa gouio oif by grkst struaturhs eiets upphr port. V`h boson noyhrs kg t`h mrovhn akitoeicknnusa osskaeotekis kg o akkn thcphroth anecoth, oifTonohknkxkfki rhcoeis. V`es eifeaoths t`ot t`h boson soifmrovhns whrh fhpksethf fureim t`h troiseteki kg t`h notheithrmnoaeon tk t`h horny mnoaeon. Orthgoats gkuif ei t`es porkg t`h shateki whrh, wet`kut oiy hxahpteki, coiugoaturhfgrkc bontea gneit. Opprkxecothny ?444 kbjhats orh prhshit(Coieo ?506, ?500< Vkhpghr ?57?, ?570, ?5=4). V`hfhiufoteki rhsefuh kg t`h Hnsthreoi mnoaemhikus shfechitst`h bosh kg t`h mrovhn shhcs tk `ovh bhhi t`h skurah kg t`row cothreon, os et akitoeis o normh iucbhr kg normh gneitikfunhs. V`h orthgoats cem`t rhprhshit t`h rhcoeis kg
wkrls`kps kiah setuothf ot t`h bkttkc kg t`h vonnhy.Opprkxecothny =8% kg t`h orthgoats akisest kg gnolhs, 21%kg akrhs oif kiny 2% orh tkke pehahs wet` rhtkua`h. Qconnprhporoteki oif rhtkua` fhbres wos ikt aknnaathf, sk normhgnolhs fkceioth, wet` sezhs bhtwhhi 18 oif ckrh t`oi?44 cc, oif oi ovhromh vonuh kg opprkxecothny 74 tk=4 cc. V`h akrhs rhoa` sezhs kg ckrh t`oi ?84 cc, butckrh t`oi 04% orh sconnhr t`oi 08 cc, ckstny hx`ousthfhxhcpnors. Ckst gnolhs orh s`krt oif t`eal, errhmunornys`ophf wet` t`her akrthx kgthi ikt yht rhckvhf. V`hy `ovhnormh gnoleim oimnhs (58´ tk ?84´, ovhromh vonuh ?28´) oifwhnn prkikuiahf bunbs kg phrausseki. Nhvonnkes akrhs oswhnn os prhporhf akrhs ushf gkr t`h prkfuateki kg bnofhs
onsk kaaur, os fk gnolhs grkc sua` akrhs. Kiny o ghw gnolhtkkns orh prhshit, ckstny sarophrs. Qkch gnolhs `ovhikta`hf kr fhiteaunothf hfmhs. Qkch arufhny gnolhf tkknsrhshcbnh rkum`kuts kg `oifoxhs.
6.?4. QA@×IEIMHI, EI V@H FEQVREAV KG @HNCQVHFV
V`h nkaonety Qa`÷ieimhi (V`ehch ht on. ?551) es setuothf
ei t`h ikrt`hri rhmeki kg t`h sub-`hrzyiea bosei ikrt` kg t`@orz ckuitoeis. Et es nkaothf ei o I]-QH a`oiihn w`ea`gknnkws t`h skut`hri hfmh bosei kg t`h QtroBgurt-@hncsthftsont soffnh. Ogthr subhrkseki t`h a`oiihn a`oimhf eitk os`onnkw swocpy nolh ei w`ea` o shquhiah kg 0 c shfechi`os bhhi fhpksethf. V`h shquhiah akisests kg gevh shrehswet` ot t`h bosh neciea shfechits w`ea` troisghr eitk nkw-nyeim phots oif swocpy skens.
V`h eithrmnoaeon fhpksets ei w`ea` t`h seth Qa`÷ieimhi ?es nkaothf neh ki tkp kg t`h Hnsthreoi mnoaeon fhpksets - mrkuickroeih oif chnt wothr shfechits - oif orh akvhrhf byt`h mnoaeon shrehs kg t`h Qooneoi mnoaeoteki shisu streatk.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 105/342
58 FEHVREA@ COIEO - V@H HNBH-:
Qtufehs kg t`h gnkron oif gouion rhcoeis eifeaoth t`ot t`hnkwhr shquhiah foths tk o gunny fhvhnkphf worc thcphrothanecotea p`osh, t`h Rheisfkrg Eithrmnoaeon (Xrboi, ei V`ehchh! on. ?551< Xrboi. ei prhss). Vwk ora`ohknkmeaon `krezkiswhrh fesakvhrhf ei t`h nettkron shfechits kg t`h shquhiah kgmyttjo oif phots: o nkwhr kih nyeim ei o gnot onnuveon goi kgmyttjo soifs oif oi upphr kih ei swocpy oif phot
shfechits 2 tk 1 c `em`hr ei t`h shquhiah.
6.?4.?. Whmhtoteki
Tknnhi oionyshs by B. Xrboi yehnfhf gkur vhmhtotekip`oshs gkr t`h nkwhr shquhiah:
- p`osh no: cexhf kol-peih wkkf phrekf (wet` Ozknno
geneaunkefhs),
- p`osh nb : cexhf kol-neifhi-peih wkkf phrekf,- p`osh 2: onfhr-`ozhn phrekf,- p`osh 1: `kribhoc-peih-spruah-ger phrekf (wet Tthrk-
aoryo oif Ahntes).
Ora`ohknkmeaon geif `krezki ? bhnkims tk t`h troisetekionphrekf kg p`osh 2 oif 1, teif`krezki 2 tk t`h geion stomh kgp`osh 1.
V`h genneim up kg t`h nolh nhf tk t`h sprhof oif obuifoitkaaurrhiah kg t`h onfhr trhh< onfhr bkms fhvhnkphf. Teih oifbera` trhhs ropefny eiarhosh ei t`h shquhiahs kvhrnyeim t`h
ora`ohknkmeaon `krezkis. Hifeaotekis kg noth eithrmnoaeonakifetekis oppaor onthr o nkim `eotus aoushf by t`h genneimup kg t`h nolh. O gerst horny mnoaeon eithrstofeon es prkbobnyrhprhshithf ei t`h phot kg t`h upphr gkurt` shquhiah.
6.?4.2. Cknnusaoi gouio
O t`hrckp`enkus gouio rea` ei sphaehs wet` Chfethr-roihoi oif skut`host Hurkphoi hnhchits secenor tk t`h
@hneaemkio boioteao gouio `os bhhi rhakrfhf grkc t`hRheisfkrg (Qa`÷ieimhi ?2) Eithrmnoaeon fhpksets. @kwhvhr,
@hneaemkio boioteao `os ikt yht bhhi efhitegehf. V`hikrt`whsthri hfmh kg t`h festrebuteki kg t`h sphaehs esopprkxecothny ?8 tk 24 lc skut`-host kg Qa`÷ieimhi, eit`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih trovhrteihs kg Qa`woihbhal oc@uy oif t`h trovhrteihs kg Ksthrkfh oc Gonnsthei.Ecpkrtoit hxktea sphaehs ei t h Qa`÷ieimhi ?2 gouio orh
Ohmkpes vhrteaennus, Tomkfuneio pomkfuno, Ep`emhio
fhishstreoto, Aka`nkfeio akstoto oif Wetrho subrecoto,
oif t`h chrefekion sphaehs Vruiaothnneio anoustrones. Onnt`hsh sphaehs a`oroathresh t`h anecotea coxecuc os
corlhfny worc thcphroth wet` Chfethrroihoi eignuhiah.V`h ovhromh oiiuon thcphroturhs whrh opprkxecothny 2 tk1 fhmrhhs `em`hr t`oi ot prhshit. Ei t`h cknnusaoi gouiot`hrh es o rhnotevhny `em` prkpkrteki kg sphaehs w`ea` orheifeaotevh kg kphi thrroei - ei akitrost tk t h ankshfvhmhtoteki eifeaothf by t`h pknnhi oionyses. V`h cknnusaoigouio eifeaoths o rhnotevhny fry anecoth oif kphi wkkfs eit`h surrkuifeims kg t`h seth.
<-QOONH RHMEKI (MHRCOIU)
Ei t`h upphr shquhiah, ckrh worct` fhcoifeim hnhchitsorh cesseim. Ei porteaunor, osskaeotekis eifeaotevh kg o akknthcphroth p`osh oif wet` o `em`hr phrahitomh kg sphaehsw`ea` ei`obet kphi thrroei, kaaur. Cknnusas `ovh ikt yhtbhhi fhthrceihf grkc t`h gkurt` shquhiah. @em`hr upworfsoratea swocpy nkhss oif nkhss osskaeotekis (Gu`ih mnoaeon;)onrhofy opphor.
6.?4.1. Cocconeoi gouio
Whrthbroth rhcoeis kg ges`, rhptenhs, ocp`ebeois, berfs
oif coccons orh whnn rhprhshithf ei t`h eithrmnoaeonfhpksets.
V`h coccon gouio efhitegehf by V. voi Lkngsa`kthi,akisests kg t`h gknnkweim sphaehs: Qkrhx ceiutus, Qkrhx sp.(8. oroihus mrkup), Fhscoio sp., Vrkmkit`hreuc auvehre,
Aostkr gebhr, Nhccus nhccus, Anht`rekikcys mnorhknus,
Orveakno thrrhstres aoiteoio, Cearktus subthrroihus,
C. orvonesEC. omrhstes, C. khakikcus, Opkfhcus sp. V`hsconnhr coccon gouio es o typeaon Orveakno thrrhstres
aoiteoio-Vrkmkt`hreuc auvehre osskaeoteki, onsk fhsarebhfgkr Benzeimsnhbhi.
O fevhrsh normhr coccon gouio wet`: Xrsus sp., Cus-thnefoh, Hnhp`os (Tonohknk.xkfki) oitequus. Feahrkr`eius
lera`bhrmhises, Hquus sp., Qus sarkgo, Ahrvus hnop`us,
Aoprhknus aoprhknus oif Bks/Beski `os bhhi aknnhathf oswhnn. Rhcoeis kg bkvefs oif wenf `krshs prhvoen ockim t`hgouio `uithf.
6.?4.6. Aunturh
V`h hxaovothf orthgoats `ovh ikt yht bhhi stufehf by
@. V`ehch ei gunn fhtoen. Orthgoats (Gem. 7) coiugoaturhf kgbontea gneit, wet` o ckrp`knkmy rhshcbneim t`ksh grkc t`h
seth kg Benzeimsnhbhi, prhvoen. Gnolhs, gnoleim fhbres oif oghw secpnh akrhs whrh gkuif. Qkch `occhrstkihs kg sconnquortz oif quortzeth phbbnhs orh prhshit. Ockim t`h tkknsfhiteaunoths oif ikta`hs prhvoen. Offetekionny, `hovy-futysconn sarophrs os whnn os gnolhs wet` akivhx rhtkua`hfhfmhs, _ueiski oif Voyoa pkeits kaaur. O normh akrh wosushf os o a`kppeim tkke. V`hrh orh skch eifeaotekis t`otwkkfhi orthgoats cem`t bh prhshrvhf ot t`h seth, w`enh skchhvefhiah kg gerh es prhshit tkk.
8. AkianusekiV`h knfhst Tonohknet`ea geifs grkc t`h Hnbh-Qoonh rhmeki
foth tk t`h phrekf bht whhi t`h Hnsthreoi oif t`h Qooneoimnoaeoteki (@knsthei akcpnhx) (Vobnh ?). Rhahit eivhste-motekis s`kw t`ot t`es phrekf aoi bh fevefhf eitk t`rhh eitar-mnoaeons. V`h trovhrteih shmchits akiihathf wet` gkrchrvonnhy bkttkcs oif thrroahs orh o strkim hvefhiah gkr t`es otBenzeimsnhbhi. Et es nelhny t`ot Benzeimsnhbhi EEE es efhiteaonwet` t`h F÷cietz Eithrmnoaeon, t`h @knstheieoi akrrhspkif-eim het`hr tk Benzeimsnhbhi E kr tk Benzeimsnhbhi EE.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 106/342
57 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
>k
Yp-
Gem. 7. Qa`÷ieimhi - Rheisfkrg
V`h mnoaeons bhtwhhi t`hsh eithrmnoaeons whrha`oroathreshf by oratea akifetekis. V`h mnoaeon bhtwhhi
Ben/.eimsnhbhi EE oif Benzeimsnhbhi EEE akrrhspkifs tk t`hGu`ieoi. Onn t`hsh Ceffnh Tnhestkahih eithrmnoaeons orha`oroathreshf by porteaunor sconn vhrthbroth, cknnusaoi oifgnkron osskaeotekis (Orveakno thrrhstres aoiteoio-
Vrkmkit`hreuc auvehi-osskaeoteki, @hneaemkio boioteao-
osskaeoteki akitoeieim Ozaao chilhoio, o gnkro wet Chfe-thrroihoi oif subakiteihiton anhchits: Buxus, Qyreimro,
Ahntes oif kt`hrs).
noaeon fhpksets, gneit orthgoats. Qaonh ei ac.
V`h ckst ecpkrtoit ora`ohknkmeaon geif `krezki essetuothf ei t`h ceffnh trovhrteihs (Benzeimsnhbhi EE) kg
Benzeimsnhbhi, hvefhiah hikum` tk oboifki ets gkrchrottrebuteki tk t`h F÷cietz Eithrmnoaeon. Oaakrfeim tkrofekchtrea foths t`es trovhrteih es 184 tk 644 Lyr knf. Kit`h mrkuif kg ckrp`knkmeaon ghoturhs, t`h `kceief rhcoeihxaovothf t`hrh orh ossemihf tk o noth rhprhshitotevh kg
@kck hrhatus. V`h hxaovotekis brkum`t tk nem`t o aocp swet` fegghrhit struaturhs oif geif osskaeotekis (oatevetyzkihs).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 107/342
5= FEHVREA@ COIEO - V@H HNBH-QOONH RHMEKI (MHRCOIU)
Vobnh ?. Qtrotemrop`eaon sa`hch.
Qtrotemrop`y kg Benzeimsnhbhi
oif Qooeh Rhmeki
Mnoaeon fhpksets Eithrmnoaeon fhpksets a`oroath restea s Tonohknet`ea seths
Qooneoi Akcpnhx
Mnoaeon (]ort`eoi ) Nkhss
8-0c thrroah
Qooneoi Akcpnhx Eithrmnoaeon Benzeimsn. EW
?6c nhvhn
Ahntes
@hnex-gouio
Ihucorl-Ikrf
H`reimsfkrg
Qooneoi Akcpnhx
Mnoaeon (Qoone oi / Frhit`e oi) Mnoaeon Qhrehs Nkhss
?8-?0c thrroah
Corllnhhbhrm
Hyt`ro (Nhepzem)
@knstheieoi Akcpnhx
Eithrmnoaeon (F÷cietz-nit.) Benzeimsn. EEE
24c nhvhn
Ahntes
@hnex-gouio
@knstheieoi Akcpnhx
Mnoaeon (Gu`ih- Mnoaeon ) Nkhss
22c thrroah
]onnhifkrg
@knstheieoi AkcpnhxEithrmnoaeon Benzeimsn. EE
27c nhvhn
124-6?2 Lyr BT
Ahntes
Boioteao-gouio
Akrbeauno-gouio
Ihucorl-Qþf
Benzeimsnhbhi
Qoa`shiburm
L÷a`sthft
@knstheieoi Akcpnhx
Mnoaeon Nkhss
2=c thrroah
@knstheieoi Akcpnhx
Eithrmnoaeon (@knsthei-nit.) Benzeimsn. E
12c nhvhn
Ahntes
Boioteao-gouio
V`hkfkxus-gouio
]oimhi
Chcnhbhi
Hnsthreoi Akcpnhx
Mnoaeon (Hesthr EE;) Mnoaeon Qhrehs EE ;
18c thrroah
Hnsthreoi Akcpnhx Eithrmnoaeon ;Hnsthreoi Akcpnhx
Mnoaeon (Hesthr E kr Hesthr n+nn;) Mnoaeon Qhrehs E (+EE;)
68-84c thrroah
Onkim wet` akorsh phbbnh tkkns, rhnotevhny sconn sezhfsphaeoneshf tkkns kg gneit opphorhf. Offetekionny, orthgoats kgbkia, oitnhr, evkry oif wkkf whrh hxaovothf.
O sconn orthgoat osshcbnomh kg soify mrovhns grkc t`hXistrut vonnhy ihor ]oimhi es pnoahf eitk t`h hornehreithrmnoaeon. V`h eivhitkry kg Chcnhbhi shhcs tk bh kg t`hsoch omh. Onn t`hsh orthgoats rhshcbnh t`h Benzeimsnhbhicothreon. V`es es onsk truh gkr t`h orthgoat geifs grkc t`hRheisfkrg eithrmnoaeon grkc Qa`÷ieimhi ei t`h Ikrf`orzvkr-
noif. Ot Qa`÷ieimhi, t`hrh es opporhitny o secenor shquhiahtk t`ot gkuif ei Benzeimsnhbhi wet` t`rhh eithrmnoaeons.
V`h gneit orthgoats akceim grkc t`h Qooeh mrovhns kg]onnhifkrg orh ottrebuthf tk t`h ceffnh Oa`hunhoi. V`hyfhrevh grkc t`h troisetekion phrekf kg t`h ceffnh eithrmnoaeontk t`h Gu`ih mnoaeon. V`h normh Oa`hunhoi akcpnhx kg Corllnhhbhrm foths grkc t`h nothst port kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahiheithrmnoaeon shquhiah oif bhnkims tk t`h horny port kg t`hQooeh mnoaeon.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 108/342
50 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
rhghrhiahs
Ofreoi, ].
Oifrhh, J.
Boucoi, ].,F. Coieo
?502 Feh Ontstheizhet ei Kstwhstgonhi uif Nepph, Guifochito Rhe`a O 0, L÷ni.
?515 Fhr heszhetnea`h Chisa` ei Fhutsa`noif uif sheih Lueturhi, Qtuttmort.
?501 Feh ponoknet`esa`h Ihuguifh vki Corllnhhbhrm bhe Nhepzem, Whr÷gg. Noifhscus. Wkrmhs
Frhsfhi ?7, Bhrnei.
B÷`ch, M. ?505 Feh Ocp`ebehi- uif Rhptenehirhsth fhr Guifsthnnh Benzeimsnhbhi, Ht`ikmr. Ora`okn. Z. 1
1=4-1=0.
Ahphl, M.O.
Aknneis, F.C.
Fehbhn, L.,
@. Tehtrzhieul
?507 _uothriory Qtrotemrop`y kg t`h Mhrcoi Fhckaroteh Rhpubnea. _uothriory Mnoaeotekis eit`h ikrt`hri @hcesp`hrh, _uothriory Qaehiah Rhvehws 8, 185-176.
?570 Chtresa`hr uif typknkmesa`hr Bhwhes gþr feh Qhnbstoifemlhet fhs Oa`hunhhis uif Anoa-tkiehis ei Himnoif uif Fhutsa`noif. Jo`rhssa`r. cetthnfhutsa`h Wkrmhsa`. 82. 2=-10.
?504 Tnhestkzoih Kstrolkfhi ous fhc Trkgen fhs @kck hrhatus Guifkrths bhe Benzeimsnhbhi,
Ht`ikmr. Ora`okn. Z. 2? . 27-18.
HeMcoii, N.,
V. Nett
?552 V`h Qooneoi shquhiah ei t`h typh rhmeki (Ahitron Mhrcoiy), QH_Q Fesausseki Chhteim
?5-26.?4 ?552 ei @onnh/Qoonh, @onnh/Qoonh.
Hrf, L. ?5=1 Tknnhioionytesa`h Mnehfhruim fhs Tnhestkzois fhr Fhutsa`hi Fhcklrotesa`hi Rhpubnel,
Z.g.Mhkn. ]ess. ?, ?40=-??41.
?5=0 Tknnhistrotemrop`eh ec Mhbeht fhr sloifeiovesa`hi Whrhesuimhi, Qa`r.g. Mhkn. ]ess. 5, 5??5.
Gesa`hr, L.
Gesa`hr. L..H.]. Muhit`hr,].F. @heirea`,F. Coieo,R. Cusen,V, I÷tzkln
?55? ]enfreifhrrhsth (Bkvefoh, Ortekfoatyno. Cocconeo) ous fhc cetthnpnhestkzoihi @knsthei
Lkcpnhx vki Benzeimsnhbhi, Whr÷gg. Noifhscus. Wkrmhsa`. @onnh 66 , ?15-?6=.
?551 Wkmhn (Ovhs) uif cetthnmrkBh bes lnheih Aorievkrhi (Cocconeo) ous fhr @knsthei-
]orczhet vki Benzeimsnhbhi (V`þreimhi), Wkrtrom W. Beneeimsnhbhi-Lknnkqueuc ?-8.?2.5
ei Jhio uif Benzeimsnhbhi.
?55? Benzeimsnhbhi EW, Whr÷gg. Noifhscus. Wkrmhsa`. @onnh 66, Bhrnei.
Mro`coii, R.
Mrecc, @..F. Coieo.W. Vkhpghr
Muhit`hr, H.].
?588 V`h nkwhr ponohknet`ea seth kg Corllnhhbhrm oif kt`hr akcporobna nkaoneteas iaor Nhepzem
Vrois. Ochr. p`en. Qka. I.Q. 68 , 845-70=.
?5=6 Hei ihuhr @kceiefhiguif ei Hurkpo: Ioa`trom zuc Wkrbhrea`t þbhr Benzeimsnhbhi, Z.g.
Ora`okn. 0, ?=8-?=7.
?55? Feh Mhbessh fhr ]onfhnhgoithi vki Benzeimsnhbhi, Whr÷gg. Noifhscus. Wkrmhsa`. @onnh
66, ?65-?=6.
@hbem, ]. ?501 Feh Gesa`rhsth vki Benzeimsnhbhi, Ht`ikmr. Ora`okn. Z. 26, 880-875.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 109/342
55 FEHVR?A@ COIEO - V@H HNBH-QOONH RHMEKI (MHRCOIU)
nnaeiia`, ].F. ?505 Bekchtresa`h Xithrsua`uimhi oi Gkssenrhsthi fhs Bebhrs (Aostkr gebhr) ous t`þreimesa`hi
Vrovhrteihi, Ht`ikmr. Ora`okn. Z. 14, 156-641.
?55? Bekchtresa`h Xithrsua`uimhi oi Gkssenrhsthi fhs Bebhrs (Aostkr gebhr N.) ous fhrGuifstotth Benzeimsnhbhi. Zur bekstrotemrop`esa`hi Heikrfiuim fhr Guifstotth Benzeims
nhbhi oi @oif gkssenhr Lnheisoumhtehrh, Whr÷gg. Noifhscus. Wkrmhsa`. @onnh 66, 18-72,
=?-=5.
Nh`coii, R. ?522 Fos Fenuveuc fhs uithrhi Xistruttonhs vki Q÷cchrfo bes zur Cþifuim, J`. `onn. Whrb.I.G. 1, 05-?26.
Nh`coii, @.,R. Nh`coii
?52? Feh onthrh Qtheizhet ei Cetthnfhutsa`noif, Coiius ?1, 275-140.
Coe, F.nn. ?501 Feh gkssenh Tgnoizhiwhnt fhs eithrmnozeonhi Vrovhrteis vki Benzeimsnhbhi, Whr÷gg.
Noifhscus. Wkrmhsa`. @onnh 17, 68-?25.
?500 Heiemh hxktesa`h Mh`÷nzh ei fhi Eithrmnozeongnkrhi fhr Cetthnfhutsa`hi Gnkrhirhmeki,
Ghffhs Rhphrt. 55,6?5-67?.
?505 Feh Vrovhrteignkro vki Benzeimsnhbhi. ]hethrh Guifh uif e`rh vhmhtotekismhsa`ea`tnea`h
Bhfhutuim, Ht`ikmr. Ora`okn. Z. 14, 147-1?4, Bhrnei.
Coe. [email protected]). Coco.V. I÷tzknf,W. Vkhpghr,H. Wnahl,].F. @heirea`
?501 Benzeimsnhbhi EE, Whr÷gg. Noifhscus. Wkrmhsa`. @onnh 17, Bhrnei.
Coieo, F. ?5=1 Tonok÷lknkmeh, Gouihihitwealnuim uif Qtrotemrop`eh fhs Heszhetonthrs ec cettnhrhi Hnbh-
Qoonhmhbeht oug Mruif vki Cknnuslhimhshnnsa`ogthi, Mhknkmeh Bhe`hgt =0/=5, Bhrnei.
?5=6 Benzeimsnhbhi, Lr.Orthri. Heih ontponoknet`esa`h Vrovhrteiguifsthnnh ec i÷rfnea`hiCetthnhurkpo (Wkrbhrea`t), Z. g. Orh`okn. 0, ?8=-?=1.
?501 Feh Cknnuslhigouio fhs cetthnpnhestkzoihi Vrovhrteilkcpnhxhs bhe Benzeimsnhbhi uif e`rh
÷lknkmesa`-strotemrop`esa`h Oussomh, Whr÷gg. Noifhscus. Wkrmhsa`. @onnh 17, ?1?-?88.
?506 Zur Mhka`rkiknkmeh fhs Cetthnpnhestkzois uif heiemhr ponoknet`esa`hr Guifsthnnhi ecQooeh- uif cettnhrhi Hnbhmhbeht, Orbhets- uif Gkrsa`uimsbhrea`th zur soa`s. Bkfhifhil-
conpgnhmh 2=/20, ?1-80.
?500 Nh Tonhknet`equh oiaehi ht ckyhi fh no råmeki fh no Qooeh ht ?'Hnbh, Onnhcomih fh ?'Hst, N'Oit`rkpknkmeh 52, ?48?-?452.
?505 Qtrotemrop`eh, ×lknkmeh uif Tonoknet`eluc fhs Cetthn- uif Juimpnhestkzois ec Hnbh-Qoonhmhbeht, Ht`ikmr. Ora`okn. Z. 14, 717-771.
?554 Oug fhi Qpurhi fhs Xrchisa`hi. Feh Guifh oug fhr Qtheireiih bhe Benzeimsnhbhi,
Bhrnei.
ei prhss Ontponoknet`eluc uif grþ`hs Cetthnponoknet`eluc ec Hnbh-Qoonhmhbeht. Guifbhr. @hsshis,
(hf. N.Gehfnhr), Corburm.
Coco. F.,C. Onnhrcoii
?5=4 Zur Mnehfhruim fhs Juim- uif Cetthnpnhestkzois ec cettnhrhi Qooehton bhe Bof L÷shi,
Mhknkmeh ?5, ??7?-??01.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 110/342
?44 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Coieo, F.,F.@. Coe
?575 ]orc/.hetnea`h Cknnuslhi uif Tgnoizhirhsth ous fhc Cetthnpnhestkzoi fhs Mheshntons(sþfn. vki @onnh), Mhknkmeh ?0, 7=6-754.
Coieo. E)..
X. Coieo
?500 Fhnebhroth Himroveims ki Bkih Orthgoats kg @kck hrhatus, Rkal Ort Rhshora` 8, 5?-?4(wet` akcchits).
Coieo, F.,
H. Wnahl.X. Coieo
?551 Nothst geifs kg `kceief rhcoeis grkc t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih trovhrteih kg Benzeimsnhbh
prhshit stoth kg rhshora`, N 'Oit`rkpknkmeh, ei prhss.
Coieo, F..V. ]hbhr
?507 Benzeimsnhbhi EEE, Whr÷gg. Noifhscus. Wkrmhsa`. @onnh 15, Bhrnei.
Coieo, F.,W. Vkhpghr,H. Wnahl
?504 Benzeimsnhbhi E, Whr÷gg. Noifhscus. Wkrmhsa`. @onnh 12, Bhrnei.
Coieo, F.,C. V`kcoh,V. Nett,V. ]hbhr
?554 Ihucorl-Mr÷bhri. Bhetromh zur Jomf fhs cetthnponoknet`esa`hi Chisa`, Whr÷gg. Noifhs
cus. Wkrmhsa`. @onnh 61 , Bhrnei.
Chilh, B.
Chrtei, @.
Cusen. R.
I÷tzknf, V.
?504 ]oalhi, Hnsthr-Mnozeon, coreihs @knsthei-Eithrmnozeon uif ]oalhi-]orczhet, _uortQr
Hxlursekihi ei Qa`nhswem-@knsthei 27-18, Lehn.
?564 Fos hrsteithrmnozeonh Wkrlkcchi vki Akr`eauno gnuceiones bhe L÷a`sthft whstn. @onnh
Qooeh, Z. ƒ. Mhsa`ehbhgkrsa`uim u. Noa`noifmhknkmeh ?7, 81-0?.
?55no Feh Borhi vki Benzeimsnhbhi, Whr÷gg. Noifhscus. Wkrmhsa`. @onnh 66, 0?-?42.
?55?b Tghrfh ous Benzeimsnhbhi, Whr÷gg. Noifhscus. Wkrmhsa`. @onnh 66, ?41-?14.
?501 A`orkp`ythigrultegelotekihi vki Benzeimsnhbhi, Whr÷gg. Noifhscus. Wkrmhsa`. @onnh 17
6?-66.
Ruslh, R. ?576 Fos Tnhestkzoi zwesa`hi @onnh, Bhriburm uif Fhssou, Mhknkmeh ?1, 8=4-85=.
?578 Zur Mnehfhruim fhr @knsthei- uif Qoonhzhet ec ×stnea`hi @orzvkrnoif, Heszhetonthr uif
Mhmhiwort ?7, 00-57.
Qa`othr, F. ?505 Hei ontponoknet`esa`hr Kbhrgnoa`higuifpnotz vkc ]effhrbhrmh bhe ]hecor, Ont V`þreim
26, =-12.
Qa`woraz, @.T.,R. Mrþi,O.M. Not `oc.F. Coieo,L. Bruiioalhr
?500 V`h Benzeimsnhbhi Ora`ohknkmeaon Qeth: Ihw Foteim Hvefhiah, Ora`ohkchtry 14, 8-?=.
Qkhrmhn, ]. ?526
V`ehch, @., ?552
B. Xrboi,F. Coieo,V. voi Lkngsa`kthi
?551
Feh fenuveonhi Vhrrosshi fhr Enc uif e`rh Bhfhutuim gþr feh Mnehfhruim fhs Heszhetonthrs. Jh
Jomfbhuthrhsth uif Qtheiwhrlzhumh fhs Xrchisa`hi. Onthsth Guifsa`ea`thi Iehfhr-soa`shis ec Vomhbou Qa`÷ieimhi, Cett. Brouisa`whem. Lk`nhibhrmwarlh OM @hncsthft
u. Vka`thrmhs. ??, 1-5, @hncsthft.
Qa`÷ieimhi (Ikrf`orzvkrnoif). Heih ontponoknet`esa`h Guifsthnnh ous fhc cettnhrhi Heszhetonthr, Ora`ohknkmesa`hs Lkrrhspkifhizbnott 21 , ?6=-?71.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 111/342
?4?
Vkhpghr, W.
Ximhr, L.T.
Xrboi, ne.R. Nhi`orf,F. Coieo,B. Onbrha`t
Xrboi, B,
Wnahl. H.
]hbhr, V.
]ehmhrs, G.
]knsthft, T.
F?HVREA@ COIEO - V@H HNBH-QOONH RHMEKI (MHRCOIU)
?511 Feh mnozeonhi uif promnozeonhi Qa ktthrthrrosshi ec ceiehrhi Qooehton, Ioucburm.
?574 Fos nhtzteithrmnozeonh celrknet`esa`h Tonoknet`eluc vki Benzeimsnhbhi, Lr. Orthri, Ous-
mrobuimhi u. Guifh 8, =-??.
?57? Fos Ontponoknet`eluc ec GnuBmhbeht fhr uithrhi Qooeh uif fhr Cetthnhnbh, Mhknkmeh ?4,
8=4-808.
?570 Fos Anoatkiehi ec Qoonh-Cetthnhnbhmhbeht. Jo`rhssa`r. cetthnfhutsa`h Wkrmhsa`. 8=, ?-27.
?5=4 Qtrotemrop`eh uif ×lknkmeh fhs Tonoknet`elucs, Ththrcoiis Mhkmrop`. Cei. Hrmoizuims-
`hge 2=6, 125-622.
?501 Hei Kbhrlehghrgromchit fhs N÷whi ous fhc Vrovhrteilkcpnhx vki Benzeimsnhbhi, Lr.
Orthri, uif feh Guifsthnnhi pnhestkzoihr N÷whi ec Mhbeht fhr FFR, Whr÷gg. Noifhscus.
Wkrmhsa`. @otth 17. ?71-?=1.
?5=6 _uortor, Mhknkmeh vki V`þreimhi, =62-=02.
?55? Cetthnpnhestkzoi ec Vomhbou Qa`÷ieimhi, Nlr. @hncsthft, Z. fr. mhkn. Mhs. ?62, 18?-1=2.
ei prhss Tonyiknkmeaon hvefhiah kg Ukuimhr Ceffnh Tnhestkahih Eithrmnoaeons (@knstheieoi oifRheisfkrg oif Qa`÷ieimhi) ei t`h Qa`÷ieimhi kphi aost nemieth ceih (Hosthri Nkwhr
Qoxkiy/Mhrcoiy), Chfhfhneimhi Rejls Mhknkmesa`h Fehist 82, ?-2.
?5=0 O ihw fesakvhry kg @kck hrhatus ei Ahitron Hurkph, Jkurion kg @ucoi Hvknuteki =, 215-
28?.
?507 Nhs Oithihoifhrtonehis hi Hurkph Ahitronh ht nhur akcporeski ovha ?'@kcch fh Voutovhn.
N'Oit`rkpknkmeh 54, 841-8?1.
?55? N'@k cch gkssenh hi Hurkph Ahitronh, N'Oit`rkpknkmeh 58, 645-6=.
?5== Anoatkiehiguifh vki Chcnhbhi, lr. Ihbro, Ousmrobuimhi u. Guifh 22, ?58-?55.
?520 Fenuveonh Wkrmhsa`ea`th fhs Chisa`hi, Qtuttmort.
?518 Feh Bhzeh`uimhi zwesa`hi fhi ikrfesa`hi Whrhesuimhi uif fhi ponoknet`esa`hi Qtotekihi
vki Ikrf- uif Cennanfhutsa`noif. Coiius 2=, 2=8-20=.
Fehtrea` Coieo
Ebro`ecstrossh 25
7544 Jhio
Mhrcoiy
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 112/342
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 113/342
Mhr`orf Bkseisle = V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph:]hsthri Ahitron Hurkph
?
`knothf geifs grkc t`h Lornea` pet eifeaoth o noth HornyTnhestkahih kaaupoteki. Hxaovothf osshcbnomhs orh likwi
grkc t`h ceffnh port kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih kiworfs, otLornea` M oif Cehshi`hec. V`h Cotthr coifebnh rkum`nyfoths tk t`ot phrekf tkk. Eithrmnoaeon kaaupoteki es otthsthf,w`eth geifs grkc Lornea` @ (KEQ ?2) pkeit tk kaaupoteki kgaknf sthppea hiverkichits.
?. Mhkmrop`eaon oif mhknkmeaon boalmrkuif
?.?. MHKMROT@EAON KWHRWEH]
]hsthri Ahitron Hurkph nehs bhtwhhi t`h Onps oif t`hIkrt` Qho (Gem. ?). V`h normhst, ckst whsthrny port kg t`hrhmeki es froeihf by t`h R`eih oif ets trebutorehs. Vk t`hQKXt`host t`h rhmeki eianufhs t`h upphr froeiomh bosei kgt`h Foiubh, w`enh tk t`h ikrt`host t`h ]hshr wet` etstrebutorehs t`h Gunfo oif t`h ]hrro gkrc t`h ckst ecpkrtoitrevhr systhc.
Ei t`h skut`whst kg t`h rhmeki es t`h Xpphr R`eih mrobhi,o rhmeki kg gnot noif up tk 84 lc wefh. V`h ahitron port kgt`h rhmeki - ikrt` kg t`h revhrs Coei oif Io`h - esgkrchf by t`h R`hies` Qnoth Cosseg. V`h R`eih, tkmht`hrwet` ets trebutorehs No`i oif Ckshnnh, subfevefh t`h cosseg
eitk gkur rhmekis, t`h @uisrþal oif Vouius tk t`h skut` oift`h Heghn oif ]hsthrwonf tk t`h ikrt`. V`h ahitron R`eihrhmeki (R`hies` Q`ehnf) es uifhrmkeim o prkahss kg snkwupnegt, w`ea` `os aoushf eiarhoshf fkwiautteim by revhrs eirhnotevhny iorrkw vonnhys. Ot t`h ahitrh kg t`es rhmeki nehst`h Ihuwehf Bosei, oi orho kg nkwnoif chosureim skch24 x 14 lc, w`ea` gkrchf os o rhsunt kg o nkwhr roth kgthatkiea upnegt ot t`es pkeit.
V`h ikrt`hri port kg t`h rhmeki es gkrchf by t`h ahitronport kg t`h Ikrt` Hurkphoi Tnoei, t`h gnotnoifs kg w`ea` orhkiny eithrrupthf by t`h ikrt`hri upnoif hxthiseki kg t`hVhutkburmhr Gkrhst oif t`h ]eh`himhbermh. V`h Tnoei
hxthifs skut`worfs eitk t`h Xpnoif Zkih, ei t`h gkrc kgt`h Nkwhr R`eihnoif L÷nihr Bua`t. Ei akitrost tk t`h R`hies`Q`ehnf, w`hrh prkahsshs kg upnegt kphroth, t`h Nkwhr R`eihnoif es o rhmeki kg thatkiea subsefhiah. V`es `os nhf tk t`hfhpkseteki kg normh quoitetehs kg shfechits, ei porteaunor kgfhhp mrovhn bhfs Eoef fkwi by t`h R`eih oif t`h Chush.Ei t`h ikrt`hri Nkwhr R`eihnoif t`h Tnhestkahih fhpksetsrhoa` t`ealihsshs kg os cua` os ?,444 c.
?.2. WKNAOIEQC
Vhrteory vknaoikhs orh gkuif ei t`h @hmou rhmeki tk t`hwhst kg Nolh Akistoiah, oif ei porteaunor ei t`h @hsseoifhprhsseki, wet` t`h normh vknaoiea Wkmhnsbhrm cosseg, oifei t`h ]hsthrwonf, w`hrh t`hy eianufh t`h Qehbhimhbermagkrcoteki ihor Bkii. V`h Tnhestkahih sow t`h gkrcotekikg t`h ]hst oif Host Heghn vknaoiea gehnfs (Grha`hi ?5=7<Qa`ceialh, Nkrhiz oif Qhal ?501< Chyhr ?507). Ei t`h]hst Heghn, anksh tk Foui, orh nkaothf skch 244vknaoikhs. V`h Host Heghn vknaoiea gehnf, bhtwhhi t`h
revhrs Brk`n oif Ckshnnh, akitoeis skch ?44 vknaoikhs(Qa`ceialh ?500). Cojkr hxpnksevh vknaoiea hruptekiskaaurrhf ei t`es rhmeki skch 644,444 yhors omk (Rehfhiaonfhro), omoei ot ao. 244,444 (]h`r aonfhro) oif geionnyot ??,444 BA aon. (Nooa`hr Qhh aonfhro) (T. voi fhiBkmoorf oif Qa`ceialh ?554< Qtrhht, Boonhs oif]hieimhr ?556). V`hsh hxpnksevh hruptekis akvhrhf normhorhos kg t`h Ahitron R`eihnoif wet` puceah, os esporteaunorny anhor ei t`h aosh kg t`h ykuimhst, Nooa`hr Qhhhrupteki. V`hsh vknaoiea fhpksets orh kg cojkr ecpkrtoiahtk t`h prh`estkry kg t`h rhmeki, shrveim bkt` os a`rkiknkmeaoncorlhr `krezkis (T. voi fhi Bkmoorf oif Qa`ceialh ?500)
oif os akvhr oif prkthateki tk ora`ohknkmeaon seths. V`hgkrcoteki kg t`h iuchrkus sakreo akihs kg t`h ]hst oifHost Heghn wos o cua` nhss frocotea prkahss oif t`h thp`rofhpksets kg t`hsh vknaoikhs orh ikrconny kg kiny nkaonsemiegeaoiah. Ihvhrt`hnhss, t`h novo gnkws oif, ei porteaunor,t`h arothrs kg t`hsh vknaoikhs oif t`h govkurobnh shttnhchitnkaotekis w`ea` t`hy kgghrhf, orh onsk ecpkrtoit gkrprh`estkreh rhshora`.
?.1. MNOAEOVEKI
V`h eah kg t`h einoif mnoaeoteki ofvoiahf ot nhost tweahoarkss t`h ikrt`hri Nkwnoif Zkih os gor os t`h bkuifory kg
t`h Xpnoif Zkih (Gem. ?< ]knfsthft ?588). V`h eah ofvoiahgkrahf t`h R`eih eitk o ckrh whsthrny froeiomh systhc. Ott`h soch tech, t`h hihrmy kg t`h R`eih froeiomh systhc oift`h akiteiuon hrkseki kg t`h mnoaehr grkit prhvhithf o ckrhskut`-whsthrny eah ofvoiah (V`kch ?580). V`h nkaoteki kgt`h fegghrhit mnoaehr grkits es porteaunorny whnn prhshrvhf eit`h whsthri Nkwhr R`eihnoif ei t`h gkrc kg shrehs kgckroeihs. Ei t`h skut` kg t`h rhmeki uifhr akisefhroteki,
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 114/342
?46 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. ?. Nkwhr Tonohknet ea seths ei whsthri Ahitron Hurkph oif hxthitkg t`h Tnhestkahih mnoaeon coxecuc.
?. Lornea`< 2. Cehshi`hec< 1. Couhr< 6. Oa`hi`hec< 8. Lortstheitrovhrteih< 7. B÷iiem`hec< =. Cþizhibhrm rhmeki.
t`h onpeih mnoaehrs onsk ofvoiahf gor kut eitk t`h gkkt`enns(Thial oif Brþhlihr ?54?-45). Ei offeteki, ei skchaknfhr p`oshs, t`h Xpnoif Zkih obkvh a. 544 c KF wosonsk mnoaeothf. V`h Bnoal Gkrhst oif t`h Wksmhs, eiporteaunor, `of oi eah-aop ot t`hsh phrekfs. Ei mnoaeothfrhmekis knfhr seths `ovh ikrconny bhhi fhstrkyhf by t`hofvoiah kg mnoaehrs up tk shvhron ?44 c t`eal. Et est`hrhgkra porteaunorny ecpkrtoit t`ot o cojkr port kgwhsthri Ahitron Hurkph nehs bhtwhhi t`h onpeih mnoaehrsoif t`h ikrt`hri einoif eah, oif wos ihvhr subjhat tkmnoaeoteki.
?.6. RnWHR VHRROAHQ
Ei t`h prhshit akithxt kiny t`h revhr thrroahs kg t`hAhitron oif Nkwhr R`eih orh kg ecpkrtoiah. Ei t`h R`einoif, thrroah gkrcoteki wos `hoveny eignuhiahf by thatkioatevety. Ei t`h Ahitron R`eihnoif rhmeki kg thatkiea upnt`h fegghrhit thrroahs orh porteaunorny anhorny fhgeihf. V`@em` Vhrroah nehs `hrh ot 144 c KF, 244 c obkvh t`h
nhvhn kg t`h R`eih tkfoy. V`h Ceffnh Vhrroahs orh onskvhry `em`, bhtwhhi ?44 c oif 244 c KF, e.h. 64-?64 cobkvh t`h prhshit revhr nhvhn (Loeshr ?57?). By akitrost,thrroah gkrcoteki ei t`h Nkwhr R`eihnoif `os bhhieignuhiahf by thatkiea subsefhiah sk t`ot t`h eifevefuonthrroah gkrcotekis orh `hrh stoalhf obkvh hoa` kt`hr(Bruiioalhr, Bkhieml ht on. ?5=0< Bruiioalhr, Gorrkl` oQeferkpkunos ?502< Bruiioalhr oif Bkhieml ?501< Lnkscoii ?552).
?.8. NKHQQ
Nkhss fhpksets, ecpkrtoit bkt` gkr Tnhestkahih strote-mrop`y oif gkr t`h survevon kg ora`ohknkmeaon seths, orh w
rhprhshithf ei whsthri Ahitron Hurkph oif rhoa` fhpt`s kup tk 14 c. Vypeaon nkhss rhmekis orh t`h Xpphr R`eihWonnhy, t`h R`eih-@hsseoi Tnothou oif t`h R`heimou, t`hIhalornoif, Groiakieo oif t`h ]htthrou oif t`h @hsseoiFhprhsseki. Ei t`h Ahitron R`eihnoif, nkhss es gkuif ei t`revhr vonnhys oif ei t`h Ihuwehf Bosei. Ei t`h NkwhrR`eihnoif, nkhss a`oroathrezhs t`h skut`hri port kg t`hL÷nihr Bua`t oif gkrcs o brkof bhnt onkim t`h ikrt`hrihfmh kg t`h Xpnoif Zkih.
2. A`rkiknkmeaon grochwkrl
2.?. QXBFEWEQEKI KG V@H TNHEQVKAHIH
V`h ikrt`hri oif onpeih ckroeih shquhiahs oif t`hTnhestkahih subfevesekis boshf upki t`hc rhprhshit kinykih osphat kg Tnhestkahih p`hikchio. Gkr t`es rhoski t`hgrochwkrl kg t`es pophr es boshf upki ghoturhs rhakmiezhei t`h phremnoaeon orho, ei porteaunor t`h revhr thi-oahs oifnkhss fhpksets. Gurt`hr buenfeim bnkals orh prkvefhf bybekstrotemrop`y, thp`ro noyhrs oif obsknuth foteim cht`kfEi offeteki, fhhp sho esktkph aurvhs orh hxoceihf gkr t`hpurpksh kg supro-rhmekion akcporeski.
Eieteon oif Horny Tnhestkahih fhpksets orh porteaunornywhnn rhprhshithf ei t`h Nkwhr R`eih Bosei, w`hrh t`hy oroaahssebnh ei normh kphi aost nemieth ceihs (Bkhieml,Lkwonazyl oif Bruiioalhr ?5=2< Bkhieml ?5=0). V`hsubfeveseki kg t`h Ceffnh oif Noth Tnhestkahih es, byakitrost, whnn prhshrvhf ei t`h Ahitron R`eihnoif vknaoiearhmeki.
Kiny t`h phrekf grkc t`h hif kg t`h Horny Tnhestkahihuiten t`h noth Ceffnh Tnhestkahih es rhnhvoit gkr t`h NkwhrTonohknet`ea kg kur rhmeki. V`es phrekf es whnn rhprhshithfby t`h suphrgeaeon fhpksets kg t`h Lornea` anoy pet, anksh tk
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 115/342
?48 MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - ]HQVHRI AHIVRON HXRKTH
Lkbnhiz< gkr t`es rhoski t`h strotemrop`ea shquhiah kg t`esseth wenn shrvh `hrh os o rhghrhiah shateki (Bruiioalhr,Qtrhet oif Qa`erchr ?575< Bruiioalhr, @hnnhr oif Nkzhl?5=?< A`r. voi fhi Bkmoorf, T. voi fhi Bkmoorf oifQa`ceialh ?505< Bkseisle ?552).
2.2. V@H LORNEA@ TRKGENH
V`h bosh kg t`h Tnhestkahih shquhiah ot Lornea` esgkrchf by @em Vhrroah mrovhns fhpksethf by t`h R`eih oift`h Ckshnnh (Gem. 2). V`h uifhrnyeim R`eih goaehs mrovhnsorh mrhy, t`h upphr, Ckshnnh mrovhns orh aknkurhf rhf by t`h
Bek-strotemrop`y
®
©
b
F
®
_@ Bb
®|2×? Bo
LORNEA@
J NJN
••(gcc.
LOH-BV6157?24
LOH-FV2687 «0
LOH-FV?681?=.7?0:?1
an Coccut us , j£precemhieus £¼
Akhnkfkitkoitequetotes
Coccun`ustrkmkin`hie
| § v«;neakrie«
neYsLgeettots
o EE
en
an Coccut`ustrkmkin`hie
@eppkpktocus
ORE-FV62?8@
ORE-FV1ak 6?4
ORE-Kr 26?5*?0.68? 3 7
ORE-FV?ak 654 : : : : :s g : jy r : : : : :
OREHIFKRG
NFXV c
ro
(8h)
NX
©
NX
>F@OHQOHRVQNKHQQ j ë÷S
NF@
NFE
•y . e e f Lfrnea`hr
r&ë;:J BrkaXhitunn
Tuceah
Bosonnea os`
@ucea `krezki
Tonohkskn
\ m Y j Mrovhn
W W 'a h wh f
5h s
@eonus
\ V | \Z~| Aknf p`oshs
( t ) , D ]orc p oshs
Gem. 2. Qubfeveseki kg t`h Tnhestkahih ei t`h Ahitron R`eihnoif boshf ki t`h shatekis ot Lornea` oif
Orehifkrg.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 116/342
?47 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
eianuseki kg Ihw Rhf Qoifstkih gkuif ei t`h rhmekifroeihf by t`es revhr. Bhtwhhi t`h twk mrovhn goaehs es oiennuveothf soif noyhr. V`h comihtea gehnf es rhvhrshf ei t`esnoyhr, but ikrcon ei noyhrs obkvh t`h kvhrnyeim Ckshnnhmrovhns, pnoaeim t`h Cotuyoco-Brui`hs bkuifory ei t`hnhvhn kg t`h Ckshnnh mrovhn goaehs (Bkhieml, @hyh ht on.
?5=6< Bruiioalhr, Bkhieml ht on. ?5=7). V`es corls t`h
bkuifory kg t`h Horny oif Ceffnh Tnhestkahih ot =04 Lyr BToif nonns wet`ei Kxymhi Esktkph Qtomh (KEQ) ?5. Venthfshfechits (Noyhr O) whrh prhshrvhf kiny nkaonny bhnkw t`h@em` Vhrroah shquhiah. V`hy akisest kg ikrconnycomihtezhf mrovhn, soif oif nkhss fhpksets w`ea` pkssebnyfoth tk t`h Jorocennk Hvhit ot 544 Lyr BT (KEQ 21). Oiecpkrtoit pehah kg bekstrotemrop`ea hvefhiah es t`h prhshiahei t`hsh noyhrs kg @eppkpktocus, w`ea` onsk gerst opphors otkt`hr Ahitron Hurkphoi nkaonetehs fothf tk t`h JorocennkHvhit (Lo`nlh ?508< ei prhss).
V`h "cexhf mrovhns" ot t`h tkp kg t`h R`eih mrovhn goaehs(Leernea` Bo) orh ogghathf by eah whfmh pshufkckrp`s oif
arykturboteki ghoturhs. V`es es t`h knfhst hvefhiah ei t`hAhitron R`eianoif gkr o prkikuiahf aknf p`osh wet`phremnoaeon p`hikchio, foteim tk t`h hif kg t`h HornyTnhestkahih oif hquevonhit tk KEQ 24. V`h @em` Vhrroahmrovhns (Leernea` B) orh gknekwhf by o gnkkf nkoc (Noyhr A)oif t`hi by nkhss fhpksets. V`h tkp kg Noyhr A es corlhfby o whol sken gkrcoteki. Qtrotemrop`eaonny ecpkrtoit es t`hprhshiah ei Noyhr A kg Ceckcys soveie (Woi Lkngsa`kthi,Rkt` oif Vurihr ?554< Woi Lkngsa`kthi oif Vurihr, eiprhss). V`h kvhrnyeim Nkhss F es pkkrny fhgeihf oif iktosskaeotaf wet` o sken gkrcoteki< gouio! rhcoeis orh vhryrorh.
Obkvh t`es gknnkws o boifhf aknnuveon fhpkset, Noyhr H.
Noyhrs F oif H orh shporothf by o anhor bkuifory, w`ea`summhsts t`ot hrksekion prkahsshs whrh oatevh oif rhprhshitso pkssebnh `eotus ei t`h shquhiah. Noyhr H akitoeisiuchrkus cknnusaoi rhcoeis a`oroathrestea kg aknf stomhhiverkichiton akifetekis. V`h bosh kg t`h strotemrop`eaonny`em`hr Nkhss G s`kws hvefhiah kg rhfhpkseteki. Eiporteaunor. sconn, rhffes`-brkwi quortz phbbnhs wet`ei t`hnoyhr `ovh bhhi fhrevhf grkc Vhrteory "Lehshnkknet`"thrroahs. Nkhss G es usuonny ponh yhnnkw ei aknkur oif t`htkp s`kws o anhor sken fhvhnkpcait. Tost out`krs `ovhfhsarebhf o bosontea os` wet`ei Nkhss G os t`h knfhstvknaoiea noyhr prhshit ei t`h Leernea` shquhiah, `kwhvhr,
t`es thp`ro wos ikt nkaothf by kur rhahit eivhstemotekis.Nkhss G akitoeis rea` gouion rhcoeis (Woi Lkngsa`kthi,
Rkt` oif Vurihr ?554< Vurihr ?554, ?55?< WoiLkngsa`kthi oif Vurihr, ei prhss). Eithrhsteim ei t`hcoarkgouio es t`h prhshiah kg Chmonkahrks vhrteakries oift`h efhitegeaoteki kg hnhp`oit cknors os Ora`efeslkfki
chrefekiones. V`h prhshiah ei t`h cearkgouio kg Ceckcys
soveie es ecpkrtoit. Nkhss G es t`h ykuimhst noyhr ei w`ea`
Ceckcys soveie kaaurs< ei noyhrs obkvh t`es, t`h sphaehs Orveakno thrrhstres aoiteoio kaaurs. V`es bekstrotemrop`eabkuifory, w`ea` a`oroathrezhs t`h hif kg t`h Be`oreoi(Coun ?554), corls t`h hif kg t`h hornehr port kg t`h CefTnhestkahih (Woi Lkngsa`kthi ?554o).
O strotemrop`eaonny ecpkrtoit a`oimh ei t`h sphatruc k`hovy ceihrons es rhakmiezobnh ei Noyhr G. Fhhphr noyhrs
orh fkceiothf by t`h `hovy ceihrons zeraki, rutenh oifmrhhi `kribnhifh, w`ea` orh fhrevhf grkc t`h R`eihmrovhns< t`h kvhrnyeim noyhr akitoeis sphatro kg vknaoieakremei fkceiothf by brkwi `kribnhifh (Zepthr ?55?).Nkhss G es akrrhnothf wet` KEQ ?7, ets sken fhvhnkpchit wKEQ ?8. V`h upphr port kg t`h gknnkweim Nkhss M es a`orhrezhf by o prkikuiahf sken fhvhnkpchit - o cojkr corl`krezki ei t`h Leernea` shateki. V`h nkwhr port kg t`h nkhsakitoeis o `hoveny whot`hrhf bosontea thp`ro (Loh-BVn)kremeioteim grkc o vknaoik kg uilikwi omh oif nkaoteki(A`r. voi fhi Bkmoorf, T. voi fhi Bkmoorf oif Qa`ceia?505). Leernea` M akitoeis o rea` cearkgouio. Qtrotemrop`eaonny ecpkrtoit es t`h prhshiah kg Orveakno thrrhstres
aoiteoio, o sphaehs a`oroathrestea kg t`h ahitron port kg t`Ceffnh Tnhestkahih. V`h coarkgouio akitoeis r`eikahrks(Feahrkr`eius sp.) oif Chmonkahrks vhrteakries (Woi Lksa`kthi, Rkt` oif Vurihr ?554).
]`hrhos t`h vknaoiea `hovy ceihron sphatruc kg Noyhres fkceiothf by brkwi `kribnhifh, t`h kvhrnyeim Noyhr @`os o sphatruc kg vknaoiea `hovy ceihrons fkceiothf bypyrkxhih (Zepthr ?55?). V`es a`oimh ei t`h `hovy ceihrosphatro es strotemrop`eaonny ecpkrtoit oif onnkws, gkrhxocpnh, t`h seth kg Cehshi`hec E tk bh fothf tk bhtwhhiLeernea` M oif @ (shh bhnkw). V`h sken fhvhnkpchit kgLeernea` M es akrrhnothf wet` KEQ ?1. Nkhss @ akitoeis tw
vknaoiea fhpksets (Gem. 1). Ei porteaunor, t`h puceah (Loh-FV?) oif kvhrnyeim bosontea thp`ro (Loh-BV2) ot t`h boshkg Noyhr @ gkrc oi ecpkrtoit corlhr `krezki, w`ea` es ogkuif kvhrnyeim t`h Cehshi`hec E ora`ohknkmeaon seth.Ceihronkmeaon oionyses s`kws t`ot t`h thp`ro Loh-FVnkremeioths grkc oi hrupteki ahitrh kg stenn uilikwi nkaoteObsknuth foteim (64Or/15Or seimnh aryston noshr foteim)mevhs o coxecuc omh gkr t`es thp`ro kg 7?0 Lyr BT (T. vfhi Bkmoorf, @onn ht on. ?50=< A`r. voi fhi Bkmoorf,T. voi fhi Bkmoorf oif Qa`ceialh ?505). Ki t`h hvefhikg t`h Lþrnea` shateki oif t`h bekstrotemrop`ea rhakrf ot kt`seths t`es coxecuc omh opphors tk bh skch ?44,444 yhors
tkk knf oif o akivhitekion foth (64Or/15Or sthp-`hoteim) 681 ¿ = Lyr BT opphors ckrh prkbobnh (Neppknt ht on.
?507< Wknnbrha`t ?552). Qnem`tny `em`hr ei Leernea` Noyhr o puceah noyhr (Loh-FV2) kg up tk ? c ei fhpt` nehsecchfeothny obkvh o t`ei bosontea thp`ro. V`h tkp kg t`hpuceah noyhr es eithrrupthf by eah whfmh pshufkckrp`s.Vhp`ro Loh-FV2 es ceihronkmeaonny secenor tk t`h Loh-FVthp`ro fhsarebhf obkvh oif `os bhhi fothf by t`h 64Or/
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 117/342
?4= MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - ]HQVHRI AHIVRON HXRKTH
E
8 LohYBVX 1~57¿24Y
* g * &
•2***£9
eQþgQghw;
Gem. 1. Wknaoiea os` ei Lornea` Nhvhn @. wet` t`her coxecuc omh boshf ki 64Or/15Or seimnh aryston noshrfoteim (shh thxt).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 118/342
?40 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
15Or seimnh aryston noshr cht`kf tk 687 ¿ 0 Lyr BT.Lornea` @ es aopphf by o sken akitoeieim s`hnns kg thcphrothcknnusaoi sphaehs (Rhcy ?585< Woi Lkngsa`kthi, Rkt` oifVurihr ?554< Rkt`, ei prhss o) oif t`h ecprhssekis kgnhovhs (efhitegehf es o sphaehs kg copnh) oif shhfs kg Ahntes
(Nkzhl ?5=?). V`h rea` cknnusaoi gouio es a`oroathrestea kgoi eithrmnoaeon p`osh wet` snem`tny ckrh Akiteihiton
akifetekis t`oi ot t`h prhshit foy (Rkt`, ei prhss o). V`essken es shonhf by t`h "Lornea` Brkalhitugg" (Loh-BV6).V`es es o pkkrny skrthf fhpkset fhrevhf grkc oi hrupteki eit`h ecchfeoth veaeiety kg t`h seth, w`ea` ot t`es pkeit brklht`rkum` bkt` t`h uifhrnyeim Fhvkieoi bhfrkal oif onskVhrteory anoy noyhrs oif Tnhestkahih Xpphr Vhrroah mrovhns.Bnkals kg onn t`hsh cothreons gkrc t`h tugg reim kg t`h"Lornea` Brkalhitugg", w`ea` `os bhhi fothf by t`h64Or/15Or seimnh aryston noshr cht`kf tk 157 ¿ 24 Lyr BT.V`h ceihronkmeaon akcpkseteki kg t`h thp`ro s`kws t`ot etfhrevhs grkc t`h Rehfhi hruptekion p`osh. V`h hrupteki kgt`h Lornea` Brkalhitugg kaaurrhf tkworfs t`h ceffnh kg oieithrmnoaeon w`ea` cem`t bh hquothf wet` KEQ ??. V`h gerstport kg t`es eithrmnoaeon es rhprhshithf by t`h sken gkrchfupki Lornea` Noyhr @. Fhpksets grkc t`h shakif `ong kgt`es eithrmnoaeon orh prhshrvhf ei t`h skut`host kg t`hLornea` anoy pet ei o fhprhsseki gkrchf subshquhitny tk(oif prkbobny os o rhsunt kg) t`h hrupteki kg t`hBrkalhitugg. V`hsh shfechits akitoei t`h ora`ohknkmeaonseth Lornea`-Qhhughr (shh bhnkw). ]et` t`h hxahpteki kgt`es fhprhsseki, ei w`ea` ykuimhr fhpksets orh prhshrvhf,t`h Brkalhitugg rhprhshits t`h succet kg t`h shquhiah otLornea`. Obkvh t`h precory Brkalhitugg fhpkset orh gkuifkiny t`ei fhpksets kg Nost Mnoaeon nkhss oif Nooa`hr Qhhpuceah.
2.1. V@H OREHIFKRG TRKGENH
Ecpkrtoit nkr t`h ykuimhr port kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahihes t`h seth kg Orehifkrg (Bruiioalhr, N÷`r ht on. ?5=8<@ohsohrts ?554< Bkseisle ?552). Ot t`h Orehifkrg mrovhnquorry t`h Fhvkieoi snoth bhfrkal es kvhrnoei by o 14 cfhpkset kg R`eih Ceffnh Vhrroah mrovhns (NhubsfkrgVhrroah), gknekwhf by o shquhiah kg nkhss fhpksets oifponohkskns (Gem. 2). V`h upphr port kg t`h gnuveotenhshquhiah akitoeis o `hoveny whot`hrhf oif arykturbothfpuceah fhpkset (Ore-FVn), w`ea` es fothf tk a. 654 Lyr BToif es pkssebny hquevonhit tk t`h Lornea` puceah Loh-FVn.@em`ar ei t`h shquhiah twk gurt`hr puceah noyhrs akvhr osken gkrcoteki. V`h nkwhr puceah fhpkset (Ore-FV2) `os ocoxecuc omh (64Or/15Or seimnh aryston noshr foteim) kg68? ¿ 7 Lyr BT. V`h upphr thp`ro (Ore-FV1) es skch4.04 c t`eal oif akitoeis iuchrkus ecprhssekis kg nhovhs.Et tkk wos fothf by t`h 64Or/15Or seimnh aryston noshrcht`kf tk opprkxecothny 6?4 Lyr BT (T. voi fhi Bkmoorfoif Qa`ceialh ?554) oif, offetekionny, by akivhitekion
64Or/15Or sthp-`hoteim (t`h socpnh es onckst ahrtoeiny OFV2) tk 6?5 ¿ ?0 Lyr BT (Neppknt ht on. ?507).
T. voi fhi Bkmoorf oif Qa`ceialh (?554) pkeit kutt`ot bkt` t`h Orehifkrg thp`ro Ore-FV2 oif Ore-FV1 oift`h Lornea` Brkalhitugg (Loh-BV6) aoi bh ossemihfceihronkmeaonny oif a`hceaonny tk t`h Host Heghn Rehfhihruptevh p`osh. V`h vknaoiea fhpksets ot bkt` Lornea` oif
Orehifkrg whrh hrupthf fureim oi eithrmnoaeon. V`hshormuchits - soch hruptevh p`osh, secenor omh, eithrmnoaeonakithxt - colh et pnousebnh tk rhmorf bkt` t`h Lornea`Brkalhitugg (Loh-BV6) oif t`h Orehifkrg thp`ro noyhrs OFV2 / Ore-FV1 os fhpksets grkc t`h soch eithrmnoaeon,prkbobny KEQ ??. Ki t`es boses et es pkssebnh tk syit`hsezht`h shatekis ot Lornea` oif ot Orehifkrg (Gem. 2). V`h gkur(;) Orehifkrg nkhss bhfs t`us akrrhspkif tk t`h ykuimhrport kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih oif t`h Noth Tnhestkahih. Vfhhphst nkhss ("@ohsohrts nkhss"< Gem. 2) akunf bhnkim tkKEQ ?4, t`h sken ki tkp kg et tk KEQ 5. Grkc t`es nkwhr pokg t`h Orehifkrg shquhiah t`hrh orh ik ora`ohknkmeaon geifEi t`h whsthri port kg Ahitron Hurkph kiny orthgoats grkct`h Lortsthei trovhrteih (shh bhnkw) akunf foth tk t`es geiostomh kg t`h Nkwhr Tonohknetea (KEQ 5). Ora`ohknkmeaoncothreon grkc t`h bosh kg t`h t`erf Orehifkrg nkhss bhf(KEQ 0) aoi onrhofy bh ossemihf tk t`h bhmeiieim kg t`hCeffnh Tonohknet`ea.
1. Hornehst troahs kg `ucoi kaaupoteki
V`h knfhst hvefhiah gkr `ucoi prhshiah foths tk t`h hikg t`h Horny Tnhestkahih oif tk t`h knfhst (Ceckcys sovei
gouio) port kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih. V`h cothreon akiseshxanusevhny kg seimnh, aknnhathf geifs kg net`ea cothreonwet`kut gurt`hr akithxtuon eigkrcoteki.
1.?. LORNEA@ O
L. ]þrmhs gkuif t`rhh quortzeth phbbnh tkkns ei t`h soinkhss-nkoc kg Lornea` Noyhr O (]þrmhs ?507< Wknnbrha`t?552). Onn t`rhh orthgoats orh gnolhf ki kih surgoah kiny, ea`kpphrs (Gem. 6). Kih sphaechi `os subshquhitny spnetonkim o quortz vhei. O tkkt` gromchit kg @eppkpktocus
akchs grkc t`h soch strotemrop`eaon uiet (Vurihr ?554:?55?). V`h geifs akunf bh akithcpkrory wet` t`h JorocennHvhit oif akrrhnothf wet` KEQ 21.
1.2. LORNEA@ BO
Ot t`h bosh kg t`h R`eih mrovhn shquhiah kg t`h @em`Vhrroah (Bo) L. ]þrmhs fesakvhrhf oi orthgoat coiugoa-turhf kg troa`ytea tugg (]þrmhs ?507< Wknnbrha`t ?552). V`pehah es o akrh s`kweim shvhron gnolh saors oif aoi bhossemihf tk o noth p`osh kg t`h Horny Tnhestkahih. Et es knfht`oi t`h prkikuiahf aknf p`osh (hquothf wet` KEQ 24)s`kwi by phremnoaeon oatevety ot t`h succet kg t`h R`eihMrovhn goaehs (Bo).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 119/342
?4') MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - ]HQVHRI AHIVRON HXRKTH
Gem. 6. Lornea` O. Thbbnh tkkns.
Qaonh ei ac.
Ogthr ]þrmhs (?507) oif Wknnbrha`t
(?552).
O iucbhr kg stkihs (orthgoats;) gkuif by L. Qa`cufh ei@em` Vhrroah mrovhns ei t`h Nkwhr R`eihnoif pkssebnybhnkim tk oi hquevonhit phrekf (Qa`cufh ?552).
1.1. LORNEA@ BB
L. ]þrmhs aknnhathf hem`t orthgoats kg rhffes`-brkwiquortzeth grkc t`h surgoah kg t`h Ckshnnh mrovhn goaehs(]þrmhs ?507< Bkseisle ?552< Wknnbrha`t ?552). V`horthgoats orh snem`tny rknnhf oif orh fhrevhf grkc o nkaonetygurt`ar upstrhoc. V`hrh orh twk akrhs, gkur gnolhs, o••pabbnh-sarophr" oif o peal-nelh tkke (Gem. 8). Qhvhron
bkihs oif thht` kg o fhhr (Ahrvus sp.) oif o bkveih(Bks/Beski) whrh gkuif ei o akcporobnh strotemrop`eaonpkseteki (Vurihr ?55?). V`hsh geifs orh ossemihf tk t`h
eieteon p`osh kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, skki ogthr t`hCotuyoco-Brui`hs bkuifory w`ea` es nkaothf ei t`hCkshnnh mrovhns (Bb).
Orthgoats aknnhathf by N. Gehfnhr oif O. vki Bhrm grkct`h surgoah kg t`h @em` Vhrroah orkuif Lkbnhiz orh pkssebnybrkofny akithcpkrory (Bhrm oif Gehfnhr ?501< ?50=<Gehfnhr ?55?). Ockim t`hsh quortz oif quortzeth orthgoatsorh ikt kiny phbbnh tkkns, gnolhs oif akrhs, but onsk begoahs.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 120/342
??4 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 8. Lornea` Bb. Thbbnh sarophr (?), gnolh (2), akrh (1) oif peal-nelh orthgoat kg quortzeth (6). Qaonh ei ac. Ogthr ]þrmhs (?507) oif Wknnbrha`
(?552).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 121/342
EEE MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - ]HQVHRI AHIVRON HXRKTH
6. Qeths grkc t`h horny Ceffnh Tnhestkahih
V`es port kg t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea es fhgeihf osakcpreseim t`ksh geifs fothf tk t`h gerst port kg t`h
Orveakno thrrhstres aoiteoio gouion stomh, hquevonhit tkKEQ ?6-?2.
6.? . LORNEA@ M
Kvhr o phrekf kg tech ?6 orthgoats kg quortz oif quortzeth`ovh bhhi gkuif (coeiny by L. ]þrmhs) ei Lornea` noyhr M(]þrmhs ?55?< Wknnbrha`t ?552). V`h pehahs akcpresh t`rhh
akrhs, gevh gnolhs, kih anhovhr-nelh oif twk bkrhr-nelh tkkns(Gem. 7). Iuchrkus bkihs kg normh coccons whrh onskgkuif ei noyhr M, eianufeim Feahrkr`eius sp., Hquus sp.,
Onahs sp.. Foco sp., Chmonkahrks vhrteakries oif Bks kr Beski (Vurihr ?55?). V`h shfechits kg Noyhr M orhakrrhnothf wet` KEQ ?6 oif ?1. V`her `hovy ceihronsphatruc es fkceiothf by brkwi `kribnhifh, sk tneot
orthgoats grkc Lornea` M orh knfhr t`oi t`ksh grkcCehshi`hec E, w`hrh pyrkxhih onrhofy fkceioths ei t`hprk genh.
Gem. 7. Lornea` M. _uortz (?-1, =) oif quortzeth orthgoats. Qaonh ei ac. Ogthr Wknnbrha`t (?552).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 122/342
??2 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
6.2. Cnn-QHI@HEC E
Cehshi`hec E wos eivhstemothf uifhr t`h ferhateki kgH. Vurihr grkc ?502-?55?. V`h seth nehs ki t`h snkph kg t`hIhtth vonnhy, skch 8 lc grkc t`h Lornea` anoy pet(Bksa`heihi, Bkseisle ht on. ?506< Bkseisle, WoiLkngsa`kthi oif Vurihr ?500< Woi Lkngsa`kthi ?554b<Vurihr, ei prhss). V`h seth kremeionny noy anksh tk o s`onnkw
bkfy kg wothr, pkssebny oi knf choifhr kg t`h R`eih. V`hgeifs orh nkaothf ei o forl, krmoiea "oickkr" shfechit(Noyhr G) oif ei t`h mrhy-yhnnkw nkoc (Noyhr M)ecchfeothny uifhrnyeim t`es (Gem. =). @em`hr ei t`h shateki
TRKGEN
eeëëeeeëegenëeeeeëe'
eeeeeeeie
. • . - . • • / • Y " • •:
Ceh-BV ?Ceh-FV ?
akI
K
"K
a
>&9•>;9
Gem. =. Efhonezhf shateki ot Cehshi hec E., tkton `hem`t opprkxecothny8 c. Ogthr H. Vurihr.
orh gkuif o puceah (Ceh-FVn) oif o bosontea thp`ro (CehBV ?) w`ea` ankshny rhshcbnh thp`ro noyhrs ei Lornea` Noy@ (Loh-FVn oif Loh-BV2 rhsphatevhny). V`h Lornea` thp`ovh oi efhiteaon ceihronkmeaon oif a`hceaon akcpksetekitk t`ksh ot Cehshi`hec E (T. voi fhi Bkmoorf oifQa`ceialh ?554) oif orh fothf ot t`h gkrchr seth tk 7?0 ?0 Lyr (coxecuc omh) oif 681 ¿ = Lyr BT. Qeiah t`h
Cehshi`hec E `hovy ceihron sphatruc es fkceiothf bypyrkxhih oif t`hrhgkrh ykuimhr t`oi Lornea` Noyhr M(w`hrh brkwi `kribnhifh es fkceioit), Cehshi`hec E esossemihf tk o p`osh bht whhi Lornea` M oif @. V`h sethprkbobny bhnkims ei t`h soch eithrmnoaeon fureim w`ea` t`t`eal sken gkrchf ki Lornea` Noyhr M oif w`ea` aoi bhakrrhnothf wet` KEQ ?1.
V`h rea` cknnusaoi gouio (Rkt`, ei prhss b) fhckistrotoi eithrmnoaeon anecoth, skchw`ot ckrh Akiteihiton t`oi ott`h prhshit foy. Ei offeteki et s`kws t`h nkaon prhshiah kgwhtnoif wet` stoifeim wothr, swocp-nelh boils oif pota`kg gkrhst. V`h obuifoit sconn coccon rhcoeis akigerc t`
peaturh (Woi Lkngsa`kthi, ei prhss). Bhovhr (Aostkr gebhr)oif hxteiat meoit bhovhr (Vrkmkit`hreuc auvehre) coy `ovgurt`hr akitrebuthf tk t`h prhshiah kg whtnoif akifetekiswet` t`her focs. Ihkcys ag. ihwtkie, Qkrhx soveie,
Fhscoio sp. oif Orveakno thrrhstres aoiteoio ei`obethf t`whtthr ports kg t`h s`krhneih, Qaeurus sp., Hnekcys
quhraeius, Cusaorfeius ovhnnoioreus, Anht`rekikcys
mnorhknus oif Opkfhcus synvoteaus kaaurrhf ei ofjoahitwkkfnoif.
V`h sconn coccon gouio grkc Cehshi`hec E aoi, eioffeteki, bh ossemihf tk t`h ahitron Ceffnh Tnhestkaaih Or
akno thrrhstres aoiteoio - Qkrhx (Frhpoikskrhx) sp. Akiaurhit-roimh-subzkih (Woi Lkngsa`kthi ?554< ei prhss o).
V`h normh coccon sphatruc es a`oroathrestea gkr oi hornCeffnh Tnhestkahih eithrmnoaeon. V`es es porteaunorny truh kgt`h sphaehs Aoies cks`oa`hises, Hquus cks`oa`hises oifXrsus fhieimhre (Vurihr, ei prhss). Ot t h soch tech, t`hgouio rhvhons fhtoens kg hiverkichiton akifetekis anksh tkt`h seth. Rkh fhhr (Aoprhknus aoprhknus) oif rhf fhhr(Ahrvus hnop`us) fkceioth t`h gouio. V`h prhshiah kg `kr(Hquus cks`oa`hises) s`kws t`ot kphi mrossnoif orhos whonsk prhshit.
Kg porteaunor eithrhst es t`h top`kikcea eivhstemoteki kgt`h seth (Vurihr, ei prhss). Rkh fhhr es fhgeiethny rhprhshithby ot nhost 5 eifevefuons (1 juvhienhs oif 7 ofunts), but t`h
spoteon festrebuteki kg t`h cothreon summhsts t`ot ot nhost ?1eifevefuons cem`t bh rhprhshithf. V`h shoski kg fhot` kg tykuim oiecons wos bhtwhhi Oumust oif t`h weithr ckit`Tkssebny t`h bkihs rhprhshit t`h rhcoeis kg o normh mrkup koiecons w`ea` whrh lennhf (;) `hrh. Rhf fhhr es rhprhshithby ot nhost 7 eifevefuons (2 juvhienhs oif 6 ofunts). V`h omstruaturh oif spoteon festrebuteki kg t`h cothreon summhstst`ot t`es coy bh o "`orhc" kg ghconhs oif ykuim oiecons
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 123/342
??1 MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - ]HQVHRI AHIVRON HXRKTH
Gem. 0. Cehshi hec E. O: Rhcoeis kg t`h "porteon aoraoss", Rkh fhhr F os gkuif fureim hxaovoteki, B: Rhcoeis kg t`h "porteon aoraoss" Bkvef
B, os gkuif fureim hxaovoteki (grkc: Vurihr, ei prhss).
lennhf (;) `hrh ei outuci kr weithr. @krsh es rhprhshithf byot nhost gkur eifevefuons. V`h omh struaturh kg t`h cothreonsummhsts t`ot o "goceny mrkup" es rhprhshithf. Ei t`h aoshkg t`h fhsarebhf sphaehs - rkh fhhr, rhf fhhr oif `krsh -t`h necb bkihs oif slunns (wet` thht`) orh onwoys prhshit,w`hrhos anhchits kg t`h rucp (rebs oif vhrthbroh) orh rorhny
rhprhshithf (Gem. 0). O secenor festrebuteki es kgthi prhshitki Ceffnh oif Xpphr Tonohknet`ea seths ei t`h AhitronR`eihnoif oif prkbobny rhgnhats o shnhateki gkr chot-bhoreim ports by `ucois. O bkveih aoraoss ot Cehshi`hec Es`kws o akcpnhthny fegghrhit festrebuteki potthri (Gem. 0):onckst onn ports kg t`h slhnhtki orh prhshit ei t`h aosh kg
Gem. 5. Cehshi hec E. Orthgoats kg nyfeth (?), quortz (2) oif quortzeth (1). Qaonh ei ac. Ogthr H. Vurihr.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 124/342
??6 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
t`es knf eifevefuon, w`ea` coy pnousebny `ovh fehf ioturonnyei t`h swocpy wothrsefh setuoteki.
Fuh tk geih-strotemrop`eaon oionyses et opphors t`ot t`hkvhrmrkwi boils kg t`h Tnhestkahih R`eih whrh rhphothfnyt`h saàih kg `ucoi `uiteim hpeskfhs. Fureim kih sua`hpeskfh o goieeny mrkup kg gkur `krshs wos lennhf<subshquhitny o mrkup kg ?1 rkh fhhr oif o `hrf kg sex rhf
fhhr whrh onsk suaahssgunny `uithf. Ei offeteki, et espkssebnh tk fhckistroth t`h prhshiah ot t`h seth kg oieconsw`ea` fehf ioturonny (s`kwi porteaunorny anhorny ei t`h aoshkg o bkveih) oif whrh t`hi saovhimhf by aorievkrhs. V`hnet`ea osshcbnomh es coiugoaturhf grkc cothreons w`ea` aoibh gkuif ei t`h orho, sua` os quortz, quortzeth oif nyfeth.V`h prhshiah kg akrhs oif rhgetthf orthgoats s`kws t`ot ckstorthgoats whrh prkfuahf ot t`h seth (Gem. 5). O gnolh kg nyfethoif o normh gnolh kg geih-mroeihf Vhrteory quortzeth opphor,`kwhvhr, tk `ovh bhhi brkum`t tk t`h seth ei t`her prhshitgkrie. V`h notthr pehah (Gem. 5.1) es rhtkua`hf ot t`h fkrsonbkrfhr kg t`h streleim pnotgkrc oif es t`h kiny ckfegehf
orthgoat ei t`h sconn osshcbnomh. V`h orthgoats `ovh osecenor spoteon festrebuteki tk t`ot kg t`h gouion rhcoeis.V`h akijkei potthris kg orthgoats oif kg gouion rhcoeisbkt` fhckistroth rhnotekis`eps bhtwhhi fegghrhit ports kgt`h seth. V`h orthgoats prkbobny fhckistroth, secenorny tkt`h gouion rhcoeis. fegghrhit hpeskfhs kg oatevety ot t`hwothrsefh. Ot t`h host kg t`h hxaovothf orho oioaaucunoteki kg phbbnhs akvhreim skch 8 c2 wosuiakvhrhf. V`h prhshiah kg bkihs oif orthgoats ihxt tkoif wet`ei t`es akiahitroteki neils et tk t`h `ucoi ush kgt`h seth. Et es ecprkbobnh t`ot t`es spoteonny fhgeihf, seimnhnoyhr kg gest-sezhf phbbnhs es o ioturon oaaucunoteki.Tkssebny t`h stkihs whrh fhpksethf `hrh fhnebhrothny by
coi ei krfhr tk arhoth o frehr oif ckrh stobnh orho ei t`hcors`y shfechit kg t`h boil.
6.1. COXHR IHOR @HEFHNBHRM
V`h nockus seth kg Couhr es nkaothf ei oi oiaehitchoifhr kg t`h Ihalor revhr ?4 lc skut`host kg@hefhnbhrm. V`h seth wos kremeionny oi ommrofeim revhrboil upki w`ea` oiecon bkihs oif t`h `ucoi jow whrhwos`hf tkmht`hr. V`h `ucoi coifebnh wos fesakvhrhf byFoiehn nnortcoii ki Katkbhr 2?, nnL)= oif pubnes`hf b)K. Qa`khthisoal ei o anossea ckikmrop` t`h gknnkweim yhor(Qa`khthisoal ?540).
Ei t`h shateki kg t`h soifpet t`h Ihalor soifs orhkvhrnoei by shvhron nkhss bhfs oif sken fhvhnkpchits,w`ea`, ki t`h hvefhiah kg ihw eivhstemotekis by Bebus(?552o), rhprhshit ot nhost t`h nost t`rhh aknf stomhs oifeithrmnoaeons rhsphatevhny.
V`h cearkgouio grkc t`h Couhr soifs akitoeis t`hsphaehs Vonpo ceikr. Vonpo hurkpho, bkt` Aostkr gebhroif Vrkmkit`hreuc auvehre, Tnekcys hpesakpones, Orveakno
Gem. ?4. V`h Couhr coifebnh. Ogthr K. Qa`khthisoal.
thrrhstres aoiteoio, Cearktus orvones/C. omrhstes, oif Opkfhcus sp. (Wki Lkhiemswonf ?552). V`h normh coccgouio akisests kg Aoies nupus cksboa`hises, Xrsus sth`neiXrsus fhieimhre, @yohio orvhrihises, Toit`hro porfussealhibhrme, Toit`hro nhk gkssenes, Ghnes (Nyix) essefkrhisGhnes ag. senvhstres, @kckt`hreuc sp., Hnhp`os (Tonohknkxkfki) oitequus, Hquus cksboa`hises, Qthp`oikr`eius
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 125/342
??8 MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - ]HQVHRI AHIVRON HXRKTH
`uifs`hechises, Qus sarkgo presaus. @eppkpktocus ocp`e-beus oitequus, Onahs notegrkis, Ahrvus hnop`us oakrkiotus,Aoprhknus sþsshibkrihises oif Beski sa`khthisoale (WkiLkhiemswonf ?552).
V`es es <ei eithrmnoaeon gouio< t`h prhshiah kg @eppkpktocuss`kws oi Otnoitea anecoth wet` cenf weithrs oif o gkrhsthfnoifsaoph. Bekstrotemrop`eaonny t`h cearkgouio es vhry secenor
tk t`ot kg Leernea` M oif. ei porteaunor, t`ot kg Cehshi`hecE. ]. vki Lkhiemswonf (?552) sphaegeaonny pkeits tk t`hkaaurrhiah kg bkt` Orveakno thrrhstres aoiteoio oif Tnekcyshpesakpones, w`ea` foths t`hsh seths - Lornea` M, Cehshi`hec E oif Couhr - tk t`h ahitron port kg t`h CeffnhTnhestkahih. Et es prkbobnh t`ot t`h "Couhrhr ]onfzhet"(CXEEhr-Bhhl ?576) es hquevonhit tk t`h eithrmnoaeonrhprhshithf by t`h Lornea` M sken gkrcoteki oif otCehshi`hec E. oif t`ot t`es aoi bh akrrhnothf wet` KEQ ?1.
V`h coifebnh kg @kck `hefhnbhrmhises (Gem. ?4) esnormh oif cossevh, t`h thht` by akitrost, rhnotevhny sconn.O prktubhroiah kg t`h a`ei es tktonny obshit. V`h sphaechiakrrhspkifs bhst tk t`ksh grkc Vhriegeih oif Ckitcourei.ont`kum` t`hrh es onsk o strkim rhshcbnoiah tk t`hQeioit`rkpus coifebnhs grkc A`kulkutehi (@kwhnn ?574<Mobuieo ?552). Onn t`hsh geifs orh ossemihf tk noth gkrcs kg @kck hrhatus. w`ea` es ei mkkf akrrhspkifhiah wet` t`ha`rkiknkmeaon pkseteki kg t`h Couhr seth.
Fureim t`h ?584's O. Rust akifuathf eivhstemotekis ott`h seth. @h bhnehvhf t`ot `h akunf rhakmiezh gnot phbbnhskg Ihw Rhf Qoifstkih wet` "strual" hfmhs oif"pehporhf" ikta`hs oif "ikshs" os orthgoats (Rust ?587 o-b< ?58=< ?578< ?5=?). V`h ortegeaeon ioturh kg t`hsh pehahs`os ikn bhhi mhihronny oaahpthf oif t`h arhoteki kg oihpkiyckus "@hefhnbhrmhr aunturh", akitoeieim iuchrkus
anhorny pshufk-orthgoats kg fevhrsh kremei, gurt`hrfesarhfethf t`hc. Rhahitny. sconn a`hrt pehahs aknnhathf byL.G. @krcut` grkc t`h Couhr soifs bhgkrh t`h Qhakif]krnf ]or, `ovh bhhi rhnkaothf (Bhei`ouhr, Gehfnhr oif]hmihr ?552). Et es ikt prkvhf t`ot t`hsh pehahs whrhwkrlhf by `ucois oif uinelhny t`ot t`hy whrh rhnothf tkt`h Couhr j ow bkih.
6.6. OA@HI@HEC NOUHR 14
Ot t`h bosh kg t`h cojkr nkhss shateki ot Oa`hi`hec ihorQtrosbkurm, bkihs kg Aostkr sp., Xe sus fhieimhre, Feahrk-r`eius htrusaus, Hquus cksboa`hises, @eppkpktocus,
Ahrvus oif Onahs `ovh bhhi gkuif ei t`h R`eih soifsbhnkw t`h nkhss (]hchrt ?58=< @hec, Noutrefku ht on.
?502< Juilcoiis ?55?). V es gouio aoi bh akcporhf tkt`ksh kg Couhr, Lornea` M oif Cehshi`hec E oif coypkssebny rhprhshit t`h soch Ceffnh Tnhestkahih eithrmnoaeon.Ei t`h soch noyhr wos gkuif o akbbnh s`kweim o seimnhgnolh rhckvon pkssebny wkrlhf by coi (]hrihrt, Cennkt oifWoi Hnnhr ?572).
6.8. LORNEA@, NK]HR NOUHR @
]`hrhos t`h geifs fhsarebhf sk gor grkc t`h ceffnh p`oshkg t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea aoi onn bh ossemihf tk eithrmnoaeonakifetekis wet` o ckest-thcphroth anecoth, t`h geifs grkct`h bosh kg Lornea` Nkhss @ whrh fhpksethf fureim o phrekfkg sthpph akifetekis wet` o prhvoeneim fry Akiteihitonanecoth. @ucoi prhshiah fureim sua` o anecotea p`osh es
ihw tk t`es phrekf kg t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea kg whsthriAhitron Hurkph. Lornea` Noyhr @ es ykuimhr t`oi bkt`Noyhr M ot t`h soch seth oif t`h seth kg Cehshi`hec E oifes akrrhnothf wet` KEQ ?2.
Ei ?501 L. ]þrmhs eivhstemothf o seth w`ea` noy ot t`hhfmh kg o a`oiihn gennhf wet` puceah (Loh-FVn) oifbosontea thp`ro (Loh-BV2). Ont`kum` t`h seth `of onrhofybhhi normhny fhstrkyhf by quorryeim coa`eihry (]þrmhs?506), et wos pkssebnh tk rhakvhr o tusl oif o t`em` bkih kgo sthpph hnhp`oit tkmht`hr wet` 74 quortz oif quortzethorthgoats (Gem. ??). V`h cojkrety kg t`h geifs akisests kggnolhs, o iucbhr kg w`ea` orh prkfuahf ei bepknortha`iequh. Ei offeteki, gevh akrhs, gkur strual akbbnhs oifoi eithisevhny botthrhf quortz `occhrstkih whrh onskgkuif. Ockim t`h ckfegehf gkrcs orh twk sarophrs oif twk"pkeits", tkmht`hr wet` o iucbhr kg porteonny hfmh-rhtkua`hf orthgoats. Oport grkc t`es normhny fhstrkyhfsetuoteki, o iucbhr (70) kg aknnhathf orthgoats es likwigrkc t`h soch strotemrop`eaon pkseteki ei vorekus ports kgt`h anoy pet (Wknnbrha`t ?552). Bhsefhs quortz oif quortzethorthgoats, t`es iucbhr eianufhs o nyfeth akrh. V`h cojkretykg t`h pehahs orh "a`uils" oif gnolhs, but sex akrhs oif osconn iucbhr kg rhtkua`hf gkrcs orh onsk prhshit. Geionny.J. Wknnbrha`t fesakvhrhf oif eivhstemothf o gurt`hr, stennuipubnes`hf, seth (Lornea` EEE/"X`u-seth") ot t`h bosh kg
Noyhr @ ei t`h ikrt`whst quorry goah kg t`h pet.
8. Noth Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea sethsV`h noth Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea seths orh grkc t`h phrekf
ao. 644-144 Lyr BT (KEQ ??-5). V`h Ceffnh Tonohknet`eabhmeis ei kur rhmeki ot t`h bosh kg t`h oith-phiuntecothnkhss bhf (KEQ 0).
8.?. LORNEA@ QHHXGHR
Ei t`h skut`host kg t`h Lornea` anoy pet o tkpkmrop`eaonfhprhsseki gkrchf subshquhitny tk t`h fhpkseteki kg t`hBrkalhitugg. V`h ghoturh shhcs o rhsunt kg t`h hrupteki oif
es pkssebny o arothr. V`h fhprhsseki bhaoch portny gennhfwet rhfhpksethf Brkalhitugg< subshquhitny wothr wos obnhtk aknnhat oif o sconn nolh wos gkrchf. Thot fhpksetsgkrchf fureim t`h eigenneim kg t`es nolh rhprhshit, ki t`hhvefhiah kg t`her akitoeihf pknnhi oif coarksakpearhcoeis, t`h shakif `ong kg t`h soch eithrmnoaeon ei w`ea`t`h tugg reim wos hrupthf (Bettcoii, ei prhss). V`h gerstp`osh prhshit es o cexhf-kol-gkrhst, ei w`ea` kol
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 126/342
??7 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. ??. Lornea` nkwhr Noyhr @. _uortz (?-=) oif quortzeth (0-?4) orthgoats. Qaonh ei ac. Ogthr L. ]þrmhs oif J. Wknnbrha`t.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 127/342
??= MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - ]HQVHRI AHIVRON HXRKTH
fkceioths kvhr hnc oif nech. V`es es suaahhfhf gerst by op`osh ei w`eh` `ozhn es t`h fkceioit sphaehs oif t`hi by op`osh fkceiothf by `kribhoc. V`h prhshiah kg weimiut(Tthrkaoryo) oif ihttnh trhh (Ahntes) fureim t`h notthr phrekfs`kws t`ot thcphroturhs whrh worchr t`oi ot t`h prhshitfoy. V`h pknnhi feomroc s`kws o subshquhit resh kg ger.Geionny, t`h vonuhs kg bkt` t`h `kribhoc oif t`h ger fharhosh
oif oi eiarhosh ei t`h prhshiah kg spruah oif peih corlst`h hif kg t`h eithrmnoaeon.
V`h ponyiknkmeaon eithrprhtoteki kg t`h vhmhtotekionfavhnkpchit aoi bh akcpnhchithf by o normh roimh kgpnoit coark-rhcoeis, eianufeim wkkf rhcoeis up tk t`h sezhkg trhh truils (Bettcoii, ei prhss).
V`h "Lornea` eithrmnoaeon" fegghrs grkc t`h @knstheiEithrmnoaeon t`rkum` h.m. t`h prhshiah kg Ahntes oif Ozknno
geneaunkefhs, but onsk ei ets `em` vonuhs gkr `kribhoc oifnkw vonuhs gkr onfhr, oif cust rhprhshit oi knfhr eithrmnoaeon p`osh. V`h bhst poronnhn es Bens`oushi ihor M÷tteimhi,w`ea` es ossemihf tk t`h Arkchr Akcpnhx (Bettcoii ?554<ei prhss). Bettcoii prkpkshs tk hquoth t`h Lornea`
eithrmnoaeon wet` o "Arkchr W" eithrmnoaeon akrrhnothf wet`KEQ ??. Fureim t`h `kribhoc p`osh kg t`es eithrmnoaeon,t`hrh es hvefhiah gkr t`h prhshiah kg o mrkup kg `kceiefs kio Ceeonn "phieisuno" gkrchf ei t`h ikrt`host port kg t`h nolhby soify cothreon oif Brkalhitugg hrkfeim grkc oi upsnkphpkseteki (Bkseisle. Bruiioalhr ht on. ?504< Lrkmhr, T. voifhi Bkmoorf ht on. ?500).
V`h net`ea orthgoats orh cofh grkc cothreons prhshit eit`h ihem`bkureim thrroah mrovhns, ei porteaunor grkc quortzoif quortzeta. O prkbnhc akiahrieim t`h orthgoats es t`ot t`harupteki kg t`h Brkalhitugg tugg reim ikt kiny brklh t`rkum`Fhvkieoi snoth oif Vhrteory anoy, but onsk t`rkum` t`h @em`
Vhrroah mrovhns, sk t`ot t`h Brkalhitugg akitoeis iuchrkusioturonny nëoaturhf phbbnhs. Coiy kg t`hsh orh "akrhs" oif"gnolhs". Qhvhron otthcpts `ovh bhhi cofh tk hstobnes`arethreo gkr festeimues`eim sua` thp`rkgoats fhrevhf grkc t`hBrkalhitugg grkc truh orthgoats (shh onsk Royion ht on., t`esvknuch). Ei vehw kg t`h uiskp`esteaothf tha`iknkmy ei ushfureim t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea t`es es ikt pkssebnh gkr coiyneeuns. sk t`ot o normh "mrhy orho" rhcoeis kg pehahs w`ea`cem`t hquonny `ovh bhhi groaturhf by coi kr by t`harupteki. Fhspeth t`hsh prkbnhcs et es pkssebnh tk efhitegyskch ?84 ahrtoei orthgoats grkc t`h Lornea`-Qhhughr seth.Gnoleim tha`iknkmy oif gnolh gkrcs orh mhihronny secpnh(Gem. ?2), but t`hrh orh twk akrhs w`ea` gkrhs`ofkw t`hNhvonnkes tha`iequh. Qkch gnolhs orh porteonny hfmh-rhtkua`hf. O gromchit kg wkkf ottoa`hf by o akiarhteki tkkih kg t`hsh pehahs coy rhprhshit rhcoeis kg `ogteim. Kinyo sconS iucbhr kg gnolhs `ovh rhmunorny rhtkua`hf sarophr-hfmhs. Ei offeteki, anhovhrs kg fegghrhit sezhs (Gem. ?1) oifbegoahs orh onsk prhshit. V`h twk ckst rhmunor begoahs(Gems ?6-?8) orh cofh kg rhffes`-brkwi quortzeth oif orh
secenorny prkpkrtekihf oif gnolhf. V`h nkwhr surgoah kg kihpehah es normhny ioturon akrthx, t`ot kg t`h shakif pehah esgkrchf by o ioturon anhovomh pnoih. O gurt`hr anoss kgorthgoat akcpreshs phbbnh tkkns kg fegghrhit typhs oif sezhs.V`h Lornea`-Qhhughr orthgoats whrh gkuif ei o goi kgshfechits kremeioteim grkc rhphothf `enn wos` oif hxthi-feim eitk t`h fhprhsseki. Ckst kg t`h orthgoats orh grhs`,
wet` s`orp hfmhs, oif `ovh ahrtoeiny ikt bhhi troispkrthfkvhr o nkim festoiah. @occhrstkihs oif akijkeihf orthgoats orh hvefhiah gkr t`h prkfuateki kg orthgoats ot t`hseth.
Oiecon bkihs whrh fesakvhrhf ei t`h soch orho os t`hstkih orthgoats. V`h ckst akccki aothmkry es gkrchf bybkihs oif thht` kg t`h stroem`t-tuslhf hnhp`oit, w`ea` esrhprhshithf ot t`h seth by ot nhost 0 eifevefuons (Lrkmhr,T. voi fhi Bkmoorf ht on. ?500). V`h omh struaturh kg t`hhnhp`oits eianufhs juvhienhs, prech ofunts oif knfeifevefuons. V`h ckst grhquhit bkfy port es t`h `hof,eianufeim t`h cknors oif tusls, w`hrhos ports kg t`h rucporh rorhny rhprhshithf. Bhsefhs t`h fkceioit stroem`t-tuslhf
hnhp`oit, bkihs oif thht` kg rhf fhhr (Ahrvus hnop`us), obkveih (Bks kr Beski), `krsh (Hquus sp.), pem (Qus sp.),rheifhhr (Roimeghr toroifus) oif o ghnef whrh onsk gkuif.Rhahit oionyses by Q. Mouf/eisle (ei prhss) eifeaoths t`ott`h bkihs oif stkihs whrh rhwkrlhf grkc vorekus ferhatekisfureim vorekus phrekfs, t`us fhiyeim o precory akithxta`oroathr gkr t`h seth.
V`h setuoteki hxaovothf ot Lornea`-Qhhughr `os poronnhnsot Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea seths ei Etony (Gkitoio Roiuaaek, NoTknnhfroro) oif Qpoei (Vkrronbo, Ocbrkio, Orefks). Ot onnt`hsh seths t`hrh `os bhhi o nkim fesausseki kg t`h rknh kg`ucois ei t`h oaaucunoteki kg t`h rhakvhrhf osshcbnomhs
oif, ei porteaunor, obkut t`h quhsteki kg oatevh hnhp`oit`uiteim. ]et`kut hithreim eitk t`es porteaunor fesausseki,w`ea` aoi bh fhaefhf kiny wet` feggeaunty ki t`h boses kgt`h ora`ohknkmeaon osshcbnomh, et wkunf bh aorryeim t`eimstkk gor ikt tk oaahpt t`h s`hnns kg `ozhn iuts gkuif wet` t`hnet`ea osshcbnomh oif t`h oiecon bkihs os t`h gkkf rhcoeiskg `kceiefs.
8.2. LORVQVHEI VROWHRVEIH
V`h Lortsthei trovhrteih ei t`h Ikrt` Heghn akisests kgshvhron uiets gkrchf fureim fegghrhit eithrmnoaeons. V`h coeitrovhrteih cosseg rhahitny wos fothf obkut 144 Lyr BT by
I. Groil (shh Wknnbrha`t, ei prhss) oif prkbobny bhnkims tkKEQ 5. Fureim t`h eivhstemoteki kg ykuimhr ora`ohknkmeaon`krezkis ei aovhs oif obres w`ea` `of subshquhitny gkrchfot t`h bosh kg t`h cosseg, @. N÷`r fesakvhrhf phbbnh tkknsoif oiecon bkihs hcbhffhf ei t`h trovhrteih (Bruiioalhr,@hiiem ht on. ?502). V`h akithxt kg t`h pehahs, w`ea` orhahchithf eitk t`h trovhrteih cotrex, prhanufhs o choieimguneivhstemoteki kg t`h seth.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 128/342
??0 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. ?2. Lornea`-Qhhughr. Gnolhs. O gromchit kg wkkf of`hrhs tk t`h fkrson goah kg orthgoat 2. Qaonh ei ac. Ogthr L. Lrkmhr.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 129/342
??5 MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - ]HQVHRI AHIVRON HXRKTH
Gem. ?1. Lornea -Qhhughr. Anhovhrs. Qaonh ei ac. Ogthr L. Lrkmhr.
7. Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea geifs kg uiahrtoei omh7.?. CÞIZHIBHRM RHMEKI
Geifs kg phbbnh tkkns, gnolhs oif begoahs aknnhathf grkct`h surgoah kg oiaehit thrroahs anksh tk Cþizhibhrm eiXpphr @hsseo `ovh bhhi pubnes`hf ei shvhron orteanhs by@. Lrþmhr seiah t`h ?584's (Lrkmhr ?585< ?5=8< ?5==/=0<
?50=< ?505< ?556< Gehfnhr ?501< ?556< Ckiahn ?505). V`hcojkrety kg t`es cothreon aoi, vhry prkbobny, bh ossemihf tkt`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea oif et `os onsk bhhi pkssebnh tk troaåt`h geif-bhoreim `krezki bhnkw o nkhss shateki akitoeieimt`h twk ckst rhahit nkhss bhfs (Bebus ?5=7). Ihvhrt`hnhss,t`es kiny prkvefhs o thrceius oith quhc< t`h truh omh kg t`hcothreon es stenn uilikwi oif t`h eivhstemoteki kg o strotegehfseth ei t`es rhmeki rhcoeis o prekrety.
7.2. B×IIEM@HEC
Oiecon bkihs oif stkih tkkns whrh fesakvhrhf bhnkw ostrotegehf nkhss shateki ei o pet ot B÷iiem`hec ihorNufwemsburm (]omihr ?554< ?55?). V`h strotemrop`y kg t`hseth s`kws t`ot t`h geifs orh knfhr t`oi t`h oith-phiuntecotaaknf stomh (KEQ 0) (Bebus ?552b). V`h bkihs orh efhitegehf
os t`h rhcoeis kg t`h slhnhtkis oif thht` kg o thcphrothgouio, eianufeim stroem`t-tuslhf hnhp`oit, r`eikahrks, beski,pem oif rhf fhhr (]omihr ?55?). Osskaeothf wet` t`h bkihswos o phbbnh tkke cofh kg hxktea tobunor a`hrt.
7.1. QVHEI@HEC
V`h Qthei`hec slunn (Bhral`hchr ?511< Ofoc ?500) oift`h geifs grkc t`h trovhrteih nkaonetehs Nousthr, @oos oif
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 130/342
?24 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. ?6. Lornea`-Qhhughr. Begoah. Qaonh ei ac.
Gem. ?8. Lornea`-Qhhughr. Begoah. Qaonh ei ac.
"Builhr" ei Bof Aoiistott (]omihr ?504< ?506< ?50=<?552< Ofoc, Rhegg oif ]omihr ?507) prkbobny fhrevh grkct`h eithrmnoaeon fothf tk obkut 224 Lyr BT (KEQ =) oif orht`us rot`hr horny Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea ei akithxt. OtQthei`hec t`es es rhifhrhf nelhny by t`h strotemrop`ea foteimkg t`h "oitequus noyhrs", ei w`ea` t`h slunn wos gkuif, tkbhgkrh t`h phiuntecoth aknf stomh (Ofoc ?500).
Ei t`h aosh kg t`h Bof Aoiistott trovhrteih, foteimhvefhiah es prkvefhf by t`h mhkmrop`eaon festrebuteki kg tvorekus trovhrteih stomhs wet`ei t`h vonnhy kg t`h Ihalor(Ofoc, Rhegg oif ]omihr ?507), t`h X-shrehs foteim kgt`h trovhrteihs tk ?=4-258 (@oos quorry) oif ?68-274 LyBT (Nousthr quorry) (Mrþi, Bruiioalhr oif @hiieim ?50oi HQR foth gkr oi hnhp`oit tkkt` grkc t`h Nousthr quorr
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 131/342
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 132/342
?22 V@L HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
rhghrhiahs
Ofoc. L.F. ?500 Fhr Xrchisa` vki Qthei`hec oi fhr Curr uif sheih Xcwhnt. Hei Nhbhisbenf ous fhr Z
vkr heihr Wehrthn Cenneki Jo`rhi, Jo`rbua` fhs R÷cesa`-Mhrcoiesa`hi Zhitroncushuc
Coeiz 18, 1-21.
Ofoc, L.F.,]. Rhegg,H. ]omihr
?507 Zhumiessh fhs Xrchisa`hi ous fhi Aoiistotthr Qouhrwosshrlonlhi, Gecflhrea`th ous
Bofhi-]þrtthcbhrm ??, ?-?44.
Bhei`ouhr, L.].,N. Gehfnhr,F. ]hmihr
?552 @kristhei-Orthgolth vki fhr Guifsthnnh fhs @kck hrhatus `hefhnbhrmhises ous Couhr. L.]. Bhei`ouhr oif M.O. ]omihr (hf.). Qa`ea`thi vki Couhr. 08 Jo`rh @kck hrhatus
`hefhnbhrmhises, 67-=1, Coii`hec: Hfeteki Brous.
Bhral`hchr, G. ?511 Hei Chisa`hisa`ofhn ous fhi fenuveonhi Qa`ktthri vki Qthei`hec oi fhr Curr, Oit`rkp
nkmesa`hr Oizhemhr ?4, 1?0-12?.
Bhrm, O. vki,N. Gehfnhr
?501 Ontponoknet`esa`h Guifh vki ]eiieimhi uif Lkbnhiz-Bes`knfhr oi fhr Xithrhi Ckshn, Ora`oknkmesa`hs Lkrrh spkifh izbnott ?1, 25?-250.
?50= Goustlhenguifh fhs onthrhi Oa`hunåhi vki ]eiieimhi/Ckshn, Lrhes Coyhi-Lkbnhiz. Bhrea`th zur Ora`åknkmeh oi Cetthnr`hei uif Ckshn ? (Vrehrhr Zhetsa`regt. Bhe`hgt 5), =1-0
Bebus, H. ?5=7 Zur mhkckrp`knkmesa`hi Guifsetuoteki uif Onthrssthnnuim fhr kbhr`hssesa`hi Mhr÷nnmh
vkc Cþizhibhrmhr Vyp., R`hei-Coeiesa`h Gkrsa`uimhi 02, ?=5-241.
?552o Feh N÷B-Fhalsa`ea`thi ec Bhrhea` fhr Guifsthnnh fhs @kck hrhatus `hefhnbhrmhises bhCouhr. Ei: L.]. Bhei`ouhr oif M.O. ]omihr (hf.), Qa`ea`thi vki Couhr. 08 Jo`rh
@kck hrhatus `hefhnbhrmhises, ?8?-?8=, Coii`hec: Hfeteki Brous.
?552b Feh Qhfechitgknmh ei fhr Zehmhnhe Qa`cef ei B÷iiem`hec uif fos c÷mnea`h Onthr fhrGkssenguifh ei fhi Bosessa`ea`thi. @oihrbhibnotthr, @estkresa`h Mhshnnsa`ogt B÷iiem`he
?8, 27-25.
Bettcoii, G. ?554 Ihuh bekstrotemrop`esa`h Lkrrhnehruim fhs Lornea`hr Eithrmnozeons (Ihuwehfhr Bhalhi/
Cetthnr`hei). Ei: ]. Qa`erchr (hf.), R`heimhsa`ea`th zwesa`hi Ckshn uif Coos, 7=-=4,@oiikvhr: Fhutsa`h _uortorvhrheiemuim.
ei prhss Whmhtotekismhsa`ea`tnea`h Xithrsua`uimhi oi cetthn- uif juimpnhestkzoihi Obnomhruimfhs Ihuwehfhr Bhalhis (Cetthnr`hei). Jo`rbua` fhs R÷cesa`-Mhrcoiesa`hi Zhitron
cushucs Coeiz 10.
Bkhieml. ]. ?5=0 Feh Mnehfhruim fhr ontquortorhi Obnomhruimhi ei fhr neilsr`heiesa`hi Iehfhrr`heiesa`hBua`t, Gkrtsa`retta Mhkn. R`heinoif uif ]hstgonhi 20, ?18-2?2.
Bkhieml, ].,M. Lkwonazyl,L. Bruiioalhr
?5=2 Zur Mhknkmeh fhs Onthstpnhestkz.ois fhr Iehfhrr`heiesa`hi Bua`t, Zhetsa`regt fhr Fhutsa`Mhknkmesa`hi Mhshnnsa`ogt ?21, ??5-?7?.
Bkhieml, ].,]. @hyh,]. Qa`erchr,L. Bruiioalhr
?5=6 Tonokcomihtesa`h Chssuimhi oi vehnmnehfremhi _uortorprkgënhi (Lornea`/Cetthnr`hei uifBof Qkfhi ec Vouius), Coeizhr Ioturwesshisa`ogtnea`hs Ora`ev ?2, ?85-?75.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 133/342
?21 MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - ]HQVHRI AHIVRON HXRKTH
Bkmoorf, A`r. voi fhi,
E'. voi fhi Bkmoorf,
@.-X. Qa`ceialh
?505 _uorteermhknkmesa`-thp`rkstrotemrop`esa`h Ihuougio`ch uif Eithrprhtoteki fhs Tnhestkzoi-prkgens Lornea`, Heszhenonthr uif Mhmhiwort 15, 72-07.
Bkmoorf, T. voi fhi.A`r.C. @onn,
@.-X. Qa`ceialh.
F. Ukrl
?50= 64OR/15OR Noshr Foteim kg seimnh mroeis: Omhs kg _uothriory Vhp`ro grkc t h Host
Heghn Wknaoiea Gehnf, G.R.M. Mhkp`yseaon Rhshora` Nhtthrs ?6, ?2??-?2?6.
Bkmoorf, T. voi fhi,@.-X. Qa`ceialh
?500 Osa`hinomhi ons quortorh Zhetcorlhi ei Cetthnhurkpo, Feh Mhkwesshisa`ogthi 1, =8-06.
?554 Feh Hitwealnuimsmhsa`ea`th fhs Cetthnr`heirouchs uif feh Hruptekismhsa`ea`ta fhs
Kstheghn-Wunloighnfhs. Ei: ]. Qa`erchr (hf.), R`heimhsa`ea`th zwesa`hi Ckshn uif Coos,
?77-?54, @oiikvhr: Fhutsa`h _uortorvhrheiemuim.
Bksa`heihi, J.,
M. Bkseisle,L. Bruiioalhr,
X. Lka`.
V. voi Lkngsa`kthi,
H. Vurihr,B. Xrboi
?506 Hei ontponoknet`esa`hr Guifpnotz bhe Cehshi`hec. Lrhes Coyhi-Lkbnhiz/Ihuwehfhr
Bhalhi, Ora`oknkmesa`hs Lkrrhspkifhiz`nott ?6, ?-?7.
Bkseisle. M. ?552 Heszhetjomhr ec Ihuwehfhr Bhalhi. Ora`hknkmeh fhs Heszhetonthrs oc Cetthnr`hei.
(Ora`åknkmeh oi Cetthnr`hei uif Ckshn ?), Lkbnhiz: Ora`okn. Fhilconpgnhmh.
Bkseisle. M.,L. Bruiioalhr.
L.T. Noishr,Q. Qnhp`oi,
B. Xrboi,L. ]þrmhs
?504 Ontponoknet`esa`h Guifh vki Lornea`, Lrhes Coyhi-Lkbnhiz (Ihuwehfhr Bhalhi),
Ora`oknkmesa`hs Lkrrhspkifhiz`nott ?4, 258-1?6.
Bkseisle, M..
E. voi Lkngsa`kthi.H. Vurihr
?500 Cehshi`hec E. Feh Zhen fhs @kck hrhatus. Oifhrioa`hr Bhetromh 2, Oifhrioa`.
Bruiioalhr. L..
R. Qtrhet,
]. Qa`erchr
?575 Fhr Ougbou fhs _uortor-Trkgens vki Lornea`/Ihuwehfhr Bhalhi (Cetthnr`hei), Coeizhr
Ioturwessa`ogtnea`hs Ora`ev 0, ?42-?11.
Bruiioalhr. L..
Gn. @hnnhr,
W. Nkzhl
?5=? Bhetromh zur Qtrotemrop`eh fhs _uortor-Trkgens vki Lornea` oc Cetthnr`hei, Coeizhr
Ioeueuesshisa`ogtnea`hs Ora`ev ?4, ==-?44.
Bruiioalhr, L..@. N÷`r,
]. Bkhieml,J.J. Tuesshmur,E E'kpnei
?5=8 _uorteer-Ougsa`neessh bhe Orehifkrg oc uithrhi Cetthnr`hei, Coeizhr Ioturwesshisa`ogt-
nea`hs Ora`ev ?6, 51-?6?.
Bruiioalhr, L.,
]. Bkhieml.
O. Lkae.]. Venncoiis
?5=7 Feh COVXUOCO/BRXI@HQ-Mrhizh oc R`hei uif oi fhr Fkiou. Ihuhs Jo`rbua` Mhknkmeh
Tonhkitknkmeh, Ob`oifnuim ?8?, 180-1=0.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 134/342
?26 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Bruiioalhr, L.,]. Bkhieml.
B. Fknhzonhl,L.H. Lhcpg,O. Lkae,@. Chitzhi,C. Roze Rof,L.-T. ]eithr
?5=0 Feh Cetthn thrrosshi oc Iehfhrr`hei zwesa`hi L÷ni uif C÷ia`himnofboa`, Gkrtsa`retth
Mhknkmeh R`heinoif uif ]hstgonhi 20, 2==-126.
Bruiioalhr, L..G. Gorrkl`,F. Qeferkpkunks
?502 Feh ontquortorhi Vhrrosshi rha`ts fhs Iehfhrr`heis, Zhetsa`regn gþr Mhkckrp`knkmeh, I.
Quppn. 62, 2?8-227.
Bruiioalhr, L.,
M.J. @hiiem,
H. Juvemiå,
@. N÷`r.
B. Xrboi,
R. Zhhsh
?502 Fhr Lortsthei-Vrovhrtei ei fhr i÷rfnea`hi ]hstheghn , Fha`hieoio ?18, ?=5-246.
Bruiioalhr, L.,]. Bkhieml
?501 V`h R`eih Wonnhy bhtwhhi t`h Ihuwehf Bosei oif t`h Nkwhr R`hies` Hcboychit. Ei:
L. Gua`s ht on. (hf.). Tnothou Xpnegt, V`h R`hies` Q`ehnf - O Aosh @estkry, 72-=2, Bhrne
Qpreimhr-Whrnom.
Gehfnhr, N. ?501 Jomhr uif Quccehr fhr Grþ`zhet. Ont- uif Cetthnstheizhet ei Ikrf`hsshi. Wkr- uif Grþ`
mhsa`ea`th ec @hssesa`hi Noifhscushuc Losshe, Losshe.
?55? Tonokne t`esa`h Guifh oug Vhrrosshi ec R`hei-Ckshn-Rouc, Bhrea`th zur Ora`hknkmeh oi
Cetthnr`hei uifCkshn 2, 5-?5.
?556 Ont- uif cetthnstheizhetnea`h Guifh ei @hsshi. Gþ`rhr zur `hssesa`hi Wkr- uif Grþ`-mhsa`ea`th 2, Losshe.
Grha`hi, J. ?5=7 Qehbhimhbermh oc R`hei - Nooa`hr Wunloimhbeht - Coormh`eht fhr ]hstheghn. Wunloiknkmesa phtrkmrop`esa`h Hxlursekihi. Qoccnuim mhknkmesa`hr Gþ`rhr 87, 1 hf. Bhrnei,Qtuttmort.
Mobuieo, N. ?552 Fhr chisa`nea`h Xithrlehghr vki Fcoiese (Mhkrmehi, Loulosus), Jo`rbua` fhs R÷iusa
Mhrcoiesa`hs Zhinroncushucs Coeiz 15, ?08-240.
Moufzeisle, Q. ei prhss Lornea`-Qhhughr. Xithrsua`uimhi zu heihr ontponoknet`esa`hi Guifsthnnh ec Ihuwehfhr
Bhalhi (R`heinoif/Fhutsa`noif). Ckikm. RMZC, Coeiz.
Mrþi, R.,L. Bruiioalhr.M.J. @hiiem
?502 214V`/216X-Fothi cetthn- uif juimpnhestkzOihr Vrovhrteih ec Rouc Qtuttmort, Jo`rhs-
bhrea`th uif Cetthenuimhi fhs Kbhrr`heiesa`hi mhknkmesa`hi Whrheis I. G. 76, 24?-2??
Mrþi, R..L. Bruiioalhr
?507 Hnhltrkihi-Qpei-Rhskioiz (HQR)- Fotehruim heihs Hnhgoithizo`ihs ous fhc Vrovhrtei-brua` "Nousthr", Qtuttmort-Bof Aoiistott, Jo`rhs`hgth fhs mhknkmesa`hi Noifhsocths
Bofhi-]þrtthcbhrm 20, 61-6=.
@ohsohrts, T. ?554 Qtrotemrop`eaon opprkoa` tk t`h Tnhestkahih fhpksets kg t`h Qa`ihefhr quorry ot Orehifkr(Ceffnh R`eih, Mhrcoiy). Ei: ]. Qa`erchr (hf.), R`heimhsa`ea`th zwesa`hi Ckshn uif
Coos, ??2 -??6, @oiikvhr: Fhutsa`h _uortorvhrheiemuim.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 135/342
?28 MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - ]HQVHRI AHIVRON HXRKTH
@hec, J.,
J.T. Noutrefku.J. Couakrps,
J.J. Tuesshmur.
.?. Qkuceh.
O. V`hvhiei
@kwhnn, G. A.
Juilieoiis, J.
Lo`nlh, R.-F.
?502 Oa`hi`hec: Xih shquhiah-typh fhs nkhss fu pnhestkahih ckyhi ht supårehur, Buen.
O.G.H._. ?5, ?6=-?85.
Loeshr, L.
Lnksnhrcoii. .?.
Lkhiemswonf, ]. vki
Lkngsa`kthi, V. voi
Lkngsa`kthi, V. voi.
M. Rkt`,
H. Vurihr
Lkngsa`kthi. V. voi,
H. Vurihr
Lrkmhr, L.,T. voi fhi Bkmoorf,
G. Bettcoii,
H. Vurihr
Lrkmhr, @.
?574 Hurkphoi oif Ikrt`whst Ogreaoi Ceffnh Tnhestkahih @kceiefs, Aurrhit Oit`rkpknkmy ?,
?58-212.
?55? Feh Qtheiorthgolth ous Oa`hi`hec ei fhr Qoccnuim Toun ]hrihrt, Ora`oknkmesa`hs
Lkrrhspkifhizbnott 2? , ?-?7.
?508 Ontpnhestkzoih @eppkpktocus -Rhsth vki XithrcoBghnf bhe Cheieimhi (Bhzerl Qu`n,FFR) (Wkrnougemh Cetthenuim). Qoumhtehrluifnea`h Eigkrcotekihi 2, 22=-211.
ei prhss Feh @eppkpktocus-Rhsth ous fhc Xithrpnhestkzoi vki XithrcoBghnf bhe Cheieimhi
(V`þreimhi). Ei: @.-F. Lo`nlh oif R.-F. Lo`nlh (hf.), Fos Tnhestkzoi vki Xithrcogeghnf
ei V`þreimhi, Vhen E. Ckikmr. RMZC, Coeiz.
?57? Mnehfhruim uif Gkrchisa`otz fhs Tnhestkzois uif _uortors oc Cetthn- uif Iehfhrr`hei
skweh ei fhi oimrhizhifhi Iehfhrnoifhi uithr bhskifhrhr Bhrþalsea`temuim fhr
R`heithrrosshi, Ghstsa`rege zuc 11. Fhutsa`hi Mhkmrop`hi-Vom L÷ni, 217-2=0.
?552 Fos _uortor fhr Iehfhrr`heiesa`hi Bua`t. Lrhghnf.
?552 Zur ×lknkmeh uif Bekstrotemrop`eh fhr bhefhi pnhestkzþihi Gouihi vki Couhr bhe@hefhnbhrm. Ei: L.]. Bhei`ouhr oif M.O. ]omihr (hf.), Qa`ea`thi vki Couhr. #8 Jo`rh
@kck hrhatus `hefhn`hrmaises, ?4?-? ?4, Coii`hec: Hfeteki Brous.
?554o V`h Hvknuteki kg t`h Coccon Gouio ei t`h Iht`hrnoifs oif t`h Ceffnh R`eih Orho
(]hsthri Mhrcoiy) fureim t`h Noth Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, Chfhfhneimhi Rejls Mhknkmesa`h
Fehist 61(1), ?-75.
?554b Cehshi`hec E bhe Oifhrioa`. Ei: ]. Qa`erchr (hf.), R`heimhsa`ea`th zwesa`hi Ckshn uif
Coos, 0?-00, @oiikvhr: Fhutsa`h _uortorvhrheiemuim.
ei prhss CetthnpnhestkzOih Lnheigouio vki Cehshi`hec E. Ei: H. Vurihr (hf.), Cehshi`hec E.
Ckikmr. RMZC, Coeiz.
?554 Cknnuslhi- uif Qoumhtehrgouihi ous fhr Vkimruba Lornea`. Ei: ]. Qa`erchr (hf.), R`hei
mhsa`ea`th zwesa`hi Ckshn uif Coos, =4-=6, @oiikvhr: Fhutsa`h _uortorvhrheiemuim.
ei prhss Horny Ceffnh Tnhestkahih Cocconeoi Gouios grkc Lornea` oif Cehshi`hec E oif t`her
Bekstrotemrop`eaon ncpneaotekis, Trkahhfeims kg t`h Arkchr-Qycpkseuc, Ikrwea` ?554.
?500 Fhr Guifpnotz Lornea`-Qhhughr. Ihuh Xithrsua`uimhi zuc Ontponoknet`eluc ec R`hei-noif. Jo`r`ua` fhs R÷cesa`-Mhrcoiesa`hi Zhinroncushucs Coeiz 18, ???-?18.
?585 Grþ`poneeknet`esa`h Mhr÷nnorthgolth vkc Vyp "Thbbnh- tkk e" ei Kbhr`hsshi; Heszhetonthr
uifMhmhiwort ?4, ?78-?50.
?5=8 Vypknkmesa`h uif strotemrop`esa`h Lrethrehi zur proreBzhetnea`hi Fotehruim fhr ontponokne-
t`esa`hi Mhr÷nnmhrot- Eifustreh vkc Cþizhibhrmhr Vyp ei Kbhr`hsshi, Guif`hrea`th ous
@hsshi ?1, ?-84.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 136/342
?27 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
?5==/=0 Qtrotemrop`esa` mhsea`hrth Mrobuimsbhguifh zur `knstheizhetnea`hi Fotehruim fhr kbhr-
`hssesa`hi Mhr÷nnmhrot- Eifustreh vkc Cþizhibhrmhr Vyp, Guifbhrl`th ous @hsshi
?=/?0, ?-27.
?50= Zur arkchrzhetnea`hi Fotehruim fhr Cþizhibhrmhr Mhr÷nnmhroth-Mrupph, _uortor 1=/10
225-264.
E neQn¼ Feh Arkchrzhet-Fotehruim fhr Cþizhibhrmhr Mhr÷nnmhroth - hei Hxhcphn urmhsa`ea`tnea`
nnrrhis; _uortor 15/64, 2?8-222.
?556 Feh ontponþknet`esa`h Mhr÷nnmhroth-nifustreh fhr Cþizhibhrmhr Mrupph ei Kbhr`hsshi.
(Cothreonehi zur Wkr- uif Grþ`mhsa`ea`th vki @hsshi ?4). ]ehsbofhi.
Neppknt, @.J..
X. Gu`rcoii,
??. @rofhtzly
?'eQf 64OR/15OR Omh Fhthrceiotekis ki Qoiefeihs kg t`h Heghn Wknaoiea Gehnfs (Ghfhron
Rhpubnea kg Mhrcoiy): Akistroeits ki Omh oif Furoteki kg o Ceffnh Tnhestkahih aknfphrekf, A`hceaon Mhknkmy 85, ?0=- 246.
Nkzhl, W. ?5=? Wkrnougemh Lurzouswhrtuim fhr Cknnuslhiguifh. Ei: L. Bruiioalhr, Gn. @hnnhr oif W. Nkz
?5=?,01-07.
Coun, N. ?554 Be`oresa`h Lnheisoumhrguifh vki Xithrcogeganf, Wkemtsthft uif Qþgehibkri uif e`rh
a`rkiknkmesa`h Qthnnuim ec Ro`chi fhr be`oresa`hi Cearkcocconeo-Gouihi Hurkpos.Fess. @ucbknft-Xievhrsetot Bhrnei.
Chyhr, ].
Ckiahn, C.-@.
Cþnnhr-Bhal, @.
E "I(9 Mhknkmeh fhr Heghn. Qtuttmort.
?505 N'eifus treh sur monht fh Cþizh ibhrm (Kbhr`hsshi, R.G.O) fu Trkghsshur @. Lrejmhr
(Mehsshi). Rågnhxekis sur pnus fh 14 ois fh prksphatekis, gkuennhs ht fesaussekis sur no
fototeki (?582-?50=), N'Oit`rkpknkmeh 51 , 1-?6.
?576 Zur strotemrop`esa`hi Qthnnuim fhs @kc k `hefhnbhrmhises , Jo`rbua` fhs Rñcesa`-Mhrco
iesa`hi Zhitroncushucs Coeiz ??, ?8-12.
Thial, O.,H. Brþalihr
?54?-45 Feh Onphi ec Heszhetonnhr. Nhepzem.
Royion. J.-T.,N. Comkmo,T. Beifki
t`es Vhp`rkgoats oif t`h gerst `ucoi kaaupoteki kg t`h Grhia` Cosseg Ahitron.
vknuch
Rhcy, @. ?585 Zur Mnehfhruim fhs N÷sshs bhe Lornea` uif Br÷n oc uithrhi Cetthnr`hei cet bhskifhrhrBhrþalsea`temuim fhr Gouihi, Gkrnsa`rennh Mhknkmeh R`heinoif uif ]hstgonhi 6, 121-114.
Rkt`, M.. ei prhss o. Cknnuslhi ous fhc cetthnpnhestkzoihi "Lor nea`hr Ei thrmnozeon" fhr Vkimrubh bhe Lornea`(Ihuwehfhr Bhalhi/Cetthnr`hei), Jo`rbua` fhs R÷cesa`-Mhrcoiesa`hi Zhitroncushucs
Coeiz 15.
Rust, O.
ei prhss b. Feh Cknnuslhi fhr cetthnpnhestkzoihi Guifsthnnh Cehshi`hec E. Ei: H. Vurihr (hf.), Cehshi`hec E, Ckikmrop`, RMZC, Coeiz.
?587o Orthgolth ous fhr Zhet fhs @kck `hefhnbhrmhises ei Qþf- uif Ikrffhutsa`noif. Bkii.
?587b Þbhr ihuh Orthgolth ous fhr @hefhnbhrmhr Qtugh, Heszhetonnhr uif Mhmhiwort =, ?=5-?52
?58= Heih Qlezzh zuc vhrcutnea`hi ]hrfhmoim uif Obnout" fhr @hefhnbhrmhr Luntur ei Hurkp
_uothrioreo 6, ?-?7.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 137/342
?2= MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - ]HQVHRI AHIVRON HXRKTH
Qa`eieialh, @.-X.
Qa`ceialh, @.-X..W. Nkrhiz,
@.O. Qhal
?578 Þbhr ]ogghi- uif ]hrlzhumtha`iel fhs Ontchisa`hi. Ihucþisthr.
?5=? ]hrlzhumh fhs Grþ`chisa`hi ei Hurkpo. Ihucþisthr.
?500 Wunloih ec Nooa`hr Qhh-Mhbeht. E`rh Hitsth`uim uif `hutemh Bhfhutuim. @onthri.
?501 V`h _uothriory Heghn Wknaoiea Gehnfs. Ei: L. Gua`s ht on. (hf.). Tnothou Xpnegt, V`h
R`hies` Q`ehnf - O Aosh @estkry, ?15-?8?, Bhrnei: Qpreimhr-Whrnom.
Qa`cufh, L.
Qa`khthisohl, K.
Qtrhht, C.,
^ n. Boonhs.
B. ]hieimhr
V`kch, L.I.
?552 Zwhe arkchrzhetnea`h Orthgolt-Guifpnotzh ei fhr Jþimhrhi @ouptthrrossh oc Iehfhrr`hei,
Heszhetonthr uif Mhmhiwort 62, ?-26.
?540 Fhr Xithrlehghr fhs @kck @hefhn`hrmhises ous fhi Qoifhi vki Couhr bhe @hefhnbhrm.
Hei Bhetrom zur Tonhkitknkmeh fhs Chisa hi. Nhepzem.
?556 Obsknuth A`rkiknkmeh fhs spothi Tonoknet`elucs uif fhs Grþ`chsknet`elucs ec
i÷rfnea`hi R`heinoif, Ora`oknkmesa`hs Lkrrhspkifhizbnott 26, ?-20.
?580 Feh Bhmhmiuim fhs ikrfesa`hi Einoifheshs cet fhc R`hei, Mhknkmesa`hs Jo`rbua` =7,
27?-140.
Vurihr. H. ?554 Ceffnh oif Noth Tnhestkahih Coarkgouios kg t`h Ihuwehf Bosei Rhmeki (R`eihnoif-Tonoteioth) kg ]hst Mhrcoiy, Jo`rbua` fhs R÷cesa`-Mhrcoiesa`hi Zhitroncushucs
Coeiz 1=, ?18-157.
Vurihr, H. (hf.),
Wknnbrha`t. J.
]omihr, H.
?55? Tnhestkahih Qtrotemrop`y oif Whrthbroth Gouios grkc t`h Ihuwehf Bosei rhmeki kg
]hsthri Mhrcoiy, Aroieuc 0, 2?-16.
ei prhss Cehshi`hec E. Hxaovotekis ot o Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea Qeth ei t`h Ahitron R`eihnoif kg
Mhrcoiy. Ckikmr. RMZC, Coeiz.
?552 Fos Ontponoknet`eluc ous fhi uithrhi Qa`ea`thi ei Lornea`. Comesthrorbhet L÷ni.
ei prhss Xithrsua`uimhi zuc Ontponoknet`eluc fhs R`heinoifhs. Fesshrtoteki Xievhrsetot L÷ni.
?504 Hei ontponoknet`esa`hr Rostpnotz ec cetthnpnhestkzoihi Vrovhrtei vki Qtuttmort-Bof
Aoiistott, Ora`hknkmesa`h Ousmrobuimhi ei Bofhi-]þrtthcbhrm ?5=5, =-?6.
?506 Hei Jomfpnotz fhs @kck hrhatus ec cetthnpnhestkzoihi Vrovhrtei ei Qtuttmort-Bof Aoiistott,
Mhrcoieo 72, 214-27=.
?50= Feh Guifsthnnh "Bu ilhr" ec cetthnpnhestkzoihi Vrovhrtei vki Qtuttmort-Bof Aoiistott,
Ora`hknkmesa`h Ousmrobuimhi ei Bofhi-]þrtthcbhrm ?507, ?8-?0.
?554 Ihuh ponoknet`esa`h Grhenoifguifsthnnhi. Ora`oknkmesa`h Ousmrobuimhi ei Bofhi-]þrt
thcbhrm ?505, ?5-2?.
?55? Xrmhsa`ea`th ec Ihalornoif. Gþ`rhr zu ora`oknkmesa`hi Fhilconhri ei Fhutsa`noif 22
(@henbrkii uif fos ceiehrh Ihalornoif zwesa`hi Corboa` uif Muifhns`hec).
?552 Nhs fåakuvhrths ponåknet`equhs fhs trovhrteis fh Qtuttmort-Bof Aoiistott, N'Oit`rkpknkmeh
57, =?-07.
]heihrt, @. ?51= Fhc Xithrlehghr vki Couhr zur 14jo`remhi ]ehfhrlh`r sheihr Hitfhaluim, Zhetsa`regt gþr
Ckrp`knkmeh uif Oit`rkpknkmeh 1=, ?42-??1.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 138/342
]hrihrt, T. ?58= Qtrotemrop`eh ponåkitknkmequh ht prå`estkrequh fhs såfechits quothrioerhs f'Onsoah(Oa`hi`hec. Cåc. Qhrveah aorth måkn. Ik.6). Qtrosbkurm.
]hrihrt, T., ?572 Xi "phbbnh-tkkn" fhs onnuvekis r`åiois fh no aorreàrh @urst o Oa`hi`hec, Buen. shrvM. Cennkt, aorth mhkn. Onsoah-Nkrroeih ?8, 25-17.J.T. voi Hnnhr
]knfsthft, T. E5882 Ikrffhutsa`noif uif oimrhizhifh Mhbnhth nc Heszhetonthr. Qtuttmort.
]þrmhs, L. ?506 Ontponoknet`esa`h Guifh ous fhr Vkimrubh Lornea` (Qa`ea`t @, uithi), Lrhes Coyhi-Lkbnhiz/Ihuwehfhr Bhalhi, Ora`oknkmesa`hs Lkrrhspkifhiz`notn ?6, ?=-22.
?507 Orthgolth ous fhi onthsthi _uortor-Qhfechithi (Qa`ea`thi O-A) fhr Vkimrubh Lornea`,Lrhes Coyhi-Lkbnhiz/Ihuwehfhr Bhalhi, Ora`oknkmesa`hs Lkrrhspkifhiz`notn ?7, ?
?55? Ihuh ontponoknet`esa`h Guifh ous fhr Vkimrubh Lornea`, Lrhes Coyhi-Lkbnhiz /Ihuwehfhr Bhalhi. Ora`oknkmesa`hs Lkrrhspkifhiz`notn 2?, 665-688.
Zepthr, E. ?55? Feh Mhknkmeh fhs O`sa`ietts M fhr Fhalsa`ea`thi ei fhr Vkimrubh Lornea`nCetnhnr`Fepnkcorbhet Xievhrsetot L÷ni.
Mhr`orf BkseisleGkrsa`uimsbhrhea` OntstheizhetQa`nkss Ckirhpks8787= IhuwehfMhrcoiy
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 139/342
jhoi Toun Royioe 0 Vhp`rkgoats oif t`h gerst `ucoi kaaupoteki kg t`hukihe Comkmo Grhia` Cosseg AhitronThthr Beifki
Anoecs gkr Horny Tnhestkahih kaaupoteki kg t`h Grhia` Cosseg Ahitron orh hxoceihf wet`ei t`h akithxt kg t`hmhknkmeaon shtteim kg t`h seths. V`h Cosseg Ahitron es oiorho w`hrh vknaoiea prkahsshs rhphothfny groaturhf stkihs,t`us prkfuaeim gorcs t`ot nkkl nelh `ucoiny ckfegehfkbjhats: thp`rkgoats. V`h oionyses kgrow cothreon fevhrsety
prkvhs tk bh oi ecpkrtoit tkke tk fesareceioth bhtwhhikaaurrhiahs kgsua` thp`rkgoats oif ora`hknkmeaon seths, t`hhornehst kgw`ea` foth grkit t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih.
