tyco model ec-25 storage sprinkler

20
Benefits of the TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler James Golinveaux Jeff Barkley Kevin Maughan

Upload: duongquynh

Post on 03-Jan-2017

242 views

Category:

Documents


7 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

Benefits of the TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

James GolinveauxJeff BarkleyKevin Maughan

Page 2: TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

Copyright © 2011 Tyco Fire Protection Products. All rights reserved.

The products and specifications published herein are for general evaluation and reference purposes only and are subject to change by Tyco Fire Protection Products without notice. For the most up-to-date information, please visit www.tyco-fire.com. The infor-mation provided in this application paper should not be relied on as a substitute for professional advice concerning specific appli-cations. ALTHOUGH TYCO FIRE PROTECTION PRODUCTS HAS ENDEAVORED TO ENSURE ITS ACCURACY, ALL INFORMATION HEREIN IS PROVIDED ON AN “AS IS” BASIS, WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EITHER EXPRESS OR IMPLIED. Without limiting the foregoing, Tyco Fire Protection Products does not warrant the accu-racy, adequacy or completeness of any such information. All users of the information provided herein assume the risk of use or reliance on such information and Tyco Fire Protection Products shall not be liable for any damages for such use including, but not limited to, indirect, special, incidental or consequential damages.

Benefits of the TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

Page 3: TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

Benefits of the TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

1

Contents

Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2

Benefits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2

Better Fire Protection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3

Sprinkler Spacing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7

NFPA 13 Operating Pressures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10

FM Global Lowest Hydraulic Demand . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12

Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14

About the Authors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15

References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16

Page 4: TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

Benefits of the TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

2

IntroductionTyco Fire Protection Products developed, introduced, and improved the revolutionary technology of Extended Coverage sprinklers for Extra Hazard and Storage Occupancies. The TYCO Model EC-25 Sprinkler provides the complete package for the higher density, extended coverage requirements of the fire sprinkler industry. The Model EC-25 Sprinkler is a “Control-Mode Extended Coverage Sprinkler” for Extra Hazard and High Piled Storage occupancies in accordance with NFPA 13 (2002 and later editions) and a “Storage Sprinkler” in accordance with FM Global Data Sheet 8-9. Its use is especially advantageous as a means of protecting occu-pancies requiring an density/area application of water while providing better fire protection than standard coverage sprinklers.

BenefitsKey benefits of the Model EC-25 Sprinkler include lower installed cost and better fire protection when com-pared to standard coverage sprinkler systems. These benefits are provided by:•Fewer opened sprinklers and fewer consumed pallets than K-8.0 (115), K-11.2 (160), and K-16.8 (240)

standard coverage sprinklers as shown in full-scale fire tests performed at UL•Fewer branch lines and fewer sprinklers as a result of the extended coverage area•Lower operating pressures in accordance with the S x L Spacing Rules defined by NFPA 13, Section 8.5.2•Lowest hydraulic system demand provided in FM Global Property Loss Prevention Data Sheet 8-9,

July 2011 Revision, and Engineering Bulletin 06-11

Page 5: TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

Benefits of the TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

3

Better Fire ProtectionNew fire protection technologies are tested against baseline performance. Baseline tests for virtually all NFPA 13 density/area applications for high piled storage were performed with K-5.6 (80) sprinklers in the early 1970s. Current laboratory protocol includes more stringent pass/fail criteria than existed for these base-line tests. New technologies such as the Model EC-25 Sprinkler must duplicate the same testing with equal or better results.The following table shows fire test results for K-5.6 (80) and K-11.2 (161) standard coverage sprinklers spaced at 100 ft2 (9,3 m2) versus Model EC-25 Sprinklers spaced at 196 ft2 (18,2 m2).

