•

•

MINUTE ITEM 11 This 081r,,radar Item No. -wa8 ~roved as Minute Item No. bY the Stats !:Ffis Commission by av~ -­to a · at Its -"•"'""tiil.""""-­meetf ng.

A 7

CAL:.EN.DAR .I-TEM'

/

. . ·10/07/88 : .1.7

s 1 W 204.0f ~- PRC :7258 J. ·Ludlow

APPL~(;ANli:

RECREATlONAL rIER PERMIT

Mur-ray M. Smith, et al 31lb Goid Canal Driua Rancho Cordoua, Califohnia 95670·

AREA, TY,PE LflND ANO LOCATION: A r;arcel of' Sl:Jbmar,_ged land' in Lake Tahoe I El' Dorado County,

LAND l~~E: Construction and maintenance of a ~ecreational mu[ti-use pier and continued use and m~intena~ce ·of' two ~bor~ng-bu~ys.

TE~M~ ~F PROPOSED PERMt~~ Initial period: Ten years .beginning o~·tober 7,

198.8 • ·-CON~t'IDERATION: Re11t-fr~e pursµal'!t to Section. 6503. S·~f the

P.R.C.

AP~LICANT STATUS: Ap·plicant is. owner o'f upland.

PREREQU+SITE CONDITIONS, °FEES AND .EXPENSES: Filing· fee and pr~cessing· costs haue .been receiuep·.

·STATUTORY ANO OTHER. REFERENCES:

I

A. ;p. R', c. : Diu. 6-, Parts. •l and .2 :. D;lu: -~la.

B. Cal. ~dm. Code:· Title 2, D:i:u. 3;. Title: ~4, Div. 6.

~1-

(ADDED 10/0f /88 pgs. 108-108.iO)

.,.

. ,,

-tB a, CALENDAR PAOE 3 3 3 . : MINuTE PAGE·---------

0

. " "'/

CAl..:ENDAR ITEM NO. _t .z ·~,~ONT'~).

AB 884: 02/13/89.

OTHER PERTINENT ;INFORMATION: 1. As to the mooring buoys, pursuant to the

commission's delegation of author.i'ty .and the S~ate CEQA Guidelines (14'Cal. Adm. Code 15061), a* a categorically ~xempt project. The .project is exempt un.der: Clas,s l, Exis.ting facilities, 2 Ced. Adm. code ·29,05(a) ~1.2'->: · · · Authority: P.R.C. 21084, 14 Cal. Adm. Code 1~300, ~nd· 2 Cal. Ad~~ Code 2905.

2. Aj to the new pier, pursuanb~o thi ,Commissl:pn Is delegation,.,gf authori~y and; the Stati CEQA Guideline~ (14 Cal~ ~dm. ·code 150611, fhe staff ha~ dete~mined.that thi-s actiui ty :is exe~pt fr.om the requiremijnts. qf the CEQA-as a ~ategorical~~ exempt project. The project is exempt under· Class 3 I New Construc·tion of ·small ~tructure~ 2 ~al. Adm. Co~e J905(c)(l)~

Authority: P.R.C. 21084, 14 Cal. Adm. Code 15300, and 2 Cal. Adm. C~de 2905.

3. In order to determine other potential trust uses in, the ar~ea of th·e proposed proj ec:t, the staff ;contacted representatives of the following agencies: -·TRP.A, Department of fish and Game, County of El Dorado, and· the Tahoe'conserua~cy. None· of these agencies exprei~~d a coricerri that the proposed project would have a. ~ignificant negative effect orr trust USSS' in the area. The agencies did not identify any truit needs ~hich w~re not being m~t by existing facili~ties in the area, and a · field inspecticN by staff ~onfirmed that trust neBds w&re being m~t in·~ satisfactory .marine~. Identified :trust .uses in this ;area would include· swimming,. boating, walking alon~ the bea~h, ~nd u~ews of the 1ake.·

-2-

_ CAt!=~D~R pAG!::

MINUl-.!PAOE

•

•. ' '

• 08.1

.-...3_034

•

•

•••

,, CALENDAR ITEM NO.~ 17. (CONT''D),

~. Staff has detetmined that the proposed project is not locatsd ~h ~~ araa ~dentified as ·prime fish habitat, fish spawnin,g area, 1or a habitat' •restoration area, ident'ifi-~.d by the Tah?~ Regional Planning AgencY. and the 'Department of Fish and Game.

