complaint counsel' pursuant to rule 3.46(c)€¦ · highland park, ilinois tr. 4882 - 4924...

58
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA BEFORE FEDERA TRAE COMMISSION In the matter of Docket No. 9315 Public Evanston Northwestern Healthcare Corporation a corporation, and ENH Medical Group, Inc. a corporation. COMPLAINT COUNSEL' S WITNESS INDEX PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)

Upload: others

Post on 05-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

UNITED STATES OF AMERICABEFORE FEDERA TRAE COMMISSION

In the matter of

Docket No. 9315

PublicEvanston Northwestern Healthcare

Corporationa corporation, and

ENH Medical Group, Inc.a corporation.

COMPLAINT COUNSEL'S WITNESS INDEXPURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)

Page 2: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

IN T

HE

MA

TT

ER

OF

EV

AN

STO

N N

OR

TH

WE

STE

RN

HE

AL

TH

CA

RE

- D

ocke

t No.

931

5W

ITN

ESS

IN

DE

XN

ame

.. T

itle

CQ

mpa

nyTranscript Cite

Dat

eA

nkin

, Mic

hael

G.,

Phy

sici

an a

nd P

resi

dent

Pul

mon

ary

Phy

sici

ans

of th

eT

r. 5

032

- 50

963/

24/2

005

Nor

th S

hore

Tr.

510

3 -

5105

in c

amer

a3/

24/2

005

in c

amer

aB

alle

ngee

, Jan

eT

erri

tory

Dir

ecto

rP

rivat

e H

ealth

Car

e S

yste

mT

r. 1

41 -

216

2/10

/200

5(P

HC

S)T

r. 2

24 -

272

in c

amer

a2/

10/2

005

in c

amer

aB

aker

, Jon

atha

n, B

.E

cono

mis

t and

Law

yer

Was

hing

ton

Col

lege

of L

awT

r. 4

587

- 46

103/

22/2

005

and

Cha

rles

Riv

erPh

DR

espo

nden

t's

Exp

ert W

itnes

sA

ssoc

iate

sT

r. 4

617

- 48

21 in

cam

era

3/22

/200

5 in

ca

mer

aB

elsk

v, M

icha

elT

he H

onor

able

May

orH

ighl

and

Park

, Ilin

ois

Tr.

488

2 -

4924

3/23

/200

5C

han

, The

resa

Adm

inis

trat

or o

f Ph

ysic

ian

Chi

ldre

ns

Mem

oria

l Hos

pita

lT

r. 6

47 -

748

2/14

/200

5Se

rvic

esT

r. 7

77 -

867

in c

amer

a2/

14/2

005

in c

amer

aP

hysi

cian

; The

Edm

ond

A.

Gug

genh

eim

Pro

fess

or o

f Hea

lthT

r.51

18-

5405

3/28

/200

5C

hass

in, M

ark

R.

Pol

icy;

Cha

irman

of t

heM

ount

Sin

ai S

choo

l of

Tr.

541

2 -

5421

in c

amer

a3/

28/2

005

in c

amer

aD

epar

tmen

t of H

ealth

Pol

icy;

Med

icin

eT

r. 5

428

- 56

263/

29/2

005

Exe

cutiv

e V

ice

Pre

side

nt fo

rE

xcel

lenc

e in

Pat

ient

Car

eA

ssoc

iate

Dire

ctor

of

Dorsey, Kevin A.

Uni

vers

ity o

f Il

lnoi

sM

anag

ed C

are

and

Tr.

142

7 -

1491

2/17

/200

5B

usin

ess

Rel

atio

ns

Dra

gon

, Leo

n, M

.Pr

actic

ing

Phys

icia

n, M

edic

alU

nive

rsity

of I

llino

isT

r. 4

299

- 44

113/

18/2

005

Onc

olog

yE

lzin

ga, K

enne

th G

.T

he R

ober

t C. T

aylo

r P

rofe

ssor

of

Uni

vers

ity o

f Virg

inia

Tr.

234

2 - 2

418

2/25

/200

5Ph

.E

cono

mic

s

Fouc

re, J

ilian

Ren

eeR

egio

nal V

ice

Pre

side

nt fo

rU

nite

d H

ealth

Net

wor

ksT

r. 8

76 -

951

.2/

15/0

5C

entr

al R

eqio

nT

r. 1

075

-11

31 in

cam

era

2/15

/05

in c

amer

aT

r. 2

433

- 25

023/

1/20

05T

r. 2

509

- 26

49 in

cam

era

3/1/

2005

in c

amer

aH

aas-

Wils

onP

rofe

ssor

of E

cono

mic

sSmith College

Tr.

265

6 -

2689

3/2/

2005

Deb

orah

, Ph.

Tr.

269

6 -

2908

in c

amer

a3/

2/20

05 in

cam

era

Tr.

291

5 -

2946

3/3/

2005

Tr.

303

4 -

3042

in c

amer

a3/

3/20

05 in

cam

era

Har

ris, B

ruce

, M.

Sta

ff P

hysi

cian

and

Med

ical

Hig

hlan

d P

ark

Hos

pita

lT

r. 4

201

- 42

993/

18/2

005

Dir

ecto

rT

r. 4

418

- 44

28 in

cam

era

3/18

/200

5 in

cam

era

Page 3: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

LO LO LO000000N NNNNN

---

N N N

!: !:

.. 0Q) .-1; COQ) L-3: 0.c E-t 0o U

!: ..

.. 0tn

!: =:

m m:; Q)W I

LO LO

I' I'

.. ..

'0 3: Q) .c E

co 0zQ)c. Z!: L- Q) ~ o~o co 1;.c rn J: enU !:=:'o=:!:

.-

co co !: co co

:5 Jj~ ~Jj

3: -Q) s;

..

Q) U.E a: "Q) 13 cQ)

Q) C co in E a: L- Q) 'a.

.g

:5 ~'E'O

..

U- Q) i-

CO~L-Q).!:00:;2:0t) E Q) "" "Q)9c.o!:i5.5$

o I

!:

tn Q) 3: .c ZQ) ZQ)c .. C .. 0 .. 0tn .c tn c:! C CO CO CO CO:; Q) :; Q)W I W I

..

.E

Q) -in tn

CD ~:E

!: a..-gjQ) 2: L-m o Q)a.

a.

01 - 0

.-

~ aico ;:Q)

!:

m "t= .CO tn.c Q) :!0: a. en ..

LO LO

M MN NM M

.. Mco Vco m

M Mco mv v

.. ..

I- I-

LO LO

to to

.. ..(;

CO CO

.. ..

Q) Q) CO m

~ .~ .

LO LO LO LO LO LO000000000000NNNNNN

-- -- -- -. -- -.

....LOLOtOtOT-T- T"T"

-. -- -- -- -. --

NNNNNN

LO LO

N N

.. ..

co .9 CO L. tJ I- Q) 01 CO Q) CD E co:; CO O:: .; E Q) co .

~ .

o motOCON .. -: !:

..

tO..MV

('(".. ..

::m.. I co m.ovLOT" I . I'LOV to!: I NI'COCOI'O O~LOLOMMvm

to co M .. M ~ I' .. LO "-. "- MMMtO cito gVLOm......

~~~~~ ~~~~~~

ro E Q) c. - tn tn

.c ~~ t Co 0 a. ZQ)2Q)gmgjiiai -;

comtco

.-

:; Q) 0 I WIZI

!:

co L-E 0!: 13co Q)

.. .

01 a: .

.. - ..!: ::

co "".9

-g

tn 04)

"!:

s; . g~:B:B

E !:tn .. coQ) ..3: 0.c E-t 0o U!: L-

o m- 0tn

!: =:

m m:; Q)W I

.- Q)tn

~ !Ea. 0

to toV I'to I'o LOco LOLO I'

I- I-

Q) :2

.. =:

co co

:5 Iro Q)Q) !:I 01; Q)

S 5ii oQ) Q)L- ..C) e:

Q) o !:~ 0

.. .-

Q) a:Z ..

.. .

Q) 001 ..co a.

!: "

co !:

LO LOOOLOLOLOLO000000NNOOOONNNNT"T"-.-.----....vvLOLO

---.-.-.---.

N N M M M M

co co ~G3 .E E.co coE0 ::

~ .~~~~~

mmovtO..T"N..T" ..I co

