the origins of the embodied self

8/13/2019 The Origins of the Embodied Self

1/24

The Origins of the Embodied Self:

Parental Embodied Mentalising

Dana Shai, Ph.D.

[email protected]


2/24

Mentalisation

!"#$"%&%'() +',"#-./',%'() /', %'."#!#"0'( /$01'-23"4/&%1+#- %' ."#5- 16 %'."'01'/7 5"'./7 -./."-

8"4/&%1+# !#",%$./37" /', 5"/'%'(6+7 9:"$. #"(+7/01' /', -"76;1#(/'%-/01'

#151."- -"$+#" /=/$45"'.?@1'/(A) B"#("7A) C+#%-.) D E/#(".) FGGFH @1'/(A) B"#("7A) D E/#(".) FGGIJ

22


3/24

Empirical Findings

K >/#"'./7 5"'./7%-%'( /', /=/$45"'. -"$+#%.A9#'1= D L"%'-) FGGIH @1'/(A) M.""7") D M.""7") NOONH L"%'-) @"#'A41+(4) @#/,7"A) D E+$P"A) FGGNH M7/,")8"#'3/$4) B#%"'"'3"#("#) Q147("5+.4 R"&A) D R1$P"#) FGGS

K


4/24

Measuring Parental Mentalising

>/#"'./7 U@ ; >]^?M7/,") FGGF) FGGSH M7/,") 8"#'3/$4) B#%"'"'3"#("#) R"&A) D R1$P"#) FGG[J

^'-%(4_+7'"-- 9--"--5"'.?`!!"'4"%5) X1#"';X/#%") D M/(%) FGGNJ

L%',;L%',",'"--

?L"%'- NOOI) NOOOJ

4


5/24

Verbal Parental Mentalising

U@ %'%0/77A +-", %'."#$4/'("/37A a%.45"'./7%-/01'

b!"# %#&' () *#&+ %, %"# !"#$%&!'%()*%&!',*%"# -+./",0,12/30 -&,/#++#+ 456#&0.251 %"#/3-3/2%. %, '#5%302+#7?@1'/(A ". /7W) FGGF) !W F[J

8() 2+ 35 !+#$, .%')/#*,%&!'9 25 '%$$%&+#9 ,*35 2562:26430;+ '#5%302+251 /3-3/2%.7 ?M7/,") FGGS) !W FcOJ

55


6/24

Intermediate Summary

NW8A 1'" A"/# 16 /(" .4" %'6/'. 4/- "-./37%-4", /' ^QL 16 .4"/=/$45"'. #"7/01'-4%! a%.4 !#%5/#A $/#"(%&"#

FW >/#"'./7 5"'./7%-%'( !#",%$.- .4%- /=/$45"'. -"$+#%.A#"!#"-"'./01' 16 .4" $4%7, /', 1.4"# ,"&"71!5"'./7 1+.$15"-

\W >/#"'./7 5"'./7%-%'( %- 5"/-+#", .1 ,/." -17"7A &%/ &"#3/7/--"--5"'.-

[W Q" $/' $1561#./37A /--+5" .4/. &"#A A1+'( $4%7,#"' $/''1.$15!#"4"', .4" -+3.7"0"- 16 .4" $1'."'. 16 -!""$4 16 !/#"'.-a4"' ./7P%'( .1 1# /31+. .4"5

66


7/24

BUT

Q4/. %- .4" !#"&"#3/7 $4%7,T- #


8/24

Nonverbal Developmental Research

eA";$1'./$.2 (/Y" !/="#'-?8""3") FGGGH 8""3" D R/$45/'') NOOVH @1("7) NOO\H C/:" D @"7,-."%') NOIGH E#"&/#.4"') NOIOJ

h1$/7 #4A.45-?8""3") C/:") R/$45/'') @"7,-."%') /!1+i"P D >/!1+i"P) NOVIJ

j"/, 51&"5"'.- ?8""3" D M."#') NOII) 8""3" ". /7W) FGNGH C/:" ". /7W) FGGNJ

Q4"#" a417" 31,A k "%.4"# $/."(1#%$/72,%-$#"."1# '1. ,A/,%$

88


9/24

Parental Embodied Mentalising

U"$1'$"!.+/7%-%'( !/#"'./7 5"'./7%-%'(Z1';,"$7/#/0&") %5!7%$%.) 1+. 16 /a/#"'"--9 a/A 16 P'1a%'( .4#1+(4 .4" 31,A

^'&"-0(/01' .4#1+(4 .4" P%'/"-.4"0$ 7"'- M+3.7" 51&"5"'. l+/7%0"- ; m",=T #/.4"# .4/'

m="3%TH .4" +"36#) '1. .4" /,0,4&

^'."'01'/7 5"'./7 -./."- /- a417";31,AP%'/"-.4"0$ 5/'%6"-./01'-

99


10/24

Parental Embodied Mentalising (PEM): Definition

NW E4" $/!/$%.A .1 %5!7%$%.7A $1'$"%&") $15!#"4"',) /',

"f.#/!17/." .4" %'6/'.n- 5"'./7 -./."- 6#15 .4"

