closing the gap between knowing and doing · how to develop secure human behaviour? closing the gap...

38
How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP [email protected]

Upload: others

Post on 17-Aug-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing

11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72

Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP [email protected]

Page 2: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

About BeOne DevelopmentAbout BeOne Development

Page 3: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

An introduction

Page 4: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP
Page 5: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP
Page 6: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP
Page 7: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP
Page 8: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Holle Bolle Gijs eats 460.000 kilos of paper a year.

Holle Bolle Gijs has eaten a total of more than 25 million kilos of paper.

Page 9: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Technology, organisation and ….. humans

Page 10: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

The human factor is hot …

Page 11: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Security Awareness in the past

…. but often ineffective

Page 12: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Security Awareness in the past

❑❑❑❑❑❑❑❑

Page 13: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Why we know, but don’t do

Source: Tali Sharot, ‘The optimism bias’

Page 14: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Security awareness is a process

✓ Involve management

✓ Organise the right project team

✓ On-boarding for new employees

✓ Information security fundamentals

Page 15: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Is broadcasting knowledge sufficient?

Page 16: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Behavioural change

10:30

Open minded

Understanding

Willing

Maintaining

Doing

Be able to

Source: M.F.K. Balm, ‘Behavioural change model’

Page 17: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Confrontation by testing

Page 18: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Moving with pleasure

and

freezing with fear

Page 19: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Start with making an

emotional connection

Page 20: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP
Page 21: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Ebbinghaus forgetting curve

Page 22: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Learning piramid & retentie

Source: Institute for Applied Behaviour Sciences

Lecture

5 %

Demonstration

30 %

Practice by doing

75 %

Reading

10 %

Audio-visual

20 %

Teaching

80 %

Using a blend of approaches results in a substantial increase in knowledge retention

Page 23: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Is warning sufficient?

Page 24: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Add confrontation and immediate feedback

Page 25: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

From knowing to doing

Page 26: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Normative beliefs

Please reuse your towels to safe money

30%

75% of the hotel guests reused the towels

Help safe the environment.

You can show your respect for nature and help save the environment

by reusing your towels during your stay

15%

45%

50%75% of the guests who also stayed in this room reused the towels

Page 27: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Normative beliefs

+12%

+5%

+16%

9 out of 10 people in Britain paid their tax on time

9 out of 10 people in your town paid their tax on time

9 out of 10 people in your town paid their tax on time

and you are one of the few people who have not paid yet

Page 28: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Monitor Knowledge & skills

Simulate & test

Report compliance and offer feedback

PDCA approach: immediate feedback with awareness dashboard

Page 29: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Use a risk based approach

Page 30: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Theme: phishing

Knowledge Skills

Repeat

Test

Feedback

Page 31: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Theme: strong passwords

Page 32: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Theme: social engineering

Page 33: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Theme: USB sticks

Page 34: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Theme: cloud services

Page 35: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Develop a continuous multi channel communication program

Test & confrontation Inform, knowledge & skills Report compliance

Page 36: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Take aways to create a positive security culture

1. Develop a long term communication program

2. Measure behaviour & confrontation

3. Train knowledge & skills continuously

4. Give direct feedback & show behavioural compliance

Page 37: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

Questions?

Page 38: Closing the gap between knowing and doing · How to develop secure human behaviour? Closing the gap between knowing and doing 11:30 uur - Amsterdam ‘72 Wilbert Pijnenburg CISA CISSP

For more information see our website: www.beonedevelopment.com

Bergweg 44

1217 SC Hilversum

The Netherlands

[email protected] +31 (0)35 20 30 216

Contact Information