6th grade science unit 1: setting things in motion pop-out ......student version stanford ngss...

20
Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 6th Grade Science Unit 1: Setting Things in Motion Pop-Out 1: Engineering for Equity Student Version Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 2018 1 Pop-Out Essential Question: How can we use engineering to provide more access for people with disabilities? The role of an engineer is to tackle some of the world’s biggest problems. In doing so, they have created technologies that have completely changed the world we live in. Some of these technologies can improve the way all of us live. However, some technologies specifically try to improve the lives of those with disabilities so they can do some of the same things other people do. In this unit, you have been thinking about an activity that requires your body to make an object move. What about people who aren’t able to do this physical activity because of a disability? How can we make this activity accessible to as many people as possible? In this Pop-Out, you will research designs that engineers have come up with to make different activities accessible to people with disabilities. You’ll use these as inspiration to brainstorm ideas for your own activity. Engage When we think of engineers, we often think of adults. However, students can be engineers as well! 1. As a class, watch the following video showing how a group of students engineered a solution for a child with a disability: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TwCL0BEUXjs. Then discuss with a partner: a. What need did Cillian have? What problem were the students trying to solve for Cillian? b. In what ways did this design solution make the world more accessible for Cillian? How might it benefit other kids and adults? c. In what ways do you think the students benefited, learned, or grew from this engineering experience? 2. For your culminating project, you picked an activity that also requires movements. With your group, discuss: a. In what ways might your activity be difficult or impossible for some people to do? b. Brainstorm some initial ideas of what you could engineer (design) so that more people could do this activity?

Upload: others

Post on 04-Oct-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 6th Grade Science Unit 1: Setting Things in Motion Pop-Out ......Student Version Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 2018 4 c. Why do you think Universal Design might be a good idea?

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum6thGradeScienceUnit1:SettingThingsinMotion

Pop-Out1:EngineeringforEquity

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 1

Pop-OutEssentialQuestion:Howcanweuseengineeringtoprovidemoreaccessforpeoplewithdisabilities?Theroleofanengineeristotacklesomeoftheworld’sbiggestproblems.Indoingso,theyhavecreatedtechnologiesthathavecompletelychangedtheworldwelivein.Someofthesetechnologiescanimprovethewayallofuslive.However,sometechnologiesspecificallytrytoimprovethelivesofthosewithdisabilitiessotheycandosomeofthesamethingsotherpeopledo.Inthisunit,youhavebeenthinkingaboutanactivitythatrequiresyourbodytomakeanobjectmove.Whataboutpeoplewhoaren’tabletodothisphysicalactivitybecauseofadisability?Howcanwemakethisactivityaccessibletoasmanypeopleaspossible?InthisPop-Out,youwillresearchdesignsthatengineershavecomeupwithtomakedifferentactivitiesaccessibletopeoplewithdisabilities.You’llusetheseasinspirationtobrainstormideasforyourownactivity.EngageWhenwethinkofengineers,weoftenthinkofadults.However,studentscanbeengineersaswell!

1. Asaclass,watchthefollowingvideoshowinghowagroupofstudentsengineeredasolutionforachildwithadisability:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TwCL0BEUXjs.Thendiscusswithapartner:

a. WhatneeddidCillianhave?WhatproblemwerethestudentstryingtosolveforCillian?b. InwhatwaysdidthisdesignsolutionmaketheworldmoreaccessibleforCillian?Howmightit

benefitotherkidsandadults?c. Inwhatwaysdoyouthinkthestudentsbenefited,learned,orgrewfromthisengineering

experience?

2. Foryourculminatingproject,youpickedanactivitythatalsorequiresmovements.Withyourgroup,discuss:

a. Inwhatwaysmightyouractivitybedifficultorimpossibleforsomepeopletodo?

b. Brainstormsomeinitialideasofwhatyoucouldengineer(design)sothatmorepeoplecoulddothisactivity?

