when securitization complicates foreclosure

8/4/2019 When Securitization Complicates Foreclosure

1/31

KII

%#$)!7$801(+(\&+(,)!4,A=2(8&+$'!+#$!F''0$Y!

%#&+!X1$!+#$!b,A$,?)$1C'!h$3$)'$'!+,!g,1$82,'01$q

V(8+,1(&!V>!4,1-$1

K"@1-*)2*3)&(-&(#*

! F>!!F)+1,-08+(,)!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!OUU

! FF>!!S1(*()'!,3!+#$!W,1+*&*$!g,1$82,'01$!41('('!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!OUK

! ! X>!!h$1$*02&+(,)!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!OUK! ! c>!!7$801(+(\&+(,)!&)-!+#$!6('$!,3!+#$!7#&-,?!c&)E()*!7$8+,1!>>>>!OUM! ! 4>!!g,1$82,'01$!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!OU]! ! h>!!.$*&2!F''0$'!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!OHU

! FFF>!!.(+(*&+(,)!7,20+(,)'!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!OHH! ! X>!!"#$!7+&)-()*!lh$3$)'$l!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!OHH! ! ! H>!!h('A(''&2Y!!%#$)!"#$1$!('!G,!h,80A$)+&+(,)!!

! ,3!X''(*)A$)+!,3!+#$!G,+$!&)-!W,1+*&*$!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!OHJ! ! ! K>!!7&)8+(,)'Y!!%#$)!+#$!W,1+*&*$!X''(*)A$)+!!! ! ! ! ('!W('1$=1$'$)+$-!+,!+#$!4,01+!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!OHN

! ! ! O>!!",0*#$1!7,20+(,)'Y!!%#$)!+#$!Q2&()+(33!('!G,+!!

! ! ! ! +#$!b,2-$1!()!h0$!4,01'$!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!OH]! ! ! ! &>!!7+&)-()*!%(22!F)8$)+(5(\$!.,&)!6$)$*,+(&+(,)!>>>>>>>>>>!OKU

! FV>!!.$*('2&+(5$!7,20+(,)'!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!OKH! ! X>!!.,&)!7$15(8$1'!4&)!6$)$*,+(&+$!.,&)'!;>>>!OKO! ! c>!!%#,!7#,02-!g&8(2(+&+$!.,&)!6$)$*,+(&+(,)q!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!OKJ

! ! ! H>!!Q1(5&+$!.,&)!W,-(3(8&+(,)!('!F-$&2('+(8!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!OKJ! ! ! K>!!7+&+$!.&?'!X1$!Q1$$A=+$-!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!OKT! ! ! !

! />h>B! %&'#()*+,)! &)-! .$$! P)(5$1'(+c>B! X1+! b('+,1!!F!?,02-!2(E$!+,!$D=1$''!A!


2/31

OUU PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A3A5A*S*6T3A*.U6KA*WYY*VWXXYZ

! ! ! O>!!g$-$1&2!.&?'!4&)!F)8$)+(5(\$!7$15(8$1'!!! ! ! ! +,!W,-(3>>>>>>>>>>>>>!OKN! ! ! ! ;>!!6$5(5$!+#$!b,A$!S?)$1'C!.,&)!4,1=,1&+(,)!>>>>>>>>>>>!OKN

! V>!!4,)820'(,)!>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>!OK]

;1/%+%(G*)2*($-*>"0?-(bL*+)11"0#*

3)&(0"7(/"1*"00"&'->-&(#*@-(:--&*%(%(/(%)*"&+*7)/-1bL*+)11"0#*\/07$"#%&'*>)0('"'-#*%&*@/1?*"&+*#-7/0%(%E%&'bL*+)11"0#*5/#$*()*2%1-8*#1):*()*0-7)0+*"2(-0*=/+'>-&(bL*+)11"0#*

K$-*=/0%#+%7(%)&"1*%&(-'0%(G*)2*($-*U&%(-+*6("(-#*F%#(0%7(*3)/0(b\0%7-1-##A*

b./+'-*3$0%#()[$-0*JA*M)G?)8*

U&%(-+*6("(-#*F%#(0%7(*3)/0(*9)0($-0&*F%#(0%7(*)2*T$%)H

OA**O&(0)+/7(%)&*

7()8$! +#$! #,0'()*! A&1E$+! =$&E$-! ()! KUUTBK! XA$1(8&)! #,A$! 5&20$'!#&5$! 3&22$)! +?$)+O! ! X'! &! 1$'02+! ,3! -$82()()*!#,A$! $`0(+J! ! 7(D!A(22(,)! XA$1(8&)'! ?(+#! ,0+'+&)-()*! '0;=1(A$!2,&)'M!&1$!&+!

! H>! F)! 1$! g,1$82,'01$!4&'$'B!G,>! HYUN85KK]KB!$+!&2>B!KUUN!%.!OKOKJOUB!&+!fO!)>O!9G>h>!S#(,!S8+>!OHB!KUUN:!r#$1$()&3+$1!c,!

KA* ;FO3^**6("(->-&(* )2* 6$-%1"* 3A* M"%08* 3$"%0>"&8* ;-+-0"1* F-[)#%(* O/0"&7-*3)0[)0"(%)&* )&* 6(0-&'($-&%&'* ($-* C7)&)>G^* * ;)0-71)#/0-* \0-4-&(%)&* "&+* 9-%'$@)0$))+*\0-#-04"(%)&^**M-2)0-*($-*3)>>%((--*)&*M"&?%&'8*R)/#%&'*"&+*U0@"&*J22"%0#n*."&/"0G*pP8*WXXr %&! 7PcQ6FWR! 46RhF"! 46F7F7Y RVR6d"bFGj! dSP GRRh!"S! nGS%!NKNB!NKI!9Q1&8+(8()*!.&?!F)'+(+0+$B!KUU]:!r#$1$()&3+$1!c&(1!"$'+(A,)7>!#,0'()*!;,,A!,3!+#$!3(1'+!#&23!,3!+#$!KUUU'!$)-$-!&;10=+2!

! O>! h&5(-! W>! X;1,A,?(+\B! !$-&*%&* F)/@(8*f-11* `;"&&%-* D"-8`! bPggFGj"SG! QS7"B7$=+>! HIB! KUU]B! #++=Yee???>#033()*+,)=,'+>8,Ae-&5(-LAL&;1,A,?(+\e?#$)L()L-,0;+L#+A2! 92&'+! 5('(+$-! S8+,;$1! HIB! KUUI:! 9l%#$)! =1(8$'! -1,=! ()! &!)$(*#;,1#,,-B!+#$!>!>!r3s,1!+#$!3(1'+!+(A$!'()8$!+#$! j1$&+!h$=1$''(,)B!XA$1(8&)!#,A$! 5&20$'!)&+(,)&22!

JA* O+ >

! M>! X!'0;=1(A$!2,&)!('!*$)$1&22!!5-2)0>*;)0-71)#/0-8*\0-+"()0G*D)0('"'-*"&+*\"G+"G*,-&+%&'* %&*J>-0%7"N#* 3%(%-#* M-2)0-* ($-* RA* 3)>>A*)&* T4-0#%'$(* "&+*c)4-0&>-&(B HHU+#!


3/31

!RC9*6C3U5OKOqJKOT9*3TD\,O3JKC6*KRC*O66UC! OUH!

1('E!,3!-$3&02+()*>T!!X'!#,A$,?)$1'!*,!()+,!-$3&02+B!2$)-$1'!10'#!()+,!8,01+!+,!3,1$82,'$>N!!X'!A,1$!#,A$'!1$A&()!5&8&)+!()!)$(*#;,1#,,-'B!+#$!#,0'()*!5&20$!,3!$)+(1$!)$(*#;,1#,,-'!-$81$&'$'!301+#$1!()!&!5(8(,0'!8 ]!!"#$'$!3(*01$'!'0**$'+! +#&+! +#$! A,1+*&*$! 3,1$82,'01$!81('('!('!),+!&! '$23L8,)+&()$-!=1,;2$A>I

Q&1+!F! ,3! +#('!G,+$! -('80''$'! +#$!,1(*()'!,3! +#$!A,1+*&*$! 3,1$82,'01$!81('('>!! 7=$8(3(8&22! ! Q&1+! FF! &--1$''$'!-$3&02+()*! A,1+*&*,1'C! '+&)-()*! -$3$)'$! +,! 3,1$82,'01$! =1,8$$-()*'!

()'+(*&+$-! ;! ! F+! &1*0$'! +#&+! +#('!-$3$)'$! ('! ),+! ,)2

4,)*>!J!9KUUN:B!9+$'+(A,)#,0'$>*,5e-,80A$)+'eKUUNUOKKHNMMMOLJUI]K>=-3>!!",! ,33'$+! +#$! 1('EB!'0;=1(A$!2,&)'!*$)$1&22!

! T>! 4RG"R6! gS 6! 6R7QSG7Fc.R! .RGhFGjB! XGd! 6RX.! 7S.P"FSG! WP7"! 7"SQ!

gS6R4.S7P6R7! H! 97$=+>! KOB! KUU]:B! #++=Yee???>1$'=,)'(;2$2$)-()*>,1*eA,1+*&*$L2$)-()*e=,2(8!

! I>! X2+#,0*#B! 0)-,0;+$-2 R6G7"! a %RF! .FB 4RG"R6! gS6! 6R7QSG7Fc.R!.RGhFGjB PGgXF6!.RGhFGjY "bR!RggR4"!Sg!6X4R!XGh!R"bGF4F"d!SG!"bR!Q6F4R!Sg!7PcQ6FWR!WS6"jXjR7! JZM! 9W&1$'=,)'(;2$2$)-()*>,1*eA,1+*&*$L2$)-()*e1$'$&18#L&)&2=-3! 9),+()*! +#&+! '$5$1&2! 1$'$&18#!&)&2


4/31

OUK PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A3A5A*S*6T3A*.U6KA*WYY*VWXXYZ

A,1+*&*$'!+#&+!&1$!&+!1('E!,3!-$3&02+>!!F+!&1*0$'!+#&+!3$-$1&2!2$*('2&+(,)!A&!

