utopias & the information society (fk13 | hm)
TRANSCRIPT
Informationsphilosophie. Information und urbanes Systeme 1
Utopias andthe Information Society
Philosophy of Information (Course in English)Fakultät 13, Hochschule München, Winter Semester 2016-2017
José María Díaz Nafría (Universidad de León, Spain)
Utopias and the Information Society
I. An amalgamation of Utopias from long ago (the project of modernity)1. Social ideal2. Abstract vs concrete utopias3. Utopias of the information society4. Past, present and future utopias
II. Designing liberty1. Information in organisms2. Cybernetics eyes3. Cybersyn: deploying democracy
III. Security vs Trust (the Island or the Globe)1. Is the solar system a secure place to live in?2. Historical remarks3. Soft/Hard Power (lyric vs. Obsession)4. Rousseau vs. Bentham5. Liberalistic Foundations6. Utopias and Globalization
Utopias and the Information Society 2
Bibliography
• MATTELART, A. (2003). The Information Society: An Introduction. Thousand Oak, CA, USA: SAGE Publications.
• HESSE, H. (1943, orig.). The Glass Bead Game (transl. from orig. Das Glasperlenspiel). Vintage. (s. documents section)
• BORGES, J.L. (1941). The Library of Babel, transl. by James E. Irby, in Labyrinths, 1962. Availableat: http://jubal.westnet.com/hyperdiscordia/library_of_babel.html
• ZAMYATIN, E. (1921). We. Englisch edition, E. P. Dutton (s. documents section)• ORWELL, G. (1949). Nineteen Eighty-Four. Penguin, London 2008 [BBC TV - George Orwell's 1984
(1954), in Internet Archive: http://www.archive.org/details/Meatpies_1984].• HUXLEY, A. (1932). Brave New World. [Other related resources in Internet Archive: David Gilbar.
SomaBNW (short Film): http://www.archive.org/details/SomaBNW; Qi Yang. Brave New World - The Hatchery].
• BRADBURY, R. (1953). Fahrenheit 451. München: Heyne-Verlag, 2000.• CHOMSKY, N. (1972). Problems of Knowledge and Freedom. Th Russel Lectures. New York,
USA: Vintage [In Internet Archive: Mark Achbar and Peter Wintonick (1993). Manufacturing Consent: Noam Chomsky and the Media http://www.archive.org/details/manufacturing_consent]
• FUCHS, C. (2010). Critical Theory of Information. In Díaz, Pérez-Montoro, Salto. Glossarium BITri. León, Spanien: Universidad de León. [online: http://glossarium.bitrum.unileon.es]
Utopias and the Information Society 3
PRIMEREducation Programme
4
Education & Research programmeInternational Summer Academies
Support: EU (under request)Period: 2015-2019Venues: Spain, Austria, Greece
I. An amalgamation of utopias (the project of modernity)1. Social Ideal/programme
“Universal History is perhaps the history of a few metaphors” (J.L. Borges)“Universal History is perhaps the history of a few UTOPIAS” (A. Mattelart)
Utopia as a kind of social programme (social ideal) | Plato, The Republic“You are quite right, he replied, in maintaining the general inferiority of the female sex: although many women are in many things superior to many men, yet on the whole what you say is true. And if so, my friend, I said, there is no special faculty of administration in a state which a woman has because she is a woman, or which a man has by virtue of his sex, but the gifts of nature are alike diffused in both… Isn’t it the best for the republic counting with the best men and the best women?...”
