a critical edition of kā´sikā s´ lokavā 176
Post on 13-May-2022
2 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
Kei KATAOKA
1. Manuscripts
The following edition is the continuation of Kataoka 2014 and 2015 that covers
Sucarita’s Kāsikā ad Slokavārttika apoha vv. 95‒176. In preparing the present edi-
tion four manuscripts are consulted as before.
A1 A manuscript preserved in the Adyar Library, Chennai, No. 38.G.5‒5,
63359, TR 66‒5. Paper. Devanāgarī. pp. 2727.9‒2800.4. （TR 66‒7, a man-
uscript of the same series, is designated by Shida as TA.）
G1 A manuscript preserved in the Government Oriental Manuscript Li-
brary （GOML）, Chennai, R. 3778, S.R. 2126. Paper. Devanāgarī. pp.
442.6‒475.17. （Designated as TG by Shida）
K1 A manuscript preserved in the Oriental Research Institute & Manu-
script Library （ORI）, University of Kerala, C.O.L. No. 1333. Palm Leaf.
Malayalam script. ff. 35r11‒43r9. （Designated as K1 by Shida）
S1 A manuscript preserved in the Sarasvatī Bhavan Library, Varanasi, No.
29032. Paper. Devanāgarī. ff. 401v5‒413r7. （Designated as S by Shida）
See Ōmae 1998, Shida 2013, and Kataoka 2014 for further information of these
― 320 ―（1）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
manuscripts.
Acknowledgments
I thank Kunio Harikai, Futoshi Ōmae and Taisei Shida for their help in obtaining
copies of manuscripts. I am indebted to the following libraries and institutes for
giving me permission to consult manuscripts: the Adyar Library, Chennai; the
Government Oriental Manuscript Library, Chennai; the Oriental Research Insti-
tute & Manuscript Library, University of Kerala; the Sarasvatī Bhavan Library,
Varanasi. The complex typesetting of the present edition is made possible thanks
to the EDMAC macros developed by John Lavagnino and Dominik Wujastyk.
Bibliography
See the bibliography in Kataoka 2014 and 2015 for other references.
Primary sources
Pramān3
asamuccaya
See Pind 2015.
Brahmasiddhi
Brahmasiddhi by Ācārya Mand3 3
anamisra with Commentary by
San3 khapān3
i. Ed. S. Kuppuswami Sastri. Madras: The Superintendent,
Government Press, 1937.
Mahābhārata
The Mahābhārata. Ed. V.S. Sukthankar et al. Poona: Bhandarkar Orien-
tal Research Institute, 1927‒59.
― 319 ―（2）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
Secondary literature
Kataoka, Kei（片岡 啓）
2014 “Sucaritamisra’s Critique of Apoha: A Critical Edition of Kā sikā ad
Slokavārttika apoha v.1.” The Memoirs of Institute for Advanced Studies
on Asia, 165, 362（1）-289（74）.
2015 “A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad Slokavārttika apoha vv. 2‒94.” The Mem-
oirs of Institute for Advanced Studies on Asia, 167, 466（39）-400（105）.
Pind, Ole Hoten
2015 Dignāga’s Philosophy of Language: Pramān3
asamuccayavr3
tti V on Anyā-
poha. 2 parts. Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissen-
schaften.
― 318 ―（3）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
95
— 5
,
,
,
— 10
96ab
3 ] Slokavarttika apoha 85cd–86.
4 ] Slokavarttika apoha 87–91.
2 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 3 ] A1G1S1 ; om. K1 3
] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1S1 ; om. K1 4 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 5 ] A1G1 ; K1S1
6 ] S1 ; A1G1K1 6 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 6
] A1G1K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 7 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 8 ]
A1G1 ; K1S1 8 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 8 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 9 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 10 ]
A1G1S1 ;
K1
—
96cd
, —
5
97
,
10 —
98
— , ,
15 , ,
1 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 3 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 4
] A1G1K1 ; S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 5 ] A1G1S𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 ;
K1 ; S𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
9 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 9 ] A1G1 ; K1
S1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ;
S1 13 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 13
] A1G1K1 ; S1 15 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 15 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 15 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
― 317 ―（4）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
—
96cd
, —
5
97
,
10 —
98
— , ,
15 , ,
1 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 3 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 4
] A1G1K1 ; S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 5 ] A1G1S𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 ;
K1 ; S𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
9 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 9 ] A1G1 ; K1
S1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ;
S1 13 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 13
] A1G1K1 ; S1 15 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 15 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 15 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
― 316 ―（5）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
,
—
, —
5
99ab
, —
99c
, 10
—
99d
— 15
100abc
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 ; S𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎
1 2 ] A1
G1S1 ; K1 2 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 2 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 3 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 3 ]
A1G1 ; K1S1 4 ] K1S𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎1 ; A1G1 ;
S𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 5 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 7 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
8 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1
10 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 11 ] A1G1
S1 ; K1 13 ] A1G1K1S𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎1 ;
S𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 14 ] K1 ; A1G1 ; S1 14 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 15 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 15 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1
5 ,
,
10 ,
“ ” ,
,
13 Slokavarttika apoha 92cd.
1 ] S1 ; A1G1 ; K1 1
] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 2
] A1G1K1 ; S1 2 ] A1G1 ; K1S1
3 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 3
] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 4 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 9 ] A1G1S1 ;
om. K1 9 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 10 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 11
] S1 ; A1G1 ; K1 11 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 13
] A1G1K1 ; S1 14 ] S1 ; A1G1 ;
