these phung version finale corrigee

8/6/2019 These PHUNG Version Finale Corrigee

1/144

INSTITUT NATIONAL POLYTECHNIQUE DE GRENOBLE

N attribu parla bibliothque|__|__|__|__|__|__|__|__|__|__|

T H E S E

pour obtenir le grade de

DOCTEUR DE LINPG

Spcialit : Gnie Electrique

prpare au Laboratoire dElectrotechnique de Grenobledans le cadre de lEcole Doctorale Electronique, Electrotechnique, Automatique,

Tlcommunication et Signal

prsente et soutenue publiquement

par

PHUNG Anh Tuan

le 28 Septembre 2006

Titre :

DVELOPPEMENT DE FORMULATIONS LECTROMAGNTIQUES LMENTS FINIS 3D POUR LAMODLISATION DES DISPOSITIFS EN FRQUENCE LEVE

Directeurs de thse :

MEUNIER GrardCHADEBEC Olivier

KERADEC Jean-Pierre

JURY

M. NICOLAS Alain , Prsident et RapporteurM. PIRIOU Francis , RapporteurM. CHADEBEC Olivier , Co-Directeur de thseM. KERADEC Jean-Pierre , Co-Directeur de thseM. MEUNIER Grard , Directeur de thseM. LEFLOCH Yann , ExaminateurM. STEPHAN Herv , Examinateur
http://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/


2/144


3/144


4/144


5/144

Lu

n n ny con xin dnh t ng Ba M


6/144


7/144

!"#$!% &' (( )#%* (

( (( !"#$!%(+((",)-.'!/!)0)((()#%*&

(1(," &+2!%.'!) 0 +3 " ( 4 0 * (( $ (

5 !4,)- 0 $ %((')!'%.6*

+./$!0$(()#%*$ 7 8 3


8/144

!(9:!;3"'),$#& 4 !"#$!% & 4


9/144

?

!"#$%&'(( @@ + @?@: ) :A

) #*+(!"#$$,#!$!"(-.!*+/$!"0 ) #*+(!"#$$,#!$!"(.("*+/$!" ))

B@ 46A&C :: !"# $ % & $$ '()*+ ,

B: )6A :D **& - **.

BB 46A&C BA /+!0 *1

BE 6A0 3 BBBF +4 BD

% * 2% **

1 #$.("#$ 1)

2 3 14

!.!"#$%(.#$$&"! 15


10/144

3*4

@A

@@ EG 5*+ 2 6 %

@: )7*1 FA /+ % 8*"* % * %

) #,*!#+!" 41:@ )3

H*@??BIH@??DI FE % 9*+* %% 8*"+* %$ 9))* %2

:: " ( 03 J@ 9*+*: $ ;*3*++*: $

*


11/144


12/144

@:


13/144

@B

)(33$#+(9$#+;!(9!;

(( ! (

!

.( 3 3

(

3$

3)

K).,L!

(3M (( 9

;

((

39/!;(33394';(

394!;+((

3 ( 3 K

3L1(

3 .


14/144

?*

@E

3 ) 3

3

3

3

.

!(

4"N ) 3

3

!

31

3

3

(

F3E+G

$3B'

3 3 3 !

3

'

3 3

33

+(

(&1

3


15/144

?*

@F

=G

)B((

33'

3 "

(3

)

3 . (

4"N 1 33

) 3

(

33

(

(

!3 (

K+* "L

4"N*3 ( ) (

(3

3 9 O-P

(P;$33

3

/ ( 3

B'

#


16/144

?*

@J

3 Q

'(

)&1 (

(!3

9 R; $

3B'(


17/144

@D

A , " ! *

!"#$%&'((

@@ + @?

@: ) :A) #*+(!"#$$,#!$!"(-.!*+/$!"0 ) #*+(!"#$$,#!$!"(.("*+/$!" ))

B@ 46A&C :: !"# $ % & $$ '()*+ ,

B: )6A :D

**& - **. BB 46A&C BA

/+!0 *1

BE 6A0 3 BB


18/144

GD****+****"

@G

BF +4 BD% * 2% **

1 #$.("#$ 1)

)( 3

(

3#3

38

3(

S!(

S1 3

H3( :AA:I H @??DI ! 33

S 3 S 1

!

