working as a mastermind group what are the legal basics?...11 working as a mastermind group – what...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Working as a Mastermind Group What are the Legal Basics?...11 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics? Rule of Reason = Balancing • Applies to most agreements](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051905/5ff7f79ea85cee3629650f34/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics?
2018 NARPM® Broker/Owner Retreat Alvin Dunn
Senior Counsel Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP
April 9, 2018
![Page 2: Working as a Mastermind Group What are the Legal Basics?...11 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics? Rule of Reason = Balancing • Applies to most agreements](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051905/5ff7f79ea85cee3629650f34/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics?
The Legal Framework
• NARPM® Members are actual competitors
• NARPM® Members are potential competitors
• The antitrust laws apply to competitor collaborations
![Page 3: Working as a Mastermind Group What are the Legal Basics?...11 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics? Rule of Reason = Balancing • Applies to most agreements](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051905/5ff7f79ea85cee3629650f34/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics?
The Basic Law
• Sherman Act § 1:
– Anticompetitive agreements are illegal: “Every contract . . . or conspiracy, in restraint of trade or commerce . . . is declared to be illegal.” 15 U.S.C. § 1.
![Page 4: Working as a Mastermind Group What are the Legal Basics?...11 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics? Rule of Reason = Balancing • Applies to most agreements](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051905/5ff7f79ea85cee3629650f34/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics?
The Rough Part:
• Criminal penalties
– Imprisonment
– Fines
– Big fish, smaller fish
![Page 5: Working as a Mastermind Group What are the Legal Basics?...11 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics? Rule of Reason = Balancing • Applies to most agreements](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051905/5ff7f79ea85cee3629650f34/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics?
More Common:
• Civil sanctions: – Injunctive relief – Divestiture, rescission, forfeiture – Damages (U.S. as a purchaser of goods)
• Private civil lawsuits: – Injunctive relief, treble damages, attorneys’ fees
• Just defending an investigation or lawsuit is a substantial burden
![Page 6: Working as a Mastermind Group What are the Legal Basics?...11 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics? Rule of Reason = Balancing • Applies to most agreements](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051905/5ff7f79ea85cee3629650f34/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics?
Not Much Guidance in the Statute:
• All agreements restrain trade – Prohibited: Agreements that “unreasonably” restrain trade
• Unlike with certain regulatory regimes, there is no place to go for a quick answer for many collaborations – The antitrust agencies have issued formal guidance in only
limited areas – Cases are usually fact-specific – Informal opinions are available but take a long time and a lot of
money to obtain
![Page 7: Working as a Mastermind Group What are the Legal Basics?...11 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics? Rule of Reason = Balancing • Applies to most agreements](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051905/5ff7f79ea85cee3629650f34/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics?
Elements of a Section 1 Antitrust Violation:
1. Agreement
– no agreement, usually no antitrust exposure
2. Unreasonably restrains trade
– fact-specific
3. Affects interstate or foreign commerce
– just about always met
![Page 8: Working as a Mastermind Group What are the Legal Basics?...11 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics? Rule of Reason = Balancing • Applies to most agreements](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051905/5ff7f79ea85cee3629650f34/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics?
The Agreement
• Could be express (written or oral)
• Could be implied from conduct
– “conscious parallelism”
– winks & nods, perhaps at association meetings
![Page 9: Working as a Mastermind Group What are the Legal Basics?...11 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics? Rule of Reason = Balancing • Applies to most agreements](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051905/5ff7f79ea85cee3629650f34/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics?
Determining Whether the Agreement To Restrain Trade Is Unlawful
• Per se v. rule of reason
– A critical determination
![Page 10: Working as a Mastermind Group What are the Legal Basics?...11 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics? Rule of Reason = Balancing • Applies to most agreements](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051905/5ff7f79ea85cee3629650f34/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics?
Per Se = Automatically Illegal • “Naked” agreement on prices or output • No legitimate business justification • Typically applies only to “horizontal” agreements:
– Price fixing among competitors – Market allocation among competitors
• Per se violations can be criminal violations – Prison sentences – Individual and corporate fines
• The civil lawsuits almost always follow
![Page 11: Working as a Mastermind Group What are the Legal Basics?...11 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics? Rule of Reason = Balancing • Applies to most agreements](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051905/5ff7f79ea85cee3629650f34/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics?
Rule of Reason = Balancing
• Applies to most agreements with some legitimate business justification, even if between competitors
• The test asks “whether the questioned practice imposes an unreasonable restraint on competition, taking into account a variety of factors, including specific information about the relevant business, its condition before and after the restraint was imposed, and the restraint’s history, nature, and effect.”
![Page 12: Working as a Mastermind Group What are the Legal Basics?...11 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics? Rule of Reason = Balancing • Applies to most agreements](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051905/5ff7f79ea85cee3629650f34/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics?
