the flag pole · the royal purple member 24, john g. robertson, has sent in reports of purple royal...

12
THE FLAG POLE Newsletter of the BNAPS Flag Cancel Study Group Volume 2 Number 2 September 1988 Editor T.E.A lmond, 2 Filbert Drlve, Tl lehurs t, Readlng, RG3 5DZ, England. ............................................................................. EDlTORS MESSAGE This edit ion is unfor tunately very much delayed as a result of a comblnat ion of circumstances. As you may know the United Kingdom suffered a postal strike during the late summer, I decided to delay the production of Flag Pole until the last possible moment to allow the maximum amount of material to be submitted and in addition I have been working overseas for many weeks. However I can assure you that, given the material, I will publlsh on time in future. F" This edit ion fee tures contributions from three study group members. Doug L ingard has subm i t ted an interest lng article show ing that postmarks have !xen collectec! and studied for rather longer than many of us would think. He has also prepared a revised listing of the World War I flags, this results from his analysis of members returns. There are some surprises to be found in this listing Dan Rosenblat, who is also editor of the Slogan Study Group Newsletter, Slogan Box, has submitted a chronology of the use of the B, K and L Enlist Now dies in various locat ions. There Is great scope here for members to report their findings in or-der thet the dates of transfers between towns can be established. John Robertson has answered David Session's request for informat ion on purple iioyal Train flags with details of sorne examples from hts own collection. Finally, I must mention the fact that Doug Lingard is still awaiting survey returns for the Enlist Now and the 1939 Royal Train Flags, he has only received 12 so far. Flease keep him supplied with Information. FLAGS AT THE CPSGB CONVENTION The annual conventelon of the Canadian Phil~telicSociety of Brft~in was held in Sou tharnpt,on, England from 5 th .-9 th. October. Three members of the Flag Cancel Study Group were in attendance:- David Sessions, J lm McLaren and the edltor. David n presented s superb display of flags whIch contained many beautiful covers and I rarities. His display of inver ten flags was part icularly impress lve.

Upload: others

Post on 23-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: THE FLAG POLE · THE ROYAL PURPLE Member 24, John G. Robertson, has sent in reports of purple Royal Train cance 1 la t ions on cards to On tar io postmasters. John has a card addressed

T H E FLAG POLE

N e w s l e t t e r o f t h e BNAPS F l a g Cancel S t u d y Group

Volume 2 Number 2 September 1988

E d i t o r T.E.A lmond, 2 F i l b e r t D r l v e , T l l e h u r s t, Readlng, RG3 5DZ, England. .............................................................................

E D l T O R S MESSAGE

T h i s e d i t ion i s un fo r t u n a t e l y v e r y much de l ayed a s a r e s u l t o f a comblnat ion o f c i r c u m s t a n c e s . As you may know t h e United Kingdom s u f f e r e d a p o s t a l s t r i k e d u r i n g t h e l a t e summer, I d ec ided to d e l a y t h e p roduc t i on o f F l a g Pole u n t i l t h e l a s t p o s s i b l e moment t o a l l ow t h e maximum amount o f m a t e r i a l t o b e s u b m i t t e d and in a d d i t i o n I have been working o v e r s e a s f o r many weeks. However I can a s s u r e you t h a t , g i ven t h e m a t e r i a l , I w i l l p u b l l s h on t ime in f u t u r e .

F" T h i s e d i t ion f e e t u r e s c o n t r i b u t i o n s from t h r e e s t u d y g r o u p members.

Doug L ingard h a s subm i t t e d a n i n t e r e s t lng a r t i c l e show ing t h a t pos tmarks have !xen collectec! and s t u d i e d f o r r a t h e r l onge r than many o f u s would th ink . He h a s a l s o p r epa red a r e v i s e d l i s t i n g o f t h e World War I f l a g s , t h i s r e s u l t s from h i s a n a l y s i s o f members r e t u r n s . T h e r e a r e some s u r p r i s e s t o b e found in t h i s l i s t i n g

Dan Rosenb l a t , who i s a l s o e d i t o r o f t h e S logan S t u d y Group N e w s l e t t e r , S logan Box, h a s s u b m i t t e d a chronology o f t h e u s e of t h e B, K and L E n l i s t Now d i e s in v a r i o u s l o c a t ions . T h e r e I s g r e a t s c o p e h e r e f o r members t o r e p o r t t h e i r f i n d i n g s in or-der t h e t t h e d a t e s o f t r a n s f e r s be tween towns can b e e s t a b l i s h e d .

