this cover and their final version of the extended essay to

is are

is

a not

use

Examiner 1 Examiner 2 Examiner 3

research 2 2

B introduction 2 D 2

c 4 4

D 4 4

E reasoned 4 4

F and evaluation 4 D 4

G use of 4 4

H conclusion 2 D 2 D formal 4 4

J abstract 2 D 2

K holistic 4 4

IloHHMaHue PyccKoii ApxuTeKTYPbi.

KaK H3MeHeHHSI B PyccKoii apxuTeKTYpe Cepe6pSIHOro seKa, no3HTHBHO oTpa3HJIHCb Ha

fiOHHMaHHH If BOCnpHSITHe HX pyCCKHM HapO,LI;OM.

Pa6oTa rro.n;roTOBJieHa

KaH).lH).laTOM ).lHrrJioMa Me)l<).lyHapo).lHOro EaKaJiaBpHaTa

AMep)KaHoBoi1 HennH

IIpe).lMeT PyccKHH.H3hiK E, KaT. 2 (6)

IBO World School

CeccH.H: Mail 2013

Word count: 3621

Understanding of Russian Architecture.

How do the changes in Russian architecture of Silver Century positively reflected on Russian people's understanding and acceptance of them?

By:

An Extended Essay

Submitted as a Candidate for the

International Baccalaureate Diploma

Subject Russian B Cat:2(b)

IBO World School

Word count: 3621

ii

Acknowledgement

First of all I would like to thank my supervisor who was generous enough to

agree in helping me doing my extended essay, as well as she helped me structure my ideas and

develop good topic for my essay. Secondly, I would like to thank who was

supportive and honest as well as very straight forward that helped me stay organized and meet

my deadlines.

Finally, I would like to say thank you to my family, friends for their support and encouragements.

iii

Ha3BaHHe: lloHHMaHHe PyccKoH: ApxHTeKrypbi.

KaK H3MeHeHHSJ B PyccKoH: apxHTeKrype Cepe6pSIHoro BeKa, no3HTHBHO oTpa3HJIHCb Ha

llOHHMaHHH H BOCnpHSITHC HX pyCCKHM Hapo~OM?

CeccHSJ Mail 2013

A6CTpaKT

B 3TOM 3cce 6y.l(eT o6cy)K,l(aThC>I TeMa paccBeTa PyccKoH: ApxHTeKryphi. Bo BpeM>I, KOTopoH:

6hiJIH COBeprneHHbi .l(paMaTW-IeCKHe OTKpbiTH>I HOBbiX CTHJieH H H,l(eH, KOTOpbie ITOBJIH5IJIH Ha

6y.l(yw:ee KYJihT)'pHoro pa3BHTH>I cTpaHbi. KpoMe Toro 6y.l(eT rrpe.l(cTaBJieHo MHeHHe Hapo.l(a Ha

mMeHemm CB5!3aHHhie c rrepeMeHaMH B apxHTeKType. A TaK )Ke 6y.l(yT rrpe.l(cTaBJieHhi

apryMeHThi, KOTOpbre rro.l(.l(ep)KaT MOH rJiaBHhiH Borrpoc: KaK H3MeHeHim ~ PycckoH:

apXHTeKType Cepe6p>IHOrO BeKa, IT03HTHBHO OTpa3HJIHCb Ha ITOHHMaHHH H BOCITpH5ITHe HMH

pyCCKHM HapO.l(OM. 0.l(HaKO B XO,l(e H3yqeHH>I 3TOH TeMhl y MeH>I IT05IBHJIOCb MHOrO BOITpOCOB,

Ha KOTOpbie 51 6hi XOTeJia HaHTH OTBeThi:

KaK HMeHHO H3MeHHJiach apxHTeKrypa? I1oqeMy HMeHHO ceH:qac? KaK JIIO.l(H BocrrpHH5IJIH 3TH

rrepeMeHbi? KaKa>I CB>I3b Me)K.l(y rrepeMeHaMH B apXHTeKrype H ITOJIHTHqeCKOH CHTyau,HH B

CTPaHe? KaK rroJIHTHqecKa>I cHryau,H5! B CTPaHe CKa3aJiacb Ha HOBOM CTHJie 3,l(aHHi1? EcJIH

Me)K,l(y HHMH KaKa5!-HH6y.l(h CB>I3b?

B XO,l(e pa60Tbl Ha,l( 3TOH TeMOH >I 06Hapy)KHJia MHQ)KeCTBO cpaKTOpOB, KOTOpbie ITOMOrJIH

BHeCTH >ICHOCTb B BOITpOChi, KOTOpbre 6hiJIH ITOCTaBJieHhi MHOH B HaqaJie.

0rrpe.l(eJIHB OCHOBHhie cpaKTOpbi, ITOBJIH5IBWHe, Ha H3MeHeHH>I apXHTeKT)'pHOro CTHM >I

ITOITbiTaiOCb 06b>ICHHTb, KaK BCe 3TH H3MeHeHH5! MOrJIH CKa3aThC>I Ha HX ITOHHMaHHH pyCCKHM

Hapo.l(OM. KaKoBa 6hrJia HX peaKIJ,H5! Ha pa,l(HKaJihHhie rrepeMeHhi B apxHTeKrypHOM

iv

CTpOHTeJJhCTBe, He CMOTp5I Ha nOJJI1THqecKyiO CIHyaU:HIO B CTpaHe. KaKHM o6p8.30M OHH CMOrJJH

npHH5ITb TaKHe pa,n:HKaJJbHbie H3MeHeHH5I B apXHTeKrypHOM CTHJJe 3.D:aHHH. B 3aKJJIOqeHHH Bbiiiie

CK8.3aHHOro, 3CCe nO.IJ:BO.IJ:HT HTOr, npe,n:CTaBHB BbiBO.IJ:bi H TIU:aTeJJhHO npOaHaJJH3HpOBaB BCe

H3MeHeHH5I, npOH30IIIe.D:IIIHe B nepHO.D: Cepe6p5IHOrO BeKa 0 TOM, KaK Hapo,n: BOCnpHH5IJ1 BCe 3TH

HOBIIIeCTBa H nepeMeHhi.

(KOJJHqeCTBO CJJOB: 226)

v

Author:

Title: Understanding of Russian Architecture. How do the changes in Russian architecture

of Silver Century positively reflected on Russian people's understanding and acceptance of

them?

Session: May 2013

Abstract

This essay wiii discuss the topic dawn of Russian architecture. At the time, which were perfect

dramatic discoveries of new styles and ideas that have influenced the future of cultural

development. In addition will be presented to the people's opinion on the changes associated with

changes in the architecture. And also will be presented arguments that support my main question

is: How do the changes in the Russian Silver Age architecture, had a positive impact on the

understanding and perception of the Russian people.

However, during the study of the topic I had a lot of questions that I would like to answer:

Exactly how to change the architecture? Why now? How do people accept these changes? What

is the relationship between the changes in the architecture and the political situation in the

country? As the political situation in the country said the new-style buildings? If any connection

between them? During the work on this topic, I found a lot of factors that have helped to clarify

the issues that were raised by me in the beginning.

The main factors that influenced on the change of architectural style, I try to explain how these

changes may affect their understanding of the Russian people. What was their reaction to the

radical change in the architectural construction, in spite ofthe political situation in the country.

How they were able to take such a radical change in the architectural style of buildings. At the

end of the preceding sentence, the essay concludes by presenting findings and careful analysis of

vi

all the changes that have taken place during the Silver Age of how people saw all these

innovations and changes.

