Use of some statistical techniques in optical metrology

Bhat, Y.K.

Published: 01/01/1968

Document VersionPublisher’s PDF, also known as Version of Record (includes final page, issue and volume numbers)

Please check the document version of this publication:

• A submitted manuscript is the author's version of the article upon submission and before peer-review. There can be important differencesbetween the submitted version and the official published version of record. People interested in the research are advised to contact theauthor for the final version of the publication, or visit the DOI to the publisher's website.• The final author version and the galley proof are versions of the publication after peer review.• The final published version features the final layout of the paper including the volume, issue and page numbers.

Link to publication

General rightsCopyright and moral rights for the publications made accessible in the public portal are retained by the authors and/or other copyright ownersand it is a condition of accessing publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights.

• Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose of private study or research. • You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain • You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the public portal ?

Take down policyIf you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediatelyand investigate your claim.

Download date: 15. Jul. 2018

techni'sche hogeschool eindhoven laboratorium voor mechanisehe technologie en werkplaatsteehniek

rapport van d. sectie: '" .'

werkplaatstechniek.

m.1:

auteur(s):

,.ctlel.ider:

hoogleraar:

USE OF SOME STATISTICAL TECHNIQUES IN OPTICAL METROLOGY.

Y.K.BHA'r '(INDIA), I '

, ! Ir. J .M. Ub~ink • Drs. J. Koning.

I r, ,I r I , I'

ii ;i I I

sam.nvatting r ' /i I,

Iii With the help or a ~heodolite and collimator?a plannec

experiment was conducted f,o,r determining the accuracY' or a turn table. The second experiment consisted in measuring

the flatness of a long narrow metallic bed bY' two independan methods for the purpose o,{ comparison = firstlY' bY' using an autocollimator with a reflecting mirror and then by Huet-1ineaal. In both the exp.riments the errors associated with different instrumentsJsettings were estimated.

-J r\ , j I j I

progno,. \

\

\ I \ \ ! ,\

r--------, blL .0. van1~ biz.

rapport nr. 0200

codering:

M8 t

M9 b

trefwoord:

Meettechniek

datum: 29-5-1968

aantal biz. 15

g.schikt voor publicatie in:

RApport nr.0200

Foul( Til /NTE/fNAT/O/V/}L COt/IPSE f="O.,f

INlJU5TA'//lf, t){JALITY INST.RtlC7t?A'S

PL/iCIf li!c.A n';.s~ /lO?f!sCAoot

P-t-~/(}J) /·S'·~S t. 3/. $. '8

S(J~.:TEC 7: {/se of SI'3Jbe staf,sticaf

J. /'1. {/b.6;)JA­

( /"Itf''II tD.,)

"

o)tt'cal "'·e t,1'3 ttl;;.

,

Eon :l'AI'3Hh

tecHhll·tls ;"

y. k· .BAal (/,If;'/J/A)

( l't:.lI"t,'cipQ.'II t)

C;

-1-

US£ OF' SO/lll£ STATISTICAl. 7'ECHN/(lI.lCS

(JPTICAL if

J. /IVTRO..J)UCTION

/.J ,Pla.ce: 7l~ ?n.e~/oQ' ~#~ 0/ ./h E~d~t:J~ ,7.!.Jn...~

Rapport No.0200

Cln4~7 ,~ J ~L fta:m- /ht #7 ~ ,3/$.iY7 aA /~ i ?If;-­

,Mc~d ~d<:J ~.~) M a. ~dOt ~0t r 7/rJ.~.o.vt

RAv?,~ ,A-t.d~. Jt ~t. oJ a. ?1Mmb i ~~,~ a.-d

~~ fo & ~~77~ 0/ ~au.6 r'}~ £4 ~;;U~,

a.--~, ~C-e- ~f.'J"&<.,r/tI!M .et. 7te£cU ~ a 1?t,a.d..'7'rL dr- ~4..Ac-lrl:..

