the paradigm shift: migrating from teacher-centered to student-centered instruction & learning
DESCRIPTION
The paradigmatic shift from a teacher-centered learning environment to a student-centered one is not an easy transition; and, does not occur effortlessly. What is student-centered learning? Necessary areas of change. Strategies for the shift. Positive outcomes. The paradigm shift. What changed? Teacher-centered vs. learning-centered instruction. 8 steps in the change process. Instructor concerns. Measurable objectives. Agent for change. Action plan.TRANSCRIPT
The Paradigm Shift: Migrating from Teacher-Centered to
Student-Centered Instruction & Learning
Milisa Sammaciccia Ismail, MEd.
24 October 2011
The significant problems we face cannot be solved
at the same level of thinking we were at when
we created them.
~ Albert Einstein
Problem
The paradigmatic shift from a teacher-centered learning environment to student-centered:• Is not an easy transition• Does not occur effortlessly
What is Student-Centered Learning? Information and content is relevant and
interesting to students. Content is built to expand on their current
knowledge base. Focuses on the student rather than the
transmission of information. Students can experiment with their learning. Learning is more meaningful. Students are more engaged. Learning is deeper and long-term.
Necessary Areas of Change
The balance of power
The function of content
The role of the teacher
The responsibility for learning
The purpose and processes of evaluation
Strategies for the Shift
Active involvement
Social Integration
Self-Reflection
Personal Validation
Positive Outcomes
Deep learning
Intrinsic Motivation
Student Retention
The Paradigm Shift
Two AAHE national conferences 12 years apart revealed a clear shift in higher education focus:
1986: Taking Teaching Seriously
1998: Taking Learning Seriously
What Changed? Instruction Shifted:
• From: Teacher-centered/Content-driven• To: Learner-centered/Process-driven
Student Role Shifted:• From: Passive recipient/empty receptacle• To: Engaged learner and active agents
Instructor Role Shifted:• From: Disseminator of factual information• To: Facilitator/Learner mediator
Teaching-Centered vs.
Learning-Centered Instruction Teaching Goals
• TCI: Covers discipline• LCI: Students learn -
– How to use the discipline– How to integrate disciplines to solve complex
problems– An array of core learning objectives
Organization of Curriculum• TCI: Courses in the catalog• LCI: Cohesive program with systematically created
opportunities to - – Synthesize– Practice– Develop increasingly complex ideas, skills & values
Teaching-Centered vs.
Learning-Centered Instruction Core Structure
• TCI: Faculty covers topics• LCI: Students master learning objectives
How Students Learn• TCI: Listening, reading, independent learning, often
in competition for grades• LCI: (1) Students construct knowledge by
integrating new learning into current knowledge. (2) Learning is viewed as a cognitive & social act.
Pedagogy• TCI: Based on delivery of information.• LCI: Based on engagement of students.
Teaching-Centered vs.
Learning-Centered Instruction Course Delivery
• TCI: Lecture, assignments & exams for summative purposes.
• LCI: Active learning, assignments for formative purposes, collaborative learning, community service learning, cooperative learning, self-directed learning, problem-based learning.
Course Grading• TCI: Faculty as gatekeepers. Normal distribution
expected.• LCI: Grades indicate mastery of learning objectives.
Teaching-Centered vs.
Learning-Centered Instruction
Faculty Role• TCI: Sage on the stage.• LCI: Designer of learning environments.
Effective Teaching• TCI: Teach (present information) well and those
who can, will learn. • LCI: Engage students in their learning. Help all
students master learning objectives. Use classroom assessment to improve courses. Use program assessment to improve the program.
8 Steps in the Change Process
1. Shock
2. Denial
3. Strong Emotion
4. Resistance & Withdrawal
5. Surrender & Acceptance
6. Struggle & Exploration
7. Return of Confidence
8. Integration & Success
Instructor Concerns1. Spending time on active learning does not
allow for syllabus coverage.
2. Lack of lecture means loss of control.
3. Students do not understand reading material when independent.
4. Students do not understand open-ended problems vs. finding the right answer.
5. Group work resistance.
6. Cooperative teams are superficially working on assignments & lack of participation from all group members.
Measurable Objectives Objectives should be specific & measurable.