Page 2: 6th Grade Science Unit 1: Setting Things in Motion Pop-Out ......Student Version Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 2018 4 c. Why do you think Universal Design might be a good idea?

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum6thGradeScienceUnit1:SettingThingsinMotion

Pop-Out1:EngineeringforEquity

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 2

ExploreEngineershavebeenworkingforyearstodesignsolutionsthatmakeiteasierforpeoplewithdisabilitiestodoeverydayactivities,includingthosethatinvolvemovingobjects.Asagroup,

1. Researchexamplesofsolutionsthatengineershavedesignedtoimprovethelivesofpeoplewithdisabilities.Asyouresearch,recordnotesinthetablebelow:

Solution Howdoesithelppeoplewithdisabilities? Wouldithelpapersonwithadisabilitydoyouractivity?Ifyes,how?

Page 3: 6th Grade Science Unit 1: Setting Things in Motion Pop-Out ......Student Version Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 2018 4 c. Why do you think Universal Design might be a good idea?

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum6thGradeScienceUnit1:SettingThingsinMotion

Pop-Out1:EngineeringforEquity

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 3

2. UseyourresearchasinspirationtobrainstormapotentialsolutiontomakeyourCulminatingProjectActivitymoreaccessibletosomeonewithadisability.Describeyoursolutionbelow:

Explain

1. Asagroup,preparea1-2minutepresentationtoshareyoursolutionwiththeclass.Inyourpresentation,include:

• Whatyouractivityis• Whatmightmakethisactivitydifficultforsomeonewithadisability• Whatyoursolutionisandhowithelpstosolveaproblem• Whatresearchinspiredyoursolution

2. Presenttotheclass,makingsureeveryoneinthegroupshares.

3. Asaclass,discusshowsomeofthesesolutionsmightbeusedformanydifferentactivities.

ElaborateManyofthesolutionsyouresearchedandpresentedwereengineeredtomakeanexistingactivitymoreaccessibletopeoplewithdisabilities.However,whatifweinsteaddecidedtoalwaystrytoengineerproductsandenvironmentstobeusablebyallpeoplefromtheverybeginning?

1. Asaclass,watchthefollowingvideoaboutanewapproachtoengineeringcalled“UniversalDesign”:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bVdPNWMGyZY(5:05–10:10).

2. Withapartner,discuss:a. DescribetheexampleofUniversalDesignheusedinthevideo.

b. Canyouthinkofanotherexampleyouhaveseenintheworldthatnotonlyworksforpeoplewithdisabilities,butalsoforeveryone?

Page 4: 6th Grade Science Unit 1: Setting Things in Motion Pop-Out ......Student Version Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 2018 4 c. Why do you think Universal Design might be a good idea?

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum6thGradeScienceUnit1:SettingThingsinMotion

Pop-Out1:EngineeringforEquity

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 4

c. WhydoyouthinkUniversalDesignmightbeagoodidea?EvaluateandReflectionIndividually,takeafewminutestothinkaboutwhatyoulearnedinthisPop-Out.Thenreflectonthequestionsbelow:

1. Lookatthepicturesandthecaptionsbelow.

http://agentsofgood.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Equality-vs-Equity-Illustration3.jpg

a. Howdoyouthinkthephotosshowthedifferencebetweenequality,equity,andjustice?

b. Lookatthepictureontheleft:whycanonlypracticingequaltreatmentsometimesbeaproblem?

Page 5: 6th Grade Science Unit 1: Setting Things in Motion Pop-Out ......Student Version Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 2018 4 c. Why do you think Universal Design might be a good idea?

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum6thGradeScienceUnit1:SettingThingsinMotion

Pop-Out1:EngineeringforEquity

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 5

2. Whydoyouthinkitisimportantforustopracticeusingequityorjustice,insteadofjustequality?

3. Howcanengineeringbeusedtopromoteequityandjusticeforallhumanbeings?

Page 6: 6th Grade Science Unit 1: Setting Things in Motion Pop-Out ......Student Version Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 2018 4 c. Why do you think Universal Design might be a good idea?

