draft for public comment australian/new zealand standard · performance of electrical...
Post on 22-Jul-2020
0 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
103934 AS NZS 3823.4.2 2014 Amdt 1 Public Comment.doc - 11/10/2016 13:27:37
COMMITTEE EL-056
DR AS/NZS 3823.4.2:2014 Amd 1:2016
(Project ID: 103934)
Draft for Public Comment Australian/New Zealand Standard LIABLE TO ALTERATION—DO NOT USE AS A STANDARD
BEGINNING DATE FOR COMMENT:
18 October 2016
CLOSING DATE FOR COMMENT:
20 December 2016
Important: The procedure for public comment has changed – please read the instructions on the inside cover of this document.
Amendment 1 to AS/NZS 3823.4.2:2014 Performance of electrical appliances—Air conditioners and heat pumps Part 4.2: Air-cooled air conditioners and air-to-air heat pumps—Testing and calculating methods for seasonal performance factors—Heating seasonal performance factor (ISO 16358-2:2013 (MOD))
COPYRIGHT
103934 AS NZS 3823.4.2 2014 Amdt 1 Public Comment.doc - 11/10/2016 13:27:37
Draft for Public Comment Australian/New Zealand Standard
The committee responsible for the issue of this draft comprised representatives of organizations interested in the subject matter of the proposed Standard. These organizations are listed on the inside back cover.
Comments are invited on the technical content, wording and general arrangement of the draft.
The method for submission of comment on this document is to register and fill in an online form via Standards Hub Website. Instructions and examples of comment submission are available on the website. . Please use the following link—
https://hub.standards.org.au/hub/public/listOpenCommentingPublication.action
Comment must be via Hub, any emails or forms sent to us by fax or mail will not be considered by the Committee when it reviews the Public Comment received.
Please place relevant clause numbers beside each comment.
Editorial matters (i.e. spelling, punctuation, grammar etc.) will be corrected before final publication.
The coordination of the requirements of this draft with those of any related Standards is of particular importance and you are invited to point out any areas where this may be necessary.
Please provide supporting reasons and suggested wording for each comment. Where you consider that specific content is too simplistic, too complex or too detailed please provide an alternative.
If the draft is acceptable without change, an acknowledgment to this effect would be appreciated.
Once you have registered and submitted you comments via the online form, your comments are automatically submitted to the committee for review.
Normally no acknowledgment of comment is sent. All comments received via the Standards Hub Website by the due date will be reviewed and considered by the relevant drafting committee. We cannot guarantee that comments submitted in other forms will be considered along with those submitted via the Standards Hub online form. Where appropriate, changes will be incorporated before the Standard is formally approved.
If you know of other persons or organizations that may wish to comment on this draft Standard, could you please advise them of its availability. Further copies of the draft are available from the Publisher SAI Global at http://www.saiglobal.com/
SAI GLOBAL Customer Service Centre
Telephone: 13 12 42
Facsimile: 1300 65 49 49
e-mail: mailto:sales@saiglobal.com
Internet: http://www.saiglobal.com/shop
103934 AS NZS 3823.4.2 2014 Amdt 1 Public Comment.doc - 11/10/2016 13:27:37
Draft for Public Comment
STANDARDS AUSTRALIA/STANDARDS NEW ZEALAND
Committee EL-056—Room Air Conditioners
DRAFT
Australian/New Zealand Standard
Performance of electrical appliances—Air conditioners and heat pumps
Part 4.2: Air-cooled air conditioners and air-to-air heat pumps—Testing and calculating methods for seasonal performance factors—Heating seasonal
performance factor (ISO 16358-2:2013 (MOD))
(Amendment 1 to AS/NZS 3823.4.2:2014)
Comment on the draft is invited from people and organizations concerned with this subject. It would be appreciated if those submitting comment would follow the guidelines given on the inside front cover.
Important: The procedure for public comment has changed – please read the instructions on the inside cover of this document
This document is a draft Australian/New Zealand Standard only and is liable to alteration in the light of comment received. It is not to be regarded as an Australian/New Zealand Standard until finally issued as such by Standards Australia/Standards New Zealand.