"#('! G,+$! 8,)820-$'! +#&+! &! 8&'$L;!!b,?$5$1B!2(+(*&+()*!82&(A'!()-(5(-0&22

),+!&!=1,&8+(5$!,1!=$1A&)$)+!',20+(,)>!c!!c

+#$! #,2-$1'! ,3! +#$! '$801(+(\$-! ),+$'B! '$15(8$1'! ?(22! ;$! ()8$)+(5(\$-! +,!1$)$*,+(&+$! 2,&)'! ;$8&0'$! +#$1$! ?(22! ;$! ),! #(--$)! 8,'+'>! ! g()&22!

OOA**T0%'%*)2*($-*D)0('"'-*;)0-71)#/0-*30%#%#*

JA**F-0-'/1"(%)&*

"#$!8011$)+!A,1+*&*$!3,1$82,'01$!81('('!?&'!=1$8(=(+&+$-!;

=,2(8($'! ,3! 3()&)8(&2! 1$*02&+,1'! &)-! +#$! *,5$1)A$)+'! ?#,! 3&8(2(+&+$-! +#$!82(A&+$! ,3! -$1$*02&+(,)! ,)! %&22! 7+1$$+! ;$*())()*! ()! +#$! HI]U'>HU

HUA* 6--* 6,;$1+! %&-$B!;%&"&7%"1* 5-'%>-* 3$"&'-oB!MO! G.6!MB! HK!9KUU]:!9lF+! ('! ),!$D&**$1&+(,)! +,! '&l:>!!%&-$!0'$'!+#$!+$1A!l)$,2(;$1&2('Al!+,!2&;$2!+#$!$8,),A(8!A,-$2!()!=2&8$!31,A!HINM!+,!KUU]!+#&+!$)8,01&*$-!*,5$1)A$)+'!+,!2(;$1&2(\$B!=1(5&+(\$B!&)-!-$1$*02&+$!&'!=&1+!,3!3()&)8(&2!*2,;&2(\&+(,)>!!O+A!&+!M>!!c0+!Q$+$1!j,?&)!),+$'!+#&+!()!&--(+(,)!+,!+#$!)$,2(;$1&2('A!+#$,1!!Q$+$1! j,?&)B! 30%#%#* %&* ($-*R-"0(1"&+ * * 3)-h/-&7-#* )2* ($-*9-:* !"11* 6(0--(* 6G#(->B!MM!G.6!MB!HIZKU!9KUUI:>!!j,?&)C'!+#$'('B!#,?$5$1B!1$@$8+'!;,+#!+#$!)$,2(;$1&2!&)-!&88(-$)+'!


5/31

!RC9*6C3U5OKOqJKOT9*3TD\,O3JKC6*KRC*O66UC! OUO!

h$1$*02&+(,)HH! $)&;2$-! 3()&)8(&2! ()'+(+0+(,)'! +,! 8&11HT

+#$,1($'!&)-!&1*0$'!+#&+!+#&+!+#$!)$?!'+108+01$!,3!%&22!7+1$$+!?&'!),+!#&=#&\&1-!&+!&22B!;0+!?&'! &)!,18#$'+1&+$-!8,A=2$D! ',1*e1$=,1+'e',2-~,0+>=-3>!!"#$!+?$25$!'+$='!%$(''A&)!2('+'!&1$Y!!9H:!+#$!1$=$&2! ,3! j2&''L7+$&*&22B! 9K:! ,33L+#$L;,,E'! &88,0)+()*! 3,1! ;&)E'B! 9O:! =1$5$)+()*! +#$!4,AA,-(+($'! g0+01$! "1&-()*! 4,AA(''(,)! 31,A! 1$*02&+()*! -$1(5&+(5$'B! 9J:! 3()&)8(&2!-$1(5&+(5$!-$1$*02&+(,)!0)-$1!+#$!4,AA,-(+($'!g0+01$'!W,-$1)(\&+(,)!X8+B!9M:!1$A,5&2!,3!7R4! 8&=(+&2!2(A(+'! ,)!()5$'+A$)+!;&)E'B! 9T:!?$&E!8&=(+&2! 1$'$15$! 1$`0(1$A$)+'! 3,1! ;&)E'!0)-$1!c&'$2!FFB!9N:!3&(201$!+,!=,2(8$!=1$-&+,1

81$&+$-!&!+,,L;(*L+,L3&(2!A$)+&2(+l:>! ! F)! KUUJB! +#$!7$801(+($'!&)-!RD8#&)*$!4,AA(''(,)!97R4:!1$2&D$-!+#$!)$+L8&=(+&2!102$>!!j,?&)B!#/[0"*),+$!HUB!&+!HM>!! "#$!1$'02+!,3!+#('!?&'!+#&+!()5$'+A$)+!;&)E'!?$1$!&22,?$-!+,!-$8(-$!+#$(1!,?)!2$5$1&*$>!!O+A

! HO>! CA'>B!A,1+*&*$L;&8E$-!'$801(+($'>!!6--*h&5(-!j,2-'+$()!a!n$5()!j>!b&22B!\0%4"(-*6-7()0*,)"*9)(*;"&&%-*)0*;0-++%-8*K0%''-0-+*30%#%# B!W44.X"4bd!%X7bFGj"SG!cP6RXP9S8+>! HKB! KUU]:! #++=Yee???>A882&+8#8,AeKMHe'+,1#+A2! 92&'+! 5('(+$-! S8+>! HIB!KUUI:! 9-$3()()*! A,1+*&*$L;&8E$-! '$801(+($'! &'! lA,1+*&*$'! +#&+! &1$! ',2-! +,! &! 8,A=&)

81('('!()!&!2$&*0$!,3!(+'!,?)l:>!HMA* 6--*j,?&)B!#/[0"*),+$!HUB!&+!T!92&;$2()*!+#$!3()&)8(&2!'+108+01$'B!&8+,1'B!=1&8+(8$'B!

&)-!-!

HTA* 6--* %+A!&+!NZ]!9(-$)+(3


6/31

OUJ PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A3A5A*S*6T3A*.U6KA*WYY*VWXXYZ

F)!+#$!2&+$!HIIU'B!-$1$*02&+(,)B!?#(8#!#&-!=&''(5$2H]! !"#$!1$'02+()*! l2(*#+L+,08#!1$*02&+(,)lHI!?&'!+#$!802A()&+(,)!,3!+#$!PnC'!=2&)!+,!201$!3()&)8(&2!;0'()$''!&?&

6$=1$'$)+&+(5$'!1$=$&2$-!+#$!j2&''L7+$&*&22!X8+BKH!8&'+()*!(+!&'(-$!&'!&!1$2(8!,3!-$=1$''(,)L$1&!1$*02&+(,)!+#&+!?&'!),!2,)*$1!)$$-$->KK!!"#$!$33$8+!?&'!l-$!3&8+,!3()&)8(&2!2(;$1&2(\&+(,)>l KO!!"#$!'+108+01$!,3!+#$!)$?!%&22!7+1$$+!?&'!),+!,)2NO]!;(22(,)!,)!3$-$1&2!$2$8+(,)!8&A=&(*)!8,)+1(;0+(,)'!;$+?$$)!HII]!&)-!KUU]:>!! X)!&--(+(,)&2! _O>O! ;(22(,)!?&'!'=$)+!,)! ,33(8(&22!!O+A

! H]>! j,?&)B!#/[0"*),+$!HUB!&+!HT>!

! HI>! "#$!g()&)8(&2!7$15(8$'!X0+#,1(+!

KHA* 6--* j1&AAL.$&8#Lc2(2$! .>! G,>! HUTZHUKB! HHO! 7+&+>! HOO]!9HIII:!91$=$&2()*!=&1+!,3!+#$!j2&''L7+$&*&22!X8+!,3!HIOOB!J]!7+&+>!HTK!9HIOO:!98,-(3($-!()!'8&++$1$-! '$8+(,)'! ,3! HK! P>7>4>:B! ?#(8#! '$=&1&+$-! 8,AA$18(&2! ;&)E()*! &8+(5(+($'! 31,A!()5$'+A$)+!;&)E()*!&8+(5(+($':>!! g,1!4,)*1$''(,)&2!()+$)+!;$#()-!=&''()*!+#$!j2&''L7+$&*&22!X8+B!'$$!7> 6RQ> GS>!NOZNNB!&+!H]!9HIOO:>!!4,)*1$''!?&'!8,)8$1)$-!?(+#!+#$!'0;+2$!#&\&1-'!+#&+!,8801!?#$)!&!8,AA$18(&2!;&)E!$)+$1'!+#$!()5$'+A$)+!;&)E()*!;0'()$''!&)-!8$&'$'!+,!A$1$2!!O+A

KKA* 6--*%&-$B!#/[0"* ),+$!HUB!&+!HK!9-$'81(;()*!+#,'$!?#,!5($?$-!+#$!j2&''L7+$&*&22!X8+! &'!&)! l,)$1,0'l!1$*02&+(,)!&)-!),+()*! +#&+! =,2(+(8&2! A,A$)+0A!*1$?!()! +#$!HIIU'! +,!1$=$&2!(+:>!