5Utopias and the Information Society
I.2 Abstract vs concrete utopias
6
Ideas
Form AppearanceI
Observer
Decontextualizing: Die existing Forms belong
to the otherworldliness (a-spatial, a-temporal)
Utopias and the Information Society
7
I.2 Abstract vs concrete utopiasThe platonic model encapsulated in the
utopic understanding of information
Utopias and the Information Society
• From the viewpoint of the modern signal theory (Digital Transmission): Ideal of transparence
Si{S1, S2,… SN}
Noise
Si’ Compared with{S1, S2,… SN}
Si
I.3 Utopias of the information society
8Utopias and the Information Society
Utopicbackground
Supporters Utopias of the Information Society
Supporters Dystopia
Perfect Language Lull, Wilkins Computable Language Turing, Chomsky
Borges: „The analytic language of John Wilkins“
Perfect thought Lull, Leibniz Computable Thought Babbage, Hollerith, Turing
Hesse: „The Glass Bed Game“
Perfect wisdom Bacon, Encyclopedist,Comte
Unlimited Availability of Knowledge
Outlet, La Fontaine
Borges: „The library of Babel“, „Funes the Memorius“
Perfect social order Nicholas of Cusa, Encyclopedist (Turgot)
Computable Social Order (Normalization)
Saint Simon, Comte, Babbage
Huxley: “Brave New World”Deleuze: „Control society“
Transparent society Rousseau, Bentham, Emerson, Chevalier
Communication without borders
Mumford, Shannon, McLuhan
Orwell: “1984”Wachowski bros.: “Matrix”
Trustful society Bentham, Tarde Security vs Trust of the Information Society
J. Nye Orwell: “1984”
11
I.3 Perfect Language / DystopicBorges (1899-1986): The analytic language of J. Wilkins
Utopias and the Information Society
12
I.3 Perfect Thinking / PastGottfried Wilhelm Leibniz (1646-1716)
Utopias and the Information Society
13
I.3 Perfect Thinking / I.S.C. Babbage (1791-1871) | A. Turing (1912-1954)
Utopias and the Information Society
14
I.3 Perfect Thinking / DystopicH. Hesse: The Glass Bead Game (1877-1962)
Utopias and the Information Society
15Utopias and the Information Society
I.3 Perfect Wisdom / PastR. Llull | Francis Bacon (1561-1626) | W. Leibniz
Leibniz scholar's cabinet of quotes and references
16Utopias and the Information Society
I.3 Perfect Wisdom / I.S.Paul Outlet (1868-1944) | La Fountaine (1854-1943)
17
I.3 Perfect Wisdom / DystopicBorges – Funes the memorius (1899-1986)
Utopias and the Information Society
Ireneo Funes, who, after falling off his horse and receiving a bad head injury, acquired the amazing talent — or curse — of remembering absolutely everything. “He knew the forms of the clouds in the southern sky on the morning of April 30, 1882, and he could compare them in his memory with the veins in the marbled binding of a book he had seen only once,” Borges relates.
18
I.4 Perfect Social Order / PastNicolas of Cusa (1401-1464) | A. Quetelet (1796–1874)
Utopias and the Information Society
Cusa: Earthly order as an image of heavenly order
Quetelet: Moral science as a physics of average man
21
I.4 Transparent Society / PastJean-J. Rousseau (1712-1778) | J. Bentham (1748-1832)
Utopias and the Information Society
23
I.4 Transparent Society / DystopicG. Orwell (1903-1950): “1984”
Utopias and the Information Society
24
I.4 Trustful Society / PastJohn Locke (1632-1704) | Gabriel Tarde (1843-1904)
Utopias and the Information Society
“All mankind… being all equal and independent, no one ought to harm another in his life, health, liberty or possessions.” J. Locke
25
I.4 Trustful Society / I.S.Joseph Nye (1937-)
Utopias and the Information Society
“As we think of power in the 21st century, we want to get away from the idea that power’s always zero sum –my gain is your loss and vice versa. Power can also be positive sum, where your gain can be my gain.”
From tree-like structures to Complex Networks| Systems vs Networks
27
Complex Networks (species, language, science…)
The tree of encyclopedic knowledge
The tree of species (evolutionism)
Again: What is the Information Society?Trees vs Networks (commentary on “The Power of Networks”)
Utopias and the Information Society
28Utopias and the Information Society
Again: What is the Information Society?Trees vs Networks (commentary on “The Power of Networks”)
29Utopias and the Information Society
Again: What is the Information Society?Trees vs Networks (commentary on “The Power of Networks”)
30
D’Alambert & Diderot’s Encyclopedia(XVIII century)
Utopias and the Information Society
Again: What is the Information Society?Trees vs Networks (commentary on “The Power of Networks”)
31Utopias and the Information Society
Again: What is the Information Society?Trees vs Networks (commentary on “The Power of Networks”)
32
2.1 Los tres grandes momentos históricos de búsqueda de la verdad:
antigüedad, modernidad, post-modernidad
The actual structure of the Networks
Utopias and the Information Society
I.4 Past, present and future utopias
33
Mythologised citiesImagined territoriesDystopiasCinematographic utopiasUrban utopiasCommunitarian utopias
Green: oldYellow: XVI-XVIII C.Orange: XIX C.Red: XX-XXI C.
