uranium and radon: a public health perspective jean-claude dessau, md msss
TRANSCRIPT
URANIUM AND RADON:
A PUBLIC HEALTH PERSPECTIVE
Jean-Claude Dessau, mdMSSS
22
UraniumUranium
Heavy metal, radioactive, occurs naturally anywhere on earth
3 natural radio-isotopes : 238U (99,28 %), 235U (0,71 %), 234U (0,0054 %)
Estimated World production: 44 000 Tons/Year
CanadaCurrently the largest producer of uranium in the world (9000 tons of U3O8 in 2008, representing 20% of world production) before Australia and KazakhstanCanada has nearly 10% of global reserve
SaskatchewanThe Canadian company Cameco (subsidiary of Areva), which operates mines that are among the largest in the world. In 2011, the province will have ten operating sitesAthabasca Basin : Uranium content 12%
Nova Scotia and British ColumbiaMoratorium: real potential unknown
QuébecIntense exploration activity and development (no exploitation)
33
Approvals required before opening a uranium mine
Prospecting Licence (MRNF - Ministère des ressources naturelles et de la faune)Environmental Certificate of Authorization for advanced exploration work (excavation and stripping)(MDDEP - Ministère du développement durable, (CNSC-Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission)Obtaining a mining lease (MRNF)Filing a restoration plan and financial guarantees (Investors)Consultation of the Public Health Department (Direction de santé publique-DSP)Assessment and approvals at each stage of the project (CNSC - MDDEP)Mandatory public hearings (BAPE or its equivalent in Federal Territory)
Laws applying to uranium mining projects
Mining Law, Forest Law (MRNF), Law on Environmental Quality, Order 019 on the mining industry (MDDEP) Metal Mining Effluent Regulations (REMM), Health, safety and Security Law (LSST) and Nuclear safety and Control Law (CNSC)
Regulatory Process
44
Uranium in Quebec Uranium in Quebec
Dozens of mining companies to work
Over 200,000 active mining claims covering over 120,000 km2 (7% of Québec)
13% of exploration expenditures ($ 43M invested in over 220 projects)
Pegmatite and uranium vein concentration generally less than 1%
Ex: Project Matoush (0.34 to 0.89%)
55
Climatic
Economic
Energy
Environmental
Industrial / Technology
Medical (isotopes)
Public health
Societal and ethical
Key Issues
66
Chemical toxicity occurs at much lower doses than the radiological toxicity
This is why the Provincial Norm for drinking water is based on toxicity as inorganic metal (20 µg / L) and not as radionuclide
Mainly due to the ingestion of water rich in uranium
Institut National de Santé Publique du Québec - INSPQ has produced a factsheet on the toxicity of uranium in water.
Toxicological Risk of UraniumToxicological Risk of Uranium
7
Radiological risk of UraniumRadiological risk of Uranium
7
Radiological risk associated with ingestion, inhalation and exposure to external radiation
Risk potentially more important during periods of exploitation The exploration does not pose a risk to health or the environment
Health Hazard Radon and its decay products are historically responsible for high levels of
lung cancer listed among uranium miners
Risk modulated by the concentration, duration of exposure and smoking
Nowadays all mines are well ventilated and lung cancer associated with Radon in mines is not an issue anymore
8
The “Sievert”The “Sievert”
One sievert (Sv) is a very large dose
The effects caused by short-term exposure to very high doses of radiation (acute exposure) vary depending on the dose. Here are some examples:
10 Sv (Sievert) : risk of death within days or weeks;1 Sv : risk of cancer occurring later in life (5 out of 100);0,1 Sv : risk of cancer occurring later in life (5 out of 1000);
Fortunately no one is exposed to such high doses
The « Sievert » is the measure of the effect of radiation on humans
9
The “Sievert”The “Sievert”Even workers who are generally more exposed than the general population are exposed to much lower doses
What are the limits of exposure to radiation?
For Radiation Workers:The Threshold Limit Values (TLVs) published by the ACGIH (American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists) are used in many jurisdictions occupational exposure limits or guidelines: 50 mSv - TLV for the annual dose of radiation workers during any year;20 mSv - TLV for average annual dose for radiation workers, averaged over five yearsThe actual exposure of workers is only one to two mSv per year
(See next slide)
For general public: To the order of a thousandth of a Sievert
1 mSv - Recommended annual dose limit for general public (ICRP - International Commission on Radiological Protection).
1010
Workers Exposure Workers Exposure
11
ConclusionsConclusions
11
Quebec uranium potential is substantial
Perception of uranium industry non-uniform in the population
Uranium mining subject to numerous laws and regulations
There are a lot of information to evaluate the risk of exposure to uranium in the industry
Currently, on average, the uranium miners are exposed to lower levels of radon in the workplace than in their homes
12
Press Review: Protégez-vous, mai 2009Press Review: Protégez-vous, mai 2009
13
Press Review: La facture: 20 octobre 2009Press Review: La facture: 20 octobre 2009
14
Sources of radioactivity for the average Canadian adult Sources of radioactivity for the average Canadian adult
15
QuestionQuestion
What is Radon ?What is Radon ?