Objectives should be focused on the student. Effective objectives encompass:
• Behavior• Performance• Understanding
Objective should complete the statement: “The student will be able to…”
Should be aligned with level of learning:• Knowledge• Comprehension• Application• Analysis• Synthesis• Evaluation
Agents for Change
Instructor• How do they view their role?• At what levels are they willing to accept change?• Teaching does not bring about learning• Only learners can control their own learning
Professional development• Development of skills• Enhancement of current skills• Collaboration on instructional strategies
Action Plan
Step 1: Assessment of Applicability• Discipline• Class size• Subject within the discipline• Room layout• Environmental factors for the room• Teacher personality• Classroom dynamics (Weimer, 2002, para. 4)
Step 2: Strategy Suggestions• Active Learning• Cooperative Learning
Action Plan Step 2 continued…
• Inductive teaching & learning– Inquiry-based learning– Case-based instruction– Problem-based learning– Project-based learning– Discovery learning– Just-In-Time learning
Timeline to Implementation• Syllabus: students should have direct input in creation.• First Day/Week of Class:
– Discuss the climate– Open discussion about previous experiences in
classes
Action Plan Timeline continued…
– Decisions are made about which assignments to tackle & due dates.
– Short essay about why the student is taking the course, what they hope to learn and content.
– Prioritize list of skills to be successful• Class Structure
– Promote self-awareness with content– Use short activities often– Utilize learning center staff– Use supplementary materials– Teach students how to study the textbook– Let students summarize– Have students collaborate on what makes a group successful– Have students provide examples
Action Plan• Class Structure continued…
– Write concepts on the board during discussions and make connections through illustration.
– Use matrices and concept mapping.• Assignments
– Students discuss details of assignments. – Make them interactive.– Students self-assess their work prior to submission.– Allow time for students to discuss progress during process.– Allow time for debriefing.
• Assessments– Should be linked to content.– Can be negotiated but must be specific.– Various forms of assessment can be used:
» Peer assessment» Group assessment» Expert assessment
Action Plan
• Feedback– Solicit feedback early and often.– Students should complete a start, stop & continue feedback
sheet on the class.– Use questions to solicit feedback.– Ask students questions.
Conclusion Both instructors and students can feel overwhelmed by the process. With proper application, skill and familiarity, SCI may change:
• The way students learn; and,• The way teachers teach• The very nature of higher education
Lecture method is still the dominant pedagogical strategy• Research has proven its ineffectiveness
Promoting higher learning outcomes is at the core Overestimating students’ cognitive involvement during lecture has
been one of the major illusions for instructors. Proper implementation brings an increase in motivation. Diverse learning needs are met. Not just a short-term fix but has demonstrated long-term results.
“Effective teaching strategies begin with realizing that there are multiple pathways to learning. Frequent and
careful assessment aligned with observation determines the direction taken for optimal learning. Respect for all learners takes place. Varying
teaching styles within a student-centered environment maximizes
educational effectiveness.”
~ Mary Rose
RESOURCESCuseo, J. (n.d.). The case for learner-centered education. Unpublished raw data,
Psychology Department, Marymount College, Rancho Palos Verdes, CA. Retrieved from http://www.oncourseworkshop.com/Miscellaneous018.htm
Felder, R. (2011). Student-centered teaching and learning. Unpublished raw data, Engineering Department, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC. Retrieved from http://www4.ncsu.edu/unity/lockers/users/f/felder/public/Student-Centered.html
Felder, R., & Brent, R. (1996). Navigating the bumpy road to student-centered instruction. Informally published manuscript, School of Education, East Carolina University, Greenville, NC. Retrieved from http://www4.ncsu.edu/unity/lockers/users/f/felder/public/Papers/Resist.html
Freire, P. (1970). Pedagogy of the oppressed. New York, NY: Herder & Herder.
Huba. , & Freed, (2000). Teacher-centered vs. student-centered paradigms . Unpublished raw data, University of Connecticut, Storrs, CT. Retrieved from http://assessment.uconn.edu/docs/TeacherCenteredVsLearnerCenteredParadigms.pdf
Mandernach, B. (2003). Writing quality learning objectives. Retrieved from http://www.park.edu/cetl2/quicktips/writinglearningobj.html
Rose, M. (2008). Differentiation. Teacher Scholastic, 1(3). Retrieved from http://www.eht.k12.nj.us/~jonesj/differentiated%20instruction/Newsletter%203%20proofed.pdf
RESOURCESSer Professor Universitario. (2011). 33 ways to make your classroom more learner-
centered. Retrieved from http://serprofessoruniversitario.pro.br/m%C3%B3dulos/m%C3%A9todos-de-ensino/33-ways-make-your-classroom-more-learner-centered
Using student centered language to conceptualize learning objectives. (2011). Unpublished raw data, Saint Peter's College, Jersey City, NJ. Retrieved from http://www.spc.edu/pages/2873.asp
Weimer, M. (2002). Learner-centered teaching: five key changes to practice. San Francisco, CA.: Jossey-Bass. Retrieved from http://www.amazon.com/Learner-Centered-Teaching-Five-Changes-Practice/dp/0787956465/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1253296206&sr=8-1