John Robertson h a s answered David S e s s i o n ' s r e q u e s t f o r i n fo rma t ion on p u r p l e iioyal T r a i n flags wi th d e t a i l s o f sorne examples from h t s own c o l l e c t i o n .

F i n a l l y , I must ment ion t h e f a c t t h a t Doug Lingard i s s t i l l a w a i t i n g s u r v e y r e t u r n s f o r t h e E n l i s t Now and t h e 1939 Royal T r a i n F l a g s , h e h a s o n l y r ece ived 12 s o f a r . F l e a s e keep him s u p p l i e d w i th Informat ion .

FLAGS AT THE CPSGB CONVENTION

The a n n u a l conventelon of t h e Canadian P h i l ~ t e l i c S o c i e t y of B r f t ~ i n was he ld in Sou tharnpt,on, England from 5 t h .-9 t h . Oc tobe r . T h r e e members o f t h e F l ag Cancel S t u d y Group were in a t t endance : - David S e s s i o n s , J lm McLaren and t h e e d l t o r . David

n p r e s e n t e d s s u p e r b d i s p l a y o f f l a g s whIch con t a ined many b e a u t i f u l c o v e r s and I r a r i t i e s . His d i s p l a y o f inver t en f l a g s was p a r t i c u l a r l y impress lve.

Page 2: THE FLAG POLE · THE ROYAL PURPLE Member 24, John G. Robertson, has sent in reports of purple Royal Train cance 1 la t ions on cards to On tar io postmasters. John has a card addressed

THE ROYAL PURPLE

Member 24 , John G . Robertson, h a s s e n t in r e p o r t s of pu rp le Royal Tra in cance 1 l a t ions on c a r d s t o On tar io pos tmas te r s .

,- : .

- John h a s a card addressed t o The Pos tmaster , New Germany, Ont. and ano the r addressed t o The Pos tmaster , Rydal Bank, Ont. Each b e a r s t h e French Tra in Royal Flag cancel Mai 15 , 3 A M in pu rp le on t h e f r o n t and on t h e back. The ca rd to Rydal Bank a l s o b e a r s t h e English Royal Tra in Flag cancel May 21, 5PM, in black.

In add i t ion John h a s a n unaddressed c a r d wi th t h e black Royal Tra in Flag f o r May 21 , 5PM with a pu rp le smudge on the back!

- Does any o t h e r member have any s f m i l a r cards? I s i t poss ib l e t h a t pu rp le c a n c e l l a t ions were used on t h e 2 1 s t . May?

Page 3: THE FLAG POLE · THE ROYAL PURPLE Member 24, John G. Robertson, has sent in reports of purple Royal Train cance 1 la t ions on cards to On tar io postmasters. John has a card addressed

- CROSS REFERENCED USAGES OF ENI.TST NOW FLAGS B,K AND L.

D A N E G. ROSENBLAT P L The Volume 1 No. 3 i s s u e o f t h e F l a g Pole g i v e s a v e r y comprehens ive r e v i e w o f

t h e En1 i s t Now F l a g c a n c e l l a t i o n s . T h i s c l e a r l y ind ica tes t h a t in mos t c a s e s e a c h o f t,ha f lng d i e s was used i n two o r more a d j a c e n t o f f ices on a r o t a t i o n a l b a s i s . The p e r i o d s o f u s e c a n be a r r a n g e d in g r o u p s in s u c h a way t h a t t h e t r a n s f e r s be tween o f f i c e s c a n b e i d e n t i f i e d .