DRAFT ONLY 1 DRAFT ONLY
103934 AS NZS 3823.4.2 2014 Amdt 1 Public Comment.doc - 11/10/2016 13:27:37
AS/NZS 3823.4.2/Amdt 1/
STANDARDS AUSTRALIA/STANDARDS NEW ZEALAND
Amendment No. 1 to
AS/NZS 3823.4.2:2014 Performance of electrical appliances—Air conditioners and heat pumps
Part 4.2: Air-cooled air conditioners and air-to-air heat pumps—Testing and calculating methods for seasonal performance factors—Heating seasonal performance
factor (ISO 16358-2:2013 (MOD))
REVISED TEXT
The 2014 edition of AS/NZS 3823.4.2 is amended as follows; the amendments should be inserted in the appropriate places.
SUMMARY: This Amendment applies to the Preface, Appendix ZZ and Appendix ZA (new)
Published on . Approved for publication in New Zealand on behalf of the Standards Council of New Zealand on
Preface
At the end of the third paragraph, add the following sentence:
Appendix ZA has been added to provide information on the development of the climate files for Australia and New Zealand.
Appendix ZZ
ZZ2 Delete the text of Paragraph ZZ2 and replace with the following:
The following modifications are required for Australian/New Zealand conditions:
3.12 Delete the definition in Clause 3.12 and replace with the following:
heating full-load operation
operation with the equipment and controls configured for maximum continuous refrigeration capacity at H1, H2 or H3 conditions, the compressor setting is the same for all conditions
3.13 Delete the definition in Clause 3.13 and replace with the following: heating extended-load operation
operation of the equipment at maximum continuous refrigeration capacity at a higher compressor capacity than full-load operation at H2 or H3 conditions, where this mode is available
6.2 Third paragraph, delete the equation and replace with the following: 0 10015 C and 0 Ct t
6.3 After the third paragraph, add the following text: The calculation of Australian and New Zealand cooling and heating seasonal
performance factors is based on temperature bin distributions for three reference climate files. They are derived from the 2016 Nationwide House Energy Rating Scheme (NatHERS) climate files. These consist of a typical meteorological year (TMY) file compiled from raw Bureau of Meteorology climate data.
AMDT No. 1
AMDT No. 1
DRAFT ONLY 2 DRAFT ONLY
103934 AS NZS 3823.4.2 2014 Amdt 1 Public Comment.doc - 11/10/2016 13:27:37
Table 3 Delete Table 3 and replace with the following three tables:
TABLE 3.1
REFERENCE OUTDOOR TEMPERATURE BIN DISTRIBUTION FOR ‘HOT/HUMID’ ZONE
Bin number j
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Outdoor temperature tj °C
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1 2
Fractional bin hours
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Bin hours nj n1 n2 n3 n4 n5 n6 n7 n8 n9 n10 n11 n12 n13
Reference bin hours (nj)
