The Origin of Life

Darwin (1871):

"... in some warm little pond with all sorts of ammonia and phosphoric, - light, heat, electricity, etc. present, that a protein compound was chemically formed, ready to undergo still more complex changes, at the present day such matter would be instantly devoured, or absorbed, which would not have been the case before living creatures were formed."

The Origin of Life0. Definitions of Life.

I. Conditions for the “life-conditions”/ “Warm Little Pond” as we know it.Habitability.

II. Chemical evolutionExperiments (i.e. Miller,Urey 1953)Origin of the Building Blocks: amino acids, nucleotides, sugars, lipids.ChiralitySelf-Reproducing Sets of Molecules. Robustness of Life: Temperature, Pressure, Chemical Environment,….History (i.e. earliest signs of life & where)

III. First living systemsWhy RNA World?HypercyclesLife on surface, the pyrite-world

IV. From surface life to cellular lifeChemotonThe stochastic corrector

V. From RNA world to protein worldRNAs as enzymesAmino acids as cofactors

Definitions of Life.

Physically connected unit that has metabolism, can reproduce and evolve by natural selection.

Metabolism:

Thermodynamically open system

Makes complex molecules from simple monomers

Heredity/variability:

Balance between fidelity and variability

Unlimited possible combination needed

Definitions of Life.

As we know it, it will have:

Genetic Material

Metabolism

Cell membrane

More Earth centred still:

Carbon based

Necessitates presence of fluid water & solid core.

Stability for Billions of Years.

Creating a “Warm little Pond”

In the right kind of Universe

Creation of Stars with Planetary System

Long Term Stability of Planets in a Habitable Zone (HZ)

Right Kind of Star

Right Kind of Planet:

Size

Distance from Sun

Big Moon

No comet/meteor storm, i.e large outer planets.

Alternatives: Dark Side of Mercury like planet, Moons of Hot Giants, Hot vents anywhere powered by gravitational friction

B. Radiation i. O2/O2

ii. Chirality iii. H2O

C. Fluctuation in luminosity.

D. Seeing it

Methods for Searching for Extra-Solar PlanetsA. Perturbation of star path.• Q = (mp /M)(r/D) = (mp /D)(P/ M)2/3 = .5*10-8

• Q - amplitude (present resolution ~10-9)• mp - mass of planet - 1.9*1030 g.• M - mass of Star - 1.3*1033 g. • r - radius of orbit - 8.15*1011 m - 6 AU. • P - orbital period - 4332 days - 12 years.• D - distance from observer - 1016 m - 1prc.• Radial velocity v = 30 mp*sin(i)/(rM).5 = 3*10-4 km/sec.• Observation: Wobbling or Dobbler Effect.

• Present limit to DE : 0.5 m/s. Earth induces 10cm/s. Planet gets Rocky as Teams clash over small Worlds (2004) Science 305.382-

Konacki et al(2003) “An extrasolar planet that tranists the disk of its parent star” Nature 421. 507-

From http://exoplanets.org/massradiiframe.html and Annual Review Astro (2007) Udry

4.07.06:136 planetary systems, 172 planets, 18 multiple planet systems, 14 transiting

Statistics over Extrasolar Planets

• Clearly a trend towards smaller planets.

• Transiting planets additionally allows diameter and atmosphere measurements.

• Multiple planets - Keplerian system with many bodies constrained by stability requirements.

Robustness of Life - Ranges

Rothchild,L and Mancinelli (2001) Life in extreme environments. Nature 209.1092-, Sharma et al.(2002) “Microbial activities at GigaPascal pressueres” 295. 1514-

Temperature: Acidity:

Pressure:

>1200 atmospheres

Vacuum as spore, but reproducing at how low pressure?

Radiation:

D. Radiulans ~150.000*

Habitability. (Franck,2001)

Equilibrium Temperature

Te4 = (1-A)S/4 where A is albedo (the fraction reflected), S

the amount of solar insolation and is the Stefan-Boltzmann constant.