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum6thGradeScienceUnit2:ExtremeLiving

Pop-Out2:EquityinSTEM

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 1

Pop-OutEssentialQuestion:IstherediversityinSTEMandwhydoesitmatter?Inthisunit’sculminatingproject,yourjobistodesignaproductthatmakesitmorecomfortableforpeopletoliveinextremeclimates.Whatyouaredoingisengineering!EngineeringispartofalargercategoryyoumayhaveheardofbeforecalledSTEM–Science,Technology,Engineering,andMath.Inthelast30years,STEMjobshavegrown79%andtheyoftenpayamuchhighersalarythannon-STEMjobs(seegraphtoright).Withlotsofjobsavailableandhigherpay,youmightthinkallkindsofpeopledecidetoworkinSTEMprofessions!InthisPop-Out,youwillexplorewhoworksinSTEMfieldsandwhythismattersfortherestofsociety.EngageInnovationsfromSTEMfieldsareallaroundyou,affectingmostaspectsofyoureverydaylife!Howdidtheseinnovationscomeaboutandwhodidtheycomefrom?

1. Individually,thinkaboutwhenyou’veactedlikeanengineer,forexamplewhenyoudesignedasolutiontoaproblem:

a. Doyouthinkyou’dcomeupwithabettersolutiononyourown,orifyouhadachancetoshareideaswithothers?Why?

b. Let’ssayyoudecidetoworkwithateam.Doyouthinkyou’dcomeupwithabettersolutionifyourteamwasmadeupofpeoplewithidenticalbackgrounds,perspectives,andexperiences?Or,doyouthinkyoursolutioncouldbeimprovedbyworkingwithpeoplefromdifferentbackgrounds,perspectives,andexperiences?Why?

2. Diversityreferstodifference.DoyouthinkdiversityisimportantinSTEMfields?Why?Shareyouropinion,firstwithapartnerandthenwiththeclass.

Page 7: 6th Grade Science Unit 1: Setting Things in Motion Pop-Out ......Student Version Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 2018 4 c. Why do you think Universal Design might be a good idea?

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum6thGradeScienceUnit2:ExtremeLiving

Pop-Out2:EquityinSTEM

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 2

ExploreYou’vediscussedwaysinwhichdiversityisgoodforSTEM.Let’sexplorehowdiverseSTEMfieldsactuallyare.YouwillbegivenfourResearchCards.EachcontainsadifferentgraphofdatathatshowsthegroupsofpeoplerepresentedinSTEM.Asagroup,revieweachResearchCardandusethegraphanalysisquestionstohelpyouunderstandeachsourceofdata.Fillinthegraphicorganizerwithyournotesbelow:ResearchCard#

Whatisthisgraphabout? DiscussionQuestions

1 Isthereahigherfemale-to-maleratioinnon-STEMorSTEMfields?AretheremorewomenormenmajoringinSTEMfields?

2 AretheremorefemalesormalesineachSTEMeducationlevel?AtwhatlevelofSTEMeducationistherethemostdifferencebetweenthepercentageoffemalesandmales?

3 WhichracialgroupholdsthelargestpercentageofSTEMjobsandwhichracialgroupholdsthelowestpercentage?WhichSTEMfieldhasthemostwhitepeople?WhichSTEMfieldhasthefewestunderrepresentedminorities(BlackandHispanicpeople)?

4 Whichracialgroupismostrepresented(largestbar)andwhichracialgroupisleastrepresented(smallestbar)ateachProfessorRankLevel?

Page 8: 6th Grade Science Unit 1: Setting Things in Motion Pop-Out ......Student Version Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 2018 4 c. Why do you think Universal Design might be a good idea?

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum6thGradeScienceUnit2:ExtremeLiving

Pop-Out2:EquityinSTEM

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 3

AtwhichProfessorRankistherethemostdifferencebetweenwhiterepresentationandrepresentationofotherraces?