5.. This ·actiui ty i'nuolues lal')ds identified as • possessing significant environmental values pursuant to P.R~C. 63~0, et seq. Bas~d upon ttte staff's consultatior. with the persons fiomiriat~ng iuc~ l~nas and through the CEQA review:·process, it·is;.the staff's· opinion that tho project •. ~i p~6posed, ·is consisterit·with'jts use ~l~ssiticafion.

6. All permits covari~g structures in. Lake Tahoe will' include a condition sul;;sequent that if any strtJcttn .. ~ ·authorized is found ~o be i~ -nonconformance· with the Tahoe ·Regional ~lanning Agency~ s shorezone ordinance and· if any alterations, repitlrs, or removal required pursuant to cSaid ordinance are not' accomplished within the designate~ time period, then the ·permit . , , I

,willi be. automat~cally termi~ai:e~, e'ffectiue· i upon notice·b~ the State, and tHe site · shall be cleared pursuant to th'e terms l · thereof. · · · ' .

APPROVALS OBTAINED: Tahoe Regional Planrjing Agenc!f. United State~ Army Corps of Engineers.

FURTHER APPROVALS REQUIRED: County of ·El ~or~d~~

E~HIBITS: A. .Land Descriptior1. B. Location Map. ·c. El Dorado County Requirements. D. TflPA Permit.

IT IS RECOMMENDED 1HAT THE COMMISSION:

1. AS TO THE MOORING BUOYS, FIND THAT THE·ACTIV+TY IS .EXEMPT .

~3-

CALENI?~~ PAGE

l

' ' '

·CALENDA'R ITEM NO.. 1 7 (CONT'D)

FROM THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE CEQA PURSUANT TO 14 CAL. ADM. CODE 1506t AS A CATEGORICALLY EXEMPT ~ROJECT, CLASS 1, EXISTING :FACILITIES', 2 CAL. ADM."· coot --?905(a) (·2).

2. AS TO THE NEW PIER, FfND THAT THE ACTIVITY IS EXEMPT FROM~ THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE CEQA PURSUANT.TO l~ CA~. ~DM. . CODE 15061 AS A CATEGORICALLY EXEMPT PROJECT, CLASS 3, NEW CONSTRUCTION OF SMALL STRUCTURE, 2 CAL. ADM. CODE 2905(c)(l).

3. AUTHORIZE IS~'JANCE TO MURRAY M. SMITH I CAROL J. CASTRO I

DONOYAN C DAVIS ANO JEANNE M. DAVIS, OF A TEN-YEAR RECREATIONAL PIER PERMIT 3EGINNING OCTOBER 7, 1~88, FOR THE CONSTRUCTION, ,USE AND .MAINTENtiNCE OF ONE MULTI-USE' PIER AND THE ~ONTINUED USE AND MAINTENANCE OF TWO EXISTING MOORING BUOYS ON THE LANQ DESCRI~EO ON EXHIBIT "A" ATtACHED AND BY REFERENCE MADEJA PART HERPOf.

-4-:-

C"t~~DAR PACE

\

'

•

•

, " .. .,....~-.,.' ~·- . ,... ..~ ..

EXHIBIT "A"

EXHIBIT 11B11

w 20403

I f-

-L ,A- .K 'E

H 0 ,E

T13N

-.

• COUNTY OF

El DORADO COMMUNITY D~!::."OPMENT DEPARTMENT

BUILOING .OIViSION

MA!H OFFJCI: 300 FAIR.LANE ~~cA~

soUnt LAKE TAHOE omce: 13a9 'JOHNsoN BLVD;.

~'6) 821"531S

P.O; BOX 14506 ' sOuTH LAKE TAHOE;CA.1?5702 - - (IU8} 573-3145

Se?tember 16, 1988

Ms. Judy Ludlow California St:ate r:a .. ~

Conll\ission 1807 13th Street Sacramentc, CA 95814

SUBJECT: Pier Permit . .Require.'llents - El ~rado county

Dear .fJis. Ludlow:

To obtain a building permit for pier 9onstruction from El Dorado County the following are ~equired.

Tahoe Re9ional Planning Agency-Approval

Department of Army· Approval {Regulatory Sec. ~03-181)

P~ot Plan

Construction Plans

Structural Calculations

If you have 5lny;1questie>ns, y~u may reach me at 916-573-3!45.

