uranium mining/milling/tailings and water quality issues€¦ · • radon presentation . legacy...

45
Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues Presented By: Mansel A. Nelson Senior Program Coordinator Tribal Environmental Education Outreach Program (EEOP) Institute for Tribal Environmental Professionals (ITEP) Northern Arizona University (NAU) www.nau.edu/eeop/

Upload: others

Post on 27-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and

Water Quality Issues

Presented By:

Mansel A. Nelson

Senior Program Coordinator

Tribal Environmental Education Outreach Program (EEOP)

Institute for Tribal Environmental Professionals (ITEP)

Northern Arizona University (NAU)

www.nau.edu/eeop/

Page 2: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

• Legacy Issues – Mining

– Milling

– Environmental Impacts

– Human Health Impacts

• Current Mining – Northern Arizona

• Nuclear Fuel Cycle – In Situ Leachate Mining

– Uranium Enrichment

– Depleted Uranium (DU)

• Radon

Presentation

Page 3: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Legacy Issues

Page 4: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Open Pit Mining

Page 5: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Tunnel Mining

Page 6: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Mining and Milling on Navajo

Page 7: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Abandoned Mines

Page 8: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Abandoned Open Pit Mines

Page 9: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

•Tuba City : Rare Metals 1955 - 1966

•Mexican Hat : Texas-Zinc Minerals Corp. 1956 - 1965

•Monument Valley : VCA 1955 - 1968

•Shiprock : Kerr McGee & Foote Minerals 1954 - 1963

Uranium Mill Sites

Page 10: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Tuba City – Rare Metals

Page 11: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Rare Metals Clean Up

• Ground water clean-

up continues

• Eliminated – Blowing dust

– Radiation

– Radon

Page 12: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Rare Metals The clean-up continues

Spread to dump????

Ground water contamination

Page 13: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Outreach to Navajo Students

• Seeing the Unseen

• Half-life

• Electromagnetic Spectrum

• Gamma Radiation

• Atomic Theory

• Protection

Page 14: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Outreach to Community

Continuing Legacy

Page 15: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Water Sampling

Page 16: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Northern Arizona University

Continues Research

Ground water and surface water contamination

Cancer Partnership with University of Arizona - Health impacts of Uranium

Page 17: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Ground Water Contamination

• Investigations

continue

• Clean-up continues

Page 18: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

• Radon impacts on the lungs

• Lost miners and millers in communities due to radon exposure

• Radon continues to be an issue

Radon Protection

Page 19: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Mining – Contaminated Structures

• Homes

• Driveways

• Roadways

Page 20: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Current Mining

Page 21: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

• Uranium prices increasing

• New mining methods developed

• Environmental impacts continue to be a concern

• Health impacts continue to be a concern

• Navajo Nation – no mining, but…..

• Efforts to slow mining expansion near the Grand Canyon

• Active mining in Northern Arizona / New Mexico

Uranium Mining Today

Page 22: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Current Mining in Arizona

• Near Grand Canyon

• Plans to expand, but

restrictions are in place

• Ore being hauled to

Blanding, UT

• Inspection revealed

concerns

• Permits still an issue

• Temporary shut-down?

Page 23: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

In Situ Leachate Mining

Page 24: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

• In Situ Leachate

• In Situ = in place

• Leachate = solution containing material leached from earth material

• Leaching = process in which water removes and transports inorganic nutrients in solution

ISL Mining

Page 25: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

ISL Processing Plant

Page 26: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

ISL Pumping Field

Page 27: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

ISL Process

Page 28: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

• cheaper infrastructure requirements

• combines mining and milling into one step

• no large-scale tailings dams

• no large open cut or underground mine to rehabilitate

• lower occupational health and safety: accidents, dust, and radiation

ISL Advantages

Page 29: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

• risks of contaminating groundwater systems outside the mining zone

• inherent difficulties in the hydraulic and geochemical behavior of the deposit

• difficult to restore groundwater to pre-mining quality

• large volumes of waste water and solutions

ISL Disadvantages

Page 30: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Uranium

Enrichment

Page 31: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Uranium Enrichment

• Uranium-235 (U235) – comprises less than 1 percent by weight of U that is mined

• Fuel for reactors – natural Uranium is enriched to increase U235 to 3 to 5 percent

Page 32: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Uranium Enrichment

• Yellow Cake - Uranium fuel cycle begins by mining and milling uranium ore to produce U3O8

• U3O8 is converted into uranium hexafluoride (UF6).

• UF6 is then enriched before being made into nuclear fuel – gas centrifuge

– gaseous diffusion

Page 33: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Enrichment Plant

Page 34: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Depleted

Uranium (DU)

Page 35: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

What is DU?

• U-235 (Small portion of U) is used for nuclear power

and weapons.

• The remaining U, known as depleted U (DU)

• Double the density of lead

• DU is 40 percent less radioactive then natural uranium

• DU is used for a number of military and technical

applications

– tank armor

– balance weights for aircrafts.

Page 36: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Health Issues for DU

• DU poses little risk when outside the body

• DU has about as much toxicity as other heavy

metals, like lead

• DU can cause kidney damage if inhaled or

ingested

• DU exposure should be avoided by humans

and animals

Page 37: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Radon

Page 38: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

www.nau.edu/eeop

• Odorless, colorless

• Radon in air is ubiquitous

• Found in outdoor air and indoor air of

buildings of all kinds

• No known safe level of radon

Radon

Page 39: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

www.nau.edu/eeop

• Red alert - radon level above 4 pCi/L

(pico Curies per Liter)

• Yellow alert - radon levels between 2

pCi/L and 4 pCi/L

• Average radon indoor air is about 1.3

pCi/L

Radon Levels

Page 40: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Radon “Daughters”

www.nau.edu/eeop

Radon, Polonium,

Lead, Bismuth, and

Polonium have short

half-lives

Results in several

exposures in a

short time

Page 41: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

www.nau.edu/eeop

Radon in Lungs

• Radon or decay

products inhaled

• Particles irradiate

lungs

• Irradiation can cause

lung cancer

• Cigarette smoking

synergistic impact

Radon

Page 42: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

www.nau.edu/eeop

• From the soil

• Lower parts of

building at greatest

risk

• “Stack effect”

Radon in Buildings

Page 43: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

www.nau.edu/eeop

Radon Testing

Page 44: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

www.nau.edu/eeop

Radon Mitigation

Page 45: Uranium Mining/Milling/Tailings and Water Quality Issues€¦ · • Radon Presentation . Legacy Issues . Open Pit Mining . Tunnel Mining . Mining and Milling on Navajo . Abandoned

Contact

Mansel A. Nelson

Senior Program Coordinator Environmental Education Outreach Program (EEOP)

Northern Arizona University (NAU)

http://www.nau.edu/eeop/

[email protected]

Voice 928 523 1275

FAX 928 523 1280

PO Box 5768, Flagstaff, AZ 86011