S


19/144

GD****+****"

@?

!"#$%&'((

0 *#9(:+!B,!!"#$0

#33S

S9;$ S 9C


20/144

GD****+****"

:A

4@+

)'

('S

3U

BHB += 9@@E;

ED = 9@@F;

V W X * S

0) #$%"!"#$&("+"!0

*VSS

U

H B = 9@@J;

& H = 9@@D;

& (

33

( S3

( 33 " S


21/144

GD****+****"

:@

)

$ 3 3 U

3 YY

3 YY

/

S 3

# 3

) #*+(!"#$$,#!$!"(-.!*+/$!"0

) 3 SS

SZAU

AB = 9@:@;

) 3 S +

S S

)U

) =A 9@::;

) 3 V

S$S

!38

9 3

; * 3 3

S1(

( H% :AA:I )

3 S 9


22/144

GD****+****"

::

;Q+

VH'(

@??EIH@??DIH4(:AA:I

!!S33

39

; 3 H @??DI )S

3

1#(

#*+(!"#$$,#!$!"(.("*+/$!"

+3(

U 3 4

34)

3


23/144

GD****+****"

:B

4:'3

'S3UIH 9@B@;

I)B 9@B:;

' S 9@B@; S S

U

.-=H 9@BB;

) S

3$3333 S

)3(S3V

P

#


24/144

GD****+****"

:E

0T

= 9@BF;

) S S

3 S

U

.I 0TH 9@BJ;

(

(


25/144

GD****+****"

:F

+1>

U

& 3


26/144

GD****+****"

:J

' S 3 9

;#SS

#9(BE;

!"#

.((33

S3U

S= oTH 9@B?;

3.-=H 9@B@A;

)3 ZD+ZA

S3Z1

U

I.J) ; 3 9@B@@;

.J)J = ;0T


27/144

GD****+****"

:D

$ '()*+

# ( 3

9!4; ( S

3+S

&13 (

(3U

[ ]{ } { }


28/144

GD****+****"

:G

(


29/144

GD****+****"

:?

= 00 T

9@B@J;


30/144

GD****+****"

BA

3

**.

)C

S333

9@B@J;!

2; 0H 9@B:A;

A3


31/144

GD****+****"

B@

3 33

(U

=0

0? 0k0 tT 9@B::;

0UO

U

?0

0 = 0ktH S9; 9@B:B;

=H 39@; 9@B:E;

)


32/144

GD****+****"

B:

C ==

+

=

=

=

0?000

0

L

&

MN

??

MN

?

MNO

H&LMN

9@B:D;

,

&)

&9@@B:D;

0=

=0?

MN

9@B:G;

)3

LH?

&

H&L&?

&

H&L??

MNO

L 0

L

&

0

L

&

000

=

=

=

=

9@B:?;

. S 3SA$O

U

LH

LH?

&LH

?

&LH

?

&O

L

0

L 0L 0L 00

=

+

=

=

0

01

0

9@BBA;

4SU

LH

?KL

0000

+= 9@BB@;


33/144

GD****+****"

BB

.SA3U

L?J

?KL 0

000000

+= 9@BB:;

)(

S

S=

#_"`Z_"@":RR"#`

(9;U

=

+ EK?H

H9 ]

0 9@BBB;

E

H

9

000

**0*

**

EE

]=

=

=

=

0

0

9@BBE;

01


34/144

GD****+****"

BE

3 J 3

3

133 >

(9(;9;

+ 3


35/144

GD****+****"

BF

= oHH S9;

.1 += H 39@;

0?=0ko hH

00? =

4D)3

) 3 #

LF9;

396

SS33;+

3 LFU

= 0H 3 9@BBJ;

+ (

!S303

+S


36/144

GD****+****"

BJ

.( F

(3(S.

33U

@b;;9;9 IJ)J 9@BBG;

AbS; .J)J =0H 9@BB?;

> 3 33

S!33

U

?K 0000

+= 9@BEA;

LHLH

LH?

&LH

?

&LH

?

