before the honourable judge mokgohloa djp third …f.m maluleka inc noko maimela inc 80. mabilu...
TRANSCRIPT
1
OFFICE OF THE CHIEF JUSTICE IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA,
LIMPOPO DIVISION POLOKWANE Private Bag X 9693; Polokwane; 0700. 36 Biccard Street; Polokwane; 0699
Tel no. (015) 230 4000; Fax no: (015) 230 4223
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE MOKGOHLOA DJP
THIRD FLOOR COURT 2 CIVIL TRIALS: 26 JUNE 2017
No Names of
Parties Case no
Plaintiff’s Attorneys
&
Defendant Attorneys
Outcomes
1. Eustin Pidima Moakamela V Road Accident Fund
1536/2014
Sonto Chawane Att Hammann-Moosa Inc (Settlement)
2. Mpapi Samuel Maluleke V
Road Accident Fund
A967/2015
L.J Kgomo Att
Mathobo, Rambau & Sigogo Att (Settlement)
2
3. Mmala Matsedi Pinkie V Road Accident Fund
2571/2015
Mafetse Mogashoa Att Rachoene Inc (Settlement)
4. Ngomane Sibongile V Road Accident Fund
4923/2016
Chavalala Att Mathobo, Rambau & Sigogo Att
5. Makhado Stella V Road Accident Fund
185/2015
Ramavhale Att Mathobo, Rambau & Sigogo
6. David Nkhumeleni Mukheli V Road Accident
Fund
575/2011
Gildenhuis Malatji Att Mathobo, Rambau & Sigogo
3
7. Maluleke Magezi December V Road Accident Fund
196/2012
Mvundlela & Ass State Attorney
8. Heila Dolpiena Duvenhage V The Mec for the Department of Health & Social Development Limpopo Province
430/2012
Smit & Mare Att State Attorney
9. Mohale Matome Nkoana V Road Accident Fund
562/2012
Mahowa Inc Mathobo, Rambau & Sigogo Att
10. Chipana Nakedi Dipuo V
Road Accident Fund
929/2012
P.M.K Tladi & Ass
Pule Inc
4
11. Tebele Londa Manngolwane obo Kgantso V Road Accident Fund
962/2012
Mafori Lesufi Inc Noko Maimela Inc
12. Tebele Londa Manngolwane obo Precious V Road Accident Fund
963/2012
Mafori Lesufi Inc Noko Maimela Inc
REMOVED
13. Baloyi Glenda V Road Accident Fund
106/2013
Marori Lesufi Inc Pule Inc
REMOVED
14. Malatjie Mahlomola V Road Accident Fund
165/2013
Mafori Lesifu Inc Noko Maimela Inc
5
15. Malatjie Mmakosha Gladys V Road Accident Fund
189/2013
Mahowa Inc Noko Maimela Inc
16. Raliwedzha Azwihangwisi Dorcus V Road Accident Fund
753/2013
Maloka Att Noko Maimela Inc
17. Anna Mahlogonolo Ledwaba & 01 Another V Serobi Maja
1318/2013
Popela Maake Att M.L Mashego Att
18. Molokomme Mmaseliki Shirtina V
Road Accident Fund
109/2014
Mashabane Inc
Noko Maimela Inc
6
19. Mphosi Masedi Alpheus V Road Accident Fund
110/2014
Mashabane Inc Mathobo, Rambau & Sigogo Att
20. Mhlang Petrus V Road Accident Fund
116/2014
Mafori Lesufi Inc Noko Maimela Inc
21. Nkosi Betana Elsie V Road Accident Fund
128/2014
Toka Mathabatha Att Rachoene Inc
22. Makgafela Califonia Mmangakane V Road Accident Fund
434/2014
Mashabela Att Hammann-Moosa Inc
7
23. Makgoba Masilo Amos V Road Accident Fund
791/2014
M.C Rathelele Att Pule Inc
