ams-02 antiprotons reloaded - taup · pdf fileams-02 antiprotons reloaded martin w. winkler in...

20
AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded Martin W. Winkler in collaboration with R. Kappl and A. Reinert based on JCAP 09/2014 and arXiv:1506.04145 TAUP 2015 Torino September 9 2015 Martin W. Winkler (Bonn University) AMS-02 Antiprotons September 9 2015 1 / 14

Upload: ngotuong

Post on 10-Feb-2018

216 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded - TAUP · PDF fileAMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded Martin W. Winkler in collaboration with R. Kappl and A. Reinert based on JCAP 09/2014 and arXiv:1506.04145

AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded

Martin W. Winklerin collaboration with R. Kappl and A. Reinert

based on JCAP 09/2014 and arXiv:1506.04145

TAUP 2015Torino

September 9 2015

Martin W. Winkler (Bonn University) AMS-02 Antiprotons September 9 2015 1 / 14

Page 2: AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded - TAUP · PDF fileAMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded Martin W. Winkler in collaboration with R. Kappl and A. Reinert based on JCAP 09/2014 and arXiv:1506.04145

Why Antiprotons?

low fraction of antimatter in cosmic rays p̄/p ∼ 10−4

very sensitive probe for new physics

complemantary to gamma ray searches

1 101 10210-6

10-5

10-4

10-3

10-2

10-1

T @GeVD

Fp

@Hm2

ssr

Ge

VL-

1D

200GeVHiggsino

Background

example: dark matterpair-annihilation

no clear spectral featuresexpected

precise prediction for the p̄-background is indispensable

Martin W. Winkler (Bonn University) AMS-02 Antiprotons September 9 2015 2 / 14

Page 3: AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded - TAUP · PDF fileAMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded Martin W. Winkler in collaboration with R. Kappl and A. Reinert based on JCAP 09/2014 and arXiv:1506.04145

Secondary Antiprotons

scattering of primary cosmic rays (p,He) on the interstellar matter

qsec(T ) ∼∫

dT ′(dσdT

)p̄ prod

nAISMΦA A = H,He, . . .

1 101 102 103 104 105

103

104

T [GeV/n]

ΦiTOA·T

2.7[m

-2sr

-1s-1(GeV

/n)1.7] Proton

Helium

CREAM

AMS-02

primary proton andhelium fluxesYoon et al., Astrophys. J. 728 (2011)

Aguilar et al., Phy. Rev. Lett. 114 (2015)

clear indication ofspectral breaks

Martin W. Winkler (Bonn University) AMS-02 Antiprotons September 9 2015 3 / 14

Page 4: AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded - TAUP · PDF fileAMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded Martin W. Winkler in collaboration with R. Kappl and A. Reinert based on JCAP 09/2014 and arXiv:1506.04145

Antiproton Cross Sections

new calculation of p̄ productiondi Mauro et al., Phys. Rev. D90 (2014)

Kappl et al., JCAP 09 (2014)

experimental data from NA49NA49 collaboration, Eur. Phys. J. C65 (2010)

hyperon decay

ç ç ç ç çç

çç

çç

çç

çç

çç

çç

ç

0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.3010-3

10-2

10-1

xf

dn

L�d

xf

0.2 ´ dn�dxf

0.3 ´ dn�dxf

data from Alt et al., Eur. Phys. J. C45 (2006)

isospin enhanced n̄ production

��

� �

��

è

èè

è

è

è

è

è

è

è

èè è- 0.1 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3

0.05

0.10

0.15

0.20

xf

dn

�dx f

isospin factor 1.37isospin factor 1

�� p n Dataèè p p Data

data from Fischer et al., Heavy Ion Phys. 17 (2003)

improved modeling ofproton-nucleus scattering

Martin W. Winkler (Bonn University) AMS-02 Antiprotons September 9 2015 4 / 14

Page 5: AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded - TAUP · PDF fileAMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded Martin W. Winkler in collaboration with R. Kappl and A. Reinert based on JCAP 09/2014 and arXiv:1506.04145

Propagation

propagation: random walk through the galaxy

from D. Maurin

diffusion equation

∇(−K ∇Np̄ + Vc Np̄) + ∂E (bloss Np̄ − KEE ∂ENp̄) + Γann Np̄ = qp̄

semi-analytic solution in two-zone diffusion modelMaurin et al., Astrophys. J. 555 (2001), Donato et al., Astrophys. J. 563 (2001)

five transport parameters: K0, δ, L, Vc , Va ⇐= B/C analysis

Martin W. Winkler (Bonn University) AMS-02 Antiprotons September 9 2015 5 / 14

Page 6: AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded - TAUP · PDF fileAMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded Martin W. Winkler in collaboration with R. Kappl and A. Reinert based on JCAP 09/2014 and arXiv:1506.04145