&O

L

0

L

L 0L 0L 00

+=

+

=

=

10

01

0kh

9@BE@;

4&

3U

L

HL

H?K

L

0

L

000 +

+=

10

0kh 9@BE:;

3 & (

3)3 LF3

S ( 3 S

=

3S9

#;U

=

+ EK?H

H9 ]

0 9@BEB;


37/144

GD****+****"

BD

E

H

9

000

*

0*

*

*

EE

]=

+=

=

=

110

110

okokol

ol

tth

h 9@BEE;

! 3 33

S 33 (

3

3 3 P 9

3; 3


38/144

GD****+****"

BG

%

9C.;3

SS1

V#S

9;

4G%

% *

3


39/144

GD****+****"

B?

) =

=

T

JT 9@BED;

.&$Z


40/144

GD****+****"

EA

% **

) S

9 S ; '

(

S 1 3 (S.93;

+S* J#.

@.

9(; !#.

(3U

E =;9 oct 9@BF@;

*.3

(SU

?

?

+=

+=

oc

oco

tTH

tTH 9@BF:;

V


41/144

GD****+****"

E@

39

V


42/144

GD****+****"

E:

3H*

:AABI

1 #$.("#$

# 3 )(

33

P

)

! 33 >

+ 3

)

&

3 33

!333&

3

+ 7


43/144

GD****+****"

EB

> ) ( $$

333

+

9 ;

3B'9

;

+

33 3 &

3 (

3 ,

3 ( Q

1H:AABI)(3

($$$

!3(

( $$ $$$

3

3


44/144


45/144

EF

A , " ! * )

23

!.!"#$%(.#$$&"! 15

@@ EG

5*+ 2 6 %@: )7*1 FA

/+ % 8*"* % * %

) #,*!#+!" 41:@ )3

H*@??BIH@??DI FE % 9*+* %%

8*"+* %$ 9))* %2:: " (

03 J@ 9*+*: $ ;*3*++*: $ *


46/144

G3*4:"

EJ

-$!/!"$.#$-$"$! 61 +**(7"+,($!!"#$%$((#/"."(2 654 8("%!"#$ * $ ,*#9(:+ "$%!*"(0 ,,(".!"#$ ; (

+#%("!"#$%+#!*-!0


47/144


48/144

G3*4:"

EG

!.!"#$%(.#$$&"!

) (

U7*1

)#

&1)

0 $*("!

5*+

+3(P"

( @ "

"3!1

9;V9;

.3

"3:

B'33

3 /

3

3#33"3

( ;9' 3

3 3

($3

c 3

+ 3 3

33&394;9

; 9 +; .


49/144

G3*4:"

E?

3 + 3 3

)(

'3(:::3)&

4Z:Z:+Z:

3EGE3

U4ZEZG+ZE

"33

+ (

U

.34ZE

ZE+Z:

4?'

(

4@A'

4@@"(


50/144

G3*4:"

FA

4@:

@

6

K"$"!"#$M

@ N + * 3 3

+5*55"*N#*N

+*

+333

3 &

% ( + (

3&

A.(3

+3@:

)

9,P;

@&&

0) *.!*"!"%7(*E#"$.*

/+

'3

3[

9+34;#

3

$

+ 4 )

M


51/144

G3*4:"

F@

)&338U

++#5*


52/144

G3*4:"

F:

02

2

2

=

=

=+=

G

D@ 9:@B;

#33

1

) $

&

4@E'33

E G E 3 #

7*1

U

12

2

0

=

=

=+=

G

D@ 9:@E;

* 3 :E:3U

12

2

06126

=

=

=+=+=

G

D@ 9:@F;

#3


53/144

G3*4:"

FB

4@F"

$ G @J J 3

7*1U

22

2

26168

=

=

=+=+=

G

D@ 9:@J;

#:

*

# 7*1

3$

3 (9

3;

#d9&&;

( 33 3

)3!33

( 1

(

)4"Ne7

33$

3>

'


54/144

G3*4:"

FE

) #,*!#+!"

'

H- * @?GFI H * @??BI H @??DI

H)*:AA:I#

(3

# !3

(3

)(

)0 *!"#$!#+!"%(.#,*,*%/#$K(+$!

