underwater vessel noise in the haro strait lindsay h. robinson university of puget sound intern with...
TRANSCRIPT
Underwater Vessel Noise in the Haro Strait
Lindsay H. RobinsonUniversity of Puget SoundIntern with Beam Reach
Marine Science and Sustainability School
Photo: Lindsay Robinson
Orcas’ Acoustic Environment• Orcas may be threatened in U.S.
and are endangered in Canada• ~ 100 whale watching vessels
interact with orcas every summer day in the Haro Strait
• This doesn’t include tankers, cargo ships and other commercial vessels.
• Vessel sound may disrupt the orcas’ ability to echolocate and communicate.
• Orcas responded to Navy ship in May 2002 by grouping together and staying at the surface.
• How loud are these boats?• What is the orientation of sound?• What implications might these
have on policy?
Photo:Guen Jones
•Study siteHaroStrait Friday
Harbor•Vancouver Island
Procedure and Instruments
• Cat’s Cradle was used as typical privately owned boat.
• At 3500 rpm’s, vessel ran transect from me on shore, over fixed hydrophones 0, 1 and 2.
• I used a laser range finder to measure distances.
• Sound was measured from approaching and departing vessel.
Photo: Val Veirs
•Me
H1H2
H0
H3
Analysis Methods• I used computer
sonogram program to find received levels from hydrophone 0.
• Formula for source level:
Source Level=
Received Level + Transmission Loss
Photo: Patrick Duffy
Source Level Results
Min
(dB)
Max (dB)
RL0 120 133
SL0 147 157
•Average Source level is 152 dB re 1µPa @ 1 meter.
Source Level w/ my spreading model
0
2
4
6
8
10
147 149 151 153 155 157
Source Level (dB)
Number of Events
Preliminary Asymmetry• Average SL for
approaching vessel:
154 dB re 1µPa @ 1m • Average SL for
departing vessel:
156 dB re 1µPa @ 1m • More data must be
analyzed to make any conclusions.
Departing Spreading Model dB rec = -15.219 Log R + 156.01
R2 = 0.8006
115
120
125
130
135
140
1 1.5 2 2.5
Log Distance
Recieved Level
Approaching Spreading Model
dB rec= -8.2364 log R + 144.16
R2 = 0.5674
dB rec= -15.421x + 154.32
R2 = 0.9817
120
125
130
135
140
1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2 2.2
Log Distance
Received Level
In context
• Source Levels of the Washington State Ferry, a whale herding device and an average orca call
• Received Level is an important perspective given different distances.
Photo: Val Veirs
Cat Pipe WSF Orca
SL 152 164 215 160
Dist. 100m 1km 10km 10m
RL 132 134 175 150
Assuming cylindrical spreading
Implications
• This study showed a method for measuring source levels that can be used on other vessels.
• “Be Whale Wise” guidelines may need to be updated.
• Vessels departing from whale watching may be inadvertently directing the most noise orcas.
Photo : Guen Jones
Conclusions
• Small private vessels probably aren’t the most disturbing sound in the area (Unless they are really close!)
• Other boats may prove to be asymmetrical or too loud to be in 100 meter range of orcas.
Photo: Lindsay RobinsonPhoto : Guen Jones
Sonogram frequency spectrum