Word count: 226

vii

OrnasneHrAe

Acknowledgement ...................................................................................................................... iii

A6crpaKr ........................................................................................................................................ iv

Abstract ........................................................................................................................................ vi

BBeAeHrAe ....................................................................................................................................... 1

'-laCTb 1 ............................................................................................................................................. 3

Vlcroplllfl apxlllreKrypbl AO Ha4alla Cepe6pf!Horo seKa ............................................................... 3

nollli1Tll14eCKafl ClllTyaU,lllfl B CTpaHe ................................................................................................ S

'-laCTb 2 ............................................................................................................................................. 7

ApxrATeKrypa Cepe6peHoro BeKa .................................................................................................. 7

BlllllfiHMe Esponbl B snoxy MoAePHM3Ma B PoccMl-1 ...................................................................... 10

I..JaCTb 3 ................................................................................................................................................ 14

BocnplllfiTMe Hosoro CTlllllfl apxl!1TeKrypb1 ........................................................................................ 14

PeaKU,Mfl Ha M3MeHeHMfl ................................................................................................................... 15

3aKnK>4eHrAe ...................................................................................................................................... 16

6rA6nrAorpacprAH .................................................................................................................................. 18

viii

MeiDI Bcer.n;a HHTepecoBa.rra apxHTeKTYpa 3,D;aHHH, pa3Hhie CTHJIH, CTPYKTYPa, AH3ai1H,

OT,D;eJIKa H BCe MHOrOe ,D;pyroe, l.J:TO CB.H3aHHO CO BCeB03M0)KHbiMH CTpOeHH.HMH. B l.J:aCTHOCTH

MeH.H npHBJieKna PycCKM Apxi-ITeKTYpa. 0Ha 6hma Bcema 3HaMeHHTa CBOHMH xpaMaMH,

uepKB.HMH, ,D;BopuaMH, 11 co6opaMH. Bc.H HCTOp11.H PyccKoli apx11TeKryphi Ol.J:eHh HHTepecHa, 11

3axBaThiBaiOme nornomaer qmaTeM. 0AHaKo .H Bhi6pa.rra 11MeHHO apxHTeKrypy KOHUa XIX

BeKa, l.J:TO, no MOeMy MHeHHIO, .HBJI.HeTC.H caMI1M paccBeTOM PyccKoli Apx11TeKTYphi Bcex BpeMeH.

5f Cl.J:HTaiO :ny TeMY aKTYa.ITbHOH, TaK KaK 3a 3TOT nepHO,D; pyccKa.H KYJihTypa CyMeJia

AOCTI1rHYTh MHpoBoro ypoBH.H. To l.J:TO caMhiH paccBeT PyccKOH apxHTeKryphi npOH30IIIeJI

HMeHHO no,D; KOHeu XIX BeKa, KoHel.J:HO )Ke, He cnyqaliHOCTh. Bee l.J:TO npoHCXOAHJIO B CTpaHe c

KY JihTYPHOH H TIOJIHTHl.J:eCKOH TOl.J:KH 3peHI15I ChirpaJIO 60JibiiiYIO pOJib B OTHOIIIeHHH JliO,D;eH K

CKOpbiM nepeMeHaM.

lf3 3a BCeX 3THX nepeMeH, CaMO C060H pa3yMeeTC5I, BJiaCTb B CTpaHe 6hiJia He

opraHH30BaHHOH H 6hiJIO omymeHHe, l.J:TO Ha3peBa.rra peBOJIIOUHH. O,D;HaKo, HeCMOTp.H Ha 3TOT

cpaKTop PyccKa.H KYJihTypa Bee )Ke cMorna BhmrpaTh BhirDAY ,D;a)l<e B TaKoe BpeM.H. IIepeHHMa.H

HeKOTOpbie KYJibrypHbie HOBIIIeCTBa C 3ana,D;a. ITo MOeMy MHeHHIO JliO,D;eH Ha riHKe C06biTHH 3TO

Marro BOJIHOBa.rro. 0AHaKo noTOM 3TO Cbirpa.rro CBOIO ponh B pa3BI1THH PyccKOH ApxmeKryphi.

IJ.eJihiO Moero 3cce .HBJI.HeTc.H H3yl.J:eHHe apxHTeKTyphi Cepe6p.HHoro BeKa H aHaJIH3 Toro

KaK 3TH H3MeHeHI15I OTpa3HJIHCb Ha TIOHHMaHHH H BOCTipH5ITHH pyCCKOrO HapO,D;a. ,lJ;M TOro

l.J:T06hi JIYl.J:IIIe TIOH.HTb BCe 3TH H3MeHeHH5I 5I pa3,D;eJIHJia 3CCe Ha HeCKOJlbKO qacTeH. r,D;e B

Ka)K,ll;OH l.J:aCTH OTIHCbiBaeTC.H onpe,D;eJieHHbiH MOMeHT pa3BHTH5I apXHTeKTypbi TOrO BpeMeHH.

B nepBOH qaCTH CBOeH pa60Tbi 5I xoqy paCCMOTpeTh BCe TO, l.J:TO npOHCXO,D;HJIO ,D;O

o6pa3oBaHH.H caMoro Cepe6p.HHoro BeKa. B qacTHOCTH o6b.HCHHTh, l.J:TO 11MeHHO npe,D;cTaBJI.HJia

co6oi1 apxmeKrypa Haqana H cepe,D;HHa XIX BeKa. A TaK )Ke nonmuqecKa.H c11ryaUH.H B crpaHe

B Tel.J:eHHH 3Toro speMeHH. Bo BTopoli qacTH 3cce .H 6hi xoTena no3HaKOMHTh l.J:I1TaTeJI.H c

1

apXHTeKTypOH KOH~a )l.eB5ITHa)l,~aTOrQ H Ha'Iana )l.Ba)l.~aTOrO BeKOB. A TaK )l(e 06Cy)l.HTb

3Ha'IHTeJ1bHbie H3MeHeHH5I, B apXHTeKrype KOTOpbie, ITOJ1Q)KHTeJ1bHO CKa3anHCb Ha apXHTeKType

B 3TOT KOpOTKHH rrpOMe)l<yTOK BpeMeHH. KpoMe TOrO B 3TOH 'IaCTH 5I 6y.ll.y rOBOpHTb 0 TOM KaK

apXHTeKrypHbiH CTHJ1b B EBporre ITOBJ1H5IJ1 Ha apXHTeKTypy 3TOrO BpeMeHH. I1 HaKOHe~, B

TPeThei1 qacTH 5I 6y.ll.y roBopHTb o TOM, KaK PyccKM PeBonro~H5I 1905 ro)l.a Morna rrOBJ1H5ITb Ha

MHeHHe J1IO)l.eH H HX rrpH3HaHHe apxHTeKrypHbiX H3MeHeHHH B 3TH rO)l.bi. I1 B 3aKJ1fOqeHHH 5I

ITO)l.Be)l.y HTOr TOrO 'ITO J1IO)l.H .ll.yManH 0 HOBOM CTHJ1e apXHTeKrypbi H KaK BCe Bbiille

rrepe4HCJ1eHHbie <f>aKTOpbi ITOBJ1H5IJ1H Ha MHeHHe J1IO)l.eH.

2

McTOpHSI apxHTeiiTyphi AO Ha~mJia Cepe6pSIHoro seKa

lfCTOpllii apXIfTeKTypbl HaCLJ:HTbiBaeT, MHOrO BeKOB HaLJ:HHaJ! C TIHpaMH,I{ B lH3e I1 3aKaHLJ:HBa51:

nocTpoH:KaMH He6ocKpe6os s ToKHO. EcnH )Ke paccMaTpHBaTb nepHO,I{ apxHTeKTypbi, KOTOpbiH

rrpe,I{lllecTBosan, Cepe6p5IHOMY seKy TO 3To 6bm rrepHO,I{ KnaccHQH3Ma. f'nasHoif qepToif

apXHTeKrypbi KJ1aCCHQI13Ma 6biJ10 o6pameHHe K 3TMOHY rapMOHHH, rrpOCTOTbi, CrpOroCTH,

5ICHOCTH I1 MOeyMeHTaJlbHOCTH. 1

0,I{HHM I13 OTJ1HLJ:HTeJ1bHbiX <PaKTOpOB KJ1aCCHQI13Ma 6biJ1a CHMMeTpllii. He TO LJ:TO 6bi 3TO 6biJ10

LJ:eM TO HOBbiM HO BCe )Ke Hrpano He ManyiO pOJ1b B CTpOHTeJ1bCTBe 3,I{aHHH TOrO BpeMeHH. XOTb