A t p r e s e n t t h e r e is n o t enough r e c o r d e d u s e f o r a l l o f t h e d i e s to make p u b l i s h i n g a s a g r o u p o f i n t e r e s t . However In t h e c a s e o f d i e s B, K , and L , t h e s e q u e n c e s t h a t t h a t can be e s t a b l i s h e d o r e s t i m a t e d a r e r a t h e r f a s c i n a t i n g . Using them m e t e r i n l can b e a r r a n g e d by d i e s in each o f t h e i d e n t i f fed s h o r t time p e r i o d s , r a t h e r than Jn s e q u e n c e f o r e a c h o f f i c e o v e r t h e e n t i r e p e r i o d o f u s e in a n p e r t lcu l a r o f f i c e . T h u s es t a b 1 i sh ing t h e i n t e r e s t i n g i n t e r c h a n g e s o f t h e same d i e b e tween a d j a c e n t o f f ices.

The d a t e s o v e r l e a f a r e t h o s e p r o v i d e d by Dan w i t h t h e e x c e p t ion o f t h o s e marked ""' which a r e in t h e e d i t o r ' s c o l l e c t i o n .

I The Connecticut Web t; Backle Company, I I

Bridgeport, Conn.,

Die B, T o r o n t o 1 0 t h . O c t o b e r 1941 , EKD o f s e v e n t h p e r i o d o f sage. S e e o v e r l e a f f o r d e t a i l s .

Page 4: THE FLAG POLE · THE ROYAL PURPLE Member 24, John G. Robertson, has sent in reports of purple Royal Train cance 1 la t ions on cards to On tar io postmasters. John has a card addressed

D i e B Universal Machine ? - The recorded usage s u g g e s t s a f r e q u e n t , though poss ib ly i r r e g u l a r , p a t t e rn of s h o r t pe r iod r o t a t ions 1 exchange of th is d i e be tween Toron t o and Ham i 1 ton dur ing the period between J u l y 30 1941 t o J u l y 6 1942. Recorded usage is s u f f i c i e n t t o iden t l f y 27 probable in terchanges s t r e g u l a r in t e rva l s . Both o f f i c e s used two hubs and the d i e s u f f e r e d two success ive s t a g e s of a break.

TORONTO USAGE HAMILTON USAGE

1 s t . JY30 - AU12 Unbroken hub I 2nd. AU14 - AU20 Unbroken hub I

3 r d . AU22 - AU25 Unbroken hub I1 AU26 - SP04 S t a g e 1 hub I1 4 t h . SP06 - SP12 S t a g e 1 hub I

5 t h . SP15 - SP27 S t a g e 1 hub I1 6 t h . OCOl - OC09 S t a g e 1 hub I

7 t h . OC1OV: - OC16 S t a g e 1 hub 11 OCl8 - OC24 S t a g e 2 hub I1 6 t h . OC28 - NO04 S t a g s 2 hub I

9 th . NO06 - NO20 S t a g e 2 hub I1 10 th . NO21 - NO28 S t a g e 2 hub I

11 th . N029" - DE09 S t a g e 2 hub I1 12th . DE15 - DE22 S t a g e 2 hub I

1 3 t h . DE27 - J A l O Stage 2 hub I 14 th . ' JA13 S t a g e 2 hub I1 JA14 - JA19 S t a g e 2 hub I

15 th . JA2i - FE04 S t a g e 2 hub I 16 th . FE05 - FE06 S t a g e 2 hub I FElO S t a g e 2 hub I1

1 7 t h . FE13 - FE25 S t a g e 2 hub I 18 th . MR06 S t a g e 2 hub I

19 th . MR08 - MR23 S t a g e 2 hub I1 20th . MR25 - APO1 S t a g e 2 hub I1

2 1 s t . AP02 - AP16 S t a g e 2 hub I 22nd. AP18 - AP24 S t a g e 2 hub I1

23rd . AP27 - MY07 S t a g e 2 hub 11 24 th . MY14 - MY20 S t a g e 2 hub I1

25 th . MY22 - JU04 S t a g e 2 hub I 26 th . JU06 - JU12 S t a g e 2 hub I1

27 th . JU15 - JY02 s t a g e 2 hub I 5'104 - JY06 S t a g e 2 hub 11

Page 5: THE FLAG POLE · THE ROYAL PURPLE Member 24, John G. Robertson, has sent in reports of purple Royal Train cance 1 la t ions on cards to On tar io postmasters. John has a card addressed