~ 0../ oj&-J ~~~ 4 ~c:u...sCbr/ ~vd ... L~ a".-,c:{. awtc..rlt'hta-

-lev. ~ ~ ~~, pu:cA: anvd /~uc-iu ~dUr fo ~

frciGJ ?~' 12 5t~tC6 and (J5!'c.J' ~~/o&Y: ~ ~ ~ i £ ~.:rM

ej-t.J ~~.t -' ~ r?~ of A ,.k~ -r- ~ ~~cY; ~

~r~J ~ -fA if ~aA..a.?n~ ~~a, .JI d. fo ~ ~ £:k.I

~nr.a!u '7f dlfuuni ~ ,.h- /~J ~ ~kv? ~ ~4u~

au of fod.'c:J hrf6ocmCA-' S~ .~~ ~~~ ar;.,d 4

~~ oj',/4 ~ d' Aud .ex>~~ ~~ ~ otM~.&:ot

~ ~ kjd,

,3.; ?..tfh;t~: 7Xe ~&~ oj & ,aCUi4a;y 0./ ~ ~ amJ d.'vY'o&:-,

h~ A..6 aL7Je.&t ~J~ai& .v,.., ~J ~?U ~I r a 7M,l~~ of jc&

-tik ~./.t;..,? / .k~/ a...d /:;6&m~ ~a ~ acca4.a./, oj'./;b.. ~

r& M dvudf ~~ ~ /k OCCUA-a7 0/, ~ ~ ~. M.-Ik i~.v-\ 1 -{:' "" ~ ... <:. ~

;P~d& c:f 4 ~uat.?4~/ a. ~ /~ ~·a ·di~T'~ ~

h'lt L..~ ~ h0ed· '7k- /~d wkL" ~ NM ~ctM ~

~~ ">no~ a. ~ ~ f' 3" M., -&d 0/ ~ M1rDU'd?7A'

.A-o LkJ fo a ~~ c«cJa/l.- ~otrc~ qf ~ ~ (~ ~'o·)/

- .'2 - Rapport nr.0200

1-20 'h2Jt'~-tcn.A 0::( ~ ~cL ~t v'

2· 2 171b~'77u/r,t U,Jd ~

2·2·/ /l ,l-kodot:~ (kiLl} /lat1.~rJ' r-z - 7-Z03S) r ~~J ,Ad:~ o-t ~·cJ a-n.-?~ ~J-&.Cft-~-t ~d ~~ /U _~B c:ha'~

-h!aa d a ~. (I q~ :' O· 9 <> ,10 ~ a C47n,/;U h.e 'V!Jtffvt.~ cr=f I U 0 0 / V

3{.oc L~/-4x.cLs A~. 400 ;tm-tr ~aJfr)

z·z·z A c:ud.o-~~4 w-hid ~ ~ ~d fo ck~. ~

. atr~ oi- ~~~ of ~'ndf fl'ed 4wa-j.cU.. Tk ~.&.

c.?n- ~d /~ ~/zLnwJ ~ ..a ~~ A.- /-"-j?'/' ..It ~~

of ~ ~-cdZ·~ ~ 1, dd _~rct. ~~.Di!~. ~ ¥ ~ ~ Ac4c ~~ /~CL d7' & C;~L'cJ ~~ oJ' £kt. ~~.

II ~&.- C2J )2£u.:r..ra ctA1;.d JUj4cLs /Ad ~ ~cA ~ £k ~ k.

Sf 1k- ~p~CL 1 C.J) ..d ac~~ rAct,euk ~ -t4 'r~J ~X4, . '

/a J'zejtd.t;i ~. 4rt£f kk.?V ,d7 ~ c:1t;?~ ~~ ~

amd -<j/ ~fou ~ /t~ ~ ..h /.pIaced /.fa /A'd ~ ~~

r "a".a cd ~ficJ~& f 1~ ~ L/ ~,a. ~ fa"

foJ?LLd -7 tk- JUf&cU ¥ ~C4m. /~ ClJ tdr/L C~I!<c6.. ~:,& a ,+

Ji OJ'U ~ o~ ~d. ~ ~ c~ M d~j U,&;L cd- a-. ~?i

& ) &- mj&JLd ¥ ~ hLt ~ /C'k ;?z.MIL cd a".., ~ :(.(9 ~

fom- ~ ~? "c," ':f Lk ;P~ "a -, cd a ~-t~~ a.6,' . 24'

r::iu.1!ac£~ oj £k ~~ c:I Lk ch.&S ~ "a+ .,t "IJ' ..a ~dtv.J

~ ~,;Ik. ~u & oj'.tk ?nt'M,ai. '~d ..a :nd a£A-cU ? ~ . ~J c:;I.b..~ u, 0/ Lk 7hi~4 ~ ~ . ~ - Ctl-a,:~tn. ~ ot...-.-tevnc.C. a.d.

