300v VSPAC( ~84BBBORBIIIBVIRQINIA OAB AND OIL BOARD Qgg (

IN RE:

SUPPLEMENTAL ORDER REGARDING DOCKET NUMBER VGOB-01-01164862

ELECHONS: UNIT C-16(berein "Stsbiuct Drlihng Unit" )

REPORT OF Bf)ARD

FlhHMNGS AND ORDER

Tide supphmtnnd Order is ca«red by 0» Bosrd Bno spence in tba Sum~by 6» Board at beerhgsbebl on pchu«y 15, 1994and Juac 16, 1992; and Ibh Supplemenml Order is behg recorded for 0» purpose ofSBVV'—==-"=-Ibe Onbr pmvhusly h tbc capthasd mmtsr On Aprg 13,2001 which was recorded st Deed Book522, Page 460 in tbe Oghe of0» Cksk ofIbe Ckcuk Court ofBmdmtmt Cot»ty, Vkghie, on April 19,2001,(bemh "Bomd OnhPj aad~S» raconl ragsrdhg ehctk»s.

Tbe Bcenl Onkr dbsc«d Consol Emsgy hc. (bnain "Dmigantad OpceaoP) to mail copies oftbc Bomd Orderto ag Best»ad«m whose ~ifnay, wma pooled bye» said Bomd Order,

Tbsp=-' -Op»asar Shd Ss agkhvlt ofshe&ms dhokniag that it bad meged a «I» and consct oopy ofthe Bomd's Onhr m ag Smpcmhah wbces imssuect, ifany, wssa pooled by said Bead Order;

Tbc Board Otdtr ttxtukad aacb ihw- —~wboee htsreats, ifany, wmu pooled by the «sn» ofmtd BomdOnbr tomabs m ehcthn wbbhddtty(30) &ps agar Ibe dsss of«»ging or rnxxdhg, m appgcabls, ofsaid Ordar,the agkhvb ofehcttw Shd bcmia and mussed btsam as Exbibit A st»a«(0 wbeg»r Back Respondeat basmade or Sdlad to mabn a thndy chctbn; (S) tbc nanna ofmry ehcticn(s) madtc sad (ig) wbegsn; by ra«am ofaStkaa» sb»ter totkneiy elect ot» or nxuu ~~~ma deemed, under tbe «trna oftbe Bomd's Otdar, tobava haeed ag Ibek rlgbh, SthB intsreata, estmn and chin» h Subiaet Drggeg Unk to 0» Appgcar,

'lbat d»etgdavbcfehcthm aantncdbsmto wbb 6» Estdbks subndned gnrawbb khntigm 0» Saspmdtsn(s)mskbg athudyehclw, ifsay hhnttgm 0» Rmpoadent(s), ifany, wbo ara deemed to bava leased; idsodSas 6»

knnaah aml chkm wbicb rtvpdtu mcrow; ideattgm tbe kn«ua» aud chbns, ifsay, ratpdrhg mcrowunder Vhghh Code sec«an 45.1-361213X;md idwttgm «» Ssapcmlants, ifauy, wbo may be disa&»ed byramtn ofbavhg leased cr «tered heo a vohanny n»~ wbb S» Applhmt.

Tbe atgdavb ofahcgms hdhetm gmt Ibe mctow ofSade h requkad wib regard to Unit C-16;

Qgba. BytbisOtdtr, 6» Bomd ordered» ~Opsratcr to tender, ocnsbtam wbb audie ccocdanmwkb 6» Smgags sat Sngt et eeragrapb 2. above and 0» annexed sSdavk ofehcthns wbb Exbibbs S»neo, anysmds subbsx» eecmw and h&ucm 0» Escrow Agent, First Unhn Nascaal Beak, ccrportle Trust pA1 320,123Broad Street, Pbihdelpbia, PA 19109-1199,Tehpbona (215) 905-3405 or (000) 664-9359, Anm DcaBaghgbW m auy w~ named by 6» Bcmd tn csmbgsb httreet baerhg escrow acocum(s), ISS TaxR' '=—' Number 54-1629506, in~~witb 0»~~ sct Sudt ia Ibe agkhvk ofchctkx» wkbtbddbks dusuto, to receive iknds end eccctmt to 0» Board duaugn.

