the mechanics of memetics - digital methods · facebook pages: celebrate pride, gay right media,...

20
University of Amsterdam Summer School June-July 2015 Political Memes in a globalized world team: Bastiaan Baccarne, Angeles Briones, Stefan Baack, Emily Maemura, Janna Joceli, Peiqing Zhou, Humberto Ferreira. Facilitators: Cristel Kolopaking, Fernando van der Vlist, Jennifer Veldman THE MECHANICS OF MEMETICS

Upload: others

Post on 25-Jun-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: THE MECHANICS OF MEMETICS - Digital Methods · Facebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride,

University of AmsterdamSummer School June-July 2015

Political Memes in a globalized world

team: Bastiaan Baccarne, Angeles Briones, Stefan Baack, Emily Maemura, Janna Joceli, Peiqing Zhou, Humberto Ferreira.

Facilitators: Cristel Kolopaking, Fernando van der Vlist, Jennifer Veldman

THE MECHANICS OF MEMETICS

Page 2: THE MECHANICS OF MEMETICS - Digital Methods · Facebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride,

Research Question

How do memes act as an expression of socio-political orientation in terms of support or counter-reaction?

Page 3: THE MECHANICS OF MEMETICS - Digital Methods · Facebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride,

Methods1. Hashtag exploration to find pro-program and contra-program.

Result: definition of 2 positive and 2 negative hashtags.→ Tools: Instagram Scraper, Netvizz, Gephi.

2. Scraped memes from Facebook, Instagram using the defined hashtags.→ Tools: Instagram Scraper, Netvizz

3. Merge of data collection. → Excel, Gephi, R Studio

4. Cluster visualization of images and map the data.→ ImagePlot, Google Fusion Tables

5. Content analysis→ Gephi

Page 4: THE MECHANICS OF MEMETICS - Digital Methods · Facebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride,

Instagram query #lovewins

Page 5: THE MECHANICS OF MEMETICS - Digital Methods · Facebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride,

Instagram query

Page 6: THE MECHANICS OF MEMETICS - Digital Methods · Facebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride,

Query Design

Page 7: THE MECHANICS OF MEMETICS - Digital Methods · Facebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride,

Expansion of #lovewins reactions in Instagram

Page 8: THE MECHANICS OF MEMETICS - Digital Methods · Facebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride,

ImagePlotall images

Page 9: THE MECHANICS OF MEMETICS - Digital Methods · Facebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride,

imageplot

program anti-program

Page 10: THE MECHANICS OF MEMETICS - Digital Methods · Facebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride,

Findings1. Memetic reactions are supported by

existing cultural units.

Page 13: THE MECHANICS OF MEMETICS - Digital Methods · Facebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride,

Findings2. Mapping meme activity: can't compare quantities and countries; depends on the platform.

Page 14: THE MECHANICS OF MEMETICS - Digital Methods · Facebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride,

#jesuswins

Instagram Scraper Top 20 liked

#celebratepride

Page 15: THE MECHANICS OF MEMETICS - Digital Methods · Facebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride,

Positive reactions to #LoveWinsInstagram Scraper (#celebratepride) Top 20 liked

reaffirming religion

comments tension

celebrating cause

defending cause; asking for respect/no judgement

supporting cause

Page 16: THE MECHANICS OF MEMETICS - Digital Methods · Facebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride,

Instagram Scraper (n=60,000): #celebratepride (20,081), #goswins (5,229), #jesuswins (5,914), #loveloses (1,837)

love won

Negative reactions to #LoveWinsInstagram Scraper (#godwins, #jesuswins, #loveloses)

anti meme? red revolution

defending belief

community building (‘real’ believers)

jesus won

Page 17: THE MECHANICS OF MEMETICS - Digital Methods · Facebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride,

Facebook Pages EngagementNetvizz. Top engager for each page

Facebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride, Supporting Marriage Equality in OhioFacebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride, Supporting Marriage Equality in OhioFacebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride, Supporting Marriage Equality in Ohio

Facebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride, Supporting Marriage Equality in Ohio

Facebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride, Supporting Marriage Equality in Ohio

Page 18: THE MECHANICS OF MEMETICS - Digital Methods · Facebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride,

Conclusion

The expression of socio-political orientation becomes visible in the medium specific usage of the platforms Facebook and Instagram through:

- Images: Colours of Flag filters (Rainbow vs Red)- Hashtags: #Lovewins vs #Jesuswins / #RedRevolution- Comment space: autonomous function- Geo-Location: Trace origins of socio-political orientation

Page 19: THE MECHANICS OF MEMETICS - Digital Methods · Facebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride,

Questions?

Page 20: THE MECHANICS OF MEMETICS - Digital Methods · Facebook pages: Celebrate Pride, Gay Right Media, Love Is Love, Human Rights Commission, lesbian, Marriage Equality USA, Gay Pride,

Thanks