-i6 £p-ed.La 2/c! ~ /.¢ :tAt: focJ Lu..,J& c.I ~ ~ L.

?-.',3 54 -10 cvnd ?Jait Gtfu.t.'an: TJu- b.wdot~ ~ ~awf j&.~

at fk cen&. OJ -'k k7'V -",t,.u" 7k auio - cd!tmden. NM ;5&u..:L cd ,

0. ki~ce. h ~ LM-otdo(:£ .<m. .,fk ~~. qfdicJ kJ 4-! ~

if' ~odeg£ MbC-<!>fe- Ao ,Ikd a. kdld ~ if./k c:J. ~~ ,

-.3 , Rapport nr.0202

!

~ c&~ ~'M, (Ata ;:7,2)- fifo ~ .4v ~~ .J 0

Jo~:6trn, ~d //>.fi"I~ ~ '0/ A £~ ~! ~ heo-~j' oj' 1k Jtkodot~ ~c~ Am.4 ~. T/U ~ociot4, ML~ :W«A' ~ •

/

cJM.tuh~d ant-d 4d at!~ ~ r a ~c~)U<:l.k.". Tk..~ .£

Ac1hId~-kJ ~ k;>u.d A."x L»z.i& .GUJ-vd r ,6e/ d ~ ;6c&-,d,~

10 4jcia. MtaA~ of 18" ~ ~ ~ £a.M. -4c ~ fri."4i~

0/ iIu- ~~ M-~? / ~ £h.QdoLd: Ma:~;r' ~ ~ a.4;

~ ~ ~ CPwk 7k fo~ Afl<.A ~'?u<.ed ~d A ~-L~

Ct::rnt lAM U j'~ Nz",Udx. fc :tkL ~ cd< Z / /~ :f ~ ~ ~ta.,..?ud (& ~4-vd. 0/ /8''' ~ ~ ~Ce. "d ~rofu,t

-to a ~d fr. oJ -20 !trnA' ~d a.k )o~4JM ~ a.o&~ , ,

'?7M-7n~ oj cr?s</t-vJ:~ ~cL Lk k ..... ~)

J'h ik k-ccr;,;d and ~ k"V?J~~ c)/ --tk ~-~~/~

~? /22a~? oJ £k &"dot-li ~ ~ d ~k~ of /8'-,

T~ ~ 4Z ~ k2RJU"~, ~ ~ ~~ o?w,...~ Alke4J

~ ~ 4ec~d amd ~ kVlJ'U~ ~ koz.e' Z/ cr?s-6\-~

..ea.d· 7L o.ct...J /~~?, aM- &~v&d ~ ~~ (2) .z. (f-) l' ~ /. 2, f IJnat~ ~d F~cfh..,1f.:

, 0 . v

;,.4./ EA-6.:;zatA 0.( ,/Modo.t~ hea.~zI' -bUoL 0>~): r~ ,Ik ~I /~~

~f ~~~ ;/k /lhpda-t:~ cd?cu'~d ~ ~ ~ ~~A1:O?v 0/

iIw /~-~) ~ d~cM(d) ~ ~foU, TN. -i-M, '~

c:t/;6-&'.ed /t.: /t~ dJ.l~cu} dowcd £kJ /~ -U. ?io 17'.!-t.~'c

d.;f;Len.emce hc~ /ik jVd cM7d 4eurnd .4d 1 OM.a~0:n.4,

(1;: d ... ~/. ~x% O'57~dZk';laL-J~d~'1L ~~ 1';-6 x/(;r~

c:/iJ.1N./.nJ..($?V WJ,,a ..co d/,- ..J- & 5~ hrf~a ~ .2 .:ta...~J :: '<,Oli")

7M ~ /~:JU .IvU& ~. ft~d . CJ7V ::::~'" dd [,M.... F':'/l 3 (CZ)] amd

~ ~d ~ 2a '1 /t/u.- ..,j/,IdvJi. ~ w,Zt0, ~ £~

£d?7Vak a/ ~~'67'v ~h-.- ~7' /ik ~d.I!~ ,U. ~

Rapport cdeui~ aA P,t:: p~ 7 0·00/0;td71- (~:d .... ~ ~ -3'/) nr.0200

,(2 .