K1 14 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
― 315 ―（6）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
5 ,
,
10 ,
“ ” ,
,
13 Slokavarttika apoha 92cd.
1 ] S1 ; A1G1 ; K1 1
] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 2
] A1G1K1 ; S1 2 ] A1G1 ; K1S1
3 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 3
] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 4 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 9 ] A1G1S1 ;
om. K1 9 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 10 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 11
] S1 ; A1G1 ; K1 11 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 13
] A1G1K1 ; S1 14 ] S1 ; A1G1 ;
K1 14 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
― 314 ―（7）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
,
—
100d
— 5
10
101
15
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1S1 ; ++ K1
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 2 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
3 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 5 ] K1S1 ; A1G1
5 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 5 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 6 ] A1G1 ; ++
+ K1 ; S𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 ; S𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎
1 7 ] A1G1 ;
K1S1 7 ] A1G1K1S𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎1 ; S𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎
1 9 ] A1G1
K𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎1 ; K𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎
1 ; S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
10 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; om. S1 10 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 13 ] G1K1S1 ; A1 14 ] A1G1K𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎1 S1 ;
K𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 14 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 14 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
14 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 14 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
—
102ab
—
5
10
102cd
—
103ab
15
,
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 1 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 3 ] A1G1
K1 ; S1 5 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 5 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 6 ] K1S1 ;
A1G1 7 ] S1 ; A1G1K1 7
] A1G1K1 ; S1 9 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 9
] A1G1K1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 12
] A1G1K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 15 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 16
] K1 ; A1G1S1 16 ] A1G1 ;
K1S1 16 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 16 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1
― 313 ―（8）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
—
102ab
—
5
10
102cd
—
103ab
15
,
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 1 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 3 ] A1G1
K1 ; S1 5 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 5 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 6 ] K1S1 ;
A1G1 7 ] S1 ; A1G1K1 7
] A1G1K1 ; S1 9 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 9
] A1G1K1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 12
] A1G1K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 15 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 16
] K1 ; A1G1S1 16 ] A1G1 ;
K1S1 16 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 16 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1
― 312 ―（9）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
—
103cd
—
104 5
—
105ab
10
—
105cd
1 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] A1G1S1 ; om. K𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 ;
K𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎1 (eyeskip) 3 ] A1G1K
𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎1 ;
S1 3 ] K𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎1 ; A1G1 ; om. S1 4 ]
A1G1 ; K𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎1 ; S1 4 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 6 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1K𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎1
S1 ; K𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 8 ] A1G1 ;
K1S1 8 ] K1S1 ; ¯ A1G1 8 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1
11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 11 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 12 ] A1G1 ;
K𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 ;
K𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎1 ; S1
—
106ab
5 ,
—
106c
—
10
106d–107a
—
107bcd
15 ,
1 ] A1K1S1 ; G1 1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1
] A1G1K1 ; S1 2 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 4 ] K1 ;
A1G1 ; om. S1 5 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 6
] A1G1K1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 6 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 6 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 8 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 9 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 10
] A1G1S1 ; K1 12 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 13 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 15 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 15 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 15 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 16
] A1G1K1 ; S1 16 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1
― 311 ―（10）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
—
106ab
5 ,
—
106c
—
10
106d–107a
—
107bcd
15 ,
1 ] A1K1S1 ; G1 1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1
] A1G1K1 ; S1 2 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 4 ] K1 ;
A1G1 ; om. S1 5 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 6
] A1G1K1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 6 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 6 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 8 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 9 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 10
] A1G1S1 ; K1 12 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 13 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 15 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 15 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 15 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 16
] A1G1K1 ; S1 16 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1
― 310 ―（11）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
—
“ ”
108
— , 5
109abc
10
,
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 4 ]
A1G1K1S𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 ; S𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝
1 4 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 4 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 5 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 5 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1 ;
K1S1 7 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1 ;
K1S1 10 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 10 ]
K1S1 ; A1G1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 12 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 13 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 13
] A1G1S1 ; K1 13 ] K1S1 ;
A1G1 14 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 14 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 14 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 14 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
—
109d
,
5 —
110
—
10
“ ”
,
11 Slokavarttika apoha 85a.
1 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 3 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 4 ] S1 ; A1G1K1 4 ]
A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 5 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
7 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 7 ] K1S1 ; om. A1G1
8 ] S1 ; A1G1 ;
K1 8 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10
] K1S1 ; A1G1 10 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
12 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
12 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 14 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 14 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
14 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
― 309 ―（12）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
—
109d
,
5 —
110
—
10
“ ”
,
11 Slokavarttika apoha 85a.
1 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 3 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 4 ] S1 ; A1G1K1 4 ]
A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 5 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
7 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 7 ] K1S1 ; om. A1G1
8 ] S1 ; A1G1 ;
K1 8 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10
] K1S1 ; A1G1 10 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
12 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
12 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 14 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 14 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
14 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
― 308 ―（13）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
111
,
, 5
,
“ ” —
112
—
, 10
,
113ab
—
7 Slokavarttika apoha 3c.
1 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 4 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 5 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1 ;
K1S1 6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 6
] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 7
— ] A1G1S1 ; ++
K1 9 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 9 ] A1G1K1 ;
S𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 ; S𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎
1 10 , ] A1G1S1 ;
++++++ K1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; om.
S1 11 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 12 ] K1S1 ;
A1G1 14 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 14 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
,
113cd
5
—
10
,
15
“
16 Slokavarttika apoha 3a.
1 ] A1G1S1 ; +++++++ K1 1 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 1 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 2 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 5 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1S1 ;
++++ K1 8 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 8
] A1G1S1 ; K1 11 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1S1 ; ++ K1 11 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅] A1G1S1 ; K1(eyeskip) 12 ] A1G1 ;
S1 12 ] A1G1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1 ;
S1 14 ] A1G1 ; om. S1 16 ] A1G1K1 ; om.
S1
― 307 ―（14）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
,
113cd
5
—
10
,
15
“
16 Slokavarttika apoha 3a.
1 ] A1G1S1 ; +++++++ K1 1 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 1 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 2 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 5 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1S1 ;
++++ K1 8 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 8
] A1G1S1 ; K1 11 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1S1 ; ++ K1 11 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅] A1G1S1 ; K1(eyeskip) 12 ] A1G1 ;
S1 12 ] A1G1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1 ;
S1 14 ] A1G1 ; om. S1 16 ] A1G1K1 ; om.
S1
― 306 ―（15）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
”
114
,
, 5
,
,
,
— 10
115–116c
—
14 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] Praman. asamuccaya 5.2.