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Bin number j
14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
Total
Outdoor temperature tj °C
3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
Fractional bin hours
0.004 0.014 0.036 0.061 0.105 0.108 0.191 0.155 0.108 0.094 0.069 0.054
Bin hours nj n14 n15 n16 n17 n18 n19 n20 n21 n22 n23 n24 n25
Reference bin hours (nj)
1 4 10 17 29 30 53 43 30 26 19 15 277
DRAFT ONLY 3 DRAFT ONLY
103934 AS NZS 3823.4.2 2014 Amdt 1 Public Comment.doc - 11/10/2016 13:27:37
TABLE 3.2
REFERENCE OUTDOOR TEMPERATURE BIN DISTRIBUTION FOR ‘MIXED’ ZONE
Bin number j
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Outdoor temperature tj °C
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1 2
Fractional bin hours
0 0 0 0 0 0 0.001 0.001 0.003 0.007 0.018 0.029 0.036
Bin hours nj
n1 n2 n3 n4 n5 n6 n7 n8 n9 n10 n11 n12 n13
Reference bin hours (nj)
0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 4 9 23 37 47
Bin number j
14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
Outdoor temperature tj °C
3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
Fractional bin hours
0.050 0.084 0.077 0.102 0.099 0.095 0.111 0.087 0.080 0.061 0.041 0.020
Bin hours nj
n14 n15 n16 n17 n18 n19 n20 n21 n22 n23 n24 n25
Reference bin hours (nj)
64 108 99 132 128 122 143 112 103 79 53 26 1291
DRAFT ONLY 4 DRAFT ONLY
103934 AS NZS 3823.4.2 2014 Amdt 1 Public Comment.doc - 11/10/2016 13:27:37
TABLE 3.3
REFERENCE OUTDOOR TEMPERATURE BIN DISTRIBUTION FOR ‘COLD’ ZONE
Bin number j
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Outdoor temperature tj °C
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1 2
Fractional bin hours
0 0 0 0 0.001 0.005 0.008 0.017 0.020 0.026 0.029 0.044 0.045
Bin hours nj
n1 n2 n3 n4 n5 n6 n7 n8 n9 n10 n11 n12 n13
Reference bin hours (nj)
0 0 0 0 3 13 22 44 54 69 77 116 121
Bin number j
14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
Total
Outdoor temperature tj °C
3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
Fractional bin hours
0.059 0.064 0.081 0.089 0.123 0.098 0.092 0.071 0.061 0.038 0.020 0.009
Bin hours nj
n14 n15 n16 n17 n18 n19 n20 n21 n22 n23 n24 n25
Reference bin hours (nj)
156 169 216 238 327 262 245 189 163 101 52 23 2660
6.4.4 Delete Item b) 2) of Formula 11 and replace with the following: h j ful, jFullcapacityoperation fL t t
j PL j 1X t F t
j ful, jft t in Formula (11)
j ful, jfP t P t
Annex A Delete Figures A.1, A.2, A.3 and A.4 and replace with the following:
DRAFT ONLY 5 DRAFT ONLY
103934 AS NZS 3823.4.2 2014 Amdt 1 Public Comment.doc - 11/10/2016 13:27:37
OUTDOOR TEMPERATURE, °C
CA
PA
CIT
Y o
r L
OA
D,
WP
OW
ER
IN
PU
T,
W
t j
t100
P fu l(-7)
P fu l(7)
P fu l , f(2)
Φ fu l(7)
Φ fu l(-7)
Φ fu l(2)
0.82 × Φ fu l(7)
-7 0 2 5.5 7 10 to
Lh(t j)
Φ fu l(t j)
