abbey house media v. apple - ebook price fixing complaint (another one)

46
JS44C/SDNY REV. 2/2014 .14»<l CIVIL (y xt> IM 2 1 2014 Ths JS-44 eMI cover sheet and me UiformalKin oontainad herein witter replace rwsupplemertote filingand service of pleadings w othar papara a* required by law, except as provided by local ruteaofcouft, Tlus form, approved by the JudicialConfaranca of tha Untied Statas In September 1974, is required for use of trw Clerk of Court for the puipose of Initiating thaefcttdoektt sheet PLAINTIFFS Abbey House Media. Inc.d/b/a BooksOnBoard ATTORNEYS (FIRM NAME. ADDRESS. AND TELEPHONE NUMBER Eric M. Creteman, Creizman LLC. 565 Fifth Avenue. New York. New York 10017. T: (212) 972-0200; Maxwell M. Btecner &Jordan L Ludwkj (pro hac viceperidrng). BkMher Collins Papperman&Joye DEFENDANTS Apple inc. et at. ATTORNEYS (IF KNOWN) CAUSE OF ACTION (CITE THEUS. CML STATUTE UNDER WHICH YOU AREFUNGANO WRITE A BRIEF STATEMENT OFCAUSE) (DO NOT CITE JURISDICTIONALSTATUTES UNLESS DIVERSITY) 15 U.S.C. § 1, Section 1 of the Sherman Act. Unlawful restraint of trade Has this action, case, or proceeding, or one essentially the same been previously filed In SONY at any time? NcQrteQjudge Previously Assigned if yes, was this case Vol. Q kwol. D Dismissed. No Yes Q_ If ves. dive date 4 Case No. UTIM AN UTTEftJUTIONAL ARBITRATION CASE? NO SI Yes XL (PLACE AN M INONEBOX ONLY) CONTRACT 11110 11120 (1130 1)140 ()1» NATURE OF SUIT (|362 PERSONAL INJURY- 1)610 MEO MALPRACTICE 1)820 PERSONAL INJURY PRODUCTUABIUTY [ )«23 ACTIONS UNDER STATUTES OTHER STATUTES INSURANCE MARINE MILLER ACT NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENT RECOVERY OF OVERPAYMENTS ENFORCEMENT OF JUDGMENT MEDICARE ACT RECOVERY OF DEFAULTS) STUDENTLOANS (EXCLVETERANS) RECOVERYOF OVERPAYMENT OF VETERANS {1310 AIRPLANE I )315 AIRPLANE PRODUCT UABIUTY 1)320 ASSAULT,LIBELS SLANDER (1330 FEDERAL EMPLOYERS' UABUTY [|340 MARINE [|345 MAWNePRODUCT UABIUTY [ 1350 MOTOR VEHICLE [ 1386 MOTOR VEHICLE PRODUCT LIABILITY 113*0 OTHER PERSONAL ()3SS INJURY (1385 AGRICULTURE OTHER FOOD 4 DRUG DRUG RELATED SEIZURE OF BANKRUPTCY ()422 APPEAL 28 USC 158 ( )423 WITHDRAWAL 28 USC 157 11400 04410 11450 11450 11480 ||470 STATE REAPPORTIONMENT ANTITRUST BANKS S BANKING (1368 ASBESTOS PERSONAL •UURY PRODUCT LIABILITY 1)151 |)1S2 I 1370 11371 (1380 OTHER FRAUD TRUTH MLENDINO OTHER PERSONAL PROPERTY DAMAGE PROPERTY DAMAGE PRODUCT UABUTY 1)830 1)840 1)850 (1880 1)880 21 USC 881 LIQUOR LAWS RR STRUCK AMJNERECS OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY/HEALTH OTHER 1)820 COPYRIGHTS ( |830 PATENT [)840 TRADEMARK II 480 1)810 (|8S0 DEPORTATION RACKETEER INFLU- ENCEOSCORRUPT ORGANIZATION ACT (RICO) CONSUMER CREDIT CABLESATELUTETV SELECTIVE SERVICE SECURITIES/ COMMODITIES/ EXCHANGE CUSTOMER CHALLENGE 12 USC 3410 OTHER STATUTORY ACTIONS AGRICULTURAL ACTS 1)153 ()160 STOCKHOLDERS suns (]190 OTHER CONTRACT |)1«5 CONTRACT PRODUCT LIABILITY ( ) 188 FRANCWSE ACTIONS UNDER STATUTES CML RIGHTS | 1441 VOTING 114*2 EMPLOYMENT 1)443 HOUSING/ ACCOMMODATIONS I |444 WELFARE 1)445 AMERKANSWrm OHASILrnES- EMPLOYMENT 11448 AMEncANswrm OlSABLmES OTHER 1)440 OTHER CML RJGHTS (NMvPrUmf) REAL PROPERTY 1)210 1)220 11230 I12W 11245 1)290 LAND CONDEMNATION FORECLOSURE RENT LEASES EJECTMENT TORTSTOLAND TORT PRODUCT LIABILITY AUOTHER REAL PROPERTY Check If demanded In complaint: D DEMANDS CHECK IF THIS IS A CLASS ACTION UNDER F.R.C.P. 23 OTHER. Check YES onlyIfdemandedk±com/Mm JURY DEMAND: B YES • NO 1)710 1)720 1)730 ( )510 MOnONSTO VACATE SENTENCE 28USC2239 | )740 1)530 HABEA8CORPUS ()7*0 (|S3S DEATH PENALTY (| 540 MANDAMUS 4 OTHER ( )791 FAK LABOR STANDARDS ACT LABORMGMT RELATIONS REPORTING 8 DISCLOSURE ACT RAILWAY LABORACT ()870 TAXES (US. PHtnM a OTHERLABOR Drfanlart) LmGATMN () 871 IRS-THIRDPARTY EMPLRETmC 28 USC 7808 SECURITY ACT [)881 HIA (13858) (1862 BLACKLUNG (823) (1883 DWC/DIWW (408(g)) ()884 SSIDTITLE XVI ()8S5 RSI(408(g)) FEDERAL TAX SUIT8 PRISONER CML RIGHTS UUSGRATON 1)482 NATURALIZATION APPLICATION (1483 HABEASCORPU8- AUEN DETAINEE I 1485 OTHER IMMIGRATION ACTIONS 11875 1)880 11881 11892 11883 11884 (|88S 1)800 (1*90 STABILIZATION ACT ENVIRONMENTAL MATTERS ENERGY ALLOCATION ACT FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT APPEAL OF FEE DETERMINATION UNDER EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE CONSTITUTIONALITY OF STATE STATUTES IJSS0 1)888 crvn. rights PRISON CONDITION DO YOU CLAIM THIS CASE IS RELATED TO A CIVIL CASE NOW PENDING INS.D.N.Y.? IF SO. STATE: JUOGE Hon. Denise L Cote docket number1:13-ciK)6516 NOTE: You must also submit at the time of Wng the Statement of Relatedness form (Form IH-32).