Important Climatic Factors Water C02

Tectonics

(Franck et al.,2001)

Escape velocity: Sqr(2GM/R) in Km/sec

Earth Moon Jupiter Sun 11.2 5.0 59.5 1800

The Atmosphere (Rampino & Caldeira,1994, Kasting & Catling,2003 & Alonso-Finn,1968)

Green House Effect (Celsius)Venus Earth Mars 4-500 50-60 7-10

Exobase – collision free: >500 km

Homopause – no turbulence: ~100 km

Density :4N(m/2kT)3/2 v2e -(mv*v/2kT)

m mass of particles, v velocity, k Boltzman's constant and N .1. Temperature proportional to kinetic energy of particles (mv2/2), 2. Velocity of particles increases roughly like square root of T.

3. Velocity of particle inversely proportional to weight of particles.

Climate simulations: http://vortex.bd.psu.edu/~williams/LExEn/table.html

Distribution from body of temperature T, h planck's constant, c velocity of light, wavelength, k Boltzman's constant and x = hc/kT.

(8k5T5/c4h4)*(x5/ex-1)

1. T*(peak ) = constant. 2. Total Energy : constant*T4

3. Redshifted Planck distribution becomes a planck distribution at another temperature.

Black body & Background radiation.

Habitability.Venus - No H2O = > no removal of CO2 from atmosphere by weathering.

Earth - The CO2 is tied up in CaCO3

Mars - Too low temperature & gravity, so no greenhouse developed. No tectonics=> no return of CO2 to atmosphere.

Continuously Habitable Zone - (CHZ)- Water for Billions of Years:

HZ: .95-1.37 AU CHZ:.95-1.15

Main Problem: The Sun's increasing luminosity means that the HZ should move out through the solar system.

S(t) = S0/(1-.38t/0) -4.5 Gyr < t < 4.77 (0 = 4.55 Gyr)

Right Kind of Star

Frank (2001) Naturwissenschaften and Kasting (1993)

• Smaller stars have very long life times, but narrow HZ

• Tidal lock creates interesting weather.

No comet/meteor storm.(from Thomas et al.,1997)

v - velocity (8-15 km/sec - max 70), m - mass ( example 1km about 1015 kg), g - constant (surface gravity, angle, meteor density) (Moon - 1.6*103kg s-1.67 m-2.13)m= g v-1.67 Di 3.80 Energy Released .5mv2

Categories of Bad Things. Evaporating the Oceans: 500 km 14km/s - 1500 km crater 1034 ergs. Imbrium type 3.8Gy: 1034 ergs - boil 40 m water, surface temp 150.

Craters

Giordano Bruno (Moon - 18.6.1178 - 110 km)“Suddenly the upper horn split into two. From the midpoint of this division a flaming torch sprang up, spewing out over considerable distance fire, hot coals and sparks. Meanwhile the body of the moon which was below writhed as if it was in anxiety ... and throbbed like a wounded snake”

Famous Craters3.8-4.1 GA 10 major (i.e. Imbrium) on Moon (>100 on Earth) Permian Extinction (225 Myr 120 km)Cambrian-Tertiary (Yukatan - 65 Myr - 10 km - D 180 km)Arizona (50 Kyr 1,2 km)Tunguska (30.6.1908) (60m stony meteorite, 10-20 MT)

The Earliest Fossils

Schopf et al.(2002) 3.45 Byr

Brasier et al. (2006) no proof earlier than 3.0 Byr

From Joyce, 2002

Creating Life in the “Warm little Pond”

Creating the Monomers

Making Polymers

Making Systems

1. Buildup of building blocks in solution.2. Formation of Coacervates.3. Heterotrophic.Problems.1. Low concentration of building blocks.2. Hydrolysis favoured.3. No reasonable pathway to the nucleotides.4. Chirality.