KOA* 6--* %+A! 9&1*0()*! +#&+! *0++()*! +#$!j2&''L7+$&*&22! X8+! &22,?$-!;&)E'! +,!$)*&*$! ()!8,AA$18(&2! ;&)E()*B! 0)-$1?1(+()*B! &)-! ()5$'+A$)+! ;&)E()*:>! ! 6--* '-&-0"11G! 7+$=#$)!.&;&+,)B!3)&'0-##*\"##-#*!%+-i5"&'%&'*M%11*C"#%&'*M"&?*,":#B!G>d> "FWR7B!G,5>!MB!HIIIB!&+!XH!9-$'81(;()*!;1($32!

KJA* 6--*j,?&)B!#/[0"*),+$!HUB!&+!NZ]!9(-$)+(3


7/31

!RC9*6C3U5OKOqJKOT9*3TD\,O3JKC6*KRC*O66UC! OUM!

MA**6-7/0%(%E"(%)&*"&+*($-*5%#-*)2*($-*6$"+):*M"&?%&'*6-7()0*

"#$!'$801(+(\&+(,)KT!,3!A,1+*&*$'!&)-!+#$!1('$!,3!+#$!'#&-,?!;&)E()*!'$8+,1! ()! =&1+(802&1! #&5$! #&-! (A=,1+&)+! 1,2$'! ()! +#$!A,1+*&*$!3,1$82,'01$!81('('>KN! ! %#$)! +#$! g$-$1&2! 6$'$15$! '2&'#$-! ()+$1$'+! 1&+$'! ()! KUUKB!;,11,?()*! A,)$

;0'()$''! A,-$2>K]! ! W,1+*&*$! ,1(*()&+,1'! '+,==$-! #,2-()*! ,)+,! A,1+*&*$'!&)-! '+&1+$-! '$22()*! +#$A! +,! +#(1-! =&1+($'B! '08#! &'! ()5$'+A$)+! ;&)E'! ,1!*,5$1)A$)+!'=,)',1$-!$)+(+($'!9j7R':B!&)-!0'$-!+#$!8&=(+&2!+,!3()&)8$!)$?!A,1+*&*$'>KI! ! "#$! A,1+*&*$! ,1(*()&+,1'! ?$1$! ()8$)+(5(\$-! +,! '$22! +#$!A,1+*&*$'!;$8&0'$!+#$ OH

;&)E()*!'!

KMA* 6--*j,?&)B!#/[0"*),+$!HUB!&+!KU!9'+&+()*!+#&+!,5$1!+#$!8,01'$!,3!XA$1(8&)!#('+,1!

KTA* 6--*n&12!c$(+$2B!K$-*6/@[0%>-*F-@"71- B!WSG"b.d! 6RVFR%B!W&A,)+#2,1*eU]UMHK;$(+$2>=#=! 92&'+! 5('(+$-! S8+>! HIB! KUUI:! 9-$3()()*!

'$801(+(\&+(,)! &'!+#$! =1,8$''!,3!+1&)'3,1A()*!3,1A$12

K]A* 6--* X10)! j0=+&B!;%&"&7%"1* D-1(+):&* PXPB! "bR! FGhdQRGhRG"B! S8+>! HOB! KUU]B!"4"%1"@1-* "(! #++=Yee???>&2+$1)$+>,1*e'+,1! HIB! KUUI:! 9$D=2&()()*!+#&+!2,?!()+$1$'+!1&+$'!A&-$!(+!$&'($1!3,1!#,A$;03$-$1&21$'$15$>*,5e3,A8e30)-'1&+$>#+A! 92&'+! 5('(+$-! S8+,;$1! HIB! KUUI:! 9,)! 3(2$!?(+#!%&'#()*+,)!&)-!.$$!/,01)&2!,3!4(5(2!6(*#+'!&)-!7,8(&2!/0'+(8$:>!

! KI>! O+>

OUA* 6--* c$(+$2B! #/[0"! ),+$! KT! 9l"#$'$! ()'+10A$)+'! rWc7's! &1$! +,-&-*R)>-*Ch/%(G*D"0?-(B!MH!7>4>! .>! 6$5>! JNOB! MOH! 9KUUU:! 9&1*0()*! +#&+! '$801(+(\&+(,)! &)-! +#$! ()81$&'$-! )0A;$1! ,3!A,1+*&*$!;1,E$1'!#$2=$-!+#$!'0;=1(A$!#,A$!$`0(+


8/31

OUT PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A3A5A*S*6T3A*.U6KA*WYY*VWXXYZ

F)! ,1-$1! +,! A&E$! +#$! A,1+*&*$'! &==$&1! 2$''! 1('EOK! ! X3+$1! +#$

;&8E$-! '$801(+OO! ! "#$! ;&)E'! +#$)! ',2-! +#$!Wc7'!()+,!&!'$8,)-&1

=1(5&+$! 2&;$2! Wc7'B! + ON

F)!,1-$1!+,!,;+&()!A,1$!8&'#!&)-!-('+1(;0+$!+#$!1('E!,3!-$3&02+!+,!A,1$!=&1+($'B! ;&)E'! 81$&+$-! $D,+(8! '$801(+(\$-! -$;+! ()'+10A$)+'! '08#! &'!8,22&+$1&2(\$-! -$;+! ,;2(*&+(,)'! 94hS':>O]! ! g()&)8($1'! 81$&+$-! 4hS'! ; OI!!"#$!-(33$1$)+!

OKA* 6--* j0=+&B!#/[0"* ),+$!K]!9$D=2&()()*!+#&+!&''01&)8$!lA$&)'!,)$!,3!+#$!&*$)8($'!

8$1+(3($'!+#&+!+#$!2,&)'!&1$!81$-(+?,1+#!!F)!KUUJB!+,!&--1$''!2,?!1&+$'!,3!#,A$!,?)$1'#(=!&A,)*! 2,?L()8,A$! =,=02&+(,)'! &)-! 8,AA0)(+($'! ,3! 8,2,1B! 4,)*1$''! ;$*&)! $)8,01&*()*!j7R'!+,!&''01$!$5$)!'0;=1(A$!A,1+*&*$'>!!O+A

OOA* O+A

! OJ>! c$(+$2B!#/[0"!),+$!KT>!

OMA* 6--* 4bX6.R7! /> jSR"pB .X%!XGh! R4SGSWF47!HK]!9HI]J:!9-('80''()*!+#$!=1,8$''!,3!81$-(+!$)#&)8$A$)+! ;!>!>!8&)!;$! 1$8,*)(\$-!&'!1$2$5&)+!+,!+#$!-0+

O]A* 6--!c$(+$2B!#/[0"!),+$!KT!9-$3()()*!4hS'!&'!()5$'+A$)+!+10'+'!;&8E$-!;


9/31

!RC9*6C3U5OKOqJKOT9*3TD\,O3JKC6*KRC*O66UC! OUN!

+1&)8#$'!?$1$!+#$)! 1&+$-!;!

JHA* O+A**g,1!&!-('80''(,)!,3!+#$!l1&8$!+,!+#$!;,++,Al!&)-!+#$!1,2$!+#$!1&+()*'!&*$)8($'!=2&!

JKA* 6--*c$(+$2B!#/[0"!),+$!KT!9$D=2&()()*!+#&+!+#$!2,?$'+!90)1&+$-:!+1&)8#$!('!+#$!3(1'+!+,!&;',1;!2,''$'B!&)-! &--(+(,)&2!2,''$'! &1$!&==2($-! +,!+#$! )$D+! +1&)8#$B! &)-!',! ,)B! 0=!+#$!2&--$1! ,3! +1&)8#$'>! "#('! +#$,1$+(8&22:>!

JOA* 6--* %+A* 9-$'81(;()*!#,?!8,AA$18(&2!=&=$1!(''0$-!;!

JJA* 6--* j,?&)B!#/[0"* ),+$!HUB!&+!HO!9$D=2&()()*!+#&+!7FV'B!#$-*$!30)-'!&)-!=1(5&+$!$`0(+l:>!


10/31

OU] PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A3A5A*S*6T3A*.U6KA*WYY*VWXXYZ

?$1$! ',25$)+B! -$;+'! 1,22$-! ,5$1! &+! A&+01(+JN

c0+! +#('! A,-$2! 1$2($-! ,)! +#$! &''0A=+(,)! +#&+! #,A$! 5&20$'! ?,02-! E$$=!1('()*>J]!!"#$JI

g1,A! +#$! ;$*())()*B! +#$'$! '$801(+(\$-! -$;+! ()'+10A$)+'! ?$1$! #(*#2

()'+10A$)+'>MU!!c$8&0'$!+#$1$!?&'!),!=1(A&1MH! ! "#$! 1&+()*'! -(-! ),+! 8,11$'=,)-! +,!+#$(1!1('E()$''>MK!!7$8,)-B!+#$1$!?&'!),!A&1E$+!=1(8$!3,1!+#$!()'+10A$)+'!;$8&0'$!+#$! ',018$! ,3! +#$! 0)-$12MO!!c$8&0'$!+#$!0)-$12

JNA* 6--*c$(+$2B!#/[0"!),+$!KT!9lrF3s!=018#&'$1'!,3!+#('!=&=$1!9+#$!A,)$

()(+(&22!>!>!rA&-$s!),!'$)'$l:>!

JIA* 6--* c&(1!"$'+(A,)!

MHA* 6--* %+A!9l"#$!4hS'!?$1$!+

+#$!A,1+*&*$!#,2-$1'!8,02-!),!2,)*$1!;$!&!3&8+,1!()!+#$!'$801(+($'C!=1(8$':>!MJA* 6--* c$(+$2B!#/[0"!),+$!KT!9lr"s#$!=1,2(3$1&+(,)!,3!+#$'$!)$?!3,1A'!,3!'$801(+(\$-!

81$-(+!#&-!),+!$)*()$$1$-!1('E!,0+!,3!+#$!'l:>!