Upload: mark-h-jaffe

Post on 26-Nov-2015

34 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

DESCRIPTION

Independent publishers sue Apple and major publishers for antitrust violations for e-book price fixing. The United States Department of Justice had previously brought charges against the defendants. The publishers settled, and a court held against Apple in a bench trial.Mark's note: the plaintiffs are likely seeking a judgment that Apple is collaterally estopped from defending the price-fixing allegations, meaning that they cannot argue that the facts are not true. Successful antitrust actions can yield triple damages for plaintiffs. For informational purposes only. Not legal advice. I am not representing any parties in this action. For more information about our practice, see:http://torekeland.com/about/mark-h-jaffeand legal tidbits on my twitter feed:@MarkJKings

TRANSCRIPT

  • JS44C/SDNYREV. 2/2014

    .14 IM 2 1 2014Ths JS-44 eMI cover sheetand me UiformalKin oontainad herein witter replace rwsupplemertote filingand service ofpleadings w othar papara a* required by law, except as provided by local ruteaofcouft, Tlus form, approved by theJudicialConfaranca of tha Untied Statas In September 1974, is required foruse of trw Clerk of Court for the puipose ofInitiatingthaefcttdoektt sheet

    PLAINTIFFS

    Abbey House Media. Inc.d/b/a BooksOnBoard

    ATTORNEYS (FIRM NAME. ADDRESS. AND TELEPHONE NUMBEREric M. Creteman, Creizman LLC. 565 Fifth Avenue. New York. New York10017. T: (212) 972-0200; MaxwellM. Btecner &Jordan L Ludwkj (pro hacviceperidrng). BkMher Collins Papperman&Joye

    DEFENDANTS

    Apple inc. et at.