242 £~t;77VaA of £k, ~~. /~l ~ (4,,) : ,F~ Afk

~J.1Nck..l ~ ~~?u.,cl f't- a. /~ f c( /.5'.:' . '" .s~¢. f ~

~,ted-&. .0v /tXe, /kCA7vd a-.d ~ h.el/?J~d-nJ (d~M. 4 GIm(;i s '.f

TaK /) ~ d~UA (ef) ~ ~d, & L-"w ~ ~~~ ,

4 ,~ d~uA / ~d 'Lk:J ~ '--d> ?za ~.d~c d~u...

.L.<~ £k ~/-:t5~. ~ c;/.l!k .2 n4- a.;;nd .3?-d .k.e nt...-t.<rnA '. t.

= _ =- //'5x/0 >£./37 .:/{;o (i ol' -~') Ad/./:;; 3.2 ,11" /~-~ .:nu..dc::ln'l.

~ ';:1 ka..ryv? ~ etA.. ~ (J:1v 4,( A-am..;u ~ fM1,d ~d tnd ,

tk:d edt ~.L wd/ 4P~ AZ. esnAd' ~~ [ /.kL ;::..:; 30))

7Xe .id;J ~vL~dJv ~ ~ ~9 "'A"" /5d':: C)·c;JO-Z.3;td"M tv 7{ N) " C ~

i:kmu.. -tk d'~a& 0/ ik ~~ A--c/4{,.? ~ A~ ~ c.JJ~

a..& j.A../ _~2. "" 0.002 (j67W (rv 71

/).

Jf ~ ~L? (~d afto 0/ rdw.J! ~ ~ ~~ A.d ~

~ k ~ jan.dw-hd Aellh..; M almd ka a-5 ??t»-d a6 Lh.

~ ~ .?6 & JUa.cl;..J.6/ ~odot/i,

2,~. 3 [-i-£4U.cL.,,,. CWl2IC fo'~ ~-i~ : IJ /1AdcJ ~ ~ /k

~vut-j~m {~~ c:&k,7>L<~ /tk ??z,a~~4 t5j/ d~ (.; .

~01-5) ~ k .0v .~ ~~. af /lk ,~~ U4-ve cj A-

~-taJ& r //:kr·damu 0/ ~ 9aa£d1-, S~~ JI ~ ML

O/wt..~ (4a uIl.n.~ -Z Z s '1 ~a.It. / i fo f?ad ridn, crj' -tk ~ - .t.J.4:

a.i ~~ i IS':' .J ..a:';' ... ?Ua11~ .z; cr&ta..0v ~ ~-t~ ~

CU 4. L-d .Mi.~o1.- .

. S6?JU af ~ I~~ ~~ ~ £k )WJaJ ~014 ~~ "

eu;t/. .At.d ~ aAe. ~Aed oui ~ 7~ 2. (7k adr~?nodd fit-. ,

:Ik F;~ -u /ttd eMIl ~~·CJv WiLt ~ 1 ik ~ ~kl ~

~""- ~ ~ ~ ~? .</ ~01~ ~,.j. dtmo/k.r... ~~ ~

~ " -£ ka~c1 0/ ~:~t-d)

- 5-

Rapport nr.0200

'" I/~ (.1-') 7)fe 0/ a,~? £MA

i)~~~ ~14~ /()~ vj /~S +.2S" fiAj. -.' ~AA. (ccd1.'In-M 2,3,4-4-5' oj' T~/) 9:;( 4 ':I

:: / cJ - t, .j79O

ii) S~fo ~? 1 3 ~ck..?/ L.Acl If (4~'- + A;) /O-~//"7+3.3 a:1! 07Lt-:f,6{.. h.L a~ -i- 8... / g ~ /0- ~ / /Ij'O JlL1n>t.J.~ 0~ ~ .3,4,5 </ 7..J&. I) .