~ 2 3TO I1 5IBJ15IeTC5I OTJ1HLJ:HTeJ1bHOH LJ:aCTbiO KJ1aCCHQI13Ma , CHMMeTpllii rrpHCYTCTBYeT ITOLJ:TH BO

scex cTpoeHH5IX. Ebmo 6bi CJ10)KHO )J<HTb s ,I{OMe, ecnH 6bi CTeHbi HJ1H non 6biJ1 6bi He

rrporropQHOHMeH HJ1H He CeMepHLJ:eH. }:Ln5I J1IO,I{eH 3TO 6biJ1 6bi KY JlbrypHbiH ill OK, I1 OHM He

CMOrJ1H 6bi I10H5ITb, KaK TaKOe COOpy)KeHHe 6biJ10 ITOCrpOeHO. 0,I{HaKO 11,I{J15I 3TOrO rrepHO,I{a

xapaKTepHbi TaKHe 3,I{aHH5I KaK TaspHLJ:eCKHH ,I{BopeQ3

pa60Tbi CTaposa. A TaK )Ke OH 5IBJ15IeTC5I

O,I{HHM H3 HaH6onee THnHLJ:HbiX KJlaCCHQHCTiflfeCKHX 3,I{amiH TieTep6ypra. I(eHTpMbHbiH

,I{BYX3Ta)KHbiH KOprryc ,I{BOpQa C llleCTH KOJ10HHbiM I10pTHKOM yseHLJ:aH I1J10CKHM KYITOJ10M.

lJlaBHbiH KOprryc 06be,I{HHeH O,I{H03Ta)KHbiMH ranepe5IMH C 60KOBbiMH ,I{BYX3Ta)KHbiMH

KOprrycaMH, orpaHHLJ:HBaiOI.IJ;HMH lliHpOKHH rrapa,I{HbiH ,[{BOp". 4

TaKHe coopy)KeHllii KaK TeaTpbi, se,I{OMCTBa, yLJ:e6Hbie 3aBe,I{eHI15I 6biJ1H O,I{HHMH H3 caMbiX

pacrrpOCTpaHeHHbiX ITOCTpOeK I1 CLJ:HTaJ1HCb ITOCTpOHKaMH TOrO BpeMeHH. ECJ1H TI.I.{aTeJlbHO

ITO,I{yMaTb II rrepeOCMbiCJ1HTb, TO 3TO ,I{eHCTBHTeJlbHO TaK. Bo MHOrHX 113 3THX 3,I{aHHH 6biJ1

BH,I{eH CBOH C06CTBeHHbiH CTHJ1b, KOTOpbiH 6biJ1 rrepe,I{aH LJ:epe3 pa3H006pa3HOCTb QBeTa I1

1 oa/laKMHa T.Vl., http://protown.ru/, PyccKaR apXI4TeK"fYpa nepaoi-1 n0/10BI4Hbl 19 BeKa, 2008

2 3)laHrre ceHaTa B MocKOBCKOM Kpe1vme. 1783 npe,llocTaBJieno nrrJKe. 3 TaBpH'ICCKHll )lBopen: npeAOCTaB/leHHoe HM>Ke.

4 Caxapoa A.H.,<http:/ /archirussia.com/istoriya-2/klassicizm-v-arxitekture-rossii/>, KllaCC14U,143M a apXMTeK"fYpe

PoccMM, 11 AeKa6pR2012

3

oT,n:eJIKM. TaK KaK 3TOT CTMJib 6hiJI, B Haqane BeKa M u:apcKoe BpeM5I Bee eme npeo6na,n:ano, 3TOT

apxiiTeKTypHbiH CTMJib QqeHb XOpOlllO BnMCbiBaJIC5I M 6hiJI npM3HaH Hapo,n:OM. CB5I3M C TeM qTQ

3TOT CTMJib He 6biJI CTOJib HOBbiM M He06biqHbiM Hapo,n:y OH He Ka3aJIC5I y:>I<aCHbiM M TeM CaMbiM

np05IBMB XOpornee BneqaTJieHMe Ha JIIO,n:eif. JliO,L(5IM 6biJI MHTepeceH 3TOT KpaCMBbiH M

M3biCKaHHbiH CTMJib.

3i>artUe ceHama e MocKOBCIWAt f{peJHJie. 1783

4

TaeputteCKUii oeopelf

B TO BpeM.H BO rnaBe rocy,lJ.apcTBa CTO.HJI u:aph HHKonail II. OH yiTpaBJI.HJI cTpaHoil ITPH ITOMOI.IJ:H

OrpOMHOH apMHH 'IHHOBHHKOB. Ilo 3aKOHY OHH 6hiJII1 HCITOJIHHTemiMH BOJIH u:ap.H, HO B

,lJ.ei!cTBHTeJihHOCTH 'IHHOBHH'IeCTBO Hrpano 6onee 3Ha'IHTeJibHYIO ponh. B ero pyKax 6hma

pa3pa60TKa 3aKOHOB, OHO )Ke ITpeTBOp.HJIO HX B )KI13Hb.

Mo)l<HO cpaBHHTh ITpaBHTeJihCTBO HHKOJIM II c coBpeMeHHhiM ITpaBmeJibCTBOM

BeJIHK06pHTaHHI1. r)J.e ,lJ.~e ITpHTOM, 'ITO y HHX eCTb KOpOJieBa, KOTOpa.H MO)KeT ITpaBHTb, OHa

He MO)KeT C,lJ.enaTh Heqero 6e3 pa3pewemm ITapnaMeHTa. Ero BJiaCTh He 6hma CTOJih Ba)l(Ha

ITOTOMY 'ITO ITO 60JiblliOMY cqery OH He MOr ITpaBHTb CTpaHOH. If ITpH'IHHOH BCeMy 3TOMY 6hiJia

ero He CITOC06HOCTb MaHHITYJIHpOBaTh JllO,lJ.bMH. Jho)J..HM B ITepHO,lJ. ero ITpaBJieHH.H He 6hiJIO

11CJia,lJ.K0

11 TaK KaK HeKOTOpbie C06hiTU.H, KOTOpbie ITpOHCXO,lJ.HJIH B 3TO BpeM.H 6hiJII1 ITO erO

ITpHKa3Y, HO 0 KOTOpbiX OH ,lJ.a)l<e He 3HaJI. Il03TOMY JllO,lJ.H He BepHJIH B ero CHJibi I1 TO 'ITO UX

)K)J.eT B 6y.lJ.ymeM.

lf3 3a TOrD 'ITO TBOpHJIOCb C ITpaBHTeJihCTBOM PoCCHH B 3TO BpeM.H JllO,lJ.H He MOfJIH 60Jibllie

TepiTeTb I1 IT03TOMY 6hiJia opraHH30BaHHa peBOJIIOI.:(H.H.

5

IlpHY:HHhi peBOJIIOUHH 6hiJIH oeHOBaHhi Ha yxy~weHHe MaTepHaJibHOro ITOJIO)f(eHH51 TPY~5IIIJ;HXe51

H3-3a KpH3Hea 1900- 1903 rr. H pyeeK0-5IITOHeKoM: BOHHhi 1904-1905rr. 5

To Y:TO KpeeTh51He

~OJI)f(Hbi 6hiJIH pa60TaTb ITO 18 Y:aeOB B ~eHh 3TO y)f(aeHO. 3TO HapyrnaeT Bee HOpMbi I1 5IBJUieTe51

He ~OITyeTHMbiM. KoHelfHO )f(e OHH ITO~H5IJIH 6yHT I1 peliiHJIH OTeT05ITb eBOH ITpaBa. B 3TO BpeM51

OTeTaHBaTh CBOH ITpaBa 6hiJIO He~oiTyeTHMO, ITOTOMY lfTO Bee KpeeTh51He 6hiJIH eo6CTBeHHOeThiO

KOpOJUI I1 OHH He HMeJIH ITpaBa B03pa)f(aTb ero perneHI15IM. Ho ueey KOTOpyiO HM HY)KHO 6hiJIO

3aiTJiaTHTh 1fT06hr ITOJIYlfHTh 3TY CITpaBe~JIHBOeTh, He B03MmKHO 11 ITpe~CTaBHTh. He B03MO)!CHO