Oparin-Haldane (late 20s) (from Fenchel, 1998)

From Schopf,2002

The Building Blocks – The first experimentUrey, Miller 1953 – from Schopf, 2002 & Smith, Szathmary,1995

Schopf, 2002

1. Early atmosphere probably didn’t contain hydrogen H2. This reduces the production of organics.

2. Most polymers are unstable at high temperature. Does not replicate by themselves reliably, when longer than 40-60 units.

3. A non chiral system cannot select among mirrored versions of the same molecule.

Problems

Polymers (Joyce, 2002)

Chirality.

Biological Importance of Chirality: i. Is chirality a necessity for life? ii. Life will probably lead to chirality.

Questions: 1. How Many "quasi-independent" chiral decisions have been taken in Earth Life? (at least L-amino Acids & D-Sugars. By "quasi-independent" is meant that the molecules are not likely do have influenced each other.

From Mason, 1990

Chiral Forces - kinetic: Polarized light Magnetic fields. Thermodynamic reason for chirality:The Main Forces i. Gravity ii. Electro-Magnetic Force iii.Weak Interaction: involved in -decay. iv. Strong Interaction.

Symmetries T - Time C - Charge P - Parity (Space Mirroring)

The Fall of ParityFrom Mason,1990

A - substrateL (D) - enantiomeric moleculeP - product1: A + L (D) <--- k1,k-1 ---> 2L (2D)2: L + D --k2--> P

Frank (1953) DynamicsFrom Mason, 1990

Eew/kT = 10-17 eV. This corresponds to a tilt in direction of the favoured enantiomers of about 106 molecules if a mole (6.06 * 1023) is present. Simulation of a lake 1 km in diameter, 4 m deep with 10-2 M AA corresponding to 106 years. This will create a probability of 98% of the favoured enantiomer.

Frank Dynamics & The EW Interaction.(Kondepudi & Nelson, 1985 – from Mason,1990)

• 1990: More L-Valine than D-Valine

• Possibility of contamination great, since it is a biological amino acid.

• Racemization: 104 years at 50 C & 106 years at 0C.

• Much slower if the Hydrogen group is substituted with larger group.

• 1997: 4-9% Excess of L-form if H-> Larger group. Cause: Polarized

Synchronic Radiation from Stars.

Chirality in Murchison's Meteorite.

From Schopf, 2002

From biochemical molecules to biochemical systems

Made by Isvan Miklos

Error threshold

aN

aq

q

N

log

If q = 0.99, a = ½ , then N 69

This is too short for a complete genome!Solution: separation into many short sequence.But: reproduction rate will not be equal, one of them will spread.

q: probability that a nucleotide will be copied without errorN: length of the polymera: percentage of accurate copies

Solutions

Quasi species, Hyper cycle (Eigen, 1970)

Made by Isvan Miklos

Quasi Species & Hyper-cycles

Quasi Species: Strings can replicate giving a distribution around a more fit Master Sequence in case error is below a given threshhold.

Hypercycles: Families of replicating strings can enhance each others reproduction and outcompete “egoists”

1E

1E1E

2E

2E2E

3E3E

3E

4E4E

4E

: catalytic aid

: duplication

Made by Isvan Miklos

Selfish mutations in Hyper-cycles

1E

1E1E

1'E

1'E1'E

Made by Isvan Miklos

1E

1E1E

1'E

1'E1'E

Possible solutions: Spatial heterogeneitySpatial waves Surface life “pre-biotic pizza”Compartments (stochastic corrector)

Von Kiedrowski, from Burmeister.

Template

Making covalent bound: irreversible step

MonomersProduct

Minimal replication

More complex systems: Cross catalytic self replication

Monomers

Templates

Three starting materials: CCG, CG and G (A,B,C)

More complex systems

AC

BC

ABCAA

(Julius Rebek & von Kiedrowski)Replication: Autocatalysis with molecular recognition.

Dynamics No AC: A + B -> AB f([A],[B]) AC: A + B -> AB f([A][B][AB])

Test: Added Autocatalysis should accelerate output.

Examples von Kiedrowski (1986) - 6-RNA ligating 2 3-RNAs von Kiedrowski (1993) - 3- component self-replication.