%(7"*N#$*%!(0OPN#$/OP

)(3

+

U )

. 7*1

" 3 & 3

(3("

1$

3

(8

($

33

3 ( *

(P


55/144

G3*4:"

FF

9*+*

)(H@??DIU

@*)*"+"+**335

# *


56/144

G3*4:"

FJ

4@J/(3

[J333

#3

3

8*"+*

# ( 4"Ne '

( 3 33

$1

3 1 " 3

(33

3 ( 3

3


57/144


58/144

G3*4:"

FG

4"N "

3

4:A

4:@*3

3 :@ 3 #

33 3

#

)

(

9))*

(33

> ! 1

(

) (

)/


59/144


60/144

G3*4:"

JA

4::!

1(3

3

(

1+

1(

3) ((

(!

3

(


61/144

G3*4:"

J@

)0) $$#-((+!A#%%.*!"#$!#+!"%

.#,*3/#$K(+$!%."*."!+/$!"

1

M $

3

Q M (

[3

33

$

1 3 )& M


62/144

G3*4:"

J:

9*+*:

( (

3$

38U

$"!"("!"#$

'"**)*"C

")?**#AI

* "*" * *

3**0'"*))*


63/144

G3*4:"

JB

4:B'(3

1 2

3 4

5 6

7 8

9 10

11


64/144

G3*4:"

JE

+ 3

( ( +

(([

3

'3

# 3

(D?

[333

31((+

3*3:B

3(31

(0(3

;*3*++*:

!

333

3K3L )

33913:';

((

3:EU

"


65/144

G3*4:"

JF

D

4:E'33

*


66/144

G3*4:"

JJ

4:F)

3

3)JEAAA

4:J6:

# 3

(3

33

J

+$=@G-P@

3

(3

3 ( 3 )

3(


67/144


68/144

G3*4:"

JG

3

!33

&

P3

'3(

3

(

1 +**(7"+,($!!"#$%$((#/"."(2

" 3 3 &

#

3

9;

4:D)

'(&>

1

+ & LF 93

($;U

00 = & ;9 Q. 9:E@;

3 = 9:E:;

g:(

g@

g:

gB(

gB

\

g@()

$


69/144

G3*4:"

J?

)

( . + ( 3

)U

[ ] =

*& 00 ;9 9:EB;

(


70/144

G3*4:"

DA

4 8("%!"#$*$,*#9(:+"$%!*"(0,,(".!"#$;(

+#%("!"#$%+#!*-!0

40 .*",!"#$

3

) &&

U"93;9

;

4:G

33

:AWJJAA*4"N

33M

*

GFAAA AGF 6 3

33

U33


71/144

G3*4:"

D@

)&3

!33

3 )33 .

3*

33(

40) #$.!"#$$+$!!"+(!"#$0

(

)(3

3&33

(

4"N @JDBJF

M


72/144

G3*4:"

D:

4:?)0=

#

# 1

1

==

?&* 0 9:F@;

#33BA


73/144

G3*4:"

DB

-4,00E-01

-3,00E-01

-2,00E-01

-1,00E-01

0,00E+00

1,00E-01

2,00E-01

3,00E-01

4,00E-01

5,00E-01

0 5 10 15 20 25

Delta_phi_automatique

Delta_phi_manuelle

4BA)hC

%(

4B@)

[ ( 3 B@

3

# 1

3B@

'

37#

3


74/144

G3*4:"

DE

6 #$.("#$

' (

)

7*

1

3

"3

( .

('

$(

3 9

( $ ; *

.3

9;)33

'

33


75/144

G3*4:"

DF

3


76/144

DJ


77/144

DD

A , " ! *

2

28

*"$.",%(,*+9"("!.#+,(&=>?@ 5

) !*+"$!"#$ % ( ,*+9"("! .#+,(& ,#* (.#$%.!**#$% 5:@ ) GE

=*3*45 2 =*3*4> 2% ' 2%

:: - GG ?+*@A 22 ':& 2-

:B =:'( ?A:E ) ?:

.#$%.!**.!$/("* B@ $( ?BB: .( ?E


78/144

G'**3**")*

DG

6*** -2% " 1 "


79/144

G'**3**")*

D?