~~~~~

tOmmvv

~~~~

.. .. .. I- L.I-I-I-I-I-UO

4i Q) co

~ .

!: momm.- M N N VvvO..NNI' .. to to to tovlO

I co r- r- r-cococovNMI'mCOO..NNvLOtOtOtO.. L. I- I- I- I- I- I-

a: tQ) Q)~ c.;: x" W

!:

co :;

-; :B

"- "

E !:o 0!: c.

wa:

.c .Q) .o .cZ a.

Page 4: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Tr.

347

0 -

3581

3/15

/200

5B

rien,

Mar

yPr

esid

ent

Hig

hlan

d P

ark

Hos

pita

lT

r. 3

662

- 36

80 in

cam

era

3/15

/200

5 in

cam

era

CX

628

7 at

1- 4 (O'

Bri

en3/

18/2

005

Dep

.4/

7/20

05O

gden

, Kim

Jan

ette

For

mer

Par

tner

Bai

n &

Com

pany

RX

204

7 at

1- 6

6 (O

gden

Dep

.Po

rn, L

ouis

, M.

Par

tner

in th

e H

ealth

care

Are

aD

eloi

tte C

onsu

ltino

Tr.

563

6 -

5690

3/30

/200

5T

r. 2

962

- 30

273/

3/20

05T

r. 3

043

- 32

36 in

cam

era

3/3/

2005

in c

amer

aR

oman

o, P

atric

k, S

.P

rofe

ssor

of I

nter

nal M

edic

ine

Uni

vers

ity o

f C

alif

orni

aT

r. 3

244

- 34

423/

14/2

005

Dav

is, S

choo

l of M

edic

ine

Tr.

344

9 -

3462

in c

amer

a3/

14/2

005

in c

amer

aT

r. 6

271

- 62

904/

7/20

05T

r. 6

303

- 63

71 in

cam

era

4/7/

2005

in c

amer

aP

ract

icin

g P

hysi

cian

and

Hea

d of

Evanston Northwestern

Tr.

443

5 -

4566

3/21

/200

5R

osen

gart

, Tod

d, M

.th

e D

ivis

ion

of C

ardi

otho

raci

cH

ealth

care

Tr.

457

8 -

4580

in c

amer

a3/

21/2

005

in c

amer

aSu

raer

v

Schellng, Heidi

Vic

e Pr

esid

ent o

f B

usin

ess

Palla

tive

Car

eCen

ter

and

CX

630

7 at

1- 2

8 (S

chel

lng,

Dev

elop

men

tH

ospi

ce N

orth

Sho

reD

ep.

Sim

pson

, Joh

nEconomist, Complaint Counsel'

Fed

eral

Tra

de C

omm

issi

onT

r. 1

616

- 165

02/

18/2

005

Exp

ert

Sira

bian

, Joh

nV

ice

Pres

iden

t of

Fina

nce

Evanston Northwestern

Tr.

569

1 -

5765

3/30

/200

5H

ealth

care

(E

x-em

Dlo

vee)

Silv

er, R

icha

rdO

bste

tric

ian

and

Gyn

ecol

ogis

tEvanston Northwestern

Tr.

375

7 -

3868

3/16

/200

5H

ealth

care

Tr.

387

9 -

3937

in c

amer

a3/

16/2

005

inca

mer

aSp

aeth

, Ron

ald

G.

Pre

side

nt a

nd C

EO

Evanston Northwestern

Tr.

207

4 -

2318

2/24

/200

5Healthcare COrDoration

Tr.

232

6 -

2332

in c

amer

a2/

24/2

005

in c

amer

a

Stearns, Neele E.

, Jr,

Dir

ecto

rEvanston Northwestern

CX

630

5 at

1- 1

9 (S

tear

ns,

Healthcare COrDoration

Dep

.

Sty

er, J

ames

Cha

irm

anH

ealth

care

Fou

ndat

ion

ofT

r. 4

950

- 50

313/

24/2

005

Hio

hlan

d Pa

rk

Vic

tor ,

Tho

mas

, A.,

Cha

irman

of t

he D

epar

tmen

t of

Evanston Northwestern

Pathology and Laboratory

Healthcare Corporation

Tr.

358

2 -

3655

3/15

/200

5M

edic

ine

Wag

ner ,

Arn

old

, Jr.

Obs

tetr

icia

n an

d G

ynec

olog

ist

Evanston Northwestern

Tr.

394

4 -

4082

3/17

/200

5H

ealth

care

Page 5: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I hereby certify that on May 20 2005 , I caused copies of the Complaint Counsel' s Witness Index

to be served on the following persons by electronic mail and first class mail delivery:

Michael L. Sibarum. WISTON & STRAWN, LLP

1400 L Street, NWWashington, DC 20005

Duane M. KelleyWISTON & STRAWN, LLP35 West Wacker DriveChicago, IL 60601-9703

Charles B. KleinWISTON & STRAWN, LLP1400 L Street, NWWashington, DC 20005

and the delivery of three copies and an electronic version to:

The Honorable Stephen J. McGuireFederal Trade Commission600 Pennsylvana AvenueRoom 113Washington, DC 20580

!ytJ/u5Date Chul Pak

Complaint Counsel

Page 6: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

UNITED STATES OF AMERICABEFORE FEDERA TRAE COMMISSION

In the matter of

Evanston Northwestern HealthcareCorporation

a corporation, and

ENH Medical Group, Inc.a corporation.

Public

Docket No. 9315

COMPLAINT COUNSEL'S EXHIBIT INDEXPURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(b)

Page 7: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

IN T

HE

MA

TT

ER

OF

EV

AN

STO

N N

OR

TH

WE

STE

RN

HE

AL

TH

CA

R -

Doc

ket N

o. 9

315

CO

MPL

AIT

CO

UN

SEL

'S E

XH

mIT

IN

DE

X O

F A

DM

ITT

ED

DO

CU

ME

NT

SE

xhib

itD

ocum

ent.

Titl

eA

dmis

sibi

ltyT

rans

crip

t Cite

at w

hich

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yIn Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

Num

'ber

Ord

erE

xhib

it is

Dis

cuss

ed.

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

lHig

hlan

d P

ark

Hos

pita

l , Rep

rese

ntat

ives

to J

oint

CX

OO

OO

ID

iscu

ssio

nsJX

IT

r. 5

019-

5027

CX

0000

2M

inut

es o

f M

edic

al E

xecu

tive

Com

mitt

eeJX

IT

r. 1

044

2212

- 221

4 (P

ub)

CX

0000

3F

all G

ala

Tha

ned

Mr.

Kra

emer

for

the

use

of B

axte

r B

uild

ing

JX I

Tr.

220

5-22

07 (

Pub

)T

r. 5

0-, 2

209-

2212

, 221

4-22

19C

X00

004

Rep

ort o

f th

e C

hair

man

JX I

2216

- 221

723

03-2

305

(Pub

)T

r. 5

2, 3

69-3

71, 4

65, 1

195-

1197

1388

1819

- 182

320

55- 2

058

(Pub

)C

X00

005

Minutes of Evanston Nortwestern Healthcare Board of Directors ' E

xecu

tive

Com

mitt

eeJX 1

838

(In

Car

)T

r. 1

197-

1200

, 138

8-13

89, 1

821-

CX

0000

6Minutes of Evanston Nortwestern Healthcare Board of Directors ' E

xecu

tive

Com

mitt

eeJX 1

1822

2058

(P

ub)

CX

0000

7M

inut

es o

f E

NH

Fin

ance

Com

mitt

ee B

oard

of

Dir

ecto

rs.

JX I

CX

0000

8Minutes ofENH Finance Committee Board of Directors

JX I

Mem

o tr

om N

eara

n to

Boa

rd o

f D

irec

tors

, Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

re:

CX

0000

9m

erge

r an

d in

tegr

atio

n ac

tiviti

esJX 1

CX

OO

OIO

Min

utes

of

Ove

rsig

ht C

omm

ttee

For

Syst

em I

nteg

ratio

nJX

ICXOOO II

Minutes of Evanston Nortwestern Healthcare Board of Directors ' M

eetin

gJX

IT

r. 1

823-

1824

(Pu

b)C

XO

OO

12

Min

utes

of

the

Hea

lthca

re S

ervi

ces

Com

mitt

ee -

Hig

hlan

d Pa

rkJX

IM

emo

trom

Nea

ran

to th

e B

oard

of D

irect

ors

, Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

re:

Tr.

53-

1200

- 120

218

16- 1

817

CX

OO

O 1

3Ju

ly 4

, 200

0- "

Inde

pend

ence

Day

JX I

(Pub

); 2

738-

2739

(In

Cam

)

Mem

o tr

om M

ittem

an to

EN

H M

edic

al G

roup

IP

A P

arci

patin

g Ph

ysic

ians

re:

Con

trac

tC

XO

OO

l4Grid. Attched ENH Medical Group Evanston Pod H

ealth

Pla

n C

ontr

acts

JX I

Ordered 2/9/0S

Agenda of Evanston Nortwestern Healthcare, Healthcare Services Commttee of the

CX

OO

OIS

Boa

rd o

f Dire

ctor

s. A

tach

ed m

inut

es o

f 07/

19/0

0 m

eetig

.JX 1

CX

OO

Ol6

Min

utes

of

the

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

Fin

ance

Com

mitt

ee M

eetin

gJX

IT

r. 1

9, 1

202-

1203

, 179

3 (P

ub)

Tr.

120

3-12

09, 1

370-

1371

, 181

7-M

emo

trom

Nea

ran

to B

oard

of D

irect

ors

, Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

re:

Fin

al18

1920

22-2

023

2041

- 204

2 (P

ub);

CX

OO

O 1

7R

epor

t --

Mer

ger

Inte

grat

ion

Act

iviti

es. A

ttach

ed B

oard

of

Dir

ecto

rs' S

umaI

.JX

I27

39-2

740

(In

Cam

)C

XO

OO

l8Le

tter

trom

Nea

ran

to J

ohno

n. A

ttach

ed le

tter

trom

Joh

nson

to N

eara

n.JX

lJX

ST

r. 6

260

(Pub

)Highland Park Hospita1vanston Northwestern Healthcare

, "

Impr

ovin

g H

ealth

care

inC

XO

OO

l9O

ur N

ort S

hore

Com

mun

ties

JX 1

Tr.

103

6, 1

038

, 180

1-18

02 (

Pub)

Tr.

126

9 (P

ub);

Tr.

192

7-19

28 (

InC

X00

020

Lette

r tr

om V

oss

to N

eara

nJX

IC

ar)

CX

0002

IFT

C R

eque

sted

Inf

Olm

atio

n C

ompl

ianc

e: C

onfi

dent

ial R

epor

tJX 1

Tr.

107

5, 1

076

, 111

1, 1

126

(In

Car

)Ordered 2/9/0S

CX

0002

2R

ESE

RV

ED

eXO

OO

BSt

atus

Rep

ort ,

Ern

st &

You

ng, M

erge

r R

elat

ed O

ppor

tniti

esJX

IM

emo

trom

Cha

n to

Gilb

ert r

e: E

stim

ate

of A

nual

Inc

reas

e in

Net

Rev

enue

. Atta

ched

CX

0002

4ex

hbit.

JX I

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

Page 8: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Adl

lissi

bjIi

tyT

rans

crip

t Cite

at .

whi

chR

elat

edSU

llmar

yN

Ullb

erD

Ocu

llellt

Titl

eO

rder

Exb

ibiti

sDis

cuss

edE

xhib

itE

xhib

itIn Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

CX

0002

520

00/2

001

Bud

get A

ssum

ptio

ns a

nd H

ighl

ight

sJX 1

CX

0002

6E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re E

stim

ated

Anu

al I

ncre

ase

in N

et R

even

ueJX 1

CX

0002

7A

gend

a of

EN

H O

vers

ight

Com

mitt

ee F

or S

yste

m I

nteg

ratio

n B

oard

of

Dir

ecto

rsJX 1

CX

0002

8R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0002

9M

inut

es o

f O

vers

ight

Com

mitt

ee f

or S

yste

m I

nteg

ratio

nJX 1

Tr.

205

8 (P

ub)

Mem

o fr

om C

han

to N

ewto

n an

d G

ilber

t re:

Ana

lysi

s of

Man

aged

Car

e C

ontr

acts

.T

r. 6

88, 6

90, 7

16 (

Pub)

; 821

, 824

(In

CX

0003

0A

ttach

ed r

elat

ed d

ocum

ents

.JX

IC

ar)

CX

0003

1E

cono

mic

Mea

sure

s of

Suc

cess

: EN

H/H

PH M

erge

r/FY

200

0JX

IT

r. 1

263-

1269

(Pu

b)C

X00

032

-C

X00

041

RE

SER

VE

DM

emo

from

Ber

ger

to C

harg

emas

ter

Tra

nsiti

on T

ear

re: A

gend

a fo

r 0

l/06/

2000

CX

0004

2meeting. Attached agenda materials.

JX I

CX

0004

3L

ette

r fr

om P

orn

to H

ilebr

and

re: p

ropo

sal f

or s

trat

egic

hos

pita

l pri

cing

rev

iew

JX I

Tr.

567

1-56

76 (

Pub

)Email fi. om

Hod

ges

to W

asha

, et a

l re:

Atta

ched

, Atta

ched

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rnC

X00

044

Hea

lthca

re S

trat

egic

Pri

cing

Rev

iew

Pro

ject

Upd

ate.

JX 1

Tr.

203

2-20

36 (

Pub

)

Mem

o fr

om C

ohen

to H

ilebr

and

re: S

trat

egic

Pri

cing

Pro

ject

Doc

umen

tatio

n. A

ttach

edE

NH

Str

ateg

ic P

rici

ng P

roje

ct -

Lis

t of

File

s In

clud

ed o

n C

D- R

om; S

trat

egic

Pric

ing

CX

0004

5R

evie

w G

uide

; EN

H S

trat

egic

Pri

cing

Rev

iew

Gui

de F

inal

Pro

ject

Sum

ar.

JX 1

Tr.

171

9-17

2156

84- 5

687

(Pub

)C

X00

046

Em

ail f

rom

Bal

leng

ee to

Krz

emin

ski r

e: H

PH

/van

ston

sce

naro

sJX 1

Tr.

241

- 249

, 261

- 264

(In

Car

)R

X77

2Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0004

7 -

CX

0005

3R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0005

4Email fi. om

Hile

bran

d to

Min

ugh

re: P

rici

ng -

Pay

or C

omm

unic

atio

n St

rate

gyJX 1

Tr.

194

0-19

42 (

In C

ar)

CX

0005

5 -

CX

0005

6R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0005

7E

mai

l fro

m H

ilebr

and

to N

eara

n an

d G

olbu

s re

: Uni

ted

Upd

ate

JX 1

Tr.

192

3-19

24 (

In C

ar)

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

CX

0005

8R

ESE

RV

ED

Tr.

179

4-18

00 (

Pub)

Mem

o fr

om C

han

to G

ilber

t and

Sir

abia

n re

: CIG

NA

' s R

eque

st f

or H

isto

rica

l Pri

ceC

X00

059

Incr

ease

Inf

ornl

atio

nJX 1

Tr.

846

, 849

(In

Car

)C

X00

060

-C

X00

065

RE

SER

VE

DL

ette

r fr

om F

arka

s to

Nea

ran

re: p

ropo

sed

appr

oach

to m

erge

r. A

ttach

ed N

H N

orth

CX

0006

6sl

ides

.JX 1

Tr.

115

5-11

58, 1367-

1369

(Pu

b)

(Ord

ered

2/9

/05)

. . N

ote:

Bai

n &

Com

pany

, Eva

nsto

n N

orth

wes

tern

Hea

ithca

re G

row

th Opportities from the

Tr.

118

0-11

87, 1

387-

1388

, 180

6-R

espo

nden

t with

drew

In

CX

0006

7H

ighl

and

Park

Mer

ger

Fina

l Pro

ject

Rev

iew

JX I

1810

2059

- 206

1 (P

ub)

RX

0785

Cam

era

Sta

tus;

Tr.

118

1T

r. 1

371

1812

- 181

620

23- 2

022

CX

0006

8E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re, C

orpo

rate

Str

ateg

y 20

01- 2

003

JX 1

(Pub

)C

X00

069

Eff

ectiv

e C

omm

unca

tions

Dur

ing

a H

ospi

tal M

erge

rJX 1

CX

0007

0 -

CX

0007

3R

ESE

RV

ED

Page 9: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Adm

issi

bilty

Tra

nscr

ipt C

ite a

t whi

chR

elat

edSu

mm

ary

Num

ber

Doc

umen

t Titl

eO

rder

Exh

ibit.

isD

iscu

ssed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

In Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

Bai

n &

Com

pany

, Eva

nsto

n N

orth

wes

tern

Hea

lthca

re G

row

th Opportities nom the

Tr.

116

1-11

70, 1

369-

1370

, 180

0-C

X00

07 4

Hig

hlan

d Pa

rk M

erge

rJX

I18

01 (

pub)

Bai

n &

Com

pany

, Eva

nsto

n N

orth

wes

tern

Hea

lthca

re G

row

th Opportties nom

the

(Ord

ered

2/9

/05)

. Not

e:T

r. 1

170-

1173

, 133

9-13

46, 1

383-

Res

pond

ent w

ithdr

ew I

nC

X00

07 5

Hig

hlan

d Pa

rk M

erge

rJX

I13

84, 1

802-

1806

(Pu

b). R

X06

84C

amer

a st

atus

CX

0007

6 -

CX

0008

3R

ESE

RV

ED

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

and

Lak

elan

d Se

rvic

es: P

ropo

sed

Mer

ger

CX

0008

4Pr

esen

tatio

n to

the

Boa

rd o

f D

irec

tors

with

attc

hmen

ts.

JX I

Tr.

179

3-17

94 (

Pub)

CX

0008

5L

akel

and

Hea

lth S

ervi

ces ,

Inc.

, Pro

file

and

Com

pars

on to

EN

H.

JX I

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

, Reg

iona

l Mar

ket O

pportty Assessment

, Pha

se I

CX

0008

6E

xecu

tive Su

nar,

Mar

ketin

g D

epar

ent

JX I

CX

0008

7E

NH

lPH

Tra

nsiti

on T

eam

Onc

olog

yJX

IC

X00

088

-C

X00

090

RE

SER

VE

DC

X00

091

1998

Goa

ls, L

akel

and

Hea

lth S

ervi

ces

JX I

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s , In

c., S

trat

egic

Pla

n 19

99-2

003

, Joi

nt F

inan

ce a

nd P

lang

CX

0009

2C

omm

ittee

JX I

Tr.

212

4, 2

134

, 215

5-21

56 (

Pub)

C:X

0009

3R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0009

419

97 M

ajor

Acc

ompl

ishm

ents

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

sJX

IC

X00

09 5

Min

utes

of

the

Boa

rd o

f D

irec

tors

, Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s, I

nc.

JX I

Tr.

387

- 388

460-

462

2148

- 215

5;C

X00

096

Min

utes

of

the

Boa

rd o

f T

rust

ees ,

Hig

hlan

d P

ark

Hos

pita

JX I

5016

- 501

9 (P

ub)

CX

0009

7M

emo

nom

Spa

eth

to M

embe

rs o

f th

e Fi

nanc

e C

omm

ttee

re: 1

999

Bud

get

JX I

Mem

o fr

om S

paet

h to

Exe

cutiv

e C

omm

ittee

, Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s , I

nc. r

e: f

isca

lC

X00

098

proj

ectio

nsJX

IT

r. 2

113-

2117

(P

ub)

CX

0009

9L

ette

r fr

om S

paet

h to

Ste

ams ,

Jr.

re:

maj

or is

sues

for

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

sJX

IT

r. 1

371-

1372

2117

- 211

9 (p

ub)

CX

OO

100

Rel

atio

nshi

p of

Per

form

ance

Im

prov

emen

t to

Stra

tegi

c Pl

anJX

IC

XO

OIO

IL

akel

and

Prim

ar C

are

Ass

ocia

tes ,

Lak

elan

d M

anag

emen

t Ser

vice

sJX

IC

XO

OI0

2 -

CX

OO

I 04

RE

SER

VE

D

CX

OO

I05

Mem

o no

m N

eara

n to

Kng

ht, e

t al r

e: U

pdat

e on

Hig

hlan

d Pa

rk H

ospi

tal D

iscu

ssio

nsJX

IT

r. 1

064

(Pub

)C

XO

OI0

6 -

CX

OO

11

0R

ESE

RV

ED

(Ord

ered

2/9

/05)

. Not

e:L

ette

r to

Jam

es L

. Wat

son

, V.P

. Med

ical

Del

iver

y Sy

stem

s , U

nite

d H

ealth

care

of

Ilin

ois

Res

pond

ent w

ithdr

ew I

nC

XO

O 1

11no

m J

ack

Gilb

ert ,

Sr.

V.

, Fin

ance

, Chi

ef F

inan

cial

Off

cer

with

atta

chm

ent.

JX I

Tr.

187

5-18

86, 1

899-

1901

(pu

b)R

X06

96C

amer

a St

atus

CX

OO

112

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

Ol1

3L

ette

r fr

om C

han

to B

erns

re:

PH

CS

rate

pro

posa

l res

pons

e, A

ttach

ed d

ocum

ents

.JX

IT

r. 2

33-2

35 (

In C

ar)

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

CX

OO

114

Mem

o fr

om C

han

to S

irbi

an r

e: U

nica

re.

JX I

Tr.

841

842

(In

Car

)C

X00

115

Let

ter

nom

Ber

ns to

Cha

n. A

ttche

d PH

CS

rate

pro

posa

l.JX

IT

r. 2

35- 2

36 (

In C

am)

Ordered 2/9/05

Page 10: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Document Title

Adm

issi

bilty

Tra

nscr

ipt C

ite a

t whi

chR

elat

edSl

!mm

ary

In Camera

Ord

erN

umbe

rO

rder

Exh

ibiti

sDis

cuss

edE

xhib

itE

xhib

itIn Camera

Page

(s)

Lette

r fr

om H

illeb

rand

and

Gol

bus

to B

alle

ngee

. Atta

ched

Eva

nton

NO

lthw

este

rnC

XO

Oll6

Hea

lthca

re F

inal

Rat

es.

JX I

Tr.

236

(In

Cam

)O

rder

ed

2/9/

0SC

XO

O 1

17L

ette

r fr

om B

alle

ngee

to H

illeb

rand

re:

fac

ilitie

s ra

tes

JX 1

Ord

ered

2/

9/0S

CX

OO

1l8

-C

XO

Oll9

RE

SER

VE

D

Let

ter

from

Hill

ebra

nd a

nd G

olbu

s to

Jan

s re

: EN

H f

inal

pro

posa

l to

CC

N. A

ttach

edC

XO

O 1

20E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re F

inal

Pro

posa

l on

Hos

pita

l . P

hysi

cian

Rat

es C

CN

.JX

IO

rder

ed

2/9/

0SFa

x fr

om J

ans

to C

han.

Atta

ched

Fac

ility

Con

trac

t Bet

wee

n C

CN

and

Eva

nsto

nC

XO

Ol2

1N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

.JX

IO

rder

ed 2

/9/0

5C

X00

122

Let

ter

from

Jan

s to

Hill

ebra

nd a

nd G

olbu

s re

: res

pons

e to

fial proposal

JX I

Let

ter

from

Hill

ebra

nd a

nd G

olbu

s to

Mal

otra

. Attched Evanston Nortwestern

CX

OO

l23

Hea

lthca

re P

ropo

sal t

o A

etna

.JX

IT

r. 5

31-5

40, 5

46- 5

49 (

in c

am)

Ordered 2/9/05

Let

ter

from

Hile

bran

d an

d G

olbu

s to

Flo

res.

Atta

ched

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rnC

XO

O 1

24H

ealth

care

Pro

posa