;//j /V~ ~Jc ! .IJ,. 4.M~ /(r4< j/~7r--lS /jl"l Z .$)'Z ?siLt ,14 h;;.:~ '1 ~:.2 -J.l. .!J ,t 7'>8 '.! =/o-~ .Ins

fk.c~ 1 ik d/~~ -0t- fk m,~L~ '1' ~~ a-nd A~ / .u. a.k

,t-cdt. )u~~ iI;al ~ N-C:~ aAA/l-a.? (u. ;;;) r ~ bd '~ntaA

t;u.b, .th ..t.J. /~g ~oi, 7k ~ ~ oJ'JJd .::v»d ~

.i- d (i') l' U&. /' 7AL. c.tud.~ (/M,lbc. <rl- ;;u;Jcd.fft:. c::kr'd'<1?14.

~ ;/.k :n~'>1J ~ ~ -zo;onJ. ~c.i" ...(.0 A 7Ju~ f -bid

. ~J~) U/2L' r ~ -fk ~ 3 ~-m-:n,l. '1 ~ /. ZZt. cAu~

8uA.1Jt! Ah ~ ~'/"~;;l~' .;

J:' j}£T~>fl'1//V//VG ;:-L/l7/V~S5 OF /l SUffh'Cc"

3·/ ?4Aft;Pou: M: 7Jle~? 0/ ~;rt~ cpf £7 a-d AeU'~7

~dKJ 4Mfc.M. /iGd qA '-&c:Ls 0/ k? b~ ~ fo??~/ 7ha~

~ a ~ G!f7n7J16n ?U~'f ~ 0;;1 A%'JA;.r~c;;5 ;£-t ~ ~ of ~

~Zrf;;j,t.?:~m / a Ld71? Wtde:JZ:c..ted f /t?(} em )( .5 S C9h .(ra.6 ~~, ~

fta.l~ N3d ~ot 7 ~' k d~?7u-~ ~f -7 ~ ~-C.r&?nJcri J0;~ a kf£-eh:J ?n<'M~ ~ ~ 7 ~ ~':Ie4~ (A-u 3,2.· I an-.d 3·.2,.2) -

,3 ·2-1 '1.k eucL, -~::?ta!m. (' Au ~ 2.';,<) 4:/1:& a ~~dn:.? ~.~ ';i!,

~i- a ~~~ ~~~ fo ~;; A f&d~ cf '"- ~.J'u

4 .:L /7 .ted ~CL ,a /U.~ ~ k ~ Lk ~~d~ c:rj'

~?UM ;f Lk ~ ~ a k?'4.d:.'~ ~d:~. ~ a-4c4·."...t"..

Rarport nr.0200

~d (Alait. )t.~pk) ~d a: ~~? ac~a~ i d1u - ,/,t,.,/X f c:t

M~ i;LI ~ -a 7n.:-uct. Zk. ~ ~ ~ /0 Om k;t ~d ~ kac:lM." rf -< ~ec,.,d Lo ~ £6. c:uc.it, c4.?),.aL~ t:Mu~duL 4! a. ~

0'- f1L . '1 / '/?Uc407V .4v 4h- /0 om. ~-tama ~ ~ ~;'Ct ~ ~¥)

. 3.2·,2 J/u.d 11?U.a.J a a.,...,. ~&~ ~d fo 7/bI.~ ~ -tI/n~~

at a ~;a dtnl-! a evn4al ~. U~ 'l71dl'kn.&d, O?I- ~ ~u ~4..

-ltd d ?1U~ ~ ¥ af a ~u ~ a Jl4~u?f~ ~

~ 'i' ~ClttrnA· ~ ~Vifo hn-kr!l .~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~ .~ . <~cL ~ /'''J ,.

~·23 1 iIu.- ~ja.a k .be9 ~~d M 1'. ~ ~'kff A.ra? 1r ~ 8.c- La7tJ(fkcL?r-J ck..,dd7v ~ (£:&~), ~ a. ~

& . ~./ud h a A ~tw~ ~d .(/'.~s~d~ ;a. ~ ~

~ I~~J ~ ~ 4t:~? ~ Aea.k;. ~CJ2. J -i4 ~ ~

~ ~ ~ out ~ 4 k ~ 0/ /~.t&- ~~ ~ a­

~d'~ ~LaACrn,.