Antiproton Excess in AMS-02?

preliminary data on the antiproton fraction in cosmic raysA. Kounine, Talk at the AMS Days at CERN (2015)

dark matter interpretationIbe et al., Phys. Rev. D91 (2015), Hamaguchi et al., Phys. Lett. B747 (2015)

background underestimated? Giesen et al., arXiv:1504.04276 (2015)

Martin W. Winkler (Bonn University) AMS-02 Antiprotons September 9 2015 6 / 14

Page 7: AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded - TAUP · PDF fileAMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded Martin W. Winkler in collaboration with R. Kappl and A. Reinert based on JCAP 09/2014 and arXiv:1506.04145

A Glance at B/C

preliminary B/C dataA. Oliva, Talk at the AMS Days at CERN (2015)

101 102 103

10-1

ℛ [��]

�/�

���

������ �/�

���-�� �/�

indicate that propagation parameters are outdated ⇐= reanalysis

Martin W. Winkler (Bonn University) AMS-02 Antiprotons September 9 2015 7 / 14

Page 8: AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded - TAUP · PDF fileAMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded Martin W. Winkler in collaboration with R. Kappl and A. Reinert based on JCAP 09/2014 and arXiv:1506.04145

Primary Fluxes

10-1 1 101 102 10310-13

10-12

10-11

10-10

10-9

10-8

10-7

10-6

10-5

10-4

10-3

10-2

10-1

1

101

102

T [GeV/n]

ΦiTOA·T

2.7

[m-2sr

-1s-1(GeV

/n)1.7]

Carbon

Oxygen·10-2

Nitrogen·10-4

Neon·10-6

Magnesium·10-8

Silicon·10-10

CREAM-II

HEAO

PAMELA

ACE

B/C ratio used to determinepropagation parameters

B is pure secondary

C, N, O, Ne, Mg, Sispallation contributes& 98% to B flux

data from ACE, HEAO,CREAM-II, PAMELALave et al., Astrophys. J. 770 (2013), Engelmannet al., Astronom. Astrophys. 233 (1990), Ahn etal., Astrophys. J. 707 (2009), Adriani et al.,Astrophys. J. 791 (2014)

Martin W. Winkler (Bonn University) AMS-02 Antiprotons September 9 2015 8 / 14

Page 9: AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded - TAUP · PDF fileAMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded Martin W. Winkler in collaboration with R. Kappl and A. Reinert based on JCAP 09/2014 and arXiv:1506.04145

Spallation Cross Sections

σspall: straight-ahead approximation

constant at T & 10 GeV

10-1 1 101

30

35

40

45

50

� [���]

σ(���

→�)[��]

����

������ ����

����

Webber parameterizationAstrophys. J. Suppl. 144 (2003)

large uncertainties, nohigh-energy data

introduce energy biasMaurin et al., Astron. Astrophys. 516 (2010)

needed: experimental data on spallation cross sections

Martin W. Winkler (Bonn University) AMS-02 Antiprotons September 9 2015 9 / 14

Page 10: AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded - TAUP · PDF fileAMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded Martin W. Winkler in collaboration with R. Kappl and A. Reinert based on JCAP 09/2014 and arXiv:1506.04145

B/C Analysis

new AMS-02 data on B/C ratioA. Oliva, Talk at the AMS Days at CERN (2015)

selected 500 configurations, trend towards smaller δ = 0.3− 0.6

Martin W. Winkler (Bonn University) AMS-02 Antiprotons September 9 2015 10 / 14

Page 11: AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded - TAUP · PDF fileAMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded Martin W. Winkler in collaboration with R. Kappl and A. Reinert based on JCAP 09/2014 and arXiv:1506.04145

B/C Analysis

new AMS-02 data on B/C ratioA. Oliva, Talk at the AMS Days at CERN (2015)

0 5 10 15 200.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

Vc @ kpc Myr-1D

MED

selected 500 configurations, trend towards smaller δ = 0.3− 0.6

Martin W. Winkler (Bonn University) AMS-02 Antiprotons September 9 2015 10 / 14

Page 12: AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded - TAUP · PDF fileAMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded Martin W. Winkler in collaboration with R. Kappl and A. Reinert based on JCAP 09/2014 and arXiv:1506.04145