l to

Uni

care

.JX

IT

r. 1

532-

1535

; 158

0-15

81 (

In C

am)

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

OO

125

RE

SER

VE

DM

emo

tram

Cha

n to

GIl

bert

et a

l re:

Sta

tus

of M

anag

ed C

are Contracllg Acbvll1es.

Atta

ched

Sta

tus

of M

anag

ed C

are

Con

trac

tig A

ctiv

ities

and

lette

rs f

rom

Hile

bran

d an

dC

XO

O 1

26G

olbu

s.JX

IOrdered 2/9/05

CX

OO

l27

Agenda oflP A Integration Meetig. A

ttche

d ag

enda

mat

eria

ls.

JX I

Ord

ered

2/

9/0S

CX

OO

128

RE

SER

VE

D

Tr.

IS

SS- 1

5S6;

15

61- 1

562;

157

9-C

XO

Ol2

9M

emo

from

Pet

ers

to H

olt-

Dar

cy r

e: E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

reT

r. 1

562

1580

(In

Cam

)O

rder

ed

2/9/

0SC

XO

Ol3

0 -

CX

OO

l34

RE

SER

VE

DE

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re, T

op 5

Hos

pita

l Con

trac

ts, P

relim

inar

Rev

iew

CX

OO

l3S

Exe

cutiv

e Su

mar

JX I

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

OO

l36

-C

XO

Ol4

3R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

OO

l44

Em

ail f

rom

Gla

dden

to L

evin

e re

: Uni

ted

Upd

ate

JX I

, JX

5T

r. 6

260

(Pub

)O

rder

ed

2/9/

0SC

XO

Ol4

SE

mai

l fro

m L

ovel

and

to N

eam

an r

e: c

o-in

sura

nce

paym

ents

JX I

CX

0014

6 -

CX

OO

l61

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

Ol6

2L

ette

r fr

om S

irab

ian

to E

ckel

re:

Uni

ted

rate

pro

posa

lJX

IC

XO

Ol6

3Le

tter

from

Cha

n to

Wat

son.

Atta

ched

fax.

JX I

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

CX

OO

l64

-C

XO

O 1

70R

ESE

RV

ED

Let

ter

from

Cha

n an

d Si

rabi

an to

Bal

leng

ee r

e: E

NH

mer

ger.

Atta

ched

Pre

ferr

edC

XO

O 1

71Fa

cilit

y A

gree

men

t Hig

hlan

d Pa

rk H

ospi

tal.

JXI

CX

OO

172

Let

ter

from

Ber

ns to

Cha

n. A

ttach

ed P

HC

S Pr

opos

al.

JX I

Tr.

233

(In

Cam

)O

rder

ed 2

/9/0

5C

XO

Ol7

3 -

CX

OO

l7S

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

Ol7

6Fa

x fr

om B

erns

to C

han.

Attc

hed

PHC

S In

patie

nt P

ropo

sal f

or P

PO/P

OS.

JX I

Tr.

236

- 240

(In

Cam

)Ordered 2/9/05

Page 11: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

uD1en

tTitl

eA

dmis

sibi

lity

Tra

nscl

'ptC

ite a

twhi

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yIn Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

Num

ber

Ord

erExhibit is Discussed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

CX

OO

l77

-C

XO

Ol8

5R

ESE

RV

ED

Lette

r !T

om H

ilebr

and

and

Gol

bus

to G

rafr

e: E

NH

term

inat

ion

ofC

igna

con

trac

t.C

XO

Ol8

6A

ttach

ed E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re P

ropo

sal t

o C

IGN

A H

ealth

care

ofl

linoi

s.JX

IOrdered 2/9/05

CX

OO

l87

-C

X00

214

RE

SER

VE

D

CX

0021

5A

men

dmen

t I to

the

Agr

eem

ent B

etw

een

Rus

h Pr

uden

tial I

nsur

ance

Com

pany

and

HPH

JX I

Let

ter

!Tom

Pet

ers

to S

irab

ian.

Atta

ched

Uni

care

Lif

e &

Hea

lth I

nsur

ance

Com

pany

Tr.

154

8-15

49; 1

599-

1600

; 160

4-C

X00

216

Pari

cipa

ting

Hos

pita

l Agr

eem

ent

JX I

1605

(In

Car

)Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0021

7R

ESE

RV

ED

Lette

r !T

om H

ilebr

and

to F

lore

s re

: Rus

h P

rude

ntia

l and

Uni

care

con

trac

ts. A

ttche

dC

X00

218

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

Pro

posa

l to

Uni

care

.JX

IOrdered 2/9/05

CX

0021

9.C

X00

222

RE

SER

VE

DLe

tter

!Tom

Sira

bian

to C

un r

e: P

refe

rred

Pla

n ra

tes.

Attc

hed

Add

endu

m to

Pre

ferr

edC

X00

223

Plan

Con

trac

t with

Eva

nton

iGle

nbro

ok H

ospi

tals

ofl

linoi

s.JX

IC

;X00

224

.C

X00

245

RE

SER

VE

D

Lette

r !T

om C

han

and

Sira

bian

to J

ans

re: c

ontr

acts

. Atta

ched

Con

sent

to S

ign

and

CX

0024

6A

men

dmen

t to

Hos

pita

l Con

trac

t bet

wee

n C

CN

, Inc

. and

Hig

hlan

d P

ark

Hos

pita

l.JX

IC

X00

247

-C

X00

259

RE

SER

VE

DC

X00

260

Lette

r !T

om C

han

and

Gol

bus

to M

oldo

van

JX I

CX

0026

I R

ESE

RV

ED

Lette

r !T

om H

illeb

rand

and

Gol

bus

to N

ear.

Atta

ched

Eva

nsto

n N

orth

wes

tern

Tr.

755

, 760

(In

Car

); 1

436-

1438

CX

0026

2H

ealth

care

Pro

posa

l to

One

Hea

lth P

lan

of I

linoi

s.JX

I(P

ub)

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

CX

0026

3Le

tter

!Tom

Lev

ine

to N

ear

JX I

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0026

4Le

tter

!Tom

Hile

bran

d an

d G

olbu

s to

Dor

sey

re: O

ne H

ealth

not

ice

of te

rmin

atio

nJX

IC

X00

265

RE

SER

VE

DM

emo

!Tom

Mitt

eman

to L

evin

e, H

ilebr

and

, and

Gol

bus

re: O

ne H

ealth

plan

. Attc

hed

CX

0026

6le

tter.

JX I

CX

0026

7 -

CX

0027

7R

ESE

RV

ED

Lette

r !T

om H

illeb

rand

and

Gol

bus

to H

olde

rbau

m a

nd A

rang

o re

: req

uest

for

Tr.

201

8-20

2, 2

018.

2021

(P

ub);

Tr.

CX

0027

8re

nego

tiatio

n. A

ttach

ed E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re P

ropo

sal t

o H

MO

llin

ois.

JX I

1953

(In

Car

)C

X00

279

-C

X00

283

RE

SER

VE

DC

X00

284

Let

ter

!Tom

Ara

ngo

to G

ilber

t re:

HM

O ll

inoi

s Hospita Contract

JX I

CX

0028

5 -

CX

0032

3R

ESE

RV

ED

Page 12: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Adm

issi

bilty

Tia

nscr

iptC

ite a

twhi

chR

elat

edSU

Jrm

ary

Num

ber

Doc

umen

t Titl

eO

rder

Exh

ibit

is D

iscu

ssed

.E

xhib

itE

xhib

itIn Ca

era

()rd

erIn

Ca

era

Page

(s)

Lette

r fr

om H

illeb

rand

and

Gol

bus

to D

onov

an. A

ttach

ed E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

CX

0032

4H

ealth

care

Fin

al P

ropo

sal o

n H

ospi

tal a

nd P

hysi

cian

Rat

es.

JX I

RX

0839

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0032

5 -

CX

0034

7R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0034

8C

ombi

ned

Cor

e Se

rvic

e A

rea

Ana

lysi

sJX

IC

X00

349

RE

SER

VE

DE

mai

t fro

m N

eam

an to

Hile

bran

d re

o C

ompe

titiv

e M

arke

t Sha

re. A

ttach

ed E

vans

ton

CX

0035

0N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

Inpa

tient

Tot

al M

arke

t Sha

re D

ashb

oard

.JX

IT

r. 1

212-

1216

(Pu

b)C

X00

35I

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

Inp

atie

nt T

otal

Mar

ket S

hae

Das

hboa

rdJX

IC

X00

352

-C

X00

355

RE

SER

VE

DC

X00

356

EN

H C

onsu

mer

Aw

aren

ess

and

Attt

ude

Res

earc

hJX

IC

X00

357

-C

X00

35 8

RE

SER

VE

DE

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re a

nd L

akel

and

Hea

lth S

ervi

ces:

Pro

pose

d M

erge

rT

r. 1

047

, 104

9, 1

051

, 179

2-17

93C

X00

359

Pres

enta

tion

to th

e E

xecu

tive Conuittee of the Board of D

irec

tors

.JX

I(P

ub)

CX

0036

0E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

reIL

akel

and

Hea

lth S

ervi

ces , I

nc. M

arke

t Ass

essm

ent.

JX I

CX

0036

I -C

X00

367

RE

SER

VE

DC

X00

368

BA

IN f

ile r

eo E

NH

JX I

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0036

9 -

CX

0037

2R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0037

3L

ette

r fr

om N

eam

an to

Kng

ht. A

ttach

ed M

aste

r Sp

ace

Plan

, Sec

ond

Dra

f.JX

IC

X00

374

-C

X00

380

RE

SER

VE

DC

X00

381

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re N

etw

ork

His

tory

and

Fut

ue S

trat

egic

Dire

ctio

nJX

IT

r. 1

007

, 101

0 (P

ub)

CX

0038

2 -

CX

0038

3R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

003

84 .

Lette

r fr

om K

apla

n to

Mec

klen

burg

re:

Ern

est &

You

ng w

ork

for

NH

NJX

IC

X00

385

-C

X00

387

RE

SER

VE

DC

X00

388

Minutes of Evanston Nortwestern Healthcare Board of Directors ' M

eetin

gJX

IC

X00

389

-C

X00

392

RE

SER

VE

DC

X00

393

Cre

atio

n of

a R

egio

nal H

ealth

care

Del

iver

y Sy

stem

JX I

Tr. 1026 ,

102

7, 1

033

(Pub

)T

r. 1

018

, 178

9-17

9220

19- 2

020

CX

0039

4E

vans

ton

Hos

pita

l Cor

pora

tion.

JXI

(Pub

)C

X00

395

Nam

e-B

rand

Des

igna

tion

- N

H N

ort

JX I

Tr.

102

3-10

24, 1

363

, 136

4 (P

ub)

CX

0039

6Northwestern Healthcare Nort: Key Considerations

JX 1

Mem

o fr

om S

paet

h to

Boa

rd o

f D

irec

tors

and

Boa

rd o

f T

rust

ees

reo

2000

Bud

get.

CX

0039

7A

ttach

ed P

rese

ntat

ion

to th

e Fi

nanc

e Conuittee and 2000 Proposed Capita Budget

JX I

Page 13: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Adm

isi

bilit

yT

rans

cl'ip

JCite

atw

hich

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yN

umbe

rD

ocum

entT

itle

Ord

erExhibit is Discussed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

InC

amer

aO

rder

In Camera

Page

(s)

CX

0039

8 -

CX

0040

4R

ESE

RV

ED

Em

ail f

iom

Sin

ger

to G

olbu

s , M

iller

, and

Mur

os r

eo S

wnm

y of

mee

tings

with

CX

0040

5ph

ysic

ians

. Atta

ched

Sum

my

of I

nter

view

s w

ith E

NH

Ind

epen

dent

Phy

sici

ans.

JX I

JX5

Tr.

626

0 (P

ub)

CX

0040

6R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0040

7N

et O

pera

ting

Rev

enue

JX 1

CX

0040

8R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0040

9E

mai

l fio

m L

eona

r d to

Vag

noni

. Atta

ched

Per

fonn

ance

Im

prov

emen

t and

Pee

r R

evie

wJX

IC

X00

410

RE

SER

VE

DC

X00

411

Em

ail f

iom

Rya

n to

Vag

noni

reo

Phy

sici

an A

sses

smen

t in

GI

Lab

JX 1

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0041

2E

mai

l fio

m G

olbu

s to

Sch

ulz

reo

Med

ical

Gro

up C

ompe

titio

n.JX

IT

r. 1

244-

1246

5846

- 584

758

56-

CX

0041

3Ili

nois

Hea

lth F

acili

ties

Pla

nnig

Boa

rd A

pplic

atio

n fo

r P

enni

t for

HPH

JX 1

5859

(P

ub)

CX

0041

4 -

CX

0042

1 R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0042

2E

mai

l fio

m A

ram

oo to

Vag

noni

reo

Anu

al P

atie

nt S

afet

ylE

rror

Red

uctio

n R

epor

tJX 1

Ord

ered

1/2

6/05

(as

CX

0042

3E

mai

l fio

m M

ylin

to F

oucr

eJX 1

RX

1401

)C

X00

424

RE

SER

VE

DM

emo

fiom

Cau

lkin

s to

Hoo

ks r

eo S

umar

y of

Dec

embe

r 20

03 N

PSG

rel

ated

rep

orte

dC

X00

425

even

tsJX 1

Ordered 2/9/05

Ord

ered

1/2

6/05

(as

CX

0042

6L

ette

r fi

om W

asha

fio

m F

ouc

reJX 1

Tr.

109

9, 1

100

, 110

1 (I

n C

ar)

RX

1527

)O

rder

ed 1

/26/

05 (

asC

X00

427

Cha

rJX 1

RX

424)

CX

0042

8E

mai

l fio

m L

evin

e to

Gla

dden

reo

EN

H C

ontr

act

JX 1

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0042

9 -

CX

0043

7R

ESE

RV

ED

Lette

r fio

m N

eara

n to

Spa

eth.

Attc

hed

Key

Goa

ls, Principles and Timing of Proposed

CX

0043

8M

erge

r of

HPH

INH

JX 1

CX

0043

9Fi

nanc

e C

omm

ittee

, Man

aged

Car

e R

evie

w.

JX 1

Tr.

788

(In

Car

)C

X00

440

-C

X00

44 1

RE

SER

VE

DMemo fiom Nearan to Knght

, et a

i. re

o E

NH

lPH

Phy

sici

an M

eetin

g w

ithC

X00

442

atta

chm

ents

.JX 1

Tr.

104

0 (p

ub)

CX

0044

3 -

CX

0044

9R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0045

0E

mai

l fio

m C

han

to L

evin

e , r

eo T

erm

Let

ters

with

str

ing

of p

rior

e-m

ails

.JX 1

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0045

I -

CX

0045

4R

ESE

RV

ED

Page 14: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

tTitl

eA

dmis

sibi

ltyT

rans

crip

t Cite

at .

whi

chR

elat

edSu

mm

ary

In. C:atnera ()

rder

In C:amera

Page

(s)

Num

ber

Ord

erE

xhib

it is

Dis

cuss

edE

xhib

itE

xhib

itL

ette

r tr

om

Lev

ine

to M

ylin

. Atta

ched

cha

r en

title

d U

nite

d H

ealth

care

Cou

nter

-C

X00

455

Prop

osal

.JX

IC

X00

456

-C

X00

463

RE

SER

VE

DC

X00

464

Em

ail

trom

G

arci

a to

Vag

noni

re:

idph

res

pons

e. A

ttche

d do

cum

ent.

JX 1

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0046

5 -

CX

0048

I R

ESE

RV

ED

Em

ail f

rom

Wei

ss to

Gra

dy, e

t al r

e: H

ospi

ta c

ost p

er A

PD

. Attc

hed

Hos

pita

l Cos

t per

CX

0048

2A

djus

ted

Patie

nt D

ay c

har

JX I

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

CX

0048

3 -

CX

0049

5R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0049

6M

emo

nom

Gor

don

to R

osen

gar

re: E

NH

affl

iate

d ph

ysic

ians

with

car

diol

ogy

adm

itsJX

IC

X00

497

-C

X00

500

RE

SER

VE

DA

gree

men

t and

Pla

n ot

Mer

ger

date

d as

otO

ctob

er 2

9, 1

999

amon

g E

vans

ton

Nor

thw

este

rn H

ealth

care

Cor

pora

tion

, Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s, I

nc"

and

Hig

hlan

d Pa

rkC

;X00

50 I

Hos

pita

lJX

IC

X00

502

RE

SER

VE

DC

X00

503

Em

ail n

om T

racy

to V

agno

ni r

e: J

CA

HO

res

pons

e (f

Olw

arde

d).

JX I

CX

0050

4R

ESE

RV

ED

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s, P

relim

inar

Out

line

for Afliation Discussions with E

vans

ton

CX

0050

5N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

.JX

IE

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re, F

inan

cial

Con

side

ratio

ns fo

r th

e E

NH

lHS

Mer

ger,

CX

0050

6D

iscu

ssio

n D

ocum

ent.

Del

oitte

Con

sulti

ng.

JX I

CX

0050

7Fa

" m

emo

nom

Nea

man

to S

paet

h re

: enc

lose

d sl

ides

with

rev

isio

ns.

JX I

CX

0050

8 -

CX

0050

9R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0051

0E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re, D

iscu

ssio

n D

ocum

ent.

JX I

Mem

o no

m N

eam

an to

Kng

ht, e

t al.

Attc

hed

hand

writ

ten

note

nom

Liv

ings

ton

toC

X00

511

Nea

man

re:

Com

men

ts n

om N

eele

; let

ter

nom

Nea

man

to K

nght

, II ,

et a

lJX

IC

X00

512

-C

X00

5l3

RE

SER

VE

DC

X00

514

Minutes of Evanston Nortwestern Healthcare Board of Directors ' M

eetin

g.JX 1

Tr.

106

2 (P

ub)

CX

0051

5R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0051

6Minutes of Evanston Nortwestern Healthcare Board of Directors ' M

eetin

g.JX

ITr. 1776-

1781

2231

4152

4180

CX

0051

7H

PH O

pera

tions

and

Acc

ount

s R

ecei

vabl

e w

ith a

ttach

men

ts.

JX I

(Pub

)C

X00

518

-C

X00

526

RE

SER

VE

DC

X00

527

EN

H B

oard

Rec

omm

enda

tions

.JX

IC

X00

528

-C

X00

529

RE

SER

VE

D

Page 15: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

ulJe

ntT

itle

Adm

isi

bilty

Transcript Cite at which

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yIn Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

Num

ber

Ord

erE

xhib

it is

Di

cuss

edE

xhib

itE

xhib

itC

X00

530

Lette

r IT

om N

eam

an to

Spa

eth.

Attched notes ITom March 10

, 199

9 m

eetin

gJX 1

CX

0053

I -C

X00

533

RE

SER

VE

DC

X00

534

Fax

ITom

Nea

man

to L

ivin

gsto

n. Attched documents.

JX 1

Tr.

125

6-12

5941

74 (

Pub

)M

emo

ITom

Hile

bran

d to

Boa

rd o

f Dire

ctor

s , E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re re

oC

X00

535

EN

HlP

H M

erge

r D

ue D

ilige

nce

JX 1

CX

0053

6 -

CX

OO

S40

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

OS4

1Memo ITom Spaeth to Executive Coinittee

, Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s , In

c.JX 1

CX

OO

S42

Hig

hlan

d P

ark

Hos

pita

l Cha

iran

s R

epor

t.JX 1

CX

OO

S43

Min

utes

of B

oard

of T

rute

es H

ighl

and

Par

k H

ospi

tal

JX 1

CX

OO

S44

Min

utes

of

Exe

cutiv

e C

omm

ittee

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s , In

c.JX 1

Pres

enta

tion

of th

e Fi

nanc

ial P

lan

, Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s , I

nc. a

nd H

ighl

and

Park

Tr.

80

428-

434

438-

443

2134

2lSS

CX

OO

S45

Hos

pita

l , 1

999.

2003

JX 1

21S7

4160

-416

1 (P

ub)

CX

OO

S46

CX

OO

S61

RE

SER

VE

DH

ighl

and

Park

Hos

pita

l, E

vans

ton Nortwestern Healthcare

. Est

ablis

hmen

t of

Ope

nC

X00

562

Hea

rt S

urge

lY, C

ertif

icat

e-of

- Nee

d A

pplic

atio

nJX 1

CX

OO

S63

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s , I

nc. T

reas

urer

s R

epor

t - A

nual

Mee

tin.

JX I

CX

OO

S64

CX

0056

5R

ESE

RV

ED

Hig

hlan

d Pa

rk H

ospi

tal ,

Med

ical

Exe

cutiv

e C

omm

ittee

, Per

form

ance

Impr

ovem

ent

CX

OO

S66

Exe

cutiv

e Su

m81

.JX

IC

XO

OS6

7Major Monitorig Functions Anual 1998.

JX 1

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0056

8 -

CX

OO

S82

RE

SER

VE

DB

oard

of D

irect

ors

' Sum

m81

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

Mer

ger

Sequ

entia

lC

X00

583

Lis

ting

of A

ccom

plis

hmen

tsJX

IC

X00

584

-C

XO

OS8

6R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

OO

S87

Min

utes

of

Hea

lthca

re S

ervi

ces

Com

mitt

ee, H

ighl

and

Park

.JX 1

CX

0058

8 -

CX

0059

0R

ESE

RV

ED

Not

e: R

espo

nden

t20

01- 2

003

Cap

ital E

xpen

ditw

. e a

nd C

ash

Flow

Pro

ject

ions

, App

rove

d by

: Eva

nsto

nT

r.

IS48

; 19

19-1

922

(In

Car

); T

r.(K

elle

y) w

ithdr

ew IC

CX

OO

S91

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re F

inan

ce C

omm

ittee

of

the

Boa

rd.

JX 1

1977

- 198

8 (P

ub)

Sta

tus;

Tr.

197

7-19

78C

XO

OS9

2

CX

0059

4R

ESE

RV

ED

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

, Com

petit

ive

Any

sis ,

Dis

cuss

ion

Doc

umen

t,C

X00

595

Del

oitte