16
Physical characteristics of radonPhysical characteristics of radon
Radioactive gasEverywhere on the earth's crustFrom natural uraniumImperceptible by the senses
ColorlessOdorless
Inert (chemically unreactive)
17
Physical characteristics of radonPhysical characteristics of radon
Half-life: 3.8 days
Half a given amount of radon is disintegrated in 3.8 days
Unit of measure: Bq/m3 (Becquerel per cubic meter)
Measurement of radon activity
1 Bq = 1 disintegration per second
18
High Permeability
Low Permeability
Clay
Silt
Sand
gravel
Importance of soil permeability
19
20
Factors influencing the infiltration of radon in homes Factors influencing the infiltration of radon in homes
> 800 Bq/m3
150 à 800 Bq/m3
< 150 Bq/m3
10 000 Bq/m³
18 Bq/m³
Oka
21
INFILTRATION ROUTES
Outdoor concentrations • 0,7 to 35 Bq/m3
• Average: 7 Bq/m3
* Source: Santé Canada
Indoor concentrations • 30 to >2000 Bq/m3 • Average: 45 Bq/m3
Source: Ressources naturelles Canada
22
Effect on health Effect on health
The only known effect of radon is an increased risk of lung cancer
This risk depends on:Concentrationexposure timeSmoking
23
Global Consensus Global Consensus
Radon is a serious public health
2nd leading cause of lung cancer after smoking
First rank among non-smokers
We can not identify a level below which the risk of exposure to radon is nonexistent;
Combined exposure to radon and tobacco:The health effects are greater than the sum of their individual effects.
24
Risk analysis at the provincial level
smokers60%
former smokers
30%
non smokers10%
Othercauses
90%
associated to radon10%
Estimating causes of deathby lung cancer in Quebec
Total: N = 5 436(Statistic Canada 2004)
Deaths associated to radon: N = 540
CigaretteAsbestos
Arsenic
Chrome
Nickel
Atmospheric Pollution
POPULATIONAL RISK
25
Levels of risk associated with radonLevels of risk associated with radon
Lifetime Risk8 h per day
annual average concentration Smoker Non-
smoker
For exposure to 800 Bq/m3 30 % 5 %
For exposure to 200 Bq/m3 17 % 2 %
For exposure to radon at outdoor level (10 Bq/m3) 12 % 1 %
Individual risk(Health Canada)
Measurement Unit : Bq/m3 = Becquerel per cubic meter of air
= Measurement of radon activity
= Number of decays per second per cubic meter of air
26
Measured concentrations in Quebec Measured concentrations in Quebec
Geometric meanin the basement
Geometric meanGround floor
34,6 Bq/m3
(n = 781)
18,0 Bq/m3
(n = 616)
A study in 1992-1993 at the provincial level on 900 homes (Lévesque et al., 1995)
Annual geometric mean concentrations(All areas combined)
27
Estimated exposure of Quebec people
(2008)
Measured concentration(Ground floor)
Estimated number of houses
> 200 Bq/m3 27 000 (1,3%)
> 800 Bq/m3 4 100 (0,2%)
Measured concentrations in Quebec Measured concentrations in Quebec
28
QuestionQuestion
Initiatives about radonInitiatives about radon
29
Health Canada StrategyHealth Canada Strategy
1. Developing policy on radon Lowering the directive 800 to 200 Bq/m3
2. Data collection and advice Federal Buildings in Quebec Measures in 15,000 homes - national study Measurement guides and radon mitigation guide
3. Education and public awareness Workshops, exhibitions, conferences, website and printed documentsQuébec real estate brokers Information campaign for the MRC
30
Canadian Guideline on radon Canadian Guideline on radon
1. Remedial measures should be undertaken in a dwelling whenever the average annual radon concentration exceeds 200 Bq/m³ in the normal occupancy area (where a person can spend more than four hours per day ).
Applies to new and existing buildings
31
Canadian Guideline on radonCanadian Guideline on radon
2. The higher the radon concentration, the sooner remedial measures should be undertaken
radon Concentration(Bq/m3)
Time to take corrective measures
Over 600 In less than a year
Between 200 and 600 In less than 2 years
Less than 200 No action required
Bq/m3 = Becquerel per cubic meter of air
32
Canadian Guideline on radonCanadian Guideline on radon
3. When remedial action is taken, the radon level should be reduced to a value as low as practicable.
4. The construction of new dwellings should employ techniques that will minimize radon entry and will facilitate post-construction radon removal, should this subsequently prove necessary.
33
Radon Measurement Radon Measurement
Measuring time
Radon levels in a building can vary significantly with time
Health Canada recommends a long-term measurement from three to twelve months (preferred)
The ideal time to perform a test of three months is during The ideal time to perform a test of three months is during the heating season which extends from October to April the heating season which extends from October to April
For more information, see the guides at Health Canada:
www.hc-sc.gc.ca/ewh-semt/radiation/radon/index-eng.php
34
Why 3 -12 months? Why 3 -12 months?
Radon levels double / triple between day / night and vary from one week to another, from one season to another .
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
10/13 10/20 10/27 11/3 11/10 Date
R a d o n C o n c e n t r a t I o n (Bq/ m3)
35
Radon Measurement Radon Measurement
In general, the cost of a radon test can vary between $ 50 and $ 100
Other measurement methods available which require specialized services of a competent technician (see Health Canada measures Guides)
a b
The types of long term detectorsa) Electret Ion Chamber
b) Alpha-track detector
Corrective Measure Corrective Measure
Active sub-slab depressurization
37
Key messages for citizens Key messages for citizens
Radon is the leading cause of lung cancer among non-smoker, second only to smoking
Measure radon in your home to protect your family. It's simple and cheap
If the level exceeds the guideline, there are solutions: mitigate
38
Thank you !