ITpe~eTaBHTb BeiO 3TY 60Jib qepe3 KOTOpyiO HM ITpHliiJIOeh ITpOHTH. fi03TOMY peBOJIIOUI151 6hiJia

HX IToene~HeM: Ha~e)f(HOH, 3a 6oph6y 3a eiTpaBe~JIHBOeTh.

l'I3-3a HOBbiX ITpaBHJI, KOTOpbie 6hiJIH ITOeTaBJieHbi uapeM, 6biJIH o6pa30BaHHbi HOBbie

eouHaJihHhie rpyiTIThi " 6yp~a3HH". 06eTaHOBKa B eTPaHe 11 TaK 6hrna He olfeHh xopoweM:

ITOTOMY Y:TO ITpaBHTeJibeTBO Y:HHOBHHKOB 6hiJIO BeehMa He OpraHH30BaHHb!M I1 uapb He KaK He

Mor pernHTh ITpo6neMbi e He~oBOJiheTBOM o6meeTBa. B eBoeM: BHYTPeHHeM: ITOJIHTHKe HaY:ana

XX B. ITpaBHTeJibeTBO He eMOrJIO y~OBJieTBOpHTb 3aiTpOehi HH O~HOH eOUHaJibHOH rpyiTITbi.

)J;a)f(e ITOMeiiJ;HKH 6hiJIH He~OBOJihHbi, TaK KaK, ITO HX, MHeHHIO, BJiaeTh 0Ka3aJiaeb HeeiTOe06HOH

3aiiJ;HTHTb HH ee651, HH eBOIO eOUHaJihHYIO OITOpy. Cpe~H KOHeepBaTHBHO- MOHapXHY:eeKOH

qaeTH HaeeneHH51 (IToMern;HKH, ~yxoBeHeTBO, KYITUhi ) IT05IBHnaeh H~e51 eo3~aHH51 ITOJIHTHY:eeKHX

HJIH o6rn;eeTBeHHbiX OpraHH3aUHH ~JI51 ITOMOIIJ;H ITpaBHTeJiheTBY B ero 60pb6e e

peBOJIIOUHOHepaMH I1 JIH6epanaMH.

0~HHMH 113 OeHOBHbiX 3a~aq peBOJIIOUHH 6biJIO- BBe~eHHe eB060~bl eJIOBa, eo6paHHH, ITapTHH

11 o6be~HHeHHif; YHHY:TmKeHHe ITO-Mern;Hlfhero 3eMJieBna~eHH51 11 Ha~eneHHe KpeeTh5IH 3eMneM:;

eOKparn;eHHe ITpO~OJI)f(HTeJihHOeTH pa6oqero ~H51 ~0 8 qaeOB, ITpH3HaHHe ITpaBa pa60Y:HX Ha

eTaY:KH H e03~aHHe ITpo<PeeCHOHaJibHbiX eOI030B; yeTaHOBJieHHe paBeHeT-Ba Hapo~OB PoeenH.

5 COL\V1AilbHO-nOllV1TV14ECKvH1 CTPO~ V1 06LL\ECTBEHHOE ,IJ,BV1}!{EHV1E B POCCV1V1 B HA4AilE XX s.

6

HOBbiX CTpOHTeJ1bHbiX MaTepHaJIOB rrpOH30IIIJ10 COBepiiieHCTBOBaHHe apXHTeKT)'pHbiX CTHJ1eH.

liTO B CBOIO oqepe.D:b 0Tpa3HJ10Cb Ha CTHJ1HCTHKe 3.[{aHHH qTO rrpHBeJ10 HaCK BOrrpocy: A KaK :>Ke

J1IO,[{I1 OrpearHpOBaJIH Ha :no? 3TOT BOITpOC oqeHb Ba)KeH, TaK KaK HMeHHO peaKU:IDI J1IO,[{eH

6biJ1a Ba:>KHa. Be.[{b 3TO HMeHHO OHH 6yJJ:yT XO.[{HTb B 3TH TeaTpbi, My3eH, Mara3HHbi H KaK He

CTpaHHO BCe 3TO HaXO,[{HJ10Cb B HX HHX pyKaX. TaK o6pa30M o6pa30BaJIC.H CTHJ1b «MOJJ:epH».

rJ1aBHOH qepTOH 3TOro CTHJ1.H 6biJ10 BOCITpH.HTHe rrpOCTbiX H.[{eH I1 yMeHHe HCITOJ1b30BaTb HX B

HOBOM HarrpaBJ1eHHI1. A TaK )Ke xapaKTepHbiM 3J1eMeHTOM 3TOrO CTHJ1.H 6biJ10 HCITOJ1b30BaHHe

rrpe.n:MeTOB ITOBCe,[{HeBHOrO 06HXO.[{a, KOTOpbie HeCJ1H OTrreqaTOK HapO.[{HbiX H,[{eH H Tpa.D:HU:HH.

O.n:HHM H3 caMbiX BhiJJ:aiOmwxc.H apxmeKTopoB Poccwn 6hiJ1 IllexTeJ1b. B

TBOpqeCTBe <D.0.lliexTeJ1.H (1859-1926) B HaH60J1biiieH Mepe BOITJ10THJ1HCh OCHOBHhie

TeH.[{eHU:HH pa3BHTIDI H :>KaHpbi pyCCKOfO MOJJ:epHa. 9CTaHOBJ1eHHe CTHJ1.H B TBOpqeCTBe MaCTepa

IIIJIO ITO ABYM HarrpaBJ1eHH.HM - HaU:HOHaJibHO-pOMaHnJ.qeCKOMY, B pyCJ1e Heo-pyCCKOrO CTHJ1.H I1

paU:HOHaJlbHOMY. 10

O.n:HHM H3 caMbiX HHTepeCHbiX rrocTpoeK Toro BpeMeHH 6hm Oco6IDIK P.H6yiiiHHCKoro ll'

TaK KaK B HeM nyqiiie Bcero BHJJ:HO BJ1IDIHHe Mo.n:epHa Ha apxHTeKTypy PoccwH. EbiJIH

HCITOJ1b30BaHhi HOBbie H,[{eH qTO 6biJIO ,[{OBOJihHO pHCKOBaHHO, HO BCe :>Ke OHH rrpOH3BeJIH

ITOJ10:>KHTeJibHbie OTpbiBbi OT Hapo.n:a. 3TO 6biJ10 oqeHb CMeJ1biM peiiieHHeM, TaK KaK 3TO 6hiJ10

qeM TO eiiJ,e oqeHb HOBbiM I1 He H3Be.[{aHHbiM. il03TOMY MHOrHe cqwTaJIH, qTO lliexTeJib rrpO.HBHJI

HeHCTOBYIO CMeJIOCTb, C,[{eJ1aB, qTO TO B 3TOM HOBOM cnme. Be.[{h HHKTO He 3HaJI, KaK 3TO

BOCITpHMeT 06IIJ,eCTBO.

CaM OC06H.HK BbirJ1e.[{eT He COBCeM B CTHJie MOJJ:epH IillH KaK 3TO eiiJ,e MO)J<HO Ha3BaTb B

MocKOBCKOM CTHJie Mo.n:epH. OH He oco6o BbiJJ:emreTC.H cpe.n:w ocTaJihHhiX 3JJ:aHHH HO 3aTo

9 ryros A.r <http://1143help.ru/rusarhitektura-skulrtura19-nach20 >,PyccKail apXlo1TeKrypa KOHL\a 19- Ha4aJla 20 BeKa, 2007

10 Poll\eHR fJ..A. <http:/ /www.nivestnik.ru/2001_3/6.shtmi>,Mop,epH PyccKoi1 Apxl-1TeKrypbl Ha4aJla 20 seKa, 2001

11 Oco6mrK P5l6ymnHcKoro rrpe,LiocTannen HIDKe

8

BHYTPM 3TO rrpOI13Be,n:eHMe MCKYCCTBa. necTHMI.(bi I1 CTeHhi OT,n:enaHhi .n:o ManeH:rneH: .n:eTanM I13

KaMH5I I1 MpaMOpa, BCe c,n:enaHO oqeHh I13biCKaHO, I1 o6,n:yMaHHO.