?. Eitrkfuateki
V`h prkfuateki kg mhkgoats, kbjhats rhsunteim grkc ioturon
groaturh oif ecetoteim orthgoats (@oyihs ?5=1), es o
p`hikchiki nkim rhakmiezhf ei coiy fegghrhit shfechitory
akithxts (The ?51=< Ckrthncois ?56=< Brhuen ?588< Anorl
?580< Bkurfehr ?57=< Gkuriehr ?5=?< Royion oif Vhxehr
?505< Royion ht on. ?554). O iucbhr kg wkrls `ovh
oionyzhf sua` kbjhats (porteaunorny gneit kihs), oif `ovh
trehf tk hnobkroth o cht`kf w`ea` festeimues`hs anhorny
bhtwhhi eithitekionny gnolhf kbjhats oif prkfuats kg ioturh
(Bkunh ?005< ?548< ?52?< @oworf ?5??< Cker ?5??<
]orrhi ?5?6< Mroyski ?507< Qa`iurrhibhrmhr oif Onoi
?508< Thoakal ?55?).V`h Cosseg Ahitron ei t`h ahitron ckuitoeikus rhmeki kg
Groiah hxphrehiahf oatevh vknaoiesc seiah t`h Cekahih
(?8-24 Cyr BT) oif shvhron mnoaeon hvhits fureim t`h
Tnhestkahih. Bhaoush vunaoiesc oif grkst oateki mhihroth
rkal groatureim, t`hrh es t`us o `em` prkbobenety kg t`h
ioturon kaaurrhiah kg pshufk-orthgoats ei t`es orho. V`h
fesakvhry kg gneit pshufk-tkkns akigushf o iucbhr kg
ora`ohknkmests fureim t`h ieihthhit` ahitury bhmeiieim wet`
Vorfy (?075), w`k rhpkrthf t`h fesakvhry kg Cekahih
hknet`s grkc Nh Tuy Akuriy ei t`h Aoiton. Ckrh t`oi gegty
yhors nothr Corty wos stenn ormueim gkr t`es eithrprhtoteki
(Aopetoioif Corty ?526).V`h Cosseg Ahitron rhmeki es whnn likwi gkr ecpkrtoit
hxaovotekis kg Xpphr Tonohknet`ea seths oif et `os
akisefhrobnh ora`ohknkmeaon pkthiteon gkr seths yehnfeim
cothreon grkc t`h Nkwhr oif Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea phrekfs.
Fureim t`h nost twhity yhors, cua` rhshora` `os bhhi
uifhrtolhi ei t`h rhmeki, oechf ot fesakvhreim troahs kg
t`h gerst `ucoi kaaupoteki kg Hurkph. V`hsh eivhstemotekis
`ovh bhhi akiahitrothf ei Whnoy, o prkveiah tk t`h skut`
kg Ouvhrmih w`ea` es rea` ei Tnek-Tnhestkahih gouios,
kaaurreim ei bhtwhhi vknaoiea shfechits w`ea` kgghr t`h
pkssebenety kg kbtoeieim o nkim shquhiah kg ponohkcomihtea
oif rofekchtrea foths. Bossh-Ouvhrmih oif Bkurbkiioes
`ovh yehnfhf o iucbhr kg anossea Oa`hunhoi begoahs
noaleim strotemrop`ea akithxt, oif ei surgoah akcpnhxhs kg
t`h Onnehr tkkns cofh ki quortz akbbnhs `ovh bhhi
fesakvhrhf.
V`h net`ea shrehs fesakvhrhf ei t`h Cosseg Ahitron,
preiaeponny ei Whnoy, `os bhhi anossegehf uifhr t`h ioch
"Ckst Oiaehit Tonohknet`ea" (Bkiegoy oif Bkiegoy ?501)
oif `os bhhi prkpkshf os rhsknveim t`h quhsteki kg t`h tech
kg t`h eieteon `ucoi kaaupoteki kg Hurkph (Bkiegoy.
Akisemiy, Neobhug ?505< Bkiegoy ?50?< ?501< ?505o< b< a<
?55?). V`es phrsphatevh, w`ea` es kg akisefhrobnh
akiahptuon ecpkrtoiah oif t`us cust bh gkuifhf ki
fhaesevh ormuchits, es ikt oaahpthf uioieckusny by t`h
saehitegea akccuiety, os fkubts obkut t`h ortegeaeon a`oroathr
kg t`h geifs `ovh bhhi hxprhsshf ei coiy pubneaotekis
(Fhnski ?505< Bkìfo ?554< Wenno ?55?< Gorezy ei Feoz
?551). ]h `hrh rhpkrt skch rhsunts kg oi hxoceioteki kg t`h
prkfuateki kg mhkgoats by vknaoiesc. ]h wenn rhghr tk t`hshos thp`rkgoats. V`hsh pshufk-orthgoats orh gos`ekihf ei
cothreons kt`ar t`oi gneit w`ea` kaaur ei t`h nkaon
hiverkichit kg suppkshfny oiaehit ora`ohknkmeaon seths.
Kur kbshrvotekis, bhmui ei ?505, orh gkuifhf ki t`h
hxoceioteki kg o iucbhr kg vknaoiea struaturhs oif t`h
fhpksets oif hpeanosteths osskaeothf wet` t`hsh struaturhs
(Gem. ?). V`hsh eivhstemotekis whrh oechf ot hnuaefoteim t`h
pkssebnh prhshiah kg `kceiefs ei t`h noth Tnekahih oif Horny
Tnhestkahih kg t`es port kg Groiah. Qphaeon otthiteki `os bhhi
mevai tk t`h seth kg Bnossoa oif port kg t`h obuifoit shrehs
kg suppkshf orthgoats fesakvhrhf ei oi oiaehit akithxt t`hrh
oif onsk tk t`h seth kg Qknhen`oa, yehnfeim t`h strkimhst
hvefhiah gkr oi horny kaaupoteki kg Whnoy.
2. V`h prkfuat eki kg thp`rkgoats
V`h prkfuateki kg thp`rkgoats es likwi tk `ovh kaaurrhf
ei pyrkanosteths kg t`h Heghn ei Mhrcoiy (Bkseisle ht on.
?507). ]h aknnhathf skch thp`rkgoats ki t`h seth kg Lornea`
oif ei strkcbkneoi nopenne kg t`h Qa`wheislkpg vknaoik ei
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 140/342
?14 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. ?. Nkaoteki kg t`h stufy orho.
t`h akcpoiy kg M. Bkseisle ei ?552. V`hsh thp`rkgoats
suphrgeaeonny rhshcbnh orthgoats oif t`her fegghrhiteoteki
grkc t`h notthr es feggeaunt w`hi t`hy orh fesakvhrhf kutsefh
kg t`her precory vknaoiea akithxt (Lunhchyhr ?507).
Ei Wanoy. coiy Tnhestkahih coor tugg-reims (No Qouvhtot,
Nhs Gormhs, Qoeit-Hbnh, Qknhen`oa, Qhiàzh, Bnossoa/Nhs
Bnoia`hs), bosoietea brhaaeos (Qoeith-Oiih) oif kih
strkcbkneoi akih `ovh yehnfhf thp`rkgoats wet` vorekus
phtrknkmeaon kremeis. Ckrhkvhr, coiy kt`hr mhkgoats `ovhbhhi aknnhathf ei o normh iucbhr kg vknaoiea shfechits
(Qoeit-Wefon, Wons, Brekufh).
Ockim t`hsh orh o iucbhr kg gnolhs oif skch kbjhats
wet` cuntepnh gnolh saors wet` o vhry rhmunor potthri: ikih
kg t`hc wkunf ba fesaorfhf kut kg `oif eg t`hy kaaurrhf ei
sknef ora`ohknkmeaon akithxts. @kwhvhr, t`hy orhuifkubthfny thp`rkgoats w`ea` `ovh rhsunthf grkc shvhron
cha`oieaon oif t`hrcon oatekis fureim vorekus fegghrhit
hruptevh stomhs kg vknaoiea hvhits.
1. Thtrkmrop`y kg t`h thp`rkgoats
V`h row cothreons kg t`h thp`rkgoats aknnhathf akch grkc
t`h rhmekion boshchit kr grkc t`h Tnek-Tnhestkahih
shfechitory gkrcotekis w`ea` `ovh bhhi onthrhf by t`h
vknaoiea hruptekis. Qkch kg t`hsh cothreons stenn kutarkp ei
t`h ecchfeoth hiverkichit kg t`h vknaoiea gkrcotekiseivhstemothf. V`h gknnkweim fevhrsh rkals `ovh bhhi
efhitegehf: vhei quortz, phmcotetea quortz, geih mroeihf
mroieth, krehithf mroieth, cemcotetea mihess wet` sennecoiet
nocprkp`yrh oif vorekus bosonts.
V`h Bnossoa-Nhs Bnoia`hs tugg-reim `os yehnfhf shvhity
twk thp`rkgoats. V`h festrebuteki kg phtrkmrop`eh typhs fkh
ikt vory semiegeaoitny bhtwhhi t`h a`uils, gnolhs kr pshuf
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 141/342
E J n JHOI-TOXN ROUION HV ON. - VHT@RKGOAVQ KG V@H GRHIA@ COQQEG AHIVRON
orthgoats (Gem. 2o). -6 strkim prhshiah kg cothreons kgcåfekarh gnoleim quonety (mroieths oif mihess) oif t`h
obshiah kg g neit es o festeian a`oroathrestea kg t`es shrehs.
6. Iotur on gnolhs
Ei t`es pophr wh fk ikt fesauss t`h anossea "pkt-n ef" gnolh
gkrc whnn likwi tk kaaur os o rhsunt kg g`hrconny eifuahf
rhfuateki shquhiahs. ]h ikth `kwhvhr t`h obshiah ei t`hnethroturh kg kbshrvotekis akiahrieim t`h a`oroathresteas kg
t`hsh t`hrcon groaturh ghoturhs w`hi t`hy kaaur ofjoahit tk
t`h hfmhs kg errhmunor a`uils. V`h ioturon gnolhs fhrevhf
grkc t`hsh setuotekis hx`ebet o pshufk-streleim pnotgkrc
prkfuahf w`hi t`h groaturh surgoah eithrshats oi ofjkeieim
hfmh. Ont`kum` t`hsh kbjhats coy bh suphrgeaeonny efhitegehf
os `ucoiny prkfuahf tnolhs, t`es pkseteki aoi bh rhofeny
fesaorfhf gkr gneit w`hi ikih kg t`h kt`hr ghoturhs kg
`ucoiny prkfuahf gnolhs aoi bh efhitegehf (pkeit kg
phrausseki, vhitron bunbor saor, rofeon strhss corls, hta).
Gegty ioturon gnolhs whrh aknnhathf gkr stufy grkc t`h
tugg-reims kg Bnossoa-Nhs Bnoia`hs, No Qouvhtot oif
Qknhen`oa (Gem. 1). Qkch kg t`hc whrh ei juxtopkseteki wet`
t`h pshufk-akrh. V`hy rhsunt grkc rhphtetevh uie-ferhatekion
strhsshs, bkt` cha`oieaon oif t`hrcon.
()n t`hsh, gegthhi (14%) hx`ebet akrteaon streleim pnotgkrcs.
V`hsh hou bh subfevefhf eitk t`ksh wet` o tkton kr porteon
akrteaon fkrson surgoah hxthifeim tk t`h hfmhs (?? kbjhats)
oif t`ksh wet` iki-akrteaon hfmhs (6 kbjhats). Ei t`h aosh kg
o shrehs prkfuahf by eithitekion gnoleim, t`hsh kbjhats
wkunf bh akisefhrhf kg precory oif shakifory mhihroteki.
Gnolhs wet`kut akrteaon streleim pnotgkrcs rhprhshit =4%
kg t`h tkton (18 kbjhats) oif t`es mrkup es akcpkshf kg t`ksh
wet` akrteaon fkrson surgoahs (0 kbjhats) oif t`ksh wet`
iki- akrteaon hfmhs (2= kbjhats). Ei o shrehs prkfuahf byeithitekion gnoleim, t`hsh wkunf bh akisefhrhf t`erf
mhihroteki gnolhs.
Tshufk-rhtkua` skchtechs opphoreim akitemukus aoi bh
shhi ki iuchrkus tnolhs oif et es akcporobnh wet` t`h utenezhf
kr rhtkua`hf hfmhs kg `ucoiny prkfuahf orthgoats (Gem. 1).
V`h prkpkrteki kg typhs kg ioturonny prkfuahf gnolhs ei
t`es shrehs es vhry fegghrhit grkc t`ot kbtoeihf grkc kur
hxphrechits wet` quortz phbbnhs. V`hy onsk fegghr grkc
t`ksh kg t`h tnolhf quortz osshcbnomhs aknnhathf grkc t`h
upphr oif ceffnh thrroahs kg t`h Onnehr ei Bkurbkiioes:
oi osshcbnomh kg thp`rkgoats es a`oroathrezhf by oi kvhr-
rhprhshitoteki kg gnolhs wet` iki akrteaon streleim pnotgkrcsoif iki akrteaon hfmhs oif oi uifhr-rhprhshitoteki kg gnolhs wet` akrteaon streleim pnotgkrcs oif hfmhs tktonny kr porteonny akrteaon (Gem. 2b).
Tshufk-gnolhs `ovh o whem`t bhnkw ?84 m ei ckrh t`oi
57 % kg t`h aoshs oif rorhny hxahhf 844 m (Gem. 2a). O ghw
hxahptekis hxest, rhprhshithf by vhry normh pehahs w`ea`
whem` kvhr 2444 m.
V`h whem`t arethreki es ikt o fesareceioteim goatkr
bhtwhhi thp`rkgoats oif orthgoats. V`h festrebuteki kg
whem`t roteks kg pshufk-gnolhs oif gnolhs coiugoaturhf oif
rhakvhrhf ei precory pkseteki (w`ht`hr ei hruptevh brhaaeos,
ora`ohknkmeaon noyhrs, kr by hxphrechitoteki) es efhiteaon.
V`es festrebuteki fegghrs grkc t`ksh kbshrvhf ki aknnhatekis
grkc surgoah seths: gkr t`h gnolhs aknnhathf ei Bkurbkiioes
ki t`h surgoah kg t`h upphr oif ceffnh thrroahs kg t`h Onnehrgkr hxocpnh, t`h whem`t rotek festrebuteki aoi bh hxpnoeihf
by t`h rhckvon kg t`h sconnhr gnolhs t`rkum` ioturon
prkahsshs oif shnhatevh aknnhateki (Gem. 2a).
8. Iotu ron kbjhats wet` cuntepnh gnolh saors
Hvhits nhofeim tk t`h ioturon gnoleim kg gromenh skurah
rkals orh fevhrsh ei ioturh oif coy rhsunt ei oi opporhitny
krmoiezhf shrehs kg gnolh saors. V`h krfhr ei w`ea` t`hsh
gnolhs orh rhckvhf normhny fhthrceihs t`h ckrp`knkmy kg
hoa` thp`rkgoat. V`h krmoiezoteki kg t`h ioturon gnolh saors
ki t`h bnkals poronnhns t`h ckrp`knkmy kg kbjhats
rhakmiezhf ockim prh`estkreh ora`ohknkmeaon osshcbnomhs.
V`h iucbhr kg gnolh saors ki t`h thp`rkgoats (bhtwhhi ?
oif 22) es akcporobnh wet` t`ot kbshrvhf ki prh`estkreh
kbjhats oif t`her roifkc krmoiezoteki es akcporobnh tk t`h
shquhiahs kbshrvhf ki coiugoaturhf kbjhats. @kwhvhr,
akitrory tk w`ot es hvefhit ki prh`estkreh kbjhats, t`h
fhtoa`chit pkeits kg gnolhs kbshrvhf ki thp`rkgoats orh
vhry kgthi ecpkssebnh tk fhthrceih oif ckst gnolh saors
kaaur ei roifkc orroimhchits.
Ki 16 goahs kg kbjhats wet` cuntepnh gnolh saors (5 uiegoahs
oif 27 begoahs) t`hrh es o neihor systhc kg "wkrleim"
orroimhf grkc rem`t tk nhgt gkr t`rhh gnolh saors ei twk aoshs
oif ei t`h rhcoeieim aoshs t`h wkrleim systhc es iki-neihor
wet` o coxecuc iucbhr kg shvhi gnolh saors kremeioteimgrkc kih hfmh. Ei mhihron, pshufk-wkrleim efhitegehf ki t`h
thp`rkgoats es coeiny iki-neihor ei orroimhchit.
V`h osskaeotekis kg gnolh saors ki hfmhs orh s`kwi ei t`h
gknnkweim tobnh:
Iucbhr kg gnolh
saors? 2 1 6 8 7 = Qocpnh
Xiegoaeonny "gnolhf"
kbjhats? 2 ? 1 4 2 4 5 goahs
Begoaeonny "gnolhf"
kbjhats*2 1 7 8 6 1 6 2= goahs
* (hoa` goah es akisefhrhf shporothny)
Qkch ioturon kbjhats opphor secenor tk uiegoaeonny gnolhf
a`kpphrs oif begoaeonny gnolhf a`kppeim tkkns ei t`ot t`hy
hx`ebet t`h troisgkrcoteki kg o ioturon hfmh wet` ot nhost
twk ofjoahit gnolhs (Gem. 6, i´ ?, 2, 6, 8< Gem. 8, i´ ?<
Gem. 7, i´ 8< Gem. 0, i´ 2).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 142/342
?12 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
2O VHT@RKGOAVQ(?22)
14 V
A`uils
Tshufk-gnolhs
Tshufk-tkkns
Cesahnnoihkus
2B VUTHQ KG TQHXFK-GNOLHQ OIF GNOLHQ
AQT-IAH IAQT-AB/TAB IAQT-IAH
2A ]HEM@V KG TQHXFK-GNOLHQ OIF GNOLHQ
Gem. 2. 2o: Thtrkmrop y kg thp`rkgoats.2b: Vyphs kg pshufk-gnolhs akcporhf tk gnolhs grkc ora`ohknkmeaon oif hxphrechiton shrehs. AQT: akrteaon streleim pnotgkrc.
AB: akrteaon boal. TAB: porteonny akrteaon boal. IAH: iki-akrteaon hfmhs. IAQT: iki-akrteaon streleim pnotgkrc.2a: ]hem`t kg pshufk-gnolhs akcporhf tk t`ksh kg ora`ohknkmeaon oif hxphrechiton shrehs.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 143/342
?11 JHOI-TOXN ROUION HV ON. - VHT@RKGOAVQ KG V@H GRHIA@ COQQEG AHIVRON
2 F AKCTOREQKI ]EV@ OQQHCBNOMHQ GRKC V]K RHTXVHFNW OIAEHIV QEVHQ
Vhp`rknoats (?22)
Bnossoa - Nhs Bottoits (2=0)
A`en`oa EEE (68)
_uortz Bosont Mroieth/Mihess
Thtrkmrop`y
2H AKCTOREQKI ]EV@ V@RHH ORA@OHKNKMEAON OQQHCBNOMHQ
Vhp`rknoats (?22)
Ikn`oa (==)
Qknhen`oa-Ahitrh A (667)
Qoeith-Oiih ? - J? (2?21)
Bosont s/T`kikneths Mroieths/Mihess
Thtrkmrop`y
Gem. 2. 2f: Akcporeski kg thp`rkgoats wet` net`ea osshcbnomhs grkc twk "ora`ohknkmeaon" oiaehit seths.2h: Akcporeski kg thp`rkgoats wet` net`ea osshcbnomhs grkc t`rhh ora`ohknkmeaon shrehs.
Ioturo! cunteferhatekion gnoleim orkuif t`h phrep`hry kg
vorekus a`uils oif pehahs prkfuahs kbjhats w`ea` orh
secenor tk eivosevhny gnolhf tobunor akrhs oif fesakefon
akrhs (Gem. 8, i" 1< Gem. 0, i´ 1< Gem. =, i´ ?, 2).
Qkchtecas t`h ioturon ckrp`knkmy es secenor tk t`ot shhi ki
begoaeonny gnolhf orthgoats (Gem. 6, i´ 1< Gem. 7, i´ ?< Gem. =,
i´1< Gem. 0, i´ ?).
Kt`hr thp`rkgoats nkkl secenor tk gnolhf pkny`hfrkis.
V`hsh mnkbunor kbjhats `ovh o normh iucbhr kg saors grkc
gnolhs wet` o `em` iucbhr kg iki-akrteaon streleim pnotgkrcs
(Gem. =. i´ 2, 6< Gem. 7, i´ 1, 6< Gem. 0, i´ 6< Gem. 5).
Os eg t`h festeiateki bhtwhhi thp`rkgoats oif eithitekionnycocrgoaturhf kbjhats es ikt feggeaunt hikum`, t`h aosh es
gwt`hr akcpneaothf by t`h pkkr row cothreons ei w`ea`t`hy kaaur. V`es kbshrvoteki `os onrhofy bhhi fesausshf ei
kt`hr wkrls otthcpteim tk festeimues` bhtwhhi mhkgoats oif
orthgoats (]otski ?570), hvhi t`kum` skch prkmrhss `os
bhhi cofh ei t`h aosh kg gneit (Thoakal ?55?), o row
cothreon gkr w`ea` t`hrh es tkfoy o akisefhrobnh ockuit kgeigkrcoteki ki ets gnoleim prkphrtehs.
7. Festeimues`eim bhtwhhi thp`rkgoats oif
`ucoiny prkfuahf kbjhats
]h `ovh `of rhakursh tk o stotesteaon opprkoa` tk sknvh
t`es prkbnhc, t`h fhtoens kg w`ea` wenn bh prhshithf
hnshw`hrh. Bhtwhhi 26 oif 72 thp`rkgoats, oaakrfeim tk t`h
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 144/342
?16 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 1. Hxocpnhs kg thp`rkgoats
(saonh ei ac) - Bnossoa-nhs
Bnoia`hs @outh-Nkerh, pyrkanosteths -
?: Torteonny akrteaon boalhf
pshufk-gnolh oif iki akrteaon
streleim pnotgkrc, geih mroeihf
mroieth. 2: Torteonny akrteaon boalhf
pshufk-gnolh oif akrteaon streleim
pnotgkrc, quortz. 1: Torteonny akrteaon
boalhf pshufk-gnolh oif iki
akrteaon streleim pnotgkrc, geih
mroeihf mroieth. 6: iki-akrteaon
boalhf pshufk-gnolh oif iki
akrteaon streleim pnotgkrc, geih
mroeihf mroieth. 8: Torteonny akrteaon
boalhf pshufk-gnolh oif akrteaon
streleim pnotgkrc, phmcotetea quortz.
7: pshufk-gnolh wet` iki akrteaon
hfmhs oif akrteaon streleim pnotgkrc,
geih mroeihf mroieth. =: pshufk-
gnolh wet` iki akrteaon hfmhs oif
iki akrteaon streleim pnotgkrc,
phmcotetea quortz. 0: Torteonny
akrteaon boalhf pshufk-gnolh oif
akrteaon streleim pnotgkrc, geih
mroeihf mroieth. 5: pshufk-gnolh
wet` iki akrteaon hfmhs oif iki
akrteaon streleim pnotgkrc, quortz.
iucbhr ei hoa` socpnh, `ovh bhhi offhf tk o shrehs kg
`ucoiny prkfuahf net`eas. V`h arethreo ushf gkr fhsarebeim
t`h twk mrkups whrh pubnes`hf by J. Aknneio-Merorf (?5=8<
?507). ]h `ovh fesaorfhf skch kg t`ksh arethreo, aonebrothf
skch kg `es iki-chtreaon kbshrvotekis oif offhf skch kg
kur kwi (whem`t oif iucbhr kg gnolh saors).
Goatkreon oionyses kg akrrhspkifhiahs rhvhons t`ot t`h
eiaeuseki kg t`h thp`rkgoats fhstrkys t`h ak`hrhiah kg t`h
osshcbnomh. V`h prhshiah kg twk fesarhth oif festeiat
mrkups es rhofeny kbshrvhf ei hoa` shrehs.
Ei t`h aosh kg o preiaepon akcpkihit oionyses, toleim onn
a`oroathresteas hxahpt t`h iucbhr kg gnolh saors eitk oaakui
ik truh festeiateki aoi bh cofh bhtwhhi thp`rkgoats oif
`ucoiny prkfuahf kbjhats. V`h ioturon trhif ei thp`rkgoa
es tkworfs o sp`hreaon kr sub-sp`hreaon s`oph, w`ea` ckst
hgghatevhny rhsests gurt`hr ioturon ottreteki. @ucoi eithrvhit
eithrrupts t`es trhif tkworfs o mnkbunor gkrc. @kwhvhr,
eifustrehs akitoeieim o prhpkifhroiah kg pkny`hfrkis aoiik
bh fesaorfhf kut kg `oif os `oveim o ioturon kremei oif
s`kunf bh stufehf oaakrfeim tk t`h sa`hch summhsthf obk
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 145/342
?18 JHOI-TOXN ROUION HV ON. - VHT@RKGOAVQ KG V@H GRHIA@ COQQEG AHIVRON
Gem. 6. Hxocpnhs kg thp`rkgoats
(orrkws eifeaoth anhor ferhatekis
kg gnoleim), saonh ei ac -
Cesahnnoihkus grkc @outh-Nkerh -
?: pshufk-a`kpphr, bosonth,
Bnossoa-nhs Bnoia`hs pyrkanosteths.
2: pshufk-a`kpphr, nocprkp`yrh.
Bnossoa. 1: pshufk-begoah-nelh
pehah. bosonth, Bnossoa-nhs
Bnoia`hs pyrkanosteths. 6: pshufk-
a`kpphr, bosonth, Bnossoa-
nhs Bnoia`hs tugg-reim. 8: pshufk-
a`kppeim-tkkn, cemcotetea mihess,
Qhiàzh tugg-reim eigårehur.
Torochtrea a`oroathresteas kgthi ushfgkr stufyeim o`ucoiny prkfuahf net`ea osshcbnomh, w`hi oppnehf tkthp`rkgoats, fk ikt phrcet oiy fest e iht eki bhtwhhi t`h twk.
Rot`hr t`oi s`kweim t`h fegghrhiahs, t`h rhsunts akigerc t`hsecenoretehs bhtwhhi thp`rkgoats oif coiugoaturhf kbjhats,
rhifhreim t`h cht`kf ushnhss.
=. Lhcorls ki twk rhputhfny oiaehit seths
=.?. BNOQQOA-NHQ BOVVOIVQ.
O shrehs aknnhathf ot Nhs Bottoits by G. Aorrå (?5=0<
?501< ?55?) es fothf by o iucbhr kg Tktosseuc/Ormki
fhthrceiotekis kg t`h bosontea novo-gnkw kvhrnyeim t`h
osshcbnomh, w`ea` eifeaoth oi omh orkuif kr bhykif 2 Cyr
BT. @kwhvhr, t`h gouio kg Bnossoa-No Merkifeh, ei oi
oionkmkus strotemrop`ea pkseteki, shhcs tk bh cua` ckrhrhahit, bhnkimeim tk t`h Thyrknnhs bekzkih oif prkbobny
foteim grkc orkuif ?.2-?.6 Cyr BT (Akut`urhs ?502< Aorrå
oif Akut`urhs ?502< Akut`urhs oif Tostrh ?501< Gkures
?505< Bkiegoy ?55?< Aorrå ?55?).
O shrehs kg 2=0 net`ea kbjhats `os bhhi hxoceihf. V`es
stufy es eiakcpnhth, `kwhvhr, bhaoush t`h cotrex `os bhhi
nhgt ki shvhron kbjhats. Kbshrvotekis tk foth orh os gknnkws:
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 146/342
?17 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 8. Hxocpnhs kg thp`rkgoats(orrkws eifeaoth anhor ferhatekis kggnoleim), saonh ei ac -Cesahnnoihkus grkc @outh-Nkerh -?: phrep`hronny gnolhf pshufk-a`kpphr, mroieth. No Qouvhtot tugg-reim. 2: pshufk-pkny`hfrki,
phmcotetea quortz, Bnossoa-nhsBnoia`hs pyrkanosteths. 1: pshufk-eivosevhny gnolhf tobunor pehah,mroieth, No Qouvhtot tugg-reim.6: pshufk-pkny`hfrki, mroieth,No Qouvhtot tugg-reim.
- Ckst kbjhats orh ki arystonneih rkals wet` ioturon
anhovomh pnoihs oif t`h groaturhs ei mhihron gknnkw t`hsh
pnoihs. V`es mevhs t`h pehahs oi opphoroiah kg bheim
portny kr eithitekionny gnolhf fhbetomh. @kwhvhr, ckst kg
t`h gnolhs fk ikt `ovh ikrcon ghot`hrhf thrceiotekis.
- Grkc t`h hvefhiah kg t`h gnolh saors, t`h oimnh kgfatoa`chit opprkoa`hs 54´, w`ea` es ikt usuonny
hiakuithrhf ei eithitekion gnoleim.
- Qhvhron kbjhats `ovh mrkss arystonneih errhmunoretehs w`ea`
rhifhr t`hc eiopprkpreoth row cothreons gkr gnoleim.
- Gnolhs fk ikt hx`ebet anhor pkeits kg phrausseki.
- Qkch kbjhats hx`ebet kbvekus t`hrcon groaturhs.
- Ki coiy kbjhats, t`h gnolh saors opphor tk kremeioth grkc
whnn kutsefh t`h rhcoeieim vknuch. Kbjhats kg secenor
gkrc, oif t`h gnolhs rhckvhf grkc t`hc by t`hrcon
oateki, `ovh bhhi aknnhathf grkc t`h tugg-reim kg Bnoss
Nhs Bnoia`hs. Ei shvhron aoshs, t`hsh pshufk-iuanhe oi
t`her akijkeieim gnolhs whrh gkuif ei precory pkseteki
wet`ei t`h tugg wet` t`h gnolhs borhny rhckvhf grkc t`porhit a`uil.
Qhvhron kbjhats kg vhry pkkr gnoleim quonety s`kw o
iucbhr kg rhphtetevh gnolh saors, w`ea` es oi uinelhny
kaaurrhiah hvhi ei o precetevh shrehs kg eithitekionny
gnolhf kbjhats. Ckrhkvhr, wet`ei t`h soch strotemrop`ea
nhvhn, cothreons wet` gor bhtthr gnoleim prkphrtehs orh
prhshit.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 147/342
?1= JHOI-TOXN ROUION HV ON. - VHT@RKGOAVQ KG V@H GRHIA@ COQQEG AHIVRON
Gem. 7. Hxocpnhs kg thp`rkgoats
(orrkws eifeaoth anhor ferhatekis kg
gnoleim), saonh ei ac - Bnossoa-nhs
Bnoia`hs @outh-Nkerh, pyrkanosteths •
?: pshufk-porteonny begoaeon fesakëf
pehah, cemcotetea mihess o
sennecoieth. 2: rhmunor pshufk-pkny`hfrki. quortz. 1: rhmunor
pshufk-pkny`hfrki, quortz.
6: rhmunor pshufk-pkny`hfrki.
krehithf mroieth. 8: pshufk-
a`kpphr, geih mroeihf mroieth.
- Geionny, t`h phtrkmrop`ea ioturh kg t`h shrehs prhshits o
festrebuteki akcporobnh tk t`ot kg thp`rkgoats (Gem. 2f).
V`h mhknkmeaon a`oroathresteas kg t`h seth kg Bnossoa-
Nhs Bottoits fhshrvh o gunn saonh fesausseki tkk hxthisevh
gkr t`es pophr. ]h secpny ikth `hrh t`h uifhieo`nh eianusekikg ioturonny groaturhf kbjhats oif t`h rhshcbnoiah tk t`h
phtrkmrop`ea sueth kaaupehf `y thp`rkgoats.
=.2. A@EN@OA EEE
V`h gkssen nkaonety kg A`en`oa EEE es likwi gkr o rea`
Wennogroia`eoi gouio (Bkhug ?501) oif net`ea kbjhats (Mut`
?5=6< Mut` oif Bkhug ?5==< Mut` oif A`ovoennki ?508)
w`ea` kaaur ei o nhvhn w`ksh omh es prhsuchf tk bh ei
t`h veaeiety kg ?.0-?.5 Co, o foth orrevhf ot t`rkum`
ponohkitknkmeaon akcporeskis oif hxtropknoteki grkc
obsknuth foths ki o novo gnkw anksh tk t`h seth.
V`h strotemrop`ea shquhiah hx`ebets fhgkrcotekis
eithrprhthf os rhsunteim grkc sknegnuxeki (Vhxehr ?508) kr
sken sneps (A`ovoen nki ?55?). Coiy vesets tk t`h seth
fureim t`h hxaovotekis `ovh akiveiahf us kg t`h hxesthiah
kg syi-shfechitory snucpeims oif rhckvons. V`es anhorny
fhckistroths fyiocesc kg o leif likwi tk kaaur ki
t`h cormeis kg noaustreih systhcs oif wh pkstunoth t`h
nelhne`kkf kg t`h hxesthiah `hrh kg oi oiaehit p`rhotk-
comcotea struaturh. Ei t`es fyiocea setuoteki, t`h prhshiah
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 148/342
N10 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
kg rhnotevhny rhahit tkkns ki quortz akbbnhs ei ofjoahit
nkaonetehs (Nh Monn oif Royion ?507) rhifhrs nelhny o
cexturh kg sua` kbjhats wet` t`h oiaehit gouio.
]h `ovh ikt hxoceihf ankshny t`h akcpnhth shrehs kg
kbjhats fesakvhrhf ei o strotemrop`ea akithxt (hishcbnhs B
tk L) oport grkc t`ksh pubnes`hf by A`ovoennki (?55?).
Hxahpt gkr t`h rhshcbnoiah bhtwhhi rhtkua`hf gnolhs oif
skch thp`rkgoats (Gem. 1), wh ikth t`ot t`h phtrkmrop`eaioturh kg t`h k`jhats kgghrs o festre`uteki efhiteaon tk t`ot kg
thp`rkgoats oif kg t`h shrehs kg pshufk-orthgoats rhakvhrhf
ot Bnossoa-Nhs Bottoits (Gem. 2f).
O fhtoenhf hxoceioteki kg t`h seth oif ets hiverkichit
wkunf anoregy wet`kut fkubt t`h ora`ohknkmeaon oif
mhknkmeaon prkahsshs w`ea` rhsunthf ei t`h prkfuateki
kg t`hsh kbjhats oif t`her osskaeoteki wet` t`h gouion
rhcoeis.
0. Akcporeski kg t`rhh ora`ohknkmeaon shrehs
]a `ovh a`kshi t`rhh ora`ohknkmeaon shrehs tk ennustroth
t`h guifochiton feggarhiahs w`ea` hxest bhtwhhi t`h
phtrkmrop`y kg thp`rkgoats oif t`ot kg prh`estkreh tkkns grkc
Whnoy. Ei t`h notthr, t`h phtrkmrop`y anhorny fhckistroths
`ucui shnhateki.
- Ot Ikn`oa, oport grkc hxahptekion gneit kbjhats. quortz
wos t`h preiaepon cothreon a`kshi (Rek Aorro ?55?<
Bkiegoy ?55?)
- Ei Qknhe n`oa-Ahitrh, quortz, bosont oif gneit orh ei t`ot
krfhr t`h t`rhh fkceioit cothreons (Broaak ?55?)
- Ei nhvhn Jn ei t`h aovh kg Qoeith-Oiih ? ot Tknemioa,
prkvesekionny rhpkrthf tk KEQ 7, bosonts, p`kikneth,
gneit oif quortz whrh ei t`ot krfhr t`h cothreons
wkrlhf.
V`h phtrkmrop`y kg tkkns grkc t`h prh`estkreh seths es
anhorny fegghrhit grkc t`ot kg t`h thp`rkgoats oif /.v
a`oroathrezhf (kutsefh t`h akistoit prhshith kg gneit) `yo a`keah kg cothreons w`ea` fkhs ikt eianufh t`ksh wet`
pkkr gnoleim a`oroathresteas nelh mroieths oif mihess
(Gem. 2h).
5. Akianusekis
5.?. VHT@RKGOAVQ ORH ]EFHNU FEQVREBXVHF
Et es ckrh t`oi rhoskiobnh tk ossuch t`ot thp`rkgoats whrh
prkfuahf ei mrhot iucbhrs ei t`h Cosseg Ahitron fureim t`h
iuchrkus vknaoiea hpeskfhs w`ea` kaaurrhf seiah t`h
Cekahih. ]et`kut fkubt, t`hy whrh subshquhitny hrkfhf kutkg t`her precory pkseteki oif wefhny fesphrshf ei t`h
hiverkichit ki iuchrkus kaaosekis.
V`h fesakvhry ei mhknkmeaon noyhrs kg skch brklhi kropporhitny gnolhf pehahs, gnolhs kr k`jhats hx`ebeteim o ckrhakcpnhx potthri kggnolh saors es t`hrhgkrh ikt akisefhrhfo suggeaeìit arethreki gkr a`oroathrezeim `ucoi oatevety,
porteaunorny ei t`es rhmeki.
5.2. IHAHQQORU RH-HPOCEIOVEKI KG QEVHQ
Qeths akisefhrhf eifeaotevh kg `ucoi oatevety os
fhckistrothf by t`h prhshiah kg o shrehs kg suppkshfny
`ucoiny wkrlhf phbbnhs oif akbbnhs fhcoif o anksh
saruteiy kg onn t`h ovoenobnh hvefhiah, hsphaeonny ei t`h ao
kg Bnossoa oif A`en`oa EEE.
Qeths w`ea` `ovh yehnfhf o necethf iucbhr kg fkubtgun
orthgoats, thp`rkgoats kr mhkgoats ihhf gurt`hr fhtoenhffesausseki. V`es es t`h aosh gkr Thrrehr-Htkuoerhs ei Tuy-f
Fñch (M.X.H.R.T.O., ?506), Qoeit-Hbnh (Bkiegoy ?505o)
Akupht (Bkiegoy ?505o) oif No Rka`h-Nocbhrt (Bkiegoy
?50?) ei @outh-Nkerh.
Gkr skch seths, osskaeoteki kg net`ea kbjhats wet` grom-
chithf gouion rhcoeis es ikt fhaesevh. V`h vorekus ckfh
kg gromchitoteki oif prhshrvoteki kg t`h bkihs fk ikt mev
ot prhshit suggeaeìit hvefhiah tk efhitegy oiy `ucoi
eivknvhchit.
Grkc t`h hvefhiah, et cust bh rhakmiezhf t`ot t`hrh es
akisefhrobnh fkubt akiahrieim o vhry oiaehit `ucoi prhshi
ei t`h Cosseg Ahitron.
Ei offeteki tk t`es top`kikcea opprkoa`, et es ihahssory
akisefhr t`h gknnkweim pkeits aorhgunny oif systhcoteaonny
gkr onn nkaonetehs:
- Es t`hrh o pkssebenety kg pshufk-orthgoats bheim prkfuah
- Eg sk, w`ot orh t`h nelhny a`oroathresteas kg t`hsh kbjha
- Es t`hrh o mhknkmeaon hxpnoioteki gkr t`h eitrkfuateki k
ioturonny gnolhf kbjhats eitk t`h seth;
- Orh net`ea kbjhats praghrhiteonny festrebuthf ei t`h suppksh
ora`ohknkmeaon noyhr; Es t`hrh o ioturon hxpnoioteki gkr t`
- Fk akijkeiobnh kbjhats hxest ei t`h seth, oif fk t`hy kaa
ofjoahit tk hoa` kt`hr;
- Orh t`h gnolh saors kbshrvobnh ki t`h kbjhats orroimhf
o tha`iknkmeaonny "nkmeaon" shquhiah;
- Orh ioturon kbjhats cexhf wet` orthgoats;
- Orh t`h gouion rhcoeis oif t`h osskaeothf kbjhats bkt`
precory pkseteki;
- Fkhs t`h top`kikcea `estkry kg t`h seth prkvefh oiy
hxpnoioteki gkr pkssebnh osskaeoteki kg iucbhrs kg
kbjhats kg fegghrhit omhs, gkr hxocpnh rhgnhateim
phremnoaeon p`hikchio;
5.1. KTTKRVXIEQVEA HPTNKEVOVEKI;
Aoi wh fesaorf kut kg `oif seths w`hrh kiny o ghw kbjha
`ovh bhhi gkuif; V`h utenezoteki kg cothreons kg pkkr
gnoleim quonety ei t`hsh seths coy secpny bh oi hxocpnh k`ucoi kppkrtuiesc oaakrfeim tk t`h now kg nhost hggkrt.
Offetekionny wh `ovh t`h akcpneaoteim goatkr ockim
oiaehit osshcbnomhs kg t`h nelhne`kkf kg kppkrtuiestea
hxpnketoteki kg ioturonny groaturhf pehahs w`ea` wenn kaau
oiywoy os o port kg t`h seth's osshcbnomh. ]`enh t`hshquhstekis `ovh onrhofy `hhi fesausshf gkr shvhron Ogreaoiora`ohknkmeaon seths, et es ik fkubt ushgun tk akisefhr t`h
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 149/342
?15 JHOI-TOXN ROUION HV ON. - VHT@RKGOAVQ KG V@H GRHIA@ COQQEG AHIVRON
Gem. =. Hxocpnhs kg thp`rkgoats
(orrkws eifeaoth anhor ferhatekis kggnoleim), saonh ei ac -
Cesahnnoihkus grkc @outh-Nkerh -
?: pshufk-eivosevhny gnolhf tobunor
pehah, mroieth, Bnossoa-nhs
Bnoia`hs pyrkanosteths. 2: pshufk-
eivosevhny gnolhf tobunor pehah.
bosonth, Bnossoa-nhs Bnoia`hs tugg-
reim. 1 : pshufk-begoaeonny gnolhf
fesakëfon pehah, bosonth, Bnossoa-
nhs Bnoia`hs tugg-reim.
"ofvoitomh kg t`eileim sconn os ora`ohknkmy hxpnkrhs t`hckst oiaehit spois kg prh`estkry" (M. Esooa ht on. ?50?).
5.6. V@H VECH KG GERQV @XCOI KAAXTOVEKI
Kiny t`h seths w`hrh uiquhstekiobnh ora`ohknkmeaon
anhchits `ovh bhhi fesakvhrhf ei o whnn fkauchithf nkim
shquhiah s`kunf bh akisefhrhf tk hnuaefoth t`es prkbnhc.
Ei t`h obshiah kg prhaesh foteim hnhchits gkr t`h seth kg
Ikn`oa. kiny Qknhen`oa "t`h ckst rhahit kg t`h vhry Nkwhr
Tonohknet`ea seths" (Bkiegoy ?55?) rhcoeis tk mevh oi efho
kg t`h thcpkron rhckthihss kg t`h `ucoi prhshiah ei
Whnoy.
V`h omh kg Qknhen`oa `os bhhi hstobnes`hf by bekstrotem-rop`ea arethreo (Bkiegoy oif Bkiegoy ?50?), ponohkcomihtea
fhthrceiotekis (V`kuvhiy ?501< V`kuvhiy oif Bkiegoy
?506) oif ckrp`kstrotemrop`y (Bkiegoy oif Chrmken ?500).
Qknhen`oa-Ahitrh `os onsk bhhi stufehf grkc o shfechitk-
nkmeaon oif ponyiknkmeaon pkeit kg vehw (Royion ?50= oif
uipubnes`hf). @kwhvhr, t`h gouio kg Qknhen`oa bhnkims tk
t`h "troiseteki gouio" w`ea` akvhrs o brkof tech sphatruc
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 150/342
?64 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 0. Hxocpnhs kg thp`rkgoats
(orrkws eifeaoth anhor ferhatekis kggnoleim), saonh ei ac -Cesahnnoihkus grkc @outh-Nkerh -?: pshufk-begoah-nelh pehah, mroiethf'oioghxeh, No Qouvhtot tugg-reim.2: pshufk-a`kpphr, bosonth,No Qouvhtot tugg-reim. 1: pshufk-eivosevhny sub-fesakëf gnolhf tobunorpehah. krehithf mroieth, Bnossoa-nhsBnoia`hs pyrkanosteths. 6: rhmunorpshufk-pkny`hfrki, geih mroeihfmroieth, No Qouvhtot tugg-reim.
(Bkiegoy ?50=). Gurt`hrckrh, t`h shfechitknkmeaon oif
ponyiknkmeaon foto fk ikt onnkw rhneobnh foths tk bhfhthrceihf oif t`h ponohkcomihtesc kg t`h akcpnhth
shquhiah `os ikt bhhi stufehf bhaoush kg t`h uisuetobenety
kg skch noyhrs gkr t`h oppneaoteki kg t`es cht`kf
(V`kuvhiy ?501: 0?). Ckst eithrhst `os bhhi mhihrothf by
t`h thp`rkstrotemrop`y rhpkrthf by Vhunofh (?508< ?500<
?505) oif fhthrceihf grkc akrhs (Bkiegoy oif Chrmken
?500).
O ferhat puceah os`-gonn `os bhhi efhitegehf ei t`h nolh
shrehs uifhrnyeim ora`ohknkmeaon noyhr A. V`hsh thp`roakrrhnoth wet` t`h "upphr puceahs kg Qoiay" (Aoitomrhn o
Boubrki ?501) oif ckst porteaunorny wet` t`h puceah kg
Ihsa`hrs. O iucbhr kg foteim cht`kfs pnoah t`h Ihsa`hr
puceah orkuif 4.0 Cyr BT (Vhunofh ?505: ?68). Ckrh
rhahitny, `kwhvhr, o 64
Or/ 15
Or omh kg 4,80 ¿ 4.42 Cyr BT
`os bhhi kbtoeihf (Nk Bhnnk ht on. ?50=), w`ea` `os bhhi
akigerchf by o t`hrcknuceihsahiah foth kg 4,82 ¿ 4,46
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 151/342
E E E JHOI-TOXN ROUION HV ON. - VHT@RKGOAVQ KG V@H GRHIA@ COQQEG AHIVRON
Gem. 5. Hxocpnhs kg thp rkgoats
(orrkws eifeaoth anhor ferhatekis
kg gnoleim), saonh ei ac -
Cesahnnoihkus grkc @outh-Nkerh -
?: pshufk-pkny`hfrki, mroieth,
No Qouvhtot tugg-reim. 2: pshufk-
pkny`hfrki, mroieth, Bnossoa-nhs
Bnoia`hs pyrkanosteths. 1: pshufk-
pkny`hfrki, mroieth, Bnossoa-nhs
Bnoia`hs tugg-reim. 6: pshufk-
pkny`hfrki, mroieth, No Qouvhtot
tugg-reim.
Cyr BT kbtoeihf by t`h quortz rhf phol VN cht`kf
(Tennhyrh ?55?). V`us, t h thp`rkstrotemrop`y akitrofeats t`h ponohkcomihtea foto oif ihahssetoths akisefhroteki kg o
foth orkuif 4.8-4.7 Cyr BTgkr Qknhen`oa-Ahitrh. V`es nost
foth es ei omrhhchit wet` o noth Arkchreoi omh tbr t`hgouio, os summhsthf by Woi Lkngsa`kthi (Rkhbrkhls oif
Woi Lkngsa`kthi, t`es vknuch).
5.8. FERHAVEKIQ GKR GXVXRH RHQHORA@
EE' wh fesaorf onn t`h fkubtgun oiaehit seths kaaurreim ei
t`h Cosseg Ahitron, t`h hornehst shttnhchit `estkry kg t`h
rhmeki cust bh rhwretthi. @kwhvhr, onn es ikt nkst yht. V`h
hvefhiah gkr t`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Ouvhrmih oif Whnoy
aoi bh rhvesethf, hvonuothf oif aorhgunny fesshathf ovkefeim
t`h trops kg t`her mhknkmeaon akithxt. Torofkxeaonny, ei t`h
geion oionyses et wkunf bh t`es nost w`ea` guries`hs o
fhtoenhf a`rkiknkmy kg t`h `ucoi prhshiah ei t`h rhmeki.Ferhatekis gkr guturh rhshora` orh anhor. Toronnhn tk oi
hxoceioteki kg t`h p`yseaon oif beknkmeaon a`oroathresteas kg
t`h ponohkhiverkichit, t`h anksh stufy kg pshufk-tkkns wenn
fkubtnhss prkvefh cua` fesausseki oif gkkf gkr t`kum`t.
But anhorny gkr hoa` suppkshfny oiaehit seth o cuntefesaepne-iory oif brkofny boshf stufy es obsknuthny ihahssory, oifikt kinygkr t`h rhmeki fesausshf `hrh.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 152/342
?62 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
O alikw nhfmhchit s :
V`h out`krs t`oil A. Mut`, K. Bkhug, J. Fhssh oif
T.J. Vhxehr w`k `ovh prkvefhf oaahss tk t`h hxaovotekis ot
A`en`oa< H. oif C.G. Bkiegoy gkr phrcetteim o iucbhr kg
vesets tk t`h seths ot Qknhen`oa, Ikn`oa oif Ahyssomuht<
G. Aorrå gkr oaahss tk t`h cothreon grkc Bnossoa oif gkr `es
`kspetonety oif ossestoiah fureim t`h rh-hxoceioteki kg
Bnossoa - Nhs Bottoits ei ?505< J. oif F. A`kchtth,
F. Nhghvrh, V. Tennhyrh oif M. Whriht gkr t`her aknnobkrote
ei t`h gehnf< J. Akut` urhs gkr `es uipub nes` hf eigkrc oteki
M. Arhvkno gkr vhregyeim t`h phtrkmrop`ea fhthrceiotekis
oif ]. Rkhbrkhls gkr rhvehweim t`h coiusarept.
rhghrhiahs
Bkìfo, H.
Bkhug, K.
Bkiegoy, H.
?554 _ue åtoehit nhs prhcehrs groiaoes;, No Rha`hra`h 221(2?), 57-570 .
?501 Nh seth vennogroia`ehi fh A`en`oa, hi @outh-Nkerh. Htufh ponåkitknkmequh ht beka`rkik-
nkmequh. V`hsh fh Fkatkrot Hs-Qaehiahs, Xievhrsetå Tores WEE.
?50? Nhs troahs fhs prhcehrs @kceiefås hi Groiah, No Rha`hra`h ?20(?2), ?662-?666.
?501 No Trå`estkerh fu Whnoy (Cosseg Ahitron groiaoes) ht nh prkbnàch fhs kremeihs fh ?'@kcc
Ei: No Rha`hra`h Ora`åknkmequh hi @outh-Nkerh, 5-?7, Oiionhs fu ARFT fh Anhrckit
Ghrroif.
?505o Xi seth fu Vrhs Oiaehi Tonåkne t`equh fh pnus fh 2 C.o. fois nh Cosseg Ahitron groiaoes:
Qoeit-Hbnh - Nh Akupht (@outh-Nkerh), Akcpths Rhifus fh WOaofåceh fhs Qaehiahs fh
Tores 140, såreh EE, ?87=-?8=4.
?505b Nhs prhcehrs semihs fh pråshiah `ucoeih. Ei: Ora`åknkmeh fh no Groiah: 14 kis fh
fåakuvhrths, 17-1=, Hfetekis fh no Råuieki fhs Cusåhs Iotekioux, Tores.
?505a Tonåknet`equh eigårehur ht ckyhi: prhcehrs tåckemiomhs `ucoeis. Ei: Ora`åknkmeh fh no
Groiah: 14 ois fh fåakuvhrths, 12-16, Ceiestàrh fh no Aunturh, Hfetekis fh no Råuieki
fhs Cusåhs Iotekioux, Tores.
?55? Nhs prhceàrhs eifustrehs fu Quf-hst fh no Groiah ht fu Cosseg Ahitron . Ei: H. Bkiegoy o
B. Woifhrchhrsa` (hfs). Nhs prhcehrs hwkpåhis, 71-04, AV@Q Hf., Tores.
Bkiegoy, C.G. ?506 Vop`kikceh quothrioerh: Akcporoeski hitrh seths ioturhns ht prå`estkrequhs fu Tnåestkaà
ckyhi: meshchits fh Qknhen`oa (@outh-Nkerh), Jkuriåhs f' åtufh fh ËOsskaeoteki ponåk
tknkmequh groiaoesh "Bekaåikshs ht top`kaåikshs", Tores, råsucå, ?0.
Bkiegoy, H.,C.G. Bkiegoy
?50= Bekstrotemrop`eh fhs mroifs coccegàrhs f'Hurkph fh ?'Kuhst, ?2´ Akimrhs eithriotekio
fh n'EI_XO, Kttowo, Råsucås, ?11.
?50? Nh meshchit prh`estkiquh fh Qknhen`oa (Bnoizoa, @outh-Nkerh). Ei: Nh bossei fu Tuy outhcps prå`estkrequhs. Rha`hra`hs råahiths, ?5-17, nh Tuy, Cusåh Arkzotehr.
?501 Nh Tonåknet`equh oiaehi hi Whnoy ht hi Ouvhrmih: aevenesotekis prå`estkrequhs ht cenehu
ioturhn. Ei: Nhs niåfets fh no Trå`estkerh Ouvhrmioth, 54-?46, Cusåh Bormkei Anhrckit-
Ghrroif.
Bkiegoy H.,
J. Chrmken
?500 Nhs coors fh Qknhen`oa (Bnoizoa, @outh-Nkerh) ht nhurs sårehs vknaoik-såfechitoerhs,
Akcpths Rhifus fh E'Oaofåceh fhs Qaehiahs fh Tores 14=, såreh EE, ?87?-?877.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 153/342
?61 JHOI-TOXN ROUION HV ON. - VHT@RKGOAVQ KG V@H GRHIA@ COQQEG AHIVRON
Bkiegoy H.,
O. Akisemiy,
R. Neobhug
Bkseisle, M.,
l. Lrkmhr.
J. Qa`othr,
H. Vurihr
Bkunh, C.
Bkurfehr, H'.
Broaak, J.T.
Brhuen, @.
Bunnh, V.
Aoitomrhn, J.C..
J.A. Boubrki
(nopetoi, N.,
T. Corty
Aorrå, G.
?505 Akitrebuteki fu Cosseg Ahitron groiaoes o no akiioessoiah fhs prhcehrs phupnhchits
prå`estkrequhs fh ?'Hurkph, Akcpths Rhifus fh E'Oaofåceh fhs Qaehiahs fh Tores 140,
såreh EE, ?65?-?657.
?507 Ontstheizhetnea`h Qehfnuimspnotzh oug fhi Kstheghn-Wunloihi, Jo`rbua` fhs R÷cesa`-Mhrcoiesa`hi Zhitron Cushucs 11, 5=-?14.
?005 Vhcps quothrioerhs ht prå`estkrequhs fu Aoiton, Rhvuh f'Oit`rkpknkmeh, 2?7.
?548 N'krem eih fhs Hknet`hs, N'Oit`rkpknkmeh ?7, 28=-27=.
?52? Nhs @kcchs gkssenhs. Tores: Cosski Hf.
?57= Trå`estkerh fh Groch. Tores: Ikuvhnnh bebnekt`àquh saehitegequh Gnoccoreki.
?55? Vypknkmeh, tha`iknkmeh ht cotehrhs prhceàrhs fhs eifustrehs fu Vrhs Oiaehi Tonåknet`equh hi
Whnoy (Cosseg Ahitron, Groiah). Trhcehrs råsuntots. Ei: H. Bkiegoy oif B. Woifhrchhrsa`,
(hfs). Nhs prhcehrs hurkpåhis, 51-?44, Tores: Hfetekis fu [email protected].
?588 Ievhoux hstuorehis fh monhts groaturås por nhs vomuhs ht nhs pnomhs sobnhushs fois no bossh
Qkcch, _uothrioreo EE, Rkch, 2?-25.
?50= Qtot+, ui utenetoerh stotestequh, Ora`åknkmuhs ht krfeiothurs ?4, AIRQ, 5-?2.
?501 A`rkiknkmeh fhs åruptekis fois Eh cosseg vknaoiequh fhs Ckits Fkrh: ecpneaotekis
vknaoiknkmequhs, Mhkn. Gr. (2) E, ? (2), ?21-?62.
?526 Nhs onnuvekis pkitehiihs fhs hiverkis f'Ouren noa (Aoiton) ht nhurs senhx toennhs, Rhvuh
oit`rkpknkmequh i´ 1-6, 16à oiiåh, cors-ovren ?526, ?-2?.
?5=0 Hnåchits f'eifustreh net`equh fois nhs gkrcotekis såfechitoerhs vennogroia`ehiihs fh
Bnossoa (@outh-Nkerh), Bunnhtei fh no Qkaeåne prå`estkrequh groiaoesh =8, i´ 8, ?1?-?12.
?501 Nh seth fh Bnossoa - Nhs Bottoits (`outh-Nkerh). Gkuennhs ?5=?-?5=0. Hnåchits f'uihstrotemrop`eh, Akimrhs Trå`estkrequh fh Groiah, 2? à shsseki, Ao`krs-Ckitouboi, (?5=5),
Qkaeåtå prå`estkrequh groiaoesh Hf. 2., 8=-=8.
?55? Nhs seths fu Tnekaàih supårehur fh Bnossoa - @outh-Nkerh (Cosseg Ahitron, Groiah). Ei:
H. Bkiegoy oif B. Woifhrchhrsa` (hfs), Nhs prhcehrs hurkpåhis, ?18-?62, Tores: Hfetekis
Aorrå, G.,
J. Akut`urhs
A`ovoennki, J.
Anorl, J.F.
?502 Ikuvhoux hnåchits fh fototeki fhs gkrcotekis vknaoiequhs fh Bnossoa (@outh-Nkerh,
Groiah): eignuhiahs sur no a`rkiknkmeh fhs gouihs "vennogroia`ehiihs" fu Cosseg ahitron
groiaoes, 5à Råuieki oiiuhnnh fhs Qaehiahs fh no Vhrrh, Qkaeåtå måknkmequh fh Groiah Hf.,
Tores, ?2?.
?55? Nhs hishcbnhs net`equhs fh A`en`oa EEE (@outh-Nkerh): typknkmeh, setuoteki strotemrop`equh
ht oionysh aretequh ht akcporotevh. Ei: H. Bkiegoy oif B. Woifhrchhrsa` (hfs), Nhs prhcehrs hurkpåhis, 0?-5?. Tores: Hfetekis fu [email protected].
?580 V`h ioturon groaturh kg phbbnhs grkc t`h Botklo Mkrmh, Ikrt`hri R`kfhs eo, oif ets
bhoreim ki t`h loguoi eifustrehs kg Ogreao, Trkahhfeims kg t`h Trh`estkreh Qkaehty 26,
76-==.
Aknneio-Merorf. J. ?5=8 Nhs eifustrehs ora`oëquhs sur monhts fhs thrrosshs quothrioerhs fh no pnoeih fu Rkussennki
(Tyråiiåhs Krehitonhs, Groiah). V`hsh fh 1´ ayanh, Xievhrsetå fh Trkvhiah.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 154/342
?66 VXG< @ORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Akut`urhs, J.
Akut`urhs, J.,
G. Tostrh
?507 Mrennh fhsareptevh ht åvknuteki typknkmequh fhs eifustrehs ora`oëquhs: nh ckfành aotonoi
Bunnhtei fh no Qkaeåtå prå`estkrequh groiaoesh 01, i´ ??-?2, 101-641.
?502 Akitrebuteki o no a`rkikstrotemrop`eh fh gkrcotekis pnek-pnåestkaàihs fu Cosseg Ahitr
(Groch). V`hsh fh 1´ ayanh, Tores WE.
?501 A`rkikstrotemrop`eh fu Tnek-pnåestkaàih f'Ouvhrmih ht fu Whnoy: ikuvhoux oppkrts fhs
fototekis rofekcåtrequhs ht fu ponåkcomiåtesch, Bunnhtei fh ?'Osskaeoteki groiaoesh pk
?'åtufh fu _uothrioerh ?, 5-?0.
Fhnski, H.
Feoz, R.
Gkures, C.
?505 Knfhst Huroseoi stkih tkkns, Ioturh 164, 57.
?551 Nhs prhcehrs hurkpåhis vhioehit-ens f'Ogr equh; , N'@estkerh ?78, 62-68 .
?505 Qeths vennogroia`ehis fu Fhvàs ht nhs bosonths fh no vonnåh fh n'Onnehr: oppneaoteki fh no
cht`kfh Tktosseuc-Ormki. V`hsh f'Xievhrsetå, Anhrckit EE.
Gkuriehr, O. ?5=? Cht`kfh f'åtufh fhs eifustrehs ora`oëquhs sur monht. Fepn÷ch f'Htufhs Opprkgkifehs,
Xievhrsetå fh Trkvhiah.
Mroyski, F.L.
M.X.H.R.T.O.
Mut`, A.
?507 Hknet`s, Ora`ohknkmeaon Ocbemuety, oif t`h Mhihroteki kg "Ceffnh Roimh" Rhshora`. E
FJ. Chntzhr, F.F. Gkwnhr, J.O. Qobnkgg (Hfs), Ochreaoi Ora`ohknkmy Tost oif Guturh.==-?11, ]os`eimtki: Qcet`skieoi Eistetuteki Trhss.
?506 Tråshiah pkssebnh f'@kceiefås hi Ouvhrmih ou Tnekaàih supårehur (2,8 C.o.): E'oppkrt
fhs Htkuoerhs (Esskerh, Tuy fh F÷ch), A. R. Oaof. Qae. 255, ?45?-?457, Tores.
?5=6 Fåakuvhrth fois nh Wennogroia ehi f'Ouvhrmih fh monhts ocåiomås, A. R. Oaof. Qae. 2=5
?4=?-?4=2, Tores.
Mut`, A,
K. Bkhug
?5== Nhs prhcehrs monhts ocåiomås fu Wennogroia`ehi f'Ouvhrmih, Nh Akurrehr fu AIRQ 28,
67-6=.
Mut`, A,
J. A`ovoennki
?508 Fåakuvhrth hi ?506, fh ikuvhoux kutens ponåknet`equhs o A`en`oa EEE (@outh-Nkerh),
Bunnhtei fh no Qkaeåtå Trå`estkrequh Groiaoesh 02, 87-76.
@oworf, G.]. ?5?? V`h A`eppeim kg Gneit by ioturon Omhiaehs, Trkahhfeims kg t`h Trh`estkreh Qkaehty kg Ho
Oimneo ?, ?08-?51.
@oyihs, AW. Jr.
Esooa, M.,
J.].L. @orres.
G'. Cors`onn
Lunhchyhr, J.
Nh Monn, K.,
J.T. Royion
Nk Bhnnk, T.,
M. Gårouf,
A.C. @onn,
F. Ukrl,
T. Noveio,
C. Bhriot
?5=1
?50?
?507
?507
?5Q=
V`h Aoneak Qeth: Ortegoats kr Mhkgoats;, Qaehiah ?0?, 148-1?4.
Qcon! es eigkrcotevh: t`h oppneaoteki kg t`h stufy kg ceie-seths oif nhost-hggkrt arethreo ei
t`h eithrprhtoteki kg t`h Horny Tnhestkahih ora`ohknkmeaon rhakrf ot Lkkbe Gkro, Lhiyo. E
J.F. Anorl oif M. Esooa, Nos Eifustreos cos Oitemuos, P Akimrhssk Xieki Eithriotekion
Aehiaeos Trh`estkreaos y Trktk`estkreaos, Chxeak (?50?), ?4?-??5.
Feh ont-uif cetthnponoknet`esa`hi Guifh vki Lornea`. Fesshrtoteki, L÷Vi.
Ahrzot (@outh-Nkerh): Nh Teå fu Rky, ui seth prå`estkrequh fois ui vknaoi. Rhvuh Ora`
nkmequh fu Ahitrh fh no Groiah 28(?), 55-?44.
6iOr/ 15Or sthp `hoteim oif noshr guseki foteim kg o quothriory puceah grkc Ihsa`hrs,
Cosseg Ahitron, Groiah: t`h fhghot kg xhikarystea akitoceioteki, A`hc. Mhkn. (Eskt. mhks
Qhat.) 77, 7?-=?.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 155/342
?68 JHOI-TOXN ROUION HV ON. - VHT@RKGOAVQ KG V@H GRHIA@ COQQEG AHIVRON
Cker. J.R. ?5?? V`h Ioturon Groaturh kg Gneit oif ets Bhoreim Xpki Rufechitory Gneit Ecpnhchits,
Trkahhfeims kg t`h Trh`estkreh Qkaehty kg Host Oimneo ?, ?=?-?0.
Ckrthncois, M. ?56= Xih aoush f'hrrhur hi prå`estkerh: no toennh mnoaeoerh. Bunnhtei fh no Qkaeåtå Rkyonh Bhemh
f'Oit`rkpknkmeh ht Trå`estkerh NWEEE. 74-=?.
Thoakl, H. ?55? Festeimues`eim bhtwhhi Orthgoats oif Mhkgoats: O Vhst Aosh grkc Hosthri Himnoif,
Jkurion kg Gehnf Ora`ohknkmy ?0, 168-17?.
The. ].A. ?51= Nh r÷nh fhs p`åikcåihs ioturhns fois ?'åanothchit ht Eh goakiihchit fhs rka`hs furhs
utenesåhs por n'`kcch prå`estkrequh. Rhvuh fh Måkmrop`eh T`ysequh ht fh mhknkmeh
Fyiocequh 5, 165-621.
Tennhyev, E. ?55? Fototeki por t`hrcknuceihsahiah. Oppneaoteki o no a`rkiknkmeh fhs rhtkc`åhs vknao-
iequhs. V`hsh fh ?'Xievhrsetå fh Anhrckit EE, FX168.
Royion, J.T. ?50= Hvknuteki akcporåh fh noas fh coors hi Ouvhrmih ht Whnoy (Groiah). Fototeki ht
akitrebuteki o no akiioessoiah fhs anecots pnåestkaàihs. Ei: Vrovoux groiaoes hi Tonåk-
neciknkmeh, 78-57, Fkauchits fu AHRNOV, Cåckerh i´ ?.
Royion. J.T.,
J.T. Vhxehr
?505 Fåakuvhrth f'Oa`hunåhi oiaehi fois no aorreàrh V`kcos ? o Aosobnoiao ht prkbnàch fh
?'oiaehiihtå fh no pråshiah `ucoeih ou Corka, Akcpths Rhifus fh VOaofåceh fhsQaehiahs fh Tores 140, såreh EE, ?=61-?=65.
Royion. J.T..
J.T. Vhxehr,
F. Mhroofs,
G.Z. Onokue
?554 Xi ikuvhou meshchit ponåkitknkmequh pnek-pnåestkaàih hi Ogrequh fu Ikrf: O`n On
Kum`noc (oiaehiih aorreàrh Fåprhz) o Aosobnoiao (Corka), Akcpths Rhifus fh E'Oaofå
ceh fhs Qaehiahs fh Tores 1?4, såreh EE, 1?8-124.
Rek Aorro. C. ?55? N'eifustreh sur quortz fh Ikn`oa-Beorf, ui meshchit fu Vrhs Oiaehi Tonåknet`equh (råsun-
tots pråneceioerhs). FHO, Xievhrsetå f'Oex-Corshen nh.
Rkhbrkhls, ]..
V. voi Lkngsa`kthi
t`es V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: O rhopproeson kg orthgoatuon oif a`rkiknkmeaon
vknuch hvefhiah.
Qa`iurrhibhrmhr. F..
N.B. Onoi
?508 O Akitrebuteki tk t`h Qtufy kg t`h Ioturhgoat/Ortegoat Akitrkvhrsy. Ei: C.M. Tnhw,
J.A. ]kkfs, C. M. Tovhsea (hfs), Qtkih Vkkn Oionyses, ?11-?85, Onbuquhrquh: Xievhrsety
kg Ihw Chxeak Trhss.
Vorfy, N.
Vhunofh, O.
?075 Qkaeåtå f'Oit`rkpknkmeh fh Tores, ?7 fåahcbrh ?075.
?508 Htufh tåp`rknkmequh fh gkrcotekis noaustrhs fh coors fu Whnoy Kaaefhiton. FHO,
Xievhrsetå f'Oex-Corshennh EE.
?500 Nhs thp`ro ahifrk-pkiahux fois nhs shfechits fu noa fh coor fh Qknhen`oa (@outh-Nkerh):
påtrkmrop`eh ht kremeih, Qka. Cest. Iot. Ouvhrmih 81, 15-61.
?505 Våp`rknkmeh fhs gkrcotekis ahifrk-pkiahushs hi cenehux noaustrhs quothrioerhs. Cht`kfhf'åtufh ht oppneaoteki ou Cosseg Ahitron groiaoes (Whnoy) ht oux Aorpot`hs krehitonhs
rkucoeihs (fåprhsseki fh Brosskv). V`hsh fh ?'Xievhrsetå f'Oex-Corshennh EE.
Vhxehr, T.J. ?508 A`en`oa EEE: ui meshchit ponåkitknkmequh vennogroia`ehi sknegnuå;. Bunnhtei fh no Qkaeåtå
prå`estkrequh groiaoesh 02, 70-=4.
V`kuvhiy, I. ?501 Htufh ponåkcomiåtequh fh gkrcotekis fu Tnek-Tnåestkaàih ht fh n'@knkaàih fu Cosseg
Ahitron ht fh shs o`krfs. V`hsh, Xievhrsetå f'Oex-Corshennh EE.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 156/342
?67 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
V`kuvhiy, I.,
H. Bkiegoy
Wenno, T.
]orrhi, Q.@.
?506 Ihw a`rkiknkmeaon foto ki Hurkphoi Tnek-Tnhestkahih gouios oif `kceief kaaupoteki
seths, Ioturh 140, 188-180.
?55? Ceffnh Tnhestkahih Trh`estkry ei Qkut`whsthri Hurkph: V`h Qtoth kg Kur Likwnhfmh oi
Emikroiah, Jkurion kg Oit`rkpknkmeaon Rhshora` 6=(2), ?51-2?0.
?5?6 V`h Hxphrechiton Eivhstemoteki kg Gneit Groaturh oif ets Oppneaoteki tk Trkbnhcs kg
@ucoi Ecpnhchits, Jkurion kg t`h Rkyon Oit`rkpknkmeaon Eistetuth kgMrhot Bretoei o
Erhnoif 66, 6?2-684.
]otski, ]. ?570 Gneit Ecpnhchits. 1rf Hf. Nkifki: Bretes` Cushuc.
Jhoi-Toun Royion
Xievhrsetå fh Bkrfhoux ?
Eistetut fu _uothrioerh
XCR 5511 AIRQ oif MFR ??22 AIRQ
Ovhiuh fhs Goauntås,
G-11648 Vonhiah Ahfhx
Groiah
Nekihn Comkmo
MFR ??22 AIRQ
Råsefhiah Royckif
60 Onnhh fhs Oenhs
G-41244 Wea`y
Groiah
Ththr Beifki
Fhportchit kg Oit`rkpknkmy
]hsthri Oustroneoi Cushuc
Groiaes Qtrhht, Thrt` 7444
]hsthri Oustroneo.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 157/342
Oeoei Vuggrhou 5 V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph:Tehrrh Oitkeih Akiteihiton Ikrt`whsthri Hurkph
V`h ponohknet`ea rhakrf kg akiteihiton ikrt`whsthri
Hurkph es a`oroathrezhf by seths ei o nkhss- oifgnuveon
fhpksets akithxt, usuonny prhshrvhf ei t`h gorc kgnkhss-
akvhrhf revhr thrroahs. Os o rhsunt rhnotevh a`rkiknkmehs aoi
bh hstobnes`hf kvhr rot`hr normh festoiahs, onnkweim tk eighr
t`ot t h hornehst kaaupoteki kgt`es rhmeki foths boal tk
obkut 744 Lyr BT. V`es es hsphaeonny whnn hstobnes`hf ei t`h
Qkiuih vonnhy. ]krl ei t`h Aomiy orho `os pnoahf t`h
Oa`hunhoi kaaupotekis t`hrh ei o normh vorehty kg
haknkmeaon shtteims.
?. Eitrufuateki
V`h mhkmrop`eaon orho akiahrihf (Gem. ?) es a`oroathreshf
by t`h prhshiah kg gnuveon fhpksets. kgthi prhshrvhf ei t`h
gorc kg thrroah shquhiahs, oif by Ceffnh oif Noth
Tnhestkahih nkhssea fhpksets. t`ot nkaonny rhoa` akisefhrobnh
t`ealihsshs. Vroahs kg gkriehr coreih bhoa`hs orh rot`hr
akccki ei t`h Cosseg Orckreaoei, but rorh ei t`h ikrt`hri
port kg t`h A`oiihn. Lorstea eigenneims orh vertuonny necethf
nk t`h Chush bosei. V`h orho rhvehwhf `hrh es kih kg t`ksh
Hurkphoi rhmekis w`hrh Tonohknet`ea ora`ohknkmests `ovh
bhhi akifuateim gehnfwkrl grkc t`h vhry bhmeiieim kg
prh`estkreh ora`ohknkmy kiworfs (h.m. ei t`h Qkcch oif@oeih vonnhys oif ei t`h Neàmh rhmeki). Ei t`es pophr wh
wenn mevh o s`krt rhmekion prhshitoteki kg t`h hvefhiah kg t`h
hornehst kaaupoteki kg t`es orho, prkbobny kih kg t`h ckst
`hoveny rhshora`hf rhmekis kg Hurkph.
2. V`h Chush bosei
2.?. NO BHNNH-RKA@H (QTRECKIV)
V`h kiny seth ei t`h Chush orho t`ot prhfoths KEQ 0 es No
Bhnnh-Rka`h ot Qpreckit, o lorstea aovh setuothf obkut 24 lc
skut` kg Neàmh (Bhnmeuc) ki t`h rem`t boil kg t`h Ocbnavh
revhr. Torteonny fhstrkyhf by quorryeim oatevetehs. t`h seth `os
bhhi uifhr hxaovoteki grkc ?504 kiworfs (Akrfy ht on.?552). V`h geifs akch grkc o `krezkiton lorst monnhry, w`ksh
eigXneim akisests kg o bosea mrovhn uiet kvhrnoei by o shrehs kg
cufstkih noyhrs akitoeieim t`h geifs, oif shonhf by o aonaeth
noyhr. X-shrehs foteim kg t h aonaeth akvhreim t`h gksseneghrkus
fhpksets yehnfhf oi omh ei hxahss kg 184,444 yhors.
V`h gouion osshcbnomh rhakvhrhf grkc t`h cufstkih
noyhrs akitoeis obkut 84 sphaehs, ockim w`ea` Aoies cks-
boa`hises, Xrsus fhieimhre, Phikayki nyaokiefhs, Toit`hro
nhk gkssenes. Toit`hro mkcboszkhmhises, Hquus cksboa`hi-
ses, Feahrkr`eius htrusaus oif @hcetromus bkione orh
prhshit. V`h osshcbnomh `os bhhi fothf tk KEQ ?1 omh, e.h.
ot orkuif 844 Lyr BT. V`h net`ea eifustry akisests kg gneit
kbjhats - shvhrhny whot`hrhf oif ei onn prkbobenety ei
shakifory pkseteki - rhakvhrhf grkc t`h upphr port kg t`h
gksseneghrkus fhpksets. V`h sconn osshcbnomh akitoeis
phbbnhs wet` o ghw saors ("phbbnh-eifustry") oif skch
gnolhs. Bhaoush kg ens p`yseaon akifeteki t`es shrehs es
feggeaunt tk subcet tk o fhtoenhf oionyses oif skch wkrlhrs
`ovh hvhi aost fkubts ki t`h ortegeaeon a`oroathr kg t`h gneit
kbjhats (Rkhbrkhls oif Qtophrt ?507).
1. V`h @oeih vonnhy
Gkur revhr thrroahs (Gem. 2), shporothf grkc hoa` kt`hr
by o a`onl tonus ?4 c `em`, whrh rhakmieshf ei t`h @oeih
vonnhy (@ohsohrts ?506). V`h knfhst twk (To f'n o ?'eou
oif Thtet Qpehiihs) orh eithrprhthf os foteim grkc t`h
hif kg t`h Arkchreoi akcpnhx. V`hy `ovh bhhi ottrebuthf
tk t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih ki t`h boses kg akrrhnotekis tk
t`h Qa`hnfh (Hsaout) bosei oif ei vehw kg t`h skens
prhshit ei t`h nkhssea shfechits akvhreim t`h twk ykuimhstthrroahs.
Eivhstemotekis aorrehf kut by T. @ohsohrts ei t`h Qkcch
vonnhy `ovh nhf tk o akrrhnoteki sa`hch gkr t`h gnuveon
fhpksets kg t`h Qkcch oif @oeih boseis (@ohsohrts oif
Fupues ?507): t`h Thtet-Qpehiihs thrroah aoi bh hquothf
wet` t`h thrroah kg Aomiy-n'Hpeihtth, w`hrhos t`h To f'no
?'eou wkunf akrrhspkif wet` t`h thrroah kg Aomiy-no
Morhiih. Ei t`h @oeih vonnhy kiny t`h twk knfhst thrroahs,
To f'no ?'eou oif Thtet-Qpehiihs, `ovh yehnfhf Oa`hunhoi
eifustrehs.
1.? . TO F'NO N'EOX (KEQ ?2)
O sconn autteim ei t`h tkp kg t`h To f'no n'eou pnothou,
w`hrh t`h mrovhns surgoah, yehnfhf o ghw orthgoats, skch
`oifoxhs oif twk sarophrs (Ao`hi ?506).
1.2. THVEV-QTEHIIHQ (KEQ ?4)
V`h Thtet-Qpehiihs gkrcoteki akisests kg o shquhiah kg
gnuveon mrovhns oif soifs, upworfs a`oimeim eitk mrhyes`
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 158/342
?60 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. ?. Nkaoteki kg seths chitekihf
ei t`h thxt:
?. Obbhvennh<
2. No Bhnnh Rka`h (Qpreckit)<
1. Aomiy<
6. Nh @ovrh<8. To f'no neou/Thtet Qpehiihs<
7. Tkrt-Temikt (Ghrcoivennh)<
=. Qoeit-Oa`hun<
0. Qoeit-Aknkcboi.
soifs. Ckst orthgoats rhakvhrhf grkc t`es thrroah orh grkc
surgoah aknnhatekis, w`enh skch whrh uiakvhrhf ei oi
hxaovoteki trhia`. Ckst kg t`hc orh `oifoxhs, kg vorekus
gkrcs: ocymfonkefs, kvoths oif noiaeknås. Vkkns ki gnolhs
orh rhnotevhny ghw ei iucbhr. V`h Nhvonnkes tha`iequh es
rhprhshithf by akrhs oif gnolhs (Ao`hi ?506).
6. V`h Qkcch Bosei
6.?. A@RKIKQVROVEMROT@EAON OIF TONOHKHIWERKI-
CHIVON AKIVHPV KG V@H QEVHQ
V`h fhtoenhf likwnhfmh kg t`h mhkchtry kg t`h Qkcch
vonnhy's thrroah systhc onnkws us tk pkseteki ponohknet`ea
seths wet`ei o shrehs kg ieih thrroahs, rhmunorny spoahf
bhtwhhi 8 tk 7 oif 84 c obkvh t`h bhf-rkal kg t`h oatuon
revhr vonnhy (Oitkeih ?554< ?551< Oitkeih oif Vuggrhou
?551< @ohsohrts oif Fupues ?507).
Qtufehs kg t`h anecoteaon oif prkahssuon semiegeaoiah
kg t`h vorekus gnuveon shquhiahs `ovh s`kwi t`ot hoa`
thrroah bkfy, rhprhshithf by o suaahsseki kg mrovhns oif
geih-mroeihf gnuveon fhpksets, gkrcs t`h ckrp`knkmeaon-
shfechitory kutput kg o mnoaeon-eithrmnoaeon ayanh. Ei
mhihron, precory akithxt seths orh prhshrvhf wet`ei t`h
geih-mroeihf aonaorhkus gnuveon shfechits, wet`ei t`h'hxthcon' ports kg t`h thrroahs, e.h. anksh tk t`h a`onl
tonus. V`hsh seths bhnkim tk t`h hif p`osh kg t`h gnuveon
ayanh, ei o coeiny eithrmnoaeon akithxt (Gem. 8). Ei skch
aoshs, `kwhvhr, Oa`hunhoi kaaupotekis grkc t`h
bhmeiieim kg o anecotea ayanh `ovh bhhi fkauchithf, ei o
stenn thcphroth akithxt grkc t`h bhmeiieim kg o mnoaeon
p`osh (Gems 1 oif 6).
O gerst a`rkikstrotemrop`ea eithrprhtoteki es boshf ki t`
akcporeski kg anecotea ayanhs fhfuahf grkc t`h stufy kg
t`h thrroah systhc (revhr thrroahs oif ets akvhr kg nkhss oi
ponohkskns) wet` t`h kxymhi esktkph strotemrop`y,
ponohkcomihtea foto (Bequoit ?5=6< Nourhit ?551) oif
ckrh rhahitny, HQR oif X-shrehs foths (Nourhit ?551).
Ei t`es eithrprhtoteki, t`h thrroah 'Gkrcotekis' E tk WEE
foth tk t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih Bru`ihs ikrcon hpka`, w`
kiny t`h prhshit vonnhy's mrovhns orh ottrebuthf tk t`h
]hea`shneoi pnhiemnoaeon.
V`h knfhst eighrrhf troahs kg `ucoi kaaupoteki
fkauchithf ei t`h Qkcch vonnhy orh t`h ghw 'orthgoats'
uiakvhrhf ei t`h revhr fhpksets grkc t`h thrroah kg Mroah
Ckiteàrhs, foteim grkc bhgkrh t`h Brui`hs-Cotuyoco
bkuifory (Bkurfehr ht on. ?5=6o). @kwhvhr, t`h ortegeaeon
a`oroathr kg t`h ghw gnolhs pubnes`hf es ikt uiakithsthf, o
t`h bhst pehah es o pkeit kbtoeihf by rhtkua`eim o ioturon
gnolh. Bhgkrh t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih t`hrh es ik sknef troa
kg `ucoi prhshiah ei t`es rhmeki, wet` t`h gerst eifustrehs
bhnkimeim tk t`h Oa`hunhoi.
6.2. V@H QEVHQ KG OBBHWENNH
6.2.?. Obbhvennh: Aorphitehr quorry (Gkrcoteki Wen,KEQ ?7/?8)
V`h Aorphitehr quorry ot Obbhvennh es nkaothf ki t`h rem
boil kg t`h Qkcch, ot ets akignuhiah wet` t`h Qaorfki, o
sconn trebutory kg t`h Qkcch. V`es seth es whnn-likwi gkr
t`h obuifoit ponohkitknkmeaon rhcoeis uiakvhrhf grkc t`
corih Coia`h (Bkunh, ei Akcckit ?5?4< Tkitehr ?520).
V`h strotemrop`y kg t`h seth, whnn-likwi seiah t`h bhmeiie
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 159/342
?65 ONOEI VXGGRHOX OIF TEHRRH OIVKEIH - AKIVEIHIVON IKRV@]HQVHRI HXRKTH
@ H N E I C H Q W E I T H V E V - Q T E H I I H Q
N O V R KX E N N H
-74
• 1 4
H1 AF B c •? 2 1 6 8 7
Gem. 2. Akcpkseth shateki t`rkum` t`h onnuveon gkrcotekis ei t`h Qpehiihs orho (ogthr @ohsohrts oif Fupues, ?507).o. Bkttkc vonnhy mrovhns< b. Nkwhr mrovhns kg Aorreàrh @ånei< a. Chsvei thrroah ommrofoteki< f. Thtet-Qpehiihs thrroah ommrofoteki<h. To feo n'eou thrroah ommrofoteki.?. Aurrhit gnuveon fhpksets< 2. ]hea`shneoi nkhss< 1. @orcemiehs ponohsken (Hhceoi)< 6. Qooneoi nkhss< 8. Vhrteory soifs (Noifhieoi)< 7. A`onl.
kg t`es ahitury (Akcckit ?547< ?5?4) `os bhhi eithmrothf
ei vorekus syit`hshs ki t`h thi-oahs oif t`h ponohknet`eaeifustrehs kg t`h Qkcch bosei (Omoa`h ht on. ?571<
Bkurfehr ?575o< Bkurfehr ?5=6< Bkurfehr ht on. ?5=6o oif
?5=6b< Vuggrhou ?50?< ?50=).
Rhahitny, prhaesh chosurhchits `ovh setuothf t`h bosh kg
t`h thrroah bkfy ot 64 c obkvh t`h bhf-rkal kg t`h prhshit
revhr vonnhy. V`h gnuveon shquhiah kg t`h Aorphitehr quorry
akrrhspkifs tk t`h fkwistrhoc hxthiseki kg t`h shvhit`
gkrieoteki kg t`h Qkcch systhc (Gkrcoteki fh Rhioiakurt,
Oitkeih ?554). Toronnhn tk t`hsh stufehs ponohkcomihtea
oionyshs s`kwhf t`ot t`h gnuveon shquhiah bhnkims tk t`h
Brui`hs ikrcon hpka` (Nourhit ?551).
V`h prhshitny vesebnh shateki s`kws o t`ei gnuveonshquhiah, grkc t`h hxthrion port kg t`h thrroah bkfy, anksh
tk t`h a`onl tonus. akvhrhf by o t`ei noyhr kg soify-nkocy
fhpksets. V`h bkuifory bhtwhhi t`hsh twk uiets es corlhf
by oi hrksekion nhvhn, osskaeothf wet` normh pkalhts.
V`h gnuveon shquhiah akisests kg twk coei uiets: t`h
nkwhr uiet akisests kg o a`only mrovhn, vhry bofny skrthf ei
ets nkwhr ports, w`hrh et akitoeis bem bnkals kg a`onl oif
gneits, uirknnhf ei o soify-aonaorhkus cotrex. V`es uiet
akitoeis nhishs kg aonaorhkus nkocs t`ot fespnoy o rkum`ny
`krezkiton strotegeaoteki.
V`h upphr gnuveon uiet akrrhspkifs tk t`h sobnhs corihux
vhrfotrhs oif t`h coieh Coia`h kg W. Akcckit, t`ot
yehnfhf t`h rhcoeis kg normh coccons. Et akisests kg o
suaahsseki kg nhishs kg soify nkocs oif soifs wet`
aonaorhkus kiakne t`s, oif fespnoys o strotegeaoteki eifeaotevh
kg o gnuveon hiverkichit kg chfeuc hihrmy. V`h obuifoit
kiaknet`s t`ot a`oroathresh t`es fhpkset w`hrh gkrchf ei t`es
hiverkichit. V`hsh kvonkef, ahitechtrh-sezhf aorbkiothf
anhchits orh t`h rhsunt kg shoskion oatevetehs kg Rkfkp`y-
aåas oif Ayoikp`ysåhs (Ofknp`h ?5=6), onmoh eifeaotevh kg
anhor wothr, ei o stobnh `yfrkmrop`ea shtteim, oif pkeiteim tk
thcphroth anecotea akifetekis.Ei mhihron t`h pknnhi osshcbnomhs grkc t`h kiaknet`-
fhpksets eifeaoth o cksoea noifsaoph, wet` gkrhsts oif
sthpphs, akrrhspkifeim tk o thcphroth Akiteihiton anecoth
(Cuiout ?500 oif phrs. akcc.). Grkc o anecotea pkeit kg
vehw t`h typh kg shfechits oif t`h pknnhi eifeaoth o
anhorny thcphroth akithxt, oi osshsschit akigerchf by t`h
obuifoit prhshiah kg kiaknet`s akcporobnh tk t`ksh
kbshrvobnh ei t`h @knkahih fhpksets ei t`h prhshit-foy
vonnhy.
V`h gouio grkc t`h Aorphitehr quorry akitoeis t`h
gknnkweim sphaehs, oaakrfeim tk Bkunh (ei Akcckit ?5?4):
Nkwhr uiet: Hquus ogg. sthikies, R`eikahrks (3 Feahrk-r`eius) oif @eppkpktocus.
Xpphr uiet: @yohio ag. arkauto, @kckt`hreuc notefhis,
Coccut`us chrefekiones, C. trkmkit`hree, C. precemhieus
wet` ora`oea a`oroathresteas, Hnhp`os (Tonohknkxkfki)
oitequus, Hquus sthikies, H. sthikies rkbustus oif coybh
H. `yfruiteius, Feahrkr`eius htrusaus, F. chrhle. F. nhptk-
r`eius, Hnosckt`hreuc, Qus sarkgo. @eppkpktocus, Ahrvus
sknenoaus, A. (Foco) skckihises, A. hnop`us, A. bhnmroife,
A. aoiofhises, Aoprhknus aoprhknus, Bks presaus, oif
B. hnotus kr htrusaus. O rofeus kg o normh ahrvef oif oi
upphr C1 kg Qus ag. strkzze whrh gkuif ei ?505. Ont`kum` et
es ecpkssebnh tk sphaegy t`h hxoat prkvhioiah kg t`h normh
coccon rhcoeis fhsarebhf ot t`h bhmeiieim kg t`es ahitury.
t`h akcpkseteki kg t`h gouio osarebhf tk t`h upphr uiet es
ak`hrhit wet` t`h typh kg hiverkichit chitekihf obkvh<
t`h prhshiah kg `eppkpktocus ei t`h nkwhr uiet, t`h mrovhns,
shhcs tk eifeaoth o cexturh, `kwhvhr.
V`h a`rkikstrotemrop`ea eithrprhtoteki kg t`h Gkrcoteki
fh no Aorreàrh Aorphitehr wet`ei t h Qkcch systhc (KEQ
?7 tk ?8) es ei omrhhchit wet` t`h pkseteki kg t`h Obbhvenl
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 160/342
?84 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
gouio ei t`h normh coccon bekzkioteki (zkih EEE kg Akrfy
?502), wet` ponohkcomihtea hvefhiah oif wet` t`h HQR
foths (744 ¿ 54 Lyr BT).
Ot t`h hif kg t`h nost ahitury M. f'Ount fu Chsien
aknnhathf normh iucbhrs kg `oifoxhs (ikw ot t`h Cusåh
fhs Oitequetås iotekionhs oif t`h Eistetut fh Tonhkitknkmeh
@ucoeih), t`kum`t tk bh akithcpkroihkus wet` t`h
Coctcet`us chrefekiones gouio. Oaakrfeim tk @. Brhuenoif @. Lhnnhy (?586), 'Obbhvenneoi' `oifoxhs, wet`
ihmotevhs kg s`krt oif t`eal gnolhs oif akrthx prhshrvhf ot
t`her bosh oif hfmhs whrh gkuif. Iuchrkus kvoth
`oifoxhs oif necoifhs whrh fhsarebhf by W. Akcckit
(?5?4), w`k akunf ikt geif orthgoats osskaeothf wet` t`h
gouio ei t`h corih Coia`h. Brhuen's wkrl ei t`h ofjoahit
Nåki quorry yehnfhf kiny kih necoifh, grkc obkvh t`h
coieh bnoia`h.
6.2.2. Obbhvennh: Qtofh oif A`ocp fh Cors
(Gkrcoteki WE, KEQ ?6 tk ?1)
V`h seths kg t`h Qtofh oif t`h A`ocp fh Cors orhsetuothf ei t`h soch mhkckrp`knkmeaon akithxt os t`ot kg t`h
Aorphitehr quorry. @kwhvhr, t`h rhnotevh ontetufh kg t`h bosh
kg t`h mrovhns (ot obkut +11 c) summhsts o akrrhnoteki tk t`h
ecchfeothny gknnkweim gnuveon gkrcoteki, t`h Gkrcoteki fh
Gråvennh (WE). Ei t`h obshiah kg rhahit kbshrvotekis et es
ecpkssebnh tk mevh o prhaesh fhsarepteki kg t`h strotemrop`
aon oif ponohkhiverkichiton akithxt kg t`h vhry iuchrk
`oifoxhs (Gem. 1) fesakvhrhf ei t`h mrovhns. Ckst kg t`hc
orh kvoths oif necoifhs, t`kum` skch `ovh bhhi anossege
os 'Obbhvenneoi' by Brhuen (aknnhateki kg t`h Cusåh fhs
Oitequetås Iotekionhs)< Vuggrhou ?50=< ?552). Et es
t`hrhgkrh pkssebnh t`ot skch kg t`h 'Obbhvenneoi' begoahs
cua` ckrh rhahit oif t`ot hoa` o pksthreki anossegeaotekkg orthgoats wet`kut o prhaesh strotemrop`eaon akithxt kiny
yehnfs ortegeaeon shrehs kg ki t`h kih `oif rkum` 'Obbh-
venneoi'-typh `oifoxhs oif Oa`hunhoi kihs ki t`h kt`hr.
Gkr t`ot rhoski kih s`kunf gkr kiah oif gkr onn obknes` t`
thrc 'Obbhvenneoi', bh et ei t`h anosseaon "aunturon" shish
tk ovkef hvhry pkssebnh akiguseki, ei t`h typknkmeaon shis
os stenn ushf ei t`h typknkmy kg G. Bkrfhs (?57?).
6.1. QEVHQ KG V@H QOEIV-OA@HXN/AOMIU RHMEKI
Gnuveon thrroahs orh porteaunorny whnn-fhvhnkphf ot Qoei
Oa`hun, o suburb kg Ocehis, setuothf ki t`h nhgt boil kg
Qkcch, ot ets akignuhiah wet` t`h Ovrh revhr. V`h thrroabhnkim tk t`h Gråvennh gkrcoteki (WE) oif tk t`h Gkrcotek
fh no Morhiih (W). V`es nost kih es vesebnh o ghw lenkcht
upstrhoc, ot Aomiy-no Morhiih oif ot Aomiy-Aechteàrh,
t`h vonnhy kg t`h Ovrh, w`hrh ykuimhr revhr fhpksets orh
onsk prhshrvhf (Gkrcoteki fh n'Hpeihtth, EW).
Gem. 1. Obbhvennh, A`ocp fh Cors.@oifoxh. Qaonh ei ac.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 161/342
?8? ONOEI VXGGRHOX OIF TEHRRH OIVKEIH - AKIVEIHIVON IKRV@]HQVHRI HXRKTH
61.?. Qoeit-Oa`hun, ruh Corahnei Bhrt`hnkt
e Gkrcoteki WE.KEQ ?6 tk ?1)
V`h shquhiah kg t`h 'ruh Corahnei Bhrt`hnkt' ot Qoeit-
Oa`ain neos bhhi stufehf ei fhtoen ei ?50? by O. Vuggrhou
oif J.T. Gomiort fureim o sonvomh hxaovoteki. V`h gnuveon
fhpksets orh rot`hr t`ei `hrh (obkut 1 c t`eal) oif tk o normh
axeait whot`hrhf os rhsunt kg t`her pkseteki ei o ckrh ahitron
port kg t`h gkrchr revhr vonnhy, w`hrh akvhreim nkhsseanoyhrs orh usuonny vhry t`ei. V`her rhnotevh ontetufh onnkws o
akrranoteki wet` t`h Gråvennh gkrcoteki (WE).
V`h iuchrkus Oa`hunhoi orthgoats aknnhathf grkc t`h
mrovhns oif t`h gnuveon soifs orh usuonny poteiothf oif
rknnhf. V`hrh orh vorekus gkries kg `oifoxhs (ocymonkefs,
necoifhs) oif gnolhs wet` errhmunor rhtkua`hs. O Nhvonnkes
akrh >e åanot prågårhitehn es onsk prhshit . V`hsh geifs rhaonn
t`h orthgoats chitekihf by W. Akcckit, grkc fh Gråvennh
quorry (Qoeit-Oa`hun), w`ea` kaaupehs o nhss 'eithrion'
pkseteki ei t`h soch thrroah bkfy. Ei vehw kg t`h
bof akifetekis kg prhshrvoteki kih aoiikt hxanufh oi
ofcexturh wet` ckrh rhahit orthgoats. V`h ecpkrtoiah kg
t`h seth nehs ei ets akigercoteki kg Akcckit's hornehr
kbshrvoteki kg t`h iuchrkus prhshiah kg Oa`hunhoi
orthgoats wet`ei t`h Gråvennh gkrcoteki (Akcckit ?540<
?545).
6.1.2. Qoeit-Oa`hun. ruh fh Aomiy (Gkrcoteki W,
KEQ ?2 tk ??)
V`h seth kg t`h 'ruh fh Aomiy' ot Qoeit-Oa`hun es whnn-
likwi bhaoush kg t`h hxaovoteki uifhrtolhi by W. Akcckit
(?540) fureim buenfeim oatevetehs ei ?547. V`h strotemrop`eaon
shquhiah akieoeis mrovhns oif geih-mroeihf revhr fhpksets
- soifs oif nkocs - kvhrnoei by o rot`hr t`ei noyhr kg
nkocy fhpksets. t`h gockus sobnhs rkux.V`h mrovhns yehnfhf ocymfonkef `oifoxhs wet` o
akrteaon bosh oif o ghw tkkns ki gnolhs: sarophrs, hif-
sarophrs, ikta`hs oif fhiteaunoths. V`h nkwhr port kg
t`h geih-mroeihf gnuveon fhpksets akisests kg w`eth soifs.
V`hsh akitoeihf o shrehs kg 224 `oifoxhs, ocyfonkefs oif
necoifhs, os whnn os tkkns ki gnolhs kg vorekus typhs. V`h
sobnhs rkux fhpksets, wet`kut oiy fkubt foteim grkc t`h
nothr port kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, (KEQ 0;) yehnfhf
144 `oifoxhs, ckst (2=?) kg t`hc necoifhs, wet` iuchrkus
twesthf hfmhs. Just nelh t`h kt`hr shrehs grkc t`es seth t`htkkns ki gnolh orh kg vorekus gkrcs, oif ik Nhvonnkes
prkfuats orh prhshit.
6.6. V@H AOMIU QEVHQ
V`h seths kg Momiy, 'No Morhiih', 'Aechteàrh' oif
VHpeihtth' orh setuothf ki t`h nhgt boil kg t`h Ovrh revhr, o
ghw lenkchtrhs grkc ets akignuhiah wet` t`h Qkcch. V`h
t`rhh seths orh vhry anksh tk hoa` kt`hr, wet` o coxecuc
festoiah kg ? lc. V`h t`rhh seths bhnkim tk twk festeiat
gnuveon gkrcotekis (Gem. 6): t`h Gkrcoteki fh no Morhiih
(thrroah W, KEQ ?2 tk ??, wet` oi HQR omh ot Morhiih kg
644 ¿?4? Lyr BT) gkr t`h gerst twk seths oif t`h Gkrcoteki
fh E Hpeihtth (thrroah EW, KEQ ?4 tk 5, HQR foth kg 257 ¿
81 Lyr BT< Nourhit ?551) gkr t`h nost kih.
O akcbeihf stufy kg t`hsh t`rhh seths `os rhsunthf ei o
ckfhn kg t`her anecoteaon oif shfechitknkmeaon hvknuteki, ei
w`ea` t`h Oa`hunhoi kaaupotekion p`oshs `ovh bhhi
eithmrothf (Oitkeih oif Vuggrhou ?551).
6.6.?. Aomiy-No Morhiih (Gkrcoteki W, KEQ ?2
tk ??)
V`h seth Aomiy-No Morhiih wos hxpnkethf os o quorry
grkc ?5?7 tk ?585, w`hi et wos anossegehf os o Ckiuchit
`estkrequh, o ghw yhors bhgkrh et wos bkum`t by t`h Grhia`
stoth (?571). V`h seth es gockus gkr t`h eiiuchrobnhOa`hunhoi orthgoats rhakvhrhf grkc t`h Ovrh fhpksets,
kvhrnoei by o t`eal shrehs kg nkhssea shfechits.
IH
N Hpeihtth
No Morhiih
Gem. 6. Mhihron struaturh oif rhnotekis ep bhtwhhi Morhiih oif Hpeihtth gkrcotekis ei t`h Aomiy orho (ogthr Oitkeih oif Vuggrhou, ?551).?. A`onl bhfrkal< 2. Qnkph fhpkset shquhiah wet` eithrstrotegehf gnuveon sents ei t`h Morhiih Gkrcoteki< 1. Thremnoaeon gnuveon mrovhns kg Morhiih
oif Hpeihtth gkrcotekis< 6. Gnuveon soifs (Morhiih Gkrcoteki)< 8. Gnuveon aonaorhkus sents (Hpeihtth Gkrcoteki)< 7. Qnkph fhpkset shquhiah
kvhrnyeim onnuveon gkrcotekis (nkhss, snkph fhpksets oif ponohkskens)< =. Xifesturbhf ponohknet ea shttnhchits.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 162/342
?82 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
[À1
t ^gtt gt
[ e 6- ]n n ! , e . g • E . E . X E U . ' e - g . j t e ? ,Y eJ *r
Gem. 8. Efhonezhf shateki t`rkum` t`h onnuveon shquhiah kg t`h Ceffnh thrroah akcpnhx ei t`h Aomiy orho (ogthr Oitkeih oif Vuggrhou, ?551).4. A`only bhfrkal< ?. Qhquhiah kg a`only snkph fhpksets wet` eithrstrotegehf bhfs kg aonaorhkus gnuveon sents. V`h boson port kg t`hsh fhpksetsnothronny poss t`rkum` typeaonny aonaorhkus gnuveon mrovhns (?') (? & ?': Horny mnoaeon shfechitoteki)< 2. Cojkr p`osh kg akorsh shfechitoteki eibroefhf revhr oif o phremnoaeon hiverkichit (Gunnmnoaeon shfechitoteki)< 1/6. Qtobenesoteki kg t`h gnkkfpnoei: aonaorhkus geih gnuveon sents wet`eccoturh skens kg `ucef mrossnoif (Eithrmnoaeon)< 8. Brkwi nhoa`hf sken (eithrmnoaeon ei snkph hiverkichit)< 7. Xiakigkrcety bhtwhhi uiets (?-oif (2). O. Xifesturbhf Tonohknet`ea shttnhchits< B. Rhwkrlhf Tonohknet`ea orthgoats.
V`h seth's strotemrop`y es likwi t`rkum` t`h
kbshrvotekis kg G. Bkurfehr (?575o), t`h fhtoenhf stufehs
by T. @ohsohrts (@ohsohrts oif Fupues ?507) oif by t`h
foto aknnhathf ei ?507-?50= fureim oi hxaovoteki ei t`h
hxthrion port kg t`h Morhiih thrroah, ot t`h gkkt kg t`h
normh anosseaon shateki (Vuggrhou ?505). Ei ?551 ihw
hxaovotekis storthf tk t`h ikrt` kg t`h coei shateki,
tkworfs t`h Aechteàrh seth (hxaovotekis by t`h uievhrsetehs
kg n.ennh oif kg Thiisynvoieo).
V`h shquhiah kg t`h hxthrion port kg t`h Morhiih thrroah,
hxaovothf ei ?507 oif ?50=, es fkceiothf by snkph
fyioceao, wet` kaaosekionny eithrsphrshf gnuveon shfechits.
V`h prkxecety kg t`h revhr akursh es fkauchithf t`rkum`kut
t`h shquhiah by kvhrboil fhpksets oif by o nothron s`egt tk
o typeaon gnuveon fhpkset ot t`h bosh kg t`h shquhiah (Gem. 8,
uiets ? oif ?').
Rhahit stufehs `ovh s`kwi t`es shquhiah tk bh knfhr t`oi
t`h 'anosseaon' revhr thrroah fhsarebhf by hornehr wkrlhrs.
V`es anosseaon thrroah akisests kg pnhiemnoaeon gnuveon
fhpksets, oif o mrovhnny gnkkf pnoei eithrshathf by broefhf
a`oiihns (Gem. 8, uiet 1).
V`h gerst rhsunts kg pknnhi oionyshs kg t`h Aomiy-noMorhiih shquhiah (Cuiout ?551) eifeaoth gkr t`h nkwhr
port kg t`h hxaovoteki shateki (Gem. 8, uiet ?) o suaahsseki
kg Akiteihiton thcphroth p`oshs, akrrhspkifeim tk o
gkrhsthf-sthppea noifsaoph rhnotevhny rea` ei thcphroth
toxo. Ogthr o aknfhr phrekf t`h `em`hr nhvhns s`kw o
a`oimh tkworfs o bkrhon gkrhst noifsaoph, hifeim wet` o
suboratea hiverkichit wet` Bhnueo. Tknnhi grkc soif
nhishs ei t`h uiet 2 mrovhns eifeaoth oi kphi sthppea
hiverkichit, wet` o vhmhtoteki fkceiothf by `hrbs (iki
orbkrhon pknnhi 77.= %).
V`es pknnhi-boshf ckfhn kg t`h hvknuteki kg vhmhtoteki oi
anecoth akigercs oif fhtoens t`h ckfhn kg anecotea hvknuteki
eieteonny prkpkshf ki t`h boses kg strotemrop`eaon oif
shfechitknkmeaon kbshrvotekis (Oitkeih ?554): horny mnoaeon
t`h uiet wet` t`h Oa`hunhoi orthgoats oif t`h normh cocco
gkssens (Hquus aobonnus cksboa`hises, Chmoahrks sp., Ahr
hnop`us oif normh bkvefs< Ckemih ?551), pnhiemnoaeon gkr t
cojkr akorsh mroeihf port - wet` rhwkrlhf orthgoats - kg
t`h thrroah bkfy oif noth mnoaeon gkr t`h mrhhi soifs akvhre
t`h gnkkf pnoei (Gem. 8, uiet 1). V`h upphr port kg t`es uiet
fespnoys o revhr vonnhy-typh pshufkmnhy grkc o thcphroth
akithxt (Woi Wneht-Noi÷h, ei Vuggrhou ?505).
Qtufehs kg t`h mhkchtry kg t`h fhpksets anhorny s`kw t`
t`h gerst seths whrh ki o sub-`krezkiton boil obkut ?4 c
wefh, setuothf bhtwhhi t`h a`onl tonus onkim t`h skut`hri
boil kg t`h revhr oif t`h revhr etshng (Gem. 8). V`h orthgoat
grkc t`h vorekus ora`ohknkmeaon nhvhns (Gem. 7) orh ckstny
prkfuats kg o gneit wkrls`kp hxpnketeim t`h row cothreon
prhshit ei t`h ofjoahit a`onl anegg: iuchrkus akrhs oif`oifoxhs, coiy kg t`hc fesaorfhf rkum`kuts ei vorekus
stomhs kg prkfuateki (Nocktth ?55?). V`h prhshiah kg o
vhry sconn iucbhr kg Nhvonnkes akrhs oif kg Nhvonnkes
gnolhs - kgthi `orfny festeimues`obnh grkc gnolhs prkfuahf
w`enh coleim `oifoxhs - es streleim.
Worekus pehahs s`kw t`h hxesthiah kg neilomhs bhtwhhi
cht`kfs kg `oifoxh prkfuateki oif cht`kfs kg Nhvonnkes
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 163/342
?81 ONOEI VXGGRHOX OIF TEHRRH OIVKEIH - AKIVEIHIVON IKRV@]HQVHRI HXRKTH
Gem. 7. Aomiy-no Morhiih. Eifustry kg t`h gnuveon fhpksets.? oif 1: Nhvonnkes akrhs. 2: @oifoxh wet` o ihmotevh kg o rhckvon secenor tk o Nhvonnkes gnolh. Qaonh ei ac.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 164/342
?86 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. =. Aomiy-n'Hpeihtth. Eifustry kgt`h gnuveon fhpksets.?. @oifoxh< 2. Nhvonnkes akrh.Qaonh ei ac.
fhbetomh. Qkch `oifoxhs brklhi fureim gnoleim `ovhyehnfhf o normh åanot prågårhitehn. Kt`hr `oifoxhs, geies`hf
os s`kwi by t`h prhshiah kg shakifory rhtkua` ki t`h
autteim hfmas, fespnoy prkxeconny o streleim pnotgkrc t`ot
shrvhf nkr prkfuaeim o normh gnolh ki t`h kt`hr sefh.
Ei skch aoshs t`h normh gnolh `os bhhi strual
phrphifeaunorny tk t`h oxes kg t`h `oifoxh. Qua` hxocpnhs
orh likwi bkt` Hrkc t`h rhahit hxaovotekis os whnn os grkc
knf aknnhatekis (Brhuen oif Lhnnhy ?586). V`h ckrp`knkmykg `oifoxhs es ei o woy akcporobnh tk t`ot kg Nhvonnkes
akrhs, wet` twk eithrshateim surgoahs kg nothron oif feston
akivhxety, kih shrveim gkr t`h prhporoteki kg t`h streleim
pnotgkrc, t`h kt`hr gkr t`h gnoleim kg t`h åanot prågårhiteh
Ei vehw kg t`es kih akunf akisefhr `oifoxhs, fesaorfhf
fureim prkfuateki kr os geies`hf kbjhats, os Nhvonnkes akrh
V`h obkvh-chitekihf prkfuats kbtoeihf grkc t`hc orh
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 165/342
?88 ONOEI VXGGRHOX OIF TEHRRH OIVKEIH - AKIVEIHIVON IKRV@]HQVHRI HXRKTH
Gem. 0. Aomiy-n'Hpeihtth. Eifustry kgt`h gnuveon fhpksets. Qaonh ei ac.
Nhvonnkes tnolhs. Ot Aomiy-no Morhiih t`hrh es o anhor
akiaaptuon neil bhtwhhi t`h prkfuhteki kg `oifoxhs oif t`h
prhshiah kg Nhvonnkes gnoleim cht`kfs.
6.6.2. Aomiy-Aechteàrh (Gkrcoteki W. KEQ ?2 tk ??)
V`h strotemrop`y kg t`h Aechteàrh quorry ot Aomiy wos
stufehf by G. Bkurfehr (Bkurfehr ht on. ?5=6b) oif
ogthrworfs t`h seth wos t`h kbjhat kg hxaovotekis by
O. Vuggrhou (Vuggrhou ?504o oif ?504b< ?50=< Vuggrhou
ht on. ?502). Offetekion kbshrvotekis whrh cofh ei ?551
fureim o rhsauh hxaovoteki ot t`h ahchthry kg Aomiy,
ofjoahit tk t`h ikw oboifkihf quorry.
V`h nhvhns akiahrihf orh ei t`h soch ckrp`knkmeaon
pkseteki os t`ksh grkc Aomiy-no Morhiih (rhnotevh ontetufh
+20 c). ot o festoiah kg 244 c. V`h Aechteàrh shquhiah,
`kwhvhr. wos gkrchf ei o nhss hxthrion port kg t`h gnkkf
pnoei, w`hrh t`h knfhst shfechitory uiets orh obshit
(Gem. 6).
V`h fhpkseteki kg geih-mroeihf gnuveon shfechits bhmeis
wet` o noyhr kg strotegeaf soifs, fhpksethf ei a`oiihns
hrkfeim t`h upphr port kg t`h mrovhns. V`hsh soifs yehnfhf o
ghw orthgoats oif akitoei obuifoit trhh pknnhi (orbkrhon
pknnhi 04 %, ag. Cuiout ?5=6< ?500) eifeaoteim o thcphroth
akiteihiton anecoth, akitrosteim wet` t`h akifetekis fureim
gkrcoteki kg t`h mrovhns.
V`h geih-mroeihf shfechitoteki akiteiuhs wet` o normh
saonh `krezkiton fhpkseteki kg soifs oif strotegehf nkocs,
subshquhitny ogghathf by t`h gkrcoteki kg aonaeth akiarhtekis.
Tknnhi oionyses fesahrihf t`rhh ponyikzkihs: twk sthppea
p`oshs shporothf by o ckrh gkrhsthf hpeskfh, t`h eithrstofh
fh Aomiy (Cuiout ?5=6< ?500), oi eithrprhtoteki akigerchf
by t`h stufy kg t`h sconn coccons (A`oneih ?5=6).
V`h Oa`hunhoi seths kg Aomiy-Aechteàrh orh t`hrhgkrh
akithcpkroihkus wet` shvhron p`oshs kg senteim up kg t`h
gnkkfpnoei, t`ot oaakcpoiehf t`h hstobnes`chit kg thcphroth
akifetekis oif kg o gkrhst sthpph uifhr o akiteihiton
thcphroth anecoth. Kaaupoteki akiteiuhf fureim t`h
eithrmnoaeon oif t`h p`osh kg t`h anecoth fhthrekroteki
corleim t`h bhmeiieim kg t`h ihxt ayanh.
V`h mhkchtry oif t`h strotemrop`y kg t`h uiets kg t`h
Morhiih thrroah onnkw us tk pkseteki t`h eifustrehs kg t`h
geih-mroeihf gnuveon fhpksets kg t h Aechteàrh seth - t`kum`
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 166/342
?87 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
setuothf ei t`h soch thrroah os t`ksh kg Morhiih - ot t`h hif
kg t`h gnuveon ayanh, shporothf grkc t`h Morhiih geifs by o
pnhiemnoaeon p`osh (t`h bhmeiieim kg KEQ ?2 ot Morhiih, horny
KEQ ?? ot Aechteàrh).
V`h net`ea eifustry es rot`hr pkkr, akcpreseim hnkimothf
`oifoxhs osskaeothf wet` tkkns ki gnolhs, coeiny ikta`hs
oif fhiteaunoths. V`hrh orh ik eifeaotekis tk rhnoth t`h net`ea
osshcbnomh tk t`h gouion rhcoeis rhakvhrhf grkc t`h sochfhpksets.
6.6.8. Aomiy-n'Hpeihtth (Gkrcoteki EW, KEQ ?4 oif 5)
V`h eithrprhtoteki kg t`h Hpeihtth shquhiah es boshf ki
cuntefesaepneiory stufehs kg t`h iuchrkus shatekis
mhihrothf fureim t`h hxaovotekis by O. Vuggrhou, grkc
?504 kiworfs (Vuggrhou ht on. ?502< Vuggrhou ht on. ?507<
Oitkeih oif Vuggrhou ?551. Qeiah ?55? t`h seth es
hxaovothf jkeitny by o thoc kg t`h Xievhrsety kg Nennh oif
t`h Xievhrsety kg Thiisynvoieo). V`es shquhiah es t`h
stronktyph kg t`h Hpeihtth gkrcoteki (EW), wet` o rhnotevh
ontetufh kg 2? c obkvh t`h revhr's coxecuc eiaeseki,
e.h. 7 c nkwhr t`oi t`ot kg t`h Gkrcoteki fh no Morhiih
(Gem. 6).
Ot Aomiy-n'Hpeihtth t`h gnuveon fhpkseteki storts wet`
pnhiemnoaeon mrovhns. V`h tkp kg t`hsh gkrchf t`h surgoah
fureim t`h coei Oa`hunhoi kaaupoteki fkauchithf ei t`h
ikrt`hc port kg t`h hxaovoteki. Iaxt o shrehs kg bofny
skrthf aonaorhkus gnuveon nkocs wos fhpksethf. V`h gerst kg
t`hsh (?2) es o geih-mroeihf aonaorhkus nkoc fhpksethf ei o
s`onnkw fhprhsseki ei t`h tkp kg t`h mrovhns. V`es nhvhn,
prkbobny rhgnhateim o a`oiihn ei w`ea` shttneim tkkl pnoah,
AKXnf os yht kiny bh fkauchithf kvhr o ghw squorh
chtrhs.
V`h geih-mroeihf gnuveon shfechitoteki akiteiuhs wet` t`hfhpkseteki kg o aonaorhkus nkoc (EE) ki t`h hxthrion port kg
t`h thrroah - nkoc wet` akccki rknnhf gneits oif a`onl
porteanhs. Ei t`h nost p`osh kg t`h gnuveon shfechitoteki o
uiet kg `kckmhihkus nkoc wos fhpksethf, omoei wet`ei o
a`oiihn autteim t`rkum` t`h nkwhr nhvhns.
V`h upphr port kg t`es shquhiah wos t`hi subjhathf tk
sken gkrcoteki. V`h rhsunteim nkocy-`ucea brkwi-bnoal
ponohkskn thstegehs tk sken gkrcoteki ei o `ucef hiverkichit,
akrrhspkifeim tk o stobenesoteki kg t`h gnkkf pnoei. Tknnhi
oionyses kg t`h upphr port kg t`hsh fhpksets eifeaoths oi
kphi gkrhst kg o bkrhon typh (ovhromh kg orbkrhon pknnhi:
70.6 %) oif o thcphroth akiteihiton anecotea shtteim. V`hshrhsunts orh ei omrhhchit wet` t`h rhsunts kg t`h cearkcoccon
stufehs, w`ea` efhitegehf sphaehs a`oroathrestea kg o akkn-
thcphroth anecoth, eifeaoteim eithrstofeon kr torfemnoaeon
akifetekis (stufehs by J.C. Akrfy oif V. voi Lkngsa`kthi).
V`h `ypkt`hses kg oi eithrmnoaeon phfkmhihses ot t`es nhvhn
es akrrkbkrothf by t`h obuifoit prhshiah kg aonaeth
akiarhtekis ei t`h upphr port kg t`h geih-mroeihf fhpksets
oif by t`h ahchitoteki kg t`h mrovhn noyhr J. Ei goat, t`es
'`ucef hiverkichit' phfkmhihses es rkum`ny akithcpkro
kus wet` t`h fhvhnkpchit kg o brkwies`-rhf sken vesebnh k
t`h a`onl snkph, ot t`ot tech t`h boil kg t`h revhr vonnhy
(Gem. 8, uiet 8).
V`hsh foto eifeaoth t`ot t`h gkrcoteki kg t`h geih-mroei
fhpksets ot Aomiy-n'Hpeihtth tkkl pnoah ot t`h hif kg t`h
anecotea ayanh, ei oi horny-eithrmnoaeon akithxt, oi eithrprhtoteki rhahitny akigerchf by t`h rhsunts kg t`h nothst
pknnhi stufehs. V`h Oa`hunhoi kaaupotekis kg Aomiy-
n'Hpeihtth t`hrhgkrh tkkl pnoah ot t`h cormeis kg t`h gnkkf
pnoei grkc t`h bhmeiieim kg t`h anecotea ochnekroteki
kiworfs.
Ei t`h gnuveon nkocs t`h gknnkweim sphaehs orh prhshit:
Hnhp`os (T.) oitequus, Hquus cksboa`hises, Hquus
`yfruiteius, Hquus sp., Foco foco, Ahrvus hnop`us oif
Bks precemhieus. Kiny twk aorievkrh-rhcoeis whrh gkuif
yht: o gkx coifebnh oif o `yhio `uchrus. V`h nhvhns @,
E oif EE fegghr ei t`her gouion akcpksetekis. Ei @ `krsh e
whnn rhprhshithf w`hrhos nhvhns E oif EE orh fkceiothf
by bkvefs. Gromchits kg fhhr oitnhr orh akccki ei E oi
??. V`h prhshiah kg s`hf oitnhrs oif t`h omh kg t`h ykui
bkvefs shhcs tk eifeaoth oi kaaupoteki ot t`h hif kg
outuci kr weithr gkr nhvhn EE. Qkch bkihs s`kw aut-
corls.
V`h gerst `ucoi kaaupoteki tkkl pnoah ki t`h tkp kg t`h
mrovhns, w`hrhos kt`hr troahs opphor ei t`h shquhiah kg gei
mroeihf gnuveon fhpksets. Ei t`h geih-mroeihf nkocs o anhor
spoteon krmoiezoteki kg geifs akunf bh fesahrihf, wet` o
akiahitroteki kg ikfunhs, t`ot, jufmeim grkc t`her ckr-
p`knkmy, cem`t `ovh bhhi eitrkfuahf by `ucois, oif zki
wet` vorekus aothmkrehs kg bkihs (vhrthbroh, gromchits kg nec
bkihs oif oitnhrs).V`h noyhrs akvhreim t`h gnuveon shquhiah akrrhspkif tk
t`h nkwhr port kg t`h akvhreim noyhrs ot No Morhiih. V`h
eifustry (Gems =-0) akitoeis `oifoxhs oif tkkns ki gnolhs,
skch kg w`ea` whrh cofh ki ioturon gnolhs, eifeaoteim o
rot`hr kppkrtuiestea ottetufh tkworfs row cothreons, ei stor
akitrost tk w`ot wos kbshrvhf ot Aomiy-no Morhiih
(Vuggrhou ht on. ?558).
8. V`h nettkron seths kg t`h A`oiihn oif t`h
Otnoitea Kahoi
8.?. ]nCHRHXP, NO TkeIVH-OXP-KnHQ
V`h seth (]echrhux, Tos-fh-Aonoes) es ot 8 lc ikrt` kgBkunkmih-sur-Chr, bhtwhhi t`h aneggs kg no Tkeith-oux-Keh
oif t`h hstuory kg t`h Qnoal, ei o nettkron anegg kg Tos-fh-
Aonoes.
Obkvh Tkrtnoifehi fhpksets, wet` oi upphr port akrrhs
pkifeim tk oi knf obroseki surgoah, t`h anegg fespnoys o
shquhiah kg mrovhns oif brkwies` nkocs kg coreih kremei,
t`ot `ovh bhhi akrrhnothf tk t`h gnuveon-coreih shquhiah
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 167/342
?8= ONOEI VXGGRHOX OIF TEHRRH OIVKEIH - AKIVEIHIVON IKRV@]HQVHRI HXRKTH
Gem. 5. Qoeit-Aknkcboi (Aorioa, Ckrbe oi). Gnolh-tkkns (ogthr Ckiiehr ?508)?, Gnolh< 2. Tshufk-Nhvonnkes pkeit< 1 oif 6. Qefh-sarophrs< 8. Ikta`< 7. Fhiteaunoth< =. VroisvhrsoE sefh-sarophr< 0. Akcpkseth gnolh-tkkn (ikta`oif fhiteaunoth)< 5. Qeimnh akivhx sefh-sarophr< ?4. Fåjhtå sarophr< ??. Fhiteaunoth< ?2. Benn-`kkl< ?1. Qeimnh sefh-sarophr< ?6 tk ?7. Fhiteaunoths<?=. Qeimnh sefh-sarophr< ?0. Bkrhr< ?5 tk 26. Fhiteaunoths oif ikta`hs< 28 oif 27. Qeimnh sefh-sarophrs< 2= tk 25. Fhiteaunoths oif ikta`hs<14. Qarophrs< 1?. Fhiteaunoth< 12. Qefh-sarophr< 11. Ioturonny boalhf liegh< 16. Fhiteaunoth< 18. Akivhx troisvhrsh sefh-sarophr. Qaonh ei ac.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 168/342
?80 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. ?4. Nkaonesoteki kg t`hponohknet`ea seths ei t`h shfechitoryshquhiah kg t`h Qkcch Bosei,wet` o `ypkt`hteaon akrrhnoteki tkt`h kxymhi esktkph strotemrop`y.?. Bt `krezki kg brkwi nhoa`hf sken<2. Bt `krezki kg rhf anoyhy sken<1. Eitropnhiemnoaeon bkrhon nhoa`hfsken< 6. Horny mnoaeon `ucea sken<8. Horny mnoaeon mrhy gkrhsthf`ucea sken< 7. Aonaorhkus nkhss<=. Aonaorhkus bhffhf nkhss< 0. Eah
whfmhs oif grkst aroals< 5. Qoifyaonaorhkus nkhss< ?4. Qoify nkhss<?? . Rubbnh a`onl< ?2. Qoify snkphaknnuveucs< ?1. Horny mnoaeon snkphfhpksets shquhiah wet` eithr-stro-tegehf aonaorhkus sents< ?6. Akorshgnuveon mrovhns< ?8. Gnuveonaonaorhkus sents< ?7. Thot (ckfhrignkkf pnoei)< TQ?-QR-Qkn fhRkakurt (Hhceoi). TQ2, TQ1, TQ6-prh-Hhceoi ponohkskns. *HQR fothski gnuveon quorz. +X/V`-foths kibkihs. Anecotea ayanh: O. Eithrmnoaeon<B. Horny Mnoaeon< A. Gunn mnoaeon. ? 2 ? > 8 « = J ¼ ?4 ?? ?2 ?) ?6 ?8 ?7 ? ,-eu. C. .,.
wet` Coccut`us chrefekiones oif @eppkpktocus cojkr kg
]essoit (Bkurfehr ?575b). V`h shquhiah gurt`hrckrh
akisests kg oiaehit gnuveon fhpksets (mrovhns oif soifs) kg t`h
Qnoal, akvhrhf by strotegehf soifs oif t`h @knkahih fuihs.
Nothronny t`h Tnhestkahih fhpksets orh kvhrnoei by o nkhss
akvhr wet` o ponohkskn kg eithrmnoaeon a`oroathr (Qkccå
oif Vuggrhou ?5=7 oif ei prhp.). Ckrh stufehs orh ihhfhf
- hsphaeonny ponohkcomihtea kihs - tk sphaegy t`h omh kg
t`h coreih fhpksets t`ot bhor wetihss tk t`h kphieim kg t`h
Tos-fh-Aonoes (Qtroet kg Fkvhr) grkc t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih
kiworfs (Aknbhoux ht on. ?504). V`hy prkbobny foth grkc
skchw`hrh ei t`h Arkchr akcpnhx (KEQ ?1 tk 2?).
V`h net`ea eifustry, uirknnhf, but wet` oi eithisevh brkw
tk yhnnkw aknkur poteio, wos aknnhathf grkc t`h nkwhr mrov
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 169/342
?85 ONOEI VXGGRHOX OIF TEHRRH OIVKEIH - AKIVEIHIVON IKRV@]HQVHRI HXRKTH
noyhr (t`h coreih fhpkset) t`ot es hxpkshf fureim `em` oif
strkim tefhs ki t`h prhshit bhoa`. Qkch ckrh obrofhf
orl-E oats `ovh nelhwesh surgoahf grkc t`h gnuveon mrovhns.
V`h osshcbnomh coeiny akisests kg gneit ikfunhs wet` o
autteim hfmh kbtoeihf by suaahssevh kr onthrioteim begoaeon
ioleim, O ghw rorh `oifoxhs wet` normh gnolh-saors ('prktk-
begoahs') orh onsk prhshit. Bhaoush kg t`h woy t`h
osshcbnomh `os bhhi aknnhathf gnolhs orh ikt iuchrkus(Vuggrhou ?5=?).
8.2. V@H QEVHQ KG IKRCOIFU
V`h bhoa`hs kg Nh @ovrh (Qheih-Coretech) `ovh yehnfhf
coiy orthgoans grkc t`h hif kg t`h nost ahitury kiworfs, gkr
hxocpnh shrehs wet` coiy `oifoxhs (ocymfonkefs oif
noiahknoth gkrcs) grkc t`h 'Qtoteki Rkcoei'. Kt`hrs orh
a`oroathreshf by t`h obuifoiaa kg t`eal gnolhs wet` o wefh
gnoleim oimnh, t`ot `ovh bhhi rhnothf tk t`h 'Anoatkieoi'.
V`hy onsk pksshss skch `oifoxh rkum`kuts, s`kweim t`ot
ei Eoat wh orh fhoneim wet` Oa`hunhoi gneit lioppeim seths
(K`hn oif Nha`hvonehr ?5=5: ]ottå ?50=). V`her akithxt kgfesakvhry - t`h bhoa`hs - colhs et feggeaunt tk hstobnes` t`h
omh kg t`hsh shrehs.
V`h Tkrt-Temikt seth (Ghrcoivennh, Coia`h) yehnfhf o net`ea
eifustry setuothf ki tkp kg knf coreih fhpksets kg t`h Akthitei
phieisuno. akvhrhf by Qooneoi snkph fhpksets (`hof). Ei vehw
kg t`h rhmekion akithxt t`h knf bhoa` akunf bh kg @knstheieoi
ei eitro-Qooneoi omh. V`h net`ea eifustry, anossegeobnh os
hvknvhf Oa`hunhoi, akitoeis skch Nhvonnkes prkfuats oif o
ghw ocymfonkef `oifoxhs. Qkch struaturhs `ovh bhhi
fhsarebhf grkc t`es seth, ockimsn w`ea` gkur stkih-neihf
`hort`s orh t`h hosehst rhakmiezobnh kihs (Cea`hn ?502).
8.1. QOEIV-AKNKCBOI
V`h seth es setuothf ot no Tkeith fh Qoeit-Aknkcboi, ot
Aorioa (Ckrbe`oi), ki t`h skut`hri akost kg Brettoiy, oif
`os bhhi hxaovothf grkc ?50? kiworfs (Ckiiehr oif
Nh Ankerha ?508< Ckiiehr oif Ckneihs ?551). V`h strote-
mrop`ea shquhiah, vesebnh ei o anegg, akisests kg soifs grkc
oi knf coreih bhoa` akvhrhf by o `hof. V`es knf bhoa`
sbkunf bh knfhr t`oi t`h nost eithrmnoaeon, os akigerchf by
HQR foths (KEQ ?? kr ?1) kbtoeihf ot t`h Tnhuveihs seth.
V`h net`ea osshcbnomh (Gem. 5) grkc t`h coreih shquhiah
akisests kg tkkns ki gnolhs (coeiny ikta`hs oif fhiteaunoths)
oif kg phbbnh-tkkns, ckstny a`kpphrs. "Aknkcboiehi" `os
bhhi summhsthf os o thrc tk eifeaoth t`h sphaegea a`oroathr
kg t`es typh kg osshcbnomh. Oi osshcbnomh akcporobnh tkt`h kih grkc Qoeit-Aknkcboi `os bhhi rhakvhrhf ei oi
efhiteaon strotemrop`eaon akithxt ot t`h seth kg Chihz-Fråmoi
? (@onnhmkuht ht on. ?552).
7. Akianusekis
V`hrh es ik troaå kg `ucoi kaaupoteki ei ikrt`whsthri
Groiah oif Bhnmeuc knfhr t`oi KEQ ?8. V`h knfhst eifustry
akchs grkc t`h Aorreàrh Aorphitehr ot (Gem. ?4). Obbhvennh,
oif et es oi Oa`hunhoi kih. Onn net`ea osshcbnomhs grkc kr
knfhr t`oi KEQ 5 aoi bh ottrebuthf tk t`h Oa`hunhoi, w`ea`
s`kws o normh typknkmeaon voreobenety ei t`h akcpkseteki kg
`oifoxh gkrcs. Ot Aomiy-no Morhiih t`h opphoroiah kg t`hNhvonnkes fhbetomh es setuothf ei o akithxt kg `oifoxh
prkfuateki, eifeaoteim o akiahptuon neil bhtwhhi t`h gnoleim
kg `oifoxhs oif t`h hchrmhiah kg t`h Nhvonnkes gnoleim
cht`kfs. V`h prhshiah kg seths sphaegeaonny oechf ot
aknnhateim chot (Aomiy-n'Hpeihtth) kr net`ea row cothreons
(Aomiy-no Morhiih) es onsk o pkeit tk hcp`osesh. V`hsh
kbshrvotekis s`kw t`ot t`h prhshiah kg t`h Oa`hunhoi es
prkbobny ikt t`h rhsunt kg o nkaon hvknuteki, but rot`hr oi
eitrusevh p`hikchiki wet` o normh voreobenety, t`ot strhsshs
t`h ortegeaeon a`oroathr kg t`h anosseaon brhol bhtwhhi t`h
Nkwhr oif t`h Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea.
V`h hxesthiah kg kremeion "Aknkcboiehi" osshcbnomhs ei
Brettoiy pkshs t`h quhsteki kg t`her eifevefuonety ei t`h akithxt
kg t`h Oa`hunhoi. Orh wh fhoneim wet` osshcbnomhs rhsunteim
grkc sphaeoneshf oatevetehs wet`ei t`h Oa`hunhoi kr fk t`hy
rhgnhat fegghrhit trofetekis; V`h oiswhr tk t`es quhsteki es tk o
normh hxthit fhphifhit ki t`h fhvhnkpchit kg rhshora` ei Bret
toiy, w`hrh t`h Oa`hunhoi shisu streatk es `orfny rhprhshithf.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 170/342
?74 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
rhghrhiahs
Ofkp`h, J.-T. ?5=6 Nhs fromhhs aonaoerhs fh Ckiteàrhs-Mroah ht fh no corih bnoia`h f'Obbhvennh, Buen. Oss
Gr. Ht. _uothri. ??, ?71-?76.
Omoa`h, R.,
G. Bkurfehr,
R. Thtet
?571 Nh _uothrioerh fh no bossh Qkcch: thitotevh fh syit`hsh, Buen. Qka. Måkn. Gr. (=), W,
622-662.
Oitkeih, T. ?554 A`rkikstrotemrop`eh ht hiverkiihchit fu Tonåknet`equh fu Bossei fh no Qkcch, Tu`neao
tekis fu AHRT 2, 21? p., Xiev. Qaehiahs Vha`i. Nennh.
?551 Nh systàch fh thrrosshs fu Bossei fh no Qkcch: ckfành f'åvknuteki ckrp`ksåfechi-
toerh ayanequh ht aofrh ponåk-hiverkiihchiton pkur nh Tonåknet`equh, _uothrioerh 6(?),
1-?7.
Oitkeih, T.,
O. Vuggrhou
?551 Akithxth strotemrop`equh, anecotequh ht ponåktkpkmrop`equh fhs kaaupotekis oa`hunåhii
fh no ckyhiih thrrossh fh no Qkcch, Buen. Qe9h. Trå`est. Gr. 54, 261-284.
Bequoit, F. ?5=6 Tkseteki a`rkiknkmequh fh no trhs `outh iopph onnuveonh fh Mroah (vonnåh fh no Qkcch)
roppkrt o no neceth ponåkcomiåtequh Bru`ihs-Cotuyoco. Buen. Oss. Gr. Ht. _uothri. ??,
?8=-?85.
Bkrfhs, G.
Bkurfehr, G.
?57? Vypknkmeh fu Tonåknet`equh oiaehi ht ckyhi, Tubn. Eist. Trå`est. Xiev. Bkrfhoux.
?575o Hxaurseki fois nh bossei fh Tores fh ?'osskaeoteki eithriotekionh pkur ?'åtufh fu
_uothrioerh fu ?0 ou 20 okut ?575: åtufh akcporåh fhs fåp÷ts quothrioerhs fhs bosseis
fh no Qheih ht fh no Qkcch, Buen. eigkrc. Måkn. Bossei Tores 2?, ?75-224.
?575b Qur no pkseteki a`rkiknkmequh fu Tonåknet`equh fh Qoimotth, ]essoit ht ]echrhux (Tos-
Aonoes), Buen. Qka. Trå`est. Gr. NPWE, 214-21?.
?5=6 No "corih bnoia`h" f'Obbhvennh, meshchit typh fh ?'Obbhvennehi, Buen. Oss. Gr. Ht.
_uothri. ??, ?7?-?71.
Bkurfehr, G.,
J. A`oneih.
O.W. Cuioun,
J.J. Tuessåmur
?5=6o No trhs `outh iopph onnuveo nh fh no Qkcch, Buen. Oss. Gr. Ht. _uothri. ??, ?1=-?61.
?5=6b Nh akcpnhxh ceifhnehi: EE- No ckyhiih thrrossh fh n'Ovrh, Buen. Oss. Gr. Ht. _uothri.
??, ?70-?04.
Brhuen, @’@. Lhnnhy
?586 Nh Tonåknet`equh oiaehi: Obbhvennehi, Anoatkiehi. Oa`hunåhi, Nhvonnkesehi. Ei: Nhsmroifhs aevenesotekis prå`estkrequhs fh no Groiah, Buen. Qka. Trå`est. Gr. NE, 5-27.
Ao`hi. F. ?506 E.h Tonåknet`equh eigårehur ht ckyhi hi Bhnmequh. Ei: F. Ao`hi oif T. @ohsohrts
(hf.), Thupnhs a`osshurs fh no Bhnmequh fois nhur aofrh ioturhn, ?11-?88,
Bruxhnnhs.
A`oneih. J. ?5=6 Nhs rkimhurs, ?'omh ht ?'hiverkiihchit fh no trhs `outh thrrossh fh Mroah o Ckiteàrhs
(Qkcch), Buen. Oss. Gr. Ht. _uothri. ??, ?8?-?8=.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 171/342
ONO?I VXGGRHOX OIF TEHRRH OIVKEIH - AKIVEIHIVON IKRV@]HQVHRI HXRKTH
Aknbhoux, J.-T.,
('ne. Fupues,
G. Rkboszyisle,
J.T. Ouggrht,
T. @ohsohrts,
.?. Qkuceh
?504 Nh fåtrket fu Tos-fh-Aonoes: ui hnhchit fois no thatkiequh fh bnkhs fh n'Hurkph ikrf-
kaaefhitonh, Buen. eigkrc. Mekn. Bossei Tores ?= (6), 6?-86.
Akcckit, W. ?547 Hxaurseki fh no Qkaeåtå Neiiåhiih o Obbhvennh, nh 28 cors ?547, Buen. Qka. Neiiåhiih
Ikrf fh no Groiah 1=?, ??4-??2.
?540 Nhs eifustrehs fh Voifhi Qoeit-Oa`hun, N'Oit`r. PNP, 82=-8=2.
?545 Qoeit-Oa`hun ht Ckiteàrhs. Ikths fh mhknkmeh, fh ponhkitknkmeh ht fh prå`estkerh, Cåc.
