challenges for new regional turboprop...

20
Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration Pierluigi Della Vecchia, PhD. University of Naples Federico II Department of Industrial Engineering Via Claudio, 21, 80125 Naples [email protected] http://wpage.unina.it/pierluigi.dellavecchia/ http://wpage.unina.it/fabrnico/DAF/ Pierluigi Della Vecchia 1 Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5 th SCAD (Symposium on Collaboration in Aircraft Design 12 th -14 th October 2015 TCAD Technical Committee Aircraft Design

Upload: others

Post on 04-Aug-2020

6 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configurationwpage.unina.it/fabrnico/SCAD2015/presentations/DellaVecchia_SCAD2015.pdfChallenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th

Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration

Pierluigi Della Vecchia, PhD.

University of Naples Federico II Department of Industrial Engineering Via Claudio, 21, 80125 Naples [email protected] http://wpage.unina.it/pierluigi.dellavecchia/ http://wpage.unina.it/fabrnico/DAF/

Pierluigi Della Vecchia 1 Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th SCAD (Symposium on Collaboration in Aircraft Design 12th-14th October 2015

TCAD Technical Committee

Aircraft Design

Page 2: Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configurationwpage.unina.it/fabrnico/SCAD2015/presentations/DellaVecchia_SCAD2015.pdfChallenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th

Pierluigi Della Vecchia 2

Table of Contents

✈ Introduction ✈ Aircraft Components Design and Optimization

Nose Wing-Fuselage junction Nose Wing Laminar flow Winglet Design Vertical Empennage Design

✈ Effects on Aircraft Performance ✈ Conclusions

TCAD Technical Committee

Aircraft Design

Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th SCAD (Symposium on Collaboration in Aircraft Design 12th-14th October 2015

Page 3: Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configurationwpage.unina.it/fabrnico/SCAD2015/presentations/DellaVecchia_SCAD2015.pdfChallenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th

Pierluigi Della Vecchia 3

Introduction

TCAD Technical Committee

Aircraft Design

Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th SCAD (Symposium on Collaboration in Aircraft Design 12th-14th October 2015

Typical regional turboprop aircraft configuration

- High wing - T-tail - Twin Engine on wing - Aluminum alloy - Easy access on cabin - Low maintenance and operability costs

Page 4: Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configurationwpage.unina.it/fabrnico/SCAD2015/presentations/DellaVecchia_SCAD2015.pdfChallenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th

TCAD Technical Committee

Aircraft Design

Introduction Drag polar and typical mission profile

Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th SCAD (Symposium on Collaboration in Aircraft Design 12th-14th October 2015 4

CD0 = 0.0300 e = 0.83 AR = 12

TOTAL MISSION = 200 nm climb = 50 nm descent = 50 nm Vcruise = 270 kt

Page 5: Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configurationwpage.unina.it/fabrnico/SCAD2015/presentations/DellaVecchia_SCAD2015.pdfChallenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th

Pierluigi Della Vecchia 5

Introduction

TCAD Technical Committee

Aircraft Design

Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th SCAD (Symposium on Collaboration in Aircraft Design 12th-14th October 2015

Effects of CDo Effect of Oswald e

Page 6: Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configurationwpage.unina.it/fabrnico/SCAD2015/presentations/DellaVecchia_SCAD2015.pdfChallenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th

Pierluigi Della Vecchia 6

Typical regional turboprop aircraft – 70 seats WTO b S Lf DMAX,f

23000 kg 27 m 61 m2 27 m 2.5 m

AR e CD0 12 0.83 0.0306

SBP N° of engines ηp Cruise

altitude

2750 hp 2 0.85 20000 ft

Geometrical characteristics

Characteristics to estimate drag polar

Engine Performance characteristics

Aircraft Components Optimization

Condition α β M Re Cruise 0° 0° 0.43 11.5 ∙106 Climb 6° 0° 0.3 8.0 ∙106

Reference aerodynamic analysis conditions

TCAD Technical Committee

Aircraft Design

Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th SCAD (Symposium on Collaboration in Aircraft Design 12th-14th October 2015

Page 7: Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configurationwpage.unina.it/fabrnico/SCAD2015/presentations/DellaVecchia_SCAD2015.pdfChallenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th