24. Maite Harry Molokomme N.O V The MEC for Health Limpopo
1440/2014
Smit & Mare Att State Attorney
25. Sipho Thomas Mashimbye V Road Accident Fund
1545/2014
Kern & Dekker Inc Mathobo, Rambau & Sigogo Att
26. Tshimangadzo Surprise Mudoseni V Road Accident Fund
1588/2014
N.R Munyai Att Noko Maimela Inc
8
27. Nkhensani Agnes Shingange V Road Accident Fund
A1653/2014
T.G Hlungwani Inc Rachoene Inc
28. Nkwe Raisibe Annah V Road Accident Fund
1656/2014
Mashabane Inc Mathobo, Rambau & Sigogo Att
29. Johanna Ntsesang Moseamedi obo Terrance Mathata V Road Accident Fund
1806/2014
T.G Hlungwani Att Mathobo, Rambau & Sigogo Att
30. Khumalo Masobelele Johannes V
Road Accident Fund
1820/2014
L.J Kgomo Att
Mathobo, Rambau & Sigogo Att
9
31. Winnie Phuti Thantsha V Road Accident Fund
1874/2014
Mathopo Makweya Att Hammann-Moosa Inc
32. Mothoko Julius Masehamela
V Road Accident Fund
151/2015
HLM Mamabolo Att
Noko Maimela Inc
33. Lesiba Abram Mphahlele V Road Accident Fund
186/2015
L.J Kgomo Att Noko Maimela Inc
34. John Chitehwe Ndlovu V Road Accident
Fund
207/2015
Mamokgalake Chuene Att Hammann-Moosa Inc
10
35. Marakalala Mercy Rabokale obo Hunadi, Lesiba & Lebogang V Road Accident Fund
753/2015
Mashabela Att Pule Inc
Removed
36. Rachidi Mmabore Mpho V Road Accident Fund
909/2015
Mashabela Att Mathobo, Rambau & Sigogo Att
Removed
37. Mmankoko Gladys Shibambo V Road Accident Fund
A974/2015
L.J Kgomo Att Mathobo, Rambau & Sigogo Att
38. Vhulahani Francinah Musundwa V Road Accident Fund
986/2015
Chueu Att Pule Inc
11
39. Mashudu Evans Rathumbu V Road Accident Fund
991/2015
Chueu Inc Mathobo, Rambau & Sigogo Att
40. Jogbeth Mmampho Maswezi V Road Accident Fund
1031/2015
Chueu Inc Pule Inc
41. Xolani Cyprian Mathebula V Road Accident Fund
1037/2015
Chueu Inc Pule Inc
42. Nthabiseng Mojapelo V Road Accident Fund
1441/2015
HLM Mamabolo Att Pule Inc
12
43. Sambo Tsakani Ciscar V Road Accident Fund
1467/2015
Baloyi & Shirinda Inc Noko Maimela Inc
44. Motsepe Mmakoma Johanna V Road Accident Fund
1596/2015
Mphela & Ass Mathobo, Rambau & Sigogo Att
45. Nkuna Tintswalo Grace V Road Accident Fund
1756/2015
M.G Mabunda Att Pule Inc
REMOVED
46. Thabo Samuel Manthosi V Road Accident
Fund
2039/2015
Maloka Att Noko Maimela Inc
13
47. Shokane Tebatso Winnie V Road Accident Fund
2109/2015
MI Senyolo Att Noko Maimela Inc
48. Themba Innocent Mnisi V Road Accident Fund
2127/2015
Mushwana Inc Mathobo, Rambau & sigogo Att
49. Morongwa Moreen Mokgosi V Road Accident Fund
2146/2015
M.D Mashabela Att Mamokgalake Chuene Att
50. Mampa Mahlodi Paulinah V Road Accident
Fund
2184/2015
M.S Moloto Inc Mathabo, Rambau &
Sigogo Att
14
51. Ngobeni Martha V Road Accident Fund
2207/2015
M.G Mabunda Att Noko Maimela Inc
REMOVED
52. Prince Maswanganyi
V Road Accident Fund