BOGY, 528 PAGE 585

esetue cfOwtr erst W ofAtgdsvtc Tbe~Operator under dm cap&oned Order ar sbag &h sna&bhvit wltb tbe Secretary of tbs Based widua ten (10)drgu ager tbe dhe ofreceipt of&de Order stetiag dmt amw turdcarrect aapyaftbb Onhr wmmeiled to eacb Rsspomlent wbose hterests or chbns me subject to eecmw

aad wboss addrme is bnown witbia ssvmt ssvwt (I)days Som the dues oftucipt ofdm Onhr.

Ethcdve Dear. TIds Onhr ebs& be a&bctive on the date ofbe esscudan.

DONE AND EXECIJIED dds Dent~ day af W~, 2001, by a majority oftbsVirghh Gas and Oil Bared. 0

STATE OF VIRGBIIACOUNTY OF WISE

Achuwdsdgsdmt~ deyaf ,2001,peanagy hdhe nw a notaryprddh h emlgu tbe Comtmunnultb ofVbgbde, ~Barmy R. Wamphr, being duly sworn dbl dspase andeaytbstbe h Cbahnsa oftbs Vbghh Gas end O& Bond, dwt be euscutM tbs amus ead wm autbcrhM to do sa

Swan G. GarrettNotary

Myv ~eonsupbes: 747 BW

DONE AND FERFORMED TIIIS 2. dayof Au rf mxf,2001, byOnhr ofde Board.

K R.W&mnDirector oftbs Division ofGas 4 0&Bandaad Fincipal ~to tbe Board

STATE OF VIRGINIACOUNTY OF WASHINGTON

Acbmowtnlgsd antbis3 dsyaf II~rM,2001, Seecne&ybekue ms anctety pub&c ia end Str tbe Cammewmabb ofVujinh, kppsrued B.R.W&son, being duly swam rgd deposesud suy duu be h Acung ~~to tbs Ste&; Vbghh Gas sad Oil Based, tbat be euecuted tbenmw turd was utbarhed to do so.

Mycammhsbmaspbes: 4JZD J> ~ I.

Q.= nM,~Disso J.Davis, No&ay

BOOK MS FACE586

VIRGINIA:Exhibit A

BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD

IN RE:

Appgcmhm of BUCfhQVN PRODUCIION CO. SxForced Fcogag of brtsres» ia CSM Umt C-16VGOB41+I I641062 ia 6» North Grundy Dhtrit ofBrxkwwt County, Vhgbke

AFFIDAV1T OF Consol Energy Inc. (btrein "Dtsitpxrhxl OPtrato) REGARDING EUKTIONS, ESCROWAND SUPIriEMENTAL ORDER

14sgs K.~hsing Snx duly sworn oa oak, deposes aad says:

That your a&hm is snqkoyed by Consol Bsargy Inc., m a Gas Engb»rx aad is duly~to mabs this

amdavb on brbalf ofthe asigaatrd opsraux,

That the Ordtr cntsmd on April 13,2001, by the Vhghka Gas and Oil Board beech»gm ~egardiag the capthmsd CBM Unit requhrd the Appgcaat to mail a tn» aad ccnect ocpy ofsaid Onhr m each

parson parked by the Ordsr,

Tbst wigkn seven (T) days ofreoipt ofan executed copy ofthe Onbx rogxred to at~2. above, youraigant caused a tn» aad ccrrtxx copy of said Onhr to be»aged vbt S» Unhed Bourn Peek Ssrvhe to sechF=.==a»asd in 0» ctpthx»d Appgcakon, whose addmes was hewn, aad to ag persons, ifany, wbo were