Table 1: 20-ft (6,10 m) High Rack Storage of Class II Commodities in a 30-ft (9,14 m) High Building with a Density of 0.37 GPM/ft2

Fire Test Series #74

Model EC-25 Extended Coverage

Sprinkler at 196 ft2 (18,2 m2)

K-5.6 (80) Standard Coverage

Sprinkler at 100 ft2 (9,3 m2)

K-11.2 (161) Standard Coverage

Sprinkler at 100 ft2 (9,3 m2)

Number of Open Sprinklers 4 18 9

Number of Pallets Consumed 1 41 5

Pressure 8.5 psi (0,59 bar)

43 psi (3,00 bar)

11 psi (0,76 bar)

Gas Peak Temperature 682°F (361°C)

829°F (443°C)

631°F (333°C)

Gas 1-Minute Peak Temperature 462°F (239°C)

765°F (407°C)

570°F (299°C)

Steel Peak Temperature 138°F (59°C) Not Measured 308°F

(153°C)

Steel 1-Minute Peak Temperature 137°F (58°C) Not Measured 306°F

(152°C)

As you can see from Table 1, in protecting Class II Commodities, the Model EC-25 Sprinkler:

•activated fewer sprinklers,•consumed the lowest number of pallets,•operated at lower pressures, and•maintained lower temperatures.

Page 6: TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

Benefits of the TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

4

Testing a higher fire risk, the following table compares K-8.0 (115) and K-11.2 (161) standard coverage sprin-klers spaced at 80 ft2 (7,4 m2) with the Model EC-25 Sprinkler spaced at 196 ft2 (18,2 m2).

Table 2: 15-ft (5,6 m) High Palletized Storage of Group A Plastic Commodities in a 25-ft (7,6 m) High Building with a Density of 0.6 GPM/ft2

Fire Test Series SP-18

Model EC-25 Extended Coverage

Sprinkler at 196 ft2 (18,2 m2)

K-8 (115) Standard Coverage

Sprinkler at 80 ft2 (7,4 m2)

K-11.2 (161) Standard Coverage

Sprinkler at 80 ft2 (7,4 m2)

Number of Open Sprinklers 2 24 16

Number of Pallets Consumed 6 20 2

Pressure 22 psi (1,52 bar)

36 psi (2,48 bar)

19 psi (1,31 bar)

Gas Peak Temperature 506°F (263°C)

2004°F (1096°C)

1509°F (821°C)

Gas 1-Minute Peak Temperature 282°F (139°C)

1818°F (992°C)

1377°F (747°C)

Steel Peak Temperature 133°F (56°C) Not Measured 203°F

(95°C)

Steel 1-Minute Peak Temperature 132°F (56°C) Not Measured 196°F

(91°C)

As you can see from Table 2, in protecting Group A Plastic Commodities, the Model EC-25 Sprinkler returned results similar to those shown for Class II Commodities (Table 1). Specifically, the Model EC-25 Sprinkler:

•activated fewer sprinklers, •operated at lower pressures, and•maintained lower temperatures.

Page 7: TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

Benefits of the TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

5

When comparing a larger K-factor sprinkler such as the K-16.8 (242) standard coverage sprinkler spaced at 100 ft2 (9,3 m2) with the Model EC-25 Sprinkler spaced at 196 ft2 (18,2 m2), the Model EC-25 Sprinkler pro-vides better fire protection even at the minimum operating pressure.

Table 3: 15-ft (4,6 m) High-Rack Storage of Group A Plastic Commodities in a 25-ft (7,6 m) High Building

Fire Test Series RSP-7

Model EC-25 Extended Coverage

Sprinkler at 196 ft2 (18,2 m2)

Model EC-25 Extended Coverage

Sprinkler at 100 ft2 (9,3 m2)

K-16.8 (242) Standard Coverage

Sprinkler at 100 ft2 (9,3 m2)

Density 0.6 > 0.6 [1] 0.6

Number Open Sprinklers 1 3 7

Number of Pallets Consumed 1 4 4

Pressure 22 psi (1,52 bar)

7 psi (0,48 bar)

12.5 psi (0,84 bar)

Gas Peak Temperature 294°F (146°C)

264°F (129°C)

537°F (281°C)

Gas 1-Minute Peak Temperature 152°F (67°C)

189°F (87°C)

312°F (156°C)

Steel Peak Temperature 89°F (32°C)

132°F (56°C)

135°F (57°C)

Steel 1-Minute Peak Temperature 88°F (31°C)

131°F (55°C)

134°F (57°C)

[1] At the minimum required pressure of 7 psi (0,48 bar), the Model EC-25 Sprinkler flows 67 GPM (253,6 LPM). This flow, over a coverage area of 100 ft2 (9,3 m2), results in an actual density of 0.67 GPM/ft2 (27,2 mm/min).