Lee (1996) 32-peptide ligating 15mer & 17mer. Lee (1997) Peptide Hypercycle.

Self-replication.

Self-Reproducing Automata.

•Von Neumann mid 50s: “Universal Constructor. (published 1966 by Burks) CA

•Penrose & Penrose (1959) Self-Replicating Tiles

•Conway (1968) “Game of Life” CA

•Ganti (1970) The Chemoton

Penrose & Penrose (1959) from Smith & Szathmary,1995)

Chemoton: The Simplest Organism(Tibor Ganti, 1970, from Ganti, 1997)

Y – Waste, X – nutrient

V’ – monomer of genetic material, pVi – polymer

T’ – precursor of membranogenic molecule.

Ai’s – intermediates in metabolic cycle.

Metabolism generates: waste, membrane & genetic molecule.

The Chemoton has:

Metabolism

Heredity

Membrane

From RNA world to protein world

Fact: protein enzymes have better catalytic activity thanRNA enzymes have.

(20 amino acids vs. 4 nucleic acids)

But: Evolution is myopic: an event happening now wouldn’t be selected for just because it will turn out advantageous million years later

Therefore we need a plausible scenario

Recent + & - factors for frequency of life.

“+”: “-”:

Self replication easy

Self assembly easy

Many extrasolar planets

Hard to make proper polymerisation

No convincing scenario.

No testabilityIncreased Origin Research:

In preparation of future NASA expeditions.

The rise of nano biology.

The ability to simulate larger molecular systems

Summary of Origin of Life

I. Conditions for the “life-conditions”/ Warm Little Pond” as we know it. Habitability.

II. Given “life-conditions” how does life arise?

Experiments (i.e. Miller,Urey 1953)

Origin of the Building Blocks: amino acids, nucleotides, sugars, lipids. Self-Reproducing Sets of Molecules. Robustness of Life: Temperature, Pressure, Chemical Environment,….

History (i.e. earliest signs of life & where)

III. Life “as we know it” theorizing.

From biochemical molecules to biochemical systems.

The RNA World.

The origin of genetic code and protein enzymes

References: Books & WWWBooks(2001) Journals: “Astrobiology” & “International Journal of Astrobiology”

Bengtson ed. (1994) “Early Life on Earth” Nobel Symposium Very Good

Bennet et al.(2003) “Life in the Universe” Addison-Wesley A bit popular. Ignores the difficult problems. Pretty pictures

Brack, A. (ed.) (1998) “The Molecular Origins of Life” CUP

Cambridge Atlas of Astronomy (1995) CUP Great visual introduction to Astronomy - unfortunately on editions after 3rd.

Dick,S (1998) “Other Worlds” CUP Traces views on extra terrestrial life in literature and religions – surprisingly good.

Fenchel, T. et al. (1998) “Bacterial Biogeochemistry” 2nd Ed. Academic Press Ch.10 Good overview

Fenchel, T. et al. (2002) “Origins of Life and Early Evolution” OUP Good overview, not in depth about chemistry --> life transition

Ganti, T (1971, 2004) “Principle of Life” OUP

Lunine, J.(2003) Astrobiology - A Multidiciplinary Approach. Good all round text book. No detailed discussion of theories.

Mason, SF (1990) “Chemical Evolution” OUP Highly readable.

Maynard Smith,J & E.Szathmary (1995) “Major Transitions in Evolution.” Chapts.1-7 Excellent with focus on ideas.

Morowitz, H.(1992) “Beginings of Cellular Life.”

Schopf,W (ed.) (2002) “Origin of Life” California Good, basic – a bit old fashioned.

Sigmund, K.(1991) “Games of Life” Penguin chapt. 1 excellent introduction to self-reproducing automata

Thomas,P. et al. (eds)(1997) Comets and the Origin and Evolution of Life. Springer Good - somewhat specialized toward comets & “bad things”.