    ATTORNEYS (IF KNOWN)

    CAUSE OF ACTION(CITE THEUS. CML STATUTE UNDER WHICH YOU AREFUNGANO WRITE A BRIEF STATEMENT OFCAUSE)(DO NOT CITE JURISDICTIONALSTATUTES UNLESS DIVERSITY)

    15 U.S.C. 1, Section 1 of the Sherman Act. Unlawful restraint of trade

    Has this action, case, or proceeding, or one essentially the same been previously filed In SONY at any time? NcQrteQjudge Previously Assignedif yes, was this case Vol. Q kwol. D Dismissed. No YesQ_ If ves. dive date 4 Case No.UTIM AN UTTEftJUTIONAL ARBITRATION CASE? NO SI YesXL(PLACE AN M INONEBOXONLY)

    CONTRACT

    1111011120(11301)140

    ()1

    NATURE OF SUIT

    (|362 PERSONALINJURY- 1)610MEOMALPRACTICE 1)820PERSONAL INJURYPRODUCTUABIUTY [ )23

    ACTIONS UNDER STATUTES

    OTHER STATUTES

    INSURANCEMARINEMILLER ACTNEGOTIABLEINSTRUMENTRECOVERY OFOVERPAYMENTSENFORCEMENTOF JUDGMENTMEDICARE ACTRECOVERY OFDEFAULTS)STUDENTLOANS(EXCLVETERANS)RECOVERYOFOVERPAYMENTOF VETERANS

    {1310 AIRPLANEI )315 AIRPLANE PRODUCT

    UABIUTY1)320 ASSAULT,LIBELS

    SLANDER(1330 FEDERAL

    EMPLOYERS'UABUTY

    [|340 MARINE[|345 MAWNePRODUCT

    UABIUTY[ 1350 MOTOR VEHICLE[ 1386 MOTOR VEHICLE

    PRODUCT LIABILITY113*0 OTHER PERSONAL ()3SS

    INJURY

    (1385

    AGRICULTUREOTHER FOOD 4DRUGDRUG RELATEDSEIZURE OF

    BANKRUPTCY

    ()422 APPEAL28 USC 158

    ( )423 WITHDRAWAL28 USC 157

    11400

    04410114501145011480||470

    STATEREAPPORTIONMENTANTITRUSTBANKS S BANKING

    (1368 ASBESTOS PERSONALUURY PRODUCTLIABILITY

    1)151|)1S2 I 1370

    11371(1380

    OTHER FRAUDTRUTH MLENDINOOTHER PERSONALPROPERTY DAMAGEPROPERTY DAMAGEPRODUCT UABUTY

    1)8301)8401)850(1880

    1)880

    21 USC 881LIQUOR LAWSRR STRUCKAMJNERECSOCCUPATIONALSAFETY/HEALTHOTHER

    1)820 COPYRIGHTS( |830 PATENT[)840 TRADEMARK II 480

    1)810(|8S0

    DEPORTATIONRACKETEER INFLU-ENCEOSCORRUPTORGANIZATION ACT(RICO)CONSUMER CREDITCABLESATELUTETVSELECTIVE SERVICESECURITIES/COMMODITIES/EXCHANGECUSTOMERCHALLENGE12 USC 3410OTHER STATUTORYACTIONSAGRICULTURAL ACTS

    1)153

    ()160 STOCKHOLDERSsuns

    (]190 OTHERCONTRACT

    |)15 CONTRACTPRODUCTLIABILITY

    ( ) 188 FRANCWSEACTIONS UNDER STATUTES

    CML RIGHTS

    | 1441 VOTING114*2 EMPLOYMENT1)443 HOUSING/

    ACCOMMODATIONSI |444 WELFARE1)445 AMERKANSWrm

    OHASILrnES-EMPLOYMENT

    11448 AMEncANswrmOlSABLmES OTHER

    1)440 OTHER CML RJGHTS(NMvPrUmf)

    REAL PROPERTY

    1)2101)22011230

    I12W11245

    1)290

    LANDCONDEMNATIONFORECLOSURERENT LEASESEJECTMENTTORTSTOLANDTORT PRODUCTLIABILITYAUOTHERREAL PROPERTY

    Check If demanded In complaint:

    DDEMANDS

    CHECK IF THIS IS A CLASS ACTIONUNDER F.R.C.P. 23

    OTHER.

    Check YES only Ifdemanded kcom/MmJURYDEMAND: B YES NO

    1)710

    1)7201)730

    ( )510 MOnONSTOVACATE SENTENCE28USC2239 | )740

    1)530 HABEA8CORPUS ()7*0(|S3S DEATH PENALTY(| 540 MANDAMUS 4 OTHER ( )791

    FAK LABORSTANDARDS ACTLABORMGMTRELATIONS

    REPORTING 8DISCLOSURE ACTRAILWAY LABORACT ()870 TAXES (US. PHtnM aOTHERLABOR Drfanlart)LmGATMN () 871 IRS-THIRDPARTYEMPLRETmC 28 USC 7808SECURITY ACT