MMA* 6--* j0=+&B!#/[0"* ),+$! K]! 9),+()*! +#&+! ?(-$'=1$&-! A,1+*&*$! -$3&02+'! '=1$&-! +,!'+108+01$-!-$;+!()'+10A$)+'!2(E$!4hS'!&)-!Wc7'B!8&0'()*!+#$!'


11/31

!RC9*6C3U5OKOqJKOT9*3TD\,O3JKC6*KRC*O66UC! OUI!

()5$'+()*!()!A,1+*&*$L;&8E$-!3()&)8(&2!=1,-08+'>MT!!c&)E'!#,&1-$-!8&'#!()!8&'$!+#$TH V&8&)+! #,0'$'! ;$8,A$! 502)$1&;2$! +,!

81(A$! &)-! '`0&++$1'>TK! ! X'! &! 1$'02+B! A&)!l:>!

MNA* 6--* c$(+$2B!#/[0"! ),+$! KT! 9$D=2&()()*! +#&+! ?#$)! ;&)E'! ?(+#! 7FV'! 1$&2(\$-! +#$!

M]A* O+A

MIA* 6--* j,?&)B*#/[0"* ),+$!HUB!&+!H]!9l%#$)!+#$!%&22!7+1$$+!;&)E'!+1($-!+,!,33L2,&-!+#$(1!4hS'B!+#$


12/31

OHU PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A3A5A*S*6T3A*.U6KA*WYY*VWXXYZ

FA**,-'"1*O##/-#*

"#$!A,1+*&*$!3,1$82,'01$!81('('!('! &+!&! =1$8&1(,0'!=,'(+(,)!()!1$2&+(,)!+,!+#$!-$;+!81('('!,3!KUU]Y!!F+!('!;,+#!&!8&0'$TM!&)-!&)!$33$8+>TT!!F)!=&1+B!+#$!()-0'+1NU! ! X)-! =1(5&+$!

()5$'+A$)+!;&)E'!+#&+!&1$!#,2-()*!,)+,!A,1+*&*$L;&8E$-!'$801(+($'!()!+10'+B!

TMA* 6--*%&-$B!#/[0"* ),+$!HUB!&+!HH!9-$'81(;()*!+#$!#,0'()*!;0;;2$!&'!l,)$!=&1+!,3!&!A08#! ?(-$1! 10)L0=! ,3! -$;+l:[! j,2-'+$()B! #/[0"* ),+$! HO! 9-$'81(;()*! =1$-&+,1!

TTA* 32A* j,?&)B!#/[0"* ),+$!HUB!&+!H]!9&1*0()*!+#&+!+#$!%&22!7+1$$+!;&)E'!-$2(;$1&+$2l:>!

T]A* 6--*/,'#0&!b,22&)-B!!"11*6(0--(*R/#(1-0#*M/%1(*"*tPXX*K0%11%)&*R)/#-*)2*3"0+#*"&+*6(/7?* f)/* !%($* ($-* ;"11)/(B! X!b$1G$+B! S8+>! KKB! KUU]! 9,)! 3(2$! ?(+#! %&'#()*+,)!&)-! .$$!/,01)&2!,3!8(5(!6(*#+'!&)-!7,8(&2!/0'+(8$:!9$D=2&()()*!+#&+!+#$!#(*#!-$A&)-!81$&+$-!;

;$3,1$!+#$!-$;+!81('('!,3!KUU]B!'$$!W&)'3($2-B!#/[0"!),+$!OH>!TIA* 6--* X;1,A,?(+\B!#/[0"! ),+$! O!9-('80''()*! #,?! +#$!'$801(+(\&+(,)! ,3!1('E!

NUA* 6--* b,22&)-B! #/[0"! ),+$! T]! 9-('80''()*! +#$! l,1(*()&+$L+,L,?)l! A,-$2! ,3!A,1+*&*$':[!j,2-'+$()B*#/[0"*),+$!HO!9-('80''()*!+#$!'$8,)-&1


13/31

!RC9*6C3U5OKOqJKOT9*3TD\,O3JKC6*KRC*O66UC! OHH!

?#(8#! &1$! ),?! ?,1+#2$''BNH! &1$! 3,18$-! +,! -$8(-$! ?#$+#$1! +#$!

"#0'B! &! =&1&-,D(8&2! '(+0&+(,)! #&'! $A$1*$-! ()! ?#(8#! +10'+$$'B! +#$!&''(*)$$'!,3!A,1+*&*$'B!&1$!82&(A()*!+#$!1(*#+!+,!3,1$82,'$!,)!A,1+*&*,1'!()!-$3&02+BNK!;0+!&+!+#$!'&A$!+(A$B!&1$!-$) NO!!"#('!=1,;2$A!8&)!;$!',25$-!?(+#!&!+?,L=1,)*!&==1,&8#!()5,25()*!2(+(*&+(,)!&)-!3$-$1&2!2$*('2&+(,)>!

OOOA**,%(%'"(%)&*6)1/(%)*

S)8$! +#$! +10'+$$! ()'+(*&+$'! 3,1$82,'01$! =1,8$$-()*'B! +#$! ,;5(,0'!=1,;2$A!+#&+!3&8$'!-$3&02+()*!A,1+*&*,1'!('!-$3$)-()*!+#$(1!),)=& NJ

"#$!'$8,)-!A&@,1!#01-2$!3,1!A,1+*&*,1'!9(3!+#$

S)$! -$3$)'$! +#&+! -$3$)-&)+LA,1+*&*,1'! 8&)! ()5,E$! ()! 3,1$82,'01$!

=1,8$$-()*'B! ,1! +#$! 8,01+! 8&)! ()5,E$! '0&! '=,)+$BNT

! ('! '+&)-()*>! ! ",! #&5$!

NHA* 6--*R1(8!7+$()B!5-1%-4%&'*!"11*6(0--(*)2*F-@(*F)-#*9)(*K0""(-*O&()*($-*5%'$(*()*6()[* ;)0-71)#/0-#B 4RG"R6! gS6! 6R7QSG7Fc.R! .RGhFGjB! 7$=+>! KJB! KUU]B!#++=Yee???>1$'=,)'(;2$2$)-()*>,1*eA,1+*&*$L2$)-()*e=,2(8!

NOA* M/(* # --* R**$1+8* %&20"! ),+$! HJM!9'+&+()*! +#&+! 2,&)! '$15(8$1'!&1*0&;2!

! NJ>! S;5(,0'2!!g,1!&!-('80''(,)!,3!+#$!#,A$,?)$1C'!-$3$)'$'! +,! &8+0&2! 31&0-B! '$$! n&+#$1()$! Q,1+$1B!D%#@-$"4%)0* "&+* D%#("?-* %&* M"&?0/[(7G*D)0('"'-*31"%>#B!]N!"Ri> .> 6RV>!HKHB!HOOZJU!9KUU]:>!

! NM>! F!?(22!0'$!+#$!+$1A!=2&()+(33L2$)-$1!*$)$1(8&22!!F+!-,$'!),+!1$3$1!+,!+#$!=2&()+(33'!'+&+0'!&'!+#$!A,1+*&*$!,1(*()&+,1>!!

NTA* 6--* 4$)+>! 7+&+$'! 7$>! a! 7?>! X1$&'! b$&2+#! a! %$23&1$! g0)-! 5>! W$18ELW$-8,!W&)&*$-!4&1$B!.>.>4>B!JOO!g>O-!H]HB!HI]!9K-!4(1>!KUUM:!9'+&+()*!+#&+!'+&)-()*!8&)!;$!1&('$-!


14/31

OHK PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A3A5A*S*6T3A*.U6KA*WYY*VWXXYZ

'+&)-()*! ;$3,1$! &! 3$-$1&2! 8,01+B! &! =2&()+(33! A0'+! '&+('3!&1+>!FFF!9$'+&;2('#()*!+#$!@0-(8(&2!;1&)8#!,3!+#$!P>!7>!*,5$1)A$)+:>!

N]A* 6--*%+A!v!KB!82>!H!9l"#$!@0-(8(&2!Q,?$1!'#&22!$D+$)-!+,!&22!4&'$'B!()!.&?!&)-!R`0(+O-!MHOB!MKOZKJ!9T+#!4(1>!KUUH:::>!

NIA* 6--* ,)0-&B!MUM!g>O-!&+!TUN!9lF3!Q2&()+(33'!8&)),+!$'+&;2('#!8,)'+(+0+(,)&2!'+&)-()*B!+#$(1!82&(A'!A0'+!;$!-('A(''$-!3,1!2&8E!,3!'0;@$8+!A&++$1!@01('-(8+(,)>l!98(+()*!4$)+>!7+&+$'!7$>!a!7?>!X1$&'!b$&2+#!a!%$23&1$!g0)-!5>!W$18ELW$-8,!W&)&*$-!4&1$B!JOO!g>O-!H]HB!HI]!9K-!4(1>!KUUM:::A

]UA* 6--*W(-3(1'+!c&)E!5>!h&5$)=,1+B!G,>!OYUNL4VLJUMB!KUUN!%.!JKJTKNHB!&+!fK!97>h>!S#(,!G,5>!KIB!KUUN:!9l",!'#,?!'+&)-()*!>!>!>!()!&!3,1$82,'01$!&8+(,)B!+#$!=2&()+(33!A0'+!'#,?!+#&+!(+!('!+#$!#,2-$1!,3!+#$!),+$!&)-!+#$!A,1+*&*$!&+!+#$!+(A$!+#$!8,A=2&()+!?&'!3(2$->l:>!!"#$!3,1$82,'01$! =2&()+(33! A0'+! &2',! '#,?! +#&+! #$! ,1! '#$! ('! #&1A$-B! l0'0&22!!"#$!6$'+&+$A$)+!&''0A$'!+#&+!&!+1&)'3$1!,3!+#$!A,1+*&*$!&2',!+1&)'3$1'!+#$!,;2(*&+(,)!&;'$)+!()+$)+!+,!+#$!8,)+1&1!! O+A*8A+>!8>!!7+1(8+2!!O+A!!b,?$5$1B!+#$!'+&)-()*!-$3$)'$!=0+'!+#$!,)0'!,)!+#$!+10'+$$!+,!'#,?!()+$)+!+,!+1&)'3$1!+#$!$)+(1$!,;2(*&+(,)o+#$!),+$!&)-!+#$!A,1+*&*$o;!!!"#$1$!