Die K P e r f e c t Machine

The recorded usage s u g g e s t s a f r equen t , though poss lbly i r r e g u l a r , p a t t e r n . o f .. s h o r t per iod r o t a t i o n a l exchange of t h i s d i e between Vancouver, V lc to r i a and New Westmjnster d u r i n g t h e per iod between August 4 1941 t o J u l y 6 1942. The recorded u s e in N e w Westmlnster i s cons iderably l e s s than t h a t of t h e o t h e r two o f f i ce s , s o a s t o prec lude an a t t e m p t t o number t h e usages , b u t t h e p a t t e r n i d e n t i f i e s p o s s i b l e inc l u s ions o r om lss ions.

V lc to r i a and New Westmins ter used only one hub, b u t Vancouver used fou r hubs wi th Die K.

VANCOUVER VICTOR IA NEW WESTM INSTER

AU04 - AU16 Hub I AU18 - AU21

AU31 - SP04 Hub I

S P O ~ H U ~ T I spoa - S P ~ 1 SPIS - s p i a

SP2 1 - SP27 Hub I1 OC07 - OCll OC16 - OC18

OC21 - OC24 Hub IT1 OC25 - OC29 Om i t t ed be tween Vic tor la l a t e Oct and Vancouver e a r l y Nov use?

F NO05 Hub I Omitted be tween Vancouver NO07 - NO10 Nov 5 and N. Westminster Nov 7 use?

I NO13 - NO17 Hub I1 N025"- NO29 Unrecorded e a r l y Dec use?

DEl 1 Hub I DE16 - DE17 Unrecorded l a t e Dec use?

Unrecorded l a t e Dec, e a r l y JA05 - J A 1 1 Unrecorded mid Jan use? Jan use?

JA21 - FE02 Hub IV FE06 FE05, r epor t ed , uncomf irmed

FE16 - FE22 Hub IV MR09 - MR13

MR28"- APOl Hub I1 AP09"- AP22

MY04 - MY1 1 Hub I JU03 - JU08 JU11 - JU16 -

Probably no l a t e June u s e JU22 - JY06 Probably l a s t use .

Die 0 repor t ed wi th Hub V from June 22.

m

Page 6: THE FLAG POLE · THE ROYAL PURPLE Member 24, John G. Robertson, has sent in reports of purple Royal Train cance 1 la t ions on cards to On tar io postmasters. John has a card addressed

Die L Perfect Machine ?

The recorded u s a g e s u g g e s t s a f r e q u e n t , t h o ~ ~ g h p o s s ill ly i r r e y u l a r , p a t t e r n of shor- t per lod r o t a t iona 1 i n t e r change of t h i s d l e be tween Mon tree 1, Quebec end T r o Is Rivlet-es d u r i n g t h e pe r t od August 4 1941 t o J u l y 4 1942 . The r e c o r d e d u s e of a l l . o f f i c e s 1s s u r f j c l en t t o a t t e m p t a numbered l i s t i n g of p r o b a b l e i n t e r c h a n g e s a t re 1s t i v e l y r e p l a r in t c r v a 1s d u r i n g t h e p e r iod.

MONTREAI.. QUEBEC TROIS R IV IERES

1s t . A l l 0 1 - AUOR HI.I~:, I 2nd. hU12 - hU16 Hub 7 3 r d . AU20 - AU2 1

4 t h . SP02 - SPlO Hub I1 5 t h . SP13 - SP18 Hub T 6 t h . SP22 - SP26

7 t h . OC02":- OC13 Hub IIT 8 th . OC17 - OC23 Hub I 9 t h . OC28 - OC31

1 0 t h . NO07 - NO17 Hub J 1 1 t h . NO17 - NO29 Hub I 12 th . DE03 - DE05 NO17 i s 1230 PM NO17 fs unconf lrmed,

la te everling use?

