winter wheat based rotations agronomic evaluation of ipm ... per_0.pdf · • ex-ante analysis...

Winter wheat based rotations – Agronomic evaluation of IPM

strategies in on-station experiments

P. Kudsk, C. Colnenne-David, S. Dachbrodt-Saaydeh, R. Kierzek, B. Melander, A. Newton, L. N. Jørgensen & C. Toque

IPM Innovation in Europe, 14-16 January 2015 Poznan, Poland

Location of on-station trials

Speaker's name Meeting and date IPM Innovation in Europe, 14-16 January 2015

Poznan, Poland

Location of on-station trials

IPM Innovation in Europe, 14-16 January 2015 Poznan, Poland

Experimental approach

Speaker's name Meeting and date

• Four new long-term experiments were initiated in D, DK, PL and UK

• Existing experiments were used/modified in F (INRA at Versailles and Arvallis at Boigneville)

• Comparing current practice (CP) to two levels of IPM (intermediate (IM) and advanced (AD))

IPM Innovation in Europe, 14-16 January 2015 Poznan, Poland

Trial design

• Trials in D, DK, PL were 3-year rotations, small-plot experiments, all crops every year

• Trial at INRA in F was a 4-year (CP), 5 year (IM) and 6-year rotation (AD), two locations, large plots (4000 m2), AD was no pesticides, all crops not cultivated every year

• Trial at Arvalis in F was 4-year (CP & IM) and 7-year rotation (AD), large plots (hectares), AD was organic+perennial crop, all crops cultivated every year

• Ex-ante analysis using DEXiPM

IPM Innovation in Europe, 14-16 January 2015 Poznan, Poland

Treatments

• Current practice

– Good agricultural practice (primarily winter annual crops, pest monitoring, use of optimized pesticide doses)

• Intermediate IPM

– Crop diversification, cultural practices, disease resistant varieties, non chemical weed control methods etc.

• Advanced IPM

– As intermediate IPM + cover crops, forecasting models + innovative tools

Speaker's name Meeting and date IPM Innovation in Europe, 14-16 January 2015

Poznan, Poland

IWM tools

• Weeds

– Crop diversification, seeding rate, delayed sowing, false seed bed, harrowing, interrow cultivation, herbicide decison support system

• Diseases

– Resistant varieties, variety mixtures, forecasting models, biological control methods, elicitors, electron seed treatment

• Insect pests

– None

Speaker's name Meeting and date IPM Innovation in Europe, 14-16 January 2015

Poznan, Poland

Pest control

• General good control of weeds, diseases and pests in the CP and IM systems

• Lower and more variable effects in the AD system in some locations in some years but no general trends

• Weed flora shifts have occured in the French trials and are becoming apparent in the Polish trial

• More detailed statistical analyses will be done

Speaker's name Meeting and date IPM Innovation in Europe, 14-16 January 2015

Poznan, Poland

Winter wheat yields (t/ha) Denmark UK Germany

Poland France (INRA) France (Arvalis)

Yields

• Winter wheat yields generally highest in the CP system

• Winter wheat yield losses in the IM and AD systems varied between locations and years

• Yield differences smaller for break crops (OSR, winter barley and maize) than for winter wheat.

Speaker's name Meeting and date IPM Innovation in Europe, 14-16 January 2015

Poznan, Poland

IPM tool: Mechanical weeding

Speaker's name Meeting and date IPM Innovation in Europe, 14-16 January 2015

Poznan, Poland

Interrow cultivation

Weed harrowing

IPM tool: Weed harrowing

Speaker's name Meeting and date

Pct covera

ge/N

um

ber

of panic

les m

-2

--------Dicots------- -------APESV-------

IPM Innovation in Europe, 14-16 January 2015 Poznan, Poland

IPM tool: Weed harrowing P

ct covera

ge/N

um

ber

of panic

les m

-2

--------Dicots------- -------APESV-------

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

2012 2013 2014

CP

IM

AD

IPM Innovation in Europe, 14-16 January 2015 Poznan, Poland

IPM tool: Variety mixtures

---2012--- -------2013-------- -------2014-------

% S

epto

ria o

n leaf

1

IPM Innovation in Europe, 14-16 January 2015 Poznan, Poland

IPM tool: Variety mixtures

---2012--- -------2013-------- -------2014-------

% S

epto

ria o

n leaf

1

IPM Innovation in Europe, 14-16 January 2015 Poznan, Poland

Control plots

IPM tool: Variety mixtures

Speaker's name Meeting and date

---2012--- -------2013-------- -------2014-------

% S

epto

ria o

n leaf

1

IPM Innovation in Europe, 14-16 January 2015 Poznan, Poland

Treated plots

IPM tool: Variety mixtures

Current Susceptible variety Intermediate Resistant variety Advanced Variety mixture

Untreated Treated

IPM tool: Delayed sowing

Speaker's name Meeting and date

Mild Cold Mild

IPM Innovation in Europe, 14-16 January 2015 Poznan, Poland

t/h

a

Pesticide use

Speaker's name Meeting and date

TF

I

IPM Innovation in Europe, 14-16 January 2015 Poznan, Poland

Thank you for your attention!

The research leading to these results has received funding from the European Union Seventh Framework Programme (FP7/ 2007-2013) under the grant agreement n°265865- PURE