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 1
] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅] A1G1S1 ; ++++++++++++++++++ K1
2 ] A1G1 ; S1 5 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 5 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 5 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 6 ] A1G1K𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 ; K𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝
1 ; S1
6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 6 , ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ]
A1G1S1 ; ++++++++++++++++++ K1 6 ] A1G1 ;
S1 8 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 9 ]
A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 10 ] K1 ; +++++++++
+++++++++ K1 12 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
12 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 14 ] A1G1 ; +++ K1 ; S1
14 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] A1G1S1 ; +++++++++++++++ K1
5
—
116cd–117ab
— ,
,
10 ,
,
117cd
15 —
5 ] Slokavarttika apoha 130cd.
2 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 4 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] A1G1S1 ; +++
++++++++++++++ K1 4 ] A1G1 ; S1 6
] A1G1 ;
K1 ;
S1 8 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 8 —
] A1G1S1 ; +++++++++++++++++
K1 9 , ] A1G1K1 ; S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 9 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 10 ]
A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 11 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] A1G1S1 ;
+++++++++++++++++ K1 11 ] A1G1 ; S1
12 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 14 ] A1G1 ;
K1S1 14 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 15
] A1G1S1 ; K1
― 305 ―（16）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
5
—
116cd–117ab
— ,
,
10 ,
,
117cd
15 —
5 ] Slokavarttika apoha 130cd.
2 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 4 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] A1G1S1 ; +++
++++++++++++++ K1 4 ] A1G1 ; S1 6
] A1G1 ;
K1 ;
S1 8 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 8 —
] A1G1S1 ; +++++++++++++++++
K1 9 , ] A1G1K1 ; S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 9 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 10 ]
A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 11 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] A1G1S1 ;
+++++++++++++++++ K1 11 ] A1G1 ; S1
12 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 14 ] A1G1 ;
K1S1 14 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 15
] A1G1S1 ; K1
― 304 ―（17）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
118ab
,
—
118cd 5
,
,
10
,
, ,
—
119ab
15
,
3 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] A1G1S1 ; ++++++++++++
+++++ K1 3 ] A1G1 ; S1 4 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 6 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 6 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 7 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 7 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
7 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 7 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] A1
G1S1 ; +++++++++++++++++++ K1 8 ] G1K1 ;
A1S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 12
⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] A1G1S1 ; +++++++++++++++++++ K1
12 , ] A1G1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 15 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
15 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
—
119cd
5
,
—
120
10
—
14 Praman. asamuccaya 5.4a.
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1 ; S1 1
⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] A1G1S1 ; ++++++++++++++++++ K1
2 ] A1G1S1 ; +++ K1 2
] A1G1S1 ; K1 3 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
3 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 5 ] A1
G1K1 ; S1 5 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 5 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ]
A1G1S1 ; +++++++++++++++++++ K1 7 ] A1G1
S1 ; K1 9 ] A1G1K1S𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 ;
S𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅
] A1G1S1 ; +++++++++++++++++++ K1 10 ]
A1G1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1 ; S1 11 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1K𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 ;
K𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 14 ] A1G1S1 ; K1(unmetrical)
― 303 ―（18）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
—
119cd
5
,
—
120
10
—
14 Praman. asamuccaya 5.4a.
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1 ; S1 1
⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] A1G1S1 ; ++++++++++++++++++ K1
2 ] A1G1S1 ; +++ K1 2
] A1G1S1 ; K1 3 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
3 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 5 ] A1
G1K1 ; S1 5 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 5 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ]
A1G1S1 ; +++++++++++++++++++ K1 7 ] A1G1
S1 ; K1 9 ] A1G1K1S𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 ;
S𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅
] A1G1S1 ; +++++++++++++++++++ K1 10 ]
A1G1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1 ; S1 11 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1K𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 ;
K𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 14 ] A1G1S1 ; K1(unmetrical)
― 302 ―（19）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
—
121–122
, 5
,
10
1 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] A1G1S1 ; +++++++++++++++++++
K1 1 ] A1G1 ; S1 2 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 2 ] A1G1 ; +++ K1 ; S1
3 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1
5 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 5
] A1G1K1 ; S1 5 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 6 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 6 ] A1G1 ; + K1 ;
S1 6 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 8 ] A1G1S1 ; om. K1 9
] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ;
om. S1 9 ] A1G1S1 ; +++++ K1 10 ] A1G1K1 ;
om. S1 11 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 13 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 13 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 13 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
—
123ab
5 —
—
10
123cd
—
,
15
124ab
10 ] Jaiminisutra 1.3.33:
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 8 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 8 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 9 ] A1G1 ;
K1S1 9 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
10 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 10 ] K1 ;
A1G1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
11 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; om.
S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 14 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 14 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1
― 301 ―（20）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
—
123ab
5 —
—
10
123cd
—
,
15
124ab
10 ] Jaiminisutra 1.3.33:
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 8 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 8 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 9 ] A1G1 ;
K1S1 9 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
10 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 10 ] K1 ;
A1G1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
11 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; om.
S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 14 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 14 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1
― 300 ―（21）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
,
—
124cd
, 5
—
125ab
—
10
,
—
125cd
— 15
1 ] A1G𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 S1 ; G𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝
1 ; K1 1
] S1 ; A1G1 ; K1 2 ] K1 ;
A1G1S1 2 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 5 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 5 ] G1K1S1 ; A1 5 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 6 ]
A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 9
] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 12 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
13 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 15 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 15 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1(unmetrical)
126a
—
126b
5
—
126cd
—
10
127ab
—
127c
15 —
5 ] Praman. asamuccaya 5.4b:
2 ] A1G1K𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 ; K𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝
1 ;
S1 2 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 4 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 5 ] K1 ;
A1G1 ; S1 5 ] em. ;
A1G1 ; +++ K1 ; S1 5 ] A1G1K1 ;
S𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝1 ; S𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝
1 6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
6 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 8 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 9 ] G1K1S1 ; A1
10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 13 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 15 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 15 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 15 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
― 299 ―（22）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
126a
—
126b
5
—
126cd
—
10
127ab
—
127c
15 —
5 ] Praman. asamuccaya 5.4b:
2 ] A1G1K𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 ; K𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝
1 ;
S1 2 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 4 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 5 ] K1 ;
A1G1 ; S1 5 ] em. ;
A1G1 ; +++ K1 ; S1 5 ] A1G1K1 ;
S𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝1 ; S𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝
1 6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
6 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 8 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 9 ] G1K1S1 ; A1
10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 13 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 15 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 15 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 15 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
― 298 ―（23）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
,
127d
— ,
5
,
—
10
,
15
128abc
—
9 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] Praman. avarttika 1.84.
