s. microys, j. hall, c. den...
Post on 12-Mar-2020
15 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
Systems Transformation – Safety Culture S. Microys, J. Hall, C. den Rooijen
BACKGROUND Safety Culture • “an integrated pattern of individual and
organizational behaviour, based upon shared beliefsand values that continuously seeks to minimizepatient harm, which may result from the processes of care delivery” (Kristensen 2016)
• Concerted efforts have been made to improvepatient safety over the past decade BUT
- We are not where we want to be - We need to do better - To make the next leap in safety, a culture of safety is considered key
INSTRUCTIONAL METHODS • Case-based teaching
• Small group facilitated discussion• Large group – patient/family speaker
• Modelling intended behaviour in the moment• Embed in other existing teaching sessions• Online modules• Review patient feedback• Portfolio
ASSESSMENT METHODS • Case based discussion participation• Situational judgment testing scenarios• 360/Multisource feedback• OSCE station• Presentation at M and M rounds• Simulation• Safety culture surveys• Portfolio
INTENDED LEARNING OUTCOMES • Knowledge – Describe system factors that can
affect patient safety, including resource availabilityand physical and environmental factors; Describe the features of a “just culture” approach to patientsafety
• Skills – Use cognitive aids such as proceduralchecklists, structured communication tools or care paths to enhance patient safety
• Attitudes and Behaviours – Demonstrate ability to recognize the role of patient safety in safehealthcare delivery
• Integration – Speak up in situations where patient safety may be at risk
CASE A junior resident assesses a patient who has presented to the Plastic Surgery clinic for removal of a basal cell carcinoma. During this assessment, the resident recognizes that the patient has dementia and will not be able to consent to the procedure. When the junior resident informs the senior resident of his findings, the senior resident indicates there is no need to go through a full consent discussion with the patient as the patient has dementia and will not understand. The junior resident states that since this is not an emergency procedure, he will wait to start the procedure until the patient’s substitute decision maker returns so that consent may be obtained.
Questions for discussion ü How can the junior resident handle this
situation? ü What is the perspective of the substitute
decision maker or patient? ü What are the challenges and opportunities to
teach patient safety in this setting?
TEACHER’S GUIDE Organization members should feel comfortable reporting errors when they occur. Analyze errors with a sense of curiosity instead of shame. It is hoped that providing a safe environment where staff can openly examine errors without fear of punishment will improve reporting of errors so that they can be avoided in the future.
A just culture is not a blame-free culture though. For truly egregious behaviour, there is a role for punitive action. But the norms, policies, and disciplinary process need to be fair, clear, and graded.
How do you know when you have a safe culture? People speak up because they feel safe. Video from The Joint Commission (4:16) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DBVuu4Qj-Fs
OTHER RESOURCES A TED Talk by Atul Gwande on the importance of checklists (19:19) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L3QkaS249Bc WHO Online Patient Safety Quiz http://www.who.int/patientsafety/education/curriculum/en/
OBJECTIVES • To demonstrate how one can contribute to a culture
that promotes patient safety• To outline the importance of the leader in setting
the culture, including leaders at every level• To enable one to use many techniques to teach
leadership in setting a culture of patient safety
SAFE
TY C
ULT
URE
REF
EREN
CES
1.Be
snar
d D,
Hol
lnag
el E
. Som
e m
yths
abo
ut in
dust
rial s
afet
y. C
RC T
echn
ical
Rep
ort.
Soph
ia A
ntip
oli,
Fran
ce: C
entr
e fo
r Res
earc
h on
Risk
s and
Cris
es; 2
012.
2.Bo
twin
ick
L, e
t al.
Lead
ersh
ip g
uide
to p
atie
nt sa
fety
. IHI
Inno
vatio
n Se
ries.
IHI;
2006
.3.
Busa
ri JO
, et a
l Eva
luat
ing
med
ical
resid
ents
as m
anag
ers o
f car
e: a
crit
ical
app
raisa
l of a
sses
smen
tm
etho
ds. A
dv M
ed E
duc
Prac
t. 20
14; 5
:27-
37.
4.
Cald
er L
A, K
wok
ESH
, et a
l. En
hanc
ing
the
qual
ity o
f mor
bidi
ty a
nd m
orta
lity
roun
ds: t
he O
ttaw
a M
&M
Mod
el. A
cad
Emer
g M
ed. 2
014;
21(
3):3
14-3
21.
5.
Cox
S, C
ox T
. The
stru
ctur
e of
em
ploy
ee a
ttitu
des t
o sa
fety
– a
Eur
opea
n ex
ampl
e. W
ork
and
Stre
ss.
1991
; 5:9
3-10
6.
6.De
kker
J. Ju
st c
ultu
re: b
alan
cing
safe
ty a
nd a
ccou
ntab
ility
. Ash
gate
Pub
lishi
ng; 2
012.
7.Em
anue
l LL
et a
l eds
. Pat
ient
Saf
ety
Educ
atio
n Pr
ogra
m (P
SEP)
– C
anad
a Cu
rric
ulum
. 201
1.8.
Esta
broo
ks C
A, e
t al.