Antiproton Fraction

comparison of p̄ background with new AMS-02 dataA. Kounine, Talk at the AMS Days at CERN (2015)

1 101 102

10-5

10-4

� [���/�]

�/�

������� �������������

����������� �������������

�/� ����

���-�� � /� ����

updated background consistent with data

Martin W. Winkler (Bonn University) AMS-02 Antiprotons September 9 2015 11 / 14

Page 13: AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded - TAUP · PDF fileAMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded Martin W. Winkler in collaboration with R. Kappl and A. Reinert based on JCAP 09/2014 and arXiv:1506.04145

Antiproton Fraction

comparison of p̄ background with new AMS-02 dataA. Kounine, Talk at the AMS Days at CERN (2015)

1 101 102

10-5

10-4

� [���/�]

�/�

������� �������������

����������� �������������

� /� ����

���-�� � /� ����

updated background consistent with data

Martin W. Winkler (Bonn University) AMS-02 Antiprotons September 9 2015 11 / 14

Page 14: AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded - TAUP · PDF fileAMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded Martin W. Winkler in collaboration with R. Kappl and A. Reinert based on JCAP 09/2014 and arXiv:1506.04145

Antiproton Fraction

comparison of p̄ background with new AMS-02 dataA. Kounine, Talk at the AMS Days at CERN (2015)

1 101 102

10-5

10-4

� [���/�]

�/�

������� �������������

����������� �������������

����

���-�� � /� ����

updated background consistent with data

Martin W. Winkler (Bonn University) AMS-02 Antiprotons September 9 2015 11 / 14

Page 15: AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded - TAUP · PDF fileAMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded Martin W. Winkler in collaboration with R. Kappl and A. Reinert based on JCAP 09/2014 and arXiv:1506.04145

Comparison of p̄/p and B/C

101 102 103

10-1

ℛ [��]

�/�

( � /� )× ����

Martin W. Winkler (Bonn University) AMS-02 Antiprotons September 9 2015 12 / 14

Page 16: AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded - TAUP · PDF fileAMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded Martin W. Winkler in collaboration with R. Kappl and A. Reinert based on JCAP 09/2014 and arXiv:1506.04145

Comparison of p̄/p and B/C

101 102 103

10-1

ℛ [��]

ℛ-����

ℛ -����/�

( �/� )× ����

p̄/p flatter by ∼ R0.25

Martin W. Winkler (Bonn University) AMS-02 Antiprotons September 9 2015 12 / 14

Page 17: AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded - TAUP · PDF fileAMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded Martin W. Winkler in collaboration with R. Kappl and A. Reinert based on JCAP 09/2014 and arXiv:1506.04145

Comparison of p̄/p and B/C

101 102 103

10-1

ℛ [��]

ℛ-����

ℛ -����/�

( �/� )× ����

p̄/p flatter by ∼ R0.25

explained by injection

10 50 100 500

1000

2000

3000

4000

� [���/�]

��/Φ

��_/Φ

�-���

Martin W. Winkler (Bonn University) AMS-02 Antiprotons September 9 2015 12 / 14

Page 18: AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded - TAUP · PDF fileAMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded Martin W. Winkler in collaboration with R. Kappl and A. Reinert based on JCAP 09/2014 and arXiv:1506.04145

Remark on Propagation Unceratinties

10-1 1 101

30

35

40

45

50

� [���]

σ(���

→�)[��]

����

������ ����

����

Martin W. Winkler (Bonn University) AMS-02 Antiprotons September 9 2015 13 / 14

Page 19: AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded - TAUP · PDF fileAMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded Martin W. Winkler in collaboration with R. Kappl and A. Reinert based on JCAP 09/2014 and arXiv:1506.04145

Remark on Propagation Unceratinties

10-1 1 101

30

35

40

45

50

� [���]

σ(���

→�)[��]

����

������ ����

����

Martin W. Winkler (Bonn University) AMS-02 Antiprotons September 9 2015 13 / 14

Page 20: AMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded - TAUP · PDF fileAMS-02 Antiprotons Reloaded Martin W. Winkler in collaboration with R. Kappl and A. Reinert based on JCAP 09/2014 and arXiv:1506.04145

Conclusion

substantial progress in modeling antiproton production

AMS-02 B/C data have strong impact on propagation parameters:higher slope of diffusion coefficient

AMS-02 antiproton data are consistent with background

Martin W. Winkler (Bonn University) AMS-02 Antiprotons September 9 2015 14 / 14