('! '0;'+&)+(&2! 8,)+1&1!! 6--8*-A'AB F)!1$!b011(8&)$!6$',1+!4,>B!OU!c>6>!KM]B! KTH! 9c&)E1>! 7>h>! g2&>! HI]O:!93()-()*! +#&+! +#$!=&1+


15/31

!RC9*6C3U5OKOqJKOT9*3TD\,O3JKC6*KRC*O66UC! OHO!

F)! 3&22! KUUNB! 3$-$1&2! 8,01+'! ()! S#(,! ;$*&)! +,! $)3,18$! +#$! '+&)-()*!1$`0(1$A$)+! -1&8,)(8&22]O! ! F)! -,()*! ',B! +#$!8,01+'!8&22$-!()+,!`0$'+(,)!+#$!8,AA,)!=1&8+(8$!?#$1$!2$)-()*!()'+(+0+(,)'!10'#! +,! 3(2$! 3,1$82,'01$! &8+(,)'B! ,;+&()! -$3&02+! @0-*A$)+'B! &)-! 8,22$8+!()+$1$'+!,)!+#$!@0-*A$)+'!+#&+!*,!0)=&(-> ]J

F)!O&* 0-* ;)0-71)#/0-* 3"#-#B]M! =2&()+(33L2$)-$1! h$0+'8#$! c&)E! 9hc:!',0*#+!+,!3,1$82,'$!,)!)()$+$$)!'$801(+(\$-!1$'(-$)+(&2!A,1+*&*$'!+#&+!(+!#$2-!()! +10'+>]T! ! "#$! 8,01+! ,1-$1$-! hc! +,! '0;A(+! &)! &33(-&5(+! '#,?()*! (+! ?&'!$(+#$1!+#$!,1(*()&2!A,1+*&*$!#,2-$1!,1!+#$!&''(*)$$B!+10'+$$B!,1!'088$'',1L()L()+$1$'+!+,!+#$!A,1+*&*$!#,2-$1!()!$&8#!3,1$82,'01$!=1,8$$-()*>!]N!!!F)!+$)!,3!+#$!8&'$'B!+#$!),+$!&)-! A,1+*&*$!&++&8#$-!+,!$&8#!8,A=2&()+!(-$)+(3($-!+#$!

2$)-$1!&'!+#$!,1(*()&2!2$)-()*!()'+(+0+(,)B!),+!hc>]]!!!F)!3,01!,3!+#$!,+#$1!

*$)$1&2B!&!A,1+*&*$!('!0)$)3,18$&;2$!(3!(+!('!#$2-!;l:>!

]OA* 6--*c,!HYUN85KK]KB!$+!&2>B!KUUN!%.!OKOKJOUBB!&+!fHZO!9G>h>!S#(,!S8+>!OHB! KUUN:! 9-('A(''()*! 3,01+$$)! 3,1$82,'01$! =1,8$$-()*'! 3,1! 2&8E! ,3! '+&)-()*:[! F)! 1$!g,1$82,'01$!X8+(,)'B!G,>!HYUN85HUUNB!$+!&2>B!KUUN!%.!JUOJMMJB!&+!fH!9G>h>!S#(,!G,5>!HJB!KUUN:! r#$1$()&3+$1! SCW&22$!

]JA* 6--*c,O!9-('80''()*!+#&+!+#$!2$)-$1'C!-$8('(,)'!+,!3(2$! 3,1! 3,1$82,'01$!&'! 3&'+! &'!=,''(;2$!&1$!-1(5$)! ;

+#$A! +1&)'&8+(,)!8,'+'!?#$)!+#$(1!=018#&'()*!+#$! '$801(+(\$-!A,1+*&*$'! ?(+#,0+!=&l:[! #--* "1#)*4&-?&2&-$1! W$A,B!#/[0"! ),+$! ]TB! &+! K! 9'+&+()*! +#&+! ),)$! ,3! +#$! +$)! 8&'$'! ?#$1$! +#$!A,1+*&*$!&''(*)A$)+'!,88011$-!&3+$1!+#$!8,A=2&()+!?&'!3(2$-!'#,?$-!+#$!)&A$-!Q2&()+(33!+,!;$! +#$! ,?)$1! ,3! +#$! 1(*#+'B! +(+2$! &)-! ()+$1$'+! &'! ,3! +#$! -&+$! ,3! +#$! 8,A=2&()+:>! ! "#$!&''(*)A$)+'!A$1$2


16/31

OHJ PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A3A5A*S*6T3A*.U6KA*WYY*VWXXYZ

8&'$'B!hc!3&(2$-!+,!3(2$!&)7>! h('+1(8+! 4,01+! 3,1! +#$! G,1+#$1)!

h('+1(8+!,3!S#(,!-('A(''$-!+#$'$!3,01+$$)!8,A=2&()+'!?(+#,0+!=1$@0-(8$!,)!+#$!*1,0)-'!+#&+!hc!-(-!),+!#&5$!'+&)-()*!+,!'0$>IU

"#('!+?,L=1,)*!-,80A$)+&+(,)!1$`0(1$A$)+! ?&'!301+#$1!82&1(3($-! +?,!?$$E'!2&+$1!;lIK! !F)!,+#$1! ?,1-'B! +#$! =2&()+(33! ()! &! 3,1$82,'01$! =1,8$$-()*! ('! 1$'=,)'(;2$! 3,1!'#,?()*!9H:!+#&+!+#$!A,1+*&*$$!&)-!+#$!=2&()+(33!()+$)-$-!+,!&''(*)!;,+#!+#$!A,1+*&*$!&)-!+#$!),+$!+,!+#$!=2&()+(33!&)-!9K:!-(-!()!3&8+!-,!',!;$3,1$!+#$!=2&()+(33!;1,0*#+!&)!&8+(,)!+,!3,1$82,'$>!

PA**F%#>%##"1^**!$-&*K$-0-*%#*9)*F)7/>-&("(%)&*)2*J##%'&>-&(*)2*($-*9)(-*

"&+*D)0('"'-**

"#$!#,2-()*!,3!O&*0-*;)0-71)#/0-*3"#-#* ('!)&11,?>IO!!/0-*$!c,]IA* 6--*4&-?&2&-$1!W$A,B!#/[0"*),+$!]TB!&+!K!9lF)!+#$!,+#$1!3,01!8&'$'B!),!A,1+*&*$!&''(*)A$)+'!?$1$!=1$'$)+$-!;!

IKA* O+A! ! /0-*$!SCW&22$!>!>!>l! !O+A**M/(*#--*c&)E!,3! G$?!d,1E! 5>!7+0&1+B! G,>!UT4XUU]IMOB! KUUN!%.!IOTNUTB!&+!fKZO!9S#(,!X==>!I!h('+>!W&18#!OUB!KUUN:!93()-()*!+#&+!+#$!=2&()+(33L2$)-$1!#&-!'+&)-()*!+,!;1()*!&!3,1$82,'01$!&8+(,)!&*&()'+!+#$!-$3$)-&)+!$5$)!+#,0*#!+#$!&''(*)A$)+!,3!+#$!),+$!-(-! ),+!+&E$!$33$8+!0)+(2!3(5$!A,)+#'! &3+$1!+#$! -&+$! ,3!+#$! 8,A=2&()+!;$8&0'$! +#$!&''(*),1!?,02-!#&5$!;$$)!=1$820-$-!31,A!;1()*()*!'0(+:>!

IOA* 6--!4&-?&2&-$1!W$A,B!#/[0"!),+$!]TB!&+!H!9lX2+#,0*#!+#$!8&'$'!&==$&1!+,!#&5$!


17/31

!RC9*6C3U5OKOqJKOT9*3TD\,O3JKC6*KRC*O66UC! OHM!

,)2 IM!!g01+#$1A,1$B!+#$!A,1+*&*,1'!8,02-!),+!;$!$D=$8+$-!+,!E),?!+,!?#,A!+#$IN! ! G,+&;2!

IJA* 6--* c,[1"%&(>l!!O+>!!9$A=#&'('!&--$-:>!

! IM>! /0-*$! c,! ! "#('! ('! &! 1$&2! =1,;2$A! 31,A! +#$!A,1+*&*,1C'!=$1'=$8+(5$!$5$)!()!'(+0&+(,)'!?#$1$!+#$!A,1+*&*,1!('!),+!()!-$3&02+>!!g,1!&!3&8+!=&++$1)! (220'+1&+()*! #,?! $&'(2X>!5>! j1$$)B!]UT!G>R>K-!TUJB!TUM!9S#(,!4+>!X==>!KUUJ:>!