Oco6HRK PR6yuamc7W20

3TOT CTMflb B KOpHe 0TflMqanC5I OT KnaCCMI.(I13Ma I1 He TOflbKO MaTepHanOM, KOTOpbiH 6hin

MCI10flb30BaH HO I1 BCeM OCTaflhHbiM, TaKMMM BeJ.I.:(aMM KaK rapMOHlfqHOCTb, 6anaHC Me:/l<,n:y

<PopMaMM I1 rrporrOpl.(I15IMI1. KnaCCMI.(I13M 6hin oqeHh 3a)l{aT 11 6hin OCHOBaH Ha CTepeOTI1ITaX

rpeqeCKOH apX11TeKTYpbl CO BCeMI1 KOflOHHaMI1 11 TpeyronhHbiMI1 KpbilliaMI1. B 0Tfllfql1e OT

KnaCCI11.(113Ma MO,n:epH 6hin 6onee CB06o,n:eH 11 He 11Men rpaH11l.(, OH 6h!fl OTHOCMTenhHO HOBbiM I1

eme He .ll:O KOHI.(a 113yqeHHhiM. Bee 3TO MO)l{HO cpaBHI1Tb Ha nyTellieCTBMe B Hei13Be,n:aHHOe.

KnaccMI.(I13M 3TO TO qTo Te6e y)l{e oqeHh xoporno 113BeCTHO M Thi y)Ke 3Haernh Bee OT KpaH:HOCTI1

)l:O KpaHHOCTM. Ho B COITOCTaBneHMIO B KflaCCMI.(I13MOM MO,n:epH 3TO KaK Hei13Be,n:aHHa5I 3eMn5I r,n:e

HeT, KaKI1X, TO CTepeOTI1I10B I1 rpaHI1l.(, MO)l{HO TBOp11T; BCe qTO yro,n:HO 11 KaK yro,n:HO. B 3TOM 11

COCTOI1T pa3HI1l.(a Me)!{ 3TI1MI1 CTI1fl5IMM B apX11TeKrype.

9

Bmumue EBponhi B 3noxy Mo.llepHHJMa B Poccuu

Ha py6e)J{e BeKOB, cHaqana B EBpone, a 3aTeM B Poccm1, Bee qame ncnOJib3YeTC5I CJIOBO

«modern», 0603HaqHBillee HOBbie TeH,[{eHI . .'(HH B 3aCTpOHKe ropO.[{OB H B CaMOH apxHTeKType

,[{aBrnee HM5I HOBOMY CTHJIIO. ITepBbiH apxHTeKTOp, KOTOpbiH HCTIOJib30BaJI, HOBbie TeXHHKH H3

CTHJIJI MO.[{epH 6bm EenbrHH:ueM no HMeHH BHKTOP OpTa. OH aKTHBHO ncnOJib30BaJI HOBbie

MaTepHMbi, B nepByro oqepe.[{b, MeTaJIJI H cTeKJio.12

B EBpone 3TOT CTHJib 6biJI 6onee pa3BHT H3

3a TOrO qTO OH 6biJI 6onee 3HaKOM H npHBbiqeH. 0H He CHJibHO OTJIHqaJIC5I OT npeBe.[{ymero

apXHTeKTypHOrO CTHJI5I H TI03TOMY JIIO,[{H CTIOKOHHee OTHOCHJIHCb H TaKOMY orpOMHOMY

pa3H006pa3HIO.

HoBbiH CTHJib Bonnoman B ce6e nepeocMbiCJieHHoe eBponeH:cvoe HCKyccTBO, 3CTeTHqecKoe

o6o6meHHe OTibiTa qeJIOBeqecTBa, HCTOpHqeCKHX Tpa.[{HUHH, HaJIO)J{eHHbiX Ha H,[{eiO

nporpecca. 13

0H TibiTaJIC5I npeO.[{OJieTb pa3,[{eJieHHe, npOTHBOpeqHJI Me)K,[{y paUHOHaJibHOCTbiO H

H35ImeCTBOM, KpaCOTOH If TIOJib30H.

qTO KacaeTC5I PyCCKOrO MO,[{epHa TaK 3TO TO qTO OH HeMHOrO OTJIHqaJIC5I OT MO.[{epHa B

EBpone. PyccKHH MO.[{epH o6na.[{an HeKOTOpbiMH oco6biMH qepTaMH, Bbl,[{eJIJIIOmHMH ero H3

MaCChi npoqHX CTHJieH. Bo nepBbiX C6JIH)J{eHHe apXHTeKrypbi H HCKYCCTBa. )J;o MO,[{epHH3Ma B

uepKB5IX POCCHH CTeHbi He 6biJIH paCTIHCaHbi Q:>peCKaMH HJIH XOTb KaKHM-TO ,[{eKOpOM. C

TI05IBJieHHeM MO,[{epHH3Ma XY.[{O)J{HHKH HaqaJIH BOCTipHHHMaTb 3,[{aHHe KaK XOJICT, Ha KOTOpOM

3HaqHMbi .[{a)Ke CaMbie MeJibqaii:rnHe ,[{eTaJIH, BKJIIOqaJI .[{eTaJIH BeyTpeHHero CTpOeHH5I, KOTOpbie

rapMOHWfHO BTIHCbiBaiOTC5I B o6myro KOHUeTIUHIO.

12 Pow.eHfl /J,.A. <http://www.nivestnik.ru/2001_3/6.shtmi>,Mop,epH PyccKot:i Apx"lTeKrypbt HaYaJla 20 seKa, 2001

13 Pow.eHfl /J,.A. <http://www.nivestnik.ru/2001_3/6.shtmi>,Mop,epH PyccKot:i ApX"lTeKrypbt HaYaJla 20 seKa, 2001

10

Bo BTOpbiX. apxrneKT)'pa Mo):{epHa pacrrpOCTPaiDieTC5I He TOJibKO B O):{HOM CTHJie a Cpa3y B ):{BYX

pa3HbiX CTHJI5!X. 0):{HH 5!BJI5leTC5I MO):{epHH3MOM B MOCKBe, a ):{pyrOH MO):{epHH3MOM B

I1eTep6ypre. 14

0):{HHM 113 5IpKHX rrpHMepOB MOCKOBCKOrO MO):{epHH3Ma 5!BJI5leTC5! 5lpOCJiaBCKHH BOK3aJI

ITOCTPOeHHH B 1862 H OTpecTaBpHpOBaHHOM ITO):{ CTHJib MO):{epHa B 1902 ro):{y apXHTeKTOpOM

0 .lliexTeJieM. XOTb OH H 6biJI OTpeCTaBpHpOBaH B rrepHO):{ MO):{epHa 3TO ):{OBOJibHO CJIQ)KHO

ysH):{eTh TaK KaK caMo 3):{aHHe BOK3aJia 6oJibllle rroxo)I<e Ha opHrHHaJihHYIO rrOCTPOHKY

C,l:{eJiaHHIO B rrepHO):{ apXHTeKT)'pHOrO KJiaCCHl.(H3Ma. 0):{HaKO lliexTeJib BCe-TaKH ITOI1biTaJIC5!

BHeCTH H3MeHeHH5!, TaKHe KaK rrpOCTOpHbie BeCTH6IOJIH H y):{06Hbie I10MeilieHH.5!. CKa30qHOrO

TepeMKa CTami BOITJIOIIIeHHeM MO):{epHa. TeM He MeHee 6biJIH BH):{Hbl HeKOTOpbie 3JieMeHTbi

KJiaCCHI.(H3Ma.

B I1eTep6ypre caMhiM Bbi):{al01IIHMC5! rrpHMepoM MO):{epHa MO)I(HO Ha3BaTh ,l.J;oM

KoMrraHHH «3HHrep». 3To 3):{aHHe so HCTHHY MO)I(HO Ha3BaTh YHHKaJihHbiM. ApxHTeKTop ITasen

CI030p ):{eHCTBHTeJibHO HCI10Jlb30BaJI HOBbie H):{eH H 3a):{yMKH KOTOpbie OH rrepeiDIJI OT pa60T

C):{eJiaHHbiX B Esporre, H HCI10Jlb30BaJI HX KaK OCHOBY CBOero rpaH):{H03HOrO rrpOeKTa.