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
3 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 4 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅] A1G1K1 ;
S1(eyeskip) 7 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1
K1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1(unmetrical) 10 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1(unmetrical) 11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 12
] A1G1 ; ++ K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 14 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 14 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 14 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 15 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 17 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 17 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
,
5 —
128d
—
10 129ab
,
, ,
—
1 Praman. asamuccaya 5.8cd:
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1
] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 1 ]
A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 2 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 2 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
5 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 5 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 5 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 7 ] A1
G1S1 ; K1 7 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 7 ] A1G1S1 ; om. K1 8 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 9 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 11 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; S𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 ;
S𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎1 12 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 12 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1 ;
K1S1 13 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1
― 297 ―（24）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
,
5 —
128d
—
10 129ab
,
, ,
—
1 Praman. asamuccaya 5.8cd:
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1
] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 1 ]
A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 2 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 2 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
5 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 5 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 5 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 7 ] A1
G1S1 ; K1 7 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 7 ] A1G1S1 ; om. K1 8 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 9 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 11 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; S𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 ;
S𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎1 12 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 12 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1 ;
K1S1 13 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1
― 296 ―（25）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
—
5
129cd–130ab
— 10
130cd
—
—
, 15
3 Praman. asamuccaya 5.28ab.13 Praman. asamuccaya 5.9ab.
1 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 1 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 2 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 3 ] K1S1 ;
A1G1 3 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 5 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 8 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 10 ] A1
G1K1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ]
A1G1S1 ;
K1 12 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 14 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 14 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 15 ] A1G1 ;
K1S1 16 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1
“
”
,
5 “ ”
,
, “ ”
10 “ ”
“ ”
2 Source unknown. Cf. Pind 2015: II 42, n. 130.5 Praman. asamuccaya 5.9b.
6 ] Slokavarttika apoha 128d.
9 Slokavarttika apoha 88a (88–91).
10 Slokavarttika apoha 115a (115–119).
11 Slokavarttika apoha 120a (120–130ab).
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1
K1 ; S1 2 ” ] em. ; A1G1 ;
+++++ K1 ; S1 3 ] K1S1 ;
A1G1 3 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 5 ” ] A1G1
K1 ; S1 5 ] K1 ; A1G1 ;
S1 6 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 6 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 8 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 8
] A1G1S1 ; K1 8 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
9 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 9 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ] S1 ;
A1G1 ; K1 10 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ]
A1G1 ; om. K1 ; S1
― 295 ―（26）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
“
”
,
5 “ ”
,
, “ ”
10 “ ”
“ ”
2 Source unknown. Cf. Pind 2015: II 42, n. 130.5 Praman. asamuccaya 5.9b.
6 ] Slokavarttika apoha 128d.
9 Slokavarttika apoha 88a (88–91).
10 Slokavarttika apoha 115a (115–119).
11 Slokavarttika apoha 120a (120–130ab).
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1
K1 ; S1 2 ” ] em. ; A1G1 ;
+++++ K1 ; S1 3 ] K1S1 ;
A1G1 3 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 5 ” ] A1G1
K1 ; S1 5 ] K1 ; A1G1 ;
S1 6 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 6 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 8 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 8
] A1G1S1 ; K1 8 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
9 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 9 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ] S1 ;
A1G1 ; K1 10 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ]
A1G1 ; om. K1 ; S1
― 294 ―（27）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
131abcd
, , ,
5
—
—
, 10
131d
15
7 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] Praman. asamuccaya 5.9cd–10a.
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] K1S1 ;
A1G1 3 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 4 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 4 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 5 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
5 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 5 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 5 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 9 ] K1S1 ;
A1G1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10
] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
12 ] A1 ; G1 ; K1 ;
S1 12 ] A1G1S1 ; om. K1 13 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 15 ] A1G1 ;
++ K1 ; S1
—
132
—
,
5 “ ”
—
10
—
9 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] Pind’s reconstruction is different. Praman. a-
samuccaya 5.10cd–11ab:
12 Praman. asamuccaya 5.11b.
1 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 1 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 1 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 3 ] K1 ;
A1G1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 4
] A1G1K1 ; S1 4 ] K1 ; A1G1 ;
S1 5 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 6 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅] A1G1 ; K1(eyeskip) ; ⋅ ⋅ ⋅S1 6 ] A1G1 ; S1 7 ] S1 ; A1G1 7
] A1G1 ; om. S1 9 ] A1G1 ; S1
10 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 12 ] K1S1 ;
A1G1 13 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
― 293 ―（28）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
—
132
—
,
5 “ ”
—
10
—
9 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] Pind’s reconstruction is different. Praman. a-
samuccaya 5.10cd–11ab:
12 Praman. asamuccaya 5.11b.
1 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 1 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 1 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 3 ] K1 ;
A1G1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 4
] A1G1K1 ; S1 4 ] K1 ; A1G1 ;
S1 5 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 6 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅] A1G1 ; K1(eyeskip) ; ⋅ ⋅ ⋅S1 6 ] A1G1 ; S1 7 ] S1 ; A1G1 7
] A1G1 ; om. S1 9 ] A1G1 ; S1
10 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 12 ] K1S1 ;
A1G1 13 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
― 292 ―（29）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
5
“ ”
, 10
,
6 ] Cf. Brahmasiddhi 5.6: “
” ; Nyayavarttikatatparyat. ıka ad 4.2.1 (606.13):
14 ] S1 ; A1G1 ; K1 14 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 3 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 4 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 6
] A1G1K1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 6 ] S1 ;
A1G1K1 7 ] A1G𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 ; G𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎
1 S1 ; K1 8
] A1G1 ; K1S1 8 ] A1G1S1 ; om. K1 8
] A1G1S1 ; K1 9 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 10 , ] A1G1K1 ; S𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 ; S𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎
1
10 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 11 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 12 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 13 ] A1G1S1 ; om. K1
—
,
5
133ab
“ ” ,
—
10 , ,
“ ”