INA* 6--* 4&-?&2&-$1!W$A,B!#/[0"* ),+$!]TB!&+! K!9'+&+()*!+#&+!+#$!+$)!8&'$'! ?#$1$!+#$!A,1+*&*$!&''(*)A$)+'!,88011$-!&3+$1!+#$!8,A=2&()+!?&'!3(2$-!-(-!),+!'#,?!+#$!=2&()+(33!+,!;$!+#$!,?)$1!,3!+#$!1(*#+'B!+(+2$!&)-!()+$1$'+!0)-$1!+#$!A,1+*&*$!&+!(''0$:[! #-- "1#)*c,=1,A('$$! &'! +#$! ,1(*()&2! 2$)-()*! ()'+(+0+(,)! 1&+#$1! +#&)! +#$!=2&()+(33! &)-! +#&+! +#$1$! ('! ),!1$3$1$)8$!+,!+#$!=2&()+(33!()!+#$!1$8,1-$-!8#&()!,3!+(+2$:>!!F)-$$-B!'2,==


18/31

OHT PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A3A5A*S*6T3A*.U6KA*WYY*VWXXYZ

()-(8&+$'!+#&+!#$!?&'!1$&8+()*!+,!+#$!&0-&8(+

3(3+$$)!-&HUU! ! /0-*$! 6,'$! '=,E$! -(1$8+2HUK! ! "#$1$3,1$B! =2&()+(33'! 8&)! $&'(2 HUO

-('A(''$-B! +#$! A,1+*&*$! &''(*)A$)+'! ?$1$! $D$80+$-! &)-! 1$8,1-$-! ;$3,1$! +#$! 8,A=2&()+'!?$1$!3(2$->l:>!

IIA* 6--* c,O! 9lQ2&()+(33C'B! m/0-*$B! l:>! ! X'+,0)-()*2Y WS6"jXjR7!v!M>J!8A+>!&!9HIIN:!9lrRsD=$1($)8$!'0**$'+'!+#&+B!?(+#!3&(1!31$`0$)8


19/31

!RC9*6C3U5OKOqJKOT9*3TD\,O3JKC6*KRC*O66UC! OHN!

WA**6"&7(%)^**!$-&*($-*D)0('"'-*J##%'&>-&(*%#*D%#0-[0-#-&(-+*()*($-*3)/0(*

F)!301+#$1&)8$!,3!+#$!S#(,!3$-$1&2!8,01+'C!&8+(,)'!+,!-$3$)-!A,1+*&*,1'!()!3,1$82,'01$!=1,8$$-()*'B!&+!2$&'+!,)$!;&)E10=+8

+#$!=2&()+(33L2$)-$1!?&'!),+!+#$!#,2-$1!,3!+#$!),+$B!;0+!1$=1$'$)+$-!(+'$23!&'!+#$! #,2-$1! +,! +#$! 8,01+>HUM! ! F)! O&* 0-* 9)#-?BHUT! ?(+#,0+! $5$)! &--1$''()*!?#$+#$1!(+!?&'!+#$!()+$)+!,3!+#$!A,1+*&*$$!&)-!+#$!=2&()+(33!+,!&''(*)!+#$!),+$! &)-! +#$! A,1+*&*$! +,! +#$! =2&()+(33B! +#$! 8,01+! 3()$-! =2&()+(33L2$)-$1!XA$1(`0$'+!0)-$1!(+'!602$!IUHH!'&)8+(,)!=,?$1'B!'+&+()*YHUN!!l"#$!&1*0A$)+!+#&+!+#$!&''(*)A$)+!,3!+#$!),+$!&)-!A,1+*&*$!?&'!&!A&++$1!,3!=0;2(8!1$8,1-!&)-!+#$1$3,1$!+#$!h$;+,1!E)$?!,1!'#,02-!#&5$!E),?)!,3!G,1?$'+C'!(-$)+(+

HUJA* 6--*gRh> 6> cXGn> Q>!IUHH98:!9$'+&;2('#()*!'&)8+(,)'!3,1!5(,2&+(,)'!,3!+#$!102$!+#&+!;!

HUMA* 6--*F)!1$!G,'$EB!O]T!c>6>!ONJB!ON]!9c&)E1>!h>!W&''>!KUU]:B!4"7"(-+B!JUT!c>6>!JOJ!

9h>!W&''>!KUUI:!9$D=2&()()*!+#&+!XA$1(`0$'+!?&'!+#$!2,&)!,1(*()&+,1B!;0+!),+!+#$!),+$!#,2-$1!&'!,3!+#$!-&+$!,3!+#$!-$;+,1C'!;&)E10=+8!!"#('!()3,1A&+(,)!?&'!),+!1$5$&2$-!+,!+#$!4,01+!0)+(2!7$=+$A;$1!KNB!KUUN!$5$)!+#,0*#!+#$!-$;+,1C'!=$+(+(,)!?&'!3(2$-!,)!S8+,;$1!KB!KUUK>!!O+A!&+!ONN>!

HUTA* 6--* %+A!&+!O]MZ]T!9(A=,'()*!'&)8+(,)'!,)!&!2,&)!,1(*()&+,1B!(+'!&++,1)$l:>!

HU]A* O+A!&+!O]K>!!/0-*$!6,'$)+#&2C'!1$&',)()*!('!2(3+$-!-(1$8+2M!8A+>!8!

9HIIN:>! ! "#$! 2$)-$1C'! &1*0A$)+! +#&+! +#$! A,1+*&*,1! #&-!),+(8$! ?&'! $)+(1$2l:>!!"#$! ;&)E10=+8!


20/31

OH] PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A3A5A*S*6T3A*.U6KA*WYY*VWXXYZ

#&-!A('1$=1$'$)+$-!(+'$23!+,!+#$!-$;+,1> HUI!!h$'=(+$!+#('!3&8+B!+#$!8,01+!*&5$!+#$!-$;+,1B!1&+#$1!+#&)!+#$!2$)-$1!&)-!(+'!'088$'',1L()L()+$1$'+B!+#$!;$)$3(+!,3!+#$!-,0;+>HHU

pA**K)/'$-0*6)1/(%)^**!$-&*($-*\1"%&(%22*%#*9)(*($-*R)1+-0*%&*F/-*3)/0#-*

6$`0(1()*! =2&()+(33'! +,! #&5$! '+&)-()*! A&++$1'! ;$8&0'$! +#$1$! ('! &! 1$&2!`0$'+(,)! &'! +,! ?#$+#$1! &''(*)$$'! ?$1$! ;,)&! 3(-$! =018#&'$1'! ,3! +#$!A,1+*&*$BHHH!()!&--(+(,)!+,!+#$!=1,;2$A'!+#&+!&1('$!?#$)!+#$!'&A$!A,1+*&*$!('!()!+?,!,1!+#1$$!-(33$1$)+!=,,2'>HHK!!"#$!()-0'+1

8&)!),!2,)*$1!8,5$1!0=!+#$!3&8+!+#&+!+#$!2&8E!,3!-,80A$)+&+(,)!#&'!;$8,A$!&!8,)'+&)+!;0'()$''!=1&8+(8$! ()!+#$! ?&E$! ,3!'$801(+(\$-!A,1+*&*$'>HHJ!!W&)

HUIA* 6--*O&*0-*9)#-?B!O]T!c>6>!&+!O]K!9),+()*!XA$1(`0$'+C'!&1*0A$)+!+#&+!=1,,3!,3!+#$!-$;+,1C'! E),?2$-*$!,3!+#$! +10$! (-$)+(+!!O+A!&+!ONNZ]U>!

HHUA* 6-- %+A!&+!O]K!9l"#('!4,01+!?(22!),+!8,0)+$)&)8$!81$-(+,1'!&)-!81$-(+,1'C!&++,1)$!>!>!>!!F+!('!+#$!70-+%()0N#*1$'=,)'(;(2(+!>!>!>l:>!

HHHA* 6--* c,;! F51! KKB! KUU]B! "4"%1"@1-* "( ! #++=Yee???>;2,,A;$1*>8,Ae!&=='e)$?'q=(-KUTNUUUHa1$3$10'a'(-&$@/p-`,-"4W! 92&'+! 5('(+$-! S8+>! HIB! KUUI:! 9lF)!+#$!10'#! +,!,1(*()&+$!A,1$!2,&)'! -01()*!+#$! P)(+$-!7+&+$'!A,1+*&*$!;,,AB! 31,A!KUUO! +,!KUUTB!+#&+!&''(*)A$)+!,3!,?)$1'#(=!?&')C+!&2?&!

HHKA* 6--*j1$+8#$)!W,1*$)',)B!;)0-71)#/0-#*R%(*"*6&"'*2)0*,-&+-0# B!G>d> "FWR7B!G,5>!HMB!KUUN!91$=,1+()*!+#$!82&(A!+#&+!()!'$5$1&2!()'+&)8$'!A,1+*&*$!$D=$1+'!#&5$!,;'$15$-!+#$!'&A$!2,&)!()!'$5$1&2!-(33$1$)+!A,1+*&*$!=,,2':>!

HHOA* 32A!c,!HYUN85KK]KB!$+!&2>B!KUUN!%.!OKOKJOUB!&+!fO!)>O!9G>h>!S#(,!S8+>!OHB!KUUN:!981(+(8(\()*!=2&()+(33L2$)-$1C'!&1*0A$)+!+#&+!/0-*$!c,A')>8,Ae(-eK]KNNJKUe!92&'+!5('(+$-!S8+>!HIB!KUUI:!9`0,+()*!,)$!&++,1)$!!.,'+L),+$!&33(-&5(+'!&1$!+#$!102$!()!+#$!()-0'+1!!O+A!!!


21/31

!RC9*6C3U5OKOqJKOT9*3TD\,O3JKC6*KRC*O66UC! OHI!

8,01+'B!$5$)!+#,'$!,0+'(-$!,3!S#(,B!#&5$!+&E$)!),+$!&)-!),!2,)*$1!&88$=+!+#$!l+&E$!A! ! X=1(2!4#&1)$HHI! ! "#('! 8,02-! $D=2&()! +#$! +10'+$$'C! ?(-$'=1$&-! 2&8E! ,3!-,80A$)+&+(,)>HKU! ! W,1$,5$1B! (+! 1$()3,18$'!+#$! )$$-! 3,1! 8,01+'! +,! $)3,18$!'+&)-()*! 1$`0(1$A$)+'! +,! -$3$&+! +#$! ,0+-&+$-! =1$'0A=+(,)! +#&+! +#$!&''(*)A$)+!,3!+#$!),+$!?&'!+1&)'3$11$-!?(+#!+#$!A,1+*&*$!&;'$)+!()+$)+!+,!