R —— SS bmbgbklhN ~~lh\~<atbaalhgba~baatsmheed to 6» Dbdsbm ofGas aml OiL tbe CMSoe ofthe Gas aad OS~,m~Vhghke;

Tbst the Onhr oftbs Board bt the capthxud mmter rcquhtd ag ptsscns pooled thereby to tender their wrhsralsctions to 0» Unit Opsraux wbbh Skrty(30) dtga of0» dass tbe Order was recorded in tbe ccoaty 'dsntgbxl

above; tbm sebi Onhr wm recmdsd oa April 19,2001;

That 0» ' '=:cprratcr Consol Energy lac. bm sstabgsbsd pnocsdun» to mview ag mail reorived and agwrhtm dccumsrm mceb»d ctbtrd»abymag» ascertabt wbstbrx paths whose hmxes» have baca pooled bovemade awrbtsa shaSaa, laasmsly Subba, mmquhedbyths ~Urdar, that sebi pocsdusm wme fogonedto bhug(F the shokcns, lfaqy, made whh reganl to 6» Subject Unit; d»t 6» lbgowbtg pan»ns oliver'y mailm otbsrwhs, wrhnm ehxshx» S» Unit Opmnxx; whbht the Smty day shxxhx» psrhxb

None.

%MS 'hlbbMIH~m~&hlamh m~~l bd»ir scag»d meg»ne rights, hncnxm and cbmns to Applicant, ag as provided in 6» Board's Order ofAprg 13,2001;

10Ptt 528 f40( 587

That the rights, huervvm snd ohdms ofthe tbgowiag persons me subject to escrow uader tbe Boenps Ordw

poogng tbe capthmed Unit, Board Rsguhshats and the Cods ofVhghia

None

That agw ths poogag hearing behl ia the~mmttr, the following psrscae have leased cr sstmed ln«a vohmtmy ~wbb tbe~Operetta:

that to the «neat say ofsaid persons lhnsd ht Exhtbh B-2 have rights, hnsrests and chdtns which are not subject«mcruw, they sbcuhlbe ~mmtpmxhnts; the Operator requmts tbst tbe Sdtowhg pemcas be dimhsedas Rmpatdeats:

Lena Vates, Debcruh B.Ogle snd Jobs 1L Lath

That ths pmscas hharttged in Exhibit EE anacbed hem«have catered ht« tntuby split agreemerm that sgowths AppgcaaaG~~ Opera«r to pep them dheogywhbout the need to secrnw Smds which would otbenrimbe m coagtct.

None

Tbtt pmsaem« the tuviskns ofVAC23-160 70%.10.and C snd VAC 23-16040 ths annexed supplemesndorder mm Satb tbe htmrsrus and claims that teqmre escrow ofSade pursuaat «Vhgbda Code sscgons 45.1-361212K ead 4$.1-36122A3. sad 4.

Jystsd m TmawelL Vhghda, this Z~ ~ day of~sf dl , 2001.

Lmt«X.~ )

Tahe, sbecabed sml swam to before me by Ltnge K. Amnion@ Gas Engineer ofConsol Energy Inc„onbehalf ofthe ocrporsm ~Operator, ~& day of , 2001.

Notary

My cratmdmicn exphvvc /I/3djID/I r

PROPERIY Lsms mICWIV WEPE ~ .«=v IIYA VVPSpRovloEI} eY coNscL Inc. Rc wKRE vot SL'+YKYEC

eOOX 528PAGE588

// E 975,379.93

~'

/ 80 ACRE UNIT

E 973,517.58 f1,

/I I

I

I'I

I II

/'/

i '

I

I

II

I I I

II

I.I--. '

I I

CBM-CI6 117I

/j Ji '.(

M---(- I .I '-.gJ )I7 ))) N 3E',863.H 1 (( N 361,794.76I'

'(i' ~"((

(I

I

EXHIBIT A

OAKWOOD FIELD UNIT C-16FORCE POOLING

VGOB-01-0116-0862

"'

Campony CONSOL Emrav lr ". Well Nasa and Number UNIT C16

Tract No. ElevationCounty Buchanan „'v~ ~ NC .h Grundvr Scale: ~ = -OdteL/ /I"= shO'-- " ': I i/DyDI3.