Qka. Måkn. Ikrf WE (EEE).
?5?4 Hxaurseki fh no Qkaeåtå måknkmequh fu Ikrf ht fh no Goauntå fhs Qaehiahs fh Nennh o
Obbhvennh, nh ?? juei ?5?4. Nhs meshchits ponåkne t`equhs f'Obbhven nh. Qtrotemrop`eh, gouih,
eifustreh `ucoeih, Oii. Qka. Måkn. Ikrf PPPEP, 265-251.
Akrfy, J.C. ?502 Bekzkioteki fu _uothrioerh pkst-vennogroia`ehi Akiteihiton f'Hurkph kaaefhitonh o porter
fhs mroifs coccegàrhs, Oii. Qka. Måkn. Bhnmequh 248, 141-1?6.
Akrfy, J.C,
¼. Bostei,
A. Hl,
R. Mhhrohrts,
O. Kzhr,
U. _ueieg,
J. V`krhz,
C. Xnrex-Ankssat
?552 No Bhnnh-Rka`h (Qpreckit, Bhnmeuc): t`h Knfhst Qeth ei t`h Bhihnux. O Rhpkrt ki o Gehnf
Vrep. Ei: C. Vkussoeit (hf.), Aeiq cennekis f'oiiåhs, ?'ovhiturh `ucoeih, HROXN 87,
20=-14?, Neàmh.
@ohsohrts, T. ?506 Osphats fh ?'åvknuteki fu poysomh ht fh n'hiverkiihchit hi Bhnmequh ou _uothrioerh. Ei:
F. Ao`hi, T. @ohsohrts (hf.), Thupnhs a`osshurs fh no Bhnmequh fois nhur aofrh ioturhn,
2=-15, Bruxhnnhs.
@ohsohrts, T.,
A`. Fupues
?507 Akitrebuteki o no strotemrop`eh fhs iopphs onnuveonhs fh no Qkcch ht fh ?'Ovrh fois no
råmeki f'Ocehis. Ei: O. Vuggrhou, J. Qkccå (hf.), A`rkikstrotemrop`eh ht goaehs aunturhns
fu Tonhknet`equh eigårehur ht ckyhi fois n'Hurkph fu Ikrf-Kuhst, Quppn. Buen. Oss. Gr. Ht.
_uothri. 27, ?=?-?07.
@onnhmkuht, B.,
Q. @eimuoit,
O. Mhb`orft,
J.N. Ckiiehr
?552 Nh meshchit ponhknet`equh eigårehur fh Cåihz-Fråmoi ? (Tnku`eiha, Geiestàrh). Trhcehrs
råsuntots fhs gkuennhs. Buen. Qka. Trå`est. Gr. 05, ==-0?.
n.ocktta. O. ?55? Htufh fhs vhstemhs net`equhs fhs ievhoux fu meshchit fh Aomiy-no Morhiih (Qkcch) ht fh
ievhou O fu meshchit fh Mkuzhouakurt. Cåckerh fh F.H.O.. Xievhrsetå fhs Qaehiahs ht
Vha`iequhs fh Nennh, Nennh.
Nourhit. C. ?551 Fototeki por råskioiah fu Qpei hnhatrkiequh fh quortz fh gkrcoteki quothrioerhs:
akcporoeski ovha nh ponåkcomiåtesch. V`hsh Fkatkrot. Cushuc Iotekion f'@estkerh
Ioturhnnh, Tores.
Cea`hn, F. ?502 Nh meshchit prå`estkrequh fh Tkrt-Temikt o Ghrcoivennh (Coia`h), Monneo-Trå`estkerh 28,
?-70.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 172/342
u9: V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Ckiiehr, J.N.,
R. Nh Ankerha
?508 Nh meshchit ponåknet`equh eighrehur fh no Tkeith fh Qoeit-Aknkcboi o Aorioa (Ckrbe`o
Monneo-Trå`estkerh. 20, =-17.
Ckiiehr, J.N.,
I. Ckneihs
Cuiout, O.-W.
?551 Nh "Aknkcboiehi": ui goaehs råmekion fu Tonåknet`equh eigårehur sur nh nettkron orckreaoi
otnoitequh, Buen. Qka. Trå`est. Gr. 54, 201-256.
?5=6 Nhs oionyshs ponyiknkmequhs fh no ckyhiih thrrossh fh Aomiy-Aechteàrh (Qkcch), Bu
Oss. Gr. Ht. _uothri. ??, ?0?-?08.
?500 N'hiverkiihchit våmåton fh quhnquhs fhpkts quothrioerhs fu bossei fh no Qkcch. Ei:
O. Vuggrhou ht on. (hf.), Aunturhs ht eifustrehs ponåknet`equhs hi cenehu nkhssequh, Ocehi
?507, Rhv. ora`åkn. Teaorfeh ?-2, 68-87.
K`hn, C.U.,
Nha`hvonnehr
?505 Aomiy-n'Hpeihtt h: oionyshs ponyiknkmequhs. Ei: "Nevrht-muefh fh n'hxaurseki fois
no vonnåh fh no Qkcch". Aknnkquh "N'Oa`hunåhi fois n'Kuhst fh n'Hurkph" , =8-=5,
Qoeit-Requehr.
?551 Oionysh ponyiknkmequh fhs såfechits gnuveotenhs f'uih ckyhiih thrrossh fh ?'Ovrh o
Aomiy-no-Morhiih (Qkcch) obretoit fevhrs ievhoux f'kaaupoteki oa`hunåhis. Ei: O. Vuggrh
(hf.), N'Oa`hunåhi fois n'Kuhst fh n'Hurkph. Ttt`neaoteki fu AHRT 6, ei prhss.
?5=5 V`h "Anoatkieoi" kg Nh @ovrh oif ets `horeim kg t`h Himnes` Anoatkieoi, _etortor. 25-1
08-?48.
Tkitehr, T.
Rkhbrkhls, ]..
F. Qtophrt
Qkccå. J..
O. Vuggrhou
?520 Nhs ånåp`oits gkssenhs f'Obbhvennh, Oii. Qka. Måkn. Ikrf NXE, 24-67.
?507 Ki t`h "Nkwhr Tonohkn et`ea" seth No Bhnnh Rka`h : Oi Onthcot evh Eithrprhtoteki, Aurrh
Oit`rkpknkmy 2=, 175-1=?.
?5=7 Nhs gkrcotekis quothrioerhs ht nhs eifustrehs fh no Tkeith-oux-Kehs (]echrhux, Tos-fh-
Aonoes). Ei: Nevrht-muefh fh n'hxaurseki OEK: Ikrf-Kuhst fh no Groiah (Bossei fh no
Qheih, bossei fh no Qkcch ht Ikrf), EPh Akimr. XEQTT, ?71-?70, Ieah.
Vuggrhou. O. ?5=? _uhnquhs kbshrvotekis sur nh Tonåknet`equh fh no Tkeith-oux-Kehs o ]echrhux (Tos-fh-
Aonoes), Buen. Qka. Trå`est. Gr. NPWEEE, 657-846.
?504o Nh Tonåknet`equh eigårehur fh no ckyhiih thrrossh fh no Qkcch: Aomiy-Aecåteàrh ht
Aomiy-n'Hpeihtth: gkuennhs råahits, Buen. Qka. Trå`est. groia. ==, ?5=-?50.
?504b Nhs gkuennhs ponåknet`equhs fh Aomiy-Aecåteàrh (Qkcch): roppkrt pråneceioerh, Ao`ehrs
ora`åk. Teaorfeh =. 8-?=.
Vuggrhou, O. (hf).
Vuggrhou, O.,
O.W. Cuiout.
J.J. Tuessåmuer,
J. Qkccå
?50? N'Oa`hunåhi fois no Groiah shpthitrekionh, Oit`rkpknkmeh PEP/2, ?=?-?01.
?50= Nh Tonåknet`equh eigårehur ht ckyhi fu Ikrf fh no Groiah (Ikrf. Tos-fh-Aonoes, Teaorf
fois ski aofrh strotemrop`equh. V`hsh fh Fkatkrot f'Htot, Xiev. Qaehiahs ht Vha`i. fh Ne
?505 Nevrht-muefh fh n'hxaurseki fois no vonnåh fh no Qkcch. Aknnkquh "n'Oa`hunåhi fois
n'Kuhst fh n'Hurkph" , Qoeit-Requehr.
?552 N'Oa`hunåhi hi Hurkph kaaefhitonh f'opràs nhs fkiiåhs fu bossei fh no Qkcch. / prece
o`eoite fhnno vonnh pofoio: Ckith Tkmmeknk, 6?-65, Cenoik.
?502 Qtrotemrop`eh ht hiverkiihchit fhs eifustrehs oa`hunåhiihs fh no ckyhiih thrrossh fu
bossei fh no Qkcch, Buen. Oss. Gr. Ht. _uothri. ?5, =1-02.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 173/342
?71 ONOEI VXGGRHOX OIF TEHRRH OIVKEIH - AKIVEIHIVON IKRV@]HQVHRI HXRKTH
Vuggrhou, O..
J.T. Bkua`ht.
O.W. Ckemih,
O.-W. Cuiout
?507 Nhs ievhoux oa`hunåhis fh no ckyhiih thrrossh fh no vonnåh fh no Qkcch o Aomiy-
?'Hpeihtth (Qkcch), N 'Oit`r. 54, 5-2=.
Vuggrhou, ^..
T. Oitkeih,
T`. A`osh.
@.N. Febbnh,B.B. Hnnwkkf,
V. voi Lkngsa`kthi,
O. Nocktth.
Q`.T. CaT`hrrki,
O.C. Ckemih.
O.-W. Cuiout
?558 Nh meshchit oa`hunåhi fh Aomiy-n'Hpeihtth (Qkcch). Buen. Qka. Trå`est. Gr. 52, ?75-?5?.
]ottå, J.-T. ?50= Meshchits ponhknet`equhs fhs pnomhs fu @ovrh (`obetot oa`hunåhi fh no "stoteki Rkcoei")
ht fh Qoeith-Ofrhssh (othnehrs "anoatkiehis") (Qheih-Coretech), Oiionhs fu Cusåuc fu
@ovrh 15, ?-1?.
Onoei Vuggrhou oif Tehrrh Oitkeih
HRO 1=, fu ARO, AIRQ
Xievhrsetå fhs Qaehiahs ht Vha`iknkmehs fh Nennh
G-85788 Wennhihuvh f'Osaq Ahfhx
Groiah
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 174/342
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 175/342
Corl B. Rkbhrts ?4 V`h hornehstaeevh s Mocbnh t`h Bretes` EsnhsFovef R. Brefmnoif
kaaupoteki kg Hurkph:
V`h hvefhiah prhshithf `hrh summhsts t`ot t`h Bretes`
Esnhs wosgerst aknkiezhf ot t`h `hmeiieim kg t`h thcphroth
kr eithrmnoaeon stomh t`ot ecchfeothny prh-foths t`h Oimneoi
aknf Qtomh. Net`kstrotemrop`ea oif a`rkikstrotemrop`ea
ckfh @eim akrrhnoths t`h Oimneoi wet` Kxymhi Esktkph
Qtomh ?2. w`ea` es fothf tk bhtwhhi 6=0. oif 621 Lyr BT.
Oaakrfeimny, t`h hornehst kaaupoteki kgBretoei kaaurrhf
orkuif `ong o cenneki yhors omk. V`h horny aknkiezhrs orh
ossemihf, grkit t`h Bkxmrkvh sphaechi, tk t`h sphaehs @kckag `hefhnbhrmhises. Kih `uifrhf t`kusoif yhors nothr, ot
Qwoisakcbh, t`es mrkup `hmeis tk hx`ebet skch aroieon
slhnhton a`oroathresteas usuonny osskheothf wet` t h
Ihoifhrt`on neihomh. V`rkum`kut t`h phrekf akvhrhf by t`es
po/thr n/eara es opporhit stoses ei t`h net`ea eifustrehs, w`ea`
eianufh bkt` begoah fkceioit osshcbnomhs oifgnolh tkke
fkceioit osshcbnomhs. Qtreat feveseki bhtwhhi t`hsh twk
typhs kg osshcbnomhs es ik noimhr thiobnh ki typknkmeaon kr
> `rkiknkmu on mrkuifs.
?. EitrkfuatekiVel- rhcet kg t`es pophr es tk stufy t`h khhupoteki kg t`h
Bretes` Esnhs grkc t`h gerst hvefhiah kg `ucoi aknkiezoteki
tk t`h hif kg t`h shakif cojkr thcphroth hvhit ogthr t`hOimneoi aknf Qtomh. Ont`kum` t`h storteim pkeit es shnghxpnoiotkry, t`h aut-kgg pkeit coy shhc ot gerst tk bh kg oiorbetrory ioturh. @kwhvhr, et coy bh fhckistrothf t`ot byt`es tech t`h akiteihit kg Hurkph, kutsefh t`h eah cormeis(@knc oif Norsski, t`es vknuch), wos aknkiezhf kvhr onormh port kg ets noif coss oif t`ot ei kur mhkmrop`eaonrhmeki kg Bretoei oif ikrt`whst Hurkph, t`h aut-kgg pkeitakeiaefhs wet` t`h hchrmhiah kg t`h Nhvonnkes tha`iequh kgnet`ea rhfuateki oif gnolh prkfuateki.
V`h seths eianufhf ei t`es pophr (Gem. ?) `ovh het`hr bhhirhahitny kr orh aurrhitny bheim, hxaovothf oif/kr stufehf os
port kg ki-mkeim rhshora` prkmrocchs. Qeths t`ot sotesgyt`hsh arethreo `ovh bhhi a`kshi bhaoush t`h rhshora`cht`kfknkmy utenezhf ei t`her stufy es cuntefesaepneiory oift`us t`h quonety kg t`h akithxtuon eigkrcoteki goaenetothsmrhothr oaauroay ei bkt` eithr-seth oif eithr-rhmekionakrrhnoteki.
V`h seths `ovh bhhi fevefhf eitk twk mrkups, t`ksh t`otprh-foth oif t`ksh t`ot pkst-foth t`h Oimneoi Mnoaeoteki.
V`es feveseki es ikt boshf ki oiy s`egt, rhon kr phrahevhf, ei`kceief cothreon aunturh ikr ki oiy akiahpt kg `kceiefsphaehs a`oimh< rot`hr et rhgnhats t`h normh saonh a`oimhs tkt`h ponohkmhkmrop`y oif cocconeoi gouio akcpkseteki kgBretoei, t`ot kaaurrhf os t`h rhsunt kg p`yseaon oif anecoteagoatkrs rhnoteim tk t`es mnoaeon/aknf hvhit. V`h gexeim ei techkg t`h Oimneoi Qtomh `os ikt yht bhhi uihquevkaonny omrhhfupki by Bretes` _uothriory saehitests but t`h whem`t kghvefhiah summhsts akrrhnoteki wet` Kxymhi Esktkph Qtomh(KEQ) ?2 (shh bhnkw oif Vobnh ?). V`h ckfhn prhshithf`hrh, ont`kum` et gets wet` t`es `ypkt`hses, es grhh-stoifeimoif onnkws gkr guturh geih tuieim kg t`h mhka`rkiknkmeaontechsaonh.
Ki t`h hvefhiah aurrhitny ovoenobnh tk _uothriorysaehitests, et es t`kum`t t`ot t`h gerst `kceiefs orrevhf eiBretoei opprkxecothny `ong o cenneki yhors bhgkrh t`hprhshit foy. V`es vehw gets whnn wet` t`h s`krt a`rkiknkmyphrsphatevh kg t`h fhckmrop`ea hxpoiseki kg `ucoist`rkum` akiteihiton Hurkph (Rkhbrkhls ?556< Rkhbrkhlsoif Woi Lkngsa`kthi ?556, t`es vknuch) oif ahrtoeinyoaakrfs wet` t`h peaturh grkc ikrt`hc Groiah, Bhnmeuc,Qpoei oif Tkrtumon (shh vorekus akitrebutekis ei t`es
vknuch), w`hrh t`h hornehst seths orh fothf tk t`h hif kg t`hArkchreoi Akcpnhx. V`hrh rhcoeis o prkbnhc kgrhakiaeneim t`hsh foths wet` t`h cua` hornehr foths kg sethsei skut`hri Groiah (Bkiegoy oif Woifhrchhrsa` ?55?) oifahitron Hurkph (Wonka` ?55? oif t`es vknuch). @kwhvhr,coiy kg t`hsh seths orh akitrkvhrseon oif ikt onn kg t`hc orhoaahpthf by ora`ohknkmests os akitoeieim hvefhiah kg `ucoikaaupoteki (Rkhbrkhls oif Woi Lkngsa`kthi ?556< Royionht on., t`es vknuch). V`hrh coy `kwhvhr, `ovh bhhispkrofea aknkiezoteki kg t`h Chfethrroihoi rhmeki gkr o nkimphrekf kg tech prekr tk t`h coei mhkmrop`eaon hxpoisekikg @kck orkuif 844 Lyr BT. V`h rhoskis bh`eif t`es
opporhitny suffhi oif frocotea ckvhchit orh bhykif t`hsakph kg t`es pophr but et coy bh ikthf t`ot sknveim t`hprkbnhc kg t`h aknkiezoteki kg Hurkph fureim t`h CeffnhTnhestkahih es mkeim tk bh fhphifoit ki ckveim owoy grkco seth boshf opprkoa` tk `ucoi haknkmy tkworfs normh saonhrhmekion ckfhnneim onkim t`h neihs kg Mhkmrop`eaonEigkrcoteki Qysthcs (MEQ), tk stufy mhkmrop`ea oifanecotea goatkrs (Mocbnh ?507) t`ot coy `ovh ogghathf
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 176/342
?77 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Vobnh ?. Rhveshf strotemrop`ea akrrhnoteki gkr port kg t`h Ceffeh oif Noth Tnhestkahih.Rhghrhiahs. ?. Ceta`hnn hg on. ?5=1. 2. Rkbhrts, t`es pophr. 1. Ofopthf grkc Zomweji ?552. 6. Q`oalnhtki ?50=.
Akivhitekion
Bretes` stomhs'Ckfegehf sa`hch2
QethsFuta`/Lurkphoi
shquhiah-'KEQ
6
KEQ fk ikt oppny
tk t`es aknuci
Fhvhiseoi Fhvhiseoi ]hea`shneoi 8f+
\pswea`eoi Epswea`eoi Bkbbets`knh, Vrogonmor Qquorh Hhceoi 8h
V`hsh stomhs ikt
rhakmieshf
Aknf stomh
Qooneoi Akcpnhx
7V`hsh stomhs ikt
rhakmieshfVhcphroth/eithrmnoaeon
stomh
Corswkrt`, Qtoitki @orakurt
Qooneoi Akcpnhx
=
V`hsh stomhs ikt
rhakmieshf
Aknf stomh Qooneoi Akcpnhx 0
V`hsh stomhs ikt
rhakmieshf
@kxieoi @kxih;, Nettnh V`urrkal,
Mnkbh Tet, Turgnhht
Qooneoi Akcpnhx
5
]knstkieoi Aknf stomh
Qooneoi Akcpnhx
?4
@kxieoi Vhcphroth/eithrmnoaeon
stomh
Qwoisakcbh, Bori`oc,
Bhha`hs Tet, Anoatki
@knstheieoi ??
Oimneoi Oimneoi Hnsthreoi ?2
Arkchreoi Vhcphroth/eithrmnoaeon
stomh
Bkxmrkvh, @em` Nkfmh,
]evhi`kh, ]hstbury-sub-
Chifep. Lhit's Aovhri,
]orrhi @enn, ]ovhrnhy ]kkf
Arkchreoi EW ?1
Bhhstkieoi Aknf stomh Mnoaeon A ?6
fhckmrop`ea hxpoiseki. Qua` ckfhnneim wkunf prkvefh ogrochwkrl wet`ei w`ea` kt`hr voreobnhs sua` ostha`iknkmeaon aopoaety (Beigkrf ?505), gkkf ovoenobenety(Rkhbrkhls ht on. ?552) oif akcphteteki grkc kt`hrcoccons (O. Vurihr ?552) akunf bh hcpereaonny thsthf.
2. Ceffeh Tnhestkahih Aknkiezoteki kg I] Hurkph:
Qeths prh-foteim t`h Oimneoi Aknf Qtomh
2.?. EIVRKFXAVEKI
V`h iucbhr kg' ora`ohknkmeaon seths fothf tk t`h phrekf kgt`h Arkchreoi Akcpnhx (Zomweji ?508< ?552) ei Bretoei`os eiarhoshf frocoteaonny ei t`h post twk fhaofhs. V`hseths orh nkaotaf wet`ei t`h bnkal kg tech bhtwhhi t`hArkchreoi shisu streatk, os rhprhshithf ei t`h typh shateki
ot ]hst Ruitki, Ikrgknl, oif t`h Oimneoi Mnoaeoteki. V`hrhhxests `kwhvhr o prkbnhc ei gexeim t`h pkseteki kg ]hstRuitki ei t`h _uothriory techsaonh< prhvekus bekstrote-mrop`eaon oif net`kstrotemrop`eaon wkrl by Qtuort (?5=8) oif]hst (?504) pkstunothf t`ot t`h Arkchreoi shisu streatk
worc stomh ecchfeothny prh-fothf t`h Oimneoi. V`esakrrhnoteki wos quastekihf by Bes`kp (?502) ei `es rhpkrtki t`h gouio grkc t`h seth ot ]hstbury-sub-Chifep,
Qkchrsht. Aurrhit rhshora` ot Bkxmrkvh (Rkbhrts ?554) oki t`h prh-fevhrseki akursh kg t`h Revhr V`otihs (Brefmno?556), tkmht`hr wet` wkrl ei t`h R`eih Wonnhy kg Mhrcoiot Cehshi`hec E oif Lornea` (Woi Lkngsa`kthi ?554< WoLkngsa`kthi oif Vurihr, ei prass) gurt`hr suppkrts t`h veht`ot t`hrh wos ot nhost kih gunny thcphroth hvhit bhtwhhit`h Arkchreoi shisu streatk oif t`h Oimneoi/Hnsthreoi(Vobnh ?).
Onn t`h seths nesthf bhnkw orh t`kum`t tk kaaur ei othcphroth stomh t`ot ecchfeothny prhahfhs t`h Oimneoi< t`stomh `os bhhi akrrhnothf wet` t`h eithrmnoaeon Arkchreoi ei t`h Futa` strotemrop`ea shquhiah (Fh Jkim ?500<Zomweji ?508< ?552). @kwhvhr, t`hrh hxests o prkbnhc wt`h foth ossemihf tk t`es stomh by t`h ogkrhchitekihf
rhshora`hrs< t`her pnoahchit kg Eithrmnoaeon EW ot kr orkui644 Lyr BT es boshf upki ykuim foths gkr t`h `kribnhifhoumeth bkuifory grkc t`h Heghn orho vknaoiea hruptekis(Hvhrifhi ht on. ?58=< Grha`hi oif Neppknt ?578). Aurrhirhshora` ikw puts t`es troiseteki hornehr ei t`h CeffehTnhestkahih (A. voi fhi Bkmoorf ht on. ?505< Bkseisle, t`vknuch). Eg t`h akrrhnoteki kg t`h Oimneoi Mnoaeoteki oifaknf hvhit tk KEQ ?2 es akrrhat (Qebrovo ht on. ?507<
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 177/342
?7= CORL B. RKBHRVQ, ANEWH Q. MOCBNH OIF FOWEF R. BREFMNOIF - V@H BREVEQ@ EQNHQ
Gem. ?. Nkaoteki kg seths chitekihfei t`h thxt:?. ]ovhrnhy ]kkf< 2. ]orrhi @XE<1. @em` Nkfmh< 6. Bori`hc<8. Bhha`hs Tet< 7. @kxih< =. ]evhi-`kh< 0. Anoatki< 5. Turtnhht<?4. Nettnh V`urrkal< ??. Qwois-akcbh< ?2. Bkxmrkvh< ?1. ]hstbury-sub-Chifep< ?6. Lhits Aovhri.
Q`oalnhtki ?50=< Bkwhi ?55?< Brefmnoif ?556), t`hi`kceiefs gerst hithrhf t`h Bretoei ei KEQ ?1, bhtwhhi 826oif 6=0 Lyr BT (Ecbreh ht on. ?506).
2.2. ]OWHRNHU ]K KF GORC TEV . QT 178 =? 8'.
]OR]EALQ@ERH
V`h ]ovhrnhy ]kkf orthgoats (Gem. ?) (Q`kttki ht on.
?551< ]esh ?551), w`ea` eianufh t`rhh whnn cofhsycchtreaon oifhseth begoahs oif o iucbhr kg gnolhs, whrhevakvhrhf grkc t`h bosh kg t`h Bomeitki-Nenneimtki Mrovhn(Q`kttki ?581< ?570). Ei offeteki oikt`hr gnolh wosrhakvhrhf grkc t`h krmoiea fhpksets uifhrnyeim t`hBomeitki-Nenneimtki Mrovhns (Gem. 1) (Q`kttki ht on. ?551).V`h krmoiea fhpksets ot ]ovhrnhy ]kkf Gorc `ovh bhhiosarebhf tk KEQ ?8 by oceikstrotemrop`ea akrrhnoteki(Bkwhi (=>//. ?505< Bkwhi ?55?). Eg t`es foth kg 9878 LyrBT (Ecbreh ht on. ?506), w`ea` rhcoeis hquevkaon, esoaahpthf t`hi t`es kaaurrhiah kg orthgoats es t`h hornehstfesakvhrhf ei Bretoei tk foth.
Oport grkc t`h oceik oaef mhka`rkiknkmy t`hrh orh kt`hrneihs kg hvefhiah, hsshiteonny net`kstrotemrop`ea, t`ot summhstt`h fhpksets orh prh-Oimneoi (prh KEQ ?2). Rkså (?50=<?505< ?552) prkpkshf t`ot t`h Bomeitki-Nenneimtki Mrovhns,tkmht`hr wet` t`her fkwistrhoc hquevonhits t`h Byt`oc
Qoeuns oif Mrovhns, t`h Q`kunf`oc Qoifs oif Mrovhns oift`h Eim`oc Qoifs oif Mrovhns oif t`her upstrhocakrrhnotevhs ot Qietthrgehnf (Coffy oif Nhwes ?55?) whrhfhpksethf by o revhr (Gem. 2), ei o ikw burehf vonnhy, t`otgnkwhf whst tk host t`rkum` t`h Cefnoifs tk skut`Neiaknis`erh, t`hi skut`hostworfs eitk Ikrgknl oif Quggknl,w`hrh et wos akignuhit wet` t`h Revhr V`ochs oif geionnyhostworfs eitk w`on es ikw t`h Ikrt` Qko. Rkså (?505<
?552< ?556), `os onsk summhsthf t`ot t`es revhr wosfhpkseteim kvhr o substoiteon phrekf kg tech fureim t`h Hornyoif horny Ceffnh Tnhestkahih.
Ei Host Oimneo t`h Eim`oc Qoifs oif Mrovhns uifhrnehst`h Nkwhstkgt Venn (Oimneoi) oif es fespkshf os o shrehs kgthrroah ommrofotekis (Brefmnoif oif Nhwes ?55?< Nhwes?551). V`h knfhst gkrcoteki aoi bh akrrhnothf (Nhwes ?551)wet` t`h Qthbbeim Gkrcoteki kg t`h @em`-nhvhn LhsmrovhQubmrkup \Qufbury Gkrcoteki: (]`ethcoi oif Rkså?552)S, port kg t`h Lhsmrovh Mrkup kg t`h Revhr V`ochs.V`h ykuimhst gkrcoteki es akrrhnothf wet` t`h hiterh Nkw-nhvhn Lhsmrovh Qubmrkup \Akna`hsthr Gkrcoteki (Nhwes
?551)S. V`us t`hsh mrovhns prkbobny spoi grkc t`h HornyTnhestkahih tk t`h Oimneoi Qtomh. @kwhvhr, t`hsh HornyTnhestkahih mrovhn ommrofotekis ei ahitron Host Oimneoaoiikt bh akrrhnothf wet` t`h Bomeitki Gkrcoteki ei t`h]hst Cefnoifs os t`hrh orh ik upstrhoc hquevonhits kg t`hknfhr thrroahs efhitegehf wet`ei t`h Eim`oc Gkrcoteki eit`ot orho. V`h Bomeitki Gkrcoteki ei t`h ]hst Cefnoifs,tkmht`hr wet` t`h Byt`oc oif Q`kunf`oc Gkrcotekis kgNeiaknis`erh oif whst Ikrgknl rhsphatevhny, orh akrrhnothfwet` kiny t`h nkwhst (oif ykuimhst) chcbhr kg t`h Eim`ocGkrcoteki oif prkbobny rhprhshit o froeiomh potthri t`othxesthf ecchfeothny prekr tk t`h Oimneoi mnoaeoteki.
V`h krmoiea a`oiihn genns ot ]ovhrnhy ]kkf Gorc(Q`kttki ht on. ?551) oif Broifki (Coffy ht on. ?556)w`ea` kaaur wet`ei t`h Bomeitki Gkrcoteki, akitoeiponohkhaknkmeaon hvefhiah gkr o worchr anecotea rhmech.Oionyshs kg pknnhi oif t`h aknhkpthroi osshcbnomh (Akkph,ei Q`kttki ht on. ?551< Mebborf oif Thmeor ?505< Q`kttki ht
on. ?551) kg t`h nkwhr krmoiea fhpkset ot Broifki oif]ovhrnhy ]kkf summhsts t`hsh a`oiihns coy bh kg t`h
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 178/342
?70 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 2. Tkseteki kg t`h Cefnoifs/Byt`oc Revhr, oif t`h noth Arkchreoi Revhr V`ochs.
Bomeitki / Nenneimtki Mrovhn oifsoif wet` arkss bhffhf soifoif geih mrovhn a`oiihn genns
?44 c
Gem. 1. Qhateki t`rkum` t`h strotemrop`y ot ]ovhrnhy ]kkf (grkc Q`kttki ht on. ?551).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 179/342
!(->9 CORL B. RKBHRVQ, ANEWH Q. MOCBNH OIF FOWEF R. BREFMNOIF - V@H BREVEQ@ EQNHQ
soch omh ei obsknuth tarcs, oif prkbobny onsk rhprhshit t`hsoch tech spoi wet`ei o thcphroth stomh kr sub-stomh.Coffy ht on. (?556) summhsthf t`ot t`h Bomeitki Gkrcotekico^ spoi KEQ ?8 tk ?2.
V`h cocconeoi gouio grkc t`hsh fhpksets es omoeihquevkaon os t`hrh orh ik truny t`hrckp`enkus hnhchits(Nesthr ?505), w`enh skch bkrhon/aknf anecoth toxo orh
prhshit. Bekstrotemrop`eaonny t`h gouio, os o mrkup, es w`otwkunf bh hxphathf grkc oi horny Oimneoi kr horny Qooneoiakithxt. V`hrh orh secenoretehs wet` t`h Oimneoi gouio grkc@kchrsgehnf ei Ikrgknl (Qtuort ?50?< Akxki ?5=5), butt`hrh orh ikih kg t`h anossea Arkchreoi Akcpnhx gkssenst`ot wkunf bh hxphathf eg t`h shfechits orh os knf os Rksåbhnehvhs. V`h Qkrhx soveie C' grkc ]ovhrnhy ]kkf(rhpkrthf by Q`kttki ?505) wos cesefhitegehf oif t`hrhgkrh,os `os bhhi stothf obkvh. t`h cocconeoi osshcbnomhakitoeis ik Arkchreoi Akcpnhx typh gkssens but kinycothreon osskaeothf ei Bretoei oif ikrt`hri oif ahitronHurkph wet` t`h kisht kg t`h Oimneoi/Hnsthreoi aknf stomh krwet` nothr phrekfs.
Ei akianuseki t`h oceik oaef mhka`rkiknkmeaonossemioteki kg ]ovhrnhy ]kkf tk KEQ ?8 es shrekusnyquhstekion. V`es seth w`ea`, ki t`h oceikstrotemrop`eatechsaonh, es put os knfhr t`oi ]hst Ruitki (Bkwhi ?552)akitoeis t`h fhsahifoit, Orveakno thrrhstres aoiteoio, kgt`h ]hst Ruitki gkrc kg t`h wothr vknh, Ceckcys soveie.
V`h `estkry oif ioturh kg t`h a`oimh, grkc t`h rkkthf tk t`huirkkthf gkrc kg t`es rkfhit, es whnn fkauchithf (gkrsuccory shh Wki Lkhiemswonf oif Woi Lkngsa`kthi, eiprhss) oif oaahpthf by onn rhsaora`hrs eitk Tnhestkahih rkfhitnouios. V`us tk eivhrt t`h omhs kg t`hsh seths ki t`h boses kgoceik oaef roteks ferhatny akitrofeats o whnn hstobnes`hf oif
oaahpthf bekstrotemrop`eaon neihomh. V`h hvefhiah grkc]ovhrnhy ]kkf oif ets pkseteki wet`ei t`h Bomeitki/Eim`ocRevhr systhc summhsts o strotemrop`ea pkseteki ei KEQ ?1 kr ott`h bhmeiieim kg KEQ ?2 oif ik knfhr.
2.1. @EM@ NKFMH, CENFHI@ONN. VN =15 =86.
QXGGKNL
V`h seth ot @em` Nkfmh (Gem. ?) es nkaothf ot t`h whsthrihfmh kg t`h nkw Brhalnoif Tnothou oif ot t`h skut`hosthricormei kg t`h Ghi Bosei (Rkså ?552< Akkl ht on. ?55?<Os`tki ht on. ?552). V`h Tnhestkahih shfechits orh nkaothfei o a`oiihn aut eitk t`h a`onl ot o `hem`t roimh bhtwhhi
?5-14c KF.V`h ora`ohknkmeaon cothreon es akitoeihf wet`ei o bkfy kg
sents oif anoys t`ot `ovh bhhi troispkrthf os o whfmh by t`heah s`hht rhspkisebnh gkr fhpkseteim t`h uifarnyeimfeoceatki, t`h Nkwhstkgt Venn. V`hsh rogthf, geih mroeihffhpksets orh kvhrnoei oif ei pnoahs fesshathf by o shrehs kgmrovhnny fhpksets, wefhny eithrprhthf os mnoaekgnuveonkutwos` t`ot akitoei fhrevhf ora`ohknkmeaon cothreon. Ei goat
t`hsh fhpksets gkrc t`h `em`hst kg o shrehs kg thrroahs kg t`hknf Norl vonnhy (Brefmnoif oif Nhwes ?55?) oif o gnuveotenhkremei es phrghatny pkssebnh. V`h net`ea eifustry (Gem. 6)akitoeihf wet`ei t`h sents oif anoys coy bh fhsarebhf os ognolh eifustry prkfuahf ki t`h fhbetomh grkc akrh rhfuateki(Os`tki ?552). V`h gnolhs orh skchtechs wkrlhf gurt`hr byt`h gnolhf gnolh tha`iequh (Os`tki ht on. ?55?), kr cofh
eitk anossea @em` Nkfmh sarophrs wet` shce-eivosevh, shce-saonor oif iki-sthpphf rhtkua`: t`h ckfh kg phraussekibheim `orf `occhr. V`h gnolh eifustry wos kremeionnyt`kum`t tk bh Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea ki t`h boses kg t`hckrp`knkmy kg t`h gnolh tkkns (Oiki ?570< Akunski ?554),t`us pkst-foteim t`h @kxieoi Eithrmnoaeon. V`h ush kgtypknkmy tk foth t`h eifustry akigneathf wet` vehws kgmhknkmests wkrleim ot t`h seth (A. Vurihr ?5=1) oif nhf tk ofhnoy ei t`h pubneaoteki kg t`h seth rhpkrt (Os`tki ?552).Et es ikw oaahpthf ki net`kstrotemrop`eaon mrkuifs t`ot t`hseth cust prh-foth t`h Oimneoi, os t`h kiny eah s`hht t`otaoch os gor skut` os @em` Nkfmh ei t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahihgkrchf fureim t`h Oimneoi (Thi-ei hn on. ?5=5). V`es
hvefhiah gkr foteim es gurt`hr akrrkbkrothf by t`h fesakvhryei t`h sents oif anoys kg o cknor kg Qthp`oikr`eius
`uifs`hechises. w`ea` bhaoch hxteiat ei ikrt`hri Hurkphfureim t`h Oimneoi/Hnsthreoi. V`h ora`ohknkmeaon cothreon eit`h kvhrnyeim soifs oif mrovhns akitoeis skch gnolhs oifgnolh tkkns rhwkrlhf grkc t`h sents oif anoys bhnkw, butckrh ecpkrtoitny et es onckse hxanusevhny akcpkshf kgbegoahs, w`ea` mevhi t`her akifeteki orh t`kum`t tk fhrevhgrkc o ihorby skurah oif coy bh akithcpkroihkus wet`t`h gnolh eifustry.
V`h ponohkhiverkichit kg t`h @em` Nkfmh sents oifanoys, w`ea` akitoei t`h gnolh/akrh eifustry, es eithrprhthfos o mhitny gnkweim gnuveon systhc, gkrceim t`h sents oifanoys os oi kvhrboil fhpkset, osskaeothf wet` o gnkro kgspruah-peih wkkfnoif wet` cors` oif oquotea pnoits. V`heishat gouio suppkrts t`h sahiorek kg s`onnkw pkkns oifswocpy mrkuif oif eifeaoths akkn-thcphroth akifetekis.Ki t`h boses kg t`h net`knkmy (Nhwes ?552), ceihronkmy(Rkså ht on. ?552) oif t`h osshcbnomh kg prh-_uothriorypknnhi oif spkrhs (@uit oif Rkså ?552), t`hsh shfechitswhrh fhpksethf ki t`h gnkkfpnoei kg o revhr froeieim skurahorhos ei t`h Himnes` Cefnoifs (Gem. 2), rhprhshithf by t`hBomeitki Gkrcoteki ei t`h Cefnoifs oif by t`h Eim`oc oifQ`kunfoc Gkrcotekis ei Host Oimneo.
V`us et es nelhny t`ot t`h @em` Nkfmh gnolh eifustry woscofh ot t`h hif kg o thcphroth stomh ecchfeothny prh-foteim t`h Oimneoi mnoaeoteki. V`h omh kg t`h begoahs esprkbnhcotea mevhi t`her akithxt but et es nelhny t`ot t`hy orhkg o secenor kr snem`tny nothr omh kg t`h gnolh eifustry. V`eseifustry geifs poronnhns t`rkum`kut t`h Bretes` Tonohknet`ea,gkr hxocpnh ot Anoatki oif @kxih (Os`tki oif CaIobb?552) oif es ikt shhi tk `ovh oiy strotemrop`ea ecpkrtoiah.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 180/342
?=4 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 6. @em` Nkfmh sarophrs (grkc Os`tki ht on. ?552). Qaonh ei ac.
2.6. ]ORRHI @ENE.. VN =66 =61. QXGGKNL
V`es seth (Gem. ?), kr ckrh oaaurothny t`h fhpksets kg t`esorho, `os prkfuahf t`h normhst iucbhr kg `oifoxhs eiBretoei (Rkh ?570< ]ychr ?508). Ot V`rhh @enns, t`h portkg ]orrhi @enn w`hrh mrovhn quorryeim wos uifhrtolhi, twk
net`knkmeaonny festeiat uiets orh rhakmieshf. V`hsh orh. Brkct`h bosh upworfs, t`h ]orrhi @enn Qoifs oif Qents oif t`h]orrhi @enn Qoifs oif Mrovhns (]ychr ht on. ?55?). V`hsoifs oif sents whrh fhpksethf ei o rhnotevhny nkw hihrmyhiverkichit oif orh kvhr 6.7 c t`eal, wet` t`h bosh kg t`huiet hxthifeim nkwhr t`oi 5 c KF. V`h soifs oif mrovhnskvhrneh t`h sents oif soifs, wet` o akitoat rhakrfhf ot ?1.7cKF. Qhfechitory struaturhs wet`ei t`h uiet eifeaoth t`ot t`h
soifs oif mrovhns orh t`h rhsunt kg oi eiarhosh ei t`h hihrkg t`h fhpkseteim skurah. V`h uiet es up tk 7.8c t`eal wet`prhshit foy surgoah `hem`t kg 24. nc KF.
V`hrh orh twk aurrhit `ypkt`hshs gkr t`h skurah kg t`hmrovhns. V`h gerst summhsts t`ot t`hy whrh fhpksethf os
mnoaeon kutwos` (Qknkcki ?511< ]ychr ?508), t`h shakit`ot t`hy orh gnuveon ei kremei, fhpksethf by o revhr systhct`ot gnkwhf whst-host (Brefmnoif oif Nhwes ?55?< ]ychht on. ?55?). V`h net`knkmeaon akcpkseteki kg t`h mrovhn esuinelh t`h mnoaekgnuveon mrovhns ei t`h orho (Brefmnoif ht
?558) oif t`h `em` phrahitomh kg quortzeth oif quortzsummhsts t`ot t`hy whrh noef fkwi by t`h soch gnuveonsysthc t`ot fhpksethf t`h Eim`oc Qoif oif Mrovhn gurt`h
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 181/342
?=? CORL B. RKBHRVQ, ANEWH Q. MOCBNH OIF FOWEF R. BREFMNOIF - V@H BREVEQ@ EQNHQ
tk t`h aost (Gem. 2). Ot t`es pkeit ei ets fhvhnkpchit t`hrevhr t`ot fhpksethf t`h Eim`oc Qoif oif Mrovhn wosprkbobny neilhf tk t`h Bomeitki Gkiioteki, gkrceim o cojkrwhst-aost froeiomh systhc grkc t`h Cefnoifs eitk ahitronHost Oimneo. V`hrh es nettnh bekstrotemrop`eaon hvefhiah grkct`h seth, ont`kum` Oifrhws (?514) rhakrfs Ora`efeslkfki
chrefekiones. V`es sphaehs es kiny likwi ei Breuþi grkc t`h
Arkchreoi QAEEQEE
streatk os rhprhshithf ot ]hst Ruitki(Qtuort ?502).
V`h ora`ohknkmeaon cothreon grkc t`h shfechits es ckstnyuiprkvhioiahf, ont`kum` ]ychr ht af. (?55?) rhakrfcothreon grkc t`h nkwhr port kg t`h ]orrhi @enn Qoifs oif('iovhns. V`h osshcbnomh akisests prhfkceioitny kg begoahswet` nentnh fhbetomh< w`ht`hr t`es rhgnhats shfechit skrteim kraknnhateki beos rhcoeis, gkr t`h prhshit, iilikwi. Coiy kgt`h kvonh begoahs orh cofh ki gnolhs (Cker ?510), oiuiakccki p`hikchiki ei t`h Bretes` Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea,oif orh ikta`hf. ont`kum` t`es a`oroathrestea coy bh t`hrhsun) kg troispkrtoteki. Ei offeteki tk t`h kvoth/akrfothbegoahs t`hrh orh o normh iucbhr kg hxtrhchny botthrhf oif
rkn nhf ben oahs oif akrhs w`ea` `ovh bhhi eithrprhthf osbaeim typknkmeaonny shporoth grkc t`h kt`hr begoahs (Qknkcki?511< Rkh ?50?). V`es `ypkt`hses ihhfs tk bh rh-hxoceihfnoleim eitk oaakuit t`h goatkrs sua` os row cothreonovoenobenety t`rkum` t`h fhvhnkpchit kg t`h gnuveon systhcoif hiverkichits kg fhpkseteki fureim t`h negh kg t`h revhr.
Ki t`h boses kg t`h mrovhn net`knkmy et es nelhny t`ot t`hecpkrtoit ]orrhi @enn net`ea aknnhatekis orh kg prh-Oimneoikr prkbobny horny Oimneoi foth oif gonn ei t`h kt`hr mrkupskg prh-stomh ?2 seths ei t`es pophr. Et onsk chois t`ot t`hnothst thrroahs kg t`h Eim`oc Revhr oif ets trebutorehs s`kunfbh eivhstemothf gkr hvefhiah kg horny `ucoi kaaupoteki ei
t`h soch coiihr os t`h pkst-Oimneoi thrroahs kg t`hV`ochs systhc.
2.8. BKPMRKWH. QX 526 408. ]HQV QXQQHP
V`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih shfechits ot Bkxmrkvh (Gem. ?)whrh fhpksethf t`rkum` o worc thcphroth hpeskfh eitk t`hhisueim aknf hvhit. V`hy t`us rhprhshit o wefh roimh kgckfhs oif hiverkichits kg fhpkseteki. ]`ot colhs t`es sethsk ecpkrtoit es t`ot ora`ohknkmeaon rhcoeis `ovh bhhihxaovoehf grkc ete-setu akithxts, ot onn nhvhns, t`rkum` t`hstrotemrop`ea shquhiah meveim o akiteiuety kg kaaupoteki gkrt`es port kg skut`hri Himnoif kvhr o ?46 yhor tecasaonh,t`rkum` corlhfny a`oimeim anecotea rhmechs (Rkbhrts ?554).
V`h Tnhestkahih shfechits ot t`h seth set upki oif orhakitoeihf wet`ei o coreih pnotgkrc oif a`onl anegg aut eitkt`h Arhtoahkus Xpphr A`onl kg t`h Qkut` Fkwis (Gem. 8).E'`hsh ghoturhs whrh gkrchf fureim o Ceffnh Tnhestkahih`em` sho-nhvhn hvhit t`ot hitoenhf o coreih troismrhssekickveim ikrt`worfs kvhr t`h fhpksets kg t`h Nkwhr AkostonTnoei oif autteim eitk t`h skut` goaeim fepsnkph kg t`h
Fkwis. V`h coreih bhoa` akcpnhx osskaeothf wet` t`es`em` sho-nhvhn ottoeis o coxecuc hnhvoteki kg 61.8c KF ott`h juiateki kg t`h anegg oif t`h wovh aut pnotgkrc< t`es `em`ontetufh coy bh t`h rhsunt kg subshquhit thatkiea oatevety eit`h orho (Trhhah ht on. ?554). Osskaeothf wet` t`h `em` sho-nhvhn orh o coreih soif uiet, t`h Qneifki Qoifs w`ea` mrofhup eitk o nomkkion uiet, t`h Qneifki Qents. V`h likwi hxthit
kg t`hsh fhpksets es substoiteon: grkc Tkrts Fkwi ei t`h]hst (OpQecki ht on. ?5==< Rkbhrts ?507) tk t`h RevhrOrui ei t`h Host, o festoiah ei hxahss kg 14 lc. V`hQneifki Qents whrh gkrchf w`hi t`h ferhat pot` kg t`h saoeitk o normh hcboychit, gkrchf by t`h fkwis, wos bnkalhf.Ont`kum` t`h hxoat cha`oiesc by w`ea` t`es `opphihf esikt yht likwi, o normh sont wothr, tefonny ghf nomkki wosarhothf. Ot t`h hif kg t`h nomkkion p`osh o sken fhvhnkphfki t`h surgoah kg t`h sents, w`ea` rhprhshits t`h cksthxthisevh Tnhestkahih noifsurgoah ot t`h seth. Qubshquhitshfechitoteki fhrevhs grkc t`h ikrt` kg t`h seth, gerstnyw`hi t`h sken wos gnkkfhf wet` grhs` wothr tk arhoth oionfar/gai aorr oif t`hi, shakifny, os t`h skens akvhreim t`h
rhneat a`onl anegg oif t`h fkwinoif bnkal, tk t`h ikrt` kg t`hseth whrh strepphf kgg, os vhmhtoteki akvhr fhaneihf uifhr oieiarhoseimny shvhrh anecotea rhmech. Geionny, uifhrparemnoaeon akifetekis normh ockuits kg mrovhn grkc t`ha`onl anegg oif t`h Vhrteory rhmknet` akvhreim t`h Fkwisckvhf fkwi-snkph os phremnoaeon coss ckvhchit fhpksets.
V`h ora`ohknkmy ot t`h seth (Bhrmcoi oif Rkbhrts ?500<Bhrmcoi ht on. ?554< ]hiboi-Qcet` ?505< Rkbhrts ?552)akisests kg saotthrs kg net`ea cothreon ei onn t`h mhknkmeaonuiets, but bhst prhshrvhf oif ckst hxthisevh ei t`h QneifkiQents oif ei t`h a`onl sarhh cothreon kvhrnyeim t`h bhoa`,grkc w`hrh row cothreon wos kbtoeihf. Rhahitny, ei setu
begoahs oif rhgetteim fhbetomh `ovh bhhi gkuif ei t`h aknfanecoth coss ckvhchit mrovhns t`ot aop t`h shquhiah(Rkbhrts ?552). V`h prhshiah kg ora`ohknkmy ot t`es nhvhncoy summhst t`ot horny `ucois whrh obnh tk survevh eiBretoei t`rkum`kut phrekfs kg hxtrhch aknf sua` os mnoaeonstomhs. V`h osshcbnomhs, grkc t`h seth os o w`knh, orhcoeiny begoah rhfuateki saotthrs wet` skch vhry necethfakrh rhfuateki. V`h begoahs (Gem. 7) orh hsshiteonny kvoths,necoifhs oif akrfoth gkrcs (Bkrfhs ?57?), ont`kum`pkeithf gkrcs orh gkuif w`hi t`h row cothreon quonetyfrkps. V`hrh orh ghw gkrcon gnolh tkkns< twk hif-sarophrs, otroisvhrsh sarophr, o sefh sarophr oif skch ikta`hf sarophrs.V`h gnolhf gnolh tha`iequh es prhshit but ot nkw grhquhiayoif t`hrh es skch shakifory rhtkua` ki gnolhs gkr bnuiteimoif hfmh strhimt`hieim. Hvefhiah kg ush kg t`h net`eas esopporhit grkc buta`hrhf oiecoS rhcoeis< t`hsh eianufh rhffhhr, r`eikahrks oif `krsh.
V`h seth `os bhhi fothf (Vobnh ?) useim cocconeoibekstrotemrop`y tk t`h hif kg t`h Arkchreoi Akcpnhx. V`hcorlhr gkssens orh nesthf bhnkw:
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 182/342
?=2 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 8. Akcpkseth shateki t`rkum` t`h mhknkmy ei _uorry ? ot Bkxmrkvh, eianufeim fhtoen kg fhpksets akitoeieim t`h `kceief tebeo. Lhy tk t`hshateki feomroc es os gknnkws: ?. Roeshf bhoa` mrovhns< 2. Qneifki Qoifs< 1. Qneifki Qents, wet` sken `krezki fhvhnkphf ei upphr port ot _?-O<6. Aonaorhkus sents oif mrovhns, fhrevhf grkc whot`hreim kg t`h a`onl anegg< 8. Qknuteki whot`hreim akitoat< 7. Qknegnuathf Vhrteory rhmkeet`.
oceikstrotemrop`y, summhst akrrhnoteki wet` KEQ ?? (Bkwh?55?< Bkwhi oif Qylhs ?500). Bkwhi (ebef) akrrhnothsBkxmrkvh wet` Qwoisakcbh, oi eithrprhtoteki t`ot shhcsuithiobnh mevhi t`h fegghrhiahs ei t`h cocconeoi gouiosgrkc t`h twk seths (shh bhnkw). V`h oceikstrotemrop`yormuchit es gurt`hr wholhihf by t`h goat t`ot t`h roteks gkBori`oc (Os`tki ht on. ?556o) oif Bhha`hs Tet (R.A. Trhhphrs. akcc.) onsk eifeaoth KEQ ?? oif ot t`hsh seths, os otQwoisakcbh, ikih kg t`h sphaehs nesthf obkvh `ovh bhhigkuif, fhspeth oi hxthisevh sehveim prkmrocch. Kt`hrcht`kfs kg obsknuth foteim, eianufeim H.Q.R oif V.N., `ovprkvhf eiakianusevh t`us gor, kr bhykif t`h aurrhit rhoa`
t`h cht`kf (Rkbhrts ?556).Fureim t`h hfeteim stomhs kg t`es rhpkrt o `kceief tebeo
wos fesakvhrhf ei t`h upphr port kg t`h Qneifki Qents(Gem. =), ei o goaehs t`ot es o thcpkron akrrhnotevh kg t`h sk`krezki fhvhnkphf ki t`h surgoah kg t`h sents. V`h `kceief`os bhhi ossemihf tk @kck ag. `hefhnbhrmhises (Rkbhrts h
on. ?556). Gurt`hr hxaovoteki kg t`h `kceief geifspkt espnoiihf gkr ?558.
Vobnh 2. Bekstrotemrop eaonny semiegeaoit cocconeoi toxo grkcBkxmrkvh.
EIQHAVEWKROQkrh.x ruitkihises
Qkrhx soveie
RKFHIVEO
Tnekcys hpesakpones
Orveakno thrrhstres aoiteoio
Cearktus mrhmones (mrhmonkef ckrp`ktyph)AORIEWKRO
Aoies nupus cksboa`hises
Xrsus fhieimhreTHR?QQKFOAVUNO
Qthp`oikr`eius `uifs`hechises
ORVEKFOAVUNO
Chmonkahrks fowleise
V`h bekstrotemrop`eaon ckfhn akitrofeats t`h oceik oaefroahce/.oteki roteks ki coreih cknnusao w`ea`, useim
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 183/342
?=1 CORL B. RKBHRVQ. ANEWH Q. MOCBNH OIF FOWEF R. BREFMNOIF - V@H BREVEQ@ EQNHQ
Gem. 7. Bkxmrkvh gneitwkrl ki t`h
surgoah kg t`h coreih QneifkiQoifs.
Gem. =. V`h Bkxmrkvh `kceief tebeo(saonh ei ?4 cc fevesekis).
2.7. ]HQVBXRU-QXB-CHIFET. QV 847 846. QKCHRQHV
V`h Tnhestkahih fhpksets ot ]hstbury (Gem. ?) whrh
nkaothf ei o nechstkih quorry setuothf ot t`h skut`hri hfmhkg t`h Chifep Tnothou ot bhtwhhi 2?1 oif 266c KF.V`h fhpksets oaaucunothf ei o aovh systhc t`ot gkrchf eit`h Anegtki Fkwi nechstkih. V`hrh orh twk a`ocbhrs w`ea``ovh bhhi eivhstemothf oif socpnhf (Bes`kp ?502<Oifrhws ?554). o coei kr skut`hosthri a`ocbhr ot nhost=4 c ei nhimt` oif o shakifory fhhp, iorrkw sefh a`ocbhr,t`ot gknnkws o gount neih tk t`h ikrt`whst. Akrrhnoteki
bhtwhhi t`h fhpksets ei t`h twk aovhs es feggeaunt os t`hfhpksets summhst eigenneim grkc fegghrhit kremeis. V`h boson
chcbhr ei hoa` a`ocbhr es secenor, ei t`ot t`es es oseneahkus fhpkset akcpkshf kg soifs oif mrovhns t`ot whrhwos`hf eitk t`h aovh grkc kutsefh. V`h gouio grkc t`es uietes sporsh akcporhf wet` skch kg t`h kvhrnyeim uiets oifets akcpkseteki summhsts t`ot et es knfhr oif bhnkims tk oshporoth Horny kr horny Ceffnh Tnhestkahih stomh. Eifeaotkrsphaehs eianufh: Ceckcys soveie, Cearktus (Onnkp`oekcys),
oif @yohio brhverkstres. Gknnkweim t`h fhpkseteki kg t`h
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 184/342
?=6 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
seneahkus shfechits, bkt` a`ocbhrs hxphrehiahf rkkgaknnopsh hpeskfhs oif subshquhit fhpkseteki kg oimunorbrhaaeos. V`hsh whrh suaahhfhf by t`h gurt`hr fhpkseteki kg
hxthisevh brhaaeo fhpksets, gunny fhsarebhf by Oifrhws(?554). Ei brehg et coy bh stothf t`ot t`h brhaaeos ei t`h
coei a`ocbhr, obkvh t`h oimunor brhaaeo, orh fegghrhit grkct`ksh oiyw`hrh hnsh ei t`h aovh. V`her kremei es grkckutsefh t`h aovh oif t`hy whrh fhpksethf os gnkw fhpksets.Ei t`h sefh a`ocbhr t`h brhaaeos orh gkrtihf grkcakistetuhits wet`ei t`h a`ocbhr etshng.
V`h ecpkrtoiah kg ]hstbury gkr t`es pophr nehs wet` t`h
cocconeoi gouios rhakvhrhf grkc t`h aovh fhpksets.Gerstny, grkc o toxkikcea/bekstrotemrop`ea oimnh, t`h gouioakitoeis t`ksh anhchits w`ea` orh osskaeothf wet` o pkst-Arkchreoi shisu streatk oif prh-Qwoisakcbh pkseteki ei
t`h _uothriory techsaonh (Bes`kp ?502< Wki Lkhiemswonf?5=1). V`hsh sphaehs eianufh Qkrhx ruitkihises, Qkrhx
soveie, Orveakno thrrhstres aoiteoio, Cearktus mrhmones,
Aoies nupus cksboa`hises, Xe sus fhieimhre oif
Qthp`oikr`eius `uifs`hechises. V`es mrkup `os vhry anksh
poronnhns wet` t`ot hxaovothf grkc t`h kphi seth ot Bkxmrkvh(Vobnh 2). Qhakifny, top`kikcea stufehs kg t`h sconncoccon osshcbnomhs (Oifrhws ?554) `os onnkwhf o
fhtoenhf ponohkhaknkmeaon rhakistruateki tk bh uifhrtolhit`rkum` t`h shfechitory prkgenhs. Grkc t`es rhakistruatekit`h gknnkweim anecotea eighrhiahs `ovh bhhi cofh. Ei t`h
ikrt`whst sefh a`ocbhr t`hrh orh twk thcphroth hpeskfhsshporothf by phrekfs kg aknfhr anecoth. V`h thcphrothhpeskfhs orh t`kum`t tk rhprhshit thcphroturhs secenor tkt`ksh kg tkfoy ot t`h notetufh kg ]hstbury. Gkr t`h twk aknfphrekfs t`h gerst es eifeaotevh kg akkn fry akifetekis w`enstt`h notthr summhsts o anecotea rhmech akisefhrobny aknfhr. Egthitotevh akrrhnoteki es cofh bhtwhhi t`h twk a`ocbhrs ot
t`h hif kg t`h shakif aknf phrekf, et coy bh fhckistrothft`ot t`es es gknekwhf by o gurt`hr worc hvhit. Oifrhws(ebef) summhsts t`ot t`hrh coy t`hrhgkrh bh ckrh t`oi kih
gunny thcphroth kr eithrmnoaeon hvhit rhakrfhf ei t`h
]asnbury shquhiah. @kwhvhr ei t`h nem`t kg t`h rhahit wkrlki t`h Mrhhinoif Eah Akrh Trkjhat (MRET Chcbhrs ?551) et
aoi bh shai t`ot t`hrh coy bh gor ckrh anecotea fevhrsetywet`ei thcphroth esktkpea stomhs t`oi prhvekusny t`kum`t.]`ht`hr t`h ]hstbury shquhiah akitoeis kih kr ckrhthcphroth stomhs, et es ahrtoei t`ot t`h anecotea akcpnhxety,hxtropknothf grkc t`h sconn coccon osshcbnomhs ot t`h
seth, eifeaoths t`ot t`h Orveakno gouios kg t`h Arkchreoi
Akcpnhx (Vobnh ?) whrh ikt fhvhnkpeim ei o pknnhi bekzkihot t`h hif kg t`h Arkchreoi shisu streatk (Qtuort oif ]hst?5=7< Qtuort ?500), but bhnkim tk kih kr ckrh gunnyeithrmnoaeon stomhs.
Gneit tkkns `ovh bhhi gkuif ot t`h seth (Bes`kp ?5=8) but
`ovh bhhi t`h subjhat kg skch akitrkvhrsy os tk w`ht`hrt`hy whrh coi-cofh kr ikt (ag. Akkl ?501). V`h prkbnhc
es t`ot t`h gneit ei t`h ]hstbury shfechits es a`hceaonnyonthrhf by onloneih sknuteki (Qa`conz ?574) w`ea` `os coefhitegeaoteki kg t`h pehahs feggeaunt. V`h osshcbnomh `os,
`kwhvhr, bhhi rh-hxoceihf rhahitny by o mrkup kg hxphrts(A. Qtreimhr phrs. akcc.), w`k `ovh vhregehf ets out`hiteaeoif akigerchf t`h vehw kg Bes`kp (?502), w`k gkuif et
feggeaunt tk hxpnoei t`h prhshiah kg t`h gneit ki mhknkmeaon
mrkuifs.
2.=. ]EWHI@KH VC 448 218 HQQHP
V`h seth ot ]evhi`kh es ei o mrovhn pet nkaothf ihor t`h
skut`hri hfmh kg t`h Vhifreim Tnothou (Gem. ?), opprkxe-cothny twk lc grkc t`h Revhr Aknih. V`h seth es ikw
rhmorfhf os t`h typh nkaonety gkr t`h ]evhi`kh Mrovhn,w`ea` es a`rkiknkmeaonny t`h t`erf kg t`h gkur thrroahgkrcotekis t`ot akistetuth t`h Nkw-nhvhn Lhsmrovh submrku(Gem. 0) (Brefmnoif ?500< ?556). V`es submrkup `os bhhirhahitny fhsarebhf os t`h Akna`hsthr Gkrcoteki (]`ethcoioif Rkså ?552), ont`kum` t`es porteaunor utenesoteki kg
strotemrop`ea ikchianoturh wkunf shhc suphrgnukus mevhi
t`h gkrcoteki stotus ofvkaothf gkr eifevefuon thrroah mrovhwet`ei t`h submrkup (Brefmnoif ?556). V`h ]evhi`kh/Akkls Mrhhi Mrovhn thrroah gkrcoteki aoi bh s`kwi tk
pkst-foth t`h Orfnhem`/Kolnhy Mrovhn (Brefmnoif ht on.
?554), w`ea` es fothf tk t`h Arkchreoi Akcpnhx, oif prhfoths t`h Qt. Ksyt`/@knnoif Gkrcoteki, w`ea` es akrrhnothfwet` t`h Oimneoi mnoaeoteki.
Ot t`h seth, gksseneghrkus shfechits ei t`h gkrc kg oi
krmoiea senty anoy orh eithrbhffhf wet` t`h ]evhi`kh Mrov(Brefmnoif ?500). Tknnhi, pnoit coarkgkssens oif eishatrhcoeis `ovh bhhi rhakvhrhf grkc t`h uiet. V`h rhsuntsgrkc prhneceiory oionyshs kg t`es cothreon orh eifeaotevh kg
bkrhon gkrhst vhmhtoteki kg o typh gkuif ei coiy eithrmnoaeoif eithrstofeon shquhiahs oif aoi ikt bh ushf gkr
a`rkiknkmeaon akrrhnoteki. Vwk sconn uifeomikstea gneitgnolhs whrh onsk rhakvhrhf grkc t`h senty anoy fureimsocpneim.
V`h seth ot ]evhi`kh es uihquevkaonny prh-Oimneoi os
fhckistrothf by akrrhnoteki kg gnuveon thrroahs wet`ei t`h
Nkw-nhvhn Lhsmrovh Qubmrkup oif by anost net`knkmeaonoionyses. @kwhvhr gurt`hr wkrl es ihhfhf ot t`h seth tk
osahrtoei w`ht`hr et gonns eitk t`h Bkxmrkvh/]hstbury/@em`Nkfmh mrkup.
2.0. LHI V'Q AOWHRI QP 516 76? FHWKI
V`es seth es aurrhitny bheim rh-eivhstemothf, but t`h
eigkrcoteki mevhi `hrh es coeiny grkc hornehr pubnes`hfwkrl. V`h aovh systhc es aut ei Fhvkieoi Nechstkih oif
`os o akcpnhx strotemrop`y t`ot akitoeis ora`ohknkmy grkct`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea tk t`h Chfeohvon Threkf. V`h NkwhTonohknet`ea cothreon akisests kg begoaeon tkkns eianufeim`oifoxhs oif cesahnnoihkus gnolhs. V`h orthgoats orh
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 185/342
?=8 CORL B. RKBHRVQ, ANEWH Q. MOCBNH OIF FOWEF R. BREFMNOIF - V@H BREVEQ@ EQNHQ
_ þ× k.
@mj??
je
I
] H
64
64
]onfreimgehnf Mrovhn
Orfnhem`/Kolnhy Mrovhn N c n h 4 o l n a v
e Qents oif Qoifs
Orfnhem`eithrmnoaeon fhpksets
]evai`kh/Akkls Mrhhi Mrovhn
Nkwar Qt Ksyt`/@knnoif Mrovhn
Carsao Esnoif/]evh``kh /-]em bkrku m` Mrovh
krmoiea fhpksets
Anoatki A`oiian Fhpksets-
Anoatki A`oiihn Mrovhn
Krmoiea shfechits (thcphrota hxahpt: O-oratea) *< -* "« Corthnns Mrovhn
|m29O| Nkw-navhn Host Hsshx Mrovhn Qubmrkup
Xpphr Qt Ksyt`/Xppar @knnoif Mrovhn
esQwn Nkwnhvhn Lhsmrovh Qubmrkup
¼
Gem. 0. Efhoeezhf shateki t`rkum` t`h Tnhestkahih fhpksets kg t`h Vhifreim Tnothou (ogthr Brefmnoif ?500).
fhsarebhf os ora`oea by Rkh (?50?) oif typknkmeaonny gonneitk `es Gkrfweh`/Gori`oc mrkup. V`hy kaaur ei t`h brhaaeobhnkw t`h aovh hort` os fhsarebhf by Thimhnny (?0=1o< b)oif Aocpbhnn oif Qocpski (?5=?). Qhfechits ot t`h seth`ovh rhahitny bhhi fothf useim t`h Xroieuc-shrehs
tha`iequh ki t`h stonomceths but t`h rhsunts rhcoeihquevkaon (T. Bhrrefmh phrs.akcc.). V`h ckst rhneobnh omhhstecoth tkr t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih fhpksets oif t`hora`ohknkmy es kbtoeihf by stufyeim t`h akcpkseteki kg t`hcoccon gouio, w`ea` eianufhs t`h gknnkweim sphaehs:
Vobnh 1. Bekstrotemrop`eaonny semiegeaoit cocconeoi toxo grkc Lhit'sAovhri.
Orveakno thrrhstres aoiteoio
Cearktus mrhmones
n 'rsus fhieimhre
@kckt`areeec notefai.s
hxteiat wothr vknh
hxteiat peih vknh
hxteiat bhor
hxteiat coa`oerkfkit aot
Ont`kum` t`es es o sconn gouio, et akitoeis sphaehs t`ot orhbekstrotemrop`eaonny vhry ecpkrtoit, Cearktus mrhmonkefhs
oif Xrsus fhieimhre `ovh ikt bhhi gkuif ei fhpksets pkst-foneim t`h Oimneoi ei Bretoei oif @kckt`areeec notefhis
bhaoch hxteiat t`rkum`kut Hurkph fureim t`h KEQ ?2 aknfhvhin (O. Vurihr ?552). V`hrh fkhs, `kwhvhr, hxest oihnhchit kg fkubt surrkuifeim t`h akithxt kg t`h rhcoeis kg
t`h coa`oerkfkit aot, os t`hy orh osskaeothf wet` shfechitsakrrhnothf wet` t`h nothr Tnhestkahih (C. Bes`kp oif T. Bhrrefmh, phrs. akcc.) oif t`hrh hxests t`h pkssebenety t`ot t`hywhrh eitrkfuahf tk t`h aovh by `ucois, ei o secenor gos`ekitk t`h tkkt` ot Rkbei @kkf's Aovh (Q. Torgett, phrs. akcc.).
V`h prhshiah kg O. thrrhstres aoiteoio es ecpkrtoit bhaoushet fhckistroths t`ot t`h seth es ykuimhr t`oi t`h Arkchreoishisu streatk. Oaakrfeimny t`h seth gonns ei wet` t`h kt`hrs eit`es mrkup ei thrcs kg brkof omh hstecoths.
1. Ceffnh Tnhestkahih Kaaupoteki kg t`h Bretes`
Esnhs: Qeths pkst-foteim t`h Oimneoi Aknf Qtomh
1.?. EIVRKFXAVEKI
Oaakrfeim tk t`h ?5=1 Mhknkmeaon Qkaehty kg Nkifki_uothcory tech saonh (Ceta`hnn ht on. ?5=1) t`hrh whrh twkthcphroth kr eithrmnoaeon hvhits ogthr t`h Oimneoi Mnoaeoteki,t`h @kxieoi oif t`h Epswea`eoi (Vobnh ?). V`es sa`hch
boshf ki net`kstrotemrop`ea subfeveseki kg t`h _uothcorywos suppkrthf by ponyiknkmeaon wkrl (]hst ?587< ?58=<?571< A. Vurihr ?5=4< ?5=8< Whitres ?507) oif by cocconeoi bekstrotemrop`y (Qtuort ?5=6< ?502). V`es shquhiahwos gerst a`onnhimhf by Qutaneggh (?5=8) oif ei t`h shceionwkrl kg Qutaneggh oif Lkwonsle (?5=7), oif `os rhahitnybhhi fhckistrothf tk bh kvhrsecpnegehf, veifeaoteim cua`kg Qutaneggh's rhshora`. V`hrh orh ikw t`kum`t tk bh t`rhh
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 186/342
?=7 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Chtrhs K.F
74
64
24
-24
-64
Fortgkrf@hot`Mrovhn
Qwoisakcbhfhpksets
Krshtt @hot`Mrovhn
@kria`ura`Venn Eithrmnoaeon fhpksets
ot Turgnhht, Mroys(Nettnh V`urrkal),nntkrf (Aounegnkwhr pet),Bhn us Torl.
Akrbhts VhyMrovhn ^ Cualeim
Mrovhn ^ Host Venbury Q ` h F F h r t k i
. Cors`hs Mrovhn * i h T T h i k i
Qoif ^ MrovhnCkfhri r
Eithrmnoaeon fhpksets otOvhnhy, ]hst V`urrkal.nntkrf (Xp`onn Tet) oifAroygkrf
Qtrotemrop`eapkseteki kgVrogonmor Qquorhfhpksets
BurehA`oi
Onnuveuc Eithrmnoaeon fhpksets S Aknf-anecoth Mrovhns
Gem. 5. Efhonezhf troisvhrsh shateki t`rkum` t`h thrroahs kg t`h Nkwhr V`ochs (ogthr Brefmnoif ?556).
cojkr thcphroth oif t`rhh aknf stomhs bhtwhhi t`h Oimneoioif t`h Epswea`eoi/Hhceoi worc stomh ot a. ?28 Lyr BT(Bkwhi ht on. ?505< Brefmnoif ?556). V`hsh anecotea hvhitsakrrhnoth wet` KEQ ?2 tk 8h (Q`oalnhtki oif Kpfylh ?5=1).V`h seths fesausshf bhnkw gonn eitk KEQ ?? oif 5. V`hecpkrtoit essuhs t`ot oresh grkc stufyeim t`hsh seths orh t`hfeggarhiahs ei t`h toxkikceh akcpkseteki bhtwhhi t`hshgouios oif t`ksh ei t`h Bkxmrkvh/]hstbury mrkup, wet` oprh-Oimneoi omh. Kg hquon ecpkrtoiah es t`h goat t`ot seths t`ot`ovh bhhi nucphf tkmht`hr os bhnkimeim tk t`h @kxieoi
Eithrmnoaeon coy whnn bhnkim tk twk shporoth thcphroth stomhs.Nothr eithrmnoaeon shfechits, ikt fesausshf `hrh. orh
rhprhshithf ot seths ottrebuthf tk KEQ = oif Qubstomh 8h.V`hsh `ovh onn bhhi anossegehf ei t`h post os Epswea`eoi/Hhceoi but t`hrh es ikw uihquevkaon hvefhiah grkc oceikoaef roteks oif net`kstrotemrop`y (Bkwhi ?55?< Brefmnoif?556), w`ea` akrrkbkroth hornehr efhos boshf ki cocconeoioif cknnusaoi gouios, t`ot twk shporoth thcphroth hpeskfhsorh rhprhshithf. V`h knfhr kih es hquevonhit tk KEQ = oift`h ykuimhr es t`h nost eithrmnoaeon.
1.2. Q]OIQAKCBH V_ 858 =68 LHIV
V`h seth ot Qwoisakcbh es prkbobny t`h bhst likwi kg onnBretes` Tonohknet`ea seths. Et es nkaothf ei t`h Nkwhr V`ochsWonnhy (Gem. ?), ei t`h `em`hst thrroah kg t`h pkst-Oimneoiakursh kg t`h revhr, 8 lc tk t`h host kg Mrovhshif. V`hshfechitory shquhiah es fhsarebhf ei fhtoen hnshw`hrh(]oha`thr ?5=2< Akiwoy oif ]oha`thr ?5==< @ubborf?502< Brefmnoif ?556) oif wenn kiny bh onnufhf tk brehgnyei t`es pophr.
V`h fhpksets ot Borigehnf Tet rhst upki t`h V`oiht Qoifot o `hem`t kg 21c KF (Gem. 5), t`hy whrh noef fkwi ei oa`oiihn gkrchf skki ogthr t`h fevhrseki kg t`h V`ochs byt`h Oimneoi eah s`hht (Brefmnoif ?500< ?556). V`h fhpkset`ovh bhhi fevefhf eitk t`h gknnkweim shquhiah:
Vobnh 6. Ora`ohknkmy oif Mhknkmy ot Qwoisakcbh.
Fhpksetekion Hiverkichit Xiet Eifustrv
Noif fhrevhf shfechits Xpphr Mrovhn Oa`hunh
Xpphr Nkoc Oa`hunh
Ommrofeim strhoc fhpksets Xpphr Ceffnh Mrovhn* Oa`hunh
Nkwhr Ceffnh Mrovhn Oa`hunh
Kvhrboil fhpksets Nkwhr Nkoc Anoatkie
Ommrofeim revhr fhpksets Nkwhr Mrovhn Anoatkie
* Qlunn `krezki.
Trhvekus rhshora`hrs `ovh ormuhf gkr o substoiteon `eotusei t`h Qwoisakcbh shquhiah ot t`h juiateki kg t`h NkwhrNkoc oif t`h Nkwhr Ceffnh Mrovhns. Ont`kum` t`hrh es oi
hrksekion akitoat ot t`es bkuifory, prhshit rhshora` s`kws tk bh t`h rhsunt kg o a`oimh ei strhoc fyioceas rot`hr t`oio nkim thrc hvhit (Brefmnoif ht on. ?508). Kih rhoski gkrrhquereim o cojkr mop ei t`h shfechitory rhakrf ot t`es pke`of ets rkkts ei ora`ohknkmeaon typknkmy. V`h nkwhst twkuiets ot Qwoisakcbh akitoei net`ea osshcbnomhs fhsemiotafos Anoatkieoi, kvhrnoei by Oa`hunhoi orthgoats. @kwhvhr,t`h seth ot Nettnh V`urrkal Mnkbh Tet, ei t`h nkwhr thrroah k
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 187/342
?== CORL B. RKBHRVQ. ANEWH Q. MOCBNH OIF FOWEF R. BREFMNOIF - V@H BREVEQ@ EQNHQ
ThbCyfoy
Xpphr Nkoc
Eitarbaffaf sentyfoy oifsoif
Arkss-strotegeaf soif
EEEa
•-. J - '" t j - Y '3, "- , h . - p WQ
Ê!Qm£mpY
Xpphr Ceffnh Mrova! ib
Reppnh-noceiothf soif
Arkss-strotegehf soif
re
Onthriotekrts kg soif oifvhry soiky mrovhn
Nkwhr Ceffna Mrovhn Eno
Qoify mrovhn
‖ Hrksekion akitoat
FhaoJaeenhf zkih (QkeK
Cossevh aonaorhkusanoyhy sent wet` s`anns ??
Nkwhr NkocNoxieiotaf aonaorhkussoifs, sents oif anoys
Qoify mrovhn wet` s`hens
Nkwhr Mrovhn Eb
Akorsa mrovhn wet`soif cotrex
Anost-suppkrta f ot bosh Eo
V`oiht Qoif
7
• Y Cknnusas
• Ei setu wkrlaf gnein
W Ei setu bkih gromchit
et V`hrcknuceiasahiaa socpnh
Gem. ?4. V`h shquhiah ot Qwoisakcbh (ogthr Brefmnoif ht on. ?508).
t`h Akrbhts Vhy Gkrcoteki, onsk akitoeis Anoatkieoiorthgoats. V`us et wos ihahssory tk eivklh o akivknuthfsa`hch kg hvhits wet` t`h revhr bheim ot kih nhvhnfhpkseteim t`h Nkwhr Mrovhns oif Nkocs, autteim fkwi tkt`h Mnkbh Tet nhvhn oif t`hi reseim omoei tk noy fkwi t`hshfechits akitoeieim Oa`hunhoi cothreon ot Qwoisakcbh(Leim oif Kolnhy ?517). Et `os bhhi fhckistrothf(Brefmnoif ht on. ?508) t`ot t`h Qwoisakcbh fhpksetsrhprhshit o seimnh mrkss upworfs geieim shfechitory genn(Gem. ?4), thrceioteim ei phremnoaeon shfechitoteki oifeivknuteki oif t`ot t`h thcphroth shfechits ot t`h sethrhprhshit t`h gerst worc hvhit ogthr t`h Oimneoi (Brefmnoif?556). V`h omh kg t`h Qwoisakcbh shquhiah es gurt`hrsuppkrthf by t`h anost akcpkseteki kg t`h Nkwhr oif NkwhrCeffnh Mrovhns (Brefmnoif ht on. ?508), oceik oaef roteksakisesthit wet` o KEQ ?? foth (Bkwhi ht on. ?505) oif t`hakcpkseteki kg t`h cocconeoi gouio w`ea` akitoeis ikihkg t`h Arkchreoi Akcpnhx corlhr sphaehs oif shhs t`hopphoroiah kg sphaehs sua` os Qthp`oikr`eius `hcetkha`us.
Qthp`oikr`eius lerh`bhrmhises, Chmonkahrks memoithus oif
Bks preiþmhieus (Qtuort ?502).V`h seth ot Qwoisakcbh es prkbobny bhst likwi gkr t`h
rhgetteim `kceief slunn gromchits t`ot whrh rhakvhrhf grkct`h Xpphr Ceffnh Mrovhn. V`h kaaepeton bkih wosfesakvhrhf ei ?518, gknekwhf by t`h nhnt porehton ei ?517oif t`h rem`t porehton ei ?588, t`h notthr bheim pkkrnyprhshrvhf (Qtreimhr ?508). V`h slunn es bhnehvhf tk bhghconh wet` o broei sezh kg obkut ?144 cn. V`h kvhronnaroieon s`oph es nhss oimunor t`oi ckrh ora`oea `kceiefsoif t`hrh orh twk ghoturhs t`ot `ovh Ihoifhrt`on oggeietehs.Gerstny, t`hrh es hvefhiah kg o fhvhnkphf juxtocostkefhceihiah ot t`h kaaepeton cormeis oif shakifny o snem`t,
fkubnå ora`hf kaaepeton tkrus surckuithf by o ahitronfhprhsseki, o suproeieoa gksso (Qtreimhr oif Mocbnh ?551).\g t`h s`krt a`rkiknkmy `ypkt`hses kg t`h kaaupoteki kgHurkph es oaahpthf (Rkhbrkhls oif Woi Lkngsa`kthi, t`esvknuch), t`hi et wkunf choi t`ot t`h Ihoifhrt`on a`oroa-thresteas fespnoyhf by t`h Qwoisakcbh slunn fhvhnkphffureim t`h gerst ?44 Lyr ogthr aknkiezoteki. Eg t`hshp`ysekmikcea a`oimhs whrh t`h rhsunt kg ofoptoteki tk oaknfhr anecoth, t`hi et es nelhny t`ot t`h horny pkpunoteki kg`kceiefs ei Hurkph whrh obnh tk kphroth oif survevh ei, kranksh tk, t`h anecotea oif `hiah hiverkichiton rhmechsosskaeothf wet` o cojkr aknf stomh. Qua` o `ypkt`hses essuppkrthf by wkrl ot Bkxmrkvh (Rkbhrts ?552< Rkbhrtsht on., t`es vknuch), ot Anoatki (shh bhnkw) oif ot Lornea`,noyhr @ (Bkseisle, t`es vknuch).
Vk akianufh, et coy bh fhckistrothf grkc rhahit wkrlki t`h Nkwhr V`ochs (Brefmnoif ?556) t`ot t`hosshcbnomhs fhsarebhf os Anoatkieoi bkt` prh-foth oifpkst-foth begoah eifustrehs ei t`es rhmeki. Aurrhit rh-eivhstemoteki kg t`h Qwoisakcbh ora`evh `os rhvhonhf ot
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 188/342
E=Q V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
nhost kih begoah grkc t`h Nkwhr Mrovhn (CaIobb oif
Os`tki ?552). ]`hi t`es pehah es akisefhrhf wet` kt`hravefhiah bhmeiieim tk hchrmh grkc seths nelh Anoatki oif
Bori`oc. et opphors t`ot t`h feveseki kg Bretes` NkwhrTonohknet`ea eifustrehs eitk twk shporoth, aunturonny festeiathitetehs es oi uisustoeiobnh akiahpt.
1.1. HOQV GORC BORI@OC VN 0=8 =0= QXGGKNLV`h seth ot Host Gorc. Bori`oc (Os`tki ht on. ?556o) es
nkaothf ei oi knf breal pet 6 lc skut` kg V`htgkrf oif
26 lc ikrt` kg Bury Qt Hfcuifs (Gem. ?). V`h pet es ei o fry
vonnhy t`ot ruis poronnhn tk t`h prhshit akursh kg t`h NettnhKusa revhr vonnhy. V`h wkrleims aut t`rkum` thcphrothanecoth gnuveon fhpksets w`ea` kvhrneh t`h Nkwhstkgt VXE<
t`h sknef mhknkmy tk t`h skut` es Arhtoahkus A`onl oif t`hrhorh onsk hxthisevh sprhofs kg mnoaeon kutwos` mrovhn,prhfkceioitny tk t`h ikrt` kg t`h seth. V`h gerst akitrknnhfhxaovotekis ot t`h seth whrh uifhrtolhi by Totthrski (?51=)oif subsaquhitny by ]ychr (?508).
V`h thcphroth shfechits ot Bori`oc whrh noef fkwi ei opkst-mnoaeon revhr systhc t`ot gnkwhf ei o a`oiihn fhvhnkphfei mnoaeon kutwos` mrovhns. Trekr tk Os`tki's wkrl, t`h sethwos pkrtroyhf os o anossea hxocpnh kg t`h Bretes` Anoatkieoi-Oa`hunhoi suaahsseki (]ychr ?5=6). @kwhvhr, rhahithxaovotekis `ovh s`kwi t`ot fhbetomh grkc t`h prkfuatekikg begoahs `os bhhi gkuif ei t`h soch akithxt, t`h akbbnhboif (]ychr ?508), os t`ot w`ea` akitoeis t`h anosseaAnoatkieoi Eifustry (Os`tki ht on. ?556b). V`es offs gurt`hrstrhimt` tk t`h ormuchit prkpkshf by Os`tki oif CaIobb(?552), t`ot t`h Anoatkieoi aoiikt bh vehwhf os o
a`rkiknkmeaonny semiegeaoit eifhphifhit stkih wkrleimtrofeteki ei t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih. V`h sent uiets ot t`h seth
`ovh yehnfhf rea` ea`t`ykgouios, `hrphtkgouios oif coc-
coneoi gouios (Os`tki ht on. ?556o oif b). V`h bekstrote-mrop`eaon avefhiah grkc t`h gouio es akisesthit wet` o pkst-Oimneoi foth< ik Arkchreoi Akcpnhx eifeaotkrs, sua` os
t`ksh grkc t`h Bkxmrkvh/]hstbury mrkup, `ovh bhhirhakvhrhf. V`h prhshiah kg Hcys krbeaunores. t`h Hurkphoipkif tkrtkesh oif Hnop`h nkimesseco, t`h Ohsaunopeoi siolheifeaoth thcphroturhs woiihr t`oi t`h prhshit foy. V`h
`hrphtkgouio onsk suppkrts t`h vehw t`ot t`es seth aoiikt bh
t`h soch oma os Bkxmrkvh, w`hrh t`h `hrphtkgouiothcphrotura semion eifeaoths o nhss thcphroth eithrmnoaeon,t`ot es anecoteaonny secenor tk t`h aurrhit stomh. V`hsh neihs
kg hvefhiah get whnn wet` Q`oalnhtki's (?50=) eithrmnoaeonthcphroturh `estkrehs (Vobnh ?). Oceik oaef roteks grkc t`h
seth orh akisesthit wet` o foth t`ot hquoths tk KEQ ??
(Bkwhi ei Os`tki ht on. ?556o).
1.6. ANOAVKI VC ?60 ?20 VK VC ?=8 ?61 HQQHP
Tnhestkahih shfechits ot Anoatki (Gem. ?) whrh gerstfhsarebhf horny nost ahitury (Brkwi ?064), t`h osskaeothf
Tonohknet`ea ora`ohknkmeaon cothreon wos gerst rhakmieshf b
Lhiwkrt`y (?050), seiah w`ea` tech t`h seths ot Anoatki`ovh bhhi oaakrfhf eithriotekion semiegeaoiah gkr t`herora`ohknkmy, strotemrop`y oif ponohkitknkmy.
V`h hxpksurhs rui grkc Neki Tkeit ei t`h skut`whst tk
Anoatki-ki-Qho ei t`h ikrt`host (Gem. ??). V`h ora`ohknkmeagneitwkrl `os bhhi aknnhathf oif hxaovothf grkc o shrehs k
a`oiihns t`ot orh aut t`rkum` t`h Nkifki Anoy oif CeffnTnhestkahih mrovhns kg t`h prh-fevhrseki V`ochs-Chfwoygnuveon systhc. V`h coei a`oiihn kg t`h Anoatki shquhiahwos gkrchrny hxpkshf ei t`h ]hst Anegg, Anoatki-ki-Qho (V
?=6 ?61). @hrh t`h a`oiihn es kvhr 644c wefh oif `os o
coxecuc fhpt` kg ?8c (Brefmnoif ht on. ?500). Ot t`esnkaoteki t`h ikrt`whsthri hfmh kg t`h a`oiihn `os bhhikbshrvhf autteim t`rkum` t`h Nkwhr @knnoif Mrovhns, oif
ets ghot`hr hfmh t`h a`oiihn es kvhrnoei by pkst-fevhrsekimrovhns kg t`h V`ochs-Chfwoy revhr. V`h strotemrop`y kg
t`h coei a`oiihn ot Anoatki es fhsarebhf by ]orrhi (?588(shh Brefmnoif ?556 gkr o gunn nest kg rhghrhiahs).
Ei brehg t`h boson uiets kg t`h a`oiihn orh grhs`wothrshfechits, akcpreseim gnuveotenh mrovhns oif soifs, wet`kaaosekion photy nhishs. V`h pekihhreim ponyiknkmeaon wkrkg Telh oif Mkfwei (?581) nhf tk t`hsh uiets bheimossemihf tk bekzkih @k EE (Vurihr oif Lhrihy ?5=?).Qhfechitknkmeaonny t`h grhs`wothr shrehs es fevefhf eitk t`
Nkwhr oif Xpphr Grhs`wothr Bhfs, bkt` uiets akitoeiAnoatkieoi orthgoats oif t`h nkwhr bhf es porteaunorny rea`
gouion rhcoeis. Ecpkrtoit gouion hnhchits eianufhVrkmkit`hreuc auvehre, Tonohknkxkfki oitequus,
Qthp`oikr`eius hcetkha`us, Qthp`oikr`eius lera`bhrmhi
ses oif Foco foco "anoatkieoio". Kvhrnyeim t`h
Grhs`wothr Bhfs neh t`h Hstuoreih Bhfs. V`hsh akcpresh
nkocs, corns oif anoys wet` nhishs kg s`hnny soif oif
hstuoreih phot. V`h hstuoreih bhfs akitoei nettnh cocconeogouio oif orthgoats orh rorh. Vurihr (Vurihr oif Lhrihy?5=?) pnoahs t`es uiet ei bekzkih @k EEE. Et es os whnn tkhcp`osezh t`ot t`h coei a`oiihn ot Anoatki es t`h kinypnoah w`hrh t`es strotemrop`ea suaahsseki es kbshrvhf.
Vwk akitrknnhf hxaovotekis `ovh bhhi uifhrtolhi ot
Anoatki tk t`h host kg t`h coei Anoatki A`oiihn, t`h gerst Joyweal Qoifs (Kolnhy oif Nholhy ?51=) oif ckrhrhahitny ot t`h Mkng Akursh seth (Qeimhr ht on. ?5=1). V`h
strotemrop`y rhakrfhf ot t`h Mkng Akursh seth (succorezhfei Rkh ?50?) es eithrprhthf os bheim fhpksethf ot t`h hif k
t`h Oimneoi, os t`hrh es hvefhiah kg phremnoaeon p`hikchiooif ei t`h horny port kg t`h hisueim thcphroth hpeskfh.V`h uiets akitoeieim orthgoats orh onn t`kum`t tk prh-foth t`
fhpkseteki kg t`h coei a`oiihn shfechits. V`h net`eaosshcbnomhs grkc Anoatki orh prh-fkceioitny akcpkshf k
gnoleim fhbetomh grkc akrh rhfuateki, gknnkweim o trofeteki(CaIobb ?552) t`ot ruis t`rkum` t`h Bretes` NkwhrTonohknet`ea grkc a.844 Lyr BT tk a.144 Lyr BT (Ecbreh
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 189/342
?=5 CORL B. RKBHRVQ, ANEWH Q. MOCBNH OIF FOWEF R. BREFMNOIF - V@H BREVEQ@ EQNHQ
FesXiaa ei leekchtrhs
n-ve Iucbhreimkga`oiiabosei]2rrhi(?588),' Qhfechits hxpksaf ot mkng ak ur x oif
`knefoy aocp neil a`oiiab v oif ? oifeiakrpkrota ]orrai's a`oiihn en oif prkbobny ve c
. • ]embkrkum` Mrovhn
Hstuoreia Bhfs
Gras`wotar Bafs
Nkwhr @knnoif Mrovhn
@nX e
Anoatki A`oiihn Fhpksets
Gem. ??. Qhateki t`rkum` t`h Anoatki orho, s`kweim t`h vorekus Anoatki A`oiihn kaaurhiahs (ckfegehfgrkc ]orrhi ?588).
an on. ?506). Lhhnhy (?5==) wos obna tk akijkei kvhr24 gnolhs grkc t`h Mkng Akursa Eifustry oif gkuif ush-whortroahs eifeaotevh kg buta`hry oif wkkf wkrleim ki skch kgt`h gnolhs. Rhahitny fkubt `os bhhi aost ki t`h stotus kg t`hAnoatkieoi os o shporoth aunturon trofeteki (Os`tki ht on.
?556b) oif hvefhiah grkc Anoatki ei t`h gkrc kg twkbegoahs grkc ]orrhi's aknnhatekis, cofh ot Neki Tkeit, offsuppkrt tk t`es vehw (CaIobb oif Os`tki ?552). Ikthsgrkc t`h ]orrhi ora`evh onsk chiteki t`rhh begoahs grkct`h "Hnhp`os" oitequus bhf ot ]hst Anegg, ei t`h coei
a`oiihn, t`es bhf es wet`kut fkubt port kg t`h grhs`wothrshrehs grkc t`h a`oiihn. V`us. ont`kum` t`h prhfkceioittha`iequh kg net`ea rhfuateki es akrh boshf, t`hrh es onsk oiuihquevkaon begoah prhshiah ot t`h seth. V`es rhvhnoteki,kaaurreim os et fkhs ot t`h Anoatki typh seth shrekusny aonnseitk fkubt t`h vonefety kg rhtoeieim t`h ioch Anoatkieoi.
V`h shfechits ot Anoatki whrh fhpksethf grkc t`h hif kgt`h Oimneoi eitk t`h gknnkweim eithrmnoaeon (Vobnh ?), t`hhornehsn ora`ohknkmy bheim fothf tk t`h noth Oimneoi. V`hfhpksets orh akrrhnothf wet` Qwoisakcbh ki t`h boses kgcknnusaoi bekstrotemrop`y (A. Vurihr oif Lhrihy ?5=?),t`h coppeim kg nkim fkwi strhoc prkgenh mrofehits bhtwhhi
t`h seths (Brefmnoif ?556) oif ki oceik oaef roteks (Bkwhiht on. ?505).
1.8. @KPIH VC ?=7 =75 QXGGKNL
V`h seth ot @kxih es t`h typh nkaonety kg t`h @kxieoiEithrmnoaeon Qtomh ei Bretoei (Gem. ?). V`h seth es eianufhf`hrh os o ikth bhaoush t`hrh onrhofy hxests o vknuceikusockuit kg nethroturh ki t`h seth (]ychr ?501< ?508 oif
Qeimhr ht on. ?551). V`h ecpkrtoiah kg t`h seth tk t`es pophres twkgknf. Gerstny t`hrh es o mrkweim bkfy kg kpeieki t`otbhnehvhs t`h shfechits ot @kxih tk foth grkc o shporoththcphroth stomh tk Qwoisakcbh oif Bori`oc, boshf kioceik oaef roteks (Bkwhi ht on. ?505< Bkwhi ?55?) oif est`hrhgkrh hquevonhit ei tech tk seths sua` os Nettnh V`urrkal,Mnkbh Tet. V`hrh hxests nettnh hvefhiah het`hr tk suppkrt krakitrofeat t`es vehw. V`h gouios grkc KEQ ?? oif KEQ 5 eithrcs kg toxkikceh akcpkseteki orh vhry secenor< t`hora`ohknkmy gkuif ot @kxih `os bhhi s`kwi ei t`es pophr
tk bh prhvonhit ei t`h Bretes` Esnhs gkr kvhr o quorthr kg ocenneki yhors oif es t`us rhfuifoit os foteim fhveah.Qhakifny rhahit wkrl ki t`h gneitwkrl grkc @em` Nkfmhoif t`h @kxih Xpphr Eifustry (]`eth ?551) `os s`kwit`hc tk `ovh vhry fhgeieth tha`iknkmeaon secenoretehs, butt`ot t`hsh orh t`h rhsunt kg rhfuateki strothmehs rot`hr t`oioiy secenorety ei omh (Gem. ?2). V`h ponyiknkmeaon wkrl ott`h seth (]hst ?587) fhckistrothf o akiteiukus pknnhiprkgenh grkc noth mnoaeon eitk t`h gknnkweim thcphroth stomh.]`hi t`es hvefhiah wos akisefhrhf ei akijuiateki wet` t`hsuppkshf ckfh kg kremei kg t`h @kxih fhpkset - ei o lhttnh`knh nhgt by t`h rhtrhoteim Oimneoi eah s`hht - t`h aosh gkr o
Qtomh ?? foth nkklhf queth strkim, oif wos subshquhitnygurt`hr strhimt`hihf by A. Vurihr's (?5=4) wkrl ki t`hpknnhi grkc Corl's Vhy. @kwhvhr Bkwhi, ormueim eigovkur kg t`h oceik oaef roteks, summhsts t`ot t`h fhprhssekiot @kxih akunf `ovh gkrchf by sknuteki kg t`h uifhrnyeimaonaorhkus stroto (Bkwhi ?55?). Gurt`hr ckrh fhtoenhf wkrles rhquerhf ki t`h sconn coccon osshcbnomhs grkc t`h sethtk rhsknvh t`es fhboth.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 190/342
?04 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. ?2. @kxih eifustry sarophrs (grkc ]ychr ?501). Qaonh ei ac.
1.7. BHHA@HQ TEV, ]HQV QVK] VN =50 =?5 QXGGKNL
V`h seth ot Bhha`hs Tet es nkaothf ?? lc tk t`h skut`whstkg Boc`oc ei whst Quggknl (Gem. ?). V`h hxpksurhs orhei oi knf brealyorf (Trhhah ht on. ?55?) oif orh aurrhitny
bheim rh-eivhstemothf by o cuntefesaepneiory thoc grkc t`h_uothriory Rhshora` Osskaeoteki oif o thoc kgora`ohknkmests grkc Nevhrpkkn Xievhrsety, uifhr t`hferhateki kg Jk`i Mkwnhtt. V`h shfechitory shquhiahakisests kg uiets kg anoy oif senty anoy kvhrnyeim o a`onlyfeoceatki, efhitegehf os t`h Nkwhstkgt Venn. Ei ports kg t`hknf wkrleims o aonaorhkus tugoahkus fhpkset es rhvhonhfkvhrnyeim t`h feoceatki oif bhihot` t`h anoys. V`h tugo
akitoeis o rea` thcphroth cknnusa gouio t`ot eifeaothsgkrcoteki ei spreim ghf pkkns ei o thcphroth gkrhst (Lhrih?5=7, Trhhah ht on. ebef). V`h cknnusa gouio es vhry secenotk t`ot grkc @eta`ei, @hrtgkrfs`erh (Lhrihy ?587), oif
akitoeis sphaehs gkuif kiny ot t`hsh twk seths ei t`h BretesEsnhs, ont`kum` Akiteihiton Hurkphoi akrrhnotevhs orh likwgrkc eithrmnoaeon tugos ei Groiah (Rkusshou ?50=< Rkusshooif Tuessåmur ?554). O cocconeoi gouio `os bhhirhakvhrhf grkc oi krmoiea anoy boif (uiet 1) obkvh t`ha`only feoceatki oif grkc t`h tugoahkus fhpksets (Torgett,ei Trhhah ht on. ?55?). V`h gouio es eifeaotevh kg othcphroth wkkfnoif hiverkichit ei t`h tugo oif t`h nkwhr
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 191/342
?0? CORL B. RKBHRVQ, ANEWH Q. MOCBNH OIF FOWEF R. BREFMNOIF - V@H BREVEQ@ EQNHQ
24
[ e
Noceiothf sent, soif,XLS anoy
Trhfkceioitny mrovhn X V ~ Y ~ ~ Wary s`hnny soif oif sent -_
Boson mrovhn Brhaaeothf a`onl
Gem. ?1. Efhonezhf shateki t`rkum` t`h fhpksets ot Turgnhht (ckfetehf trkc @knnei ?5==).
port kg uiet 1, w`enh t`h upphr port kg uiet 1 eifeaoths oa`oimh tk ckrh kphi mrossnoif akifetekis. V`h cocconeoigouio akcpkseteki es secenor tk t`ot grkc kt`hr "@kxieoi"senks. hsphheonny t`ot grkc ihorby Bori`oc, @kwhvhr, t`hrhorh corlhf fegghrhiahs ei t`h tkkt` ckrp`knkmy kg t`hwothr vknh Orveakno thrrhstres aoiteoio ot t`h twk seths(Q. Torgett. phrs. akcc.), w`ea` mevhi t`h prkxecety kg t`htwk socpnhs tk hoa` kt`hr, orh eithrprhthf os eifeaoteim t`ot
t`h seths orh kg fegghrhit omhs.
V`h orh`ohknkmy ot t`h seth akisests kg begoahs oif gnolhs.V`hsh `ovh ckstny bhhi aknnhathf fureim shateki autteim,bun t`h ?551 oif ?556 shoskis kg hxaovoteki ot t`h seth`ovh onsk prkfuahf cothreon, eianufeim rhgetteim gnolhs oif orhgetthf hif s`kal begoah (Mkwnhtt phrs. akcc.).
1.=. NEVVNH V@XRRKAL, MNKBH TEV V_ 727 =01 HQQHP
V`h seth ot Mnkbh Tet es nkaothf tk t`h ikrt` kg t`h RevhrV`ochs ei t`h thrroah kg t`h Nyia` @enn/Akrbhts VhyGkrcoteki (Gem. ?). V`es thrroah kaaurs bhnkw t`h thrroahakitoeieim t`h Qwoisakcbh eithrmnoaeon shfechits (Gem. 5).
Anoatkieoi nnolhs oif akrhs `ovh bhhi rhakvhrhf grkc t`hmrovhn uifhrnyeim t`h thcphroth brealhort`s, Brefmnoif(?556) ottr ebuths t`hsh twk uiets tk KEQ ?4 oif KEQ 5rhsphatevhny (Brefmnoif oif @orfeim ?551). ]ychr (?508)summases t`ot t`h brealhort`s coy onsk akitoei "ceit"Anoatkieoi gnolhs os whnn. V`h brealhort` es t`kum`t tk bht`h soch uiet os t`ot gkuif ot Nettnh V`urrkal, Mroys(Zhuihr ?585), w`ea` akitoeihf o rea` cocconeoi gouio
but ik orthgoats. @kwhvhr, rhahit rh-eivhstemoteki kg t`esgouio by Q.O. Torgett (phrs. akcc.) `os fhckistrothf t`hprhshiah kg aut corls ki skch kg t`h bkihs. V`hecpkrtoiah kg t`es seth es t`ot et s`kws t`ot t`h Anoatkieoilioppeim trofeteki es ikt rhstreathf tk o seimnh stomh kreithrmnoaeon oif eg, os skch rhshora`hrs bhnehvh (]ychrphrs. akcc.), et hxests os oi shporoth hitety grkc t`hOa`hunhoi, t`hi et bkt` prh- oif pkst-foths et (Brefmnoif
oif @orfeim ?551).
1.0. TXRGNHHV: BNXHNOIFQ, MRHHINOIFQ, HQQK OIF
BKVOIU TEVQ, HQQHP. (GRKC V_ 887-8=4 OIF
=08-=07)V`hsh pets, w`ea` orh aut fkwi tk t`h a`onl, akitoei
Tnhestkahih gnuveon shfechits ossemihf tk t`h Akrbhts VhyGkrcoteki (Brefmnoif ?556), w`ea` orh ei turi kvhrnoei bysnkph fhpksets (Gems ?, 5). Net`ea cothreon fhsarebhf osOa`hunhoi, Anoatkieoi (]ychr ?570< ?508) oif Nhvonnkes(Tonchr ?5=8) `os bhhi rhakvhrhf grkc t`hsh seths. V`hmhihron Turgnhht shquhiah `os Anoatkieoi cothreon ei t`h
boson mrovhn, suaahhfhf by Anoatkieoi oif Oa`hunhoiorthgoats (Gem. ?1) grkc t`h mrovhn obkvh t`h thcphrothshfechits< `em`hr up ei t`es mrovhn uiet o Nhvonnkes gnolhwos rhakvhrhf (Tonchr Cf). Ot Bktoiy Tet t`h boson mrovhnakitoeis `oifoxhs oif coy akrrhnoth wet` t`h mrovhn obkvat`h eithrmnoaeon fhpksets ot Bnuhnoifs oif Mrhhinoifs(Brefmnoif ?556). V`h fhpksets roimh ei omh grkc KEQ ?4gkr t`h boson mrovhn, tk KEQ 0 gkr t`h upphr port kg t`h
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 192/342
?02 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
mrovhn shquhiah oif akigkrc tk Brefmnoif's (?556) ckfhnnkr thrroah gkrcoteki. V`h eithrmnoaeon shfechits orh fothftk KEQ 5. Chiteki cust bh cofh `hrh, `kwhvhr, kg t`h `em`vonuh oceik oaef roteks kbtoeihf ki cknnusas grkc t`hthcphroth shfechits (Cennhr ht on. ?5=5< Bkwhi ht on.
?505). V`hsh roteks summhsthf o foth wet`ei KEQ ?1 but t`esgemurh es `orf tk rhakiaenh wet` t`h net`kstrotemrop`eaon
hvefhiah, os t`h V`ochs wos ikt fevhrthf eitk t`es akurshuiten t`h notthr port kg t`h Oimneoi, w`ea` es akrrhnothf wet`KEQ ?2(Vobnh ?).
6. AkihnusekiV`h hornehst hvefhiah gkr t`h `ucoi kaaupoteki kg Bretoei
kaaurs orkuif `ong o cenneki yhors omk ei oi eithrmnoaeon/thcphroth hpeskfh t`ot ecchfeothny prh-foths t`h OimneoiMnoaeoteki. V`es stomh es os yht uiiochf ei Bretoei.
V`h hornehst kaaupoits kg Bretoei hxpnkethf o wefh roimhkg mhkmrop`ea orhos oif hiverkichits. V`hrh esora`ohknkmeaon hvefhiah gkr `ucoi kaaupoteki kg Bretoeibkt` grkc aknf anecoth fhpksets noef fkwi fureim t`hOimneoi oif grkc shfechits foteim tk t`h hif kg t`hOimneoi. V`us `kceiefs coy `ovh bhhi prhshit ei Bretoeit`rkum`kut t`h furoteki kg t`h mnoaeon. V`es pkeit pkshseithrhsteim quhstekis obkut t`h ofoptobenety kg CeffnhTnhestkahih `kceiefs.
Et es whnn likwi t`ot t`h strotemrop`ea rhakrf gkr t`h Bretes`Esnhs bhtwhhi t`h Oimneoi oif t`h Epswea`eoi `os bhhikvhrsecpnegehf, precoreny by rhnyeim tkk `hoveny kiponyiknkmeaon wkrl. V`hrh es ikw hvefhiah t`ot t`h twkworc phrekfs gknnkweim t`h Oimneoi akitoei secenorvhmhtotekion oif cocconeoi semioturhs. V`es `os nhf tk sethskg fegghrhit omhs bheim hrrkihkusny mrkuphf tkmht`hr. Et `os
bhhi summhsthf rhahitny (Bkwhi ht on. ?505< Bkwhi ?55?)t`ot t`h seth ot @kxih coy bh o w`knh anecoth ayanh ykuimhrt`oi t`ot ot Qwoisakcbh. Eg t`es es t`h aosh t`hi t`h
eithrmnoaeon gknnkweim t`h Oimneoi wenn ihhf tk bh rhioch
Fureim t`h phrekf t`ot akvhrs t`h eieteon kaaupoteki, t`orh bkt` begoah oif gnolh tkke eifustrehs: t`hsh eifustrehsorh ikt cutuonny hxanusevh ei t`h ora`ohknkmeaon rhakrf.V`hrh es ik thcpkron krfhreim bhtwhhi t`hsh eifustrehs.bkt` trofetekis aorry ki t`rkum`kut t`h rhst kg t`h CeffnhTnhestkahih.
V`h sk-aonnhf Anoatkieoi Eifustry aoi bh s`kwi tk prhfoth oif pkst-foth begoah eifustrehs ogthr t`h Oimneoi,t`hrhgkrh t`h akiahpt kg t`h Oa`hunhoi suaahhfeim t`hAnoatkieoi ei Bretoei es gonsh. ]h t`hrhgkrh summhst t`ot teieteon Ceffnh Tnhestkahih kaaupoits kg Bretoei utenezhf bbegoah oif akrh rhfuateki tha`iequhs t`rkum`kut t`es techphrekf. Aurrhit hvefhiah summhsts t`ot t`h fegghrhittha`iequhs aoi bh ihet`hr aunturonny kr thcpkronnyfesteimues`hf. V`us tk akiteiuh tk fhsarebh t`hsh tha`iequei thrcs t`ot ecpny bkt` aunturh oif tech es cesnhofeim ooaakrfeimny, et es summhsthf t`ot t`h thrcs Oa`hunhoi oifAnoatkieoi s`kunf bh oboifkihf gkrt`wet`.
OalikwnhfmhchitsV`h out`krs orh mrothgun tk Qecki Nhwes (Ahitrh gkr
Hiverkichiton A`oimh oif _uothriory Rhshora`,A`hnthi`oc) oif Qecki Torgett (Eistetuth kg Ora`ohknkmyXievhrsety Aknnhmh Nkifki) gkr areteaonny rhvehweim t`escoiusarept. ]h onsk t`oil Jk`i ]ychr, Ieal Os`tki oit`h hfetkrs kg t`h Jkurion kg _uothriory Qaehiah oif t`hTrkahhfeims kg t`h Mhknkmests' Osskaeoteki gkr phrcessektk rhprkfuah prhvekusny pubnes`hf gemurhs.
ikth
? Iotekion mref rhghrhiah akkrfeioths.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 193/342
?01 CORL B. RKBHRVQ, ANEWH Q. MOCBNH OIF FOWEF R. BREFMNOIF - V@H BREVEQ@ EQNHQ
rhghrhiahs
Oifrhws, @.
Oifrhws, T.
Oiki
OpQecki, O.C.,
AQ. Mocbnh,
C.N. Q`oalnhy
Os`tki, I.C.
?514 Ki skch gkssen coccons kg whsthri Quggknl, Vroisoatekis kg t`h Quggknl Ioturonests'
Qkaehty ?, ?58-?55.
?554 Kwns, Aovhs oif Gkssens. Nkifki: Ioturon @estkry Cushuc Tubneaotekis.
?570 @em` Nkfmh Tonohknet`ea eifustry, Ioturh 224, ?478-?477.
?5== Tnhestkahih roeshf bhoa`hs ki Tkrtsfkwi, @ocps`erh, Trkahhfeims kg t`h @ocps`erh Gehnf
Anub oif Ora`ohknkmeaon Qkaehty 11, ?=-12.
?552 V`h @em` Nkfmh Gneit Eifustrehs. Ei: I.C. Os`tki, J. Akkl, Q.M. Nhwes oif J. Rkså (hfs),
nneL Nkfmh: Hxaovotekis by M. fh M. Qehvhleim ?572-70 oif J. Akkl ?500, ?26-?71,
Nkifki: Bretes` Cushuc Trhss.
Os`tki. I.C.,
J. CaIobb
?552 V`h eithrprhtoteki oif akithxt kg t`h @em` Nkfmh eifustrehs. Ei: I.C. Os`tki, J. Akkl,
Q.M. Nhwes oif J. Rkså (hfs), @em` Nkfmh: Hxaovotekis `y M. fh M. Qehvhleim ?572-70
oif J. Akkl ?500, ?76-?70, Nkifki: Bretes` Cushuc Trhss.
Os`tki, I.C.,
T. Fhoi,
J. CaIobb
?55? Gnolhf gnolhs: w`ot, w`hrh, w`hi oif w`y ;, Net`eas ?2, ?-??.
Os`tki, I.C..
J. Akkl,
Q.M. Nhwes,J. Rkså (hfs)
?552 @em` Nkfmh: Hxaovotekis `y M. fh M. Qehvhleim ?572-70 oif J. Akkl ?500. Nkifki:Bretes` Cushuc Trhss.
Os`tki, I.C.,F._. Bkwhi,
J.O. @kncoi.AK. @uit,
B.M. Erveim,
R.O. Lhcp.Q.M. Nhwes,
J. CaIobb,
Q.O. Torgëtt,
C.B. Qhffki
?556o Hxaovoteki ot t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea seth ot Host Gorc Bori`oc, Quggknl: ?505-?552,
Jkurion kg t`h Mhknkmeaon Qkaehty ?8?, 855-748.
Os`tki, I.C..
J. CaIobb,
Q.M. Nhwes,
Q.O. Toenenn
?556b Akithcpkroihe ty kg Anoatkieoi oif Oa`huneoi gneit eifustrehs ot Bori`oc. Quggknl,
Oitequety 70 (274), 808-805.
Bhrmcoi, AO.,C.B. Rkbhrts
Bhrmcoi, AO.,
C.B. Rkbhrts,
Q.I. Aknnautt,
T. Bornkw
?500 V`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea seth ot Bkxmrkvh, ]hst Qusshx, Himnoif, Rhvuh Ora`oåknkmequhfh Teaorfeh ?-2 (iuchrk spåaeon), ?48-??6.
?554 Rhgetteim oif spoteon oionyses kg orthgoats grkc _uorry 2 ot t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih
Oa`huneoi seth kg Bkxmrkvh, ]hst Qusshx, Himnoif. Ei: H. Azehsno, Q. Heal`kgg, I. Orts
oif F. ]eithr (hfs), V`h Bem Tuzznh, 278-202, Bkii: @knks.
Beigkrf, NR. ?505 Fhboteim Ora`ohknkmy. Qoi Fehmk: Oaofhceh Trhss.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 194/342
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 195/342
?08 CORL B. RKBHRVQ. ANEWH Q. MOCBNH OIF FOWEF R. BREFMNOIF - V@H BREVEQ@ EQNHQ
Brkwi, .?. ?064 Ikteah kg o gnuvek-coreih fhpkset akitoeieim cocconeoi-rhcoeis kaaurreim ei t`h pores`
kg Nettnh Anoatki ki t`h Hsshx akost. Comozeih kgIoturon @estkry, Qhrehs 2 6, ?5=-24?.
Aocpbhnn, J.B..A.M. Qocpski
?5=? O ihw oionyses kg Lhit 's Aovhri, Fhvkis`erh, Himnoif, Xievhrsety kg Krhmki Oit`rk-
pknkmeaon Tophrs 1.
Akiwoy, B.].,J. f'O ]oha`thr
?5== Nkwhr V`ochs oif Chfwoy vonnhys - Borigehnf Tet, Qwoisakcbh, Himnoif. Ei:
H.R. Q`hp`orf-V`kri oif J.J. ]ychr (hfs), Qkut` HosE Himnoif oif t`h V`ochs Wonnhy,
10-66, Muefh Bkkl gkr Hxaurseki O8, P Eiquo Akimrhss, Berceim`oc. Mhkobstroats:
Ikrwea`.
('kkl. .?. ?501 Feh Gkrsa`uimsorbhet oi fhr Guifsthnnh ]hstbury-sub-C hifep, Qkchrsht/Himnoif,
Ht`ikmr.-Ora`þkn. Zhetsa`regt 26, 820-81?.
Akkl, J.,
I.C. Os`tki.M.R. Akkph,
A.K. @ect.Q.M. Nhwes,
J. Rkså
?55? @em` Nkfmh, Cenfhi`onn, Quggknl (VN =15=86). Ei: Q.M. Nhwes, A.O. ]`ethcoi oif
F.R. Brefmnoif (hfs), Ahitron Host Oimneo oif t`h Hhi Bosei, Gehnf Muefh, 2?-26,Nkifki: _uothriory Rhshora` Osskaeoteki.
Akxki. E'. ?5=5 Tnhestkahih Hiverkichiton @estkry ei Ahitron Host Oimneo. T`.F. t`hses, Xievhrsety kgAocbrefmh.
('kunski. Q.F. ?554 Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea Eifustrehs kgMrhot Bretoei, Qtufehs ei Ckfhri Ora`ohknkmy, Wkn. 6.Bkii: @knks.
Hvhcfhi, J.G.,
M.@. Aurtes.R. Lestnhr
?58= Tktosseuc ormki foteim kg Tnhestkahih vknaoieas, _uothrioreo 6, ?-8.
Grha`hi, J.,
@.J. Neppknt
Mocbnh, A.Q.
Mebborf, T.N.,
Q.C. Thmnor
?578 Loneuc-Ormki-Fothi zuc Onthr fhs Nooa`hr Wunloiescus, fhr R`heithrrosshi uif feh
Heszhethi, Heszhetonthr uif Mhmhiwort ?7, 8-14.
?507 V`h Tonohknet`ea Qhttnhchit kgHurkph. Aocbre fmh: Aocbrefmh Xievhrsety Trhss.
?505 Tonyiknkmy kg t`h gksseneghrkus fhpksets ot ]et`oc ki t`h @enn, Neiaknis`erh. Ei: F.@. Lhhi
(hf.), V`h Tnhestkahih kg t`h ]hst Cefnoifs, Gehnf Muefh, ?1?-?11, Aocbr efmh: _uothriory Rhshora` Osskaeoteki.
Mrhhinoif Eah-akrh Trkjhat (MRET)
Chcbhrs
?551 Anecoth eistobenety fureim t`h nost eithrmnoaeon phrekf rhakrfhf ei t`h MRET eah akrh,
Ioturh 176, 241-24=.
Enknnei. J.V. ?5== V`ochs eithrmnoaeon seths, Epswea` eoi sho nhvhns oif Oitoratea eah surmhs, Bkrhos 7, 11-82.
@knc, J.,
N. Norsski
E n n es
vknuch
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: Qaoifeioveo.
@ubborf, R.I.N.B. ?502 V`h hiverkichiton hvefhiah grkc Qwoisakcbh oif ets ecpneaotekis gkr Tonohknet`ea
ora`ohknkmy. Ei: T.H. Nhoa` (hf.), Ora`ohknkmy ei Lhit tk OF ?844, Akuiaen gkr Bretes`
Ora`ohknkmy, Rhshora` Rhpkrt 60, 1-=.
nnuit, AK.,J. Rkså
?552 Rhayanhf ponyikckrp`s grkc t`h @em` Nkfmh anoyhy-sents. Ei: I.C. Os`tki, J. Akkl,
Q.M. Nhwes oif J. Rkså (hfs), @em` Nkfmh: Hxaovotekis `y M. fh M. Qehvhleim ?572-70
oifj. Akkl ?500, ?41-?40, Nkifki: Bretes` Cushu Trhss.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 196/342
?07 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Ecbreh, J.,
J.F. @oyhs,
F.M. Corteiski,
O. Coanityrh,
O.A. Ceals,
J.J. Ckrnhy,
I.M. Teseos.
].N. Trhnn,
I.J. Q`oalnhtki
?506 V`h krbeton t`hkry kg Tnhestkahih anecoth: suppkrt grkc o rhveshf a`rkiknkmy kg t`h
coreih K?0 rhakrf. Ei: O. Bhrmhr, J. Ecbreh, J.F. @oyihs, M. Lulno oif B. Qont/.coi (h
Cenoilkveta` oif anecoth Tort ?, 275-147, Fkrfrha`t: Rhefhn.
Jkim, J. fh ?500 Anecotea voreobenety fureim t`h post t`rhh cenneki yhors. os eifeaothf by vhmhtotekion
hvknuteki ei ikrt`whst Hurkph oif wet` hcp`oses ki foto grkc V`h Iht`hrnoifs. T`en
Vrois R Qka Nkif B1?0: 741-7?=.
Lhhnhy, N.@. ?5== Oi hxphrechiton stufy kgcearkwhor troahs ki shnhathf Bretes` Tonohknet`ea ecpnhchits
T`.F. t`hses, Xievhrsety kg Kxgkrf.
Lhiwkrt`y, J.].
Lhrihy, C.T.
?050 Ikth ei Hsshx Ioturonest ?4, 647.
?587 Oi eithrmnoaeon tugo ihor @eta`hi, @hrtgkrfs`erh, Trkahhfeims kg t`h Mhknkmests' Osskaeo
teki =4, 122-11=.
?5=7 Cknnusao grkc oi eithrmnoaeon tugo ei Host Oimneo, wet` t`h fhsarepteki kg Nyrkfesaus
Tensbry (Mostkpkfo: Zkietefoh), Jkurion kg Akia`knkmy 25, 6=-84.
Leim, ].B.R.,
L.T. Kolnhy
?517 V`h Tnhestkahih suaahsseki ei t`h nkwhr port kg t`h V`ochs vonnhy, Trkahhfeims kg t`h
Trh`estkreh Qkaehty ?, 82-=7.
Lkhiemswonf, ]. vki ?5=1 Whroifhruimhi ei fhr Lnheisoumhr gouio vki Cetthnhurkpo zwesa`hi Arkchr uif Hhc
(Tnhestkzoi), Heszhetonthr uif Mhmhiwort 2V9E2O, ?85-?7=.
Lkhiemswonf, ]. vki,V. voi Lkngsa`kthi
ei prhss V`h Ceckcys-Orveakno bkuifory oif t`h hiochn t`ealihss qukteìit (QF_) kg Orveakno strotemrop`ea corlhrs ei t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, Trkahhfeims kg t`h 'Arkchr-Qycpkseii
Ikrwea`, ?554.
Lkngsa`kthi, V. voi ?554 V`h hvknuteki kg t`h coccon gouio ei t`h Iht`hrnoifs oif t`h Ceffnh R`eih orho (]hs
Mhrcoiy) fureim t`h noth Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, Chfhfhneimhi Rejls Mhknkmesa`h Fehist
61(1), ?-75.
Lkngsa`kthi, V. voi,H. Vurihr
ei prhss Horny Ceffnh Tnhestkahih Cocconeoi Gouios grkc Lornea` oif Cehshi`hec ? oif
t`her bekstrotemrop`eaon ecpneaotekis, Trkahhfeims kg t`h 'Arkchr-Qycpkseuc', Ikrwea
?554.
Nhwes, Q.M. ?552 @em` Nkfmh - strotemrop`y oif fhpksetekion hiverkichits . Ei: I.C. Os`tki, J. Akkl,
Q.M. Nhwes oif J. Rkså (hfs), @em` Nkfmh: Hxaovotekis `y M. fh M. Qehvhleim ?572-70
oif J. Akkl ?500, 8?-08, Nkifki: Bretes` Cushuc Trhss.
?551 V`h stotus kg t`h ]knstkieoi mnoaeoteki ei t`h Himnes` Cefnoifs oif Host Oimneo. T`.F.
t`hses, Xievhrsety kg Nkifki.
Nesthr, O.C. ?505 Coccon eoi gouios oif t`h ]knstkieoi fhboth . Ei: F.@. Lhhi (hf.), V`h Tnhestkahih
kg t`h ]hst Cefnoifs, Gehnf Muefh, 8-?2, Aocbre fmh: _uothriory Rhshora`Osskaeoteki.
Coffy, F.,Q.M. Nhwes
?55? V`h Tnhestkahih fhpksets ot Qietthrgehnf, ]orweals`erh, Trkahhfeims kg t`h Mhknkmeaon
Osskaeoteki ?42(6), 205-144.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 197/342
?0= CORL B. RKBHRVQ, ANEWH Q. MOCBNH OIF FOWEF R. BREFMNOIF - V@H BREVEQ@ EQNHQ
Coffy, F.,
M.R. Akkph,
T.N. Mebborf,
A.T. Mrhhi,
Q.M. Nhwes
?556 Rhopproeson kg Ceffnh Tnhestkahih gnuveon fhpkse ts ihor Broifki, ]orweals`erh oif t`her
semiegeaoiah gkr t`h ]knstki mnoaeon shquhiah, Jkurion kg t`h Mhknkmeaon Qkaehty. Nkifki
?8?,22?-211.
CaIob`. J.
CaIo``. J’
I.C. Os`tki
?552 V`h Anoatkieoi: Bretes` Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea tha`iknkmy ei begoah oif iki-begoah osshc
bnomhs. T`.F. t`hses, Xievhrsety kg Nkifki.
?552 V`h Autteim Hfmh, Begoahs ei t`h Anoatkieoi, Net`eas ?1, 6-?4.
Cennhr. M.@.,
J.V. @knnei,J. Oifrhws
?5=5 Oceikstrotemrop`y kg XL Tnhestkahih fhpksets, Ioturh 20?, 815-861.
Ceta`hnn, M.G.,
N.G. Thiiy.G.]. Q`kttki,
R.M. ]hst
?5=1 O akrrhnoteki kg _uothriory fhpksets ei t`h Bretes` /v/av. Nkifki: Mhknkmeaon Qkaehty kg
Nkifki Qphaeon Rhpkrt Iucbhr 6.
Cker, J. Rhef
Kolnay. L.T.,
C. Nholhj
?510 Gkur gneit ecpnhchits Oitequorehs Jkurion ?0, 280-27?.
?51= Rhpkrt ki hxaovotekis ot Joyweal Qoifs, Hsshx (?516), wet` skch kbshrvotekis ki t`h
Anoatkieoi Eifustry, oif ki t`h gouio oif mhknkmeaon semiegeaoiah kg t`h Anoatki a`oiihn,
Trkahhfeims kg t`h Trh`estkreh Qkaehty 1, 2?=-274.
Tonchr, s. ?5=8 O Tonohkne t`ea seth ot Ikrt` Rkof, Turgnhht, Hsshx, Vroisoatekis kg t`h Hsshx Orh`ohkn-
kmeaon Qkaehty =. ?-?1.
Totthrski, V.V.
Thimhnny. ].
?51= Qtufehs ei V`h Tonohknet`ea Quaahsseki ei Himnoif: ik.N, V`h Bori`oc Qhquhiah, Trk-
ahhfeims kg t`h Trh`estkreh Qkaehty 1, 0=-?18.
?0=1o Ieit` rhpkrt kg t`h Akccetthh gkr hxpnkreim Lhit's Aovhri, Fhvkis`erh, Bretes` Ossk
aeoteki gkr t`h Ofvoiahchit kg Qaehiah: Rhpkrt E@=1, ?50-245.
Thrrei, R.C.Q.
J. Rkså,
@. Fovehs
?0=1b V`h Gneit oif A`hrt Ecpnhchits gkuif ei Lhit 's Aovhri, Vkrquoy, Fhvkis`erh. Bretes`
Osskaeoteki gkr t`h Ofvoiahchit kg Qaehiah: Rhpkrt ?0=1. 245-2?6.
?5=5 Net`knkmy kg t`h A`only Bkunfhr Anoy, Ioturh 268, ?4?-?46.
Telh, L..
@. Mkfwei
?581 V`h eithrmnoaeon ot Anoatki-ki-Qho. Hsshx, _uorthrny Jkurion kg t`h Mhknkmeaon Qkaehty
?40, 27?-2=2.
Trhhah, R.A.,
J.F. Qakursh,
Q.F. @kum`tki,L.N. Liufshi,
F.I. Thiihy
?554 V`h Tnhestkahih sho-nhvhn oif ihkthatkiea `estkry kg t`h hosthri Qknhit, skut`hri Himnoif,
T`enkskp`eaon Vroisoatekis kg t`h Rkyon Qkaehty kg Nkifki B120, 628-6==.
Trhhah, R.A.,
Q.M. Nhw es.
J.J. ]ychr,
F.R. Brefmnoif,
Q.O. Tornete
?55? Bhha`hs Tet, ]hst Qtkw, Quggknl. Ei: Q.M. Nhwes, AO . ]`ethcoi oif F.R. Brefmnoif
(hfs), Ahitron Host Oimneo oif t`h Ghi Bosei, Gehnf Muefh, 56-?46, Nkifki: _uothriory
Rhshora` Osskaeoteki.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 198/342
?00 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Royion, J.-T.,Comkmo. N..
Beifki, T.
Rkbhrts. C.B.
Rkbhrts. C.B.,
A.B. Qtreimhr,Q.O. Torgett
Rkh, F.O.
?50?
Rkhbrkhls, ]. ?556
Rkhbrkhls. ]., ?556V. voi Lkngsa`kthi
Rkhbrkhls, ]., t`esV. voi Lkngsa`kthi vknui
Rkhbrkhls, ]., ?552I.J. Akiorf,V. voi Lkngsa`kthi
t`es Vhp`rkgoats oif t`h gerst `ucoi kaaupoteki kg t`h Grhia` Cosseg Ahitron.
vknuch
?507 Hxaovoteki kg o Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea seth ot Ochy's Hort`oc Tet, Bkxmrkvh, ]hst Qusshx
O prhneceiory rhpkrt, Trkahhfeims kg t`h Trh`estkreh Qkaehty 82, 2?8-268.
?554 Ochy' s Hort`oc Tet, Bkxmrkvh. Ei: A. Vurihr (hf.), V`h Arkchr Qycpkseuc, Ikrwea`
?554, Gehnf hxaurseki muefh, 72-7=, Aocbrefmh.
?552 Bkxmrkvh: V`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea seth ei Ochy's Hort`oc Tet (QX 526 408). Ei V`h
Ora`ohknkmy kg A`ea`hsthr oif Festreat (hf Q. ]kkfworf). A`ea`hsthr: A`ea`hsthr FestrAkuiaen. 2?-26.
?556 @kw knf es Bkxmrkvh Coi; Rhpny tk Bkwhi oif Qylhs. Ioturh 1=?: =8?
?556 O `kceief tebeo grkc Ceffeh Tnhestkahih shfechits ot Bkxmrkvh, XL, Ioturh 175, 1??
1?1.
?570 O Mozhthhr kg Bretes` Nkwhr oif Ceffeh Tonohknet`ea Qeths. Akuiaen gkr Bretes` Ora`ohkkmy Rhshora` Rhpkrt Ik. 0.
V`h Nkwhr oif Ceffeh Tonohknet`ea Threkfs ei Bretoei. Nkifki: Rkutnhfmh oif Lhmoi To
Xpfoteim t`h Hornehst Kaaupoteki kg Hurkph. Aurrhit Oit`rkpknkmy 18(1), 14?-148.
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: o s`krt a`rkiknkmy, Oitequety 70, 605-841.
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: O rhopproeson kg orthgoatuon oif a`rkiknkmeaonvknuch hvefhiah.
Fhish gkrhsts, aknf sthpphs, oif t`h Tonohknet`ea shttnhchit kg ikrt`hri Hurkph, Aurrhit
Oit`rkpknkmy 11(8), 88?-807.
Rkså, J. ?50= Qtotus kg t`h ]knstkieoi mnoaeoteki ei t`h Bretes` _uothriory, _uothriory Ihwsnhtthr 81
?-5.
?505 Vroaeim t`h Bomeitki-Nenneimtki Qoifs oif Mrovhns grkc t`h ]hst Cefnoifs tk Host
Oimneo. Ei: F.@. Lhhi(hf.), V`h Tnhestkahih kg t`h ]hst Cefnoifs, Gehnf Muefh, ?1?-?1Aocbrefmh: _uothriory Rhshora` Osskaeoteki, ?42-??4.
?552 @em` Nkfmh-rhmekion akithxt oif mhknkmeaon boalmrkuif. Ei: I.C. Os`tki, J. Akkl,
Q.M. Nhwes oif J. Rkså (hfs). @em` Nkfmh: Hxaovotekis by M. fh M. Qehvhleim ?572-70
oifJ. Akkl ?500, ?1-26, Nkifki: Bretes` Cushuc Trhss.
?556 Cojkr revhr systhcs kg ahitron oif skut`hri Bretoei fureim t`h Horny oif Ceffeh Tnhes
tkahih, Vhrro Ikvo 7, 618-661.
Rkså. J.,
@. Fovehs.Q.M. Nhwes
Rkusshou, F.F.
?552 Ei: I.C. Os`tki. J. Akkl, Q.M. Nhwes oif J. Rkså (hfs). @em` Nkfmh: Hxaovotekis by
M. fh M. Qehvhleim ?572-70 oifJ. Akkl ?500, 56-?42, Nkifki: Bretes` Cushuc Trhss.
?50= Nhs osskaeotekis conoaknkmequh gkrhstehrh fhs tugs '@knstheiehis' fh no Groiah shpthi-trekionh. Xih oppneaoteki fu akiahpt fh bekch. Bunnhtei fh no Ahitrh Mekckrp`knkmequh
12, 5-?0, AIRQ.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 199/342
?05 CORL B. RKBHRVQ. ANEWH Q. MOCBNH OIF FOWEF R. BREFMNOIF - V@H BREVEQ@ EQNHQ
Rkusshou, F.F.,
J.J. Tuesshmur
Qa`conz, R.G.
Q`oalnhtki, I.J.
Q`oalnhtki, I.J.,
I.F. Kpfylh
?554 T`ynkmhiàsh ht bekmåkmrop`eh fh Rhteihnno (Nyrkfesaus) Tensbry (Mostrkpkfo: Zkietefoh),
Mhkbeks 21, 8=-=4.
?574 Gneit oif poteioteki kg gneit orthgoats, Trkahhfeims kg t`h Trh`estkreh Qkaehty 27, 66-65.
?50= Kxymhi esktkphs, eah vknuch oif sho nhvhn, _uothriory Qaehiah Rhvehws 7, ?01-?54.
?5=1 Kxymhi esktkph oif ponohkcomihtea strotemrop`y kg hquotkreon Toaegea akrh W20-210:
Kxymhi esktkph thcphroturhs oif eah vknuchs ki o E4 8 oif o ?47 yhor saonh, _uothriory
Rhshora 1, 15-88.
Q`kttki, G.].
Q`kttki. G.]..
F.@. Lhhi,
M.R. Akkph,
O.T. Aurroit,T.N. Mebborf,
C. Oontk,
Q.C. Thmnor,E N . Rkbeiski
Qebrovo. W.,
F._. Bkwhi.
M.C. Rea`ckif (hfs)
Qeimhr, R..
J.J. ]ychr,
B.M. Mnofghnthr,
R.M. ]kngg
?581 V`h Tnhestkahih fhpksets kg t`h orho bhtwhhi Akvhitry, Rumby oif Nhoceimtki oif t`her
bhoreim upki t`h tkpkmrop`ea fhvhnkpchit kg t`h Cefnoifs, T`enkskp eaon Vroisoatekis kg
t`h Rkyon Qkaehty kgNkifki B21=, 245-274.
?570 V`h Tnhestkahih suaahsseki orkuif Broifki. T`enkskp`eaon Vroisoatekis kg t`h Rkyon
Qkaehty kgNkifki B286, 10=-644.
?551 V`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih fhpksets kg ]ovhrnhy ]kkf Tet, ]orweals`erh, Himnoif, Jkurion
kg _uothriory Qaehiah 0, 251-128.
?507 _uothriory mnoaeotekis ei t`h ikrt`hri `hcesp`hrh, _uothriory Qaehiah Rhvehws 8.
?5=1 Hxaovoteki kg t`h Anoatkieoi Eifustry ot t`h Mkng Akursh, Anoatki-ki-Qho, Hsshx,
Trkahhfeims kg t`h Trh estkreh Qkaehty 15, 7-=6.
Qeimhr, R..B.M. Mnofghnthr.J.J. ]ychr
Qknkcki, J.F.
?551 V`h Nkwhr Tonhknet`ea Qeth ot @k.xih, Himnoif. A`eaomk: V`h Xievhrsety kg A`eaomk Trhss.
?511 V`h ecpnhchiteghrkus mrovhns kg ]orrhi @enn, Jkurion kg t h Oit`rkpknkmeaon Eistetuth 71,
?4?-??4.
Qtreimhr, A.B.
Qtreimhr, A.B,
AQ . Mocbnh
?508 Ceffnh Tnhestkahih `kceief voreobene ty oif t`h kremei kg noth Tnhes tkahih `ucois. Ei:
H. Fhnski (hf.), Oiahstkrs: t`h `orf hvefhiah, 205-258, Ihw Ukrl: Onoi Ness.
?551 Ei shora` kg t`h Ihoifhrt`ons. Nkifk i: V`ochs oif @ufski.
Qtuort , O.J. ?5=6 Tnhestkahih `estkry kg t`h Bretes` vhrthbronh gouio, Beknkmeaon Rhvehw 65, 228-277.
?5=8 V`h vhrthbroth gouio kg t`h typh Arkchreoi, Bkrhos 6, 71-=7.
?50? O akcporeski kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih coccon gouios kg Wkemtsthft (V`ureimeo, Mhrcoi
Fhckaroteh Rhpubnea) oif ]hst Ruitki (Ikrgknl, Himnoif), _uortfrponokitknkmeh 6, ?88-
?71.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 200/342
?54 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Qtuort, O.J.,
R.M. ]hst
?502 Tnhestkahih vhrthbroths ei t`h Bretes` Esnhs. Nkifki oif Ihw Ukrl: Nkimcoi.
?500 Trhmnoaeon Tnhestkahih vhrthbro th gouios kg Host Oimneo. Ei: T.N. Mebborf oif J.O. Zono-
sehweaz (hfs), Tnekahih-Ceffnh Tnhestkahih kg Host Oimneo. Gehnf Muefh, Aocbrefmh:_uothcory Rhshora` Osskaeoteki,
?5=7 Noth Arkchreoi gouio oif gnkro ot Ksthif, Ikrgknl, Mhknkmeaon Comozeih ??1, 675-6=1
Qutaneggh, O.J. ?5=8 O `ozorf ei t`h eithrprhtot eki kg mnoaeon/ eithrmnoaeon shquhiahs, _uothcory Ihwsnhtthr
?-1.
Qutaneggh, O.J.,
L. Lkwonslj
Vurihr, O.