& T

ouch

e C

onsu

ltig

Gro

up.

JX I

Tr.

122

3-12

24 (

Pub)

CX

OO

S96

RE

SER

VE

DE

mai

l IT

om S

ilver

stei

n to

Gal

aghe

r re

o N

ursi

ng H

ours

per

AP

D. A

ttche

d E

NH

Tot

alC

XO

OS9

7H

ospi

tals

and

Clin

ics:

Nur

sing

Hou

rs p

er A

djus

ted

Patie

nt D

ayJX

IOrdered 2/9/05

Page 16: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Adm

issi

bilty

Tra

nscl

"pt C

i teat

w

bid

Rel

ated

SlIm

ID:tr

yN

umbe

rD

ocuI

Dllt

T

itle

Ord

erE

xhib

it is Discussed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

In

Cam

era

Ord

er

In Camera

Page

(s)

CX

0059

8 -

CX

0060

5R

ESE

RV

ED

File

of

1999

Bud

get F

inan

ce C

omm

ittee

199

9 R

evis

ed O

pera

ting

and

Cap

ital B

udge

tsC

X00

606

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s , In

c.JX

IPr

esen

tatio

n to

the

Fina

nce

Com

mite

e , L

akel

and

Hea

lth S

ervi

ces ,

Inc

" 20

00 P

ropo

sed

CX

0060

7C

orpo

rate

Bud

get

JX I

Tr.

838

, 840

(In

Cam

)O

rder

ed 2

/9/0

5C

X00

608

.C

X00

624

RE

SER

VE

DC

X00

625

Fax

trom

Sus

sman

to G

ilber

t re:

Upd

ated

Bas

elin

e.JX

IT

r. 2

231

, 223

5 (P

ub)

CX

0062

6R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0062

7M

emo

trom

Nea

man

to S

paet

h. A

ttach

ed d

ocum

ents

pre

pare

d by

Pea

rlm

an.

JX I

Tr.

124

7-12

4922

30- 2

231

(Pub

)In

itial

Fin

anci

al S

tate

men

t Ana

lysi

s, E

vans

ton Nortwestern Healthcare & Lakeland

CX

0062

8H

ealth

Ser

vice

s, In

c.JX

IC

X00

629

-C

X00

634

RE

SER

VE

DC

X00

635

Let

ter

trom

Bos

s to

Nea

man

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

, Fin

anci

al S

tate

men

ts, F

or F

isca

l Vea

r E

nded

CX

0063

609

/30/

200

IJX

IE

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re, N

ew A

ppro

ache

s F

or A

New

Cen

tury

, 200

IC

X00

637

Fina

ncia

l Sta

tem

ent

JX I

CX

0063

8 .

CX

0065

0R

ESE

RV

ED

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

, Cap

ital P

lan

Sum

ar, D

ecember 2001 ($

CX

0065

I Millons) with attachments.

JXI

CX

0065

2R

ESE

RV

ED

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s , In

c., F

inan

ce C

omm

ttee ,

199

9 R

evis

ed O

pera

ting

and

Cap

itaC

X00

653

Bud

gets

with

atta

clnn

ents

.JX

IC

X00

654

-C

X00

656

RE

SER

VE

DC

X00

657

Min

utes

of

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

, Boa

rd o

f D

irec

tors

' Mee

tigJX

IT

r. 2

058

(Pub

)C

X00

658

.C

X00

673

RE

SER

VE

DC

X00

674

2001

- 200

3 C

apita

l Exp

endi

tues

and

Cas

h Fl

ow P

roje

ctio

ns w

ith a

ttach

men

ts.

JX I

CX

0067

5 -

CX

0067

8R

ESE

RV

ED

Cha

rt e

ntitl

ed E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re In

patie

nt S

tatis

tical

Info

rmat

ion

Bas

edC

X00

679

on O

ctob

er. S

epte

mbe

r Fi

scal

Yea

rJX

I

CX

0068

0C

har

entit

led

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

His

toric

al L

icen

sed

Bed

Inve

ntor

yJX

IC

X00

68I

Prof

ile: E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re.

JX I

CX

0068

2 -

CX

0068

8R

ESE

RV

ED

Cha

rt e

ntitl

ed E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re, I

npat

ient

Man

aged

Car

e T

op 1

0 pl

usC

X00

689

Hum

ana

Staf

f M

odel

, Net

Rev

enue

%s

(Exc

ludi

ng R

eser

ve)

FVE

200

0.JX

I

Page 17: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Adm

issi

bilty

Tra

nscr

iptC

itat

wbi

chla

ted

Sum

mar

yN

umb

Doc

umnt

Titl

Ord

Exhibit is Discussed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

In Camera

Ord

In Camera

Pag

(s)

CX

0069

0 -

CX

0069

2R

ESE

RV

ED

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s, I

nc. a

nd A

fflia

ted

Cor

pora

tions

Com

bine

d Fi

nanc

ial

Tr.

585

2-58

56, 6

179-

6180

(P

ub);

CX

0069

3St

atem

ents

As

of 1

2/31

/199

9 an

d 19

98 T

oget

hr

with

Aud

itors

' Rep

ort

JX I

6250

(In

Car

)C

X00

694

-C

X00

696

RE

SER

VE

DE

vans

ton

Nor

thw

este

rn H

ealth

care

Boa

rd o

f D

irec

tors

Spe

cial

Mee

ting

of th

e B

oard

toC

X00

697

Rev

iew

Inf

onna

tion

Syst

ems.

JX I

CX

0069

8R

ESE

RV

ED

Foundation Anual Report with attached

1997

1199

8 Anual Report

, Hig

hlan

d Pa

rkT

r. 2

084-

2088

, 210

9, 2

123

, 224

9-C

X00

699

Hos

pita

l , H

ighl

and

Park

Hos

pita

l Fou

ndat

ion.

JX I

2252

(P

ub)

CX

0070

0 -

CX

0070

4R

ESE

RV

ED

Em

ail I

Tom

Nea

ran

to B

loom

er a

nd H

illeb

rand

reo

Sw

edis

h C

oven

ant R

adia

tion

CX

0070

5O

ncol

ogy

JX I

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

CX

0070

6 -

CX

0070

7R

ESE

RV

ED

Cha

rt e

ntitl

ed E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re C

apita

Pla

n Su

mar

. Atta

ched

CX

0070

8char ofENH

Cap

ital E

quip

men

t Exp

endi

tue

Sum

ar.

JX I

CX

0070

9R

ESE

RV

ED

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s , I

nc. a

nd A

flia

ted

Cor

pora

tions

, Com

bine

d F

inan

cial

CX

OO

7IO

Sta

tem

ents

as

of D

ecem

ber

3 I ,

199

8 an

d 19

97 T

oget

her

with

Aud

itors

' Rep

ort

JXI

Tr.

409

4, 4

148

(Pub

)C

X00

711

-C

X00

712

RE

SER

VE

DE

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re B

y-L

aws

of E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

reC

X00

713

Cor

pora

tion

JX I

CX

0071

4 -

CX

0072

8R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0072

9E

NH

Pat

ient

Saf

etyl

Err

or R

educ

tion

Com

mitt

ee, F

alls

Tas

k Fo

rce

JX I

Em

ail I

Tom

Hw

nini

ak to

Vag

noni

reo

Qua

tros

onl

ine

data

entl training m

odul

e is

CX

0073

0av

aila

ble

for

all e

mpl

oyee

sJX

IC

X00

73 I

-C

X00

738

RE

SER

VE

DC

X00

739

Gra

phs:

Hig

hlan

d Pa

rk F

alls

by

Indi

cato

rJX

IC

X00

740

-C

X00

744

RE

SER

VE

DC

X00

745

Eco

nom

ics

of th

e H

wna

na C

ontr

act.

JX I

CX

0074

6 -

CX

0075

3R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0075

4R

even

ue E

nhan

cem

ents

JX I

CX

0075

5E

xpe1

1e R

educ

tions

JX I

CX

0075

6 -

CX

0077

2R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0077

3Email fi' om

Nea

ran

to K

hnde

kar

JX I

Tr.

123

4-12

38 (

Pub)

Page 18: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

tTitl

eA

dmis

sibi

ltyT

rans

crip

tCite

atw

hich

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yIn Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

Num

ber

Ord

erE

xhib

it is

Dis

cuss

edE

xhib

itE

xhib

itC

X00

774

.C

X00

777

RE

SER

VE

DC

X00

778

Mem

o tr

om W

eiss

to G

alla

gher

et a

I re

o St

rate

gy D

rive

n Sc

orec

ard

JX I

CX

0077

9 .

CX

0078

7R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0078

8H

ighl

and

Park

Hos

pita

l Yea

r 20

00 in

Rev

iew

JX 1

CX

0078

9 .

CX

0079

0R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0079

1E

NH

Qua

lity

Impr

ovem

ent S

ubco

mm

ittee

JX 1

CX

0079

2 .

CX

0079

3R

ESE

RV

ED

HSC

- HPH

. Atta

ched

Boa

rd o

f D

irec

tors

Hea

lthca

re S

ervi

ces

Com

mitt

ee-

Hig

hlan

d Pa

rkC

X00

794

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

200

0 M

eetin

g S

ched

ule;

age

nda

mat

eria

ls.

JX 1

CX

0079

5 .

CX

0079

8R

ESE

RV

ED

GX

0079

9Evanston Hospita Corporation

JX 1

CX

0080

0R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0080

1M

inut

es o

fEN

H H

ealth

care

Ser

vice

s C

onut

tee

of th

e Board of Directors

JX 1

CX

0080

2 -

CX

0080

8R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0080

9E

NH

Boa

rd o

f D

irec

tors

Mee

ting

JX 1

Tr.

372

- 376 (Pub)

CX

0081

0.C

X00

8 19

RE

SER

VE

D

CX

0082

0Minutes of Evanston Nortwestern Healthcare Board of Directors ' E

xecu

tive

Com

mitt

eeJX 1

CX

0082

1R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

008n

Qui

ck F

ixes

for

200

4 St

anda

rds

JX 1

CX

0082

3 .

CX

0083

6R

ESE

RV

ED

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

FY

E 0

9/30

/199

8 . H

MO

/PP

O C

ontr

actu

al A

naly

sis

CX

0083

7as

of

09/3

0/19

98JX 1

CX

0083

8R

ESE

RV

ED

Eva

nsto

n N

onnw

este

rn H

ealth

care

Hlg

lUan

a l'a

rK H

ospi

tal O

utpa

tient

Gro

ss R

even

uean

d N

et R

even

ue S

MS/

Alle

gra

Dat

a. A

ttche

d H

ighl

and

Park

Hos

pita

l Inp

atie

ntC

X00

839

Info

nnat

ion.

JX 1

Eva

nsto

n N

onnw

este

rn H

ealth

care

FY

E 0

9/30

/200

2 In

pabe

nt M

anag

ed C

are

Con

trac

tual

Ana

lysi

s as

of 0

8/31

/200

2. A

ttche

d E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re H

MO

Log

CX

0084

0S

umar

- Year 10 Date as of 08/31/2002.

JX 1

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

CX

0084

1 -

CX

0084

7R

ESE

RV

ED

Min

utes

of

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

Boa

rd o

f D

irec

tors

' Exe

cutiv

e C

omm

ittee

CX

0084

8M

eetin

gJX

I

Page 19: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Adm

issi

bilty

. TJa

nscH

ptC

itat

wl1

ich

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yN

umbe

rD

ocum

elltT

itle

.O

rder

Exhibit is Discussed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

InC

:aer

a ()

rder

In C:a

era

Page

(s)

CX

0084

9 -

CX

0085

1R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0085

2M

inut

es o

fEN

H E

xecu

tive

Com

mtte

e M

eetig

JX 1

CX

0085

3R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0085

4M

inut

es o

f E

NH

Exe

cutiv

e C

omm

ittee

Mee

tigJX 1

CX

0085

5 -

CX

0087

0R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0087

1M

inut

es o

f Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

Boa

rd o

f Dire

ctor

s M

eetin

gJX 1

Tr.

123

0-12

31 (

Pub)

CX

0087

2E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re B

oard

of D

irect

ors

Mee

ting

JX 1

CX

0087

3R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0087

4M

inut

es o

f E

NH

Boa

rd o

f D

irec

tors

Mee

ting

JX I

Tr.

122

9-12

30 (

Pub)

CX

0087

5 -

CX

0087

8R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0087

9M

inut

es o

f H

ealth

care

Ser

vice

s C

omm

itte

- H

ighl

and

Park

.JX

IC

X00

880

.C

X00

881

RE

SER

VE

DA

gree

men

t for

Per

fusi

onis

t Ser

vice

s. A

ttach

ed A

gree

men

t for

Car

diac

Sur

gery

Ser

vice

s;C

X00

882

Agr

eem

ent f

or T

hora

cic

Serv

ices

.JX 1

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0088

3 -

CX

0088

4R

ESE

RV

ED

LHS and Subsidiares Comparative Statements of Cash Flows. Attached Finacial

CX

0088

5do

cum

ents

.JX 1

CX

0088

6 -

CX

0089

0R

ESE

RV

ED

Let

ter

from

Nea

man

to S

paet

h re

: Bus

ines

s R

evie

w. A

ttach

ed E

NH

lHPH

Bus

ines

sC

X00

89 1

Rev

iew

.JX 1

CX

0089

2 -

CX

0091

1R

ESE

RV

ED

Mem

o fr

om V

agno

ni to

JC

AH

O S

teer

ing

Com

mitt

e M

embe

rs r

e; S

umar

of J

CA

HO

CX

0091

2Mock Surey

JX 1

Tr.

123

8-12

40 (

Pub)

CX

0091

3 -

CX

0094

4R

ESE

RV

ED

I M

emo

trom

Nea

man

to lo

ll an

a W

llte

re: H

ighl

ana

ParK

U1S

cuss

lons

. Attc

hed

Key

Goa

ls a

nd P

rinc

iple

s of

Pro

pose

d M

erge

r of

Hig

hlan

d Pa

rk H

ospi

tava

nsto

nC

X00

94 5

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re.

JX 1

CX

0094

6 -

CX

0094

8R

ESE

RV

ED

Fax

trom

Nea

man

to K

nght

, et a

t re;

HIg

hlan

d Pa

rK A

uaite

a Fm

anci

al S

tate

men

ts.

Atta

ched

fax

and

lette

r re

: Hig

hlan

d Pa

rk H

ospi

tal A

udite

d Fi

nanc

ial S

tate

men

ts;

CX

0094

9H

ighl

and

Park

Aud

ited

Fina

ncia

l Sta

tem

ents

.JX

IF

ax fr

om N

eanl

an to

Spa

eth

re: c

omm

W1c

atio

ns/p

ublic

rel

atio

ns d

ocum

ents

. Atta

ched

CX

0095

0do

cum

ents

rc:

inte

nt to

mer

ge.

JX I

CX

0095

1 -

CX

0095

8R

ESE

RV

ED

Page 20: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

ocum

ent T

itle

Adm

issi

bilty

Tra

nser

iptC

ftea

twhi

chR

elat

edSu

mm

ary

In Camera.

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

Num

ber

Ord

erE

xhib

it.is

Dis

cuss

edE

xhib

itE

xhib

itlV

emo

trom

Nea

ran

totla

rd o

f D

Irec

tors

Eva

nton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re re

o O

urF

irst 1

00 D

ays.

Attc

hed

Boa

rd o

f Dire

ctor

s' S

wna

r E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re M

erge

r Se

quen

tial L

istin

g of

Acc

ompl

ishm

ents

(Fi

rst 1

00 D

ays

- A

pril

10C

X00

959

2000

); E

NH

Cri

teri

al f

or E

valu

atin

g H

ealth

care

Qua

lity

Rep

ort.

JX I

CX

0096

0 -

CX

0096

9R

ESE

RV

ED

Mak

e a

JX (

stev

e) F

ax f

rom

Nea

man

to S

paet

h re

o E

vans

ton Nortwestern Oversight

Com

mitt

ee f

or S

yste

m I

nteg

ratio

n. A

ttach

ed E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re B

oard

of

CX

0097

0D

irec

tors

Ove

rsig

ht C

omm

ittee

for

Sys

tem

Int

egra

tion

, Wed

nesd

ay, J

anua

r 19

, 199

9JX

IC

X00

971

-C

X00

978

RE

SER

VE

DC

X00

979

Mem

o fr

om N

eara

n to

Kng

ht r

eo d

efin

itive

mer

ger

agre

emen

t.JX

IC

X00

980

-C

X00

996

RE

SER

VE

DM

emo

trom

Nea

ran

to A

clir

ustr

atlv

e St

aff Deparent Chamnen

, Dep

aren

t Hea

dsO

ffcer

s of

the

Pro

fess

iona

l Sta

ff re

: Man

gem

ent S

taff

Pro

mot

ions

and

Cha

nges

.C

X00

997

Atta

ched

Cor

pora

te O

rgan

izat

ion

Cha

r 10

/01/

2000

.JX

IC

X00

998

-C

XO

IOl9

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

I020

Age

nda

for

Hea

lthca

re S

ervi

ces

Com

m 7

/21/

99 m

eetin

g pl

us o

ther

doc

wne

nts

JX I

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

Age

nda

for

EN

H H

ealth

care

Ser

vice

s C

omm

ittee

of

Boa

rd o

f D

irec

tors

Mee

ting

CX

OI0

2101/12/2000. Attched docwnents.

JX 1

CX

OI0

22 -

CX

OI0

25R

ESE

RV

ED

Age

nda

ofE

NH

Hea

lthca

re S

emce

s C

omm

Ittee

of t

he B

oard

ofD

uect

ors

03/0

9/20

01M

eetin

g. M

inut

es o

fEN

H H

ealth

care

SerVices Committee of the Board of Directors

CX

O 1

026

09/2

2/20

00.

JX I

CX

OlO

27 -

CX

O 1

028

RE

SER

VE

DA

gend

a fo

r E

NH

Hea

lthca

reS

ervi

ces

Com

mitt

ee o

f the

Boa

rd o

f Dire

ctor

s 06

/07/

2001

CX

OI0

29Meeting. Attached agenda materials.

JX I

CX

OI0

30M

inut

es o

f Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

Qua

lity

Impr

ovem

ent S

ubco

mm

tteJX

IOrdered 2/9/05

CX

OlO

31 -

CX

O 1

032

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

103

3Minutes ofENH Healthcare Services Committee of the Board of Directors.

JX I

Tr.

140

0-14

01 (

In C

ar)

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

OI0

34E

NH

Qua

lity

Impr

ovem

ent S

ubco

mm

ittee

Jan

uar

4, 2

002

Tr.

3183

Tr.

318

1-31

83 (

In C

ar)

CX

OI0

35 -

CX

O 1

045

RE

SER

VE

DL

ette

r tr

om K

ing

to A

lly, r

eo A

sses

smen

t, H

wna

n R

esou

rces

and

Inf

omat

ion

CX

O 1

046

Man

agem

ent C

ompl

aina

nt: L

ucie

nne

Y. M

ulvi

hill

Cas

e: #

3147

5JX

IOrdered 2/9/05

CX

O 1

047

Em

ail f

rom

Vag

noni

to K

ing

reo

JCA

HO

Per

iodi

c Pe

rfor

man

ce R

evie

wJX

IOrdered 2/9/05

Page 21: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

tTitl

eA

dmis

sibi

ltyT

rans

crip

t Cite

at w

hich

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yIn Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

Num

ber

Ord

erE

xhib

it is

Dis

cuss

edE

xhib

itE

xhib

itC

XO

I048

-C

XO

I051

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

105

2M

inut

es o

f A

nual

Mee

ting

Boa

rd o

f D

irec

tors

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s , I

nc.

JX I

Tr.

210

9-21

12 (

Pub

)M

ake

a JX

(st

eve)

Let

ter

from

Spa

eth

to S

tear

s re

: Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vces

, Inc

. goa

lsC

XO

I053

and

rela

tions

hip

with

EN

HJX

IM

emo

from

Spa

eth

to E

xecu

tive

Com

mitt

ee, L

akel

and

Hea

lth S

ervi

ces ,

Inc

. re:

CX

OI0

54re

sults

/ope

ratio

ns r

evie

w f

or 1

998.

JX I

Min

utes

of

the

Fina

nce

Com

mitt

ee P

lanl

1g C

omm

ittee

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s , In

c.C

XO

I055

Hig

hlan

d Pa

rk H

ospi

tal M

eetig

JX I

Tr.

432

. 416

2 (P

ub)

CX

OI0

56 -

CX

OI0

58R

ESE

RV

ED

Let

ter

of I

nten

t Bet

wee

n E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re C

orp

and

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

CX

O 1

059

Serv

ices

, Inc

. and

Hig

hlan

d Pa

rk H

ospi

tal

JX I

CX

OI0

60R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

OI0

61L

akel

and

Hea

lth S

ervi

ces,

Inc

. , C

onso

lidat

ed F

inan

cial

Sta

tem

ents

JX I

CX

OI0

62 -

CX

OI0

64R

ESE

RV

ED

Min

utes

of

the

Fina

nce

Com

mitt

ee, P

lann

g C

omm

ittee

, Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s, I

nc.

CX

OI0

65H

igla

ndPa

rk H

ospi

tal M

eetig

JX I

Tr.

214

4 -

2148

(Pu

b)M

inut

es o

f th

e Fi

nanc

e C

omm

ittee

, Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s, In

c., H

ighl

and

Park

CX

OI0

66H

ospi

tal M

eetig

JX I

CX

O 1

067

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

I068

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s . I

nc. C

onso