This plat is a nev pic- v : an updated plat or KL final plat

I Mvv~ lk, I 1 )~ ~ "" AIRE'fit< Seal IFcrm OGO-GO-7Rev. 9/91 'censed sr Cfese I oncl Eng'neer or

Linseed

Land SurvdXor

o'vvlNpl~paoLcIspoo~ rs'ma30c&sss1 Av

GPPII 5/8 PAGE <389 December 13, 2000

CONSOL ENERGY INC.UNIT C18

Tract Msngfhadons

Yukon Pocahontaa, et el. Tr. 80- Coal, ON & GaeCoal LesseeIshmd Creek Coal Company - Sehw Dtahsge Coal LeasedSuchstum ProducNon Company - CSM'eased27.98acres 34.9750%

Keaehr Dawson - Sutl'aceJmmNC tauon ~~-SheSari W. Ystea, et sl. (Hale of Louhs B.Yshe) - Coal, ON 5 GaeCoal LesseeIsland Creek Coal Company- Behw Dtahage Coal LeasedJeweN Btnekslese Coal Ccitp. - TSer aad Above Coal LeasedBuchatum ProducNon Conipany - ON 0 Gae and CSM Leased (19/32)Gaty Dean BaMtth - SurNtce (50%)Mshtshs Lse Mwh - SurAtce (50%)3.30scree 4.1250%

Yukort Pocahonhs, et ai Tr. 118-Coal, ON 8 GaaCoal LeasesIsland Creek Coal Company - Sehw Dtahage Coal LeasedJewel Smokeless Coal Corp. -Above ~Coal LeasedBuchstum ProthcNon Company - CSMILeased122 scree 1.5250%

Inez Wegand —FeeCoal Leaseshhnd Oaek Coal Company - TNler snd Sehw Coal Leased0.43 scree 0.5375%

0 orlrldge Heka - Coal, ON 8 GaeCoal LesseehAnd Creek Coal Company - Btdew Dmhege Coal LeasedJeweN Smokeless Coal Corp. - Wdow Kennedy Seam Leased37.70scree 47.1g!0%

DawtuMs Fowler WINsme, et al. - Coal, ON 5 GaeCoal LesseeIsland Osek Coal Company- Below Dndnags Coal LeasedJewsg Smokeless Coal Company -Abtrve Drahage Coal LeasedBuchan'roducNon Company - CSM Leased (%%)9.37acres 1 L7125 %