+#$!8,)+1&1!F)!8,)820'(,)B!8,01+'!)$$-!+,!+&E$!&!A,1$!&8+(5$!1,2$!()!=1,+$8+()*!+#$!

#,A$,?)$1! 31,A! ?(22302! ),)8,A=2(&)8$! ;!!"#('!A&d> "FWR7B!W&18#!HB!KUUIB!&+!cPH!9-('80''()*!@0-*$'!()!,+#$1!'+&+$'!?#,!&1$!1$`0(1()*!3,1A&2!=1,,3!,3!&''(*)A$)+:>!

! HHN>! X=1(2! 4#&1)$! ! g,1! A,1$!()3,1A&+(,)!&;,0+!X=1(2!4#&1)$!>!>!>l:>!

HKUA* M/(* # --* 4&-?&2&-$1! W$A,B!#/[0"! ),+$! ]TB!&+! J!9$5(-$)8()*!+#$!;$2($3!+#&+!+#$!+10'+$$'!?$1$!&8+()*!()!*,,-!3&(+#!&)-!A$1$2l!!O+A**g,1!&),+#$1!',018$!&++1(;0+()*!+#$!+10'+$$C'!2&8E!,3!=&=$1?,1E!+,!,5$1'(*#+!'$$!F51


22/31

OKU PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A3A5A*S*6T3A*.U6KA*WYY*VWXXYZ

8,01+'!+,!10;;$1!'+&A=!+#$(1!3,1$82,'01$!=1,8$$-()*'>HKH!!X),+#$1!',20+(,)!('!3,1!8,01+'!+,!*,!&!'+$=!301+#$1!&)-!-('A(''!8&'$'!?(+#!=1$@0-(8$!?#$)!+#$!8,01+!-$8(-$'!+#&+!=2&()+(33L2$)-$1'!?(22!)$5$1!;$!&;2$!+,!=1$'$)+!-,80A$)+'!'033(8($)+!+,!'#,?!&''(*)A$)+!,1!,?)$1'#(=!;$3,1$!+#$!-&+$!+#$!8,A=2&()+!?&'!3(2$-!;$8&0'$!+#$

X+! 3(1'+! *2&)8$B!'+&)-()*!('! ),+!&! =$1A&)$)+! ',20+(,)!;$8&0'$! (+! -,$'!),+!&--1$''!+#$!0)-$12 HKO!! "#$!'+&)-()*!-$3$)'$!-,$')C+!5,(-!+#$!A,1+*&*$>HKJ! ! G,1! ('! (+'! '088$''! 2(E$2

=1$@0-(8$>HKM! ! h$3$)-()*! &! 3,1$82,'01$! =1,8$$-()*! +&E$'! ;,+#! +(A$! &)-!A,)$!!R5$)!(3!&!#,A$,?)$1!8&)!&33,1-!&!-$3$)'$!&++,1)$!!g()&22

b,?$5$1B!,)$!=,'(+(5$!&'=$8+!,3!+#$!'+&)-()*!-$3$)'$!('!+#&+!;HKN! ! F3!

HKHA* 6--*W(-3(1'+!c&)E!5>!h&5$)=,1+B!G,>!OYUNL4VLJUMB!KUUN!%.!JKJTKNHB!&+!fH!97>h>!S#(,! G,5>! KIB! KUUN:! 9lc$8&0'$! '+&)-()*! ()5,25$'! +#$! 3$-$1&2! 8,01+C'! '0;@$8+! A&++$1!@01('-(8(,)B!(+!8&)!;$!1&('$-!'0&!'=,)+$>l:>!

HKKA * 32A*TND"11-GB!G,>!HYUN85HUUNB!$+!&2>B!KUUN!%.!JUOJMMJB!&+!fH!9G,5>!HJB!KUUN:!

9-('A(''()*!+#$! 3,1$82,'01$!&8+(,)'! ?(+#,0+! =1$@0-(8$! ;$8&0'$!+#$! 3,1$82,'01$! =2&()+(33! -(-!),+!=1,5(-$!-,80A$)+&+(,)!+#&+!(+!?&'!+#$!,?)$1!&)-!#,2-$1!,3!+#$!),+$!&)-!A,1+*&*$!&+!+#$!+(A$!+#$!3,1$82,'01$!&8+(,)!?&'!3(2$-:>!

HKOA* 6--*7+08E$! 70==>! K-! TMUB! TMJ! 97>h>! S#(,! KUUN:!9-('A(''()*!+#$!8,A=2&()+'!?(+#,0+!=1$@0-(8$:>!

HKTA* 6--8* -A'AB* O&* 0-* !%11%">#B! OIM! c>6>! &+! JI! 9-('A(''()*! =2&()+(33C'! '0(+! ?(+#,0+!=1$@0-(8$:>!

HKNA* 6--* 7+08E$


23/31

!RC9*6C3U5OKOqJKOT9*3TD\,O3JKC6*KRC*O66UC! OKH!

8,01+'! &81,''! +#$! 8,0)+1HKI

F)! '0AB! ?#$)! +#$! =2&()+(33L2$)-$1! ('! ),+! &8+0&22!!%#$)!+#$!=2&()+(33L2$)-$1!('!+#$!#,2-$1!()!-0$!8,01'$!;0+!

#&'! 3,1! 2,*('+(8&2! 1$&',)'! A('=2&8$-! ,1(*()&2!-,80A$)+'! '#,?()*! +#&+! +#$!$)+(1$!,;2(*&+(,)!?&'!&''(*)$-!+,!+#$!=2&()+(33!=1(,1!+,!3(2()*!+#$!8,A=2&()+B!+#$! '+&)-()*! -$3$)'$! ?,1E'B! ;0+! ,)2HOU! ! F+! ('! (A=,1+&)+! +#&+! 8,01+'! 1$8,*)(\$! ?#$)! +#$!

! HOH>! "#('! -('80''(,)! ,3! A,1+*&*,1'! ?#,! ?&)+! +,! 1$)$*,+(&+$! +#$! +$1A'! ,3! +#$(1!A,1+*&*$'!('!),+!2(A(+$-!+,!'0;=1(A$!;,11,?$1'>!!F+!#&'!;$8,A$!()81$&'()*2!! 6--!c&(1!"$'+(A,)


24/31

OKK PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A3A5A*S*6T3A*.U6KA*WYY*VWXXYZ

&-@0'+&;2$! 1&+$! 2,&)'! ?#(8#! &1$! '0;@$8+! +,! =&HOT!!Q1$5$)+()*!3,1$82,'01$!?(22!&2',!;$)$3(+!+#$!+10'+$$'!,3!'$801(+(\$-!-$;+!()'+10A$)+'>! !Wc7'!#$2-!; HON

! HOK>! g,1! $D&A=2$B!&! OL!! 6-- %+A!&+!NOU!9-$'81(;()*!&!+

HOOA* 6-- %+ !98#&1&8+$1(\()*!+#$!()81$&'$-!A,)+#2!>!>!8#&22$)*()*!$)5(1,)A$)+B!=&l:>!

HOMA* 6--* %+A! &+!NKI!9=1,=,'()*!+#&+! 2,&)! A,-(3(8&+(,)'!=1,5(-$!+#$! ;$'+!?&!

HOTA* 6--* %+A*&+!NOK!9),+()*!+#&+!A,-(3!>!>!>l:>!


25/31

!RC9*6C3U5OKOqJKOT9*3TD\,O3JKC6*KRC*O66UC! OKO!

JA**,)"&*6-04%7-0#*3"&*5-&-')(%"(-*,)"*@G*3)&(0"7(*5%'$(*

"#$!3(1'+! =1,;2$A!+#&+!&1('$'! ?#$)! &! 2,&)!('! 1$)$*,+(&+$-! ('! ?#$+#$1!2,&)!'$15(8$1'B!?#,!8,22$8+!=&HO]!!Wc7'!&1$!*,5$1)$-!;

&11&)*$A$)+'!E),?)!&'! =,,2()*!&)-! '$15(8()*! &*1$$A$)+'!9Q7X':!$)+$1$-!()+,! ;

;,)-#,2-$1C'!;$'+!()+$1$'+'>HJK!!c0+!),+#()*!()!&!+l:>!

HOIA* 6--* 6,;()! 7>! j,2-$)! a! 7&A$$1&! g&\(2(B! 5"%#%&'* ($-* 5))2 * J++0-##%&'* ($-*D)0('"'-*;)0-71)#/0-*30%#%#*K$0)/'$*3)11"@)0"(%)&*M-(:--&*3%(G*c)4-0&>-&(*"&+*"*,":*67$))1*31%&%7B!K!X.c> jSVC" .> 6RV!KIB!O]!9KUUI:!92('+()*!2,&)!'$22$1'B!-$=,'(+,1'B!+10'+$$'B!

()5$'+,1'B! '$15(8$1'B! ()'01$1'B! &)-! 1&+()*'! &*$)8($'! &'! +#$! =,+$)+(&2! =&1+($'! +,! +#$! Wc7!+1&)'&8+(,):>!

HJUA* 6--!c&(1!"$'+(A,)>A* )&* R)/#%&'* "&+* 3)>>/&%(G*T[[)0(/&%(GB! HHU+#! 4,)*>! HN! 9KUUN:! 9'+&+$A$)+! ,3! "&1&! "?,A$!