As shown in Table 3, the Model EC-25 Sprinkler once again outperformed standard coverage sprinklers with the following consistent results:

•activated fewer sprinklers, •consumed the same or the lowest number of pallets even at a pressure of 7 psi (0,48 bar),•operated at lower pressures, and•maintained lower temperatures.

Page 8: TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

Benefits of the TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

6

Comparing the Model EC-25 Sprinkler in unobstructed and obstructed construction applications, the Model EC-25 Sprinkler demonstrated exceptional performance while protecting Group A Plastic Commodities, as shown in Table 4. Note that the 15-in obstruction test simulated standard coverage “distance from obstruc-tion” requirements, rather than extended coverage requirements. In essence, the Model EC-25 Sprinklers were positioned closer to the obstruction than allowed by extended coverage obstruction rules.

Table 4: 20-ft (6,1 m) High-Rack Storage of Group A Plastic Commodities in a 25-ft (7,6 m) High Building with 0.6 GPM/ft2

Model EC-25 Sprinkler at 196 ft2 (18,2 m2)

Unobstructed Obstructed

Obstruction Depth None 9 inch 15 Inch

Number of Open Sprinklers 4 3 3

Number of Pallets Consumed 1 2 3

Pressure 22 psi (1,52 bar)

22 psi (1,52 bar)

22 psi (1,52 bar)

Gas Peak Temperature 955°F (513°C)

1194°F (646°C)

1369°F (743°C)

Gas 1 Minute Peak Temperature 570°F (299°C)

733°F (389°C)

955°F (513°C)

Steel Peak Temperature 151°F (66°C)

201°F (94°C)

270°F (132°C)

Steel 1 Minute Peak Temperature 150°F (66°C)

193°F (89°C)

269°F (132°C)

While the performance of the Model EC-25 Sprinkler was degraded by the increasing size of the obstruction, this sprinkler still performed well with low pressure, few activations, and the impressive statistic of consuming only 3 pallets of material.

Figure 1: FM obstruction test arrangement

7'-0"42" 42"

15"8"

7"Sprinkler

Obstruction

Ceiling

Top of Commodity

5'-4"

Page 9: TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

Benefits of the TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

7

Sprinkler SpacingNFPA 13 sprinkler spacing rules for extended coverage extra hazard and storage sprinklers are cited in Table 8.8.2.1.2 in the 2010 and 2007 Editions and Chapter 8.8.2 in the 2002 Edition. New in the 2007 Edition, the 15 ft (4,6 m) maximum spacing of extended coverage sprinklers offers even greater flexibility in optimiz-ing the number of sprinklers in a bay, as well as the location of outlets on the branch lines, especially when used with welded or mechanical tee fittings. Even when the 15-ft (4,6 m) maximum spacing allowance does not save a branch line, the ability to space the Model EC-25 Sprinkler at 12 ft (3,7 m) along the branch lines results in typical 24-ft (7,3 m) branch line pipe lengths with 2 outlets. Standard coverage sprinklers hav-ing the 100 ft2 (9,3 m2) spacing maximum result in spacing along the branch lines at 8 ft-0 in or 8 ft-3 in (2,4 m or 2,5 m), requiring 3 outlets and the possibility of non-typical branch line pipe lengths. Table 5 summarizes the spacing allowance for extended coverage sprinklers in Extra Hazard and High-Piled Storage Occupancies in NFPA 13. This table shows maximum spacing based on coverage area regardless of obstruction:

•14-ft maximum spacing when coverage area exceeds 144 ft2 (13,4 m2) up to 196 ft2 (18,2 m2) coverage area, or

•15-ft maximum spacing when coverage areas are equal to or less than 144 ft2 (13,4 m2)

Table 5: Summary of NFPA 13 Table 8.8.2.1.2 Coverage Areas and Maximum Spacing for Extended Coverage Sprinklers

Extra Hazard/High-Piled Storage

Construction Type Coverage area Spacing

Unobstructed/ Obstructed196 ft2 (18,2 m2) 14 ft (4,3 m)

144 ft2 (13,4 m2) 15 ft (4,6 m)

Using the larger coverage area or the larger spacing provides a significant amount of flexibility, resulting in significant branch line savings when using the Model EC-25 Sprinkler as shown in Table 6.