1 3 t h . DE15 - DElY Hub 1 1 4 t h . DE27- DE29 Hirb I1 1 5 t h . DE31 - JA07

1 6 t h . JA12 - JAl5 Hub IV 1 7 t h . JA23 - FE02 Hub I 1 8 t h . MR09 - MRlG JA13 - JA20 Hub I1 -

1 9 t h . MR17 - MR27 Hub V 2 0 t h . AP02 - AP08 Hub I 2 1 s t . APl l - AP14

22nd. AP21 - AP27 Hub VI 2 3 r d . MY02 - MY09 Hub I 2 4 t h . MY11 - MY18

2 5 t h . MY20 - MY28 Hub I1 2 6 t h . JU02 - JU04 Hub 1 2 7 t h . JUl 1 - JU17

2 8 t h . JU22 - JU26 Hub V I I JU29 - JY04 Hub I I I

Note t h a t w i th t h e excep t i on of t,he excep t i on o f t h e gap in Feb rua ry and e a r l y March, between s t a g e s 17 and 18, t h e r eco rdeed d a t e s a r e v e r y s y m m e t r i c a l and cons i s t e n t w i th a r e g l l l a r l y s chedu l ed i n t e r change a t s t a n d a r d in t e r v a 1s.

NEW MEMBERS

iJe a re pleased t o welcome 3 new members t o t h e group:-

30 Dick Lamb, Box 5 7 3 , K i t .chener, ON N2G 4A2.

3 1 John Tdlman, 8ox 7 0 Adelaide St.. P.O., To ron to , ON M5C 2H8.

32 Jim McLaren, 15 Murray P lace , Viewlands, P e r t h , S c o t l a n d , PHI IBP.

Page 7: THE FLAG POLE · THE ROYAL PURPLE Member 24, John G. Robertson, has sent in reports of purple Royal Train cance 1 la t ions on cards to On tar io postmasters. John has a card addressed

THANK YOU MR. PIKE!

By Doug Lingard

Introduction

Most of you may find this a rather strange heading for an article on the World war I Flag Cancels. However, as you read the article, your should find the title very appropriate.

In 1920, A. E. Pike of Buffalo, N . Y . , was the president of the International Postmark Society. On February 23rd, 1920, he wrote to the Postmaster General seeking a listing of the advertising postmarks that had been used up to that time in Canada. His closing paragraph reads as follows:

"We especially want a list of the cities, the slogans used, and the name of the cancelling machine. All of this may seem trivial to you but we assure you that the collecting of these has a very large following among intelligent people."

In response to this request, the purchasing agent for-the post office wrote Mr. Pike on March 2nd and provided him with a 5 page list of slogan cancels that had been used up to that time. These were mostly exhibition slogans but included the Buy War Savings Stamps and Victory Bond slogans that were issued

P in 1919. The reply did not mention either the 1917 or 1918 Flag Cancels. However, there was another 3 page listing of 50 1917 War Savings Certificates Flag Cancel dies in the same box as the Pike correspondence. This typed listing had been-.prepared by the Office of the Purchasing Agent on September 19th, 1918 and had hand written notes indicating the dates that-these dies had been sent out and returned to Ottawa. This listing was probably given to Mr. Pike also, as these £la2 cancels were included in his 20 page listing of early slogan cancels that appeared in the October 1922 edition of the Collectors' Digest. Ron Kitchen was kind enough to provide me with a copy of this listing which must surely be the first listing of Canadian slogan cancels. Incidently, all of the information on the other slogan cancels has been sent off to Jeff Switt, the Chairman of the Slogan Cancel Study Group.

