I ISSOX

5~~PSSI~

BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD

SUFFLEMENTAL ORDER REGARDING DOCKET NUMBER VGOB-9947204729-01

ELECTIONS: UNIT S-32(herein "Subject Drilhng Unit" )

RRPORT OF BOARD

FINDINGS AND ORDER

1lds Suppkascmal Onhr is satcredbytbe Bo«d sts«spoon. in tbs form autbcshsdby tbe Board at bsariagsbebl on Psbnaay 1S, 1994 sad tuse 16, 1992; aad this Supplemental O«dsr is being reccnhd Sa tbs purpose ofstvv' ='= Sts Onbr Previously in tbs coPtkasd near oa May 26, 2000 which was teo«ded m Deed BookSgg, Pays 101 h tbe Otgce of tbs Cbsk oftbe Circub C«at oF Buchan Ccusty, Virghis, on Jmw 2, 2000,(hach "Board One) sad~«be tec«d tegsrdhg ehctims.

1bs Bc«ad Onhr dbecaal CONSOL lnc. (bc«eh "Designsttd ~to mail capias oftbs Board Order toag Bespcmlsms wbces iatsnuts, iFaay, w«e pool«1 by«be sebi Bond Onhr,

1bs L''- '::- Operas«Shd ih agbhvg ofchances dhckshg tbm b bad maged anus «md cone«ocpy ofIh Iba4 ~h &R————~~Lm PWWhhaR~Ihd

Tbe Bcmd Onhr rs«pdted each Bespcadsat whose hterssts, ifsay, w«e poohd by tbs t«nas ofsaid Bc«dOnbr to mobs an she«ha wÃda dd«ty(30) d«ga sg«r «be dtss ofmsgieg cr menSsg, ss sppgcsbls, ofsebi Order,the agbhvit ofehcgces Shd b«eia sad mmessd bc«no as Ibdtgdt A~:(1) wbednr cack Beep««dern basmade «S«gad to wake a tbnsly obetkn; (S) tbe ammo ofmty ehctkn(s) msdn and (St) wbsgt«, by rema ofa Btbsem shet sr totbn«dy shet «m or nano Bmpcadsms me dssme«L ader tbe nsnn of«be Boenl's Onhr, tobove hosed ag tbsb rigbts, tbh, htarests, sstmm asd dime h Subject Drggsg Unb to tbs Appgcanb

1bmdm tdgdsvb cfshttkss mnattdbnmo wlbtbe Bsbgd«s~tbsrewbb idsnggm tbs Bssp«absn(s)MS'h~hà ~~h hhÃ'",~ ~h I ~~h~—-'-'- httmsh aad chhn wbkb te«pdm «ecmw; bhnttgm tbe iattrests and clakes, iFsay,~cmxow«md«Virghh Code secgca 45.1-3612124 and id«egg« tbe:—:=-=~ifany, wbo mey be dhmhsed by«eanm ofbivhg leased ««meed bno a vobnnay sgnasnnn udgt tbe Appgcmn,

1be agbhvb ofehcti«n hdkstm Sue«be ce«ow ofSash is tequbed wbb «egad to Unit S-32;

Bytbis Onbr, tbe Bo«d «dere tbe~Opsnncr to ttu«hr, c«whttm wbb aad ia~wgb «be Sngags set Satb et Sarsgrspb 2. above aad gm sanssed sSdsvit ofeh«icas wbb Bstdbgs Suasto, aaySmds aabjsct to ««soused hshuels Sr« Escrow Agsst, Pbst Uaka Nmknal Bank, Corponae Trust PA1 320 123B«Oad Stre%, Ptht hchhthth. PA 19109-1199,Tehpbcmt (215) 905-3605 «(000) 664A659, Atua DsaBslgaglt«df, or sny secular named by tbe Bo«d to sshbgsb bntvsst bs«ieg «c«ow scca«a(s), Btg Tax' '- Number 54-1629506,h~~wbb «be~~sst Satb h tbe a%davit ofehctioas wbbBsbhih ~to lecelve Smds «nd acc«mt to tbs Bcenl tbcrefcr.

r „

000< 511FIICI557

Metuso sr tbvtvr sod Fttlae ofAgtdvvie The~Opsratcr under Sre ceptioad Order or shag Sie aardgdavh whh the Secretary ofSre Board wigda tea (IO) days ager dre date ofrecrdpt ofdds Order suxing that a

I pj CSE~ ~R bR '~ Id &~Iaad whose addasss is hanna wigdn seven swee (7)days Som tbs dsss ofreceipt ofthis Ordsr.