?5=7 Tnhestkahih rkfhits kg t`h Bretes` Esnhs, Bunnhtei kg t`h Bretes` Cushuc (Ioturon @estkry
(Mhknkmy) 2=(2).
?552 Normh aorievkrhs oif hornehst Hurkphoi `kceiefs: a`oimeim fhthrceioits kg rhskurah
ovoenobenety fureim t`h Nkwhr oif Ceffnh Tnhestkahih Jkurion kg@ucoi Hvknuteki 22.
?45-?27.
Vurihr, A.
Vurihr, A.,
C.T. Lhrihy
Wonka`, L.
?5=4
?5=1
?5=8
?5=?
?55?
Ebes
vknuch
V`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih fhpksets ot Corls Vhy, Hsshx, T`enkskp`eaon Vroisoatekis kg t`h
Rkyon Qkaehty B28=, 1=1-664.
@em` Nkfmh, Cenfhi`onn. Ei: J. Rkså oif A. Vurihr (hfs), _uothcory Rhshora` Osskaeo
teki Gehnf Chhteim Muefh, Anoatki, ?4?-?48, Nkifki: Berlbhal Aknnhmh.
V`h akrrhnoteki oif furoteki kg Ceffnh Tnhestkahih eithrmnoaeon phrekfs ei ikrt`whstHurkph. Ei: L.]. Butzhr oif M.N. Esooa (hfs), Ogthr t`h Oustronkpet`eahihs, 285-140, V`@omuh: Ckutki.
V`h omh kg t`h grhs`wothr bhfs kg t`h Anoatki A`oiihn, Jkurion kg t`h Mhknkmeaon Qkaeh
kg Nkifki ?2=, 0=-51.
Nhs prhcehrs phupnhchits `ucoeis hi Ckroveh (Va`åaksnkvoqueh). Ei: H. Bkiegoy oifB. Woifhrchhrsa` (hfs), Nhs Trhcehrs Hurkpåhis, Tores. Hfetekis fu [email protected]..
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: Hosthri, Ahitron oif Qkut`hosthri Hurkph.
Whitres, T.O.
]oha`thr, J. f'O.
]orrhi, Q.@.
?507 V`h Ior Wonnhy. Ei: R.M. ]hst oif AO. ]`ethcoi (hfs), V h Ior Wknnhy oif Ikrt`
Ikrgknl, Gehnf Muefh, =-88, Akvhitry: _uothcory Rhshora` Osskaeoteki.
?5=2 Qwoisakcbh ?5=?, Trkahhfeims kg t`h Rkyon Oit`rkpknkmeaon Eistetuth (nkr ?5=?), =1-=0
?588 V`h Anoatki (Hsshx) a`oiihn fhpksets. _uaerthrny Jkurion kg t`h Mhknkmeaon Qkaehty kg
Nkifki ?88,201-14=.
]hiboi-Qcet`, G.G.
]hst, R.M.
?505 V`h ush kg aoikieaon voreoths nkr fhthrceioteki kg begoah coiugoatureim tha`iknkmy otBkxmrkvh Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea seth oif t`h bh`ovekuron ecpneaotekis kg t`es tha`iknkmy,
Jkurion kg Ora`ohknkmeaon Qaehiah ?7(?), ?=-27.
?587 V`h _uothcory fhpkse ts ot @kxih, Quggknl. T`enkskp eaon Vroisoatekis kg t`h Rkyon
Qkaehty kg Nkifki B215, 278-187.
?58= Eithrmnoaeon fhpksets ot Bkbbets`knh, Epswea`, T`enkskp`eaon Vroisoatekis kg t`h Rkyon
Qkaehty kg Nkifki B26?, ?-1?.
?571 Trkbnhcs kg t`h Bretes` _uothcory, Trkahhfeims kg t`h Mhknkmests' Osskaeoteki =6, ?6
?07.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 201/342
?5? CORL B. RKBHRVQ, ANEWH Q. MOCBNH OIF FOWEF R. BREFMNOIF - V@H BREVEQ@ EQNHQ
?504 V`h prh-mnoaeon Tnhestkahih kg t`h Ikrgknl oif Quggknl akosts. Aocbrefmh: Aocbrefmh
Xievhrsety Trhss.
]`eth. C.J. ?551 Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea Akrh oif Gnolh Vha`iknkmy: O Akcporeski kg @kxih oif @em`
Nkfmh. BO fesshrtoteki. Xievhrsety kg Nkifki.
]`ethcoi, AO.,
J. Rkså
?552 V`ochs revhr shfechits kg t`h Bretes` horny oif Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, _uothcory Qaehiah
Rhvehws ??, 171-1=8.
]esh, T.
]ychr, J.J.
?551 ]ovhrnhy ]kkf Gorc Tet, Aurrhit Ora`ohknkmy ?11, ?2-?6.
?570 Nkwhr TonhkXt`ea ora`ohknkmy ei Bretoei: Os Rhprhshithf by t`h V`ochs Wonnhy. Nkifki:
Jk`i Bolhr.
?5=6 Anoatkieoi oif Oa`huneoi Eifustrehs ei Bretoei - t`her a`rkiknkmy oif semiegeaoiah, Trk
ahhfeims kg t`h Mhknkmests Osskaeoteki 08, 15?-62?.
?501 V`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea seth ot @kxih, Trkahhfeims kg t`h Quggknl Eistetuth kg Ora`ohknkmy
oif @estkry 18, ?75-?05.
?508 Tonohknet`ea Qeths kg Host Oimneo. Ikrwea`: Mhk Bkkls.
?500 Tonohknet`ea ora`ohknkmy oif t`h Bretes` _uothriory shquhiah, _uothcory Qaehiah
Rhvehws =, =5-50.
]ychr, J.J..
Q.M. Nhwes,F.R. Brefmnoif
?55? ]orrhi @XE, Cenfhi`onn, Quggknl (VN =66=61) . Ei: Q.M. Nhwes , AO . ]`ethcoi oif
F.R. Brefmnoif (hfs), Ahitron Host Oimneo oif t`h G hi Bosei, Gehnf Muefh, Nkifki:_uothriory Rhshora` Osskaeoteki.
Zomweji. ].@. ?508 Oi kutneih kg t`h _uothriory Qtrotemrop`y kg t`h Iht`hrnoifs, Mhknkmeh hi Cejibkuw 84,6?-80.
?552 V`h bhmeiieim kg t`h Eah Omh ei Hurkph oif ets cojkr subfevesekis, _uothriory Qaehiah
Rhvehws ??, 801-85?.
Zhuihr, G.G. ?585 V`h Tnhestkahih Threkf. Nkifki: @uta`eiski.
Corl B. Rkbhrts
X.A.N. Eistetuth kg Ora`ohknkmy
1? -16 Mkrfk i Qquo rh
Nkifki ]A ?@KTU
Himnoif
Anevh Q. Mocbnh
Xievhrsety kg Qkut`ocptki
Fhportchit kg Ora`ohknkmy
Qkut`ocptki Q45 8I@
Himnoif
Fovef R. Brefmnoif
Xievhrsety kg Fur`oc
Fhportchit kg Mhkmrop`y
Fur`oc F@? 1NH
Himnoif
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 202/342
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 203/342
jkrmhi @kec ?? V`h hornehstNors Norsski
kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: Qaoifeioveo
V`es pophr h.xoceihs anoecs gkr Ceffnh oif Nkwhr
Tonohknet`ea geifs grkc Qaoifeioveo, wet`ei t`h akithxt kg
t`h mhknkmeaon `estkry kg t`h orho, w`hrh mnoaehrs
rhphothfny ckfegehf Tnhestkahih noifsaophs. V`kum` ik
uiocbemukus precory akithxt troahs kg'prh-@ocburmtoi
kaaupoteki orh likwi yht, o rhvehw kg vorekus nkaoneteas ei
skut`hri Fhicorl s`kws t`ot t`es orho `os o mrhot
pkt h ite on gkr suant geifs, tk `h hxpnkethf ei guturh rhshora`.
?. ( kuf
en ee CEQ gkr `ucoi shttnhchit
O stufy kg t`h p`yseaon akifetekis gkr shttnhchit es
hsshiteon gkr oi uifhrstoifeim kg t`h cemroteki kg `ucois.
KXV likwnhfmh kg t`h Qaoifeioveoi noifsaoph fureim t`h
Tnhestkahih es, `kwhvhr, hxtrhchny gromchitory fuh tk t`h
noae t`ot Qaoifeioveo wos ogghathf by o iucbhr kg mnoaeotekis.
Krmoiea shfechits gkuif eithraonothf ei ckroeihs t`rkum`-
kut t`h w`knh kg Qaoifeioveo `ovh bhhi eithrprhthf os
prh-foteim t`h @knstaeieoi Eithrmnoaeon ei ahrtoei aoshs,
ont`kum` t`her oatuon omh es stenn `em`ny uiahrtoei. Et es ikt
cuen t`h nnknstheieoi Eithrmnoaeon t`ot nkaotekis kg prkgenhs
eivhstemothf by pknnhi oionyshs hx`ebet o suggeaeìit
mhkmrop`eaon festrebuteki t`rkum`kut t`h w`knh kg
Qaoifeioveo tk phrcet o sa`hcotea ecprhsseki kg t`h
haknkmeaon akifetekis. V`h foto orh gor tkk eiakcpnhth,
`kwhvhr, tk phrcet t`h rhnotekis`ep bhtwhhi noif oif sho,
gkr hxocpnh, tk bh hxoceihf wet` o vehw tk efhitegyeim oiy
p`yseaon kbstoanhs tk `ucoi hxpoiseki. Fureim t`h Hhceoi
Eithrmnoaeon, t`h ovoenobnh foto prhshit oi ecomh kg skut`hri-
ckst Qaoifeioveo fevefhf eitk o iucbhr kg queth normh
esnoifs secenor tk t`h prhshit-foy setuoteki ei hosthri
Fhicorl (Qtroif Ththrshi ?508< @kucorl-Iehnshi ?505)
(Gems ? oif 2). Jutnoif coy etshng `ovh bhhi shporothf grkc
t`h Hurkphoi coeinoif by o skuif fureim ahrtoei ports kg
t`h Hhceoi Eithrmnoaeon. V`es wkunf `ovh prhvhithf
cemroteki fureim t`h phol kg t`h eithrmnoaeon, ont`kum``orfny fureim ets horny port, w`hi o akisefhrobnh vknuch kg
wothr wkunf stenn bh tropphf ei t`h eah s`hhts.
Oport grkc t`h ferhat hvefhiah gkr kaaupoteki, geifs kg
vorekus coccon rhcoeis aoi bh ushf ei t`h fesausseki ki
pkssebnh cemroteki rkuths. Kiny o sconn iucbhr kg gkssens
grkc t`h Arkchreoi oif t`h @knstheieoi `ovh bhhi gkuif ei
noaustreih fhpksets ei Fhicorl. V`h knfhst _uothriory
bkih, o pehah kg oitnhr grkc o rhf fhhr (Ahrvus hnop`us)
wos gkuif ei Jutnoif, ei myttjo pkssebny foteim grkc t`h
Arkchreoi Eithrmnoaeon (Oores-Q4rhishi, ?500). Oi ueio kg o
wenf `krsh (Ha/uus ghrus), wos rhakvhrhf grkc grhs`wothr
fhpksets, fothf tk t`h @knstheieoi ki t`h boses kg pknnhi
oionyses. V`es geif wos onsk cofh ei Jutnoif.
Et es ikt uiten t`h Hhceoi Eithrmnoaeon t`ot t`h gkssen
rhakrf bhakchs ckrh obuifoit, wet` bhovhr (Aostkr gebhr),
stroem`t-tuslhf hnhp`oit (Hnhp`os iocofeaus (3 Tonohk-
nkxkfki oitequus)), Chral's r`eikahrks (Feahrkr`eiuslera`bhrmhises), gonnkw fhhr (Foco foco), rhf fhhr
{Ahrvus hnop`us), oif beski (Beski presaus). Qkch kg t`hsh
sphaehs whrh gkuif kiny ei shakifory akithxts ei ckroeih
fhpksets, oif t`her sphaegea rhnoteki tk t`h Hhceoi
Eithrmnoaeon es boshf ki ckrh skut`hri geif akithxts. Onn
t`hsh geifs whrh cofh ei Jutnoif w`ea` summhsts o pkssebnh
cemroteki rkuth tk t`ot port kg skut`hri Qaoifeioveo fureim
ahrtoei ports kg t`h Hhceoi Eithrmnoaeon. Coccon geifs grkc
kt`hr ports kg Qaoifeioveo orh uigkrtuiothny obshit. V`es
aoi bh tolhi os oi eifeaoteki t`ot normhr coccons fef ikt
hxest ei t`es orho. @kwhvhr, seiah t`h likwi nkaotekis kg
cothreon grkc Hhceoi geif spkts, os t`ksh grkc hornehr
eithrmnoaeons, orh vhry ghw ei iucbhr, t`h obshiah kg geifs
es ikt o mkkf ormuchit gkr eighrreim t`ot cemroteki rkuths tk
t`h Qaoifeioveoi phieisuno whrh hiterhny noaleim.
V`h anoec t`ot t`h Hhceoi wothr bosei akvhreim ports kg
t`h prhshit-foy Bontea coy onsk `ovh `of o akiihateki wet`
t`h Oratea Kahoi veo Lorhneo es fesputhf by ihw rhshora`.
@of t`es bhhi t`h aosh, t`hrh wkunf `ovh bhhi o suetobnh
cemroteki rkuth gkr thrrhstreon gouio eianufeim `ucois.
Tknnhi oionyshs grkc ikrt`hri Geinoif eifeaoth fhpksets
fothf tk o phrekf bhgkrh t`h Hhceoi Eithrmnoaeon,
prhsucobny t`h @knstheieoi Eithrmnoaeon, wet` o suaahsseki
kg vhmhtoteki t`ot wos haknkmeaonny hquevonhit tk t`ot kg t`h
aurrhit eithrmnoaeon (Ocbrkseoie ?554). V`es onsk oppnehs tko akisefhrobnh hxthit tk t`h Hhceoi (Rkbhrtski ?55?). Eg o
noif neil `of hxesthf ei prhshit-foy Lorhneo, t`h opprkpreoth
akifetekis wkunf `ovh hxesthf gkr t`h cemroteki kg shvhron
sphaehs kg thrrhstreon coccons ofopthf tk o bkrhon gnkro.
V`h kaaurrhiah oif t`h hxthit kg t`h mnoaeotekis wet`ei
t`h horny ]hea`shneoi kg Qaoifeioveo rhcoeis o a`onnhimeim
orho kg rhshora`. O iucbhr kg porteonny akigneateim
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 204/342
?56 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. ?. Cop kg Qkut`whstQaoifeioveo, s`kweim t`h ckst
ecpkrtoit geif nkaotekis rhthrrhf tk
ei t`h thxt.
?. @knnhrup< 2. Qhhst< 1. Lknfeim
Gjkrf< 6. Whjstrup Qlkv< 8. HjbyLneit< 7. Whjstrup Ofon.
prkpksons gkr gurt`hr wkrl `ovh bhhi subcetthf (Bhrmnuif
oif Nomhrnuif ?50?< Qtroif Ththrshi ?508< @kucorl-
Iehnshi ?505< Gkrsstr÷c oif Hrkihi ?55?< Coimhruf
?55?). Mnoaeotekis kg voryeim hxthit `ovh bhhi fothf tk
kxymhi esktkph stomhs (KEQ) 8f oif 8b, os whnn os tk t`h
troiseteki bhtwhhi KEQ 8 oif 6. V`hsh orh bhnehvhf tk `ovh
AKvhrhf normh ports kg t`h Qaoifeioveoi phieisuno, ont`kum`
t`h twk knfhst t`owhf akcpnhthny fureim eithrjoahit
eithrstofeons. V`h nothr mnoaeoteki, `kwhvhr, es uifhrstkkf tk
`ovh vorehf ei ees hxthit uiten oa`ehveim ets coxecuc
festrebuteki fureim t`h Noth ]hea`shneoi. Kg t`h eithr
stofeons. t`h Br4rup opphors grkc pknnhi oionyshs akifuathf
ei Fhicorl tk `ovh eiaeufhf t`h oggkrhstoteki kg t`h
skut`ac port kg t`h Qhoifeioveoi phieisuno.
Ckroeih fhpksets `ovh yehnfhf o akisefhrobnh iucbhr kg
geifs. akisesteim coeiny kg t`h tusls oif thht` kg t`h wkknny
cocckt` (Cocecetnies precemhieus) ei bkt` skut`hri oifikrt`hri Qaoifeioveo (Bhrmnuif ht on. ?5=7< Oores-Q4rhishi
gt on. ?554< Nhpelsoor ?552). A?6 foteim `os rhvhonhf t`ot o
iucbhr kg geifs mevh eigeieth vonuhs, kr geieth vonuhs ot t`h
roimh necet kg t`h cht`kf, eifeaoteim t`ot t`hy bhnkim tk oi
horny port kg t`h ]hea`shneoi. ]et` t`h hxahpteki kg o
akupnh kg Noth Mnoaeon foths, t`h socpnhs mevh vonuhs kg
bhtwhhi 12 oif 22 Lyr BT. V`es vhry prkbobny akeiaefhs
wet` t`h @himhnk oif Fhihlocp Eithrstofeons, gkr w`ea`
pknnhi oionyshs eifeaoth o sporsh pkpunoteki kg peih oif
bera` oif o prhfkceioiah kg Ayphroahoh oif Mroceihoh.
V`es hiverkichit, akcpotebnh gkr t`h cocckt`, hxesthf o
gor os t`h skut`hri ports kg ikrt`hri Qwhfhi, w`hrh shvhr
wkknny cocckt` geifs `ovh bhhi cofh.
]kknny r`eikahrks (Akhnkfkito oitequetotes), meoit fhhr
(Chmonkahrks memoithus), rheifhhr (Roimeghr toroifus),
sthpph beski (Beski presaus), cusl kx (Kvebks cksa`otus
oif soemo oithnkph (Qoemo totoreao), onsk kaaur fureim t`h
Ceffnh ]hea`shneoi. V`h cocckt` sthpph, wet` ets mkkf
mrozeim gkr bkt` normh oif sconn `hrf oiecons, wos oi
hiverkichit w`ea` akvhrhf akisefhrobnh ports kg Hurkph
fureim t`h mnoaeon phrekfs oif onsk shrvhf os suetobnh
`uiteim mrkuifs gkr `ucois. V`h prhshiah kg oi obuifoit
gouio summhsts t`h hxesthiah kg opprkpreoth cemroteki rkut
gkr `kceiefs grkc bkt` t`h skut`whst oif t`h host.
2. Eifeaotekis kg shttnhchit fureim t`h Nkwhr
oif Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea
O iucbhr kg uiahrtoei Foies` geifs kg o Nkwhr kr
Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea a`oroathr orh hxoceihf bhnkw. ]`ot e
ecchfeothny anhor es t`h goat t`ot onn t`hsh geifs whrh cof
wet`ei t`h orho kiah akvhrhf by t`h ]hea`shneoi eah. V`es
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 205/342
?58 J4RMHI @KNC OIF NORQ NORQQKI - QAOIFEIOWEO
Gem. 2. Cop kg Qkut`whst Qaoifeioveo. V`h `ota`hf orhos eifeaoth
noif fureim t`h Hhceoi Eithrmnoaeon. V`h coxecuc hxthit kg t`h noif
eah fureim t`h ]hea`shneoi - t`h Coei Qtotekiory Neih es eifeaothf.
es t`h orho w`hrh t`h sconn iucbhr kg phkpnh w`k `ovh
akiahrihf t`hcshnvhs wet` t`h prkbnhc nevh, oif et es kiny
ei t`es orho t`ot o shora` gkr horny Tonohknet`ea orthgoats `os
bhhi uifhrtolhi.
2.?. WHEQVRXT QLKW (WHJQVRXT ]KKF)
Ocothur ora`ohknkmests `ovh bhhi aknnhateim rkum` gneit
orthgoats grkc shvhron nkaonetehs anksh tk t`h tkwi kg
A`resteoisghnf ei Qkut`hosthri Jutnoif seiah t`h ?574s.
O ghoturh s`orhf by onn t`hsh geifs es t`ot t`hy fhrevh grkc
t`h bkttkc kg W-s`ophf hrkseki munnhys up tk ?8 c ei
fhpt`, arhothf by t`h chnt wothr grkc t`h ]hea`shneoi eah,
w`ea` akvhrhf t`h orho ki o iucbhr kg kaaosekis. Ei ?5=? o
nhst hxaovoteki on t`h ckst prkceseim kg t`hsh nkaonetehs,
Whjstrup Qlkv, wos aorrehf kut by t`h Eistetuth kg Trh`es
tkreh Ora`ohknkmy kg t`h Xievhrsety kg Oor`us, uifhr t`h
ferhateki kg Q.@. Oifhrshi. V`h noyhr grkc w`ea` t`h geifs
`of bhhi wos`hf kut wos suaahssgunny efhitegehf ki t`es
kaaoseki. V`h noyhr es ikw t`h bhf kg t`h brkkl w`ea`gnkws t`rkum` t`h vonnhy. O sconn iucbhr kg wkrlhf gneits,
secenor nk t`h geifs onrhofy cofh ei shakifory akithxts ot t`h
bkttkc kn' t`h vonnhy, whrh gkuif ei o noyhr kg rust aknkurhf
soif oif mrovhn akvhrhf by obkut 0 c kg ckroeih anoy.
Normhr hxaovoteki gknekwhf ei ?5=2, t`es tech wet` t`h
eivknvhchit kn'quothriory mhknkmests. O iucbhr kg trhia`hs
whrh fum ki t`h whsthri snkph ei krfhr tk hxpkså t`h
precory noyhrs, w`ea` `of bhhi akvhrhf by rhahit noifsneps
prekr tk t`h hxaovoteki. V`h geif bhoreim noyhr wos o
grhs`wothr fhpkset, akisesteim kg normhr stkihs oif akorsh
mrovhn cexhf wet` soif oif kvhrnoef by twk kr t`rha
]hea`shneoi ckroeihs, rhprhshiteim t`h soch iucbhr kg
ofvoiahs by t`h eah, oif uifhrnoef by t`h Qooneoi ckroeih.
V`h mhknkmests whrh obnh tk hstobnes` t`ot t`es wos oi
Hhceoi grhs`wothr fhpkset, ont`kum` et es ecpkrtoit tk pkeit
kut t`ot t`h noyhr onsk akitoeihf coiy gkroceiegaro
a`oroathrestea kg t`h @knstheieoi Eithrmnoaeon. V`es aerauc-
stoiah, akcbeihf wet` t`h goat t`ot o iucbhr kg t`h gneit
orthgoats whrh rknnhf oif t`us s`kwhf semis kg rh-fhpkseteki,
nhf tk t`h ossucpteki t`ot t`h geifs ckst prkbobny fothf
grkc t`h @knstheieoi. Ikt kiny Foies` ora`ohknkmests, but
onsk hxphrts grkc kt`hr akuitrehs frhw porteaunor otthiteki
tk t`h anksh secenorety wet` t`h Anoatkieoi eifustry. V`h
geif cothreon, w`ea` fkhs ikt eianufh oiy `oifoxhs,
akisests prhfkceioitny kg rkum` gnolhs oif akrhs, skch kg
w`ea` coy bh eithrprhthf os a`kpphrs/a`kppeim tkkns,
rhtkua`hf gnolhs, hif oif troisvhrsh sarophrs oif pehahs
wet` ikta`hs oif fhiteaunoths (Gem. 1).
V`h Whjstrup Qlkv hxaovoteki bhaoch oi ora`ohknkmeaon
shisoteki. O fhmrhh kg aonc `os shttnhf ki t`h subjhat seiah
t`hi oif t`h geifs ikw rhahevh kiny brehg chiteki
(Oifhrshi ?50?< Bhalhr ?5==< @knc ?507). Ik saehitegea
prhshitoteki `os oatuonny bhhi cofh tk foth. V`es es
ottrebuthf coeiny tk t`h goat t`ot akisefhrobnh uiahrtoeity
`os oreshi kvhr t`h yhors obkut t`h aeraucstoiahs oif
foteim kg t`h geifs. V`hrh es o thifhiay tk rhmorf t`h geif
bhoreim fhpkset os o Tkstmnoaeon brkkl noyhr t`ot bhaoch
akvhrhf fureim t`h @knkahih by rhwkrlhf ckroeih fhpksets.
V`es vehw, eithr oneo, es bkrih kut by t`h kbshrvoteki t`ot
t`h geif bhoreim noyhr toens kgg ropefny wet`ei t`h whsthrisnkph oif t`ot t`h noyhr snkphs fkwi tkworfs t`h bkttkc kg
t`h vonnhy. Et es feggeaunt tk rhakiaenh t`es vehw wet` t`h
foteim kg t`h noyhr tk t`h @knstheieoi/Hhceoi Eithrmnoaeon.
Gurt`hrckrh, twk akrh socpnhs tolhi ei t`h veaeiety `ovh
rhvhonhf o secenor strotemrop`y - oi Hhceoi noyhr wet`
rhfhpksethf kr cexhf @knstheieoi cothreons.
2.2. LKNFEIM GJKRF
Ot Lknfeim Gjkrf, ei Qkut`host Jutnoif, ocothur
ora`ohknkmests `ovh aknnhathf o ghw t`kusoif gneit gnolhs,
akrhs oif rkum` ecpnhchits kg oi horny Tonohknet`ea
a`oroathr, w`ea` `ovh bhhi fhsarebhf ei o brehg, eithrecorteanh (Qthvi`kvhf ?552). V`h geifs whrh cofh kvhr o
festoiah kg 24-14 c ot t`h gkkt kg oi opprkxecothny 14 c
`em` akoston anegg. Ecchfeothny obkvh t`es orho, o rhahitny
uprkkthf trhh hxpkshf ports kg t`h precory noyhrs. V`hsh
akisest kg o noyhr kg brkwi anoy - ottrebuthf tk t`h
Qooneoi mnoaeoteki ki t`h boses kg prkvesekion mhknkmeaon
oionyshs - vesebnh ot t`h vhry bkttkc, gknekwhf by o
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 206/342
?57 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 1. Gneit orthgoats grkc Whjstrup Qlkv. Froweim: Krno Qvhifshi. Qaonh ei ac.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 207/342
?5= J4RMHI @KNC OIF NORQ NORQQKI - QAOIFEIOWEO
84 ac noyhr kg chnt wothr soif, oif ot t`h tkp shvhron
noyhrs kg mrhy/mrhyes` brkwi anoy akitoeieim oi obuifoiah
kt Qhiki @eit, prhsucobny rhprhshiteim kih kr ckrh
]hea`shneoi ckroeihs, V h chnt wothr soif `os bhhi
mevhi o prkvesekion VN-foth kg ?=4 - 2?4 Lyr BT. Ei t`ksh
pnoahs w`hrh et aoi bh kbshrvhf, t`h gkkt kg t`h anegg
akisests kg o bnoales` brkwi sknef noyhr kg anoy, prkbobny
grkc t`h Qooneoi.Ei speth kg fhthrceihf hggkrts kvhr coiy yhors, et `os stenn
ikt bhhi pkssebnh tk geif oiy orthgoats ei sec ei t`h anegg.
O prkphr axaovoteki es, ei goat, runhf kut by t`h sthhpihss kg
t`h anegg oif t`h grhquhit noifsneps. Qthvi`kvhf boshs `hr
vehw t`ot t`h orthgoats cust kremeioth grkc o tech bhgkrh t`h
ckst rhahit mnoaeoteki ki twk preiaepon ormuchits: ki t`h
kih `oif t`h tha`iknkmeaon ghoturhs oif ki t`h kt`hr `oif
t`h goat t`ot t`h gneit orthgoats fespnoy vorekus gkrcs kg
poteioteki w`ea` `ovh ikt bhhi kbshrvhf ki Foies` Noth
Mnoaeon oif Tkstmnoaeon orthgoats. V`es eianufhs ockimst
kt`hrs petthf hrkseki surgoahs, "kroimh-phhn" (weif
hrkseki), rkuifeim kg hfmhs, fhprhssekis oif rebs (weif
hrkseki) oif o strkim, porteon kr gunn surgoah mnozh-nelh
pknes` (weif hrkseki). Ei offeteki, opprkxecothny 84% kg
t`h cothreon hx`ebets nëkst gessurhs. V`hsh kbshrvotekis
akiaur wet` t`h geifeims kg Futa` oif ikrt`hri Mhrcoi
eivhstemotekis (Qtophrt ?5=7: @ortz ?507).
Bv n'or t`h normhst prkpkrteki kg t`h geif cothreon akisests
kg akrhs oif gnolhs. Qkch sconn akrhs ankshny rhshcbnh
a`kpphrs kr a`kppeim tkkns. O rkum`, Nhvonnkeseoi tha`iequh
es gkuif ei akijuiateki wet` sconnhr akrhs. Os o mhihroS
runh, t`h gnolhs `ovh o normh streleim pnotgkrc, kaaosekionny
goahtthf, oif o normh (bnuit) streleim oimnh. O ghw errhmunor
bnofh-nelh ortegoats orh prhshit tkk. Kiny obkut twhity
tkkns `ovh bhhi gkuif. V`hsh orh substoiteon gnolhs wet`
`em`, sthhp hfmh rhtkua`h, bnofhs wet` rhtkua`eim ki
t`h nkim hfmh, oif gnolhs wet` porteon, sarophr-nelh
rhtkua`eim.
Qthvi`kvhf `hrshng aoutekusny summhsts o foteim kg t`h
orthgoats tk t`h Hhceoi, kr tk kih kg t`h hornehst
]hea`shneoi eithrstofeons.
2.1. HJBU LNEIV (HJBU ANEGG)
Oi ocothur ora`ohknkmest aknnhathf shvhron t`kusoif
akorsh gneit gnolhs oif akrhs grkc t`h bhoa` bhihot` oi
opprkxecothny 24 c `em` akoston anegg ot Hjby, ihor
Eshgjkrfhi, Ikrt` Zhonoif, eianufeim a`kpphr-nelh pehahs(Cofshi ?571< Cofshi ?570o< Cofshi ?570b). Ei `es
kpeieki t`h cothreon s`kws o streleim secenorety wet` t`h
Anoatkieoi eifustry (Gem. 6) (?).
Xigkrtuiothny, onn t`hsh geifs akch grkc rhwkrlhf
fhpksets. Ei t`h ceffnh kg t`h anegg, Cofshi gkuif oi
Hhceoi coreih mrovhn fhpkset, w`ea` shporoths oi upphr
oif o nkwhr ckroeih grkc t`h ]hea`shneoi oif Qooneoi
rhsphatevhny. V`h gneit orthgoats coy `ovh bhhi wos`hf kut
grkc t`h nkwhr ckroeih anoy but t`ot rhcoeis tk bh
fhckistrothf.
2.6. WHJQVRXT OFON (WHJQVRXT REWHR WONNHU)
Ei ?5=0, kih kg t`h out`krs kg t`es orteanh (J.@.) gkuif o
iucbhr kg gneit orthgoats kg o Nkwhr kr Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea
typh ki t`h bkttkc kg t`h Whjstrup Ofon (revhr vonnhy) kiQkut`host Guihi. Qkchw`ot nhss t`oi ?444 gneit ethcs whrh
rhakvhrhf grkc t`h bkttkc kg t`h revhr ei t`h akursh kg
rhphothf vesets tk t`h seth kvhr o iucbhr kg yhors (@knc
?507< @knc ?50=).
V`h vonnhy `os o I]-QH krehitoteki, es opprkxecothny
8 lc nkim, oif rhoa`hs fhpt`s kg ?8-24 c. V`es es oatuonny
o W-s`ophf hrkseki vonnhy, prhsucobny gkrchf by chnt
wothr - oif phr`ops hvhi o froeiomh a`oiihn gkr t`h fhof
eah grkc Ahitron Guihi. V`h revhr gnkws eitk t`h Qtkrhbosnt
stroet nhss t`oi 6 lc grkc t`h seth. V`hrh es ik fkubt t`ot
t`h orho wos akvhrhf by eah ki shvhron kaaosekis fureim
bkt` t`h Qooneoi oif t`h ]hea`shneoi mnoaeotekis. O sconniucbhr kg akrh socpnhs tolhi ei o fegghrhit akiihateki ei
t`h veaeiety kg t`h seth fef ikt rhvhon oiy noyhrs knfhr t`oi
t`h ]hea`shneoi. @kwhvhr, o thst trhia` fum eitk kih snkph
kg t`h vonnhy ei ?50? `os rhvhonhf t`h prhshiah, ot o fhpt`
kg obkut ?4 c, kg oi opprkxecothny kih chtrh t`eal shrehs
kg gnuveotenh soifs, shvhrhny fespnoahf by t`h prhssurh kg t`h
eah, w`ea` shporoth oi upphr oif o nkwhr ckroeih. Et cust
bh ossuchf t`ot t`h orthgoats whrh wos`hf kut grkc fhhp
nyeim noyhrs ei t`h snkphs kg t`h vonnhy, ont`kum` ik
orthgoats akunf bh gkuif ei precory akithxts fureim t`h
ogkrhchitekihf thst hxaovoteki. Oikt`hr pkssebenety es t`ot
t`hy kremeioth grkc t`h nkwhr, mrhy, stkiy ckroeih anoy t`ot
wos ikthf fureim t`h hxpnkrotkry hxaovoteki oif es onsk
hiakuithrhf ferhatny bhnkw t`h revhr bhf.
V`h soch typh kg wkrlhf gneit aoi bh gkuif ei t`h revhr
kvhr o festoiah kg ckrh t`oi ? lc< t`es aeraucstoiah aoi bh
hxpnoeihf by t`h goat t`ot t`h cothreon wos troispkrthf by t`h
kaaosekionny strkimny gnkweim wothr. V`es chois t`ot t`h
pnoah kg kremei kg t`h orthgoats cust bh skum`t ot t`h pkeit ot
w`ea` t`hy gerst kaaurrhf upstrhoc. Orthgoats orh onsk gkuif
ki t`h bhf kg o coi-cofh aoion kg ckrh rhahit foth, w`ea`
akunf eifeaoth t`ot t`h geifs orh ikt rhstreathf tk t`h revhr
akursh but aoi kaaur kvhr t`h hiterh weft` kg t`h vonnhy.
V`h geif cothreon akisests tk o mrhot hxthit - ckrh t`oi
54% - kg rkum`, normh gnolhs, oif o ghw errhmunor bnofhs(Gem. 8). V`h gnolhs `ovh normh streleim pnotgkrcs (strual
wet` o stkih`occhr - `orf phrausseki), brkof oif
kaaosekionny goahtthf pnotgkrcs, oif bnuit streleim oimnhs
(??4-?24´). V`hrh orh onsk obkut 28 akrhs, skch kg w`ea`
orh vhry normh.
V`h iucbhr kg oatuon tkkns es queth sconn, opprkxecothny
24 ei iucbhr, eianufeim 2 ocymfonkef `oifoxhs (kr, ot oiy
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 208/342
E'¼P V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 6. Gneit orthgoats grkc Hjby Lneit. Froweim: Jk`i ]ychr. Qaonh ei ac.
roth, pehahs rhshcbneim `oifoxhs), hif oif sefh sarophrs,
fhiteaunoths, oif kbnkim akrh ecpnhchits kg treoimunor
arkss-shateki (tre`hfron peals). O gromchit kg o pknes`hf
Ihknet`ea gneit oxh wos t`h kiny festeiatny ykuimhr geif.
O rhprhshitotevh shnhateki kg t`h cothreon `os bhhi s`kwi
tk aknnhomuhs grkc kt`hr akuitrehs (2). V`hy whrh
uioieckus ei pkeiteim kut, eifhphifhitny grkc hoa` kt`hr,
t`h horny Ceffna Tonohknet`ea (Oa`hunhoi) a`oroathresteas kg
t`h cothreon oif ets anksh rhshcbnoiah hsphaeonny tk t`h geifsgrkc Corllnhhbhrm, ihor Nhepzem (Boucoii ht on. ?501).
Eifeaotekis kg o prktk-Nhvonnkes tha`iequh whrh gkuif ei t`h
cothreon.
2.8. @KNNHRXT
O whnn-likwi Foies` geif kg oi horny Tonohknet`ea
a`oroathr, akisests kg t`h corrkw spnet gonnkw fhhr bkihs
gkuif ei Hhceoi grhs`wothr fhpksets ot @knnhrup, ki t`h
ikrt`hri sefh kg t`h Mufhio vonnhy tk t`h whst kg t`h tkw
kg Noimo (Ahitron Jutnoif). V`h akcchraeon hxtroateki oi
utenezoteki kg feotkc cuf wos akifuathf `hrh grkc ?058
uiten obkut ?574. V`h mhknkmest oif bktoiest I. @ort/.
hstobnes`hf ei ?057 t`ot t`h noaustreih noyhrs hxthifhf gkr
obkut 284 c, oif whrh uifhrnoef by noyhrs kg soif wet` o
t`ealihss kg ckrh t`oi ?4 c. Obkvh t`es oif ot t`h fhhph
pkeit es o 6 c noyhr kg aonaeuc rea` cuf, oif obkvh t`ot turi es o noyhr kg obkut 8 c kg feotkc cuf, t`h tkp kg
w`ea` `os oi ofcexturh kg anoy oif soif. Obkvh t`h feot
cuf nehs opprkxecothny ?4 c kg strotegehf soif, oif ot t`
vhry tkp o queth t`ei aoppeim kg ckroeih mrovhn. V`h cuf
noyhrs rhprhshit t`h w`knh kg t`h Hhceoi Eithrmnoaeon,
w`hrhos t`h anoy bhoreim cuf oif t`h soif whrh fhpkseth
ot t`h bhmeiieim kg t`h ]hea`shneoi. V`h mnoaehrs kg t`h
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 209/342
?55 J4RMHI @KNC OIF NORQ NORQQKI - QAOIFEIOWEO
notthr mnoaeon phrekf fef ikt nhovh oiy troahs kt`hr t`oi t`h
t`ei noyhr kg ckroeih mrovhn.
V`h rhcoeis kg = gonnkw fhhr slhnhtkis whrh gkuif ei t`h
feotkc cuf ei t`h phrekf bhtwhhi ?05= oif ?528. Ei t`h
?58()s o stufy wos aorrehf kut ki t`h bkias grkc @knnhrup.
eianufeim kih onckst akcpnhth, but `em`ny gromchithf
slhnhtki - geif W grkc ?5?2 (C4`n-@oishi ?588). Ogthr
rhgetteim skch kg t`h bkih gromchits et wos kbvekus t`ot t`h
bkihs ikt kiny `of grhs` groaturhs aoushf by bheim negthf,
bun onsk hx`ebethf coiy knf, precory groaturhs w`ea` `ovh
t`h soch aknkur oif bnoal stoeis kr fhifreths (pnoit nelh
prhaepetoteki kg coimoihsa kxefh) os t`h rhst kg t`h bkih
surgoah (Gem. 7). Ei offeteki, t`h bkihs `of bhhi strual ei
poers ei t`h soch woy - t`h soch potthri ki t`h rem`t oif
nhgt s`kunfhr bnofh oif ki t`h rem`t oif nhgt `uchrus, hta.
V`hrh whrh festeiat streleim orhos wet` s`otthrhf hfmhs,
a`oroathrestea tbr bkihs aut tk rhckvh corrkw oif secenor
tk t`ksh grkc Chsknet`ea seths. Et es t`kum`t prkvkleim t`ot
t`h kiny cojkr necb bkihs t`ot orh cesseim orh t`h twk
ghckro. Et es onsk ikthwkrt`y, `kwhvhr, t`ot proateaonny t`h
hiterh slhnhtki es prhshit. V`hrh es ik semi kg gerh `oveim
bhhi ushf, just os t`h prhshiah kg aut corls akunf ikt bh
fhckistrothf. Kih kg t`h kt`hr slhnhtkis grkc @knnhrup.
Ik. ?, s`kws coiy semis prhvekusny eithrprhthf os rhsunts kg
autteim tk mht ot t`h corrkw.
V`h gonnkw fhhr bkihs whrh gkuif ei t`h fhhphst pore
kg t`h feotkc cuf, w`ea` prhsucobny foths grkc o
akcporotevhny noth port kg t`h Hhceoi, t`h `kcbhoc/spruah
phrekf kr t`h spruah phrekf, e.h. ogthr t`h cexhf kol gkrhst
`of rhoa`hf ets phol.
Gem. 8. Gneit orthgoats grkc Whjstrup Ofon. Froweim: Jkrmhi @knc. Qaonh ei ac.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 210/342
244 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
O ihw oionyses kg t`h bkihs trkc @knnhrup es aonnhf gkr,
wet` o sphaeon hcp`oses ki fesareceioteim bhtwhhi
aorievkrh-eifuahf oif `ucoi brholomh kg t`h bkihs
(Beigkrf ?50?).
2.7. QHHQV
Opprkxecothny ?44 oiecon bkihs oif o ghw gnolhs oif
bnofhs, w`ea` coy foth grkc t`h phrekf prekr tk t`h ckstrhahit mnoaeoteki, `ovh bhhi gkuif seiah ?584 ei o shrehs kg
mrovhn pets ot Qhhst, ki t`h whsthri kutslerts kg Lknfeim,
Qkut`host Jutnoif (]hsthrby ?58=). Oaakrfeim tk t`h
aurrhit vehw `hnf by mhknkmests, t`h Qhhst orho es port kg t`h
Host Jutnoif ykuim ckroeih noifsaoph t`ot wos arhothf
fureim t`h ]hea`shneoi mnoaeoteki. V`hrh es brkof omrhhchit
t`ot t`h orho wos akvhrhf by eah, ot nhost fureim t`h cojkr
ofvoiah likwi os t`h Groilgurt stomh, opprkxecothny
24 Lyr BT w`hi t`h eah rhoa`hf t`h preiaepon Coei
Qtotekiory Neih ?4-?8 lc tk t`h whst kg Qhhst, phr`ops onsk
fureim t`h nothst ykuim Bontea troismrhsseki. Kih prkbnhc,
`kwhvhr, es t`h obshiah kg uiakithsthf troahs kg ckroeih
fhpksets ei t`h upphr port kg t`h shquhiahs.
V`h geifs kg oiecon bkihs oif gneit orthgoats kremeioth
grkc ot nhost = mrovhn pets ei t`h Lknfeim Ofon. V`h shfe-
chits ei t`h mrovhn pets akisest coeiny kg gnuveotenh soif
oif mrovhn fhpksets.
(Jigkrtuiothny, onn t`h rhcoeis kg gouio oif orthgoats whrh
gkuif ei shakifory akithxts, gkr hxocpnh ei t`h cothreon
onrhofy hxaovothf, ot t`h gkkt kg snkphs, oif ei skrthf `hops
Kg stkihs. V`h fhpt` kg t`h mrovhn pets roimhs grkc o akupnh
kg chtrhs fkwi tk os cua` os opprkxecothny 0 c.
Kiny port kg t`h bkih cothreon `os bhhi efhitegehf tk
sphaehs nhvhn (Oores-Q4rhishi ?500): Hnhp`os iocofeaus
(3 Tonohknkxkfki oitequus), Feahrkr`eius lera`bhrmhises, Chmonkahrks memoithus, Foco foco oif Beski presaus.
Ikih kg t`h bkihs s`kws troahs kg `ucoi eivknvhchit
(sua` os autteim tk mht ot t`h corrkw oif/kr corls nhgt by
saropeim/autteim), ont`kum` et mkhs wet`kut soyeim t`ot o
nkaoteki wet` sua` oi obuifoiah kg bkihs es onsk o
nkaoteki kg pkthiteon ora`ohknkmeaon eithrhst. V`h mrovhn
pets `ovh yehnfhf o fkzhi kr sk uicestolobnh gneit
orthgoats, eianufeim kih bnofh obkut 0 ac nkim (Gem. =).
V`h pehah `os o yhnnkw aknkur (ghrrea kxefhs) oif hx`ebets
o snem`t s`hhi ei pnoahs, w`ea` coy bh ottrebuthf tk soif
pknes`eim. V`h bnofh wos gkuif ei o shakifory akithxt,
but ei o shateki kg t`h mrovhn pet grkc w`ea` t`h tkp sken`of bhhi rhckvhf bhgkrh`oif, t`hrhby hxanufeim t`h
pkssebenety kg ets ofcexturh. O gurt`hr akisefhroteki es t`h
toat t`ot soif wos of`hreim gercny tk t`h bnofh, t`ot,
oaakrfeim tk t`h shfechitknkmests, akunf saorahny `ovh
akch grkc t`h upphr noyhrs kg t`h mrovhn pet.
V`h ckst nelhny hxpnoioteki es t`ot t`h geif `horeim
fhpksets whrh fhpksethf by chnt wothr fureim t`h Noth
Gem. 7. Rem`t oif nhgt iuchrus kg gonnkw fhhr grkc @knnhrup - spnet
t`h soch woy tk mht ot t`h corrkw. T`ktkmrop`: Mhhrt Brkvof.
Qaonh ei ac.
]hea`shneoi (mnoaeon kutwos`), ont`kum` t`h pkssebenety
aoiikt bh hxanufhf t`ot t`hsh orh gnuveon fhpksets foteim
grkc t`h Hhceoi oif horny ports kg t`h ]hea`shneoi
mnoaeoteki. V`hrh es o mkkf fhon kg hvefhiah tk summhst t`
t`h Lknfeim vonnhy onrhofy hxesthf ei t`h Hhceoi Eithr-
mnoaeon. V`h aurrhit vehw kg Foies` os whnn os Qwhfes`
mhknkmests es t`ot t`h nost Eah Omh fef ikt rhonny prkfuah
t`h prhvekusny ossuchf veknhit troisgkrcoteki ki t`h
noifsaoph. Et es pkssebnh, t`hrhgkrh, t`ot t`h Qhhst geifs cu
bh hxpnoeihf ei rhnoteki tk t`h hxesthiah kg Lknfeim Ofon
(Lknfeim revhr vonnhy) ot o cua` hornehr stomh t`oi prhveku
ossuchf.
2.=. EQKNOVHF GEIFQ< ORVHGOAVQ RHQHCBNEIM @OIF
OPHQ
Chiteki cust onsk bh cofh kg o akupnh kg Foies` geif
w`ea` bhor o streleim ckrp`knkmeaon oif tha`iknkmeaon
rhshcbnoiah tk Oa`hunhoi `oifoxhs (Bhalhr ?5=?). Kih
t`hsh es chitekihf ki o iucbhr kg kaaosekis ei t`h
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 211/342
24? J4RMHI @KNC OIF NORQ NORQQKI - QAOIFEIOWEO
pubnes`hf nethroturh oif `os bhhi hifkrshf os o mhiueih
`oifoxh by nhofeim hxphrts grkc kt`hr akuitrehs. @kwhvhr,
t`h corchr ei w`ea` et wos kbtoeihf oif ets prkvhioiah
pksh akisefhrobnh prkbnhcs. V`h orthgoat es soef tk `ovh
bhhi gkuif ot Wennhstrup, ei t`h ikrt` kg Jutnoif, onthr w`ea`
et posshf eitk t`h `oifs kg o whont`y aknnhatkr. V`es ocothur
ora`ohknkmest pura`oshf ora`ohknkmeaon sphaechis grkc oi
ora`oaknkmeaon fhonhr, w`k bkum`t sphaechis ei Groiah.V`es `os mevhi resh tk sk coiy cesmeveims surrkuifeim t`h
prkvhioiah kg t`h orthgoat, t`ot et s`kunf ikw fhgeiethny bh
fesrhmorfhf. V`h kt`hr orthgoat, w`ea` `os onsk rhahevhf t`h
hifkrshchit kg gkrhemi hxphrts, wos gkuif ki t`h bhoa` ot
Gehi÷, oi esnoif setuothf ei t`h Nennhbohnt Qtroet bhtwhhi
Guihi oif Jutnoif. Et akunf hquonny bh o Chsknet`ea gneit
akrh oxh kr o Ihknet`ea orthgoat. V`h prkbnhc goaeim us
- ot nhost ei Qkut` Qaoifeioveo - es t`h feggeaunty, eg ikt
ecpkssebenety, kg festeimues`eim bhtwhhi mhiueih `oifoxhs
oif Noth Ihknet`ea bnoils nkr fommhrs, sphor`hofs oif akri
sealnhs. V`es fhboth `os akiteiuhf ei Fhicorl gkr coiy
yhors oif aoiikt, ei onn goerihss, bh soef tk bh coleim oiy
prkmrhss (Mnkb ?5=2).
O gromchithf oif `hoveny rknnhf orthgoat wet` oi onthrhf
surgoah, rhshcbneim o `oifoxh, wos gkuif ot Lorslkv Lneit,
o akoston anegg ki Noimhnoif, oi esnoif skut` kg Guihi<
fhtoens whrh pubnes`hf by o Mhrcoi ora`ohknkmest oif o
Foies` mhknkmest (Mrkth oif Coomoorf Jolkbshi ?502). V`h
ecprhsseki wet` w`ea` kih es nhgt ogthr rhofeim t`h orteanh
es t`ot t`h orthgoat wos gkuif ei setu ei o ckroeih noyhr,
`oveim bhhi fhpksethf fureim t`h ckst rhahit - Ukuim
Bontea - troismrhsseki. V`es es ikt akrrhat, `kwhvhr. Et wos
gkuif ei shakifory akithxt ki t`h bhoa` bhnkw t`h anegg
(ag. H. Coomoorf Jolkbshi, phrskion akccuieaoteki).
1. V`h knfhst uiakithstobnh troahs kg `ucoi
kaaupoteki
V`h rhcoeis kg w`ot es mhihronny oaahpthf os t`h hornehst
shttnhchit bhnkim tk t`h @ocburmeoi Aunturh. V`h knfhst
seths whrh eivhstemothf os noth os ?50?-06 ot Jhns, ei
skut`hri Jutnoif (@knc oif Rehal ?552). Gurt`hr shttnhchit
rhcoeis `ovh bhhi akigerchf ei ckrh rhahit yhors ki
skut`hri Jutnoif (@knc ?551), oif ei hosthri Fhicorl
(Woim Ththrshi oif Jk`oishi ?551). Kih seth ei
skut`hrickst Qwhfhi yehnfhf orthgoats w`ea` s`orh ahrtoei
ghoturhs wet` t`h hornehst geifs ei Fhicorl (Norsski ?556).
Rofekaorbki foteim kg rheifhhr bkih osskaeothf wet`rhcoeis grkc t`h @ocburmeoi Aunturh `ovh prkfuahf o
foth kg ?2,824¿?54 BT (OOR-547) (@knc ?551). V`h
Brkcch Aunturh grkc t`h Onnhr4f Eithrstofeon hijkys o
rot`hr ckrh wefhsprhof festrebuteki ei t`h Qaoifeioveoi
phieisuno. Et es ikt uiten t`h horny port kg t`h Trhbkrhon t`ot
shttnhchits sprhof ropefny os gor ikrt` os ikrt`hrickst
Ikrwoy.
Gem. =. Gneit bnofh grkc Qhhst. Froweim: Hrel ]hsthrby. Qaonh ei ac.
6. Fesausseki
Ont`kum` o fhtoenhf likwnhfmh kg Tonohknet`ea
shttnhchits ei Qkut` Qaoifeioveo fureim t`h phrekf ?6 844 -
?4 444 BT `os mrofuonny bhhi buent up, t`h stufy kg t`h
Nkwhr, Ceffnh oif ckst kg t`h Xpphr Tonohknet`ea es stenn
ot o akitrkvhrseon oif pekihhreim stomh. V`hrh es ik noal kg
geifs ei Fhicorl w`ea` pkeit tk o gosaeioteim tha`ieaon oif
ckrp`knkmeaon secenorety wet` Nkwhr oif Ceffnh Tonohk
net`ea typhs kg ecpnhchits ei kt`hr akuitrehs. @kwhvhr,
seiah ckst kg t`hsh whrh gkuif ei shakifory nkaotekis,
fhtoa`hf grkc t`her kremeion mhknkmeaon akithxts, t`hy orh
fhbotobnh. Ki t`h boses kg oi osshsschit kg anecotea oifioturon akifetekis, t`hrh es ikt`eim t`ot wkunf `ovh
prhvhithf `ucois grkc neveim ei Qkut` Qaoifeioveo, ot nhost
fureim eithrmnoaeon phrekfs oif eithrstofeons nkim bhgkrh t`h
nost mnoaeoteki (Oifhrshi ?5=5< Oores-Q4rhishi ?500). Ei
krfhr tk fhvhnkp oi efho kg w`hi t`h gerst phkpnh coy `ovh
orrevhf `hrh, et es kbvekus tk tolh os o storteim pkeit t`h
knfhst geifs ei t`h ihem`bkureim akuitrehs tk t`h skut`. Eg
wh nkkl ot Mhrcoiy oif Himnoif, gkr hxocpnh, et es anhor
t`ot t`hsh seths bhnkim tk t`h hornehst ei Hurkph (Rkhbrkhls
ht on. ?552).
]`ot rhoskis orh t`hrh t`ot aoi hxpnoei w`y wh orh
nommeim sk gor bh`eif kur aknnhomuhs ei akuitrehs tk t`hskut` kg Fhicorl; V`h ckst phssecestea hxpnoioteki wkunf
bh t`ot wh orh shora`eim gkr p`oitkcs, oif t`ot, ei speth kg
govkurobnh anecotea oif ioturon akifetekis, t`hrh wos queth
secpny ik shttnhchit sk gor ikrt` fureim t`h Nkwhr oif
Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea. @kwhvhr, wh orh ckrh eianeihf tk pkeit
tk kt`hr rhoskis. Gerst oif gkrhckst, t`hrh es ik rhshora`
trofeteki ei t`es orho, w`ea` wenn kiny bh hstobnes`hf kiah
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 212/342
242 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
wh `ovh toimebnh, rhneobnh geifs tk wkrl wet`. ]h onsk noal
t`h hxphrtesh w`ea` aoi kiny bh oa`ehvhf t`rkum` foeny
akitoat wet` oif gerst`oif stufy kg orthgoat cothreon foteim
grkc t`hsh phrekfs.
V`es es o veaekus aeranh w`ea` es cofh hvhi ckrh feggeaunt
by t`h goat t`ot, gkr coiy yhors, t`h cojkrety kg Qaoi-
feioveoi ora`ohknkmests `ovh rhgushf hvhi tk fesauss t`h
pkssebenety kg sua` oi horny shttnhchit ei Qaoifeioveo. Kit`h w`knh, t`es tkpea `os bhhi tolhi up kiny by uibeoshf
oif eitrhpef ocothur ora`ohknkmests, w`k fk ikt `ovh o
aorhhr tk wkrry obkut, ont`kum` t`hy orh likwi tk opprkoa`
t`her wkrl ei o skchw`ot uiareteaon oif kvhrhit`useostea
corchr ki kaaosekis. Et es ihvhrt`hnhss typeaon t`ot t`h Noth
Tonohknet`ea geifs oif t`h ckrh kr nhss uiahrtoei geifs kg oi
Nkwhr kr Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea a`oroathr kg w`ea` wh orh
onsk oworh `ovh bhhi fesakvhrhf by ocothur ora`ohknkmests
ei t`h cojkrety kg aoshs.
V`h fhghotest ottetufh tk t`h prkbnhc ockimst prkghs
sekion Qaoifeioveoi ora`ohknkmests es ikt hiterhny wet`kut
justegeaot eki, `kwhvhr. Et es `kwhvhr ihahssory tk hcp`osesh
t`ot, oport grkc ets cormeion, ikrt`hri nkaoteki, Qaoifeioveo
wos rhphothfny akvhrhf wet` eahaops kvhr t`h nkim phrekf
wet` w`ea` wh orh akiahrihf `hrh. V`es `ocphrs t`h
fesakvhry kg geifs foteim grkc t`h Nkwhr oif Ceffnh
Tonohknet`ea, w`ea` ei ckst aoshs coy bh hxphathf tk bh ei
shakifory akithxt oif fhhpny burehf. By onn oaakuits t`h
Qooneoi eahaops akvhrhf t`h w`knh kg Qaoifeioveo w`ea`
rhfuahs t`h a`oiahs kg fesakvhreim Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea
geifs, gkr hxocpnh grkc t`h @knstheieoi Eithrmnoaeon.
A`oiahs kg fesakvhreim geifs grkc t`h Hhceoi Eithrmnoaeon
oif nothr phrekfs orh bhtthr, `kwhvhr. V`hrh es o festeiat
pkssebenety kg sua` geifs bheim cofh ei t`h noifsaoph
arhothf by t`h Qooneoi eah ei Qkut`whst Jutnoif, os t`es orho
wos ikt arksshf by t`h eah fureim t`h ]hea`shneoi
mnoaeoteki. Ei kt`hr wkrfs, t`hrh s`kunf bh hxahnnhit a`oiahs
kg fesakvhreim ora`ohknkmeaon cothreon `hrh mkeim boal ot
nhost ?14,44 yhors.
V`hrh orh mrkuifs gkr kptecesc ei t`h goat t`ot tktonny
rhneobnh geifs `ovh bhhi cofh ei ikrt`whst Mhrcoiy, ei oi
efhiteaon noifsaoph (t`h Ontckroihre), gkr eistoiah ot
Qa`onl`knz, w`hrh gneit gnolhs whrh gkuif ei o phot fhpkset
w`ea` akunf bh fothf tk t`h Br4rup Eithrstofeon (Oriknf
?5=0< @ortz ?507). Oif o goerny normh iucbhr kg `hoveny
ckfegehf gneit orthgoats, eianufeim o `oif oxh kg
akiveiaeimny Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea a`oroathr, wos gkuif kit`h surgoah kg o `enn ihor Frhnsfkrg ei t`h @usuc orho
(Lrhes Ikrfgrehsnoif), queth anksh tk t`h Mhrcoi-Foies`
bkrfhr (@ortz ?507).
V`h vehw kg t`h out`krs es t`ot t`h `ypkt`hses, w`ea`
coeitoeis t`ot onn Nkwhr oif Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea geif
kaaurrhiahs ei Qaoifeioveo cust bh rhmorfhf os `oveim
bhhi kbnethrothf by subshquhit eah troismrhssekis oif
hrkseki, es tkk phssecestea oif ei goat rhprhshits t`h norma
kbstoanh tk o brholt`rkum` ei t`es orho kg rhshora`. Kihakunf stoth, wet` hquon justegeaoteki, t`ot t`h vhry soch
mnoaeon oif hrksekion prkahsshs t`ot orh aopobnh kg fhstrky
orh hquonny aopobnh kg prkthateim kr, ei govkurobnh
aeraucstoiahs, kg breimeim kremeionny fhhpny burehf geifs
t`h surgoah. V`es es suppkrthf by hxocpnhs grkc kt`hr
akuitrehs: @em` Nkfmh ei Himnoif (Os`tki ht on. ?55?)
oif geifs grkc vorekus mrovhn-pets ei t`h Iht`hrnoifs
(Qtophrt ?50?). Ei offeteki, Horny Tonohknet`ea cothreon ei
ikrt`hri ports kg Qaoifeioveo coy `ovh survevhf ei rkal
gessurhs oif aovhs, os whrh t`h opprkxecothny 244,444 yh
knf geifs grkc t`h Tkitihwyff aovh ei Ikrt` ]onhs,
akvhrhf by eah ki shvhron kaaosekis (Mrhhi ?506).
Eg kih whrh tk otthcpt o rkum` succory kg t`h Foies`
geifs rhghrrhf tk obkvh, et es anhor t`ot ikih kg t`hsh es
suggeaehitny rhneobnh tk survevh o t`krkum` skurah-areteaon
hvonuoteki. Hvhi eg fhhpny burehf, t`hrh orh strkim
eifeaotekis t`ot t`h geifs whrh ikt ei precory akithxt. Ki
eithrhsteim akisefhroteki es t`ot Qaoifeioveoi ora`ohknkme
`ovh ofkpthf o fescessevh kr hxtrhchny fkubtgun ottetufh
ottoa`eim o mrhot omh tk t`h geifs, w`hrhos ora`ohknkmests
grkc kt`hr ports kg Hurkph wet` akisefhrobnh hxphrtesh ei
Tonohknet`ea geifs oif t`h aeraucstoiahs ei w`ea` geifs or
cofh fk ikt fespnoy t`h soch ihmotevh ottetufh. Ont`kum`
t`hy coy ikt bh hiterhny goceneor wet` t`h cothreon auntur
grkc Qkut` Qaoifeioveo, t`h goat s`kunf ikt bh kvhrnkklh
t`ot t`hy `ovh eitecoth likwnhfmh kg t`h prkbnhcs
osskaeothf wet` t`h geifs. Ora`ohknkmests ei kt`hr ports kg
Hurkph orh onsk goahf wet` t`h a`onnhimh kg festeimues`eim
bhtwhhi Ihknet`ea oif Tonohknet`ea orthgoats aknnhathf os
surgoah geifs.
ikths
? Jk`i ]ychr tkkl port ei t`h eivhstemotekis oif akisefhrs t`hcothreon tk pksshss Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea a`oroathresteas.
2 V`h cothreon wos hxoceihf by Onoei Vuggrhou, w`k vesethf t`nkaonety ei ?50?. Mhr`orf Bkseisle oif Joi Cea`on Burfulehweaz
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 213/342
241 J4RMHI @KNC OIF NORQ NORQQKI - QAOIFEIOWEO
rhghrhiahs
Oores-Qkrhishi, L.
Wores Qkehishi. L..
L. Qtroif Ththrshi,@. Voubhr
?500 Foicorls gkr`estkreslh fyrhvhrfhi. Gro Estef ten Weleimhtef. Lkbhi`ovi.
?554 Foies` Geifs kg Cocckt` {Coccut`us precemhieus (Bnuiehiboa`)). Qtrotemrop`eaon
pkseteki, foteim oif hvefhiah kg Noth Tnhestkahih hiverkichit. Foicorls MhknkmeslhXifhrs4mhnsh, Qhreh B: ?6. Lkbhi`ovi.
Ocbrkseoie, M.L. ?554 Tnhestkahih strotemrop`y ei Ahitron oif Ikrt`hri Qwhfhi - o rheivhstemoteki kg skch
anosseaon seths, Xievhrsety kg Qtkal`knc, Fhportchit kg _uothriory Rhshora` Rhpkrt ?7.
Oifhrshi, Q.@.
Oifhrshi, Q.V.
?50? Qthionfhrhi E. Jahmhrsthionfhrhi. Qhsocs Foicorls`estkreh. Lkbhi`ovi.
?5=5 Estefhr km chnnhcestefhr. Ei: O. Ikrrhvoim oif V.J. Chyhr (hfs.), Foicorls ionur, Beif ?,
?55-284, Noifslobhrihs kpstohi, Lkbhi`ovi.
Oriknf, W.
Os`tki, I’
O. Rkbhrts,
.?. ('kkl
?5=0 Ihuh Guifh ous fhr Qtheizhet Fet`corsa`his, Fet`corsa`hi I.G. 1/6.
?55? @em` Nkfmh. Nkifki: Bretes` Cushuc.
Boucoii, ]..
F. Coieo,
W. Vkhpghr.
N. Hesscoii
?501 Feh ponoknen`esa`hi Ihuguifh vki Corllnhhbhrm `he Nhepzem. Bhrnei: WHB.
Bhalhr, A.J. ?5=? Estefscoifhis rhfslobhr, Qlonl ?5=?:6, 1-=.
?5== Kc estefs-jo<mhrih km fhrhs rhfslobhr. Ei: J. Brkifsthf, Fh ahnfsth refhr. Tknetelhis
Foicorls`estkreh, Hgthrslregt, 82?-828.
Bhrmnuif, B’Q. @oloisski,
H. Nomhrnuif
?5=7 Rofekaorbki-fothf cocckt` (Coccut`us precemhieus Bnuchiboa`) geifs ei Qkut`Qwhfhi, Bkrhos 8, ?==-?5?.
Bhrmnuif. B.H.,
H. Nomhrnuif
?50? Hhceoi oif ]hea`shn eoi strotemrop`y ei Qkut` Qwhfhi, Bkrhos ?4, 121-172.
Beigkrf. N.
Gkrsstr÷c, N.,
C. Hrkihi
?50? Bkihs. Oiaehit chi oif ckfhc cyt`s. Ihw Ukrl: Oaofhceh Trhss.
?55S Ihw Eigkrcoteki ki t`h Hhceoi oif Horny ]hea`shneoi ei Geinoif. Ei: B.M. Oifhrshi oif
N.-L. L÷iemsski (hfs.), Noth _uothriory Qtrotemrop`y ei t`h Ikrfea Akuitrehs ?84,444-
?8,444 B.T.Qtreoh 16, 1?-1=.
Mnkb. E'.W.
Mrhhi. @.Q. (hf.)
?5=2 Gornem gneit, Qlonl
?5=2:?, ?0-24.
?506 Tkitihwyff Aovh, o Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea `kceief seth ei ]onhs: V`h gerst rhpkrt. Aorfegg:
Iotekion Cushuc kg ]onhs.
Mrkth. L..
H.C. Joakbshi
?502 Fhr Goustlhen vkc Lorslkv-Lnegg oug Noimhnoif (Foihcorl) , Ora`oknkmesa`hs Lkrrhspki-
fhizbnott ?2, 20?-208.
@ort/ . Q. ?507 Toneeknetesa`h Guifh ous fhc Ontckroihimhbeht Ikrfgrehsnoifs, Kggo, ?48-?6=.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 214/342
V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Cknc. .?. ?507 V`h _uothriory oif t`h Horny/Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea kg Fhicorl. Ei: O. Vuggrhou oif Q. Qkc
(hfs.), A`rkikstrotemrop`eh hn goaehs aunturhns fu Tonåknet`equh eighrehur ht ckyhi fois
e'Hurkph fu Ikrf-Kuhst, Quppnåchit ou Bunnhtei fh ?'Osskaeoteki Groiaoesh pkur Gåtu
fu _uothrioerh 27, =8-04.
?50= Trecetev gneit e Whjstrup Ofon - fh gkrsth gyibkhr;, Orbkmgkr Qvhifbkrm km Kchmis
Cushuc, 0-?7.
?551 Qhttnhchits kg t`h @ocburmeoi oif Ghfhrchsshr Aunturhs ot Qnktshim, Qkut` Jutnoif, Jkurion kg Foies` Ora`ohknkmy ?4 (?55?), =-?5.
@knc, J’ ?552
G. Rehal
@kucorl-Iehnshi, C. ?50"
Norsski, N. ?556
Nhpel&oor, J. ?552
Cofshi, H. ?571
nstefsjwmhrh vhf Jhnss4hrih. @ocburmlunturhi e Foicorl, Qlregthr gro cushucsrofht gk
Qkifhrjynnoifs oct 8. @ofhrsnhv.
Foicorl e estefhi - hi thmihshreh. Worv ?505:2.
V`h Hornehst Qhttnhchit ei Qkut`hri Qwhfhi. Noth Tonohknet`ea Qhttnhchit Rhcoeis ot
Geijosj÷i, ei t`h Ikrt` kg Qaoieo, Aurrhit Qwhfes` Ora`ohknkmy 2, ?85-?==.
Rhcorls ki t`h ]hea`shneoi chmogouio (Coccut`us, Akhnkfkito oif Beski) kg t`h
"eitromnoaeon" orho orkuif t`h Bontea, Oiiuon Zkknkmeao Ghiieae 20, 225-264.
Trecetev gneitluntur vhf Eshgjkrf, Oorb4mhr gkr ikrfesl Knflyifem`hf km @estkreh, =5-51
?570o Hi orlohknkmesl-mhknkmesl uifhrs4mhnsh og lneithi vhf Hjby Brk, Eshgjkrf, Chffhnhnshr g
Foisl Mhknkmesl Gkrhieim ?0:?, 11-67.
Coimhruf, J.
?570b Xi seth foikes o senhx prå`estkrequhs precetegs. Rhvuh Oit`rkpknkmequh, ?6-22.
?55? V`h Nost Eah Omh ei Qaoifeioveo. Ei: B.M. Oifhrshi oif N.-L. L÷iemsski (hfs. ). Noth
_uothriory Qtrotemrop`y ei t`h Ikrfea Akuitrehs ?84,444-?8,444 B.T., Qtreoh 16, ?8-25
Ck`n-@oishi, X. ?588 G4rsth selrh spkr og chiihslhr gro eithrmnoaeontef e Foicorl. Corvsponthfh likmnhr gro
feotkcåjkrfhi vhf @knnhrup, Oorb4mhr gkr ikrfesl Knflyifem`hf km @estkreh ?586, ?4?
?27.
Rkbhrtsski, O.-C. ?55? V`h Bekstro temrop`y kg t`h Noth Tnhestkahih ei Qwhfhi ?84,444-?8,444 B.T. - o Qurvhy
Ei: B.M. Oifhrshi oif N.-L. L÷iemsski (hfs.). Noth _uothriory Qtrotemrop`y ei t`h
Ikrfea Akuitrehs ?84,444-?8,444 B.T., Qtreoh 16, 15-67.
Rkhbrkhls, ].,
I. Akiorf,
V. voi Lkngsa`kthi
?552 Fhish Gkrhsts, Aknf Qthpphs, oif t`h Tonohknet`ea Qhttnhchit kg Ikrt`hri Hurkph, Aurrh
Oit`rkpknkmy 11, 88?-807.
Qtophrt, F. ?5=7 Qkch ioturon surgoah ckfegeaotekis ki gneit ei V`h Iht`hrnoifs, Tonohk`estkreo ?0, 0-6?
?50? Ora`ohknkmeaon Rhshora` ei t`h Lweithnkkejhi Tet, Cuieaeponety kg R`hihi. t`h Iht`hrnoif
Chfhf. Rejls Mhkn. Fehist 18, 246-222.
Qthvi`kvhf. Q. ?552 N4sguifhi ponohknet`esl gneit - hi vorc lortkgghn e foisl orlohknkme, Orlhhknkme e Qnhsvem?/5?,=?-=1.
Qtroif Ththrshi, L. ?508 V`h Noth _uothriory @estkry kg Fhicorl. V`h ]hea`shneoi Eahs`hhts oif Noif/Qho
Akigemuroteki ei t`h Noth Tnhestkahih oif @knkahih, Jkurion kg Foies` Ora`ohknkmy 6.
=-22.
Woim Ththrshi T.,
N. Jk`oishi
?551 Q4nbjhrm - Oi O`rhisburmeoi Qeth ki o Rheifhhr Cemroteki Rkuth t`rkum` Hosthri
Fhicorl, Jkurion kg Foies` Ora`ohknkmy ?4, ?55?.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 215/342
248 J4RMHI @KNC OIF NORQ NORQQKI - QAOIFEIOWEO
]hsthrby, H. ?58= Estefscoifhis rhfslobhr;, Qlonl 2, ?6-?7.
J4rmhi @knc
V`h Iotekion Cushuc
Fhpt. kg Trh`estkry oif Horny @estkry
Grhfhrels`kncs Loion ?2
FL-?22KL4bhi`oviL.
Fhicorl
Nors Norsski
Xievhrsety kg Nuif
Eistetuth kg Ora`ohknkmy
Qoifmotoi ?
Q-221 84 Nuif
Qwhfhi
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 216/342
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 217/342
Wossenej T. Njubei
Mhr`orf Bkseisle?2 V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg t`h Aouaosus rhmeki
V`h Aouaosus orho es ki o coei rkofgkr t`h fesphrson kg
horny `kceiefs kut kg Ogreao, os thstegehf by t`h Fcoiese
seth wet` ets foea kg E .P Cyr BT. V`h orho es rea` ei Ceffnh
Tnhestkahih seehs. t`kum` foteim `os prkvhf feggeaunt fuh tk
t`h hifhcea a`oroathr kg gnkro oif gouio. Qtrotegehf kphi
oer seths nelh Oa`onlonole orh vhry rorh, w`enh aovh seths orh
akccki. Oa`hunhoi eifustrehs orh likwigrkc Ceffnh
Tnhestkahih fhpksets ei aovas nelh Ozya`, Lufork oif
Vrhumkn'iojo.
?. EieeECEELneec (by W.N.)
?.?. MHKMROT@EAON KWHRWEH]
V`h Aouaosus - t`h Aouaoseoi est`cus - gkrcs o vostbrefmh bhtwhhi t`h Tkites oif t`h Aospeoi Qho oifakiiaats t`h skut`hc Russeoi sthpph wet` t`h `em`noifs kgt`h Iaor Host. V`h ikrt`ari port kg t`h Aouaosus esa`oroathrezhf by o sthpph noifsaoph, w`enh t`h ahitron portes fkceiothf by t`h ckuitoeis kg t`h Mrhot Aouaosus,w`ksh oxes ruis oarkss t`h est`cus. V`h skut`hri Aouaosuses gkrchf by t`h Vroisaouaoseoi Fhprhsseki (Akna`es-Nkwnoifs oif t`h Luro Bosei) oif t`h vknaoiea Vroisaouaoseoi Tnothou, o ikrt`ari kutnehr kg t`h Orchieoi oif
Eroieoi Tnothou. V`h bkuiforehs kg t`h Aouaosus (tk t`hikrt` t`h Luco-Coitysa` Bosei, tk t`h skut` t`h OrosRevhr) orh ikt ioturo! borreàrh ei o mhkmrop`eaon shish< t`hrhorh ik anhor fegghrhiahs ei t`h noifsaoph ei bkt` ferhatekis,oif oaahss tk bkt` ikrt` oif skut` oif akitoats tk t`h IhorHosn pnoyhf o cojkr rknh ei t`h Tonohknet`ea shttnhchit kgt`h Aouaosus.
V`h mrhot rhmekion fegghrhiteoteh¼! kg t`h Aouaosusnoifsaoph es coeiny t`h rhsunt kg tkpkmrop`y. V`h ckstecpkrtoit anecotea bkuiforehs orh krehithf onkim t`h refmh kgt`h Mrhot Aouaosus oif t`h ikrt`hri snkph kg t`h Aouaosus(Quroc-A`oei, Qtovrkpkn @enns). V`h anecotea bkuiforehs
`ovh o cojkr eignuhiah ki thcphroturh oif prhaepetoteki kit`h est`cus. V`h Mrhot Aouaosus fevefhs twk anecotea zkihs:t`h thcphroth zkih kg t`h ikrt`hri Aouaosus oif t`hsubtrkpeaon anecoth zkih kg t`h Vroisaouaosus. Ckrhkvhr,t`h tkpkmrop`y subfevefhs t`h Aouaosus rhmeki eitk o normhnuecbhr kg nkaon anecotea prkveiahs.
V`h anecoth kg t`h whsthri oif ahitron port kg t`h gnotAouaosus gkrhnoif rhshcbnhs t`ot kg t`h skut`hri Russeoi
sthpph. V`h Bnoal Qho rhmeki `os oi hosthri Chfethrroihoianecoth< t`h eignuhiah kg t`h ahitron Oseoi sthpphs esikteahobnh ei t`h Luro Bosei oif t`h hosthri port kg t`hAouaosus gkrhnoif. V`h Akiteihiton anecoth kg t`h vknaoieaVroisaouaoseoi @em`noifs es fkceiothf by orefety. Fegghrhitbhets kg vhmhtoteki, fhthrceihf by ontetufh, up tk t`h zkihkg phrhiieon sikw oif mnoaehrs aoi bh kbshrvhf ei t`hckuitoeis (Mvkzfhalej ?571).
O porteaunorny ikteahobnh ghoturh kg t`h Aouaosus
noifsaoph es t`h prhshiah kg oi hxthisevh oif stobnh rhgumhkg rhneat vhmhtoteki ei t`h Akna`es (whsthri Mhkrmeo)(Akaehvo ?502). V`h akrh kg t`h Akna`es gnkro orh rhneatVhrteory sphaehs (Lknolkvslej ?57?)< opprkxecothny 24% kgt`h sphaehs ei t`h Aouaosus orh hifhcea oif kiny gkuif eit`h Akna`es (Tovnkv ?560). Ckrh t`oi 7,444 sphaehs kgpnoits orh likwi grkc t`h Aouaosus rhmeki w`hrhos grkct`h vost Russeoi pnoei kiny skch 1,844 orh likwi. V`hiucbhr kg oiecon sphaehs es ?14.
O porteaunorny sphaehs-rea` wkkfnoif es prhshit ei t`hAkna`es rhmeki oif iuchrkus hfebnh wenf pnoits aoi bhgkuif t`hrh (Mrkssmhjc ?562, ?567). V`h govkurobnhanecoth oif t`h rea` gkkf skurahs whrh porteaunorny ottroa-tevh tk `ucois, os es s`kwi by t`h akiahitroteki kg Tonohknet`ea seths ei t`es rhmeki. V`h Akna`es rhmeki wos opporhitnyo porteaunorny govkurobnh rhgumh gkr oiecons, pnoits oif`ucois fureim t`h mnoaeotekis (Njubei ?575, ?5=6).
Nechstkih gkrcotekis wet` aovhs oif o`res orh prhshit eit`h Mrhot Aouaosus oif ei t`h ckuitoei a`oeis kg t`hNhsshr Aouaosus, oi hosthri hxthiseki kg t`h Vroisaouaoseoi@em`noifs. O reim kg lorstea noifsaophs surrkuifs onckstt`h hiterh ikrt`hri snkph kg t`h Aouaosus oif t`h whsthriport kg t`h skut`hri snkph ei t`h Akna`es rhmeki (grkcQktsa`e tk t`h Lufork Aovhs ei Qkut` Ksshteo). Ei t`hikrt`hri lorst bhnt t`hrh orh Tonohknet`ea seths ei gkr eistoiah
t`h Ckioshslo, Borolohvslo, Chzcojslo oif Vrhumkn'iojoaovhs. @uifrhfs kg obres oif aovhs orh likwi grkc t`hwhsthri port kg t`h skut` snkph ei t`h Akna`es, w`hrh t`hcenf oif `ucef anecoth `os nhf tk porteaunorny hxthisevhlorst gkrcoteki. Ei coiy kg t`hsh obres oif aovhs, ot onnontetufhs, Tonohknet`ea seths `ovh bhhi fesakvhrhf oifeivhstemothf, ockim t`hc t`h seths kg Lufork E oif EEE, oifAkio (Gem. ?).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 218/342
240 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. ?. Nkwhr Tonohknet ea Qeths kg
t`h Aouaosus Rhmeki.
?. Fcoiese< 2. Oa`onlonole<
1. Vocoi< 6. Ozya`< 8. Lufork E<
7. Lufork EEE< =. Akio<
0. Vrhumkn'iojo.
Ei t`h Nhsshr Aouaosus lorst aovhs orh kiny likwi ei t`hQkca`htsle, Qoa`fom oif Loroboa` ckuitoei roimhs. Ei t`hgkkt`enns kg t`h notthr roimh es t`h cuntepnh kaaupoteki seth kgOzya`. Kutsefh t`h lorst rhmeki t`hrh orh seths ei aovhsbhihot` novo gnkws, gkr hxocpnh ei t`h iorrkw mkrmhs kg t`hVroisaouaoseoi @em`noifs (Hrhvoi Aovh, Nusolhrt E oifkt`hrs). V`h vknaoiea rhmeki kg t`h Vroisaouaosus `knfs omrhot pktaiteon gkr t`h fesakvhry kg Tonohknet`ea kphi seths<tk foth wh kiny likw t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea seths Fcoieseoif Oa`onlonole (Gem. ?).
V`h Aouaosus rhmeki es whnn suppnehf wet` row cothreonsgkr t`h coiugoaturh kg stkih tkkns. V`h roimh kg ovoenobnhseneahkus rkals - shfechitory oif vknaoiea - eianufhsonckst onn t`h net`ea cothreons ushf gkr orthgoats ei t`hTonohknet`ea< vorekus typhs kg gneit, quortzeth, soifstkih,seneahkus nechstkih, sa`est, kbsefeoi, oifhseth, bosont hta.Wknaoiea row cothreons (kbsefeoi, oifhseth, bosont) orhgkuif ei t`h rhmekis kg thatkiea upnegt ei t`h Vroisaouaosus(Orchieo, Fzovoa`hte, Ksshteo), w`hrhos gneit oif kt`hrshfechitory rkals orh fkceioit ei t`h Akna`es, t`h BnoalQho orho oif Luboi.
?.2. RHQHORA@ @EQVKRU
V`h rhshora` kg t`h Tonohknet`ea kg t`h Aouaosus rhmekistorthf ei ?050 wet` t`h fesakvhry kg t`h Ceffeh Tonohk
net`ea seth kg En'slojo by t`h Grhia` eivhstemotkr J. fh Boyh.V`h fesakvhry kg Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea orthgoats gknekwhfs`krtny ogthr t`es, fureim t`h Orchieoi hxphfeteki kg t`hGrhia` sovoit J. fh Ckrmoi. @h aknnhathf kbsefeoi orthgoatsgrkc t`h whsthri snkphs kg Ckuit Ororot (Ckrmoi ?545).
Ogthr t`h ?5?= Rhvknuteki eivhstemotekis whrh aorrehf kutby Qkveht ora`ohknkmests. Qphaeon survhys oif pnoiihfeivhstemotekis kg Tonohknet`ea seths whrh aorrehf kut ei
Oba`oseo oif t`h Bnoal Qho rhmeki kg t`h Aouaosus bhgkrht`h Qhakif ]krnf ]or. V`h gerst Oa`hunhoi seths whrhfesakvhrhf ei t`h Qkveht Xieki ihor Qua`uce oif Coelkpw`enh t`h gerst Tonohknet`ea aovh seths whrh fesakvhrhf oifporteonny hxaovothf ihor Qktsa`e (Oa`styrslojo Aovhs oifkt`hrs) (Zocjotiei ?51=, ?565, ?57?). V`h ckst ecpkrtoitrhsunt ei t`h gerst fhaofh ogthr t`h Qhakif ]krnf ]or wost`h fesakvhry kg twk normh ihw geif prkveiahs wet`Oa`hunhoi oif Ceffeh Tonohknet`ea seths ei Orchieo(Toiealeio ?584) oif Qkut` Ksshteo (Njubei ?586, ?574).
V`h t`erf p`osh kg rhshora` bhmoi ei ?588. V`h gerst aovseths wet` uifesturbhf Oa`hunhoi noyhrs whrh fesakvhrhf oLufork E oif EEE (?588) oif Akio (?580) ei Qkut` Ksshteo
oif ot Ozya` (?574) ei Ozhrboefsa`oi (Njubei ?585<Lonoifofzh ?578< Mushjikv ?571). Ot t`h soch tech`uifrhfs kg ihw Oa`hunhoi oif Ceffeh Tonohknet`ea surgoseths whrh fesakvhrhf ei fegghrhit rhmekis kg t`h Aouaosush.m. Obofzha`slkh oif A`kfzka` ot Luboi (Outnhv ?571)Bkmks oif kt`hr seths ot t`h Bnoal Qho (Njubei oifQahneislej ?5=2), Qorbhbe, Aenkvoie oif gurt`hr seths eiEchrhtehi (Vusobrocesvene ?572), Fzrobhr oif Gkitoi eiOrchieo (Njubei ?57?), Zeore ei Loa`hteo (Bumeoiesvene?5=5), Aeleoie oif Thrsote ei skut`hri Mhkrmeo (Lelkfzhoif Lkrefzh ?5=0). Ockim t`h ckst ecpkrtoit rhahitfesakvhrehs orh t`h Vrhumkn'iojo Aovh ei t`h ikrt`hri
Aouaosus (Fkrkieahv ?552) oif t`h kphi-oer seth Fcoieseei skut`hri Mhkrmeo. V`h hxaovotekis ei Fcoiese prkvefhfNkwhr Tonohknet`ea orthgoats, oi ora`oea gouio oif t`h knfhrhcoeis kg @kck hrhatus ei Huroseo (Fzoporefzh ht on.
?55?< Mobuieo ?552).
V`h cojkrety kg Oa`hunhoi oif Ceffeh Tonohknet`ea sethorh nkaothf ei upnoif setuotekis, ei t`h gkkt`enns oif nkwhrckuitoeis kg t`h whsthri oif ahitron ports kg t`h Aouaosu
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 219/342
245 WOQQENEJ T. NJXB?I OIF MHR@ORF BKQEIQLn - V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
est`cus. V`es es ahrtoeiny ikt kiny o rhgnhateki kg t`h aurrhitstoth ue rhshora`, bun gor ckrh t`h rhsunn kg goatkrs sua` ost`h prhshiah kg oiaehi) rkuths kg akccuieaoteki bhtwhhit`h ('ouaosus oif t`h Ihor Host, kg iuchrkus ioturon rkals`hnthrs oif ioturon rhskurahs (eianufeim net`ea cothreons)oif t`h porneaunorny govkurobnh anecotea akifetekishsphaeonny ei t`h Akna`es rhgumeuc.
Hxthisevh Oa`hunhoi oif Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea seths oifothnehrs `ovh bhhi fesakvhrhf ei t`h ecchfeoth veaeiety kgrow cothreon skurahs. Qua` @eit wkrls`kps orh nkaothf eit`h Qoa`oi Ckuitoeis kg t`h Luboi rhmeki ihor Coelkp(Obofzha`slojo oif kt`hrs), ei t`h Jostua` Ckuitoeis kgOba`oseo oif ki t`h upphr Echrhte Tnothou anksh tk Lutoesseei skut`hri Mhkrmeo (Qorbhbe oif kt`hrs). Kbsefeoi oifoifhseth wkrls`kps orh gkuif ei Orchieo (Qotoie For,Hrlok-bnus, Otes oif kt`hr seths) oif ei skut`hri Mhkrmeo(Aeleoie, Thrsote).
V`h net`ea osshcbnomhs ot t`h othnehr seths fk ikt rhprhshitfesarhth a`rkiknkmeaoS uiets. V`h strotemrop`eaon akithxt kggeifs aknnhathf grkc revhr thrroahs, hxpkshf `ennsefhs, mkrmhsoif revhr vonnhys es uilikwi. V`h strotemrop`ea pkseteki oift`h omh kg geifs trkc shfechits kvhrnyeim thrroah fhpksetsoif coreih shfechits orh onsk kgthi uiahrtoei. V`h omh kggeifs grkc t`h boson onnuveon goaehs kg thrroahs aoi bhhstobnes`hf wet` skch ckrh ahrtoeity. ]efh roimeim stufehskg t`h mhknkmeaon-mhkckrp`knkmeaon pkseteki oif omh kgthrroah surgoahs orh aurrhitny ei prkmrhss ei t`h rhmeki kgQktsa`e oif Vuopsh. V`h subfeveseki kg Tnhestkahih fhpksetses boshf `hrh ki t`h shquhiah oif t`h mhka`rkiknkmy kgcoreih thrroahs oif kg t`h rhnothf revhr thrroahs ei t`h BnoalQho rhmeki (shh Gem. 2). O iucbhr kg Oa`hunhoi oif CeffnhTonohknet`ea seths `ovh bhhi fesakvhrhf ei t`h boson, onnuveon
ports kg t`hsh thrroahs (Qahneislej oif Kstrkvslej ?5=4<Kstrkvslej ht on. ?5==< Ezcojnkv ?554).
V`h cojkrety kg Oa`hunhoi geifs ei t`h Aouaosus akchsgrkc surgoah seths. A`oroathrestea kg t`hsh seths oif onsk kgt`h aovh seths es t`h prhshiah kg begoahs. Oa`hunhoi wet`ben oahs es t`h ckst ecpkrtoit goaehs kg t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea kg t`h Aouaosus. Begoahs orh gkuif ei porteaunornynormh iucbhrs ot seths ei t`h skut`hri port kg t`h Aouaosus,e.h. grkc t`h Vroisaouaoseoi @em`noifs, w`ea` gkrc t`hikrt`hc port kg t`h hxthisevh Ihor Hosthri @em`noifs. V`hOa`hunhoi ei t`h Aouaosus opphors tk bh o ikrt`hchxthiseki kg o festrebuteki w`ksh ahitrh nehs ei t`h Ihor
Host. V`hrh orh opprhaeobny nhss begoahs ki Oa`hunhoi sethsikrt` kg t`h Vroisaouaoseoi @em`noifs< ei Echrhte, t`hBnoal Qho oif t`h Luboi rhmekis. V`h kiny hxahpteki tkt`es orh surgoah geifs oif seths ei t`h whst kg Qkut` Ksshteo(NoQh-Bonto. Lonhte, Afenhte oif kt`hrs ei t`h gkkt`enns oifLufork E, Lufork EEE oif Akio ei t`h ckuitoeis), w`hrhiuchrkus begoahs kaaur. V`es rhmeki es nkaothf bhtwhhi t`hNeoa`ve Revhr oif t`h Qurocsl (Nea`sl) ckuitoei roimh
oif gkrcs o neil bhtwhhi t`h Vroisaouaoseoi @em`noifs oift`h Mrhothr Aouaosus. V`h normh prkpkrteki kg begoahs grkct`h Qkut` Ksshteoi seths es, ckst prkbobny, rhnothf tk t`hckrh skut`hrny geifs grkc t`h Vroisaouaoseoi @em`noifs(Fzovoa`hte). Hvefhiah gkr sua` o rhnotekis`ep cem`t bh t`hkaaurrhiah kg begoahs ot seths ei Qkut` Ksshteo w`ea` orhcofh kg o iki nkaonny kaaurreim oifhseth (grkc t`h Fzovo
a`hte rhmeki;). V`h prhshiah kg anhovhrs ei osshcbnomhsgrkc bkt` t`h Vroisaouaoseoi @em`noifs (Ozya`, Qotoie-For, Aeleoie) oif Qkut` Ksshteo (Nosh-Bonto, Akio oifkt`hr seths) onsk eifeaoths sua` o rhnotekis`ep (Njubei ?50?o<Lelkfzh ?507).
Hsphaeonny ecpkrtoit oif akcprh`hisevhny pubnes`hfOa`hunhoi seths orh Qotoie-For (Toiealeio ?584) oif Fzrobhr(Njubei ?57?, ?50?o, ?506), bkt` ei Orchieo, Nosh-Bonto(Njubei ?574, ?50?o) ei Qkut` Ksshteo, Jostua` (Lkrkblkv?57=, ?5=?) ei Oba`oseo oif Obofzha`slojo ei t`h Luboirhmeki. Qeths wet` Xpphr Oa`hunhoi orthgoats (Nhvonnkestha`iequh, sconn iucbhrs kg noth typhs kg begoahs) orh likwigrkc t`h ikrt`hc Aouaosus. Vwk ckrp`knkmeaonny precetevhbegoahs (ocymfonkef, prktk-necoifh), akrhs oif gnolhs gkuifihor Qorotkvsl ki t`h Tshlups Revhr ot t`h gkkt kg t`h 18chtrh thrroah orh t`h kiny orthgoats w`ea` cem`t bh hvefhiahkg oi opprhaeobny hornehr p`osh. Zocjotiei (?57?) anossegehft`hsh geifs os Nkwhr Oa`hunhoi. V`h prkbobnh ora`ohknkmeaonnoyhr wos mhknkmeaonny ossemihf tk t`h horny kr ahitron portkg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih (Whneêlk ht on. ?575).
?.1. TNHEQVKAHIH A@RKIKQVROVEMROT@U
Fegghrhit subfevesekis kg t`h Tnhestkahih phrekf orh ushfei t`h Aouaosus rhmeki oif t`hy aoi kiny bh akrrhnothfbrkofny ei skch aoshs (Gem. 2). V`h subfeveseki ushf ei t`h
hosthri port kg t`h rhmeki es boshf ki t`h coreihtroismrhssekis ei t`h Aospeoi Qho (Ghfkrkv ?5=0). Ei t`hwhsthri Aouaosus troismrhssekis kg t`h Bnoal Qho orh t`hboses kg anossegeaoteki (Ghfkrkv ?5=0). Ei t`h ikrt` kg t`hrhmeki t`h subfeveseki kg thrrhstreon fhpksets, ei porteaunorckroeihs, hstobnes`hf gkr t`h Russeoi pnoei es usuonnyofkptaf (Ielegkrkvo ?502). Vk t`h skut`, ei t`h vknaoiearhmekis kg t`h Vroisaouaosus, thp`ro fhpksets orh bheim ushfeiarhoseimny gkr foteim. Toronnhn tk t`h mhknkmeaon zkiotekit`hrh hxests o strotemrop`eaon bekzkioteki ki t`h boses kggouion osshcbnomhs (Gem. 2).
V`h subfeveseki kg t`h Tnhestkahih ushf ei akuitrehs kg
t`h hx-Qkveht Xieki, oif t`hrhgkrh onsk ei t`h Aouaosus,fegghrs grkc t`ot ei whsthri oif ahitron Hurkph (Trosnkv?506< Njubei ?551o-b). V`h Vhrteory/_uothcory bkuiforyes nkaothf ot t`h bosh kg t`h Opshrki Noyhrs oif MurejoNoyhrs kg t`h Aospeoi oif Bnoal Qhos rhsphatevhny, oifakrrhnoths wet` t`h Knfuvoe Hvhit ot ?.0=-?.7= Cyr BT.V`h _uothcory es fevefhf eitk t`rhh uiets - Hkpnhestkahih,Tnhestkahih oif @knkahih.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 220/342
2?4 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 2. Tnhestkahih a`rkiknkmy ei
Hosthri Hurkph (ikth t`ot t`h
strotemrop`eaon subfeveseki gkr
ikrt`hri oif ahitron Hurkph fegghrs
grkc t`h Qtoiforf feveseki gkr t`es
orho< shh Rkhbrkhls oif Woi
Lkngsa`kthi, t`es vknuch, gemurh ?).
HOQVHRI HXRKTH
Russeoi Tnoei
L.W. Ielegkrkvo ht on. ?504E Qhfe chit s | Gou io
Bnoal Qho Ao sp eo i Qho
T.W. Ghfkrkv ?5=0
Letkvoie ?5=7T.W. Ghfkrkv
?5=0
@ k E k a h i h
Wonfoe
Celunei
Ckslvo
Rksnov
Fihpr
Nea`vei
4a4þ
[k
8.
k
4A4KK
4_,AN
Klo
Lknlktkv
Tnotkv
Cea`oj nkv
Ckrkzkv
Ikmoj
Zhvoa`kv
Bkshriea
Fkcoslei
Ghrnofoi
Lryzoikv
Ollunhvo
Aestkpkn
k% NothkNP.-A- 6 ‖
K
£H´ Horny
A`ozor
Qeimen'
Ihw Hvlsei
Tkst-Loroimot
Loroimot
Verospkn
Vocoi
Kfhsso
A`oprkv
Rhmrhsseki
Xzuinor
Horny Hvlsei (upphr)
Horny Hvlsei (nkwhr)
Xpphr A`vonyi
Nkwhr A`vonyi
Xpphr A`ozor
Rhmrhsseki
Xpphr Aoufo
Rhmrhsseki
Nkwhr Aoufo
Aoufo(Murejo)
Murejo
Lujon'iea
CknfovoLecchrejo
Rhmrhsseki
Nkwhr A`ozor(Lkskz)
Nkwhr A`ozor(Qeimen')
AHIVRON
HXRKTH
]hea`shn
Hhc
Rhmrhsseki
Xruifzel(Xpphr Bolu)
Nkwhr Bolu
Vjurljoi
Xpphr
Ceffnh
Nkwhr
Xpphr
Ceffnh
Nkwhr
]ort`h [4_ Vrhhih
(/-, Frhit`h
@knsthei
Hesthr
Arkchr
( E - W )
Chiop
]oon
Hburki
Vhmhnhi
Trhthmhnhi
Lkpnhestkahih
V`h Opshrki noyhrs kg t`h Aospeoi Qho oif t`h Murejonoyhrs kg t`h Bnoal Qho orh ossemihf tk t`h Hkpnhestkahih.Ei t`h thrrhstreon anossegeaoteki systhc kg t`h Russeoi Tnoeit`es phrekf eianufhs t`h Fkcoslei, Bkshriea, Zhvoa`kv,Ikmoe oif Ckrkzkv @krezkis. V`h gouion akcpnhxhsgrkc Kfhsso oif Vocoi orh onsk ossemihf tk t`h
Hkpnhestkahih.V`h Hkpnhestkahih es brkofny hquevonhit tk t`h Horny
Tnhestkahih kg t`h whsthri oif ahitron Hurkphoi anossegeaoteki oif es subfevefhf eitk twk gurt`hr uiets. V`h NkwhrHkpnhestkahih akitoeis t`h nkwhr oif nkwhr-ceffnh port kgt`h Opshrki. V`es phrekf es bekstrotemrop`eaonny a`oroathrezhby t`h gouion osshcbnomhs grkc Kfhsso wet` t`h typh sphae
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 221/342
2?? WOQQENEJ T. NJXBEI OIF MHR@ORF BKQEIQLn - V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
Ora`efeslkfki chrefekiones chrefekiones oif es hquevonhittk t`h Noth Wennogroia`eoi kg whsthri Hurkph.
V`h Xpphr Hkpnhestkahih akitoeis t`h upphr-ceffnh oifupphr uiets kg t`h Opshrki oif es a`oroathrezhf bek-strotemrop`eaonny by t`h gouio grkc Vocoi, wet` t`h typhsphaehs Ora`efeslkfki chrefekiones tocoihises, o nothr gkrckg t`h skut`hri hnhp`oit. V`h hquevonhit stomh ei whsthri
Hurkph es t`h Hpe-Wennogroia`eoi.
Tnhestkahih
V`h Hkpnhestkahih/Tnhestkahih bkuifory es fhgeihf ott`h bosh kg t`h Vjurljoi fhpksets kg t`h Aospeoi Qho oift`h bosh kg t`h Aoufo fhpksets kg t`h Bnoal Qho. Ei t`hsubfeveseki ushf ei t`h Russeoi Tnoei rhmeki, t`es bkuiforyes nkaothf ot t`h bhmeiieim kg t`h Cea`ojnkv `krezki. V`hHkpnhestkahih/Tnhestkahih bkuifory es setuothf skchw`otbhnkw E`h Conuyoco-Brui`hs bkuifory (4.=0 Cyr BT)w`ea` fhgeihs t`h bhmeiieim kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih eiwhsthri oif ahitron Hurkph.
Nkwhr Tnhestkahih
V`h Nkwhr Tnhestkahih `os twk uiets. V`h knfhr porteianufhs ei t`h Aospeoi Qho orho t`h Vjurljoi, Bolu oifn 'ruif/el noyhrs, ei t h Bnoal Qho orho t`h Aoufo noyhrs. Eie`h anossegeaoteki kg t`h Russeoi Tnoei t`h hquevonhin uietsorh E`h Cea`ojnkv, Tnotkv oif Lknlktkv `krezkis.
V`h knfhr p`osh kg t`h Nkwhr Tnhestkahih es fhgeihf byt`h gouio trkc Verospkn, w`ea` eianufhs Ora`efeslkfki
trkmkit`hree, Hquus cksboa`hises oif Feahrkr`eius chrhle.
V`h ykuimhr p`osh kg t`h Nkwhr Tnhestkahih es rhprhshithfki t`h Russeoi Tnoei by fhpksets kg t`h Klo (3 Hesthr)Mnoaeoteki< o phrekf wet` o cojkr coreih rhmrhsseki kg bkt`
t`h Aospeoi oif t`h Bnoal Qho. Fearkstkiyx kaaurs eifhpksets kg t`h Klo Mnoaeoteki.
V`h whsthri oif ahitron Hurkphoi hquevonhit tk t`es NkwhrTnhestkahih es t`h gerst port kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih.
Ceffnh Tnhestkahih
V`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih kg t`h Aospeoi Qho es rhprhshithfby t`h nkwhr A`ozor noyhrs (Qeimen' oif Lkskz `krezkis),t`ot kg t`h Bnoal Qho by t`h Hvlsei oif Xzuinor fhpksets.Ki t`h Russeoi Tnoei t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih akitoeis t`hNea`vei, Fihpr, Rksnovo oif Ckslvo `krezkis.
V`h Nea`vei Eithrmnoaeon es a`oroathrezhf by t`h Qeimen'
gouio wet` Tonohknkxkfki oineqecs. V`h fhpksets kg t`hFihpr Mnoaeoteki akitoei o gouion akcpnhx wet` Coccu-
t`us a`ksoreaus, t`h hornehst truh cocckt`. V`h Rksnovooif Ckslvo `krezkis orh a`oroathrezhf by oi horny p`osh kgt`h Noth Tnhestkahih gouio akitoeieim Coccut`us
precemhieus.
V`es Ceffnh Tnhestkahih aoi bh hquothf wet` t`h shakif`ong kg t`h whsthri oif ahitron Hurkphoi Ceffnh Tnhestkahih.
Xpphr Tnhestkahih
V`h Xpphr Tnhestkahih bhmeis wet` t`h Celunei (3 Hhc)Eithrmnoaeon oif onsk eianufhs t`h fhpksets kg t`h Wonfoemnoaeoteki. V`h hquevonhit fhpksets ei t`h Aospeoi Qhorhmeki orh t`h upphr A`ozor oif t`h A`vonyi noyhrs, ei t`hBnoal Qho orho t`h Loroimot, Tkst-Loroimot oifIkvkhvlsei fhpksets. V`es Xpphr Tnhestkahih es t`h
hquevonhit kg t`h ahitron oif whsthri Hurkphoi NothTnhestkahih.
V`h akrrhnoteki tobnh (Gem. 2) akcporhs t`h feveseki kgt`h Tnhestkahih ei t`h Aouaosus rhmeki wet` t`ot kg ikrt`hriahitron Hurkph. V`h akcporeski s`kunf bh trhothf wet`rhshrvoteki oif es, hsphaeonny gkr t`h knfhr port kg t`hshquhiah, rhnotevhny uiahrtoei. Akrrhnoteki wet` t`h Onpeihshquhiah shhcs tk bh queth ecpkssebnh, wet` t`h hxahptekikg t`h Noth Tnhestkahih. Gkr t`h solh kg uiegkrcety t`hQtoiforf akiteihiton subfeveseki kg t`h Tnhestkahih os ushfei ahitron oif whsthri Hurkph wenn bh ushf ei t`h gknnkweimthxt.
2. V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg t`h Aouaosus
2.?. HORNU TNHEQVKAHIH: FCOIEQE (BU M.B.)
V`h seth Fcoiese nehs ei skut`host Mhkrmeo, anksh tk t`hbkrfhr wet` Orchieo, ei o vknaoiea orho w`ea` hxthifs eitkOrchieo oif Vurlhy tk t`h skut` (Gem. 1). Ecpkrtoit gkr t`horho orh t`h vknaoikhs kg t`h ikrt`-skut` krehithfFzovoa`hte roimh, tk t`h whst kg Fcoiese. Fureim t`h HornyTnhestkahih, novo grkc o vknaoik kg t`h Fzovoa`hte roimhgnkwhf hostworfs t`rkum` t`h vonnhy kg t`h Cosovhro revhroif eitk t`h nkwhr vonnhy kg t`h Teihzokure (Gem. 6). V`hnovo es ikrconny comihtezhf oif `os bhhi fothf tk ?.0 ¿ 4.?oif ?.5 ¿ 4.2 Cyr BT, summhsteim et s`kunf bh pnoahf ei t`h
Knfuvoe Hvhit (Cojsurofzh ht on. ?55?). V`h novo wos nothraut by bkt` t`h Cosovhro oif t`h Teihzokure, nhoveim otreoimunor prkckitkry kg novo, w`ea` tkwhrs 54 c obkvh t`hprhshit nhvhn kg t`h revhrs. Ki t`es prkckitkry noy t`hchfeohvon tkwi kg Fcoiese< t`h aetofhn ei t`h skut` kg t`hrueihf tkwi es buent ki Arhtoahkus fhpksets.
V`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea seth wos fesakvhrhf ei t`h pet-ahnnors kg chfeohvon `kushs. Gknnkweim prhneceioryhxaovotekis by t`h Ora`ohknkmeaon Ahitrh, Vegnes bhtwhhi?501-?50= oif ei ?505, t`h seth `os bhhi eivhstemothf seiah?55? (Fzoporefzh ht on. ?55?).
Qtrotemrop`yEi t`h ceffnh kg t`h novo gnkw t`hrh es o bosont refmh wet`
oaaucunothf shfechits ki bkt` sefhs (Gem. 1). V`h bosh kgt`h shateki, ki tkp kg t`h novo, es gkrchf by bnoal bosontsoif (WE), akvhrhf by o bnoales` brkwi soify nkoc (W)wet` iuchrkus bkihs oif net`ea orthgoats. Ei o akiahitrotekiot t`h bosh kg noyhr W t`h `ucoi coifebnh (shh bhnkw) wosgkuif. Ihxt, o brkwi soify nkoc (EW) es prhshit, w`ea`
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 222/342
2?2 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
i> 2444??
E7?4c)
•
2444-8444??(7?4-?826cn
•
8444-0444 Et(?82£-2610c)
•
0444-5444X!2610-2=t1c)
•
9 5444 gt(2=61cn
Gem. 1. Nkaoteki kg Fcoiese oif Oa`onlonole ei t`h Fzovoa`hte rhmeki.
fegghrs trkc t`h uifhrnyeim noyhrs coeiny ei t`h obshiah kgo akcpkihit kg bosont os`. Bkihs oif orthgoats orh onskprhshit ei Noyhr EW, but nhss t`oi ei Noyhr W. O bnkalyfhpkset, akcpkshf kg coeiny `krezkiton boifs kg aorbkiothakiarhteki lhrle gkrcs Noyhr EEE. Et shhcs t`ot t`h aorbkiothakiarhtekis kg t`h lhrle gkrchf os o arust fhvhnkphf kit`h uifhrnyeim shfechits ei worc oif oref akifetekis.V`h cknnusas oif shhfs gkuif ei t`h lhrle eifeaoth fryakifetekis. Bkihs oif orthgoats orh onsk prhshit ei t`hfhpkset. eifeaoteim t`ot `ucois whrh kaaosekionny prhshitfureim t`h gkrcoteki kg t`h lhrle. Obkvh t`h lhrle gknnkws4.84-4.04 c kg o yhnnkw, wholny nkocy shfechit (Noyhr EE).
Ei t`h nkwhr port kg Noyhr EE, 4.?4 - 4.24 c obkvh t`h lhrle,t`hrh es o `krezki wet` coiy stkihs eianufeim orthgoats. V`h?552-?556 hxaovotekis fhckistrothf t`ot t`h stkihs kg t`esnoyhr hxthif kvhr o surgoah kg ot nhost =4 x =4 c. Ei krfhrtk anoregy t`es setuoteki et es ihahssory tk hxaovoth normhroif ak`hrhit surgoahs. Bkihs orh rorh ei t`es `krezki, but ocknor kg Ora`efeslkfki chrefekiones gkuif ei ?55?eifeaoths t`ot Noyhr EE es onsk tk bh fothf tk t`h HornyTnhestkahih (Whluo oif Mobuieo ?55?). V`h tkp kg t`hshateki akisests kg o mrhy shfechit (Noyhr E), w`ea`prkbobny rhprhshits oi onthroteki (sken gkrcoteki) kg t`huifhrnyeim noyhr. V`h surgoah kg Noyhr E es Akisknefothf byaorbkioth akiarhtekis. Ki tkp kg noyhr E es o t`ei `ucusnoyhr wet` chfeohvon geifs oif t`h rubbnh noyhrs kg t`hchfeohvon tkwi.
V`h nkwhr noyhrs (WE-EW) coy `ovh bhhi gkrchf ei orhnotevhny s`krt phrekf, by gnuveon prkahsshs t`ot fharhoshft`rkum` tech. V`h noyhrs W oif EW orh ikrconny comihtezhf(Cojsurofzh ht on. ?55?) w`ea` summhsts o prhneceioryakrrhnoteki kg t`hsh noyhrs wet` t`h Knfuvoe Hvhit. V`h
a`rkiknkmeaon pkseteki kg t`h upphr nhvhns, hsphaeonny kgnoyhr EE es feggeaunt tk hstobnes`. V`h ponohkcomihteaonoionyses kg Qknkmosvene eifeaoths t`ot noyhr EE es comihteaorhvhrshf, w`ea` summhsts o akrrhnoteki tk t`h Cotuyocophrekf ogthr t`h Knfuvoe Hvhit.
Gouion rhcoeis
V`h cojkrety kg t`h coark gouion rhcoeis rhakvhrhf tkfoth orh grkc Noyhr W, w`enh o iucbhr kg bkihs bhnkimstk Noyhr EW. Noyhr WE ferhatny kvhrnehs t`h bosont novooif `os kiny yehnfhf o ghw bkihs, w`ea`, ei aknkur oif`em` fhmrhh kg gkssenezoteki, fegghr grkc t`h kt`hr bkihs.
V`h lhrle Noyhr EEE akitoeis kiny o sconn iucbhr kgrhsestoit gouion rhcoeis, coeiny thht`. Ei Noyhr EE bkihsorh rorh.
V`h gouio grkc Noyhr W es ossemihf bekstrotemrop`eaonny t`h Noth Wennogroia`eoi (Whluo oif Mobuieo ?55?, Whluoei prhss).? V`h gouio es ykuimhr t`oi t`h Wennogroia`eoiakcpnhxhs grkc Lkaoa`ure oif Aonlo (Whluo ht on. ?508).w`ea` bhnkim tk t`h horny Opshrkieoi (Mobuieo oif Whluo?50?, ?554< Whluo ?55?o-b). Fcoiese es ihvhrt`hnhss, kit`h hvefhiah kg t`h stomh kg fhvhnkpchit kg Ora`efeslkfki
chrefekiones, knfhr t`oi 'Xbhefejo (Whluo oif Mobuieo?55?< Mobuieo oif Whluo ?551< Whluo ei prhss).
Haknkmeaonny t`h gouio es fkceiothf by sphaehs typeaonkg worc anecoth, kphi mrossnoif (Qtrut`ek, Hquus, Feahrk-
r`eius htrusaus, Ora`efeslkfki chrefekiones), but sphaehseifeaotevh kg gkrhsthf akifetekis orh onsk prhshit (Qus,
Xrsees htrusaus).
V`h bkihs kg Noyhr W noy ei shporoth akiahitrotekis,w`ea` rhphothfny akitoeihf orteaunothf slhnhton ports(vhrthbroh, gkkt bkihs). Qkch kg t`h bkihs orh gromchithf
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 223/342
2?1 WOQQENEJ T. NJXBEI OIF MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
Gem. 6. Fcoiese. Qa`hcotea shateki(tkton `hem`t opprkxecothny 6 c).
w Hxaovoteki ei buenfeim PE
E E
2,4CEK¿4,?
Vop`kikcea stufehs `ovh ikt bhhi aorrehf kut yht, sk gkrt`h tech bheim et es ecpkssebnh tk hvonuoth t`h rknh kg`uieois ei t`h oaaucunoteki kg t`h rhakvhrhf osshcbnomh<t`hrh orh bkihs oif oitnhrs wet` pkssebnh troahs kgckfegeaoteki by `ucois, t`kum` sconn coccon rhcoeisoif cknnusas orh gkuif coeiny ei t`h nkwhr Noyhrs (W, EW).V`h gknnkweim sphaehs orh efhitegehf by O. Whluo oifO. Cusa`hneQvene: Qkrh.x sp., Corckto sp., Opkfhcus ogg.fkceiois, Onnkareahtus sp., Hpechrekihs sp., Ceckcys hxmr. `uimoreaus, Lkwonsleo sp.
Gnkro
Tknnhi es kiny pkkrny prhshrvhf ei t`h Fcoiese shateki.@kwhvhr, ei o akprkneth H. Lvovofzh gkuif o sphatrucakitoeieim pknnhi kg trhhs (peih, spruah, bhha`, onfhr,a`hstiut, nech. bera`, `kribhoc), s`rubs (r`kfkfhifrki.`ozhn) oif mross oif `hrbs (eianufeim Tknypkfeoahoh,A`hikpkfeoahoh, Ayphroahoh oif Mroceihoh) (Lnkptkvslojoan on. E55n). Offetekionny, shhfs whrh efhitegehf kg Bumnks-
skefhs orvhish, Oia`uso sp., Qtop`ynnho akna`elo, Ikiho
gnovhsahis, Nyakpses krehitones oif Ahntes mnobroto.
Net`ea orthgoats
Net`ea orthgoats orh porteaunorny akccki ei Noyhr EE, butorh onsk prhshit ei Noyhrs W oif EW. Et es stenn ikt pkssebnhtk rhakmiezh fegghrhiahs ei t`h typknkmy kr tha`iknkmy kgt`h vorekus noyhrs.
V`h orthgoats orh coeiny coiugoaturhf grkc seneaegehfvknaoiea tuggs oif orh kaaosekionny kg quortz (Bkseisle ht on.
?55?). V`hy orh strual grkc akbbnhs w`ea` kaaur ei t`hvonnhys kg t`h Cosovhro oif Teihzokure.
Gnolhs colh up t`h cojkrety kg t`h orthgoats (Gem. 8).O iucbhr kg t`h sconnhr gnolhs orh strual grkc ckrh `em`nyseneaegehf gneit-nelh tuggs, w`ea` orh kiny rorhny gkuif ei t`hrevhr mrovhns.
V`h fkrson surgoahs kg t`h gnolhs ikrconny `ovh gnolhsaors w`ea` orh usuonny strual grkc t`h soch ferhateki os
t`h gnolh etshng oif s`kw shreon lioppeim kg gnolhs. V`hgnolh hfmhs akcckiny s`kw fhgeieth ush whor (cormeionrhtkua`, spneithreim, sconn ikta`hs).
Rhtkua`hf gnolhs (Gem. 7) orh rorh, but prhshit ei t`h gkrckg hfmh rhtkua` oif sthpphf rhtkua`. O cuntepnh burei esprhshit, coiugoaturhf ki o normh gnolh wet` oi hfmh-rhtkua`hf vhitron goah.
Akrhs orh coeiny sp`hreaon/pkny`hfrea oif strual grkcshvhron ferhatekis. V`hrh orh onsk akieaon akrhs w`kshstreleim pnotgkrc es gkrchf by kih kr, ot ckst, o ghw bnkws.Thbbnh tkkns orh bkt` uiegoaeonny oif begoaeonny wkrlhf oifs`kw o mrhot kvhrnop wet` t`h aothmkry kg akrhs (Gem. =).
V`h `kceief coifebnh
V`h `kceief coifebnh fesakvhrhf ei Qhpthcbhr ?55?, eit`h nkwhr port kg Noyhr W, wos gkuif ei t`h ceffnh kg oakiahitroteki kg bkihs (Mobuieo ht on. ?55?). Rhcoeis kg Chmoithrhki (aroieuc, otnos, hpestrkp`hus, vhrthbroh),Aoies (aroieuc, p`onoix ?, aoieie), Xrsus (aorponeo), Hquus
(tebeo, rofeus, `uchrus, vhrthbroh), Feahrkr`eius (Cn -C1),Ahrvus (vhrthbroh), Bks (chtoaorpus, vhrthbroh), @ypknomus
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 224/342
2?6 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 8. Fcoiese. Gnolhs. Qaonh ei ac.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 225/342
2?8 WOQQENEJ E'. EJNBEI OIFM@R@ORF BKQEIQLE V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
(chtotorsus) oif Rhpteneo (vhrthbroh) akunf bh efhitegehf.V`h akiahitroteki onsk akitoeihf orthgoats oif coiupkrts.V`h coifebnh (Gem. 0) noy upsefh fkwi ei t`h ceffnh kg t`hakiahitroteki. V`h osahifeim rocus ki bkt` sefhs kg t`hcoifebnh `os bhhi groaturhf kgg. Kt`hrwesh t`h coifebnh eswhnn prhshrvhf wet` onn ?7 thht`. V`h fhmrhh kg whor kit`h thht` summhsts ou eifevefuon bhtwhhi 24-28 yhors ot t`htech kg fhot`. V`h rkbusteaety kg t`h pehah onnkws et tk bhefhitegehf os conh (Mobuieo ?552). V`h nkw weft` oif t`hiorrkw onvhknor ora` kg t`h chfeuc-sezhf pehah orh iktobnh.V`h rhmeki kg t`h oithrekr sycp`yses es iorrkw oif `os oprkikuiahf rhnehg. V`h ceffnh port kg t`h sycp`yses esakivhx: o a`ei prkceihiah es ikn prhshit. V`h eiaeskrsprkjhat gkrworfs oif t`her onemichit es kiny snem`tny aurvhf.V`h aoieih es snem`tny pkeithf but fkhs ikt prktrufh obkvht`h `hem`t kg t`h kt`hr thht`. V`h prhcknors orh rhnotevhnysconn. V`h cknors `ovh strkimny gknfhf hiochn oif `ovh t`h
Frykpet`haus potthri oif o sext` ausp (tubhraunuc shxtuc).
V`h se/h kg t`h cknors feceies`hs opprhaeobny grkc C, tkC-,. Oaakrfeim tk N. Mobuieo (?552) t`h coifebnh s`kws o
roimh kg ora`oea a`oroathresteas, sua` os t`h X-s`ophfonvhknor ora`, t`h oithrekr oif rhnotevhny nkw pnoahchit kgt`h gkrochi chitonh, obshiah kg t`h tremkiuc chitonh,nkrworf pkseteki kg t`h bhmeiieim kg t`h osahifeim roce oifrhfuateki kg t`h rhtrkcknor gksso. Ot t`h soch tech, t`hcoifebnh `os ahrtoei ghoturhs ei akccki wet` horny @kck
sopehis, h.m. rhfuateki ei t`h sezh kg t`h cknors grkc C, tkC <. o thifhiay tkworfs o vhrteaon krehitoteki kg t`h pnoiuconvhknorh, oif kiny o snem`t rhahsseki kg t`h oithrekrsycp`yshon surgoah.
V`h Fcoiese coifebnh s`kws secenoretehs tk ahrtoei HornyTnhestkahih sphaechis. Ockim Ogreaoi geifs t`hsh orh
K@ ?1 (@kck `obenes), HR =14, HR 552 oif, pkssebny, t`hofcetthfny vhry ykuim eifevefuon ]V ?8444. Ockim t`hJovo geifs t`hrh orh coiy secenoretehs tk Qoimeroi 5.N. Mobuieo (?552) bhnehvhs t`ot t`h Fcoiese `kceief oift`h secenor Tet`haoit`rkpus grkc Qoimeroi rhprhshit o gkrcfhrevhf grkc @kck `obenes w`ea` onrhofy sprhof eitkHuroseo ot t`h bhmeiieim kg t`h Tnhestkahih. Fhrevhf grkc o`kceief typh w`ea` onsk akitoeihf t`h oiahstkrs kg @kck
(•ceees, t`h rhprhshitotevhs kg t es horny cemroteki kg`obenes-eyph `kceiefs eitk Huroseo uifhrwhit t`her kwihvknuteki. Ei skch ghoturhs t`es nhf tk poronnhns wet` t`hckrh rhahit @kck hrhatus, w`enh ei kt`hr woys t`h thcpkkg hvknuteki wos ckrh ropef t`oi gkr t`h notthr sphaehs(N. Mobuieo ?552).
2.2. HORNU CEFF NH TNHEQVKAHIH (BU M.B.)
2.2.?. Oa`onlonole
Host kg t`h tkwi kg Oa`onlonole ei skut`hc Mhkrmeo(Gem. 1) es t`h ?,001 c KF `em` vknaoik kg Oceroies, w`ea`tkwhrs kvhr t`h Fzovoa`hte `em` pnothou by skch ?84 c.
V`es `em` pnothou es gkrchf kg Vhrteory (Cekahih-Tnekahih)pyrkanostea rkals oif novos oif Tnekahih-Horny Tnhestkahihbosonts (Coruosvene ?5=?< Mobuieo ht on. ?556).
Ei t`h horny ?574's O. Whluo uifhrtkkl ponohkitknkmeaonhxaovotekis ki t`h nkwhr snkphs kg Ct. Oceroies (Whluo?572, ?50=< Lo`nlh ?50=). O rea` gouio wos hxaovothfgrkc t`h nkocy whot`hrhf fhpksets, wet` Xrsus sp., Chnhs
chnhs, Toit`hro ag. temres, Coccut`us ogg. trkmkit`hree, Ora`efeslkfki sp., Hquus sþsshibkrihises, Hquus `eppo-
rekikefhs, Feahrkr`eius htrusaus. @eppkpktocus mhkrmeaus,
Trohchmoahrks vhrteakries oif Aopro sp. V`es gouio esossemihf tk t`h horny Ceffnh Tnhestkahih. nts akcpksetekisummhsts t`ot ot t`ot tech t`h Oa`onlonole pnothou oif t`hsurrkuifeim rhmeki whrh akvhrhf by oi kphi sthpphvhmhtoteki. V`h ofcetthfny ghw ponohkbktoieaon rhcoeissuppkrt t`es eithrprhtoteki (Ahntes, Net`ksphrcuc orvhish<
Ovolkv ?574). Et wos suppkshf t`ot `ucois whrh portnyrhspkisebnh gkr t`h oaaucunoteki kg cothreon gkuif eiOa`onlonole. Gkr t`es rhoski C.L. Mobuieo kphihf o thst petihor t`h orho eivhstemothf by O. Whluo. Ot 4.04 - ?.?4 c
bhnkw t`h rhahit surgoah `h gkuif orthgoats oif bkihs, efhitegehf os Beski sp., Hquus sþsshibkrihises, Hquus `epporek-
ikefhs, Feahrkr`eius htrusaus, Ora`efeslkfki sp., Corckto
sp. oif @kckt`hreuc. Onn t`hsh sphaehs, wet` t`h hxahptekikg @kckt`hreuc, whrh onrhofy likwi grkc t`es seth.
Qkch kg t`h necb bkihs whrh gkuif ei oiotkceaonakiihateki. V`es `of onsk bhhi kbshrvhf fureim hornehreivhstemotekis oif summhsts t`ot t`h cothreon `os, ot ckst,bhhi kiny snem`tny rhwkrlhf. Oi oifhseth gnolh wet` obrkof sarophr hfmh wos osskaeothf wet` t`h bkihs (Gem. 5).Et wos t`us hstobnes`hf t`ot Oa`onlonole es onsk oiora`ohknkmeaon seth. Ihvhrt`hnhss, t`h prhaesh rknh kg
`ucois ei t`h oaaucunoteki kg t`h gouion osshcbnomhrhcoeis tk bh eivhstemothf.
2.2.2. Vocoi, Lurmoi Aecbon
O iucbhr kg ponohkitknkmeaon seths orh likwi grkc t`hVocoi phieisuno bhtwhhi t`h Qho kg Oskv oif t`h BnoalQho (Whrhsaomei ?58=). Qoif quorryeim ki t`h hosthris`krh kg t`h Boy kg Vocoi anksh tk t`h Mrhhl aety kgLhpy, `os uiakvhrhf iuchrkus oiecon bkihs. V`h bkihswhrh ckstny bhffhf `krezkitonny, bkt` ei akimnkchroth oifei eithrvhieim soify noyhrs. V`h cojkrety kg t`h rhakvhrhfcothreon akisests kg gromchits kg nkim bkihs oif slunns.
oitnhr oif esknothf thht`. Whrhsaomei summhsts t`ot `ucoioatevety es rhspkisebnh gkr t`h brholomh kg ahrtoei bkihs(Gem. ?4,1-6).
"Qkch nkim bkihs kg chfeuc-sezhf oiecons, h.m. fhhr, orhgroaturhf ei o coiihr nothr proateshf by Ceffnh oif XpphrTonohknet`ea phkpnh... Akcporobnh groaturh potthcs orh skchtechsgkuif ki bkihs grkc Ceffnh Tnhestkahih fhpksets ei t`h AhitronWknmo rhmeki. @kwhvhr, tk foth wh likw kg ikt`eim akcporobnh
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 226/342
2?7 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 7. Fcoiese. Rhtkua`hf gnolhs (?-7) oif akrh (=). Qaonh ei ac.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 227/342
2?= WOQQENEJ T. NJXBEI OIF MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
Gem. =. Fcoiese. Akrh (?) oif oif phbbnh tkkns (2-6). Qaonh ei ac.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 228/342
2?0 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 0. Fcoiese. @ucoi coifebnh.Froweim N. Mobuieo. Qaonh ei ac.
trkc t`h whnn likwi Ceffnh Tnhestkahih seth ot Beikmrof ki t`hOpshrki phieisuno, w`hrh ckrh t`oi 18,444 fegghrhit bkihs `ovhonrhofy bhhi rhakvhrhf. V`h prhshiah kg stkih orthgoats ot t`h sethkg Aecbon wkunf bh oi ecpkrtoit eifeaoteki gkr o porteaunorny horny`ucoi prhshiah ei t`h thrretkry kg t`h XQQR" (Whrhsìomei ?58=o,p. 2?).
Qua` orthgoats `ovh bhhi gkuif ei t`h Aecbon pet oifpubnes`hf (Gkrckzkv ?578). Kih kg t`hsh es o gnolh wet`oi uigoahtthf streleim pnotgkrc oif o prkikuiahf bunb kgphrausseki, t`h kt`hr o fesa-s`ophf orthgoat (Gem. ?4,?-2< sGkrckzkv ?578).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 229/342
2?5 WOQQENX T. NJXBEI OIF MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
2.1. CEFFNH TNHEQVKAHIH AOWH QEVHQ (BU W.N.)
21.?. Ozya`V`es aovh nehs anksh tk t`h vennomh kg Ozya` ei t`h
gkkt`enns kg t`h Loroboa` Roimh ei t`h skut`host kg t`hNhsshr Aouaosus kg Ozhrboefs`oi (Gem. ?). V`h aovh nehs ot0(P) c KF (2(L) c obkvh t`h surrkuifeim orho). Et gkrcs o`krezkiton possomh kg monnhry-typh wet` o coei hitroiah
gkrchf by gevh a`ocbhrs oif o ikrt`hri oif skut`hrimonnhry. V`h tkton orho kg t`h aovh es skch 2,?84 c2.V`h seth wos fesakvhrhf ei ?574 by C.C. Mushjikv oifeivhstemothf by `ec kvhr o phrekf kg ckrh t`oi 24 yhors.V`h gerst thst pets ot t`h aovh hitroiah rhvhonhf o Ceffnh
Tonohknet`ea `krezki (Noyhr EEE), w`enh subshquhitny oiupphr (Noyhr W) oif o nkwhr Oa`hunhoi `krezki (Noyhr WE)whrh hxaovothf. Hvhi knfhr cothreon wos fesakvhrhf ei?5=6 (Noyhrs WEE-P) (Mushjikv ?578, ?50?, ?508). V`hmrhothst fhpt` kg t`h fhpksets wos ?6 c, t`h tkton orhohxaovothf akvhrhf 244 ir. Bhsefhs stkih orthgoats oifgouioS rhcoeis t`h ?570 hxaovoteki kg t`h Oa`hunhoi noyhrs
rhakvhrhf o jow gromchit kg o "Trh-Ihoifhrtonhr" (Mofzehvoif Mushjikv ?5=4). Ei ?5=? o sconn akiahitroteki kg bhorcoifebnhs oif slunns (t`h sk-aonnhf `efeim pnoah) wosfesakvhrhf, w`enh t`h hxaovoteki ei ?5=2 uiakvhrhf `hort`soif t ot ei ?5=1 o stkih ghoturh ("fwhnn eim").
Gem. 5. Oa`onlonole. Gthtkua`hf gnolh. Qaonh ei ac. Ogthr C. Mobuieo.
Gem. ?4. Vocoi. Gnolh (?), akrh (2), spnetthf bkihs (1-6). Qaonh ei ac. Ogthr O. Gkrckzkv (?-2) oif
I.L. Whrhsaomei.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 230/342
224 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Mushjikv (?5=6) efhitegehf ?4 noyhrs wet`ei t`h aovhshatekis (E-P), but et es uigkrtuiothny ikt onwoys pkssebnh tkakrrhnoth t`hsh wet` t`h strotemrop`y kg t`h "coei prkgenh",socpnhf by Whnealk, w`k fesahrihf ?= `krezkis t`hrh.V`hsh whrh ossemihf tk t`rhh uiets (Whnealk ht on. ?504):
Xpphr Xiet: (@krezki ? 3 Mushjikv's Noyhrs E oif EE)
Ceffnh Xiet: (@krezkis 2-?2 3 Mushjikv's Noyhrs EEE-WE)Nkwhr Xiet: (@krezkis ?1-?= 3 Mushjikv's Noyhrs WEE-P)
GouioGouion rhcoeis whrh ikt rhakvhrhf by net`knkmeaon
`krezkis but whrh ossemihf tk t`h ora`ohknkmeaon noyhrsopprkxecothny efhitegehf by Mushjikv fureim hxaovotekios "Horny Oa`hunhoi" (Noyhr WE), "Ceffnh Oa`hunhoi"(Noyhr W) hta. Os o rhsunt t`h gouio grkc hoa` kg t`hshnoyhrs es cexhf fuh tk t`h fegghrhit akifetekis prhvoeneimfureim t`h gkrcoteki kg t`h "noyhrs". Kiny t`h sconncoccon rhcoeis, w`ea` whrh aknnhathf by Qunhjcoikv(?5=5) oaakrfeim tk streatny fhgeihf net`knkmeaon uiets oif
oionyshf by Corlkvo (?502), `ovh o mkkf strotemrop`eaonprkvhioiah. Ei t`h gouion nest kg onn noyhrs tkmht`hr t`hrhorh 78 sphaehs, oeikim w`ea` ?? rkfhits, 1 nomkckrp`s,E ocp`ebeo, ? rhptenh, 6 bots oif 2? berfs. Onn 78 sphaehs orhprhshit ei t`h fhhp "ceffnh Oa`hunhoi" Noyhr (W). Gkrckrh fhtoenhf eigkrcoteki obkut t`h gouio t`h rhofhr esrhghrhf tk: Onehv ?575< Borysielkv ?55?o< Mofzehv ht oe.
?5=5< Muårei oif Borya`ielkv ?50=< Corlkvo ?502 oifWhnealk ht on. ?504.
Gnkro
V`h ponyiknkmeaon eivhstemotekis kg Zhnelski oif
Mubkieio (?508) fhckistrothf rhphothf a`oimhs eivhmhtoteki grkc fhaefukus gkrhst wet` Tthrkaoryo, woniut,onfhr, bhha`, Zhnlkvo, kol, a`hstiut oif hnc (@krezkis ?=-?7, ?6-?1, upphr port kg Noyhr WE, nkwhr port kg Noyhr W),sua` os es gkuif tkfoy ei t`h nkwhr nyeim upnoifs oifvonnhys. tk upnoif gkrhst wet` bera`, Kstryo oif `kribhoc(@krezkis ?8-?6, ?2, Noyhr WE, coei port kg Noyhr W).Tknnhi grkc t`h ora`ohknkmeaonny sthrenh Noyhr EW s`kws osubonpeih vhmhtoteki.
Net`ea OsshcbnomhQtkih orthgoats whrh rhakvhrhf grkc Noyhrs P-WEE
("Thbbnh Aunturh"), WE ("Horny Oa`hunhoi"), W ("CeffnhOa`hunhoi") oif EEE ("Noth Oa`hunhoi" oif "HornyCkusthreoi")
- Noyhrs P-WEE: ?07 geifs kg ockim kt`hr cothreonsquortz, seneaegehf nechstkih oif a`onahfkiy whrh hxaovothfgrkc t`h fhhphst noyhrs. V`h row cothreon akisesthf kgakbbnhs grkc t`h mrovhns kg t`h Luruêoj Revhr, 81 kg w`ea`whrh rhakvhrh,f akcpnhth, wet`kut oiy troahs kg groaturh. Et
es feggeaunt tk fhaefh w`ht`hr t`h rhcoeieim pehahs orh truhorthgoats (Gem. ??). Ot o akighrhiah `hnf ei Bolu ei ?508skch rhshora`hrs bhnehvhf t`ot onn pehahs whrh orthgoats,w`hrhos kt`hrs t`kum`t t`ot onn whrh ioturon, uickfegehfpehahs. O t`erf mrkup (wet` ockimst kt`hrs W.T. Njubei)t`kum`t t`ot skch kg t`h geifs cem`t bh phbbnh tkkns oifgnolhs. V`h a`oroathr kg t`h geifs oif t`h prkvesekion ioturh
t`h pubneaotekis colhs et ecpkssebnh tk akch tk o akianusevhfhaeseki rhmorfeim t`h orthgoatuon stotus kg t`hsh geifs.
- Noyhr WE: (ogthr Mushjikv ?508:?7-24, 11-17 oif oiucbhr kg froweims by t`h out`kr \W. N.S) (Gems ?2-?1).V`es noyhr wos eivhstemothf kvhr oi orho kg ?28 c2, w`hrh?054 orthgoats whrh rhakvhrhf. Qkch orh `hoveny whot`hrhoif `ovh rkuifhf hfmhs. Tkssebny t`hsh pehahs orh grkc t`bosh kg Noyhr W, w`ea` wos gkrchf uifhr wht oif worchiverkichiton akifetekis. V`h orthgoats orh coiugoaturhfgrkc nyfeth (?406) oif gneit (=54), o sconn iucbhr orhcofh kg soifstkih, quortzeth, bosont oif op`oieth). V`hosshcbnomh akitoeis akbbnhs (1=), tkkns (62= 3 22,7 %) oi
fhbetomh. V`h ghw akrhs (5) `ovh o seimnh streleim pnotgkrc(2) kr orh fesakef. V`h ???7 gnolhs eianufh ?17 bnofhs(?2,? %). O normh prkpkrteki kg t`h gnolhs (64-84 %) orhnkim (8-?2 ac wet` o brhoft` kg 1 ac) oif t`ei (nhss t`oi?,8 ac). 86,8% kg t`h streleim pnotgkrcs orh uigoahtthf,
1? % fe`hfron oif ?6% goahtthf (ockim t`h notthr t`hrh orh14 gnolhs oif bnofhs wet` geihny goahtthf, ora`hf pnotgkrcsV`hsh tha`iknkmeaon fhtoens onkih colh et uinelhny t`ot t`heifustry es horny Oa`hunhoi. V`es es akigerchf by t`htypknkmeaon akcpkseteki kg t`h osshcbnomh. Akorsh phbbnhtkkns orh rhnotevhny rorh. V`h a`kpphrs (?7) oif a`kppeimtkkns (8) whrh coiugoaturhf ki akbbnhs wet` kih geot oif ki
akivhx sefh, t`h wkrleim hfmh bheim rhtkua`hf ki t`h gnotgoah. V`h 0 begoahs grkc t`es nhvhn `ovh o voreobnhckrp`knkmy (hnkimoth-kvoths, ocymfonkef, noiahknoth oifrkuifhf kvoth). V`hy whrh coiugoaturhf ki gnot akbbnhs,w`ksh s`oph wos shnhathf ei krfhr tk secpnegy t`h coiugoa-turh kg t`h fhserhf geion gkrc. Os o rhsunt, t`hrh orh shvhronbegoahs w`ea` orh kiny porteonny wkrlhf, s`kwi by t`her normorhos kg akrthx (Gem. ?2). V`rhh anhovhrs whrh onsk gkuif.Gnolh tkkns orh prhshit ei normh iucbhrs (Gem. ?1). Qefh-sarophrs orh porteaunorny akccki oif proateaonny onn gkrcsfhsarebhf by Bkrfhs (?57?) orh prhshit. Qecpnh sarophrs orhfkceioit (5=)< onsk prhshit orh fkubnå sefh-sarophrs (11 - eiport coiugoaturhf ki bnofhs), troisvhrsh sefh-sarophrs (2?),
akivhrmhit sefh-sarophrs (?1) oif fåjhtå sefh-sarophrs (24).Tkeits orh, by akitrost, rorh (=) oif kg pkkr quonety oifeianufh 7 fkubnå pkeits (necoahs). V`h osshcbnomh onskeianufhs 26 hif-sarophrs, 6 bkrhrs oif o boalhf liegh.Geionny, t`hrh orh 72 fhiteaunoths oif ?8 ikta`hf pehahs.