133cd
8 Praman. asamuccaya 5.11c.
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1S1 ; om. K1 1 ]
A1G1S1 ;
K1 2 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 2 ] K1S1 ; A1
G1 2 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 2 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 2 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 4 ] A1
G1S1 ; K1 4 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 4 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 7 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 7 ]
A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 9
] A1G1S1 ; K1 9 ] A1
G1 ; K1S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
10 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 10 ] K1S1 ;
A1G1 11 , ] A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 12 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 14 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 14 ] K1S1 ; A1G1
14 ] K1S1 ; A1G1
― 291 ―（30）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
—
,
5
133ab
“ ” ,
—
10 , ,
“ ”
133cd
8 Praman. asamuccaya 5.11c.
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1S1 ; om. K1 1 ]
A1G1S1 ;
K1 2 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 2 ] K1S1 ; A1
G1 2 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 2 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 2 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 4 ] A1
G1S1 ; K1 4 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 4 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 7 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 7 ]
A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 9
] A1G1S1 ; K1 9 ] A1
G1 ; K1S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
10 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 10 ] K1S1 ;
A1G1 11 , ] A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 12 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 14 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 14 ] K1S1 ; A1G1
14 ] K1S1 ; A1G1
― 290 ―（31）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
—
,
134
,
, 5
—
135ab
—
10
135cd
—
15
1 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 2 ] K1 ; A1G1 ;
S1 2 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 2 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 6 ]
A1G1S1 ;
K1 8 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 8 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 8 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
9 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 10
] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
13 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 14
] A1G1K1 ; S1 15 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
15 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 15 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1
—
,
5
136ab
—
10
136cd
—
137ab
1 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 1 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 1
] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 2 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1
3 ] A1G1 ; om. K1S1 4 ] A1G𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 K1S1 ; G𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝
1 4
] K1 ; A1G1 ;
S1 6 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 6 ] A1G1 ; K1S1
6 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 6
] A1G1 ; K1S1 7 ] S1 ;
A1G1K1 9 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 9 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 12 ] G1K1S1 ;
A1 12 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 12 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1
― 289 ―（32）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
—
,
5
136ab
—
10
136cd
—
137ab
1 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 1 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 1
] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 2 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1
3 ] A1G1 ; om. K1S1 4 ] A1G𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 K1S1 ; G𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝
1 4
] K1 ; A1G1 ;
S1 6 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 6 ] A1G1 ; K1S1
6 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 6
] A1G1 ; K1S1 7 ] S1 ;
A1G1K1 9 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 9 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 12 ] G1K1S1 ;
A1 12 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 12 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1
― 288 ―（33）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
,
—
137cd
, 5
—
138
,
— 10
139ab
—
139cd
15
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 2 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 3 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 3
] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 5 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 5 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 6 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 6 ] S1 ; K1 ;
A1G1 8 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 8 ]
A1G1K1 ; om. S1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 —
] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 12 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 13
] A1G1K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 15 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
,
—
,
5 140ab
,
, ,
10
—
140cd
—
15 141
1 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 1
] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 2 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 2 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 3 ] A1G1 ; om. K1S1
6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 8
] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 8 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 8 ] A1G1
S1 ; K1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 10 ] K1S1 ; A1G1
10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 11 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
14 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
― 287 ―（34）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
,
—
,
5 140ab
,
, ,
10
—
140cd
—
15 141
1 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 1
] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 2 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 2 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 3 ] A1G1 ; om. K1S1
6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 8
] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 8 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 8 ] A1G1
S1 ; K1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 10 ] K1S1 ; A1G1
10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 11 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
14 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
― 286 ―（35）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
,
—
142ab 5
,
—
142cd
, 10
—
143ab
,
4 ] Both readings, i.e., and , are attested
in Slokavarttika manuscripts.
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
2 ] A1G1K1S𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 ; S𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝
1 2
] A1G1S1 ; K1 3 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1
3 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 3 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 3 ]
K1S1 ; A1G1 3 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 4
] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 6 ] A1K1 ; G1 ;
S1 6 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 6 ] A1G1
K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1K𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 ; K𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝
1 ;
S1 8 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 12 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
14 ] A1G1S1 ; om. K1 14 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
,
,
—
5 143cd
, ,
10 —
144ab
—
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 1
] A1G1K1 ; S1 2 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 2 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1 ; K1S1
3 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 4 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
6 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 7
] A1G1K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 8 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 8 ] A1
G1K1 ; K1 8 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 ; S𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎
1 8 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10
] A1G1S1 ; K1 12 ]
A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 14 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 14 ] A1G1
S1 ; K1 14 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1
― 285 ―（36）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
,
,
—
5 143cd
, ,
10 —
144ab
—
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 1
] A1G1K1 ; S1 2 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 2 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1 ; K1S1
3 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 4 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
6 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 7
] A1G1K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 8 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 8 ] A1
G1K1 ; K1 8 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 ; S𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎
1 8 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10
] A1G1S1 ; K1 12 ]
A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 14 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 14 ] A1G1
S1 ; K1 14 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1
― 284 ―（37）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
144cd
,
—
145ab
, 5
—
—
10
,
145cd
—
,
— 15
146a
7 Quoted from Dignaga’s lost Hetumukha. Cf. Pind 2015: II 161, n. 539. Also
quoted in Tattvasangrahapanjika 385.11–12.
2 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 3 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 3
] A1G1S1 ; K1 5 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 7 ] G1K1
S1 ; A1 7 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 8 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 9 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 13 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 14 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 14 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 14 , ]
A1G𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 K1S1 ; G𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝
1 15 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
15 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
,
—
146ab
5
—
146cd
,
,
10
,
—
147ab
15
—
1 ] Slokavarttika apoha 36cd–41.