lidat

ed F

inan

cial

Sta

tem

ents

JX I

CX

OI0

69 -

cxol

onR

ESE

RV

ED

Min

utes

of

the

Fina

nce

Com

mitt

ee L

akel

and

Hea

lth S

ervi

ces,

Inc

. Hig

hlan

d Pa

rkC

XO

I073

Hos

pita

lJX

IC

X01

074

-C

XO

107

6R

ESE

RV

ED

Min

utes

of

the

Fina

nce

Com

mitt

ee, L

akel

and

Hea

lth S

ervi

ces ,

Inc.

, Hig

hlan

d Pa

rkC

XO

I077

Hos

pita

l Mee

ting

JX I

CX

OI0

78 -

CX

O 1

079

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

I080

Fina

nce

Com

mitt

ee, 1

999

Rev

ised

Ope

ratig

and

Cap

ital B

udge

tsJX

IC

XO

I081

.C

XO

I094

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

I095

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s , I

nc. F

inan

ce C

omm

ttee

Man

aged

Car

e R

evie

wJX

IT

r. 7

77, 7

78, 7

81 (

In C

ar)

CX

OI0

96.

CX

O I

098

RE

SER

VE

DLe

tter

from

Cha

n to

Sua

bian

re:

Hlg

lIand

Par

le H

ospl

tai' s

hos

pIta

l agr

eem

ents

with

man

aged

car

e pl

ans.

Atta

ched

cha

rs o

f C

ompa

rson

of

Con

trac

t Fin

anci

al T

erm

s E

NH

CX

O 1

099

vs. H

PH

.JX

IT

r. 8

11, 8

12, 8

19, 8

20 (

In C

ar)

RX

0581

Mot

ion

5/12

/05

CX

OII

OO

.C

XO

lI39

RE

SER

VE

D

Page 22: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

t Titl

eA

dmis

sibi

ltyTranscriptpteat which

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yIn Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

Num

ber

Ord

erE

xhib

itisD

iscu

ssed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

CX

O 1

140

Phys

cian

Epi

c Se

rvic

es P

acka

ge E

v:an

ston

Nortwestern Healthcare

JX 1

Tr.

193

4-19

35 (

In C

ar)

CX

0114

1 -

CX

0116

3R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

O 1

164

Min

utes

ofE

NH

Fac

ulty

Pra

ctic

e A

ssoc

iate

s E

xecu

tive

Com

mitt

ee M

eetin

g.JX 1

CX

0116

5 -

CX

0119

9R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

O 1

200

Email fi. om

Nea

ran

to K

ing

re: E

PIC

and

FT

CJX 1

Tr.

213

1-21

32, 2

993

(Pub

)C

X01

201

-C

XO

128

0R

ESE

RV

ED

vans

ton

Non

nwes

tern

liea

lthC

are

I'eno

nnan

ce I

mpr

ovem

ent l

naex

ror

\.uar

er A

pril-

June

200

2; P

ress

, Gan

ey O

utpa

tient

Pee

r G

roup

Per

cent

ile S

core

s fo

r W

ay- f

indi

ng a

ndC

XO

l281

Ease of Registration

JX I

CX

Ol2

82 -

CX

Ol3

19R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

O 1

320

Em

ail f

rom

Vag

noni

to H

ende

rson

, re;

Ini

tial M

eedi

ng o

fQI

Subc

omm

ittee

JX 1

CX

0132

1-C

XO

l328

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

l329

Em

ail f

rom

Vag

noni

to K

ing.

JX 1

CX

O 1

330

-

CX

Ol3

46R

ESE

RV

ED

Age

nda

and

Min

utes

ofH

igW

and

Park

Ind

epen

dent

Pra

ctic

e A

ssoc

iate

s, I

nc. A

nual

Mem

bers

hip

Mee

ting.

Atta

ched

bal

lot ,

Pre

side

nt' s

Rep

ort ,

Cap

itatio

n lU

te, E

stim

ated

CX

O 1

347

Cost Reductions Required in Order to Accept Market Capitation Rate,

JX I

Tr.

801

(In

Car

)C

XO

l348

-C

XO

I372

RE

SER

VE

DI M

emo

trom

Cha

n to

Hoa

rd o

t Ulfe

ctor

s r1

lglU

ane

rark

liea

lthca

re, I

nc. r

e: N

ext

Mee

ting

of th

e H

igW

and

Park

Hea

lthca

re, I

nc. B

oard

- W

edne

sday

, Nov

embe

r 17

, 199

9.A

ttche

d ag

enda

for

nex

t Boa

rd o

f D

irec

tors

Mee

ting;

Min

utes

of

Oct

ober

22

, 199

9C

XO

l373

Boa

rd o

f D

irec

tors

Mee

ting;

Res

ults

of

the

Anu

al E

lect

ion;

etc

.JX 1

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

Ol3

74 -

CX

Ol3

83R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

O 1

384

EN

H M

edic

al G

roup

IPA

Exe

cutiv

e C

omm

ttee

Mee

tigJX

IC

XO

l385

-C

XO

l400

RE

SER

VE

D

CX

Ol4

01A

gend

a of

the

EN

H M

edic

al G

roup

IPA

Car

e M

anag

emen

t Mee

ting.

Attched minutes.

JX I

CX

Ol4

02 -

CX

O 1

466

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

146

7M

emo

from

Gol

bus

to I

PA E

xecu

tive

Com

mtte

e re

: 10/

19/2

000

Mee

ting

Miu

tes

JX I

CX

Ol4

68 -

CX

Ol5

18R

ESE

RV

ED

Mem

o fr

om C

han

to G

ilber

t and

New

ton

re: F

easi

bilit

y of

Ass

ingi

ng C

erta

in M

anag

edC

XO

l519

Car

e C

ontr

acts

to E

NH

IT

om H

PH A

ttche

d m

emos

and

ana

lysi

s.JX 1

Page 23: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

tTiti

eA

dmis

sibi

ltyT

rans

crip

t Cite

at w

hiC

hR

elat

edSu

mm

ary

In Camera

Ord

erIn

Cam

era

Page

(s)

Num

ber

Ord

erExhibit is Discussed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

CX

Ol5

20 -

CX

Ol5

38R

ESE

RV

ED

Mem

o fr

om C

han

to G

ilber

t et a

l re:

Con

fere

nce

Cal

l with

PH

CS.

Atta

ched

lette

r , EN

HC

XO

I 53

9C

ontr

actin

g PH

CS

Tal

king

Poi

nts ,

and

PH

CS

Neg

otia

tion

JX I

Tr.

230

- 232

(In

Car

)O

rder

ed 2

/9/0

5C

XO

l540

-C

XO

l541

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

l542

Rev

iew

of

Out

patie

nt C

ardi

ac R

ehab

iltat

ion

Serv

ices

, EN

H (

Dra

ft)

JX I

CX

0154

3-C

XO

l560

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

l561

Em

ail f

rom

Joh

n C

avat

aio

to C

hrst

ophe

r E

ssig

re:

FT

C R

eque

sts

Re

Lab

Sta

tistic

sJX

IC

XO

l562

RE

SER

VE

DE

NH

IHPH

Iss

ues

and

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s P

relim

inar

Out

line

for

Affl

iatio

nC

XO

l563

Dis

cuss

ions

with

Eva

nsto

n Nortwestern Healthcare

JX I

Mem

o fr

om N

eara

n to

Gol

bus

et a

l re:

pro

posa

l for

spe

cial

ince

ntiv

e co

mpe

nsat

ion

CX

O I

564

prog

rar.

Attc

hed

Spec

ial "

Shar

ing

the

Succ

ess

Plan

JX I

CX

Ol5

65R

ESE

RV

ED

Tr.

113

2, 1

133

, 113

4 (I

n C

ar);

136

4-C

XO

156

6Pr

esen

tatio

n to

EN

H Deparent Heads

Tr.

113

413

65; 1

374-

1375

(Pu

b)C

X01

567-

CX

O 1

584

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

l585

Em

ail n

om P

orn

to B

row

n re

: dra

ft of

e-m

ail f

or R

ayJX

IO

rder

ed 2

/9/0

5C

XO

l586

-C

XO

l587

RE

SER

VE

DL

ette

r no

m G

rady

to J

ones

re:

Acu

te M

enta

l Hea

lth C

ateg

ory

of S

ervi

ces

at H

ighl

and

CX

O 1

588

Park

Hos

pita

JX I

CX

Ol5

89R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

Ol5

90M

emo

from

Gra

dy to

Nea

ran

re: C

linic

al R

atio

naiz

atio

nJX

IC

X01

591.

CX

Ol6

06R

ESE

RV

ED

Fax

nom

Mill

er to

Ogd

en r

e: F

irst

Uni

ted

Mee

ting

Mat

eria

ls. A

ttach

ed m

emo

and

draf

tsC

XO

l607

of m

eetin

g m

ater

ials

.JX

IT

r. 6

92 (

Pub)

; 838

, 840

(In

Car

)Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0160

8.C

XO

l609

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

l610

/lino

is H

ospi

tal P

rice

Sur

vey

Rep

ort:

1999

JX I

CX

OI6

11-

CX

Ol6

55R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

O 1

656

Em

ail n

om K

ing

to A

mar

oo r

e: n

otifi

catio

nJX

IOrdered 2/9/05

CX

O 1

657

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

l658

Mem

o no

m W

eiss

to G

alla

gher

, et a

l re:

Str

ateg

y-D

rive

n Sc

orec

ard

JX I

CX

Ol6

59 -

CX

Ol6

60R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

Ol6

61Email from King to Huminiak rc: perineal 18cerations

JX 1

Ordered 2/9/05

Page 24: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

t Titl

eA

dmis

sibi

ltyTranscript Cite at which

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yIn. Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

rs)

Num

ber

. Ord

erE

xhib

it is Discussed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

CX

Ol6

62 -

CX

Ol6

67R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

O 1

668

Em

ail f

rom

Kin

g to

Bar

ton

re: C

ritic

al S

tadi

ng O

rder

s E

rror

JX I

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0166

9 -

CX

Ol6

73R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

Ol6

74Email fi. om

Kin

g to

Ken

t re:

Dila

udid

use

JX I

CX

Ol6

75 -

CX

0167

9R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

O 1

680

Em

ail f

rom

Kin

g to

Lov

ell r

e: a

cas

e at

HPH

LD

RP

JX I

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

CX

0168

1-C

XO

l686

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

l687

Em

ail f

rom

Kin

g to

Erd

beer

re:

FT

C Inqui from ENH.

org

JX I

JX5

Tr.

626

0 (p

ub)

CX

O 1

688

Em

ail f

rom

Kin

g to

Wag

ner

re: r

oot c

ause

JX I

CX

O 1

689

-

CX

Ol6

90R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

Ol6

91E

NH

vs.

Ben

clua

rk T

each

ig H

ospi

tals

JX I

CX

0169

2R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

Ol6

93E

vans

ton

Nor

thw

este

rn H

ealth

care

: 200

2 Q

ualit

y R

epor

tJX

IC

XO

l694

-C

XO

l719

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

I720

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

, Inc

. Fin

al D

ue D

ilgen

ce R

epor

tJX

IT

r. 2

228-

2230

(P

ub)

CX

OI7

21H

ighl

and

Park

Hos

pita

l Exe

cutiv

e B

enef

itsJX

IC

XO

172

2R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

OI7

23A

rthu

r A

nder

sen

Aud

it R

epor

tJX

IC

XO

I724

RE

SER

VE

DL

ette

r fr

om E

llens

by to

Lue

hrs

re: m

eetin

g w

ith H

ildeb

rand

and

mee

ting

with

Ern

st &

CX

OI7

25Y

oung

. Enc

lose

d M

emor

andw

n. S

umar

of C

ompe

nsat

ion

, etc

.JX

IC

XO

I726

Let

ter

from

Ern

st &

You

ng to

Nea

man

re:

adv

isor

y se

rvic

es f

or E

NH

and

HPH

JX I

CX

OI7

27 -

CX

0173

1R

ESE

RV

ED

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s , I

nc. a

nd A

fflia

ted

Cor

pora

tions

Fin

anci

al S

tate

men

ts a

s of

CX

Ol7

32December 31

, 199

9 an

d 19

98 T

oget

her

with

Aud

itors

' Rep

orte

d B

alan

ce S

heet

--A

sset

sJX

IT

r. 2

327

Tr.

2327

CX

0173

3-C

XO

l736

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

l737

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s , I

nc. D

ue D

ilige

nce

Man

aged

Car

e C

ontr

acts

JX I

CX

O 1

738

-

CX

Ol7

60R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

Ol7

61M

inut

es o

f N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

Man

agin

g D

irec

tors

Com

mitt

eeJX

IC

XO

l762

-C

XO

l767

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

l768

Minutes of Nortwestern Healthcare Managing Directors Committee M

eetin

gJX

IT

r. 9

99, 2

200-

2202

(P

ub)

Page 25: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

t Titl

eA

dmis

sibi

ltyT

rans

crip

fCite

at which

Rel

ated

Suni

mIn Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

Num

ber

Ord

erE

xhib

it.is

Dis

cuss

edE

xhib

itE

xhib

itC

X01

769

-C

XO

I776

RE

SER

VE

DN

etw

ork

Aff

liatI

on A

gree

men

t Am

ong

Chi

ldre

ns

Mem

oria

l Med

ical

Cen

ter

and

Eva

nsto

n H

ospi

tal C

orpo

ratio

n an

d L

akel

and

Hea

lth S

ervi

ces ,

Inc

. and

Nor

thw

este

rnC

XO

177

7M

emor

ial C

orpo

ratio

nJX

IC

XO

I778

-C

XO

177

9R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

Ol7

80Network Affiation agreement

JX 1

Tr.

967

(Pu

b)C

XO

l781

RE

SER

VE

DMinutes of Nortwestern Healthcare Network Board of Directors Meetig. A

ttche

dC

XO

l782

Nortwestern Healthcare Network R

ecom

men

ded

Act

ions

.JX 1

Tr.

977

(Pu

b)C

XO

l783

-C

XO

l796

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

l797

Minutes of Nortwestern Healthcare Network Chief Executives C

omm

ittee

JX 1

CX

Ol7

98 -

CX

Ol7

99R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

O 1

800

Minutes of Nortwestern Healthcare Network Chief Executives C

omm

ittee

Mee

ting

JX 1

CX

Ol8

01R

ESE

RV

ED

Tr.

978

1362

1363

2195

-219

9C

XO

l802

Minutes of Nortwestern Healthcare Network Chief Executives C

omm

ittee

Mee

ting

JX 1

(pub

)C

XO

l803

RE

SER

VE

D

CX

O 1

804

Minutes of Nortwestern Healthcare Network Chief Executives Committee Meeting

JX 1

CX

Ol8

05Minutes of Nortwestern Healthcare Network Chief Executives C

omm

ittee

Mee

tiog

JX 1

CX

Ol8

06 -

CX

Ol8

11R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

Ol8

12M

inut

es o

f Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re N

etw

ork

Ope

ratig

Com

mitt

ee M

eetig

JX I

CX

Ol8

13 -

CX

O 1

829

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

183

0M

inut

es o

f Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re N

etw

ork

Boa

rd o

f Dire

ctor

s m

eetig

JX 1

Min

utes

ofN

HN

Boa

rd o

f Dire

ctor

s M

eetin

g. A

ttche

d In

stitu

tion

With

draw

al P

olic

yC

XO

l831

ard

Rem

oval

ofi

nstit

utio

n D

irec

tors

and

Chi

ef E

xecu

tive

Off

cers

.JX

IT

r. 9

73, 9

74 (

Pub

)C

XO

l832

Minutes of Nortwestern Healteare Network Board of Directors m

eetin

gJX

IC

XO

l833

Ari

cles

of

Dis

solu

tion.

JX 1

CX

O 1

834

-

CX

O 1

845

RE

SER

VE

D

Tr.

199

2-19

9620

38- 2

039

5676

-C

XO

l846

EN

H S

trat

egic

Pri

cing

Rev

iew

, Ste

erin

g C

omm

ittee

Upd

ate

JX 1

5678

(P

ub)

CX

Ol8

47 -

CX

Ol8

59R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

Ol8

60B

ain

& C

ompa

ny!

NH

Man

aged

Car

e St

rate

gyJX

IT

r. 9

87, 9

90 (

Pub

)

Page 26: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

t Titl

eA

.dm

issi

bilty

Tra

nscr

ipt C

ite. a

t wl1

ich

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yIn Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

Num

ber

Ord

erExhibit is. Discussed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

CX

0186

1N

ote

ITom

Nea

man

to S

paet

h re

: tho

ught

s on

mer

ger

prop

osal

. Attc

hed

Mem

o.JX

IT

r. 2

202-

2204

(P

ub)

Lette

r IT

om K

aufm

an H

all t

o N

eam

an a

nd M

eckl

enbu

rg r

e: p

ropo

sal f

or H

PH

onc

olog

yC

XO

l862

prog

ram

JX I

Tr.

222

6-22

27 (

Pub

)C

XO

l863

Gui

de to

Mer

ger

Dis

cuss

ions

and

Opt

ions

, Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

sJX

IT

r. 2

219-

2222

(Pu

b)C

XO

l864

Mem

o to

File

re:

Eva

nsto

n H

ospi

taig

hlan

d Pa

rk H

ospi

tal

JX I

Tr.

220

4-22

05 (

Pub)

Tr.

79-

, 222

2-22

25, 2

267-

2269

CX

Ol8

65Le

tter

ITom

Nea

man

to S

paet

hJX

I(p

ub)

Mem

o IT

om S

paet

h 10

Gol

der

el a

l re:

HP

H a

nd E

NH

dis

cuss

ions

ofm

arke

l sha

reC

XO

l866

opportities and other strategies. Attc

hed

lette

rs.

JX I

Tr.

222

5-22

26, 2

269-

2273

(P

ub)

CX

Ol8

67Le

tter

ITom

Nea

man

to S

paet

hJX

IC

X01

868

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s , I

nc. 1

999-

2002

Str

ateg

ic P

lan

JX I

Tr.

322

- 344

, 440

- 441

, 582

7 (P

ub)

RX

363

Tr.

33

, 345

- 354

, 402

- 403

, 586

8-58

73C

XO

l869

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s, I

nc. S

trat

egic

Pla

nng

Ret

reat

Dra

ftJX

I(P

ub)

CX

O 1

870

Mee

ting

with

Mar

k N

eam

anJX 1

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s Pr

elim

inar

Out

line

for

Aff

liatio

n D

iscu

ssio

ns w

ith E

vans

ton

CX

OI8

71Nortwestern Healthcare

JX I

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s E

vant

on N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

Pri

cipl

es o

fC

XO

I872

Impl

emen

tatio

nJX

IT

r. 2

326-

2327

(In

Cam

)H

ighl

and

Park

Hos

pita

l Res

pons

e to

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

Pro

posa

l for

aC

XO

l873

Com

bine

d H

ealth

Car

e PI

. ovi

der

Syst

emJX

I

CX

Ol8

74Le

tter

ITom

Spa

eth

to E

xecu

tive

Com

mte

e, H

ighl

and

Park

Hos

pita

l re:

Let

ter

of I

nten

tJX

IC

X01

875

Dis

cuss

ion

of T

rans

actio

n V

alue

. Attched handwritten notes.

JX 1

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s an

d E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Pro

pose

d M

erge

r: P

rese

ntat

ion

toT

r. 2

158-

2162

, 230

0, 2

301

, 414

8C

X01

876

the

Boa

rd o

f D

irec

tors

of

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

JX I

4149

(P

ub)

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s , I

nc. a

nd A

fflia

ted

Cor

pora

tions

Com

bine

d B

alan

ce S

heet

-C

XO

I877

Ass

ets

JX I

Tr.

232

7-23

28 (

In C

am)

CX

0187

8B

reas

t Can

cer

Pat

hway

JX I

CX

Ol8

79H

PH R

espo

nse

to E

NH

Pro

posa

l For

a C

ombi

ned

Hea

lth C

are

Prov

ider

Sys

tem

JX I

Tr.

220

7-22

09 (

Pub

)C

XO

l880

-C

XO

l883

RE

SER

VE

DA

gend

a of

Em

erge

ncy

Serv

ices

Uni

t. A

ttach

ed E

NH

Sta

tistic

al C

ompa

rson

s an

dC

XO

188

4Sw

nari

esJX

IC

XO

l885

-C

XO

l886

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

l887

Lette

r IT

om K

aufm

an to

Spa

eth

re: p

ropo

sal t

o as

sist

with

mer

ger

JX I

Mem

o fr

om M

ajka

and

Kau

fman

to G

ilber

t re:

Dra

ft " Quick & Dirt" Valuation

CX

Ol8

88A

naly

sis.

Atta

ched

dis

cuss

ion

docu

men

t.JX

IC

XO

l889

-C

XO

189

0R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

Ol8

91D

iscu

ssio

n of

Tra

nsac

tion

Val

ueJX

IC

XO

l892

-C

XO

190

2R

ESE

RV

ED

Page 27: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

t Titl

eA

dmiu

ibilt

yTranscript Cite at which

Rel

ated

.Su

mm

ary

In Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

Num

ber

. ...

Ord

erE

xhib

it is

Dis

cuss

ed.

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