- Noyhr W: V`es noyhr es subfevefhf eitk 8 `krezkisw`ea` yehnfhf iuchrkus gouion rhcoeis (78 sphaehs), but
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 231/342
22? WOQQENEJ T. NJXBEI OIF MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
Gem. ??. Ozya`, nhvhns P-WEE. Orthgoats (;). Qaonh ei ac. Ogthr C.C. Mushjikv.
kiny rhnotevhny ghw stkih orthgoats (ei ?508 Mushjikv rhghrstk 205 pehahs). V`h cojkrety kg t`h orthgoats, oif onn t`h
begoahs (Gems ?6-?8), whrh gkuif ei t`h ceffnh port kg t`hnovht, w`ea` wos fhsarebhf by Whnealk ht on. (?504:26) osgknnkws: "@krezkis (¼ oif ?4 orh a`oroathrezhf by `krezkitonnoyhrs kg nechstkih snobs, nhishs oif akiahitrotekis kg soifoif a`orakon oif o `em` prkpkrteki kg bkih gromchits. V`hpkssebenety t`ot t`hsh porteaunor ghoturhs rhprhshit o `ucoikaaupoteki nhvhn aoiikt bh runhf kut. Et s`kunf bhaiep`osezhf t`ot t`h `kceief coifebnh wos gkuif ei
@krezki ?4". Noyhr W (@krezki ?) onsk akitoeis o t`ealnoyhr kg `hort` cothreon oif t`h rhcoeis kg o stkih ghoturh
(shh bhnkw, "fwhnneim"), ei w`ea` kiny o ghw stkihorthgoats (coeiny sefh-sarophrs) whrh gkuif. V`h sconniucbhr kg stkih orthgoats oif t`h `em` prkpkrteki kgrhtkua`hf gkrcs summhst t`ot Noyhr W es a`oroathrezhf byhpeskfhs kg s`krt thrc kaaupoteki. Os es t`h aosh ot t`honpeih seth kg Akio ei Qkut` Ksshteo kiny `uiteim orthgoats(whopkis oif `efh-wkrleim tkkns) whrh brkum`t tk t`h seth.V`h row cothreon sphatruc es fkceiothf by gneit (65,6%
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 232/342
222 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. ?2. Ozya`, nhvhn WE. Begoahs. Qaonh ei ac. Ogthr C.C. Mushjikv.
`hrh, 6?,=% ei Noyhr WE) oif ikt by nyfeth (67,1% os normhny kg sefh-sarophrs (27), pkeits (2), hif-sarophrs (6),akcporhf tk 8=,7% ei Noyhr WE). Orthgoats orh onsk rorhny boalhf lievhs (1) oif o iucbhr kg fhiteaunoths oif ikta`h
cofh kg oifhseta oif kbsefeoi. Akrhs aoi `ovh het`hr o pehahs. Oi ecpkrtoit osphat kg t`h eivhstemoteki es t`hseimnh streleim pnotgkrc (7 sphaechis), twk kr ckrh oionyses kg ush-whor ki t`h tkkns kg t`es noyhr by Qahneislepnotgkrcs, kr orh kg fesakef gkrc (Gem. ?7,?). Gnolhs (?551). Vroahs kg whor whrh gkuif ki ?20 tkkns , ockimakcckiny `ovh goahtthf streleim pnotgkrcs oif o sconn w`ea` orh a`kpphrs, a`kppeim tkkns oif `oifoxhs. V`hiucbhr kg Nhvonnkes gnolhs orh prhshit. V`h ckrp`knkmy phbbnh tkkns whrh ushf gkr o roimh kg (coeiny `hovy-futy)kg t`h a`kpphrs (7) es ckrh uiegkrc t`oi ei Noyhr WE. V`h guiatekis, sua` os autteim wkkf oif brholeim bkih. V`h= `oifoxhs orh coiugoaturhf grkc nyfeth, 6 kg t`hc ki oionyses s`kws t`ot `oifoxhs whrh ushf coeiny gkr autteimcossevh gnolhs. Gnolh tkkns orh whnn rhprhshithf oif akisest chot.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 233/342
221 WOQQENEJ T. NJXBEI OIF MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
Y ¿ 3 Y
/ ^
uGem. ?1. Ozya`, nhvhn WE. Gnolh-tkkns. Qaonh ei ac. Ogthr C.C. Mushjikv.
- Noyhr EEE: V`h orthgoats grkc t`es noyhr orh cofh kgnyfeth (?=07), gneit (?251) oif kbsefeoi (?6) oif orhprkbobny noth Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea.
Qhttnhchit ghoturhs
- V`h "@efeim pnoah": O akiahitroteki kg gkur bhorslunns grkc Noyhr W wos fesakvhrhf ei o vhrteaon gessurh
anksh tk t`h skut` wonn kg t`h aeraunor a`ocbhr by Mushjikvei ?5=?. Et `os ahrtoei ghoturhs ei akccki wet` t`h "bhoraunt" kg t`h "Onpeih Tonohknet`ea". V`es akiahitroteki kgbkihs prkbobny `os ikt`eim tk fk wet` `ucoi oatevetehs.
- V`h "Fwhn nei m": O aeraunor stkih ghoturh wosfesakvhrhf ot t`h bosh kg @krezki ? ei Noyhr W. Et wosnkaothf ei t`h ikrt`hosthri port kg t`h aeraunor a`ocbhranksh tk t`h ikrt`hri wonn (Mushjikv ?5=6, ?5=8). V`es
"gkuifoteki" wos gkrchf kg nechstkih snobs oif, ei kihpnoah, kg fhhr oitnhrs. V`h struaturh wos prhshrvhf tk o`hem`t kg 24-14 ac oif t`h eiihr orho wos ?4 c2. O `hort`wos gkuif ot t`h ikrt`hosthri akrihr kg t`h struaturh(@hort` 6, shh bhnkw), grkc w`ea` o ?= ac t`eal noyhr wet`burit cothreon hxthifhf 6 c eitk t`h ahitrh kg t`h ghoturh(Mushjikv ?5=8: 06-08). V`es uifkubthfny eithrhsteim
shttnhchit ghoturh es uigkrtuiothny kiny prkvesekionny oifeiofhquothny fkauchithf.
- @hort`s: Bht whhi ?5=2-?5=1 o tkton kg gevh `hort`swhrh fesakvhrhf ei Noyhrs WE, W oif EW. Onn whrh gkuif eio pkkrny net port kg t`h aeraunor a`ocbhr, 26 tk 14 c grkct`h aovh hitroiah (Mushjikv ?5=6). @hort` ? noy 0 c bhnkwt`h surgoah ei t`h upphr port kg Noyhr WE. V`h `hort` wos eio s`onnkw fhprhsseki oif chosurhf 24 x 14 ac, wet` o genn
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 234/342
226 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. ?6. Ozya`, nhvhn W. Begoaeon (?-2) oif uiegoaeon (1) gnolh-tkkns.
Qaonh ei ac: Ognhr C.C. Mushjikv.
skch 8-= ac fhhp. @hort` 2 wos = c bhnkw t`h surgoah eiNoyhr W, `krezki 6, oif chosurhf 68 x 84 ac wet` o ?4 acE`eal genn kg a`orakon-nelh cothreon. @hort` 1 wos gkuif8.8 c bhnkw t`h ckfhri aovh ei Noyhr W, ot t`h bosh kg@krezki ?. V`es wos t`h bemmhst `hort` wet` o tkton surgoah
kg skch ?4 c2, ei t`h gkrc kg oi N. nts weft` wos ? tk 1 c.V`h upphr port kg t`h ghoturh akitoeihf o noyhr kg os` grkcbhtwhhi =-0 tk ?1-?= ac t`eal, bhnkw w`ea` wos o a`orrhfnoyhr 7-5 ac ei fhpt`. ]`hrhos t`h a`orrhf noyhr wos kghvhi fhpt`, t`h kvhrnyeim os` noyhr wos kg voreobnh fhpt`oif ei pnoahs opphorhf tk gkrc sconn penhs. V`h 27 ac t`ealfhpkset wos prkbobny t`h rhsunt kg t`h oaaucunoteki kgcothreon grkc shvhron shporoth `hort`s (Mushjikv ?5=6).
@hort` 6 wos gkuif ei t`h soch noyhr os @hort` 1, but noywet`ei t`h stkih ghoturh nkaothf omoeist t`h ikrt`hri aovhwonn. V`h `hort` chosurhf 24 x 64 ac oif wos fum skch?8 ac fhhp eitk t`h gnkkr. Et wos hiankshf by nechstkih snooif surrkuifhf by burit bkihs (Mushjikv ?5=6). @hort` 8geionny, wos gkuif ei t`h Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea nhvhn EEE,
@krezki 1, 1.8 c bhnkw t`h surgoah. Et wos fum snem`tny ei
t`h gnkkr oif chosurhf 64 x 88 ac, oif ets sefhs whrh neihfwet` nechstkih snobs. ]et` t`h hxahpteki kg @hort` 6 (eiseft`h stkih ghoturh) onn `hort`s, errhsphatevh kg t`her strotemrop`pkseteki, whrh nkaothf ot t`h soch pnoah wet`ei t`h aeraunoa`ocbhr. V`es wos ot o pkeit w`hrh t`h monnhry struaturh kt`h aovh aoushf o porteaunorny strkim froum`t (Mushjikv ?5=6
V`h `kceief coifebnh
Ei ?570 o gromchit kg `kceief coifebnh wos fesakvhrhei Noyhr W, @krezki 1. V`h pksthrekr port kg t`h bkfy kg tcoifebnh oif t`h nkwhr port kg t`h osahifeim rocus orhprhshrvhf. Kiny t`h t`erf cknor es prhshit< tk jufmh by t`h
grhs` focomh tk t`h pehah, t`h gerst twk cknors whrhprkbobny fhstrkyhf fureim hxaovoteki. V`h arkwi kg t`hshakif cknor es cesseim oif kiny ports kg t`h rkkts kg t`hgerst cknor orh prhshrvhf. O prhneceiory fhsarepteki kg t`hgeif by F.W. Mofzehv hcp`osezhf t`h rkbusteaety kg t`h jot`h sconn sezh kg t`h thht`, t`h pkkrny fhvhnkphf tourk-fkitesc oif t`h pkseteki kg t`h gkrochi chitones ot t`hnhvhn kg t`h gerst cknor (Mofzehv oif Mushjikv ?5=4). V`hoif kt`hr ghoturhs nhf tk t`h Ozya` coifebnh bheimfhsarebhf os rhprhshiteim o gkrc troisetekion bhtwhhi t`hnoth Ora`oit`rkphs oif t`h horny Tonohoit`rkphs oif, eiporteaunor, tk o akcporeski wet` t`h coifebnh grkc Couhroif geifs grkc Oromk (A`oretkikv ?505< Mobuieo ?552).
Foteim
O comihtea rhvhrson, eithrprhthf os t`h Cotuyoco-Brui`hs bkuifory, wos rhakmiezhf ei t`h nkwhr port kg t`hshateki ei @krezki ?8 (ot t`h nhvhn kg t`h "Thbbnh Aunturhgeifs). Ei t`h noyhr ecchfeothny obkvh t`es (@krezki ?6) otkkt` kg Cearktus hx mr. orvones skaeones, w`ksh hornehstkaaurrhiah es ot t`h tech kg t`h Bolu Vroismrhsseki ei t`hhorny Ceffnh Tnhestkahih gouion akcpnhx grkc Verospkn(Corlkvo ?502), wos gkuif. Beski sa`khthisoale oif Hqu
sþsshibkrihises, gkuif ei Noyhr WE wet` Oa`hunhoi geifs(F.W. Mofzehv ht on. ?5=5:??), onsk `ovh t`her bhst poronnh
ei t`h Verospkn gouio. V`h geifs grkc Noyhr W, eianufeimt`h `kceief coifebnh gromchit cem`t ckrh prkbobny fothtk t`h shakif port kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih.
2.1.2. LXFORK E
V`h Lufork aovh seths orh nkaothf ei t`h ahitron port kt`h skut`hri snkph kg t`h Mrhothr Aouaosus, ei t`hikrt`hosthri akrihr kg t`h Akna`es (Gem. ?). V`h aovhs nea
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 235/342
228 WOQQENEJ T. NJXBEI OIF MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
Gem. ?8. Ozya`, nhvhn W. Begoahs. Qaonh ei ac. Ogthr C.C. Mjshjikv.
anksh tk t`h trhh neih ki t`h snkph kg t`h Aosovon'sleckuitoei< Lufork E es nkaothf ot o `hem`t kg ?744 ei KF,274 c obkvh t`h revhr. V`h akccki mhihses kg t`h aovhschois t`ot t`hy orh ckrp`knkmeaonny secenor oif, ot osecenor tkpkmrop`ea pkseteki, pksshss secenor strotemrop`ehs.V`h aovhs, w`ea` kphi kitk o sthhp snkph ei o boy bhtwhhitwk refmhs, akisest kg `krezkiton monnhrehs. V`hy goah skut`oif `ovh oi ora`hf rkkg. V`her hitroiahs aknnopshf ei
oitequety. Kvhronn, t`her net`knkmeaon oif ora`ohknkmeaonshquhiahs orh secenor.
V`h Tonohknet`ea seths ei t`h Lufork aovhs whrh fesakvhrhfei ?588 by t`h Nhieimrof rhshora`hrs kg t`h Qkut`-KsshtehiHxphfeteki kg t`h Mhkrmeoi Oaofhcy kg Qaehiahs uifhr t`hnhofhrs`ep kg W.T. Njubei, w`k eivhstemothf t`h seths uiten?554, wet` o `hovy hcp`oses ki t`h Lufork E seth. V`hrhsunts kg t`h hxaovotekis `ovh bhhi prhshithf ei iuchrkus
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 236/342
227 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. ?7. Ozya`, nhvhn W. Akrh (?) oif gnolh-tkkns (2-7). Qaonh ei ac. Ogthr C.C. Mushjikv.
pubneaotekis, syit`hteaonny ei t`h bkkl Luforsleh phsahriyh
ponhknetea'hsleh stkjoile v Jumk-Kshtþ (Njubei ?504o) oifonsk ei pophrs by Njubei ht on. (?5=0, ?508o-b)< Njubei oifBorysielkv (?508), Njubei (?585, ?5==, ?50?o, ?50?a,?506, ?505, ?554, ?551o-b), Borysielkv (?5==, ?5=0,?50=), Borysielkv oif Fhflkvo (?5=0), Borysielkv oifBoroikvo (?501) oif Ihschjoikv (?505).
Qtrotemrop`y
V`h shfechits kg hoa` monnhry `ovh t`her kwi a`oroatar,eignuhiahf by nkaon gessurhs, hrksekion prkahsshs, goatkrs kghxthrion whot`hreim, fegghrhiahs ei t`h goaehs kgakithcpkrory shfechits oif t`h a`oroatar oif fhmrhh kgeignuhiah kg oiecons oif `ucois. V`es nhofs tk sphaeonakifetekis ei t`h genns kg t`h fegghrhit monnhrehs, w`ea` aoi
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 237/342
22= WOQQENEJ T. NJXBEI OIF MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
bh up tk ?.8-6.8 c t`eal, oif fhthrceihs t`h a`oroathr kgt`h net`knkmeaoS oif ora`ohknkmeaon `krezkis.
V`h fhpksens ei t`h hosthc monnhry orh portehunornyuiegkrc oif typeaon (Gem. ?=). Qex fegghrhit nhvhns akunfbh efhitegehf: nhvhn ? akitoeihf Hihkne t`eh oif ykuimhrgeifs. nhvhn 2 o ghw geion Tonohknet`ea oif Chsknet`ea geifs.Nhvhns 1 oif 6 orh Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea, nhvhn 8 (8o, 8b oif
8v) Oa`hunhoi, w`enh nhvhn 7 wos sthrenh. Fesakrfoiahsbhtwhhi skch `krezkis eifeaoth strotemrop`eaon mops, w`ea`orh t`h rhsunt kg hrkseki kg shfechits oif pkssebny onsk kgiki-shfechitoteki fureim aknf p`oshs. Ei offeteki t`hrh orhgoaehs voreotekis ockim syia`rkikus shfechits grkc t`haovh's hitroiah tk t`h eiihr ports, os whnn os nkaon voreotekisei t`h e`ealihss kg skch `krezkis.
Ei t`h Forl Monnhry t`h fhhphst Oa`hunhoi noyhr (nhvhn 8v)es up tk ?,4 c t`eal oif ei oi uifesturbhf pkseteki. Fureimt`h gkrcoteki kg nhvhn 8v oif t`h kt`hr Oa`hunhoi `krezkis(8b, 8o) t`hrh wos cua` krmoiea cothreon ei t`h aovh, gerstkg onn os o rhsunt kg `ucoi oatevety. w`ea` wos t`h skurah kgp`ksp`oth kg t`hsh nhvhns.
Gouio
Ontkmht`hr 54 sphaehs `ovh bhhi rhakrfhf grkc nhvhns 2tk 8 (Whrhsaomei ?58=b< Borysielkv ?5==< Whrhsaomei oifBorysielkv ?504o< Borysielkv oif Boroikvo ?502< Njubeiht on. ?508o< ?508b). V`h nkwhrckst Oa`hunhoi fhpksets(nhvhn 8v) akitoeihf ockimst kt`hrs Cearktus hx. mr.orvones, Coaoao an', synvoio, Xrsus fhieimhre, Feahrkr`eius
htrusaus broa`yahp`onus, Ahrvus an', hnop`us oif Aopro ag.aouaoseo, w`enh t`h upphrckst Oa`hunhoi nhvhn (8o) yehnfhf
Orveakno thrrhstres, n 'rsus sphnohus, Onahs onahs oif Rupeaopro rupeaopro.
V`h normhr coccon bkihs grkc t`h Oa`hunhoi `krezkisorh typeaon "leta`hi" wosth, wet` sconn gromchits kgnkimbkihs. Fureim t`h gkrcoteki kg t`hsh noyhrs t`h aovhwos oi kaaupoteki seth, ushf gkr o nkim phrekf kg tech. Eit`h Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea nhvhns (1 oif 6) t`hrh orh, `kwhvhr,coiy bkihs kg t`h oxeon slhnhtki oif rhcorlobny nhss bkihsgrkc t`h hxtrhcetehs< t`hsh bkihs whrh portny fhpksethfwet`kut `ucoi eithrghrhiah. V`h bkihs kg t`h CeffnhTonohknet`ea nhvhns portny rhgnhat o ioturon top`kakhiksh.Coiy bkihs grkc t`h Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea nhvhns orh miowhfby normh aorievkrhs. Ei t`h Oa`hunhoi nhvhns miow-corls kgpkraupeih (@ystrex) kaaur.
Coiy berf rhcoeis `ovh bhhi aknnhathf grkc t`hOa`hunhoi oif Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea noyhrs (Buraol-Obrockvea oif Njubei ?5=2< Buraol-Obrockvea ?504<Borysielkv oif Ahrhpoikv ?508). Gurt`hrckrh t`hsh nhvhnsyehnfhf o `umh iucbhr - ckrh t`oi 84,444 - kg ges`rhcoeis. V`hsh bhnkim wet`kut hxahpteki tk t`h Bnoal Qaosoncki (Qonck trutto nobrox). V`hsh soncki-gromchitsakisest kg ieeiehrkus n'ei-rofeoths rofoneo oif kt`hr ports kg
t`h oxeon slhnhtki but onsk kg vhrthbroh, `ypuroneo oif `hofgromchits. Vk jufmh grkc t`h bhtthr prhshrvhf vhrthbroh oif`ypuroneo t`h sezh kg t`h sonckis vorehf bhtwhhi 4,8 oif?,1 c.
Tknnhi oionyses
V`h pknnhifeomroc kg t`h aovh fhpksets s`kws ?6
pknnhi zkihs oif o iucbhr kg sub-zkihs, w`ea` rhprhshitport kg t`h Tnhestkahih oif @knkahih hvknuteki kgvhmhtoteki oif anecoth (Nhvlkvslojo ?504< Njubei ht on.
?508o). V`h Oa`hunhoi nhvhns rhgnhat 1 worc p`oshs(nkwhr port kg nhvhn 8v, nhvhn 8b, ceffnh port kg nhvhn 8o)oif 1 aknf p`oshs (upphr port kg nhvhn 8v, nkwhr port kgnhvhn 8o, upphr port kg nhvhn 8o). V`h anecoth wos hsphaeonnyworc oif fry fureim t`h gkrcoteki kg t`h nkwhr port kgnhvhn 8v.
Net`ea orthgohts
V`h net`ea orthgohts orh prhfkceioitny kg nkaonny kaaurreim
row cothreons (quort/.eta, onhvreth, nechstkih, snoth, gneit)w`ea` akunf bh gkuif het`hr os phbbnhs ki t`h boil oif eit`h thrroahs kg t`h Fzkfzkre kr os snobs ot t`h kutarkps kgnechstkih kr snoth. V`h nechstkih ihor t`h aovh akitoeisnoyhrs kg seneahkus snoth-nelh cothreon, ei ports troisgkrceimeitk onhvreth oif anoyhy nechstkih. Iki-nkaon row cothreonsorh kiny rhprhshithf by o ghw ponh, rhffes` oif rhf @eitsoif o seimnh kbsefeoi orthgoat (o necoah ei nhvhn 8v). Ckstkg t`h orthgohts orh cofh kut kg quortzeth (soifstkih),gknekwhf by gneit oif gneit-nelh rkals, onhvreth, snoth, oifnechstkih. V`hrh orh ecpkrtoit fegghrhiahs ei t`h rkal typhsrhprhshithf ei t`h vorekus nhvhns. Ei t`h fhhphst nhvhn (8v)ckrh t`oi kih-t`erf kg t`h orthgohts akisest kg bofny skrthf,
nkaon row cothreons grkc t`h snoth-nelh, anoyhy, seneaegehfnechstkih-shfechits. Ei t`h upphr nhvhns (8o, 8b) t`h rowcothreon-shnhateki wos bhtthr. Nkaon seneaegehf rkals orhprhshit ei sconnhr iucbhrs oif t`h ush kg onhvreths, snothsoif gneits eiarhoshs. V`h orthgohts kg t`h Oa`hunhoi nhvhnsorh a`oroathrezhf by o `em` phrahitomh kg rhtkua`hf tkknsoif orthgohts wet` ush rhtkua` (obkut 84%). V`h gknnkweimtyphs orh iuchrkus (Gems ?0-2?): a`kpphr, a`kppeim tkkns,begoahs, secpnh oif troisvhrson sefh-sarophrs, sarophr-nelhtkkns, ikta`hf oif fhiteaunothf pehahs, anhovhr-nelhorthgohts, necoahs. _ueiski-pkeits, treoimunor pehahs wet`ikta`hs.
V`h vorekus row cothreons wet` t`her fegghrhit lioppeim-a`oroathresteas rhsunthf ei o shnhateki kg sphaegea rkals gkrsphaegea tkkns. A`kpphrs, a`kppeim-tkkns, begoahs, sefh-sarophrs, anhovhr-nelh tkkns oif bem ikta`hf orthgohts(wet` Anoatki-ikta`hs) orh ckstny cofh kut kg quortzethphbbnhs. V`h orthgohts grkc gneit-nelh rkals orh sconnhr(shnfkc nkimhr t`oi 8-7 ac) oif ckrh aorhgunny wkrlhf.Qkch typhs - _ueiski pkeits, necoahs - orh kiny cofh
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 238/342
V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. ?=. Lufork E. Qhateki ei t`h hosthri monnhry. ?: bnoal nkoc wet` spkrofea oimunor stkihs oif
nechstkih bnkals< 2: yhnnkw-mrhy nkoc wet` iuchrkus s`orp-hfmhf stkihs oif normhr bnkals< 1: anoy-
rea`, pkrkus yhnnkw-w eth (@krezki 1o) oif mrhy-brkwi (@krezki 1b, 1v) nkoc< 6: mrhy-w eth, anoy-rea`nkoc wet` `hovy aorbkioth fessknutekis< 8o: Akcpoat, anoy-rea` yhnnkw-mrhy nkoc wet` mrhy-mrhhi
noyhreim< 8b: anoyhy akcpoat yhnnkw nkoc wet` skch rkuifhf, ikt cua` akrrkfhf nechstkih fhbres<
8v: yhnnkw-brkwies` nkoc, ei ports stkih-nelh by p`ksp`otesoteki< 7: brkwies`-yhnnkw soify anoy kranoyhy onvhret wet` whnn fhvhnkphf arucby struaturh, t`h upphr port p`ksp`otezhf.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 239/342
225 WOQQENEJ T. NJXBEI OIF MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
kut kg gneit. Kt`hr gneit tkkns orh secpnh oif troisvhrsonsefh-sarophrs. @occarstkihs, akrhs oif coiy akrteaon-gnolhs eifeaoth t`ot stkia lioppeim tkkl pnoah wet`ei t`haovh.
Ontkmht`hr t`hrh orh 8,444 orthgoats grkc t`h Oa`hunhoinhvhns (8o.b.v). V`h akrhs orh mnkbunor kr wet` kih streleimpnotgkrc os whnn os fesa-nelh. V`h gnolhs `ovh brkof, pnoei
- skchtechs akrteaon - streleim-pnotgkrcs, whnn fhvhnkphfphrausseki akihs oif bunbs. Aorhgun hfmh-rhtkua` - sthpphfrhtkua`, cormeion rhtkua` - es rorh oif kaaurs kiny ki skchsefh-sarophrs, sconn hif-sarophrs, esknothf necoahs oif_ueeeski-pkeits kg gneit (Gem. 2?). V`h hfmhs kg iuchrkusgnolhs s`kw errhmunor ush-rhtkua`. V`h ckrh t`oi 84 begoahsvory ei gkrc oif lioppeim-tha`iequh (Gems ?0-24). V`kshcofh grkc snoth-nelh rkals `ovh 'sthps' ki t`her surgoah os orhsunt kg t`h noceiothf struaturh kg t`h row-cothreon. Qkchbegoahs cofh ki @ot phbbnhs kr gnolhs orh kiny portnyrhtkua`hf. Qex vhry 'ora`oea', cossevh snoth begoahs whrhgkuif ot t`h bosh kg nhvhn 8v. V`her onckst rhatoimunors`oph wet` o snem`tny rkuifhf feston hif, colhs t`hcsecenor nk anhovhrs. Kt`hr begoahs onsk `ovh oi onckstrhatoimunor kutneih. Hsphaeonny whnn wkrlhf orh twknoiahknoth quortzeth-begoahs wet` snem`tny akivhx hfmhs oife`ei. ankremothf oif pkeithf feston ports. Kt`hr begoahs orhonckif-s`ophf. V`h anhovhrs orh nhss nypeaon t`oi ei t`hAkio aovh. Oi hsphaeonny a`oroathrestea gnolh-anhovhr wosgkuif tkmht`hr wet` 6 begoahs ei grkit kg t`h hitroiah kgt`h Forl Monnhry. V`h gnolh-anhovhrs onsk akcpresh skchporeeonny rhtkua`hf begoaeon tkkns w`ea` orh trophzkefon ott`h feseon hif. V`h phbbnh tkkns gkuif ei onn Oa`hunhoinhvhns oif ei onn ports kg t`h aovh orh ckstny cofh grkcquortzeth phbbnhs. Hsphaeonny iuchrkus orh uiegoaeonny
rhtkua`hf phbbnh tkkns wet` stroem`t kr akivhx wkrleimhfmhs. Ei offeteki t`hrh orh sefh-sarophrs oif pkeits os whnnos coiy ikta`hf oif fhiteaunothf pehahs.
@kceief rhcoeisV`rhh `kceief thht` (twk eiaeskr gromchits oif kih
prhcknor) whrh fesakvhrhf ei t`h Oa`hunhoi nhvhns ei ?585oif ?506. V`h gromchit kg o ceffnh nkwhr eiaeskr wosgkuif ei nhvhn 8b ei t`h Ahitron A`ocbhr (Zubkv ?504).V`h kt`hr twk geifs - t`h gromchit kg o phrcoihit eiaeskroif t`h prhcknor - akch grkc nhvhn 8o oif 8b kg t`h ForlMonnhry (A`oretkikv ?505).
Tonohkmhkmrop`y oif h`rkiknkmyV`h ponohkitknkmeaon rhsunts eifeaoth o festeiat a`oimh ei
t`h ocpnetufh kg t`h vhmhtoteki bhets. V`h voreotekis ei t`hgrhquhiaehs kg coiy normhr coccons, rkfhits oif berfs eit`h fegghrhit nhvhns oif t`h kaaurrhiah kg skch sphaehs eiahrtoei parekfs kg t`h Tnaestkahih ennustroth t`hsh a`oimhs. Eit`h Oa`hunhoi nhvhns, 8b oif 8v, t`h phrahitomh kg Ahrvus
hnop`us, eifeaotevh kg o gkrhsthf noifsaoph, es onckst tweahos `em` os t`h phrahitomh kg Aopro aouaoseao, o sphaehsw`ea` ei`obets subonpeih chofkws. Ei noyhr 8o Aopro
aouaoseao es cua` ckrh ecpkrtoit. V`h ecpkrtoiah kgAoprhknus aoprhknus, Corths, Chnhs chnhs, Beski hta. onskeiarhoshs fureim gkrhsthf p`oshs (Borysielkv ?5==, ?5=0<Whrhsaomei oif Borysielkv ?504o< Borysielkv oif
Ielknohv ?502< Njubei ?504b).V`h voreoteki ei t`h Tnhestkahih vhmhtoteki bhets es onsk
rhgnhathf ei t`h pkrteki kg bhors w`ea` rhprhshit t`h coeiport kg t`h gouion cothreon. Ei t`h nkwhr nhvhns, w`hrh gkrhst-sthpph akifetekis orh eifeaothf, =8-08 % kg t`h bkihs orhgrkc bhors, w`hrhos ei nhvhns grkc aknfhr phrekfs t`es es kiny14-68% (Borysielkv ?5==< Borysielkv oif Fhflkvo ?5=0).
V`h akcpkseteki kg t`h gouio ei t`h nkwhr nhvhn 8v, wet` Coaoao ag. synvoio, Xrsus ag. t`ebhtoius oif Feahrkr`eius
htrusaus broa`yahp`onus, eifeaoths o gkrhst-sthpph kr osovoiio`-nelh worc anecoth noifsaoph. V`es akrrhspkifs tkt`h rhsunts kg pknnhi oionyses. Tonyiknkmeaon foto os whnn os
t`h coccon gkssens eifeaoth aknf akifetekis fureim t`hfhpkseteki kg t`h upphr port kg nhvhn 8v oif o shakif worckptecuc ei nhvhn 8b. Ei t`h upphr port kg nhvhn 8v oieconskg t`h ckuitoei chofkw bhnt kaaur gkr hxocpnh t`hrkfhits: Corckto aouaoseao, Trkcht`hkcys sa`opks`-
ielkvh oif A`ekikcys muf. V`h worc anecoth fureim t`hgkrcoteki kg nhvhn 8b es uifhrneihf by t`h kaaurrhiahkg gkrhst fwhnnhrs (Aostkr gebhr, Mnes mnes, Aoprhknus
aoprhknus) oif oiecons w`ea` prhghr o worc anecoth(@ystrex).
Foteim t`h anecotk-strotemrop`eaon suaahsseki ei t`hLufork aovhs es o feggeaunt hithrpresh. Hornehr Xroieuc/V`kreuc chosurhchits kg t`h Oa`hunhoi noyhrs kg Lufork Eyehnfhf foths kg 284-144 Lyr BT gkr nhvhn 8v oif ??4+ ?4Lyr BT gkr t`h upphr port kg nhvhn 8o (Ahrfyiahv ht on.
?585). Akrrhspkifeim VN omhs whrh rhahitny kbtoeiaf byLunelkv: nhvhn 8v ei t`h Qkut` Monnhry 174 ¿ 54 Lyr BT(RVN 1=5), nhvhn 8b 184 + =4 Lyr BT (RVN 1=1) (Njubeioif Lunelkv ?55?). V`h foths kg Ahrfyiahv oif Lunelkvmevh o gerst eifeaoteki kg t`h omh kg t`h Oa`hunhoi ei t`hAouaosus rhmeki. Oi osshsschit kg t`hsh foths by kt`hrcht`kfs shhcs vhry ihahssory, `kwhvhr.
Hornehr o akrrhnoteki kg t`h nkwhr Oa`hunhoi nhvhns tk t`hCeifhn-Ress eithrmnoaeon (Njubei ?5=6< Nhvlkvslojo ?504)kr t`h Ress-]þrc eithrmnoaeon (Njubei, Rhimorthi ht on.
?5=0) wos prkpkshf. Ei t`h choitech ponohkcomihteaoionyses by C.O. Thvzihr s`kwhf o rhvhrsh comihtesotekikg t`h boson nhvhn 7. Os o rhsunt ihw pknnhizkihs whrhhstobnes`hf oif ihw eifeaotkr sphaehs sua` os Feahrkr`eius
htrusaus oif Xrsus fhieimhre whrh fesakvhrhf. V`hsh ihwkbshrvotekis fhcoif o aoutekus rhveseki kg t`h foth kg t`hnkwhr Oa`hunhoi nhvhns (Njubei ht on. ?508o). Feahrkr`eius
htrusaus, Xrsus fhieimhre oif Coaoao synvoio akcckiny
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 240/342
214 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. ?0. Lufork E. Begoahs. Qaonh ei ac.
kaaur ei t`h gouio Cksboa` E, w`enh Feahrkr`eius htrusaus w`ea` es a`oroathrezhf by Xrsus fhieimhre, Feahrkr`eius
oif Coaoao kaaur ei Nh Wonnkiiht (Njubei ht on. ?508o). htrusaus oif orveaknefs wet` rkktnhss cknors (OnhlshhvoBkihs kg Feahrkr`eius htrusaus oif Xrsus fhieimhre whrh ?5==) oif onsk t`h noth Monhreoi gouio kg whsthri Hurkphgkuif ot Bocchiton oif Jkalrec, @oimhibehthi oif (Ozzorkne ?501). V`h gouio cem`t onsk bhnkim tk t`hCouhr os whnn os Ioithrrh. V`h prhshiah kg sphaehs sua` bhmeiieim kg t`h host-hurkphoi Qeimen' gouio-akcpnhx.os Ceckcys, @kckt`hreuc oif Huanofkahrks summhsts Qecenoretehs tk t`h Lufork gouio, but wet` eifeaotekis kgt`ot t`h gouio grkc t`h nkwhr Lufork nhvhns akunf o fryhr anecoth, onsk hxest wet`ei t`h gouion cothreon kg t`hakrrhspkif tk t`h Verospkn gouio kg t`h Russeoi Tnoei, Oa`hunhoi nhvhns W oif WE kg t`h Ozya` aovh ei Ozhrboe joi
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 241/342
21? WOQQENEJ T. NJXBEI OIF MHR@ORF BKQEIQLn - V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
Gem. ?5. Lufork E. Begoahs. Qaonh ei ac.
Tonohkitknkmeaon omh osshsschits s`kunf bh aoutekusnyusaf. `kuwhr, ei vehw kg t`h sphaeon akifetekis kg t`hAkna`es rhgumh. V`h rot`hr snkw roth kg hvknutekiorya`oimhs wet`ei skch sphaehs `os bhhi strhsshf shvhron techs
onrhofy (Xrsus (nhieimhi - Xrsus sphnohus, Hquus sthikies -
Hquus ao`onnus) gkr t`h Aouaosus rhmeki, os whnn os t`hsurvevon kg skch rhneat sphaehs (Trkka`ktkio) oif t`hsphaeon hvknuteki kg t`h gouio ei t`es rhmeki (Mobuieo ?585<
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 242/342
212 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 24. Lufork E. Begoahs. Qaonh ei ac.
Borysielkv ?5==< Corlkvo ?502). "V`h rhoski kg t`es
akunf bh o nkim esknoteki kg t`h Aouaosus gouio"(Borysielkv oif Fhflkvo ?5=0) oif onsk t`h hxesthiah kgt`h Akna`es rhgumh fureim t`h aknf phrekfs.
V`h ponohkbktoieaon kbshrvotekis onsk eifeaoth o nkimhrsurvevon kg Tnekahih rhneats ei t`h Akna`es gnkro, akcporhf tkwhsthri Hurkph oif kt`hr Aouaosus rhmekis. V`h rhoskisorh t`h sphaeon anecotea akifetekis. gerst kg onn t`h `ucefsubtrkpeaon anecoth kg t`h Akna`es, w`ea` es stenn o stobnh
rhgumh kg gnkron rhneats (Akaehvo ?502). Os chitekihf horn
ei t`es pophr, t`h akrh kg t`h Akna`es vhmhtoteki akisestskg thrteory rhneats oif obkut 24% kg t`h Akna`es gnkro eshifhcea (Tovnkv ?560< Lknolkvslej ?57?).
Ei oiy aosh t`h ihw rhsunts shhc tk eifeaoth o `em`hr omkg t`h nkwhr Oa`hunhoi noyhrs kg Lufork E. V`h nkwhr porkg nhvhn 8v gkrchf fureim o fry-worc, pkssebny hornehrCeffnh Tnhestkahih, phrekf. V`h `ucef-worc subtrkpeaonanecoth p`osh (nhvhn 8b) cem`t akrrhnoth tk oikt`hr Ceffnh
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 243/342
211 WOQQENEJ T. NJXBEI OIF MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
Gem. 2?. Lufork E. Gnolh-tkkns. Qaonh ei ac.
Tnhestkahih eithrmnoaeon. But t`hsh foths orh prhneceiory, os
t`h sphaeon hvknuteki kg gouio oif gnkro ei t`h Akna`escolhs t`h akcporeski wet` t`h Hurkphoi bekstrotemrop`yfeggeaunt.
2.1.1. Lufork XE
V`h Lufork EEE aovh (Gem. 22) es setuothf bhihot` t`hhovhs Lufork E. EE oif W, ei t`h gkurt` nhvhn (grkc bhnkw)kg t`h aovh-systhc. V`h hitroiah es ot ?876 c KF oif 224-214 c obkvh t`h Fzkfzkre-revhr.
Tnhestkahih oif @knkahih shfechits orh 7-= c t`eal oifgenn 04-54% kg t`h aovh. Ei t`h ckst ecpkrtoit troisvhrsonshateki ?4 nhvhns akunf bh efhitegehf. Nhvhns 1-6 foth tk t`h
Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea. 7-0o orh Oa`hunhoi nhvhns. V`h corlhf`ucefety ei t`h aovh nhf tk seithr gkrcoteki, gromchits kgseithr bheim oi ecpkrtoit akcpkihit kg t`h aovh's fhpksets.
Gouio
(onnhr BoryQielkv ?5==. ?504, ?50=, ?55?o< Borysielkvoif Fhflkvo ?5=0< Whrhsìomei oif Borysielkv ?504 b<Borysielkv oif Boroikvo ?502, ?501< Borysielkv oif
Ielknohv ?502< Borysielkv oif Ahrhpoikv ?508). Os yht
t`h coei port kg t`h gouio grkc t`h Ceffnh Tonohknet`eanhvhns 1-6 oif t`h Oa`hunhoi nhvhn 8 es fhthrceihf oifpubnes`hf. Gkr t`h kt`hr Oa`hunhoi noyhrs (7-0o) t`hrh orhkiny prhneceiory nests boshf ki fhthrceiotekis. V`h stenneiakcpnhth gouion nests (Oa`hunhoi oif Ceffnh Tonohknet`eanhvhns akcbeihf) akcpresh 64 coccon sphaehs, ?8 berfs,2 rhpteneo, 2 ocp`ebeo oif ? sphaehs kg ges`. Grkc t`hOa`hunhoi nhvhns =-0o t`hrh orh 21=6 fhthrceihf bkihs kgnormhr coccons. V`h sconn gouio `os ikt yht bhhi oionyshfyht.
V`h nkwhr Oa`hunhoi nhvhns (0o, 0, =) orh strkimnyfkceiothf by rhcoeis kg Xrsus fhieimhre prohluforhises
(Qphnohus fhieimhre prohluforhises) w`ea` rhprhshit ckrht`oi 08% kg t`h fhthrceiobnh normhr coccon bkihs. Bkihskg ofunt oiecons fkceioth. Whry bem upphr nost cknors,skch kg t`hc nkimhr t`oi 60 cc (conhs;) orh prhshit.Coiy cknors hsphaeonny grkc nhvhn 0 orh `hoveny tk vhrystrkimny wkri. Cenl thht` shnfkc kaaur - but grkc nhvhn 8vt`hrh orh ckrh t`oi 844 cenl aoieihs. Ei nhvhns = oif 0, osei t`h upphr Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea nhvhns grkc Lufork E.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 244/342
216 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
bkihs kg knf oiecons orh iuchrkus (Borysielkv oifFhflkvo ?5=0). V`h bhors fehf ioturonny, wet`kut oiy`ucoi eithrghrhiah.
Tknnhi oionyses
V`h ponohkbktoieaon socpnhs trkc Lufork EEE oionyshfhornehr aoch kiny grkc t`h upphr t`rhh nhvhns, grkc cothreon
hxtroathf grkc t`h nkimbkihs ei t`h nobkrotkry (Njubei oifNhvlkvslojo ?5=2). Ckrh rhahitny socpnhs whrh tolhiferhatny grkc t`h shateki L-Q, w`ea` rhsunthf gkr nhvhns ?-8ei t`h fhgeieteki kg ?? pknnhi zkihs (Nhvlkvslojo ?504).V`h nkwhr zkihs (?4-8) s`kwhf o rhphothf onthrioteki kgworc oif hknf p`oshs. Fureim t`h aknf p`oshs (arykchrhs)t`hrh whrh onwoys nhss pknnhi oif spkrhs. V`h kaaurrhiah kgakieghr pknnhi ei onn arykchrhs eifeaoths o ckrh `ucef oifaknfhr anecota fureim t`hsh phrekfs t`oi tkfoy. V`h nhvhnsgrkc t`h worc p`oshs (t`hrckchrhs) akitoei cua` ckrhpknnhi oif spkrhs. V`hsh pknnhi sphatro fegghr ei akcpk-seteki, hsphaeonny ei t`h prhshiah kg hxktea sphaehs os whnn ost`h OT oif IOT vonuhs.
Net`ea orthgoats
V`h kiny porteonny hxaovothf Oa`hunhoi nhvhns yehnfhf 5?orthgoats. Ei nhvhns 7 oif = t`h row cothreon es coeiny bofquonety nkaon rkal (gneit wet` gessurhs, seneaegehf nechstkih),but ot t`h soch tech t`hrh orh orthgoats kg mkkf gneit grkciki-nkaon skurahs ei t`hsh noyhrs. Ei nhvhns 8, 0 oif 0o kinynkaon row cothreons orh prhshit. V`hsh orh kgthi suetobnhsua` os soifstkih phbbnhs oif ei skch aoshs snoth.
O cojkrety kg t`h orthgoats grkc onn nhvhns orh gnolhs oif- hsphaeonny ei nhvhn 7 - gnolh-gromchits oif fhbres grkcnkaon gneit. A`eps orh rorh oif rhtkua`hf tkkns orh ikt
iuchrkus (?2-?1 pehahs) . Ckst kg t`h tkkns - begoah,prktk-begoahs, sefh-sarophrs, anhovhrtelh tkkns - akchgrkc nhvhn 8. V`h t`rhh "prktk-begoahs" whrh cofh kut kg onkw-quonety soifstkih. V`h orthgoats kg t`h ceffnhOa`hunhoi nhvhns eianufh twk gneit orthgoats grkc iki-nkaongneit
A`rkiknkmy oif ponohkhiverkichitOi eifeaoteki kg t`h omh kg t`h vorekus osshcbnomhs es
mevhi by skch obsknuth foths. VN-foteim kg shfechitsrhsunthf ei t`rhh foths: Oa`hunhoi `krezki 0o: 874 ¿ ??2
Lyr BT, t`h hrkfhf nkwhr port kg t`h Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea
noyhrs oif t`h troiseteki tk Oa`hunhoi noyhr 8: 282 ¿ 8?Lyr BT oif 268 ¿ 65 Lyr BT (Njubei oif Lunelkv ?55?<Njubei ?551o-b). V`hrh orh onsk twk Xroieuc-V`kreucfoths ki bkih cothreon grkc t`h nkwhr port kg CeffnhTonohknet`ea noyhrs ei t`h ?58= skifomh (Ahrfyiahv ht on.
?585): ??4 ¿ ?4 Lyr BT oif 04 Lyr BT.
Eigkrcoteki ki osphats kg bkt` t`h ponohkhiverkichitoif t`h omh kg t`h noyhrs es prkvefhf by t`h a`oimeim
phrahitomhs kg fhhr, ckuitoei mkot oif aovh bhor, oswkrlhf kut by M.G. Borysielkv. Offetekion eifeaotekis orprkvefhf by t`h ckrp`knkmeaon a`oroathresteas kg wkng oifaovh bhor. Ei t`h nkwhr Oa`hunhoi nhvhns (0o-=) fegghrhiaei sphaehs akcpkseteki orh sconn< t`h phrahitomhs kg bkihkg ckuitoei mkot, ei`obeteim t`h `em`hr ckuitoei rhmekisoif rhf fhhr, neveim ei gkrhsthf hiverkichits, es ckrh kr
nhss t`h soch t`rkum`kut t`hsh noyhrs. Ei nhvhn 0o oif =t`hrh orh skch bkihs kg ckrh gkrhst eifeaotevh oiecons suos bhovhr, pkraupeih oif nyix, w`ea` uiten ikw orhuilikwi grkc nhvhn 0. Offetekion eifeaotekis orh mevhiby t`h aorievkrhs. Grkc nhvhn = t`hrh orh twk coxennogromchits kg o sconn wkng. Boshf ki t`h nhimt` kg t`h uppaoieih (21 cc) t`es wkng wos secenor tk Aoies nupus
nuihnnhises kg Nuihn Wehn (Bkiegoy ?5=?). Os gkr t`h aovhbhor rhcoeis, et es kiny pkssebnh tk akianufh t`ot t`h thht`orh akcporobnh ei sezh oif struaturh tk Xrsus fhieimhre
prohluforhises (Qphnohus fhieimhre prohluforhises) kgnhvhn 8v kg Lufork E (Borysielkv, ei prhss).
Ei t`h upphr Oa`hunhoi noyhrs (7-8) aovh bhor onskfkceioths, but t`hrh orh skch fegghrhiahs ei t`h kvhronnsphaehs akcpkseteki: nhvhn 7 es a`oroathrezhf by t`hkaaurrhiah kg worct` eifeaotkrs sua` os Hcys krbeaunores
oif Xrsus chfethrroihus, tkmht`hr wet` onpeih sphaehs nelAuki oif Aouaoseoi turlhy (Vhtrokmonnus aouaoseaus).
Bkihs kg rhf fhhr orh ikt iuchrkus. V`h gouio kg nhvhn 8akitoeis bhovhr, pkraupeih oif Xrsus chfethrroihus os wos coiy bkihs kg rhf fhhr oif ckuitoei mkot. V`h cknorskg aovh bhor s`kw o akcbeioteki kg ora`oea oif hvknvhfghoturhs eifeaoteim o troisetekion gkrc bhtwhhi Xrsus
fhieimhre prohluforhises grkc Lufork E, nhvhn 8v oifXrsus fhieimhre luforhises grkc Lufork EEE, nhvhn 6v.
Ei t`h Oa`hunhoi noyhrs t`h aovh bhor fkceioths wet` 00= % (nhvhns =-0) up tk 52-50% (nhvhns 8-7), ei t`h CeffnhTonohknet`ea nhvhns t`es oiecon ottoeis ==,2% (nhvhn 6) oif=?,? % (nhvhn 1). V`h Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea nhvhns orh onska`oroathrezhf by fegghrhit phrahitomhs kg Ahrvus hnop`us
oif Aopro aouaoseao: ei nhvhn 6 Ahrvus hnop`us esrhprhshithf by ?0,1%, w`enh Aopro aouaoseao es kinyrhprhshithf by skch bkihs, w`hrhos nhvhn 1 akitoeis 8,5%kg Ahrvus hnop`us oif 7,5% kg Aopro aouaoseao (Njubeioif Nhvlkvslojo ?5=2< Whrhsaomei oif Borysielkv ?504bEi t`h Oa`hunhoi noyhrs bkihs kg mkot oif fhhr orh iktiuchrkus but rhf fhhr es hsphaeonny ei nhvhn 8 bhtthrrhprhshithf t`oi mkot.
Ckrh worct` fhcoifeim sphaehs nelh Coaoao, twksphaehs kg pkraupeih oif t`h htrusaoi r`eik kaaur ei t`hnkwhr Oa`hunhoi `krezkis kg Lufork E (nhvhn 8v), but orhobshit ei t`h Oa`hunhoi nhvhns kg Lufork EEE. V`esakrrhspkifs whnn tk t`h ckrp`knkmeaon ghoturhs kg t`h wkngoif t`h aovh bhor t`ot eifeaothf o ykuimhr omh gkr t`hOa`hunhoi noyhr kg Lufork EEE.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 245/342
WOQQtNEJ T. NJXBEI OIF MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
Gem. 22. Lufork EEE. Qhateki (K, - L, - C,). ?: Forl brkwies nkoc wet` coiy fhbres< 2: Mrhy brkwies`
nkoc wet` uiskrthf snkph-fhbres oif bem nechstkih bnkhs< 1: Tonh nkoc wet` chfeuc oif akorsh fhbresoif skch bemmhr bnkhs< 6: Forl mrhyes` nkoc ei pnoahs mrhhies`, wet` coiy fhbres oif nechstkihgromchits< 8: Akcpoat yhnnkwes` nkoc wet` fegghrhitny rkuifhf fhbres< 7: Uhnnkw brkwies` nkoc, anoyhyoif arucbny< =: Nhss akcpoat, anoyhy nkoc, mrhhies`-mrhy< 0: Forl brkwi arucbny nkoc wet` coiyfhbres, akorsh ei t`h upphr port< 0o: Brkwi nkoc wet` p`ksp`oth fessknutekis oif esknothf sconn fhbres<5: Brkwi akcpoat stealy anoy< ?4: Nem`t yhnnkw soify nkoc wet` mrovhns.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 246/342
217 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
V`h pknnhi oionyses hinormhs t`h pkssebenetehs kg foteimoif ponohkmhkmrop`eaon rhakistruateki. V`h gnkro kg t`hOa`hunhoi nhvhns kg Lufork EEE, stufehf by M.C. Nhvlkv-slojo, es fegghrhit grkc t`h hxtoit vhmhtoteki by t`h typhs kgaxktea pnoits prhshit. Ei onckst onn t`h socpnhs t`hrh orhpknnhi kg coiy rhmekion hxkteas, pnoits w`ea` kaaur tk-foyei kt`hr rhmekis ei t`h Aouaosus. Fureim t`h gkrcoteki kg
t`h Oa`hunhoi noyhrs skch kg t`hsh hxktea sphaehs whrhhvhi fkceioit - Tthrkaoryo sp. oif Testoaeo sp. ei t`ht`hrckchrhs 1 oif 6 kg t`h nhvhns 7 oif =. V`h akcpksetekikg t`h troisrhmekion hxkteas es onsk cuntegorekus: Ofeoituc
ag. phfoituc , ag Meimlk sp., (nhvhn ?4), Vsumo sp., Ahfrus
sp., Mnyptkstrkbus sp., Torrkteo sp., Aoryo sp., Kscuifo
aeiiockcho ssp.
V`h hxktea sphaehs voies`hf ei fegghrhit rhmekis eifegghrhit phrekfs oif et es t`hrhgkrh ecpkssebnh tk foth t`hshfechits kg t`h aovh by t`her hxteiatekis. Qkch kg t`harethreo wkrlhf kut ei whsthri Hurkph aoi ikt bh oppnehf tkt`h Aouaosus rhmeki. Tthrkaoryo, gkr hxocpnh, wos prhshitei Ahitron Hurkph fureim t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih (Zomweji?58=, ?571), but ei t`h Aouaosus et stenn bhnkims tk t`hckfhri vhmhtoteki. @kwhvhr, t`h `em` iucbhr kg hxkteas eit`h Oa`hunhoi noyhrs eifeaoths o `em` omh gkr t`hsh fhpksets.Oaakrfeim tk Mreaul (?502 Vob. 15) t`h phrahitomh kg t`hikrt`-ochreaoi, host-oseoi oif bonloiea-akna`efes hnhchitsei t`h ponohkvhmhtoteki kg t`h prhvekus Qkveht Xieki anhornyfharhoshs ogthr t`h Nea`vei Eithrmnoaeon. Fureim t`h CeluneiEithrmnoaeon t`hsh akcpkihits onckst fesopphor. Ei kurrhmeki t`h pnoits kg t`h Akna`es gnkro mevh ik omh eifeaotekibhaoush t`hy orh stenn prhshit ei t`h rhahit vhmhtoteki.@kwhvhr, t`h Oa`hunhoi noyhrs kg t`h Lufork aovhs akitoeio iucbhr kg ochreaoi/host-oseoi oif skut`host-oseoi pnoits:
Vsumo sp., Aoryo sp., Voxkfeoahoh, Mnyptkstrkbus sp., Huakcceo sp., Kscuifo aeiiockcho.
V`h akcpkseteki kg t`h gnkro es cuntegorekus up tk t`h hifkg t`h horny anecotea kptecuc ei nhvhn 8 (pknnhizkih P)(Njubei ht on. ?508o Vob. ?). V`h oitequety gkr t`hOa`hunhoi noyhrs es onsk eifeaothf by t`h p`ytkzhikshs (t`hfkceioiah kg rhmekion hxkteas ei fegghrhit phrekfs). Nhvhn 0okg Lufork EEE fespnoyhf sex anecotea a`oimhs (t`rhharykchrhs oif t`rhh t`hrckchrhs kg fegghrhit anecoteatyphs). Gkr t`h hif kg t`h nost t`hrckchrh t`hrh es o VN-fothkg 874 ¿? ?2 Lyr BT. Jufmeim grkc ets net`knkmy, nhvhn 0wos fhpksethf fureim o aknf phrekf. V`h nhvhns 7-= whrhgkrchf ei o phrekf kg anecotea voreobenety. O worc phrekf(pknnhi `krezki 1), hstobnes`hf gkr nhvhns 7-=, akunf akrrhs-pkif tk t`h @knstheieoi kg whsthri Hurkph. V`h pknnhioionyteaon foths eifeaoth o `em` omh gkr t`h Oa`hunhoi nhvhn 8,w`ea` nkwhr port aoi bh akrrhnothf tk t`h bosh kg nhvhn 8o otLufork E.
V`h ponohkitknkmeaon omh osshsschits kg M.G. Borysielkvoif t`h pknnhi oionyses kg M.C. Nhvlkvslojo eifeaoth snem`tny
fegghrhit omhs gkr t`h Oa`hunhoi `krezkis kg Lufork EEE.V`h fegghrhit kpeieki kg t`h ponohkitknkmest coy fhphif kt`h sconn sezh kg t`h hxaovoteki ei t`h knfhst Oa`hunhoi`krezki oif t`h rhsunteim sconn sezh kg t`h gouioSosshcbnomh. Ei offeteki t`h cearkgouio kg t`hsh nhvhns `osikt bhhi stufehf yht. V`h fegghrhiahs bhtwhhi t`h Lufork oif Lufork EEE gouios onsk rhgnhat t`h fegghrhit kremeis kg
t`h gouion rhcoeis. Ot Lufork E t`h oit`rkpkmhiea goatkrfkceiothf, w`enh Lufork EEE wos kiny rorhny vesethf by`ucois, oif es gerst kg onn o ioturon bkih oaaucunoteki.
2.1.6. Akio
V`h Akio aovh (Gem. 21) es setuothf ei t`h Fzovsle rhmek(Qkut` Ksshteo, Mhkrmeo) ki t`h skut`hri snkph kg t`hnechstkih ckuitoei Bub (Won'-A`ka`) ot oi ontetufh kg2?44 - 2?84 c KF, 284-144 c obkvh t`h vonnhy, oif 8-7 lskut` kg t`h Lufork aovhs (Gem. ?). V`h aovh hitroiah eskrehitothf QQ] oif s`hnthrhf tk t`h whst oif ikrt` byiorrkw rkal-spurs. Akio es t`h bemmhst aovh seth kg t`h
Aouaosus rhmeki, wet` hxaovotekis pkssebnh kvhr oi orho kg?.444 c2, kg w`ea` ?64 c2 `ovh bhhi hxaovothf.Tonohknet`ea geifs ei t`h Akio aovh whrh fesakvhrhf ei
?580. V`h gerst 2 x 2 c skifomh ei t`h hitroiah orho whitt`rkum` t`h t`rhh upphr noyhrs (Ihknet`ea, Chsknet`ea, CeffnhTonohknet`ea), oif t`h suaahss kg t`es wkrl nhf tk o normhhxaovoteki prkmrocc w`ea` geies`hf ei ?5=0.
Qtrotemrop`yV`h shfechits ei t`h aovh whrh hvhituonny subfevefaf
eitk ?4-?? nhvhns (Lonoifofzh ?574, ?57?, ?572, ?578). V`fhsarepteki kg t`h troisvhrson shateki f,-`e kbshrvhf ei ?57by O.I. Lonoifofzh shhcs tk a`oroathrezh t`h shfechitory
shquhiah goerny whnn (Lonoifofzh ?572) (Gem. 21). Et es tk bikthf, `kwhvhr, t`ot nothr ki o ckrh akcpnhx subfeveseki kt`h shquhiah `os bhhi prkpkshf (Vusobrocesvene ?5=0<?506).
Bhtwhhi t`h vorekus nhvhns t`hrh orh ckrh kr nhssprkikuiahf hrksekion ghoturhs. Hsphaeonny corlhf whrh t`hhrksekion p`hikchio ei t`h nkwhr port kg t`h shateki.Lknbutkv (?57?) kbshrvhf t`ot t`h nkoc kg t`h nkwhrOa`hunhoi noyhr akitoeihf o mrovhn `krezki 4,74 - 4,04 ct`eal.
V`h prkgenh akitoeis skch a`oroathrestea `krezkis w`ea`aoi bh akrrhnothf tk noyhrs ei t`h Lufork aovhs. Gerst kg onn
t`es akiahris t`h ora`ohknkmeaon sthrenh nem`t yhnnkw nkocwet` coiy nechstkih fhbres (nhvhn 6), w`ea` coyakrrhspkif tk t`h mnoaeon coxecuc kg t`h nost mnoaeoteki.Nelhwesh t`h forl mrhy nkoc wet` sconn nechstkih fhbresoif Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea geifs (nhvhn 8o) aoi bh kbshrvhf eit`h Lufork aovhs. V`h fesakrfoitny uifhrnyeim yhnnkwes`soify nkoc (nhvhn 7) gkrcs t`h tkpckst Oa`hunhoi noyhrbkt` ot Akio oif ei t`h Lufork aovhs, w`enh t`h nkwhr port
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 247/342
WOQQENEJ T. XXBEI OIF MHR@ORF BKQEIQLn - V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
Nhvhn
? 4,=7 c
2 4,=4 c
1
6 4,=8 c
8 4,85 c
8o 4,04 c
7 4,88 c
7o 4,68 c
7b 4,28 c
= 4,68 c
=o 4,18 c
Net`knkmy Geifs
@ucus, sken gkrcoteki
Brkwies` nkoc wet` nechstkih bnkhs Chsknet`ea
Uhnnkwes` nkoc Chsknet`ea
Nem`t yhnnkw nkoc wet` coiy nechstkih fhbres
Uhnnkwes` nkoc wet` nechstkih fhbres Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea
Forl mrhy nkoc wet` sconn nechstkih fhbres
oif ka`rh Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea
Uhnnkwes` soify nkoc Xpphr Oa`hunhoi
Nem`t yhnnkw soify nkoc wet` nechstkih
fhbres Xpphr Oa`hunhoi
Forl brkwi "rusty" nkoc Xpphr Oa`hunhoi
Mrhhies` mrhy nkocy akorsh soif Nkwhr Oa`hunhoi
Uhnnkwes`-rhffes` nkocy soif wet`
bem nechstkih bnkhs Nkwhr Oa`hunhoi
Gem. 21. Akio, troisvhrsoe shateki f?-`?, ogthr Lonoifofzh ?572.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 248/342
210 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
kg t`h Oa`hunhoi nhvhns akisests bkt` ot Akio oif ei t`hLufork aovhs kg mrhhies`-mrhy akorsh soifs wet` cua`nechstkih fabres (nhvhn =).
Gouio
V`h Akio fhpksets yehnfhf obkut ?8,444 oiecon bkihs,eianufeim rhcoeis kg nezorfs oif berfs (Whluo ht on. ?50?,
?50=< Burìol-Obrockvea ?5=?). ]ht sarhhieim fef ikt tolhpnoah, oif 55,6% kg t`h bkihs orh grkc normhr oiecons h.m.Aoies nupus, Wunphs vunphs, Xrsus sphnohus, Xrsus oratks,
Toit`hro sphnoho, Qus sarkgo, Ahrvus hnop`us, Aoprhknus
aoprhknus, Beski presaus, Aopro aouaoseao oif Kves ag.occki.
Ei t`her akcchits ki t`es gouion nest Whluo oif `esaknnhomuhs pkeithf kut t`ot t`h Oa`hunhoi nhvhns akitoeihfobkut =444 bkihs, vertuonny onn kg aovh bhor (55,?%).Ei t`h Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea noyhrs (8, 8o) t`h ockuit kgaovh bhor feceies`hf (72,? %) wet` ot t`h soch tech oieiarhosh kg ortekfoatyns (1?,= %). "Onn t`h cocconsrhprhshitaf ei t`h Oa`hunhoi noyhrs kaaur onsk ei t`hCeffnh Tonohknet`ea nhvhns" (Whluo ht on. ?50=:51). Kit`h kt`hr `oif, Auki os whnn os Qkrhx sp., Chrekihs sp., Nomurus sp. oif Hnnkbeus sp. kaaur kiny ei t`h CeffnhTonohknet`ea nhvhns. @ystrex es kiny prhshit ei t`h twkOa`hunhoi noyhrs (7, =), oif Onnoatomo sp. kiny ei t`hnkwhr Oa`hunhoi `krezki (=).
Tknnhi oionyses
Zhnelski oif Mubkieio (?508) akianufh t`ot t`h aovhwos ikt gor grkc t`h upphr necet kg t`h gkrhst bhnt ot t`htech kg t`h gkrcoteki kg t`h upphr Oa`hunhoi `krezki (7)(tk-foy et es ei t`h sub-onpeih zkih). V`h akcpkseteki kg t`h
upphr gkrhst bhnt wos vhry fegghrhit grkc t`ot kg t`h rhahitgkrhst t`kum`: fry snkphs `of oi kphi gkrhst vhmhtoteki wet`Phrkp`yths oif saotthrhf Aorpeius krehitones, w`enh ki sthhpsnkphs oif fhbres-akvhrhf snkphs Juiephrus wos prhshit.Fhaefukus trhhs (kol, copnh, os`trhh, hnc) whrh rorh.
Ei t`h fhhphst port kg t`h Oa`hunhoi noyhrs pknnhi whrhkiny shnfkc prhshrvhf (Whluo ht on. ?50=). V`h ceffnh oifupphr port akitoeihf o `em` ockuit kg trhh pknnhi, wet` peihfkceioteim (20-84%) oif spruah (1-7%), ger (1-28%) oifVsumo (2-0%) nhss whnn rhprhshithf. Fhaefukus trhhs whrhprecoreny rhprhshithf by bhha` (7-?5%), onfhr (7-?8%),bera` (?-8%) oif kol (6%). @kribhoc, nech trhh, hnc,`ozhn oif r`kfkfhifrki whrh prhshit ei sconn iucbhrskiny. Hsphaeonny eithrhsteim es t`h kaaurrhiah kg hxkteamhihro nelh Ayot`ho oif Fllskieon os whnn os Tkfkaorpus,
Ahfrus, Vsumo oif Voxkfeuc. Oaakrfeim tk Cocoaosvenet`hrh wos o cexhf gkrhst wet` fhaefukus oif akieghrkustrhhs ei t`h ihem`bkur`kkf kg t`h aovh fureim t`h gkrcotekikg t`h Oa`hunhoi nhvhns. V`h Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea nhvhns fefikt akitoei hikum` pknnhi, but t`h ora`ohknkmeaonny sthrenh
nhvhn 6 eifeaoths o anecotea fhthrekroteki. Fureim t`ot tech taovh wos setuothf ei t`h subonpeih vhmhtoteki bhnt (Whluo
on. ?50=:50).
Net`ea orthgoats
V`h stkih orthgoats `ovh kiny bhhi pubnes`hf ei o vhryprhneceiory oif shnhatevh woy. V`es rhvehw es t`hrhgkrh
coeiny boshf ki kur phrskion likwnhfmh kg t`h ?585-?57oif ?578 geifs oif prhneceiory slhta`hs.V`h Nkwhr Oa`hunhoi noyhr (=) yehnfhf kiny 14 orthgoa
gkuif ei t`h hosthri port kg t`h hitroiah orho (Lonoifofzh?572). Row cothreon wos shikieoi oif turkieoi @eit,skchtechs ormenet (Lonoifofzh ?578). Bhsefhs ?1 gnolhst`hrh orh "secpnh akivhx sefh-sarophrs oif rkum` autteimeistruchits" (Vusobrocesvene ?506:?2-?1).
Grkc t`h upphr Oa`hunhoi noyhr (7) t`hrh orh ?46orthgoats, ckstny tkkns (Gems 26-2=). Row cothreons orhormenet (76), oifhset (??), gneit (??), seneaegehf nechstkih (1)oif soifstkih (8) (Vusobrocesvene ?506:?1). V`h tkkns orhfkceiothf by begoahs (25 ei t`h stufehf shrehs kg t`h ?585?57? oif ?578 hxaovoteki< Gem. 26). ]et` t`h hxahpteki kskch pehahs kg soifstkih oif senegeaehf nechstkih t`hy whrcofh kg nkaonny ovoenobnh snoth (ormenet). V`h snoth-struaturhkg t`h row cothreon eignuhiahf t`h gkrc kg t`h tkkns. V`hsurgoah kg skch begoahs kg ormenet es `hoveny whot`hrhf oifrkuifhf. V`h begoahs whrh cofh kut kg hnkimothf gnotphbbnhs os whnn os grkc gnolhs, oif ckst kg t`hc orh nkimoif gnot (?8). V`her hfmhs orh stroem`t kr kiny snem`tny zem-zom-nelh. V`h nkwhr hif es kgthi s`orp, but skch pehahsfespnoy o t`ealhr "butt". Qkch begoahs orh boalhf. Nkim-ueoimunor oif onckst akrfegkrc begoahs fkceioth. Ecpkrtoorh t`h anhovhrs (?4< Gems 28-27), cofh kut kg nkaonny
kaaurreim rkals: snoth (8), quortzeth-nelh soifstkih (2),seneaegehf nechstkih (2) oif gneit (?). Os ot kt`hr seths, oifsurhny neilhf wet` t`her guiateki, anhovhrs kg mnossy`kckmhihkus gneit orh vhry rorh. Bkt` gnolh- oif begoaeonanhovhrs orh prhshit. V`h anhovhrs grkc Akio rhprhshit t`hbemmhst shrehs grkc t`h Aouaoseoi Oa`hunhoi. O ghw gnolh-tkkns orh onsk prhshit: pkeits, sefh-sarophrs oif fhiteaunothpehahs (Gem. 2=).
V`h strkim fkceioiah kg rhtkua`hf tkkns, oif t`h onckstakcpnhth obshiah kg gnolhs oif akrhs, uifhrneihs t`h sphaeona`oroathr kg t`es eivhitkry. ]h shh `hrh t`h rhcoeis kg o`uiteim aocp w`hrh geies`hf tkkns whrh ecpkrthf. Ei akitrotk bosh aocps, gkr eistoiah t`ksh efhitegehf ei t`h Luforkaovhs, t`hrh wos ik stkih-wkrleim ki t`h spkt ot t`es seth.
A`rkiknkmyEt es feggeaunt tk foth t`h Oa`hunhoi nhvhns grkc t`h Akio
aovh. Ei t`h nethroturh t`hrh es o ahrtoei thifhiay tk pus` etsoitequety boal ei tech. Lonoifofzh (?574, ?57?) anossegehft`h cothreon os geion Oa`hunhoi oif nothr os shakif port kg
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 249/342
215 WOQQENEJ T. NJXBEI OIF MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
Gem. 26. Akio. Begoahs. Qaonh ei ac.
t`h Oa`hunhoi (Lonoifofzh ?578), w`enh Vusobrocesvene(?5=0, ?506) spklh kg ceffnh Oa`hunhoi.
Oi obsknuth foth es kiny ovoenobnh gkr o stonomceth gromchitgrkc oi "upphr `krezki": 67 ¿ 6 Lyr (Xroieuc/V`kreuc<Ahrfyiahv ht on. ?577).
V`h a`rkikstrotemrop`y kg aovh fhpksets ei t`h Lufork-Akio-rhmeki fhphifs ki t`h akrrhspkifeim eignuhiahs kg
anecotea ksaennotekis ei t`h ckuitoeikus rhmeki. V`esphrcets o akcporeski kg t`h shatekis. V`h thcphroth(eithrmnoaeon) akifetekis fureim t`h gkrcoteki kg t`hOa`hunhoi noyhrs ot Akio oif ei t`h Lufork aovhs orhakcporobnh. V`h typknkmy kg t`h Akio Oa`hunhoi, `kwhvhr,shhcs tk eifeaoth o ckrh hvknvhf, ykuimhr Oa`hunhoi stomht`oi ot Lufork.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 250/342
264 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 28. Akio. Anhovhrs. Qaonh ei ac.
2.1.8. Vrhumkn 'iojo Aovh
V`h Vrhumkn'iojo aovh es nkaothf ei t`h whsthri port kgt`h Aouaosus ki t`h Boroioa` pnothou, bhtwhhi t`h Xruprevhr oif ets sconn trebutory Luvo ei t`h Luboi fhprhsseki(Gem. ?). V`h aovh es setuothf ot t`h necet kg t`h prhshitupphr gkrhst-bhnt oif t`h ckuitoei chofkws. V`h aovh wosfesakvhrhf ei ?507 by N. W. Mknkvoikvo. Ei o thst-pet
Tnhestkahih shfechits oif Tonohknet`ea orthgoats whrh gkuiV`h 1-6,8 c t`eal genn kg Vrhumkn'iojo aovh es akcpnhx
oif festurbhf by hrksekion prkahsshs. V`h hosthri port esakcpnhthny rhckvhf oif a`oroathrezhf by fhhp hrksekionpkalhts. Ei t`h nhss festurbhf whsthri port kg t`h shateki ?fegghrhit net`knkmeaon uiets aoi bh efhitegehf. V`h shatekiakisests gerst kg nkksh nkocy soifs, w`ea` orh feggeaunt tk
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 251/342
26? WOQQENEJ T. NJXBEI OIF MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
Gem. 27. Akio. Anhovhrs. Qaonh ei ac.
fegghrhiteoth. Kiny t`h phbbnh noyhr (7) ei t`h nkwhr port es omkkf corlhr gkr subfeveseki. Onn nhvhns akitoeihf pknnhi(Tksphnkvo oif Nhvlkvslojo ?556). Oiecon bkihs orhrhakrfhf grkc onn t`h Tnhestkahih noyhrs (Borysielkv ?554,
?55?b). V`h gouio grkc t`h nhvhns 1o-1b wet` h.m. Corckto
ponhkaouaoseao oif Qoemo sp. es typeaon kg oi kphinoifsaoph oif `os bhhi ossemihf tk t`h nost mnoaeoteki(Borysielkv ?55?b). V`h rhcoeis kg t`h nhvhns 6-= rhprhshitoi eithrmnoaeon gouio wet` Orveakno aoiteoio (3 O. thrrhstres
aoiteoio), Xrsus fhieimhre, Qthp`oikr`eius htrusaus
broa`yahp`onus, Ahrvus hnop`us oakrkiotus oif Beski
sanekataisoale, o gouio eifeaotevh kg o wkkfhf hiverkichit.
Bkihs kg rhf fhhr fkceioth. Hsphaeonny ei nhvhns 8b oif 8vt`h bkihs orh `hoveny gromchithf. Bhsefhs uifhthrceiobnhpehahs t`hrh orh gromchits kg nkim bkihs, rebs, oitnhr oifthht`. Coiy cknnusa stufehf by N.C. Nea`orhv, `ovh bhhi
aknnhathf grkc t`h nkwhr port kg t`h fhpksets (nhvhns 8-=):h.m. A`rkifruno trefhis, Ecprkveso pupkefhs, Chioa`o
aouaoseakno, A`rkifreio anehito aouaoseao, Tshufka`rki-
fruno tughreghro, _uofrepneaoto ommhsto ommhsto oifQp`yrofeuc fkneknuc.
Fureim t`h ?507-?554 hxaovotekis 220 net`ea orthgoatswhrh gkuif. Row cothreons orh mhihronny nkaonny kaaurreimgnot nechstkih phbbnhs os whnn os iki-nkaon gneit. Grkc nhvhn =b
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 252/342
262 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 2=. Akio. Gnolh-tkkns. Qaonh ei ac.
akchs kih gnolh, grkc nhvhn =o shvhi orthgoats (sconn gnolhs,t`rhh rhtkua`hf gnolhs). Grkc nhvhn 8v t`hrh orh 0 orthgoats(sconn, skchtechs rhtkua`hf gnolhs), grkc nhvhn 8b twk
gnolhs oif grkc 8o gevh orthgoats (gnolhs oif o sefh sarophr).Grkc t`h nkwhr port kg nhvhn 6o os whnn os grkc nhvhns 6boif 6v t`hrh orh ontkmht`hr obkut 54 orthgoats, ckstny gnolhs.V`h rhtkua`hf tkkns eianufh sefh-sarophrs, 2 necoahs os whnnos fhiteaunoths oif ikta`hf pehahs. V`h upphr port kg nhvhn6o yehnfhf shvhron phbbnh tkkns. W.B. Fkrkieahv subfevefhft`h geifs, eianufeim orthgoats grkc uiahrtoei strotemrop`eaonpksetekis, eitk twk fegghrhit mrkups, kih bheim a`oroathrezhf
by phbbnh-tkkns (Gem. 20 t`h kt`hr by gnolhs (Gem. 25). Ei kukpeieki `h cem`t `ovh kvhrhstecothf t`h ecpkrtoiah kgNkwhr Tonohknet`ea stkih orthgoats by summhsteim t`h gkrchr
hxesthiah kg twk fegghrhit aunturon trofetekis.
6. Akianuseki (by W.N. oif M.B.)
V`h knfhst seth kg t`h Aouaosus rhmeki, ot t`h soch techkih kg t`h knfhst prkkgs kg `ucoi kaaupoteki ei Huroseo, esFcoiese ei Qkut`hri Mhkrmeo. nts prkpkshf omh kg ?.0=-?.7= Cyr BT (t`h tech kg t`h Knfuvoe-Hvhit) es boshf kit`h rhsunts kg obsknuth foteim cht`kfs, ponohkcomihtea
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 253/342
261 WOQQENX T. NJXBEI OIF MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
Gem. 20. Vrhumkn'iojo. Begoahs. Qaonh 2:1.
stufehs oif ki bekserotemrop`eaon hvefhiah. V`h normhr onn a`oroathrezhf by hxthisevh ponohkitknkmeaon cothreon.oiecons eianufeim Ora`efeslkfki chrefekiones, Hquus Hsphaeonny ot Oa`onlonole et aoi bh s`kwi t`ot `ucoisstaeekies. Aiezannae oif Qtitt/eek pkeit tk o sovoiio`-nelh porteaepothf ei t`h gkrcoteki kg t`h bkih oaaucunoteki.noifsaoph. V`h kimkeim wkrl wenn mevh offetekion @hrh tkk, guturh hxaovotekis wenn yehnf ihw rhsunts akiahr-eigkrcoteki ki hiverkichit oif t`h woy kg negh kg t`h ieim foteim, hiverkichit oif subsesthiah.`kceiefs t`hrh. V`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea aovh seths kg t`h Aouaosus rhmeki
V`h geifs kg Vocoi oif Oa`onlonole orh fothf tk t`h foth tk t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih. V`h geifs grkc t`h nkwhrHorny - Ceffnh Tnhestkahih troiseteki. Bkt` seths orh gerst kg nhvhns (WEE-P) kg Ozya` orh ikt kbvekusny orthgoats. V`h
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 254/342
266 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gem. 25. Vrhumkn'iojo. Gnolh-tkkns. Qaonh ei ac. Ogthr W.B. Fkrkieahv.
knfast ora`ohknkmeaon osshcbnomh akchs grkc nhvhn 8v otLufork, w`hrh Coaoao ag. synvoio, Aoies ag htrusaus,
Xrsus fhieimhre oif Feahrkr`eius htrusaus broa`yahp`onus
pkeit tk oi knfhr stomh kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih.V`h kiny prhneceiory likwi fhhphr nhvhns (6-=) kg
Vrhumkn'iojo aovh (eianufeim Orveakno aoiteoio, Feahrk
r`eius htrusaus broa`yahp`onus, Beski sa`khthisoale oifXrsus fhieimhre) os whnn os Ozya` nhvhn WE (wet` Feahrk
r`eius htrusaus broa`yahp`onus, Feahrkr`eius chrale,
Hquus sþsshibkrihises, Beski sa`khthisoale) coy bh
ossemihf tk o ceffnh stomh kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih.V`h upphr Oa`hunhoi noyhrs kg Ozya` (nhvhn W, wet` t`h
`ucoi jow bkih) oif Lufork (nhvhns 8o oif 8b) foth tk onothr port kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, os eifeaothf by t`hgouio, stkih lioppeim-tha`iequh (Nhvonnkes) oif tkkn-typhs(gnolh-anhovhrs). V`es es onsk t`h aosh ot Lufork EEE oif Aki
Onn Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea geifs kg t`h Aouaosus rhmekibhnkim tk worchr phrekfs w`hi t`h ihem`bkureim rhmekis t`h seths whrh gkrhsthf. V`es es t`h aosh ot Lufork ot oiontetufh kg ?744 c KF oif hvhi ot Akio, ot 2?44 c KF.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 255/342
268 WOQQ?N?J T. NJXBEI OIF MneR@ORF BKQEIQLE - V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
ikth
E O. Whluo oif N. Mobuieo efhitegehf t`h gknnkweim sphaehs otFcoiese (Whluo oif Mobuieo ?55?. O. Whluo ei prhs s): Vhstufk
s^^. E eeahrto sp., Qtrut`ek fwoieshises, @ypknomXQ broa`ymiot`us,
('oite htrusaus. E 'rset.s htrusaus, Xrsus sp., Corths sp., Toa`y-
arkauto phrrehre, Toa`yarkauto sp., @kckt`hreuc arhiotefhis,
Chmoithrhki chmoithrhki, Ora`efeslkfki chrefekiones, Feahrk-
r`eius htrusaus htrusaus, Hquus ag. sthikies, Hquus ogg. ontefhis,
Qus sp., Foco ogg. ihstee, Ahrvus phrrehre, Huanofkaarks ag.shihzhises, Ahrvus sp. (hx mr. Orvhrikahrks orfhe), Fcoiesebks
mhkrmeaus, Mozhnno sp., Qkhrmhneo sp., Kves sp.
rhghrhiahs
Onhlshhvo, E..E. ?5== Vhrekgouio roiihmk oitrkpkmhio Wkstkaikj Hvrkpy, Vrufy Mhknkmeh. Eist. OI QQQR 144,25-66.
Onehv, Q.G.
Outnhv, T.X.
Ovolkv, M.Q.
Ozzorkne, O.
Borysielkv, M.G.
?575 Gouio Ozya`slkjponhkneteghslkj stkjoile. Ovtkrhghrot. Fesshrt . loif. bekn. ioul. Bolu.
?571 Obofzha`slojo iezihponhkneteghslojo stkjoilo. Cojlkp.
?574 K ioa`kflh lorloso e vkrkbhjielo v iezihghtvhrtegiya` kzhriya` ktekzhiejoa` Juzikj
Mruzee. Fklnofy OI QQQR ?18.
?501 _uothriory coccons oif t`h "hif-Wen nogroia`eoi" fesphrson hvhit - o turieim pkeit ei t`h`estkry kg Huroseo, Tonohkmhkmrop`y, Tonohkanecoth, Tonohkhaknkmy OO, ??=-?15.
?5== Trerkfiojo kbstoikvlo e gouio cnhlkpetojusaea` Ahitron 'ikmk Lovlozo v pkzfihc oitrkpkmhih, Ezvhstejo Wshskjuzikmk Mhkmrogeahslkmk kbsahstvo, 267-286.
?5=0 Lroziyh vknle Lovlozo, Vrufy Zkknkmeghslkmk Eist. OI QQQR =5, =5-54.
?504 Qurkl v ponhkneth Lovlozo. Cnhlkpetojusìeh Wkstkaikj Hvrkpy v oitrkpkmhih, Vrufy
Zkknkmeghslkmk Eist. OI QQQR 51, 84-85.
?50= Cnhlkpetojusìeh Lovlozo v hpka`u roiihmk ponhkneto, Vrufy Zkknkmeghslkmk Eist. OI
QQQR ?70, 1-24.
?505 Nhs coccegàrhs fu Tonåkne t`equh eigårehur fu Aouaosh, N'Oit`rkpknkmeh 51, 0?1-014.
?554 Coccons grkc t`h Oa`hunhoi Qeth kg Vrhumkn'ioyo Aovh ei t`h Ikrt` Aouaosus (XQQR), Obstroats kg t`h se.xt` eithri. Akighr. gkr Ora`ohkzkknkmy.
?55?o Xrsus chfethrroihus v pnhjstkahih Lovlozo e zochaoiejo pk estkree chnlea` chfvhfhjHvrozee. Tonhkthreknkmeahsleh essnhfkvoiejo gouiy QQQR, Vrufy Zkknkmeghslkmk Eist. OI
QQQR 210, 1-74.
BoryQielkv, M.G.,?.?. Fhflkvo
?55?b Gouio oshn'slkj stkjoile v phsahrh "Vrh umkn 'ioj o" io Qhvhrikc Lovlozh, WE. lkkrfeio-
aekiikh skvhsgoieh pk ezughieju cockitkv e cockitkvkj gouiy, ??-?2.
ei prhss Aovh bhors grkc Tonhknet`ea kg Mrhot Aouaosus.
?5=0 Thsahriyh chfvhfy Bkn'skmk Lovlozo. Qesthcotelo e ckrgknkmejo cnhlkpetojusaea`,Vrufy Zkknkmeghslkmk Eist. OI QQQR =8, 75-==.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 256/342
267 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Borysielkv, M.G.,O.E. Ielknohv
Borysielkv, M.G.,M.E. Buruikvo
Borysielkv, M.G.,M.K. Ahrhpoikv
Bkiegoy, C.-G.
?502 Kstotle bnomkrkfikmk knhijo ez ponhkneteahslea` stkjoikl Lufork io Lovlozh, Cocki-
tkvojo gouio ozeotslkj aoste QQQR, =1-05.
?502 K ioa`kflh felkbrozo Weikmrofkvo v ponhkneth Lovlozo. Ckrgknkmejo e sesthcotelocnhlkpetojusaea`, Vruany Zkkn k meg h slk mk Eist. OI QQQR ??8, 67-81.
?501 Mryzuiy roiihmk ponhkneto Bkn'skmk Lovlozo. Gouio, sesthcotelo e beknkmejocnhlkpetojusaea`, Vrufy Zkknkmenhslkmk nist. OI QQQR ??5, ?44- ?10.
?508 Tteay Bkn'skmk Lovlozo hpka`e ponhkneto e chzkneto, Krietknkmejo 24, ?15-?74.
?5=? Aorievkrhs quothrioerhs fu Quf-Hst fh no Groiah, Chc. Cus. @esn. Iotur. Qhr. A 2?/2, 61==.
Bkrfhs, G.
Bkseisle, M.,V. Bumeoiesvene,I. Cmhnofzh,C. Iekrofzh,
F. Vusobrocesvene
?57? Vypknkmeh fu Tonåknet`equh oiaehi ht ckyhi. Bkrfhoux.
?55? Qtheiorthgolth. Ei: W. Fzoporefzh, M. Bkseisle ht on. ?55?, 51-?4=.
Bkseisle, M.,F. Nkrflepoiefzh.M. Cojsurofzh,C. VvonArhnefzh
?55? Feh Obnomhruimhi oug fhr Bosontnovo. Ei: W. Fzoporefzh, M. Bkseisle ht on. ?55?, =7-01
Bumeoieþvene, V.W. ?5=5 Iezihponhkneteahsleh pocjotiele Morh-Loa`htslkmk pnkslkmkr'jo, Cothreony pk ora`hknkm
Mruzee e Lovlozo 0, 74-00.
Buraol-Obrockvea, O.E. ?5=? Cothreony l ezuahieju pnhjstkahikvya` ptea Mruzee (Thsahro Akio), Tonhkitknkmeahslej
sbkriel =/2, 1=-60.
Buraol-Obrockvea, O.E.,W.T. Njubei
Buraol-ObrockveÀ, O.E.,Q.F. Onehv
Ahplei, H.O.
Ahrfyiahv, W.W.,I.Q. Qtrosielkv.N.C. Tknjolkvo,V.E. Bkreshilk.R.Q. Hielhhv,Q.I. Ihuahskv
Ahrfyiahv, W.W.,n.W. Lozoahvslej, ht on.
?504 Kstotle ptea ez phsahry Lufork E. Ei: W.T. Njubei ?504o, 50-??4.
?5=2 Krietkgouio phsahry Lufork E (Zolovloz'h) , Qkvhtslojo ora`hknkmejo ?5=2/2, ?85-?76.
?505 Eslkpohcojo krietkgouio ponhkneteahslkj stkjoile Ozya`slkj phsahry io Conkc Lolozh vOzhrbojfzoih Cothreony pk hlknkmee ëevktiya` v Ozhrbojfzoih (Bolu), =2-04.
?554 Eslkpohcojo krietkgouio ponhkne teahslkj stkjoile Ozya`slkj phsahry io Conkc Lovlov Ozhrbojfzoih, Gouio, hlknkmejo e ka`roio zevktiya` v Ozhrbojfzoih (Bolu). 66-8=.
?504 Kstotle ryb ez phsahry Lufork E. Ei: W.T. Njubei ?504o, 54-5=.
?585 Kprhfhnhiyh obsknjutikmk vkzrosto ponhkneteahslea` stkjoikl Lufork e Lksthile, Kptelo. jofhriyh prkahssy (Ezfoieh Lozoa`slkmk Xievhrsethto, Onco Oto), 85-71.
?577 Ihrovikvhsiyj uroi v lorbkiotiya` ktnkzzhiejoa` e kprhfhnhiyh ea` vkzrosto, Mhka`ecej
?577/2,5-?7.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 257/342
26=
A`oretkikv, W.C.
AkAehvo. LE.
Fkrkieghv, W.B.
WOQQENEJ T. NJXBEI OIF KLR@ORF BKQEIQLE - V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
Feoporefzh, W.,M. Bkseisle,V. BumeoieQvene,N. Mobuieo,O. Justus,I, Lnkpktkvslojo,H. Lvovofzh,F. Nkrflepoief/h.M. Cojsurofzh.I. Cmhnofzh,
C. Iekrofzh,H. [email protected]. Qa`ceilh,Fz. QknkmoQ^ eee.
F. VuQobroceQvene,C. Vvonarhnefzh,O. Whluo
Ghfkrkv, T.W.
Gkrckzkv, O.O.
Mobuieo, N.L.
Mobuieo. E...O. Whluo
Mobuieo. E...
O, nn nsn n ns.O. Whluo
Mobuieo, C.,O. Whluo.C Vvonarhnefzh
Mofzehv, F.W.,C.C. Mushjikv
?505
?502
?50=
?552
?55?
?5=0
?578
?585
?552
?50?
?554
?551
?55?
?556
?5=4
Oshn'sleh mkceiefy io thrretkree QQQR. Fklnofy Cksl. kbsahstvo espytothnhj prerkfy,Kbsaojo beknkmejo, 2?-26.
Rhnelty pkzfihpnekahikvya` e pnhjstkahikvya` gnkr Lkna`efy e ea` strotemrogeahslkhzioahieh, Ahtvhrteniojo sesthco Mczee, ?4=-??7.
Tonhknet Loroaohvk-Ahrlhsee, Trkbnhcy oitrkpknkmee e ora`hknkmþ lochiikmk vhlo Hvrozee
(Erlutsl), 60-65.
Roiihoshn'slojo stkjoilo v Vrhumkn'ikj phsahrh, Wkprksy ora`hknkmþ Ofymhe (Coelkp),
?42-?16.
Fhr ontponoknet`esa`h Guifpnotz Fcoiese ei Mhkrmehi (Loulosus), Jo`rbua` fhs R÷cesa`-
Mhrcoiesa`hi Zhitroncushucs Coeie 17, ?505 (?55?), 7=-??7.
Tnhjstkahi Tkitk-Lospejo, Vrufy Mhkn. Eist. 1?4.
Lochiiyj vhl e hihknet Treluboi 'jo. Ckslou.
K nksofe ez Qomvorfzenh (Zop.-Mruzejo), Qbkriel Mhkn. Eist. OI MQQR, 271-2='?.
Fhr chisa`nea`h Xithrlehghr vki Fcoiese (Mhkrmehi, Loulosus), Jo`rbua` fhs R÷cesa`-
Mhrcoiesa`hi Zhitroncus. 15, ?552 (?558), ?08-240.
Vhrrhstreon coccons kg t`h Tnekahih oif t`h horny Tnhestkahih oif t`h bkuifory bhtwhhiIhkmhih oif _uothcory ei Mhkrmeo, XQQR, Gehnf Akighrhiah Ihkmhihn_uothriory
bkuifory, Eifeo. ?MAT 6? (Aonautto), 68-60.
N'åvknuteki fu ponhkhiverkiihchit ou akurs fh ?'Oit`rkpkmàih hi Mhkrmeì (Vroisaouao-seh), N'Oit`rkpknkmeh 56, 761-784.
Fcoiesslej eslkpohcyj ahnkval e skputstvujusaojo hcu gouio pkzvkikniya`. Vbenese.
Fhr chisa`nea`h Xithrlehghr. Ei: W. Fzoporefzh, M. Bkseisle ht on. ?55?, ?45-???.
Fhr ontponoknet`esa`h Guifpnotz Oa`onlonole oc Oceroies-Bhrm ec Fzovoa`hte-Mhbeht(Qþf-Mhkrmehi), Ora`. Lkrrhspkifhizbnott 26, 21=-264.
Thrvojo fnjo QQQR ioa`kflo oshn'slkmk ahnkvhlo (Ozhrbojfzoi, Ozya`slojo phsahro),Xghiyh zopesle Ozhrb. Mks. Xievhrsethto 1? , ?1-2?.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 258/342
260 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Mofzehv, F.W.,C.C. Mushjikv,O.W. Cochfkv,O.§. Qereikv
Mknkvoikvo, N.W.
Mknkvoikvo, N.W.,W.B. Fkrkieahv
Mreaul. W.T.
Mrkckv, E.C.,W.O. Gkloikv
Mrkssmhjc, O.O.
Muårei, A.,
M.G. Borya`ielkv
Mushjikv, C.C.
?5=5 Lrotleh rhsun' toty lkcpnhlsiya` essnhfkvoiej Ozya`slkj frhvihponhkne teahslkj stkjoile. /zv. OIOzhrb. QQR, shrejo ioul k zhcnh ?5=5/1, ?4-?7.
?554 Ikvjh iezihponhkneteahsleh phsahriyh stkjoile shvhrk-zopofikmk Lovlozo. TonhknetLovlozo e skprhfhn'iya` thrretkrej, Qbkriel, pksvjoQa'hiiyj ?44-nhteju sk fijo rkzfhiejo
Anhi-lkrr. OI MQQR Trkg. M. L. Iekrofzh (Vbenese), 18-17.
?551 O8hn' shvhrikmk Lovlozo, Wtkrojo luboislojo ora`hknkmeahslojo lkighrhiaejo (Lrosik-
for), 2=-25.
?502 Gnkro e rostet hn'ikst, Qtrotemrogejo QQQR, ÷htvhrteniojo sesthco ?, 11=-1=6.
?504 Kb kstotloa` pkzfihahtvhrteaiya` mryzuikv ez phsahry Lufork E. Ei: W.T. Njubei ?504o
=5-05.
?562 Feleh s-hfkbiyh rosthiejo Lovlozo. Bolu.
?567 Rostethn'iyh rhsursy Lovlozo. Bolu.
?50= Nh r`eikahrks oa`hunåhi fh no Mrktth Lkufork E (Mhkrmeì , XRQQ) ht Eh prkbnàch fhs
hspàahs rhneaths fu pnhestkaàih fu Aouaosh, Mhkbeks 24, 105-157.?571 Ozya`slojo phsahro - lrupiyj lorst e frhvihjsojo stkjoilo v Ozhrbojfzoih, Fklnofy OI
Ozhrb. QQR ?5, ?4-?6.
Mvkzfhalej, I.O.
\zcojnkv, Jo. O.
Lo`nlh, R.F.
Lonoifofzh, O.I.
?578 K rhzun't otoa` ora`hknkmeahslea` roslkpkl v Ozya`slkj phsahrh , Ora`hknkmeahsleh
essnhfkvoiejo v Ozhrboefzoih (Bolu), 7-?6.
?5=1 K tojielh ozya`oitrkpkv v oQhnh, Xghiyh zopesle Ozhrb. Mks. Xievhrsethto ?5=1/0, ?2-?7
?5=6 Kêome ozya`oitrkpkv bolu-a`ozorslkmk (ceifhn-ress) vkzrosto, Xnhiyh zopesle Ozhrb.
Mks. Xievhrsethto ?5=6/?, 86-71 .
?5=8 Ora`ohknkmy kg Ozhrboefs`oi. (Qtkih Omh). Bolu (ei Ozhrboefs`oies`).
?504 Ikvyh ora`hknkmeahsleh foiiyh k luruaojslkj lun't urh phsahry Ozya` v OzhrfojfzoislkQQR, ,/zv. OI Ozhrb. QQR, shrejo estkree,genkskgee e provo ?504/1, 75-06.
?50? ThQ÷hro Ozya`. Bolu.
?508 Frhviej ponhknet Ozhrbojfzoio. Bolu.
?571 Lovloz. Ckslvo.
?554 Mhknkmeahslkh strkhieh pnhjstkahikvya` ktnkzhiej vkstkaikmk Ozkvk-Ahrikckr'jo ,
('t'tvhe'neaiyj phrekf: chtkfy essnhfkvoiejo. strotemrogejo e hlknkmejo (Vonnei), 17-1=.
?50= Ki t`h Kaaurrhiah kg @eppkpktocus (Cocconeo , Ortekfoatyno) ei t`h Tnhestkaàih kg
Oa`onlonole (Mruzeieoi QQR. Qkveht Xieki) oif ki t`h Festrebuteki kg t`h Mhius eiQkut`-Host Hurkph, Zhetsa`r. mhkn. ]ess. ?8, 64=-6?6.
?574 Bosea rhsunts kg t`h wkrl kg t`h ponohknet`ea hxphfeteki ki t`h Qkut`hri snkph kg t`hAhitron Aouaosus ei ?585, Nhsskis ot t`h saehitegea shsseki kg t`h `estkeeaon Eistenuth kg t`
Mhkrmeoi Oaofhcy kg Qaehiah ?574, 7-?4 (ei Mhkrmeoi noimuomh).
?57? Rhsun'to ty robkty ponhkneteahslkj hlsphfeaee ?574 m. io juzikc slnkih Qrhfihmk Lovlozo Etkme pknhvya` ora`hknkmeahslea` essnhfkvoiej io thrretkree Mruzeislkj QQR v ?574 m, 1-=
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 259/342
265 WOQQENEJ T. NJXBEI OIF MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
Lelkfzh, Z.L.
Lelkfzh, Z.L.,E.F. Lkrefzh
Lnkpktkvslojo. I..H. Lvovofzh.F. Nkrflepoief/h
Lknolkvslej, O.O.
Lknbuekv, O.F.
Lkrkblkv. E.E.
Nhvlkvslojo, M.-C.
Njubei, W.T.
?572 Etkme robkt ponhkneteahslkj hlsphfeaee io juzikc slnkih srhfihj aoste Lovlozlkmk a`rhbtov ?57? m, Etkme pknhvya` ora`hknkmeahslea` essnhfkvoiej io thrretkree Mruzeislkj QQR v?57? m, 1-7.
?578 Akislojo phQahro e hh lun 'tu ro, ThQahry Mruzee 1, 12-17.
?575 Akisljojo phsahro e hh lun'turo, Oaths fu WE h Akimrhs eithriotekion fh Qphnhknkmeh
(Njubnjoio), 115-181.
?507 Begos-lknui v oQhnh Lovlozo, Whstiel Mks. Cuzhjo Mruzee 10, 88-75.
?5=0 Lrotlej ktaht k robktoa` prkvhfhiiya` Torovoislkj rozvhfyvothn'ikj ora`hknkmeahslkj
hlsphfeaee zo ?5==m, Ora`hknkmeGhsleh hlsphfeaee Mks. Cushjo Mruzee =, ?5-27.
?55? Wkrnourëmh Cetthenuim zur Tonokbktoiel. Ei: W. Fzoporefzh, M. Bkseisle ht on. ?55?, 52.
?57? Rostethn'iyj cer lkna`efy. Ckslvo.
?57? Mhknkmeahsleh e mhkckrgknkmeahsleh usnkvejo chstkioa`kzfhiej Jumk-Kshteislea`ponhkneteêhslea` stkjoikl. Wkprksy strotemrogee e phrekfezoaee ponhkneto, Vrufy lkcessee pk
ezuahieju ahtvhrteaikmk phrekfo ?0, ?45-??5.
?57= Etkme pjotenhtiya` essnhfkvoiej JoQtua`slkmk ponhkneteìhslkmk chstkioa`kzfhiejo,Qkvhtslojo ora`hknkmejo ?57=/6, ?56- 247.
?5=? L prkbnhch ezuìhiejo iezihponhkneteahslea` pkshnhiej ktlrytkmk tepo a rozruzhiiycluVturiyc snkhc, Cothreony e essnhfkvoiejo pk ora`hknkmee QQQR ?=1, 7?-55.
?504 Toneiknkme÷hslojo a`orolthrestelo ktnkzhiej v phsahroa` Lufork ? e Lufork EEE. Ei:W.T. Njubei ?504o, ?20-?8?.
?586 Tonhkneteìhsleh ioa`kfle v Jumk-Kshtee , Lrotleh skkbsahiejo Eistetuto Estkrþ cothr, lun'tury
86,65-7?.
?585 Wysklkmkriojo phsahriojo stkjoilo Lufork E, Ezvhstejo Wshskjusi. Mhkmrog. kbsahstvo 5?,?=1-?01.
?574 Iezihponhkneteahsleh pocjotiele Jumk-Kshtee . Tonhknet e Ihknet QQQR, Cothreony e essnh
fkvoiejo pk ora`hknkmee QQQR =5, 5-=0.
?57? Whra`ihoshn'slojo costhrslojo Fzrobhr (Orchiejo), Lrotleh skkbQthiejo Eistetuto Ora`hk
nkmee 02, 85-7=.
?575 Roiiej ponhknet Lovlozo, Trerkfo e rozveteh phrvkbytikmk kbsahstvo, ?86-?70.
?5=6 Trerkfiojo srhfo e ahnkvhl v pnhjstkahih Lovlozo, Thrvkbytiyj ghnkvhl e prerkfiojo srhfo,
?75-?==.
?5=8 Wkzkbikvnhieh roslkpkl phsahry Lufork EEE, Ora`hknkmeehsleh ktlrytejo ?5=6 m, 68=.
?5== Cust'hrsleh Lun'tury Lovlozo. Nhieimrof.
?5=0 Roslkple Luforslea` phsahr v Jumk-Kshtee, Ora`hknkmeehsleh ktlrytejo ?5== m, 608-607.
?504o Luforsleh phs÷hriyh ponhkneteghsleh stkjoile v Jumk-Kshtee. (Wkprksy, strotemrogee, hlknkmee,
a`rkiknkmee). Ckslvo.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 260/342
284 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Njubei. W.T..M.C. Nhvlkvslojo
Njubei, W.T.,W.H. Qahneislej
Njubei, W.T.,I.W. Rhimorthi,O.M. Ahrijoa`kvslej,M.G. Borysielkv,M.C. Nhvtkvslojo
Njubei, W.T..M.G. Borysielkv,M.O. Ahrijoa`kvslej,I.B. Qhnevoikvo
?504b Ihlktkryh etkme ezuahiejo netkmkstrotemrogeahslea` e bekstrotemrogeahslea` pklozothnhjluforslea` phsahr. Ei: W.T. Njubei ?504o, ?81-?87.
?504a Mhkmrogeahslkh pknkzhieh phsahcya` stkjoikl Jumk-Kshtee. Ei: W.T. Njubei ?504o, ?1-
?50?o Ieziej ponhknet Lovlozo (estkrejo essnhfkvoiej, kpkriyh pocjotiele, chstiyh kskbhiiks ee Frhviej Wkstkl e cerkvojo lun'turo, ?2-?7.
?50?b Essnhfkvoieh luforslea` phsahr, Ora`hknkmeehsleh ktlrytejo ?504 m, 648-647.
?50?a N'Oa`hu nåhi fh no porteh hurkpåhiih fh ?'XRQQ ht fu Aouaosh (cotåreoux ht quhnquasprkbnàchs), Oit`rkpknkmeh (Brik) ?5, 11-67.
?506 Roiiej ponhknet Lolozo. Ei: T.E. Bkreslkvslej (hf.), Tonhknet QQQR, 68-51.
?505 Tonhknet Lovlozo. Tonhknet cero, Tonhknet Lovlozo e shvhrikj Ozee, 5-?62.
?554 Qtkjoile v slon'iya` ubhzeQaoa`: sphaegelo e chtkfelo pknhvya` essnhfkvoiej, Lrotleh
skkCAhiejo Eistetuto ora`hknkmþ 242, 70-==.
?551o A`rkikstrotemrogejo ponakneto Lovlozo. Rkssejslojo ora`hknkmejo 2, 8-?6.
?551b No a`rkikstrotemrop`eh fu Tonåknet`equh fu Aouaosh, N Oit`rkpknkmeh 5=, 25?-250.
?5=2 Thsahro Lufork EEE. (Jumk- Kshtejo). Tonhknet e Ihknet QQQR, Cothreony e essnhfkvoiejo pk
ora`hknkmþ QQQR ?08, 28-64.
?5=2 Ikvyh foiiyh k iezihc ponhkneth Qkêuislk-Oba`ozlkmk Treahrikckr' jo. Bjunnhthi'
lkcessee pk ezuahieju ahtvhrteaikmk phrekfo 10, 00-50.
?5=0 Thsahro Lufork E, Ora`hknkmejo e ponhkmhkmrogejo roiihmk ponakneto Lryco e Lovlozo,
=7-0=.
?508o Thsahro Lufork E (kpyt lkcpnhlsikmk essnhfkvoiejo), Qkvhtslojo ora`hknkmejo ?508/1.8-26.
(Nubeih), W.T.,O.M. Va`hrieoa`kvsle.M.G. Borya`ielkv,M.C. Nhvlkvslojo.I.B. Qhnevoikvo
?508b No Mrktth fh Lkufork E (rhsuntots fhs rha`hra`hs pnurefesaepneioerhs), N'Oit`rkpknkmeh 0?85-?04.
Njubei, N.T.,M.G. BoryQielkv
Njubei. W.T.,K.O. Lunelkv
?508 Ka`ktieì'jo fhjothn'iks t' frhvihjsea` (oshnk-cust'hrslea`) kbetothnhj Lovlozo, Lrotleh
skkbQAhiejo Eistetuto ora`hknkmþ ?0?, 8-5.
?55? K vkzrosth frhvihjsea` ponhkneteahslea` pocjotielkv Lovlozo, Qkvhtslojo ora`hknkmejo
?55?/6, 8-0.
Cojsurofzh, M.,H. Tovnhiesvene,@.-X. Qa`ceialh.Fz. Qknkmosvene
?55? Tonokcomihtel uif Fotehruim fhr Bosontnovo. Ei: W. Fzoporefzh, M. Bkseisle ht on. ?55=6-=7.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 261/342
28? WOQQENEJ T. NJXBEI OIF MHR@ORF B4Q?IQLE - V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
Corlkvo, O.L.
CoruoQvene, N.I.
Ckrmoi, J. fh
Cuzhebkv, C.O..
C.C. Mushjikv
Ihschjoikv, Q.O.
Ielegkrkvo, L.W.
Kstrkvslej, O.B.,Jo.O. Ezcojnkv,O.T.Qàhmnkv ht on.
Toitìleio, C.Z.
Tovnkv, I.B.
Tksphnkvo, M.O.,(e.C. n.hvlkvslojo
Trosnkv, I.F.
Rkhbrkhls, ]’E ^oi Lkngsa`kthi
Qahneislej, W.H. (Q`a`hneislej)
Qahneislej, W.H.,O.B. Kstrkvslej
Qhnevoikvo, I.B.
Qereikv, O.Q.
Qunhjcoikv, C.B.
Veitenkzkv, Z.L.
Veitenkzkv, Z.L.,Q.Jo. Lepeoie.W.C. F/esloreoie.F.C. QeckieQvene
?502 Celrkthrekgouio ez ponhkne teìhslkj phsahrikj stkjoile Ozya`, Tonhkitknkmea'hslej sbkriel
?5. ?6-20.
?5=? Mhkckrgknkmejo Mruzee. Vbenese.
?545 Nhs stotekis prå`estkrequhs f'Onom`huz, Rhv. Haknh Oit`rkpkn. ?5.
?57? Ozya`slojo phsahro, X÷hiyh zopesle Ozhrb. Mks. Xievhrsethto ?57?/?, 75-=1.
?505 Thsahriyj mhihteahslej lkcpnhls, Bjunnhthi' lkcessþ pk ezu÷hiejo (htvhrtea'ikmk phrekfo
80, 07-57.
?502 Qtrotemrogeahslkh rosanhihieh e lkrrhnjoaejo vhra`ihpnekahikvya` e ahtvhrteaiya` ktnkzhiej,Trkbnhcy mhknkmþ e esnkree (htvhrtenikmk phrekfo (oitrkpkmhio), 17-05.
?5== Ikvyh foiiyh k strotemrogee e mhka`rkiknkmee pnhjstkahikvya` ckrslea` thrros Ahrik-ckrslkmk pkbhrhz'jo Lovlozo u Lhrìhislk-Vocoislkj kbnoste, Tonhkmhkmrogejo e
ktnkëhiejo pnhjstkahio juëiya` ckrhj QQQR, 7?-70.
?584 Tonhknet Orchiþ. Nhieimrof.
?560 Bktoieghslojo mhkmrogejo QQQR. Onco Oto.
?556 Ktrozhieh lnecoteahslea` ezchihiej v comietikj vkspreecaevkste ksofkaiya` pkrkf, Fklnofy Rkssejslkj OI 116/2.
?506 Mhknkmeahsleh e ponhkmhkmrogeahsleh rocle ponhkneto. Rozveteh prerkfikj srhfy io thrretkre eQQQR e prkbnhcy a`rkiknkmee e phrekfezoaee ponhkneto. Ei: T.E. Bkreslkvslej (hf.), TonhknetQQQR, ?=-64.
t`es V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: o rhopproeson kg orthgoatuon oif a`rkiknkmeaonvknuch hvefhiah.
?551 Kutens pkur trovoennhr Eh bkes ht n'ks ou Tonåkne t`equh eigårehur ht ckyhi fh no Tnoeih russhht fu Aouaosh, Vroahs ht gkiateki: nhs mhsths rhtrkuvås. HROXN 84, 145-1?8, Neàmh.
?5=4 Kb kpyth mhknkmeahslkj strotegeloaee ikvya` ora`hknkmeahslea` pocjotielkv Ahrikckr-slkmk pkbhrhz'jo shvhrk-zopofikmk Lovlozo, Threkfezoaejo e a`rkiknkmee pnhjstkahio, 8-0.
?504 Cothreony essnhfkvoiejo mrubkkbnkckaikj aoste rya`nya` ktnkzhiej Lufork EEE. Ei:W.T. Njubei ?504o, 15-84.
?577 Mhkckrgknkmeahslojo foterkvlo vkzrosto Ozya`slkj phsahrikj stkjoile ponhkneteahslkmkahnkvhlo, Ezvhst. OI Ozhrb. QQR. Qhr. ioul k zhcnh ?577/8, ?2-?6.
?5=5 Qkvrhchiikh skstkjoieh lkcphlsiya` essnhfkvoiej v ponhkneteahslea` phsahroa Ozya` eVomnor (Ozhrb. QQR), Ezvhst. OI Ozhrb. QQR, Qhr. ioul k zhcnh ?5=5/7, 61-65.
?502 Qrhfo kbetoiejo phrvkbytikmk ghnkvhlo jumk-vksnklo Conkmk Lovlozo (pk foiiyc
ponhknetenhslea` phQ÷hr Ozya` e Vomnor). Ovtkrhg. fess. loiof., Ckslvo.
?5=7 Lorstkvyh phQghry Mruzee. Vbenese.
?575 Qphnhkhnkmejo ezvhstijolkvkmk cossevo Lufork-Bubo, Vhzesy etkmkv iouai. shssee Eistetuto
mhkmrogee OI MQQR ?75, ?8-?=.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 262/342
282 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Vusobrocesvene, F.C.
Whluo, O.L.
?572 Ora`hknkmeahsleh rozvhfle v uQêhnh'h r. Lvereno, Whstiel Mks. Cuzhjo Mruzee 21-b, 16-61
?5=0 Etkme robkt Auaa`votslkj e Akislkj ora`hknkmeahslea` hlsphfeaej zo ?5=7-?5== mm.,
Ora`hknkmeehsleh hlsphfeaee Mks. Cushjo Mruzee 7, 8-?0.
?506 Tonhknet Mruzee. Whstiel Mks., Cushjo Mruzee 1=-B, 8-2=.
?572 V`h Nkwhr pnhesnkahih cocconeoi gouio grkc Oa`onlonole. Vbenese (ei Mhkrmeoi noimuomh
?50= V`h Nkwhr Tnhestkahih Cocconeoi Gouio kg Oa`onlonole (Qkut`hri Mhkrmeo, XQQR),
Tonhkitkmrop`eao Etoneao =6, 71-57.
?55?o Estkrejo zevktikmk cero-pkzvkikaiyh, Mruzejo v oit`rkpkmhih, 140-10?.
?55?b Wnejoieh ahnkvhlo io gouiu pkzvkikaiyl e hmk rkn' v vyceroiee vefkv, Mruzejo v oit`rk
pkmhih, 102-152.
ei prhss Feh ]erbhntehrgouio vki Fcoiese (Mhkrmehi. Loulosus) uif e`rh bekstrotemrop`esa`hQthnnuim.
Whluo, O.L.,A F. Mobhnojo,
O.M. CuQa`hnesvene
Whluo, O.F.,F.M. Fzemoure,R.E. Vkrkzkv
Whluo, O.F.,A.A. Mobhnojo,O.M. CuQa`hnesvene,I.Q. Cocoaosvene
Whluo, O.,E . (eo`uieo
Whnealk, O.O.,n.L. Evoikvo,W.C. Curotkv
Whnealk, O.O.,M.W. Oitkikvo,H.C. Zhnelski,O.L. Corlkvo,C.C. Ckikszki,V.F. Ckrkzkvo,C.O. Thvzihr,C.B. Qunhjcoikv,V.O. A`onahvo
WhrhQaomei, I.L.
?50? Tonhkneteahslojo gouio ez phsahr Zopofikj Mruzee, Ths÷hry Mruzee. Qphnhknkmeahslee
s`kriel 5, 10-84.
?508 Ikvyh ponhkitknkmeahsleh ioa`kfle v klrhsikstjoa` Aonlo, Qkk`sahiejo OI MQQR ??0,1=1-1=7.
?50= L ezuahieju ponhkneteahslkj gouiy pkzvkikaiya` phsahry Akio, Thsthi Mruzee. Qphnhk-
nkmes'a'hslej s`kriel ??, 52-?44.
?55? Feh ]erbhntehrh vki Fcoiese uif e`rh strotemrop`esa`h Qthnnuim. Ei: W. Fzoporefzh,M. Bkseisle ht on. ?55?,01-5?.
?575 Mhknkmeìhslojo estkrejo Russlkj rovieiy, Lryco e Lovlozo v pnhjstkahih e vkzrostponhknet`eàhslea` lun'tur, Trerkfo e rozveteh phrvk`ytikmk kbQ÷hstvo io thrretkree Hvrkp
aost QQQR, 0-6?.
E'esk Tonhkmhkmrogejo stkjoile Ozya`-frhvihjshmk pkshnhiejo phrvkbytikmk ahnkvhlo io thrretkree QQQR, Ezvhst. OI QQQR Qhrejo Mhkmr. ?504/14, 24-18.
Whrhsaomei, I.L.,M.G. Borysielkv
?58=o Kstotle cnhlkpetojusaea` ez iezihahtvhrteaiya` ktnkzhiej Vocoislkmk pknukstrkvo, Vrufy
zkknkmeghslkmk eistetuto 22 (Cothreony pk estkreee gouiy ahtvhrteaikmk phrekfo (oitrkpk-mhion QQQR)), 5-=6.
?58=b Tnhjstkahikvjh pkzvkikaiyh ez phsahry Lufork ? v Jumk.Kshtee e ea` zioahieh fnjorozrobktle estkree gouiy e noifsogtkv Lovlozo, Fklnofy OI QQQR ??1/7, ?16=-?165.
?504o Kstotle cnhlkpetojusaea` v vkstkaikj monhrhh phsahry Lufork E (roslkple W. T. Njubeio?58=-?580). Ei: W.T. Njubei ?504o, 8?-72.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 263/342
281 WOQQENX T. NJXBEI OIF MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - V@H AOXAOQXQ RHMEKI
Zomweji, ].@.
?504b Kstotle cnhlkpetojusaea` ez phQahry Lufork EEE. Ei: W. T. Njubei ?504o, 71-=0.
?58= Whmhtoteki, anecoth oif tech-akrrhnotekis ei t`h Horny Tnhestkahih kg Hurkph, Mhknkmeh hi
Cejibkuw I.Q.?5, 211-266.
Zocjotiei, Q.I.
?571 Tnhestkahih strotemrop`y ei t`h Iht`hrnoifs, boshf ki a`oimhs ei vhmhtoteki oif anecoth,Whr`oifhn. Lki. Ihf. mhknkmesa` cejibkuwluifem mhikktsa`op. Mhkn. Qhr. 2?-2, ?=1-?57.
?5=8 Woreotekis ei anecoth os s`kwi by pknnhioionyses, hsphaeonny ei t`h Horny Tnhestkahih kgHurkph. Ei: O.H. ]rem`t oif G. Ckshnhy (hf.), Eah omhs: oiaehit oif ckfhri, ?1=-?82.Mhkn. J. Qpha. Essuh 7.
?51= Tonhknet Oba`ozee. Vrufy Eistetuto oba`ozslkj lun'tury ?4. Qua`uce.
?565 Ihlktkryh foiijh k ie[ihc ponhkneth Luboie, Q`kriel cuzhjo oitrkpknkmee e htikmrogee ?2,608-650.
Zhnelski, H.C.,Z.T. Mubkieio
Zubkv, O.O.
?57? Ka'hrle pk ponhknetu. Ckslvo/Nhieimrof.
?508 Qchsahieh vysktikj pkjosikste lol ksikvo rhlkistrulaee lnecoteahslea` ezchihiej vmkriya` stroioa`, Chtkfy rhlkistrulaee lnecotkv, 1=-68.
?504 K zubh ora`oitrkpo ez phQahry Lufork E. Ei: W.T. Njubei ?504o, ?82.
Wossenej NjubeiEistetuth kg Ora`ohknkmyFvkrzkvojo Iob. ?5Qt. ThthrsburmRusseo
Mhr`orf BkseisleGkrsa`uimsbhrhea` Ontstheizhet
Qa`nkss Ckirhpks8787= IhuwehfMhrcoiy
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 264/342
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 265/342
jhoi Toun Royioe ?1 V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Otnoitea Ckrkaak:Nekihe Comkmo t`h Aosobnoiao hvefhiahGoteco-Zk ro Qbe`e-OnokueFhies Mhroofs
Rhahit wkrl ei t`h Aosobnoiao orho akisefhrobny
ckfegehf hornehr eithrprhtotekis kgets prknegea Tonohknet`ea
rhakrf. Ihw rhsunts rhpkrthf ei e`es pophr strhss t`h
obshiah kg troahs kg o vhry horny `etcoi kaaupoteki. V`h
coei port kg t`h rea` Oa`hunhoi shquhiah ot Aosobnoiao
foths grkit t`h shakifport kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih,
t`kum` ponohkcomihtea foto summhsts t`ot t`h hornehst
troaås kg etcoi oatevetehs foth grkc bhgkrh t`h Brui`hs-
Cotuyoco bkuifory (V`kcos-? quorry, nhvhnN).
V`rkum`kut t`h Oa`hunhoi shquhiah t`h soch net`ea row
cothreons whrh ushf, w`ea onnkws akcporeski kg
tha`iknkmeaon a`oroathresteas kg t`h vorekus osshcbnomhs.
?. Eitrkfuateki
V`h Aosobnoiao rhmehc, ki t`h Otnoitea akost kg t`h
Ckrkaaoi Chsåto, es rea` ei Tonohknet`ea seths prhshrvhf ei
oi hxahptekionny whnn fhvhnkphf shrehs kg nettkron fhpksets
(Gem. ?). V`es shrehs gkrchf t`h boses gkr t`h fhgeieteki kg
t`h cojkrety kg t`h strotktyphs kg t`h anosseaon stomhs kg t`h
Com`rhb's coreih Tnhestkahih (Ihuvennh oif Ru`ncoi
?56?< Bebhrski ?57?< Vhxehr ht on. ?508). V`h fhpksets
yehnfhf vorekus gkssens kg `kceiefs (Bebhrski ?587<
Hiikua`e ?575, ?5=2). w`ea` orh ot t`h kremei kg t`h gerstoiotkceaonny ckfhri `ucois (@ubnei ?55?). Rhahit wkrl
`os hstobnes`hf o ihw net`kstrotemrop`eaon (Vhxehr ht on.
?556< Nhgàvrh ht on. ?556), bekstrotemrop`eaon oif
ora`ohknkmeaon grochwkrl (shh Vobnh ?), t`ot wenn bh ushf ei
t`es pophr tk fesauss t`h omh kg t`h gerst kaaupoteki kg t`h
Aosobnoiao rhmeki oif tk prhshit skch osphats kg ets
Oa`hunhoi shquhiah.
2. Lrkc t`h Tnekahih tk t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih
V`h bosh kg t`h strotemrop`ea shrehs kg Aosobnoiao es kg
Tnekahih omh (Royion ht on. ?554), foteim grkc bhgkrh t`h
_uothcory vknaoiesc kg t`h Ceffnh Otnos (Hn Mrokue?556).
V`h knfhst gksseneghrkus seth ei t`h Aosobnoiao shquhiah es
t`h Nessosgo lorst akcpnhx, fhvhnkphf ei t`h tkp kg nettkron
fhpksets t`ot `ovh t`her bosh ot obkut ?=4 c obkvh prhshit
sho nhvh!?. nts cearkgouio, w`ea` akitoeis Toroht`kcys sp.,
Rusaeikcys sp.. Cus sp. oif Mhrbennefoh, summhsts o Ceffnh
kr Horny Tnekahih omh.
O`n-On-Kum`noc es o ykuimhr seth, systhcoteaonny
hxaovothf grkc ?505 kiworfs, oif nkaothf ei o s`krhneih
aut ei bhoa` fhpksets ot ?40 c obkvh sho nhvhn (Royion
ht on. ?554). nts vhrthbroth gouio, by gor t`h rea`hst kih kg
t`h Ikrt` Ogreaoi noth Ahikzkea oif kiny akcporobnh tk t`h
rea` seths kg hosthri Ogreao, summhsts oi omh kg orkuif
2.8 Cyr BT (Mhroofs ?551o< ?558). Ckrh t`oi =4 sphaehs
`ovh bhhi efhitegehf, bhnkimeim tk onn coei mrkups: ges`hs,
rhptenhs (meoit tkrtkesh, nezorfs, siolhs, arkakfenhs oif t`h
rorh Ocp`esbohiefoh), vorekus berfs (wet` o rhcorlobnh
akhxesthiah kg phimuei oif kstrea`, oif wet` pshufkfkitkr-
iet`hs, meoit sho berfs wet` gonsh thht`) oif coccons, t`h
ckst akccki mrkup. Aorievkrhs orh rhprhshithf by 21 toxo,
?1 kg w`ea` orh ihw (Mhroofs, ei prhss), h.m. @yohiefoh
(Arkauto, Tnekarkauto), o sobrh-tkkt`hf ghnef, Custhnefoa,
Aoiefoh (Wunphs, Iyathrhuths), t`h knfhst likwi bhor grkc
Ogreao oif o ckrsh. V`h `hrbevkrhs akcpresh hnhp`oit, o
costkfkit, o gkssen pem (Lknpka`khrus p`oaka`khrkefhs), o
bkvef-sezhf meroggh (Qevot`hreuc couruseuc), oithnkphs
(Lkbus oif Foconesaus), o t`rhh-tkhf `krsh (@epporeki), o
r`eikahrks (Ahrotkt`hreuc), o ckilhy (V`hrkpet`haus), os
whnn os o normh vorehty kg rkfhits oif eishatevkrhs. Et es
kbvekus t`ot t`h normh prhfotkrs pnoyhf o cojkr rknh ei t`hgkrcoteki kg t`es gksseneghrkus seth, kg w`ea` wh `ovh o
rhprhshitotevh socpnh ikw. Vroahs kg `kceiefs, bh et os
gkssens kr ei t`h gkrc kg orthgoats, orh akcpnhthny obshit ei
t`es normh osshcbnomh, oif t`h O`n-On-Kum`noc seth t`us
shhcs tk foth grkc bhgkrh t`her orrevon ei t`h Com`rhb.
V`h Horny Tnhestkahih kg Aosobnoiao, ikt whnn likwi ei
fhtoen yht, es aurrhitny t`h kbjhat kg systhcoteaon rhshora`,
oif vorekus strotemrop`eaon uiets `ovh bhhi efhitegehf
bhtwhhi 68 oif ?44 c obkvh sho nhvhn. Ik ecpkrtoit
gksseneghrkus seth es likwi yht, oif ik stkih orthgoats `ovh
bhhi rhakvhrhf ei setu. Geifs rhakvhrhf grkc fhpksets
gkrchrny ottrebuthf tk t`h Cooregehi, t`h Ckunkuyhi kr t`hQonåtehi orh het`hr mhkgoats aknnhathf grkc `em`-hihrmy
nettkron goaehs (knf aknnhatekis kg Bebhrski ei t`h Fåprhz
quorry oif rhahit aknnhatekis by J.T. Royion oif F. Nhgàvrh
ei t`h Ber Os Qcor pet), kr orh rhahit orthgoats grkc
suphrgeaeon aknnuveon fhpksets, os ei kt`hr seths ei Ckrkaak
(Royion oif Vhxehr ?505): ot yht t`hrh es ik 'Thbbnh
Aunturh' ei setu ot Aosobnoiao.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 266/342
NEV@KQVROVEMROT@ U
• w k r c (? 5 = B- ? ] 6) | ? |
RHFKOF BHIONE GKe]ÅOVEKI
n o` non tn Coc bo e
KXEOFOJJCHE GKT.COVEKI
F X O X
@OCEFOMRKXT
Gkreooteki 1
Gkrco tuei ;
For Bkua oeb K AoX _uorry
•not On Mn-kr&on _uorry
O`nOn-Kum`noc uiet 2
OC On Kum`nori CC ?
C ?= ,
8. NHGHW@H. ROr@@n. |EC6).
A@GKJKNKMU
Occkmrkup K ?1)
*4 2 Xe KQN (1)
L n g @ p kþ r en y
[ Y [ , • - '.WWe . [ : r , ! e . . Y
AOQOBNOIAO ANOQQEA QÅREHQ
( BJBGRQ_I. ?57?)
TRHQKNVOInOI\F2)
OCE1EO@ (@|COOREGEOI <Je oif
L-N-C-@-K Akcg@o¼
V` kc oe _uocoo
E oif OIGOVEOI
CHQQOKEKOI. QONHVEOIoif COOR*EOI tkri tkriorCec e oif Orpkrn Kuocoo
CHE CPK@C
@oj Qonoi B« Vo`orMoufr E oif EE
Fopr. ëf Bkua`tnb Bon Loc.
tkrcor _uoi
tvkn .of O Qromo ?
CeffX O Qtemo W
NEV ]A OQQHCBNOMHQ
net`ea totiikekmy oif anoooegeaoteki otnor C C wkrle ('?=! e w < (B)
X f f e ./ n .? . ` . k` t` . t
Eborkcouruoe<
Otor eor .
COJKR QEVHQ @KCEIEFGKQQENQ NORMH COCCONQ GOXIO
Kunof @orreefo 2 -Rof Len eo- otQefe
Obforr e t ecoio
neppor
Oa`oue eoi
neppor
Oa`oue eoi
neppor
Oa`oue eoiAop A`otolor tkp
Oa`ou`oi
"‖ ‖Qefe Obforro`rooio
Oa`ou`oi Aop A`otofor bkg nkcOa`ou`oi Aop A`otofor bkg nkcOa`ou`oi
R`eiktorko Aovo
K 1 t k 4 6 C e H Q BV`hco¼ n oif
N k w r O t o u ne o i Mroifo Hepnketoteki uto B
| Nk vro r O a o u oi | V k co o _ uo rr y ?. Bof N
AT Akbbnos oif pobbnoo "olc<K A K r mo i z of a o . ¼
N : Novonnke* g not eimQ QpiorkVfoV ViiofrkioB B et ok C
FVG Fevo-oeteof tkkno ki tnoto
QG : QooraGe tkr GIE@ O`n-OE Kuminoc
F å p . . .
......,.-
Kunof @ocefo = _uorry
EToir`oro. @ycrio Aogts WunposFeaoror`cus `hcetkoa`usQut toi/t, Tgwakagrkorut£quus. M n ¼ * . Akiihtteootot
Toctoro. Goto Aoi-t e/utpos
Arkauto. Hquu* Aocotþo.Tgeoakagekorus
Qefe Obmorro`c oio AuiottoKuro Aovo
E'Jttu*. MozoQt Rootseao
Kunof @.c.fon .Rreckaorko Aovotjraooi. Xtovt ArkautoAotonknttortuc secuc. ÌquueTorcu/oiuo T/eoakageaoruo
V`orkpoiohue
Vtekcoo e _uorry. Bof n| @/ppktctocuo. £quteo
Aoroto ekxkKkiro
OC On Kuminoi
? Ogoaoao. rreca*
Toie`oro T`ktrkauto Ooikiy*
arks whhTskI (e*C)(?;) HIIKXA@E C KQ¼. t¼=2)
\nen GnOËION C ot uipuC.*C
(?*? MHROOKQ (?C1) oif uipuietvefXHBOOAQ?? GtOVt*X.ot ?? (!• ¼. ECQ).arks whhTskI (e*C)
(?;) HIIKXA@E C KQ¼. t¼=2)\nen GnOËION C ot uipuC.*C
jg @OUIot Con. to*8
Vobnh ?. Qyit hteaon survhy kg t h Aosobnoiao Tonohknet ea rhakrf oif ets mhknkmeaon akithxt.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 267/342
28= JHOI-TOXN ROUION HV ON. - V@H AOQOBNOIAO HWEFHIAH
Gem. ?. Nkaoteki kg seths ei t`h Aosobnoiao orho: ?. Qefe Obfhr-ro`coih< 2. Mrktnh fhs Kurs< 1 Qefe Obfhrro`-coih Hxthiseki<6. V`kcos ?< 8. Mrktth fhs R`eikaårks Kunof-@ocefo ?< 7. O n-OE-Kum`noc< =. Ber Os Qcor< 0. Qefe Chssokuf< 5. Nessosgo<?4. M`oufkur Bhi @obeb< ??. Qefe On L`ofer Host.
1. V`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih
V`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih es a`oroathrezhf by obuifoit
`ucoi kaaupoteki. Fhpksets kg t`es phrekf orh vhry whnn
fhvhnkphf oif fespnoy mrhot net`kstrotemrop`eaon fhtoen:
shvhi coreih uiets orh efhitegehf, sthpphf bhtwhhi 5 oif
18 c obkvh prhshit sho nhvhn oif akvhrhf by akiteihiton
gksseneghrkus fhpksets (Vhxehr ht on. ?556). V`h obuifoit
geifs fesakvhrhf ei t`h quorrehs kg Qefe-Obfhrro`coih,
V`kcos-? oif Kunof @ocefo-E onnkw us tk a`oroathrezh t`h
akithcpkrory 'oiecon' hiverkichit oif tk hstobnes` t`h
ieoei neihs kg t`h nkaon Oa`hunhoi shquhiah.V`rkum`kut t`h shquhiah orlkshs oif aocbreoi ghnfsporea
quortzeths - kgthi rhghrrhf tk os Hn @oil quortzeths - gkrc t`h
preiaepon row cothreons. V`hy whrh obuifoitny prhshit ei
vorekus sezhs ki t`h gkrchr bhoa`hs oif rkaly kutarkps, oif
mevh t h osshcbnomhs o rot`hr 'ora`oea' a`oroathr. Hxphrechits
wet` t`hsh rkals `ovh mevhi us o mkkf efho kg t`her gnoleim
a`oroathresteas. V`h row cothreons orh vhry t`kum` oif
cossevh, oif vhry `orf tk gnolh, t`kum` lioppeim es goaenetothf
by coleim ush kg pnoih surgoahs, ioturon kr orthgeaeon kihs.
Groaturhs orh vhry anhor: `orf phrausseki arhothf fhakrteaothf
surgoahs wet` whnn corlhf ihmotevh saors oif onsk hitoenhf
grhquhit lioppeim oaaefhits sua` os brholomh kg gnolhs kr
phbbnhs onkim t`h oxes kg phrausseki (Qerht brhols,
oaaefhitonny brklhi phbbnhs, monhts o ui hinàvhchit ghifus).
Gneit akistetuths kiny obkut 8% kg t`h row cothreons, upuitenn t`h Xpphr Oa`hunhoi, w`hi gneit wos skum`t gkr ckrh
systhcoteaonny. Gneit es nkaonny ovoenobnh ei t`h gkrc kg sconn
phbbnhs (? tk 8 ac ei feochthr) ei vorekus akorsh mroeihf
nettkron fhpksets.
V`h hxpnketoteki kg t`h soch row cothreons t`rkum`kut
t`h Oa`hunhoi shquhiah ot Aosobnoiao onnkws o akcpoeëski
kg t`h tha`iknkmeaon a`oroathresteas kg skch rhprhshitotevh
shrehs. V`hy orh prhshithf `hrh onkim t`h neihs kg t`h
anossegeaoteki ckfhn fhvhnkphf ki boses kg o stufy kg t`h
osshcbnomhs grkc Xiet N kg t`h V`kcos quorry, brehgny
hxpnoeihf bhnkw. V`es ckfhn es boshf ki t`h a`oroathr kg
t`h wkrleim surgoahs, t`her fespkseteki oif hxpnketoteki< et
eithmroths fyiocea osphats (shquhiahs kg prkfuateki kg
gnolhs oif kg s`opeim, rhfuateki kg kbjhats, rh-ush hta.) oif
guiatekion kihs (sphaegea ckrp`knkmy, troisgkrcoteki by
usomh...). Qhvhi coei mrkups orh fesahrihf:
Mrkup ?: gnoleim aorrehf kut by useim akrteaon streleim
pnotgkrcs
Mrkup 2: gnoleim grkc kih iki-akrteaon streleim pnotgkrc,
pkssebny rh-ofjusthf
Mrkup 1: gnoleim useim twk iki-akrteaon streleim pnotgkrcs
gkr kih oif t`h soch wkrleim surgoah
Mrkup 6: gnoleim useim t`rhh tk gevh iki-akrteaon streleim
pnotgkrcs gkr kih oif t`h soch wkrleim surgoahMrkup 8: gnoleim grkc iki-akrteaon streleim pnotgkrcs
bhnkimeim tk vorekus wkrleim surgoahs
Mrkup 7: hxpnketoteki/s`opeim kg gnolhs oif gromchits
Mrkup =: kbjhats troisgkrchf by usomh
V`h mrkup-subfevesekis t`us rhpksh upki tha`iknkmeaon
oif/kr shakifory ckrp`knkmeaon arethreo (sua` os rh-ush kg
streleim pnotgkrcs, rhaurrhiah kg gnolh rhckvons, nhimt` kg
bnoils (bkt` orthgeaeon oif ioturon kihs), surgoah sezh kg
gnolh rhckvons oif prhshiah/obshiah kg akrthx).
Mrkup 6 akitoeis ckst kbjhats wet` cuntepnh gnolh
rhckvons. Qtorteim wet` gnoleim grkc akrteaon streleim
pnotgkrcs (mrkup ?) oif gknekwhf by oi eiarhosh kg gnolhfsurgoahs t`es mrkup akitoeis t`h cojkrety kg akcpnhx oif/kr
typeaon kbjhats. V`h ckst akcpnhth begoahs os whnn os t`h
bhst hxpnkethf akrhs orh wet`ei t`es mrkup. Mrkup 7, wet`
akrhs ki gnolhs oif gromchits oif tkkns ki gnolhs thstegehs
tk t`h geion stomhs kg t`h lioppeim prkahss.
Ethcs troisgkrchf by usomh kr rh-utenezoteki orh ot t`h
kremei kg port kg t`h kbshrvhf osshcbnomh voreobenety. Vobnh 2
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 268/342
280 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
survhys skch a`oroathresteas kg gkur rhprhshitotevh shrehs kg
t`h Oa`hunhoi shquhiah ot Aosobnoiao, os osshcbnhf grkc
?5=0 kiworfs fureim hxaovotekis by t`h Cesseki prå`estk-
requh ht ponåkitknkmequh groimoesh ou Corka oif t`h
Eistetut Iotekion fhs Qaehiahs fh n'Ora`åknkmeh ht fu
Totreckeih ot Robot: chcbhr N kg t`h V`kcos-? quorry
(V@ NE oif V@ N8). t`h Mrktth fhs R`eikaårks kg t`h
Kunof @ocefo-? quorry (MFR) oif Qefe-Obfhrro`coihHxthiseki (QOH). Vobnh ? kiny akisefhrs t`h hgghatevh tktons
kg t`h vorekus mrkups wet` hxanuseki kg (ioturon) bnoils.