Si'ncerely,

EL.DORADO COUNTY 'BUILDING DIVISION

7.~/4"~~~ John s. Walker Building Inspector III

JSYT/df

.-- ... f

~, ..

195 U.S. Hlghw•y.!O Roun~ Hill. Zephyr CC41e. NV

',•. J (702) 98-.C5'7

A • r-i P,ROJECT TYPE Shorezone-Multiple-ma·a:·Reaidential Pier '1.tiH dt6-051-04, 32 & 33

PERMITTEE(S) . Donovan Davis ~--_Murr~y Smith . . -

COUNTY/LOCATION El· Dorado, 3201, 8193 am! 8197 Meeks Ba)' A\•enue I

. ,,,,---:----;:-____ ...... :.- : ~ '

Having made ~he. findings require&·by Agency ordinanc&a·~·:Ules, TRPA Governina Board approved the project. on· 7-27-SS, .~ubject to the -~~~d :.!:Onditicna o! llpProval. attached hereto (Attachment S) and the special cCltlditfon• en the ~ack of 'thiu j>ermit.

.. ,~·~.

This permit shall expire on 7-27-91 Without further no~s~ unl~aB the construction h'm commenc;ed prior to t~is date and diligently pursue:! ~ueafter. Diliqent.,pursuit is defined a:i completion of the project within ~he -apprt:lVad eo111:truction nch-®le. ,-he expiration date 0shall r.ot be extended unle0& the project i's ditermfned b~· TRPii to be the subject of legal action which delayed or rendered i~po9sib·le the diligent pursuit of the permit. .

NO CONSTRUcTION OR GRADING SHALL COMMENCE UNTIL THE P~~~TTEl!l OBTAINS A COUNTY/CITY BU!LOING PERMIT. THE COUNTY/CITY PERMIT· AND THE TRPA nltMtT "J1RE INDEPENDENT OF EACH OTHER AND HAY HAVE DIFFERENT EXPIRATION DATES AND R ''.· REG"*'WING EXT!HSIONS. NO CONSTRUC'J'ICN OR GRADING SHALL COMMENCE .UNTIL ALL ~. ~~UCTION CoNDITIONS .. Or

•

APPROVAL, AFE SATISFIED AS EVIDENCED BY 'l'RPA' S A~ ON THE "ill.CK OF THIS PERMIT:. TI<PA'S ACKNOWLEDGEMENT IS NECESSARY TO OBTAIN: A COUNTY BUILDING PERMIT. IN • ADDITION, NO CONSTRUCTION OR GRADING SHi\LL COMTh:mC?: frBiL ':IPA· ll!CBIVES A'COPYOF THIS PERMIT UPON WHICH·. THE PERMITTEE(S} HAS ACKNCY~!·UCZIPT· o~·· 'fHZ. ·PEP.MIT AND ACCEPTi\NCE OF THE 'CONTENTS OF. THE PERMIT"ANO, A '!'RPA ,PRE-GAADilqG INSPEC'l'ION' HAS BEEN CONDUCTED.

* t ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ * * --~ ~ * * * *. * •• * -~ ~ i * * * *"*. * ~ ~.. ) f •

PERMIT'l'EE 1 S ACC.EPTA'NCE: I ·have read the pemi t an~:· i:tr. . cont!! ~i~ns o'E &pproval and understand and acct:;pt them. I also understand thai i · \iii· res~pmible fer ecmplianco with all the conditlon,s cf the permit an~, am responsib1e for my· ~:gejita •· an,d et?Ployeee • compliance with the permit c~nditions. i: 'also un~e>:~tand thal: if the property is sold, ~ remain liable for tha permit conditions until' or unloss the· new owner acknowledges the ~ransfer of the permit an~ notifies T~n- in writing of -such

Signature of Permittee{s)

* * - * ~ * * * * * • * * * * * * * * * * ~ • * * PERMIT-CONTINUED ON BACK

GC:cs

EXHIBIT "D"

Excess Cover~g& Mitigation' Fee: A::iunt ------SeE=urity Postedi Aliloiint :t -------*'robe ~etermined.

#.

to ba in ~onf o~nco .. ... ,,~

TRPA Executive Director/D~signee ~ • ... ~ . : . . ; , .,..,, ..

,.

* * * • * * *' * * * ~~ * • * * * * * * * * • * • ~ • • -· a

-- ... ~ • ,, • - ~& ~· .. ·-~ : ~ ... ~ , -

sPEciAI. co?m11'10Ns· --···:::?'· <-r:1 •·· ... :· ·' ·:: ·· Pri'or to commencement must b~, satisfied.