As a result of Mr. Pike's request, we now have information as to when most of the 1917 flag cancel dies were sent out and returned to Ottawa. Even though the information appears to be fairly accurate regarding the issue and return dates, it does not indicate the dates that some of these dies were transferred from one office to another. Although the Canadian Postal Archives has some files on the slogans that were used from about 1929 to 1940 and 1950 until 1973, the staff can not locate the files covering the 1917, 1918,- 1927 and 1941 periods when flag cancels were used. It would appear that these files may have been destroyed. However, thanks to Mr. Pike we now have information on when most of the 1917 dies were issued and returned to Ottawa which narrows the potential period of use at the various sites.

It should also be noted that these 1917 flag cancels were one of the n contributing factors that eventually lead to the development of the Canadian

designed and manufactured Perfect Cancelling Machine. However, that is a story for another day.

Page 8: THE FLAG POLE · THE ROYAL PURPLE Member 24, John G. Robertson, has sent in reports of purple Royal Train cance 1 la t ions on cards to On tar io postmasters. John has a card addressed

Revised World War I Flag Cancel Listing

You will notice three additional columns compared to the listing published in the June 1987 edition of the Flag Pole.

Issue and Return Dates

The Issue and Returned Dates are taken from the hand written notes on the listing of these cancels that was in the box with the Pike correspondence. Although they generally seem accurate, I have put a question mark next to some dates that may be incorrect or were difficult to read. A question mark by itself indicates that no date was shown. A dash indicates that the die was sent to or received from another location and may not have been distributed from Ottawa. I had to reassign some of the Montreal issue dates as based on the recorded usage, it appears that there was a mix-up in assigning issue dates to the different dies. For instance, the hand written notes show the 22-1 as being issued on March 30th and the 28-1 as being issued on February 14th. Also, I suspect that the date shown for the Renfrew 36-4 is actually the date that the 24-2 was sent there. Since most of the dies were returned between the 9th and 17th of October, it would appear that most locations used their cancels until Saturday, October 6th. It is also interesting to see that some of the Toronto and Montreal dies were returned in October, even though they were not used after late spring or early summer. Perhaps these dies were damaged but not returned to Ottawa. Also, one must wonder if the first Charlottetown die might have been sent back to Ottawa for repairs and then transferred to Sherbrooke?

Reports/Inventorv Column

The Rep/Inv column indicates the number of collections that contain an example of the cancel and the total number of examples reported. The information is based on 18 study group reports, the Larry Walker collection which I recently purchased, the Victor Hayton collection which appeared in Bob Lee's Sale #48 and the Steinhart and Narabonne stock. Accordingly, the Rep column indicates the number of collections (maximum number 22) that contained an example of the item either on cover or piece. The Imr column shows the total number of covers and pieces reported. It should be mentioned that Ed Richardson's collection is not included so there are obviously some scarce items not included in the inventory count. Incase you are interested in the number of different cancels in the better collections, I have 75 of the 76 different cancels, and some other members have reported 69, 65, 51 and 49(2) different cancels respectively.

Valuations

You may fine some of the price changes startling. Although Ed Richardson valued some of the cancels such as the 23-15, 28-1, and 28-4 at $5.00 or less, they actually appear to be very scarce items. The prices have been revised to reflect the holdings.reported since the 22 reports should provide a good indication of the relative supply of these cancels. However, other factors were also considered such as the period of use, the number of collections containing an example and the original values assigned by Ed Richardson. You will notice that some cancels are valued differently even though similar inventories are reported. This is generally due to the fact that a greater portion of the total inventory is on piece. For instance, Type 31-1 had 12

Page 9: THE FLAG POLE · THE ROYAL PURPLE Member 24, John G. Robertson, has sent in reports of purple Royal Train cance 1 la t ions on cards to On tar io postmasters. John has a card addressed

covers and 7 pieces reported, while the Type 23-6 had 18 covers and 1 piece reported. Consequently, a higher value was placed on the 31-1 than the 23-6 even though the same inventory is shown. Also, the Edmonton cancels are valued lower than the other cancels as there is apparently a large holding (including all 3 Edmonton Flag Cancels) that is held by an Edmonton collector who is not a member of the study group. If this holding is ever sold, it would certainly lower the values of these cancels (including to some extent, the values shown in this issue of the Flag Pole).