3 !

(3

,3333

V3

'

'7

($

'

33

(9WX;

9Wi; ) (

> 3


80/144

G'**3**")*

GA

)&

(

f

)(

((

' (

!

33

(

#(

)( 3

(3

3 33

3(

:'B'


81/144

G'**3**")*

G@

*"$.",%(,*+9"("!.#+,(&=>?@

3.#$%.!*!,*+9(AB!*!"$#$

.#$%.!*

(

1 ! 1

)

33

(

j3-A

4B@+

&&

,

(--i

B&&EEB&&EBB

iiii

;;9;99;9

+=+1

9B@@;)

O


82/144

G'**3**")*

G:

$

(9;

3

%

33

+3

9 ; (

33

3

'

33(

33

'3B:B

U ( 3P @?

!6

)3

) 3

3

. (

KL#

KL


83/144

G'**3**")*

GB

4B:!(U*P!U)

(3[(U(

) !*+"$!"#$%(,*+9"("!.#+,(&,#*(

.#$%.!**#$%

8

'

(

H.( @??JI '

3'(

(( U

(3 $ ((


84/144

G'**3**")*

GE

)0 %.#$%.!*"#(

=*3*45

#(

3

r0

H0

H0

4BB)(3

j

W X A

33 (

H.I

[U

;;9;9;9;9

;9;9;9;99

;;9;9;9;9

;9;9;9;99

2

20

0200

02000

2

20

0200

02000

11

111

11

111

??

??&&

??

??&&

+

+=

+

++=

9B:@;

[U

[ ]

[ ]

;9;9;;9;9;9;9

;9

;9;9;9;9

+

+=

+=

?

???

&&

?

??

&&

120200

0

1

0200

0

1

11

4

11

4

9B::;


85/144

G'**3**")*

GF

E 21=

+= = ;9 0? 3 /

3

+3

=*3*4>

$1A(

3-A

Wi

H'@?JJI

[U

;9

;9

02

2

0

02

2

0

1

1

H

0H

H

0H

=

+=

9B:B;

[3

U

01 H0H ;9 += 9B:E;

1

1

+

= i

i

0

'

3

#(

* (


86/144

G'**3**")*

GJ

)

3+

(

1 ) 1 3 3

+3

! 33 1 (

3

U

;9;9

;9;9i

0200

0200

??

??

+

= 9B:F;

# 3 BE

AZA@3

3

O

!3

(9;

O

3

*37

!(3!

(3 3(

3

3

33$3

V

(P!


87/144

G'**3**")*

GD

3 !

(

+ 3

*3)33!

33 3 (

3

(9;

9i;)

9B:F;1)

(

3

33 ( !

3

103

104

105

106

107

-0.5

0

0.5

1

Fr uence

Valeurrelative

Evolution de la Permabilit complexe

Partie relle

Partie imaginaire

4BE\

(3%UA@


88/144

G'**3**")*

GG

(

(!33&

)3

#

)0) #+#/$"!"#$,#*,("*.#$%.!**#$%

?+*@A

!3P3

33"3P

(1333

3 (

3(

93BJ;3

(+(3P

13H3*@??BI

3P33

3PO(P(P

4BF


89/144

G'**3**")*

G?

':&

( (

9;

(9i;

((

3

(1

'39i;1

4BD'3P(

4BJ63P


90/144

G'**3**")*

?A

4 BG 3

P

1 9;

33'

((3(

+

1

H@??@IU

i

i

i

i

i

+

+

+

=

0

0

0

0

1

1

0

0

")* 9B:J;

033U

0

"

2

2

0= Wi

B:F

1 (

((

$

!

'

( Q

(

$ 3

)0 8("%!"#$)%(7A#+#/$"!"#$

# ( (

4"N


91/144

G'**3**")*

?@

3 P @? AAB

A@JF

1(3

@AAO-P@A-P

. 3 9B:F; 9B:J; 3

9i;33U

6:B&@=(

*$. 8(*?A#+#/$"


92/144

G'**3**")*

?:

#

33 3 P

9i;*3

:k

)01 #$.("#$,#*(.#$%.!*;.!"#$."*.("*

.