C ~ ~Sre Srxgage and ag tenne and provisions set Satb above be aad htrehy sre grantedaad ff IS SO ORDERED.

E%ctive Date: Mia Onhr shag bs egtcgve cn the &te ofhe xtcuticn.

DONE AND EXECU1ED Cia~day of Aver~, 2000, by a nutjarity ofdre VhginiaGas aad Oil BoanL 0'a.

WISHESSTATE OF VIRGINIACOUNTY OF WISE

A 'txr Sds~daycf I'~~,2000, psousallybegxe nm a notary pubgcI'~&and SxtbeGsmxutaea% cfVhghh, appeared RhyR. Waraphx, beiag tbdy swtun dhl depose aad say Saxhs is Cbainam ofthe Vhginia Gas aad Oil BoerrL that be eeacuad Sre sane aad was axxbcrhed to do so.

Susaa G. Garron

Notary

My ccnunhsba expires: ~~4AM.

DONE AND FEltpOIMSD THigtfS day of A ~~2000, byOnhx oftbs BoanL/

Direcux oftbe Division ofGas 4 Oil Boardand Principal Exocugve to tbe Board

STA1E OF VIRGINIACOUNTY OF WASHINGTON

Achnoudedgsd oa tbh~day of~~f,2000, Srscaally befcre na a notarypublic in and gx tbs Ccrmtxrawwbb ofVhgbde, appeared B.IL Wgscn, brdeg duly swan tgd depose aad saythat he h Acgng rincipsl ~to tbe Stag; Vhghda Gas aad Oil BcerrL Sxx bs executed tbe swtw aad

My coaxniesioa exphrn: 9W)~ 1.

.Q..a~'Dbsse J.Davis, Ntpxfy

„,„511PSSI558

VIRGINIA:Exhibit A

BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD

ptdlhuthm of BUCHANAN PRODUCIION CO. kr Porced Pooling cf interesm ia CBM Unit S-32 VGOB-99%720472MI in tbe Hhuricene Disnict ofBucbenm C«uuy, Vhghda

APPIDAVII'OP CONSOL Inc. (herein "Designated ~REGARDING EIECIIONS, ESCROW AND

SUPPIZMENTAL ORDER

Leslic JL~being Erst duly sworn on osh, deposes snd says:

Ibet your aSem is cmphrJed by CONSOL hrc., as a Pcrmh Specialist snd is duly~to mshe ddssllavit on behalf ofthe desigaacsd operator,

Ibet tbe Order cnttred oa May 26, 2000, by tbc Virginia Gss end Oil Board Cseinsgm "BoartP)egsrrgag the cepthured CBM Unit nqaired tbe Applicant to mail anus sad ccnect copy ofsaid Order to each

psrsan pooled by the Order,

Ibtuwigda seven (7) days ofreceipt ofsa executed copy ofthe Order regured to at Sesggsphh 2.above, y«uaSiaat caused a nue snd comet ocpy of said Order to be magsd via tbe United Smtm P«ual Service to eachIbw named in tbe cepthmed Applicedcn, whose addnus was hnown, sad to all persons, ifsny, wbo wwedhC I = ' 4 Iw&ghklhlb plkNI~~~ l hw4&gh ~h

tembrvd to the Dtvbhm ofGes snd CN, tbe 0%eofthe Ges sad OS laspectcr, at~Virginia;

7bet the Onhr ofthe Bomd m tbe cqmoaed matter nquired all persons pooled thereby to ttndar their wrhtcnelections to the Unit Operetta wigun thirty(30) days ofthe dsm the Order wss rec«dsd in tbe c«uuy 'dcatifisdshove; that said Onbr wes recorded on June 2, 2000;

7bst dm ssigmued opsnncr CONSOL Inc. bss estebgsbrd pocsdurm to review ell mag received sad allwrinm ~ received «her thea by mug m ascsrtaia wbsthsr pmties whose husrests have been pooled havemade awrhtm ehcgsn, in a timely Sabha, m rvquhedby the cspthmsd Order, that sebi procsdurm wme followedto idcngti dre ehcthes, ifsay, made whh regred to dw Subject Unh; that the Sdhnving persons delivwed, by mailor «berwbe, vwhtsn electhms tbe Unit Operetta, wigdn tbe tbhty day lsctioas perhxL

Nuns.