Table 6: Branch Line Spacing in Various Bay Dimensions

Bay Spacing > 25 ft to 28 ft [2] (7,6 m - 8,5 m)

> 28 ft to 30 ft (8,5 m - 9,1 m)

> 36 ft to 42 ft (11,0 m - 12,80 m)

> 42 ft to 45 ft (12,8 m - 13,7 m)

Standard Coverage Sprinkler 12 ft at Max. 100 ft2

(3,7 m at Max. 9,3 m2)3 Branch Lines 3 Branch Lines 4 Branch Lines 5 Branch Lines

Model EC-25 Sprinkler 15 ft at Max. 144 ft2

(4,6 m at Max. 13,4 m2)2 Branch Lines 2 Branch Lines 3 Branch Lines 3 Branch Lines

Model EC-25 Sprinkler 14 ft at Max. 196 ft2

(4,3 m at Max. 18,2 m2)2 Branch Lines 3 Branch Lines 3 Branch Lines 4 Branch Lines

[2] NFPA exception for a 25 ft (7,6 m) bay – 12 ft-6in (3,8 m) is allowed for standard coverage sprinklers. The 12 ft-6 in (3,8 m) exception is not allowed for bays larger than 25 ft (7,6 m).

Page 10: TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

Benefits of the TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

8

The branch line saving includes not just the material, but a reduction in the labor required to hang the branch lines and install the sprinklers. As shown in Figure 1 with optimal bay sizing, you can save a branch line and take advantage of the full 196 ft2 (18,2 m2) coverage area.

Versus

>25’-0” to 28’-0”(7,62 to 8,53 m)

7’-0”(2,13 m)

14’-0”(4,27 m)

14’-0”(4,27 m

)14’-0”

(4,27 m)

10’-8 1/2”(3,26 m

)10’-8 1/2”(3,26 m

)10’-8 1/2”(3,26 m

)

4’-8”(1,42 m)

4’-8”(1,42 m)

9’-4”(2,84 m)

9’-4”(2,84 m)

7’-0”(2,13 m)

>25’-0” to 28’-0”(7,62 to 8,53 m)

Extended Coverage196 ft2 (18,2 m2)2 Branch Lines

Standard Coverage100 ft2 (9,3 m2)3 Branch Lines

Bay Bay

Figure 2: Branch Line Spacing in Bays More Than 25 to 28 ft (7,6 to 8,5 m) for a Full Coverage Area of 196 ft2 (18,2 m2)

Page 11: TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

Benefits of the TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

9

In some bays where you cannot take advantage of the full 14-ft (4,2m) spacing with 196 ft2 (18,2 m2) coverage area, you can take advantage of the Model EC-25 Sprinkler’s flexibility to reduce a branch line at the lower 144 ft2 (13,4 m2) coverage area.

Versus

>28’-0” to 30’-0”(8,53 to 9,14 m)

7’-6”(2,29 m)

15’-0”(4,57 m)

9’-7”(2,93 m

)9’-7”

(2,93 m)

10’-0”(3,05 m

)10’-0”

(3,05 m)

10’-0”(3,05 m

)

5’-0”(1,52 m)

5’-0”(1,52 m)

10’-0”(3,05 m)

10’-0”(3,05 m)

7’-6”(2,29 m)

>28’-0” to 30’-0”(8,53 to 9,14 m)

Extended Coverage144 ft2 (13,38 m2)2 Branch Lines

Standard Coverage100 ft2 (9,3 m2)3 Branch Lines

Bay Bay

Figure 3: Branch Line Spacing in Bays More Than 25 to 30 ft (7,6 - 9,1 m) for a Reduced Coverage Area of 144 ft2 (13,4 m2)