Φ fu l , f(t j)
P fu l(t j)
P fu l , f(t j)
FIGURE A.1 HEATING CAPACITY, POWER INPUT AND LOAD FOR FIXED CAPACITY UNITS
DRAFT ONLY 6 DRAFT ONLY
103934 AS NZS 3823.4.2 2014 Amdt 1 Public Comment.doc - 11/10/2016 13:27:37
OUTDOOR TEMPERATURE, °C
CA
PA
CIT
Y o
r L
OA
D,
WP
OW
ER
IN
PU
T,
W
t j
to
t100
P fu l(-7)
P fu l(7)
Pmin(7)
Pmin(-7)
P fu l , f(2)
Pmin,f(2)
Φ fu l(-7)
Φ min(-7)
Φ min(7)
Φ fu l(7)
Φ min,f(2)
Φ fu l , f(2)0.82 × Φ fu l(7)
-7 0 2 5.5 7 10
Lh(t j)
Φ fu l(t j)
Φ min(t j)Φ fu l , f(t j)
Φ min,f(t j)
P fu l(t j)
Pmin(t j)P fu l , f(t j)
Pmin,f(t j)
FIGURE A.2 HEATING CAPACITY, POWER INPUT AND LOAD FOR TWO-STAGE CAPACITY UNITS
DRAFT ONLY 7 DRAFT ONLY
103934 AS NZS 3823.4.2 2014 Amdt 1 Public Comment.doc - 11/10/2016 13:27:37
OUTDOOR TEMPERATURE, °C
CA
PA
CIT
Y o
r L
OA
D,
WP
OW
ER
IN
PU
T,
W
t j
t h t f tg td te t r
t100
tq
ta
P fu l(7)
P haf(7)
P haf(-7)
P fu l(-7)
Pmin(7)
Pmin(-7)
Pex t ,f(2)
Pex t(-7)
Φ min(-7)
Φ fu l(7)
Φ haf(7)
Φ min(7)Φ haf(-7)
Φex t ,f(2)
Φ fu l(-7)
Φex t(-7)0.82 × Φ fu l(7)
-7 0 25.5
7 10
Φ fu l(t j)
Φex t(t j)
Φ min(t j)
Φ haf(t j)
Φ min,f(t j)
Φ haf,f(t j)
Φ fu l , f(t j)
Φex t ,f(t j)
P fu l(t j)
Pex t(t j)
Pmin(t j)
P haf(t j)P fu l , f(t j)
Pex t ,f(t j)
Pmin,f(t j)
P haf,f(t j)
Lh(t j)
to
FIGURE A.3 HEATING CAPACITY, POWER INPUT AND LOAD FOR MULTI-STAGE CAPACITY UNITS
DRAFT ONLY 8 DRAFT ONLY
103934 AS NZS 3823.4.2 2014 Amdt 1 Public Comment.doc - 11/10/2016 13:27:37
OUTDOOR TEMPERATURE, °C
CA
PA
CIT
Y o
r L
OA
D,
WP
OW
ER
IN
PU
T,
WC
OE
FF
EC
IEN
T o
fP
ER
FR
OM
AN
CE
(CO
P)
t j
t h t f tg td te t rtq
ta
P fu l(7)
P haf(7)
P haf(-7)
P fu l(-7)
Pmin(7)
Pmin(-7)
Pex t ,f(2)
COP,ex t ,f(t f)
COP,haf,f(te)COP,haf(td)COP,min(tq) COP,mh(t j)
COP,mh,f(t j)COP,ht ,f(t j)COP,fe,f(t j)
COP,fu l l , f(tg)
Pex t(-7)
Φ min(-7)
Φ fu l(7)
Φ haf(7)
Φ min(7)Φ haf(-7)
Φex t ,f(2)
Φ fu l(-7)
Φex t(-7)0.82 × Φ fu l(7)
-7 0 2
5.5
7 10
Φ fu l(t j)
Φex t(t j)
Φ min(t j)
Φ haf(t j)
Φ min,f(t j)
Φ haf,f(t j)
Φ fu l , f(t j)
Φex t ,f(t j)
P fu l(t j)
Pex t(t j)
Pmin(t j)
P haf(t j)P fu l , f(t j)
Pex t ,f(t j)
Pmin,f(t j)
P haf,f(t j)
Lh(t j)
to
t100
FIGURE A.4 HEATING CAPACITY, POWER INPUT, LOAD AND COP FOR VARIABLE CAPACITY UNITS
Annex B
B.2 Insert the following sentence at the beginning of the first paragraph of B.2:
If the electric power consumption during inactive mode can be reliably determined by evaluation of control systems, this may be used as an alternative to the full physical tests of this Annex.
B.3 Delete the last paragraph of B.3 and replace with the following:
The default mode hours for the calculation of reference total heating seasonal performance factor are shown in Tables B.2.1, B.2.2 and B.2.3. The calculation of total heating seasonal performance factor may also be undertaken for other distributions of mode hours.