1 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 1 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 1 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 3 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 3 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 5 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
6 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 8 ] A1
G1K1 ; S1 8 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 9 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 9 ] K1S1 ;
A1G1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ]
A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 12 ] A1G𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 S1 ; G𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝
1 13 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1
― 283 ―（38）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
,
—
146ab
5
—
146cd
,
,
10
,
—
147ab
15
—
1 ] Slokavarttika apoha 36cd–41.
1 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 1 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 1 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 3 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 3 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 5 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
6 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 8 ] A1
G1K1 ; S1 8 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 9 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 9 ] K1S1 ;
A1G1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ]
A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 12 ] A1G𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 S1 ; G𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝
1 13 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1
― 282 ―（39）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
,
,
, 5
—
147cd
—
, 10
148ab
, ,
15
1 Praman. asamuccaya 5.28ab.
1 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 2 ] A1G1S1 ; om. K1
3 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 4 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 4 ] A1
G1 ; K1 ; S1 5 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 5 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 6 ]
A1G1K𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 ; K𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝
1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1
K1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 7 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 9 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 11 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 12
] A1G1S1 ; K1 12 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 14 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 14 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 15 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
,
,
, ,
5 ,
—
148cd
—
10 , ,
,
“ ”
,
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1
S1 ; K1 1 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 2
] A1G1K1 ; S1 2 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 2 ] A1G1 ; om. K1 ; S1 2 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 3 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 4
] A1G1S1 ; K1 4 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 5 ] K1S1 ; A1G1
6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
7 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 9
] A1G1S1 ; +++++ K1 10 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 11 ] G1 ; A1 ; K1 ;
S1 12 “ ” ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 13 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] A1G1 ;
⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] K1 ; om. S1
― 281 ―（40）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
,
,
, ,
5 ,
—
148cd
—
10 , ,
,
“ ”
,
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1
S1 ; K1 1 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 2
] A1G1K1 ; S1 2 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 2 ] A1G1 ; om. K1 ; S1 2 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 3 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 4
] A1G1S1 ; K1 4 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 5 ] K1S1 ; A1G1
6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
7 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 9
] A1G1S1 ; +++++ K1 10 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 11 ] G1 ; A1 ; K1 ;
S1 12 “ ” ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 13 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] A1G1 ;
⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] K1 ; om. S1
― 280 ―（41）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
—
“ ”
,
“ ”
, 5
149ab
,
,
“ ” 10
“ ” —
—
12 Pind’s reconstruction is different. Praman. asamuccaya 5.25cd:
1 , ] A1G1 ; ++++++ K1 2 ] A1G1 ;
K1 3 ] A1G1 ; K1 5 ]
A1G1 ; ++++++ K1 8 ] A1G1 ; K1 8
] A1G1 ; K1 9 ] A1G1 ; K1 9 ]
A1G1 ; K1 9 ] A1G1 ; K1 9 ] A1G1 ;
K1 10 ] A1G1 ; K1 10
“ ” ] A1G1S1 ; ++++ K1 10 ] A1
G1K1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 12 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 13 ] A1 ; G1 ; K1S1
13 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 14 ] A1G1 ; +++++
K1 ; S1 14 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
,
5 149cd
—
150ab
10
—
150cd
,
15 —
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 2 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3
] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1S1 ; ++
+++++ K1 3 ] S1 ; A1G1K1 6 ]
S1 ; A1G1 ; K1 6 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
7 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 7
] A1G1K1 ; S1 8 ] A1G1 ; ++++
K1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1S1 ; ++ K1 10 ] A1G1 ;
K1S1 10 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 11 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 11 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 13 ] A1K1S1 ; G1 14 ] A1G1K1 ; om.
S1 14 ] S1 ; A1G1 ; +++++++
K1 15 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
― 279 ―（42）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
,
5 149cd
—
150ab
10
—
150cd
,
15 —
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 2 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3
] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1S1 ; ++
+++++ K1 3 ] S1 ; A1G1K1 6 ]
S1 ; A1G1 ; K1 6 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
7 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 7
] A1G1K1 ; S1 8 ] A1G1 ; ++++
K1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1S1 ; ++ K1 10 ] A1G1 ;
K1S1 10 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 11 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 11 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 13 ] A1K1S1 ; G1 14 ] A1G1K1 ; om.
S1 14 ] S1 ; A1G1 ; +++++++
K1 15 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
― 278 ―（43）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
151
,
— 5
152
,
— 10
153
—
,
2 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 2 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 2 ] A1G1 ; om. K1 ; S1 2 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 2 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 4 ] A1G1S1 ; ++++++ K1 4 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 5 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 7 ]
A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 8 ] A1G1S1 ; ++
+ K1 8 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 8 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 8 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 9 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 9 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 9 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1S1 ;
K𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 ;
K𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎1
12 ] A1G1S1 ; ++++ K1 12 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 14 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 14 ] A1G1S1 ;
++++++ K1
“ ”
—
154ab
5 —
— —
10
154cd–155a
,
6 Pind’s reconstruction is different. Praman. asamuccaya 5.31ab:
,
8 Slokavarttika apoha 75cd.
1 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 1 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 1 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 2 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 2 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 3 ]
A1G1S1 ;
K1 5 ] A1G1S1 ; ++++++ K1 5
] A1G1K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 7 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
7 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 8 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1(unmetrical) 8 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 9 ] A1
G1K1 ; S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 9 ]
A1G1 ; ++++++++ K1 ; S1 10 ]
A1G1 ; K1S1 12 ] A1G1S1 ; om. K1 13 ] A1
G1 ; K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1
― 277 ―（44）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
“ ”
—
154ab
5 —
— —
10
154cd–155a
,
6 Pind’s reconstruction is different. Praman. asamuccaya 5.31ab:
,
8 Slokavarttika apoha 75cd.
1 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 1 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 1 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 2 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 2 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 3 ]
A1G1S1 ;
K1 5 ] A1G1S1 ; ++++++ K1 5
] A1G1K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 7 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
7 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 8 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1(unmetrical) 8 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 9 ] A1
G1K1 ; S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 9 ]
A1G1 ; ++++++++ K1 ; S1 10 ]
A1G1 ; K1S1 12 ] A1G1S1 ; om. K1 13 ] A1
G1 ; K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1
― 276 ―（45）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
—
155bcd
—
—
5
—
156a
—
10
, —
156bcd
—
5 Praman. asamuccaya 5.31c.12 Praman. asamuccaya 5.26ab. Also quoted in Tattvasangrahapanjika 379.7–
8.