Page 12: TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

Benefits of the TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

10

NFPA 13 Operating Pressures With the Model EC-25 Sprinkler, the myth that extended coverage sprinklers require too much pressure has been shattered. Keep in mind that this sprinkler has the flexibility of the S x L Spacing Rules for the purpose of hydraulic calculations (density/area method). NFPA 13 (2002 and later) states for determining the cover-age area of sprinklers listed for extended coverage extra hazard or high-piled storage “shall be permitted to be spaced in accordance with the requirements of 8.5.2 and 8.5.3”. Sections 8.5.2 and 8.5.3 allow the S x L Spacing Rules normally reserved for standard coverage sprinklers to determine the maximum area of coverage for these extended coverage sprinklers. Traditionally, extended coverage sprinklers such as residential squared off the maximum spacing dimension. For example, when calculating a 14 ft x 10 ft (4,3 m x 3,0 m) actual spacing for traditional extended coverage sprinklers, NFPA required squaring the maximum dimension of 14 ft (4,3 m), for a result of 196 sq ft2 (18,2 m2), rather than the actual 140 ft2 (13,0 m2). The allowance of S x L Spacing Rules for the extended coverage extra hazard or high-piled storage extended coverage sprin-klers allows the actual 140 ft2 (13,0 m2) to be used for the hydraulic calculation of the system. This allowance results in lower required sprinkler flows as compared to the “squared-off” method required for other extended coverage sprinklers for light hazard and ordinary hazard occupancies and residential sprinklers.

The 2010 Edition of NFPA 13 states the S x L Spacing Rules as follows: 8.5.2 Protection Areas per Sprinkler.

8.5.2.1 Determination of the Protection Area of Coverage.

8.5.2.1.1 The protection area of coverage per sprinkler (As) shall be determined as follows: (1) Along branch lines as follows:

(a) Determine distance between sprinklers (or to wall or obstruction in the case of the end sprinkler on the branch line), both upstream and downstream.

(b) Choose the larger of either twice the distance to the wall or the distance to the next sprinkler.

(c) This dimension will be defined as S.

(2) Between branch lines as follows:

(a) Determine perpendicular distance to the sprinkler on the adjacent branch line (or to a wall or obstruction in the case of the last branch line) on each side of the branch line on which the subject sprinkler is positioned.

(b) Choose the larger of either twice the distance to the wall or obstruction or the dis-tance to the next sprinkler.

(c) This dimension will be defined as L.

8.5.2.1.2 The protection area of coverage of the sprinkler shall be established by multiplying the S dimension by the L dimension, as follows: As = S x L

Page 13: TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

Benefits of the TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

11

While the Model EC-25 Sprinkler, when used in accordance with NFPA 13 (2010), affords very low oper-ating pressures when spaced at 196 ft2 (18,2 m2) across a wide range of densities, even lower pressures can be realized by reducing the spacing to less than 196 ft2 (18,2 m2) but greater than the maximum of 100 ft2 (9,3 m2) allowed for standard coverage sprinklers. Refer to Table 7 for examples of required pressures at different spacings greater than 100 ft2 (9,3 m2).

Table 7: NFPA 13 Operating Pressures at Different Spacings for the Model EC-25 Sprinkler

Spacing of Model EC-25 Sprinklers

Density

0.37 GPM/ft15,1 mm/min

0.45 GPM/ft18,3 mm/min

0.6 GPM/ft24,4 mm/min

0.8 GPM/ft32,5 mm/min

1.0 GPM/ft40,7 mm/min

100 ft2 or 10 ft x 10 ft 7.0 psi 7.0 psi 7.0 psi 10.1 psi 15.8 psi

(9,3 m2 or 3,0 m x 3,0 m) (0,48 bar) (0,48 bar) (0,48 bar) (0,70 bar) (1,09 bar)

120 ft2 or 10 ft x 12 ft 7.0 psi 7.0 psi 8.2 psi 14.5 psi 22.7 psi

(11,1 m2 or 3,0 m x 3,7 m) (0,48 bar) (0,48 bar) (0,57 bar) (1,00 bar) (1,57 bar)