2259/2015
Mushwana Inc
Mathobo, Rambau & Sigogo Atth
53. Maduna Maria V Road Accident Fund
2316/2015
M.G Mabunda Att Hammann-Moosa Inc
REMOVED
54. Hellen Leshiyi Mampuru V Road Accident Fund
2322/2015
Komane Att Mathobo, Rambau & Sigogo
15
55. Mathepe Mmatlawa Saphira V Road Accident Fund
A2354/2015
Toka Mathabatha Att Rachoene Inc
56. Motloung Moepone Olga V Road Accident Fund
2449/2015
Funanani Ndou Att Rachoene Inc
57. Dikotla Tshebetsi Camuel V Road Accident Fund
2487/2015
Mashabela Att Hammann-Moosa Inc
58. Maluleke Nkhensani Mpho V Road Accident
Fund
2552/2015
Mashabela Att Hammann-Moosa Inc
16
59. Matladi Isaac Ratopola V Thebe Edward Maruma
2578/2015
Smit & Maree Att Sibusiso Mashele Att
60. Lebogang Morutse Mphahlele V Road Accident Fund
03/2016
Kgasago Att Pule Inc
61. Nalana Thomas obo Minors V Road Accident Fund
37/2016
M.G Mabunda Att Hammann-Moosa Inc
REMOVED
62. Maswanganye Tsakani Joyce obo Maswanganyi V V
Road Accident Fund
212/2016
C.J Ntsoane Att
Hammann-Moosa Inc
17
63. Nthangeni Ntshengedzeni Lorda V Road Accident Fund
213/2016
C.J Ntsoane Att Hammann-Moosa Inc
64. Tshegofatso Ramoilane Ratau V Road Accident Fund
279/2016
Komane Att Noko Maimela Inc
65. Mampe Stephina Nkadimeng obo Kgapola T V Road Accident Fund
282/2016
Komane Att Noko Maimela Inc
66. Mmakgabo Mack Baloyi V Road Accident
Fund
477/2016
Maloka Att Pule Inc
18
67. Karabo Sekgobela V Road Accident Fund
894/2016
Mpholoane Att Hammann-Moosa Inc
68. Makhuvele Mandla Gostaff V Road Accident Fund
960/2016
MS Moloto Inc Mathobo, Rambau & Sigogo Att
69. Ntsoane Daniel Mogogoroane V Road Accident Fund
1037/2016
Komane Att Noko Maimela Inc
70. George MacDonald Phasumane V
Road Accident Fund
1124/2016
Marisana Mashedi Att Pule Inc
19
71. Sipho Mtileni V Road Accident Fund
1316/2016
Molepo & Phala Att Mathobo, Rambau & Sigogo Att
72. Mavhundza Phinias obo Minor V Road Accident Fund
1763/2016
Mafori Lesufi Inc Pule Inc
73. Katise Joseph Motshaisi V Road Accident Fund
2271/2016
Mashapa Inc Noko Maimela Inc
74. Mohlala George Abram V Road Accident
Fund
2644/2016
Toka Mathabatha Att Rachoene Inc
20
75. Matome Calvin Mathikithela V Road Accident Fund
3360/2016
F.M Maluleka Inc Pule Inc
76. Simon Tom Mabuza V Road Accident Fund
3361/2016
F.M Maluleka Inc Rachoene Inc
77. Maria Carlos Muhlanga obo Mathuse O. V Road Accident Fund
3627/2016
F.M Maluleka Inc Rachoene Inc
78. Maredi Ned Thaba V Road Accident Fund
3634/2016
HLM Mamabolo Att Pule Inc
21
79. Newboy Mzamo Serati V Road Accident Fund
4080/2016
F.M Maluleka Inc Noko Maimela Inc
80. Mabilu Molayi Maniekie obo Minors V Road Accident Fund
3447/2016
Moroba Sekele Att Noko Maimela Inc
81. Mulaudzi Takalani Sipho V Road Accident Fund
4972/2016
M.G Mabunda Att Mathobo, Rambau & Sigogo Att
From Pre-Trial Roll.