The FTC Can Go Further
• FTC Act Section 5 prohibits “unfair methods of competition” – Courts have ruled that Section 5 is a “penumbra
around the federal antitrust statutes”
– Used most successfully to challenge “invitations to collude”
– Little certainty
![Page 13: Working as a Mastermind Group What are the Legal Basics?...11 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics? Rule of Reason = Balancing • Applies to most agreements](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051905/5ff7f79ea85cee3629650f34/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics?
Antitrust and Professional Societies Can Be Targets
• Professional societies and trade associations are presumptively lawful and pro-competitive
• Because professional societies and associations are often groups of competitors and business partners, they can be subject to antitrust scrutiny
![Page 14: Working as a Mastermind Group What are the Legal Basics?...11 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics? Rule of Reason = Balancing • Applies to most agreements](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051905/5ff7f79ea85cee3629650f34/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics?
Antitrust and Professional Societies – Collaborations Lawful or Not?
• State Bar Association sets minimum fee schedule for title examinations
• National Society of Professional Engineers prohibits competitive bidding
• American Medical Association prohibits physician advertising
• Ethical rules prohibit members from soliciting other members’ customers/clients
• A brand-new government lawsuit against a competitor collaboration
– FTC suit against the three largest dental distributors • Alleges agreement not to sell products to Buying Groups formed by independent dental practices,
a per se violation of Section 5
• Alleges that one of the Big Three distributors invited the fourth largest distributor to join the conspiracy at a trade association meeting, a violation of Section 5
– Legal principle? Avoid an unlawful agreement to exclude competitors that could limit competition (a “group boycott”)
– Case could hurt or help NARPM members
![Page 15: Working as a Mastermind Group What are the Legal Basics?...11 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics? Rule of Reason = Balancing • Applies to most agreements](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051905/5ff7f79ea85cee3629650f34/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics?
Competitor Collaborations: Benchmarking
• Lawful: Surveys of historic cost data that meet the government’s “antitrust safety zone”
– 5+ contributors
– Not one contributor over 20%
– Data at least 3 months old
• Possibly unlawful: Detroit Nurses Case
![Page 16: Working as a Mastermind Group What are the Legal Basics?...11 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics? Rule of Reason = Balancing • Applies to most agreements](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051905/5ff7f79ea85cee3629650f34/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics?
Competitor Collaborations: Standardization
• Lawful: Beneficial standards developed through a fair and open process
• Possibly unlawful: Agreements to adhere to commercial terms that are more favorable than individual firms could obtain on their own
![Page 17: Working as a Mastermind Group What are the Legal Basics?...11 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics? Rule of Reason = Balancing • Applies to most agreements](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051905/5ff7f79ea85cee3629650f34/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics?
Competitor Collaborations: Group Purchasing
• Can members pool their purchasing power to receive better pricing from suppliers? – Yes, in most cases:
• The group should represent less than 35% of the purchases • The purchased product should represent less than 20% of
the final cost of the products/services the members sell • An independent third party (such as NARPM or a consulting
firm) should coordinate the joint purchasing • Participation should be voluntary
![Page 18: Working as a Mastermind Group What are the Legal Basics?...11 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics? Rule of Reason = Balancing • Applies to most agreements](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051905/5ff7f79ea85cee3629650f34/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics?
Competitor Collaborations: Petitioning the Government
• Can members agree on a particular position to take before a city council, state legislature, or Congress even if our members seek legislation – such as licensing requirements – to exclude competition)? – Absolutely – Noerr-Pennington protection is extremely broad – “Sham exception” applies only if parties seek to use the
process as an anticompetitive weapon – Care should be taken if confidential business information needs to be shared
to undertake a petitioning activity – The protection applies when seeking to influence the rules the government
follows when seeking bids for professional services -- but does not apply to permit competitors to coordinate their bids
![Page 19: Working as a Mastermind Group What are the Legal Basics?...11 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics? Rule of Reason = Balancing • Applies to most agreements](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051905/5ff7f79ea85cee3629650f34/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics?
Preventing Antitrust Problems
• Be familiar with NARPM’s antitrust policy and the antitrust laws
• Call out potential antitrust issues when you spot them – State the potential issue and invite discussion regarding whether
it is an issue – Consult NARPM staff and/or counsel if there are any questions
about the propriety of the conversation – Leave the meeting if participants refuse to cooperate by
addressing the issue
![Page 20: Working as a Mastermind Group What are the Legal Basics?...11 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics? Rule of Reason = Balancing • Applies to most agreements](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051905/5ff7f79ea85cee3629650f34/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics?
Questions?
![Page 21: Working as a Mastermind Group What are the Legal Basics?...11 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics? Rule of Reason = Balancing • Applies to most agreements](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022051905/5ff7f79ea85cee3629650f34/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21 Working as a Mastermind Group – What are the Legal Basics?
For More Information:
Alvin Dunn Senior Counsel Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman
1200 Seventeenth Street, NW
Washington, DC 20036-3006
Tel. +1.202.663.8355
Fax. +1.202.354.5442