DRAFT ONLY 9 DRAFT ONLY
103934 AS NZS 3823.4.2 2014 Amdt 1 Public Comment.doc - 11/10/2016 13:27:37
Table B.2 Delete Table B.2 and replace with the following three tables:
TABLE B.2.1
DEFAULT HOURS BY MODE FOR THE CALCULATION OF REFERENCE TOTAL HEATING SEASONAL PERFORMANCE FACTOR FOR THE ‘HOT/HUMID’ ZONE
Unit Active mode
h
Inactive mode, Hia
h
Disconnected mode
h
Heating only unit 277 6236 2247
Reversible unit 277
(Cooling operation: 2247) 6236 0
TABLE B.2.2
DEFAULT HOURS BY MODE FOR THE CALCULATION OF REFERENCE TOTAL HEATING SEASONAL PERFORMANCE FACTOR FOR THE ‘MIXED’ ZONE
Unit Active mode
h
Inactive mode, Hia
h
Disconnected mode
h
Heating only unit 1291 6629 840
Reversible unit 1291
(Cooling operation: 840) 6629 0
TABLE B.2.3
DEFAULT HOURS BY MODE FOR THE CALCULATION OF REFERENCE TOTAL HEATING SEASONAL PERFORMANCE FACTOR FOR THE ‘COLD’ ZONE
Unit Active mode
h
Inactive mode, Hia
h
Disconnected mode
h
Heating only unit 2660 5555 545
Reversible unit 2660
(Cooling operation: 545) 5555 0
DRAFT ONLY 10 DRAFT ONLY
103934 AS NZS 3823.4.2 2014 Amdt 1 Public Comment.doc - 11/10/2016 13:27:37
Appendix ZA
Add new Appendix ZA.
APPENDIX ZA
DEVELOPMENT OF THE AUSTRALIAN/NEW ZEALAND CLIMATE FILES
(Informative)
ZA1 HOT/HUMID ZONE FILES
The ‘hot/humid’ zone (see Figure ZA1) file is based on the 2016 NatHERS TMY(A) file for Rockhampton, Queensland. Rockhampton is situated on the Tropic of Capricorn and is located geographically and meteorologically between the milder climates of the heavily populated south-east of the zone and the sparsely populated northern tropical areas.
The heating season for the hot/humid zone is considered to be from 1 June to 30 September and all hours during this period are tallied. Heating condition temperatures that occur outside these months are not considered.
To account for the likelihood of a residential user turning on their unit in response to the outdoor temperature (tj), a percentage was applied to each bin’s total, as per Table ZA1. At milder temperatures, there is a reduced proportion of hours counted. The percentage increases as the temperature drops, as colder conditions increase the likelihood of heating being used.
ZA2 MIXED ZONE FILES
The ‘mixed’ zone file (see Figure ZA1) is based on the 2016 NatHERS TMY(A) file for Richmond, New South Wales. The mixed zone covers a large population and represents areas where both very hot and very cold weather can be encountered. As heating performance at H2 is important for determining seasonal performance, it is desirable to have a representative location that has an adequate number of bin hours at lower temperatures for this performance to be demonstrated. Coastal locations tend to have milder overnight temperatures, so Richmond, which is slightly inland, allows the calculation of seasonal performance at both low and high temperatures.
The heating season for the mixed zone is considered to be from 1 May to 30 September and all hours during this period are tallied. Heating condition temperatures that occur outside these months are not considered.
To account for the likelihood of a residential user turning on their unit in response to the outdoor temperature (tj), a percentage was applied to each bin’s total, as per Table ZA1. At milder temperatures, there is a reduced proportion of hours counted. The percentage increases as the temperature drops, as colder conditions increase the likelihood of heating being used.
ZA3 COLD ZONE FILES
The ‘cold’ zone file (see Figure ZA1) is based on the TMY(A) file for Canberra in the Australian Capital Territory. In addition to a high annual heating load, Canberra experiences many bin hours within the critical frosting temperature range. Locations closer to the coast, while still having a high annual heating load, will not adequately demonstrate seasonal energy consumption that reflects H2 performance. Canberra also has a sufficient number of cooling hours to allow meaningful cooling performance to be demonstrated. This is not the case for the colder, largely unpopulated alpine and sub-alpine regions or New Zealand.
AMDT No. 1
DRAFT ONLY 11 DRAFT ONLY
103934 AS NZS 3823.4.2 2014 Amdt 1 Public Comment.doc - 11/10/2016 13:27:37
The heating season for the cold zone is considered to be 1 April to 31 October and all hours during this period are tallied. Heating condition temperatures that occur outside these months are not considered.