Vob nh 2 s hh thxt gkr hxpnoioteki
Qeths: V@ NE V@ N8 MFR QOH
Omh: 94.=0 Cyr BT ; ¿4.6 Cyr BT >4.6 Cyr BT
Mrkups ee % i % i % i %? ?0 7 ?0 6.0 == ?8 1? 8.6
2 87 ?0.0 =5 2?.2 =? ?1.0 72 ?4.=
1 10 ?2.0 ?? 2.5 21 6.8 57 ?7.7
6 ?26 6?.7 7? ?7.6 ??4 2?.8 ?55 16.8
8 ?0 7 77 ?=.= 18 7.0 8 4.5
7 17 ?2.? 5= 27 ?44 ?5.8 ?0? 1?.6
= 0 2.= 6? EE 5= ?0.5 1 4.8
Vkton 2«)Q ?44 1=1 EE Cn 8?1 ?44 8== XCE
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki likwi yht `os bhhi fesakvhrhf ei
t`h V`kcos-? quorry, ei nhvhn N kg t`h Gkrcoteki ? kg t`h
Kunof-@ocefo Mrkup (Royion oif Vhxehr ?505). V`h
osshcbnomh akitoeis gnolhs strual grkc fesakefon akrhs oif
grkc pkny`hfrkis. Bhsefhs a`kppeim-tkkns, pkny`hfrkis oif
skch anhovhrs, begoahs gkrc t`h ckst a`oroathrestea hnhchit
wet`ei t`h tkkns. V`hy orh kgthi porteon kiny oif usuonnyfespnoy nothron kr nonaron-feston akiaovetehs, t`ot colh up t`h
pkeit kg t`h begoahs.
V`h gouio grkc t`es seth es fkceiothf by `eppkpktocus,
nelh t`h prkbobny skchw`ot ykuimhr seth kg Vem`hieg
(Vhriegeih) ei Onmhreo, oif akitoeis gurt`hrckrh hnhp`oit,
zhbro oif mozhnnhs. Tonohkcomihtea foto summhsts oi omh ei
hxahss kg 4.=0 Cyr BT gkr t`h coei port kg t`es nkaon horny
Oa`hunhoi shquhiah (Qhi, ei netthres).
Worekus seths (Qefe On L`ofer, Moif`kur Bhi @obeb,
Kunof @ocefo ?) ovh yehnfhf sconn osshcbnomhs
fkceiothf by fhbetomh. V`hsh osshcbnomhs orh bheim
stufehf ikw, oif aoi bh fothf ei t`h gerst port kg t`h Ceffnh
Tnhestkahih (Mrkup kg Kunof @ocefo). V`h coei port kg t`h
Oa`hunhoi seths grkc t`h Aosobnoiao shquhiah, eianufeim
t`h `kceief seths grkc t`h V`kcos quorrehs (Mhroofs ht on.
?504), `kwhvhr foth grkc t`h shakif `ong kg t`h Ceffnh
Tnhestkahih (Oigo Mrkup). V`h Mrktth fhs R`eikaårks kg t`h
Kunof-@ocefo-? quorry (Royion ht on. ?551) yehnfhf o rea`
net`ea eifustry oif oi obuifoit gouio wet` obkut 84
vhrthbroth sphaehs (Mhroofs ?551b, ?556) t ot eifeaoth o
rot`hr kphi oif fry hiverkichit. HQR-foteim kg tkkt`
hiochn kg Ahrotkt`hreuc secuc (R`kfhs ht on. ?556) mevh
t`h osshcbnomh oi omh kg obkut 644 Lyr BT. V`h obuifoit
rhcoeis kg w`eth r`eikaårks summhst sphaeonezhf `uiteim by
`kceiefs. Akcporhf tk t`h nkaon horny Oa`hunhoi kih aoi
kbshrvh oi eiarhosh kg fesakefon akrhs oif kg gnolh
prkfuateki< anhovhrs orh rorh w`enh begoaeon pehahs orhnormhr, a`oroathrezhf by akivhx oif/kr akiaovh hfmhs t`ot
akistetuth o pkeithf hxtrhcety (ag. Gem. 2).
Ei t`h V`kcos-? aovh t`h nhvhn t`ot yehnfhf t`h `ucoi
coifebnh ei ?575 es ikw uifhr hxaovoteki. V`h rhakvhrhf
osshcbnomh es queth fegghrhit grkc t`h shrehs kg t`h Mrktth
fhs R`eikaårks, os et es fkceiothf by gnolhf phbbnhs, oif
akcporobnh tk t`h shrehs aknnhathf ot t`h tech kg t`h
fesakvhry kg t`h jow (Mhroofs ht on. ?504). V`es voreobenety
aoi prkbobny bh hxpnoeihf by t`h sconn sezh kg t`h socpnh
rhakvhrhf grkc t`h eigenn yht.
O ckrh rhahit stomh es whnn ennustrothf ot Qefe-Obfhr-
ro`coih-Hxthiseki. @hrh wh kbshrvh oi ecpkrtoit ush kg
bnkal-gromchits oif grhquhit rhayaneim kg rknnhf orthgoats
wet` cuntepnh saors. Gnolhs orh coeiny prkfuahf grkc
fesakefon akrhs oif pkny`hfrea gkrcs orh queth rorh. Qk orh
prhfhthrceihf gnolhs, but t`hsh akhxest wet` o fevhrsh
tkknlet ki gnolhs. Begoaeon pehahs orh mhihronny cofh ki
gnolhs oif ckstny fespnoy akivhx sefhs oif thif tkworfs
kvoth gkrcs, hvhi tk fesakefon kihs. Anhovhrs orh rorh `hrh.
V`h upphr port kg t`h Oa`hunhoi shquhiah es rhprhshithf
ot t`h Aop A`othnehr seth, wet` oi omh ei hxahss kg 244 Lyr
(kpteaonny stecunothf nuceihsahiah foths by R`kfhs ?554):
prkfuateki kg prhfhthrceihf gnolhs oif t`ei, sconn begoahs,
o fevhrsh sht kg tkkns ki gnolhs oif vhry ghw anhovhrs
(Fhbhiot` ht on. ?502).V`h Oa`hunhoi shrehs kg Aosobnoiao orh t`us
a`oroathrezhf by o normh `kckmhihety, w`ea` es tk o normh
hxthit t`h rhsunt kg t`h ush kg t`h soch ceihron rhskurahs
kvhr vorekus `uifrhfs kg t`kusoifs kg yhors. V`h row
cothreon, obuifoitny ovoenobnh ei onn sezhs, onnkwhf o
prkfuateki kg normh gnolhs kr vknuceikus gromchits kg
phbbnhs oif bnkals. V`h kiny akistroeit akisesthf ei t`h
troispkrt kg `hovy kbjhats, coleim vknuceikus gnolhf ethc
rorh ei t`h hxaovothf seths. V`h vorekus typhs kg bnoils
eitrkfuahf tk t`h seths orh vhry whnn rhakmiezobnh ei t`h
begoahs kg t`h vorekus shrehs.
V`h eifustrehs thstegy tk o ahrtoei stobenety t`rkum`kut t`h
Ceffnh Tnhestkahih (nothron fessycchtreh prkphr tk o porteon
s`opeim, gkr hxocpnh), but t`hy onsk bhor wetihss kg oi
eiarhoseim akcpnhxety kg hnhchitory ckfhs kg rhfuateki
oif kg o akiteiukus tha`iknkmeaon hirea`chit ei w`ea`
hornehr oaquerhchits rhsurmh (t`h pkny`hfrea prkxecon pore
kg skch begoahs kg t`h Mrktth fhs R`eikaårks, gkr hxocpnh)
V`h kbshrvhf a`oimhs ei t`h ckrp`knkmy kg t`h vorekus
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 269/342
285 JHOI-TOXN ROUION HV ON. - V@H AOQOBNOIAO HWEFHIAH
Akivhxh hfmh(s)
Tkeit, akiaovh hfmh(s)
04
Akiaovh hfmh(s)
Avh hfmh + axh hfmh
Gem. 2. Festrebuteki (ei %) kg vorekus begoah hfmh-typhs kg t`h osshcbnomhsR eikaårks), V@?/N? (V`kcos ? _uorry, Nhvhn N?).
Tkeit, avh hfmh, avx hfmh
QOH (Qefe Obfhrro`coih Hxthiseki), MFR (Mrktth fhs
kbjhats aoi bh quoitetëhf< tbr eistoiah t`h rhcorlobnyrhmunor a`oimh kvhr tech kt" t`h oimnh gkrchf by t`h
ferhatekis kg t`h twk gnolh rhckvons t`ot fhnecet o shquhiah
kt gnolh rhckvons ki kih (kr twk) wkrleim surgoahs. V`h
ihot akrrhnoteki bhtwhhi t`h iucbhr kg gnolh rhckvons oif
t`h iucbhr kg streleim pnotgkrcs (ag. Gem. 1) es o
tha`iknkmeaon akistoit (o suaahsseki kg x gnolhs kremeioteim
trkc kih pnotgkrc), vhregeaf ei hxphrechits oif fhthrceihf
by t`h cha`oieaoS a`oroathresteas kg t`h row cothreon.
]et`ei t`es 'Oa`hunhoi' uiety t`h a`oimhs wet`ei t`h
begoahs rhgnhat ei kur vehw o ckrp`k-guiatekion hvknuteki,
rhnoyhf ei tech by o ckrh systhcotea prkfuateki kg gnolhs,
eianufeim prhfhthrceihf kihs.
O akcporeski kg t`h prkbobnh ush kg t`h kbjhats
efhitegehf ei kur anossegeaoteki wet` hxphrechiton rhsunts
(Vkt` ?508) nhofs tk t`h gknnkweim akianusekis rhmorfeim
t`h oatevetehs phrgkrchf ot t`h seths: V`kcos-? NE: skch
stkih wkrleim. `efh snetteim, `hovy futy buta`hry, bkih
brholeim< V`kcos-? N8: stkih wkrleim fkceioths. nem`t
futy buta`hry< Mrktth fhs R`eikaårks: stkih wkrleim
ecpkrtoit, `efh snetteim, nem`t oif `hovy-futy buta`hry,bkih brholeim< Qefe-Obfhrro`coih Hxthiseki: stkih
wkrleim ecpkrtoit, `efh snetteim, nem`t futy buta`hry, bkih
brholeim.
V`h normh saonh hxaovotekis t`ot orh ei prkmrhss ikw ot
Aosobnoiao wenn onnkw us tk fhvhnkp t`hsh prhneceiory
eithrprhtotekis ei ckrh fhtoen oif tk prkpksh ckrh
sphaegea guiatekion `ypkt`hshs gkr t`h vorekus seths
fesausshf `hrh.
6. Akianusekis
Os o rhsunt kg t`h rhahit oif kimkeim wkrl ei t`h
Aosobnoiao rhmeki o ghw akianufeim pkeits aoi bh strhsshf`hrh:
- os yht t h Aosobnoiao rhmeki `os ikt yehnfhf oiy hvefhiah
kg vhry horny `ucoi kaaupoteki kg t`h Ckrkaaoi Otnoitea
akoston orho
- ponohkcomihtea foto summhsts t ot t`h hornehst troahs kg
`ucoi kaaupoteki foth grkc (just;) bhgkrh t`h Brui`hs-
Cotuyoco bkuifory (4.=0 Cyr BT)
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 270/342
274 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Choi iucbhr kg gnolh rhckvons akcporhf tk iucbhr kg streleim pnotgkrcs
8 7 = 0 5
Iucbhr kg streleim pnotgkrcs phr kbjhat
? 4 ? ? ? 2 ?
Gem. 1. Choi iucbhr kg gnolh rhckvons akcporhf tk iucbhr kg streleim pnotgkrcs, gkr t`rhh osshcbnomhs: QOH (Qefe Obfhrro`coih HxthisekiMFR (Mrktth fhs R eikaårks), V@?/N? (V`kcos ? _uorry, Nhvhn N?).
- t`rkum`kut t`h voreobenety fhckistrothf by kur rhahit
hxaovotekis vorekus ckrp`k-tha`iknkmeaon stomhs orh
fesahriobnh. V`hsh fk ikt onnkw o gkrcon subfeveseki kg
t`h Oa`hunhoi shquhiah but t`h opphoroiah kg
prhfhthrceihf gnoleim tha`iequhs, oppnehf tk t`h preiaepon
row cothreon (quortzeth), ihvhrt`hnhss a`oroathrezhs o
rot`hr rhahit p`osh kg t`es shquhiah.
Geionny, kur aurrhit stoth kg likwnhfmh es prhshithf `hrh
ei t`h gkrc kg t`h syit`hteaon tobnh n< w`enh semiegeaoitny
ckfegyeim hornehr foto, t`h aurrhit grochwkrl rhgnhats kiny
o prkvesekion stomh kg kur kimkeim rhshora`.
Outkresoteki fh pubnehr ik. 672 fu ?6 juei ?558
ikth
? V`h seth wos fesakvhrhf Coy ?=t` ?558, by F. Nhgàvrh oifJ.T. Royion.
rhghrhiahs
Bebhrski, T. ?587 Nh meshchit fh n'Otnoit`rkph fh Qefe Obfhrro`coih, Bunnhtei f'Ora`åknkmeh corkaoeih10-52.
?57? Nh aofrh ponåkmåkmrop`equh fh no Trå`estkerh fu Corka otnoitequh ht Nh Tonåknet`equheigårehur fu Corka otnoitequh, Tetbneaotekis fu Qhrveah fhs Oitequetås fu Corka, Robot
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 271/342
27? JHOI-TOXN ROUION HV ON. - V@H AOQOBNOIAO HWEFHIAH
Fhbhiot`. O.,
J.T. Royion.
J.T. Vhxehr
?502 Nhs eifustrehs fhs @kck hrhatus corkaoeis: a`rkiknkmeh, typknkmeh. Trhcehr Akimrhs
eithriotekion fh Tonhkitknkmeh `ucoeih. Råsucås, 06-08, Ieah.
Hn Mrokue, C. ?556 Akitrebuteki o n'åtufh fhs gkrcotekis nerrkronhs quothrioerhs fh no råmeki fh Aosobnoiao
(Corka): såfechitknkmeh, cearkgoaeàs ht ceiåroux nkurfs. V`hsh fh ?'Xievhrsetå fh
Bkrfhoux ?.
Hiikua`e, H. ?575 Fåakuvhrth f'ui Tet`åaoit`rkpehi ou Corka, AR. Oaof. Qae. Tores F, 275, =71-=78.
?5=2 Ikuvhnnh fåakuvhrth f'ui ora`oit`rkpehi ou Corka, AR. Oaof. Qae. Tores F, 2=6, 1400-
1454.
Mhroofs, F.,
T. Bhrerk,
@. Rka`h
?504 No gouih ht n'eifust reh fhs seths o @kck hrhatus fhs aorreàrhs V`kcos (Corka). Tråaesekis
sur ?'omh fh ahs `kceiefås, AR. Oaof. Qae. Tores 25?(??), ?58-?50.
Mhroofs, F. ?504 No gouih fhs seths o @kck hrhatus fhs aorreàrhs V`kcos (Aosobnoiao, Corka), _uothr-
ioreo 22, 78-56.
?551o Lknpka`khrus p`oaka`khrkefhs (V`kcos, ?006) (Quefoh, Cocconeo) fu Tnekaàih
supårehur fh O`n on Kum`noc (Aosobnoiao, Corka), Måkbeks 27(7), =1?-=6?.
?551b Ceffnh Tnhestkahih Arkaefuro (Cocconeo, Eishatevkro) grkc Kunof @ocefo ?, Ckrkaak,
oif t`her p`ynkmhihtea rhnotekis`eps, Trkahhfeims Lki. Ihf. Olofhceh v. ]hthisa`opphi
57(1), 20?-256.
?556 Rkimhurs ht Nomkckrp`hs fu Tnåestkaàih ckyhi fh no "Mrktth fhs R`eikaårks" , Aorreàrh
Kunof @ocefo ? o Aosobnoiao, Corka, I. Jb. Tonokit. Ob`. ?5?(2), ?6=-?=2.
?558 Rkimhurs ht eishatevkrhs (Cocconeo) fu Tnekaàih geion fh O`n On Kum`noc (Aosobnoiah,
Corka), Måkbeks 20(?), 55-??8.
ei prhss Aorievkrhs fu Tnekaàih thrceion fh O`n On Kum`noc (Aosobnoiao, Corka), Måkbeks,
subcetthf.
@ubnei, J.J. ?55? N'åchrmhiah fhs @kck sopehis ora`fequ.hs: Ogrequh fu Ikrf-Kuhst ht Hurkph
kaaefhitonh. V`hsh f'Htot fh ?'Xievhrsetå fh Bkrfhoux ?.
Nhgàvrh. F.,
J.T. Vhxehr.
J.T. Royion,
Q. Kaaehtte,
J. Hvei
?556 Hirhmestrhchits-Råpkishs fhs voreotekis anecotequhs fu Tnåestkaàih supårehur ht fh
n'@knkaàih sur Eh nettkron fh Aosobnoiao (Corka ), _uothrioerh 8(1-6), ?=1-?04.
Kaa`ehtte. Q..
J.T. Royion,
T. Tea`ht,
J.T. Vhxehr
?551 Oceikstrotemrop`eh fu fhriehr ayanhs anecotequh ou Corka otnoitequh, fh Aosobnoiao o
Voimhr, AR. Oaof. Qa. Tores 1?=(??), ?728-?712.
Royion, J.T..
?.?'. E'hxehe
?505 Fåakuvhrth f'Oa`hunåhi oiaehi fois no aorreàrh V`kcos E o Aosobnoiao ht prkbnàch fh
?'oiaehiihtå fh no pråshiah `ucoeih ou Corka, AR. Oaof. Qae. Tores 140(??), ?=61-?=65.
Royion, J.T.,
J.T. Vhxehr,
F. Mhroofs,
G.Z. Qbe`e-Onokue
?554 Xi ikuvhou meshchit ponåkitknkmequh pnek-pnåestkaàih hi Ogrequh fu Ikrf: O`n On
Kum`noc (oiaehiih aorreàrh Fåprhz) o Aosobnoiao (Corka), AR. Oaof. Qae. Tores 1?4(??),
1?8-124.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 272/342
: > 9 : V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Royion, J.T.,
F. Mhroofs,
N. Comkmo,
O. @ojrokue,
J.T. Vhxehr,
F. Nhghvrh,
G.Z. Qbe`e-Onokue
?551 No Mrktth fhs R`eikaårks (Aorreàrh Kunof @ocefo ? - oiaehiihchit V`kcos EEE, Aoso-
bnoiao), ikuvhou seth oa`hunåhi fu Corka otnoitequh, AR. Oaof. Qae. Tores 1?7(??),
?6==-?601.
R`kfhs, H.
R`kfhs, H.,
J.T. Royion,
F. Mhroofs,
G.Z. Qbe`e-Onokue
?554 Kpteaon Foteim kg _uortz grkc Qhfechits. V`hsh fh fkatkrot. Xievhrsety kg Kxgkrf: Kxgkrf
?556 Trhceàrhs foth RTH pkur ?'Oa`hunåhi fu Corka otnoitequh (Mrktth fhs R`eikaårks .
Aosobnoiao), AR. Oaof. Qae. Tores 1?5(??), ??45-???8.
Vhxehr, J.T.,
J.T. Royion,
F. Nhgàvrh
?508 Ikuvhnnhs prkpksetekis pkur ui aofrh a`rkiknkmequh roeskiiå fu _uothrioerh corkaoei,
AR. Oaof. Qa. Tores 14?(??), ?01-?00.
Vkt`. I.
nn9n96 Akitrebuteki pkur ui ikuvhou aofrh strotemrop`equh fhs gkecotekis nettkronhs quothcoerh
fh no råmeki fh Aosobnoiao (Corka), AR. Oaof. Qae. Tores 1?0(??), ?26=-?281.
?508 V`h Knfkwoi Rhosshsshf, o Anksh Nkkl ot Horny Qtkih Ortegoats , Jkurion kg Ora`ohknkm
eaon Qaehiah ?2, ?4?-?24.
Jhoi-Toun Royion oif Nekihn Comkmo
Xievhrsetå fh Bkrfhoux ?
Eistetut fu _uothrioerh
XCR 5511 AIRQ oif MFR ??22 AIRQ
Ovhiuh fhs Goauntås, G-11648 Vonhiah Ahfhx
Groiah
oif
Cesseki prå`estkrequh ht ponåkitknkmequh groigoesh ou Corka
Goteco-Zk`ro Qbe`e-Onokue
Eistetut Iotekion fhs Qaehiahs fh ?'Ora`åknkmeh ht
fu Totreckeih
Ovhiuh Jk`i Lhiihfy, Aosehr Tkston
Robot-Qkuesse
Corka
Fhies Mhroofs
Nobkrotkerh fh Tonhkitknkmeh fhs vhrtåbrås ht
Tonhkitknkmeh @ucoeih
Xievhrs etå fh Tores WE, aosh ?47
6 pnoah Russehu, =8282 Tores ahfhx 4 8
Groiah,
XCR ?82 AIR Q, Cusåh fh ?'@kcch
Tnoah fu Vrkaofårk, =8??7 Tores
Groiah
oif
Cesseki prå`estkrequh ht ponhkitknkmeh groiaoesh ou Corka
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 273/342
Mhr`orf Bkseisle ?6 Qtkih orthgoats kg t`h Hurkphoi NkwhrTonohknet`ea: o s`krt ikth?
M. fh Ckrtennht rhmorfhf net`ea orthgoats os o chosurh kg
`ucoi hvknuteki. @h sow t`es prkmrhsseki os uieneihor oif
wet`kut rhmekion fegghrhiahs, Oa`hunhoi `oifoxhs
a`oroathrezhf t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea oif hsphaeonny rkum`
`oifoxhs whrh t`kum`t tk rhprhshit t`h hornehst stomh iochf
A`hnnhoi (Fh Ckrtennht ?001). By eitrkfuaeim shvhron
Oa`hunhoi substomhs Brhuen ikt kiny ckfegehf t`es
subfeveseh¼S but gerst kg onn oif akitrory tk t`h speret kg
Fh Ckrtennht's uieneihor hvknuteki `h akistruathf vorekus
aunturon trofetekis: poronnhn tk t`h "begoah aunturh" (Obbh-
venneoi, Oa`hunhoi) hxesthf o "gnolh aunturh" (Anoatkieoi,
Nhvonnkeseoi), hoa` wet` ets kwi mhkmrop`eaon oif
hiverkichiton festrebuteki (Brhuen ?512).
Vkfoy bkt` t`h efho t`ot Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea orthgoats
iaotny rhprhshit stomhs kg `ucoi hvknuteki os whnn os t`h
ossucpteki t`ot t`hy a`oroathrezh fegghrhit aunturon
trofetekis orh ikt vhry pkpunor ockim ora`ohknkmests.
Worekus akitrebutekis ei t`es vknuch uifhrneih t`h ikteki
t`ot Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea orthgoats fk ikt rhprhshit anhor
a`rkiknkmehs! uiets kr `estkreao! trofetekis. V`es coy bh kih
kg t`h rhoskis w`y nhss otthiteki es poef tk net`ea orthgoats
t`oi, nkr eistoiah, tk gouion rhcoeis kr hiverkichiton foto.
@kwhvhr, stkih orthgoats gkrc by gor t`h ckst akcckiaothmkry kg geifs grkc t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea. V`her prhshiah
thstegehs tk t`h prhshiah kg `ucois, oif stkih orthgoats orh t`h
kiny truny furobnh corlhrs kg t`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg
Hurkph. V`h knfhst seths akitoei net`ea orthgoats, a`oroathrezhf
by tnolhs wet` s`orp autteim hfmhs t`ot hiobnhf `kceiefs tk
moei oaahss tk chot, oi ofoptotekion ofvoitomh t`ot onnk whf
o gost pkpunoteki eiarhosh oif subshquhit hxthiseki kg horny
`kceiefs eitk Huroseo.
Orthgoats oif Iki-Orthgoats
Qeiaa t`h whnn-likwi hknet` fesausseki ot t`h bhmeiieim
kg t`h twhiteht` ahitury (Rutkt ?542< shh onsk Ofreoi ?560)et es akccki likwnhfmh t`ot t`hrh es o normh mrhy orho
w`hrh ik kbjhatevh arethreo tk festeimues` orthgoats grkc
ioturon prkfuats oppny. V`h prkfuats kg vknaoiea oatevetehs
shrvh os oi hxocpnh< t`hsh eianufh t`h sk aonnhf thp`rkgoats
fesausshf ei t`es vknuch by Royion, Comkmo oif Beifki
(shh onsk: Bkseisle ht on. ?504< Bkiegoy ?55?). Onsk ei
revhr mrovhns oif stkih neihs (aoennkutes) et es ikt onwoys
pkssebnh tk shporoth orthgoats grkc iki-orthgoats (ag. Qa`cufh
?552). Onn otthcpts tk anoregy t`h fegghrhiahs bhtwhhi
orthgoats oif ioturon prkfuats (ag. Totthrskis ?501< Lunh-
chyhr ?507< Onbrha`t ht on. ?556) orh `ocphrhf by t`h goat
t`ot Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea stkih wkrleim tha`iequhs whrh sk
secpnh t`ot t`hy akunf hoseny bh ecetothf by ioturon prkahsshs,
sua` os groaturh fureim vknaoiea hruptekis oif rkal gonns oif
by stkihs `etteim hoa` kt`hr ei `em` hihrmy gnuveon akithxts
(ag. Rkhbrkhls ?507< ?556< Rkhbrkhls oif Woi Lkngsa`kthi,
t`es vknuch). Ei sua` o akithxt t`h ihahssoreny remkrkus
shnhateki kg orthgoats wenn rhsunt ei o sconn shrehs kg net`eas t`ot
cem`t rhprhshit kiny o groateki kg t`ksh pehahs kremeionny
cofh by `kceiefs (ag. Moufzeisle, ei prhss).
Qkchw`ot bhtthr akifetekis hxest ot seths ei geih-mroeihf
s`krh kr revhr boil shfechits (Cehshi`hec E: Vurihr, ei
prhss), trovhrteih soifs (Benzeimsnhbhi: Coieo oif ]hbhr
?507) kr nkhss fhpksets (Oa`hi`hec: Juilcoiis ?55?< ?558).
Row Cothreons
Wertuonny onn Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea stkih orthgoats orh cofh
kut kg seneaegehf rkals w`ea` kaaurrhf ot kr anksh tk t`h
seths. V`h thrc "nkaon", w`ea` kih kgthi hiakuithrs ei t`h
saehitegea nethroturh, s`kunf bh rhstreathf tk seths ferhatnysetuothf ki t`h row cothreon kutarkps, w`ea` kgthi `ovh t`h
a`oroathr kg o wkrls`kp. Ei t`h Hurkphoi Nkwhr
Tonohknet`ea sua` seths orh rorh, Aomiy-no-Morhiih oif
Bkxmrkvh bheim twk hxocpnhs kg t`es aothmkry. Ei coiy
aoshs t`h seneahkus rkals w`ea` `kceiefs utenezhf fef ikt
kaaur ot t`h seth etshng but ot o festoiah kg o ghw lenkchtrhs
(Gnkss ?556). Esknothf row cothreons grkc festoiahs kg obkut
24 lc (Krmioa), up tk 14 lc (Vhrro Ocoto) kr hvhi grkc
"normhr festoiahs" (Lufork E) orh hxahptekis, eifeaoteim t`ot
et wos uiusuon tk troispkrt net`ea orthgoats grkc kih seth tk
oikt`hr.
V`hrh es o guiatekion rhnotekis`ep bhtwhhi tkkn-typhs oiftyphs kg row cothreon. V`h iuchrkus sconn gnolhs orh
prhfkceioitny grkc `kckmhihkus geih-mroeihf seneahkus
rkals. Ei akitrost, anhovhrs oif phbbnh tkkns orh ckstny
cofh kut kg tkum`, akorsh cothreons. Ei t`h ghw aoshs w`hrh
"phbbnh tkkns" whrh cofh kg gneit, wh cem`t bh fhoneim ikt
wet` tkkns but wet` akrhs gkr gnolh prkfuateki (ag. t`h
"phbbnh akrhs" grkc 'Xbhefeyo: Bor-Ukshg oif Mkrhi-Eibor
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 274/342
276 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
?551). V`h a`keah kg row cothreon gkr begoahs es ikt os anhor
tut. Coiy kg t`hc orh ki quortzeth oif bosont, nelh t`h
anhovhrs oif phbbnh tkkns, w`enh ei gneit-rea` rhmekis t`hrh
orh iuchrkus begoahs cofh ki brettnh gneit. Begoahs whrh
onsk cofh kut kg bkih os es whnn fkauchithf ot seths
eianufeim Gkitoio Roiuaaek, Conomrktto.
V`h strotemrop`ea suaahssekis kg Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea nhvhns,
ei Hurkph gkr eistoiah Thtronkio, Krmioa oif Voutovhn, s`kwt`ot t`h a`keah kg row cothreons fhvhnkphf t`rkum` tech. Ei
t`h upphr noyhrs kg t`hsh seths t`h ockuit kg `kckmhihkus
seneahkus rkals es `em`hr t`oi ei t`h nkwhr noyhr.
E `eleeeNe Vha`iequhs
V`h a`oroathrestea sconn gnolhs kg t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea
whrh strual grkc sconn tk chfeuc-sezhf akrhs. V`h streleim
pnotgkrc coy `ovh bhhi prhporhf by kih kr o ghw bnkws,
bun t`h rhfuateki goah wos ikt prhporhf oif bhaoch
errhmunor fureim gnoleim. Akrrhspkifeimny t`hrh es ik
fegghrhiah bhtwhhi prhghrhiteon oif prhporotkry gnolhs. Akrh
rhfuateki wos rhoneshf by ferhat "`orf" phrausseki. Nkw
quonety rkals nelh quortz whrh onsk wkrlhf ei o bepknor woy,
rasunteim ei sphaegea akrhs oif gnolh typhs wet` normh stroem`t
feston oif prkxecoe hxtrhcetehs w`ea` coy bh speeithrhf oif
nkkl nelh pehahs hsquennåhs (Lkboyos`e ?5=8).
@occhrstkihs shhc tk `ovh bhhi a`kshi of `ka oif
subshquhitny oboifkihf< `occhrstkihs wet` anhor
akiahitrotekis kg phrausseki saors thstegyeim tk o nkimhr ush,
orh rorh. Ei nothr p`oshs kg t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea normhr
cossevh gnolhs wet` t`eal streleim pnotgkrcs whrh prkfuahf
ei t`h sphaeon Anoatkieoi tha`iequh fhsarebhf gerst ei
Himnoif (Anoatki-ki-Qho, Qwoisakcbh hta).
Ot t`h hif kg t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea hnkimothf gnot gnolhs
kaaosekionny orh prhshit oif whrh prkfuahf grkc akrhs wet`prhporhf rhfuateki goahs. Qua` prhporhf akrhs orh likwi
gkr eistoiah grkc Aomiy-no-Morhiih, Nuihn Wehn oif grkc
Leernea`-Qhhughr, w`hrh t`hy kaaosekionny fespnoy o akivhx
prhporhf rhfuateki goah oif o prhporhf-streleim pnotgkrc.
Akishquhitny t`hrh es o fegghrhiah bhtwhhi prhghrhiteon oif
prhporotkry gnolhs. V`es Nhvonnkes tha`iequh akiteiuhs oif
subshquhitny fhvhnkps ei t`h Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea.
Rhtkua`hf Gnolhs
Gnolhs shrvhf os autteim tkkns, t`her s`orp hfmhs bheim
ushf wet`kut rhtkua`eim oif kgthi fespnoyeim semis kg ush.
O a`oroathrestea p`hikchiki kg t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea orh
sconnhr gnolhs wet` ikta`hf oif/kr fhiteaunothf rhtkua`hf
hfmhs. V`hsh sconn tkkns orh vhry iuchrkus ei hvhry ckrh
ecpkrtoit eivhitkry< t`hy rhgnhat o leif kg oatevety t`ot wos
wefh-sprhof oif hkccki onn kvhr t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea,
prhsucobny wkkf wkrleim. Os o rhsunt kg t`her guiateki
t`hsh sconn tkkns orh errhmunory s`ophf oif feggeaunt tk
anossegy. V`hy t`hrhgkrh movh t`h ecprhsseki kg Nkwhr
Tonohknet`ea tkkns bheim "uistoiforfezhf". Akiteiukusny
rhtkua`hf wkrleim hfmhs orh rorh ei t`hsh osshcbnomhs.
V`h Bretes` seth @em` Nkfmh es oi hxahpteki tk t`hsh
kbshrvotekis obkut Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea lioppeim tha`iequh
tkke typhs oif wkrleim hfmhs, oif rhcoeis oi hiemcotea
p`hikchiki (Os`tki ht on. ?552).
Ot @em` Nkfmh gnolhs wet` snem`tny akivhx kr onckst
stroem`t sarophr hfmhs orh hkccki oif coy bh anossegehf secpnh kr troisvhrson sefh-sarophrs. V`hrh orh onsk roankers
fåjåtås {Qpetzsa`obhr) wet` onckst stroem`t hfmhs. V`eal
hnkimothf pkeits wet` errhmunorny rhtkua`hf fhiteaunothf oi
ikta`hf hfmhs orh usuonny anossegehf os _ueiski pkeits.
Qconn oif s`krt hif-sarophrs wet` rhmunorny rhtkua`hf sarop
hifs orh hkccki.
Ei bemmhr eivhitkrehs (gkr eistoiah Benzeimsnhbhi oif
Fcoiese) bureis kaaur, skchtechs cuntepnh kihs, oif skc
ki truiaotekis. V`h burei bhvhns skchtechs s`kws semis kg
ush< but ei mhihron, eithitekion bureis orh oi hxahpteki
t`kum` ei t`h Hurkphoi Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea.
Thbbnh Vkkns
O choieimgun anossegeaoteki kg phbbnh tkkns es o feggeaunt
hithrpresh. V`h trofetekion subfeveseki eitk uiegoaeon
a`kpphrs oif begoaeonny s`ophf a`kppeim tkkns es t`h ckst
akivhiehit anossegeaoteki. Onckst onn t`h a`kppeim tkkns orh
onthriothny wkrlhf oif surhny whrh ikt autteim tkkns.
Offetekion subfevesekis gkauseim ki t`h ockuit kg t`h
wkrlhf surgoah, t`h ockuit kg akrthx, kr t`h s`oph kg t`h
wkrleim hfmh orh pkssebnh oif ushgun ei t`h fhsarepteki kg
bem shrehs os gkr eistoiah grkc surgoah aknnhatekis oif grkc
thrroah bkfehs (shh gkr hxocpnh Aknneio-Merorf ?5=7<
Vovksk ?5=0< Lrþmhr ?556< Gehfnhr ?556).
Trecory akithxt seths wet` o vorehty kg geif cothreon,eianufeim bkihs, ei mhihron akitoei kiny o necethf iucbhr
kg phbbnh tkkns. @hiah et fkhs ikt shhc urmhit tk hnobkroth
o ckrh skp`esteaothf subfeveseki kg t`hsh secpnh tkkns.
Anhovhrs
Anhovhrs orh subfevefhf eitk begoaeon anhovhrs wet` normh
autteim hfmhs oif gnolh anhovhrs cofh ki bem gnolhs. Begoaeo
anhovhrs orh sputiels kg Oa`hunhoi begoahs os t`hy kaaur
hvhryw`hrh ei t`h soch akithxt. Ei akitrost, gnolh-anhovhrs
(Vexehr ?587< Vovksk ?5=8) opphor ot t`h hif kg t`h Nkwh
Tonohknet`ea oif orh cua` ckrh iuchrkus oif a`oroathrest
ei t`h horny Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea ot seths wet` o fkceioiah
t`h Nhvonnkes tha`iequh oif kiny esknothf begoahs.
Begoahs
Os o rhsunt kg rhahit wkrl, gerst kg onn ei ikrt`hri Groiah
(Vuggrhou oif Oitkeih, t`es vknuch) oif skut`hri Himnoif
(Rkbhrts, Mocbnh oif Brefmnoif, t`es vknuch) t`h anos
segeaoteki oif subfeveseki kg begoahs nkst cua` kg ets a`orc
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 275/342
278 MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - QVKIH ORVHGOAVQ KG V@H HXRKTHOI NK]HR TONOHKNEV@EA
os t`hsh stufehs fhckistroth t`ot t`hrh orh ik rhakmiezobnh
typknkmeaon trhifs ei tech. Hsphaeonny t`h trofetekion vehw
akiahrieim t`h hvknuteki grkc rkum`ny wkrlhf horny begoahs
tk ckrh hvknvhf kvoths oif hnkimothf begoahs aoi ikt bh
suppkrthf by t`h hvefhiah grkc t`h Hurkphoi Nkwhr
Tonohknet`ea.
Vypknkmeaon voreobenety kg begoahs akunf bh fhthrceihf by
guiateki< et es. gkr eistoiah, feggeaunt tk ecomeih t`ot t`hhnkimothf begoahs wet` onthriothny s`ophf (zem-zom-nelh)
hfmhs shrvhf t`h soch purpksh os t`h Himnes` "twesthf
kvoths".
Eivhitkry Vyphs
Ei t`h Hurkphoi Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea t`hrh orh gerst kg onn
twk eivhitkry typhs: Vyph O osshcbnomhs akitoei gnolhs,
rhtkua`hf gnolhs, oif phbbnh tkkns, Vyph B osshcbnomhs
`ovh akcporobnh orthgoats, but ei offeteki t`hy akitoei
begoahs oif anhovhrs.
O gerst mrkup kg Vyph O-seths es rhprhshithf by Fcoiese
oif pkssebny Krah, knfhr t`oi ?,8 Cyr BT oif t`us knfhr
t`oi t`h gerst begoahs (ag. Bkseisle ?558). V`h gnolhs,
rhtkua`hf gnolhs oif phbbnh tkkns grkc t`hsh seths s`kw ik
cojkr fegghrhiahs grkc t`h Ogreaoi Knfkwoi seths oif akunf
bh anossegehf os "Knfkwoi". V`h shakif, cua` ckrh
ecpkrtoit, anusthr kg Vyph O-seths (sua` os Whrthsz÷nn÷s,
Thtronkio, Mojfoi. Eshrieo oif Benzeimsnhbhi) foths tk t`h
Ceffnh Tnhestkahih oif es akithcpkrory wet` t`h Oa`hunhoi.
V`hsh seths orh ikt necethf tk o sphaegea tech-spoi but foth
grkc vorekus Ceffnh Tnhestkahih phrekfs, eianufeim t`h noth
Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea (Ben/eimsnhbhi). V`her mhkmrop`eaon
festrebuteki akvhrs t`h w`knh kg ei`obetothf Hurkph,
eianufeim ets skut`hri oif whsthri ports w`hrh Oa`hunhoi
osshcbnomhs onsk kaaur. Et es o setuoteki akcporobnh tk t`hHost Ogreaoi kih, wet` akcporobnh fesaussekis oif
ormuchits (ag. Nholhy ?5=8< Qtenhs ?504).
V`h Vyph B-seths akitoei onn t`h Vyph O-orthgoats os whnn
os begoahs oif anhovhrs, oif orh trofetekionny anossegehf os
"Oa`hunhoi". Ot t`hsh seths t`h iucbhr kg begoahs oif
anhovhrs vorehs akisefhrobny, but et fkhs ikt shhc vhry ushgun
tk rhstreat t`h thrc "Oa`hunhoi" kiny tk seths wet` o `em`
phrahitomh kg begoahs (Vuggrhou ?50=). Akitrory tk t`h Vyph
O-seths t`h Oa`hunhoi fespnoys o sphaegea festrebuteki potthri,
t`ot eianufhs t`h Aouaoseoi rhmeki, t`h skut`hri Hurkphoi
phieisuno oif whsthri Hurkph, w`enh ik Oa`hunhoi seths orh
likwi grkc ahitron oif hosthri Hurkph.
V`h Aouaosus rhmeki es neilhf tk t`h Ogreaoi "arofnh" kg
begoahs oif anhovhrs by Oseo Ceikr oif t`h Nhvoiteih
akrrefkr. Grkc t`h Aouaosus rhmeki t`hsh typhs akunf `ovh
hxthifhf tk skut`hri oif whsthri Hurkph. Gkr t`h skut`whst
Hurkphoi geifs, Onechi (?5=8) prkpkshf o akiihateki tk
Ikrt` Ogreao kvhr Qeaeny oif t`h Qtroet kg Mebrontor. V`h goat
t`ot t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih gouios grkc bkt` sefhs kg t`h
stroet orh ikt rhnothf aoiikt bh ushf os oi ormuchit omoeist
akitoat by `ucois.
V`h a`oroathr kg t`h pkssebnh rhnotekis`ep bhtwhhi Vyph
O oif Vyph B `os bhhi t`h subjhat kg coiy fesaussekis.Et es ecpkrtoit t`ot t`hrh orh Vyph B-seths wet` kiny esknothf
begoahs oif anhovhrs (h.m. Qknhen`oa, Voutovhn, Nuihn Wehn,
Onfàih oif Whikso-Nkrhtk) w`ea` ei t`h obshiah kg t`hsh
esknothf pehahs wkunf akcpnhthny akrrhspkif tk Vyph O-
seths. Ei offeteki t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea suaahsseki kg
Whikso-Iktora`ereak akitoeis onthrioteim nhvhns wet` (o)
coiy phbbnh tkkns grkc nechstkih, skch begoahs kg
quortzeth oif gneit, oif sconnhr gnolhs grkc gneit os whnn os
(b) noyhrs (Onp`o H, H ?) akitoeieim gerst kg onn rhtkua`hf
oif uirhtkua`hf gnolhs kg gneit, but ik begoahs (Cusse, t`es
vknuch).
V`h hxocpnhs rhghrrhf tk obkvh akunf eifeaoth t`ot t`hrh
wos ik guifochiton fegghrhiah bhtwhhi Vyph O oif Vyph B
seths. V`h prhshiah kr obshiah kg begoahs oif anhovhrs cem`t
fhphif ki t`h leif kg oatevetehs phrgkrchf ot o seth. Ei t`es
akithxt et es streleim t`ot Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea seths wet` coiy
hnhp`oit bkihs, sua` os Vkrronbo, Ocbrkio, Orefks,
Gkitoio Roiuaaek, No Tknnhfroro oif Lornea`-Qhhughr,
mhihronny yehnf `em` phrahitomhs kg begoahs oif anhovhrs.
V`h setuoteki ot Whikso-Iktora`ereak es hsphaeonny eifeaotevh
kg t`es pkeit: t`es seth yehnfhf o slunn kg o ykuim hnhp`oit
nyeim upsefh fkwi wet` o fesorteaunothf, brklhi coifebnh.
V`h hnhp`oit's bkihs whrh surrkuifhf by begoahs, phbbnh
tkkns, oif gnolhs. @hrh et shhcs kbvekus t`ot begoahs oif
phbbnh tkkns shrvhf tk fesshat oi hnhp`oit (Tephrik ?552<Cusse, t`es vknuch)< sua` o guiateki akunf hxpnoei t`h
spoteon festrebuteki kg begoahs. V`h Orefks ? - hnhp`oit wos
ot nhost oaakcpoiehf by skch wosth gnolhs kg begoah
prkfuateki (Ropksk oif Qoitkijo, t`es vknuch) oif kiny ot
Orefks 2 oif No Tknnhfroro t`h hnhp`oit bkihs whrh gkuif
wet`kut begoahs oif anhovhrs.
ikth
? V`es s`krt ikth prkvefhs skch phrskion akcchits akiahrieimt`h Voutovhn fesausseki ki Hurkphoi Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea stkiheifustrehs, t`ot wos a`oerhf by t`h out`kr. V`h akcchit wosupfothf ei Corhi ?558 (ag. Bkseisle ?558).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 276/342
277 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
rhghrhiahs
Ofreoi, ].
Onbrha`t, M.,
@. Himhn`orf,
@. Cþnnhr-Bhal,
M. Xirot`
?560 Feh Gromh fhr ikrffhutsa`hi Hknet`hi. Tofhrbkri.
?556 Zur Xithrsa`hefuim vki Orthgolthi uif Ioturbrua` oi fhr Guifsthnnh Qh`rhcuz. Ei:
M. Onbrha`t oif @. Cþnnhr-Bhal (hf.), ?556, Fos Tonoknet`eluc vki Qh`rhcuz `he Qocs
oc Hup`rot. (Vþbeimhr Ckikmrop`ehi zur Xrmhsa`ea`th ?4), ?2?-?1?, VXbeimhi.
Onechi, C.@. ?5=8 Nhs "est `chs " `espoik-corkaoei ht seaunk-tuiesehi oux thcps oa`hunåhis, N'Oit`rkpknkm
=5, 155-617.
Os`tki, I.C.,
J. Akkl,
Q.M. Nhwes,
M. Rkså (hf.)
Bor-Ukshg, K.,
I. Mkrhi-Eibor
Bkiegoy, H.
Bkseisle, M.
?552 @em` Nkfmh. Hxaovotekis by M. fh M. Qehvhleim ?572-70 oif J. Akkl ?500. Nkifki:
Bretes` Cushuc Trhss.
?551 V`h Net`ea Osshcbnomhs kg 'Xbhefejo: O Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea Qeth ei t`h Jkrfoi Wknnhy.
Jhrusonhc: V`h @hbrhw Xievhrsety kg Jarusonhc.
?55? Nhs prhceàrhs eifustrehs fhs Quf Hst fh no Groiah ht fu Cosseg Ahitron. Ei: H. Bkiegoy
oif B. Woifhrchhrsa` (hf.), Nhs prhcehrs hurkpåhis, 71-04, Tores: Hfetekis fu [email protected]
?558 Feh hrsthi Chisa`hi ei Hurosehi. Qha`sth Rufkng Wera`kw-Wkr nhsuim ?552. Jo`rbua` f
R÷cesa`-Mhrcoiesa`hi Zhitroncushucs Coeiz 15, ?552 (?558), ?1?-?0?.
Bkseisle, M.,
L. Bruiioalhr,
L.T. Noishr,
Q. Qthp`oi.
B. Xrboi,
L. ]þrmhs
Brhuen, @.
Aknneio-Merorf, J.
Gehfnhr, N.
?504
Gnkss, @.
?512
?5=7
?556
?556
Ontponoknet`esa`h Guifh vki Lornea`, Lrhes Coyhi-Lkbnhiz (Ihuwehfhr Bhalhi),
Ora`oknkmesa`hs Lkrrhspkifhiz`nott ?4, 258-1?6.
Nhs eifustrehs o åanots fu Tonåknet`equh oiaehi. E. Nh Anoatkiehi, Trå`estkerh ?, ?28-?54.
Nhs eifustrehs ora`oequhs sur monhts fhs thrrosshs quothrioerh fh no pnoeih fu Rkussennki
(T.K., Groiah). Vrovoux fu Nobkr. fh Tonhkitknkmeh `ucoeih ht Trå`estkerh ?, Corshennh.
Ont- uif cetthnstheizhetnea`h Guifh ei @hsshi. Gþ`rhr zur `hssesa`hi Wkr- uif Grþ`-
mhsa`ea`th 2. Qtuttmort.
Rk`cothreonvhrskrmuim ec Tonoknet`eluc fhs Centhnr`heimhbehths. Ckikmr. fhs R÷cesa`
Mhrcoiesa`hi Zhitroncus. 2?, Coeiz: RMZC.
Mouf/eisle, Q.. ei prhss LorXa`-Qhhughr. Xithrsua`uimhi zu heihr ontponoknet`esa`hi Guifsthnnh ec Ihuwehfhr
Bhalhi (R`heinoif, Fhutsa`noif). Coeiz: RMZC.
Juilcoiis. J.
Lkboyos`e, @.
?55? Feh Qtheiorthgolth ous Oa`hi`hec ei fhr Qoccnuim Toun ]hrihrt, Ora`oknkmesa`hs
Lkrrhspkifhiz`nott 2? , ?-?7.
?558 Nhs hishcbnhs net`equhs f'Oa`h i`hec f'opràs no aknnhateki fh Toun ]hrihrt, Buen. fh no
Qka. prå`est. groia. 52, 27-17.
?5=8 V`h hxphrechiton stufy kg bepknor gnolhs. Ei: H. Qwoiski (hf.), Net`ea tha`iknkmy: colei
oif useim stkih tkkns, ??8-?2=, V`h @omuh-Tores .
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 277/342
27=
Lreemhr, @.
Lunhchyhr, J.
Nholhy. C.F.
Njubei. W.T.,M. Bkseisle,
Coieo, F.,
V`. ]hbhr
Ckrtennht, M. fh
Cusse. C..
Totthrskis. N.].
Tephrik, C.
Ropksk, ?...
C. Qoitkijo
Royion, J.-T.,
N. Comkmo,
T. Beifki
Rkbhrts, C.B..
AQ. Mocbnh,
F.R. Brefmnoif
Rkk`rkkls, ^^'.
Rkhbrkhls, ].,
V. voi Lkngsa`kthi
Runkt. O.
Qa`cufh, L.
Qtenas. F.
E'ovksk. ^.
Vexehr. J.
MHR@ORF BKQEIQLE - QVKIH ORVHGOAVQ KG V@H HXRKTHOI NK]HR TONOHKNEV@EA
?556
?507
?5=;
t`esvknuch
?507
?001
t`es
vknuch
?501
?552
t`es
vknuch
t`es
vknuch
?556
Feh ontpon÷knet`esa`h Mhr÷nnmhroth-Eifustreh fhr Cuezhibhrmhr Mrupph ei Kbhr`hsshi.
Cothreonehi zur Wkr- uif Grþ`mhsa`ea`th vki @hsshi ?4. ]ehsbofhi.
Feh ont- uif cettanponoknet`esa`hi Guifh vki Lornea`. Fess. L÷ni.
Aunturon Totthris ei t`h Knfuvoe Qhquhiah. Ei: L.]. Butzhr oif M.N. Esooa (hf.), Ogthr t`h
Oustronkpet`haeihs, 6==-651, V`h @omuh: Ckutki.
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg t`h Aouaosus rhmeki.
Benzeimsnhbhi EEE. @kck hrhatus - sheih Luntur uif Xcwhnt. Whr÷gghitnea`uimhi fhs
Noifhscus. gþr Wkrmhsa`ea`th ei @onnh 15. Bhrnei.
Nh Trå`estkrequh. Oitequete fh n'`kcch. Tores: Rheiwonf.
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: Etony.
Arethreo gkr Fhthrceieim t`h Ottrebuths kg Coi-Cofh Net`eas, Jkurion kg Gehnf
Ora`ohknkmy ?4, 25=-14=.
EE Tonhkneteak eighrekrh. Ei: O. Muefe oif C. Tephrik (hf.), Etoneo prhestkreao, ?15-?75.
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: t`h Ebaeeoi Thieisuno.
Vhp`rkgoats oif t`h gerst `ucoi kaaupoteki kg t`h Grhia` Cosseg Ahitron.
t`esh V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: t`h Bretes` Esnhs.
vknuch
?507 Ki t`h "Nkwhr Tonohkn et`ea" seth No Bhnnh Rka`h: Oi onthriotevh eithrprhtoteki, Aurrhit
Oit`rkpknkmy 2=, 175-1=4.
Xpfoteim t`h Hornehst Kaaupoteki kg Hurkph, Aurrhit Oit`rkpknkmy 18, 14?-148.
t`es V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: o rhopproeson kg orthgoatuon oif a`rkiknkmeaon
vknuch hvefhiah.
?542 Nhs eifustrehs precetevhs. Fåghish fhs åknet`hs. Nhs oatekis ioturhnnhs pkssebnhs skit
eiopths o prkfuerh fhs hgghts shcbnobnhs o no rhtkua`h eithitekihnnh, Chc. fh no Qka.
f'Oit`rkp. fh Bruxhnnhs 24, ?-7=.
?552 Zwhe arkchrzhetnea`h Orthgolt-Guifpnotzh ei fhr Jþimhrhi @ouptthrrossh oc Iehfhrr`hei,
Heszhetonthr uif Mhmhiwort 62, ?-26.
?504 Eifustreon toxkikcy ei t`h Horny Qtkih Omh kg Ogreao, Oit`rkpknkmeh (Brik) ?0, ?05-24=.
?5=8 Nhs `oa`hrhoux sur åanots fh ?'Oa`hunåhi Ckitoboioes. _uortor 27, ?1-1?.
?5=0 Nh Tonåknet`equh eigårehur ht ckyhi fu @outh Noimuhfka. V`hsh fh ?'Htot. Corshennh.
?587 Nh `oa`hrhou fois ?'Oa`hunåhi ikrf ogreaoei. Ikths typknkmequhs, Akimr. prå`est. fh
Groiah, ?8h shsseki, Tketehrs-Oimkunhch, 5?6-521.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 278/342
270 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Vuggrhou, O. ?50= Nh Tonhknet`equh eigårehur ht ckyhi fu Ikrf fh no Groiah (Ikrf, Tos-fh-Aonoes, Tea
fois ski aofrh stronesrop`equh. V`hsh Fkatkrot f'Htot Xievhrsetå fh Nennh, Nennh.
Vuggrhou, O., t`es V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: Akiteihiton Ikrt`whsthri Hurkph.
T. Oitkeih vknuch
Vurihr, H. ei prhss Cehshi`hec E. Hxaovotekis ot o Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea Qeth ei t`h Ahitron R`eihnoif kg
Mhrcoiy. Coeiz: RMZC.
Mhr`orf Bkseisle
Gkrsa`uimsbhrhea` Ontstheizhet
Qa`nkss Ckirhpks
8787= Ihuwehf
Mhrcoiy
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 279/342
Cortei J Oetlhi ?8 A`rkikchtrea tha`iequhs gkr t`h CeffehTnhestkahih
O brehgkut neih es mevhi kg t`h gknnkweim foteim
tha`iequhs: pktosseuc-ormki, uroieuc-shrehs, gesseki troal,
nuceihsahiah (VN oif KQN), hnhatrki spei rhskioiah (HQR),
oiþik oaef roaaiþzoteki (OOR), k`sefeoi `yfroteki, oif
mhkcomihtea rhvhrson strotemrop`y. Kxymhi esktkph
a`rkikstrotemrop y es onsk chitekihf, bkt` ei rhsphat kg
gkssen coreih cearkgouio oif ei rhsphat kg eah kbtoeihf by
chois kg nkim akrhs hxtroathf grkc t`h pknor eah aops<
rhahit rhvesekis tk t`h ostrkikceaonny-`oshf foteim kg
kxymhi esktkph stomhs `hykif Qtomh ?7 orh eifeaothf os
whnn os tk t`h pktosseuc-ormki foteim kg rhvhrson
strotemrop`y, t`h Brui`hs-Cotuyoco troiseteki ikw bheim
/9/>/>'hf ot 4.=Q Cyr oYk.
?. Eitrkfuateki
V`h vorekus tha`iequhs t`ot orh brehgny kutneihf `hrh coy
bh akivhiehitny mrkuphf eitk t`ksh boshf ki rofekoatevh
fhaoy kr buenf-up (pktosseuc-ormki< uroieuc-shrehs<
aonheuc-6?), ki t`h hgghats kg rofekoatevety (gesseki troals<
nuceihsahiah< hnhatrki spei rhskioiah), oif ki a`hceaon
a`oima (oceik oaef roahcezoteki< kbsefeoi `yfroteki). Onn
t`hsh orh prkahsshs eitreisea tk t`h socpnh. Ei offeteki t`hrh
orh t`h tech saonhs prkvefhf by mhkcomihtea rhvhrsons oifby ostrkikceaon aonebroteki kg t`h kxymhi esktkph
a`rkikstrotemrop`y< gkr akivhiehiah kg rhghrhiah skch
fhtoen kg t`hsh orh mevhi eianufeim chiteki kg t`h rhahit
snem`t nhimt`hieim kg bkt` ot t`h bhmeiieim kg t`h Ceffeh
Tnhestkahih.
Kg t`h a`rkikchtrea tha`iequhs kg eithrhst gkr t`h hornehst
kaaupoteki kg Hurkph et es t`h pktosseuc-ormki oif gesseki
troal tha`iequhs t`ot orh t`h ckst whnn-fhvhnkphf, gknekwhf
by uroieuc-shrehs (tk t`h hxthit t`ot t`h kaaupoteki wos
subshquhit tk t`ot tha`iequh's necet kg orkuif 844 Lyr).
Qeiah t`hsh orh kiny oppneaobnh ei ahrtoei mhknkmeaon rhmekis
t`hrh es strkim eithrhst ei t`h ush kg hnhatrki spei rhskioiah(HQR) oif nuceihsahiah< ihet`hr `ovh bhhi cua` trehf
ora`oaknkmeaonny bhykif shvhron ?44 Lyr, but HQR s`kunf
hiakcposs o cenneki yhors wet`kut feggeaunty oif t`hrh orh
eifeaotekis t`ot. uihxphathfny, nuceihsahiah coy rhoa`
bhykif `ong-o-cenneki. Bkt` kg t`h a`hceaon a`oimh
tha`iequhs orh `oifeaopphf by t`her strkim fhphifhiah ki
hiverkichiton akifetekis oif w`hi o iucbhr kg mnoaeon/
eithrmnoaeon ayanhs orh hiakcposshf wet`ei t`h bureon phrekf
t`h strkim thcphroturh-fhphifhiah es o porteaunor frowboal.
V`h pkssebenety kg useim aonaeuc-6? es stenn `em`ny
prkbnhcotea, oif rofekaorbki foteim, w`enh vhry pkwhrgun ei
nothr phrekfs, `os tkk s`krt o neceteim roimh tk bh rhnhvoit<
hgghatevhny et es a. 64 Lyr BT ot prhshit oif `em`ny uinelany
hvhr tk hxahhf a. =4 Lyr BT.
2. Tktosseuc-ormki foteim
2.?. BOQEQ
]et` ets hikrckus roimh (a. ?4 Lyr tk orkuif 644 Cyr)
t`es tha`iequh `os bhhi, oif es, kg aruaeon ecpkrtoiah. Et es
boshf ki t`h oaaucunoteki, ei vknaoiea novo oif os`, kg
ormki-64 prkfuahf grkc t`h snkw rofekoatevh fhaoy kg oiy
pktosseuc-64 prhshit (pktosseuc-64 es o ioturonny-kaaurreim
esktkph kg pktosseuc). V`h hvhit fothf es t`h vknaoiea
hrupteki< fureim t`es, oif w`enh novo es cknthi, prhvekusny
oaaucunothf ormki (o mos) es rhnhoshf t`hrhby shtteim t`h
rofekoatevh ankal tk zhrk. V`h omh es fhrevhf grkc t`h
chosurhf rotek kg ormki-64 tk pktosseuc-64.
Ormki-ormki foteim `os t`h soch boses but hcpnkys oi
ofvoitomhkus tha`iequh. Kih ofvoitomh es t`ot pktosseuc
oif ormki orh fhthrceihf ki hxoatny t`h soch sub-socpnht`hrhby ovkefeim pkssebnh hrrkrs fuh tk ei`kckmhihety<
oikt`hr ofvoitomh es t`ot t`h ormki aoi bh mrofuonny
rhnhoshf by sthpwesh `hoteim kg t`h socpnh oif oi omh aoi
bh fhthrceihf ot hoa` sthp. Akistoiay ei omh (oi 'omh
pnothou') es eifeaotevh kg rhneobenety. Hgghats aouseim t`h omh
tk bh hrrkihkusny tkk nkw orh t`ksh w`ea` mevh resh tk
rhnhosh kg oaaucunothf ormki fureim bureon sua` os ceihron
onthroteki (fuh tk whot`hreim), kr shakifory `hoteim< ki t`h
kt`hr `oif eiakcpnhth rhnhosh ot tech-zhrk kg prhvekusny-
oaaucunothf ormki wkunf mevh resh tk oi omh t`ot es
hrrkihkusny tkk knf, os onsk t`h prhshiah kg obskrbhf
otcksp`hrea ormki. Bhaoush kg fegghrhiteon ormki rhnhosh ot
fegghrhit stomhs kg t`h `hoteim t`hsh eithrghreim hgghats
coieghst t`hcshnvhs t`rkum` upsht tk t`h omh pnothou<
oionyses by t`h eska`rki tha`iequh es onsk feomikstea.
Xsh kg o noshr gkr `hoteim phrcets foteim kg seimnh mroeis
(kg t`h krfhr kg ? cennemroc kr nhss). V`es onnkws pktosseuc-
rea` mroeis kiny tk bh shnhathf< onsk knfhr, akitoceioteim
mroeis tk bh fhthathf oif ovkefhf.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 280/342
2=4 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
2.2. OTTNEAOVEKI
Kbvekusny t`h ecpkrtoit quhsteki es t`h rhnotekis`ep
bhtwhai t`h `ucoi kaaupoteki oif t`h vknaoiea prkfuats
t`ot orh fothf. ]`hrh twk noyhrs kg novo, kr os`, broalht t`h
ora`ohknkmy t`hrh es ik prkbnhc (hxahpt, skchtechs, o
rot`hr wefh broalht). O rhahit hxocpnh w`hrh t`h quhsteki
kg osskaeoteki es areteaon es t`h ?.0-?.7 Cyr omhs gkr `kceief
aroieon cothreon grkc Jovo (Qwes`hr ht on., ?556)< w`hrhost`h foteim kg t`h `kribnhifh arystons es ikt ei fkubt,
hxahnnhit omh pnothoux oif eska`rkis `oveim bhhi kbtoeihf,
t`h osskaeoteki kg t`h arystons wet` t`h gkssens es eiferhat.
Ckrh rhnhvoit tk Hurkph es t`h foth kg 4.=1 Cyr omk
kbtoeihf gkr t`h Etoneoi seth kg Eshrieo (Qhveil ht on., ?50?<
Akntkrte ht on., ?502)< kih s`kunf ikth `hrh t`ot ihet`hr kg
t`h fhthrceiotekis uteneshf t`h ofvoitomhkus ormki-ormki
tha`iequh, t`kum` t`h omrhhchit bhtwhhi twk nobkrotkrehs
useim fegghrhit ceihrons es summhstevh kg rhneobenety. @kwhvhr
wet`kut t`h hvefhiah kg oi omh pnothou t`h pkssebenety
aoiikt bh runhf kut t`ot ei bkt` aoshs t`h omh kbtoeihf wos
hrrkihkusny ei hxahss bhaoush kg eiakcpnhth rhckvon kg
ormki ot tech-zhrk.
1. Xroieuc-shrehs
1.?. BOQEQ
Oi hvhituon fhaoy prkfuat (o 'foum`thr') kg ioturonny-
kaaurreim uroieuc-210 es g`kreuc-214 oif w`hi t`h gkrchr
es prhshit ei ihwny-gkrchf arystons t`h mrofuon buenf-up kg
t`h notthr aoi bh ushf gkr foteim. V`h ckst wefhsprhof
oppneaoteki es tk aovh sphnhkt`hcs (stonoateths, stonomceths
oif gnkwstkihs)< ihwny-gkrchf aonaeth (aonaeuc aorbkioth)
akitoeis kiny uroieuc-210 oif ets foum`thr uroieuc-216<
t`hrhogthr t`hrh es buenf-up kg t`kreuc-214 oaakrfeim tk ets
`ong-negh kg =8.6 Lyr oif t`h roteks bhtwhhi t`hsh t`rhhonnkw t`h omh tk bh fhthrceihf. Ei skch aeraucstoiahs t`h
rotek bhtwhhi t`h twk uroieuc esktkphs aoi bh ushf gkr
foteim - ki o cua` nkimhr techsaonh. V`hrh es onsk oikt`hr
ioteeeonny-kaaurreim esktkph kg uroieuc, uroieuc-218, oif
buenf-up kg ets foum`thr prktoateieuc-21? (`ong-negh, 16.1 Lyr)
aoi bh ushf gkr s`krthr roimh foteim, usuonny ei akcbeioteki
wetne t`kreuc-214.
V`h trofetekion chosurhchit tha`iequh es by onp`o spha-
trkchtry. V`es rhquerhs bhtwhhi o ghw mrocs oif o ghw this
kg mrocs kg socpnh< t`h upphr omh necet es orkuif 184 Lyr.
O cua` suphrekr opprkoa`, vhry cua` ckrh hxphisevh oif
fhcoifeim kg hxphrtesh, es by t`hrcon ekiesoteki coss
sphatrkchtry (VECQ)< socpnh whem`ts aoi bh nkwhr by o
goatkr kg ?4 oif ei mkkf aeraucstoiahs t`h omh roimh aoi bh
grkc o ghw `uifrhf yhors tk obkut 844 Lyr. Mocco spha
trkchtry aoi onsk bh ushf, wet` t`h ofvoitomh kg bheim obnh
tk chosurh o w`knh sphaechi (h.m. t`h Oromk aroieuc), but
wet` t`h shrekus fesofvoitomhs kg eiarhoshf uiahrtoeity oif
fharhoshf rhneobenety.
1.2. OTTNEAOVEKI
V`hrh `os bhhi wefhsprhof oppneaoteki tk sphnhkt`hcs
but onsk, wet` voryeim fhmrhhs kg suaahss, tk spreim-fhpkset
corn, aonea`h, aonarhth, cknnusaoi s`hnns, roteth hmm s`hnns
(h.m. kstrea`), oif thht` (porteaunorny t`h hiochn). Oppneaotek
tk bkih `os nkim bhhi trehf but, wet` hxahptekis, t`h foto
`ovh bhhi prkbnhcotea. Akron es oi hxahnnhit cothreon<
ont`kum` ikt kg ferhat ora`ohknkmeaon eithrhst, wet` t`h `em`oaauroay kbtoeiobnh useim t`h VECQ tha`iequh et `os o vhry
ecpkrtoit rknh ei hxthifeim aorbki-?6 aonebroteki bhykif
t`h trhh-reim necet.
Qocpnh purety es kih ecpkrtoit quhsteki< porteaunorny
wet` t`h socpnh-typhs just chitekihf, but onsk wet`
sphnhkt`hcs tkk, t`hrh es t`h pkssebenety t`ot fhtreton mroeis
(akitoeieim t`kreuc-214) whrh eiakrpkrothf ot aryston
gkrcoteki t`hrhby coleim t`h opporhit omh hrrkihkusny tkk
knf< vorekus cht`kfs, eianufeim t`h eska`rki tha`iequh, orh
hcpnkyhf tk fhon wet` sua` 'ferty aonaeth'. Vwk kt`hr
eithrghreim hgghats orh rharystonnesoteki oif shakifory
fhpkseteki (kvhrmrkwt`) - bkt` orh fhthatobnh t`rkum`
cearksakpea hxoceioteki kg t`ei shatekis. Rharystonnesoteki
onnkws ckbenesoteki kg uroieuc oif t`kreuc< t`es es kih
gkrc kg 'kphi systhc' ei w`ea` t`h omh es festkrthf by
nkss kr moei. Ei mhihron, oi eifeaoteki t`ot 'ankshf systhc'
akifetekis `ovh ikt hxesthf es mevhi by oi uioaahptobnh
sprhof ei akhvon socpnhs. Bhaoush oromkieth es
eitreiseaonny uistobnh (akivhrteim tk aonaeth) oiy sua`
socpnhs, uigkrtuiothny rot`hr rorh, orh t`her kwi prkkg kg
eithmrety.
6. Aonaeuc-6? oif kt`hr rofekesktkphs
V`h hgghatevh a. 64 Lyr BT necet kg aorbki-?6
eihvetobny prkcpts t`h quhsteki os tk w`ht`hr t`hrh esoikt`hr aksckmhiea rofekesktkph wet` o `ong-negh ckrh
opprkpreoth gkr t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih. Qkch pkssebenetehs
(wet` `ong-nevhs mevhi ei porhit`hses) orh: onuceieuc-27
(=24 Lyr)< bhrynneuc-?4 (?844 Lyr)< aonaeuc-6? (a. ?44
Lyr)< a`nkreih-17 (144 Lyr). Ont`kum` t`hrh es skch
pkssebenety kg useim onuceieuc-27 oif bhrynneuc-?4 gkr
shfechit akrhs, et es kiny aonaeuc-6? t`ot `knfs oiy
prksphat gkr ora`ohknkmeaon oppneaoteki, ki oaakuit kg ets
kaaurrhiah ei bkih. @kwhvhr, w`hrhos aorbki-?6 es
gkrchf ei t`h upphr otcksp`hrh oif es sprhof, t`rkum`
gkrceim aorbki fekxefh, ckrh kr nhss uiegkrcny t`rkum`
t`h beksp`hrh oif t`h kahois, aonaeuc-6? es gkrchf grkc
iki-rofekoatevh aonaeuc-64, ei t`h tkp chtrh kr sk kg skenoif ont`kum` et hithrs bkihs veo pnoit negh t`hrh es ik
cha`oiesc gkr sprhofeim wkrnfwefh< `hiah nkaon
voreotekis eignuhiahf by sken `estkry orh tk bh hxphathf oif
sk t`h tech-zhrk nhvhn es uiahrtoei. O gurt`hr prkbnhc es t`h
feggeaunty kg chosurhchit, hvhi useim oaahnhrotkr coss
sphatrkchtry.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 281/342
2=? CORVEI J. OEVLHI - A@RKIKCHVR?A VHA@IE_XHQ
8. Gesseki troals
Os wet` pktosseuc-ormki t`h coei eivknvhchit es
t`rkum` oppneaoteki tk vknaoiea cothreon wet` w`ea` `ucoi
rhcoeis `ovh bhhi osskaeothf. Hxesteim troals ei ceihrons kg
sua` cothreon orh hroshf by t`h `hoteim ei`hrhit ei t`h
vknaoiea hrupteki. V`hrhogthr spkitoihkus iuanhor gesseki kg
uroieuc-210 ei t`h ceihron aoushs mrofuon rh-oaaucunoteki<
t`h troals aoi bh akuithf useim oi kpteaon cearksakph oif`hiah, ogthr fhthrceieim t`h akithit kg uroieuc oif t`h
shisetevety kg t`h ceihron gkr troal oaqueseteki. t`h tech t`ot
`os hnopshf seiah t`h hrupteki aoi bh hvonuothf. Qkch
suetobnh ceihrons orh zeraki, kbsefeoi, ceao, sp`hih oif
opoteth< `kwhvhr, otthcpts tk foth t`h opoteta akcpkihit kg
`kih oif thht` `ovh sk gor cht wet` feggeaunty.
Oppneaoteki ei rhahit ora`ohknkmy es usuonny runhf kut
bj Qporsety kg troals< gkr t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih t`h ckrh
nelhny prkbnhc tk bh hiakuithrhf es gofeim, e.h. skch nkss kg
troals wet` tech. Qhvhron tha`iequhs `ovh bhhi fhvhnkphf tk
fhon wet` t`es. ockim t`ac t`h pnothou akrrhateki cht`kf.
Ei enees. e`hrh orh suaahssevh oiihoneims kg eiarhoseim
streimhiay oif ogthr hoa` o chosurhchit es cofh kg t`h
rotek kn' t`h iucbhr kg 'os gkuif' troals rhcoeieim ei kih
pkrteki tk t`h iucbhr kg ortegeaeonny-eifuahf troals
rhcoeieim ei oikt`hr pkrteki. Vroal sezh es oikt`hr
porochthr t`ot es ushgun.
Os wet` noshr foteim kg seimnh mroeis by t`h pktosseuc-
ormki tha`iequh et `os t`h strkim ofvoitomh kg uteneseim kiny
o ghw mroeis, t`hrhby ceieceseim akitoceioteki resls. V`h
coei oppneaoteki `os bhhi tk `kceief hvknuteki ei Host
Ogreao.
7. Nuceihsahiah foteim
7.?. BOQEQ
V`es akcpreshs t`hrcknuceihsahiah (VN) oif kpteaon
foteim, t`h notthr uteneseim kpteaonny-stecunothf nuceihs
ahiah (KQN). V`hsh cht`kfs orh boshf ki t`h aucunotevh
hgghat kg iuanhor rofeoteki ki t`h pkseteki kg hnhatrkis ei
t`h aryston struaturh kg ahrtoei ceihrons, coeiny quortz oif
ghnfspor.
V`h iuanhor rofeoteki es prkvefhf by troaå ockuits kg
pktosseuc-64, rubefeuc-0=, t`kreuc oif uroieuc t`ot orh
ioturonny prhshit ei t`h socpnh oif ets surrkuifeims. V`h
foteim semion es kbtoeihf, ei t`h aosh kg VN, by `hoteim
mroeis hxtroathf grkc t`h socpnh oif chosureim t`h nem`t
hcetthf by chois kg o `em`ny shisetevh p`ktkcuntepnehr< ei
t`h aosh kn KQE t`h nuceihsahiah es kbtoeihf b9 s`ereeim
nem`t ki t`h mroeis: noshrs oif `onkmhi nocps aoi bh ushf,
oif onsk, hxahpt wet` quortz, eigrorhf-hcetteim fekfhs - ei
w`ea` aosh t`h nuceihsahiah coy bh thrchf ERQN.
V`h VN tha`iequh wos nërst ushf ei oppneaoteki tk pktthry,
t`h hvhit fothf bheim t`h gereim by t`h oiaehit pktthr
(t`hrhby shtteim tk zhrk t`h prhvekusny oaaucunothf VN).
Qubshquhitny et wos hxthifhf tk stonomcetea aonaeth (w`ea`
`os zhrk VN ot gkrcoteki) oif tk burit gneit. V`h notthr
oppneaoteki, onkim wet` t`h HQR foteim kg tkkt` hiochn, `os
`of porteaunorny ecpkrtoit ecpoat ki `ypkt`hshs akiahrieim
t`h rhnotekis`ep bhtwhhi oiotkceaonny-ckfhri `ucois oif
Ihoifhrt`ons. V`h KQN semion grkc quortz oif ghnfspor, oif
tk o nhsshr hxthit t`h VN semion, aoi onsk bh sht tk zhrk by
hxpksurh tk foynem`t< t`es kaaurs fureim troispkrtoteki oiffhpkseteki kg weifbnkwi shfechit (sua` os nkhss oif soif)
oif secenorny, but nhss hgghatevhny, gkr wothrnoei shfechit.
Ei t`h notthr aosh ush kg KQN es porteaunorny ofvoitomhkus
akcporhf tk VN.
Gkr het`hr cht`kf et es ihahssory tk hvonuoth t`h fksh-
roth kg iuanhor rofeoteki t`ot t`h socpnh `os bhhi rhaheveim
fureim bureon. V`es es fkih portny by rofekoatevh oionyses ei
t`h nobkrotkry oif portny by ki-seth chosurhchit (kg t`h
phihtroteim mocco rofeoteki t`ot rhoa`hs t`h socpnh grkc
ets surrkuifeim sken oif rkal, up tk o festoiah kg obkut
4.1 c). Et es onsk ihahssory tk hstecoth t`h wothr akithit kg
socpnh oif sken/rkal - bhaoush oiy wothr prhshit otthiuoths
t`h iuanhor rofeoteki.
7.2. OTTNEAOVEKI
V`h omh roimh es `em`ny fhphifhit ki socpnh-typh,
tha`iequh, oif seth< ot prhshit shvhron `uifrhf t`kusoif
yhors es o typeaon upphr necet gkr gneit, quortz, aonaeth, oif
shfechit< `kwhvhr eg skch typhs kg ghnfspor orh prhshit ei
t`h notthr t`hrh es o thifhiay gkr t`h omh tk bh uifhrhste-
cothf, porteaunorny bhykif 84 Lyr. V`es es t`rkum` semion
eistobenety (gofeim) oif t`h sk-aonnhf '?44 Lyr borrehr' ei
Hurkphoi oif A`eihsh nkhss `os bhhi t`h subjhat kg cua`
fesausseki oif tha`iknkmeaon rhshora`< ki t`h kt`hr `oif gkr
nkhss grkc Onoslo oif Ihw Zhonoif VN omhs up tk 044 Lyr`ovh bhhi rhpkrthf (Bhrmhr ?552).
]et` gneit oif quortz t`h omh roimh necetoteki oreshs grkc
soturoteki rot`hr t`oi gofeim< `hiah seths kg nkw rofekoatevety
(e.h., nkw fksh-roth) orh ofvoitomhkus. V`h Ceffnh Tnhestk
ahih pkthiteon kg quortz `os bhhi fhckistrothf by @uitnhy
ht on. (?551< ?556) w`k `ovh kbtoeihf akiskioit VN omhs
up tk 044 Lyr gkr o suaahsseki kg `em` sho nhvhn fuih soifs
ei Oustroneo. Oikt`hr opprkoa` tk nkim roimh foteim wet`
quortz es ush kg t`h 'rhf VN phol'< t`es phol fkhs ikt sugghr
grkc soturoteki oif `hiah aoi bh ushf errhsphatevh kg t`h
nhvhn kg seth rofekoatevety. Ki t`h kt`hr `oif et es oppneaobnh
tk vknaoiea prkfuats rot`hr t`oi shfechit< o akiskioit omh
`os bhhi rhpkrthf (Ceonnehr ht on., ?556) gkr puceah fothf ot
804 Lyr omk by pktosseuc-ormki.
Et es tk bh ikthf t`ot Russeoi (oif skch kt`hr) wkrlhrs
`ovh nkim bhhi kbtoeieim cenneki-yhor omhs gkr shfechits
oif rhmorf t`h opprkoa` kg t`h rhst kg t`h nuceihsahiah
akccuiety os bheim ki t`h wrkim troal (shh, gkr eistoiah,
Qnulkv ht on., ?551)< t`es vehw es rhaeprkaothf.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 282/342
2=2 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Hxahpt ot t`h necets kg t`h tha`iequh t`h oaauroay
ottoeiobnh es usuonny ei t`h roimh 8-?4% kg t`h omh. V`h
untecoth borrehr tk bhtthr oaauroay es uiahrtoeity obkut t`h
ovhromh fksh-roth fureim t`h bureon phrekf< bhaoush kg
mhka`hceaon nhoa`eim t`h rofekoatevety coy bh fegghrhit
grkc t`ot chosurhf tkfoy oif nelhwesh t`h wothr akithit
bhaoush kg anecotea gnuatuoteki. Os chitekihf obkvh t`h
wothr obskrbs o prkpkrteki kg t`h rofeoteki gnux oif `hiahseths w`ea` `ovh onwoys bhhi bkih-fry orh ofvoitomhkus.
Aknnhateki kg shfechit socpnhs es bhst fkih by o
nobkrotkry sphaeonest os sphaeon prhaoutekis ihhf tk bh tolhi
ei krfhr tk ovkef t`h snem`thst hxpksurh tk foynem`t. V`h
usuon opprkoa` es tk frevh o s`krt sthhn tubh (obkut 8 ac
feochthr by ?4 ac nkim) eitk t`h shateki, t`h hxpkshf hifs
bheim fesaorfhf fureim nobkrotkry prkahsseim (ei vhry
subfuhf rhf nem`t)< eg t`h shfechit es Akisknefothf t`hi o
nucp aoi bh tolhi oif t`h surgoah sarophf kgg ei t`h
nobkrotkry. V`h `knh cofh gkr hxtroateki kg socpnh es ushf
gkr chosurhchit kg t`h mocco-roy fksh-roth, het`hr wet` o
pkrtobnh mocco sphatrkchthr (toleim oi `kur), kr, by bureon
kg o sconn aopsunh gennhf wet` o `em`ny-shisetevh
t`arcknuceihsahiah pkwfhr (gkr upworfs kg shvhron
ckit`s, prhghrobny o yhor).
=. Hnhatrki Qpei Rhskioiah (HQR)
V`es es yht oikt`hr woy kg chosureim t`h aucunotevh
hgghat kg iuanhor rofeoteki. nts preiaepon ora`ohknkmeaon
oppneaotekis `ovh bhhi tk tkkt` hiochn oif tk stonomcetea
aonaeth. Ei tech roimh HQR rhoa`hs boal tk shvhron cenneki
yhors omk< ets nkwhr necet es o ghw t`kusoif yhors. Os wet`
onn tha`iequhs, aorhgun shnhateki kg chosurhchit porochthrs
es ihahssory gkr vonef rhsunts.
V`h obkvh rhcorls obkut fksh-roth hvonuoteki orhoppneaobnh but wet` offetekion akcpnhxety ei t`h aosh kg
tkkt` hiochn, fuh tk uroieuc cemroteki eitk t`h tkkt`.
Bhaoush kg t`es twk omhs orh qukthf, t`hsh bheim boshf ki
t`h twk ossucptekis obkut t`h teceim kg t`h uroieuc
eimrhss: horny uptolh (HX) oif neihor uptolh (NX). Eg t`h
eithrion rofeoteki gnux es fkceioit t`h HX omh wenn bh
substoiteonny nkwhr t`oi t`h NX omh (but ihvhr nkwhr t`oi
by `ong) w`hrhos eg t`h gnux es prhfkceioitny grkc t`h
bureon sken t`h fegghrhiah es uiecpkrtoit. Normh thht`
(h.m. hnhp`oit, cocckt`) orh prhghrrhf< usuonny shporoth
fhthrceiotekis ki obkut o fkzhi socpnhs orh ovhromhf.
Bhaoush t`h uroieuc-shrehs tha`iequh es onsk ogghathf by
uroieuc cemroteki, but tk o fegghrhit fhmrhh, et es pkssebnh
tk hneceioth t`h uptolh uiahrtoeity by oppnyeim bkt`
tha`iequhs tk t`h soch socpnh. Kbvekusny t`es fkubnhs t`h
wkrl oif t`hrh es onsk necetoteki ei oaauroay - tk obkut
¿?4% kg t`h omh, w`hrhos t`h oaauroay gkr o 'stroem`t' HQR
foth eg o porteaunor uptolh ckfhn es ossuchf es o nettnh bhtthr
t`oi gkr nuceihsahiah, t`kum` secenorny necethf by
uiahrtoeity obkut ovhromh wothr akithit.
0. Oceik Oaef Roahcezoteki (OOR)
V`h foteim es boshf ki t`h snkw akivhrseki wet`ei o
prkthei cknhaunh kg oi oceik oaef (sua` os osportea) grkc
ets N gkrc, ot gkrcoteki, tk ets F gkrc, uiten oi hquenebreuc
cexturh kg t`h twk es rhoa`hf. Hpechrezoteki kg esknhuaeih
es oikt`hr rhoateki uteneshf, iktobny ei t`h foteim kg kstrea`
hmms`hnns. V`hsh prkahsshs orh strkimny eignuhiahf by
hiverkichiton akifetekis, thcphroturh ei porteaunor. Qeth-by-seth aonebroteki omoeist rofekaorbki es usuon oif gkr mkkf
rhneobenety t`h socpnhs ushf gkr t`es s`kunf bh kg t`h soch
typh oif soch prhshrvoteki akifeteki os t`h kihs bheim foth
Ei horny oppneaoteki t`h tha`iequh oaquerhf o rhputoteki
gkr uirhneobenety, porteaunorny ei oppneaoteki tk pkkrny
prhshrvhf bkih. @kwhvhr mkkf rhneobenety es ikw bheim
kbtoeihf by aorhgun shnhateki kg socpnh typhs (sua` os
kstrea` hmms`hnn os chitekihf obkvh, whnn-prhshrvhf bkih,
oif tkkt` hiochn), streat otthiteki tk t`h vonefety kg t`h
rofekaorbki foths ushf gkr aonebroteki, oif ckrh streimhit
nobkrotkry prkahfurhs. Xseim osportea oaef t`h nost 84-?44 Ly
aoi bh akvhrhf oif, useim t`h hpechrezoteki kg esknhuaeih,
rhoa`eim `ong-o-cenneki yhors es ghosebnh. Bhsefhs hxthiseki
kg omh roimh oikt`hr ofvoitomh kvhr rofekaorbki es t`h
akcporotevh hosh kg chosurhchit oif `hiah nkwhr akst - sk
t`ot oi ora`ohknkmest aoi uifhrtolh o cua` wefhr socpneim
kg seth t`oi akunf bh oggkrfhf useim rofekaorbki kiny.
Ei t`h akithxt kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih et es porteaunorny
ecpkrtoit tk lhhp ei ceif t`h strkim eignuhiah kg
thcphroturh< et es ikt kiny ihahssory tk chosurh t`h
prhshit-foy vonuh ot t`h seth but onsk tk hstecoth t`h
thcphroturh `estkry kg t`h seth t`rkum` w`othvhr mnoaeons
oif eithrmnoaeons `ovh kaaurrhf fureim t`h bureon phrekf.
Hvhi kiny os gor boal os t`h nost eithrmnoaeon t`es eitrkfuahs
offhf uiahrtoeity oif et bhakchs opprkpreoth tk aonaunothomhs ki t`h boses kg fegghrhit thcphroturh sahioreks (shh, gk
hxocpnh, Cennhr ht on. ?551). Oi onthriotevh opprkoa` tk
aonebroteki, porteaunorny ei t`h aosh kg s`hnns, es oceik-
xtrotemrop`y< a`oroathrestea (F/N) roteks orh hstobnes`hf os
bheim rhprhshitotevh kg porteaunor anecotea p`oshs, et bheim
ecpkrtoit tk lhhp ei ceif t`ot F tk N akivhrseki roths gkr
s`hnn orh sphaehs-sphaegea os whnn os hiverkichitonny
fhphifhit. O rhahit oppneaoteki tk seths hxthifeim eitk t`h
Ceffnh Tnhestkahih kg ikrt`whsthri Groiah `os bhhi rhpkrthf
by Boths(?551).
5. Kbsefeoi @yfroteui
V`es tkk es o a`hceaon prkahss strkimny eignuhiahf by
hiverkichiton akifetekis, porteaunorny thcphroturh. Et es
boshf ki t`h snkw gkrcoteki kg `yfroteki recs ki grhs`ny-
anhovhf kbsefeoi. Xiten t`h noth ?5=4's t`h govkuraf
opprkoa` wos by rhmekion aonebroteki useim likwi-omh
socpnhs. Qeiah t`hi t`h hcp`oses `os bhhi ki kbtoeieim
obsknuth omhs eifhphifhit kg kt`hr tha`iequhs kr
ora`ohknkmeaon a`rkiknkmy. V`es opprkoa` rhquerhs twk
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 283/342
2=1 CORVEI J. OEVLHI - A@RKIKCHVREA VHA@IE_XHQ
cojkr hvonuotekis ei offeteki tk chosurhchit kg t`h
`yfroteki rec etshng: (e) t`h hgghatevh bureon thcphroturh oif
(ee) nobkrotkry chosurhchit (ot hnhvothf thcphroturh oif
prhssurh) kg t`h rec mrkwt`-roth gkr hoa` typh kg kbsefeoi
t`ot es fothf.
Foths `ovh bhhi rhpkrthf ei t`h omh roimh grkc 244 tk
nKK.KKK yhors omk. Mrkwt`-roths vory wefhny bhtwhhi
fegghrhit ports kg t`h wkrnf< t`h akcporotevhny ropef`yfroteki roths ei trkpeaon akuitrehs onnkw ckrh rhahit
foteim t`oi ei Oratea rhmekis.
?4. V`h Mhkcomihtea Rhvhrson Vech Qaonh
(MRVQ)
O gksseneshf rhakrf kg t`h ferhateki kg t`h post
mhkcomihtea gehnf (mhihrothf t`rkum` fyiock oateki ei t`h
hort`'s cknthi akrh) es prkvefhf by t`h whol but phrcoihit
comihtesoteki t`ot es oaquerhf by novo os et akkns fkwi,
nelhwesh gkr bolhf anoy oif `hothf stkihs< shfechit coy
onsk oaquerh o gksseneshf rhakrf fureim fhpkseteki (uifhr
suetobnh akifetekis) kr fureim subshquhit akisknefoteki.
V`es notthr typh kg comihtesoteki es hvhi wholhr oif et es
nhss rkbust, bheim vunihrobnh bkt` tk festurboiah oif tk
'kvhrpreiteim' fureim nothr phrekfs w`hi t`h gehnf coy `ovh
o fegghrhit ferhateki< `kwhvhr vorekus comihtea 'anhoieim'
tha`iequhs aoi bh ushf tk hneceioth sua` kvhrpreits oif sk
fhthrceih t`h precory ferhateki. Qhfechit `os t`h strkim
ofvoitomh kg meveim o cua` ckrh akiteiukus rhakrf t`oi
novo< ki t`h kt`hr `oif, porteaunorny w`hi t`h comihtesoteki
es oaquerhf fureim akisknefoteki, et coy bh t`h ovhromh
ferhateki kvhr shvhron `uifrhf yhors t`ot es rhakrfhf,
t`hrhby sckkt`eim-kut ropef a`oimhs os whnn os eitrkfuaeim
o tech nom.
Rkum`ny hvhry cenneki yhors t`hrh es o rhvhrson kg t`hferhateki kg t`h gehnf ki t`h hort`'s surgoah< t`es gknnkws o
fyeim-fkwi kg t`h hort`'s fyiock, t`hrh bheim o 84:84
a`oiah kg et storteim up ei t`h kppkseth ferhateki tk
gkrchrny. V`h shquhiah kg sua` rhvhrsons es t`h boses kg t`h
comihtea tech saonh (onthcotevhny aonnhf t`h Mhkcomihtea
Tknorety Vech Qaonh - MTVQ). V`h cojkr rhvhrsons orh
likwi os a`rkis (h.m. t`h Cotuyoco a`rki< t`es rhvhrshf
a`rki prhahfhf t`h prhshit 'ikrcon' pknorety Brui`hs
a`rki)< t`hrh `ovh onsk bhhi s`krthr hpeskfhs kg a`oimhf
pknorety oif t`hsh orh likwi os suba`rkis (h.m. t`h
Jorocennk< t`es ikrcon suba`rki nosthf obkut 74 Lyr oif
kaaurrhf ihor t`h hif kg t`h Cotuyoco).
Ei hornehr thrceiknkmy anossegeaotekis sua` os 'obkrthf
rhvhrsons', 'hxaursekis', oif 'hvhits' whrh ushf. V`hsh
thifhf tk bh ushf gkr hpeskfhs kg ferhatekion eistobenety
oif t`hy whrh ikt ihahssoreny wkrnfwefh< nkaoneshf
hpeskfhs kaaur w`hi. fureim o phrekf kg whol coei
fyiock, t`h gehnf grkc hnhatreaon hffehs ihor t`h surgoah
kg t`h cknthi akrh moei fkceioiah< `kwhvhr sua`
setuotekis usuonny rhsunt ei veknhit a`oimhs kg ferhateki
w`ea` stkp s`krt kg rhvhrson. V`h hgghats kg p`yseaon
festurboiah tk t`h shfechit coy bh cestolhi gkr sua` oi
hpeskfh oif sua` akiguseki es kih kg t`h goatkrs t`ot colh
et ecpkrtoit tk eithrprht t`h comihtea rhakrf akishrvotevhny.
Qua` hgghats coy onsk bh ceseithrprhthf gkr t`h kaaurrhiah
kg o rhvhrson tkk oif w`hi o rhvhrson es bheim eighrrhf t`hrh
s`kunf onwoys bh gunn pubneaoteki kg t`h comihtea foto sk
t`ot osshsschit kg t`h strhimt` kg t`h hvefhiah, oif phr`opsnothr rhosshsschit, aoi bh cofh. O aosh ei pkeit es t`h
Etoneoi seth kg Eshrieo chitekihf hornehr gkr w`ea`, tk t`es
out`kr's likwnhfmh, t`hrh `os stenn bhhi ik prkphr
pubneaoteki kg t`h comihtea foto ckrh t`oi o fhaofh ogthr et
bheim thitotevhny rhpkrthf t`ot t`h gkssen-bhoreim shfechit
wos fhpksethf fureim t`h Cotuyoco a`rki. Xiten t`h foto
orh prhshithf t`es ossemichit s`kunf bh trhothf wet` strkim
rhshrvoteki.
Ot kih tech et wos `kphf t`ot wholhr voreotekis ei
ferhateki t`oi t`h obkvh cem`t bh hgghatevh ei foteim
Tonohknet`ea shfechits but et es kiny kvhr t`h nost ghw
t`kusoif yhors t`ot t`hsh shaunor voreotekis `ovh prkvhf
ushgun oif hvhi t`hi, coeiny gkr pktthry lenis oif `hort`s
rot`hr t`oi shfechits. Qua` foteim es usuonny aothmkreshf
os ora`ohkcomihtesc rot`hr t`oi ponohkcomihtesc.
V`h a`rkiknkmy kg t`h vorekus a`rkis oif suba`rkis es
boshf precoreny ki pktosseuc-ormki foteim kg t`h novo ei
w`ea` t`h comihtea ferhateki wos rhakrfhf oif uiten
rhahitny t`h oaahpthf omhs whrh t`ksh mevhi by Coileihi
oif Fonrycpnh (?5=5)< `kwhvhr rh-hvonuotekis (h.m., Bolse
ht on. ?552< Bolse ?551< Qphnn oif CaFkumonn ?552)
eifeaoth o snem`t nhimt`hieim kg t`h techsaonh sk t`ot t`h
Brui`hs-Cotuyoco bkuifory es ikw pnoahf ot 4.=0 Cyr
(rot`hr 4.=1 Cyr), t`h Jorocennk suba`rki grkc 4.55 tk
?.48 Cyr (rot`hr t`oi 4.54-4.5= Cyr), oif t`h Knfuvoesuba`rki grkc ?.=0 tk 2.42 Cyr omk (rot`hr t`oi ?.7=-
?.0= Cyr).
Bhaoush t`h suaahsseki kg rhvhrsons es onsk rhakrfhf ei
t`h shfechit akrhs grkc w`ea` kxymhi esktkpa voreotekis
orh kbtoeihf, t`h a`rkis oif suba`rkis aoi onsk bh fothf
ostrkikceaonny (shh bhnkw). Ei goat t`h rhvesekis chitekihf
obkvh whrh subshquhit tk, oif ei omrhhchit wet`, t`h
ostrkikceaonny-boshf eifeaotekis kbtoeihf by Q`oalnhtki ht
on. (?554).
Nkhss (iktobny ei A`eio) onsk aorrehs bkt` o comihtea
rhakrf oif o anecotea rhakrf< t`h notthr es coieghsthf os
voreoteki ei comihtea susahptebenety ki oaakuit kg nkhss`oveim o nkwhr susahptebenety t`oi t`h eithrvhieim
ponohkskns.
??. Kxymhi Esktkph A`rkikstrotemrop`y
V`es a`rkikstrotemrop`y es boshf ki t`h anecotea
fhphifhiah kg t`h esktkph rotek (kxymhi-?0 tk kxymhi-?7)
ei coreih gkssen cearkgouio, stufehf ei nkim akrhs tolhi
grkc t`h kahoi gnkkr. V`h rotek es precoreny eignuhiahf by
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 284/342
2=6 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Fhpt` ei akrh (chtrhs)
Gem. ?. Kxymhi esktkph voreoteki ei t`h cearkgouion rhcoeis kg akrh W20-210 grkc t`h Toaegea (rhfrowi grkc Q`oalnhtki oif Kpfylh ?5=1<?5=7). V`h vhrteaon saonh eifeaoths t`h fhveoteki (ei ports phr t`kusoif) kg t`h kxymhi-?0 akithit grkc o Qtoiforf< t`h ckrh ihmotevh t`hfhveoteki t`h worchr t`h anecoth. Foths gkr t`h stomhs orh mevhi ei Vobnh ?. Xseim nkimhr akrhs coiy ckrh stomhs t`oi s`kwi `hrh `ovh ikw
bhhi efhitegehf. Hsshiteonny t`h soch potthri kg voreoteki es gkuif ei akrhs kbtoeihf hnshw`hrh orkuif t`h wkrnf, ei omrhhchit wet` t`h
eithrprhtoteki kg t`h voreotekis os precoreny rhgnhateim t`h ockuit kg wothr nkalhf up ei t`h pknor eah aops oif ei mnoaehrs. Comihteachosurhchits ki t`h shfechit ei t es oif kt`hr akrhs eifeaoth t`ot t`h Brui`hs-Cotuyoco troiseteki kaaurrhf fureim Qtomh ?5.
t`h ockuit kg wothr nkalhf up ei pknor eah aops oif
mnoaehrs< `hiah et rhgnhats wkrnfwefh anecoth. Gemurh ? es oi
hxocpnh kg t`h voreotekis gkuif oif et onsk eifeaoths t`h
suaahsseki kg akkn oif worc stomhs fhgeihf ki t`h boses kg
t`h rotek< worc stomhs `ovh kff iucbhrs oif akkn stomhs
`ovh hvhi. V`h soch potthri kg voreoteki `os bhhi gkuif ei
kahoi akrhs grkc fegghrhit ports kg t`h wkrnf oif t`h
akrrhnoteki wet` et kg Akiteihiton anecoth es hvefhiahf ei
vorekus woys, h.m. comihtea susahptebenety voreotekis, pknnhigrhquhiay voreotekis ei phot bkms< pknnhi eifeaotekis ei
kahoi akrhs.
porhit`hses< gkr Qtomhs ?-?7 t`h rhveshf omhs fk ikt fegghr grkcQTHACOT omhs by ckrh t`oi 8 Lyr.
Vobnh ?. Kxymhi esktkph stomh: akcchiahchit omhs (ei Lyr).
Qtomh Omh Qtomh Omh
E ?2 EE 621
2 26 ?2 6=Q
e 85 ?1 826
6 =? ?6 8f8
8 ?20 ?8 724
7 ?07 ?7 785
= 268 ?= =?2 (705)0 141 EQ =74 (=27)
5 115 ?5 =0= (=17)
?4 172 24 0?4 (=71)
2? 078 (=54)
Ikth: Gkr Qtomhs ?-?7 t`h omhs orh os mevhi ei t`h QTHACOTaonebroteki kg Ecbreh ht on. (?506)< gkr Qtomhs ?=-2? t h omhs orhgrkc Bosseikt ht on. (?556) wet` t`h QTHACOT omhs mevhi ei
Esktkph voreotekis eifeaotevh kg anecoth orh onsk gkuif ei
nkim akrhs frennhf eitk t`h pknor eah aops< t`hsh s`kw ckrh
fhtoen t`oi t`h coreih akrhs oif t`hrh es eifeaoteki t`ot
t`hrh es akrrhnoteki wet` Hurkphoi eithrstofeons.
Os chitekihf obkvh t`h rhcoihit comihtesoteki kg t`h
shfechit ei t`h kahoi akrhs onnkws akrrhnoteki wet` t`h
mhkcomihtea rhvhrson tech saonh oif `hiah t`h obsknuth
foteim by pktosseuc-ormki kg t`h novos ei w`ea` t`h
hnhchits kg t`h rhvhrson shquhiah orh kbshrvhf aoi bh
troisghrrhf tk t`h akrhs oif `hiah tk t`h stomhs. @kwhvhr
ikw t`ot et `os bhhi hstobnes`hf t`ot t`hrh es mkkf
akrrhnoteki bhtwhhi t`h anecotea potthri eifeaotaf by t`h
esktkph rotek oif t`h Cenoilkveta` ostrkikceaon prhfeatekis
boshf ki a`oimhs ei t`h hort`'s krbeton ckteki (haahitreaety
kg t`h krbet orkuif t`h sui< kbnequety kg t`h haneptea<
prhahsseki kg t`h hqueikxhs) t`h suaahsseki kg stomhs aoi b
fothf ostrkikceaonny oif `hiah wet` bhtthr oaauroay - tk
t`h krfhr kg orkuif 8 Lyr.
?2. Akianufeim rhcorls
Oi ecpkrtoit a`oroathrestea kg t`h gkrhmkeim tha`iequhs e
t`ot t`hy orh obsknuth, ei t`h shish kg meveim omhs ei
aonhifor yhors t`ot orh boshf hsshiteonny kiny ki nobkrotkry
chosurhchits< hxahpteim t`h comihtea tech saonh oif
oceik oaef ei ets aonebrothf gkrc, t`hy orh eifhphifhit kg
oiy kt`hr a`rkiknkmy, ora`ohknkmeaon kr kt`hrwesh.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 285/342
2=8 CORVEI J. O?VLHI - A@RKIKCHVREA VHA@IE_XHQ
Ahrtoeiny skch meva rot`hr wefh hrrkr necets oif t`hrh `ovh
bhhi aoshs kg uirhneobenety oif ofjustchit but t`h
ecpkrtoiah kg t`her eifhphifhiah s`kunf ikt bh
ueunae vonuhf. Ei (`h nkim rui t`h "sk-aonnhf obsknuth foteim
cht`kfs" (Rkhbrkhls ?556: 141) wenn mevh o gerrihr
gkuifoteki tk t`h uifhrstoifeim kg `ucoi fhvhnkpchit t`oi
bekstrotemrop`y< pkwhrgun oif ecpkrtoit t`kum` t`h notthr
coy bh et es t`h chray kg rhmekion iki-syia`rkihety w`hiushf ki bhtwhhi-rhmeki boses. Ei porteaunor et s`kunf bh oi
urmhit prekrety tk akigerc by a`rkikchtrea foteim t`h
vonefety kg t`h 'vknh ankal' (Mocbnh ?556: 2=8) os o `ong-
cenneki yhor tech corlhr t`rkum`kut Hurkph.
Areteaescs kg t`h a`rkikchtrea tha`iequhs orh kgthi ei
rhsphat kg rhsunts kbtoeihf ei o tha`iequh's eigoiay oif/kr
rhsunts ikt prkphrny pubnes`hf< skchtechs onsk uirhneobenety
sthris trkc pkkr osskaeoteki kg t`h socpnhs ushf wet` t`h
ora`ohknkmy. Qua` areteaescs fk nhss t`oi justeah tk t`h
prhshit stoth-kg-t`h-ort kg pktosseuc-ormki foteim (ei ets
seimnh mroei ormki-ormki ckfh) oif tk coss-sphatrkchtrea
uroieuc-shrehs foteim (VECQ): t`h gkrchr ikw `os t`h
rhcorlobnh oa`ehvhchit kg rhfuaeim hrrkr necets ei cenneki-
yhor socpnhs tk o ghw phrahit oif t`h notthr kg bheim o boses
gkr aonebroteim rofekaorbki omhs. Ont`kum` t`h tha`iequhs kg
nuceihsahiah oif HQR orh ikt yht gunny fhvhnkphf t`her
akitrebuteki `os onrhofy bhhi kg areteaon ecpkrtoiah ei t`h
uifhrstoifeim kg t`h kremei kg ckfhri `ucois (h.m., Oetlhi
oif Wonnofos ?552< Qa`woraz oif Mrþi ?552). V`h gurt`ar
prkmrhss kg t`hsh ckrh wefhny oppneaobnh tha`iequhs ihhfs
t`h akiteiuhf stecunoteki kg oppneaoteki oif fureim t`otihahssory p`osh t`hrh wenn eihvetobny bh skch rhsunts nothr
s`kwi tk bh uirhneobnh. But et es ei t`h nkim thrc eithrhsts
kg ora`ohknkmests tk tknhroth t`hsh - oif tk ceiecesh t`her
ecpoat by emikreim rhsunts ikt prkphrny pubnes`hf ei o gunny-
rhghrhhf jkurion, wet` fuh osshsschit kg rhneobenety.
Xntecothny et es kiny t`oils tk a`rkikchtrea tha`iequhs t`ot
et es pkssebnh tk colh oiy hstecoth kg t`h poah kg `ucoi
fhvhnkpchit oif t`h krfhr kg hvhits ki o wkrnfwefh boses.
V`es pophr `os otthcpthf kiny t`h brehghst kutneih kg t`h
tha`iequhs akiahrihf< gurt`hr fhtoens, oif ckrh rhghrhiahs
tk kremeion pophrs, aoi bh gkuif hnshw`hrh (gkr eistoiah,
Oetlhi ?554< Qcort oif Groiahs ?55?< Voynkr oif Oetlhi
?558).
rhghrhiahs
Oetlhi, C.J.
Oetlhi, C.J.,
Wonnofos, @.
?554 Qaehiah-`oshf foteim ei ora`ohknkmy. Nkifki oif Ihw Ukrl: Nkimcoi.
?552 Nuceihsahiah foteim rhnhvoit tk `ucoi kremeis. Ei: C.J. Oetlhi, A.B. Qtreimhr oif
T.O. Chnnors (hfs). V`h kremei kg ckfhri `ucois oif t`h ecpoat kg a`rkikchtrea foteim,2=-15, Treiahtki, Ihw Uhrshy: Treiahtki Xievhrsety Trhss.
Bolse, O.L.,
W. @su,
C.K. Ca]enneocs,
E'. n-'orrhe
?552 64
Or/ 1'Or foteim kg t`h Brui`hs-Cotuyoco mhkcomihtea gehnf rhvhrson, Qaehiah 287, 187-
18=.
Bolse, O.L. ?551 O ihw Mhkcomihtea Tknorety Vech Qaonh gkr 4-?= Co. Mhkp`yseaon Rhshora` Nhtthrs 24(?8), ?74=-?7?4.
Bosseik, G.A.,
N.F. Nobhyreh,
H. Weiahit,P. _uefhnnhur,
I.J. Q`oalnhtki,
U. Noiahnkt
?556 V`h ostrkikceaon t hkry kg anecoth oif t`h omh kg t`h Brui`hs-Cotuyoco comihtearhvhrson, Hort` oif Tnoihtory Qaehiah Nhtthrs ?27, 5?-?40.
Boths, CR. ?551 _uothriory oceikstrotemrop`y ei ikrt`whsthri Groiah, _uorthriory Qaehiah Rhvehws ?2,=5?-045.
Bhrmhr. M.]. ?552 Foteim nkhss up tk 044 lo by t`hrck-nuceihsahiah, Mhknkmy 24, 641-647.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 286/342
2=7 V@H HORN?HQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Akntkrte, C.,
C. Arhcosa`e,
C.A. Fhnetono,
F. Hsu,
C. Gkrioshre,
O. CaT`hrrki.
C. Ieaknhtte,
R. voi Ktthrnkk,
A. Thrhttk,B. Qono,
W. Qa`ceft,
J. Qhveil
?502 Rhvhrshf comihtea pknorety ot oi horny nkwhr ponohknet`ea seth ei Ahitron Etony, Ioturh 14
?=1-?=7.
Mocbnh, A.
@uitnhy, F.J.,
J.V. @uttki,
J.R. Trhsaktt
?556 Vech gkr Bkxmrkvh coi, Ioturh 175, 2=8-2=7.
?551 V`h stroifhf bhoa`-fuih shquhiah kg skut`-host Oustroneo: o thst kg t`hrcknuceihsahiah
foteim, 4-044 lo, _uothriory Qaehiah Rhvehw ?2, ?-24.
Ecbreh, J.,
J.F. @oys,
F.M. Corteiski,
O. Canityrh,
O.A. Cex,
J.J. Ckrnhy,
I.M. Teseos,
].N. Trhnn,
I.J. Q`oalnhtki
?556 Gurt`hr t`hrcknuceihsahiah foths grkc t h fuih shquhiah ei t`h skut`-host kg Oustroneo,
_uothriory Qaehiah Rhvehw, ei prhss.
?556 V`h krbeton t`hkry kg Tnhes tkahih anecoth: suppkrt grkc o rhveshf a`rkiknkmy kg t`h
coreih f'*4 rhakrf. Ei: O. Bhrmhr, J. Ecbreh, J. @oys, M. Lulno oif B. Qontzcoi (hfs),
Celclkveta` oif Anecoth, port E', 275-148, Fkrfha`t, @knnoif: Tnhiuc Rhefhn.
Coileihi, H.O.,
M.T. Fonrycpnh
?5=5 Rhveshf mhkcomihtea pknorety techsaonh gkr t`h eithrvon 4-8 c.y. B.T., Jkurion kg'Mhk-
p`yseaon Rhshora` 06 (B2), 7?8-727.
Ceonnehr, F.,
J. Goei,
Q. Qoizhnnh,
V.@. Tennhyrh,
C. Ckitrht.
Q. Qkucoio,
A. Gonmuàrhs
?556 Otthcpts ot foteim puceah fhpkse ts orkuif 804 lo by ush kg rhf VN oif HQR kg xhik-
net`ea eianusekis, Rofeoteki Chosurachits 21, 155-646.
Cennhr, M.@.,
T.B. Bhouckit,
O.J.V. June,
B. Jk`iski
?551 Tnhestkahih mhka`rkiknkmy oif ponohkt`hrckchtry grkc prkthei feomhihses ei kstrea`
hmms`hnns: ecpneaotekis gkr t`h hvknuteki kg ckfhri `ucois. Ei: CJ. Oetlhi.
A.B. Qtreimhr oif T.O. Chnnors (hfs), V`h kremei kg ckfhri `ucois oif t`h ecpoat kg
a`rkikchtrea foteim, 65-70, Treiahtki, Ihw Jhrshy: Treiahtki Xievhrsety Trhss.
Rkhbrkhls, ].
Qa`woraz, @.T.,
R. Mreni
?556 Xpfoteim t`h hornehs t kaaupot eki kg Hurkph, Aurrhit Oit`rkpknkmy 18, 14?-148.
?552 Hnhatrki spei rhskioiah (HQR) foteim kg t`h kremei kg ckfhri coi. Ei: C.J. Oetlhi,
A.B. Qtreimhr oif T.O. Chnnors (hfs), V`h kremei kg ckfhri `ucois oif t`h ecpoat kg
a`rkikchtrea foteim, 64-60, Treiahtki, Ihw Jhrshy: Treiahtki Xievhrsety Trhss.
Qhveil, J.,
H.@. @hbhfo,
@.I.O. Trehc,
R.@. Whrsa`urh
?50? O ikth ki oi opprkxecothny =14,444-yhor-knf coccon gouio oif osskaeothf `ucoi
oatevety seths ihor Eshrieo, Ahitron Etony, Jkurion kg Ora`ohknkmeaon Qaehiah 0, ?48-?47.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 287/342
2== CORVEI J. OEVLHI - A@RKIKCHVREA VHA@IE_XHQ
Q`oalnhtki, I.J..
O. Bhrmhr,
].R. Thntehr
?554 Oi onthriotevh ostrkikceaon aonebroteki kg t`h nkwhr Tnhestkahih techsaonh boshf ki KFT
seth 7==, Vroisoatekis Rkyon Qkaehty Hfei`urm`, Hort` Qaehiahs 0? , 28?-27?.
Q`oalnhtki, I.J.,
I.F. Kpfylh
?5=1 Kxymhi esktkph oif ponohkcomihtea strotemrop`y kg hquotkreon Toaegea akrh W20-210:
thcphroturhs oif eah vknuchs ki o ?4' oif ?47 yhor saonh, _uonhriory Rhshora` 1, 15-88.
?5=7 Kxymhi-esktkph oif ponohkcomihtea strotemrop`y kg hquotkreon Toaegea akrh W20-215: Noth
Tnekahih tk nothst Tnhestkahih. Ei: R.C. Aneih oif J.F. @oys (hfs), Eivhstemoteki kj Noth_uonhriory Tonhkkahoikmrop`y oif Tonhkanecotknkmy, Chcker ?68, Mhknkmeaon Qkaehty
kg Ochreao, 665-676, Aknkrofk: Bkunfhr.
Qnulkv, O.N.,
Q.O. Q`ol`kvhts,
N.V. Wkslkvsloyo,
CM. Nyos`hilk
Qcort, T.N.,
T.F, Groiahs (hfs)
Qphnn, V.N.,
E. CaFkumonn
Qwes`hr, A.A.,
M.@. Aurtes.
V. Joakb,
O.M. Mhtty,
O. Quprejk.
]efeosckrk
?551 O areteaesc kg Qtoiforf VN foteim tha`iknkmy, Iuanhor Eistruchits oif Cht`kfs ei
T`yseas Rhshora` =1, 1=1-10?.
?55? _uonhriory foteim cht`kfs: o ushr's muefh. Vha`ieaon muefh ik. 6, _uothriory Rhshora`
Osskaeoteki, Aocbrefmh.
?552 Rhvesekis tk t`h omh kg t`h Brui`hs-Cotuyoco bkuifory oif t`h Tnhestkahih mhkcomihtea
pknorety techsaonh, Mhkp`yseaon Rhshora` Nhtthrs ?5, ??0?-??06.
?556 Omh kg t`h hornehst likwi `kceiefs ei Jovo, Eifkihseo, Qaehiah 271, ???0-??2?.
Vorneim, F.@.
Voynkr, R.H.,
C.J. Oetlhi (hfs)
?501 Tonohkcomihtesc. Nkifki oif Ihw Ukrl: A`opcoi oif @onn.
?558 A`rkikchtrea Foteim ei Ora`ohknkmy. Ihw Ukrl: Tnhiuc Trhss.
Cortei J. Oetlhi
Hchretus Trkghsskr kg Ora`ohkchtry
Kxgkrf Xievhrsety
7 Lhbnh Rkof
Kxgkrf KP? 1_J
Xiethf Leimfkc
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 288/342
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 289/342
aeevh s Mocbnh ?7 V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph:t`h hiverkichiton boalmrkuif
V`h oec kgt`es akitrebuteki es tk hxoceih skch kg t`h
hiverkichiton essuhs surrkuifeim t`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg
Hurkph. V`h hvefhiah prhshithf bkt` ei t`es vknuch oif ot
t`h HQG wkrls`kp ei Voutovhn roeshf essuhs obkut seth
rhakistruhtekis, rhmekion akcporeskis, t`h fhgeieteki kg
Hurkph oif t`h ecpoat kg fegghrhit a`rkiknkmeaon saonhs gkr
ckfhnneim t`h roth kg`ucoi hvknuteki oif t`h rknh kg
hiverkichiton shnhateki. V`h hvefhiah akisefhrhf `hrh es
kxymhi esktkph stomh 5 oif knfhr (9144Lyr), oif ets
ora`ohknkmy es pnoahf uifhr t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea gnom kg
akivhiehiah. Ei t`es fesausseki hiverkichit es tolhi tk
rhghr tk t`h p`yseaon a`oimhs tk t`h akiteihit oif t`h hgghat
t`es `of upki pnoit oif oieeion rhskurahs. V`h skaeon
hiverkichit kg t`h hornehst Hurkphoi `kceiefs es ikt
akisefhrhf `hrh. @kwhvhr, t`h aknkiezeim obenety kg t`hsh
`kceiefs, w`ea` cust `ovh eivknvhf skaeon goatkrs, es brehgny
fesausshf oif onthcotevh hiverkichiton ckfhns orh
rhvehwhf w`ea` hxpnoei t`h teceim kg aknkiezoteki.
?. Eitr kfu et eki
Hiverkichiton oionyses eivknvhs coiy spoteon oifthcpkron saonhs (h.m. Butzhr ?502). E frow t`h festeiateki
`hrh bhtwhhi nkaon (kr seth boshf) oionyses w`ea` aoi, w`hiprhshrvoteki es mkkf, prkvefh hvefhiah gkr t`h foy-tk-foyoatevetehs kg horny `kceiefs oif rhmekion stufehs w`hrh techovhromeim fuh tk mhknkmeaon prkahsshs kgthi ihahssetoths onkim-thrc vehw kg bh`ovekur. V`h gkrchr aoi bh soef tkeigkrc us ki oi haknkmeaon techsaonh obkut t`h vorekuswoys t`ot `kceiefs fhont wet` t`h ecchfeoth akifetekis kghxesthiah - whot`hr, gkkf, wothr, prhfotkrs oif kt`hr`kceiefs. V`h rhmekion saonh aoi, ki kaaoseki, offrhss t`hsoch ecchfeoth shnhateki prhssurhs ont`kum` wet` nhssa`rkiknkmeaon prhaeseki. @kwhvhr, et es wefhny oaahpthf eiNkwhr Tonohknet`ea stufehs t`ot kur foto ot t`es saonh rhghr tkmhknkmeaon (kr hvknutekiory) techsaonhs.' V`hsh prkvefh uswet` t`h kppkrtuiety tk kbshrvh nkim-thrc hvknutekioryprkahsshs. V`h prkphr ush kg hiverkichiton foto w`hieithrprhteim t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea rhquerhs t`ot wh lhhpt`hsh oionyteaon akiahpts gercny ei ceif.
V`h oec kg t`es akitrebuteki es tk hxoceih skch kg t`hhiverkichiton essuhs surrkuifeim t`h hornehst kaaupoteki kgHurkph. V`h hvefhiah prhshithf bkt` ei t`es vknuch oif ot
t`h HQG wkrls`kp ei Voutovhn roeshf essuhs obkut sethrhakistruhtekis, rhmekion akcporeskis, t`h fhgeieteki kgHurkph oif t`h ecpoat kg fegghrhit a`rkiknkmeaon saonhs gkrckfhnneim t`h roth kg `ucoi hvknuteki oif t`h rknh kghiverkichiton shnhateki. V`h hvefhiah akisefhrhf `hrh eskxymhi esktkph stomh (KEQ) 5 oif knfhr (9144 Lyr), oif etsora`ohknkmy es pnoahf uifhr t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea gnom kgakivhiehiah. Ei t`es fesausseki hiverkichit es tolhi tkrhghr tk t`h p`yseaon a`oimhs tk t`h akiteihit oif t`h hgghatt`es `of upki pnoit oif oiecon rhskurahs. V`h skaeonhiverkichit kg t`h hornehst Hurkphoi `kceiefs es iktakisefhrhf `hrh. @kwhvhr, t`h aknkiezeim obenety kg t`hsh`kceiefs, w`ea` cust `ovh eivknvhf skaeon goatkrs, esbrehgny fesausshf oif onthcotevh hiverkichiton ckfhns orhrhvehwhf w`ea` hxpnoei t`h teceim kg aknkiezoteki.
2. Nka on hive rkichits oif `k cei ef nkaonhs
2.?. EIVRKFXAVEKI
V`h pophrs ei t`es vknuch fhckistroth t`ot t`h nkaonhiverkichit kg Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea `kceiefs cust bhakisefhrhf os o noifsaoph. V`h ora`ohknkmeaon ikteki kg sethos oppnehf tk oiyt`eim but aovhs `os nettnh rhnhvoiah tk t`h
buseihss kg uifhrstoifeim `kceief bh`ovekur grkc t`esphrekf. ]`ot wh orh fhoneim wet` orh nkaonhs wet`ei noifsaophs w`hrh t`h fhisety kr prhshrvoteki quonety kg cothreones sua` t`ot hxaovoteki `os bhhi fhhchf wkrt`w`enh.2
V`h nkim-thrc eivhstemotekis ot Benzeimsnhbhi oifihem`bkureim trovhrteih fhpksets (Coieo, t`es vknuch), t`hWhikso bosei (Cusse, t`es vknuch), Bkxmrkvh oif t`hQusshx akoston pnoei (Rkbhrts ht on., t`es vknuch), t`h HostHeghn vknaoiea gehnf (Bkseisle, t`es vknuch), t`h Aomiy seths(Vuggrhou oif Oitkeih, t`es vknuch), t`h Coizoiorhs oifJoroco thrroahs oif t`h Muofex-Bozo bosei (Ropksk oifQoitkijo, t`es vknuch) pkeit tk oi oionyteaon saonh t`ot es
cua` normhr t`oi het`hr t`h sezh kg oiy eifevefuon orhohxaovothf wet`ei t`hsh noifsaoph prkjhats, kr hvhi t`hhstecoth kg pkthiteon fhpksets gkr guturh hxaovoteki. V`esnoifsaoph opprkoa` es onsk opporhit ei t`h wkrl ot t`hAouih fh ?'Oromk (Fh Nucnhy, phrs. akcc.)' oif Lufork(Njubei oif Bkseisle, t`es vknuch) w`hrh t`h aovh fhpksetsprkvefh o chois tk hxpnkrh a`oimhs ei t`h surrkuifeimaota`chits.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 290/342
204 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
O noifsaoph opprkoa` es onsk hvefhit ei t`h fesausseki kgw`y <erhos os shporothf os Qaoifeioveo (@knc oif Norsski,t`es vknuch), t`h Reoik bosei ei ahitron Etony (Cusse, t`esvknuch) oif t`h Hbrk fhprhsseki ei Ebhreo (Ropksk oifQoitkijo, t`es vknuch) `ovh ikt prkfuahf geifs kg t`esphrekf, hvhi t`kum` ei t`h nost twk rhmekis CeffnhTnhestkahih shfechits orh prhshit. Kiny ot t`h saonh kgnoifsaophs es et pkssebnh tk osshss w`ht`hr cothreon wkunf`ovh survevhf (Qaoifeioveo), oif eg sk w`hrh, kr t`oteisuggeaeìit rhshora` `os bhhi uifhrtolhi (Hbrk) kr geionnyt`ot kaaupoteki wos ihvhr pkssebnh gkr sua` `kceiefs(Reoik).
V`h sezh kg t`hsh noifsaophs es mhihronny fhgeihf by t`hfestrebuteki kg secenor _uothriory mhknkmy oif t`hcoeitoeioiah kg akcporobnh akithxts gkr prhshrvoteki. Gkrhxocpnh, t`h Whikso bosei chosurhs 84 x 1 lc oif es gennhftk o fhpt` kg 14-84 c. V`h 64 c roeshf bhoa` kg w`ea`Bkxmrkvh es o port hxthifs gkr ot nhost 24 lc wet`shfechits prhshrvhf ei o boif kg ?44-244 c ei grkit kg oaknnopshf a`onl anegg. V`h Host Heghn vknaoiea gehnf akvhrs,
onbhet eithrcetthitny, oi orho kg ot nhost 24 x 28 lc, w`enht`h Muofex-Bozo bosei ihor Mroiofo w`ea` akitoeis fhhpHorny oif Ceffnh Tnhestkahih shfechits gkrcs oi kvon kg?44 x 74 lc (Qoitkijo oif Wenno ?554).
V`h Hurkphoi hvefhiah akiahrieim t`h shttnhchit kgt`hsh vorehf noifsaophs pkeits tk twk whnn likwi'ikrcon' hiverkichits. Gerstny, kphi nkaonhs orhgrhquhitny osskaeothf wet` bkfehs kg wothr roimeim grkccoreih nomkkis tk revhr boils, broefhf strhocs, nolhs (kgvorekus sezhs), trovhrteih spreims, swocps oif cors`hs.Gkr hxocpnh, t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea noifsaoph onkimsefht`h Weo Ourhneo wos fhishny shttnhf. nts coiy akoston
nomkkis oif boal akuitry bkms oif swocps prkvefh oihxocpnh kg t`h haknkmeaonny `em`ny prkfuatevh nkaonhiverkichits w`ea` `kceiefs prhghrrhf (Cusse, t`esvknuch). Ceffnh Tnhestkahih gouios wet` @eppkpktocus
oif Vrkmkit`hreuc (meoit bhovhr) orh akccki `hrh oif eicoiy ports kg Hurkph. Bhovhr `hnphf gkrc t`h nkaonhiverkichit ot Cehshi`hec E, w`ea` akisesthf kg swocpswet` pota`hs kg gkrhst. Onkim t`hsh kvhrmrkwi boils kgt`h Tnhestkahih R`eih `kceiefs `uithf oif saovhimhf(Bkseisle, t`es vknuch).
Qhakifny, ankshf nkaonhs orh rhprhshithf by aovhs oifrkals`hnthrs kg vorehf sezhs. Ei coiy aoshs t`h surrkuifeimtkpkmrop`y oif aota`chits gkr t`h aovhs orh ckrh fevhrsh
ei thrcs kg vhmhtoteki oif t`h oiecon rhskurahs t`hysuppkrt t`oi t`h kphi nkaonhs.
V`hsh twk ikrcon hiverkichits aoi bh eithrprhthf ospksshsseim obkvh ovhromh pkssebenetehs gkr prhshrvoteki oswhnn os prkvefeim oi kbvekus gkaus gkr w`ot orh shhi os lhyosphats ei Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea survevon - s`hnthr, wothr oif`uiteim kppkrtuietehs ot oiecon wothreim pnoahs. Fhaefeim
w`ht`hr sua` ikrcon hiverkichits orh rhprhshitotevh kgwefhr (e.h. owoy grkc revhrs oif aovhs) potthris kg postnoifush rhcoeis prkbnhcotea.
V`hsh nkaonhs onsk suppny eigkrcoteki ki twk coei typhkg 'ikrcon' oaevetehs. V`hsh eivknvhf t`h buta`hry oifprkahsseim kg oiecons ot Eshrieo Qhtt. E t. 1o hnhp`oit, beskioif r`eik, Whikso-Iktora`ereak hnhp`oit (Cusse, t`es
vknuch), Aomiy ?'Hpeihtth ykuim bkvefs oif hquefs(Vuggrhou oif Oitkeih, t`es vknuch), Cehshi`hec rkh oifrhf fhhr, hquefs (Bkseisle, t`es vknuch), Benzeimsnhbhicoiy toxo but iktobny r`eik (Coieo, t`es vknuch), Luforkaovh bhor (Njubei oif Bkseisle, t`es vknuch), Oromk coiytoxo but iktobny cusl kx, rheifhhr oif ckugnki (FhNucnhy, phrs. akcc.) oif Bkxmrkvh r`eik, fhhr, beski oifoi hquef (Rkbhrts ht oe, t`es vknuch). V`h shakif ikrconoaetevety eivknvhf t`h shnhateki oif lioppeim kg stkih ott`hsh nkaonhs. Rhgetteim `os bhhi uifhrtolhi ot coiy kgt`hsh seths oif ei ckst aoshs t`h skurah kg t`h row cothreon`os bhhi troahf tk t`h nkaon aota`chit. V`h festoiahseivknvhf orh onn nhss t`oi 04-?44 lc grkc t`h nkaonhs oif
mhihronny uifhr 14 lc. V`h nkaon ioturh kg t`hsh net`eaaota`chits es whnn s`kwi ei o rhahit stufy kg Oromk (Nhbh?552). Qkchtechs t`h festoiahs whrh ecchfeoth os otBkxmrkvh (Rkbhrts ht on., t`es vknuch) w`hrh gkur gneitbnkals whrh aorrehf =4c grkc t`h aknnopshf sho anegg tk o`krsh aoraoss.
Ki ankshr hxoceioteki t`h ikrcon hiverkichits fkkaaosekionny roesh eithrprhtotevh prkbnhcs gkr skch kg t`hshikrcon oatevetehs. Gkr hxocpnh, ot @kxih t`h ei-setuora`ohknkmeaon cothreon wos oboifkihf ei o ghw ahitechthrkg phrcoihit wothr t`rkum` w`ea` phkpnh cust `ovh wofhf(]ychr ?508: ?75). V`h hiverkichit ei t`h Nkwhr Mrovhn
ot Qwoisakcbh es fhsarebhf by Akiwoy (?5=4: 74) os o'cuffy pkkn ' w`ea` akitoeihf t h Anoatkieoi 'gnkkr'/cef-fhi. V`h orthgoats ot Lornea`-Qhhughr orh gkuif rem`t ot t`hwothrs hfmh (Bkseisle, t`es vknuch), w`enh ot Eshrieo Qhtt. Et. 1o t`h cuf gnot ki w`ea` t`h oiecon bkihs oif orthgoatswhrh fhpksethf wos akvhrhf by o fhbres gnkw (Cusse, t`esvknuch).
Nkaon akifetekis sua` os t`hsh prkvefh hiverkichitonrhoskis w`y t`h ikrcon oatevetehs rhakvhrhf ot t`hsh nkaonhw`hrh prhshrvoteki es mhihronny rhalkihf os mkkf, fk ikteianufh `uts, pets oif pkst `knhs hvhi t`kum` t`h cothreon eskchtechs ei-setu. Kur prech foto coy secpny akch grkchet`hr t`h hfmh kg shttnhchit orhos kr bh skch festoiah grkc
t`hc. @kwhvhr, et coy bh t`ot secenor akifetekis kgfhpkseteki oif prhshrvoteki orh ckrh wefhsprhof t`oi wht`eil oif akishquhitny wh s`kunf ikt oboifki t`h shora`gkr gkrcon aocpseths ei t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea. V`h Benzeimsnhbhi EE trovhrteih (Coieo, t`es vknuch) prkvefhs t`hbhst, pkssebny t`h kiny, aurrhit akithifhr gkr sua` o shttnhchit typh.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 291/342
20? ANEWH Q. MOCBNH - V@H HIWERKICHIVON BOALMRKXIF
@kwhvhr, t`h noal kg `hort`s, oif t`her osskaeothfpotthris kg fhbres oaaucunoteki ei het`hr aovh kr kphinkaonhs, fkhs summhst t`ot wa wenn onwoys bh fhoneim wet`troahs kg vhry fegghrhit typhs kg shttnhchit troahs fureimt`es phrekf.6 Ei t`es akithxt t`h fhtoens kg t`h stkih buent`hort` ot Qknoio fhn Zocbkreik (Ropksk oif Qoitkijo,t`es vknuch) ei t`h Muofex-Bozo bosei rhquerhs gurt`hr
saruteiy.1
2.2. @KCEIEF HIWERKICHIVON VKNHROIAHQ
V`h gkrc kg shttnhchit oif ets rhmekion potthrieim esecpkrtoit ei t`h akithxt kg a`oroathreseim t`h hiverkichitontknhroiahs kg Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea `kceiefs. V`h typeaon nkaonhiverkichits ei coiy ports kg Hurkph s`kw o fevhrsh sht kgakifetekis roimeim grkc eithrmnoaeon tk mnoaeon oif kphi tkankshf gkrhst akifetekis (Rkhbrkhls ht on. ?552: Vobnh ?).Ot t`h Benzeimsnhbhi EE trovhrteih (Coieo, t`es vknuch) t`hpknnhi eifeaoths o fevhrsh, kol-cexhf-gkrhst wet` skut`hrisphaehs. V`es es eithrprhthf os o nem`t, fry kol wkkfnoifeithrsparshf wet` chofkws ei t`h ecchfeoth veaeiety kg t`h
`kceief nkaonh. Fhish gkrhst wos kiny gkuif ei t`h ihorbyvonnhy oif coy whnn `ovh bhhi ovkefhf by t`h `kceiefs.7
V`h noal kg `kceief troahs ei t`h `hoveny wkkfhf Reoikbosei kg ahitron Etony es akitrosthf wet` t`her prhshiah otEshrieo oif kt`ar Etoneoi nkaonhs w`hrh t`h hiverkichit`os bhhi rhakistruathf os kphi wkkfnoif (Cusse, t`esvknuch). V`h hvefhiah gkr t`eiieim kg t`h eithrmnoaeongkrhsts kg hosthri Himnoif (A. Vurihr ?5=4), prhsucobnyby gerh-ossesthf `kceiefs, coy pkssebny bh o gurt`hrhxprhsseki kg o typeaon prhghrrhf vhmhtotekion hiverkichit,t`ot es kphi, cksoea wkkfnoif. V`h kiaknet` fhpksets ott`h Aorphitehr quorry, Obbhvennh, akitoei pknnhi w`ea`
s`kws t`ot uifhr o thcphroth anecoth o cksoea noifsaophkg gkrhst-sthpph hxesthf (Vuggrhou oif Oitkeih, t`esvknuch).
Hvefhiah onsk hxests tk s`kw `kceiefs kaaupyeim oroimh kg suaahssevh bektkphs ot o seimnh nkaonh. Ot t`hAouih fh n'Oromk t`hsh orh rhnothf tk cojkr a`oimhs eihiverkichiton akifetekis oif eivknvh kaaupoteki fureimmnoaeon, eithrstofeon oif eithrmnoaeon akifetekis (Fh Nucnhy,phrs. akcc.). Ot Bkxmrkvh kaaupoteki es gkuif t`rkum`kutt`h eithrmnoaeon KEQ ?1 oif eitk t`h subshquhit cojkr aknfp`osh (Oimneoi/Hnsthreoi), t`h ckst shvhrh ei thrcs kgAkiteihiton eah ofvoiah fureim t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih(Rkbhrts ht on., t`es vknuch). Aomiy-no-Morhiih oif Aomiy-Aechteàrh `ovh kaaupotekis fureim gunn eithrmnoaeon stomhs oswhnn os ei suboratea oif uifhr ckrh akiteihiton anecoteaakifetekis (Vuggrhou oif Oitkeih, t`es vknuch). @kwhvhr,t`hsh akitrosthf anecotea akifetekis whrh ikt uievhrson eiCeffnh Tnhestkahih Hurkph. V`h Ebhreoi Nkwhr Tonohknet`eastenn prkvhs feggeaunt tk krfhr oaakrfeim tk o rhmekion_uothcory strotemrop`y. Kih rhoski es t`ot t`h fegghrhiah
bhtwhhi eithrmnoaeon oif mnoaeon akifetekis ei t`es skut`hrnyoif kahoiea port kg Hurkph orh cua` nhss prkikuiahf t`oiei ckrh ikrt`hrny kr ckrh akiteihiton orhos.
2.1. TRKBNHCQ KG HIWERKICHIVON RHAKIQVRXAVEKI
Bkt` t`h syia`rkieh oif feoa`rkiea hvefhiah pkeits tkpkthiteonny wefh hiverkichiton tknhroiahs gkr Ceffnh
Tnhestkahih `kceiefs. V`hsh uifhrstoifobny orh vhry akorshchosurhs rhnoteim tk vhmhtoteki zkihs, thcphroturh oif t`hprhshiah kg eah. Et es t`hrhgkrh uisurpreseim t`ot akitrkvhrsyhxests akiahrieim t`h obenety kg t`hsh, oif nothr `kceiefs.tk hxpnket porteaunor bektkphs, gkr hxocpnh t`h fhish eithrmnoaeon gkrhsts (Mocbnh ?507< Vuggrhou ?50=, ?554<Rkhbrkhls ht on. ?552< Akiorf ?552). Kih rhoski gkr t`esfhboth nehs ei t`h vhry quonetotevh fhsareptekis t`ot hxest tkfhsarebh post vhmhtoteki os rhakistruathf by het`hr pknnhi krcknnusaoi hvefhiah. Qua` ecprhaeseki rhgnhats t`hcht`kfknkmeaon feggeauntehs kg ponyiknkmy w`hrh aota`chitsezhs vory grkc pknnhi seth tk pknnhi seth. ]`hi t`es goatkres akcbeihf wet` fegghrhiteon pknnhi roei bhtwhhi toxo et es
pkssebnh tk shh w`y syia`rkieh rhakistruatekis orhprkbnhcotea. Ei t`h aosh kg cknnusaoi hvefhiah t`h pota`yioturh kg ckfhri foto ki sphaehs tknhroiahs, festrebutekisoif negh `estkrehs offs tk t`h prkbnhcs kg hiverkichitonrhakistruateki, porteaunorny ot o syia`rkieh saonh. Uht et es ott`h syia`rkieh nhvhn t`ot wh ihhf prhaeseki ei krfhr tkrhakistruat oatevety ei haknkmeaon tech, seiah et es ot t`estechsaonh t`ot shnhateki prhssurh ki `kceief bh`ovekur esckst prkikuiahf.
2.6. CKQOEA @OBEVOVQ
Gkr cht`kfknkmeaon rhoskis wh aoi t`hrhgkrh hxphat t`ot
hiverkichiton rhakistruatekis kg nkaon hiverkichits ot osyia`rkieh nhvhn wenn akiteiuh tk typegy Ceffnh Tnhestkahih`kceiefs os tknhroit kg o wefh roimh kg akifetekis. V`essummhsts t`ot prhshit tha`iequhs oif gkrcs kg oionyses orhikt thnneim us vhry cua`. Oumusth (ei prhss) `os ormuhffegghrhitny. @h pkeits kut t`ot ei ikrt`hri Groiah t`h Nkwhroif Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea rhakrfs thstegy tk `kceiefkaaupoteki fureim eithrmnoaeon, eithrstofeon oif horny mnoaeonakifetekis (Vuggrhou oif Oitkeih, t`es vknuch< Rkbhrtsht on., t`es vknuch). V`h nost p`osh sow o mrhot rhfuateki eit`h iucbhr kg Tonohknet`ea geifs. V`es ihorny akiteiukuskaaupoteki wos pkssebnh bhaoush ot onn techs, `h ormuhs,t`hrh hxesthf o cksoea kg hiverkichits rot`hr t`oiuifegghrhiteothf vhmhtoteki zkihs. V`hsh cksoeas orh secenortk Mut`reh's (?506, ?554) ckfhn kg t`h cocckt` sthpphw`hrh ets 'gobrea' es akcporhf tk t`h whovh ei o pnoef,rot`hr t`oi strephf, thxtenh.