~L 'hlbbMIL3~~lsegNhll ~~~~Itheir coalbed methane rights, iarterests snd claims to Applicant, all as pmvidrd ia tbe Board's Order ofJuae 2,2000;

Sce Anecbcd Exhibit B-3

itPPG 5Q. PAGE 559

lint dm rights, baseets and daims af tba fogowiag persans are subject to escrow under tbe Board's Orderpoagag tbe caythmsd Un'oard Repttatians aad tbe Code ofVirgtnhc

lint ager tbe poogag beariag bdd ia tbe capthuud mmter, dw Sdtowiag pereatw have leased ar ensned buoa voluntmy ~whh the~Operator.

None

thra to tbe vntam any af sebi persona liood in Exhibit B-2 have rights, husnets and daime which me nat subjectto eneow, tbeyehaahlhs ~mnetundmar, tbe Openaor requests gmt tbe gdtowtag ptssons be diem@sad

ae Resymdams:

Nona

Tbm yunammto Ibe ptovbtam afVAC 25-160-70%.10.and C.md VAC 25-16000 tbe armand suppbmnualseder sets gath the bnerests md claims that requhe escrow ofSade ymeuaat to Vhgbds Code sections 45.1-361 212).aad 45.1-36122%3.aad 4.

Ibaedet Tamweg, Virghua,tbie J3 dsyof Q~r 4

Tabea, ubscrgud and sworn to before me by Leslis K. 's permit Specialist ofCONSOL inc., anbehdfoftbe separate ~Otuuetor, tbie ~dayof Wi LJ,2000.

r

Notary

Mycamtnimhm esphes: lO l3 I /0 I

I

I

gffg er asR» ~~~~ 5iiss@I

IN SS2.704 71I v~=o ')E 1,002,200.4e

d N SS2.834ME 1004.122.71

a

I

I

OoCSW-SM

48 hf

ll~

f .~l .tI

Q

2I

C~SEA

4E

g III I

I it

1

/s 0o ~

N .~~~AE 1XNEEWLgg 0 (

'e $0 ACIIE IINIT

E L004ASLNrr /

/g

EXHIBIT A

OAKIEOOD FIELD UNIT 5-32FORCE POOLING

VGOB-99-0720W729-Dt

CDNEDL Inc. Wel I Nates and NUsber gffIT SS2Casffany

gttats.angl 4 ""E~Ih'sstfofn'ractNo. E I evat lm

~ - 4fa 'W//of/osCcunty ~ 0 Istr t ct garden Sca I e 1 1 4fm Date

This plot ie o new plot IL an updated plat ar a final 'plat

(Affix Seal)Licensed professional Engineer WLtcensed Land Surveya"

ROOR 5117RRI%1

CONSDL, SeC.Urtlt 4a

Troct ' ——

Yuhon Pocatrordss Coal Co, ot al -Tr. 102-FseIsland Croon Coal ~~-Sskw CraheSs Coal LeasedJenaN Srr ~~Cent Cory. -Atmera~ Coat Leased~~ razes''meas Co. CINIILaaNI1MAcres 2A250%

Yrdurn.-- -- -- ~Co,ctaI-Coal,ORSOas

we4 cnsstrcaid~~ -satacr I ~4eal LeasedJertclk=. Oaaf Cesy.-lanes L~Coaltoessd

Oe. -CRlleaeatS.km-Surarcs~Aores 11$$7S%

Itadrard Qeeaha Hsaa, et al -Coal CSand OesIsRrndCreeSCyal ~~ Cert SAW TaorPsnaas Cird ~-Ciataaatre':.~n C ' ORk Oas Losses1AOacras