"ilepBOHaqaJibHO pyKOBO):{CTBO KOMITaHHH «3HHrep», rrpOH3B0):{5!IIIeH IllBeHHbie MalllHHbi,

XOTeJIO ITOCTpOHTb He60CKpe6, I10):{06HbiH TOMY, qTO B 3TO BpeM5I CTpOHJIC5I KOMITaHHeH B HblO­

HopKe: MHOr03Ta)I(HOe 3):{aHne co MHO)I(eCTBOM oqmcos. 0):{HaKo 3):{aHH.5!. B QeHTPe CaHKT­

I1eTep6ypra He Mornn rrpeBhiillaTb 23,5 MeTpos ,1:{0 KapHH3a. ApxnTeKTop 6neCT5!1IIe pa3pelllHJI

3TO rrpOTHBOpeqne: Ha,l:{ IlleCTblO 3Ta)KaMH C MaHcap):{OH OH B03BeJI H3.5!.1IIHYIO 6alllHIO,

yBeHqaHHyiO CTeKJI5!HHbiM rJio6yCOM, ,l:{HaMeTp KOTOpOrO 2,8 M. J1MeHHO 3Ta, ycTpeMJieHHM

BBbiCb 6allliDI, H C03):{aeT BrreqaTJieHHe BbiCOTHOCTH. 11 15

Ha cpoHe ):{pyrHX 3):{aHHH OHO oqeHb

Bbi,l:{eJI5IeTC.5!. ):{a)I(e ceilqac, HeCMOTp5I Ha BCe ):{pyrHe 6oJiee COBpeMeHHbiX 3,l:{aHH.5!.. rnaBHbiM

14 Poll\eHR A.A. <http:/ /www.nivestnik.ru/2001_3/6.shtmi>,Mo,a,epH PyccKOH Apx~o1TeKrypbl Ha4ana 20 seKa, 2001

15 http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/,AoM KOMnaHHH «3HHrep»,

11

cpaKTopoM 6hm, ,nH3aifH eaMoro 3,QaHIDI Bee :no 6hiJIO O'IeHb eMeno 11 04eHh ,neTaJibHO. BH,a:Ho,

4TO apXHTeKTOp XOTeJI I10Ka3aTb rapMOHHt:{HOeTb I1 eOOTHOliJeHI15l BKyea I1 eTHJI5l B 3TOH

ITOeTpOHKH. lfTO 6biJIO ,[{0B011bHO HHTepeeHO 3TO TO 4TO 3aKa3'II1KI1 3TOrO 3,QaHH5l XOTe11I1 3,QaHHe

KOTOpOe ITOXO,[{H110 6bi Ha He60eKpe6bi KOTOpbie B TO BpeM5I T011bKO Ha'IaJII1 B03BO,[{HTbe5I B

HbiO-llOpKe. I1 XOT5l apXHTeKTOp yqe11 :>Ke11aHHe 3aKa34HKa OH Bee :>Ke eMOr H306pa3HTb eBOH

eo6eTBeHHbiH YHHKaJibHbiH eTH11b, KOTOpblH He ITOXO)K HH Ha O,[{HH.

KaK 3TO He TPY,a:Ho 3aMeTHTb ecTh BH,QHMa5I pa3HHIJ;a Me)K,Qy Mo,nepHOM B MoeKBe 11

IJeTep6ypre. Pa311H'IHe ,QBYX HarrpaBJieHHH eoeT05l110 B cpopMe H erroeo6e BOITJIOIIJ;eHI15I H,neif:

,[{115! MoeKBbi 6hiJIH xapaKTepHbi IImpoTa H pa,nHKa11hHOeTh eaMOBbipa:>KeHH5I, ,[{115! I1eTep6ypra -

v 16 0 e,nep)KaHHOeTb 4yBeTB, I13BeeTHOe KaK «eeBepHbiH MO,nepH» . ,[{HHM 113 Ba)KHbiX 311eMeHTOB \

KOTOpbiH 6hiJIO e03,naHHe KOMcpOpTa, a He KpaeOTbi. I10TOMY 'ITO JllO,[{I1 rrepeeTaJIH 6biTb

pa360p'II1BbiMI1 B HeKyeeTBe I1 rrepeeTaJII1 BH,[{eTb pa3HI1IJ;y Me)K,Qy KpaeHBbiM H He KpaeHBbiM a

Ha'IaJIH 3aMe4aTb T011bKO TO 4TO rreeTpOe.

16 Pomen5l ,[(.A. <http://www.nivestnik.ru/2001_3/6.shtml>,MoAepn PyccKoii Apx>ITeK'fYpbi naqa..rw 20 Berm, 2001

12

3.n:aHH5I B CTHJie Mo.n:epH B MocKse:

JlpOCJlG6CKUii 60K3GJTJ902

3.r:t:aHH5I B CTHJie MO.r:t:epH B IleTep6ypre

Jf:oM KOMl'IGHUU «3UN2ep» ]902

13

KaK y)Ke 6biJIO CKa3aHo, apxHTeKrypa MO.[(epHa pa3Hoo6pa3Ha. Bo speM5I MO.[(epHa see Te

nOH5ITH5I KOTOpbie 6biJ1H 3HaKOMbi 6biJ1H y)Ke He yMeCTHbi H no:3TOMY He TOJlbKO apXHTeKTOpaM H

CTpOHTeJI5IM npMIIIJIOCb nepeCMOTpeTb CBOYI B3rJI5I.[(bi Ha YICKyCCTBO. CTI1Jlb 3TOT B06pan B ce65I

3JieMeHTbi BCeX npe.[(IIIeCTBYIOW:Y!X CTMJieM. 3.[(aHI15I B CHUie MO.[(epH MOryT HanOMY!HaTb l1

MaBpHTaHCKHe .[(BOpUbi, l1 3aMKH, l1 3aBO.[(CKI1e KOpnyca. 0.[(HaKO, B OTJIWIHe OT ero

npe.[(IIIeCTBeHHYIKOB, MO.[(epH He KOnlipOBaJI cpopMbi peHeCCaHCa l1 6apOKKO.

ITepHO.[( apxmeKTypbr KOHUa XIX- Haqana XX BeKa oueHHBaJIC5I no-pa3HOMY. HeKOTOpbie

soo6w:e BhrqepKMBaiOT ero l13 MCTOPMM apxMTeKT)'pbi, .[(pyrMe paceMaTpMBaiOT KaK nepMO.[(

yna.[(Ka, TpeTbli BH.[(5IT B HeH nO.[(rOTOBY!TeJibHbiH nepi10.[( B pa3BHTI1l1 ,[(aJihHeifiiieM apXI1TeKT)'pbi.

0.[(HaKO CTY!Jlb MO.[(epH 3aH5IJI esoe MeeTO B MeTOpY!H apxHTeKTypbi KaK O.[(YIH H3 eaMbiX Ba)KHbiX

B pa3Bl1THH MeKyeeTBa He TOJlbKO B PoeeHM HO H Espone. XOT5I o6a CTHJI5I MO.[(epHa 6biJ1H

nOXO)KH Me)K.[(y eo6oif , MO.[(epHH3M B PoeeHM nopa3I1Jl O'IeHb MHOrO JIIO.[(eif MMeHHO eBOYIM

HOBIIIeeTBOM H eMeJIOeTbiO HenOJib30BaTb qTO TO HOBOe.