ExplainNowthatyouhaveseenthedata,howwouldyouexplaintheamountofdiversityinSTEMtoanotherperson?Individually,filloutthegraphicorganizerbelowtohelpyoudescribediversityinSTEM,citingevidencefromthegraphs.

ClaimAboutDiversityin

STEM

Accordingtodata,wouldyousaythereisalackofdiversityinSTEM,lotsofdiversityinSTEM,orisittoodifficulttotell?

EvidenceofGenderDiversity

(Describewhatyousawin

Graphs1and2)

Evidenceof

RacialDiversity

(Describewhatyousawin

Graphs3and4)

Page 9: 6th Grade Science Unit 1: Setting Things in Motion Pop-Out ......Student Version Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 2018 4 c. Why do you think Universal Design might be a good idea?

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum6thGradeScienceUnit2:ExtremeLiving

Pop-Out2:EquityinSTEM

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 4

ElaborateToaddressthislackofgenderandracialdiversityinSTEM,weneedtobetterunderstandwhyitmightbehappening!

1. Individually,readandannotatethearticle,“WhyAreWeSeeingaLackofDiversityinSTEM?”

2. Withapartner,filloutthetablebelow:

a. FirstRow:DescribethreepossiblereasonsforthelackofgenderandracialdiversityinSTEM.b. SecondRow:Brainstormatleastonestrategytoaddresseachissuedescribedinthearticle.

ReasonsFortheLackof

GenderandRacialDiversityinSTEM

StrategiestoBringMoreWomenand

UnderrepresentedMinoritiesintotheSTEM

Field

3. Asaclass,shareideasoutandmakeaposterofpotentialstrategies.

Page 10: 6th Grade Science Unit 1: Setting Things in Motion Pop-Out ......Student Version Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 2018 4 c. Why do you think Universal Design might be a good idea?

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum6thGradeScienceUnit2:ExtremeLiving

Pop-Out2:EquityinSTEM

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 5

EvaluateandReflectIndividually,takeafewminutestothinkaboutwhatyoulearnedinthisPop-Out.Thenreflectonthequestionsbelow:

1. WhatdoyouthinkaresomebenefitstohavingamorediverseSTEMworkforce?

2. Whatdoyouthinkarethebestwaystoaddressthediversityissue?

3. DoyouwanttoworkinSTEMwhenyougetolder(asascientist,engineer,ormathematician)?

a. Whyorwhynot?

b. IfyouwereinterestedinSTEM,whatwouldhelpyoufeelmoresupportedinpursuingthistypeofcareer?

Page 11: 6th Grade Science Unit 1: Setting Things in Motion Pop-Out ......Student Version Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 2018 4 c. Why do you think Universal Design might be a good idea?

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum6thGradeScienceUnit3:NatureViaNurturePop-Out3:GeneticTesting–AccessDenied

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 1

Pop-OutEssentialQuestion:Howisgenetictestingimportantforourhealthandwhohasaccesstoit?Youhaveexaminedalotofscientificevidencearoundthenaturevs.nurturedebateandfoundthatbothgeneticsandenvironmentaffectthetraitsoforganisms.Studyinganorganism’senvironmentisnotdifficult—wesimplyobserveanorganism’shabitat.However,tofigureouthowanorganism’sgeneticinformationaffectshowitlooksorbehaves,maynotbeassimple.InthisPop-Out,youwilllearnabouttheriseofgenetictesting,includingwhyitissoimportantinmodernmedicineandwhohasaccesstoit.EngagePerfectpitchisoneofthosetraitsthatweknowishereditary,ordeterminedbyagenevariationpassedonfromafamilymember.48%ofpeoplewithperfectpitchhaveacloserelativewithperfectpitch,comparedtoonly14%ofpeoplewithoutperfectpitch.Havingperfectpitchmeansyouareabletorecognize,ormakeatonewithoutanotherreference,likehearingthetoneornoteonapiano.Here’swhereitgetsinteresting!Evenifachildhasthegeneticvariation,theyneedearlymusicaltrainingbeforeagesixinordertoactuallydevelopperfectpitch.Thismeans,withoutknowingit,someofyoumayhavethegeneticvariationforperfectpitchandnotevenknowit!Withapartner,discuss:

1. Doesthissupporttheargumentfornature,nurture,ornaturevianurture?Why?

2. Whydoyouthinkthiswouldmakesomeonewanttoknowmoreabouttheirgeneticmakeup?

3. Genetictestingisnotasimplemedicaltest.Itusescomplexmachinesandhighlytrainedprofessionalstointerprettheresults.Thismeansgenetictestingisveryexpensive!

a. Whatdoyouthinkthismeansforwhogetstofindoutabouttheirgeneticmakeup?

Page 12: 6th Grade Science Unit 1: Setting Things in Motion Pop-Out ......Student Version Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 2018 4 c. Why do you think Universal Design might be a good idea?

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum6thGradeScienceUnit3:NatureViaNurturePop-Out3:GeneticTesting–AccessDenied

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 2

ExploreKnowingwhetheryouhavethegeneticvariationforperfectpitchmaynotseemlikethebiggestpriority.However,therearelotsofothergeneticvariationsthatcanhaveabigimpactonyourhealthandthehealthofyourchildren.Forexample,somegeneticvariationsaffectthewayyourcellsororgansfunction,orwhetheryoumaydevelopcertaindiseasesinyourlifetime.So,howcanwefindoutmoreaboutourgeneticmakeup?GenetictestingisamedicaltestthatlooksforanydifferencesinyourDNAcodethatcancauseyoutodevelopand/orpassoncertaindiseases.Rememberthatyouinheritpartofyourgenes,orDNAcode,fromyourmotherandsomefromyourfather.Asagroup,pickoneofthefollowingpatientsandwatchavideooftheirstorytolearnmoreaboutwhatgenetictestingcandoandwhyitisimportant:

• Paige’sStory:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-UHg0oEqdAg• Nicole’sStory:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d7u3A1WMT5s• Jessica’sStory:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uFjv5vae1J8• Conner’sStory:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZOJ9LpNRg3Q• NicoleR.’sStory:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EvUmsi5gZY0

Takenotesintheboxbelow.Youwillusethesenotestoprepareapresentationabouthowgenetictestinghelpedyourpatient.

Page 13: 6th Grade Science Unit 1: Setting Things in Motion Pop-Out ......Student Version Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 2018 4 c. Why do you think Universal Design might be a good idea?

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum6thGradeScienceUnit3:NatureViaNurturePop-Out3:GeneticTesting–AccessDenied

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 3

ExplainGenetictestingisimportantformanydifferentpurposes.Sinceothergroupsinyourclasschosedifferentpatientstories,youcanlearnaboutsomeofthesedifferentpurposesfromeachother.

1. Asagroup,createapresentationtoshareyourpatient’sstory.Inyourpresentation,makesuretoincludethefollowing:• Abackgroundofyourpatient• Adescriptionofwhatmedicalissuesorproblemsyourpatientwasfacing• Anexplanationofhowgenetictestinghelpedyourpatientand/oryourpatient’sfamilymembers

2. Afterhearingaboutallthepatients’stories,discussasagroup:

• Whatarethedifferentbenefitsofgenetictesting?• Whyisgenetictestingimportantforhealthoutcomes?Preparetoshareoutideasasaclass.

ElaborateYouhaveseenthatgenetictestingcanplayanimportantroleinmanypeople’shealth.Sinceitissoimportant,itseemslikegenetictestingshouldbeavailabletoeveryone.Butisit?

1. Individually,readandannotatethearticlebelow,“WhoHasAccesstoGeneticTesting?”

WhoHasAccesstoGeneticTesting?