3 .

9(R;

) ,

33(


93/144

G'**3**")*

?B

.#$%.!**.!$/("*

0 $!*#%.!"#$;(!.A$#(#/",($*

3(3

!

(

!(3

3(

9?Gk;

333@AA

O-P@-P[333

(

3 (33U

3

33R

4B?63)


94/144

G'**3**")*

?E

$ 3 3

(+

3 3

3 V

! 33

)

1(

'((@'

3 / 33

3

((!33

3

0) ,,*#.A$(B!"


95/144

G'**3**")*

?F

&= 9BB@;

H7

= 9BB:;

. &H = 7 =

!9BB@;9BB:;U

&&

&&

=

=

;9 9BBB;

)7 @'

(PP

9BBB;3U

&EC

&=

2

2

9BBE;

U

0

0

&&

&&

3C

3C

=

=

=

= 9BBF;

9BBE;U

E

C& CC

=

+=

2

21

ii;9 9BBJ;

!

)@):(U

;(9

;(9;9

3

C&C&

0= 9BBD;

U


96/144

G'**3**")*

?J

;9;(9

;9;(9

33

CC

&

&

22

22

0

+

=

=

9BBG;

U

+

++

+

=

+=

+=

+=

33

CC

E33

CC

&

&&E

HHEE&

H7

22

22

22

22

1

2

0

(

(

(

(

;9 i

9BB?;

( 9BB?;

U

+

++

+

=

=

33

33

E33

33

&

C3

3

22

22

22

22

2

0

(

(

(

( 9BB@A;

#

***>")*

#

)

Wi ( &-A#

U


97/144

G'**3**")*

?D

[ ];9;9 iii

+=

=

=

E&E

&&E

&

H

2

0

9BB@@;

( 9BB@@;

U

[ ];9;9 ii +=

=

E&3E

C3

3

2

02

9BB@:;

'

+

( #

@' U

33

33

3

33

33

3

22

22

2

22

22

2

(

(

;9

(

(;9

i

i

+

=

+

+=

9BB@B;

#

( 3 #

(93E@;


98/144

G'**3**")*

?G

6***

+

3 $33

?Al 1

H:AABI93E:3BB@E;#

( 3

333U

33

33

3

33

33

3

C

C

22

22

222

22

2

22

22

222

22

2

(

(;9

(

(;9

(

(;9

(

(;9

ii

ii

+

=

+

=

+

+=

+

+=

9BB@E;

4E@\33'

:ZAG


99/144

G'**3**")*

??

% "1"


100/144

G'**3**")*

@AA

= =*

9BB@F;

! Wi 9 3 EB;

U

3@

")*")* ++

=+

+= ;9i213

111 9BB@J;

@

3

@

3

@

m

i 032

0

1

+=== 9BB@D;

[&

(

!CG

++

++

+=

i

ii

C")* 3

3

3

9BB@G;

!G

++

++

+= i

ii

C

C")*

3

3

9BB@?;

4EB


101/144

G'**3**")*

@A@

$9*"/9*C

$(3

#33FAO-P

ABB:&@

:'9WX;H:AABI(3

(9 ; 3 @

#333

6B:&@!3S](

,,#*!

R9

SH


102/144

G'**3**")*

@A:

( 3

)3(37

(

4EE.

(

*1U(

3 (9

3EJ;3(

#

1 ( !

6 @'

7&33

[

:'(@'

:'33

3

(1"

@'

@'


103/144

G'**3**")*

@AB

4EF4(

33(

4EJ)(

, *

@' 3

3 ! 3 9

3R; 3

3+33

:' ) 33 3 3

(

$3:'([(

:'


104/144

G'**3**")*

@AE

)

U $ 1

(@''(

@'3Q

1 33 *

1

'(U

(3

(

38(

33


105/144

G'**3**")*

@AF

0 ,,*#.A,*#,!"+"!"#$

# 3

$

(

)

3333

9;

9i;

D3E+

9;

3 3

# 33 (

3 (

" 3 :' 3

#+3o


128/144

@:G


129/144

@:?