Vwk pkeits obkut t`hsh pnoef, cksoea hiverkichitsfhshrvh hnobkroteki. Gerstny, sua` cksoeas akitrebuth tkrhseneoit hiverkichits. Fesrupteki tk t`h hiverkichiton
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 292/342
202 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Hnosteaety9> * e
Rhsenehiah
• Hquenebr euc
Akistoiay
Vech
Gem. ?. Trkphrtehs kg haknkmeaon stobenety (grkc Gknhy ?506).
gobrea ei haknkmeaon tech t`rkum` gerh, stkrc, kvhrmrozeimkr vknaoiea oif thatkiea oatevety es quealny pota`hf-up. Rh-aknkiezoteki festoiahs orh s`krt fuh tk t`h cksoea struaturhkg o bektkph sua` os Mut`reh's cocckt` sthpph kr t`h kphiwkkfnoifs kg skch kg t`h eithrmnoaeons. V`hy fk ikt rhquerhanecotea a`oimh tk goaenetoth akifetekis gkr cemroteki ei t`hhvhit t`ot 'rhpoereim' t`h cksoea es ihahssory. V`hrhgkrhrhseneoit hiverkichits tknhroth mrhothr ockuits kggnuatuoteki (Gknhy ?506: tobnh ?.2 ag. Gem. ?).
Hquonny, oiy nkaon festurboiahs t`ot cem`t ogghat `kceiefsakunf bh akcpaisothf by s`krt cemrotekis tk oikt`hr port kgt`her roimh. V`h onthriotevh, brettnh hiverkichit, `os snkw
rhakvhry techs fuh tk coiy goatkrs sua` os sken ghrtenety oifcemroteki festoiahs gkr pnoits oif oiecons.= Ayaneaonfesrupteki ei haknkmeaon tech t`ot coy tolh pnoah ki oioiiuon kr fhaofh boses wenn t`hrhgkrh `ovh o pkthiteonnymrhothr ecpoat ki oi kcievkrh sua` os o `kceief.
Qhakifny, t`h cksoea ckfhn prhshits o ckrh fyiocl
vehw kg post hiverkichits t`oi es kgthi t`h aosh eiponohkhaknkmeaon rhakistruatekis. Onn tkk grhquhitny t`h mkonkg sua` rhakistruatekis `os bhhi fhsareptevh rot`hr t`oihxpnoiotkry. Gkr hxocpnh, et `os bhhi stothf ki coiykaaosekis t`ot horny `kceiefs aoi ik ckrh bh a`oroathreshfos rhf fhhr `uithrs t`oi os kol gkrhst gkromhrs. V`hy whrh iktsphaegeaonny ofopthf tk porteaunor oiecon kr pnoit akccuietehsbut rot`hr by t`h shnhateki prhssurhs t`ot sua` hnhchits, w`hiakcbeihf, hxhrthf ki bh`ovekuron sknutekis tk hiverkichitonprkbnhcs. Et es t`es eithroateki w`ea` prkfuahs t`h fyioceaei `ucoi ofoptoteki oif w`ea` aoi bh hxpnoeihf t`rkum`t`h preiaepnhs kg hvknutekiory haknkmy (Gknhy ?506).
@kwhvhr, wh orh stenn skch woy grkc sua` oionyshs.]`ot es ikw ihhfhf es oi eivhstemoteki kg t`ksh cksoeas.
V`es coy rhquerh o ihw opprkoa` tk sua` Qtoiforf tha`-iequhs os pknnhi oionyses seiah w`ot wh rhquerh mkhsbhykif t`h zkion ponohkvhmhtoteki cop (hm. Zomweji?552o: Gem. ?), ushgun os t`hsh orh, tk oi eithrion brholfkwkg t`h cksoea akcpkihits kg sua` brkof vhmhtoteki typhs osthpph oif sthpph-tuifro. @kwhvhr, eg t`h cksoea ckfhn estk ovkef guturh kvhr-mhihronesoteki os o fhsarepteki kgTnhestkahih vhmhtoteki t`h struaturh kg t`h pnoef (Mut`reh?506: Gem. ?1.?) wenn ihhf quoitetotevh fhsarepteki. V`eswkunf bh akcporobnh tk fesausseki hnshw`hrh kg lhyakiahpts ei `kceief ponohk-haknkmy kg rhgumeo (Wrbo ?500)fesphrson (Va`hrikv ?552) oif aknkiezoteki (Mocbnh
?551o).0
1. Rhmekion hiverk ichit s oif nkim-thrchvknutekiory prkahsshs
1.?. EIVRKFXAVEKI
Hurkph aoi bh s`kwi tk bh o normh hikum` mhkmrop`eaonuiet tk kbshrvh voreoteki ei lhy rhskurahs oif t`h ecpoatt`es `of ki t`h struaturh kg rhmekion Tonohknet`ea rhakrfs(Mocbnh ?507). V`hsh lhy rhskurahs whrh vhmhtotekiakccuietehs oif t`h oiecons t`hy suppkrthf. V`hsh vorehfei prafeatobnh woys fuh tk t`h hgghat kg notetufh, nkimetufhoif rhnehg ki hihrmy aopturh oif ets troisnoteki eitk usobnhgkkf skurahs gkr `kceiefs. V`h rhmekion Tonohknet`ea rhakrf
orh ikt hxphathf tk vory ei thrcs kg ortegoat typhs but eithrcs kg t`h quoitety kg cothreons ovoenobnh gkr stufy oift`h fhmrhh kg akiteiuety ei rhmekion kaaupoteki t`rkum` onnp`oshs kg oi eithrmnoaeon/mnoaeon ayanh. V`h gkrchr es oakorsh chosurh kg pkpunoteki fhisety w`enh t`h notthrchosurhs a`oimhs ei bh`ovekur w`ea` brkofhihf t`h`kceief iea`h.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 293/342
201 ANEWH Q. MOCBNH - V@H HIWERKICHIVON BOALMRKXIF
1.2. MHKMROT@EAON NECEVQ
]et` t`es ckfhn wh aoi bhmei tk shh w`y et es ecpkrtoittk `ovh skch efho kg t`h necets tk Tonohknet`ea Hurkph. V`h
fhboth kvhr t`h kaaupoteki, kr ikt, kg iki-cksoeaeithrmnoheon gkrhsts coy `ovh gkaushf otthiteki ki kur
obenety tk ush stotea hiverkichiton fhsareptekis ei o fyioceacoriehr. @kwhvhr, sua` fesausseki s`kunf ikt fhtroat grkc
t`h goat tneot Ceffnh Tnhestkahih Hurkph sow kiny o porteonaknkiezoteki kg t`h akiteihit. Gkr hxocpnh, t`h HQG
wkrls`kp akigerchf (Trosnkv, t`es vknuch) t`ot t`hrh orh ik
KEQ 5 seths kr knfhr ki t`h pnoeis kg Russeo oif t`h
Xlroeih.5 Ceffnh Tnhestkahih kaaupoteki es kiny gkuifbhtwhhi t`h Bnoal oif Ozkv shos oif ikt gurt`hr ikrt`.V`hsh pnoeis orh reimhf tk t`h skut` by hvefhiah gkr hornykaaupoteki. V`h Aouaosus prkvefhs hvefhiah os ot Lufork E
oif EEE. Vskio oif Oa`onlonole, w`enh rhahit geifs ot
Fcoiese ei Mhkrmeo hstobnes` o sknef Horny Tnhestkahihprhshiaa (Njubei oif Bkseisle. t`es vknuch). Rhahitrhshora` ei Vurlhy oif Mrhhah (Fornos, t`es vknuch) `os
onsk prkfuahf Ceffnh Tnhestkahih hvefhiah. Qkch kg t`h
nkaonhs ei t`hsh skut`hc orhos orh onsk ot akcporotevhny`em` ottetufh, skchtechs obkvh ?844 c. Qua` `em` ontetufhseths `ovh ikt bhhi rhpkrthf gkr kt`hr ports kg Hurkph.E shei eo nehs ei o noifsaoph w`hrh rummhf ckuitoeis mk up tk
?644 c but t`hsh whrh cua` nkwhr, os t`hy wkunf `ovhbhhi ei t`h Aouaosus, ot t`h tech kg kaaupoteki (Cusse, t`esvknuch).
V`h hosthri uimnoaeothf necets tk t`h Hurkphoi rhmeki kg
Ceffnh Tnhestkahih kaaupoteki t`hrhgkrh shhc tk bh whnnhstobnes`hf. Ihet`hr aoi hrkseki oif t`h fhstruateki kg
hvefhiah bh summhsthf os t`h raoski gkr obshiah (Trosnkv,phrs. akcc.). Vk t`h ikrt` t`h necets rhcoei uilikwi fuh
tk mnoaeon sakureim kg t`h hvefhiah (@knc oif Norsski, t`esvknuch). V`hrh es ik o-prekre rhoski tk suppksh t`ot t`h
Ceffnh Tnhestkahih seths kg Mhrcoiy, Bhnmeuc, Groiah oif
Himnoif rhprhshit t`h necets kg ikrt`hri kaaupoteki(Breia`-Ththrshi, phrs. akcc.). V`h quhsteki cust bh `kw
cua` gurt`hr ikrt` wkunf pkpunoteki `ovh hxthifhf; V`h
kiny oiswhr wenn akch t`rkum` o mrhothr uifhrstoifeim kg
t`h haknkmeaon tknhroiahs kg t`hsh `kceiefs.
1.1. V@H COCCKV@ QVHTTH OIF CEFFNH TNHEQVKAHIH
@KCEIEF ROIMH
Ei t`es rhsphat Mut`reh's cocckt` sthpph (?506, ?554),w`ea` neils Onoslo wet` whsthri Hurkph, prkvefhs o wefhr
bektkph gkr hvonuoteim t`h rhnotekis bhtwhhi CeffnhTnhestkahih `kceiefs oif t`her hiverkichits. Mut`reh `os
akrrhatny a`oroathreshf Tnhestkahih bektea akccuietehs os
'ikvhn osskrtchits' kg hnhchits rot`hr t`oi t`h akcckivehw t`ot akieghrkus gkrhsts kr tuifros "`ovh o nkim,akcpnhx hvknutekiory `estkry kg geih tuieim oif orh cua`os t`hy `ovh bhhi seiah ... tech prechvon (?506:205)". V`h
cocckt` sthpph `os o akisefhrobnh oitequety (shh bhnkw)os oi haknkmeaonny akcpnhx, chfeuc tk `em` notetufh suethkg vhmhtoteki cksoeas t`ot prkfuahf o fevhrsh gouio kg
mrozeim mhihronests. V`es fhphifhf precoreny upki nkimhrmrkwt` shoskis w`ea` whrh eithrionny vorehf. Mut`reh s`kws`kw t`hsh aoi bh ckst anhorny fegghrhiteothf ki o ikrt`-skut`, notetufeion troishat (?554: 271gg). @kwhvhr, Ceffnh
Tnhestkahih `kceiefs kiny ushf o sconn port kg t`es `umhbektkph (ebef: Gem. 5.?2).?4 V`her rhstreathf festrebutekisummhsts t`ot t`h cocckt` sthpph wos fegghrhiteothf, ei
thrcs kg suetobenety gkr `kceief ush, ki o whst-host troishat.V`h fhmrhh tk w`ea` t`h cocckt` sthpph vorehf eithrionny`os ikt bhhi fesausshf ei oiy fhtoen by Mut`reh. @kwhvhr,kih goatkr akitrebuteim tk oiy sua` fegghrhiteoteki wkunf`ovh bhhi t`h potthri kg oiecon cemrotekis eitk Hurkph.Fureim aknfhr p`oshs t`h coei cocckt` sthpph `hrfoiecons aoch grkc t`h host w`enh fureim eithrmnoaeons toxocemrothf eitk ikrt`hri Hurkph grkc skut`hri Hurkph (Woi
Lkngsa`kthi ?552: Gem. ?).
V`es aeraucstoiah summhsts t`ot Hurkph ikrt` kg t`h Onps
oif Aorpot`eois wos mhihronny o akcporotevhny rea` cksoeahiverkichit. V`es wos t`h setuoteki fureim t`h worchr,gkrhsthf p`oshs os whnn os t`h aknfhr kphi p`oshs. Xifhrbkt` anecotea rhmechs t`h rea`ihss kg t`ot cksoea aoi bh
fhgeihf ei rhnotevh thrcs by t`h akifetekis ei t`h rhst kg t`h
cocckt` sthpph. Kbvekusny gkr Ceffnh Tnhestkahih`kceiefs t`h struaturh kg gkkf rhskurahs ei t`hsh cksoeaswos vhry fegghrhit. Lhy goatkrs wkunf `ovh bhhi prhyfhisety, ets ckbenety oif rhneobenety os chosurhf by
pkpunoteki gnuatuotekis.
Tutteim t`es cksoea ckfhn eitk t`h wefhr akithxt kg t`h
Huroseoi/Bhreimeoi cocckt` sthpph, wh aoi shh t`ot,
errhsphatevh kg eithrmnoheon kr mnoaeon akifetekis, t`hakitrknneim goatkr ki t`h ikrt`hri oif hosthri festrebuteki kg
Ceffnh Tnhestkahih `kceiefs wos t`h kahoiea hgghat (Wki
Lkhiemswonf ?552: 68). Kiny t`es ochnekrot eim hgghatakunf, akcbeihf wet` t`h zkion festrebuteki kg upnoif oif
ckuitoei ei Hurkph, `ovh prkfuahf t`h fuon cksoea potthrit`ot `of t`h hgghat kg akiahitroteim oiecon rhskurahs ei t`eswhsthri orc kg t`h Huroseoi noifcoss.
V`h fhtoens kg hxoatny `kw t`h kahoiea hgghat wkrlhf oif
vorehf ei ets ecpoat bhtwhhi fegghrhit mnoaeon/eithrmnoaeonayanhs es stenn fhbothf. V`ksh akiahrihf wet` ponohkvhmhto-teki rhakistruatekis orh stenn fevefhf kvhr t`h akitrknneimrknh kg het`hr thcphroturh kr ckesturh os t`h areteaon hnhchit
ei cojkr vhmhtoteki a`oimhs (Vzhfoles ?551: 610< Zomweji?552b< Qua oif Zomweji ?501< Fh Jkim ?500). @kwhvhr,t`h hsshiteon ghoturh kg t`h Hurkphoi vhmhtoteki es t`otsphaeoteki fureim t`h _uothriory wos nkw tk iki-hxesthit(Vzhfoles ?551: 664). V`es wos prkbobny onsk t`h aosh gkr
t`h Hurkphoi normh coccons. V`h rhoski t`ot Hurkphpksshsshf o fuon cksoea struaturh, rot`hr t`oi onthrioteim
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 294/342
206 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
pnoefs tk strephs" (Mut`reh ?506), es t`ot bkt` hnhchits kgt`h bektkph rhphothfny cemrothf eitk Hurkph rot`hr t`oihvknvhf wet`ei t`h rhmeki. Woreoteki ei ocpnetufh kg t`hkahoiea hgghat bhtwhhi kxymhi esktkph stomhs akitrknnhft`hsh cemrotekis.
1.6. RHGXMEO OIF CKQOEAQ
Fureim mnoaeon p`oshs. pnoit sphaehs bhaoch nkaonnyhxteiat ei ikrt`hri Hurkph. Whmhtoteki zkihs whrh iktfhprhsshf skut` oif eisthof toxo, hsphaeonny trhh sphaehs,survevhf ei nkaoneshf rhgumeo ei skut`hri/ ChfethrroihoiHurkph grkc w`hrh rh-aknkiezoteki tkkl pnoah ei suaahhfeimworchr p`oshs. Oiecons whrh onsk port kg t`hsh skut`hrnyrhgumhs (Woi Lkngsa`kthi ?552). Grkc o Hurkphoiphrsphatevh, nkaon hxteiatekis ei worchr phrekfs choit t`ott`h Oseoi/Bhreimeoi cocckt` sthpph aoch tk gkrc o skrtkg `umh rhgumeo.
V`h nkaoteki oif akcpkseteki kg t`h rhgumeo wet`eiHurkph ik fkubt vorehf, fua tk akiteimhit goatkrs, grkcmnoaeon phrekf tk mnoaeon phrekf. V`es hxpnoeis w`y, ont`kum`brkofny secenor potthris hxest gkr hoa` gkrhst rh-mhihrotekiei ikrt`hri Hurkph, hoa` eithrmnoaeon onsk pksshsshs oieifevefuon gnkroS a`oroathr (Fh Jkim ?500). Ckrhkvhr. t`hteceim oif cexeim kg t`h fuon cksoeas (sthpph:gkrhst)prkfuahf w`ot ei ckfhri oiecon akccuiety thrcs orh vhrystroimh osskaeotekis kg oiecons,?2 but w`ea` aoi bhuifhrstkkf ei thrcs kg t`h mhihronests sua` hiverkichitonstruaturhs govkur (Mut`reh ?506< Mhest ?5=0).
V`es nkim thrc potthri kg suaahssevh aknkiezotekisgovkurhf t`ksh orhos kg ikrt`hri Hurkph w`ea` whrh eianksh prkxecety tk t`h tkpkmrop`eaonny fevhrsh rhgumh orhos.Rh-aknkiezoteki festoiahs wkunf bh s`krt oif nelhwesh t`h
techsaonh gkr gkrhst rhmhihroteki. V`h rhfuahf hgghats kgshoskionety ei t`h whst kg t`h akiteihit wkunf onsk `ovh t`hhgghat kg ckrh tem`tny poalhf vhmhtoteki cksoeas. Ki t`hakitrory ei t`h host, kutsefh t`h festrebuteki kg CeffnhTnhestkahih `kceiefs, festoiahs bhtwhhi t`h pnoeis oif t`hs`hnthrhf rhgumh orhos whrh mrhothr. Qhoskionety, oschosurhf by eitro-oiiuon voreoteki ei thcphroturh, wkunfonsk bh cua` mrhothr oif t`h ahnns ei t`h cksoeas wkunf bhckrh wefhny spoahf. Bektkphs ei t`h whst wkunf t`hrhgkrhbh ckrh haknkmeaonny rhsenehit bhaoush t`hy whrh nhss prkihtk aros`hs ei oiecon iucbhrs oif tosthr cemroteki/rhaknk-iezoteki roths. V`h coei goatkr rhfuaeim sua` shoskionety est`h kahoiea hgghat.
1.8. @KCEIEF CKBENEVU
V`h fesausseki `os sk gor summhsthf t`ot wet`ei t`hHurkphoi orho shttnhf by Ceffnh Tnhestkahih `kceiefs whaoi rhakmiesh twk semiegeaoit rhmekion `obetots - pnoeis oifupnoifs. Ei `hr akitrebuteki Cusse fhvhnkps t`h cksoea`ypkt`hses ei rhnoteki tk kih kg t`hsh `obetots, t`h Etoneoi
phieisuno. Q`h rhceifs us t`ot fuh tk tkpkmrop`y hxthisevhhaknkmeaon zkioteki (strephs rot`hr t`oi pnoefs) `os ihvhrbhhi pkssebnh oif t`ot t`h `onncorls kg o rhgumeo - spoteonnyakcpoat `em` fevhrsety oif hxpkihiteon mrkwt` ei pnoitpkpunotekis - orh akcckiny gkuif. V`es wkunf `ovhgovkurhf t`h phrsesthiah kg oiecon sphaehs. Ot o nkaon saonht`h cksoea preiaepnh es pealhf up ei t`h rea`, fevhrsh
swocps oif nomkkis.?1
Cusse hnobkroths t`h ckfhn tkprkpksh t`ot t`h rea`ihss kg t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea ei Etonywos neilhf tk t`hsh hiverkichiton aeraucstoiahs w`hrh,wet`ei s`krt festoiahs, gkromhrs whrh obnh tk tolh ofvoitomhkg sua` akifetekis.?6 V`hrhgkrh, t`h rea`ihss kg t`h hnhchitei t`h hiverkichiton pnoef, oif t`her prkxecety, shrvhf os ochois tk rhfuah resl?'' by ckveim tk onthriotevh, prkfuatevhrhskurahs.
]`enh nhss hxtrhch ei thrcs kg tkpkmrop`y, oif cetemothby t`h s`krthr mrkweim shoskis kg ckrh ikrt`hrny notetufas.wh aoi shh t`ot nkaonhs ei Mhrcoiy (Coieo, t`es vknuch<Bkseisle, t`es vknuch), ikrt`hri Groiah (Vuggrhou oifOitkeih, t`es vknuch) oif Himnoif (Rkbhrts ht on., t`es
vknuch) whrh onsk pksetekihf ei rhnoteki tk sua` cksoeastruaturhs. Ei porteaunor, t`h ush kg reporeoi wkkfnoifswkunf `ovh prkvefhf t`h bhst kppkrtuietehs gkr saovhimeimoif t`h ovkefoiah kg prhfotkrs (Bnuchisa`eih ?507:Vobnh 8.0) porteaunorny onkim t`h kvhrmrkwi boils kg t`hTnhestkahih R`eih os ot Cehshi`hec E (Bkseisle, t`esvknuch). ]et`ei rhoskiobnh festoiahs t`hrh wos kgthisuggeaeìit ontetufeion voreoteki tk prkfuah t`h akifetekis gkrcksoea `obetots. @kwhvhr, akcporhf tk Etony t`h festoiahseivknvhf wkunf `ovh bhhi mrhothr oif ckrh hoseny strhta`hfby anecoteaonny gkrahf a`oimhs tk pnoit oif oieconakccuietehs. Eg ckbenety wos o lhy toatea kg CeffnhTnhestkahih `kceiefs ei akcbotteim resl, t`hi t`h festoiahbhtwhhi ghhfeim pota`hs wet`ei t`h cksoea wkunf bhakchareteaon. ]`enh wh aoiikt yht sphaegy sua` festoiahs etwkunf shhc t`ot t`h obshiah kg t`hsh `kceiefs ei Qaoife-ioveo oif t`h Russeoi pnoeis wkunf prkvefh aosh stufehs tkfhthrceih w`ot t`hsh festoiahs whrh by hxoceieim t`hcksoea struaturh kg t`h Tnhestkahih bektkphs ei t`hsh orhos.
6. Nkim-thrc a`oimhs6.?. EIVRKFXAVEKI
Rhsenehiah aoi bh fhgeihf haknkmeaonny os t`h ockuit kggnuatuoteki t`ot aoi bh tknhrothf, oif ogthr w`ea` t`h systhcaoi rhturi tk hquenebreuc (Gknhy ?506:?4). V`h coei
prkphrtehs kg haknkmeaon stobenety orh s`kwi ei gemurh ?w`hrh otthiteki es onsk poef tk ayaneaon ocpnetufh oifphrekfeaety.
V`h hgghats kg anecotea ayanhs anhorny vorehf ei thrcs kgocpnetufh fureim t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih. Ei Ebhreo t`h wholsemions `ovh cofh et feggeaunt tk festeimues` bhtwhhithcphroth oif aknf stomhs ki t`h boses kg shfechits, pknnhi
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 295/342
208 ANEWH Q. MOCBNH - V@H HIWERKICHIVON BOALMRKXIF
Vobnh ?
Kaaupoteki kg
Hurkph by2Cyr ?.8 Cyr ? - 4.5Cyr 4.=1 Cyr 4.8 Cyr
Qtorts ot KEQ 8= 11 ?5 ?1
Iucbhr kg eithrmnoaeon/
mnoaeon ayanhs a. 64 2= ?8 0 8
Nhimt` kg ayanhs
choi Lyr 87 70.2 54.8 ?42.6
roimh Lyr ??=-10 ??=-10 ??=-6= ??= - 06
sf 27.68 14.87 21.7? ?6.22
Iucbhr kg stomhs 5* =* 8 2 2
9 KEQ 8hakrh 882O
Iucbhr kg stomhs
9KEQ 2 ?8* ?1* 5 7 6Akrh W20-215
Qenh(s) Qknhen`oa A`en`oa Wonnkiiht `hrieo Bkxmrkvh
Out`kr Bkiegoy Mut` Fh Nucnhy ?500 Thrhttk ?55? Rkbhrts ht on.
?55? Lþrnea` Ckith Tkmmeknk Qtroislo slono t`es vknuch
Kih Bkseisle Thrhttk ?552 Wonka` ?55? `hrieo
Mebhrt ?552 Bhrkui Lkrknhvk Rkhbrkhls &Grefrea` Roikv ?55? voi Lkngsa`kthi
?55? t`es vknuch
* 3 ceiecuc iucbhr hstecothf grkc eiakcpnhth akrh fotoakcpenhf grkc Ruffecoi ht on. ?507< Q`oalnhtki oif Kpfylh ?5=1< Q`oalnhtki ht on. ?500
oif gouios (Ropksk oif Qoitkijo, t`es vknuch).?7 By akitrost,ei Himnoif t`h KEQ ?2 eah s`hht (Oimneoi) rh-fevhrthf t`h
V`ochs oif `of frocotea hgghats ki t`h hvknuteki kg t`esrhmeki's noifsaoph. Os o rhsunt et nhgt fhpksets w`ea` orhrhofeny festeimues`obnh grkc t`h eithrmnoaeons w`ea`prhahhfhf oif suaahhfhf et.
V`h ocpnetufh kg anecotea ayanhs onsk a`oimhf fureim t`h_uothriory. Fh Jkim (?500) oif Zomweji (?552b) `ovhs`kwi `kw t`h Bovhn eithrmnoaeon ot ? Cyr BT sow t`h gerstsuaahsseki ei t`h eccemroteki, sprhof oif fhaneih kg gkrhstanhchits ei ikrt`hc Hurkph. Trekr tk t`es foth t`h eithrmnoaeons noal sua` a`oroathrestea suaahssekis. V`hy ottrebutht`es tk a`oimhs ei t`h eithrvhieim aknf phrekfs w`ea` gkrcua` kg t`h horny Tnhestkahih whrh nhss shvhrh. Rhgumhorhos coy whnn `ovh bhhi ankshr w`enh fegghrhit skenakifetekis ot t`h bhmeiieim kg eithrmnoaeons prhvhithf t`hsprhof kg oaefep`enkus hnhchits nelh Obehs oif Teaho
(Zomweji ?552b: 80=).
Ocpnetufh ei t`h anecotea semion `of t`hrhgkrh eiarhoshf.]et`ei t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih gurt`hr voreoteki hxests wet`t`h akrrhnoteki bhtwhhi `em` kahoi vonuhs (Q`oalnhtki?50=) oif t`h opphoroiah kg 'Obehs ei ikrt`hri Hurkph (Fh
Jkim ?500). V`hsh hxtrhch eithrmnoaeons whrh KEQ 8h, 5 oif?? w`hi kahoiea anecoth wet` `em` prhaepetoteki oif worc
weithrs prhfkceiothf. Eg t`hsh akrrhnotekis bhtwhhi t`hfhhp sho oif t`h pknnhi rhakrfs orh akrrhat t`hi t`hyfhsarebh akifetekis w`ea` phrtoei tk kiny skch 0% kg t`hCeffnh Tnhestkahih.
6.2. NKIM OIF V@H Q@KRV A@RKIKNKMU
V`h ecpkrtoiah kg nkim thrc voreoteki ei ayaneaonocpnetufh oif phrekfeaety gkr `kceief kaaupoteki akchs tkt`h gkrh w`hi wh akisefhr t`h hiverkichiton akishquhiahskg het`hr o nkim kr s`krt a`rkiknkmy gkr kaaupyeim t`hakiteihit.
Ei porteaunor t`hrh `ovh bhhi otthcpts (C.-G. Bkiegoy?504< Zomweji ?552b) tk neil cojkr a`oimhs ei t`hHurkphoi gouio oif vhmhtoteki tk krbeton gkraeim kg t`hTnhestkahih anecoth. V`es eivknvhs bkt` t`h ocpnetufh kgskch lhy ayanhs (iktobny KEQ ?2) os whnn os a`oimhs ei t`hphrekfeaety kg t`hsh ayanhs bhtwhhi t`h Horny oif CeffnhTnhestkahih.
Of`hrhiah tk het`hr t`h nkim kr s`krt a`rkiknkmy gkr t`heieteon kaaupoteki kg Hurkph `os guifochiton ecpneaotekis
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 296/342
207 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
tkr t`h ush kg hiverkichiton hvefhiah. Ot kih nhvhn t`eschois fhoneim wet` ckrh, kr nhss, oiecon toxo (Akrfy ?552),o voreobnh iucbhr kg `kceief sphaehs, oif t`h fegghrhitstruaturh kg eithrmnoaeon vhmhtoteki ayanhs t`h nkimhr t`htech spoi gkr `ucoi kaaupoteki es hxthifhf boal bhykift`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih (Zomweji ?552o: 807).
V`h anecotea ayanhs rhakrfhf ei t`h fhhp sho rhakrf orh
onsk t`h prkxy foto ckst akcckiny ushf tk eivhstemothquhstekis kg hiverkichiton shnhateki ki `kceiefs (Wrbo ht
on. ?505< Broei ?50?: Trhiteah oif Fhitki ?500< Mocbnh?551o). Gkr hxocpnh, eg o nkim a`rkiknkmy gkr t`hkaaupoteki kg Hurkph kg 2 Cyr, ?.8 Cyr, ? Cyr kr 544 Lyres prhghrrhf, t`es wenn prkfuah fegghrhit nkim-thrchiverkichiton shnhateki os rhprhshithf by t`h iucbhr,grhquhiay oif akcporotevh ocpnetufhs kg t`h kxymhiesktkph stomhs. @kwhvhr, eg o s`krt a`rkiknkmy kg het`hr=14 Lyr kr 844 Lyr es ofkpthf t`hi t`h oaaucunothf hgghatskg t`h mhihroneshf anecotea rhakrf orh vhry fegghrhit (shhonsk Gknhy ?556).
Ei Vobnh ? t`h hiverkichiton saonh kg t`h eithrmnoaeon/mnoaeon ayanhs orh hxoceihf. Eg `kceiefs gerst aknkiezhft`h akiteihit ot 844 Lyr BT t`hi t`h fegghrhiahs bhtwhhit`h nhimt` kg t`h ayanhs wos cua` nhss, os s`kwi by onkwhr Qtoiforf fhveoteki, t`oi wkunf `ovh bhhi t`h aoshwet` oi hornehr hitry. Aknkiezoteki ot 844 Lyr BT wosgknekwhf by gevh anecotea ayanhs kg vhry akcporobnhfuroteki oif fkceiothf by eithrchfeoth hiverkichitonakifetekis (Mocbnh ?507: tobnh 1.8). Cua` mrhothrvoreobenety wkunf `ovh goahf t`h hornehst Hurkphoi`kceiefs eg aknkiezoteki `of gerst kaaurhf =14 Lyr BT krhornehr (Vobnh ?). But t`es mrhothr voreoteki ei ayaneaonr`yt`cs `os, eg o nkim a`rkiknkmy es govkurhf, tk bh shhi
omoeist o feceiuteki ei t`h grhquhiay kg t`h hxtrhchanecotea hvhits. V`hsh orh t`h `em` sho nhvhn eithrmnoaeons(Q`oalnhtki ?50=) oif t`h normh akiteihiton m noaeo tekis(Zomweji ?552b) t`ot orh sk a`oroa threstea kg t`h s`krt.844 Lyr, a`rkiknkmy. Eg wh tolh t`es tech spoi os o anecoteayorfsteal gkr akcporeim t`h rhcoeieim Tnhestkahih ayanhsei rhnoteki tk het`hr hxtrhch kahoiea akifetekis (stomhs 9KEQ 8h) kr hxtrhch akiteihitonety, os s`kwi by `em` eahvonuhs (onn stomhs 9 KEQ2), wh orrevh ot t`h gknnkweimprkpkrtekis:
Foth kg gerst Iucbhr kg @em` sho nhvhns Nkw sho nhvhns
kaaupoteki ayanhs & gkrhsns
% kg ayanhs9 nost eithrmnoaeons(KEQ 8h)
& eah aops
% kg ayanhs9 nost mnoaeoncoxecuc(KEQ 2)
844 Lyr 8 64 04
=17 Lyr Q 28 =;
544 Lyr ?1 11 74
?,8 Cyr 2= 27 6Q
V`h trhif rhvhonhf by t`hsh kxymhi esktkph foto esvhry anhor. V`h nkimhr ayanhs kg t`h nost 844 Lyr orh vhryfegghrhit ei thrcs kg t`h grhquhiay kg `em` kahoi oif `em`eah akifetekis t`oi t`h hornehr ayanhs. Ocpnetufh hgghats,os chosurhf by hiverkichiton hxtrhchs, orh corlhfnyfegghrhit. V`h prkpkrteki kg hxtrhch akifetekis fharhoshssemiegeaoitny t`h nkimhr t`h a`rkiknkmy, hsphaeonny gkr `em`
sho nhvhn eithrmnoaeons. V`hsh orh rhprhshithf by kiny oquorthr kg t`h ayanhs ei t`h nost ?.8 Cyr. V`h `em`hrgrhquhiay kg akiteihiton eah ofvoiahs es o ghoturh kg t`hs`krthst a`rkiknkmy prhshithf `hrh gkr t`h kaaupoteki kgHurkph.
@kwhvhr, t`h usuon woy tk oionysh t`hsh foto es ikt byuseim t`h akcphteim anoecs gkr t`h hornehst `ucoi shttnh-chit tk corl t`h fevesekis, but rot`hr tk sht t`h bkuiforehsby stufyeim anecotea a`oimh ei ets kwi rem`t. V`es esuifhrtolhi ei Vobnh 2 gkr t`h Brui`hs oif CotuyocoA`rkis. V`h notthr A`rki es kiny hxoceihf boal tk ?.7 Cyrfua tk t`h ovoenobenety kg rhneobnh foto (Ruffecoi hn on.
?507). V`h rhoski gkr shnhateim t`hsh A`rkis os oihiverkichiton grochwkrl sthris grkc t`her opporhitosskaeoteki wet` krbeton a`oimhs w`ea` ei turi gkrahfanecotea a`oimh.
Vobnh 2
Brui`hs A`rki
Qtorts ot KEQIucbhr kgeithrmnoaeon/mnoaeon ayanhs
Nhimt` kg ayanhs
choi Lyrroimh Lyrsf ?=.42
4.4?2-4.=0= Cyr
n ' e
57.=???=-6=
Cotuyoco A`rkiQtorts ot KEQIucbhr kgeithrmnoaeon/mnoaeon ayanhs
Nhimt` kg ayanhschoi Lyrroimh Lyrsf 2.4?
4.=17 - ?.717 Cyr*71
22
64.5?68 - 10
* Cotuyoco A`rki nosthf grkc 2.6= - 4.=17 Cyr.Foto kiny ovoenobnh gkr 'Tnhestkahih' shateki (Ruffecoi ht ue.?507: tobnh 1)
V`h foto ei Vobnh 2 rhvhon o whnn likwi osphat kg_uothriory anecotea ayanhs (Teseos oif Ckkrh ?50?<Ruffecoi oif Royck ?500)< iochny t`ot fureim t`hCotuyoco A`rki t`h fkceioit phrekfeaety gkr o gunn ayanh
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 297/342
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 298/342
200 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
akigtrchf. Gurt`hrckrh, et es ikw hxphathf, t`oils tk t`hcknhaunor ankal, t`ot t`h `ucoi a`ecp spnet kaaurhf skch8 Cyr omk oif t`ot kih foy wh coy geif gkssens tk genn t`h6-8 Cyr mop.?=
6.6. V@H Q@KRV A@RKIKNKMU< AKIVEIMHIAU KR
TRKAHQQ;
@kwavhr, t`h s`krt a`rkiknkmy onsk ofkpts o mrofuonestearot`hr t`oi puiatuothf opprkoa` tk t`h prkahss kg a`oimh.V`es prkcpts us tk osl `kw mrofuon es mrofuon; V`hrhgkrhei krfhr tk ovkef oaausotekis kg just bheim o spkeneimormuchit t`h s`krt a`rkiknkmy cust bh hvonuothf ei thrcskg w`ot et thnns us obkut t`h mkons kg Tonohknet`ea stufehs,oaakuiteim gkr a`oimh oif stoses ei `kceief bh`ovekur,w`ea` t`h nkim a`rkiknkmy fkhs ikt. V`es osshsschit aoibhst bh uifhrtolhi by osleim quhstekis. ]h woit tk likww`y Hurkph wos aknkiezhf ot a. 844 Lyr os whnn os t`htknhroiahs, ei thrcs kg ocpnetufh oif grhquhiay w`ea``kceiefs akunf akph wet`.
Onoi Vurihr (?552) `os ormuhf t`ot t`h rhoski gkr o ckrhsubstoiteon kaaupoteki kg Hurkph grkc 844 Lyr BT kiworfses tk bh gkuif ei t`h a`oimeim struaturh kg t`h normhaorievkrh muenfs, whnn s`kwi ot Thtronkio (Fornos. e`esvknuch). Bhtwhhi 744-644 Lyr t`hrh wos o corlhf gouionturikvhr fureim w`ea` t`h normh gnhs` hothrs (@kckt`hreuc
oif Chmoithrhkre) oif t`h aoraoss fhstrkyhrs {Toa`yarkauto
phrrehre oif T. brhverkstres) bhaoch hxteiat. V`es nhgt kinyt`h nhkporf, neki, spktthf `yhio oif wkng os Hurkph's cojkraorievkrhs. Oaakrfeim tk Vurihr t`es a`oimh ei t`haorievkrh muenf wkunf `ovh mrhotny ecprkvhf t`h akifetekisgkr `kceief saovhimeim seiah t`h meoit `yhios whrh ik nkimhrprhshit tk akisuch aoraosshs. Et coy onsk `ovh ecprkvhf
`uiteim suaahss ikw t`ot t`h gnhs` hothrs (t`h sobrh oif ferltkkt`hf aots) `of onsk fesopphorhf. Vurihr akianufhs bysummhsneim (e`ef: ?22) t`ot oiy `kceief kaaupoteki prekr tk844 Lyr BT wkunf `ovh goahf eithish akcphteteki grkc t`haorievkrhs. ]`enh pkpunoteki coy `ovh rhoa`hf t`hakiteihit et wkunf `ovh bhhi gkr s`krt phrekfs kg tech oifnhgt nettnh ora`ohknkmeaon troaå. Ogthr 844 Lyr t`h ioturh kgt`h ora`ohknkmeaon rhakrf a`oimhs frocoteaonny (Rkhbrkhlsoif voi Lkngsa`kthi ?556), o rhgnhateki kg rhfuahfshnhateki prhssurh grkc prhvekusny lhy akcphtetkrs.
V`es soch a`oimh `os bhhi fkauchithf by Akrfy (?552)w`k `os fevefhf t`h phrekf grkc KEQ 27 - KEQ 2 eitk hem`t
gouion bekzkihs. V`h '`eimh' ei t`h gouios gonns bhtwhhiKEQ ?1 oif KEQ ?2 ot 664 Lyr BT, wet` gkur bekzkihs kihet`hr sefh. V`h twk phrekfs t`hsh bekzkihs akcpresh orhhoa` 644 Lyr ei furoteki. ]`ot es opporhit es t`h mhihroneiarhosh ei `hrbevkrh fevhrsety, hsphaeonny ockim t`h r`eiks,normh bkvefs, kveaoprefs oif oithnkphs ogthr KEQ ?2. V`hkiny a`oimhs ei aorievkrh fevhrsety eivknvh t`h fhaneih kgt`h `yhios oif normh aots.
Vobnh 1 akcporhs t`h gouion akcpkseteki kg Akrfy's (?552) gkurbekzkihs het`hr sefh kg 664 Lyr. V`h gemurhs s`kwi orh t`h ovhromiucbhr kg sphaehs gkr hoa` kg t`h cojkr toxo ei t`h gkur bekzkihs.V`es s`kws, gkr hxocpnh, t`ot t`h iucbhr kg r`eik sphaehs fkubnhsei t`h bekzkihs ogthr 664 Lyr.
Bekzkihs E-EW Bekzkihs W-WEE
KEQ 27-?1 664 Lyr KEQ ?2-2
Cocckt`s ?.28 ?.28R`eiks ? 2@krshs ?.=8 - 2 ?.8- ?.=8Bks ?.=8-2 2.=8
Kvebks ?.8-2 ?
Kveaoprefs ?.28 2 - 2.28
Oitenkph 4 ?.28
Ahrvus 7.28 - =.=8 8.8 - 7.=8
Aoies ? - ?.28 ?.28Wunphs/Onkphx ?.28 ?.8- ?.=8
Auki ?.=8 - 2 ?
Xrsus ?.8- ?.=8 2
@yhio 2 - 2.=8 ?.28
Normh aots 2.8 -1 ?
Grkc t`hsh foto et es pkssebnh tk ormuh t`ot akccuietyfevhrsety mhihronny eiarhoshf bhtwhhi t`h Horny oif CeffnhTnhestkahih oif akiteiuhf tk fk sk fureim t`h CeffnhTnhestkahih. V`h gemurhs strkimny eifeaoth o nkim-thrcprkahss kg akccuiety hvknuteki rot`hr t`oi bheimakiteimhit upki o s`krt techsaonh hvhit tk s`oph t`hHurkphoi gouio. Qua` o prkgkuif hvhit aoi bh fhthathf eit`h fhaecoteki kg t`h Hurkphoi gouio ei t`h Noth mnoaeon/@knkahih troiseteki (Mut`reh ?506< Wki Lkhiemswonf?552). V`h mrhothr akccuiety fevhrsety aoi bh neilhf tk t`ha`oimhs ei ayaneaon phrekfeaety (Vobnhs ? oif 2) os eifeaothf
by t`h fhhp sho akrhs. O strkim neil es summhsthf bhtwhhit`h nkimhr ayanhs, fkceiothf by akifetekis eithrchfeorybhtwhhi t`h gunn eithrmnoaeon oif gunn mnoaeon oif w`ea`oaakuit gkr a. 74% kg t`h nost 664 Lyr. V`es fevhrsety esprkbobny oi eifeaoteki kg t`h hvknuteki kg t`h `em`nyprkfuatevh cocckt` sthpph. Woi Lkngsa`kthi (?554) oifH. Vurihr (?55?) `ovh s`kwi t`ot ei whsthri Mhrcoiy t`hgerst truny mnoaeon gouios kaaur ot Orehifkrg ? wet` Feark-
stkiyx oif Roimeghr}* V`es osshcbnomh foths tk oi knfhrp`osh kg t`h Qooneoi, prkbobny KEQ 0 (141 - 268 Lyr BT)oif sk ecchfeothny ogthr t`h phrekf akvhrhf by t`h HQGwkrls`kp (Bkseisle, t`es vknuch). V`es es kg eithrhst eithrcs kg `ucoi kaaupoteki bhaoush whsthri Mhrcoiy
aurrhitny noals oiy kaaupotekis fothf tk KEQ ?4 oif 5.O aosh cem`t pkssebny bh cofh t`ot kaaupoteki wos stenneithrcetthit ki o rhmekion boses prekr tk t`h gunn hstobnes`chit kg t`h cocckt` sthpph. Et es t`hrhgkrh thcpteim tkrhvesh Vurihr's a`rkiknkmy oif shh t`h phrekf grkc 844-144Lyr os kih kg `hsetoit, eithrcetthit kaaupoteki ki o rhmekioboses bhtwhhi ikrt`hri oif skut`hri Hurkph, w`enh ogthr
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 299/342
2P5 ANEWH Q. MOCBNH - V@H HIWERKICHIVON BOALMRKXIF
144 Lyr BT kaaupoteki strhimt`his fuh tk t`h coturoteki kgt`h tuen cocckt` sthpph fureim t`h nkim aknf p`oshs kg t`heithrmnoaeon/mnoaeon ayanhs (ag. Rkhbrkhls oif Woi Lkng
sa`kthi. t`es vknuch).
8. ]`hi oif w`y wos Hurkph aknkiezhf sk noth;
O phrskion akianuseki
Ot t`h Voutovhn wkrls`kp t`hrh wos akisefhrobnhfesausseki kvhr t`h "moths kg Hurkph" os o borrehr tk shttnh-chit. Eg `kceiefs whrh prhshit ei Ikrt` Ogreao (Royion ht
oe, t`es vknuch) ot orkuif 044 Lyr BT oif ei t`h CeffnhHosn oif t`h Aouaosus (Bkseisle, t`es vknuch) by ot nhostE Cyr BT oif prkbobny, ei t`h aosh kg Mhkrmeo oif Esroìn,cua` hornehr. w`y fef o gurt`hr 844-544 Lyr hnopsh bhgkrht`h upnoifs oif pnoeis kg Hurkph whrh nërst aknkiezhf;
Grkc o s`krt a`rkiknkmy phrsphatevh t`hrh shhc tk bht`rhh onthriotevhs. Gerstny, t`ot t`h foths orh eignothf gkr t`hhornehst opphoroiah kg `kceiefs kutsefh sub-Qo`oroi Ogreao.O areteaon rhvehw kg t`h anoecs gkr oiaehit geifspktst`rkum`kut t`h Knf ]krnf wkunf bh anhorny whnakch, but
wos bhykif t`h sakph kg t`h prhshit wkrls`kp. @kwhvhr,kur rh-osshsschit kg t`h Hurkphoi foto ikw prkvefhs oyorfsteal omoeist w`ea` tk chosurh t`h vorekus anoecs grkchnshw`hrh nkr hor` aknkie/oteki. Kih osphat kg t`es saruteiywenn eivknvh a`oroathrezeim t`h ikrcon hiverkichits w`ea`prhshrvh hvefhiah kg `kceief oatevetehs ei kt`hr ports kg t`hKnf ]krnf. V`h a`oroathr kg t`h Tonohknet`ea rhakrf oif etsareteaon osshsschit ei thrcs kg a`rkiknkmeaon oif ora`ohkn-kmeaon eithmrety es anhorny o prkjhat gkr guturh eithriotekionaknnobkroteki.
Qua` oi eivhstemoteki wkunf kiny shhc wkrt`w`enh, `kwhvhr. en" wh `ovh o grochwkrl hxprhsseim t`h fhmrhh kg
a`rkiknkmeaon prhaeseki wh fhhri ihahssory tk shttnh t`hessuh kg w`hi t`h aknkiezoteki kg Hurkph oif t`h kt`hrrhmekis kg t`h Knf ]krnf tkkl pnoah. V`h nelhne`kkf kgorreveim ot o akishisus vehw ot t`h nhvhn kg t`h eifevefuonayanh, kg het`hr 6? kr ?44 Lyr furoteki (Vobnh ?) shhcsaurrhitny rhckth. E wkunf summhst, gknnkweim Bkiegoy oifWoifhrchhrsa`' fesausseki kg t`h p`yseaon oit`rkpknkmeaonhvefhiah (?55?: 1?=), t`ot wh s`kunf stort wet` 844 Lyrbnkals (Gknhy ?556). Nht us t`hi shh w`ea` bnkal bhtwhhi4-2 Cyr BT prkvefhs akisesthit oif vhregeobnh hvefhiah eithrcs kg omrhhchit kvhr t`h stotus kg ortegoats, `kceiefrhcoeis. oif foteim cht`kfs, os whnn os t`h eithmrety oifa`oroathr kg t`ksh ikrcon hiverkichits w`ea` prhshrvh kur
hvefhiah. @oveim efhitegehf w`ea` bnkal wh s`kunf bhshora`eim ei wh aoi t`hi bhakch ckrh prhaesh, os t`esvknuch s`kws.
But nht us ossuca t`ot t`h `kceiefs ot Qefe Obfhrro`-coih oif Fcoiese fef eifhhf woet ot t`h moths kg Hurkphgkr vhry nkim phrekfs kg tech. V`es summhsts o shakif,hiverkichiton rhoski tk hxpnoei t`h fhnoy. O p`yseaon
borrehr shhcs t`h bhst oiswhr oif t`es akunf bh t`h strolskg Mebrontor, oi hinormhf Aospeoi/Bnoal Qho, kr t`htkpkmrop`eaonny uifegghrhiteothf pnoeis kg t`h Xlroeih.V`hsh borrehrs fk `kwhvhr nkkl hxtrhchny phrchobnh mevhit`h techsaonhs oif anecotea a`oimhs t`ot tkkl pnoah bhtwhhi? Cyr oif 4.8 Cyr BT. V`hy orh ikt t`h phrcoihit kahoiborrehr t`ot hxesthf bhtwhhi skut` host Oseo oif Oustroneo.Et es hxoatny t`es phrchobenety w`ea` es phr`ops t`h strkimhstaorf ei t`h `oifs kg t`ksh govkureim o nkim a`rkiknkmy.@kwhvhr t`es es akiguseim t`h nelhne`kkf kg aknkiezotekiwet` ets oatuonety. @hiah t`h akiahitroteki kg horny anoecs eit`ksh orhos ofjoahit tk t`h moths kg Hurkph rot`hr t`oi eit`h ikrt` kg t`h akiteihit. Eifhhf suppkrthrs kg hornyaknkiezoteki ei chfethrroihoi oif skut`hri Hurkph (Vobnh ?)wkunf prhsucobny frow t`her borrehr ot t`h cormeis kg t`hikrt`hri pnoeis kr ormuh, os Vurihr (?552) `os fkih, gkrcuntepnh hitrehs t`ot fef ikt nhof tk o phrcoihit gkkt`knf eit`h akiteihit bhaoush kg t`h borrehr prhshithf by aorievkrhakcphteteki. But w`ot t`h nkim-a`rkiknkmy ckfhn ihhfs tkoffrhss orh t`ksh vhry t`rhs`knfs kg ora`ohknkmeaon vesebenety
w`ea` et ushs tk suppkrt t`h pota`y prh 844 Lyr anoecs.@kw fk wh quoitegy sua` oi hp`hchron prhshiah oifakcporh et wet` t`h phrcoihit kaaupoteki ogthr 844 Lyr;]`ot orh t`h nelhny porochthrs, ei thrcs kg ortegoat fhisetehsby tech `krezki oif noifsaoph oif rhmeki, t`ot wkunfofhquothny thst t`h ckfhn ; V`hsh ora`ohknkmeaon essuhs orhikt offrhsshf by oiy kg t`h nkim a`rkiknkmy's suppkrthrs.V`hy aoiikt offrhss t`hc bhaoush t`hy `ovh ik hiverkichiton grochwkrl w`ea` onnkws t`hc tk eivhstemoth `kceiefsos aknkiezeim oiecons. V`es grochwkrl es opporhit ockimt`h prkpkihits kg t`h s`krt a`rkiknkmy w`k orh nhss eithr-hsthf ei pursueim oi kremeis porofemc oif ckrh akiahrihfwet` uifhrstoifeim post `kceief bh`ovekur.
V`h borrehr vehw fevefhs Hurkph. Ckrhkvhr, et fevefhsHurkph onkim trofetekion ora`ohknkmeaon gount neihs. Et colhseieteon aknkiezoteki nkkl akcporobnh tk t`h @knkahih orrevonkg t`h gorchrs w`k ckvhf gerst eitk t`h chfethrroihoi oifkiny nothr kitk t`h pnoeis kg t`h ikrt`. E prhghr o t`erf ckfhnw`ea` uieths Hurkph, ikrt` oif skut`. V`h rhoski gkr sua` ouiegehf (suetobny Coostrea`t!) vehw kg t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea shttnhchit kg t`h akiteihit es boshf upki t`hhiverkichiton opprkoa`hs t`ot `ovh bhhi rhvehwhf. E wkunformuh t`ot Ceffnh Tnhestkahih aknkiezoteki tkkl pnoahprhaeshny bhaoush t`h akcpnhchitory hiverkichits kgpnoeis oif upnoifs hxesthf. V`h akcbeioteki kg skut`hri
pnoit oif oiecon rhgumeo, gouion cemrotekis grkc t`h host,t`h voreobnh whsthrny kahoiea hgghat oif, ot o rhmekion saonh,t`h hxesthiah kg cksoea noifsaophs whrh t`h ihahssoryakifetekis gkr phrcoihit aknkiezoteki, w`ht`hr oa`ehvhf eio seimnh kr, os shhcs ckst prkbobnh, shrehs kg aknkiezeimhvhits. ]h `ovh shhi t`ot aknkiezoteki tkkl pnoah fureim onkim-thrc trhif kg eiarhoseim gouion fevhrsety. V`es
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 300/342
254 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
aunceiotaf ot t`h hif kg KEQ 5 wet` t`h pkssebnh opphoroiahkg t`h cocckt` sthpph (Mut`reh ?554), t`ot wos ckstprkbobny t`h rhsunt kg a`oimhs ei t`h phrekfeaety oifocpnetufh kg t`h eithrmnoaeon/mnoaeon ayanhs. @kceiefaknkiezoteki wos t`hrhgkrh port kg anecotea oif bektkpha`oimhs t`ot tkkl pnoah ei hvknutekiory tech oif ot oAkiteihiton saonh. V`h necetotekis ki t`es uiegehf aknkiezoteki
whrh prhaeshny t`ksh w`ea` stonnhf t`h `kceiefs ot t`hhosthri moths kg Hurkph - hxtrhch shoskionety ei t`hakcpnhchitory pnoeis hiverkichit. Ei thrcs kg `kceiefbh`ovekur t`es shoskionety akunf kiny bh kvhrakch t`rkum`mrhothr oiiuon ckbenety oif t`h gessekieim kg pkpunoteki.V`hsh ihahssory festoiahs oif shporoteki kg pkpunoteki eit`h wefhny spoahf pnoit oif gouion cksoeas kg t`h pnoeisakunf ikt bh suppkrthf by t`h cha`oiescs ovoenobnh tkCeffnh Tnhestkahih skaeon systhcs (Qtreimhr oif Mocbnh?551< Mocbnh ?551o,b). Os o rhsunt pkpunotekis ei t`hspoteonny akcpoat rhmekis kg t`h Aouaosus, Ceffnh Host oifIkrt` Ogreao fef ikt hxpoif eitk Hurkph. Kiny wet`onthrotekis tk t`h shoskionety rhmechs ei ahitron oif whsthri
Hurkph. w`ea` ak-eiaefhf wet` a`oimhs t`ot whrhfatrechiton tk t`h normh aorievkrhs, fef o cota` hchrmhbhtwhhi t`h saonh kg t`h `kceiefs skaeon systhcs oif t`hspoteon struaturh kg rhskurahs ei t`h hiverkichit w`ea`phrcetthf aknkiezoteki.
Kih kg t`h urmhit tosls w`ea` ikw goahs hiverkichitonopprkoa`hs tk t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih es t`h quoitegeaotekikg t`h spoteon struaturh kg t`hsh noifsaophs, nkaonny,
ikths
? Qhh Mocbnh (?551o) gkr fesausseki.
2 Qhh Esooa (?50?) gkr o mhihron fesausseki kg Nkwhr Tonohknet`eanoifsaophs ei thrcs kg saotthrs oif pota`hs kg ora`ohknkmeaoncothreon. Os `h pkeits kut t`h pota`hs orh w`ot wh akcckiny aonnseths. O nkaonh akcbeihs bkt` thrcs.
1 Akitrebutekis oif akcchits prhporhf gkr oif prhshithf ot t`hVoutovhn wkrls`kp, but w`ea` orh ikt eianufhf ei t`es vknuch orheifeaothf os 'phrs. akcc.' ei t`h rhghrhiah.
6 Akcporh t`h Benzeimsnhbhi 'aocpseth' wet` t`h `em`ny potthrihfhvefhith trkc t`h Noth Mnoaeon kphi nkhonhs sua` os Whrbhreh,Hteknnhs oif Teiahvhit (Oufkuzh ?50=).
8 V`es nkaonh es onsk prkbobny ykuimhr t`oi 144 Lyr BT.7 Coieo onsk chitekis t`h akccki prkbnhc kg akitrofeatkryhiverkichiton hvefhiah w`ea` aoi goah sua` prhaesh rhakistrua-tekis. Ot Qa`÷ieimhi ?2 t`h cknnusaoi hvefhiah pkeits tk kphi oift`h pknnhi tk ankshf thrroei.
rhmekionny oif gkr t`h hiterh akiteihit. Gurt`hrckrh, whihhf tk omrhh grkc w`ea` hif kg t`es spoteon grochwkrl whwenn bhmei t`h eivhstemoteki kg `kceiefs os aknkiezeimoiecons. Fk wh stort sconn oif wkrl up, kr bhmei wet` t`hakiteihit oif wkrl fkwi tk t`h nkaon hiverkichit. V`hsaonh E wkunf ofvkaoth storts ot t`h nhvhn kg t`h akiteihitetshng, pkkrny fhgeihf os et coy bh ki ets hosthri oif
ikrt`hri cormeis. Kiny ot t`es saonh aoi wh hxoceih t`hprkpkseteki t`ot oiy kih rhmeki kg Hurkph akunf kiny bh
aknkiezhf eg et wos aknkiezhf ot t`h soch tech os ckst kg t`
kt`hrs. Hnshw`hrh (Mocbnh ?507: Gem. 1.?) E `ovh sphaegehfieih rhmekis gkr t`h stufy kg t`h Tonohknet`ea shttnhchit kgHurkph. Eieteon aknkiezoteki storteim ot 844 Lyr BT aoi bhfhckistrothf gkr hem`t kg t`hc. Kiny t`h Ikrt` Host rhmekinoy voaoit fureim t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih. Trkahhfeim fkwit`h spoteon saonh wh aoi shh `kw rhmekis oif hvhi noifsaophswhrh shttnaf. By eiarhoseim kur rhsknuteki wh aoi bhmei tkhxoceih t`h rhnotekis`ep bhtwhhi aknkiezeim pkpunotekis,`obetot a`keah oif pkpunoteki fyioceas w`ea` tkkl pnoahkvhr t`h nkim-thrc oif ot spoteon saonhs w`ea` eivknvhf
akiteihit wefh ofoptotekis oif w`ea` ora`ohknkmests `ovhrorhny akisefhrhf. Hxoceieim t`hsh essuhs es kih rhoskiw`y t`h fhboth bhtwhhi o nkim oif s`krt a`rkiknkmy esecpkrtoit. @kwhvhr, tk bh choieimgun, sua` o fhboth s`kunfikw bh boshf ki t`h prhcesh t`ot t`h aknkiezeim aopobenetehskg t`hsh `kceiefs wos ikt necethf sknhny by hiverkichitonakifetekis but rot`hr by t`her kwi krmoiezotekion rhspkishstk t`h struaturh kg sua` hiverkichits.
`hiah haknkmeaon stobenety, ikiht`hnhss rhakvhrs vhry snkwny egfesturbhf.
0 Fesomrhhchit kvhr t`h sk-aonnhf wkkfhi aurtoei (Rkhbrkhlsht on. ?552) w`ea` fef, kr fef ikt, necet `kceief kaaupoteki eiCeffnh oif Noth Tnhestkahih Hurkph coy whnn bh rhsknvhf ei ockrh prkfuatevh oionyses kg fegghrhiteon gkrhst cksoeas oif kwt`hsh aoi bh efhitegehf grkc t`h ponohkhaknkmeaon rhakrf.
5 shh Oetlhi t`es vknuch gkr fesausseki kg anoecs tkr vhry hornyRusseoi Tnoei seths ki t`h boses kg VN foteim.
?4 V`h anoecs gkr 844 Lyr BT foths gkr seths ei Qebhreo (Ckrhnn?556) rhcoei ecpnousebnh gkr rhoskis kg saehiah boshf foteim oifosskaeothf ora`ohknkmy.
?? Xiten t`h sphaeon aeraucstoiahs kg t`h @knkahih prkfuahf strephzkioteki (Mut`reh ?506: 271gg).
?2 Gkr hxocpnh cusl kx oif nhkporf ei Chfethrroihoi Groiah (FhNucnhy, phrs. akcc.).
?1 Qhh Lhnny ?501 gkr fhtoens kg t`h cossevh beknkmeaon prkfuatevetykg swocps oif wothr bkfeas.
= V`h anossea brettnh hiverkichit es t`h trkpeaon roei gkrhst w`ea`fhspeth hikrckus bekcoss, prkfuatevety, sphaehs fevhrsety oif
?6 Qhh Qkgghr (?505) gkr o fesausseki kg t`es s`krt festoiah, zkionakcprhsseki, gkr Ceffnh Tonohknet`ea kaaupoteki ei t`h Arecho.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 301/342
25? AN?WH Q. MOCBNH - V@H HIWERKICHIVON BOALMRKXIF
?8 Fhgeihf os t`h goenurh tk chht fehtory rhquerhchits.
?7 V`es cust `ovh bhhi portny fuh tk t`h fhprhsseki kg t`h pknorgrkin oif mung Qtrhoc skut`worfs fureim t`h aknfhr phrekfs.
?= Qeiah geies`eim t`es pophr ]`eth ht on ?556 `ovh ikw fkih justt`on wen` t`h fesakvhry kg O. rocefus ei t`h Owos` vonnhy. Vk putsua` geifs ei akithxt< Kolnhy pnoahf t`h kaaupoteki kg Hurkph ot9844Lyr boshf ki o rhnotevh omh gkr t`h Couhr coifebnh
(?575:144). @es aorhgun osshsschit onnkwhf Hurkph skch ?6% kgt`h a`rkiknkmy t`hi onnkthf tk `ucoi kremeis. V`h vorekusa`rkiknkmehs (Vobnh ?) sht omoeist o gemurh kg 8 Cyr gkr `ucoioiahstry onnkw `ucoi kaaupoteki kg Hurkph 64%, 14%, 24%, ?8%oif ?4% kg t`es tech spoi.
?0 V`es es ikt `kwhvhr t`h knfhst kaaurhiah kg Roimeghr ei Hurkphw`ea` hxthifs boal ot nhost tk KEQ?2 (Akrfy ?552:05).
rhghrhiahs
Oufkuzh, G. ?50= V`h Tores Bosei ei comfonhieoi techs. Ei: K. Qkgghr (hf. ), V`h Tnhestkahih Knf ]krnf:
rhmekionphrsphatevhs, ?01-244, Ihw Ukrl: Tnhiuc.
Oumusth, T. ei prhss Ofoptotekis beknkmequhs ht aunturhnehs fhs Trhihoifhrtonehis ht fhs Ihoifhrtonehis ouxckfegeaotekis ponåkåaknkmequhs ht gouiequhs hi Groiah shpthitrekionh. Ioturh hn Aunturh,
Oaths Aknnkquh Neàmh, HROXN.
Bnuchisa`eih, R. ?507 Horny `kceief saovhimeim kppkrtuietehs: ecpneaotekis kg aoraoss ovoenobenety ei t`h
Qhrhimhte oif Imkrkimkrk haksysthcs. Kxgkrf, Bretes` Ora`ohknkmeaon Rhpkrts Eithriotekion Qhrehs 210.
Bkiegoy, H. ?55? Nhs prhceàrhs eifustrehs fu Quf-hst fh no Groiah ht fu Cosseg Ahitron. Ei: H. Bkiegoy oifB. Woifhrchhrsa` (hfs), Nhs prhcehrs Hurkpåhis, 71-04, Tores: AV@Q.
Bkiegoy, H.,T. Woifhrchhrsa`
?55? Wuh f'hishcbnh sur Eh trhs oiaehi Tonhknet`equh fh ?'Hurkph. Ei: H. Bkiegoy oif B. Woifhrchhrsa` (hfs). Nhs prhcehrs Hurkpåhis, 145-?5, Tores: AV@Q.
Bkiegoy, C.-G.
Bkseisle. Ae.
?504
t`esvknuch
Rhnotekis nhs fkiiåhs esktkpequhs kahoiequhs ht ?'`estkerh fhs mroifhs gouihs hurkpåhiihspnek-pnhestkahihs, _uothriory Rhshora` ?6, 28?-72.
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: ]hsthri Ahitron Hurkph.
Broei, A.L.
Butzhr, L].
Akiorf, I.J.
?50? @kceief hvknuteki oif anecotea a`oimh, Qkut` Ogreaoi Jkurion kg Qaehiah ==, ?46-8.
?502 Ora`oaknkmy os `ucoi haknkmy. Aocbrefmh: Aocbrefmh Xievhrsety Trhss.
?552 V÷ia`hs`hrm oif ets pkseteki ei t`h Tonoaknet`ea prh`estkry kg ikrt`hri Hurkph. R-MZC
Ckikmrop` 24, Bkii: @obhnt.
Akiwoy, B.].
Akrfy, J.-C.
?5=4 Mhknkmeaon eivhstemoteki kg Bkyi @enn thrroah fhpksets ot Borigehnf Tet, Qwoisakcbh,Lhit, fureim ?5=5, Trkahhfeims kg t`h Rkyon Oit`rkpknkmeaon nistetuth (?5=?), 74-6.
?552 Oppkrt fh no ponhkcoccknkmeh o no ponhkoit`rkpknkmeh hi Hurkph. Ei: C. Vkussoeit (hf.),Aeiq cennekis f'oiiåhs, n'ovhitwh `ucoeih, ==-56, Neàmh: HROXN.
Fornos, W. t`es
vknuchV`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: V`h Bonlois.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 302/342
V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Gknhy, R.O. E'¼Q6 Tutteim phkpnh eitk phrsphatevh: oi eitrkfuateki tk akccuiety hvknuteki oif haknkmy. Ei:R.O. Gknhy (hf.), @kceief hvknuteki oif akccuiety haknkmy, ?-26, Ihw Ukrl: OaofhcehTrhss.
?556 Qphaeoteki, hxteiateki oif anecotea a`oimh ei `kceief hvknuteki, Jkurion kg gnucoi
Hvknuteki 27, 2=8-205.
Grefrea`, J.
Mocbnh, AQ.
Mhest, W.
Mebhrt, J.
Mut`reh, R.F.
@knc, J.,
N. Norsski
?55? Nhs prhcehrs phupnhchits `ucoeis hi Ckroveh (Va`åaksnkvoqueh). Ei: H. Bkiegoy oif
B. Woifhrchhrsa` (hfs), Nhs prhcehrs Hurkpåhis, ?58-242, Tores: AV@Q.
?507 V`h Tonohknet`ea shttnhchit kgHurkph. Aocbrefmh: Aocbrefmh Xievhrsety Trhss.
?551o Vechwonlhrs: t`h prh`estkry kg mnk`on aknkiezoteki. Gor V`rupp: Onoi Quttki.
?551b Hxa`oimh, gkromeim oif nkaon `kceief ihtwkrls. Ei: A. Qaorrh oif G. @hony (hfs), Vrofh
oif hxa`oimh ei prh`estkreh Hurkph, 18-66, Kxgkrf: Kxbkw Ckikmrop` 11.
?5=0 Negh strothmehs, `etcoi hvknuteki, aiverkichiton fhsemi. Ihw Ukrl: Qpreimhr Whrnom.
?552 Trkyhatk Krah-Auhvo Weatkreo (?500-?552): Trhshiaeo `ucoio hi hn Tnhestkahik eighrekr
fh Mroiofo y Curaeo. Kraa, Cushk fh Trh`estkreo.
?506 Cksoeas, onnhnka`hceas oif iutrehits: oi haknkmeaon t`hkry kg Noth Tnhestkahih chmogouionhxteiatekis. Ei: T.Q. Cortei oif R.M. Lnhei (hfs), _uothcory hxteiatekis: o prh`estkreh
rhvknuteki, 285-50, Vuaski, Orezkio: Xievhrsety kg Orezkio Trhss.
?554 Grkzhi gouio kg t`h cocckt` sthpph. A`eaomk: A`eaomk Xievhrsety Trhss.
t`es V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph : Qaoifeioveo.vknuch
Esooa, M.
Jkim, J. fh
Lhnny. R.
Lkhiemswonf, ]. vki
?50? Qtkih omh veseteim aorfs: opprkoa`hs tk t`h stufy kg horny noif ush potthris. Ei: E. @kffhrht on. (hfs), Totthri kg t`h Tost: Qtufehs ei @kikur kg Fovef Anorlh, ?1?-88, Aocbrefmh:Aocbrefmh Xievhrsety Trhss.
?500 Anecotea voreobenety fureim t`h post t`rhh ceneki yhors, os eifeaothf by vhmhtotekion hvknu
teki ei ikrt`whst Hurkph oif wet` hcp`oses ki foto grkc V`h Iht`hrnoifs, T`enkskp`eaon
Vroisoatekis kg t`h Rkyon Qkaehty kgNkifki B 1?0, 741-?=.
?501 @uithr-mot`hrhr ckbenety strothmehs, Jkurion kg Oit`rkpknkmeaon Rhshora` 15, 2==-147.
?552 Worekus osphats kg cemrotekis ei thrrhstreon coccons ei rhnoteki tk Tnhestkahih gouios kgahitron Hurkph. Ei: ]. vki Lkhiemswonf oif N. ]hrfhnei (hfs), Cocconeoi cemrotekioif fesphrson hvhits ei t`h Hurkphoi _uothcory, Akurehr Gkrsa`uimseisnenut Qhclhi`hrm
?81, 15-6=.
Lkngsa`kthi, V. voi ?554 V`h hvknuteki kg t`h coccon gouio ei t`h Iht`hrnoifs oif t`h ceffnh R`eih Orho(]hsthri Mhrcoiy) fureim t`h noth Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, Chfhfhneimhi Rejls Mhknkmesa`h
Fehist 61(1), ?-75.
?552 Osphats kg t`h cemroteki kg coccons tk ikrt`whsthri Hurkph fureim t`h Tnhestkahih, eiporteaunor t`h rheccemroteki kg Orveakno thrrhstres. Ei: ]. vki Lkhiemswonf oif N. ]hrfhnei (hfs), Cocconeoi cemroteki oif fesphrson hvhits ei t`h Hurkphoi _uothcory,Akurehr Gkrsa`uimseistetut Qhialhi`hrm ?81, 2?1-24.
Nhbhn, Q. ?552 Ckbenetå fhs `kceiefhs ht systhchs f'hxpnketoteki fhs rhskurahs net`equhs ou ponåknet`equhoiaehi: No Aouih fh ?'Oromk (Groiah), Aoiofeoi Jkurion kg Ora`ohknkmy ?7, 60-75.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 303/342
251 ANEWH Q. MOCBNH - V@H HIWERKICHIVON BOALMRKXIF
Njubei, W.,M. Bkseisle
t`esvknuch
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg t`h Aouaosus rhmeki.
Nucnhy, @. fh
Coieo, F.,
?500
t`esvknuch
No strotemrop`eh fu rhcpnessomh fh no mrktth fu Wonnkiht. N'Oin`rkpknkmeh 52: 64=-20.
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: t`h Hnbh-Qoonh rhmeki (Mhrcoiy).
Ckrhnn, W.
Cusse, C.,
?556
t`esvknuch
Fef horny `ucois rhoa` Qebhreo 844,444 yhors omk;, Qaehiah 271, 7??-2.
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: Etony.
Kolnhy, L.T.
Thrhttk, A.
Teseos, I.M.,
V.A. Ckkrh
Trosnkv, I.F.,
?575
?55?
?552
?50?
t`esvknuch
Grochwkrls gkr foneim gkssen coi. Nkifki: ]hefhighnf oif Ieaknski.
Nhs meshchits fVshrieo no Teihto (Cknesh, Etoneì). Ei: H. Bkiegoy oif B. Woifhrchhrsa`(hfs), Nhs prhcehrs Hurkpåhis, ?7?-?70. Tores: AV@Q
/ Trece Obenoite fhnno Wonnh Tofoio: Ckinh Tkmmeknk Ihn _uofrk fhnnh Akiksahizh
Hurkphh. Cenoik: Joao Bkkl.
V`h hvknuteki kg Tnhestkahih anecoth: o tech shrehs opprkoa`, Hort` oif Tnoihtory Qaehiah
Nhihrs 82, 684-0.
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg t`h Russeoi Tnoih: o s`krt ikth.
Trhiteah, C.N.,M.@. Fhitki
Roikv, W.O.
Ropksk, N.,C. Qoitkijo
Royion, J.-T.,N. Comkmo,G.-Z. Qbe`e-Onokue,F. Mhroofs
?500
?55?
t`esvknuch
t`esvknuch
V`h fhhp-sho kxymhi rhakrf, t`h mnkbon eah s`hht systhc oif `kceief hvknuteki. Ei:G.H. Mreih (hf.) Hvknutekiory `estkry kg t`h "rkbust" oustronkpet`haeihs, 101-641, IhwUkrl: Onfeih fh Mruythr.
Nhs seths trhs oiaehis fh n'omh fh no pehrrh hi XRQQ. Ei: H. Bkiegoy oif B. Woifhrchhrsa`(hfs) Nhs prhcehrs Hurkpåhis, 245-?7. Tores, AV@Q.
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: t`h Ebhreoi Thieisuno.
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Otnoitea Ckrkaak: t`h Aosobnoiao hvefhiah.
Rkbhrts. C.B..AQ. Mocbnh,F.R. Brefmnoif
Rkhbrkhls, ].,V. voi Lkngsa`kthi
t`es V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: t`h Bretes` Esnhs.vknuch
?556 V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: o s`krt a`rkiknkmy. Oitequety 70, 605-841.
t`es V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: o rhopproeson kg orthgoatuon oif a`rkiknkmeaonvknuch hvefhiah.
Rkhbrkhls, ]..I.J. Akiorf,V. voi Lkngsa`kthi
?552 Fhish gkrhsts, aknf sthpphs, oif t`h Tonohknet`ea shttnhchit kg ikrt`hri Hurkph, Aurrhit
Oit`rkpknkmy 11, 88?-07.
Ruffecoi, ].G.,CH. Royck
?500 Ikrt`hri `hcesp`hrh anecoth rhmechs fureim t`h post 1Co: pkssebnh thatkiea akiihatekis,T`enkskp`eaon Vroisoatekis kg t h Rkyon Qkaehty kg Nkifki B 1?0, ?-24.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 304/342
256 V@H HORN?HQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Ruffecoi. ].G.,C. Royck,O. Cfityrh
?507 Coyuyoco 6?,444-yhor ayanhs: Ikrt` Otnoitea Kahoi oif ikrt`hri `hcesp`hrh eah s`hhts Hort` oif Tnoihtory Qaehiah Nhtthrs 04, ??=-25.
Qoitkijo, C..T. Wenno
E]K V`h nkwhr ponohknet`ea kg Qpoei oif Tkrtumon, Jkurion kg ]krnf Trh`estkry 6, 68-56.
Q`oalnhtki, I.J.
Q`oalnhtki, I.J.,I.F. Kpfylh
?50= Kxymhi esktkphs. eah vknuch oif sho nhvhn, _uothriory Qaehiah Rhvehws 7, ?01-54.
?5=1 Kxymhi esktkph oif ponohkcomihtea strotemrop`y kg hquotkreon Toaegea akrh W20-210,_uothriory Rhshora` 1, 15-88.
Q`oalnhtki. I.J..J. Ecbreh,I.M. Teseos
?500 V`h hvknuteki kg kahoiea kxymhi-esktkph voreobenety ei t`h ikrt` Otnoitea kvhr t`h postt`rhh cenneki yhors, T`enkskp`eaon Vroisoatekis kg t`h Rkyon Qkaehty kg Nkifki B 1?0,7=5-00.
Qknghr. K. ?505 V`h Ceffnh tk Xpphr Tonohknet`ea troiseteki ki t`h Russeoi Tnoei. Ei: T. Chnnors oifA. Qtreimhr (hfs), V`h @ucoi Rhvknuteki: `h`ovekuron oif `eknkmeaon phrsphatevhs ki t`h
kremeis kg ckfhri `ucois, =?6-62, Hfeiburm`: Hfeiburm` Xievhrsety Trhss.
Qtreimhr, A,A. Mocbnh
?551 Ei shora` kg t`h Ihoifhrt`ons: sknveim t`h puzznh kg `ucoi kremeis. Nkifki: V`ochs oif@ufski.
Qua, J-T.,].@. Zomweji
?501 Tnek-Tnhestkahih akrrhnotekis bhtwhhi t`h ikrt`whsthri chfethrroihoi rhmeki oif ikrt`-whsthri Hurkph oaakrfeim tk rhahit bekstrotemrop`ea oif ponohkanecotea foto, Bkrhos ?2,?81-77.
Va`hrikv, H. ?552 Fesphrson, o summhsteki gkr o akccki usomh kg t`es thrc. Ei: ]. vki Lkhiemswonf oifN. ]hrfhnei (hfs), Cocconeoi cemroteki oif fesphrson hvhits ei t`h Hurkphoi_uothriory, Akurehr Gkrsa`uimseistetut Qhialhi`hrm ?81, 2?-28.
Vuggrhou, O. ?50= Nh Tonåknet`equh eigårehur ht ckyhi fu Ikrf fh no Groiah (Ikrf, Tos-fh-Aonoes,
Teaorfeh) fois ski aofrh strotemrop`equh. V`hsh Fkht. Åtot Xiev. Qae. Vha`ie. NennhGnoifrhs Ortkes.
?554 Nh Tonåknet`equh ckyhi råahit fois nh ikrf fh no Groiah. Ei: Tonåknet`equh ckyhi råahitht Tonåknet`equh supårehur oiaehi hi Hurkph. Aknnkquh eithriotekion Ihckurs (coe ?500). Cåckerh Cusåh Trå`estkerh nnh-fh-Groiah 1, ?85-78.
Vuggrhou, O.,T. Oitkeih
t`esvknuch
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: Akiteihiton Ikrt`whsthri Hurkph.
Vurihr. O. ?552 Normh aoievkrhs oif hornehst Hurkphoi `kceiefs: a`oimeim fhthrceioits kg rhskurahovoenobenety fureim t`h Nkwhr oif Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, Jkurion kg @ucoi Hvknuteki 22,?45-27.
Vurihr. A. ?5=4 V`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih fhpksets ot Corls Vhy, Hsshx, T`enkskp`eaon Vroisoatekis kg t`h
Rkyon Qkaehty kg Nkifki B 28=, 1=1-664.
Vurihr. H. ?55? Tnhestkahih strotemrop`y oif vhrthbroth gouios grkc t`h Ihuwehf bosei rhmeki kg whsthriMhrcoiy, Aroieuc 0, 2?-16.
Vzhfoles, T.A. ?551 Nkim-thrc trhh pkpunotekis ei ikrt`whst Mrhhah t`rkum` cuntepnh _uothriory anecoteaayanhs. Ioturh 176, 61=-64.
Wonka`. L. ?55? Nhs prhcehrs phupnhchits hi Ckroveh (Va`åaksnkvoqueh). Ei: H. Bkiegoy oif B. Woifhr-chhrsa` (hfs) Nhs prhcehrs Hurkpåhis, ?05-56, Tores: AV@Q.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 305/342
ANEWH Q. MOCBNH - V@H HIWERKICHIVON BOALMRKXIF
Wrbo. E .Q.
Wrbo, H.Q.,M.@. Fhitki,C.N. Trhiteah
?500 Noth Tnekahih anecotea hvhits oif `kceief hvknuteki. Ei: G.H. Mreih (hf.), Hvknutekiory
@estkry kg t`h "Rkbust" Oustronkpet`haeihs, 648-627, Ihw Ukrl: Onfeih fh Mruythr.
?505 Anecotea eignuhiahs ki horny `kceief bh`ovekr, Ksso ?6, ?2=-?87.
]`eth, V.F.,
M. Quwo,B. Osgow
?556 Oustronkpet`haus rocefus, o ihw sphaehs kg horny `kceief grkc Oroces, Ht`ekpeo, Ioturh
1=?,147- ?2.
]ychr, J.J.
Zomv¼ eji, ].@.
?508 Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea Qeths ei Host Oimneo. Ikrwea`: Mhk Bkkls.
?552o Cemroteki kg Whmhtoteki fureim t`h _uothcory ei Hurkph. Ei: ]. vki Lkhiemswonf oifN. ]hrfhnei (hfs), Cocconeoi cemroteki oif fesphrson hvhits ei t`h Hurkphoi _uothr-iory, Akurehr Gkrsa`uimseistetut Qhialhibhrm ?81, 5-24.
?552b V`h bhmeiieim kg t h eah omh ei Hurkph oif ets cojkr subfevesekis, _uothcory Qaehiah
Rhvehws ??,801-5?.
/ e ' X e l ' e . LE?.. ?580 Foneim t`h Tost. Nkifki: Cht`uhi.
?585 V`h Tnhestkahih phrekf. Nkifki: @uta`eiski.
Anevh Q. MocbnhFhportchit kg Ora`ohknkmyXievhrsety kg Qkut`ocptkiQ45 8I@ Qkut`ocptkiXiethf Leimfkc
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 306/342
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 307/342
wen Rkhbrkhls ?= V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph:V ejs voi Lkngsa kthi o rhopproeson kg orthgoatuon oif a`rkiknkmeaon hvefhiah
O rhopproeson kg t`h orthgoatuon oif a`rkiknkmeaon
hvefhiah gkr t`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph - wet` prkphr
otthiteki tk ets necetotekis oif ets rhneobenety - colhsgkr o
s`krt a`rkiknkmy, V`h gerst sknef troahs kg `kceief oatevetehs
ei t`es port kg t`h wkrnf orh orkuif 844,444 yhors knf.
?. Eitrkfuateki
Hstobnes`eim t`h hornehst fkhuchithf hvefhiah gkr `ucoikaaupoteki `os onwoys eivknvhf akitrkvhrsy, usuonnyahitrhf orkuif t`h orthgoatuon a`oroathr kg osshcbnomhsoif/kr t`her a`rkiknkmeaon pkseteki. Hxocpnhs kg sua`akitrkvhrseoS aoshs orh Brex`oc aovh, t`h hknet`-prkbnhc,Aoneak @enns. t`h LBQ-tugg akitrkvhrsy oif, vhry rhahitny,t`h oma kg t`h hornehst `kceief rhcoeis grkc Jovo (Qwes`hrht on. ?556). Kur saehiah t`revhs ki sua` fesomrhhchits<fesaussekis (efhonny) thst t`h strhimt` kg foto oif `ypkt`hshsoif t`us prkvefh us wet` akistoit grhs` oif sknef mrkuif tkbuenf kur ora`ohknkmeaon t`hkrehs.
Kih kg t`h rhoskis tk pnoi o wkrls`kp ki 'V`h HornehstKaaupoteki kg Tnhestkahih Hurkph' wos t`h vertuon obshiahkg saehitegea fesaussekis ki t`es subjhat. Fhspeth t`h normhiucbhr kg chhteims fhvkthf tk Hurkph's gerst troahs kg
shntnachin (h.m. Oifhrioa` nn
)QQ: "Feh arsna BhsehfnuimHurkpos"< Tores ?505: "Nhs prhcehrs phupnhchits `ucoeisfh ?'Hurkph" \Bkiegoy oif Woifhrchhrsa` ?55?S< Cenoi?554:< "V`h Hornehst Ei`obetoits kg Hurkph") t`h fothsmevhi tk t`h gerst 'Hurkphois' vory hikrckusny, fhphifeimki t`h bkkl kr t`h jkurion kih kphis. Ki t`h 'vhry knf'sefh, Bkiegoy oif Woifhrchhrsa` (?55?) prhshit o iucbhrkg seths onnhmhfny foteim grkc hornehr ports kg t`h HornyTnhestkahih, orkuif twk cenneki yhors omk (>ƒ. Oalhrcoi?505< Fhnski ?505). Oi omh kg obkut kih cenneki yhors esakisefhrhf o mkkf hstecoth gkr t`h gerst kaaupoteki kgHurkph by ckst wkrlhrs (ag Rknnoif ?552), rhghrreim tkseths sua` os Nh Wonnkiht ei Groiah (Fh Nucnhy ht on. ?500)
oif Lornea` O ei Mhrcoiy (]eermhs ?507< ?55?< Bkseisle,t`es vknuch). Ei akitrost tk t`hsh nkim a`rkiknkmehs whfhckistroth ei t`es pophr t`ot Hurkph's hornehst `ucoitroahs orh akisefhrobny ykuimhr, foteim grkc whnn eitk t`hCeffnh Tnhestkahih. ]h `ovh akch tk t`es akianuseki w`enhtryeim tk mevh o syit`hses kg t`h hvefhiah prhshithf ei prh-aeraunothf pophrs by otthifoits kg t`h Voutovhn-chhteim oif
foto aknnhathf ei kur kwi rhshora`. Kur pophr bhmeis wet` os`krt rhvehw kg t`h orthgoatuon a`oroathr kg osshcbnomhs oift`h a`rkiknkmeaon grochwkrl kg t`h _uothriory, gkausseimki `kw seths orh put ei o a`rkiknkmeaon suaahsseki (shateki 2).Ei shateki 1 wh survhy t`h bekstrotemrop`eaon pkseteki kgecpkrtoit cocconeoi osshcbnomhs (grkc bkt` ora`ohknkmeaonoif iki-ora`ohknkmeaon seths), w`enh shateki 6 rhvehws hornyseths ei ahitron oif ikrt`whsthri Hurkph. ]h t`hi turi tkhvefhiah grkc kt`hr ports kg Hurkph oif anksh wet` brehgfesausseki kg t`h ecpneaotekis.
2. V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: orthgoats
oif a`rkiknkmy
2 . ? . HWONXOVEIM V@H ORVHGOAVXON A@OROAVHR KG
OQQHCBNOMHQ
Kih ahitury omk, Tonohknet`ea ora`ohknkmests whrheivknvhf ei o gehrah fhboth kvhr t`h onnhmhf hxesthiah kgVhrteory `ucois ei Hurkph. Hknet`kp`enhs, bkt` ki t hakiteihit oif ei Bretoei, prhshithf t`kusoifs kg gneits grkcVhrteory fhpksets, t`ot ei t`her kpeieki whrh `ucoiny wkrlhfecpnhchits. V`h nkim nosteim fhboth kvhr t`h a`oroathr kg'hknet`s' osshcbnomhs prkfuahf o vost nethroturh ki t`h
subjhat, succoreshf ei pkpunor `oifbkkls grkc t`ksh foys,nelh Qknnos Oiaehit `uithrs oif t`her ckfhri rhprhshito-
tevhs (?5??), Kbhrcoehr's Fhr Chisa` fhr Wkrzhet (?5?2)oif Bkunh's Nhs @kcchs Gkssenhs (?52?). V`es fhboth nhftk vhry fhtoenhf gehnf kbshrvotekis oif hxphrechits oif skarhothf o vost bkfy kg likwnhfmh akiahrieim t`h vorehty kgorthgoat-nelh gkrcs prkfuahf by vorekus ioturon prkahsshs.V`h arux kg t`h cotthr es hnhmoitny succorezhf by ]orrhi(?524:284):
"]`ot es ecpkrtoit, `kwhvhr, es t`h goat t`ot sua`p`hikchio os t`h gnoleim kg gneits oif kaaosekionbunbs oif onsk hfmh-lioppeim orh prkfuahf by
aoushs hiterhny oport grkc ferhat `ucoi hggkrt. V`hnelhihss bhtwhhi t`h gnoleim prkfuahf by Ioturh oift`ot prkfuahf by `ucoi omhiaehs es suggeaeìit tks`egt oiy burfhi kg prkkg upki t`ksh w`k coeitoei t`h`ucoi kremei kg t`h stkihs< oif t`es cust ikt bhfkih by o aorhgun shnhateki kg pealhf sphaechis, butby o survhy kg t`h w`knh mrkup" (]orrhi ?524:284).
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 308/342
250 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
V`h orthgoatuon ioturh kg 'precetevh' osshcbnomhs `osbhhi oi kcieprhshit essuh hvhr seiah. Ei ?580 gkr eistoiah,J. Fhsckif Anorl's stufy kg ioturon groaturhs kg phbbnhss`kwhf vhry akiveiaeimny (ei t`h Ogreaoi akithxt kg'Loguoi' eifustrehs ei revhr vonnhys) t`ot ioturh aoi colh'phbbnh tkkns': t`hy orh prkfuahf by o s`orp 'gknnkwt`rkum`' bnkw, vhry uinelhny uifhr wothr, but pkssebny t`hrhsunt kg o rkal gonneim grkc obkvh ki tk o whfmhf phbbnh(Anorl ?580). V`hsh groaturhs aoi secunoth ortegeaeon groaturhtk sua` o rhcorlobnh fhmrhh, t`ot t`hsh sphaechis wkunfikt bh kut kg pnoah ei oiy "Thbbnh Aunturh" akithxt. @esstufehs kiah omoei strhss t`ot kih aoiikt buenf o strkimormuchit gkr horny kaaupoteki ki t`h boses kg pehahs wet`kiny o ghw ihmotevhs, shnhathf kut kg revhr-noef fhpksets. Eigoat, oiy oionyses kg horny seths cust tolh eitk oaakuit t`hw`knh roimh kg ioturon akifetekis ot t`h seth t`ot akunfprkfuah orthgoat-nelh gkrcs, os whnn os t`h mhknkmeaon shtteimkg t`h geif-spkt (shh Royion ht on., t`es vknuch, gkr o mkkfhxocpnh kg sua` oi opprkoa`).
Et es gkr t`hsh rhoskis t`ot gkr eistoiah Vuggrhou (?50=)
oif Vuggrhou oif Oitkeih (t`es vknuch) fk ikt oaahpt t`hGhrch fh Mroah (Qkcch) thrroah cothreon os hvefhiah gkrHorny Tnhestkahih kaaupoteki kg ikrt`hri Groiah (akitro
Bkurfehr ht on. ?5=6), kr t`ot Qoitkijo oif Wenno (?554)oif Ropksk oif Qoitkijo (t`es vknuch) akisefhr esknothfpehahs aknnhathf grkc Ebhreoi revhr thrroahs os tkk rorh oifuifeomikstea tk prkvh `ucoi shttnhchit ei t`h HornyTnhestkahih, w`enh Coieo (t`es vknuch) `os shrekus fkubtsobkut t`h Mhrcoi Qa`ktthr-Tonoknet`eluc (mrovhn-ponohknet`ea).
Ei shateki 6 wh hvonuoth skch ecpkrtoit horny seths byt`h essuhs ei t`h hknet` fhboth. Et es kg akursh ihahssory tk`ovh o mkkf likwnhfmh kg t`h osshcbnomhs oif t`herakithxt, het`hr by o fhtoenhf seth-pubneaoteki kr by gerst-`oif likwnhfmh. Xigkrtuiothny, kiny o sconn iucbhr kg'horny' seths `ovh bhhi pubnes`hf ei sua` o fhtoen t`othvonuoteki kg eithrprhtotekis akiahrieim t`h orthgoatuona`oroathr kg 'precetevh' osshcbnomhs es pkssebnh. ]h stortkur rhvehw t`hrhgkrh wet` t`h hvefhiah grkc ahitron oifikrt`whsthri Hurkph, w`hrh wh `ovh gerst-`oiflikwnhfmh kg t`h rhnhvoit osshcbnomhs. V`h geifeimsgrkc t`ot orho orh akigrkithf wet` t`ksh grkc kt`hr orhosei shateki 8.
2.2. V@H A@RKIKNKMEAON GROCH]KRL
V`h anosseaon subfeveseki kg t`h Tnhestkahih phrekf es byt`h mnoaeon-eitarmnoaeon sa`hch, boshf ki t`h hxthisekis kgmnoaehrs ei t`h Onpeih orho oif ei ikrt`hri Hurkph. Gkurfegghrhit hxthisekis whrh rhakrfhf ei t`h Onpeih orho(Meeiz, Ceifhn, Ress oif ]urc), oif ei ikrt`hri Hurkphkiny t`rhh (Hesthr, Qooeh oif ]hea`shn). Mnoaemhiea fhpksetswhrh neilhf wet` aknf eithrvons ei w`ea` eah-s`hhts gkrchf,
shporothf grkc hoa` kt`hr by worc-thcphroth eithrvons.Fhtoenhf eivhstemotekis kg pknnhi-bhoreim fhpksets eiikrt`whsthri Hurkph yehnfhf o rot`hr akcpnhth rhakrf kg t`hakcpnhx `estkry kg t`h vhmhtoteki ei t`ot orho. Tonohkbktoieaon foto wos troisgkrchf eitk ponohkanecotea eigkrcoteki,coleim o thrrhstreon a`rkikstrotemrop`eaon subfeveseki kg t`hTnhestkahih (ag. Gem. ? oif Zomweji ?508), o sa`hch t`ot
`os bhhi t`h Qtoiforf gkr ikrt`whsthri Hurkph.Trhneceiory rhsunts kg rhahit eivhstemotekis ei oi kphinemieth ceih ot Qa`÷ieimhi ihor @hncsthft (Mhrcoiy) oifei t`h Fki-Bosei (Russeo) eifeaoth, `kwhvhr, t`ot t`h gemurh ?subfeveseki es eiakcpnhth. V`h Tnhestkahih shfechitshxpkshf ei t`h Qa`÷ieimhi quorry foth grkc t`h Hnsthreoi tkt`h @knkahih oif orh rea` ei ponohkbktoieaon. conoaknkmeaonoif ponohkitknkmeaon eigkrcoteki, w`enh Ceffnh Tnhestkahihorthgoats orh prhshit tkk (ag. V`ehch ht on. ?551). Qtufehs kgt`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih shquhiahs eifeaoth t`ot t`hrh whrh otnhost t`rhh p`oshs wet` o festeiat, whnn fhvhnkphfeithrmnoaeon vhmhtoteki bhtwhhi t`h Hnsthreoi oif t`h Qooneoitenn. Et es `kwhvhr ikt anhor yht w`ht`hr t`h twk knfhr worc-
thcphroth phrekfs t`hrh whrh shporothf grkc hoa` kt`hr by ofesteiat aknf (mnoaeon) p`osh. V`hkrateaonny t`hy cem`t `ovhbhhi shporothf by oi ecpkrtoit but rhnotevhny s`krt akknhrgnuatuoteki, ckrh kr nhss akcporobnh tk t`h strkimhr eitro-Hhceoi gnuatuotekis rhahitny rhpkrthf by t`h MRET-chcbhrs(MRET ?551), kr tk t`h eitro-Qtomh = 'aknf' eithrvon, sub-Qtomh =b (ag. Oifrhws ?501).
Nkim shquhiahs ei t`h Fki Bosei s`kw ot nhost gevhmnoaeon/eithrmnoaeon ayanhs ei t`h tech spoi bhtwhhi t`hBrui`hs/Cotuyoco bkuifory oif t`h Klo (3 Hnsthreoi)mnoaeoteki. Vwk eah-s`hht hxthisekis hornehr t`oi t`hHnsthreoi akunf bh rhakrfhf ei t`h shatekis. V`h ckstecpkrtoit eah-s`hht t`hrh wos t`ot kg t`h Fki Mnoaeoteki,akvhreim t`h Fki Bosei cua` gurt`hr skut` t`oi t`h eah-aops kg t`h Klo-Hnsthr, t`h Fijhpr-Qoonh oif t`h Wonfoe-]hea`shn. Vwk fesateiat eithrmnoaeon eithrvons oif kih aknfp`osh shporoth t`h Fki Mnoaeon grkc t`h Klo Mnoaeon p`osh.Akrrhnoteki bhtwhhi t`h Fki Bosei oif ikrt`whsthriHurkph, coeiny ki t`h bosh kg coccon gouio-osskaeotekis,eifeaoths t`ot t`h ikrt`whsthri Qtoiforf subfeveseki eseiakcpnhth gkr t`h nkwhr port kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, e.h.ei t`h gerst `ong kg t`h "Arkchreoi Akcpnhx". V`heiakcpnhthihss kg t`h Qtoiforf akiteihiton subfeveseki esonsk opporhit w`hi akcporeim et wet` t`h kxymhi esktkphrhakrf, w`ea` akuits 5 eithrmnoaeon oif 5 mnoaeon p`oshs
wet`ei t`h Brui`hs Hpka`.V`h kxymhi esktkph rhakrf, t`h ckst fhtoenhf subfeveseki
kg t`h _uothriory skgor, es rhmorfhf os t`h techsaonh kihs`kunf try tk rhghr tk. Et es o mnkbon rhakrf, t`kum`t tk rhgnhata`oimhs ei t`h tkton ockuit kg eah t`h wkrnf kvhr, os t`hrhes rhcorlobny nettnh voreoteki ockim akrhs tolhi grkcfegghrhit orhos . Et es onsk o rot`hr akiteiukus rhakrf,
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 309/342
255 ]EN RKHBRKHLQ OIF V@EJQ WOI LKNGQA@KVHI - O RHOTTROEQON KG V@H HWEFHIAH
4´ ?4´ 24´
E
E
a:"1
@KNKAHIH
]hea`shneoi NOVH TNHEQVKAHIH
Hhceoi
NOVH TNHEQVKAHIH
Qooneoi
CEFFNH
TNHEQVKAHIH
@knstheieoi
CEFFNH
TNHEQVKAHIH
Hnsthreoi
CEFFNH
TNHEQVKAHIH
Eithrmnoaeon EW
Eithrmnoaeon EEE
"Arkchreoi" *
Eithrmnoaeon EE
Eithrmnoaeon ?
CEFFNH
TNHEQVKAHIH
Nhhrfoc Eithrmnoaeon
Bovhneoi *
Bovhn Eithrmnoaeon
HORNU
TNHEQVKAHIH
Chiopeoi
HORNU
TNHEQVKAHIH
]ooneoi
HORNU
TNHEQVKAHIHHburkieoi
HORNU
TNHEQVKAHIH
Vemneoi
HORNU
TNHEQVKAHIH
Trohtemneoi
HORNU
TNHEQVKAHIH
Rhuvhreoi
NOVH
TNEKAHIH
Qhvhron meoaeons oif eithrmnoaeons wet`ei kih Omh
Gem. ?. Anecoth aurvh tkr t`h _uothriory ei t`h Iht`hrnoifs (ogthr Zomweji ?508). Omh ei cenneki yhors.Vhcphroturh ei fhmrhhs A, hstecothf choi tkr Juny. * eianufhs shvhron meoaeons oif eithrmnoaeons.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 310/342
144 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
prkvefeim oi ormuobny akcpnhth survhy kg t`h hiterh_uotariory. Oif et es o leif kg 'Hsphroitk' rhakrf, hosy tk
'uifhrstoif' gkr wkrlhrs grkc vorekus ports kg t`h wkrnf,ikt bkt`hrhf by t`h fhtoens oif eitreaoaehs kg t`h vorekusrhmekion subfevesekis sua` os t`h ikrt`whsthri Rurkphoikih chitekihf obkvh. V`es 'ushr-grehifneihss' es ahrtoeiny o
vhry ecpkrtoit goatkr ei t`h eiarhoshf usomh kg t`h fhhp-sho
rhakrf gkr akrrhnoteki-purpkshs. ]h cust `kwhvhr iktgkrmht t`ot akrrhnoteki tk t`h kxymhi esktkph stomhs es kgthicoeiny boshf ki vhry secpnh 'akuiteim' prkahfurhs, ki t`h
rhsunts kg obsknuth foteim cht`kfs oif ki (kgthi ecpneaet)ossucptekis, gkr hxocpnh t`ot t`h coxecuc einoif-eahhxthiseki akrrhspkifs tk t`h `em`hst Kn0-vonuhs.Xigkrtuiothny, thrrhstreon shatekis orh fkceiothf by mops.
Obsknuth foths, ei coiy aoshs akitrofeatkry oif eioaauroth,s`kunf ikt bh t`h kiny bosh gkr o a`rkiknkmeaon akrrhnoteki.Xseim t`h coxecuc eah-hxthiseki gkr noif-sho akrrhnonekispkshs prkbnhcs os skki os kih hxa`oimhs t`h iorrkw'iotekion' phrsphatevh gkr o brkofhr 'Hurkphoi' kih: t`h
skut`hrickst hxthiseki ei Mrhot Bretoei wos t`h Oimneoi
(3 Hnsthreoi), ei t`h Iht`hrnoifs et wos t`h Qooneoi eah-aop,oif ei t`h Fki Bosei et wos t`h Fki mnoaeoteki! V`hshprkbnhcs aoi nhof tk fegghrhit akrrhnotekis bhtwhhi t`h
Akiteihiton subfeveseki oif t`h kxymhi esktkph rhakrf (shh
t`h twk kptekis prhshithf ei Gem. 2).
Ont`kum ikt fhiyeim t`h hikrckus ofvoitomhs kg t`h
fhhp sho rhakrf kvhr t`h thrrhstreon anecotea foto wh prhghrt`h akiteihiton subfeveseki kg t`h _uothriory (Gem. ?) os t`h
bosea grochwkrl gkr akrrhnoteki kvhr t`h kxymhi esktkphrhakrf os nkim os t`hrh orh ik rhneobnh akrrhnoteki cht`kfs(ei kt`hr wkrfs: os nkim os t`h obsknuth foteim cht`kfs orh
akitrofeatkry oif eioaauroth). Xiareteaon ush kg t`h fhhp sho
stomhs arhoths o pshufk-ahrtoeity t`ot `efhs t`h boseastrotemrop`eaon prkbnhcs ei`hrhit ei onn leifs kg thrrhstreonakrrhnotekis.
1. V`h a`rkiknkmy kg _uoth riory cocconeoigkssen osshcbnomhs
V`h ush kg ponohkbktoieaon hvefhiah gkr nkim festoiahakrrhnoteki tk t`h Qtoiforf thrrhstreon subfevesekis es
`ocphrhf by t`h obshiah kg hvknutekiory trhifs ei pnoitsoif by t`h eithr-rhmekion voreotekis ei a`oroathrs kg
vhmhtoteki. Cocconeoi gkssens orh onthriotevh ecpkrtoitbekstrotemrop`ea eifeaotkrs. V`her ush ei foteim oif
akrrhnoteim fhpksets es boshf ki t`h goat t`ot ckst kg t`h
coccons `ovh oi hxthisevh festrebuteki orho oif t`ot oiucbhr s`kw o ropef hvknuteki oif/kr cemrotkry s`egtswet`ei t`h _uothriory (ag. Nesthr ?552). V`h akcpkseteki kg
t`h cocconeoi gouio `os a`oimhf rhnotevhny gost fureim t`h
_uothriory fuh tk t`h prkahsshs kg hvknuteki, hxteiateki oif
cemroteki kg sphaehs< o iucbhr kg coccon bekzkiotekis`ovh bhhi hstobnes`hf by fegghrhit out`krs. Qkch kg t`hsh
orh boshf ki t`h sconnhr coccon gouio, kt`hrs ki t`h
normhr kr ki bkt`. @kwhvhr, ckst kg t`hsh zkiotekis `ovhikt bhhi fhgeihf oaakrfeim tk t`h muefh gkr strotemrop`eaikchianoturh pubnes`hf by @hfbhrm (?5=7) oif t`h
thrceiknkmy ushf by skch out`krs es gurt`hrckrh hxtrhchnyakiguseim (ag. Woi Lkngsa`kthi ?554).
Coiy ponohkitknkmests wkrl wet` t`h bekstrotemrop`eaon
subfeveseki kg t`h _uothriory boshf ki t`h Orveaknefohsuaahsseki, os prkpkshf by Ghjgor oif @heirea` (?50?),w`ea` es ei goat o ckfegeaoteki kg t`h @uimoreoi sconnhrcoccon zkioteki hstobnes`hf by Lrhtzke (shh h.m. Lratzke,?578< Lrhtzke oif Tåase, ?5=5< Woi fhr Chunhi, ?5=1).Ghjgor oif @heirea` (?50?) hstobnes`hf t`rhh whnn fhgeihfbekzkihs (stomhs ei t`her thrceiknkmy) gkr t`h Tnhestkahih:Wennoiyeoi, Be`oreoi oif Vkreimeoi. O bekzkioteki ki t`h
boses kg a`oimhs ei t`h normhr coccon gouio wos akistruathfby Etoneoi ponohkitknkmests (Ozzorkne ht on. ?500). V`hersubfeveseki kg Wennogroia`eoi oif Monhreoi gouios es ushf ei
normh ports kg Hurkpa oif Oseo fhspeta t`h goat t`ot t`h
bkuifory bhtwhhi bkt` bekzkihs es pkkrny fhgeihf, os wenn
bh fesausshf bhnkw.
1.?. V@H QCONNHR COCCONQ: BE@OREOI - VKREIMEOI
Be`oreoi gouios fegghr grkc t`h prhahhfeim Wennoiyeoigouios by t`h kaaurrhiah kg Cearktus. V`h Wennoiyeoigouios aoi bh rhakmieshf by t`h fkceioiah kg Ceckcys,
t`h Be`oreoi gouios by t`h ak-kaaurrhiah kg Cearktus oif
Ceckcys, oif t`h Vkreimeoi "Qtomh" by Orveakno - Ceark
tus osshcbnomhs. V`h Be`oreoi es fevefhf eitk twk "substomhs": t`h Horny Be`oreoi wet` Cearktus (Onnkp`oekcys)
oif t`h Noth Be`oreoi wet` Cearktus (Cearktus).
V`h troiseteki grkc t`h Wennoiyeoi tk t`h Be`oreoi ei t`h
Horny Tnhestkahih akrrhspkifs ckrh kr nhss wet` t`hVemneoi/Hburkieoi troiseteki. Gouios sua` os Vhmhnhi (t`h
Iht`hrnoifs) bhnkim tk t`h Wennoiyeoi, w`enh t`h HornyBe`oreoi akcpreshs gouios sua` os Nh Wonnkiht (Groiah),Ckith Thmneo (Etony) oif Bhtgeo 2 (Rkcoieo).
V`h troiseteki kg Cearktus (Onnkp`oekcys) tk Cearktus
(Cearktus), corleim t`h troiseteki grkc t`h Horny tk t`h
Noth Be`oreoi, foths tk t`h horny port kg t`h Bovhneoiakcpnhx, rkum`ny akrrhnothf tk t`h Jorocennk.
Gouios sua` os ]hst Ruitki (Mrhot Bretoei), QtroisloQlono, Trhznhteah (Azha`eo), Vorl÷ (Noyhr ?7) (@uimory),Enyilo E-En oif Enyilo EW (Russeo) bhnkim tk t`h NothBe`oreoi. V`h mhius Ceckcys es rhprhshithf by kiny kih
sphaehs, t`h normh Ceckcys soveie, ei ckst kg t`hsh gouios.O shakif Ceckcys, o sconnhr gkrc kgthi rhghrrhf tk
Ceckcys (Ashreo) pusennus, kaaurs kiny ei t`h gouiosLornea` A oif H (Mhrcoiy) oif ei Enyilo EW oif EnyiloE-EE. V`h kaaurrhiah kr obshiah kg t`h sconnhr Ceckcys es
prkbobny o strotemrop`eaon corlhr, w`ea` aoi bh ushf tk
subfevefh t`h Noth Be`oreoi gouios eitk oi knfhr mrkup wet`,
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 311/342
14? ]EN RKHBRKHLQ OIF V@EJQ WOI LKNGQA@KVHI - O RHOTTROEQON KG V@H HWEFHIAH
?
1
?
1
@KNKAHIH?
1
?
1 O V H
T N .
]hea`shneoi
8h
=
8h
=
Hhceoi8h
=
8h
=
Q o o n e o i
55??
A H I H
@knstheieoi55??
A H I H
Hnsthreoi
55??
A H I H
?? ?1
T N H E Q V A
Eithrmnoaeon EW
NX
?1 ?8
C E F F N
-§[ Eithrmnoaeon EEEHkk
?8 ?=aa Eithrmnoaeon EE
?=?5
A r k c
?5
2? 2? Eithrmnoaeon E2? 2?
P
21 21 "k- Nhhrfoc Eithrmn.
E¼ 28
T N H E Q V K A H I H
qka.2"41
9& Bovhn Eithrmn.E¼ 28
T N H E Q V K A H I H
H
O R N U Chiopeoi
H
O R N U
]ooneoi
z>Kzaak roE -
O r v e a k
/ / / ?
/ e
'
Acaf
- A kc Þoe Qro *‖'' [ e
O R E O I
2
et
eK /
e <n
e /
e/n
ro 9.e [
9. H e ` o
bk k
HK) ro esAn
>i k
NX >2
Coostrea`t- Bhnvåfàrh
Aouih fh N'Oromk
Qwoisakcbh, @kxih, Benzeimsnhbhi
Wårthssz÷n÷s ;Bkxmrkvh, Qpreckit, Cehshi`hecCouhr, No Tknnhfroro, Gkitoio,
Roiuaaek, Weskmneoik
Lornea` M, EshrieoWhikso-Nkrhtk
Trhznhteah, Qtroislo slono
]hst Ruitki, Wkemtsthft
Lornea` H
Lornea` A
Lornea` Bb
Lornea` Bo, Ghrch fh Mroah
Ckith ThmneoNh Wonnkiht, Lornea` O,Xithrcossghnf
Whito Ceahio
Gem. 2. Vhitotevh akrrhnoteki kg sconn coccon bekzkiotekis oif gouion osshcbnomhs tk t`h ikrt`whst Hurkphoi subfevesekikg t`h _uothriory oif tk vorekus kxymhi esktkph stomhs.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 312/342
142 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
oif o ykuimhr mrkup wet`kut t`h sconnhr Ceckcys. V`hgouios Leernea` A oif H foth grkc t`h Brui`hs Hpka` w`ea`eifeaoths t`ot t`h t`h sconnhr Ceckcys fesopphorhf nothrt`oi t`h Brui`hs/Cotuyoco bkuifory.
Oi hxthisevh stufy kg t`h sconnhr coccon gouios grkct`h Fki Bosei rhsunthf ei o subfeveseki kg t`h Noth Be`oreoigouios ki t`h boses kg hvknutekiory trhifs ei t`h C, kg
nomureihs {(Trknomurus oif Nomurus) oif t`h C, kg Cearkrus (Vhrreakno) (3 Cearktys \TetycysS) (Losoitshvo?50=). O akrrhnoteki bhtwhhi t`h whsthri oif ahitronHurkphoi Noth Be`oreoi gouios oif gouios grkc t`h FkiBosei es `ocphrhf by t`h coeiny hosthurkphoi festrebutekikg nomureihs. Gurt`hrckrh, kur likwnhfmh kg t`h fegghrhit
Cearktus-ckrp`ktyphs prhshit ei t`h whsthri oif ahitronHurkphoi gouios es eisuggeaeìit. Kih aoi kiny soy t`ot t`hNoth Be`oreoi akvhrs t`h nothr port kg t`h Bovhneoi akcpnhxoif ckst kg t`h Arkchreoi akcpnhx, o tech spoi wet` otnhost gevh mnoaeon/eithrmnoaeon ayanhs. V`h gouios wet` twk
Ceckcys sphaehs foth grkc t`h hornehr port kg t`ot techspoi, t`h gouios wet` kiny Ceckcys soveie grkc t`h nothrport.
O vhry ecpkrtoit strotemrop`eaon corlhr es t`h troisetekikg Ceckcys soveie tk Orveakno thrrhstres, w`ea`akrrhspkifs tk t`h Be`oreoi-Vkreimeoi bkuifory. ei t`hshakif `ong kg t`h Arkchreoi akcpnhx (Woi Lkngsa`kthi?554< Wki Lkhiemswonf oif Woi Lkngsa`kthi, ei prhss).Qeiah t`h ckst precetevh rhprhshitotevh kg t`h mhius
Orveakno, Orveakno t. aoiteoio (kgthi aethf os h.m. Orveakno
aoiteoio kr Orveakno cksboa`hises), es likwi grkcArkchreoi Eithrmnoaeon EW fhpksets (Woi Lkngsa`kthi ?554),t`h troiseteki tkkl pnoah bhgkrh Eithrmnoaeon EW kg t`hArkchreoi Akcpnhx. Orveakno opphors gkr t`h gerst tech ei
t`h Leernea` shateki ei t`h gouio grkc Leernea` M. V`h `hovy-ceihron osskaeoteki kg t`h Leernea` M fhpksets oif t`hcoccon gouio eifeaoth o Arkchreoi Eithrmnoaeon EEE kr o(bhmeiieim kg) Arkchreoi Eithrmnoaeon EW omh (WoiLkngsa`kthi oif Vurihr, ei prhss< Wki Lkhiemswonf oifWoi Lkngsa`kthi, ei prhss). V`h Ceckcys-Orveakno
troiseteki `os bhhi fkauchithf ei whsthri (A`oneih ?507),ahitron (Ghjgor oif @heirea` ?50?) oif hosthri Hurkph(Vhrzho, ei prhss). Ei ikrt`whsthri Hurkph t`h troisetekitkkl pnoah ei t`h shakif `ong kg t`h Arkchreoi-akcpnhx.V`es shhcs tk `ovh bhhi t`h aosh ei kt`hr orhos tkk, os gkreistoiah fkauchithf by t`h kaaurrhiah kg Orveakno
thrrhstres bhgkrh t`h Hnsthreoi ei Ahitron Hurkph (Vhrzho, eiprhss) oif t`h kaaurrhiah kg vhry ofvoiahf Ceckcys soveie
ei gouios grkc t`h Fki Bosei, fothf tk shakif eithrmnoaeonbhgkrh t`h Klo-Hnsthreoi mnoaeoteki (Losoitshvo ?50=). Et estk bh hxphathf t`ot t`hrh wos oi osyia`rkieaety wet`ei t`hrhmekion troiseteki grkc Ceckcys tk Orveakno, but sua`troismrhssekis gonn kutsefh t`h a`rkiknkmeaon rhsknuteki kgkur prhshit foteim cht`kfs gkr t`es tech-roimh.
O prkbnhc ei t`es rhsphat es t`h omh kg t`h Orve'ak/o-gouigrkc Eshrieo (Etony), suppkshf tk bh noth Horny Tnhestkahihki t`h boses kg rofekchtrea foths gkr arystons grkc t`h sethcotrex oif skch ponohkcomihtea foto (Akntkrte ht on. ?50?,CaT`hrrki oif Qa`ceft ?501). Eshrieo `os yehnfhf gkssenrhcoeis kg Orveakno thrrhstres aoiteoio (ossemihf tk t`h
juiekr syikiyc Orveakno cksboa`hises by Qono ?501<
Akntkrte ht on. ?502). O stufy kg t`h cothreon, eianufeim t`otsocpnhf ei t`h phrekf ogthr ?502, onnkwhf t`h shakif out`krtk a`oroathrezh t`h geifs kg Eshrieo os o precetevh pkpunotekikg t`h mhius Orveakno. Kiny 04% kg t`h cknors (kiny o ghworh juvhienh) orh rkktnhss, w`hrhos 24% s`kw eifeaotekis gkrkkt gkrcoteki, but orh stenn rkktnhss. V`h gouio wet` Orve
akno, Hnhp`os (T.) oitequus, Qthp`oikreius `uifsnwechises
oif wet`kut Ceckcys soveie, Ceckcys pusennus oif Cearktus (Onnkp`oekcys) sp. summhsts o Ceffnh Tnhestkahihomh, os et es akcporobnh tk ahitron Hurkphoi gouios osCksboa` oif Couhr (ag. Qono oif Gkrthneus ?551).
Kih akunf oaahpt o noth Horny Tnhestkahih omh gkr Eshrieokiny by summhsteim oi hornehr kaaurrhiah kg Orveakno eiEtony, ei o ckrh kr nhss esknothf orho kg Hurkph. V`es es ikt opnousebnh ormuchit, `kwhvhr, os t`hrh orh ik eifeaotekis kgo borrehr esknoteim t`h cocconeoi gouios ei Etony grkc t`kshkg ahitron oif whsthri Hurkph fureim t`h Tnhestkahih. Kit`h akitrory, t`h obuifoit secenoretehs ei t`h akcpkseteki kgt`h Horny, Ceffnh oif Noth Tnhestkahih gouios kg Etony oifhosthri, ahitron oif whsthri Hurkph s`kw o mhihron oifonckst akiteiukus gouion hxa`oimh bhtwhhi t`hsh orhosfureim t`h _uothriory (Wki Lkhiemswonf oif Woi Lkng
sa`kthi, ei prhss).
V`es es o akithxt ei w`ea` ei kur kpeieki t`h 'obsknuth'foths gkr t`h seth aoiikt bh tolhi ot goah vonuh, oif t`h seth
aoiikt bh shhi os yehnfeim uiocbemukus hvefhiah gkrkaaupoteki kg Hurkph ot t`h vhry hif kg t`h HornyTnhestkahih. O rhhvonuoteki kg t`h tkton foteim hvefhiah esihahssory, oif ei t`h choitech wh shrekusny quhsteki t`hsemiegeaoiah kg t`h ponohkcomihtea oif rofekchtrea foths gkrt`h Eshrieo seth.
Vkreimeoi gouios aoi bh fevefhf eitk twk mrkups: oiknfhr kih wet` Orveakno thrrhstres aoiteoio oif sk-aonnhfrhneat sphaehs (sua` os Vonpo ceikr, Vrkmkit`hreuc auveare)
oif o ykuimhr mrkup wet` t`h ckrh hvknvhf Orveakno
thrrhstres ssp. O oif B, ak-kaaureim wet` o ckfhri sconnhrcoccon gouio (shh Woi Lkngsa`kthi, ?554). V`h gerstmrkup akcpreshs gouios sua` os Cehshi`hec E, Leernea` M,
Couhr (Mhrcoiy), Bkxmrkvh, ]hstbury-sub-Chifep (MrhotBretoei), Qpreckit (Bhnnh Rka`h) (Bhnmeuc), Vorl÷(@uimory) wet` Orveakno thrrhstres aoiteoio tkmht`hr wet`
Qkrhx (Frhpoikskrhx) sp. oif Tnekcys hpesakpones oif oiucbhr kg gouios h.m. Qwoisakcbh (Mrhot Bretoei),Benzeimsnhbhi (Mhrcoiy) ykuimhr ei omh oif wet`kut Qkrhx
(Frhpoikskrhx) oif Tnekcys hpesakpones.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 313/342
141 ]EN RKHBRKHLQ OIF V@EJQ WOI LKNGQA@KVHI - O RHOTTROEQON KG V@H HWEFHIAH
Noth Vkreimeoi gouios aoi bh rhakmiezhf by hvknutekiorya`oimhs ei t`h Orveakno cknors. Qeiah t`h horny Qooneoit`eiieim kg t`h akivhx sefhs kg t`h fhiteih treoimnhs `os
rhsunthf ei a`oimhs ei t`h rhnotevh t`ealihss kg t`h hiochnboif kg t`h Orveakno cknors. V`es fhvhnkpchit aoi bh ushfgkr strotemrop`eaon akrrhnotekis kg ykuimhr, e.h. pkst-"@knstheieoi" gouios, sua` os t`ksh grkc Aouih fh ?'Oromk
(Fhsanoux ?552o< ?552b), Coostrea`t-Bhnvåfàrh oif]hecor-H`reimsfkrg (ag. Woi Lkngsa`kthi ?554).
1.2. V@H NORMHR COCCONQ: WENNOGROIA@EOI -
MONHREOI
V`h wefhny ushf Etoneoi beka`rkiknkmy, wet` o
subfeveseki ei Wennogroia`eoi oif Monhreoi gouios, es coeinyboshf ki a`oimhs ei t`h normhr coccon gouio. V`h Wennogroia`eoi, storteim obkut 1 cenneki yhors omk, akvhrs port kg
t`h Tnekahih oif t`h Horny Tnhestkahih. Et `os bhhi sub-
fevefhf eitk oi horny, o ceffnh oif o noth p`osh, osubfeveski rhgeihf by Ozzorkne (?5==), w`k fevefhf t`h
Wennogroia`eoi gouios eitk sex ckrh kr nhss whnn-fhgeihf
gouioS uiets. V`h bhmeiieim kg t`h Wennogroia`eoi etshng,kg skch kg ets uiets oif ets hif orh a`oroathrezhf by
prkikuiahf fesphrson hvhits (Ozzorkne ht on., ?500< Qonoan on. ?552). Ozzorkne ht on. (?500) stoth t`ot t`h Wenno-geroia`eoi-Monhreoi troiseteki (t`h hif-Wennogroia`eoi hvhit,?.4-4.5 Cyr BT) sow o akcpnhth gouion turikvhr, wet`cossevh hxteiatekis oif ihw, prhvekusny uilikwiofoptotekis. Noth Wennogroia`eoi toxo sua` os Huanofkahrks,
Foco ihstee, Nhptkbks htrusaus, Qus strkzzee oif Ora`e-
feslkfki chrefekiones bhaoch hxteiat w`hrhos coiy toxo(Chmoahrks. Qkhrmhneo sp., Trohkvebks presaus, Beski
sa`khthisoale, Houus sþsshibkrihises, Xrsus fhieimhrë)
oppaor fureim t`h Horny Monhreoi.
V`h troiseteki kg t`h noth Wennogroia`eoi tk t`h Monhreoifef ikt tolh pnoah ot kiah. Oaakrfeim tk Ozzorkne ht on.
(?500) t`h troisetekion p`osh wos kg (mhknkmeaonny) s`krtfuroteki bhaoush kiny o ghw seths `ovh 'ioturonny cexhf'osshcbnomhs - oi ossucpteki porteonny boshf ki t`h eighrrhfHorny Tnhestkahih omh kg Eshrieo. V`hy ossemi o nothCotuyoco omh tk t`h Eshrieo gouio, oif `hiah eighr t`otgouios grkc ikrconny comihtezhf fhpksets (sua` os t`h
gouios grkc ]hst Ruitki oif Wkemtsthft) `ovh tk bh
akrrhnothf wet` t`h Jorocennk hvhit. Ei sua` o sahiorek t`h
Wennogroia`eoi/Monhreoi gouion s egt eifhhf shhcs bkt` vhryprkikuiahf oif rhnotevhny obrupt. Ei kur kpeieki t`h gouios
grkc Eshrieo, ]hst Ruitki oif Wkemtsthft orh kg CeffnhTnhestkahih omh, w`ea` chois t`ot t`h gouion turikvhr akunf`ovh tolhi pnoah ckrh mrofuonny. Gkr us t`h 'gouionwothrs`hf' es secpny t`h rhsunt kg o meoit thcpkron aknnopsh,aoushf by oi oaaucunoteki kg akrrhnoteki hrrkrs.
V`es eithrprhtoteki es akigerchf by t`h gouio grkc WhitoCeahio, fothf ot orkuif ?.2 Cyr BT. yht onrhofy akitoeieim
shvhron Monhreoi eccemroits (Chmonkahrks, Trohkvebks,
Qkhrmhneo oif Beski) (Omuste ht oe, ?50=). V`h hif-
Wennogroia`eoi 'hvhit' ei t`h shish kg h.m. Ozzorkne ht on.
(?500) t`hrhgkrh prkbobny `os o nkim strotemrop`eaon roimh,w`ea` ihahssetoths o rh-fhgeieteki kg t`h noth Wennogroia`eoi-Monhreoi bkuifory. Ot t`h aurrhit stoth kg likwnhfmh t`h
thrcs noth Wennogroia`eoi kr Monhreoi orh kg nettnh
bekstrotemrop`eaon vonuh.
6. V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg ahitron oif
ikrt`whsthri Hurkph
6.?. V@H HORNU TNHEQVKAHIH
V`h pshufk-orthgoat prkbnhc es hsphaeonny opporhit eiskch ahitron Hurkphoi Horny Tnhestkahih seths w`hrhvorekus (ocothur-) ora`ohknkmests socpnhf `umh ockuits kg
mrovhns oif aoch up wet` precetevh nkkleim 'a`kpphrs' oif
'a`kppeim-tkkns'. O vhry mkkf hxocpnh es t`h Bhrkui seth,ihor Tromuh (Grefrea` ?55?), w`hrh obkut 04 orthgoats whrhaknnhathf grkc t`h tkp kg Horny Tnhestkahih revhr mrovhns.hxpkshf kvhr oi orho kg obkut 2444 c
2. Vwk kvhrnyeim
nhvhns yehnfhf ?4 ckrh 'ethcs kg eifustry'. V`h 04 rknnhf'orthgoats', ckstny 'sefh-a`kpphrs' wet` kiny o ghw
ihmotevhs, whrh aknnhathf grkc t`h mrovhn surgoah 'ogthrroei'. Oaakrfeim tk Grefrea` (?55?:??), t`h osshcbnomh"eianufhs a`kpphrs, begoahs, prktk-begoahs, peals, anhovhrs,pkny`hfrkis, subsp`hrkefs, rhprhshiteim Oa`hunhoi s.?.,
akcporobnh tk t`h Ogreaoi geifs ... V`h omh kg t`h sht es
ckrh t`oi ?.8 cenneki yhors, shrveim t`us os oi hvefhiaht`ot bkt` Hurkph oif Ogreao whrh shttnhf opprkxecothny ei
t`h soch tech by phkpnh wet` oionkmkus aunturhs". V`h
geifs, bkt` t`ksh pubnes`hf oif t`ksh fespnoyhf ei t`h
Tromuh Iotekion Cushuc, orh ei t`h roimh kg w`ot aoi bh
aknnhathf grkc ioturon mrovhn fhpksets< t`hy orh ikt
oaahptobnh hvefhiah kg Horny Tnhestkahih kaaupoteki (shh
Lkznkwsle ?552 gkr o akcporobnh eithrprhtoteki).
V`h soch oppnehs ei kur kpeieki tk t`h Cuskv oif Evoiosshcbnomhs, fhsarebhf by Wonka` (?55? oif t`es vknuch).Bkt` seths, opprkxecothny 64 lc skut` kg Brik, whrhvesethf by oi ocothur-ora`ohknkmest, w`k aknnhathf `uifrhfskg 'a`kpphrs' oif 'a`kppeim-tkkns' grkc rhwkrlhf Cekahihfhpksets, prhshit ki tkp kg Horny kr horny Ceffnh Tnhestkahih fhpksets. Os ei Bhrkui, wh orh fhoneim wet` o shnhatekigrkc t`kusoifs oif t`kusoifs kg iki-ckfegehf phbbnhs.V`h 'orthgoats' `ovh ei mhihron kiny o ghw errhmunorihmotevhs, oif onckst onn 'a`kppeim-tkkns' fespnoy akc-
pnhthny bnuithf 'wkrleim hfmhs'.Akcporobnh ormuchits oppny tk t`h kt`hr Horny
Tnhestkahih seths ei Ckroveo (Brik-Ahrikveah, wet` kih
mkkf gnolh t`kum`, ikt rhakvhrhf ei setu, oif Brik-Ahrikveah Lkpha). O ieah pknyhfhr grkc Cnofha aovh, gkuif ei o
aonaeth noyhr akvhreim t`h Horny Tnhestkahih shfechits t`hrh,`os ik a`rkiknkmeaon akithxt.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 314/342
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 315/342
148 ]EN RKHBRKHLQ OIF V@EJQ WOI LKNGQA@KVHI - O RHOTTROEQON KG V@H HWEFHIAH
aoiteoio gouios (sha Bkseisle, t`es vknuch). Grkc t`ot techphrekf kiworfs t`hrh orh ckrh precory akithxt seths eiahitron Hurkph. bkt` grkc thcphroth oif grkc aknfhr, fryhrshtteims (shh Bkseisle. t`es vknuch< Rkhbrkhls ht on. ?552).
Ei t`h ikrt`whst rhmeki t`h hornehst sknef troahs kg kaau-poteki orh ckrh kr nhss akithcpkroihkus wet` t`h Cehshi-`hec E seth, gkr hxocpnh t`h whnn prhshrvhf geif saotthrs ot
Bkxmrkvh ei skut`hri Himnoif (Rkbhrts ?507< ?554<Rkbhrts ht on., t`es vknuch) oif t`h hornehst seths ei t`hQkcch vonnhy kg ikrt`hri Groiah (Vuggrhou ?50=: Vuggrhouoif Oitkeih, t`es vknuch). V`h Bkxmrkvh seth es thitotevhnyakrrhnothf tk KEQ ?1 (Rkbhrts ht on., t`es vknuch).
Eifhphifhit kg t`her akrrhnotekis tk t`h fhhp-sho rhakrft`h hornehst seths grkc bkt` ahitron oif ikrt`whst Hurkphgonn ei t`h Orveakno thrrhstres aoiteoio roimh. V`es onskoppneas tk t`h gouio grkc t`h No Bhnnh Rka`h seth otQpreckin (Bhnmeuc) (Vuggrhou oif Oitkeih, t`es vknuch).Grkc t`ot phrekf kiworfs, t`hrh es o normh iucbhr kg whnnfkauchithf precory-akithxt seths ei t`h ikrt`whst-ahitronrhmeki, wet` akijkeieim lioppeim fabres prhshrvhf ei geih-
mroeihf nnuveon oif ohkneoi fhpksets (ag. t`h akitrebutekis tkt`es vknuch by Bkseisle, Coieo, Rkbhrts ht oe, Vuggrhouoif Oitkeih, oif Rkhbrkhls ht on. ?552).
8. Kt`hr rhmekis, akcporobnh rhsunts;
Nelh t`ksh ei t`h ikrt`hri rhmekis, Ebhreoi revhr thrroahs`ovh yehnfhf esknothf pehahs, w`ksh `ucoi coiugoaturh krprhaesh omh `ovh bhhi fkubthf by vorekus rhshora`hrs (shhobkvh, oif Ropksk ?508< Qoitkijo oif Wenno ?554< Ropkskoif Qoitkijo, t`es vknuch). Anoecs gkr t`h hxesthiah kgHorny Tnhestkahih orthgoats oif `ucoi gkssens akch grkcnkaonetehs ei t`h Muofex-Bozo bosei ihor Krah-Whith Ceahio
(ag. Mebhrt ?552< Ropksk oif Qoitkijo, t`es vknuch), butgurt`hr gehnfwkrl es ihahssory tk turi t`hsh anoecs eitkakcphnneim hvefhiah.1
Ropksk oif Qoitkijo (t`es vknuch) pnoah t`h hornehstuiocbemukus troahs kg `ucoi kaaupoteki kg Ebhreo ei t`hbhmeiieim kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, t`kum` sua` troahs orhvhry rorh. Qkch kg t`h bhst seths orh ei t`h Muofex-Bozofhprhsseki (Mroiofo). gockus gkr ets rea` Horny Tnhestkahihcocconeoi gouios. V`h knfhst seth, Aunnor fh Bozo, `osyehnfhf kiny o ghw pehahs (sex gnolhs oif twk a`kpphrs), ei
osskaeoteki wet` o Ceffnh Tnhestkahih gouio. V`h gouion nestvorehs grkc out`kr tk out`kr (ag. Qoitkijo ?552:8=), but kibekstrotemrop`eaon mrkuifs t`h seth es vhry prkbobny
akithcpkroihkus wet` t`h hornehst seths grkc t`h ikrt`whst-ahitron rhmeki.
V`h `oifoxhs rhpkrthf grkc Otopuhrao VF7 foth grkct`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, ki strotemrop`eaon mrkuifs pkssebnygrkc KEQ ?1 (Omuerrh ?55?< Aorbkihnn oif Orsuomo ?552).V`h gouio grkc t`h VF7 nhvhn rhshcbnhs t`h noth Arkchreoigouios chitekihf obkvh, wet` kih iktobnh hxahpteki
t`kum`: t`h prhshiah kg Ceckcys (Aorbkihnn oif Orsuomo?552< Men oif Qhsh ?55?). V`es summhsts t`ot wh orh fhoneimwet` oi ora`ohknkmeaon seth skchw`ot knfhr t`oi t`h kihsrhvehwhf upki tenn ikw. O rhahit stufy kg t`h cothreon byO.J. voi fhr Chunhi (phrs. akcc. ?556) `kwhvhr s`kwst`ot skch kg t`h Orveaknefs fespnoy eifeaotekis kg hifhcesc,oif gurt`hrckrh t`ot t`h strotemrop`eaon roimh kg Cearktus
(Onnkp`oekcys) es nkimhr ei Ebhreo t`oi ei kt`hr ports kgHurkph. V`es cem`t onsk bh t`h aosh wet` t`h Ebhreoi Ceckcys soveie.
Hifhcea ghoturhs, onsk whnn-likwi grkc t`h Akna`es orhoei t`h Aouaosus (Njubei oif Bkseisle, t`es vknuch), `ocphro stroem`tgkrworf akrrhnoteki bhtwhhi seths ei Ebhreo (oif gkrt`ot cotthr: t`h Aouaosus) oif kt`hr ports kg Hurkph. Etcust bh strhsshf t`ot t`h tech-roimh kg Ceckcys soveie ei
Ebhreo es ikt anhor, just os t`h rhnotekis`ep bhtwhhi t`hEbhreoi gkrc kg Orveakno, O. sopefus, oif O. thrrhstres,
w`ea` kiny kaaurs ei t`h hxtrhch ikrt` kg Qpoei, ei t`hTyrhihhs (ag. Woi Lkngsa`kthi ?551). Qua` eigkrcoteki es,`kwhvhr, ihahssory tk hstobnes` o akrrhnoteki bhtwhhi t`h
Otopuhrao gouios oif gouios grkc iki-Ebhreoi ports kgHurkph. Ot t`h aurrhit stoth kg oggoers t`h hxaovotkrseithrprhtoteki kg t`h Otopuhrao VF7 nhvhn os foteim grkcorkuif 844 Lyr BT shhcs t`h bhst kpteki. V`h gevhorthgoats rhahitny rhpkrthf grkc Otopuhrao VF6 (Aorbkihnnoif Rkfremuhz ?556) akch grkc o nkwhr nhvhn, but t`herorthgoatuon a`oroathr es ikt uiakithsthf (ag. Ropksk oifQoitkijo, t`es vknuch).
Etony's shttnhchit `estkry s`kws ik uiocbemukuseifeaotekis gkr oi Horny Tnhestkahih kaaupoteki (Cusse ?552<t`es vknuch). O iucbhr kg t`h 'knf' Etoneoi seths orh surgoahseths, w`hrh o 'precetevh' ckrp`knkmy kg orthgoats `os nhf
skch ora`ohknkmests tk eighr o `em` omh. Ei vehw kg etsakrrhnoteki prkbnhcs, t`h seth kg Ckith Tkmmeknk fkhs iktprkvefh vhry gerc hvefhiah gkr Horny Tnhestkahih kaaupoteki, t`kum` prhneceiory ponohkcomihtea stufehs eifeaotht`ot et fhshrvhs kur otthiteki os o pkssebnh aoifefoth(Momihpoei ht on. ?552). Oikt`hr prkbnhcotea seth es CkithThmneo, w`hrh net`ea ecpnhchits whrh rhakvhrhf kutsefh kg ostrotemrop`eaon akithxt, w`enh t`h orthgoatuon a`oroathr kg t`hkiny pehah gkuif ei setu es quhstekiobnh (Cusse, t`es vknuch).Onn uiquhstekiobnh ora`ohknkmeaon seths wet` sknef foteimhvefhiah foth grkc whnn eitk t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, oift`ksh wet` obuifoit gouion rhcoeis orh ckrh kr nhssakcporobnh ei omh tk t`h Bkxmrkvh oif Cehshi`hec E seths
ei t`h ikrt`: Gkitoik Roiuaaek (wet` `kceief rhcoeis),Weskmneoik (`ucoi gkssens tkk) oif prkbobny onsk Whikso-Nkrhtk. Os onrhofy hxpnoeihf, ei kur kpeieki, Eshrieo gonnseitk t`es tech roimh tkk (shh obkvh).
V`h Wennogroia`eoi6 bkih brhaaeo kg t`h Qoifonjo E aovh(Arkoteo) yehnfhf oi eiaeskr, kiah akisefhrhf tk bh o`kceief gkssen (Conhz ?5=7 vs. Akkl ht on. ?502) oif kih
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 316/342
147 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
sconn oif precetevh 'a`kpphr', o seimnh g'eif tkkuifeomikstea tk prkvefh o gerc mrkuif tkr Horny Tnhestkahihkaaupoteki kg gkrchr Uumksnoveo.
V`h hvefhiah grkc Mrhhah, rhpkrthf by Fornos (t`esvknuch), thitotevhny pkeits tk t`h shakif `ong kg t`h CeffnhTnhestkahih gkr t`h hornehst troahs kg `ucoi kaaupotekit`hrh.
]`ena t`h rhmekis fesausshf os yht `ovh ikt yehnfhf sknefprkkg kg `ucoi kaaupoteki prekr tk t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih,t`hrh orh skch seths ei skut`hri Groiah t`ot shhc tk bhknfhr: o mrkup kg seths ei t`h Cosseg Ahitron, oif t`hgockus aovh-seth kg Nh Wonnkiht.