1 ] A1G1 ; ++++
K1 ; S1 3 ] K1 ;
A1G1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 6
] em. ; A1G1 ; + K1 ; S1 6 ]
A1G1S1 ; +++ K1 7 ] A1G1K1S𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 ; om. S𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝
1 7 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 9
] A1G1S1 ; K1 9 ] S1 ; om. A1G1K1
9 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 10 ] em. ;
A1G1 ; ++++ K1 ; S1 10 ] em. ;
A1G1K1S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 12 ] A1
G1K1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 14 ] A1G1S1 ; +++
K1
“ ”
“ ”
“
” , ,
5
157a
—
10 ,
,
,
157b
1 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 1 “ ” ] A1G1
K1 ; om. S1 2 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 2 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 2 ” ] A1G1 ; K1S1 3 ] A1G1
K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1S1 ; +++++ K1 3 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 4 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 5 ]
A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 5
] A1G1 ; K1S1 6 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1 ; K1
S1 8 ] A1G1 ; +++++ K1 ; S1
8 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 9 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 10 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 11
] A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1S1 ; ++
++ K1 12 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 12 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 13 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
― 275 ―（46）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
“ ”
“ ”
“
” , ,
5
157a
—
10 ,
,
,
157b
1 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 1 “ ” ] A1G1
K1 ; om. S1 2 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 2 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 2 ” ] A1G1 ; K1S1 3 ] A1G1
K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1S1 ; +++++ K1 3 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 4 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 5 ]
A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 5
] A1G1 ; K1S1 6 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1 ; K1
S1 8 ] A1G1 ; +++++ K1 ; S1
8 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 9 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 10 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 11
] A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ] A1G1S1 ; ++
++ K1 12 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 12 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 13 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
― 274 ―（47）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
,
,
—
157cd 5
,
—
, 10
1 ] S1 ; A1G1K1 1 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 1 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 1 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 3 ] A1G1 ; om. K1 ;
S𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 ; S𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎
1 3 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅] A1G1 ; om. K1 ;
S1 4 ] A1G1S1 ; + K1 4 — ]
A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 6
]
em. ;
A1G1 ;
K1 ;
S1 7 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 8
] S1 ; K1 ; A1G1
9 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ]
A1G1K1 ; om. S1
158
5 ,
10 ,
, ,
,
,
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 3 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 3 ] G1K1 ; A1 ;
S1 3 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 5 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 5 ] A1G𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 K1S1 ; G𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝
1 6
] A1G1K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 7
] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1
8 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ]
G𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 ; A1G
𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝1 ; K1 ; S1 11
] em. ; A1G1K1 ; S1 12 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 12 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 13 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
14 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 14
] A1G1S1 ; K1
― 273 ―（48）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
158
5 ,
10 ,
, ,
,
,
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 3 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 3 ] G1K1 ; A1 ;
S1 3 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 5 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 5 ] A1G𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 K1S1 ; G𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝
1 6
] A1G1K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 7
] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1
8 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 11 ]
G𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 ; A1G
𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝1 ; K1 ; S1 11
] em. ; A1G1K1 ; S1 12 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 12 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 13 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
14 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 14
] A1G1S1 ; K1
― 272 ―（49）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
—
— 5
159a
—
159ab
—
10
159cd
15
3 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] Praman. asamuccaya 5.35.
1 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
3 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 3 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 4 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 4 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 5 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 5 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 7 ]
K1S1 ; A1G1 7 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 9 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 9 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 12 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 12 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 15 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 15 ]
A1G1 ; K1S1
—
5 160ab
,
—
160cd
10 —
161
—
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 2 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 3 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
3 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 4 ]
A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 6
] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 7 ] A1
G1K1 ; om. S1 7 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 8 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 8 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 10 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 11 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 13 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 13 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 14 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1
14 ] A1G1 ; K1S1
― 271 ―（50）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
—
5 160ab
,
—
160cd
10 —
161
—
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 2 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 3 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
3 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 4 ]
A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 6
] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 7 ] A1
G1K1 ; om. S1 7 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 8 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 8 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 10 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 11 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 13 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 13 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 14 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1
14 ] A1G1 ; K1S1
― 270 ―（51）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
,
, 5
162abc
— , 10
,
,
162cd
,
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 2
] A1G1K1 ; S1 2 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 3 ]
G1K1S1 ; A1 4 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 4 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 5 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 5 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 5 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; om. S1 7 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 7 ] A1
G1S1 ; om. K1 9 ] A1G1S1 ; om. K1 9 ] A1G1 ;
K1S1 10 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 11 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 11 ] K𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 S1 ; ¯ ¯ ¯ A1G1 ; K𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝
1
11 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 12 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 12 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 14 ] K1S1 ;
A1G1
—
5 , “ ”
10
163
, “
”
5 Praman. avarttikasvavr.tti 32.17: ; see
also Nyayamanjarı (Kataoka 2009: 471(28), section 2.3).
14 Praman. asamuccaya 5.36d.
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1 ;
K1S1 1 ] K1S1 ; ¯ ¯ ¯ A1G1 2 ] K1S1 ;
A1G1 3 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 4 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 5 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 5 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
7 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 9 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 12 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 13 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 13 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 ;
S𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎1 14 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
― 269 ―（52）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
—
5 , “ ”
10
163
, “
”
5 Praman. avarttikasvavr.tti 32.17: ; see
also Nyayamanjarı (Kataoka 2009: 471(28), section 2.3).