Page 1

Erb8r8 88IBEyC.18

Dedrre 8VOSPOIAH988882Usl el::::::.:le be

B00K 528 PAGE".90

Puresrd ay hlaeelhIhR 18Eael -S,I8%

(I) Earl W. Yehs, el elHats af Rkherd 8 Louise B.Ydas

4.1250% 2.275%

(e) Leon Ydeedo Calby Bapay7Odr LeeSuepetL WV 24701

(b) Detach B.09le3NO Sdppee R)d9e

„VA28139

(dd) John R. Lark1415Hapyhoak CedeAlaska, FL S2708

OA11/8 af 3.30erw

0.0$1/1 28 af 3.30area

OA1

1/8 d 3.80safes

0.5158% 0.284%

0.0322% 0.018%

0.5158% 0.284%

(1) Eel W. Yehs, d C.Hats d Rfaherd 8 Iaufae IL Ydea

(s) Lean Ydeadb Cdhp Bepay7 Odr LenaSuepetk WV 24701

(b) Deboeh B.08)e3(N) Bkkrpee f859e~,Vh 28139

(dd) John R. Lak1415Halyhock CeufsApapks, FL 3270$

OA11/8 d3.30mw

0.031/128 af 3.30mm

OA1I/O d 8.30am

4.1250%

0.5158%

O.N22% 0.018%

0.5155% 0.284%

Pa9e I d 1

Sxtdbtt $4Uftfy 0-18

Docket 8VOOS4H41188882Uet of Unsexed OwnetaChtmanh

BOOY MS PAGE 59$

Penent of hhmat hUnS 10 Seat -8L18%

(1) Earl W. Y/des, at aLHeirs of Rkferd & Loube 8. Yales

4.1250% 2.275%

(c) Ttxxrula L So)cher2212 fdrby Road/8chmond, VA 23224

(d) GmSory S.BatcherRL1 Sax 289Cumberland, VA 23040

(e) ChriNne S. Hooper1000Mawb)e Ndge RoadC~~, VA 23832

ORB1/128 of 3.30acres

0.031/128 of 3.30acne

0.031/1 28 of 3.30acme

0.0322% 0.018%

0.018%

0.018%

0.031/120 of 3.30acres

0.019%

(cc) Anna Mais 8. TmesrerP.O. Box 324fkxeee M, VA 24085

0.031/120 cf 3.30acme

0.019%

(1) Inex Wts9and124 Lexis Or)usHuba/L NC 28539

0.5375% 0.298%

(1) ~HakeMark 8. Golf, A9entP.O. Sex282Gnmrly, VA 24814

37.70 acres 47.1250% 25.989%

(1) Cwmede Fewer gems et aL

(a) Oawlwxh FowhrP.O. BOx 548Wke, VA 24293

(b) Pwmda Few(sr3133Lake Ehn DriveTwnpa, FL 33818

9.37 acne

2.341/4 of 3.30acme

2.341/4 of 3.30acres

11.7125% 8.459%

2.9281% 1.515%

2.9281% 1.815%

Pa9e1 of 2

InOV 528 FACE . 9ZDsehst 0V00$4141188882

Psreerd of fntsmst tn

Uny 18Best -SL18%

(1) Barf W. Tates, at etHshs of Rkhsrd 8 Lmdse B.Yalss

(c) Thpnms L Batcher2212 l(htrf RoadRichmond, VA 23224

(d) Breyory S. Bs(cherRL1 Box 289Clrs~~ae, VA 23040

(e) Chrfsyns 8. Hooper1000 htswtys Br(dye RoadC~ ", VA 23832

(bb) Crely A. Hom901 Paul DrheBeaufsrL SC 29902

(cc) Anna Mwis S.TiessrwrP.O. Beu 324Boonse M, VA 24066

0.031/128 of 3.30sores

0.031/128 of 3.30aalu

0.031/12S of 3.$0 acres

(LOS

1/120 of S.SOacres

0.031/120 of 3.30acres

4.1250% 2.275%

0.0322% 0.018%

O.OS22% 0.018%

0.0322% 0.018%

0.019%

0.019%

(1) irma Wtsynnd124 Leeds DrheHubmt, NC 28539

Treat%. 37.78sem

0.6375%

(1) Scotrktye HeirsMerit S.Doff, AysnlP.O. Bcu 282Brand)r, VA 34814

37.70 acres 47.1250% 25.989%

(1) Dawneda Fowfsr WMsms et at

(a) Dawneds FonderP.O. Bou 548Whe, VA 24293

(b) Pamets Few(sr313SLake tBsn Drhnr

Tampa, FL 33818

9.37 acme

2.341/4 of 3.SO sores

2.S41/4 of 3.30acres

11.7125%

2.9281%

2.9281%

1.816%

1.816%

Pays2of2

goov

528'UC..ANAUICO)-VA

TTTDR T'kTT a. A a Q A TtTTt ATT DA a DA

VIRGINIA: In the Clerk', ff' of the Qepuit Court of Buchanan County. The foregoing instrument

YP~™ TESTE~ James O'Bevins J Cl k