I.4 Utopias of Enlightenment
38
SalineHouse of director control and surveillanceInhabitants perfect semicircle: equidistanceGardens
Bentham’s panoptic: inspired Orwell’s “Big Brother”
Saline d’Arc-et-Senans:Industrial architecture and integrated society (1774)
I.4 The advent of citizenship
39
Pragmatic approach: approved by the constitutive assembly of 1989
• 83 departments• Department size: half day of horse riding
distance until the administrative centre
Territorial search of equalityGeometrical approach (1780): R. de Hesseln, proposed by Abad Sieyès in the constitutive assembly of 1989.
• 1 department = 9 canton• 1 canton = 9 communities• Side of department: 72 Km
I.4 The anarchist utopia: The dream of a society without lords and states
41
Theoretical precursors
Press experiences
Rotary board of European anarchist
Will of developing an anarchist international:
London1864Geneva1866Congr. Brussels 1868Congr. Bâle 1869Saint-Imier (Suiza) 1872Amsterdam 1904International Anarchist
Congress of Amsterdam 1907
I.4 The great bifurcationFrom social to communication utopias
42
Making something together… Too much? Perfect communication
In mid 19th Century the social utopias are
abandoned (rift between Saint-Simon
school)
I.4 Esperanto: the linguistic utopia
43
Members of national esperantist associations
European Esperantist Democracy Movement (EDE): in the European elections 2009
I.4 The utopia of the species improvement
44
Birth selection: from utopia to taboo
EE.UU. and national-socialism: developments of the eugenesic project
I.4 The creative utopia (Bauhaus)
45
Global vision of the artistic disciplines
International influences through its scholars
I.4 The tragic universe of utopias
47
“1984” world according to G. Orwell
DisputedFluctuating alliances (unfounded character of warfare)
Final victory of Oceania which ensures its dominancy
I.4 The end of waste: recycling, recovering
48
Improvement of the Industrial scheme for a radical change of the flow of materials:
I.4 Save the planet: biospherical limits
49
The elusive global governability of environment
Expression of the relations of geopolitical forces:
AdversariesSupportersUndecided
Three pillars of the lasting development:
I.4 A world without growth
50
De-growth becomes a concrete utopia in the face of the natural resources depletion :
creditor state: bio-capacity > ecological footprint
Indebted state: ecological footprint > bio-capacity
I.4 Nature is reasserted in the city
51
Habitable-tree: organic structure self-conditioned(Belgian architect and designer Luc Schuiten)
SeaOrbiter: floatting lab, 51 m. height(French architect Jacques Rougerie)
I.4. 100% renewable (Green energy)
52
Global awareness raising: sceneries for a more prosperous future
Initiatives at urban scale, aiming at:- CO2 reduction- Renewal energy- Efficiency
Ongoing politics: - Public financing- Urban planning- Building regulations- Infrastructures and
public transport
Renewable energy rate in the final energy per country
I.4 Eco-utopias
54
Longo-Maï NetworkSelf-managed (alternative, laic, self-managed rural and anti-capitalist ideology)
Self-sufficientSolidary-pacifistMedia MobilisationCommodity and Ideas exchange
rol
I.4 The new interactive and free world
55
Digital paradise? The new space keep on being strongly unequal
Part of thepopulation withInternet Access (2011)
- Cyber-attackgovernmentalprivate
- Liberty under control- States which are enemy
of Internet (according to Journalist without Borders)
I.4 Other world is possible
56
Alter-globalisation movement and Indignants Movement reject neoliberalism
Mediatic birth of the alter-globalisation movement
World Social Summits
Peasant Movement, debt cancellation, against financial specualtion
Manifestations (18/11/2011 & 13/05/2012)National claims (unemployment, austerity, education…)
I.4 Rights and Dignity: an step towards democracy
57
Squares, symbol of a democratic wind?Confrontation among peoples and real powers. (squares represented by its surface)
I.4 The end of the north-south divide?