'3 3

3

3

B'

'

3

3 ) 3

(

)(

1 3

!3

3&

'

3

!33

3Q

63333

'33


130/144


131/144

**

@B@

!

3 . (

$

93 ;

' (

33

3 EF ! 33

V &

(

13*

3

!

1'(

4"N

B' $

)

3 K! +L

(3


132/144

@B:


133/144

@BB

H.(@??JI .( r'#E%"+$!"#$( .(.(!"#$ #K'"$%"$/ (# "$ !*$K#*+*s ?777 \

7*=*+@JB?&@JEEB

:AAA

H.*@??GI .+!)//4

) # + 2

%%(2%r!#.A!".(/#*"!A+

"$ (.!*#+/$!". #,!"+"G!"#$s ?777

' BJDE 0 BJGE BE

F:*@??G

H/*@??BI A/2+ %(=O2%%(

r#+,!!"#$#KE**$!*"-$I"$KK.!

*#9(+ "$/ **$! 8.!#* #!$!"(s

?777'@B:F0@B:G

:?:@??B

H/*:AAFI /=+4(5)&

r'A*E"+$"#$(=E@.(*"$"!

(+$! !A#% !# #+,!


134/144

H3*

@BE

' @BA? 0 @B@: BG : @

(:AA:

H'(@??EI '( 6 K #,(/ % ( +!A#% %

(+$! K"$" !*"%"+$"#$$( -. $

+!A#% %7$(B % ."*."! (.!*"M,,(".!"#$ ; ( +#%("!"#$ % +.A"$

!#*$$!L 6( ' $ #

+(@??E

H'@?JJI ' ! K/$!#!!"L '

!+@?JJ

H@??DI ) K-(#,,+$! % K#*+(!"#$

(+$! K"$" $ ,#!$!"( -.!*+/$!"M ,,(".!"#$ ; ( "+(!"#$ %

%",#"!"K (.!*#+/$!" $ +#-+$!K

6( ' $ # +(

@??D

H@??EI )K!*+"$!"#$%,*!,*.#*$!

%#.(!%$ ( .-%!*$K#*+!*0

#%("!"#$ % */"#$ +"$. ! ,*" $.#+,! % ( !*!"#$ % +!*"&

+/$!" $ */"+ A*+#$"L 6(

' $ # +(

@??E

H-@?GFI - ) *O r!!"$/ +(!",(B

.#$$.!% %#+"$V $!!! 6

:E?F 0:E?G :@ J #

@?GF

H:AABI K#%("!"#$%,*+:!*!%

+!*"((.!*"9#9"$,*(+!A#%%

(+$! K"$" L 6( ' $


135/144

H3*

@BF

# +(

:AAB

H2*@??:I 2 . 6 . r $' .(*

,#!$!"( K#*+(!"#$ K#* E

+/$!#!!".$."!!"$/ $# #*. K"(%.(.(!"#$s ?777 '

@@AB&@@AJ:G:@??:

H4(:AA:I 4(5K-(#,,+$!%K#*+(!"#$

(+$!K"$"EW,#*(,*"$.#+,!%

.#$%.!* +"K ! 9#9"$ -. $

.#,(/ ."*."!L 6( ' $

# +( :AA:

H*@??BI + -) -&)( %

% ' r!#+!". "+,(+$!!"#$ #K .!

"$ +(!",(B .#$$.!% +/$!". .(* */"#$

K#*%%B.**$!+#%(s?777

' @BJG 0 @BD@ :? :

@??B

H*:AAFI 5m +m 4 &+

r$!/*!% ,($* EE .#+,#$$!M "/$O

A*.!*"G!"#$ $% &,*"+$!( KK"."$.B

$(B"s?777\7*

F?B0F??:AB:AAF

H(*:AAAI ( 5 ) * + 4 r+*".(

+#%( !# %".*!"G #*. "(% "$ !A

"$"! (+$! !A#%s ?777

'JDJ0JD?BJE:AAA

H3*@??BI 3. m 4)r A"/A K*$.B +#%(

K#*"!G'"*K#*'"!.AE+#%+/$!".s?777


136/144

H3*

@BJ

?C9*=C9*'@@J?0

@@DF:,@??B

H@??DI -6K+("#*!"#$%(K#*+(!"#$$

,#!$!"( .("* +/$!" ! /$*!"#$

.#,(/$!*!"#$%.A+,!%."*."!(.!*"X 6( ' $ #

+(@??D

H+*@?G:I + 6^ % ./ r#(!"#$ #K E

%"+$!"#$( %%B .**$! ,*#9(+ M !A EY

+!A#%s ?777'5 EGJ0

E?@@?G:

H@??@I ! K#$!*"9!"#$; (+#%("!"#$%%",#"!"K (.!*#!.A$" $ - % (*

#,!"+"!"#$L6(")@??@

H@??FI ! r.*#.#,". (.!*".

A*.!*"G!"#$ #K $%( #K #$%.!#*s

?777'@EJE0@EJD

B@B@??F

H*@??GI -6 ( 5r#+,!!"#$ #K .#,(% ,*#9(+ #K %%B

.**$! $% (.!*".( ."*."! 9B "$/


137/144

H3*

@BD

+"K ,* ,*+9"("! .#+,(&s #

(!'4&'!%&-@@]?J]ADF@??J

H%:AA:I % t rEY K#*+(!"#$ K#* %%B .**$!

,*#9(+"$+(!",(B.#$$.!%*/"#$s?777

'5 FFD0FJABG:*:AA:

H*@?DEI * %( rA$(B"#K%%B.**$!s

,3*@?DE


138/144

@BG


139/144

@B?

2

) *


140/144

9

@EA

9&

1= 9.B;

!9.@;

9

9

9

9 22

2

22

2 11

=++ 9.E;

. uIvWX5

uIA

*:U

;9;9;9 9 = 9.F;

G

2

2

1

2

1

2

1

1

2

1

2

1

11111

=++

9.J;

.

( 1

+U

221

2

1

1 =

9.D;

U

;9;9;9 211 += 9.G;

.

)

#U

;9;9 11 = 9.?;

.9.D;9.J;3U


141/144

9

@E@

01

1

2

2

2

1

2

1

2

=++

;9 9.@A;

U

;9;9;9 ]? 321 += 9.@@;

?^]^

3/3@:[I5

(13[9 ;3

P+1

#3U

;9;9;9 ?9

A = 1 9.@:;

(&5.

U

;9

9

9

&

A

A

=

1 9.@B;

#(U

;9;9;9

;9;9

?

?&

?&

+=

=

+

11

1

1

9.@E;

+W3

U

0= AA 9.@F;

.1(

3U

;9;9;9 9 A 2= 9.@J;

9.@F;3U


142/144

9

@E:

01

22

2

2

2

2

2

=+

;9 9.@D;

U

322 += 9.@G;

#3U

[ ] +=

A 9 ;9;9 32 9.@?;

(U

[ ] ;9

;9;9

;9

;9

9&

9

&

A

A

+

+

+=

=

+=

=

13

12

1

3

1

2

1

9.:A;


143/144

9

@EB

;9;9;9;9

;9;9;9

;9

;9

&?

?

&?

+

+

+

+=

+

+=

1

0200

0

011

1

020201

0

1

1

9.:E;

.S3

00?0

0?0?

???

+=

=

+

+

;9;9;9S

;9;9;9

1

11

2 9.:F;

+w@)OZA

+IU

[ ]

;9;9

;9;9

;9;9

212210

2122102

0021

212210

0211

4

+

+=

+=

??

??&

??

&

9.:J;

# 3

U

[ ];9;9

;9;9;9

?

??

&9 A 1

212210

024

+= 9.:D;

U

;9;;9;9

;9;99;9

??

??&9 A +

+

+=

1

212210

2122102

00 9.:G;

%& ( + (

U


144/144

9

;;9;9

;9;99

;;9;9

;9;99

2

2

0

212210

2122100

2

2

0

212210

2122100

1

1

??

??&&

??

??&&

+

+=

+

++=

9.:?;

+(U

[ ]

[ ]

;9;9;9;9

;9

;9;9

+

+=

+=

?

???

&&

?

??

&&

12

212210

02

1

212210

02

14

4

9.BA;

these phung version finale corrigee

Documents