3·3 ~£d d'- ~aIa Gtt"ld7Z;:

}:..3.:.!. 7k ~f-c.c.- 1 Lk .bed ~ d!iV'c&.d ~ ~,~ 1 /OOb, .fk;?L.

l3e~ aj cod~ f1.ad:cJ dlf'·Jk (L:~ ?no-wn4cl :Ik /~ h:~d) >1T..

'J1iL~ ~ ~ --ta.~ cd"de. 4x>k;;?r;L ~ ~ ~ --&ed. ~

k.jlick; ~ ~ ~~'ucf jkc£d ~ -Ik /o~ ~ ~

£k ~raA, dafil>.CA-~ ~ Mad .iw Lk- a4io -uttmat-4i-. /l ~

of 8 JU~ (~ a. ~J'IL l' .?OCl»r- r~ &d) ~ cr6ia..:nu;;l.

~pJ ~~ ~ ~ cd Lk /~ .~~, (k ~""'M

2 _d .3 c:I T~ 3)

3·3·Z 7Z.. I/-ud A..·~aJ ~ ?h~ ~ Lk ~fou.. a-ol A ~~.,?1 . \

4 ;;tk. ~b- 1 a ~~a ~ -t&t-~ J "T ~-~iaJ" p.,.;,.vti ~ :lk. l?o om k..J'''- l' £ .~f'4 ~ M-. ,e,r.-J 7;u~~ ~

L k~ d Lk /~ 9'?~ (,4u. c",d,.""'M .2 a.nd .3 4' r~ ~) . .

- 7-Rapport nr.0200

J 3·~,/ I~ci~~: ,edt ~a ,Lk ~r~ J ~ a.A~'7UDf', f ~-/iJ

LAAt ~. ··M "-0 ~/"'~C', ot~u- b:~ ;t!k #. ~d Ad ~

?lu~~,

[f~ ~-cdZ:7nJdJ.., J d .. 0-3#" Ad =- /&'3" /;t : 0-5"< 7d'F

7k ~~c.<~~ ~o..·J.d 4/7'& Zk ~-cLt1nt-~ ALa7 ~ rei ;t -be /-./ /,: rf~ fo: ~ ~ -L7U~ J Arr.!4 ~ /6..

3·;;-,<.'£~ e -U.. ~.?!! L?U: Tk .e,McU .fcmt- A~~ ~ ao cdJdid perm. Lk aat.-cLl-mai~ ka.~.r evnd ~-L?Ua.~­

Jua.kr ~ /trrlb.d c:nJ -..(;".v 7~ 3 a.m.,d'.4 ~/(!dUt:f _ rat. a.

I

~~ cJ :/tk r-krJA ·f~ ~ ~ ~~~/ /th ~

~ ik ~?J ~ ~ ;R'cftd ~ ,c~ ,. -if ~d -&- ~? .M­

ud ~'.~ CJ.- A~~1 4t'??ttb>~, ~ ,t4 ~ 7 Ltc,. ~~eL' ~ . . t. .

ao 06.fa.~ t ~ k, .?/uiL.,dt.. ,M~? ,ik 6M.e~>6'~~,? ~

1 i;k. ~ju-cM form- ;;(.k )U~C-'. b'7!L, a c,!U,u:ePV ~/f'(;A'-L NrW

ea1cJdot fo ik k d aj 2f7A~. ~ 2~ l' ~ ~~ ccreflc;.-e:-.f ~ o-J /-t: £.c 0-[1:$. hf:",~ ~ /-M.ad'u_ .e..~ ':I ~ .tAr.

I 77u;tJ'o~ ~.& ~ 7f,1-- atia.-~? a.. ~ P- ~~ cdaJ /£ ~wfu jt'd??U4 cj A!'7 ma~ ~cLt-

'.

- ' .