CX

O 1

903

Mem

o fr

om G

ilber

t to

Ste

ars

et a

l re:

Str

ateg

ic r

atio

nal f

or C

onuu

nity

Fou

ndat

ion

JXI

Tr.

214

0 -

2144

, 586

7.58

69 (

Pub

)C

XO

l904

RE

SER

VE

D

CX

Ol9

05M

emo

from

Kau

ftan

to S

tear

s re

o A

lloca

tion

of D

olla

rs to

the

Con

uuni

ty F

ound

atio

nJX

IT

r. 5

861-

5867

(Pu

b)C

X01

906

-C

XO

l907

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

190

8L

akel

and

Hea

lth S

ervi

ces ,

Inc

. Str

ateg

ic P

lan

1999

. 200

3JX

IT

r. 4

05- 4

10 (

Pub

)C

XO

I909

RE

SER

VE

DT

he P

ropo

sed

Mer

ger

Bet

wee

n L

akel

and

Hea

lth S

ervi

ces

and

Eva

nsto

n N

orth

wes

tern

CX

Ol9

10H

ealth

care

JX I

CX

OI9

11R

ESE

RV

ED

Mem

o fr

om K

auft

an to

Ste

ars

and

Spae

th r

e: D

istr

butio

n of

Cas

h in

the

Prop

osed

Tr.

584

0-58

44, 5

851-

5852

, 585

9-C

XO

l912

Mer

ger

Bet

wee

n E

vans

ton

and

Hig

hlan

d Pa

rk H

ospi

tas

JX 1

5862

, (Pu

b)C

XO

l913

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

l914

Let

ter

from

Kau

ftan

to S

paet

h re

: Dra

ft L

ette

r of

lnte

n!JX 1

CX

Ol9

15R

ESE

RV

ED

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s Pr

elim

inar

Out

lne

for

Con

solid

atio

n D

iscu

ssio

ns w

ithC

XO

l916

Eva

nsto

n. H

ospi

ta C

orpo

ratio

nJX

IC

XO

l917

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

l918

Em

ail f

rom

Vag

noni

to J

assa

k, r

e: G

B K

ello

gg m

ed e

rror

eve

ntJX

IO

rder

ed

2/9/

05La

kela

nd H

ealth

Ser

vice

s P

relim

inar

Out

line

for

Con

solid

atio

n D

iscu

ssio

ns w

ithC

XO

l919

Eva

nsto

n H

ospi

tal C

orpo

ratio

nJX

IC

XO

I920

RE

SER

VE

DL

akel

and

Hea

lth S

ervi

ces

Prel

imin

ar O

utlin

e fo

r A

fflia

tion

Dis

cuss

ions

with

Eva

nsto

nC

XO

l921

Nortwestern Healthcare

JX I

CX

Ol9

22R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

OI9

23C

onso

lidat

ion

Dis

cuss

ions

bet

wee

n L

akel

and

Hea

lth S

ervi

ces

and

EN

HJX

IC

XO

I924

-C

XO

l938

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

l939

Evanston Nortwestern Healthcar 2004 Performce Improvement

Plan

JX I

CX

0194

0.C

XO

194

2R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0.19

43M

emo

from

Cha

lmer

s to

Lov

elan

d re

o H

ighl

and

Park

Hos

pita

l Pat

hway

Int

egra

tion

JX I

CX

O 1

944

-

CX

Ol9

45R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

Ol9

46M

emo

from

Cha

mer

s to

Kin

g re

: Cur

rent

Sta

tus

of H

PH C

ritic

al P

athw

ay R

ollo

utJX 1

CX

Ol9

47So

luci

ent 1

00 T

op H

ospi

tas

Nat

iona

l Res

ults

Rep

ort

JX I

Tr.

340

3-34

07, 3

430-

3440

(P

ub)

CX

0194

8.C

XO

l950

RE

SER

VE

DM

emo

from

Kin

g to

Fitz

patr

ck e

t aI

re: Q

ualit

y Im

prov

emen

t/Util

izat

ion

Man

agem

ent

CX

0195

1M

odel

JX 1

Page 28: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

t Titl

eA

dmis

sibi

ltyT

rans

crip

t Cite

at w

hich

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yIn (;an1era

()td

erIn (;un1eru

Page

(s)

Num

ber

Ord

erExhibit is Discussed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

CX

0195

2.C

X01

969

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

l970

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

Cha

rge

Des

crip

tion

Mas

ter

Ena

ncem

ent

JX I

Ord

ered

2/

9/05

CX

0197

1-C

XO

l974

RE

SER

VE

DC

X01

975

Lak

e C

ount

y In

terv

entio

nal C

ardi

olog

y V

olum

esJX 1

Ord

ered

2/

9/05

CX

0197

6 -

CX

0199

0R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

Ol9

91B

ain

Mer

ger

Inte

grat

ion

Stra

tegy

for

EN

HJX

IO

rder

ed

2/9/

05C

X01

992

-C

X01

995

RE

SER

VE

DC

XO

199

6B

ain

Man

ged

Car

e S

trat

egy

for

EN

HJX 1

CX

Ol9

97R

ESE

RV

ED

Not

e: R

espo

nden

tT

r. 1

173-

1180

, 138

5-13

8620

50-

with

drew

In

Cam

era

CX

0199

8B

ain

& C

ompa

ny, "

Growth Opportnities from the Highland Park Merger

JX 1

2053

(P

ub)

RX

1993

stat

usC

X01

999

-C

X02

036

RE

SER

VE

DL

ette

r fr

om H

ilebr

and

to Y

ale

and

Fark

as r

e: E

NH

Iain

Meeting. Enclosed financial

CX

0203

7do

cum

ents

and

str

ateg

ic p

lan.

JX I

Tr.

29-

1149

- 115

4 (P

ub)

CX

0203

8 -

CX

0204

4R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0204

5L

ette

r fr

om S

irab

ian

to K

hppl

e re

: Aet

na r

etra

ctio

n an

d co

ntra

cts

JX I

CX

0204

6 -

CX

0205

0R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0205

1A

naly

sis

of B

lue

Cro

ss P

PO r

even

ueJX

lC

X02

052

2001

Per

form

ance

Im

prov

emen

t Pla

nJX 1

Tr.

355

3 -

3555

(Pu

b)C

X02

053

RE

SER

VE

DC

X02

054

NH

N Q

ualit

y C

omm

ittee

qua

lity

outc

ome

data

JX 1

Ord

ered

2/

9/05

CX

0205

5R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0205

6M

inut

es o

f N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

Chi

ef E

xecu

tives

Com

mtte

eJX 1

CX

0205

7 -

CX

0205

8R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0205

9L

ette

r fr

om S

irab

ian

to J

ones

re:

con

trac

tual

alo

wan

ces.

JX 1

CX

0206

0 -

CX

0206

2R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0206

3L

ette

r fr

om H

ilebr

and

and

Gol

bus

to S

toll

re: t

enni

natin

g U

NIC

AR

E c

ontr

act.

JX 1

CX

0206

4 -

CX

0206

7R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0206

8C

onso

lidat

ed Fincial Statements and O

ther

Fin

anci

al I

nfon

natio

n E

NH

JX I

CX

0206

9R

ESE

RV

ED

Page 29: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

tTitl

eA

dmis

sibi

lity

Tra

nscr

ipt

Cite at Which

Rel

ated

S\lm

niar

y In Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

Num

ber

Ord

erE

xhib

it is

Dis

cuss

ed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

Tr.

52-

1810

- 181

220

21-2

022

CX

0207

0E

NH

200

1-20

03 S

trat

egic

Pla

n D

raft

JX 1

(pub

)C

X02

071

Let

ter

from

S ir

abia

n an

d L

evin

e to

Max

ell

JX I

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0207

2L

ette

r fr

om F

arka

s to

Nea

man

.JX

IT

r. 1

158-

1160

Let

ter

from

Gra

dy to

Krg

el re

o C

ardi

ac S

urge

I) A

gree

men

t. A

ttche

d G

uidi

ngC

X02

073

Prin

cipl

es A

gree

men

t dra

f.JX

IT

r. 4

532-

4540

(pu

b)L

ette

r fr

om R

osen

gar

to N

eam

an r

eo o

pen

hear

sur

geI)

join

t ven

tue.

Attc

hed

char

tC

X02

074

entit

led

Car

diov

ascu

lar

Surg

eI)

Cas

eloa

d.JX

IC

X02

075

Hig

hlan

d P

ark

Hos

pita

Car

diac

Sur

gel)

Pro

gram

Sw

nar

of A

ssw

nptio

nsJX

I

Em

ail f

rom

Gar

stec

ld to

Gra

dy e

t aI.

Attc

hed

lette

r fr

om G

arst

ecki

to T

aylo

r re

o 99

- 089

CX

0207

6H

ighl

and

Park

Hos

pita

l. A

ttach

ed a

udit

repo

rt o

f O

pen-Hear SurgeI) Services.

JX I

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

CX

0207

7C

har

entit

led

Ope

n H

ear

V o

lwne

JX 1

Let

ter

of I

nten

t (A

gree

men

t) b

etw

een

Swed

ish

Cov

enan

t Hos

pita

l and

Eva

nsto

nC

X02

078

Nortwestern Healthcare and ENH Faculty Pr

actic

e A

ssoc

iate

sJX

IC

X02

079

-C

X02

081

RE

SER

VE

DC

X02

082

Let

ter

ttom

Hill

ebra

nd to

Gill

igan

. Attc

hed

rate

pro

posa

l.JX

IOrdered 2/9/05

Min

utes

of

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

Pro

fess

iona

l Sta

ff Q

ualit

y Im

prov

emen

tC

X02

083

Com

mitt

ee.

JX I

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

CX

0208

4M

emo

from

Hod

ges

to N

eam

an r

eo B

udge

t Mee

ting

JXI

Lette

r fr

om N

ear

to C

han

reo

One

Hel

ath

Plan

s co

unte

r-pr

opsa

l to

rate

off

er. A

ttach

edC

X02

085

rate

cou

nter

- pro

posa

l.JX

IT

r. 7

60 (

In C

am)

Ord

ered

2/

Ql0

5C

X02

086

-C

X02

089

RE

SER

VE

DE

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re P

erfo

nnan

ce I

mpr

ovem

ent R

epor

t Cor

onar

Are

l)C

X02

090

BypassNalve Replacement

JX I

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0209

1 -

CX

0209

3R

ESE

RV

ED

Mem

o tto

m G

rady

to S

paet

h re

o C

ardi

ac S

urge

I) A

gree

men

t. A

ttche

d C

ardi

ac S

urge

I)C

X02

094

Agr

eem

ent B

etw

een

EN

H a

nd H

PH

.JX

IT

r. 4

528-

4540

(Pu

b)C

X02

095

RE

SER

VE

DC

X02

096

Join

t Ven

tue

Bus

ines

s Se

gmen

tJX

IC

X02

097

Exe

cutiv

e C

ompe

nsat

ion

Plan

199

9JX

IC

X02

098

Exe

cutiv

e C

omps

en,a

tion

Plan

200

0JX

IC

X02

099

Exe

cutiv

e C

ompe

nsat

ion

Pla

n 20

0 I

JX I

Tr.

137

2-13

74 (

Pub)

CX

0210

0E

van'

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re C

apita

Pla

nng

Mat

eria

lsJX

IC

X02

101

Pari

cipa

ting

Phys

icia

n Se

rvic

e A

gree

men

t of

Ale

xand

erJX

IC

X02

102

-C

X02

106

RE

SER

VE

DL

ette

r fr

om A

lexa

nder

to W

hom

it M

ay C

once

rn r

eo C

ardi

olog

ists

afli

ated

with

the

CX

0210

7E

NH

Med

ical

Gro

upJX

I

Page 30: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

t Titl

eA

dmis

sibi

ltyTranscript Cite at which

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yln

Cam

era.

O

rder

In Camera

Page

(s)

Num

ber

Ord

erE

xhib

itis

Dis

cuss

edE

xhib

itE

xhib

itC

X02

108

-C

X02

110

RE

SER

VE

DL

ette

r fr

om C

han

to F

arle

y-A

gee

re: P

ropo

sals

on

Hos

pita

and

Phy

sici

an R

ates

to F

irst

CX

0211

1H

ealth

. Atta

ched

: pro

posa

ls s

igne

d by

Hill

ebra

nd a

nd G

olbu

sJX

IO

rder

ed 2

/9/0

5Le

tter

from

Ren

o to

Fin

ance

and

Info

rmat

IOn

Tec

hnol

ogy

Com

mitt

ees

re: C

linic

alC

X02

112

Syst

em S

elec

tion.

Atta

ched

Clin

ical

Sys

tem

s Pr

ogra

m S

trat

egic

Ini

tiativ

e.JX

IC

X02

113-

CX

02l1

6R

ESE

RV

ED

cx02

117

Lette

r IT

om G

rady

to N

ewto

n re

: Con

trac

tual

Mat

ters

JX I

CX

0211

8 -

CX

0212

4R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

02 1

25St

ate

Age

ncy

Rep

ort.

Car

diac

Pro

ject

Com

plet

ion

JX I

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

CX

0212

6St

ate

Age

ncy

Rep

ort.

Car

diac

Pro

ject

Com

plet

ion

JX I

CX

02 1

27 -

CX

0216

6R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0216

7M

id- Y

ear

Stat

us R

epor

tJX

IC

X02

168

RE

SER

VE

D

C;X

0216

9E

mai

l IT

om H

odge

s to

N e

aman

. Attc

hed

Apr

il 20

04 d

raft

repo

rt.

JX I

CX

0217

0.C

X02

175

RE

SER

VE

DC

X02

176

Inte

risi

vist

Ser

vice

s A

gree

men

tJX 1

Tr.

510

3-51

05 (

In C

am)

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0217

7 -

CX

0218

5R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0218

6Minutes of Nortwestern Healthcare 1/25/1999

JX I

CX

0218

7Minutes of Nortwestern Healthcare Executive Committee of the Board of Directors

JX I

CX

0218

8 -

CX

0220

2R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0220

3E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re a

nd E

NH

Med

ical

Gro

up C

ontr

actin

g P

lan

JX I

CX

0220

4 -

CX

0221

2R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0221

3Le

tter

ITom

Vos

s to

Nea

man

JX I

CX

0221

4 -

CX022 16

RE

SER

VE

DC

X02

217

Email fi. om

Gol

bus

to M

ittle

man

, Gilb

ert.

and

Cha

n re

: ter

m le

tters

JX I

CX

0221

8 -

CX

0222

8R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0222

9E

mai

l fro

m G

olbu

s to

Che

ryl r

e: p

urch

ase

of W

ilow

Inn

Site

JX I

CX

0223

0M

arke

t Sha

re V

iew

s: S

yste

m v

s. I

ndiv

idua

l Fac

ilitie

sJX

IOrdered 2/9/05

CX0223 I

Brie

f His

tOlY

of t

he N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

Net

wor

kJX

IC

X02

232

-C

X02

233

RE

SER

VE

D

Page 31: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

t-T

itle

Adi

niss

ibilt

yT

rans

crip

t Cite

at w

hich

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yIn Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

Num

ber

Ord

erE

xhib

it is

Dis

cuss

edE

xhib

itE

xhib

itC

X02

234

Stat

us R

epor

t: E

rnst

& Y

oung

Mer

ger

Rel

ated

Opp

ortn

ities

JX I

CX

0223

5 -

CX

0223

6R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0223

7B

iwee

kly

Rep

ort-

- EN

HPH

Tra

nsiti

on T

eam

JX I

CX

0223

8B

iwee

kly

Rep

ort-

EN

HlP

H T

rans

ition

Tea

mJX 1

CX

0223

9B

iwee

kly

Rep

ort-

EN

HlP

H T

rans

ition

Tea

mJX

IT

r. 1

712-

1719

(Pu

b)C

X02

240

Min

utes

of

Cha

rge

Des

crip

tion

Mas

ter

Tra

nsiti

on T

eam

Mee

tigJX

IT

r. 1

714-

1715

(Pu

b)C

X02

24I -

CX

0225

IR

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0225

2Anuallncentive Compensation Award Analysis

JX I

CX

0225

3E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re E

xecu

tive

Cas

h C

ompe

nsat

ion

JX I

Ordered 2/9/05

Evanston Nortwestern Healthcare Execullve Casb Compensation: 2003-20

04 M

erit

CX

0225

4In

crea

seJX

IO

rder

ed 2

/9/0

5C

X02

255

-C

X02

272

RE

SER

VE

D

CX

0227

3M

emo

from

Gra

dy to

Nea

man

re:

EN

Hlig

hlan

d Pa

rk C

ance

r C

are

Cen

ter

Pro

posa

l.JX

IC

X02

274

-C

X02

285

RE

SER

VE

DM

inut

es o

f B

oard

Qua

lity

Impr

ovem

ent S

ubco

mm

ittee

Mar

ch 2

000-

August 2002.

CX

0228

6A

ttach

ed c

ones

pond

ence

, etc

.JX

IC

X02

287

Perf

orm

ance

Im

prov

emen

t Pla

n 20

0 I

Hig

hlig

hts

JX I

Mm

utes

of !

ovan

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

ltlca

re \.

Uai

lty Im

prov

emen

t liu

bcom

mltt

ee o

fth

e H

ealth

care

Ser

vice

s C

omm

ittee

. Atta

ched

Min

utes

of

the

Qua

lity

Impr

ovem

ent

Subcommittee of the Healthcare Services Committee of the Board of Directors

CX

0228

803

/07/

2000

,JX

IO

rder

ed 2

/9/0

5C

X02

289

-C

X02

294

RE

SER

VE

DC

X02

295

Path

way

Im

plem

enta

tion

Cha

lleng

es a

nd P

erfo

rman

ce I

mpr

ovem

ent P

lans

JX I

CX

0229

6 -

CX

0230

0R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0230

IC

ritic

al P

athw

ay O

utco

mes

Sta

tus

Rep

ort f

or E

RJX

IC

X02

302

RE

SER

VE

DC

X02

303

Hig

hlan

d Pa

rk H

ospi

tal P

athw

ay S

tatu

s R

epor

t -I

% 1

/200

0-0

1/31

/200

IJX

ILe

tter

from

Mas

saro

to S

paet

h re

: Joi

nt C

omm

issi

on o

n A

ccre

dIta

tion

of H

ealth

care

CX

0230

4O

rgan

izat

ions

rep

ort.

Attc

hed

Acc

redi

tatio

n R

epor

t.JX

IT

r. 2

150-

2154

(P

ub)

CX

0230

5H

ighl

and

Park

Hos

pita

Per

form

ance

Im

prov

emen

t Pla

nJX

IC

X02

306

-C

X02

309

RE

SER

VE

DH

ighl

and

Par

k H

ospi

tal S

core

card

. Atta

ched

Hig

hlan

d P

ark

Hos

pita

l DIG

Sua

mar

,C

X02

310

1998

.JX

IOrdered 2/9/05

CX023 II

RE

SER

VE

D

Page 32: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

t Titl

eA

dmis

sibi

ltyT

rans

crip

t Cite at

whi

chR

elat

edSu

mm

ary

In

Cam

era

Ord

er

Num

ber

Ord

erExhibit is D

iscu

ssed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

In Camera

Page

(s)

Hig

hlan

d Pa

rk H

ospi

tal P

erfo

rman

ce I

mpr

ovem

ent P

lan

1998

Dep

aren

t of S

urge

ry.

CX

023

12A

ttche

d C

ase

Ass

essm

ent C

rite

ria.

JXI

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

CX

0231

3 .

CX

0231

4 R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

023

I 5H

ighl

and

Park

Hos

pita

l Rep

ort o

f Si

te V

isit

Apr

i130

- May

3, 1

998.

JX I

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

Per

form

ance

Impr

ovem

ent R

epor

t: H

ip F

ract

ueC

X02

316

QIC

OC

Fir

st Q

uare

r 20

0 I

10/0

1/00

-12/

31/0

0.JX

IC

X02

317.

CX

0233

5R

ESE

RV

ED

I M

emo

!rom

Hill

ebra

nd to

Alv

arad

o et

al r

e: t;

NH

ltU' 1

i Ira

nslh

on T

eam

s. A

ttcne

dm

emo

from

Hile

bran

d to

Tra

nsiti

on T

eam

Lea

del.

s re

o E

rnst

& Y

oung

Mer

ger

Rec

omm

enda

tions

. Atta

ched

EN

HlP

H E

xpen

se R

educ

tions

and

Rev

enue

CX

0233

6E

nhan

cem

ents

spr

eads

heet

s.JX

IC

X02

337

-C

X02

354

RE

SER

VE

DG

uidi

ng P

rinc

iple

s H

ighl

and

Park

Hos

pita

l , E

vans

ton

Nor

thw

este

rn H

ealth

care

: Car

diac

CX

0235

5Su

rger

y at

Hig

hlan

d Pa

rk H

ospi

tal ,

with

han

dwri

tten

com

men

tsJX 1

CX

0235

6M

emo

from

New

ton

to F

rien

d, e

t al

JX I

Tr.

305

7 (I

n C

am)

CX

0235

7C

ardi

ovas

cula

r Su

rger

y R

ecom

men

datio

nJX

IG

uidi

ng P

rinci

ples

Hig

hlan

d P

ark

Hos

pita

, Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

: Car

diac

CX

0235

8Su

rger

y at

Hig

hlan

d Pa

rk H

ospi

tal

JX I

Gui

ding

Pri

ncip

les

Hig

hlan

d Pa

rk H

ospi

tal ,

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

: Car

diac

CX

0235

9Su

rger

y at

Hig

hlan

d Pa

rk H

ospi

tal

JX I

CX

0236

0 -

CX

0236

5R

ESE

RV

ED

Dat

a A

naly

ses

of th

e So

ciet

y of

Tho

raci

c Su

rgeo

ns N

atio

nal A

dult

Car

diac

Sur

gery

CX

0236

6D

atab

ase

JX I

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0236

7 -

CX

0236

9R

ESE

RV

ED

Highland Park Hospital Core Market Perceptions Research: Final Report of Meridian

CX

0237

0R

esea

rch

Stu

dy.

JX I

CX

0237

1EVW1ston Nortwestern Healthcare

JX I

CX

023

72R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0237

3Master Space Plan