14 Praman. asamuccaya 5.36d.
1 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1 ;
K1S1 1 ] K1S1 ; ¯ ¯ ¯ A1G1 2 ] K1S1 ;
A1G1 3 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 4 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 5 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 5 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
7 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 9 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 12 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 13 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 13 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 ;
S𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎1 14 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
― 268 ―（53）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
—
164
—
,
5
165
—
, 10
1 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 ; S𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎
1 1 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1
4 ] A1K1S1 ; G1 4 ] G1K1S1 ;
A1 4 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 4
] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 5 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 5 ] K1 ; A1G1 ;
S1 8 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 9 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 10 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 10 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 10 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 11 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 11 ]
G1 ; A1 ; K1 ; S1 11
] A1G1K1 ; S𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 ; S𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎
1 12 ] S1 ;
A1G1K1 12 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] A1G1S1 ; K1(eyeskip) 12
] A1G1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1 ; S1 12 ] A1G1 ;
S1
166abc
,
—
5 ,
,
,
166cd
10 ,
—
167ab
,
1 ] A1G1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1 ; S1 1
] A1G1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1 ; S1 3 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 4 ] A1G1 ;
K𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 ; K𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎
1 ; S1
4 ] A1G𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎1 S1 ; G𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎
1 K1 5 ] K1S1 ; A1G1
5 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 5 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 6 ]
A1G1S1 ; om. K1 6 ] S1 ; A1G1K1 7 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 7
] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ] S1 ;
A1G1K1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 11 ] A1G1S1 ; +++ K1 13 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 13 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] A1G1 ; ⋅ ⋅ ⋅S1 ; K1 14 ] A1 ; G1(marked) ;
S1
― 267 ―（54）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
166abc
,
—
5 ,
,
,
166cd
10 ,
—
167ab
,
1 ] A1G1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1 ; S1 1
] A1G1 ; S1 3 ] A1G1 ; S1 3 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 4 ] A1G1 ;
K𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎1 ; K𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎
1 ; S1
4 ] A1G𝑝𝑝𝑎𝑎1 S1 ; G𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎
1 K1 5 ] K1S1 ; A1G1
5 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 5 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1 ; K1S1 6 ]
A1G1S1 ; om. K1 6 ] S1 ; A1G1K1 7 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 7 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 7
] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ] S1 ;
A1G1K1 11 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 11 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 11 ] A1G1S1 ; +++ K1 13 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 13 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] A1G1 ; ⋅ ⋅ ⋅S1 ; K1 14 ] A1 ; G1(marked) ;
S1
― 266 ―（55）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
—
167cd
—
5
168
,
, 10
—
169a
—
169bc
— 15
1 ] A1G1 ; S1 1 ] A1G1 ; S1 1 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅] A1G1 ; K1 ; om. S1 1 ]
G1K1 ; A1 2 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 4
] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 5 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 5 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 5 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 6
] em. ; A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 8 ] A1G1S1 ; +++ K1 8
] A1G1 ; ++ K1 ; S1 8 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
10 , ] A1G1K1 ; S1 10 ] A1
G1S1 ; K1 13 ]
A1G1S1 ; ++++++++++++++++ K1
,
,
170ab
5 ,
—
170cd
—
10
171
,
,
1 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 2
] K1 ; A1G1S1 2 ] K1S1 ; A1G1
2 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 5 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 6 ]
A1G1 ; K1S1 6 ] A1G𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 K1 ;
G𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 7 ] A1G𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 K1S1 ; G𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝
1 7
] S1 ;
A1G1 ; K1 9 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 10 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 12
] A1G1S1 ; K1 12 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1
K𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 S1 ; K𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝
1 13 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 13
] A1G1K1 ; S1 14 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 14 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1
― 265 ―（56）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
,
,
170ab
5 ,
—
170cd
—
10
171
,
,
1 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 2
] K1 ; A1G1S1 2 ] K1S1 ; A1G1
2 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 5 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 6 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 6 ]
A1G1 ; K1S1 6 ] A1G𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 K1 ;
G𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 7 ] A1G𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 K1S1 ; G𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝
1 7
] S1 ;
A1G1 ; K1 9 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 9 ] A1G1K1 ; om. S1 10 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 12
] A1G1S1 ; K1 12 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1
K𝑝𝑝𝑝𝑝1 S1 ; K𝑎𝑎𝑝𝑝
1 13 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 13
] A1G1K1 ; S1 14 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 14 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1
― 264 ―（57）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
—
172ab
,
— 5
172cd
, ,
— 10
173
—
15
1 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 3 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 4 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 4 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
4 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 5 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 6 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 8 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 8 ] A1G1K1 ; S1
8 ] A1G1K1 ; S1 9 ] A1G1K1 ;
K1 ; S1 10 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
12 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 12 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 12 ] K1S1 ; A1G1 13 ] A1
G1 ; K1 ; S1 14 ]
A1G1K1 ; S1 14 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 14 ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 15 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 15 ]
A1G1K1 ; om. S1
174
—
, ,
5
175
—
, ,
10 176
2 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 3
] A1G1S1 ; K1 3 , ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 4 ] A1G1S1 ; om. K1 7 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 7 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 7 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 8 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
9 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 11
] A1G1 ; K1S1 12 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 13 ] S1 ; A1G1 ;
K1 13 ] K1S1 ; ¯ A1G1 13 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1
― 263 ―（58）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
174
—
, ,
5
175
—
, ,
10 176
2 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 3
] A1G1S1 ; K1 3 , ] A1G1 ; K1 ;
S1 4 ] A1G1S1 ; om. K1 7 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1 7 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 7 ]
A1G1S1 ; K1 8 ] A1G1S1 ; K1
9 ] A1G1 ; K1 ; S1 11
] A1G1 ; K1S1 12 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ; S1 13 ] A1G1S1 ;
K1 13 ] S1 ; A1G1 ;
K1 13 ] K1S1 ; ¯ A1G1 13 ] A1G1K1 ;
S1
― 262 ―（59）
A Critical Edition of Kāsikā ad S lokavārttika apoha vv. 95-176
—
1 ] Mahabharata Vanaparvan 313.117:
1 ] A1G1S1 ; K1 1 ] A1G1 ; K1S1
1 ] A1G1 ;
K1 ;
S1 3 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ] A1G1 ;
K1 ;
S1
― 261 ―（60）
東洋文化硏究所紀要 第 175 册
top related