    [)881 HIA(13858)(1862 BLACKLUNG (823)(1883 DWC/DIWW (408(g))()884 SSIDTITLE XVI()8S5 RSI(408(g))

    FEDERALTAX SUIT8

    PRISONER CML RIGHTSUUSGRATON

    1)482 NATURALIZATIONAPPLICATION

    (1483 HABEASCORPU8-AUEN DETAINEE

    I 1485 OTHER IMMIGRATIONACTIONS

    11875

    1)880

    1188111892

    11883

    11884

    (|88S1)800

    (1*90

    STABILIZATION ACTENVIRONMENTALMATTERSENERGYALLOCATION ACTFREEDOM OFINFORMATION ACTAPPEAL OF FEEDETERMINATIONUNDER EQUALACCESS TO JUSTICECONSTITUTIONALITYOF STATE STATUTES

    IJSS01)888

    crvn. rightsPRISON CONDITION

    DO YOU CLAIM THIS CASE IS RELATED TO A CIVIL CASE NOW PENDING IN S.D.N.Y.?IF SO. STATE:

    JUOGE Hon. Denise L Cote docket number1:13-ciK)6516

    NOTE: You must also submitat the time of Wng the Statement of Relatedness form (Form IH-32).

  • (plAcMAH x IHcWB6x6NiyHi Original D2 n4f*e*staledor D 5 Transferred from D6 MiiMdnMel D 7 Appeal to District^ - (SpK-yO*-*-) UB-on jgEju*.D3

    State Court

    Q a. a-pu-unpn-Md b. Atleaetone

    party Is prose.

    ffiLAcSANxINiiHeSoxoNlY}

    Court

    BASIS 6F JURISDICTIONn 1US PLAINTIFF D 2 U.S. DEFENDANT S 3 FEDERAL QUESTION CM DIVERSITY1-1 (US. NOT APARTY)

    IF DIVERSITY, INDICATECITIZENSHIP BELOW.

    CITIZENSHIP OF PRINCIPAL PARTIES (FOR DIVERSITY CASES ONLY)(Place an pqIn one box for Plaintiff and one box for Defendant)

    _____ PTF DEF PTF DEF^ ^ 113(13 INCORPORATED and PRINCIPAL PLACE 115 (15CmZENOFTHISSTATE IH IH "g^"""^^ *

    PLAINTIFF(S) ADDRESS(ES) AND COUNTY(IES)

    DEFENDANT(S) ADDRESS(ES) AND COUNTRIES)

    OF BUSINESS INANOTHERSTATE

    CmZENOFANOTHERSTATE I12 [12 "^^SfftSSIIME"^ "* '" FORHGNNATI0N 116 I |6

    ^^^l{m^S^S^AJ.MJtST\*E. IHAVE BEEN UNABLE. WITH REASONABLE DIUGENCE. TO ASCERTAIN THERESIDENCE ADORESSES OFTHE FOLLOWING DEFENDANTS:

    Che*one: THIS ACTION SHOULD BE ASSIGNED TO: WHITE PLAINS H MANHATTAN(DO NOT check either boxVthis aPRISONER PETITION/PRISONER CIVIL RIGHTS COMPLAINT^DATE 03/21/2014 SIGNATUREOF ATTORNEYOF RECORD ADMITTED TO PRACTICE IN THIS DISTRICT

    RECEIPT* csyTs/yist&c^ UssssstslA1'^Magistrate Judge isto be designated bythe Clerk of theCourt.Magistrate Judge .

    Ruby J. Krajick, Clerk of Court by. .Deputy Clerk, DATED.

    UNITED STATES DISTRICTCOURT(NEW YORK SOUTHERN)

    is so Designated.

  • UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURTSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK

    ABBEY HOUSE MEDIA, INC. d/b/aBOOKSONBOARD,

    Plaintiff,

    v.

    APPLE INC.; HACHETTE BOOK GROUP,INC.; HARPERCOLLINS PUBLISHERS,L.L.C.; VERLAGSGRUPPE GEORG VONHOLTZBRINCK GMBH; HOLTZBRTNCKPUBLISHERS, LLC d/b/a MACMILLAN;THE PENGUIN GROUP, A DIVISION OFPEARSON PLC; and SIMON &SCHUSTER, INC.

    Defendants.

    14 Cv ki ) f. \(^J *CASE NO.:

    COMPLAINT FOR VIOLATIONS OF:

    (1) THE SHERMAN ACT (15U.S.C. 1)(2) THE DONNELLY ACT (N.Y. GEN.BUS. LAW 340)

    JURY TRIAL DEMANDED

    1

    COCO

    5S o J TV_ ro i__!O __ Tjr

    Ol '