-- ~ :~._,i•1t .. ·. :·~ _:H •1 • •· :··

' • ;.··~'-'.1i~ • • .,,,. ' .. of construction the ·followinq .. !~l:~al ~ont'lition11t ·o~ approval

' ~\1{~~1,..;:~· •w

'i

'"' .).} ;~ J•~tl•! •,. I . 't""'-t~·.::·~ ,.·~u; . ::·--..-:· ,,

The \JSe :Jf, wood preservat~ves on -wood in c:onuei:!! · ·:: ~; :v~ter ia r.1toliibited. Extx-em~ c&±c shall be ~taken to inwro that w#-'~•-! ·.§i~~s··~, -~o( i~bCiaucecl into Lake Tahoe. Spray pa4ltin9' and the u11e ot-:"u iin· (1'1'1') will bQ pro-hibi ted. · · .. ,::;-::·~·?.+: · .

• ~ t ~~h ~· ·-·~· .;...~.~ •. f"'.!•·.'!\1\i. ' •• • -

·~ 2.

.•

3.

Disturbance of t.he lake bed mater!ab shall ·be JcePtl.'.~·~:~ .minimwn. necesaary· for . project c;ons!:ruction. ·: .;.;.~i~';'~!>. ~- ':

" ;.-.~?·~. ~. ... ·.- i·~~r~,;~K;:; ,:;;~ .. ~; ~-. ~~~i{ · .. ~·.t~..:. 1:F;;-'.;:~­ses.t practic~q. control technology uhi!-11 be mploy,~ :~:·p~cv•!J~ aa'n:n~!f ~~Ha:1-a· ._

4.

to be :resuspended as a re~ult of pier con11tru__~~Q.P. }~~.;z~·0'1ipg trans~~ ~ adjacent lake waters. The applicant ahall in•tfAll a::tum!d!t.y acreen around the entire construction site (in t:.ie wate~) prio~ ~':~ffp?tion. Thia 1creen ~Y be removed upon project ct:nnpl~tion anly upon ~ ~~&faa~o;y in~ction by 'l'RPA to insure that all tluspended materials have sett1ef:: .:;

. ..-~-~, .. :- ~··

The discharge of petroletim producbl, cqn•tr•..ib~~' and litter i14Cln&ing sawdust), or e~then ~aterials to 'th! aurtaca,~~~ ~-!J~·~· Lale• T~o~ ~aa!n ia prohibited. All surplue construction vaeta mater! · '·eh&ll ba, removed from the project site al}d deposited only 1lt legal -points ot.di'apoifal.

. • .... r. • •: . ~

In.no cas~ shall the width of i;his .pcrtion of the pier with a catwa~.~. widtho

.:.~-'

pier ba . . . . ,.:;·~ 1.-q: feet, exceP,t that 'l'h.o catwlilii : • 1 'l not e.t<°'3e4 thrae feet in

SPECIAL CONDI'i'IC>liS COh"'l'lNUBit O?i NBltT PAGE

CALENDAR PAGE

6.

~· . . . ........ . ' . :.• "~-

SPECIAL cfONDI~lC'":lS (ccn~i~~~l . • - ... J~ {" j .,·.· .. "" ~ .

- "r .... :.~ ... 1.PH 016-051-04, 32 ,~ 3~ ·: ~:·f. ....

. .#!. ; .: •

Final construc~ion drawings ahali conform' to all the ipp~ic~l~ .de•ign atnndarda of Section 54.-4.B., TRPA·Code o~ Ordinances and all other apPlicable TRPA deai911 standards.

1. The, applicant shall 5\lbmit a nw pier mitigation ·fe~ of $3,150 for the, construction of 105 feet of ·new pie:.. ·. · ~:::~. '-).. ·i

.. ";-<.,( • •. J-'.;.:. "~~- •

a. 'Th~ app~icant shall submit a construc':tio~ ach~f ;~~~ .. to ca:Denc-.nt of construction. This schedule shall ·identify· dates -~a~-:-·aif!follo¥in91 ' "' - "' .. '........ "';IJ' . ~\ ~

9.

~·; .. ';.:,."·.·~.~:·: 'i·• .. ,, • ii·· When install&tion of tmnpC!rart eroaion contr~l iiti:iicture•· and tuzf,tcU'c:y

scl:eens wii-1. .'oc_cur. · - .~

b. llhen conatruction wil1 camnence.