140 ft2 or 10 ft x 14 ft 7.0 psi 7.0 psi 11.1 psi 19.8 psi 30.9 psi

(13,0 m2 or 3,0 m x 4,3 m) (0,48 bar) (0,48 bar) (0,77 bar) (1,37 bar) (2,13 bar)

144 ft2 or 12 ft x 12 ft 7.0 psi 7.0 psi 11.8 psi 20.9 psi 32.7 psi

(13,4 m2 or 3,7 m x 3,7 m) (0,48 bar) (0,48 bar) (0,81 bar) (1,44 bar) (2,25 bar)

150 ft2 or 12 ft x 12 ft-6 in 7.0 psi 7.2 psi 12.8 psi 22.7 psi 35.4 psi

(13,9 m2 or 3,7 m x 3,8 m) (0,48 bar) (0,50 bar) (0,88 bar) (1,57 bar) (2,44 bar)

168 ft2 or 12 ft x 14 ft 7.0 psi 9.0 psi 16.0 psi 28.4 psi 44.4 psi

(15,6 m2 or 3,7 m x 4,3 m) (0,48 bar) (0,62 bar) (1,10 bar) (1,96 bar) (3,06 bar)

182 ft2 or 13 ft x 14 ft 7.1 psi 10.6 psi 18.8 psi 33.4 psi 52.2 psi

(16,9 m2 or 4,0 m x 4,3 m) (0,49 bar) (0,73 bar) (1,30 bar) (2,30 bar) (3,60 bar)

196 ft2 or 14 ft x 14 ft 8.3 psi 12.3 psi 21.8 psi 38.7 psi 60.5 psi

(18,2 m2 or 4,3 m x 4,3 m) (0,57 bar) (0,85 bar) (1,50 bar) (2,67 bar) (4,17 bar)

Page 14: TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

Benefits of the TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

12

FM Global Lowest Hydraulic DemandWhile ESFR Sprinklers have become the standard in ceiling-only storage protection over the last several years, the Model EC-25 Sprinkler now has the lowest system demand specified in FM Global Property Loss Prevention Data Sheet 8-9, July 2011 Revision, and Engineering Notice 06-11. The Model EC-25 Sprinkler only requires a 6-sprinkler design for ceilings of 30 ft (9,0 m) or less as compared to ESFR sprinklers that require a 12-sprinkler design. Reducing the sprinklers in the design by half translates into a significant saving in hydraulic demand for the system while almost doubling the sprinkler’s coverage area resulting in fewer branch lines and sprinklers.

Table 8: Design Hydraulic Requirement Including Hose for Class 1 to 4 and Cartoned Unexpanded Plastic Commodities for Ceiling Height of 30 feet (9,0 meters) in Open Frame Rack Storage Arrangements

Model EC-25 Sprinkler

ESFR K-14 (200) Sprinkler

ESFR K-17 (240) Sprinkler

ESFR K-22 (320) Sprinkler

ESFR K-25 (360) Sprinkler

Number of Sprinklers 6 12

Pressure 30 psi (2,07 bar)

50 psi (3,45 bar)

35 psi (2,41 bar)

25 psi (1,72 bar)

20 psi (1,38 bar)

Hose Allowance

250 GPM at 196 ft2

(950 LPM at 18,2 m2)

250 GPM at 100 ft2

(950 LPM at 9,3 m2)

Hydraulic Requirement

Including Hose

1078 GPM at 196 ft2

(4080 LPM at 18,2 m2)

1438 GPM at 100 ft2

(5440 LPM at 9,3 m2)

1443 GPM at 100 ft2

(5412 LPM at 9,3 m2)

1594 GPM at 100 ft2

(5957 LPM at 9,3 m2)

1602 GPM at 100 ft2

(6061 LPM at 9,3 m2)

[3] FM Global Loss Prevention Data Sheet 8-9 now requires all storage sprinkler designs to be based on the number of sprinklers calculated at a set pressure, as opposed to the Density/area option prescribed by NFPA 13, for control-mode sprinklers.

[3]

Page 15: TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

Benefits of the TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

13

The Model EC-25 Sprinkler requires an 8-sprinkler design for ceilings of 35 ft (10,5 m) compared to ESFR sprinklers, which require 12 sprinklers. This one-third reduction of sprinklers required in the design trans-lates into a significant saving in hydraulic demand for the system while requiring fewer branch lines and sprinklers.