58
NGB per inhabitant in 2010:Triad (former economic dominancy, decline in growth and trust)
Post-communist countries (integrated in the market economy)
BRICS bridgehead of the emerging world
The inequality among rich and poor is globally increasing
I.4 Restorative Justice
59
Alternative to the penal system:Restoring better than sanctioningThe person who has committed a crime has a debt with the victim and with the community
Dystopic justiceMinority Report
II.1 Information in the organisms
61
DNA RNA
Polypeptid
Transcription
TranslationSince discovery of RetrovierenReplication
Utopias and the Information Society
II.2 Cybernetic eyes and the Viable System Model (VSM)
65
The three elements as a whole system in equilibrium
• Which is the key factor of the adaptive systems?• What is inside and outside?• What is the role of the border?• The environment is or not part of the system?• Does it need to be centralized?• The organisation must respond to the changes in the
environment
Utopias and the Information Society
II.2 Cybernetic eyes and the VSM
66
The five parts of the system (inside)
Utopias and the Information Society
II.2 Cybernetic eyes and the VSM
67
Nested systems:
Recursion levelsAshby’s Law of required variety:Vorg > Venv, problem
Utopias and the Information Society
68
Focusing on (vertical dimension):
II.2 Cybernetic eyes and the VSM
Utopias and the Information Society
69
Managing complexity (horizontal):
II.2 Cybernetic eyes and the VSM
Utopias and the Information Society
70
Residual Variety (complexity):
II.2 Cybernetic eyes and the VSM
Utopias and the Information Society
II.3 Cybersyn Project: deploying democracy
• Recursion levels• Level 10 (State Economy)
73Utopias and the Information Society
Nationalisation and collectivisation process
of the industrial economy is started
1970: Allende win the elections through a
tight majority (margin of 1.3%)
74
II.3 Cybersyn Project
Utopias and the Information Society
Compañías nacionalizadas
75
II.3 Cybersyn Project
• Changes increase of: Production | GNP | Salaries• Simultaneous increase of: Inflation | Shortage
• From a macroscopic adjustment (classic) the situation couldn’t be solved• The microeconomic adjustment came across with problems of internal organisation,
corruption, excessive management costs.• Fernando Flores plans a model of cybernetic management: calls Stafford Beer• CORFO (Corporación de Fomento de la Producción) Industry
Utopias and the Information Society
• Cybernet: was designed to use the telex network for real-timemonitoring of each business. This control may seem contrary toAllende’s idea of individual freedom, however, this control waslimited to external observation, results per business day, whichwas framed in the idea of centralized economy.
• Cyberstride: collected the set of software used for collect, process, and distribute data to and from each of the state enterprises.
• CHECO: short for 'Chilean Economy' was never materialized, but it was a mathematical and statistical model sought to simulate the behavior of the Chilean economy as to predict it’s behavior and likewise seek solutions before problems arise.
• Opsroom: was a space aimed at control the whole system. Itconsisted of seven chairs with simple systems for any type ofworker could hold such positions. Opsroom was only materializedin a prototype.
76
II.3 Cybersyn Project
Utopias and the Information Society
III. On Security and Trust
79
I. Newton (1642-1727)P.S. Laplace (1749-1827)
Utopias and the Information Society
III. Security vs Trust
80
• Subjective vs. Objective Sense (certitude vs. Stability of the system)
Utopias and the Information Society
Self-realisation necessity: to be useful to others without effort
Self-esteem necessity:community acknowledgment
Necessity of belonging-to:being part of a community
Security Necessity: by group validation
Functional Necessities: finding a place to eat, sleep, drink
III. Security vs trust (the Island and the Globe)
• 1990s: Information Society (transparent and borderless) – September 11th
• Security vs. Trust (Boundary Conditions vs. Inner Conditions)
• Contradictions in the liberalist discourses with respect to protectionism and interventionism
• Pendulum with respect to the awareness of threats.