Genetictestinghasbeenontherise,helpingdoctorstoprevent,diagnose,andtreatmorediseases.However,researchhasshownthatminorityandlow-incomegroupsaremuchlesslikelytoreceivegenetictesting.Researchshowsthatamajorreasonforthisiscost.Genetictestingisveryexpensive,andprivateinsurancecompanieswillonlypayforitifthepatientmeetsspecificconditions.Forexample,aninsurancecompanymayonlyallowsomeonetogettestingforaspecificdiseaseiftheyhaveotherfamilysufferingfromthesamedisease.Otherdataalsoshowsthatminorityandlow-incomegroupsarelesslikelytoevenhavethatprivatehealthinsurance.Thesearejustsomeofthereasonswhymanypeopleoftencannotaffordthisexpensivegenetictesting.Anotherchallengeminorityandlow-incomegroupsfaceisnotknowingthatgenetictestingisavailableornotgettingenoughunderstandableinformationfromtheir

Page 14: 6th Grade Science Unit 1: Setting Things in Motion Pop-Out ......Student Version Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 2018 4 c. Why do you think Universal Design might be a good idea?

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum6thGradeScienceUnit3:NatureViaNurturePop-Out3:GeneticTesting–AccessDenied

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 4

doctor.Iftheydon’tknowthatgenetictestingasanoption,theycan’taskforit.Forexample,researchshowsthatwhitewomenaremorelikelytorequestgeneticcounselingforbreastcancerthanwomeninminoritygroups.Lastly,studiesindicatethatthereisoftenlesstrustinthemedicalsystemamongminoritygroups.Manyindividualsreportconcernabouthowtheirgenetictestresultswillbeused.Forexample,researchhasshownthatAfricanAmericanwomenperceivethattherearemorerisksandlimitationstogenetictestingthanothergroups.Howwillthisaffectthehealthofpeopleinthesegroups?Isthisfair?

AdaptedFromTheFollowingSources:

• https://www.nature.com/articles/gim200997• https://www.healthcaredive.com/news/genetic-testing-threatens-to-widen-health-

disparities/424144/

2. Withapartner,discussthearticleandanswerthequestionsbelow.Bepreparedtoshareideaswiththe

class.a. Whichgroupsofpeopleusuallyhavelessaccesstogenetictesting?

i. Whatthreereasonsdoesthearticlegivetoexplaintheirlackofaccess?

b. Thinkaboutthestoriesyouheardandhowthepatientsbenefitedfromgenetictesting.Whymightitbeaproblemifcertaingroupsofpeopledonothaveaccesstogenetictesting?

c. Howcanyouseethisbeingaproblemforoursociety?

Page 15: 6th Grade Science Unit 1: Setting Things in Motion Pop-Out ......Student Version Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 2018 4 c. Why do you think Universal Design might be a good idea?

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum6thGradeScienceUnit3:NatureViaNurturePop-Out3:GeneticTesting–AccessDenied

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 5

EvaluateandReflectIndividually,takeafewminutestothinkaboutwhatyoulearnedinthisPop-Out.Thenreflectonthequestionsbelow:

1. Howcangenetictestingbeusedfor“good”?

2. Howmightaccesstogenetictestingincreasehealthdisparities,ormaketheworldlessfair?

3. Whatdoyouthinkcouldbedonetomakesuregenetictestingisusedinafairway?

Page 16: 6th Grade Science Unit 1: Setting Things in Motion Pop-Out ......Student Version Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 2018 4 c. Why do you think Universal Design might be a good idea?

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum6thGradeScienceUnit4:AWarmerWorld

Pop-Out4:ACallForEquityinClimateAction

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 1

Pop-OutEssentialQuestion:WhydoesGretaThunbergcallforequityinclimateaction?

InyourCulminatingProject,youarefocusingonaplantoranimalaffectedbyclimatechange.However,manyof

youalreadyknowthathumansarealsosufferingtheimpactsofclimatechange,anditisonlygettingworse!