WWW

http://web99.arc.nasa.gov/abscon2/

http://nai.arc.nasa.gov/index.cfm

http://icarus.cornell.edu/

http://cca.arc.nasa.gov/

http://www.seti-inst.edu/Welcome.html

http://icarus.cornell.edu/journal/ToC/index.html

http://www.scripps.edu/skaggs/rebek/

http://www.gla.ac.uk/Project/originoflife/

http://www.issol.org/

http://exoplanets.org/

http://www.liebertpub.com/AST/default1.asp

http://vortex.bd.psu.edu/~williams/LExEn/table.html

http://www.ifa.hawaii.edu/UHNAI/ppv.htm

References: ArticlesArtificial Life vol 4.3 (1998) Special Issue on Self Replicating Automata.

Bailey,J. (2001) “Astronomical Sources of Circularly Polarized Light and the Origin of Homochirality” Origins of Life & Evolution of the Biosphere 31.167-183.

Czaran, T. & Szathmary, E. (2000) Coexistence of replicators in prebiotic evolution. In: Dieckmann, U., Law, R., Metz, J.A.J. (eds.) The geometry of ecological interactions: simplifying spatial complexity. HASA and Cambridge University Press. 2000 pp116-134.

Franck et al.(2001) “Planetary Habitability” Naturwissenschaften 88.416-426.

Ganti, T.(1997) “Biogenesis Itself” J.Theor.Biol.187.583-593

Joyce, GF (2002) “The antiquity of RNA-based evolution” Nature 418.214-221

Kasting, J & D. Catling (2003) “Evolution of a Habitable Planet” Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 41.429-63

Michael R Rampino and Ken Caldeira ”The Goldilocks Problem: Climatic Evolution and Long-Term Habitability of Terrestrial Planets” Annu. Rev. Astron. Astophys. 1994, Vol. 32: 83-114

Santos,NC,W.Benz and M. Mayor (2005)“Extrasolar Planets: Constraints for Planet Formation Models” Science 310.251-5.

Scyba, CF and KP Hand (2005) “Astrobiology: The Study of the Living Universe” Nnu.Rev.Astron.Astrophys. 43.31-74

Szathmary, E (1999) The origin of the genetic code: amino acids as cofactors in an RNA world. Trends in Genetics, 15(6).223-229 .

Szostak,J et al.(2001) “Synthesizing life” Nature 409.387-390.

Shostak, GS (2003) “ Searching for sentience: SETI today” International Journal of Astrobiology 2.2.111-4

Zintzaras, E., Santos, M., Szathmary, E. (2002) “Living” under the challenge of information decay: the

stochastic corrector model vs. hypercycles. J. theor. Biol. 217.167-181.

1809 Haüy postulates isomophism between molecular shape and crystal shape.

1848 Pasteur surmises that the ability to rotate polarized light is related to chirality (handedness).

1853. Pasteur: Molecules with more chiral units lack mirror superimposability.

1858. Pasteur: Penicillum metabolizes + tartrate isomer, leaving - isomer behind.

1874 Le Bell & van't Hoff relates chirality to the 4 bonds in the carbon atom.

1880s Plants rotated to give reverse movement of sun, hoping that it would produce other enantiomers.

1929 First enantio-selective photolysis of racemic (cluster of grapes) mixture by Kuhn.

1953: Frank's Open Flow Reactor.

1953 - Urey-Miller experiments

1956: The Fall of Parity

1959 - Cocconi and Morrison proposed radio search for civilizations elsewhere

1960 - Drake publishes his famous/infamous equation for probability of intelligent life

1966 - von Neumann posthumously publishes the manuscript on self-replicating automata

1971 Ganti publishes his “Principles of Life” with the Chemoton

1977: Chiral production of L-alanine by polarized UV-light.

1977 Viking Experiments

1985: Kondepudi & Nelson combines neutral electroweak currents with Frank Dynamics.

1990: Chirality in Murchisons Meteorite of biological Amino Acids

1997: Chirality in Murchisons Meteorite of non-biological AAs.

History of Origin of Life Research