TAeodo{;te

J. Tur~ - taP/e

,

Rapport nr.0200

, ; ~'. ~" cot t i.a tcr

-:-E ~Ril--

Ta!J!'~ I s~ F~.t IuZl9~ern- S-tec",....,t Ao.v. ~ hIu. .2)!!:.:;~ .J)t~e,L ~~ . ~dnw =A, I'~i:;..cf-l J.'h<rl kfJ /u.ad.;..~ head,.;... .. ,1,) - (:I) '#) -eS )

~I (I ti",1""') (9$ (/o- .. 347t.) (/tr" ;-) e9,", (JI/- (~) (1) r .. ) (3J (~) ($/ (t.) (1;1 ~) (9)

0 93 ·lo7~ 93·/0 7b 93- lOSt; 9.3·/0;;3 0 -7 9.3·/o~S .~.--. .- . .. .. --. -_. __ .- c--- ---~

-~ ~-~~_.- ._-- ~~---- _.- .. _-18 7,3· IOSO 7...3 ·/0'0 73· /0.34- 73·/028 -10 ~ 73·/039 ~,

----- -'--' .. ! .. .. - .. "'_.'" _ .... ~ . - ._'-._._.-- -.---

3' 5.3'093.3 53- 095' 53'/0~' 5.3·/oo,z 37 ~..y 53·/008 .31 ----- ... .

..... - --~------~- - --~-------~-.- -- -~.--------

S4- 33·0979 33'0991 33·/002 3.3·/o/~ -I-Z -/4 33-/001 7 ~- . ~-.- .... --~---

7~ 1.3· /O/~ 13·/0.3~ 13 09!l& /.3·/oZ9 -20 -,3 .3 1.3·/0/~ -15 . .. . f- ... 1--. --'-.- i-

go 393'09'91 39.3·0.984. 393·0B95 39.3· 0 g-l4 7 -4~ 393-o9~4 7-0/ '--"- I--

108 373'0851 373 '08'1 37,3'Oj7"z 373-0850 -/0 .z:z 5'!3·0fi53 83 "-''''--'- f...-- .~ 1---_. f-_ ... -~~- >--. -_ ..

• /Z~ 353·0900 35.3·0.91(; :35.3· 097.3 35.3· 08'5 -I' .. 7 353 .06'.i'~ -~3 ' .

11t../t. 3.33· 0 Bf!t; , ,333 ·09()3 333:08~7 333'0883 -17 -/~ 33.3·06'B'~ q

I~;' .

313' 0.905 313·0899 31.3·0895 -3/3·0685 , 10 3/3-09f!j~ -/Z -- .. _ ... _- 1-- •... _----- -------_ .. .- 1--- -"-180 Z93·09..3S· Z93'0931 .293·0.900 2..93· 08g~ ~ , ';:'93.09°9 . -/5

... --, .

198 ~73 ·0966 ,z73·0!J75 27.3· 0898 .27.3-09&'4 -9 -h~ .2 73· o!J4.4. -35 - '_._,- ------- ._ .... _._- -.------ -----. - .. f- .'!!..

2" ZS..3·0!J-E.3 ,lS.3· Og~6 ,l.s3,oS"!Ja ,z53'09.3' -Z3 -39 Z53·09Z3 ZI . -_ ..

.2. 3"- 233'08'70 2.33 ·08'76 -Z33·OS'1 233·01Mo - ,; -ZI 23.3·0fi'58 ,5 .. ----- - .. ~-.. ~- ---- .. --. -----.-~~- ----- t-- -- .-._--- - --- -- ------.- -_ . .. -

~5.1. '<15'0917 2.13 ·O91€ .213·091-Z ';:13·0867 ..

1 .4tS :(,1; ·0898 - .(,.0 ---_ .... -_. __ .- -- - ~. ._- _. .. -r- -.... -.... -._- . __ .

.2 70 /93·0899 /93· oB'88 Ig3'0!Jo~ 19.3·094-S II -.fl /93- 0 !!1,t, -/~ ---'- ~------ ~ ~--- -

288 1'1.3-0.1" I 17,J·o9.l1 17.3-0894 17.3·0951 0 -57 /7.3 .034.2 - 8 .

30. /53·/0.zl 153·/0/.3 . /53·O!jS-l /S3,o!1€9 9 -It /S oJ ·0979 -57

..3.l+ /33·/09, /a3·/t>g" 1.$3· /0/3 /3.3·/078 ..z -~5 /33·/0'"z -83 ..... r--

~.t,..l /1,3 ·/OS;j- //3· /()~~ //.3./033 //.3. /4..1 .. 9 !I 1/,3·/03' ."z, -- . . -.