JX I

CX

023

7 4

RE

SER

VE

DGuiding Priciples, HighlW1d Park H

ospi

ta. E

vant

on N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

, Car

diac

CX

0237

5Su

rger

y at

Hig

hlan

d Pa

rk H

ospi

tal

JX I

Handwritten comments on Guiding Priciples, Highland Park Hospita, E

vans

ton

CX

0237

6Nortwestern Healthcare

, Car

diac

Sur

gery

at H

ighl

and

Park

Hos

pita

lJX

IH

andw

ritte

n co

mm

ents

on

GU

Idin

g P

rinci

ples

, Hig

hlan

d Pa

rk H

ospi

tal ,

Eva

nsto

nC

X02

377

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re, C

ardi

ac S

urge

ry a

t Hig

hlW

1d P

ark

Hos

pita

JX 1

CX

0237

8 -

CX

0237

9R

ESE

RV

ED

Page 33: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

tTitI

eA

dmis

sibi

ltyT

rans

crip

t Cite

at w

hich

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yIn Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

Num

ber

Ord

erE

xhib

it is

Dis

cuss

edE

xhib

itE

xhib

itH

andw

ritte

n co

mm

ents

on

Gui

ding

Prin

cipl

es, H

igW

and

Par

k H

ospi

tal ,

Eva

nsto

nC

X02

380

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re, C

ardi

ac S

urge

ry a

t Hig

Wan

d P

ark

Hos

pita

lJX

IC

X02

38I

Ope

ratin

g M

argi

n C

ontr

butio

n-U

HC

Cur

rent

Rat

esT

r. 1

079

Tr.

107

8, 1

079

, 109

3, 1106 (In Cam

) Ordered 3/16/05

Let

ter

!rom

Spa

eth

to H

PH Deparent Heads

re: M

erge

r In

tegr

atio

n A

ctiv

ities

.C

X02

382

Atta

ched

rep

ort o

n m

erge

r in

tegr

atio

n ac

tiviti

es.

JX I

Let

ter

!rom

Ste

nske

to S

paet

h an

d H

illeb

rand

re:

Ren

al D

ialy

sis

Tra

nsiti

on T

ean1

.C

X02

383

Atta

ched

cha

r en

title

d R

enal

Dia

lysi

s T

rans

ition

Tea

m.

JX I

CX

0238

4B

iwee

kly

repo

rt--

EN

H/P

H T

rans

ition

Tea

mJX

IC

X02

386

Ern

st &

You

ng D

ue D

ilige

nce

Opp

ortit

ies

JX I

CX

0238

7 -

CX

0238

8R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0238

9H

ospi

ta C

apita

l Exp

endi

tues

and

Fin

anci

al In

form

atio

n R

epor

t for

199

9JX

IG

uidi

ng P

rinc

iple

s H

ighl

and

Park

Hos

pita

l , E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re C

ardi

acC

X02

390

Sur

gery

at H

igW

and

Par

k H

ospi

taJX

IC

X02

391

-C

X02

414

RE

SER

VE

D

Tr.

209

921

0021

0121

0221

03C

X02

4 I 5

Lak

elan

d H

ealth

Ser

vice

s , I

nc. 1

997

Acc

ompl

ishm

ents

JX I

2104

2105

2106

2107

(P

ub)

CX

0241

6R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0241

7H

ighl

and

Park

Hos

pita

l 199

8 C

omm

unity

Ben

efits

Rep

ort

JX I

CX

0241

8L

akel

and

Hea

lth S

ervi

ces

Man

agem

ent L

ist

JX I

CX

0241

9 -

CX

0242

2R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0242

3M

emo

!rom

Ber

ns to

PH

CS

clie

nts

reo

Sign

fica

nt N

etw

ork

Cha

nge,

Hos

pita

l Mer

ger

JX I

Mem

o !r

om B

erns

to P

HC

S C

lient

s re

: Sig

nfic

ant N

etw

ork

Cha

nge,

Ter

min

atio

n of

POS

CX

0242

4P

hysi

cian

Gro

upJX

IC

X02

425

PHC

S H

ospi

tal R

even

ue M

ocle

l Im

pact

ofT

enni

natio

nJX

IC

X02

426

Let

ter

!rom

Ham

g to

Bal

leng

ee r

e: te

rmia

tion

proc

edur

esJX

IC

X02

427

Let

ter

!rom

Sm

ith to

Ber

ns r

e: R

essu

rect

ion

s fi

nal o

ffer

JX I

CX

0242

8 -

CX

0242

9R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0243

0E

mai

l !ro

m B

alle

ngee

to J

aspe

r re

: Eva

nton

lHJX

IC

X02

43I -

CX

0243

5R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0243

6E

NH

199

9 Pe

rfor

man

ce I

mpr

ovem

ent P

lan

JX I

CX

0243

7 -

CX

0244

6R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0244

7N

oles

!ro

m L

evin

e re

: mee

ting

with

Aet

naJX

IT

r. 1

947-

1948

(In

Cam

)Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0244

8 -

CX

0245

0R

ESE

RV

ED

Eva

nsto

n N

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

Per

form

ance

Impr

ovem

ent R

epor

t: C

oron

ary

AIte

ryC

X02

45 I

BypassNalve Replacement

JX I

Ordered 2/9/05

Page 34: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

t Titl

eA

dmis

sibi

ltyT

rans

crip

t Cite

at w

hich

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yC

amer

a O

rder

In Camera

Page

rs)

Num

ber

Ord

erE

xhib

it is

Dis

cuss

edE

xhib

itE

xhib

itC

X02

452

-C

X02

454

RE

SER

VE

DLe

tter

from

Hile

bran

d to

Mal

hotr

a re

o pr

opos

al. A

ttach

ed E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

CX

0245

5H

ealth

care

Pro

posa

l to

Aet

na U

. S. H

ealth

care

JX I

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

CX

0245

6L

akel

and

Hea

lth S

ervi

ces

Fina

nce

Con

uitte

e: M

anag

ed C

are

Rev

iew

JX I

CX

0245

7 -

CX

0246

I R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0246

2E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re I

mpa

ct o

f C

harg

e C

ode

Mer

geJX

IC

X02

463

Em

ail f

rom

Am

amoo

to Z

aman

et a

IJX

IC

X02

464

Let

ter

from

Hile

bran

d to

Mat

herl

ee r

eo P

rogr

am P

arci

patio

nJX

IC

X02

465

-C

X02

466

RE

SER

VE

DC

X02

467

EN

H S

trat

egic

. Pri

cing

Rev

iew

Gui

deJX

IC

X02

468

Em

ail f

rom

Rho

ads

to S

chul

z re

o C

DM

Que

stio

nsJX

IC

X02

469

-C

X02

484

RE

SER

VE

DR

atio

nale

for

an

EN

H C

ardi

otho

raci

c Su

rger

y Fr

anch

ise

Agr

eem

ent a

t Wei

ss M

emor

ial

CX

0248

5H

ospi

tal

JX I

Tr.

454

2 - 4

544

(Pub

)C

X02

486

-C

X02

494

RE

SER

VE

DC

X02

495

Email fi. om

Gol

bus

to L

evin

e re

o FW

Cig

naJX

IOrdered 2/9/05

CX

0249

6 -

CX

0250

4R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0250

5O

pen

Hea

r S

urge

ry F

isca

l 00/

0 I

JX I

CX

0250

6 -

CX

0254

I R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0254

2Fi

scal

Yea

r 20

01-

2003

: Car

diac

Sur

gery

JX I

CX

0254

3 -

CX

0499

9R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0500

0C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd A

etna

JX I

CX

0500

IC

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd A

etna

JX I

Tr.

194

8-19

49 (

In C

am)

CX

0500

2C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd A

etna

JX I

CX

0500

3C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Aet

na.

JX I

CX

0500

4C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Aet

na.

JX I

CX

0500

5C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Aet

naJX

IC

X05

006

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd A

etna

JX I

Tr.

549

- 552

, 553

, 194

9-19

51 (

InC

X05

007

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd A

etna

JX I

Car

)C

X05

008

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd A

etna

JX I

Tr.

552

- 554

1951

- 195

3 (I

n C

ar)

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0500

9C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd C

igna

JX I

CX

0501

0C

onb.

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd C

igna

JX I

Page 35: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Adi

nisi

biU

tyT

rans

crip

t Cite

at w

hich

.R

elat

edSu

mm

ary

Doc

umen

t Titl

eIn

Cam

erll

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

Num

ber

Ord

erE

xhib

it is

. D

iscu

ssed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

CX

0501

1C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g H

PH a

nd C

igna

JX I

CX

050

12C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Cig

naJX

IC

X05

013

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd C

igna

JX I

CX

0501

4R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

050

15C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Cig

naJX

IC

X05

016

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd C

igna

JX I

CX

050

17C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g H

PH a

nd H

wna

naJX

IC

X05

0 I g

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

HPH

and

Hw

nana

JX I

CX

0501

9C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g H

PH a

nd H

wna

naJX

IOrdered 3/16/05

CX

0502

0C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Hw

nana

JX I

Ordered 3/16/05

CX

0502

1C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Hw

nana

JX I

Ord

ered

3/1

6/05

CX

0502

2C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Hw

nana

JX I

CX

0502

3C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Hw

nana

JX I

Ord

ered

3/1

6/05

CX

0502

4C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Hw

nana

JX I

Ord

ered

3/1

6/05

CX

OS0

25C

ontr

act-

rela

tedd

ocw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Hw

nana

JX I

Ordered 3/16/05

CX

0502

6C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Hw

nana

JX I

Ordered 3/16/05

CX

0502

7C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Hw

nana

JX I

Ordered 3/16/05

CX

0502

8C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Hw

nana

JX I

Ordered 3/16/05

CX

0502

9C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Hw

nana

JX I

CX

0503

0C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g H

PH a

nd B

lue

Cro

ssJX

IC

X05

031

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

HPH

and

Man

aged

Car

e N

etw

ork

Pref

erre

dJX

IC

X05

032

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

HPH

and

Blu

e C

ross

JX I

CX

0503

3C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g H

PH a

nd B

lue

Cro

ssJX

IC

X05

034

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

HPH

and

Blu

e C

ross

JX I

CX

0503

SC

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd B

lue

Cro

ssJX

IC

X05

036

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

HPH

and

Blu

e C

ross

JX I

CX

0503

7C

onn.

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g H

PH a

nd B

lue

Cro

ssJX

IC

X05

038

Con

n.B

ct-r

elat

ed d

ocw

nent

invo

lvin

g H

PH a

nd B

lue

Cro

ssJX

IC

X05

039

Con

n.ac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

HPH

and

Blu

e C

mss

JX I

CX

OS0

40C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g H

PH a

nd B

lue

Cro

ssJX

IC

X05

041

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

HPH

and

Blu

e C

ross

JX I

CX

0504

2C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Blu

e C

ross

JX I

CX

0504

3C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Blu

e C

ross

JX I

CX

0504

4C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Blu

e C

ross

JX I

CX

0504

5C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Hea

lth C

are

Serv

ices

Cor

pJX

IOrdered 2/9/05

CX

0504

6C

onn.

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Blu

e C

ross

JX I

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0504

7C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Hea

lth C

are

Serv

ice

Cor

pJX

IC

X05

048

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd B

lue

Cro

ssJX

I

Page 36: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

tTitl

eA

dmis

sibi

ltyT

rans

crip

t Cite

atw

lHch

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yIn Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

Num

ber

orde

rE

xhib

itisD

iscu

ssed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

CX

0504

9C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Blu

e C

ross

JX I

CX

0505

0C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Blu

e C

ross

JX I

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

CX

0505

1C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Blu

e C

ross

JX I

CX

0505

2C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Blu

e C

ross

JX 1

CX

0505

3C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Blu

e C

ross

JX 1

CX

0505

4C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Blu

e C

ross

JX 1

CX

0505

5C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Blu

e C

ross

JX 1

CX

0505

6C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Blu

e C

ross

JX 1

CX

0505

7C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

HPH

and

Blu

e C

ross

JX I

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

DX

0700

0, D

X07

001

CX

0505

8C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd O

ne H

ealth

Pla

nJX

IT

r. 5

96, 5

97 (

Pub

)D

X07

003

Tr.

597

, 599

, 203

1-20

32 (

Pub

);D

X07

000

, DX

0700

1C

X05

059

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

One

Hea

lth P

lan

JX I

Tr.

194

2-19

45 (

In C

am)

DX

0700

3C

X05

060

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

One

Hea

lth P

lan

JX I

DX

0700

0, D

X07

001

CX

0506

1C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

One

Hea

lth P

lan

JX I

DX

0700

3C

X05

062

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd O

ne H

ealth

Pla

nJX

IT

r. 6

1014

38-1

439

1448

(Pu

b)C

X05

063

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd O

ne H

ealth

Pla

nJX 1

CX

0506

4C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

doc u

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

One

Hea

lth P

lan

JX I

DX

0700

0, D

X07

003

Ordered 2/9/05

Tr.

628

2031

- 203

2 (P

ub);

194

5-19

46D

X07

000

, DX

0700

1C

X05

065

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd O

ne H

ealth

Pla

nJX 1

(In

Car

)D

X07

003

CX

0506

6C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

One

Hea

lth P

lan

JX I

Tr.

143

9-14

4220

31- 2

032

(Pub

);C

X05

067

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd O

ne H

ealth

Pla

nJX

IT

r. 1

946-

1947

(In

Car

)D

X07

000

, DX

0700

3Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0506

8C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd P

riva

te H

ealth

care

Sys

tem

sJX

IT

r. 2

54, 2

57, 2

69 (

In C

am)

Ordered 1/26/05

CX

0506

9R

ESE

RV

ED

Tr.

252

- 254

, 256

-257

, 268

- 269

(In

CX

0507

0C

onb.

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Pri

vate

Hea

lthca

re S

yste

ms

JX I

Car

)C

X05

071

Con

b.ac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd P

riva

te H

ealth

care

Sys

tem

sJX

IO

rder

ed 2

/9/0

5T

r. 2

49- 2

52, 2

58- 2

61, 2

69-2

70, 1

935-

CX

050n

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd P

riva

te H

ealth

care

Sys

tem

sJX 1

1939

(In

Car

)Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0507

3 .

Con

b.ac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd P

riva

te H

ealth

care

Sys

tem

sJX 1

CX

0507

4C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Uni

care

JX I

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0507

5C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Uni

care

JX I

Tr.

156

3-15

65 (

In C

ar)

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0507

6C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd R

ush

Prud

entia

lJX

IC

X05

077

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

Pru

dent

ial

JX I

CX

0507

8C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng R

ush

Prud

entia

lJX 1

CX

0507

9C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd R

nsh

Prud

entia

lJX

IT

r. 1

549-

1551

(In

Car

)C

X05

080

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd A

ncho

rJX

IOrdered 2/9/05

CX

0508

1C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Anc

hor

JX I

Page 37: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

tTitl

eA

dmis

sibi

ltyTranscripfCite at which

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yIn Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

Num

ber

Ord

erE

xhib

it is

Dis

cuss

edE

xhib

itE

xhib

itC

X05

082

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd A

ncho

rJX

IC

X05

083

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd A

ncho

rJX

IC

X05

084

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd A

ncho

rJX

IC

X05

085

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd R

ush

Prud

entia

lJX

IT

r. 1

582-

1583

(In

Car

)C

X05

086

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd R

ush

Prud

entia

lJX

IC

X05

087

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd A

cces

s H

ealth

JX I

CX

0508

8C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Rus

h A

cces

s H

ealth

JX I

CX

0508

9C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng R

ush

Hea

lth P

lan

JX I

CX

0509

0C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Acc

ess

Hea

lthJX

IC

X05

091

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd R

ush

Prud

entia

lJX

IC

X05

092

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

Cap

p C

are

JX I

CX

0509

3C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd B

eech

Str

eet

JX I

CX

0509

4C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd B

eech

Str

eet

JX I

CX

0509

5R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0509

6C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Cap

p C

ore

JXI

CX

0509

7C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Cap

p C

are

JX I

CX

0509

8C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Cap

p C

are

JX I

CX

0509

9C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Bee

ch S

tree

tJX

IC

X05

100

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

Hea

lth M

arke

tigJX

IC

X05

101

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

Hea

lth M

arke

tigJX

IC

X05

102

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd H

ealth