Inresponse,peopleallaroundtheworldaretalkingaboutclimateaction.Thesearetheeffortswecantaketo

reduceourcontributionstoclimatechangeandtoadapttothesituationwearein.InthisPop-Out,youwill

explorewhoshouldbethemajorplayersinclimateactionandwhy.

Engage

YoumayhaveheardthenameGretaThunberginthenewsorsocialmedia.SheisaSwedishenvironmental

activistthatisnotmucholderthanyouare!Inthelastfewyears,shehasmadecountlessspeechescalling

attentiontotheinternationalcrisisofclimatechange.

1. Asaclass,watchthefollowingvideoofoneofGretaThunberg’sspeeches:https://www.ted.com/talks/greta_thunberg_the_disarming_case_to_act_right_now_on_climate_change/up-next

2. Discussthefollowingquestionsfirstwithapartnerandthenasaclass:

a. HowdidlisteningtoGretamakeyoufeel?Whatwereyourfirstimpressions?

b. WhatdoesGretasayissoconfusingtoherabouttheclimatecrisis?

c. WhatdoesGretasayaboutequity,orclimatejustice?

d. Whatreasondoesshegiveforpeoplenotcaringenoughabouttheclimatecrisisrightnow?

Page 17: 6th Grade Science Unit 1: Setting Things in Motion Pop-Out ......Student Version Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 2018 4 c. Why do you think Universal Design might be a good idea?

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum6thGradeScienceUnit4:AWarmerWorld

Pop-Out4:ACallForEquityinClimateAction

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 2

Explore

InGretaThunberg’sspeech,shetalkedaboutaneedforequityorclimatejusticeinorderforclimateactionto

workonaglobalscale.Manyclimateactivistssayequityisthekeytoclimateaction.Butwhy?

YouhavebeenintroducedtothisideaofequitythroughouttheotherPop-Outsthisyear.Withyourgroup,use

whatyou’velearnedfrompreviousPop-Outstofirstdiscusswhatyouthinkequitymeans.Recordyourideasin

theboxbelow:

Nowlet’sseewhyclimateactivists,likeGreta,areaskingforequityinclimateaction.Asagroup,usetheonline

interactiveCarbonMaptohelpyoudecideforyourselfwhatmightbefairinaclimateactionplan.

1. Typecarbonmap.orgintoyourwebbrowser.Presstheplaybuttontowatchandlistentothe

introductionthatdescribeshowthisinteractivemapworks.Writeafewsentencestodescribewhatthis

interactivemapwillshowyou:

2. Youhaveseenan“Area”Mapbefore.Let’sstarttoexplorethedifferentmapsbyfirstlookingatthe

“Population”Mapandthe“Wealth”Map(Note:makesurethe“ShadeBy”tabissetto“Continents”)a. Clickonthe“Population”Map.Howisitdifferentfromthe“Area”Map?Writedown1-2things

younotice.

Page 18: 6th Grade Science Unit 1: Setting Things in Motion Pop-Out ......Student Version Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 2018 4 c. Why do you think Universal Design might be a good idea?

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum6thGradeScienceUnit4:AWarmerWorld

Pop-Out4:ACallForEquityinClimateAction

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 3

b. Nextclickonthe“Wealth”Map.Howisitdifferentfromthe“Population”Map?Writedown1-2

thingsyounotice.

i. Comparedtotheirpopulationsize,whichcontinentshavemorewealththanyouwould

expect?Howcouldyouexplainthis?

3. TherestoftheMapswillhelpyoudeterminewhichcontinentsaremostresponsibleforclimatechange

andwhicharemostvulnerabletotheimpacts.Clickonthetabsatthetoptoexploretheothermapsand

fillinthetablebelowwithyouranalysis.Foreachmap,makesuretoclickbackonthe“Population”tab

tomakecomparisons.

o HelpfulTip:ontherightside,thereisaboxlabeled“ThisMap”thatwillgiveyoumorehelpful

informationaboutthatmap.