Table 9: Design Hydraulic Requirement Including Hose for Class 1 to 4 and Cartoned Unexpanded Plastic Commodities for Ceiling Height of 35 feet (10,5 meters) in Open Frame Rack Storage Arrangements

Model EC-25 Sprinkler

ESFR K-14 (200) Sprinkler

ESFR K-17 (240) Sprinkler

ESFR K-22 (320) Sprinkler

ESFR K-25 (360) Sprinkler

Number of Sprinklers 8 12

Pressure 40 psi (2,76 bar)

75 psi (5,17 bar)

50 psi (3,45 bar)

35 psi (2,41 bar)

30 psi (2,07 bar)

Hose Allowance

250 GPM at 144 ft2

(950 LPM at 13,4 m2)

250 GPM at 100 ft2 (950 LPM at 9,3 m2)

500 GPM at 196 ft2

(1.900 LPM at 18,2 m2)

N/A at 196 ft2 (18,0 m2)

Hydraulic Requirement

Including Hose

1525 GPM at 144 ft2

(5769 LPM at 13,4 m2)

1705 GPM at 100 ft2

(6423 LPM at 9,3 m2)

1676 GPM at 100 ft2

(6338 LPM at 9,3 m2)

1840 GPM at 100 ft2

(6899 LPM at 9,3 m2)

1906 GPM at 100 ft2

(7210 LPM at 9,3 m2)

1775 GPM at 196 ft2

(6719 LPM at 18,2 m2)

N/A at 196 ft2 (18,2 m2)

The Model EC-25 Sprinkler provides similar savings for Class 1 to 4 and Cartoned Unexpanded Plastic Commodities in Solid-Piled, Palletized, Shelf, or Bin-Box storage arrangements.For storage buildings, the average ceiling height is the range of 27 to 34 ft (8.2 to 10.4 m). Therefore, for most buildings, the Model EC-25 Sprinkler provides a new level of performance that requires less water over a larger coverage area with fewer branch lines, fewer sprinklers, and often lower pressures than ESFR sprinklers in common use today.

Page 16: TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

Benefits of the TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

14

SummaryIn summary, the TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler provides lower installed cost and better fire protec-tion when compared to standard coverage sprinkler systems because of these key benefits:

•Better Fire Protection In fire tests that compared the Model EC-25 Extended Coverage Sprinkler with K-8.0 (115), K-11.2 (160), and K-16.8 (240) standard coverage sprinklers, the Model EC-25 Sprinkler opened fewer sprinklers and consumed fewer pallets.

•Fewer Branch Lines The Model EC-25 Sprinkler provides significant flexibility in optimizing the number of branch lines in a bay supporting distances from 8 ft to 14 ft (2,4 m x 4,3 m) with a coverage area up to 196 ft2 (18,2 m2). Spacing to the 15 ft (4,6 m) maximum is allowed with a maximum coverage area of 144 ft2 (13,4 m2).

•Fewer SprinklersThe same extended coverage that reduces the number of branch lines also reduces the number of sprin-klers on the branch lines.

•Lower Operating PressuresUsing the NPFA 13 S x L Spacing Rules, the Model EC-25 Sprinkler can cover smaller areas while oper-ating at lower pressures, delivering 0.67 GPM/ft (27,2 mm/min) at 100 ft2 (9,3 m2) spacing with an oper-ating pressure of only 7 psi (0.48 bar).

•Lowest Hydraulic System Demand The Model EC-25 Sprinkler provides a minimal water requirement, combined with extended coverage spacing, for ceiling heights of 35 ft (10,5 m) or less as provided in FM Global Property Loss Prevention Data Sheet 8-9, July 2011 Revision, and Engineering Bulletin 06-11.

To learn more about how you can use the TYCO Model EC-25 Sprinkler to reduce your installed system costs and provide better fire protection, contact your local Tyco Representative.