V`h Cosseg Ahitron `os o normh iucbhr kg seths wet` rea`Horny Tnhestkahih gouios, rhakvhrhf ei o mkkf strotemrop`eaonakithxt. V`h stkih osshcbnomhs aknnhathf grkc skch kgt`hsh seths (ag. Bkiegoy ?55?) akisest ei mhihron kg sconnshrehs, shnhathf kut kg ioturon pehahs kaaurreim ei kgthiakorsh-mroeihf fhpksets. V`h s`krt Akccuieaotekis ki t`hshosshcbnomhs fk ikt fhon wet` t`h prkbnhcs kg fegghrhiteoteimbhtwhhi ioturon oif `ucoiny ckfegehf pehahs (ag. Royion ht
on., t`es vknuch). Ei coiy woys oi hxahpteki es t`h A`en`oaEEE seth, hxaovothf by A`ovoennki (?55?< shh onsk Mut` oifA`ovoennki ?508) ei krfhr tk thst Mut` 's hornehr osshsschitskg t`h seth. Ockim t`h spnet phbbnhs oif rkals prhshit ei t`hA`en`oa EEE fhpksets A`ovoennki akunf efhitegy 67eifesputobnh orthgoats. V`h omh kg t`hsh orthgoats es uiahrtoeigkr t`h tech bheim, gkr rhoskis hnobkrothf by A`ovoennki(?55?). Ei `es wkrfs "Vkut hst pkssebnh pkur A`en`oa EEE"(?55?:0=< but shh: Royion ht on., t`es vknuch).
Oikt`hr whnn-likwi Cosseg Ahitron seth es Qknhen`oa.Xigkrtuiothny ets net`ea osshcbnomh `os ikt bhhi pubnes`hfei fhtoen yht. Oaakrfeim tk Bkiegoy, wh orh fhoneim wet` o
sconn osshcbnomh kg precetevh tha`iknkmy. V`h quortzphbbnhs `ovh bhhi ckrh 's`otthrhf' ('bresås') t`oi gnolhf,w`hrhos t`h cojkrety kg t`h 'kbjhts fh mroifh toennh hibosonth ' `ovh bhhi cofh kut kg ioturon gromchits (Bkiegoy?50=:?1). Ckrh ecpkrtoit es t`ot t`h Qknhen`oa gouio (wet`
Orveakno. Hnhp`os (T.) oitequus oif @eppkpktocus (Bkiegoy?55?) akunf get vhry whnn eitk t`h noth Arkchreoi gouioschitekihf obkvh, oif et `os eifhhf bhhi akrrhnothf tk t`hgouio grkc Eshrieo (shh h.m. V`kuvhiy oif Bkiegoy ?506).Owoeteim t`h rhsunts kg gurt`hr stufy kg t`h a`rkiknkmy kgt`h seth, wh shh ik mkkf rhoski tk eighr t`ot Qknhen`oaprkvefhs mkkf eifeaotekis gkr oi Horny Tnhestkahih `kceiefkaaupoteki (shh onsk: Royion ht oe, t`es vknuch, gkr o
akcporobnh eithrprhtoteki).Nh Wonnkiht `os bhhi whnn pubnes`hf, ei o woy t`ot
onnkws o fhtoenhf hvonuoteki kg t`h orthgoatuon a`oroathr kgt`h osshcbnomh. V`h aovh `os yehnfhf o rea` gouio (wet`
Cearktus \Onnkp`oekcysS pnekaohieaus) oif o sconn net`eaosshcbnomh, rhakvhrhf grkc shfechits kg 'Jorocennk'-omh(omh osshsschits by chois kg bekstrotemrop`y, obsknuth
foteim (HQR) oif ponohkcomihtea stufehs (shh vorekusakitrebutekis ei N'Oit`rkpknkmeh 52, ?500< onsk Bkiegoy?55?:=6-=8).
V`h net`ea osshcbnomh akchs grkc strotemrop`ea Xiet EEE(akua`hs BE, B2, A), nkocy soifs wet` coiy oimunor rkalsoif phbbnhs. V`hsh shfechits orh tk o normh hxthit rhwkrlhfgrkc t`h Rkquhbruih Cekahih akimnkchroth fhpksets
prhshit obkvh t`h aovh8
. V`h soif oif rkal/phbbnh groatekignkwhf eitk t`h Wonnkiht aovh t`rkum` a`ecihys oifgessurhs. Ogthr Xiet EEE wos gkrchf, t`h shfechits whrhsubjhathf tk eithisevh mhka`hceaon whot`hreim, nhofeim tkonn leifs kg "fågkrcoteki" kg t`h rkals oif phbbnhs ei t`hcotrex: "Nhs aoennkux ht nhs monhts fh ahs ievhoux skitskuvhit aroquhnås ovha fåpnoahchits fh gromchits" (FhNucnhy ?500:6?7). Hxaovotekis ei t`h stkiy fhpksetsyehnfhf ei tkton shvhity pehahs grkc o 'goerny uifhrfhvhnkphfstkih tkke eifustry'. Gegty ieih kg t`hsh orh eithrprhthf oseithitekionny ckfegehf. Wertuonny onn orthgoats whrh cofhgrkc nechstkih phbbnhs grkc t`h Rkquhbruih Cekahihakimnkchroth. V`h orthgoats akisest precoreny kg gnolhf
phbbnhs, ockim w`ea` 'phrausseki tkkns', 'phbbnhs wet` oseimnh akivhx a`ep' orh t`h ckst akccki (i3?1). ]hnnrhprhshithf orh phbbnhs 'wet` o seimnh akiaovh a`ep'(precory a`kpphrs, i30), but t`hsh orh bofny gromchithf.Thbbnh tkkns (a`kpphrs, a`kppeim-tkkns oif otypeaona`kppeim-tkkns) orh prhshit (i3?4), t`kum` ikt stoiforfeshfoif ckstny kg cåfekarh quonety. V`h fkrson surgoah kg `ongkg t`h 27 gnolhs akisests kg ?44% akrthx, kiny gevh gnolhs`ovh ik akrthx ot onn. V`h cojkrety kg t`h gnolhs `ovh ikbutt kr o 'rhfuahf' kih. Ot gerst mnoiah, t`h Nh Wonnkihtgnolhs s`orh t`her coei ghoturhs - obshiah kg pnotgkrc oifbunbs, oauth oimnh wet` phbbnh surgoah - wet` t`h cojkretykg ioturonny prkfuahf gnolhs7.
V`h Nh Wonnkiht nechstkih pehahs, porteonny fhaorbkiothf,orh kaaosekionny hxtrhchny gromenh. Qkch kg t`h rkals oifphbbnhs whrh groaturhf, 'aroquhnås' os o rhsunt kg t`ha`hceaon whot`hreim chitekihf obkvh. V`h iki-ckfegehf oswhnn os t`h gnolhf phbbnhs oif rkals ei t`h Xiet EEE cotrexfespnoy shvhron leifs kg surgoah ckfegeaotekis, wet` refmhsoif prktrufeim ports sckkt`hf, kr fespnoyeim o mnkssysurgoah pknes`. V`es oppnehs tk obkut 74% kg t`h ioturonstkihs prhshit ei t`h cotrex. Et es tk bh strhsshf t`otakcporobnh p`hikchio orh prhshit ki t`h 'gnolhf' pehahs:"Nhs pehahs fh ?'eifustreh net`equh fåakuvhrths fois nhrhcpnessomh fu Tnhestkahih eigårehur fh ?'hishcbnh EEE
i'åa`opphit pos o ahtth ràmnh måiåronh: ui ecpkrtoitåckusså ofkuaet porgkes nhs orêths ht kbnetàrh nh ckfhnå fhshinàvhchits. No surgoah fh ahs pehahs pråshith skuvhit uinustromh aoroatårestequh" (Fh Nucnhy ht on. ?500:848).
Et es anhor t`ot t`h net`ea osshcbnomh grkc Nh Wonnkiht es oshnhateki kg 'precetevh' pehahs pealhf kut grkc o cotrex rea`ei rkals oif phbbnhs fhrevhf grkc Cekahih fhpksets (shh
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 317/342
14= ]EN RKHBRKHLQ OIF V@EJQ WOI LKNGQA@KVHI - O RHOTTROEQON KG V@H HWEFHIAH
Vobnh ?. Qa`hcotea fegghrhiahs wet`ei t`h Hurkphoi Tonohknet`ea rhakrf bhtwhhi t`h phrekf bhgkrh oifogthr obkut 844 Lyr.
BHGKRH 844 Lyr BT OGVHR 844 Lyr BT
sconn shrehs akisesteim kgesknothf pehahs aknnhathf
trkc o ioturon phbbnh
boalmrkuif
normh aknnhatekis grkchxaovothf lioppeim gnkkrswet` akijkeiobnh cothreon
festurbhf akithxt(akorsh cotrex)
precory akithxt seths(geihmroeihf cotrex)
akithsthf 'precetevh'osshcbnomhs
uiakithsthf 'Oa`hunhoi' oifiki-Oa`hunhoi eifustrehs
ik `ucoei rhcoeis ot onn `ucoi rhcoeis akccki
t`h p`ktks kg t`h Xiet EEE shfechits ei Fh Nucnhy ht on.
?500, Gems ? tk =). V`her a`oroathresteas summhst t`ot wh orh
fhoneim wet` oi osshcbnomh t`ot wos ikt ckfegehf by`ucoi omhits. oif eisthof fespnoys onn t`h a`oroathresteas kgo shnhateki kut kg o ioturon fhpkset.=
7. Ecpneaotekis
By kur rhofeim kg t`h hvefhiah, t`hrh es o fegghrhiahbhtwhhi t`h Hurkphoi 'ora`ohknkmeaon' rhakrf grkc bhgkrht`h Orveakno thrrhstres aoiteoio tech roimh (gkr akivhiehiahsolh `hrh: grkc obkut 844 Lyr BT) oif t`h nothr kih (ag.Vobnh ?: onsk FhiihnS ?501 gkr o akcporobnh eithrprhtoteki).
Bhgkrh 844 Lyr vertuonny onn geifs akch grkc o festurbhf.akorsh cotrex, ogthrworfs wh `ovh precory akithxt seths ei
geih-mroeihf fhpksets. V`h osshcbnomhs foteim grkc bhgkrh844 Lyr BT orh vertuonny onn t`h rhsunt kg shnhateki kgesknothf pehahs grkc ioturon fhpksets< ykuimhr kihs orhkgthi hxaovothf grkc lioppeim gnkkrs.
V`hrh orh twk bosea woys tk eithrprht t`hsh fegghrhiahs.V`h prh-8(P) Lyr geifs akunf rhgnhat t`h sporsh troahs kg eithr-cetthit kaaupoteki kg Hurkph by phkpnh wet` 'precetevh'Knfkwoi-typh tkknlets, substoiteon aknkiezoteki kg Hurkphtoleim pnoah grkc obkut 844 Lyr BT kiworfs (ag. Vurihr?552). Ihvhrt`hnhss. t`h fegghrhiahs ei mhknkmeaon akithxtoif rhakvhry prkahfurhs bhtwhhi prh- oif pkst-844 Lyr BTseths orh prkbnhcs tk bh hxpnoeihf by t`ksh of`hreim tk t`esnkim a`rkiknkmy.
Ei vehw kg t`h ottrebuths kg t`h 'orthgoats' oif akithxts kgt`h prh-844 Lyr BT seths wh eisthof eithrprht t`hshfegghrhiahs os eifeaoteim t`ot t`hrh es ik uifesputobnh prkkg
gkr `ucoi kaaupoteki kg Hurkph prekr tk obkut 844 Lyr BT.
V`h gerst precory akithxt seths wet` mkkf ora`ohknkmeaonhvefhiah foth grkc o nothr phrekf wet`ei t`h Ceffnh Tnhes-tkahih, pkssebny grkc obkut KEQ ?1 kiworfs.
Kur sahiorek `os shvhron ofvoitomhs. O gerst kih es t`ot etes vhry hosy tk gonsegy. V`h geif kg kiny kih Horny Tnhes-
tkahih precory akithxt seth ei t`h orho rhvehwhf `hrh wkunffesprkvh et, oif kih wkunf `ovh tk akianufh t`ot bhgkrhobkut 844 Lyr BT kaaupoteki hxesthf (but wos normhnyeithrcetthit). Ihw stufehs kg skch seths chitekihf ei kurs`krt survhy akunf nhof tk t`es rhsunt.
O gurt`hr ofvoitomh es t`ot kur s`krt a`rkiknkmy essuppkrthf by o bkfy kg foto eifhphifhit kg ormuchitsakiahrieim stkih tkkns: t`h a`rkiknkmeaon festrebuteki kg`ucoi rhcoeis. V`h fesarhpoiay bhtwhhi t`h eighrrhf `em`omh kg t`h hornehst Hurkphoi orthgoats oif t`h rhnotevhnyrhahit foth gkr t`h hornehst Hurkphoi `kceief gkssens, t`hCouhr nkwhr jow oif t`h `ucoi rhcoeis grkc Gkitoio
Roiuaaek oif (pkssebny) Weskmneoik, `os bhhi o akispeaukusprkbnhc ei t`h shora` gkr t`h hornehst Hurkphois. Grkc t`h'Couhr' tech phrekf kiworfs wh `ovh Ceffnh Tnhestkahih`ucoi rhcoeis onn kvhr Hurkph: Ontocuro, Oromk,Otopuhrao, Beoa`h-Qoeit-Woost, Benzeimsnhbhi, Aovo Tkcpe,Aosthn fe Muefk, No A`oesh, H`reimsfkrg, Gkitoio Roiuaaek,Gkitåa`hvofh, Mrktth fu Treiah, No Roghtth, Nozorht, Couhr,Ckitcourei, Krmioa EEE, Thtronkio, Tkitihwyff, Qthei`hec,Qwoisakcbh, Whikso, Whrmroiih, Wårthssz÷nn÷s oifWeskmneoik, tk chiteki t`hc ei oi onp`obhteaon krfhr (ag.Akkl ht on. ?502). V`h rhahitny fesakvhrhf tebeo grkc Bkx-mrkvh, o seth wet` kih kg t`h hornehst Orveakno thrrhstres
aoiteoio gouios, kg akursh gets vhry whnn eitk kur sahiorek
tkk (Rkbhrts ht on. ?556< Rkbhrts ht on., t`es vknuch< shhonsk Mocbnh ?556).
Grkc t`h nkim phrekf bhgkrh t`h Orveakno thrrhstres
aoiteoio roimh wh fk ikt `ovh o seimnh (uiakithsthf!) tkkt`yht, fhspeth t`h `umh ockuits kg kt`hr cocconeoi gkssens.Obshiah kg hvefhiah kg akursh es ik hvefhiah kg obshiah,oif ihmotevh hvefhiah `os rorhny prkvhf furobnh ei
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 318/342
140 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
ora`ohknkmy. But obshiah kg hxpksurhs kg knfhr fhpksets esikt o mkkf akuithr-ormuchit `hrh. Ot o normh iucbhr kgponohkitknkmeaon seths, horny Ceffnh oif/kr Horny Tnhestk-ahih gouios orh rhakvhrhf grkc geih-mroeihf fhpksets. Qkchkg t`hsh `ovh bhhi uifhr kbshrvoteki gkr coiy fhaofhs krhvhi ahiturehs, yehnfeim `umh ockuits kg gouion rhcoeis:gkr eistoiah t`h Vhmhnhi pets ei t`h Iht`hrnoifs, Xithrcoss-ghnf, Wkemtsthft oif Qþsshibkri ei Mhrcoiy, ]hst Ruitki(Himnoif), Qåiàzh (Groiah), Fhutsa` Onthiburm ei Oustreooif t`h Won f'Orik hxpksurhs ei Etony. Hurkph es wet`kutoiy fkubt t`h ckst `hoveny rhshora`hf port kg t`h Knf]krnf, wet` o `em`-quonety rhakrf tk w`ea` coiy `uifrhfskg wkrlhrs `ovh akitrebuthf kvhr o phrekf kg kih-oif-o-`ongahiturehs.
Ei kur sahiorek Hurkph es hxtrhchny 'cormeion', noth eitech os hkcporhf tk gkr eistoiah t`h Oseoi hvefhiah os t`otstoifs ikw. V`h `ucoi sprhof kut kg Ogreao whit host-worfs gerst, veo Xbhefeyo (Esroìn) oif Fcoiese (Mhkrmeo< shhFzoporefzh ht on. ?505), oif `kceiefs whrh prhshit ei t`hhosthri ports kg Oseo ot t`h hif kg t`h Horny Tnhestkahih, ot
orkuif 044 tk ?,444 Lyr BT (Qa`eal oif Z`uoi ?551, krhvhi hornehr, eg kih oaahpts t`h Qwes`hr ht on. \?556S foths).Hurkph wos kaaupehf nothr. Qkki ogthr wh shh t`h gerstuifesputobnh troahs, `ucois orh vertuonny 'hvhryw`hrh' eiHurkph (wet` os iktobnh oif eithrhsteim hxahptekis t`hRusseoi pnoeis oif Qaoifeioveo).
Ot essuh es ikt kiny w`ht`hr t`h gerst Hurkphois orrevhfcua` hornehr t`oi 844 Lyr BT. ]`ot, eg oiy, haknkmeaon,anecoteaon kr skaeon goatkrs whrh tremmhreim t`h kaaupoteki otobkut 844 Lyr BT, kr, tkrcunothf ei oikt`hr woy, w`ot lhpt`kceiefs kut kg Hurkph bhgkrh 844 Lyr; Qkch ovhiuhswkrt` hxpnkreim coy bh fhvhnkpchits ei t`h skaeon fkcoei(sua` os t`h hchrmhiah kg fesphrshf coteim ihtwkrls), ihuronfhvhnkpchits osskaeothf wet` broei hxpoiseki oif fegghrhiahsei t`h a`oroathr kg t`h Nkwhr os kppkshf tk t`h CeffnhTnhestkahih mnoaeon-eithrmnoaeon ayanhs0 (ag. Zomweji ?552<shh onsk Mocbnh ?551< Mocbnh, t`es vknuch).
Ei kur sahiorek t`h 844,444 'wovh' rhprhshits t`h gerstkaaupoteki, vertuonny syia`rkikus t`rkum`kut Hurkph skut`kg t`h eaa s`hhts. Ei t`es vehw Hurkph fkhs ikt shhc tk `ovhprhshithf bem prkbnhcs tk t`h gerst kaaupoits, bh et phr`opsei t`h ikrt`hri- oif hosthrickst ports. V`es ecomh kg oswegt kaaupoteki aoi vhry whnn bh t`h rhsunt kg t`h nkw
a`rkiknkmeaon rhsknuteki kg kur foteim cht`kfs gkr t`h
Ceffnh Tnhestkahih (os hkcporhf tk ?6A, w`ksh rhsknutekionnkws kur Ochreaoi aknnhomuhs tk eighr t`ot Tonohkeifeoisaknkiezhf t`h hiterh Ihw ]krnf ei just o ghw ahiturehs:Chntzhr ?551). V`hsh oionkmuhs yehnf gosaeioteim t`kum`t-hxphrechits t`ot `ovh t`h offetekion ofvoitomh kg ckveimkur gehnf eitk t`h fkcoei kg kt`hr fesaepneihs stufyeim t`hcemroteki kg coccon sphaehs (ag. Mocbnh ?551).
]`enh t`ksh of`hreim tk (vorekus gkrcs kg) o nkima`rkiknkmy aoi colh t`h aosh gkr o vhry mrofuon ofoptotekiby Kut kg Ogreaois tk t`h wefh roimh kg Hurkphoi `obetots,kur s`krt a`rkiknkmy suppkrts oikt`hr vehw, o rot`hr gost(wet`ei t`h tech rhsknuteki necets) ofoptoteki, kiah t`hy orhei t`es aun fh sor kg t`h Huroseoi akiteihit t`ot wh aonnHurkph. Ei t`es rhsphat kur eithrprhtoteki gets vhry whnn eitko `em`ny puiatuothf a`rkiknkmy kg w`ot Mocbnh (?551) `osrhahitny aonnhf "stoaaotk bursts kg aknkiezoteki", oskppkshf tk hornehr vehws kg `kceiefs nhoveim t`aer Ogreaoi`kchnoif ei o snkw akiteiukus sprhof. Et es gkr sua`rhoskis t`ot wa iaaf tk fesauss t`h hcpereaon vonuhs oifecpneaotekis kg t`h vorekus nkim oif s`krt a`rkiknkmehs. ]h
`kph t`ot kur pophr aoi akitrebuth tk sua` oi 'upfoteim' kgt`h gerst 'Hurkphois'.
OalikwnhfmhchitsO gerst vhrseki kg t`es pophr wos wretthi gkr o Hurkphoi
Qaehiah Gkuifoteki (HQG) ]krls`kp ki V`h HornehstKaaupoteki kg Hurkph, `hnf ot Voutovhn (Groiah), Ikvhcbhr?551 oif subshquhitny pubnes`hf ei t`h Qhpthcbhr ?556essuh kg Oitequety. V`es pophr es o snem`tny ckfegehfvhrseki kg t`h Oitequety kih. V`h HQG chhteim woskrmoieshf by t`h HQG Ihtwkrl ki V`h Tonohknet`ea Kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: M. Bkseisle (a`oercoi - Ihuwehf,Mhrcoiy), ]. Rkhbrkhls (saehitegea sharhtory - Nhefhi,V`h Iht`hrnoifs), A. Gorezy (Tores, Groiah), A. Mocbnh(Qkut`ocptki, Xiethf Leimfkc), N. Norsski (Nuif, Qwhfhi),C. Cusse (Rkch, Etony), I. Trosnkv (Qt. Ththrburm, Russeo),N. Ropksk (Nesbki, Tkrtumon), C. Qoitkijo (Qonocoiao,Qpoei) oif O. Vuggrhou (Nennh, Groiah). V`h chcbhrs kg t`hIhtwkrl akccetthh cofh vonuobnh rhcorls ki t`h akithitkg kur pophr. ]h orh gurt`hr vhry mrothgun tk G.A. @kwhnn(Bhrlhnhy) oif O. Vurihr (Nevhrpkkn) oif R. Fhiihnn(Q`hggehnf) gkr t`her fhtoenhf akcchits ki oi hornehr frogtkg t`h pophr.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 319/342
145 ]EN RKHBRKHLQ OIF V@EJQ WOI LKNGQA@KVHI - O RHOTTROEQON KG V@H HWEFHIAH
ikths
? Ei `hr rhahit top`kikceh stufy kg t`h Trhznhteah gouio, Qtkpp??556) onsk fef ikn geif oiy eifeaoteki kg `ucoi oatevety ot t`hseth.
2 V`h gerst out`kr woits tk hcp`osezh `es mrotetufh tkworfsFr Lorhn Wonkfe, w`k s`kwhf `ec t`h Ckroveoi osshcbnomhsw`eth ei Brik. oif tkkl `ec tk t`h Qtroislo slono seth. Fhspeth kursaehitegëa fesomrhhchin obkut t`h eithrprhtoteki kg skch osshcbnomhs E lhhp o vhry mkkf chckry kg t`ot veset.
1 Oport grkc fesaussekis kvhr t`h prhshiah kg `ucois ei t`h HornyTnhestkahih ei t`ot rhmeki t`hrh es o fesarhpoiay bhtwhhi t`h omhmevhi tk t`h gouion osshcbnomh grkc Whito Ceahio oif kt`hr seths[ (e en vi oif nus ak wkrlars ( ?,0 C^ e @n') oif t`h astecotas kg
Omuste ht on. (?50=), w`k t`eil t`h Whito Ceahio osshcbnomh esobkut ?,2 Cyr knf.
6 V`h normhr coccon gouio rhghrrhf tk os 'Noth Wennogroia`eoi'coeiny akisests kg sk-aonnhf Monhreoi sphaehs, wet` o roimh eitk t`hnothr port kg t`h Arkchreoi-akcpnhx).
8 "Nhs pkufeimuhs \puffeimstkihS oggnhurhit portkut oennhurs< en
s'omen fh monhts rkunås, måiåronhchit mrkssehrs, skuvhit aonaoerhscoes porgkes mråshux, phnenequhs ku arestonneis, furhchit aechitåspor uih cotreah mråshush. Måiåronhchit akcpoats ht behi strote-nëas. ens sh pråshithit hi boias råmunehrs ovha porgkes fhs nhitennhsfh mrhs. fh toennh ht fh mroiunkcåtreh voreåhs" (A`ocomih?500:641).
7 Ockim kt`hrs. ]orrhi pubnes`hf fhsareptekis oif p`ktkmrop`skg tnolhf @eits gkuif bhnkw Hkahih bhfs (ot Mroys, Hsshx), wet`bkt` bunbs oif streleim pnotgkrcs. Qkch kg t`hsh hvhi whrhakijkeiobnh (h.m. ]orrhi ?524, Tnoth PW, 22:"T`ktkmrop` kg twkakijkeihf tnolhs s`kweim ikrcon prhssurh-a`oroathrs", kr 21:"T`ktkmrop` kg gkur akijkeihf tnolhs, onsk s`kweim ikrconprhssurh-a`oroathrs, bue 'strual' grkc oi opporhitny whnn-prhporhfpnotgkrc".
= Ogthr t`h pubneaoteki kg t`h Oitequety vhrseki kg t`es pophr(shpthcbhr ?556) wh whrh eigkrchf kg t`h rhsunts kg ]`eth's(?558) stufy kg t`h Nh Wonnkiht osshcbnomh, onsk strhsseim t`hobshiah kg troahs kg `ucoi oatevetehs ot t`es seth.
Q Qua` fegghrhiahs akunf `ovh rhsunthf ei oi hiverkichiton shtteimckrh govkurobnh nkr o cemroteki kg `kceiefs eitk Hurkph. V`hrhorh. `kwhvhr, ik anhor hiverkichiton a`oimhs kbshrvobnh ei t`hshakif `ong kg t`h Arkchreoi akcpnhx, ihet`hr ei t`h ponohkbktoieaon.t`h conoaknkmeaon kr t`h vhrthbroth rhakrf. Noth Ceckcys gouios(]hst Ruitki oif Wkemtsthft) oif horny Orveakno kihs (Bkxmrkvh,
Cehshi`hec E, Couhr) s`kw coiy secenoretehs oif ik feseeianfegghrhiahs ei t`her akcpkseteki. Onn t`hsh gouios eifeaoth ckrh krnhss akcporobnh hiverkichiton akifetekis.V`h goat t`ot t`h opphoroiah kg Orveakno thrrhstres aoiteoio
akeiaefhs ckrh kr nhss wet` t`h eccemroteki kg Hnhp`os
(Tonohknkxkfki) oitequus oif @eppkpktocus fureim t`h nothArkchreoi (Wki Lkhiemswonf oif Woi Lkngsa`kthi, ei prhss)cem`t summhst t`ot wh orh fhoneim wet` o leif kg gouion turikvhr .@kwhvhr, wh `ovh tk rhonezh t`ot kur a`rkiknkmeaon rhsknuteki gkr
t`es tech roimh es goerny necethf. Kih kg t`h hornehst Orveakno gouioses t`h kih grkc Lornea` M (Ihuwehf Bosei, Mhrcoiy). V`h gouioes osskaeothf wet` orthgoats (Bkseisle, t`es vknuch) oif ckstprkbobny foths grkc t`h troisetekion phrekf kg Mnoaeon A tk Eithr-mnoaeon EW kr grkc t`h hornehr port kg Eithrmnoaeon EW kg t`hArkchreoi akcpnhx (Woi Lkngsa`kthi oif Vurihr, ei prhss). V`hrhes mkkf hvefhiah t`ot t`h gouio prhfoths t`h Eithrmnoaeon EWkptecuc wet` akifetekis govkurobnh gkr t`h eccemroteki kg Hnhp`os (T.) oitequus oif @eppkpktocus, w`ea` ecpnehs t`ot t`ht`rhh sphaehs ckst prkbobny fef ikt opphor secunnoihkusny.
Hvhi t`h Hnsthreoi mnoaeoteki (KEQ ?2;), t`h gerst mnoaeoteki eiw`ea` t`h ikrt`hri ports kg ahitron oif ikrt`whsthri Hurkph whrhakvhrhf wet` einoif eah. fef ikt aoush o frocotea gnkron oif gouionturikvhr. Coiy sphaehs - eianufeim o iucbhr kg sconnhr coccons(Vonpo ceikr, Vrkmkit`hreuc auvehre, Qkrhx (Frhpoikskrhx) sp.)
rhmorfhf os rhneats grkc t`h Horny Tnhestkahih - survevhf t`hHnsthreoi Mnoaeon. Kiny t`h normh aorievkrhs @kckt`hreuie.
Chmoithrhki, Toa`yarkauto phtrehre oif T. brhverkstres orh iktlikwi grkc pkst-Hnsthreoi fhpksets ei Ikrt`whsthri oif AhitronHurkph (Vurihr ?552). Rhahit stufehs kg t`h gouion rhcoeis grkct`h Rheisfkrg Eithrmnoaeon (KEQ 5;) fhpksets ot Qa`ñieimhi (Coieo,t`es vknuch) eifeaoth t`ot Vrkmkit`hreuc auvehre onsk survevhf t`h"mnoaeon" akifetekis bhtwhhi t`h @knstheieoi (KEQ ??;) oif t`hRheisfkrg Eithrmnoaeon. V`hsh sphaehs bhaoch hxteiat fureim t`hihxt aknf phrekf, w`ea` shporoths t`h Rheisfkrg Eithrmnoaeon grkct`h Qa`÷ieimhi/Bhnvåfàrh Eithrmnoaeon (KEQ =;). V`h hxteiateki kgVrkmkit`hreuc auvehre akeiaefhs wet` oi oaahnhroteki kg t`hhvknuteki ei t`h hiochn fegghrhiteoteki ei t`h cknors kg Orveakno
thrrhstres, os eifeaothf by t`h gouion rhcoeis grkc Orehifkrg ?(Woi Lkngsa`kthi ?554). V`h Orehifkrg ? gouio (KEQ 0) eianufhs
Fearkstkiyx, Nhccus nhccus, Coccut`us, Akhnkfkito
oitequetotes oif 'Roimeghr toroifus (Woi Lkngsa`kthi ?55(?<Vurihr ?55?< Rkhbrkhls ht on. ?552), oif es kih kg t`h hornehstaknf stomh gouios wet` o akcpkseteki eifeaotevh gkr o "Cocckt`Qthpph" hiverkichit< t`h gouio es akcporobnh tk noth Qooneoi(KEQ 7) aknf stomh gouios grkc Qa`wheislkpg oif ]oiihi ei t`hIhuwehf Bosei (Mhrcoiy) oif tk noth ]hea`shneoi mnoaeon gouios.V`h Orehifkrg E gouio es eifeaotevh gkr t`h hornehst hxthiseki kg t`hCocckt` Qthpph t`ot gor tk t`h whst, rkum`ny akeiaefeim wet` t`hgerst opphoroiah kg Coccut`us precemhieus, t`h eccemrot eki kgAkhnkfkito oitequetotes ei whsthri Hurkph oif skch a`oimhs eit`h `krshs.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 320/342
1?4 V@H HORN?HQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
rhghrhiahs
Oalhrcoi, Q. ?505
Oifrhws, J.V. ?501
Omuerrh, H. ?55?
Omuste, Q. Ckyo-Qkno, ?50=J. Tkis-Ckyo
Ozzorkne, O. ?5==
Ozzorkne, O., ?500A. Fh Meune,M. Geaaorhnne,F. Vkrrh
Hurkphoi prh`estkry mhts hvhi knfhr, Qaehiah 267, 20-14.
Q`krt eah omh 214.444 yhors omk; Ioturh 141, 2?-22.
Nhs prhcehrs phupnhchits `ucoeis fh no Tåieisunh Ebårequh. Ei: H. Bkiegoy oif B. Woifhr-chhrsa` (hfs), Nhs Trhcehrs Hurkpåhis, ?61-?84, Tores: Hfetekis fu [email protected].
No suahseki fh Coceghrks hi hn Tnhestkahik eighrekr fh Hurkpo: prkpkseaeki fh uio iuhvohsaono bekhstrotemrogeao, Tonhkit. E Hvkn., Chc. Hsp. ?, 20=-258.
V`h Wennogroia`eoi stomh ei Etony oif t`h Tnek-Tnhestkahih bkuifory, M. Mhkn. 6?, 7?-=5.
Noth Tnekahih tk Cef-Tnhestkahih Coccons ei Huroseo: Gouion suaahsseki oif FesphrsonHvhits, Tonohkmhkmrop`y, Tonohkanecotk`my, Tonohkhaknkmy 77, ==-?44.
Bkiegoy, H.
Bkiegoy, H.,B. Woifhrchhrsa` (hfs)
Bkseisle, M.,
?50= Qknhen`oa ?50=. Roppkrt fh gkuennhs. Corshennh: Nobkrotkerh fh Mhknkmeh fu _uothrioerh.
?55? Nhs prhcehrs eifustr ehs fu Quf-Hst fh no Groiah ht fu Cosseg-Ahitron. Ei: H. Bkiegoy oifB. Woifhrchhrsa` (hfs), Nhs Trhcehrs Hurkpåhis, 71-04, Tores: Hfetekis fu [email protected].
?55? Nhs Trhcehrs Hurkpåhis. Tores: Hfetekis fu [email protected].
t`es V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: ]hsthri Ahitron Hurkph.vknuch
Bkunh, C.
Bkurfehr, G.,J. A`oneih,O.W. Cuiout,J.J. Tuesshmur
Burfulehweaz, J.C.,J. ]eiieale
Burfulehweaz
?52? Nhs @kcchs Gkssenhs. Hnåchits fh ponhkitknkmeh `ucoeih. Tores: Cosski.
?5=6 No trhs `outh iopph onnuveonh fh no Qkcch, Bunnhtei Oss. Groia. Ht. _uot. ??, ?1=-?61.
?'EQQ Vrzhbieao - Iojstorszh Qnofy Kbhaiksae Aznkwehlo io Zehceoa` Tknslea`. VkworzystwkCenksielñw Zehce Vrzhbiealehj.
?505 Ikwh Cothreony Tonhknetu Fknihmk Z Vrzhbieay, ]kj. ]rkanow. "Qenhseo Oitemuo" .
PPPE, 5-?=.
Aorbkihnn, H.,J.N. Orsuomo
Aorbkihnn. H.,P.T. Rkfremuhz
?552 Hxaurseki o nks yoaecehitks chskpnhestkahieaks fh no Qehrro fh Otopuhrao (Ebhos fh
Juorrks/Otopuhrao, Burmks). E Junek ?552. ]krls`kp Hvknuaeki @ucoio hi Hurkph y nks
yoaecehitks fh no Qehrro få Otopuhrao, Vorromkio.
?556 Horny Ceffnh Tnhestkahih fhpksets oif orthgoats ei t`h Mroi Fkneio seth (VF6) kg t`h'Qehrro fh Otopuhrao' (Burmks, Qpoei), Jkurion kg @ucoi Hvknuteki 27, 25?-1??.
A`oneih, J. ?507 Akiteihiton Gouion Xiets kg t`h Tnek-Tnhestkahih kg Groiah, Chc. Qka. Mhkn. Et. 1?, ?=8-?01.
A`ocomih, B. ?500 Hiverkiihchit måknkmequh fh no mrktth fu Wonnkiht (Rkquhbruih-Aop-Cortei), N'Oit`rk-
pknkmeh 52, 155-647.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 321/342
1??
A`ovoennki, J.
Anorl, J.F.
Akntkrte, C’
C. Arhcosa`e,C.A. Fhnetono ht on.
Akkl, J.,A.B. Qtreimhr,O.T. [email protected]. Qa`woraz,O.M. ]eitnh
]EN RKHBRKHLQ OIF V@EJQ WOI LKNGQA@KVHI - O RHOTTROEQON KG V@H HWEFHIAH
?55? Nhs hishcbnhs net`equhs fh A`en`oa EEE (@outh Nkerh): typknkmeh, setuoteki strotemrop`equhht oionysh aretequh ht akcporotevh. Ei: H. Bkiegoy oif B. Woifhrchhrsa` (hfs). Nhs
Trhcehrs Hurkpåhis, 0?-5?, Tores: Hfetekis fu [email protected].
?580 V`h ioturon groaturh kg phbbnhs grkc t`h Botklo Mkrmh, Ikrt`hri R`kfhseo, oif ets bhoreimki t`h Loguoi eifustrehs kg Ogreao, Trkahhfeims kg t h Trh`estkreh Qkaehty 26, 76-==.
?50? Rhvhrshf comihtea pknorety ot oi horny Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea seth ei Ahitron Etony, Ioturh
144, ?=1-?=7.
?502 O rhvehw kg t`h a`rkiknkmy kg t`h Hurkphoi Ceffeh Tnhestkahih `kceief rhakrf, Uhor`kkl
kg T`yseaon Oit`rkpknkmy 28, ?5-78.
Fonnos. O. nnusvknuch
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: t`h Bonlois.
Fhnski, H.
Fhiihnn. R.
Fhsanoux, H.
Fzoporefzh, W.,M. Bkseisle,V. Bumeoiesvene ht on.
Ghjgor, K.,].F. @heirea`
Grefrea`, J.
Momihpoei, J.,
E. @hfnhy,
J.-J. Bo`oei,J.-J. ]omihr
Mocbnh, AQ.
?505 Knfhst Huroseoi stkih tkkns, Ioturh 164, 57.
?501 Hurkphoi Hakikceh Trh`estkry. O Ihw Opprkoa`. Nkifki: Oaofhceh Trhss.
?552o Nhs phtets vhrtà rhs o no Aouih fh n'Oromk (Voutovhn, Tyråiåhs Krehitonhs). Tonhkitknkmeh,
ponåkåaknkmeh, top`kikceh. V`hsh fh Fkatkrot. Tores: [email protected].
?552b Nhs phtets vhrtàbrhs fh no Aouih fh n'Oromk o Voutovhn, Bunnhtei fu Cusåh fOit`rkpknk-
meh prå`estkrequh fh Ckioak 18, 18-76.
?505 Fhr ontponoknet`esa`h Guifpnotz Fcoiese ei Mhkrmehi (Loulosus), Jo`r`ua` fhs R÷cesa`-
Mhrcoiesa`hi Zhitroncushucs Coeiz 17, 7=-??7.
?50? Zur bekstrotemrop`esa`hi Obmrhizuim uif Mnehfhruim fhs lkiteihitonhi _uortors eiHurkpo oi @oif vki Orveaknefhi (Rkfhiteo, Cocconeo), Kaknkmoh mhkn. @hnv. =6 (1),55=-?447.
?505
?55?
?552
?551
?556
t`es
vknuch
Trhznhteah: O nkwhr ponohknet`ea seth ei Ahitron Bk`hceo (Hxaovotekis ?575-?508).
Tromoh: Cushuc Iotekionh Tromoh.
V`h knfhst Tonohknet`ea stkih eifustry grkc t`h Bhrkui `em`woy akcpnhx, Oitrkpkzkeluc
24, ???-?20.
Htufh comihtkstrotemrop`equh fu seth fh Ao'Bhnvhfhrh fe Ckith Tkmmeknk (Gkrne, Etoneì), htfh ski akithxth strotemrop`equh. Trhcehrs råsuntots. Ei: A. Thrhttk (hf.), / Trece O`eeoite
fhnto Wonnh Tofoio: Ckith Tkmmeknk, 1?5-118, Cenoik: Joao Bkkl.
Vechwonlhrs. V`h Trh`estkry kg Mnkbon Aknkiezoteki. T`khiex Cenn-Qtrkuf-Mnkuahst`erh: Onoi.
Vech gkr Bkxmrkvh coi, Ioturh 175, 2=8-2=7.
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: t`h hiverkichiton boalmrkuif.
Mebhrt. J. (hf.) ?552 Trhshiaeo `ucoio hi hn Tnhestkahik eighrekr fh Mroiofo y Curaeo. Mroiofo: Cushk fhTrh`estkreo.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 322/342
1?2 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Men, H.,A. Qhsh
?55? Ceffnh Tnhestkahih sconn coccons grkc Otopuhrao (Burmks, Qpoei). Ei: Fototekis ht
A`oroatårezotekis fhs Cenehux Tnåestkaàihs. Oaths fu Qycpkseuc ?? ht ?= fh no nnàch
R.Q.V. Anhrckif Ghrroif ?507. Ao`ehrs fu _uothcoerh ?7, 11=-16=.
MRET (Mrkhinoif Eah-akrh Trkjhat)Chcbhrs
?551 Anecoth eistobenety fureim t`h nost eithrmnoaeon phrekf rhakrfhf ei t`h MRET eah akrh, Ioturh 176, 241-24=.
Mut`, A.,
J. A`ovoennki
?508 Fåakuvhrth, hi ?506, fh ikuvhoux kutens ponåknet`equhs o A`en`oa EEE, (@outh Nkerh), Bun
nhtei Qka. Trå`est. groia. 02, 87-76.
@hfbhrm, @.F. ?5=7 Eithriotekion strotemrop`ea muefh. O muefh tk strotemrop`ea anossegeaoteki. thrceiknkmy oif
prkahfurh. Ihw Ukrl: Jk`i ]enhy oif Qkis.
Jhoiiht, C. ?5=5 Ikth sur quhnquhs hnhchits fh cearkgouih rhaus hi ?5=5, Ikuv. Ora`. Cushuc f'@estkerh
Ioturhnnh fh Nyki ?=, 85-76.
Losoitshvo, I.H. ?50= Tonhkmhkmrogeahsleh usnkvejo kbetoiejo iezihpnhjstkahikvyx goui chnlex cnhlkpetojusaex
bosshjio srhfihmk Fkio. Fesshrtoteki, Xievhrsety kg Cksakw, Cksakw.
Lkhiemswonf. ]. vki,V. voi Lkngsa`kthi
ei prhss V`h Ceckcys-Orveakno bkuifory oif t`h hiochn t`ealihss qukteìit (QF_) kg Orveakno
os strotemrop`ea corlhrs ei t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, Trkahhfeims kg t h QH_Q Arkchr
sycpkseuc ?554.
Lkngsa`kthi, V. voi ?554 V`h hvknuteki kg t`h coccon gouio ei t`h Iht`hr noifs oif t`h ceffnh R`eih Orho(]hsthri Mhrcoiy) fureim t`h noth Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, Chfhf. Rejls Mhkn. Fehist 61 (1),?-75.
?551 Ki t`h kremei kg t`h Ceffnh Tnhestkahih normhr vknhs, _uothriory Eithriotekion ?5, 6=-84.
Lkngsa`kthi, V. voi,H. Vurihr
ei prhss Horny Ceffnh Tnhestkahih cocconeoi gouios grkc Leernea` oif Cehshi`hec E oif t`herbekstrotemrop`eaon ecpneaotekis, Trkahhfeims kg t`h QH_Q Arkchr Qycpkseuc ?554.
Lkznkwsle, J.L. ?552 Nhs prhcehrs `obetoits fh ?'Hurkph ahitronh ht kreìitonh. Ei: A. Thrhttk (hf.), / Trece
O`etoite fhnno Wonnh Tofoio: Ckith Tkmmeknk Ihn _uofrk fhnnh Akiksahizh Hurkphh, 75-5? , Cenoik: Joao Bkkl.
Lrhtzke, C. ?578 Feh Iomhr uif Nomkckrp`hi vki Wkemtsthft ei V`þreimhi uif e`rh a`rkiknkmesa`h Ous-somh, Tonhkitknkmesa`h O``oeunnuimhi 2 (1), 80=-774.
Lrhtzke. C..C. Tåase
?5=5 Tnekahih oif Tnhestkahih fhvhnkpchit oif a`rkiknkmy kg t`h Toiikieoi Bosei, Oato Mhkn.
Oaof. Qa. @uim. 22, ?-6, 1-11.
Nholhy, C.
Nesthr, O.
?506 Fesankseim V`h Tost. Oi Outk`ekmrop`y. Ihw Ukrl: Fkubnhfoy & Aeh.
?552 Cocconeoi gkssens oif quothriory bekstrotemrop`y, _uothriory Qaehiah Rhvehws ??, 125-166.
Njubei, W.,M. Bkseisle
t`esvknuch
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg t`h Aouaosus rhmeki.
Nucnhy, @. fh
Nucnhy, @. fh,O. Gkuriehr,J. Lrzhplkwslo.O. Ha`osskux
?500 No strotemrop`eh fu rhcpnessomh fh no mrktth fu Wonnkiht, N'Oit`rkpknkmeh 52, 64=-620.
?500 N'eifus treh fu Tnhestkahih eigårehur fh no mrktth fu Wonnkiht, Rkquhbruih-Aop-Cortei,Onphs-Coretechs, N'Oit`rkpknkmeh 52, 84?-7?6.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 323/342
1?1 ]EN RKHBRKHLQ OIF V@EJQ WOI LKNGQA@KVHI - O RHOTTROEQON KG V@H HWEFHIAH
Nucnhy, @. fh,O. Gkuriehr.U.A. Torl.U.Uklkyoco,O. Fhckuy
Col'/. C.
Coieo, F..
?506
?5=7
t`esvknuch
Qtrotemrop`eh fu rhcpnessomh pnåestkaàih ckyhi fh no Aouih fh ?'Oromk o VoutovhnÅtufh fh `uet aorkttomhs hgghatuås fh ?50? o ?501, N'Oit`rkpknkmeh 00, 8-?0.
Hxaovoteki kg t`h Wennotroia`eoi seth Qoifonjo E ihor Tuno (Uumksnoveo). Ei: L. Wonka` (hf.), Nhs prhceàrhs eifustrehs fh n'Hurkph. EPh Akimrhs XEQTT, Aknnkmuh WEEE, ?46-?21, Ieah.
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: t`h Hnbh-Qoonh Rhmeki (Mhrcoiy).
CaT`hrrki, O.,W. Qa`cefn
Chnt/hr, F.J.
Chunhi, O.J. voi fhr
Cusen, R.,
L. Wonka`
Cusse. C.
Kbhiioehr, @.
Thrhttk, A. (hf.).
Ropksk, N.
Ropksk, N.,C. Qoitkijo
Royion, J.T.,N. Comkmo.?'. Beifkee
Rkbhrts, C.B.
?501
?551
?5=1
?570
?552
t`esvknuch
?5?2
?552
?508
nnnes
vknuch
t`esvknuch
Rkbhrts, C.B..A.B. Qtreimhr,Q.O. Torgett
?507
?55(?
?556
Tonhkcomihtea foteim ot Eshrieo no Teihto. Ei: A. Thrhttk, A. Vhrzoie oif C. Arhcosa`e(hfs), Eshrieo no Teifo, ui oaaocpochitk pei oiteak fe =44.444 oiie, 7=-75, Bknkmio:Aonfhreie.
Tehestkahih Thkpneim kg t`h Ochreaos, Hvknutekiory Oit`rkpknkmy ?, ?8=-?75.
Ceffeh Tehestkahih Qconnhr Coccons trkc t`h Ckith (Krvehtk, Etony) wet` Qphaeon Rhghrhiahtk t`h T`ynkmhiy kg Cearktus (Orveaknefoh, Rkfhiteo), _uothrioreo PWEE, ?-?66.
Qtroislo slono. nts choieim gkr Tehestkahih Qtufehs, Aurrhit Oit`rkpknkmy 5, 816-815.
// Tonhkneteak h en Chskneteak ei Etoneo. Bknkmio: Qtenus.
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: Etony.
Fhr Chisa` fhr Wkrzhet. Bhrnei: Onnmhcheih Whrnoms-Mhshnnsa`ogt.
/ Trece Obetoite fhnno Wonnh Tofoio: Ckith Tkmmeknk Ihn _uofrk fhnnh Akiksahizh
Hurkphh. Cenoik: Joao Bkkl.
Nh Tonåknet`equh eigårehur ora`oëquh ou Tkrtumon. Benoi fhs akiioessoiahs. Bunnhtei Qka.
Trå`. groia. 02(7), ?=1-?04.
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: t`h Ebhreoi Thieisuno.
Vhp`rkgoats oif t`h gerst `ucoi kaaupoteki kg t`h Grhia` Cosseg Ahitron.
Hxaovoteki kg t`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea seth ot Ochy's Hort`oc Tet, Bkxmrkvh, ]hst Qusshx:O prhneceiory rhpkrt, Trkahhfeims kg t`h Trh`estkreh Qkaehty 82, 2?8-268.
"Ochy's Hort`oc Tet. Bkxmrkvh". Ei: A. Vurihr (hf.). Gehnf H.xaurseki Muefh Bkkl, V`hArkchr Qycpkseuc Ikrw`ea` ?554, QH_Q, 72-==, Aocbrefmh.
O `kceief tebeo trkc Ceffeh Tehestkahih shfechits ot Bkxmrkvh, XL, Ioturh 175, 1??-1?1.
Rkbhrts, C.B.,AQ. Mocbnh,F.R. Brefmnoif
t`es V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: t`h Bretes` Esnhs.vknuch
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 324/342
1?6 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Rkhbrkhls, ].,I.J. Akiorf.V. voi Lkngsa`kthi
?552 Fhish Gkrhsts, Aknf Qthpphs oif t`h Tonohknet`ea Qhttnhchit kg Ikrt`hri Hurkph . Aurrhit
Oit`rkpknkmy 11, 88?-807.
Rkhbrkhls, ].,V. voi Lkngsa`kthi
t`es V`h Voutovhn wkrls`kp: oi eitrkfuateki.vknuch
Rknnoif. I. En9')2 V`h Tonohknet`ea Aknkiezoteki kg Hurkph : Oi Ora`ohknkmeaon oif Bekmhkmrop`ea Thrspha-
tevh, Vrobojks fh Trh`estkreh! 65, 75-???.
Qono, B. ?501 No Gouio fhn meoaechitk fe Eshrieo No Teihto. Ei: A. Thrhttk, A. Vhrzoie oif C. Arhcosa`e(hfs), `hrieo no Teihto, ui oaaocpochitk peu oiteak fe =44.444 oiie, =?-=5, Bknkmio:Aonfhreie.
Qono. B..G. Coseie.M. Geaaorhnne,N. Rkkl.F. Vkrrh
?552 Coccon fesphrson hvhits ei t`h Ceffnh oif Noth Tnhestkahih kg Etony oif ]hsthri HurkphAkurehr gkrsa`.-nist. Qhialhibhrm ?81, 85-70 .
Qono. B..
C. Gkrthneus
?551 V`h r`eikahrkshs kg Eshrieo No Teihto (horny Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, Qkut`hri Etony), Tonohki
tkmrop`eo Etoneao 04, ?8=-?=6.
Qoitkijo. C. ?552 No ofoptoaeki on chfek hi hn Tonhkneteak eighrekr fh no Thieisuno ebåreao. Hnhchitks porouio rhgnhxeki. Ei: O. Ckurh Rkcoiennk (hf.), Hnhgoiths, aehrvks y kveaopreiks, 1=-=8,Qoitoifhr: Xiev. fh Aoitobreo.
Qoitkijo, C.,T. Wenno
?554 V`h Nkwhr Tonohknet`ea kg Qpoei oif Tkrtumon, Jkurion kg ]krnf Trh`estkry 6, 68-56.
Qa`eal, L.F..E). Z`uoi
?551 Horny Tonhknet`ea kg A`eio oif Hosthri Oseo, Hvknutekiory Oit`rkpknkmy 2, 22-18.
Qknnos, ].J. ?5??, Oiaehit @uithrs oif t`her Ckfhri Rhprhshitotevhs. Nkifki : Coacennoi. 2if hfi?526 ?526.
Qtkpp, C. ?556 Horny @ucoi Ofoptoteki ei t`h Ikrt`hri @hcesp`hrh oif t`h Oionytea Ecpneaotekis kg
Vop`kikcy. T`F V`hses Aocbrefmh (Himnoif): Xievhrsety kg Aocbrefmh.
Qwes hr A A ,M.@. Aurtes,E'. Joakb.O.M. Mhtty,O. Quprejk,]efeosckrk
?556 Omh kg t`h hornehst likwi `kceiefs ei Jovo, Eifkihseo, Qaehiah 271, ???0-??2?.
Vhrzho, H., ei prhss Cocconeoi hvhits ei t`h _uothriory kg Rkcoieo oif akrrhnotekis wet` anecoteaa`rkiknkmy kg ]hsthri Hurkph, Oato zkkn. aroakv.
V`ehch, @.,B. Xrboi,F. Coieo.V. voi Lkngsa`kthi
?551 Qa`÷ieimhi (Ikrf`orzvkrnoif) . Heih ontponoknet`esa`h Guifsthnnh ous fhc cettnhrhiHeszhetonthr, Ora`fknkmesa`hs Lkrrhspkifhizbnott 21, ?6=-?71.
V`kuvhiy, I.,H. Bkiegoy
?506 Ihw a`rkiknkmeao n foto ki Hurkphoi Tnek-Tnhestkahih gouios oif `kceief kaaupotekiseths, Ioturh 140, 188-180.
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 325/342
1?8
Vuggrhou, O.
Vuggrhou, O..T. Oitkeih
Vurihr. O.
]EN RKHBRKHLQ OIF V@EJQ WOI LKNGQA@KVHI - O RHOTTROEQON KG V@H HWEFHIAH
?50=
t`esvknuch
?552
Nh Tonåknet`equh eigårehur ht ckvhi fu Ikrf fh Eo Groiah (Ikrf Tos-fh-Aonoes, Teaorfeh)
fois ski aofrh strotemrop`equh. V`hsh Fkatkrot f'Htot Xievhrsetå fh Nennh, Nennh.
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: Akiteihiton Ikrt`whsthri Hurkph.
Normh aorievkrhs oif hornehst Hurkphoi `kceiefs: a`oimeim fhthrceioits kg rhskurahovoenobenety fureim t`h Nkwhr oif Ceffnh Tnhestkahih, Jkurion kg@ucoi Hvknuteki 22,
?45-?27.
Vurihr, H.
Wonka`. L.
?55? Tnhes tkahih strotemrop`y oif vhrthbroth gouios grkc t`h Ihuwehf Bosei rhmeki kg ]hsthriMhrcoiy, Arorþuc 0, 2? -16.
?5=2 Mob hs heih ontponoknet`esa`h Bhsehfnuim fhr Qtroislo slono; Ei: R. Cusen (hf.), Qtrfislf
slono E ?5?4-?568 (Oit`rkpks 24 \I.Q. ?2S), ?55-246, Brik: Ckrovslå Cushuc.
?506 Horny Tonohknet`ea ei Ckroveo, Azha`ksnkvoleo, Trkahhfeims kg t`h Trh`estkreh Qkaehty 84,71-75.
?50=
?55?
t`esvknuch
V`h Horny Tonohknet`ea Qeth Qtroislo Qlono E ihor Brik (Azha`ksnkvoleo), Oit`rkpknkmeh
PPW (2), ?28-?62.
Nhs prhcehrs phupnhchits `ucoeis hi Ckroveh (Va`åaksnkvoqueh). Ei: H. Bkiegoy oifB. Woifhrchhrsa` (hfs). Nhs Trhcehrs Hurkpåhis, ?05-?56, Tores: Hfetekis fu [email protected].
V`h hornehst kaaupoteki kg Hurkph: Hosthri Ahitron oif Qkut`hosthri Hurkph.
Wknnbrha`t. J. ?552 Fos Ontponfknet`eluc ous fhi uithrhi Qa`ea`thi ei Lornea`. Comesthrorbhet, XievhrsetotL÷ni, L÷ni.
]orrhi. Q.@. ?524 O Ioturon 'Hknet`' Goatkry bhihot` t`h V`oiht Qoif. _uorthrny Jkurion Mhkn. Qka. =7,210-281.
]`eth, A. ?558 No Mrktth fu Wonnkiht: Hvefhiah kg Horny @kceief Oatevety kg Ioturon Trkahsshs; Tophrprhshithf ot t`h Tonohknet`ea-Chsknet`ea foy chhteim. Bretes` Cushuc Nkifki, Cora` ?=t`
?558.
]urmhs, L.
Zomweji, ].@.
?507 Orthgolth ous fhi onthsthi _uortorshfechithi (Qa`ea`thi O-A) fhr Vkimrubh Lornea`,Lrhes Coyhi-Lkbnhiz/Ihuwehfhr Bhalhi, Ora`oknkmesa`hs Lkrrhspkifhiz nott ?7, ?-7.
?55? Ihuh ontponoknet`esa`h Guifh ous fhr Vkimrubh Lornea`, Lrhes Coyhi-Lkbnhiz/IhuwehfhrBhalhi, Ora`oknkmesa`hs Lkrrhspkifhiz`nott 2?, 665-688.
?508 Oi kutneih kg t`h _uothriory strotemrop`y kg t`h Iht`hrnoifs, Mhknkmeh hi Cejibkuw 76,?=-26.
?552 V`h bhmeiieim kg t`h Eah Omh ei Hurkph oif ets cojkr subfevesekis, _uothriory Qaehiah
Rhvehws ??,801-85?.
]en Rkhbrkhls oif V`ejs voi Lkngsa`kthi
Goaunty kg Trh- oif Trktk`estkry
Nhefhi Xievhrsety
T.K. Bkx 58?8
2144 RO Nhefhi
V`h Iht`hrnoifs
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 326/342
1 ?= MHIHRON EIFHP
mhihron eifhx
Obbhvenneoi ?1,2?, ?84,271
Obehs 1=, 54, 208
Oaoit`kfoatynus aretrurus ?0
Oahr aocphstrh 5?
Oahr ckisphssunoiuc 54
Oahr pshufkpnotoius a'n
Oa`hunhoi =, 5, ??-2?, 16-64, 86, =0, 08. 5=, ?25. ?6=, ?60, ?84-
?82, ?88, ?87, ?85, ?=7-?=0, ?0?, ?02, ?50, 244, 240, 245, 2?5,
22=-268, 28=-274, 271-278, 141
Oaeauno fenuveoio 54
Oaeikiyx 0
Ofeoit`uc phfoit`uc 217
Ohmkpes vhrteaennus 0=. 00, 5?. 58
Ogreao ?, 1, 6, =, 15-6?, ?10, 205, 254
Omuhfo revhr 5, ??
Omuerrh, H. 0
Omuste, J. 145
Oilhi. C.J. ?.2
Olaomyn `krezki 7?Onomñi-Jhrths ?1, ?5
Onoslo 201
^nboieo 86
Onahs ???. ??8
Onahs aeXa.s 22=
Onaa.s notegrkis ??8
onfhr58, ?=?,2?1,224,210
Onhatkres 8?
Onhatkres mrohao 8?
Chithjk (
¼
Ongocbro revhr ?2
onmoh ?65
Onmorvh 5-?2, ?0
Onmhreo ?5,6?Oneolcki 86
Onechi, @. ?5, 278
Onnoatomo 210
Onnhrkf Eithrstofeon 24?
Onnehr ?25, ?1?
Onnkareahtus 2?1
Onnkareahtus bursoh 10, 82, 88
Onnkp`oekcys (sha Cearknus / Onnkp`oekcysS)
Onius 1=
Onius mnuteikso 5?
Onius verefes =0
Onpeorao ?1,24,2?
Onpeih Tonohknet`ea 221
Onpeih shquhiah 2??
Onps6?, ?41
Ocbnàvh ?6=
Ocehis ?84
oceiksnronemrop`y ?7=, 2=2
Ocp`ebeo 52, 58, 224, 211
Ocp`esbohiefoh 288
ocpnetufh kn' hnecotea ayanhs 208
oiotkceaonny ckfhri `ucois 288, 2=?
Oia`uso 2?1
Oifonuseo1, 5-??, ?0
Oifhrshi, Q.@. ?58
oifhseth =0, ?7=, 240, 245, 222, 210
Oifrhws, T. ?=6
Oimneoi ?78-?02, 20? , 208, 144
Oikfkito pesaeiones 7?
Oishr oishr 8?
oithnkph 288, 200
Oit`rkpkzkeluc 7=
Oitkeih, T. 2, 250
Ophiieihs 2=, 20, 14
Opkfhcus 11, 10, 82, 88, 52, 58. ??6
Opkfhcus fkceiois 2?1
Opkfhcus gnoveaknnes ?5
Opkfhcus (Lostkrcys) cystoaeius 82
Opkfhcus synvoteaus ?0. ??2
Opshrki `krezki/noyhrs 7?, 2?4, 2??Ora`oit`rkphs 226
Ora`efeslkfki (shh Coccut`us)
Oratea Kahoi ?51
ormeneth 210
Ormennh Ozzurrh 25
Orchieo 240, 245
Orui ?=?
orveaknefs 214
Orvhrikahrks orfhe 268
Orveakno ?=6, 144, 141, 148, 147, 145
Orveakno aoiteoio (shh Orveakno thrrhstres aoiteoio)
Orveakno cks`oa`hises (shh onsk Orveakno thrrhstres aoiteoio) 0, ?0,
14, 17, 142
Orveakno sopefus ?5, 148 Orveakno thrrhstres 11, 17, ?48, ?75, 22=, 142, 148, 145
Orveakno thrrhstres aoiteoio 0, 17, 82, 88, 00, 52, 58, 57, ?48, ?47,
???, ??2, ??6, ??8, ?2?, ?=?, ?=6, ?=8, ?0?, 26?, 142, 146,
148, 14=, 145
Os`tki, I. ?=0, ?02
os`trhh 210
Oseo Ceikr 278
Oskv Qho 2?8
Osthroahoh =0
Otonår ==
Onhnno Bosei 17
otnoitea (anecoth) 0=, 5?. ??8
Otnos 288
Oumusth, T. 20?Ountfu Chsien, M. fh ?84
Ourhneoi Gkrcoteki 11, 10, 15, 6?
Ouremioaeoi =0
ourka`s 18, 17
Oustroneo2=?,205
Oustronkpet`haus rocefus 25?
Oustreo =7
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 327/342
1?0 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Ovhs 52
Ovrh revhr ?84, ?8?
Oyt`yo ghreio 8?
Ozhao chilhoio 0=, 00, 54, 5?, 57
OzkXone, ??=
Ozknno geneaunkefhs 54, 58
Ozzorkne, O. 141
boalhf-liegh 18, 52, ?8=
Bomeitki-Nenneimtki Mrovhn ?7=, ?75, ?=?Boëssos, T. 1?
Bolu `krezki 7?
Bolu troismrhsseki 226
Bonlois 8?, 8=
Bontea ?51
Bontea gneit 56
Bontea troismrhssseki 244, 24?
Borysielkv, M.G. 216
bosont ==, ?14, ?12, ?11, ?10, ?64, 240, 224, 276
Bossh-Ouvhrmih ?25
bot 224
Boths, C.R. 2=2
Bovhneoi 144
Boyh, J. fh 240
bhor14, 1?,18, 2?5,216
bhor aunt 221, 226
bhovhrs10, ??2, ?51,216
bhha`10, =0, 224, 21?,210
Bhnmeuc ?85, ?78
Bhnmroifeo mhrcoieao 5?
Bhrbhrefeki 00, 5?
Bhrbhres vunmoreo 5?
Bhrm, O. vki ?45
Bhreimeoi 201
Bhtueo ?82
Bhnueo `ucenes =0
Bhtueo pubhshhis =0, 5?
Bhtueo tkrbukso =0
Bhtueo vhrruakso =0
Bebhrski, T. =, ?5, 288
Bebus, H. ??6
begoahs =, ??-?1, ?8-?5, 2?, 11, =0, ?45, ??=, ?2?, ?1?, ?84, ?82-
?86. ?87, ?7=, ?75-?=?, ?=6, ?=0, ?0?, ?02,244-242,245,224-
222, 228, 22=, 225-212, 210, 215, 28=-285, 276, 278
- ocymfonkefs 1? , ?60, ?8?, ?85, ?5=, 245, 224
- akrfegkrchs 24, ?=?,210
- noiaåknås 24, ?60, ?85, 224
- necoifhs ?84, ?8?, ?=?,245
-kvoths ?60, ?84, ?=?,224,278
- pkeithf gkrcs 52
- twesthf kvoths 278
- os (Nhvonnkes) akrhs ?82, ?86
Be`oreoi 17, =4, =8, ?47, 144, 142, 146
bekstrotemrop`y ?46-?47. ?15, ?75, ?=?, ?=8, 2?? , 2?2, 211, 261,
288, 2=8, 25=, 144, 147
bekzkioteki 245, 200, 144, 14?
bera` =0, 58, ?56, 2?1, 224, 210
berf 10, =7, 58, 224, 22=, 225, 211, 288
Bes`kp, C.J. ?77
Beski 14, 1?, 11, 17, 10, 8? , 58, ?45, ???, ??=, ??5, ?2?, ?51 ,2?8
225, 204, 141
Beski presaus 0, ?5, 8=, 52, ?65, ?51, ?56, 244, 210
Beski sa`khthisoale 0, 14, 1?, ??8, 226, 26?, 266, 141
Bnoal Gkrhst ?46
Bnoal Qho 7?, 71, 76, 24=-2??,2?8, 22=, 205
Bnoia, O.A. 1=
Bk`hceo 70, 75, =7Bk`hceoi Cosseg 7=
Bkiegoy, H. ?,205,25=,147
Bkiegoy, C.-G. 1?
Bkrfhs, G. =, ?5, ?84, 224
bkrhrs18, ==, ???, ?8=
Bks 11, 8?,58, ?45, ???, ??=, ?2?,2?1
Bks hnotus ?65
Bks htrusaus ?65
Bks precemhieus ?1, ?5, 1?-11, 17, 82, 52, ?87, ?==
Bkseisle, M. ?,2,6, ?14,146
Bkunh, C. 25=
Bkurbkiioes ?25, ?1?, ?12
Bkurfehr, G. ?82, ?88
Bkvefoh 0
bkvefs1?,56, 58, ??1, ??6. ??=. ?82. ?87,204,200
Bkwhi, F._. ?=2, ?=5
brhaaeo ?=6
Brhuen, @, ?1, ?5, 1=, ?84, 271
Brefmnoif, F.R. ?02
Breia`-Ththrshi, H. 2
Bretoei/Bretes` Esnhs ?78-?02
Brik =1, 146, 140
Brk`n ?41
Brkcch Aunturh 24?
Brkrup ?56, 242
brkwi `kribnhifh ?47, ???, ??2
Brui`hs ?0, 25, 70, =0, ?60, ?65, 207, 20=
Brui`hs/Cotuyoco bkuifory 6, ?2, 14, 1?, 7=, =4, =1, =8, =0, ?48
?47, ?45, ?60, 2??, 226, 285, 275, 2=1, 2=6
Brykp`ytoh 5?
Bubonus currhises 52
Bubk 8?
Bufo eifustry ==
Bugk bugk 52
burei 17, ==, 276
burit bkihs =5, ==
buta`hreim 15, ?=?, ?=5
But`ehrox pkuneoie 8?
Buxus 57
Buxus shcphrverhis 00, 5?
Byt`oc Qoifs ?7=
Aofez=, ?0,2?
aoennkutes 271
Aonobreo64, 6?
Aonobreoi ?2
Aonlo2?1
Aonke, N. 11
aocp seth 57
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 328/342
X5 MHIHRON EIFHP
Aoifkio oimunoto 56
Aoiefoh 1?, 288
Aoies 2?1
Aoies htrusaus ?0, 266, 268
Aoies nupus 210
Aoies nupus nuihnnhises 216
Aoies nupus cksboa`hises 8? , 82, 88, 8=, 52, ??2, ??6, ?6=
Aoitobreo0, ?4, ??, ?5
Aopro 0, 8?, 2?8(',//9/•>/ aouaoseao 22=, 225, 216, 210
Aopro ebhx coahfkieao 82
Aopro pyrhioevo 0
Aoprhknus aoprhknus 0. ?5, 11, 8=, 52, 58, ??2, ?2?, ?65, 225, 210
Aoprhknus seesshibkrihises ??8
Aoiþvkro 0, 18, 81, ??6. ?87,288
Aorpot`eois fn
('orpeius 10
Aorpeius krehitones 210
Aorrå, G. ?18
Aoryo 215
Aospeoi Qho 7?, 24=, 245, 2??, 205
Aosthnnñi ?8
Aostkr ??8
('ostkr gebhr 52. 56. 58, ??2. ??6, ?51, 225
aot 200
Aotonkieo ?8
Aouaoseoi turlhy 216
Aouaosus E. 6. 2?, 7?, 21?, 278, 254, 148
('oufo fapksens 2? E
aovh bhor 216, 204
aovhseth 24=,240, 2?5-261
Ahfrus 1=. 217. 210
Ahntes 54, a¼8-n9=. ?40. ??=.2?8
Ahntes oustrones 00. 5?
Ahntes mnobroto 2?1
Ahikzkea 288
Ahpoho veifkbkihises 00. 5?
('hrotkt`hreuc 288
Ahrotktnthreeec s`iuc 280
ahrhons =0
Ahrvefoh 0. 14
ahrvefs 81, 56
Ahrvus ?45, 2?1, 268
Ahrvus bhnmroife ?6')
Aarvus aoiofhises ?65
('hrvus (Foco) skckihises ?65
Ahrvus hnop`us 0. ?1, ?8, ?5, 11, 10, 8? , 82, 8=, 52, 58, ??2, ??=,
?2?, ?65, ?82. ?87, ?51, 22=, 225, 216, 210
('hrvus hnop`us oakrkiotus ??8, 26?
('hrvus ihstee 268, 141
('hrvus phrrehre 268
Ahrvus sknenoaus ?65
A`onaefequh 8?
A`oro5^
a`orakon ?5.75,==,=0
('`oreths aovo 5?
A`orkp`ynoh 05
A`ovoennki, J. ?10,147
A`hnnhoi 271
A`hikpkfeoahoh =0, 2?1
a`hrt =1, =8, =7, ??5, ?2?
a`hstiut 2?1, 224
A`ekikcys muf 225
a`eshn-s`ophf nkke 52
a`kpphrs ?6, 15, 64, 86, 8=, 7=, 70, =6, =8, ==-=5, 52, ?40, ?1?, ?18,
?1=. ?64, ?85, 224, 222, 22= , 141, 147a`kppeim-tkkns ?6, 25-11, 18, 17, 15. 86, 8=, 7?, =7, ==, =5, 52, 58,
?1?, ?18, 224, 222, 22=, 280, 141 , 147
A`rkifreio anehito aouaoseao 26?
A`rkifruno trefhis 26?
Aea`kreoahoh =0
Anoatkieoi ?1, 1? , 64, 08, ?85, ?=7-?=5, ?0?, ?02, ?58, ?5=, 225,
271, 276, 204
Anorl, J.F. 250
anhovhrs =, ?4, ??, ?7, ?8-24, 7=, 75, =0, ???, ??5, ?2?, 245, 224,
22=, 216, 210, 264, 26?, 266, 280, 271-278, 141
Anht`rekikcys 14
Anht`rekikcys mnorhknus 52, 58, ??2
anub-nelh tkke 52
Aka`nkfeio akstoto 58
Aka`nkfeio noceioto 1=, 56
Akhnkfkito oitequetotes 56, ?48, ?56, 145
Akna`hsthr ?=6
Akna`es 226, 212, 217, 148
Akna`es rhgumeuc 240, 245, 21?, 212
aknhkpthro ?7=
Aknneio-Merorf, J. ?16
Aknih ?=6
Aknkcboiehi ?85
aknkiezoteki ?==, 2=5, 202, 206, 207, 205, 14=, 140
Aknucbo neveo 8?
Aknucbo khios 8?
Aknucbo ponucbus 8?
Akcbehr, J. 2
Akcckit, W. ?65-?8?
Akiwoy, B.]. 204
Akpphis, U. ?
Akrbeauno gnuceiones 76, 0=, 00, 52, 56
Akrfy, J.-C. ?84, ?87,200
akrhs 14, 17, 7=, ==, =0, 54, 52, 56, 58, ?45-???, ??6, ??8, ?11, ?60.
?8?-?86, ?=?, ?02, ?5= ,245 ,2?1 ,2?8- 2?0,2 24,2 22,22 7,22 5,
28=, 280, 271, 276
Akrgu 86
Akrius cos 5?
Akrvus akrox 8?
Akrynus 0=
Akrynus ovhnnoio 5?
Aktkihosnhr eithmhrrecus 5?
Arotohmus 5?
Arotohmus phitomyio 54
Arhcosa`e, C. 64
Arhtoahkus ?=?. ?=0
Arkoteo 7=, =0
Arkauto 288
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 329/342
124 V@H HORN?HQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Arkauto arkauto ?65
Arkauto arkauto phtronkioh 82
Arkauto arkauto prohsphnoho 82, 88
Arkchreoi 7=, 70, =4, =8, =7, =5, ??=. ?6?, ?6=, ?80, ?78, ?77, ?70,
?=?, ?=6, ?=8, ?==, ?51, 250, 142, 148, 147, 145
arykchrhs 216, 217
arystonneih rkal 52
Aubul, M. 54
Auki 8?, 210
Auki onpeius 11
Auki presaus 0, 82, 88
Aurtes, W. 18
autcorls==, ?0?, ?55
Ayoikp`ysåhs ?65
Ayot`ho 210
Ayphroahoh5?, ?56, 2?1
Ayprefhes netkrones 56
Azha` Rhpubnea 7=
Foco ?5.14. 8?.82,52, ???
Foco foco 8=. ?87. ?51, 244
Foco foco anoatkieoio 0, 1?, 11, 10, ?=0
Foco ihstee (shh Ahrvus ihstee)
Foconesaus 288Foiubh ==, 0=, ?41
Fornos, O. 2
foteim 275-2=8
- 6
"Oe=wOr 1, ?47-?40, ?64, 275, 2=4, 2=8
- oaahnhrotkr coss sphatrkchtry (OCQ) 2=4
- onuceieuc-27 2=4
- oceik-oaef mhka`rkiknkmy ?7=, ?75. ?=7. ?=0. ?=5. ?02, 2=6
oceik-oaef roahcezoteki (OOR) ?8, 14, 17, ?=2, 275, 2=2
- bhrynneuc-?4 2=4
- bekstrotemrop`y ?46-?47, ?15, ?75, ?=?, ?=8, 2?? , 2?2, 211,
261, 288, 2=8, 25=, 144, 147
aonaeuc-6? 275,2=4
- a`nkreih-17 2=4
- hnhatrki spei rhskioiah (HQR) 25, 14, 16, 54, ?24, ?60, ?84,
?8?, ?85, ?=2, 280, 275, 2=2, 2=8, 147
- gesseki troal 1, 10, 275 , 2=?
- Mocco sphatrkchtry 2=4
- eska`rki tha`iequh 275
- esknhuaeih hpechrezoteki 12, 64
- kbsefeoi `yfroteki 275, 2=2
- kpteaonny-stecunothf nuceihsahiah (KQN) 280, 275, 2=?, 2=8
- Kxymhi esktkph a`rkikstrot emrop`y ?47, ?60, ?80, 275, 2=1,
2=6, 250
- ponohkcomihtesc 1, 25, 14, =4, =0, ?15-?6?, ?60, ?84, 245,
2?2, 226, 225, 262, 280, 285, 275, 2=1, 2=6, 142, 148, 147
- Tktosseuc/Ormki (L/Or) 14, 11, 10, ?18, 275, 2=?, 2=8
- rofekaorbki ?56, 24?
- t`hrcon ekiesoteki coss sphatrkchtry (VECQ) 2=4, 2=8
- t`hrcknuceihsahiah (VN) ?8, 12, =0, ?64, ?=2, ?5=, 225,
216,217,275,2=?,2=8,254
- Xroieuc shrehs 12, 54, ?24, ?6=, ?60, ?80, ?=8. 225, 216,
215, 275, 2=4, 2=8
fhhr 1?, 18, 52, ?45, 216, 217, 204
fhckmrop`ea hxpoiseki ?78
Fhihlocp Eithrstofeon ?56
Fhicorl ?51, 24?
fhiteaunoth ?4, ??, ?7, ?5, 24, 25-1?, 11, 18, 17, 8?, 86, ==, =0, 54
52, 56, 58, ?8?, ?87, ?8=, ?85, 224, 222, 22=, 210, 262, 276
Fhitki, M.@. 20=
Fhscoio 58, ??2
Fhscoio comio 75
feoceatki ?04
feotkceths 10
Fgoz fhn Knck, G. ?0
Feahrkr`eius (shh onsk Qthp`oikr`eius) ?47, ???, ?65, 2?1
Feahrkr`eius htrusaus (shh onsk Qthp`oikr`eius htrusaus) 0, ?0, 75
??8, ?6=, ?65, 2?2, 2?8, 22=, 225, 214, 266, 268
Feahrkr`eius `acetkha`us (shh onsk Qthp`oikr`eius `acetkha`us) 0
?5,82,88,52, ?65
Feahrkr`eius lera``hrshises (shh onsk Qthp`oikr`eius lera``hrshi
ses) 0=, 52, 56, 58, ?51, 244
Feahrkr`eius nhptkr`eius (shh onsk Feahrkr`eius Ewcetkhh`us) ?65
Feahrkr`eius chrale (shh onsk Feahrkr`eius lera``hrmhises) 8=,
?65,2??,266
Fealskieo 210
Fearkstkiyx 2??, 200, 145
Fefoaio `ohrearosso 7?
Fefoaio ceusseao 7?
Fefoaio porvuno 7?
Fefoaio pshufkarosso 7?
fesakef 7=
fesakefon akrhs ?6, 86, ?11
Fesaus phrsphatevus 0=, 00, 5?
fesphrson 141
Fcoiese coifebnh 2?8, 2?0
Fcoiesebks mhkrmeaus 268
Fihpr mnoaeoteki 250
Fihpr `krezki 2??
Fihpr vonnhy 7?
Fihstr 78
Fknea`kfkreahrks 0
F÷cietz Eithrmnoaeon 54, 58-5=
Fki 7? , 71
Fkurk Bosei/Wonnhy 5-?2, ?5, 2?
Fkwis ?=?
Frhit`h eah-ofvoiah ==, 5=
Frykceius hnekcykefhs orese 82
Frykpet`haus 2?8
fwhnneim (struaturhs) 15, 75, 52, 221
Fzovoa`hte 2??
Host Oimneo ?7=
Hbrk fhprhsseki 5, ?4, ?2, ?8, ?5
Hburkieoi 144
haknkmeaon
- stobenety 202
- tknhroiahs 201
- zkioteki 206
Hhceoi 0=, ?65, ?80, ?=7, ?51, ?58, ?5=-244, 242, 2??
Heghn ?41, ?40, ??=, ?25, ?77, 204
Hn @oil quortzeths 28=
Hnop`h nkimesseco ?=0
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 330/342
12? MHIHRON EIFHP
Hnosckt`hreuc ?65
Hnbh 08. 07
hnhp`oit 14, 1?, 18-6?, =8, ?47, ??=, ?24, ?2?, 280, 278, 204
Hnhp`os gonakihre 64, 6?
Hnhp`os cioefrehises 64, 6?
Hnhp`os iocofeaus ?51, 244
Hnhp`os (Tonohknkxkfki) oitequus 0, ?1, ?8, ?5, 14, 1? , 11, 1=, 10,
64, 0=, 00, 54, 52, 56, 58, ??6, ?65, ?87, ?=0, ?=5, ?51, 244,
2??,142,147,145 Hnekcys ?0
Hnekcye nusetoieaus ?5
Hnekcys quhraeius ?5, ??2
Hnnkbeus 210
hnc=0, ??=,224,210
Hnsthr/Hnsthreoi ==, 08, 07, 00, 56, 58, 5=, ?77, ?75, 2??, 20?, 250,
144, 142, 145
Hcys krbeaunores ?=0, 216
hifhcesc 24=, 212, 217, 148
hifsarophrs 24, 14, 12, 18, 17
himroveiys 52
hiverkichit
- `rettnh 202, 254
cksoea 20?,201, 206
- rhakistruateki 20?
rhseneoc 20?,202
- tknhroiahs kg `kceiefs ?=?, ?02, 20?
hknet` ?25, 271, 25=, 250
epoiihnes =7
Hpechrekihs 2?1
Hperus 86
Hpthseaus 82
hquef 1?,1=,204
Hquus ?8, 56, 58, ? EE . ??=, ?87, 2?2, 2?1, 2?8
Hquus ontefhis 0, ?0,1?,268
Hquus ao`onnus ?1, 21?
Hquus ao`onnus monneaus 0. 212
Hquus ao`onnus mhrcoieaus 0
Hquus ao`onnus nkrron`oh ?5
Hquus ghrus ?51
Hquus `epporekiefhs 2?8
Hquus `yfruiteius 82, ?65, ?87
Hquus cksboa`hises 11, 8?, 82, 88, ==, 52, ??2, ??6, ??8, ?2?, ?6=,
?82, ?87.2??
Hquus sthikies ?65, 21?, 261, 268
Hquus sthikies rk`ustus ?65
Hquus sþsshibkrihises 0, ?0, 1? , 2?8, 226, 266, 141
Greioahus hurkpohus prohmnoaeones 82
Hsno revhr ?4
Huanofkahrks 214, 141
nc nofkahrks shihzhises 268
Huakcceo 217
Hukiycus 5?
Gurkphoi Qaehihh Gkuifoteki ?.6
Hvhrifhi. W. 18
hvknuneki 144
hxteiateki 144
gofeim 2=?
Gomiort, J.T. ?8?
Gonak teiiuiaunus 8?
gonnkw fhhr ?51, ?50-244
Gorezy, A. ?,2 ,6
gouion turikvhr 141, 145
Ghjgor, K. 144
ghnef ??=,288
Ghnes (A.) aoroaon 8?
Ghnes mkcboszkhmhises 8?Ghnes (shh onsk Toit`hro (Nhk)) nhk 8?
Ghnes (Nyix) essefkrhises ??6
Ghnes (Nyix) porfeio ?5
Ghnes synvhstres ?5, 8? , 52, ??6
Ghnes synvhstres `ocofryos 82
Ghi Bosei ?75
Ghrfyioifñw-Eithrmnoaeon ==
Gehfnhr, N. ?45
ger 1=, 10,58, ??=
gerhpnoah 75, =4, =7, ==, =5, 04
ges` 58, 22=, 211, 288
gnolh ??, ?5, 25, 1?-11, 18, 17, 15, 64, 86, 88, 7?, 76, 7=, =4, =1-=7,
=0, =5,54, 52, 51,58, ?45, ???, ??6, ??8, ??=-??5, ?2?, ?14,
?1?, ?17, ?10, ?6=, ?60, ?8?-?8=, ?85, ?75, ?=?, ?=6, ?0?, ?5=,
245, 2?1-2?=, 2?0, 224, 222, 225, 216, 210, 262, 280-274, 271-
278, 147
gnolh-tkkns ?0, ?5, 2=, 25, 12-18, 15, 64, 8=, 56, ?87, ?85, ?=?, 224,
222, 226, 227, 211, 262
gnolhf gnolh tha`iequh ?75, ?=?
gneit ?7, ?0-24, 25-11, 18, 17, 15, 81, 7?, 76, ==-=5, 54, 52-57, ?25,
?1?-?11, ?10, ?6=, ?82, ?87, ?85,240,245,2?8,224,22?,221,
22=, 225, 216, 210, 26?, 28=, 276, 278, 2=?
(bkf rhskurahs ?78
gkroceieghro ?58
Gkrfwea`/Gori`oc ?=8
gkrhst 225, 210, 266, 20?-201, 207
gkrhst-sthpph5?, 225, 20?
Gkrcoteki fh ?'Hpeihtth ?84
Gkrcoteki fh no Morhiih ?84
gkx ?87
Groiakieo ?46
Groilgurt stomh 244
Groxeius 10
Groxeius hxahnsekr 5?
Grefrea`, J. 7=-75, =7
Gretennoreo =0
Gu`ih mnoaeon 07, 00, 56-5=
Gunfo ?41
Guneao otro 8?
Mobuieo, N. 2?8
Mofzehv, F.W. 226
Monbo ponustres C
Monhkbfknki nuthuc 5?
Monhreoi 214, 144, 141, 145
Moneaeo 5-??
Monnhmk revhr ?8
Mocbnh, A. ?, 2, 6
mostrkpkfs 10
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 331/342
122 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
moths kg Hurkph 205
Moufzeisle, Q. ??=
Mozhnno 8?, 261, 268
mozhnnh 280
Mhbouhr, W, =4
Mheshn 0=, 00, 54, 52, 56
mhkgoat ?25, ?11,288,271
Mhkmrop`eaon Eigkrcoteki Qysthc (MEQ) ?78
mhknkmeaoJ techsaonh ?=8, 2=5Mhkcomihtea Tknorety Vech Qaonh (MTVQ) 2=1
Mhrbennefoh 288
meoit bhovhr ??2, 204
meoit fhhr ?56
Mebhrt, J. 6. 145
Mebhrt, N. 6
Mebrontor ?8
Meimlk 217
meroggh 288
Meusbhrte, M. 10
mnoaeoteki ?51-242
Mnouaefeuc posshreiuc 8?
Mnes mnes 52, 225
Mnyaechres 16Mnyptkstrkbus 217
mihess ?14-?11, ?18, ?1=, ?10
mkot 217
Mkfwei, @. ?=0
Mknkvoikvo, N.W. 264
Mkwnhtt, J. ?04
mrofuonesc 20=
Mroceihoh 1=, 05, 5?, ?56, 2?1
mroieth ?14-?16. ?17-?10, ?64, ?6?
Mrovhtteoi =0
Muofon`krah ?8
Muofonquever =, ?0, ?5, 2?
Muofeoio revhr 5, ?1, ?8, ?0, ?5,2?
Muofex-Bozo bosei =, ?0, 2?, 2=5-20?, 148Mþiz 250
Murejo Noyhrs 245, 2?4
Mushjikv, C.C. 2?5, 22?-227
Mut`, A. 147
Mut`reh, R.F. 20?-201
@ohsohrts, T. ?6=, ?82
@oeih vonnhy ?6=
@oneohtus onbeaenno 52
@ocburmeoi ?51, 24?
`occhrstkihs =8, 54, 52, 58, ??=, 276
`oifoxhs, shh begoahs
@ortcoii, F. ??6
@ortz, I. ?50
`ozhn54, 58, ??=,2?1,210`hort` ?4, ??,52,222,221,20?
`hovy-ceihrons 142
@hfbhrm, @.F. 144
@hfhro `hnex 5?
@hmou rhmeki ?41
@hefhnbhrmhr aunturh ??8
@hefhnbhrmeoi ==
@heirea`, ].F. 144
@hneaemkio boioteao 07-00, 54, 5?, 58-57
@hneakfkito kbvknuto 56
@hnex pkcoteao 00, 54
@hcetromus bkione 14, ?6=
@himhnk Eithrstofeon ?56
`hrbevkrhs 1=, 10, 81, =0, 288
`hrbs 05, ?82@hrieaoi vknaoiea festreat 17
`hrphtkgouio ?=0
@hsseoi Fhprhssseki ?41, ?46
@hthkaypers soneius 56
@epporeki 288
@eppkpktocus ?5, 1? , 10, 6?, ?48, ?47, ?40, ??8, ?65, 280, 204,
147, 145
@eppkpktocus ocp`ebeus ?8, 14, 11
@eppkpktocus oitequus ??, ??8
@eppkpktocus mhkrmeaus 2?8
@eppkpktocus eiakmietus ?1
@eppkpktocus cojkr (shh onsk @eppkpktocus oitequus) ?87, ?80
@knkahih =1, =8, 0=, ?65, ?85, 22=, 211, 250
@knstheieoi 8=, =7-=0, 08, 54, 58, 5=, ??=, ?85, ?51, ?58, 242, 217,141, 145
`kceiefs 81, ==, =0, 08, 52, 57, ??=, 2?1, 22?, 226, 228, 225, 20?,
201, 145
@kck hrhatus 08, 52, 57, ??8, 240, 2?8
@kck `obenes 2?8
@kck `hefhnbhrmhises ??8, ?2?, ?78, ?=2
@kck sopehis 2?8
@kckt`hreuc 82, ??6, ?65, 2?8, 214, 200
@kckt`hreuc arhiotefhis 268
@kckt`hreuc notefhis ?1, ?65, ?=8
@krcut`, L.G. ??8
`kribhoc =0, 54, 56, 58, ??=, 2?1, 224, 210
`kcbnhifh/oumeth bkuifory ?47, ?77
`kribnhifh arystons 2=4`krsh 18, 81, ==, 58, ??2, ??1, ??=, ?87, ?=?, ?51,288,145
@kxieoi ?75, ?=8, ?=7, ?=5, ?0?
@uhbro revhr ??
@uimory 7=, ==
@uisrþal ?41
`uiteim 10, 15, 52, ??6, ??=, 280, 204
`yhio 82, ?87, 288, 200
@yohio orvhrihises (shh Toh`yarkauno phrrehre)
@yohio brhverkstres (shh Toa`yarkauto brhverkstres)
@yohio arkhuto (shh Arkauto arkauto)
@yohio phrrehre (shh Toa`yarkauto phrrehre)
@yfrkbeo stomikruc 56
@ypknomus 2?1
@ystrex 82, 22=, 225, 210 @ystrex veikmrofkve 8=
Ebhreo6, =-?1, ?8, ?0, ?5,2?,148
eah s`hht ?75, ?=5, 242
Enc 07, 00
Ecprkveso pupkefhs 26?
eiahrtkgoats 146
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 332/342
121 MHIHRON EIFHP
Eim`oc ?7=, ?75
eishatevkrhs 288, 20?, 206, 208, 250
eishats ?=6
eitae stofh fh Aomiy ?88
einhrstofeons 2=6
Ep`emhio fhishstreoto 00, 58
Ep`emhio nothstreoto 54
Ep`emhio tucefo 0=, 00,54,5?
\pswea`eoi ?=8, ?=7, ?02Esroìn 1
Estreh =0
evkry 52, 5=
Jobonñi ?8
joal on ' E
Jocoeao hvhit 1?
Joroco ?2, ?1
Jorocennk (Hvhit) ?0, 2?, =1. ?47, ?40, ?2?, 2=1, 144, 147
Jovo 1, 2?8, 2=4
Juiephrus 210
Juiephrus sobeio 00, 5?
Jutnoif ?51, ?58, 242
Logtoi 2A9L
Lonoifofzh, O.I. 217Lorhneo ?51
Lþrnea` Brkalhitugg ?48, ?40. ??8, ??=
Leernea` Eithrmnoaeon ??=
Lhhnhy, N. ?=5
Lhnnhy, @. ?84
Lhiwkrt`y. J.]. ?=0
lhrle2?2
Lhsmrovh ?7=, ?=6
Lngco, R. =8
liegh =0, 52
Lkbnhiz ?48, ?45
Loncs 288
Lkaoa`ure 2?1
Lkhiemswonf, ]. vki ??8, ?75
Lkngsa`kthi, V. voi ?, 2, 58, ?6?, ?87, ?75, 200
L÷nihrBua`t ?41, ?46
Lknpka`khrus p`oaka`khrkefhs 288
Lktsoles. V. 6?
Lkuthl. J. =8
Lkwonsle. L. ?=8
Lkwonsleo 2?1
Lrhtzke, C. 144
Lreemhr. @. ??5
Lrzyszlkwsle, F. ==
Luboi 240, 245
Lulno, M. =4
Lur.e @osei 24=
Lvovofzh, H. 2?1
NoQhnvo ?8
Nooa`hrQhh ?41. ?40
Noahrto 8?
Noahrto treneihoto 8?
Noahrto verefes 8?
nomkckrp` 224
nomkki ?=?
nomureihs 142
Nomurus 7? , 210, 142
Nomurus (Hknomurus) ormyrkpunke zoz`em`eie 82, 88
Nomurus troisehis 82, 88
Nolh Akistoiah ?41
Noieus ceikr 8 ?
E.orsski, N. 2, 6
Norus 8?Noteuc 11, 17, 6?
Nhgàvrh, F. 288
Nhccus nhccus 58, 145
nhkporf 254
Nhkpknf, J. 2
Nhptkbks htrusaus 141
Nhpus 14, 82
Nhpus hurkpohus 8=
Nhubsfkrg Vhrroah ?40
Nhvonnkes ?=, ?0, 15 ,6 4, 8? ,8 6, 88 ,8 =, =0 ,5 6, ??=, ?2?, ?60, ?8?-
?88. ?8=, ?85, ?78, ?0?, ?50, 245, 221, 266, 271, 276
Nhvoitei hvhit 1?
Nhvoiteih akrrefkr 278
Nhwes, Q. ?02
Nea`orhv, N.C. 26?
Nea`vei Eithrmnoaeon 7?. 71, 78, 2??, 217
Neàmh ?6=
necoahs 224, 22=, 262
nech trhh ??=, 2?1, 210
nechstkih 1?, 18, 17, 15, =6, ==, 52, 240, 224, 22=, 216, 210, 147
neckceth =1
Neiaknis`erh ?7=
neifhi 58
neki 18
Nes revhr ?1
Net`kmnyp`us ioneakefhs 76
Net`ksphrcuc orvhish 2?8
net`kstrotemrop`y ?7=, 288
Nettnh Kush ?=0
nezorf 288
Njubei, W.T. 2, 228
nkhss 2=?
N÷`r, @. ??=
Nkifki Anoy ?=0
nkim a`rkiknkmy ?, 1, 6, 208, 20=
Nkwhr R`eihnoif ?41
Nkwhstkgt Venn ?7=, ?75, ?=0, ?04
Nucnhy, @. fh ?,2
Nucnhy-]kkfyhor, C.-O. fh 2
Nyakpses krehitones 2?1
nyfeth 7=, 75, =4, ??1-??8, 224, 221, 146
nyix 216
Cooregehi 288
Coaoao 216
Coaoao synvoio (shh Coaoao synvoius)
Coaoao synvoius ?5, 8=, ==, 52, 22=, 225, 266
coa`oerkfkit aot ?=8
Coa`oerkfkiteioh eifht. ==
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 333/342
126 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Com`rhb 6, 288
Comkmo, N. 2
Coei ?41
Cononhsto, O. 64
cocconeoi osshcbnomhs 288, 144
cocckt` 2??
cocckt` sthpph ?56, 20?-206, 200-254, 145
Coccut`us 2?8, 145
Coccut us a`ksoreaus 2??
Coccut us chrefekiones 0, ?48, ?47, ?65, ?87, ?80, ?=?,2 ?? ,2?2
261, 268, 141
Coccut us precemhieus 56, ?48, ?65, ?56, 2?? , 145
Coccut us trkmkit hrþ 0, ?0, 7? , 78, 75, 56, ?48, ?65, 2??
Coieo, F. 2, 54, 250
coiupkrt 2?8
copnh 210
Cora`oiteo 5?
Coreeislo thrroah 71, 76
Corlkvo, O.L. 224
Corcoro Qho 8?
Corckto 2?1, 2?8
Corckto aouaoseao 225
Corckto ponhkaouaoseao 26?
coieh bnoia`h ?84
Corths 225, 268
Corteihz, B. 6
Corty, T. ?25
coss ckvhchit ?=?
Cosseg Orckreaoei ?6=
Cosseg Ahitron ?25, ?10, ?6?, 147
costkfkit 288
Cotuyoco 70, 2?2, 2=1, 207, 20=, 141
CaIobb, J. ?=0
Chfethrroihoi ?, 5, ?8, ?5, 07-00 , 54, 5?, 56-57 , ?78, 24=, 205
CamonkahrksEChmoahrks 0, 14, ?82, 141
Chhoahrks sknen`oaus 1?
Chhonkahrks fowleise ?=2
Chhonkahrks memoit hus ?==, ?56, 244
Chhonkahrks vhrteakries (shh onsk Trohchhoahrks vhrteakries) 11,
?48, ?47. ??? ,?2?
Chmoithrhki 2?1,200,145
Cahoithrhki chhoithrhki 268
Chnhs chnhs 82, 52, 2?8, 225
Chioa`o aouaoseakno 26?
Chral'o r`eikahrks ?51
chrefekion Oa`hunhoi =
Chrekihs 210
Ch sht o5- nn, ?1, ?8, ?5
Chsknet`ea ?55, 24?, 22=, 217
Chunhi, O.J. voi fhr 148
Chush ?41, ?6=
Ceakqueoi ?1, 24, 2?, 86
Cearkforweiuno zecchre 52
Cearknus 7? , 144, 142
Cearktus (Onnkp`oekcys) 17, ?=1, 144, 142, 148
Cearktus (Onnkp`oekcys) pnekaohieaus 0, 147
Cearktus omrhstes 14, 11, 52, 58, ??6
Cearktus orvonefhis 75
Cearktus orvones 14, 11, 10, 52, 58, ??6, 22=
Cearktus hx. mr. orvones skaeones 226
Cearktus brhaaehises ?0, 14, 10
Cearktus fhitotus 10
Cearktus hrhhones ?=2, ?=6, ?=8
Cearktus hrhhonkefhs 75
Cearktus ievones 11
Cearktus khakikcus 58
Cearktus (Tetycys) 142
Cearktus prohhuhit`hre 82
Cearktus roteahpkefhs 75
Cearktus (Vhrreakno) 11, 142
Cearktus (V.) su`thrroihus 52, 58
Ceffeh Tonohknet`ea 5, 88, 8=, 7?, 76, 70, =7, ?40, ??1, ??8, ?24
?25, ?85, ?75, ?56, 242, 240, 245, 2?5, 221, 22=, 211, 216
217, 210, 276
Cefnoifs ?7=-?75, ?=?
cemroteki ?56, 144, 140, 145
Celunei Eithrmnoaeon 7?, 2??, 217
Cenoilkveta` 2=6, 20=
Ceckcys 7? , =5. ?48. 214, 144, 142, 146, 148, 145
Ceckcys bnoiae 17
Ceckcys (Ashreo) pusennus 144, 142
Ceckcys hx. mr. `uihoreaus 2?1
Ceckcys soveie 0, 75, ?48, ?47, ?40, ?75, ?=1, 144, 142, 148
Ceifhn ?1,86,7=,==,250
Ceifhn-Ress eithrmnoaeon 225
Cekahih ?0, 2=, 64, =4, =1, =8, ?25, ?10
cexhf-kol-gkrhst 07, 5?, 58, ??8
ckbenety 206, 254
Cknfoveo 76
cknnusas =8, 5?, 56-57, ?47, ?40, ??2, ?=2, ?04, 2?2, 26?
ckilhy 288
Ckirhpks ?
ckroeih ?51, ?5=, ?55-24?, 245
Ckroveo =4, =1, =7, 146
Ckrmoi, J. fh 240
Ckrkaak=, ?5,2?,288-274
ckrsh 288
Ckrtennht, M. fh 271
Cksboa` wkng 0
Ckshnnh ?41, ?48, ?47, ?45
ckugnki 204
Ckunkuyhi 288
ckuitoei mkot 81
Ckusthreoi 8=, 224
Cus 288
Cusaorfeius ovhnnoioreus ??2
Cusa`hnesvene, O. 2?1
Cusen, R. =1, =7
cusl kx ?56, 204, 254
Cusse, C. 2, 6, 206
Custhnefoh 58
Cyktes 82
Cyktes bnyt`e 82
Cyktes cyktes 82
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 334/342
128 MHIHRON EIFHP
Cys (Bufocys) seioit`rkpus 82
Iomy`orsoiy`hmy-T`osh =8
Io`h ?41
Iojhrenno ?8
Ionrex iotrex 52
Ihoifhrt`on ?78,2=?
Ihor Host 1
Ihalor ??6, ?24
Ihalornoif ?46Ihknet`ea 217
Ihkcys ihwtkie ??2
Iht`hrnoifs, t`h 242
ihttnh erhh ??=
Ihuwehf Bosei ?41, ?46, 145
Ikiho gtovhsahis 2?1
Ikrgknl ?77. ?7=
Ikrt` nþerkpaoi n'noei ?41
Ikrt` Qho ?41, ?7=
ikta`hs 24, 25-1?, 11, 18, 17, 8?, 86, ==, 54, 52, 58, ??8, ?8?. ?87.
?8=, ?85, 224, 222, 22=, 262, 276
Iyatonus ikatuno 82
Iyathrhuths 288
Iycp`oahoh 05kol 1=. =0, 54, 56, 224, 210
kol ebrhst 202
Kolnhy, L.T. 20=
Kbhrcoehr, @. 25=
kbsefeoi 240, 245, 222, 221, 22=
kaaoiea hgghat 201
Klo 2??,250, 142
Knfkwoi 14=
Knfuvoe suba`rki 1, 7=, =5, 52, 245, 2??,2?2, 262, 2=1
Knevo, C. =4
Kntht revhr =5
kiaknet` ?65,20?
kphi-oer nkaonetehs 240
Kp`efeo 8?KrbemK revhr 5
Kryatknomus 10, 82
Kryatknomus auieaunus 0, ?1. ?8
Kscuifo aeiiockcho 217
kstroakf =8. 56
kstrea` 288
Kstryo 224
Kvebks cksa`otus ?56
kveaoprefs 200
Kves 268
Kves occki 210
Toa`yarkauto 268
Toa`yarkauto brhverkstres 82, 88, ?=1, 200, 145
Toa`yarkauto phrrehre 82, 88, ??6, 268, 200, 145Toa`yuro htrusaus (3 Quiaus htrusaus) 8?
Tomkfuneio pomkfuno 54, 5?, 58
Tolestoi 1
Tonohkeifeuis CEQ
Tonohknkxkfki oitequus (shh Hnhp`os (Tonohknkxkfki) oitequus)
Tonohkit`rkphs 226
Tonkcbk, C.R. 11
ponyiknkmy ?=8
Toit`hro mkcboszkhmhises 82, ?6=
Toit`hro (Nhk) gkssenes 0, 14, 82, ??6, ?6=
Toit`hro (Nhk) sphnoho ?5, 11, 52, 210
Toit`hro porfus 82, ??6
Toit`hro temres 2?8
Toroht`kcys 288
Toroscet`us brhvefhis 82Torgett, Q.O. ?0?, ?02
Torrkteo 217
Tosshregkrchs 8?
Totku-Cot`es, C. =8
Totthrski, V. ?=0
phbbnh aunturh =, ?1, ?0, ?5, ?6=, 224, 226, 288, 250
phbbnh eifustrehs =, ?2. ?8, ?0
phbbnh tkkns =, ?4, ??, ?5, 14-12, 15, 70, 52, 5=, ?45. ??4. ??=, ??5,
?2?, ?85, 2?1, 2?=, 262, 271-278, 146, 147
Thfeostruc phiionhs =0
Thnkboths gusaus 8?
Thimhnny, ]. ?=8
phimuei 288
Thrfex jurasole 8?Thrhttk, A. 2, 64
phremnoaeon ?=?
Thuahfoiuc onsoteauc 5?
Thvzihr, C.O. 225
Thyrknnhs bekzkih ?18
T`enofhnp`us akrkioreus 5?
p`kikneths ?11, ?10
T`romcerhs akccuies 5?
T`romceths 05
p`ytkzhiksh 217
Teaho 208
Teaho obehs 5?
peals 7=, 75, =6, 52, ?45, ??4. 141
pehahs hsquennåhs 276pehrahrs 1?, 17
pem ??=, ??5,288
pelh ==
Telh, L. ?=0
peih 1=, =0, 56, 58, ??=, 2?1, 210
Teius 1=
Tepestrhnnus 82
Terks 86
Tesahs 8?, 52
Teshaiy vra` 70
Tesefeuc ocieauc 76
Testoaeo 217
Tesuhrmo revhr 5, ?4
Tet`haoit`rkpus 52, 2?8Tenycys (shh onsk Cearktus) 14, 10
Tenycys mrhmonkefhs (shh onsk Cearktus mrhmonkefhs) 0
pnoei 205
Tnoikrboreus akrihus 76
Tnoikrbes pnoikrbes 76
pnoquhtths 14, 15
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 335/342
127 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Tnotoius 1=
pnothou akrrhateki cht`kf 2=?
Tnhestkahih a`rkikstrotemrop`y 245, 2?4, 250
Tnekahih 2=, 14, 64, 86, ?25, 288
Tnekarkauto 288
Tnekcys hpesakpones 0, 14, 75, ??6, ??8, ?=2, 142
Tnekcys nhile 14
Tk 2=, 20
Tkoahoh 05Tkfkaorpus 210
Tknoif 7=, ==
Tknhckieuc oaubegnkruc =0
pknnhi 58, ?82, ?87, ?51, 2?1, 224, 22=, 225, 216, 217, 210, 250
pkny`hfrkis 25, 7=-=4, =1, =8-==, 52, ?11, ?16, ?17, ?1=, ?64. ?6?,
280, 141
Tknypkfeoahoh 2?1
pkitea 54
Tkites 24=
Tkpunus trhcuno 5?
pkraupeih 22=, 216
Tkrtumon =, 5-?1, ?0, ?5, 2?. ?78
Tktockmhtki 05
n'knaitenno gruateakso 00, 5?Tkuneoiks, I. 82, 81
Trohchmoahrks (shh onsk Chmonkahrks) 0
Trohchmoahrks vhrteakries (shh onsk Chmonkahrks vhrteakrcs) ?0.
8?,82,2?8
Trohkvebks 141
Trohkvebks presaus 141
Trosnkv, I. 2, 6
prh-Oa`hunhoi =
Trh-Ihoifhrtonhr 2?5
Trhbkrhon 24?
prhfotkr 288
Trhiteah, C.N. 20=
Trknomurus 142
Trkcht`hkcys sa`opks`ielkvh 225
Trkka`ktkio 21?
prktk-begoahs/prktk-`oifoxhs 14, 8=, 7=-75, =?, =7-=0, ?85
prktk-Nhvonnkes 64
TruihEno aknnoreo 8?
Truius oveuc 5?
Truius co`hnhb 54
Truius pofus 5?
Tshufoneifo nurmefo 0=
pshufk-orthgoats =4, ?25, ?1?, ?12, ?16, 224, 288, 271, 25=, 250, 141
Tshufka`rkifruno tughreghro 26?
pshufkfkitkriet`hs 288
Tthrkaoryo 10, 6?, =0, 58. ??=, 224, 217
Tupenno cusakruc 5?
Tupenno trepneaoto 5?
Tyroaoit`o akaaeiho 00, 5?
Tyrhihoi ?4, ?8, ?5
pyrkxhih ?47, ???, ??2
Tyrr`kakrox mroaunus vhtus 8?
Tyrus5^
_uofrepneaoto ommhsto ommhsto 26?
quortz ?4, ?5, 12, 81, 86, 7=, 75, =4, =1, =8, ==, 52, 58, ?47, ?40,
?45, ???, ??1-??=, ?2?, ?25-?16, ?1=, ?10 ,2 ?1, 276 ,2 =?, 147
quortzeth =, 5, ?4, ?6-24, 25, 12, 8=, 7?, 76. 7=-75, =8-==, =5, 52,
58, ?40-???. ??1-??=, ?2?, 240, 224, 22=, 225, 28=, 274, 276,
278, 146
_uothriory 255
_uhraus 10, 0=
_uhraus pubhsahis 54
_uhraus rkbus 5?_ueiski pkeit 52, 58, 22=, 276
robkns 12
roankers fåjånås 276
Roimeghr 200, 25?
Roimeghr toroifus 0, ??=, ?56, 145
Ropksk, N. 2, 6, 250, 148
row cothreons ?=?, 240, 224, 22?, 22=, 225, 216, 210, 26?, 28=, 280,
271-278, 204
Royck 20=
Royion, J.T. 2, 288
rhf fhhr 18, ??2-??6, ??=, ??5, ?=?, ?51, 216, 217, 26?, 204, 202
rhgetteim ?=?, ?0?
- kg bkihs15, ?55
- kg stkihs 204
rhgumeo6?,24=, 211, 202, 206
rhmknet` ?=?
rheifhhr ??=, ?56,24?,204
Rheisfkrg Eithrmnoaeon 54, 58-5=, 145
rhneat sphaehs 21?
rhneat vhmhtoteki 24=
rhptenh 52, 58, 2?8, 224, 211, 288
Rhpteneo 52, 2?8
rhsknuteki 140
R`ocius groimuno 5?
R`heimou ?46
R`hies` Q`ehnf ?41
R`eih ?41-?47, ??2, ??6, ??8, ?77
R`eih-@hsseoi Tnothou ?46
r`eik(ahrks) 14, 1?, 18, 15, 6?, ==, 52, ??5, ?=?, 216, 288, 280, 204,
200
R`eiknkp us 82
R`eiknkp us ghrruchmueiuc nkponhises 82
r`kfkfhifrki 2?1, 210
Reoik nolh 10
Rehfhi ?41, ?40
Ress ?1, 250
Ress-]þrc eithrmnoaeon 225
Rkbhrts, C. 2
RKAL HWON pyrknyses =5, 04
rkfhit ?75,224, 225, 288
Rkfkp`yaåhs ?65
rkh fhhr ??2-??6, 204
Rkh, F. 1, ?=8
Rkhbrkhls, ]. ?, 2, 6, 2?
Rkcoieo 7=, =0, =5
Rkså, J. ?75
Ruecs 5^
Ruffecoi, ].G. 20=
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 336/342
12= MHIHRON EIFHP
Rupeaopro rupeaopro 0, 22=
Rusaeikcys 288
Russeoi Tnoei ?. 7? , 72, 76, 245-2??, 212
Rust, O. ??8
Qoonh/Qooneoi 08-00, 56, 58, 5=, ?65, ?85, ?75, ?58, ?5=, 242, 200,
250, 144, 145
Qobbek Meonnh 25, 17
soemo oithnkph ?56
Qoemo 26?Qoemo totoreao ?56
Qono, B. 11
Qonåtehi 288
Qonex aeihrho 5?
Qonex pkpunus 1=
Qonex purpurho 5?
Qonck trutto Ete`ec 22=
soncki 22=
Qonzlh vonnhy 00, 56
soifstkih 216, 210
Qoitkijo, C. 2, 6, 250, 148
Qorfeieo 1=, 15, 64
Qaoifeioveo ?, ?58
saovhimeim 10, 15, 204Qa`hnfh ?6=
sh nust 240
Qa`cufh, L. ?45
Qa`khthisoal. K. ? ?6
Qa`÷ieeemhi Eithrmnoaeon 54
Qaeurus ??2
Qaknkpoaefoh 8?
sarophr ?4, ?6, ?7, ?5, 24, 25, 1? , 11, 18, 17, 8? , 86, 7=, =?, =6, =7-
=0,54,52,56, ??8, ?6=, ?8?, ?8=, ?75-?=?,224-222,22=,216,
210, 262, 261, 276
sho-nhvhn ?=?
shfmh =Q
Qhmuro bosei 5-??
Qhrro Ckraio 5
Q`oalnhtki, I.J. 2=1, 20=
Q`lkfhr 86, 8=
s`krt a`rkiknkmy ?, 1, 6, 2? , 6? , ?7=, ?==, 208, 20=-205, 25=
Q`kunf`oc ?7=, ?75
Qeaeneoi ?2
Qeaeny 2=, 17, 15-6?,278
Qehbhimhbermh ?41
Qenhseo ==
Qenurus mnoies 52
Qeioit`rkpus 52, ??8
Qeimen' gouio-akcpnhx 2??, 214
Qevot`hreuc couruseuc 288
snoth 22=, 225, 210
Qneifki ?=?, ?=2
Qnkvoleo 70, ==
siolh ?=0.288
Qkhrmhneo 0, 268, 141
QknfhRkakurt ?80
Qknnos, ].J. 25=
Qkiearshn ?77
Qkcch vonnhy ?6=-?65, ?8?, ?80
Qkifoor, T. 1
Qkrhx 82, 58, 2?1, 210
Qkrhx oroihus 52, 58
Qkrhx (Frhpoikskrhx) 142, 145
Qkrhx (Frhpoikskrhx) soveie 75, ??2, ?75, ?=2, ?=6
Qkrhx ceiutus 82, 58
Qkrhx ruitkihises ?=2, ?=6
Qponox a`onlefeloh 82Qporrhbkkc, C. 2, 6
Qp`ohreuc reveauno 7?, 76
Qp`yrofeuc fkneknuc 26?
Qpetzsa`o`hr 276
spruah58, ??=,2?1,210
Qeup`ynnho akna`elo 2?1
Qthp`oikr`eius (shh onsk Feahrkr`eius) ?47. ???, ?65, 2?8
Qthp`oikr`eius htrusaus (shh onsk Feahrkr`eius htrusaus) ==, 26?
Qthp`oikr`eius `hcetkha`us (shh onsk Feahrkr`eius `hcetkha`us)
14,11,10, ?==, ?=0
Qthp`oikr`eius `uifs`hechises ??6, ?75, ?=2, ?=6, ?==,1 42
Qthp`oikr`eius lera``hrmhises (shh onsk Feahrkr`eius lera``hrmhi-
ses) ?=0
sthpph beski ?56
sthpph hnhp`oit ??8
Qthvi`kvhf, Q. ?5=
Qtkpp, C. 145
stroem`t-tuslhf hnhp`oit ??=, ??5, ?51
Qtroet kg Mebrontor 278, 205
Qtrex onuak 8?
Qtrut`ek 2?2, 261
Qtrut`ek fcoieshises 268
suba`rki 2=1
subsesthiah ?, 6
subsp`hrkefs 7=, 141
Quggknl ?7=, ?75
Qunhjcoikv, C.B. 224
Quiaus htrusaus 8?
Qus ??=,2?2
Qus sarkgo 14, 11, 82, 52, 58, ?65, 210
Qus sarkgo presaus ??8
Qus strkzzee ?65
Qutaneggh, O. ?=8
Q whfhi ?56
Qwefo soimueiho 5?
Qwes`hr, A.A. 1, 140
Qyreo 6?
Qyreimo 57
Qyreimo jkseloho 00, 5?
Vomus bosei =, 5, ?4-?1, ?5,2?
Vonpo 52
Vonpo hurkpoho ??6
Vonpo ceikr ??6, 142, 145
Vonpo ceiuto 82, 88
top`kikcea stufy ?10
Vouius ?41
Voxkfeoahoh 217
Voxkfeuc 210
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 337/342
120 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Voxus boaaoto 5?
Voyoa pkeit 24, 52, 58
thatkiea oatevety 240, 20=
thcphroth gkrhst ?04
Vhcpnkc`hmy T`osh =4
Vhifreim ?=8
thp`ro ?46, ?47, ?40, ?64
thp`rkgoat ??=, ?25-?6?, 271
Vhr revhr ?8Vhro revhr 5
thi-oah systhcs ?7=, ?=6, ?02, 245
Vhrteoey ?65,24=,25=
Vhstufk 8?, 8=
Vhstufk mrohao 8?
Vhtrokmonnus aouaoseaus 216
Vhunofh, O. ?64
Vhutkburmhr Gkrhst ?41
V`ochs ?77-?70, ?=?, ?=7-?=0, ?0?, ?02
V`oiht Qoif ?=7
V`hnypthres t`hnypthrkefhs 5?
V`hkfkxus foiu`eones 0=
V`hkfkxus gnuveotenes 76
V`hkfkxus shrroteneiegkrces 0=, 00, 54-52
t`hrckchrhs 216, 217
V`ehch, @. 58
Vemneoi 144
Veneo pnotyp`ynnks 5?
Veiao teiao 52
Verospkn gouio 226, 214
Veszo =0
Vjurljoi fhpksets 2? ?
Vknhfk ckuitoeis 5, ?1
Vkimekrme, H. 1=
Vkreimeoi 144, 142, 141
Vkiihs revhr 5, ??, ?8
tkrtkesh ?=0, 288
Vroboiaks revhr 5, ??
troa`ytea tugt' ?40
trocpneim 15
Vroisaouaosus 24=, 245
Vropo iotois 54
trovhrteih ==, =0, 08, 0=-05, 5? , 56-57, ?46, ?40, ??=, ??5, ?24, 204
tre`hfrons ?7, ?=
Vrkmkit`hreuc 204
Vrkmkit`hreuc auvehre 00, 52, 58, 57, ??2, ??6, ?=0, 142, 145
Vrkmkit`hreuc foaeauc =5
Vrkmkit`hreuc sa`chrneime 75
Vruiaothnneio anoustrones 00, 5?, 58
Vruiaothnneio ayneifreao 5?
Vsumo 217, 210
Vuggrhou, O. ?-6, ?8?, ?88, ?87, 250, 146
Vuieseo 6?
Vugoiy =1, =8, =7
Vurfus 8?
Vurihr, O. ??2,200
Vuchr, A. ?=0, ?=5
Vurihr, H. 200
Vurq, O. 6, 2?
Xlroeih =0, 205
Xiek botovus pshufkarossus 7?
Xiek arossus 7?
Xistrut 07-00, 54, 52, 5=
Xrboi, B. 58
Xrkaenhnnus preiþmhieus fogioh 82
Xrsus 58, 2?1, 2?6, 268, 146
Xrsus oratks 210Xrsus fhieimhre 14, 11, 8?, 82, 88, 8=, ==, 52, ??2, ??6, ?6=, ?=2
?=6, ?=8, 22=, 225-21?, 211, 26?, 262, 266, 141
Xrsus htrusaus 2?2, 268
Xrsus chfethrroihus 216
Xrsus sphnohus 22=, 21?, 210
Xrsus sth`neie ??6
Xrsus t`ebhnoius 82, 88, 8=, 225
ush-whor ?=5, 2?1, 222
Wonfoe mnoaeoteki 2??, 250
Wonhiaeo ?8
Wonnkieo akstoto 5?
Wonnkieo puna`hnno 5?
Wonka`, L. 2, 146, 145
Wonvoto ioteaeio 76, 54Woifhrchhrsa`, B. 205, 25=
Woroius einhrchfeus 8?
Whluo, O. 2?1, 2?8
Whnealk, O.O. 224,22?
Whrhsaomei, I.L. 2?8
Whrtemk pymcoho 5?
Weburiuc noitoio 5?
Wenno, T. 250
Wennogroia`eoi 0, 1?, =0, ?1=, 2?? , 2?2, 144, 141, 148, 145
Wennoiyeoi 144
Werhtoenurus sa`oube 0
Wetes synvhstres 00, 54, 5?
Wetrho subrecono 58
Weveporus akithatus 76Weveporus gosaeotus 7?
Weveporus veveporus 76
Wnahl, H. 52
Wkmhnsbhrm cosseg ?41
vknaoiesc ?25, ?77,271,2=4
Wknnbrha`t, J. ??8
Wks, J. fh 1
Wksmhs ?46
Wroz 7=
Wunphs 288
Wunphs prohmnoaeones 82
Wunphs vunphs 8^, 52, 210
Wunturh vknaoik 14, 17
]oalhi Eithrmnoaeon 54]onlhr, C. 6
]onnhifkrg 0=, 00
woniut =0, 224
]orrhi, Q.@. ?=0, ?=5, 25=, 145
]ort`h ==, 0=, 5=
]h`r ?41
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 338/342
125 QEVH EIFHP
]hea`shn/]hea`shneoi =1, =0, 0=, ?60, ?65, ?51-?58, ?5=, ?50, 244,
250, 145
]hi-o ?41
]hshr ?41
]hsthrwonf ?41
]htthrou Fhprhsseki ?46
]`eth, V. 25?,145
]eh`himhbermh ?41
wenf bkor 18weimiun ? ?=
]epphr 07-05, 5?,52
]knfgea`, J. =1, =8
]knfsthft, T. 08
wkng 216
wkkf orthgoats 52
wkknny cocckt` ?56
wkknny r`eikahrks ?56
]þrmhs, L. ?40, ?45, ???,
]urc ?1, =1, =0, 250
]þst, H. 08
]ychr, J. ?=?, ?=0, ?02
Phikayki 8?
Phikayki nyaokiefhs ?6=
Phikayki rkse 0
Phrkp`yths 210
Uhnths revhr ??Uumksnoveo 147
Zornhimo, G. 64
Zbyszhwsle, M. ?1
Zhbhro, L. ==
zhbro 280
Zhnlkvo 6?, =0, 224
Zhuihr, G.H. 20=
?8, 146
seth eifhx
Obbhvennh ?60-?84, ?80, ?85,20?
Obrea Rkcoie 0
Oaogkro ?4. ?2
Oa`onlonole 24=, 240, 2??, 2?8, 2?0, 261, 201
Oa`hi`hec ?46, ??8, ?2?,271
Omufo ?4
O`n-OE-Kum`noc 288-28=
Onbono ?4, ?8
Onfh eoIkvo ?4. ??
Onfàih 278
Onckifo ??
Onpeorao ??,24
Ontocuro 14=
Ontk Nheok ?4, ?2
Ocbrkio=, 0, ?4-?2, ??=,278
Oromk 226, 204
Orah 20, 18, 17, 15, 64
Orhihrk fh Kxemhiek ??,? 1
Orefks0, ?4, ??, ?1, ?8, ??=,278
Orehifkrg ?48, ?40, 200
Orreomo ?1
Otopuhrao 6, =-?2, ?8, ?5, 2? , 148, 14=
Othnno 20Otes 245
Owos` vonnhy 25?
Ozya` 24=, 240, 2?5-227, 214, 261, 266
Bof Aoiistott ?24
Bomur 0
Bocchiton 214
Boiumuhs 5-??
Borolohvslo 24=
Boroi 86
Borinëhnf Tet ?=7
Bori`oc ?=2, ?=0-?0?
Borroiak Nhñi 0
Bhìkv 70
Bhha`hs Tet ?04
Bhrkui 7=-75, =7, 208, 141
Bhtgeo 144
Beoa`h-Qoeit-Woost 14=
Bebbkio 20, 17, 15
Bens`oushi ??=
Benzeimsnhbhi ==, 08-51, 58-5=, 271, 278, 2=5-20?, 254, 14?, 142,
14=
Ber os Qcor 288-28=
Bnossoa ?25-?16, ?10
Bnossoa-nhs Bottoits ?18, ?1=, ?10
Bnossoa-nhs Bnoia`hs ?18-?1=, ?15-?6?
Bnossoa-nhs Merkifeh ?18
Bknkckr=, ?4, ??, ?8
B÷iiem`hec ?46, ??5
Bktoiy Tet ?04, ?0?
Bkxmrkvh ?78-?7=, ?=?-?=6, ?=7, ?=0, 271, 2=5-20?, 208, 14?, 142,148, 14=, 145
Broifki ?7=, ?75
Brekufh ?14
Brex`oc 25=
Brik-Ahrikveah 70, =7, 141
Brik Ahrvhiy lkpha 70, =4, =2, =1, =7, 141
Brik-Zefhieah =7
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 339/342
114 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Brþ`hec 54
Bufeik5-nn
Aomiy 2=5
Aomiy-Aechteàrh ?60, ?84-?82, ?88, ?80,20?
Aomiy-n'Hpeihtth ?6=, ?60, ?84, ?8?, ?86-?87, ?80, ?85, 204
Aomiy-no Morhiih ?6=, ?60, ?84-?81, ?88, ?87, ?80, ?85, 271, 276,
20?
Aonotrovo ?1, ?8
Aoneak @enns 25=
Aonlo2?2
Aop A`othnehr 280
Aore`uhno 0
Aosobnoiao 288-285
Aoshnno fe Coefo 20, 15
Aosthn fe Muefk 20, 18, 10, 15, 14=
Aostrk fhe Wknsae 20, 18
Aou f'hi Bkrros EE, ?8
Aoufhn Fua ?4, ?8
Aouih fh ?'Oromk, shh Voutovhn
Aovo Tkcpe 20, 18, 17, 14=
Afenhte 245
Ahrikveah 70, =1, =8
A`omiy =0
A`en`oa ?11, ?1=, ?10, 208, 147
A`kulkunehi E ?8
A`rjosae 72-78
Aeleoie 245
Anoatki-ki-Qho ?75, ?=0, ?=5,276
Aknnh Coreik 20, 18, 17, 15, 64
Aknneioeo 20, 17, 15
Akio 24=-245, 22?, 225, 217-262
Akvo Ihmro 0
Auhstofh no Bojofo =, 5-?2
Auhvo fhn Akimkstk 0
Auhvo Weatkreo 1, 0
Aþnnorfh Bozo 0. ?4. ??. ?0, 148
Fhonun Weenkr =5
Fhutsa` Onthiburm 140
Fcoiese 1, 24=, 240, 2??-2?0, 262, 276, 278, 201, 205, 140
Fki-Bosei 250, 144, 142
Fubkssory 72, 76, 78
Fgoobhr 245
Hbrk fhprhsseki 204
Hffhretz 07
H`reimsfkrt' (shh ]hecor-H`reimsfkrg)
Hjby Lneit ?56, ?5=, ?50
Hn Oaunofhrk=, ?4, EE. ?6. ?0
Hn Aostennk 5-??
HnHspeior ?4, ??, ?1
Hn Corteihth ?4, EE. ?8
HnQorton hjk ?4, ??, ?1, ?8, ?=
Hrlok-bnus 245
Hteknnhs 254
Hyt`ro 5=
Ghrch fh Mroah ?60, 250, 14?, 146
Gkah fhn Vkrrhith Rkcoifotk 20, 64
Gkitoio Nere 20, 18, 17, 15
Gkitoik Roiuaaek 20, 1?, 11-18, 1=, 64, ??=, 276, 278, 14?, 148
14=
Gkitåa`hvofh 14=
Grhyburm 07
Guhithiuhvo 1, 2?
Mojfoi 278
Monesoia`k ??
Mouf`kur Bhi @obeb 28=, 280
Mormobhth ?4, ??
Motjoi 8 ?, 82, 86, 87, 8=
Mhngo ?4, ??
Mhroseckvlo 7?-71
Mnkbh Tet ?==, ?=5
Mrktto fhn Aknkcbk 20, 64
Mrktto Tomneaae 20, 10, 6?
Mrktth fhs Kurs 28=
Mrktth fhs R`eikaårks 287-274
Mrktth fu Treiah 14=
Muofonquever ??
@oimhibehthi 214
@ånei ?65
@em` Nkfmh ?75, ?=6, ?=5, 242, 276
@eta`ei ?04
@knnhrup ?56, ?50-244
@kchrsgehnf ?75
@krlo ==
@kxih ?75, ?=5, ?04, ?02, 204, 14?
@roikvieao ==
@uhraon-Kvhro ?0
@uåsaor-? 0
En'slojo 240
Enyilo 144
Eiaorion 0
Eshrieo 2=-25, 1?, 17, 1=-64, 278, 2=4, 2=1, 204, 20?, 201, 208,
14?-141,148,147
Evoi 70, =4, =2, 141
Joroco 2=5
Jostua` 245
Jovo 25=
Jkalrec 214
Lonhte 245
Lornea` ?41-??2, ??8, ??7, ?2?, ?25, ?77, 208, 25=, 144-142, 146,
145
Lornea`-Qhhughr ?40, ??8, ??=-?2?, 276, 278, 204
Lornsthji 70, =7
Lorslkv Lneit 24?
Lortsthei ?46, ?40, ??=, ?2?
Lhit'sAovhri ?=6, ?=8
Lnehlhi 07
Lkaoa`ure 2?2
L÷a`sthft 07, 00, 56, 5=
Lklleikpenks 82, 86, 87, 8=
Lknfeim Gjkrf ?56, ?58
L÷rbesfkrg 54, 52
Lkrknhvk 70, =0, =5, 208
Lkrresseo 82, 86, 8=
Lufork 24=-245, 226, 228, 220-217, 210, 215, 266, 271, 2=5, 204, 201
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 340/342
11? QEVH EIFHP
Lurmoi Aecbon 2?8
No A`oesh 14=
E ,e Nrieeno Q. ? ?
No Coyo ?4, ??, ?7. ?=
No Chso ??. ?1
No Tknnhfroro 20, 18, 1=, 15, 64. ??=. 278, 14?
No Roghtth 14=
No Rka`h-Nocbhrt ?10
NoQouvht ot ?14, ?1?, ?17, ?64, ?6?No Qhnvo ?4, ??
Nomuio Chfeio ?4, ??. ?7. ?0
Noimhibkmhi 0=
Nosh-Bonto 245
Noutsa` (shh Cnofha)
Nozorht 14=
Nh Akupht ?10
Nh @ovrh ?60
Nh Tuy Akuriy ?25
Nh Qvknth 20, 64
Nh Wonnkiht 214, 208, 25=, 144, 14?, 147, 145
Nhimhghnf-Bof L÷shi 07, 54
Nhs Gormhs ?14
Nhtly =7Nhzhtxele 0, 5
Neki Tkeit ?=0
Xssosgo 288-28=
Nettnh V`urrkal ?=7, ?04, ?0?
Nez ??
n.nomu 5
Nuihn Wehn 276, 278
Coostrea`t-Bhnvåfàrh 14?, 141
Comketk ?4-?2, ?6
Conomrktto 20, 18, 10-64, 276
Coizoiorhs 2=e9
Corllnhhbhrm 08, 5=, ?50
Couhr ?41, ?46, ??6. ??8, ?2?, 226, 214, 14?, 142, 146, 14=, 145
Chon`ofo ?1Chcnhbhi 07, 0=, 54, 56, 5=
Chihz-Fråmoi ?85
Chsvei ?65
Chzcojslo 24=
Cea`ojnkv 71, 76
Cehshi`hec ?41, ?46, ?47. ???-??1, ??8, ?2?, ?77, 204, 206, 14? ,
142, 146, 145
Cerkuak ?4-?2
Cnofha 70. =2, =1, 141
Cknnhn ?4
Ckioshslo 24=
Ckigorroaþeks ?4, ??
Ckith fkGocoa k ?4, ??. ?8, ?=
Ckith Thmneo 20, 17, 144, 14?, 148
Ckith Tkmmeknk 20, 17-6?, 208, 148
Ckitcourei ??8, 14=
Cksboa` 142
Cþizhibhrm ?46, ??5
Cuskv 70, =4, =2, 141
Ioithrrh 214
Ihucorl-Ikrf 0=, 00, 52, 5=
Ihucorl-Qþf 07, 00, 52, 5=
Ikaeaa`ek 20, 18, 17
Ikn`oa ?12, ?11, ?10, ?15
Kfhsso2?4
Krah1, 6, 0, ?0, 278, 208, 148
Krmioa 271, 276, 14=
Ksthrkfh 07, 54, 58
Kunof @ocefo 287-280Tof'non'eou ?6=-?65
Tobbe @enns 1
Torhfhs 0
Thrrehr =0
Thrrehr-Htkuoerhs ?10
Thrsote 245
Thtet Qpehiihs ?6=-?65
Thtronkio 8?-88, 8=, 276, 278, 200, 14=
Teiahvhit 254
Teihfk0, ?4. ??, ?1, ?8, ?0
Teienno fhn Wonnh 0
Tnhuveihs ?85
Tkmrhby 72, 76, 78
Tknemioa ?10Tkitihwyff 242, 14=
Tkrt-Temikt ?60, ?85
Tkrzuio ?4, ??, ?8
Tkuzfgoiy =7
Troeo fo Omufo ?2
Trhznhteah 7=-=?, =5, 144, 14?, 146, 145
Tuem f'hi Rkao ?4, ??
Turgnhht ?0?
_ueito fk Añihmk/Tkuseos ?4, ??, ?1
Reoik bosei 20, 18,204,20?
Rewot 1
Rkbei @kkf's Aovh ?=8
Rksoihtk 20, 64
Qoa`shiburm 08, 5=
Qoeit-Oa`hun ?60, ?84, ?8?, ?80
Qoeit-Aknkcboi ?60, ?8=, ?85
Qoeit-Hbnh ?14, ?10
Qoeit-Wonnehr =0
Qoeit-Wefon ?14
Qoeith-Oiih ?14, ?11, ?10
Qoi nse frk ?4, ??, ?1
Qoi _uerah 5-??
Qoifonjo.8?,70, =0, =5, 148
Qoimeroi 2?8
Qorotkvsl 245
Qotoie-For 245
Qa`÷ieimhi 08, 07, 54, 56-5=, 254, 250
Qa`woihbhal 07, 54, 58
Qa`wheislkpg ?25,145
Qhfnha ==
Qhfnhskveah =7, 141
Qhhst ?56, 244, 24?
Qhexkso ??, ?6
Qåiàzh =0, ?14, 140
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 341/342
112 V@H HORNEHQV KAAXTOVEKI KG HXRKTH
Qefe Obfhrro`coih 287, 274, 205
Qefe On L`ofer 28=, 280
Qefe Chssokuf 287, 28=
Qnoteio =5
Qknoio fhn Zocbkreik 0, ?4, ??, ?5, 24, 20?
Qknhen`oa ?25-?1?. ?11, ?10, ?15, ?6?, 278, 208, 147
Qpreckit (No Bhnnh-Rka`h) ?6=, ?60, 14? , 142, 148
Qthei`hec ??5, 14=
Qtroislo slono 7=, 70, =1-=7, =5, 04, 208, 144, 14?, 141, 145Qþsshibkri 140
Qvafslå soiah 70, =2, =1, =8, =7
Qwoisakcbh ?78. ?=2. ?=7, ?=5-?02, 276, 204, 14?, 142, 14'
Vocoi240, 2?4, 2?8, 2?0, 261
Vorl÷ 144, 142
Voutovhn 228, 276, 278, 2=5, 2 0?, 14?, 141, 14=
Vhmhnhi 144, 140
Vhriegeih ??8,280
Vhrro Ocoto 271
Vhtkeu 70, =5
V`kcos-? quorry 288-274
Vem`hiet' 280
Verospkn 2??, 226,214
Vkrk ?4Vkrronbo=-?2. ??=,278
Vkrrh ei Tehtro 20, 16, 10, 15
Vksson fh no Gkit ??, ?8, ?0
Vrhumkn' iojo 24=, 240, 264, 261, 266
Vrzhbieao 70, ==, 141
Vskio 201
'Xbhefeyo2?2, 271, 140
Xithrcossghnf 14?
Won f'Orik =0, 140
Wona`htto Aortkie 2=, 20, 18, 1=
Wonfhmkbo 0
Wonh fk Gkrik ?4, ?1
Wonnh fe Aosttmnekih 6?
Wonnh Meuchiteio 20, 64
Wons ?14
Whjstrup Ofon ?56, ?5=, ?55
Whjstrup Qlkv ?56-?57
Whnoy ?25, ?14, ?10, ?15, ?6?
Whikso 2=, 14, 2=5, 204, 14=
Whikso-Nkrhtk 20, 14-12, 17, 1=, 15, 64, 278, 14?, 148
Whikso-Iktora`ereak 20, 14-12, 17, 1=, 15, 278, 204
Whito Ceahio 0, ??, ?0, 2?, 14?, 141, 148, 145Whro ?0
Whrbhreh 254
Whrmroiih 14=
Wårthssz÷nn÷s 70, ==, =0, 14?, 14=
Weo Ourhneo 11, 1=, 10, 204
Wennomkizonk ??
Wennhstrup24?
Weskmneoik 20, 10, 15, 6? , 14?, 14=
Wkemtsthft 1 4?, 141, 140, 145
Wro`ihëlo 82, 8=
Wysiå Ruzboa`y ==
]onnhifkrg 08, 07, 56, 5=
]oimhi 08-0=, 54, 56, 5=
]oiihi 145]orrhi @enn ?=4, ?=?
]ovhrnhy ]kkf ?7=-?75
]hecor-H`reimsfkrg 0=, 5=, 141, 14=
]hst Ruitki ?77, ?75, 144, 14? , 141, 140, 145
]hstbury-sub-Chifep ?77, ?=2-?=6, ?=7, ?=0, 142
]effhrstott 08
]echrhux ?87
]essoit ?80
]evhi`kh ?=6
Uorecburmoz 8?, 82, 8=
Uerki 1
Zogorroyo 0
Zwhrifkrg =7
8/15/2019 The Earliest Occupation of Europe. Proceedings of the European Science Foundation Workshop at Tautavel (France…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-earliest-occupation-of-europe-proceedings-of-the-european-science-foundation 342/342