HJHA* 6--! XA$1(8&)! 7$801(+(\&+(,)! g,10AB! 6("(->-&(* )2* \0%&7%[1-#8* 5-7)>>-&+"(%)*"&+*c/%+-1%&-#*2)0*($-*D)+%2%7"(%)&*)2*6-7/0%(%E-+*6/@[0%>-*5-#%+-&(%"1*D)0('"'-*,)" B!J!9/0)$! KUUN:B! #++=Yee???>&A$1(8&)'$801(+(\&+(,)>8,Ae0=2,&-$-g(2$'eX7g{KU70;=1(A${KU!.,&){KUW,-(3(8&+(,){KUQ1()8(=2$'~UTUHUN>=-3! 9lj$)$1&22l:>! ! 6--* "1#)! R**$1+B! %&20" ),+$! HJMB! &+! KNI! 9-$3()()*! l+1&)8#$! ?&13&1$l! &'! +#$!-(5$1*$)8$!,3!;,)-#,2-$1'C!()+$1$'+':>!!g01+#$1A,1$B!',A$+(A$'!(+!?,02-!;$!(A=,''(;2$!3,1!;,)-#,2-$1'!+,!'#&1$!&!8,AA,)!l;$'+!()+$1$'+l!&+!&22>!


26/31

OKJ PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A3A5A*S*6T3A*.U6KA*WYY*VWXXYZ

'$15(8$1'!31,A!1$)$*,+(&+()*!2,&)'!?(+#!()-(5(-0&2!#,A$,?)$1'!()!'(+0&+(,)'!?#$1$!+#$!GQV!,3!A,-(3(8&+(,)!$D8$$-'!+#&+!,3!&22,?()*!&!2,&)!+,!*,!()+,!3,1$82,'01$>HJO

MA**!$)*6$)/1+*;"7%1%("(-*,)"&*5-&-')(%"(%)&o*

"#$!'$8,)-!=1,;2$A!+#&+!&1('$'!?#$)!&!2,&)!('!1$)$*,+(&+$-!('!-$8(-()*!?#,! '#,02-! 3&8(2(+&+$! 2,&)! 1$)$*,+(&+(,)Y! ! =1(5&+$! &8+,1'B! '+&+$! &8+,1'B! ,1!3$-$1&2!&8+,1'>!!cHJN

HJOA* 6--!R**$1+B!%&20" ),+$!HJMB!&+!K]N!9lQ7X'!,3+$)!*1&)+!+#$!'$15(8$1!&!8$1+&()!&A,0)+!,3!-('81$+(,)!()!A,-(3

HJMA* 6--*c&(1!"$'+(A,)


27/31

!RC9*6C3U5OKOqJKOT9*3TD\,O3JKC6*KRC*O66UC! OKM!

"#$! &-5&)+&*$'! ,3!c&(1C'!=2&)! &1$! &==&1$)+>! ! F+!8&)! ;$!(A=2$A$)+$-!(AA$-(&+$2HMU

c0+! (+'! -('&-5&)+&*$'! &1$! &2',! &==&1$)+>! ! "#$1$! ('! ),! +(A$! 31&A$!1$`0(1()*!'$15(8$1'!+,!A,-(3

(A=2$A$)+! +#$!=,2(8HMH! ! X--(+(,)&22 HMK!!c$8&0'$!5,20)+&1 HMO!! g01+#$1A,1$B!+#$1$!('!),!1$?&1-!9,1!=0)('#A$)+:! 3,1! '$15(8$1'! ?#,! A,-(3HMM! ! X1*0&;2()8$)+(5(\$!(+'$23>!! F)!'0AB!+#$!=2&)!('! ,5$12!

HJ]A* 6--* %+ >! 9lX! '+1$&A2()$-! &==1,&8#! 8&)!;$! 0)-$1+&E$)! A08#! A,1$! 1&=(-2l:>!

HMUA* 6--* %+ >!9lr"s#('!=,2(8


28/31

OKT PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A3A5A*S*6T3A*.U6KA*WYY*VWXXYZ

2,&)!'$15(8$1'! +,! &8+!()! +#$! 2,)*L+$1A! ;$'+!()+$1$'+'!,3! ;,)-#,2-$1'! 1&+#$1!+#&)!()!+#$(1!,?)!(AA$-(&+$!'$23L()+$1$'+> HMT

X),+#$1! -1&?;&8E! +,! ghF4C'! =2&)! ('! +#&+! (+! ('! )&11,?2

;,11,?$1'>HMN!!c,11,?$1'!?(+#!X2+LX!,1!),)+1&-(+(,)&2!=1(A$!A,1+*&*$'!A&HM]!!%#$)!&!#,A$,?)$1!,?$'!A,1$!,)!#$1!#,0'$!+#&)!(+!('!?,1+#B!+#$!=1,;2$A!3&8()*!2,&)! '$15(8$1'! ('!&! 2&8E! ,3!*0(-&)8$B! ),+! &! 2&8E! ,3!()8$)+(5$>! HMI!!F)!+#$'$!8&'$'B!?#$1$!+#$!=1,;2$A'!3&8()*!#,A$,?)$1'!&1$!A,1$!()-(5(-0&2(\$-B!(+!('!

+,,!A08#!+,!&'E!'$15(8$1'!+,!5,20)+&1(2HTH! ! b,?$5$1B! A&)!

HMNA* 6--!c&(1!"$'+(A,)


29/31

!RC9*6C3U5OKOqJKOT9*3TD\,O3JKC6*KRC*O66UC! OKN!

3$-$1&2!*,5$1)A$)+C'!()81$&'()*!=1$$A=+(,)!,3!'+&+$!0'01HTO

pA**;-+-0"1*,":#*3"&*O&7-&(%4%E-*6-04%7-0#*()*D)+%2G*,)"*

"A**J*6("(/()0G*;%+/7%"0G*F/(G*()*M)&+$)1+-0#*

S)$! ',20+(,)! +#&+! 8,02-! ()8$)+(5(\$! '$15(8$1'! +,! A,-(3

2,)*! &'! +#$! 2&?! -,$'! ),+! A,-(3

HTJ

"#('!?,02-!=1,5(-$!'$15(8$1'!?(+#!$),0*#!2$*&2!8$1+&()+

()-0'+1l:>!

HTOA* 6--* %+A!&+! TN!9l%#(2$!1,;;()*!+#$!'+&+$'!,3! A&)

2(&;(2(+!! HTT>! g,1! &!-('80''(,)!,3! ?#!KJB!KUU]B!&+!T!9-$'81(;()*!+#$!#('+,1!


30/31

OK] PQ*!J6RA*S*,CC*.A3A5A*S*6T3A*.U6KA*WYY*VWXXYZ

*,5$1)A$)+! ;,)-':! &)-! (''0()*!A,1+*&*$'! ?(+#!A,1$! &33,1-&;2$!+$1A'! +,!#,A$,?)$1'>HT]! ! R''$)+(&22HTI

X! '(A(2&1! =1,*1&A! +#&+! &33,1-'! #,A$,?)$1'! +#$! ,==,1+0)(+

#&5$!+,!1$2HNH! ! X'! &! 1$'02+! (+! ('! +#$! 2$&'+! $D=$)'(5$! &)-! A,'+! -(1$8+!

1$A$-!

!!"#$!'+&)-()*!-$3$)'$!'#(3+'!+#$!;01-$)!,)+,!+#$!=&1+

3,1$82,'$!+,!=1,5$!(+!('!+#$!#,2-$1!()!-0$!8,01'$!&)-!$)+(+2$-!+,!+#$!1$A$-

HT]A* O+ >

HTIA* O+ >

HNUA* 6--*4#1('!X1),2-B!R)/#%&'*;%]o*5-[/@1%7"*\/#$*2)0*d*\-07-&(*,)"B!GQ6>S6jBg$;>!]B!KUUIB!"4"%1"@1-*"(!#++=Yee???>)=1>,1*e+$A=2&+$'e'+,1!!O+A

! HNO>! c,!HYUN85KK]KB!$+!&2>!KUUN!%.!OKOKJOUB!&+!fO!)>O!9G>h>!S#(,!S8+>!OHB!KUUN:>!


31/31

!RC9*6C3U5OKOqJKOT9*3TD\,O3JKC6*KRC*O66UC! OKI!

,3! 3,1$82,'01$>! ! 7#(3+()*! +#$! ;01-$)! ,)+,! +10'+$$'C! '#,02-$1'! -$31&!!%#(2$!+#('!',20+(,)!('!1$+1,&8+(5$!&)-!3,1A&2('+(8!9(+!3&(2'!+,!=$)&2(\$!+#$!2,&)!,1(*()&+,1'B!+#$!()5$'+A$)+!;&)E$1'!?#,! =,,2$-! +#$! A,1+*&*$'B! &)-! +#$! ()5$'+,1'! ?#,! *,;;2$-! +#$A! 0=:B! (+!',25$'! ,)$!=1,;2$AY! ! "#&+!A,1+*&*,1'! '#,02-! ),+!=&!

S)! +#$! ,+#$1! #&)-B! 2,&)! 1$)$*,+(&+(,)! 1$&',)'! +#&+! &22! =&1+($'! +,! +#$!2,&)!?$1$!8,A=2(8(+!()! +#$!=1,8$''!,3! '$801(+(\&+(,)B!&)-! &22!=&1+($'!'#,02-!'#&1$! $`0&22!!"#('!8&)!;$'+!;$!-,)$!?(+#!3$-$1&2!2$*('2&+(,)!1$`0(1()*!'$15(8$1'!+,!&8+!&)-!=1$-$+$1A()()*!+#$!2$*&2!-0+ HNJ

! HNJ>! 6,-! h0;(+'E1$'=,)'(;2$2$)-()*>,1*e=-3'e0'L3,1$82,'01$L3&8+L'#$$+>=-3>!

when securitization complicates foreclosure

Documents