Valuations of WWI Flap Cancels On Piece

In June 1987, I indicated that these cancels on piece were probably worth from 10% to 30% of the cover price. ThZs statement was due to the fact that these cancels are seldom offered on piece and there were no auction realizations available to use for establishing a value. However, over the past year, severa1,members have indicated that they would be pleased to acquire some of the scarcer material on piece in order to just get an example for their collections. In view of this feedback, I am now inclined to value pieces from 10% of the cover price for the very common cancels to 60% of the cover prices for the scarcer items (those valued over $50). Although I always felt that some of these WW1 cancels were very scarce, I never expected that so many of them (27 to be precise) would have fewer than 10 reported examples.

....

Condition

P. The values given are for clear impressions on covers or cards with the last 5 mm or so off the cover or card. Normally, a very fine full impression rates a premium as they are very uncommon while any item missing more than 5 mm should be discounted.

JAS. SIMMONDS, LIMTTED IY-Om=" 6 J O I O S I U QC

Cenenl Hnrd'u~are and Car* Goods

41 Upper Water Street, - HALIFAX

Messrs. J. & W. Jeaa,

ARICHAT, Nt8.

The values shown in the listing are for cancels of this quality. However, this particular item would be worth a small premium since it is also the LKD.

Page 10: THE FLAG POLE · THE ROYAL PURPLE Member 24, John G. Robertson, has sent in reports of purple Royal Train cance 1 la t ions on cards to On tar io postmasters. John has a card addressed

A very fine example of the scarce Winnipeg 23-15 cancel. This item would probably sell at a substantial premium over the value shown for the 23-15.

The EKD for the Type 21 Brandon Flag Cancel. Since it is also a complete impression, it is worth a substantial premium over the listed value.

I would like to thank the 18 members who submitted their reports and Alan Steinhart and Hank Narabonne for permitting me to record their stock of these cancels. Both dealers have some of the scarcer ones in stock. Ken Johnson of the Canadian Postal Archives deserves a special thanks as he suggested that I look in the box containing the Pike correspondence, just as I was about to pack it in for another year. Also, I must thank the Postal Archives for giving me access to these files and to Rich Toop for mentioning they existed.

Page 11: THE FLAG POLE · THE ROYAL PURPLE Member 24, John G. Robertson, has sent in reports of purple Royal Train cance 1 la t ions on cards to On tar io postmasters. John has a card addressed

REVISED LISTING OF 1917-1919 FLAG CANCELS

1917 WWL FLAG CANCELS

Location Issued EKD LKD Returned Re~/Inv Value

21-1 Brandon 04-14 (L) 09-27 10-15 5/8 $ 60 -2 Regina 02 - 12 02 - 16 04-11 - 7/9 - 60 -3 Halifax 02 - 07 02-20 (L) 10-08 10-12 20/68 5

22-1 Montreal 02-03 02-05 (L) 07-06 10-lo? 16/29 - 12

23-1 Calgary -2 Charlottetown I -3 Charlottetown I1 -4 Gananoque - 5 Lethbridge -6 London -7 Prince Rupert -8 Regina - 9 Sherbrooke -10 Sydney -11 Toronto I -12 Toronto I1 -13 Vancouver -14 Windsor -15 Winnipeg

02-28~~3 04-09 (S) 10-13 02 - 15 03-09 (R) - 04-14 10-05&) 10-13 05-05*(L),09-28 (R) 10-09

63-1b1~)10-03 10-13 02 - 22 04-23 (L) - 03-21 10 - 07 10-19 04-13 10-02 ? 04-03 (L) 10-02 10-11 04-02 10-09 10-13 02-23(L) 10-06 (L) 10-10 03-08 [q 05-31 (L) 10 -lo? 04-04 ,. 09-24 w w 10 - 17 03-20 t~-h\p-) 10 - 11 02-26 (S) 09-11 (S) 10-12

* Sessions early date of April 5 is an error, as die used in London until at least April 23. Reports of use earlier than May 5 required.