:5'0 .9.3·/tP~8 93·/0~S !J..l./Q~ '7 !lJ·/058' .3 -// 9.8· /057 -":1 --'

a...~ue~~

7~& 10 .,.."." Me-a( (")

V~ (It)

f-----.. --- --'-'

Z, 8 ,-.---~-

57 Jf:1 ..

,~ ..JI - -"- 1--.

~.1 /~ -_._--1~3 ~o

,2,0 • (,7 '- .-_. __ .

183 SfJ

183 5.9

171 SS

Iff'- 5"1 --.. /.,21 39 . /kZ 4r.~ .. .z07 '7

1-._---.. - f--------/17 S~

------ f--151 SO

/.y,j 4&

8. ~ A,f/

.J / .

-Z!J :J .-.

8 .J

::l Ii . Q f'..l o o

"

.....

- /;z- l:(apport nr. 0200

All to-C o/Lih1,r/or

PIc;. 5. PA'/NCI,oL£ (/N.J)£RLY//V(;, reST,s 8Y. /lUTO - C'OLLlft'I/lrO.li

-" - - - - - - --- - - ----

. .

----- --------------

FIG •. P/lI/VCI.I',t,E VN.lJ&"AL'YIIVG TESTS 8Y 1111£7 tIN£AA/"

. I

" Ra.pport nr.0200

TaJte. 3

frio' -t'(111 I&.adi".;r .if ~ -c:t/.7ha/"dJ :lJ.;.fJ-wS ~tAjJI Gmu .. l...t·t< A1f--i~ L44.c:44~ f4?7>~ )U4.-e ""- .t k;.. ~r ..-. 1 ti (/n1 . ~ .... ~,t (CPn) .~ (,.,,;~J" jaI( ..JJ.;......

;:~ (Ac~d4.) ("" .. :~) ~ ( --"'--"') &~~. .#JM.~' ("."..,,*-,)

(I) (.2) (3)' ( 4<-) (5) ('J (7) (B) (If;

0 0 0 0

10-20 1

1!1.J /1 I

13"5 " ~117'0'/ -,3 -3 , t 0 0 0 '"

20 30 ,I -Zk4" t' .2.<,4- " ," .,<3'1,'" t·~ 3 3 - {, -3

30-4,0 " 177" ~' 16.4 h " 17'0" 0 0 3 -9 - ,. 4-0-50 ,':to·/" " /9·5" {,' /9·8 N

2·8 I 4 -/2 -B . 50-'0 {,' 2, 7 " ('.z~5h 6' '2"'" 9·{' 'Ii '1 - /~ -7

'0-70 ,',;,/·s" 6' 23·8" {, I ...?.<"f" 58 3 /2 -19 -7

(/25"·..z " " 2S'/" " .,ls, Z '/ ;~ 70-80 82 ~ -.n, -, ,I 33 . ..z /, t: I 3.5-'./!" ,',3f"."e". 17·Z .2S ftis 80-30 9 0 ..

" :f 7k ~ ~ ..d Jh- I'f '£ C"'&'7II'" ('J .fie~.L4 4~ '1.th. ~

uk- .i.- J;., ~ 1..J ,I#$-' Z<C7t ;tJ - 8 .<- ..c 7 .s

/k.i.m ~ 'I /'(i,J 4,.,.a.d J)~/f«-""'" ~~ $MA4/-'? p.--. ;,...i.J ~c..cYoJ

(Om) (?n.i~) ~~ ~i~ ~

;:-~ ':;'c..md A~? (»Ii c4<m1.) (~~) (7/1..<~)

(I) (..2) (3) (,;) (5) C'J (7)

10 599 ,0El , (04. 0 0 a .... _--

.20 t35, '27 {,31 27 -34- -7 -.-

..30 ((0 ,,9 t'~ (0 - {,8 -8 .~ .. ~-.

4.0 (,98' 702 700 9' - 103 7 .•

So 723 728' 7-2' /2"z -137 -15-

_. .. ~~ ...

'0 7{'2 7~ '8' 7t!J- I{;I -171 -/0

70 801 BOf 801 /97 -,20, -9 ..

C;o 8#.1 f?39 g~o 23C. -.240 -~

, 90 87~ gB/ fill? 274 -.z7~ 0

~ '1

o f\.)

o o

, 41