the representation of islam in e,m. forster'sa passage to ... · the representation of islam...

29
JKAU: Arrs & Hunumities. \'01. 9, pp, 37-65 11416 A.H. I 1996 A.D.) The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster's A Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS Department of European Languages & Literature, Faculty of Arts and Humanities, King Abdulazi: University, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia ABSTRACT. The paper attempts to trace the ways Islam is represented in Forster's A Passage to India to see whether Forster's method of representation is in conformity with preconceived ideas that portray Islam in a negative light or there is an attempt to depart from the norm. The paper argues Islam, as it existed in India under British rule, is more represented as a culture. required to give individualsa sense of social belonging. rather than a religion that such individuals are bound 10 practice. The ways Forster deals with various Islamic practices, such as the veil. reveal his views of Islam. He sees the veil as a so- cial convention rather than a religious obligation. He also regards other prac- tices as remnants of the past that do not tit into the present, and for that Aziz eventually has to reject the practicality of Islam, While the novelist traces the fading phases of a practical religion reflectedin the diffusion of its adhan and in Forster's imposition of a secular stand, the paper argues that, contrary to Forster's expectation Islam is dying out. it is becoming more forceful due to the current spirit of revival, The West has to deal with lslarn now in a way that differs from the past. That will require a faithful look at methods of repre- sentation of Islam by Muslims themselves first and Westerners 100. The paper therefore sees correct representation of Islam as one of the means to remove misconceptions. eliminate threat and build bridges of communication between Islam and the West . Introduction This paper attempts to shed light on E.M. Forster's conception of Islam in A Passage to India. It seeks to trace the different ways Islam is represented as part of a culture and as a religion. Culture in this case refers to the pattern of life within the Indian community'. It comprises systems of shared ideas, concepts, rules and meanings/. The objecti ve be- hind the exploration of the above is to see whether Forster's representation of Islam is in conformity with stereotypical notions and preconceived ideas which can be traced to the medieval polemic tradition or whether his conceptions show a divorce from the norm and an earnest attempt to understand Islam in a new light away from the prevalent 37

Upload: others

Post on 03-Apr-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&

JKAU: Arrs & Hunumities. \'01. 9, pp, 37-65 11416 A.H. I 1996A.D. )

The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India

OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS

Department ofEuropean Languages & Literature, Faculty ofArts and Humanities,King Abdulazi: University, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia

ABSTRACT. The paper attempts to trace the ways Islam is represented in

Forster's A Passage to India to see whether Forster's method of representation

is in conformity with preconceived ideas that portray Islam in a negative lightor there is an attempt to depart from the norm. The paper argues th~t Islam, as

it existed in India under British rule, is more represented as a culture. requiredto give individualsa sense of social belonging. rather than a religion that such

individuals are bound 10 practice. The ways Forster deals with various Islamic

practices, such as the veil. reveal his views of Islam. He sees the veil as a so­cial convention rather than a religious obligation . He also regards other prac­tices as remnants of the past that do not tit into the present, and for that Azizeventually has to reject the practicality of Islam, While the novelist traces thefading phases of a practical religion reflectedin the diffusion of its adhan andin Forster's imposition of a secular stand, the paper argues that , contrary toForster's expectation Ih~1 Islam is dying out. it is becoming more forceful dueto the current spirit of revival, The West has to deal with lslarn now in a waythat differs from the past. That will require a faithful look at methods of repre­sentation of Islam by Muslims themselves first and Westerners 100. The papertherefore sees correct representation of Islam as one of the means to removemisconceptions. eliminate threat and build bridges of communication between

Islam and the West .

Introduction

This paper attempts to shed light on E.M. Forster's conception of Islam in A Passage to

India. It seeks to trace the different ways Islam is represented as part of a culture and asa religion. Culture in this case refers to the pattern of life within the Indian community'.It comprises systems of shared ideas, concepts, rules and meanings/. The objecti ve be­hind the exploration of the above is to see whether Forster's representation of Islam isin conformity with stereotypical notions and preconceived ideas which can be traced tothe medieval polemic tradition or whether his conceptions show a divorce from thenorm and an earnest attempt to understand Islam in a new light away from the prevalent

37

Page 2: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 3: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 4: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 5: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 6: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 7: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 8: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 9: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 10: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 11: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 12: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 13: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 14: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 15: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 16: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 17: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 18: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 19: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 20: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 21: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 22: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 23: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 24: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 25: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 26: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 27: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 28: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&
Page 29: The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to ... · The Representation of Islam in E,M. Forster'sA Passage to India OMAR ABDULLAH BAGABAS DepartmentofEuropean Languages&