To account for the likelihood of a residential user turning on their unit in response to the outdoor temperature (tj), a percentage was applied to each bin’s total, as per Table ZA1. At milder temperatures, there is a reduced proportion of hours counted. The percentage increases as the temperature drops, as colder conditions increase the likelihood of heating being used.
LEGEND: White = hot/humid zone Grey = mixed zone Black = cold zone
FIGURE ZA1 VISUAL REPRESENTATION OF THE THREE CLIMATE ZONES USED FOR AUSTRALIA AND NEW ZEALAND
DRAFT ONLY 12 DRAFT ONLY
103934 AS NZS 3823.4.2 2014 Amdt 1 Public Comment.doc - 11/10/2016 13:27:37
TABLE ZA1
FRACTION OF HEATING SEASON HOURS INCORPORATED INTO TEMPERATURE BIN DISTRIBUTION TABLES
Bin number j Outdoor temperature tj °C Fraction of raw hours counted
1 10 0.95
2 9 0.95
3 8 0.95
4 7 0.95
5 6 0.95
6 5 0.95
7 4 0.95
8 3 0.95
9 2 0.95
10 1 0.95
11 0 0.95
12 1 0.95
13 2 0.95
14 3 0.95
15 4 0.95
16 5 0.95
17 6 0.90
18 7 0.80
19 8 0.70
20 9 0.60
21 10 0.50
22 11 0.40
23 12 0.30
24 13 0.20
25 14 0.10
*** END OF DRAFT ***
PREPARATION OF JOINT AUSTRALIAN/NEW ZEALAND STANDARDS
Joint Australian/New Zealand Standards are prepared by a consensus process involving representatives nominated by organizations in both countries drawn from all major interests associated with the subject. Australian/New Zealand Standards may be derived from existing industry Standards, from established international Standards and practices or may be developed within a Standards Australia, Standards New Zealand or joint technical committee.
During the development process, Australian/New Zealand Standards are made available in draft form at all sales offices and through affiliated overseas bodies in order that all interests concerned with the application of a proposed Standard are given the opportunity to submit views on the requirements to be included.
The following interests are represented on the committee responsible for this draft Australian/ New Zealand Standard:
Airconditioning and Refrigeration Equipment Manufacturers Association of Australia
Australian Building Codes Board
Australian Industry Group
CHOICE
Clean Energy Regulator
Consumer Electronics Association of New Zealand
Consumer Electronics Suppliers Association
CSIRO
Department of the Environment and Energy
Electrical Compliance Testing Association
Energy Safe Victoria
Institute of Refrigeration Heating and AirConditioning Engineers of New Zealand
The University of New South Wales
Standards Australia
Standards Australia is an independent company, limited by guarantee, which prepares and publishes
most of the voluntary technical and commercial standards used in Australia. These standards are
developed through an open process of consultation and consensus, in which all interested parties are
invited to participate. Through a Memorandum of Understanding with the Commonwealth
government, Standards Australia is recognized as Australia’s peak national standards body.
Standards New Zealand
The first national Standards organization was created in New Zealand in 1932. The New Zealand
Standards Executive is established under the Standards and Accreditation Act 2015 and is the
national body responsible for the production of Standards.
Australian/New Zealand Standards
Under a Memorandum of Understanding between Standards Australia and Standards New Zealand,
Australian/New Zealand Standards are prepared by committees of experts from industry,
governments, consumers and other sectors. The requirements or recommendations contained
in published Standards are a consensus of the views of representative interests and also take
account of comments received from other sources. They reflect the latest scientific and industry
experience. Australian/New Zealand Standards are kept under continuous review after publication
and are updated regularly to take account of changing technology.
International Involvement
Standards Australia and Standards New Zealand are responsible for ensuring that the Australian
and New Zealand viewpoints are considered in the formulation of international Standards and that
the latest international experience is incorporated in national and Joint Standards. This role is vital
in assisting local industry to compete in international markets. Both organizations are the national
members of ISO (the International Organization for Standardization) and IEC (the International
Electrotechnical Commission).
Visit our web sites
www.standards.org.au www.standards.govt.nz
top related