using nih grant data to understand the job paths of ......k99 awards k99 institutions r00...
TRANSCRIPT
Career trajectoriesUsing NIH grant data to understand the job paths of
biomedical researchers
Christopher L. Pickett, Ph.D.Director
Rescuing Biomedical Research1
79% 60%
10%
New Ph.D.s who do a postdoc
Sauermann and Roach, 2016
Postdocs who want a faculty position
Postdocs who get a faculty position
Attrition
FundingPublications
“I have to get my K99 before I can go on the job market!”
3
4
Perc
ent F
TR01
aw
arde
es w
ith N
IH tr
aini
ng a
war
d
With F or K award before R01
With no NIH award before R01
F32
K01
K08
K23
K99
NRSA postdoctoral fellowship
Research scientist CDA
Clinical scientist research CDA
Patient-oriented research CDA
Pathway to Independence
PhD, MD
PhD
MD
MD
PhD, MD
6
25
No preference
25
Q1, Q2 prefer
25
Q3, Q4 prefer
First Time R01 awards
25% 50% 75%12
institutions23
institutions46
institutions897
institutions
Quartile 4Quartile 2 Quartile 3Quartile 1
Stanford Dartmouth Princeton
Institutional preference for training awardees
7
F32 K01 K08 K23 K99 None
Perc
ent o
f FTR
01 a
war
dee
pool
1 2 3 4
What percentage of FTR01 awardees got their F/K at the same institution as their first R01?
8
Perc
ent s
tayi
ng a
t sam
e in
stitu
tion
Conte & Omary2018 J Clin Invest
Institutional preference for training awardees
9
F32 K01 K08 K23 K99 None
Perc
ent o
f FTR
01 a
war
dee
pool
1 2 3 4
10
0 – 15%
15 – 25%
25 – 35%
35 – 50%
>50%
0-3.75%
3.75-6.25%
6.25-8.75%
8.75-12.5%
>12.5%
110 – 15% 0-3.75% 15 – 25% 3.75-6.25% 25 – 35% 6.25-8.75% 35 – 50% 8.75-12.5% >50% >12.5%
12
(12 schools)
K99 awards
K99 institutions
R00 institutions
9%
39%
(405 awards) (145 schools)
64%
R00 conversion rate
*
13
White Multiracial Asian Black
*
**
Perc
ent
K99 success rate
14
• Better understand immigrant faculty, postdoc populations
• How do T trainees affect these values?
• What are the dynamics in retention versus external hiring?
• How do K awards factor into early lab funding?
• What can small groups of universities do to diversify the research enterprise?
• How well do other grant mechanisms support underrepresented scienitsts?