24-1 Hamilton 02-19 02-20 (L) 04-18 - 15/37 12 -2 Renfrew - 04-21 09-22 10 - 09 7/12 40

'brantf ord Kings ton Ottawa Port Arthur

01-31? 02-09 (L) 01-31? 02-36 (L) 01-31? 02-08 (S) 07 - 27 08 - 03

10-08 (L) 10-10 05 - 15 ? 05-18 (L) ? 10 - 02 10-17

Edmonton Victoria

- 04-09 02-13 02-19 (L)

10-05 (L) 10-16 04-03 (L) -

Saint John Toronto

02-08 02-13 02-05 02-06 (L)

10-06 @.) 10-09 05-31 (L) 10-lo?

28-1 Montreal 03 - 30 -2 Orillia 03-29 -3 Sault SteMarie 03-17 -4 Toronto 03 - 26

06 - 22 05-30 10-01 (L) 09-28 (R)

29-1 Vancouver - -2 Gananogue (error) 02-15 -3 Gananoque

04-23 (R) 02-23 02-28 (L)

10-10 (S) ?

04 - 04

30-1 Fort William % 03 - 26 -2 Kitchener 03-26 -3 New Westminster 03-26

04-03 03-28 (L) 04 - 02

31-1 Montreal 02 - 14 02-17 (L)

Page 12: THE FLAG POLE · THE ROYAL PURPLE Member 24, John G. Robertson, has sent in reports of purple Royal Train cance 1 la t ions on cards to On tar io postmasters. John has a card addressed

Location Issued EKD LKD Returned Rev/Inv Value

32-1 Quebec -2 St. Hyacinthe -3 Trois Rivieres

33-1 Vancouver -2 Victoria

34-1 Edmonton -2 Calgary -3 Guelph -4 Montreal -5 Toronto

35-1 Saskatoon -2 Brockville - 3 Fredericton -4 Medicine Hat -5 Moncton -6 Nelson -7 North Bay -8 Stratford -9 Winnipeg -10 Brandon

02-16 (L) 10-07 (L) 02-22 (L) 10-02 (L) 02-20 09-25 (L)

02-15 04-07 04-10 "'OdF" Q+w-a) 03-29 (L) 10-06 (L) 03-28 (R) 10-06 (L) 83-U 6 ~ y l ~ C \ 1 ~ - ~ 6 (L)

03-06 04- 1 9 ~ 3 03-01 03-26 04-06 (L) 04 - 04 03-27 03-14 (L) 04-16 03-04

10-08 (L) - 10-01 10-08 09-17 (L) 07 - 25 10-05 ..

09 - 27 04-06 10 - 08 - 04-02 (L)

* PO records show an Int'l Type 23 die rather than an Universal Type 35 die was sent to Saskatoon. If correct, die may have been forwarded to Regina as there is no record of Ottawa sending a second "HELP TO ...' die to Regina. -

36-1 Hamilton - 04-20 10-06 (L) 10-12. 8/6 3 - 5 - 2 Winnipeg 02 - 06 02-09 04-14 (L) - 16/30 15 -3 London - 04-25 10-05 (L) 10-09 12/32 - 12 -4 Renfrew 04 - 142 02 - 19 04-16 - 2/3 - 8 5

1918 WWL FIAG CANCELS

Location Issued EKD LKD Returned Rev/Inv Value

37-1 Charlottetown -2 Edmonton -3 Halifax -4 Montreal -5 Ottawa -6 Quebec -7 Regina -8 Saint John -9 Toronto -10 Vancouver -11 Winnipeg

10-31 10-29 10-22 (R) 10-30 10-20 (L) 10-23 (L) 10-22 10-26 (L) 10-19 10-24 (R) 10-22 (L)

38-1 Trots Rivieres ? 10-25 (R) 11-18 (L) ? 3/3 200*

* For a legible impression cancelling a stamp on the picture side of a post card. 7

The author would appreciate receiving comments on the above listing and reports of any new purchases of flag cancels with an inventory of less than 20 items.