81Utopias and the Information Society
III.1 Historical Notes
“It is a very common clever device that when anyone has attained the summit of greatness, he kicks away the ladder by which he has climbed up, to deprive others of the means of climbing up after him […]Any nation which by means of protective duties and restrictions on navigation has raised her manufacturing power and her navigation to such a degree of development that no other nation can sustain free competition with her, can do nothing wiser than to throw away these ladders of her greatness, to preach to other nations the benefits of free trade”
(List 1885, pp. 295-296).
82Utopias and the Information Society
III.1 Historical NotesIII.2 Soft/Hard Power (lyric vs. obsession)
83
a) Beginings of freetrading | s.XXI: Famine in Ireland (1846-48) vs. Opium Wars (1842, 1858)Opium Wars (s.XIX) vs. Iraq Wars (s.XX)
i) False arguments, ii) effect of previous wariii) de facto Colonialism, iv) hindered long term development, v) Losses of historical and artistic assets, vi) separatist, ethnic and religious rebellions favoured
b) Hard Power vs. Soft Power (Joseph Nye) Global Information Dominance (Echelon, National Imagery and Mapping Agency, Future Imagery Architecture)
Utopias and the Information Society
III.3 Rousseau vs. Bentham
84
M.Foucault (The eye of the power): „Bentham was the complement to Rousseau. What in fact was the Rousseauist dream that motivated many of the revolutionaries? It was the dream of a transparent society, visible and legible in each of its parts, the dream of there no longer existing any zones of darkness [...] It was the dream that each individual, whatever portion he occupied, might be able to see the whole society…”
Utopias and the Information Society
III.3 Rousseau vs. Bentham
85
M. Foucault (The eye of the power): “[Bentham] effects the project of a universal visibility which exists to serve a rigorous, meticulous power. Thus Bentham’s obsession, the technical idea of the exercise of an ‘all-seeing’ power, is grafted on to the great Rousseauist theme which is in some sense the lyrical note of the Revolution… When the Revolution poses the question of a new justice, what does it envisage as its principle? Opinion. The new aspect of the problem of justice, for the Revolution, was not so much to punish wrongdoers as to prevent even the possibility of wrongdoing, by immersing people in a field of total visibility where the opinion, observation and discourse of others would restrain them from harmful acts”
Utopias and the Information Society
III.3 Rousseau vs. Bentham (Soft/Hard Power)
86
• G. Tarde (Sociologist and criminologist)“All the improvements of social organization… have the consequence of enabling that one meditated, coherent, individual project arrives purer, lesser polluted, deeper, and through the safer and shorter means into the minds of all the associated” (Tarde, Public opinion and the crowd. 1690, §107).
• Public Opinion (co-optionn) ~ Control Society (Deleuze) “The material and economic aspects of opinion were not acknowledged. They believed it “is fair by nature, it disseminates by itself, and it is a sort of democratic surveillance […]” (Foucault)
• Decolonisation and reaction (1950-1970s)• New International Economic Order (1974), New
World Inf. and Comm. Order (1974), C. MacBride
Utopias and the Information Society
III.4 Liberal Foundations
87
• John Locke"those, who like one another so well as to join into society, cannot but be supposed to have some acquaintance and friendship together, and some trust one in another; they could not but have greater apprehensions of others, than of one another: and therefore their first care and thought cannot but be supposed to be, how to secure themselves against foreign force. It was natural for them to put themselves under a frame of government which might best serve to that end…"
(Second Treatise on Government. 1690, §107).
• Liberal Foundations (J. Locke, A. Smith, J. Bentham, Burke)
Utopias and the Information Society
III.4 Liberal Foundations(a new difference)
88
Differences in the objective of each position:• The transparency/trustworthiness, hence the communications
without borders is at the groundings of many utopias of the Information Society (MacLuhan, Etzioni, Toffles, Barlow, etc) as well as of other technical utopias as Kropotkin’s, advocating the dissolution of (concentrated) power.
• There is a close connection with the various foundations of liberalism, in which different approaches are present:– Degree of Free-will vs Authoritarianism (Rousseau / Bentham)– Degree of Fairness/equality vs Unfairness/Unequality
(Bentham/conservative Liberals)
Utopias and the Information Society