Pierluigi Della Vecchia 7

Condition α β M Re Cruise 0° 0° 0.43 11.5 ∙106

Pressure coefficient in cruise condition

Fuselage upper, mid and lower streamlines

Rapid variation in Cp on the Nose, wf intersection and Fairing components

Aircraft Components Optimization

On body streamlines, isometric view

TCAD Technical Committee

Aircraft Design

Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th SCAD (Symposium on Collaboration in Aircraft Design 12th-14th October 2015

Page 8: Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configurationwpage.unina.it/fabrnico/SCAD2015/presentations/DellaVecchia_SCAD2015.pdfChallenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th

Pierluigi Della Vecchia 8

CHOSEN COMPONENTS TO BE OPTIMIZED ON THE BASELINE WING-BODY NOSE

WF JUNCTION

FAIRING

Aircraft Components Optimization

TCAD Technical Committee

Aircraft Design

Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th SCAD (Symposium on Collaboration in Aircraft Design 12th-14th October 2015

Page 9: Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configurationwpage.unina.it/fabrnico/SCAD2015/presentations/DellaVecchia_SCAD2015.pdfChallenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th

Pierluigi Della Vecchia 9

Symmetry plane y = 0 m

Baseline Optimized

“x” cut planes

Wing-Fuselage junction Optimization

TCAD Technical Committee

Aircraft Design

Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th SCAD (Symposium on Collaboration in Aircraft Design 12th-14th October 2015

Page 10: Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configurationwpage.unina.it/fabrnico/SCAD2015/presentations/DellaVecchia_SCAD2015.pdfChallenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th

Pierluigi Della Vecchia 10

Wing-Fuselage junction Optimization

TCAD Technical Committee

Aircraft Design

Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th SCAD (Symposium on Collaboration in Aircraft Design 12th-14th October 2015

Baseline

Optimized

Page 11: Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configurationwpage.unina.it/fabrnico/SCAD2015/presentations/DellaVecchia_SCAD2015.pdfChallenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th

Pierluigi Della Vecchia 11

Optimized

No more separation

Reduced Cp gradients

Wing-Fuselage junction Optimization

CruiseincountsCD 7.6=∆ Climb2.8 incountsCD =∆ ktsVMAX 3.3=∆

TCAD Technical Committee

Aircraft Design

Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th SCAD (Symposium on Collaboration in Aircraft Design 12th-14th October 2015

Baseline

Page 12: Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configurationwpage.unina.it/fabrnico/SCAD2015/presentations/DellaVecchia_SCAD2015.pdfChallenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th

Pierluigi Della Vecchia 12

Wing-Fuselage junction Optimization

TCAD Technical Committee

Aircraft Design

Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th SCAD (Symposium on Collaboration in Aircraft Design 12th-14th October 2015

Δvmax (h=20kft) +4kts

Δfuelsaved (200nmi, typical mission profile)

-10kg

Page 13: Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configurationwpage.unina.it/fabrnico/SCAD2015/presentations/DellaVecchia_SCAD2015.pdfChallenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th

Pierluigi Della Vecchia 13

Baseline Optimized

Nose Optimization

TCAD Technical Committee

Aircraft Design

Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th SCAD (Symposium on Collaboration in Aircraft Design 12th-14th October 2015

Page 14: Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configurationwpage.unina.it/fabrnico/SCAD2015/presentations/DellaVecchia_SCAD2015.pdfChallenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th

Pierluigi Della Vecchia 14

Transition imposed at 0.5m from the aircraft nose

CruiseincountsCD 3.3=∆

bCincountsCD lim5.3=∆

ktsVMAX 6.1=∆

%5+=αMC

Reduced Compression and

more gradual expansion

WB Config.