Responsibility

Map

Type

Whichcontinents

arelargerthantheir

“Population”map

size?

Whichcontinentsare

smallerthantheir

“Population”map

size?

QuestionstoConsider

Emissions

Comparedtotheirpopulationsize,which

continentscontributemoretocarbon

emissionsthanyouwouldexpect?

Consumption

Comparedtotheirpopulationsize,which

continentscontributemoretocarbon

emissionsfromconsumptionthanyouwould

expect?

Historical

Whichtwocontinentshavecontributedthe

mostcarbonemissionsinthepast?

Page 19: 6th Grade Science Unit 1: Setting Things in Motion Pop-Out ......Student Version Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 2018 4 c. Why do you think Universal Design might be a good idea?

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum6thGradeScienceUnit4:AWarmerWorld

Pop-Out4:ACallForEquityinClimateAction

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 4

Vulnerability

PeopleAt

Risk

Whichcontinenthasthemostpeopleatriskof

feelingtheeffectsofclimatechangeinthe

future?

SeaLevel

Whichcontinentismostindangerofsealevel

rise(aresultofclimatechange)?

Poverty

Whichcontinentsaremostvulnerabletothe

impactsofclimatechangebecauseofpoverty?

Explain

Nowthatyouhaveseenthedataforyourself,takeastance:doyouthinkweneedequityinclimateaction?In

otherwords,shouldeveryonehaveequalresponsibilityindealingwithclimatechangeorshouldsomecountries

havemoreresponsibility?

Asagroup,prepareforaclassdiscussioninwhichyouwill:

ü Voteonwhetheryouthinkequityshouldbeconsideredinclimateaction

ü Usemapdatatojustifywhyyouthinkequityshouldorshouldn’tbeanessentialpieceofclimateaction

ü Explainwhatyouthinkitwouldmeantohaveequityinclimateaction

Elaborate

Ifsomecountriesaregoingtoberesponsibleformoreoftheclimatechangeburdenthanothers,thisisgoingto

requirealotofcooperationaroundtheglobe!ThiskindofcooperationwasattemptedbytheParisClimate

Agreement,whichwassignedby195countriesin2015(includingtheUnitedStates).Atthetime,itwasseenas

themostpromisingefforttotackleclimatechangethusfar.

1. Asaclass,watchthefollowingvideothatgivesyouanewsupdateonwheretheUnitedStatesstands

withtheParisClimateAgreement:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MRCRiMNg_kM.Usethe

followingquestionstodiscussthevideo:

o WhatwasthegoaloftheParisClimateAgreement?

o WhatdidPresidentTrumpdecidetodoabouttheParisClimateAgreement?

§ Howcouldthisaffectglobalclimateaction?

o Doyouagreewiththisdecision?

§ Ifyoudon’tagree,whatwouldyoudodifferentlyandwhy?

Page 20: 6th Grade Science Unit 1: Setting Things in Motion Pop-Out ......Student Version Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 2018 4 c. Why do you think Universal Design might be a good idea?

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum6thGradeScienceUnit4:AWarmerWorld

Pop-Out4:ACallForEquityinClimateAction

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 5

2. TheParisClimateAgreementcallsforequity,butdoesn’tlayoutaspecificsystemtoensureit.Asa

group,brainstorm:Whatwouldyouincludeinaclimateagreementlikethisonetomakesureitisfair

andequitable?

EvaluateandReflect

Individually,takeafewminutestothinkaboutwhatyoulearnedinthisPop-Out.Thenreflectonthequestions

below:

1. Whydoyouthinkthatthereshouldbeequityinclimateaction?

2. Whatdoyouthinkarethebestwaystoachieveequityinclimateaction?

3. ThinkbacktoGretaThunberg’sspeechinthefirstvideo.Whatdoyouthinkyoucoulddoasayoung

environmentalactivistlikeGreta?