Mea
surin
g th
e ho
spita
l pra
ctic
e en
viro
nmen
t: a
Cana
dian
con
text
. Res
Nur
sHe
alth
. 200
2; 2
5(4)
:256
-268
. 9.
Fran
k JR
, et a
ledi
tors
. Can
MED
S 20
15 p
hysic
ian
com
pete
ncy
fram
ewor
k. R
CPSC
; 201
5.10
. Fra
nkel
AS,
Leo
nard
MW
, Den
ham
CR.
Fai
r and
just
cul
ture
, tea
m b
ehav
ior,
and
lead
ersh
ipen
gage
men
t: th
e to
ols t
o ac
hiev
e hi
gh re
liabi
lity.
Hea
lth S
erv
Res.
200
6; 4
1(4
Part
II):1
690-
1709
. 11
.Gen
niss
en L
, et a
l. Ex
plor
ing
valid
and
relia
ble
asse
ssm
ent m
etho
ds fo
r car
e m
anag
emen
t edu
catio
n.Le
ader
sh H
ealth
Ser
v (B
radf
Eng
l). 2
016;
29(
3):2
40-2
50.
12
Hae
ssle
r S e
t al G
ettin
g do
ctor
s to
clea
n th
eir h
ands
: lea
d th
e fo
llow
ers.
BM
J Qua
l Saf
. 201
2;21
:499
-02
13.I
HI. D
evel
op a
cul
ture
of s
afet
y. 2
016.
14.In
tern
atio
nal A
tom
ic E
nerg
y Ag
ency
. Saf
ety
cultu
re. N
ucle
ar S
afet
y an
d Se
curit
y Pr
ogra
mm
e. 2
011.
15.Je
an B
aker
Mill
er T
rain
ing
Inst
itute
. The
dev
elop
men
t of r
elat
iona
l-cul
tura
l the
ory.
201
3.16
.Kris
tens
en S
et a
l. St
reng
then
ing
lead
ersh
ip a
s a c
atal
yst f
or e
nhan
ced
patie
nt sa
fety
cul
ture
: are
peat
ed c
ross
-sec
tiona
l exp
erim
enta
l stu
dy. B
MJ O
pen.
201
6; 6
(5):e
0101
80
17.L
ucia
n Le
ape
Inst
itute
. Unm
et n
eeds
: tea
chin
g ph
ysic
ians
to p
rovi
de sa
fe p
atie
nt c
are.
Bos
ton,
MA:
NPS
F; 2
010.
18
.Mar
tin M
J. “T
hat’s
the
way
we
do th
ings
aro
und
here
”: a
n ov
ervi
ew o
f org
aniza
tiona
l cul
ture
.El
ectr
onic
Jour
nal o
f Aca
dem
ic a
nd S
peci
al L
ibra
rians
hip.
200
6; 7
(1):1
-2.
19.N
atio
nal P
atie
nt S
afet
y Ed
ucat
ion
Fram
ewor
k. C
anbe
rra:
The
Aus
tral
ian
Coun
cil f
or S
afet
y an
d Q
ualit
yin
Hea
lth C
are;
July
200
5.
20.N
aveh
E, e
t al.
Trea
tmen
t err
ors i
n he
alth
care
: a sa
fety
clim
ate
appr
oach
. Man
agem
ent S
cien
ce. 2
005;
51(6
):948
-960
. 21
.Pro
vono
st P
et a
l. Cr
eatin
g hi
gh re
liabi
lity…
Heal
th S
erv
Res 2
006;
41:
1599
-161
7.22
.Sin
ger S
, et a
l. R
elat
ions
hip
of sa
fety
clim
ate
…. H
ealth
Ser
v Re
s. 2
009;
44(
2 Pt
I):3
99-4
21.
23.S
wen
sen
S, e
t al
High
-impa
ct le
ader
ship
: im
prov
e ca
re, i
mpr
ove
the
heal
th o
f pop
ulat
ions
, and
redu
ceco
sts.
IHI I
nnov
atio
n Se
ries.
Cam
brid
ge, M
A: IH
I; 20
13.
24.W
eave
r SJ,
et a
l Cha
pter
33:
Pro
mot
ing
a cu
lture
of s
afet
y. In
: She
kelle
PG,
et a
l, ed
itors
. M
akin
ghe
alth
car
e sa
fer I
I. Co
mpa
rativ
e Ef
fect
iven
ess R
evie
w N
o. 2
11. A
HRQ
Pub
licat
ion
No.
13-
E001
-EF.
25
.WH O
Pat
ient
Saf
ety
Curr
icul
um G
uide
for M
edic
al S
choo
ls. F
ranc
e: W
HO; 2
009.
26.W
HO P
atie
nt S
afet
y Cu
rric
ulum
Gui
de: M
ulti-
prof
essio
nal E
ditio
n. M
alta
: WHO
; 201
1.
This
lead
ersh
ip m
odul
e on
Con
flict
Man
agem
ent c
an b
e ac
cess
ed a
t ww
w.s
anok
ondu
.ca
Mor
e in
form
atio
n ab
out T
ISLE
P is
ava
ilabl
e at
htt
p://
tisle
p.pg
me.
utor
onto
.ca
top related