CD pressure (counts)

CD skin frition (counts)

CD Total (counts)

Baseline 62.8 117.8 180.7

Optimized 59.3 118.1 177.4

Nose Optimization

TCAD Technical Committee

Aircraft Design

Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th SCAD (Symposium on Collaboration in Aircraft Design 12th-14th October 2015

Page 15: Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configurationwpage.unina.it/fabrnico/SCAD2015/presentations/DellaVecchia_SCAD2015.pdfChallenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th

Conventional 90-seats

Pierluigi Della Vecchia 16

Wing Laminar Flow – Engine Integration

TCAD Technical Committee

Aircraft Design

Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th SCAD (Symposium on Collaboration in Aircraft Design 12th-14th October 2015

Innovative rear-propelled 90-seats

Data Conventional Innovative CDo wing 0.0070 0.0051 (through 40% laminar

flow) CDo aircraft 0.0270 0.0251 e (Oswald efficiency factor)

0.78 0.85 (winglet installed)

Engine SFC [lb/(hp hr)] 0.40 0.36 or 0.32 -10% or -20%

Turboprop innovative configuration benefits Specific range

up to about 8% fuel saving can be achieved only through laminar flow on the wing

Data Conventional Innovative 1 (Laminar flow)

Innovative 2 (Laminar flow + SFC red -10%

Innovative 3 (Laminar flow + SFC red -20%

Specific Range @ M=0.56 (nm/lb_fuel) 0.23 0.25 (+9%) 0.275(+19%) 0.318(+38%) Fuel @ 300 nm mission (lb) 1304 lb 1200 lb (-8%) 1091 lb (-16%) 943 lb(-28%)

Page 16: Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configurationwpage.unina.it/fabrnico/SCAD2015/presentations/DellaVecchia_SCAD2015.pdfChallenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th

Pierluigi Della Vecchia 17

Vertical Empennage Design – Control Surface

TCAD Technical Committee

Aircraft Design

Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th SCAD (Symposium on Collaboration in Aircraft Design 12th-14th October 2015

Conventional Turboprop Vertical Empennage Innovative Turboprop Vertical Empennage

8drag counts (cruise)DC∆ =

max 4V kts∆ =

13 (200nmi mission profile)savedfuel kg∆ =

Page 17: Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configurationwpage.unina.it/fabrnico/SCAD2015/presentations/DellaVecchia_SCAD2015.pdfChallenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th

Pierluigi Della Vecchia 18

A turboprop aircraft spends 50% of its life time during climb and descent phases. About 50% of fuel during climb

Winglet Design and Optimization

TCAD Technical Committee

Aircraft Design

Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th SCAD (Symposium on Collaboration in Aircraft Design 12th-14th October 2015

Page 18: Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configurationwpage.unina.it/fabrnico/SCAD2015/presentations/DellaVecchia_SCAD2015.pdfChallenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th

Pierluigi Della Vecchia 19

Wing Tip Design for a Regional Turboprop

TCAD Technical Committee

Aircraft Design

Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th SCAD (Symposium on Collaboration in Aircraft Design 12th-14th October 2015

Possible New Turboprop wing-tip assessment

Page 19: Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configurationwpage.unina.it/fabrnico/SCAD2015/presentations/DellaVecchia_SCAD2015.pdfChallenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th

Pierluigi Della Vecchia 20

Conclusions

TCAD Technical Committee

Aircraft Design

Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th SCAD (Symposium on Collaboration in Aircraft Design 12th-14th October 2015

A novel turboprop can achieved the following improvements: - 3% drag reduction (11 counts) nose, wf-junction and fairing - 4% drag reduction (20 counts) wing laminar flow (rear engine)

- 3% drag reduction (15 counts) not balanced control surfaces

- +10% on Oswald factor with winglet TOTAL OF 40 DRAG COUNTS REDUCTION MAXIMUM SPEED IMPROVEMENT 0F V_TAS > 15 kt

FUEL CONSUMPTION REDUCTION OF 60 kg (i.e 11% during typical 200 nm mission )

+30% RATE OF CLIMB IN ONE ENGINE INOPERATIVE OEI

Page 20: Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configurationwpage.unina.it/fabrnico/SCAD2015/presentations/DellaVecchia_SCAD2015.pdfChallenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th

Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration

Pierluigi Della Vecchia, PhD.

Pierluigi Della Vecchia 21 Challenges for new Regional Turboprop Configuration, 5th SCAD (Symposium on Collaboration in Aircraft Design 12th-14th October 2015

TCAD Technical Committee

Aircraft Design

University of Naples Federico II Department of Industrial Engineering Via Claudio, 21, 80125 Naples [email protected] http://wpage.unina.it/pierluigi.dellavecchia/ http://wpage.unina.it/fabrnico/DAF/