%'6/'.T- =",0#>?,6. @253#+%"#A/ #


11/24

Theoretical Background of PEM

E4" 31,%7A -"76 ?@#"+,) NOF\J E4" %',a"77%'( 16 .4" !-A$4" %' .4" -15/

?Q%''%$1=) NOSc) NOcG) NOcFJ

L%', p >-A$4" q M15/ ?Q%''%$1=) NO[O) NOVVJ

MP%' "(1 M"$1',/#A -P%'?8%$P) NOcVH 9'Y%"+) NOVOH L$]1+(/77) NOVOH (,"') NOVOH E+-0') NOOFJW

L1.1#%$ "(1


12/24

Relational approach to PEM

012#$# )* '! *342 ,2)'5 %* % 6!789 ,2#$# )* !'(8 % 6!78 )'$#(%&!'*2)" :),2 %'!,2#$ 6!78;

?`#3/$4) FGG[) !W FVJ

U"7/01'/7 ,%/7"$0$ 31,%7A -"76 ?9#1') NOOVH Q4%.") FGG[H Q%''%$1=) NOcFJ MA-."5- .4"1#A ?"W(W) @1("7) NOO\H M/',"#) NOIIJ E4" 31,A /- / 3%,%#"$01'/7 !7/_1#5 16 #"7/01'/7

"f!"#%"'$"-

e531,%", 9=/$45"'.

12


13/24

Vitality Affects

8C35. D4302A#+ ,* *##0251 %"3% ,//4& 6, 5,% E% 25%, ,4& ##4,* 6#/!$# ), )* % :!$(7 !//!$.%( %4,*? JK%#&59 LMNO9 --B OP>OQRB

13


14/24

PEM Construct- Premises

NW L"'./7 -./."- $/') /', /#") "f!#"--", 31,%7A /',P%'/"-.4"0$/77A

FW `'"T- %'."#!#"./01' 16 .4" P%'/"-.4"0$ %'$%,"'.- 16/'1.4"# /- "f!#"--%1'- 16 5"'./7 -./."- ("'"#/."- /

$4/'(" %' .4" 51&"5"'. 16 .4" 1'" 13-"#&%'( 1#

%'."#/$0'( a%.4 .4" 51&"#

\W E4" ,"(#"" .1 a4%$4 / !/#"'. $/' %'."#!#". .4" %'6/'.T-P%'/"-.4"0$ 1$$+##"'$"- /- 5"'./7%-0$ %'$%,"'.-) /',

/- / #"-+7. #"-!1', .1 .4"5 P%'"-.4"0$/77A) $/' -"#&" /-/' /--"--5"'. 16 !/#"'./7 5"'./7%-/01'W

1414


15/24

Measuring PEM

U11.", %' L1&"5"'. 9'/7A-%- !/#/,%(5-?"W(W X"-."'3"#() NOcI) NOISH R/3/' D U1,) NOISH M4/4/#;R"&%) FGG[J

9' 13-"#&/01'/7 ,A/,%$ 5"/-+#" @1$+- 1' P%'/"-.4"0$ /', #4A.45%$ "f!#"--%1'-

16 %'."'01'/7%.A

e531,%", $%#$7"- 16 #+!.+#" /', #"!/%#?"W(W) 8"'o/5%') NOOVH B#""'-!/' D Q%","#) NOOIHE#1'%$P) NOVOJ

1515


16/24

PEM coding System

`3-"#&/01'/7 Z1 &"#3/7 %'!+. p m5+."T 51," 9'/7A-%- +'%. k e531,%",


17/24

Kinaesthetic Qualities

0$!1)"! 2("3 ?,%-.#"-- &-W $1561#.J 0$.4"?,"(#"" 16 "f$%./01'J 5)%$+,"!'()*6 ?!7"/-+#" &-W ,%-!7"/-+#"J 7'*83'61 ?"f"$+0'( %'."'.J 94'+$ ?-"76 /', %'."#!"#-1'/7 31+',/#%"-J 98):)!; ?5/'/(%'( $4/'("J

1717


18/24

PEM ECC Types

.&"?)$? 9/44"%*

/W j17,%'(

3W M$+7!0'(

@= A"?6 B3!$%18)4

/W @/$%7%./0'( /:"$. #"(+7/01'

3W 81,A 5/'%!+7/01'

$W 81,A -05+7/01'C= 0%'!1),"!1

D= 7%".",!; >E4("%',"!


19/24

Study Design

NSG ,A/,- 6#15 .4" Z^


20/24

Main findings

B713/7 >eL -$1#"- $1##"7/.", a%.4 j`Le 5/."#'/7-"'-%0&%.A ?&?N[VJ p W\\rrrJ

B713/7 >eL -$1#"- !#",%$.", -"$+#" h-W %'-"$+#"/=/$45"'. -"$+#%.A !F?S) ZpNSGJ p [WGIr

M!"$%s$/77A -"$+#" h-W /&1%,/'. %'6/'.- !F?\) ZpNGGJ p SWVOrr


21/24

Main findings

B713/7 >eL M$1#"-) e


22/24

Main findings

ultinomial Logistic Regression Predicting Attachment from ECC Mean Length

Avoidant (A) Resistant (C)

Model and Predictor Variable

Maternal Sensitivity Not Controlled

ECC Type 1.06*** .17

ECC Length 1.19** 1.13

Global PEM .41*** .59

Maternal Sensitivity Controlled

ECC Type .11*** .19**

ECC Length1.18** 1.12

Global PEM .50* .69

Maternal sensitivity.84 .87


23/24


24/24

Thank you!

2424

the origins of the embodied self

Documents