BocnpiUITHe HOBOI'O CTHJISI apXHTeKrypbi

ApXMTeKTypa KaK HeOT'heMJieMa5I qaeTb HaiiieM )Kl13HH 3aqaeryiO HeBep05ITHO MeH5IeT Hallie

BOenpi15ITI1e OKpy)l<aiOW:ero MHpa. ManeifiiiHe l13MeHeHH5I, KaK HOBbie noeTpOMKH HJIYI eHOe

eTapbiX 3.[(aHHH, BJieKyT 3a eo60M He TOJlbKO npeo6pa)KeHHe npoerpaHeTBa, HO H

nepeoeMhiCJieHHe MeeTa qenoseKa BHYTPM H3MeHHBIIIeroe5I MHpa. I1MeHHO 3TO H enyqMnoeb e

JIIO.[(bMM B nepMO.[( Cepe6p5IHOro BeKa. T(H5I HHX 3TO 6hiJIO qTo-To spo.[(e y.[(apa. HaKTo H3 JIIO.[(eii:

He Mor eMHpHThe5I e HOBIIIeeTBaMu. B nepsoe speM5I JIIO.[(RM 6biJIO eJIO)KHO a,[(anTuposaTbe5I,

nOTOMY qTO Be5I MeeTHOeTb r.[(e OHH paHbiiie )KHJIH H 3HaJIH y)Ke He BbirJl5I.[(eJia no-npe)l<HeMY.

Bee l13MeHHJIOeb 6yKBaJibHO 3a HeeKOJlbKO JleT. 3TO TO )Ke eaMOe, eeJIH 6bi B.[(pyr B UeHTpe

MoeKBbi noeTpOHJIH He6oeKpe6hr KaK B HbiO-HopKe. KoHeqHo, peaKUH5I JIIO.[(eii 6y.[(eT

.[(OBOJibHO npe.[(eKa3yeMa. Bee Ha•myT naHHKOBaTb H He eMoryT, noH5ITb, qTo )l<e 3.[(eeb TBOpHTe5I.

14

ilMeHHO TaKOe 6biJIO nepBOe BneqaTJieHMe 06W:eCTBa Ha M3MeHeHM5I B apXMTeKType B KOH[(e

XIX BeKa. Ho BCKope Bee YTMXJIO M mo.nM cTaJIM npMBbiKaTb K nocTpoliKaM M3 cTeKJia M 6eroHa.

A TaK :>Ke mo.nn 6hiJIM npn5ITHO IIIOKnpoBaHbi pacnMCHbiMM <PpecKaMH, KOTopoe Tenepb

yKpaiiiaJin u:epKBM M co6opbi.

KOHeqHO He Bee JIIO.UM 6biJIH B BOCTOpre OT TaKHX nepeMeH. Eyp)l<ya3H If JIIO.UH BbiCOKOrO

KJiacca 6biJIM B BOCTOpre TIOTOMY qTO OHH HliKOr.[la He BM.UeJIH Heqero TIOT06HOrO M HM 6biJIO

HHTepeCHO BCe He H3Be.[laHHOe II HOBOe. JliO.UH KOTOpbie 6biJIM M3 6oJiee HH3KOrO KJiacca TaKHe

KaK KpeCTb5IHe H pa6oqne 6biJIH BeCbMa He .[lOBOJibHbi TaK KaK OHM TOJibKO CTaJIM 11

CB060.UHbiMI111

OT npaBMTeJibCTBa u:ap5I M TaKMe nepeMeHbi .UJI5I HHX 6hiJIO CJIHIIIKOM y)K MHoro nepeMeH B O.UHO

BpeM5I. Ho BCe, )ICe JIIO.UM CMOrJIH npHH5ITb H3MeHeHH5I B apXMTeKType, XOT5I B nepBOe BpeM5I MM,

6hmo, CJIO:>KHO CMMPHTC5I c 3THM. Ho co BpeMeHeM OHM npMBbiKJIH H npHcnoco6HJIHCb K HOBbiM

apxmeKrypHbiM nocTpoliKaM. KaK Boo6w:e TO Bee Mbi .uomi<Hbi npnHHMaTh HOBoe n ocTaBJI5ITb

CTapoe TI03a.UH, He 3a6biBa5I 0 HeM HO I1 He )lCaJie5I 0 TOM qTO OHO y)lce YIIIJIO. Hy)KHO CMOTpeTb B

6y.nyrn:ee H a.nanTHpOBaTbC5I K HOBOMY CTHJIIO )l<If3HM M TeM, l:fTO HaC Q)KH.[laeT.

B XO.Ue BCeX 3THX nepeMeH, B apxmeKTypHbiX CTHJI5IX H TIOJIHTifqeCKHX pe<PopMaX

e.[lHHCTBeHHOe, l:fTO OCTaJIOCb HeH3MeHHbiM 3TO JIIO.[lli. 3TO He 3Hal:fHT, l:fTO JIIO.UM He

H3MeHMJIHCb , 3TO 3Hal:fHT l:fTO, He CMOTP5I Ha BeCb 3TOT xaoc, KOTOpbill TBOpHJIC5I BOKpyr. 0HI1

BCer.[la 6y.nyT OKpy)lceHbi HM, H TIOTOM HM npHIIIJIOCb Bbi6MpaTb, XOTeJIH JIH OHH 3TOrQ HJIH HeT.

0rJI5I.[lbiBa5ICb Ha TO qTO 6biJIO CKa3aHO B 3TOM 3CCe MO:>KHO CKa3aTb l:fTO BJIH5IHMe qeJIOBeKa Ha

BeW:M 5IBJI5IeTC5I Ol:feHb Ba)KHOli qacTbiO KYJihTYPbi cTpaHbi. Be.nh MMeHHO JIIO.UH cocTaBmiiOT

o6rn:eCTBO, KOTOpOe KpMTHKYeT HJIM Ha060pOT BOCXMW:aeTC5I H3MeHeHM5IMM B crpaHe.

KaK 5I y)lce rOBOpHJia Ha npOT5I:>KeHMH BCero 3CCe JIIO.UH He BCer.na 6biJIH B BOCTOpre OT TOrO l:fTO

npm1cxO.UMJIO B PoccMn Ha npoT5I:>KeHHH BpeMeHM. EcJIH JIIO.U5IM HpaBHJIHCb H3MeHeHH5I B

apxMTeKrypHbiX CTMJI5IX, .no Haqana Cepe6p5IHOro BeKa TO npo6neMoli 6hiJIO rocy.uapcTBo,

15

KOTOpOe B 3TO BpeM5I He 6hiJIO CaMbiM Ha_ne)KHbiM ll CTa6HJibHbiM. I1 Ha060pOT, eCJill )Ke

CllT)'aUll5I B CTpaHe C ITOJlllTll'IeCKOH CTOpOHbi 6hiJia B XOporneM COCT05IHllll, TO B03M0)KH0

apxHTeKTypa 6hma rro,nBep)KeHa KpHTHKe. EcJIH _na)Ke oHa 6bma rro,nBep)KeHa KpHTHKe, c o,nHo:H

CTOpOHhi 3TO BCe )Ke 6hiJIO XOpOlllHM 3HaKOM, ITOTOMY 'ITO 3TO 3Ha'lllJIO 'ITO, JII0.[(5IM He

6e3pa3Jill'!Hbi ll3MeHeHll5I, KOTOpbie I1pOHCXO.[(HJlll BOKpyr HllX.

IIo3TOMY, pa3yMeeTc5I, Bee JIIO,nH MoryT ornn6aThC5I HJIH He rrpaBHJihHO rrOH5ITh H3MeHeHH5I,

KOTOpbie B 6y,nymeM MOryT rrpHHeCTH MHOrO XOpornero.

ITo MOHM rrpe.nrroJIO)KeHH5IM peaKUI15I pyccKoro Hapo.na Ha Bee 3TH H3MeHeHH5I 6hma 6hi

ITOJIO)KHTeJihHOH, ITOTOMY 'ITO llMeHHO ll3MeHeH5I B KY Jib Type CTpaHhi BJII15IIOT Ha CaMY crpaey ll

ee JIIO,ne:H. 3TO MeH5IeT TO KaK JIIO.[(ll CMOTp5IT Ha )Kll3Hb ll TO KaK OHll CMOrp5IT Ha TO KaK OHll

)KllByT. TaKlle ll3MeHeHll5I B apXHTeKT)'pe KaK C03,[(aHlle qero TO HOBOrO 6hiJill HMeHHO TeM

TOJI'IKOM, KOTOpbiH ITOMOr 6hi Jll0.[(5IM ITOCMOTpeTh Ha BCe CO CTOpOHbi. fiOH5ITb, 'ITO HMeHHO llM

Ba)KHO a 'ITO MO:>KHO ll OCTaBHTb TaK KaK eCTb.