Page 17: TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

Benefits of the TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

15

About the AuthorsJames E. GolinveauxProduct General Manager, Water Fire Suppression, Tyco Fire Protection ProductsWith 29 years of experience in the fire protection industry including both contracting and manufacturing, Mr. Golinveaux is the General Manager of Water Suppression Products for Tyco Fire Protection Products. His current role applies his experience globally in the fire protection industry to develop advancements in water-based fire protection devices and systems. He sits on the Board of Trustees for the Fire Protection Research Foundation, as well as multiple other Boards and Councils including the Factory Mutual Advisory, AFSA, NFSA, International Fire Sprinkler Association, and the Fire Sprinkler Association of Brazil. He is also a member of the NFPA 13, 88A, 101, and 5000 Technical Committees. He has consistently served as a subject matter expert for the past two editions of the NFPA Fire Protection Handbook and the NFPA 13 Handbook.

Jeff BarkleyProduct Manager, Water Storage Products, Tyco Fire Protection ProductsWith over 20 years of product management and marketing experience in a variety of industries, Mr. Barkley is Product Manager for the Water Storage product line at Tyco Fire Protection Products, located at the Cranston Technology Center in Rhode Island. In this role, Mr. Barkley is involved with research, development, and support of existing and new products to protect high piled storage facilities such as warehouses and distribu-tion centers. Mr. Barkley has authored a number of technical papers in automatic test equipment, electronic design automation, and fire protection.

Kevin MaughanManager of Technical Services, Water Fire Suppression, Tyco Fire Protection ProductsMr. Maughan has been deeply involved in the fire protection industry for 29 years, with 13 years in the con-tracting side of the business and the remainder of his career in the manufacturing and R & D side of the busi-ness. Since 2004, he has served as Manager of Technical Services for Tyco Fire Protection Products. Currently, Mr. Maughan serves as a Principle NFPA Committee Member for NFPA 14, NFPA 24, and NFPA 80A.

Page 18: TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

Benefits of the TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

16

References Kung, Hsiang-Cheng, Vincent, Bennie G., and Troup, Joan M. A., “Performance Evaluation of Tyco Model EC-25 Control-Mode Extended-Coverage Sprinklers for Storage Occupancies,” FMRC Report J.I. 3007168/3007169, May 2001

Pabich, Martin J., and Sheppard, David T., “Report of Large-Scale Fire Tests of Retail Shelf Display and Rack Storage of Cartoned Group A Plastics Utilizing Extended Coverage Sprinklers Having a Nominal F-factor of 25.2,” UL Report 00NK22528, NC4119, November 2000

Troup, Joan M. A., “Full-Scale Fire Test Performance Evaluation of Central’s Model K17-231TM Sprinklers,” FMRC Report J.I. 0D1R8.PR (2), January 1998

Troup, Joan M. A., and Chicarello, Peter J., “Large-Scale Fire Tests of Stored Commodities Protected by Central Model D.64 Sprinklers,” FMRC Report J.I. 0W0R4.RR, September 1992

National Fire Protection Association, “Standard for the Installation of Sprinkler Systems - NFPA 13,” 2010 Edition

“Installation Guidelines for Automatic Sprinklers,” Loss Prevention Data Sheet 2-0, FM Global, Norwood, Massachusetts, January 2011

“Storage of Class 1, 2, 3, 4, and Plastic Commodities,” Loss Prevention Data Sheet 8-9, FM Global, Norwood, Massachusetts, January 2011

“Engineering Bulletin 06-11, TYCO Model TY9128, K25.2 EC (K360EC), Upright Storage Sprinkler Under Ceilings Over 30 ft (9,0 m) and Up to 35 ft (10,5 m) High,” FM Global, Norwood, Massachusetts, October 2011

Page 19: TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

Benefits of the TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

17

Page 20: TYCO Model EC-25 Storage Sprinkler

WORLDWIDE HEADQUARTERSTyco Fire Protection Products

451 N. Cannon Avenue

Lansdale, PA 19446

800-523-6512 / 215-362-0700

CRANSTON TECHNOLOGY CENTERTyco Fire Protection Products

1467 Elmwood Avenue

Cranston, RI 02910

Technical Services

800-381-9312 / 1-401-781-8220

www.tyco-fire.com October 2011