82. Moloto Benny Morasia V
Road Accident Fund
75/2015
Mafori Lesufi Inc
Hammann-Moosa Inc
From Pre-Trial Roll.
22
83. Kamogelo Tladi V Road Accident Fund
216/2016
Director Makhafola Inc Hammann-Moosa Inc
84. Mpolosana Enica Ngele V Road Accident Fund
217/2017
Director Makhafola Inc Rachoene Inc
85. Langa Raesibe Constance V Road Accident Fund
446/2016
Mphela & Ass Hammann-Moosa Inc
86. Peter Lerato Ntabane V Road Accident Fund
1432/2015
Mathopo-Makweya Att Pule Inc
23
87. Mashakwe Presida V Minister of Rural Development & Land Reform
2555/2015
Nukeri Inc Mathobo, Rambau & Sigogo Att
88. Mathuka Marth Modipa obo Nhlodi Pieterson Modipa V Road Accident Fund
A972/2015
L.J Kgomo Mathobo, Rambau & Sigogo Att
89. Mokgokoloshi Frans V Road Accident Fund
3179/2016
Ngoako Seabela Inc Hammann-Moosa Inc
90. Maite Abia Ngwendoline Malapane V
Road Accident Fund
2950/2016
Mpholoane Att
Noko Maimela Inc
24
91. Khumalo Qoli Nino-Brown V Road Accident Fund
1628/2014
Mahowa Inc Hammann-Moosa Inc
92. Mofomate Madimetsa Emmanuel V
Road Accident Fund
515/2016
Mamokgalake Chuene Att
Noko Maimela Inc
93. Ubisi Thoko Hlongolwana V Road Accident Fund
1535/2016
Mahowa Inc Hammann-Moosa Inc
94. Seanego Kgantshi Sakiel V Road Accident Fund
2522/2016
Mashabela Att Hammann-Moosa Inc
25
95. Makwana Mogaramedi Robert V Road Accident Fund
2751/2016
Mashabela Att Rachoene Inc
96. Hlamalani Marime V Road Accident Fund
145/2016
TG Hlungwani Inc Noko Maimela Inc
97. Baloyi Matimba V Road Accident Fund
392/2010
Maloka Att Noko Maimela Inc
98. Thobejane Nthabiseng V Road Accident Fund
2288/2015
Mashabela Att Mathobo, Rambau & Sigogo Att
26
99. Mokgadi Eunice Masemola obo Mogashoa M.P V
Road Accident Fund
2959/2016
Raphesu J.L Att
Noko Maimela Inc
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE
OPPOSED APPLICATIONS: 26 JUNE 2017
No Names of Parties Case no Nature Outcomes
1. Malekgau Idah Magubatlou V Makaepea Percy Kgaugelo
4479/2016
Rule 43
27
2.
Matsumathu General Trading (Pty) Ltd V Othabetswe Trading in All Aspects (Pty) Ltd
5878/2016
Interdict
3. Ba-Phalaborwa Local Municipality V Khobi ICT information
5794/2016
Mandatory Interdict
4.
Christiaan Van Nieuwkerk t/a Busfactor V Department of Roads & Transport, Lephalale & 06 Others
5071/2016 Declaratory Order
(Postponement)
5. Mpho Steyn Nangammbi V Khangwelo Desmond Musetsho & 01 Another
5533/2016
Order for Specific Performance
28
6. Blubil Transport (Pty) Ltd V Mactransco Lephalale (Pty) Ltd
826/2017
Winding Up (Postponement)
7. Button Neil David N.O & 03 Others V Phakathi Properties (Pty) Ltd
1323/2016
Payment/Execution
of Immovable Property
8. Lucky Mmola V Minister of Police
974/2016
Condonation
9. Ka Ntle Trading Enterprises & 02 Others V Readira Matlala Nyapele JV & 01 Another
1329/2016
Declaratory Order
29
10. Johannes George Kruger V Lovely Adolphina Modiba & 03 Others
3586/2016
Rule Nisi (Mandatory Interdict)