When construction slas~ and d!}>~i• will'ba r~~ - ~ ':..'~· (.:-;1•. ' .. ~

=- ' ' ?;. • f '· .... ~ ,,· ~- .,·-.. ~ When installation of all permanent ero~ion·con~o~.•t;ruaturem will cc,,:ur.

:c.

d. . :~.. ..... . . ~ ...

e. When ccns~ction will be.completed. M .; "

The applicant shall submit plans and cost eatim11tei 'f~~ the inmta113t~~n of all required' water_ quality improvaments tBMPs)· p~~: to comeneament of construction. The security r~~ir~d under Standira Condition A.3 of Attachment s shall be 110 percent of this cost estimate.

10- "This_pier shall be wood tone o~ earth tone in ~olor.

11. Prlbr to commencement of contitructicn·, the applicant. shall obtain all required approvals from the u.:s. Ar.ny· Corps of E_ngin~~ra, the ·x;uiontan ~egiona,l ·water Quality coritroi Boai;d,, thf!I California Departm~nt of' Fish ~d ·Gamet i.md the Ga~if orn!a State Lands Com:iiissio~ for tllis nev ~ier=

12. No containers :of fuel, paint, or othAr hazardous materials may be ~tored on··the pier. -

13. Th!;! applicant shail mitigate excess lanCi ~overage c~ this property in a· ~er consistent with chapter .20 of tJta 'l'RPA· Coda· ·of Or4iriarices. -Thia condition fV'.l.Y be" satisfied by ~ubmitta! of-an excees.land;coverage Ji!tigation fee .•• followca

Cost o~ project x o.os '(TRPA Reduction Factor) ~: BicttH ;an'!_ Cm1ct~a~e percentage. ~

Excess' iland· cov~rage perg~~~ag!f equals the existing iancS co\rera,9e percentage minus one percent. ?~ease p~ovide ~written cost eetimate by, your contractor. In n,o caso shall the> mitigation fee b.e less than $100.

SPECI1.L CONDITIONS CON?'INuZo ON·N!XT PAG!

CA!.ENDAR PAGE

MJNUTEPAGE

•

~-• • •• -:-1."-~ ~eo;,,'t~i~L- . ·-~ IJ' J)" ••• • ;;& ....... •

..,..... ~ ... "" .,,. . .. ,, • . i :> .! • ·'\;, .. ~- : ..

~ • :.. v.:-:1;;~ !· .. ~. .. ·.• ,-~~;11tt"". ~t. \ 1i i .) ,~~ ,.t.1. • . :::; .•

-- .~:.:·:~ -;~:.·;-:?='.

~--· ( ' i.

SPECIAL CONDI'l'IoNS Ceoriuiitiicii:. . . • AP?I 016-051-04, 32 ~ ;;.' '· '(:.

-Also, if you cho9se, existing land coverage ~~·-be ~·i:i Iicu· of· paJmerit of an e~ces~ land cover<ige mitigation !~e. 'l'o e~!~•:.. th~• lan4 ·Coverage reduction amount,. divide the amount of the mi_tiqa~~~!~J:br $5 par ac;ruar~ .foot. Please :r:evise your· site. plan land coverage calcullticns .!f .you choose thill· option. · · · ·. '/ '"'11 •

"'" . . .. . •::. '•:J ~;. -· ,.

14. The applicant shall submit three- sata of final ~n~~d:i~n drawing• and site plans; to 'l'RPA. ··:-~.- :~; .

... • ·.-J •• 15. ~roperty owners of parcels APN 016-051-04, 32, and 3l.shall heve·accass ~ tha

pier facility. ~'

16.

17.

... Deed restriri~~ons satisfactory to the TR:?A iihal.l ~ ,~iled- with the County Recorder by the OWners limiting thG rights to J>i~r• ,aj)~t;h• thre• parcala listed in Condition 15, abova, to this single multipl~ use pier.

Prior to commencement of construction th~-a~lic~t·.,~~iJ. ~t a reviaad dta plan indicating al-i Water ~a~i~y- Imprc;>vcmen~e- CiiMia) i~ accor,danc-8' wit:h Standard>Condition A•l of At~et.iiiier}.t .s.~

• ..

CALEt-JDAR PAtjE

MINUTE PAGE

1 ff8, .10 3 0°4 3 .