S.R.Itesn- SudacePerrf Itoon - Suraacs

Aiyas SSrtdctl Hcas et.al- CoaL OR 4 Oesharad CraoaCool ~- '

goal LeasedJNus5 s— - ——coal Clsry.Pennon hL Atroro Srdarao~.rs~ ce.-CQl Leased55.'la Acres SL1375%

Ooorge Card%I - SurfaceItcnntr IQsn-SurtcosCards, Mind 415coseo Horn - SurtcceIRSRwn PRSRPs -SurtsssFel Hurt- Surlasa

'IyiaSRcair7 Hsss, ot al -25% Coal, OR 4 OasVIIIRRrtc~ .~of TnnrayedaRen -75% Coal, CS 4 Osehhdd Creek Coal Cornyen7-2$ %~'~ Coal leasedJoweN Sn r r Coal Coty, -Ahura CrahaSe Coal LseesdPsnnas Inc. - Ahoeo Orhays Ceel, LancedSurtiananyrnducasn Co. -25% CO@Leased0.75Acres OART5%

February 25 2000

Page 1

Wat%gg ION 511%Of%2DeAR 0~%1%%41

Uefef t~DfsOWehs ef geeteef h

Peteete ef 1eg%jNktA ~2AAtes gf Igk QO 17~ R,tNSIL

7iee0%, %%sam

(I) ~'~-.—afY~~~.P.CL Osa ~SINeL

WARMS

IL IR.A~~

Algg1$ % %11'%DIT%

(1}'

efT ~~~

P.O. Sts flWNtlSaL W 3lhgg

ILSb ~ A7DgfNL Af ea» ADIegg%$4 efA7$ hoee

toof 44ROeddt 8~~OOfeMN

~NO —. =IW~Nrhtsn «f esNtWe ln

1st.~1A SsO ISSIO 2Aez48888%

1.%Wtes

LWoofl ostwlt dlWmw

2.28808% aero% aoeo00%

a0021% ILOSR1% alÃN02%

IWts OeeefesSeeo ISNseAss, Ol)L SOS

,>CNI «me

Is@no lese WWCweNnfVeotslOOlktsnQsOeet L~.SR oteoI

(1) ~RSOsntQsdkeNses

alb@N e)sw4NS dlMmw

a.ames aeoN8% «ISSN0%

aot810% ate)f18% assam

alice eeteslloe dIM~

o.oeeo «see

1'f,1M'soee

L oeewnsRL 2, See 78Hen&st, VA eeeNI

Aeele R Lsnohf118Ieynns Sesoos Dr.

OA 88)oe

8Wnetn C. OeeNneR O. SeneefReseottn VA eeeoo

O.ooeo woes1ISO d I.oe asw

aaoee Nnw1ISS et l.oemw

aoeee slwIlee d I.%md

O.oe810% atof18% aioN0%

0.042I0% aIOf 18% O.ION0%

aocn0% aoorlo% aosototb'

HennnOef OssMneRL 2, SW SeHen&a', VA 2eeoo

Peen I et2 2I1$2000

a00» ~~l ef1.00~ amer aanOttt ft0001gtt

Q Jela P.. OIWaftL g;gut~tONe, VA Sl&l

gtssI 'W. gssfgssP. Ct gee ttge

, tfA SgfWI

fwgfgg iaaf1tWk ef 1W~

aameS efgftggtt 0.00010tt

(a) gggtsssL, ffsshfssP. gt ~gg

Iel ftgrfgL ffss&sP. %4sw~

VA QSN1

fgngtry N. fgssgtesP. O,gfsr%N

VA 28011

(4 ~DsWas% gwhWD5ssfessP. O. gee gg8~ange, VA 08011

Irf Csrele L ifggsn1201 tWgt gsfy finedfgstt VA 'gggt

O.fgl10 tarestnt ef t.ggesess

0.0010 asmtitle ef 1.Mmw

a0010 ~Vf~ ef14I~

afgrfgttt Dieggt% aaaesa

aaftgt» 1 amma atgfgggtt

aeftgftt mam% atgfgfWt

VIRGINIA.: In the Clerk's OSce of the Circuit Court of Buchanan County. The foregoing instrument

this day presented in the 'd ', together 'th th~rtificate of acknowle4pnesregrtlPxed,