B XO,ne H3y'leHll5I 3TOH TeMhi H rrepeMeH KOTOpbie rrpOI130lllJIH 3a TaKOe KOpOTKOe BpeM5I, 5I

CMOrJia HaHTll OTBeT Ha CBOll BOI1p0Cbl ll y,nOCTOBepllTC5I B TOM 'ITO ll3MeHeHll5I BCe )Ke CblrpaJIH

O'leHh I103llTllBHO Ha BOCI1pll5ITllll llX JIIO.[(bMll.

B 3aKJIIOIJeHne xoTeJIOCh 6hi "Bee 'ITO He ,neJiaeTC5I Bee K nyqrneMY". 0TBe'la5I Ha Borrpoc: KaK

mMeHeHll5I B PyccKo:H apxHTeKType Cepe6p5IHOro BeKa, rro3HTHBHO oTpa3HJIHCh Ha rroHHMaHHll

ll BOCI1pll5ITHe llMH pyCCKllM HapO,nOM. JI Y3HaJia MHOrO pa3HhiX cpaKTOpOB KOTOpbie ITOBJlll5IJlll

Ha rrepeMeHhi B apXHTeKType ll BOCI1pll5ITHe 3TllX cpaKTOpOB JIIO.[(bMll. A TaK )Ke TO KaK Ha BCe

3TO 6hiJIO BOCI1pHH5ITO Hap,nOM pyCCKHM.

E,nHHCTBeHHOe 'ITO MO)KHO .no6aBHT K BCeMY TOMY a IJeM 5I y)Ke rrepe'IHCJIHJia 3TO TO KaK 3TO

CKa3aJIOCb Ha 6y,nymeM PoCCHll. Ce:Hqac Mbl MO)KeM CKa3aTb 'ITO BCe Te ll3MeHeHH5I KOTOpbie

16

npOXO,[(HJIH: BeKaMH Ha DpOT5DKeHl'JH MHOrO BpeMeHH, B pe3yJibTaTe CbirpaJIH 60JibliiYIO pOJib B

apxHTeKTypHbrx 3aMhrcnax H B KYJihTYPHOM pa3BHTHH PocCHH B uenoM.

Ho BCe, :>Ke JIIO,[(H CMOrJIH npHH5ITb H3MeHeHH5I B apXHTeKrype, XOT5I B nepBOe BpeM5I HM, 6biJIO,

CJIQ)KHO CMHpHTC5I c 3THM. Ho co BpeMeHeM OHH npHBbiKJIH n npHcnoco6HJIHCb K HOBbiM

apxHTeKrypHbiM TIOCTpOHKaM. KaK B006II.(e TO BCe Mbl ,[(OJI:tKHbi npHHHMaTb HOBOe H OCTaBAATb

CTapoe TI03a,[(H, He 3a6hiBa5I 0 HeM HO H He :tKaJie5I 0 TOM LITO OHO y:>Ke yuiJIO. Hy:tKHO CMOTpeTb B

6y,[(yll(ee H a,[(aTITYipOBaTbC5I K HOBOMY CTHJIIO :tKH3HH H TeM, LITO HaC O:tKH,[(aeT.

Be,[(b TQ)Ke CaMOe npOXO,[(HT H C HaMH CeHLiaC. Mbl B TOll :>Ke CHrya[(HH LITO H OHH HO TOJibKO Mbl

He 6biJIH KpeCTb5IHaMH, y KOTOpbiX He 6biJIO npaB. Ho 3aTO Mbi 6biJIH rpa)K,[(aHaMH, KOTOpbiM

6biJIO 3anpell(eHO nyTellleCTBOBaTb H B006II.(e ,[(yMaTb, a TOM, LITO :>Ke 6biJIO TaM 3a npe,[(eJiaMH

Coi03a. H TaK )Ke KaK H B HaLiaJie BeKa HOBbie apxuTeKrypHbre CTHJIH OTKpbiTbr nepe,[( HaMH H

MO:tKeT 6biTb ,[(J15I MOJIO,[(OrO TIOKOJieHH5I 3TO He TaK liiOKHpyiOII.(ee KaK ,[(JI5I 6onee TIO:tKHJIOrO HO

BCe TaK )Ke 6biCTpO MeH5IeTC5I H HHOr,[(a AyMaelllb a TOM BpeMeHH KOr,[(a He 3HaJIH LITO TaKOe

BbiCOTKH B HbiO HopKe u LITO MQ)KHO nocTpouTb 3,[(aHue B 100 3Ta)Keil ueJIHKOM H3 cTeKJia.

TaK LITO cpaKT TOrO LITO MHp H BCe B HeM BCe BpeM5I MeH5IeTC5I He ,[(OJI:tKeH OCTaHaBJIHBaTb H

nyraTh Hac. TioToMy LITO 3TO TOJibKO HaLiana XXI BeKa rAe eme MHoro He TOJibKO

apXHTeKTypHbiX HO H KYJibTypHbiX OTKpbiTHH 6yAyT C,[(eJiaHbl.

.6JiarOAap5I 3TOH pa6oTe 51 CMOrJia TIOH5ITb KaK H TIOLieMY :>Ke BCe TaK H3MeHHJIOCb H KaK JIIO,[(H

6opOJIHCb 3a TO LITO OHH CLIHTaJIH npaBHJibHbiM, liT06bi CeHLiaC Mbl MOrJIH BCTIOMHHTb BCe

npOH30llle,[(IIIee H 6biTb pa,[(bl LITO BCe o6epHy JIOCb HMeHHO TaK.

I1 BCe )Ke npoaHaJIH3HpOBaB BCe LITO 6biJIO Bbiiiie CKa3aHO, MQ)KHO TIO,[(BeCTH HTOr TOrO 'ITO

apXHTeKrypa, KYJibrypa H pa3BHTHe CTpaHbi 6y,[(eT BCer,[(a MeH5IeTC5I He 3aBHCHMO OT BpeMeHH H

He LITO He 6y,[(eT CTIOC06HO 3TO OCTaHOBHTb. Ho 3aTO JIIO,[(H Bcer,[(a MOryT npHOCTaHOBHTbC5I

LIT06bi TIOCMOrpeTb LITO TBOpHTC5I BOKpyr HHX H npHH5IT BepHOe peiiieHHe. 3TO O,[(Ha H3 Ba:tKHbiX

OTKpblTH.H C,[(eJiaHHbiX BO BpeM5I H3yLieHH5I 3TOH TeMbi.

17

En6JmorpalJ>nH

EaJiaKHHa T.H., <http://protown.ru/information/hide/4720.html>,PyccKaj! apxHTeKIJ'pa HaqaJia

20 BeKa,2008

EaJiaKHHa T.H., < http://protown.ru/information/hide/4717.html >, PyccK~ apxHTeKIJ'pa

nepBOH TIOJIOBHHbi 19 BeKa, 2008

1yToB AT <http://1143help.ru/rusarhitektura-skulrtura19-nach20 >,PyccK~ apxHTeKTypa KOHU.a

19 - HaqaJia 20 BeKa, 2007

HamoKHHa, M. B < http://www. di ssercat. com/ content/modem-v -arkhitekture-moskvy-problema­

svoeobraziya-i-zapadnoevropeiskikh-vliyanii>, Mo.[{epH B apxuTeKrype MocKBbi :Tipo6neMa

CBOeo6pa3Hji H 3aTia,[{HOeBponeifCKHX BJ1Hj!HHH,2000, 15 ,[l;eKa6pji 2012.

PomeHj! ,IJ;.A. <http://www.nivestnik.ru/2001_3/6.shtml>,Mo.[{epH PyccKoif ApxHTeKIJ'pbi

HaqaJia 20 BeKa, 2001

CaxapoB A.H.,<http:l/archirussia.com/istoriya-2/klassicizm-v-arxitekture-rossii/>, KnacCHIJ.H3M

B apxHTeKType PoccHH, 11 ,IJ;eKa6pj! 2012

18