thermo-technical retrofitting of public buildings in ... of... · nergy efficiency of public...

Page 1

Implemented by

A presentation of the project background, accomplishments, and results – so far

Thermo-technical retrofitting ofpublic buildings

in Western Mongolia

Page 2

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Page 3

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Page 4

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Energy Efficiency Project (ENEV phase III)A cooperation between• Ministry of Energy• Cabinet Secretariat• SDC• GIZ (BMZ)

A general project presentationof the activities

in the three components for2014 – 2016

Improving the governance ofEnergy Efficiency

Page 5

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Outcome 3: Public institutions, companies,

and households have intensified efforts and

increased investments in the area of Energy

Efficiency and energy conservation

Outcome 1: Compliance with Budget and

Procurement Laws relating to capital

investments at local level has improved

Outcome 2: Improved Energy Efficiency of public buildings in

Khovd and Zavkhan aimags demonstrated

Mongolian Partner:Cabinet Secretariat

Other Partners:Energy Regulatory Commission

Mongolian Partner:Cabinet Secretariat

Mongolian Partner:Ministry of Energy Budget: EUR 7,700,000

Shared by:– BMZ (GIZ)– SDC

Page 6

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Outcome 2: Improved Energy Efficiency of public buildings in Khovd and Zavkhan aimags demonstrated

Output 2.1 Qualifications of the private sector (Construction companies, Specialists, Architects, Engineer, Suppliers and Service Companies) at soum and aimag level for the implementation of energy efficiency projects in public buildings have improved

Output 2.2 Evidence of the benefits from thermo-insulation of public buildings is available

Output 2.3 A conducive environment for the rational and structured operation, maintenance and rehabilitation of public buildings is created

Output 2.4 The users of building and heat suppliers have reached an agreement on energy efficiency and energy savings based on evidence based dialogue

Output 2.5 Strengthening the ability of the local government to develop action plans, standards and protocols and to enforce them

Two buildings will be pilot cases to show how Energy Efficiency (= insulation) in practice can be carried out.

There is a matching fund (50 – 50 basis) arrangement provided for Energy Efficiency renovation works in public buildings

Page 7

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Page 8

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Page 9

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Page 10

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Page 11

Implemented by

24%

17%

1%

38%

4%

16%

What do you think is the main reason for the public buildings being cold?

Heat loss

Insufficient heating

Expensive coal andinsufficient supplyBuilding quality

Extreme coldtemperaturesAged building

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Page 12

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Outcome 3 outlines support to establish Energy Managers and Energy Auditors. As a part of their (planned) tasks, there is a need for some kind of standardized Energy Efficiency Certificate.

The Energy Efficiency Certificate consists of standard parameters

< – – Energy Efficiency Certificate for the Kindergarten in Khovd to be renovated (draft).

The target is to improve the standard (energy consumption/m2 and year) from E to C.

A 50% – or more – reduction of energy consumption is estimated.

The evaluation will be accomplished after the winter season 2014/2015.

Page 13

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Page 14

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

The kindergarten before the refurbishment.

Page 15

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

This is not a very inviting environment for a 4-year old girl. Urinary infections are probably rather common.

Page 16

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

The renovation has started.• Ceilings (roofs)• Walls• Windows• Doors• Floors

Page 17

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

58 windows were changed to 2-glass vacuum type.Most of the materials were produced locally.

It was a very clear division between female and male tasks.

Page 18

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

The task to instruct how to get a right angle could be a challenge.

Page 19

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

And how to use a label also needs thorough and hands-on instructions.

Page 20

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

The principle for the wall insulation method.

Page 21

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Cooperation with the TVET project provided training of the staff of the construction companies involved.

The “students” got a certificate for their participation in the training and practical work.

Page 22

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Workers’ safety...

Page 23

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Page 24

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Page 25

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Standards of various kinds are to be implemented.Home made solutions are adapted to the local conditions.

Page 26

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

The radiators were more or less completely clogged.

Page 27

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Monitoring of• indoor temperature• outdoor temperature• incoming heating water• outgoing heating waterwill provide valuable facts for evaluation.

Page 28

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

-20.00

-10.00

0.00

10.00

20.00

30.00

40.00

50.00

60.00

Temp indoors Temp outdoorsWater out Water in

Khovd Kindergarten #7 NOT insulated

Page 29

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

-20.00

-10.00

0.00

10.00

20.00

30.00

40.00

50.00

60.00

Temp indoors Temp outdoorsWater out Water in

Khovd Kindergarten #7 NOT insulated

Supply temperature varies at random.

Look at the difference between supply and return temperatures.

Page 30

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

-20.00

-10.00

0.00

10.00

20.00

30.00

40.00

50.00

60.00

Temp indoors Temp outdoorsWater out Water in

Khovd Kindergarten #5 insulated

Page 31

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

-20.00

-10.00

0.00

10.00

20.00

30.00

40.00

50.00

60.00

Temp indoors Temp outdoorsWater out Water in

Khovd Kindergarten #5 insulatedDifference between supply and return temperatures is much less than in the other building.

The difference between supply and return temperatures increases when it gets cold.

Data will be gathered on a 15-minutes bases from 2 insulated + 2 not insulated kindergartens. Hopefully there will be a lot to learn from this data.

Page 32

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Outdoor signboards have already increased the interests in Energy Efficiency and what the project is doing.

Page 33

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Showing that the indoor temperatures are still high during very cold periods will be hard facts to prove that insulation is efficient.

Page 34

Implemented by

There is a matching fund (50 – 50 basis) arrangementprovided for Energy Efficiency renovation works in public buildings.Approximately six additional public buildings will be refurbished.Invitations / applications sent out to local governments to participate in theprogramme.

Requirements to provide technical and financial information.

7 applications received.

Selection process ongoing. Bidding, evaluation, and contracting will follow.

Work will start in May 2015.7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Output 2.2 Evidence of the benefits from thermo-insulation of public buildings is available

Page 35

Implemented by

The cost for the refurbishing of the kindergartens is around EUR 125,000 each.With the current heat tariffs (and generally the energy tariffs) there is no direct economic incentive to insulate buildings.Life cycle cost is an “unknown” parameter.

However, it is probably better to renovate (not too) old Soviet style buildings than to demolish the old one and construct a new!?

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Page 36

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Renovated kitchen...

Page 37

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

... and well functioning heating system...

Page 38

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

... will make the children happy, healthy, and eager to learn.

Page 39

Implemented by

7 November 2014 NEXUS Workshop: Thermo-technical retrofit t ing of public buildings in Western Mongolia

Thank youand I hope we can present more results during the next NEXUS regional meeting.