Mar

ketig

JX I

CX

0510

3C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Hea

lth M

arke

tigJX

I

CX

0510

4C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd M

idw

est B

usin

ess

Med

ica!

Ass

ocia

tion

JX I

CX

0510

5C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd P

refe

rred

Car

e N

etw

ork

JX I

CX

0510

6C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd P

refe

rred

Car

e N

etw

ork

JX I

CX

0510

7C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd P

refe

rred

Car

e N

etw

ork

JX I

CX

0510

8C

onb.

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd P

refe

rred

Car

e N

etw

ork

JX I

CX

0510

9C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd H

ealth

Star

JX 1

CX

0511

0C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd H

ealth

Star

JX I

CX

0511

1-C

X05

112

RE

SER

VE

D

CX

0511

3C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Mid

wes

t Bus

ines

s M

edic

al A

ssoc

iatio

nJX

I

CX

0511

4C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Mid

wes

t Bus

ines

s M

edic

al A

ssoc

iatio

nJX

I

CX

0511

5C

onb.

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Mid

wes

t Bus

ines

s M

edic

al A

ssoc

iatio

nJX

I

CX

0511

6I

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd M

idw

est B

usin

ess

Med

ical

Ass

ocia

tion

JX I

Page 38: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

t Titl

eA

dmbs

ibili

tyTr:!nscriptCiteat whiCh

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yIn Camera

Ord

erIn

Cam

eraP

age(

s)N

umbe

r

, .

Ord

erExhibit is Discussed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

CX

OS1

l7C

onlr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Mid

wes

t Bus

ines

s M

edic

al A

ssoc

iatio

nJX

IC

XO

S1l8

Con

trct

-rel

ated

doc

umen

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Hea

lthS

taJX

IC

XO

S1l9

Con

lrac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd H

ealth

Star

JX I

CX

OS

120

Con

lrac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd H

ealth

Star

JX I

CX

OSI

21C

onlr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Hea

lthSt

arJX

IC

XO

S 12

2C

onlr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Hea

lthSt

arJX

IC

XO

S 12

3C

onlr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd S

tate

of

lIon

ios

JX I

CX

OS

124

Conlract-related document involving HPH and State of Illinois

JX I

Ord

ered

2/

9/0S

CX

OS

12S

Con

lrac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd S

tate

ofI

llino

isJX

IO

rder

ed

2/9/

0SC

XO

S 12

6Conlract-related document involving ENH and State of Ilinois

JX I

CX

OS

127

Con

lrac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd S

tate

of

Ilin

ois

JX I

Ord

ered

2/

9/0S

CX

OS

128

Con

lrac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd S

tate

of

Illio

is

JX I

Ord

ered

2/

9/0S

CX

OSI

29Contract-related document involving ENH and State of Ilinois

JX I

Ord

ered

2/

9/0S

CX

OS

130

-

C;X

OSI

31R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

OS

132

Con

lrac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd C

igna

JX I

CX

OS

133

Con

lrac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd C

igna

JX I

CX

OS

134

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd P

rude

ntia

lJX

IC

XO

S 13

SC

onlr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Ael

naJX

IC

XO

S 13

6C

onlr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd T

he T

rave

lers

JX I

CX

OS

137

Con

lrac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

, The

Tra

vele

rs, a

nd M

elro

polit

an L

ife

JX I

CX

OS

138

Con

1;ac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

, The

Tra

vele

rs, a

nd M

elro

polit

an L

ife

JX I

CX

OS

139

Con

lrac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

, The

Tra

vele

rs. a

nd M

elro

polit

a L

ife

JX I

CX

OS

140

Con

lrac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

Mel

ropo

lita

Life

JX I

CX

OSI

41C

onlr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd M

elro

polit

an L

ife

JX I

CX

OS

142

Con

lrac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

MeI

Lif

e H

ealth

care

JX I

CX

OS

143

Con

lrac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

MeI

Lif

e H

ealth

care

JX I

CX

OSI

44C

onlr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd C

hica

go H

MO

JX I

CX

OS

14S

Con

lrac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

Uni

ted

JX I

CX

OS

146

Con

lrac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd C

hica

go H

MO

JX I

CX

OSI

47C

onlr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd U

nite

dJX

I

CX

OS

148

Con

lrac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

Chi

cago

HM

O a

nd C

hica

go H

ealth

JX I

CX

OS

149

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

Uni

ted

JX I

CX

OSI

SOC

onlr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd U

nite

dJX

IC

XO

SISI

Con

trct

-rel

ated

doc

umen

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH

and

Uni

ted

JX I

CX

OS

IS2

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd M

etro

polit

an L

ife

JX I

CX

OS

IS3

Con

lrac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd M

etro

polit

a Li

feJX

I

Page 39: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Adm

issi

bilty

Transcript Cite

atw

hich

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yN

umbe

rD

ocun

ient

Titl

eO

rder

Exh

ibit

is D

iscu

ssed

E

xhib

itE

xhib

itIn Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

CX

0515

4C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Met

ropo

litan

Lif

eJX

IC

X05

155

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd M

etL

ife

Hea

lthC

are

JX I

CX

0515

6C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Met

Lif

e H

ealth

Car

eJX

IC

X05

157

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd M

eIL

ife

Hea

lthC

are

JX I

CX

0515

8C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

MeI

Lif

e H

ealth

Car

eJX

IC

X05

159

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd S

hare

Hea

lth P

lan

JX I

CX

0516

0C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Sha

e H

ealth

Pla

nJX

IC

X05

161

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd S

hare

Hea

lth P

lan

JX I

CX

05l6

2C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Sha

e H

ealth

Pla

nJX

IC

X05

163

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd S

hare

Hea

lth P

lan

JX I

CX

0516

4C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Sha

re H

ealth

Pla

nJX

IC

X05

165

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd U

nite

dJX

IC

X05

166

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd U

nite

dJX

IC

X05

167

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd U

nite

dJX

IC

X05

168

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H, C

hica

go H

MO

, and

Chi

cago

Hea

lthJX

IC

X05

169

RE

SER

VE

DC

X05

170

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd C

hica

go H

MO

JX I

CX

05l7

1C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Uni

ted

JX I

CX

0517

2C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Uni

ted

JX I

CX

0517

3C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Uni

ted

JX I

CX

0517

4C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Uni

ted

JX I

Tr.

886

, 899

(Pu

b); 1

118

(In

Car

)Ordered 2/9/05

CX

OS1

75C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Uni

ted

JX I

CX

0517

6C

onb'

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Uni

ted

JX I

Tr.

887

, 899

(P

ub)

Ordered 2/9/0S

CX

0517

7C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX

IC

X05

178

Con

b.ac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

Pre

ferr

ed P

lan

JX I

CX

0517

9C

onb.

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX

IC

XO

S 1

80C

onb.

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX

IC

X05

181

Con

b.ac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

Pre

ferr

ed P

lan

JX I

CX

OSI

82C

onb.

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX

IC

X05

183

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

Pre

ferr

ed P

lan

JX I

CX

0518

4C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX

IC

X05

18S

Con

b.ac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

Pre

ferr

ed P

lan

JX I

CX

0518

6C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

, Gle

nbro

ok, a

nd P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX

IC

X05

187

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

Gle

nbro

ok a

nd P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX

IC

X05

188

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

Gle

nbro

ok a

nd P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX

IC

X05

189

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

Gle

nbro

ok a

nd P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX

IC

X05

190

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

Gle

nbro

ok a

nd P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX

IC

X05

191

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX 1

Page 40: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

tTitl

eA

dmis

sibi

ltyT

rans

crip

t Cite

at w

hich

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yIn Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

Num

ber

Ord

erExhibit is Discussed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

CX

0519

2C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Pre

ferr

ed P

lan

JX I

CX

0519

3C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

, Gle

nbro

ok, a

nd P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX

IC

X05

194

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX

IC

X05

195

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX

IC

X05

196

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H, G

lenb

rook

, and

Pre

ferr

ed P

lan

JX I

CX

0519

7C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

, Gle

nbro

ok, a

nd P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX

IC

X05

198

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX

IC

X05

199

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H, G

lenb

rook

, and

Pre

ferr

ed P

lan

JX I

CX

0520

0C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t il1

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX

IC

X05

20 I

RE

SER

VE

DC

X05

202

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX

IO

rder

ed 2

/9/0

5C

X05

203

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX

IOrdered 2/9/05

CX

0520

4C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

, Gle

nbro

ok, a

nd P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX

IC

X05

205

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H, G

lenb

rook

, and

Pre

ferr

ed P

lan

JX I

CX

0520

6C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

, Gle

nbro

ok, a

nd P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX

IC

X05

207

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H, G

lenb

rook

, and

Pre

ferr

ed P

lan

JX I

CX

0520

8C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Pre

ferr

ed P

lan

JX I

CX

0520

9C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Pre

ferr

ed P

lan

JX I

CX052 10

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX

IOrdered 2/9/05

CX

0521

lR

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0521

2C

ontr

ct-r

elat

ed d

ocum

ent i

nvol

ving

HP

H a

nd H

FN

, Inc

.JX

IC

X05

213

-C

X05

214

RE

SER

VE

DC

X05

215

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd H

FN, I

nc.

JX I

CX

0521

6C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

HFN

, Inc

.JX

IOrdered 2/9/05

CX

0521

7C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

HFN

, Inc

.JX

IOrdered 2/9/05

CX

0521

8C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd A

ffor

dabl

e H

ealth

Car

e C

once

pts

JX I

CX

0521

9C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd C

CN

JX I

CX

0522

0C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd C

CN

JX I

CX

0522

I C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd C

CN

JX I

CX

0522

2C

ontr

ct-r

elat

ed d

ocum

ent i

nvol

ving

HP

H a

nd C

CN

JX I

CX

0522

3C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd C

CN

JX I

CX

0522

4C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Afo

rdab

le H

ealth

Car

e C

once

pts

JX I

CX

0522

5C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Aff

orda

ble

Hea

lth C

are

Con

cept

sJX

IC

X05

226

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd A

ffor

dabl

e H

ealth

Car

e C

once

pts

JX I

CX

0522

7C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Aff

orda

ble

Hea

lth C

are

Con

cept

sJX

IC

X05

228

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd A

ffor

dabl

e H

ealth

Car

e C

once

pts

JX I

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0522

9C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Fir

st H

ealth

Net

wor

kJX

IO

rder

ed 2

/9/0

5

Page 41: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Adm

issi

bilty

Tra

nscr

ipt

CUe at which

Rel

ated

..

Siun

llary

Num

ber

Doc

umen

t Titl

eO

rder

Exh

ibit

is D

iscu

ssed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

In

Cam

era

Ord

erIn

C

amer

a Pa

ge(s

)C

X05

230

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd C

CN

JX I

CX

0523

I C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

CC

NJX

IC

X05

232

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H, G

lenb

rook

, and

CC

NJX

IC

XO

S233

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H, G

lenb

rook

, and

CC

NJX

IC

X05

234

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H, G

lenb

rook

, and

CC

NJX

IC

X05

235

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd C

CN

JX I

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0523

6C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g H

PH a

nd O

ne H

ealth

JX I

CX

0523

7C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g H

PH a

nd P

HC

SJX

IO

rder

ed 2

/9/0

5C

XO

S238

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd A

etna

JX I

CX

OS2

39C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Aet

naJX

IC

X05

240

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd A

etna

JX I

CX

OS2

41C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Aet

nJX

IC

XO

S242

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd A

cces

sJX

IC

X05

243

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd A

ncho

rJX

IC

X05

244

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd P

rude

ntia

lJX

IC

X05

245

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd P

rude

ntia

lJX

IC

X05

246

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd P

rude

ntia

lJX

IC

X05

247

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd R

ush-

Con

trac

t Car

eJX

IC

X05

248

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd A

cess

JX I

CX

0524

9C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Pru

dent

ial

JX I

CX

0525

0C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Rus

h C

ontr

act-

Car

eJX

IC

X05

25 I

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H, G

lenb

rook

, and

Pru

dent

ial

JX I

CX

0525

2C

onbo

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g H

PH a

nd B

eech

Str

eet ,

Inc

.JX

IC

XO

S2S3

Con

b.ac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd C

APP

Car

e , In

c.JX

IC

X05

254

Con

b.ac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd A

NC

HO

RJX

IC

X05

255

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd P

refe

ned

Car

e N

etw

ork

JX I

CX

0525

6C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Pre

fene

d C

are

Net

wor

kJX

I

CX

0525

7C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Hea

lthSt

a M

anag

ed C

are

Cor

pora

tion

JX I

CX

0525

8C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Hea

lthSt

ar M

anag

ed C

are

Cor

pora

tion

JX I

CX

052S

9C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Mid

wes

t Bus

ines

s M

edic

al A

ssoc

iatio

nJX

I

CX

0526

0C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

/Gle

nbro

ok a

nd H

ealth

Star

(va

riou

s pr

ogra

ms)

JX I

CX

0526

1C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Hea

lthSt

aJX

IC

X05

262

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd B

lue

Cro

ssJX

IC

X05

263

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd H

eald

l Car

e Se

rvic

e C

orpo

ratio

nJX

IC

X05

264

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd H

wna

naJX

I

Page 42: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

. Doc

umen

t Titl

eA

dmis

sibi

ltyT

rans

crip

t Cite

at w

hich

Reh

ited

Sum

mar

yIn Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

Num

ber

Ord

erExhibit is Discussed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

CX

0526

5C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

HFN

JX I

CX

0526

6C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Pre

felT

ed P

lan

JX I

CX

0526

7C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd H

FNJX

IC

X05

268

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd P

refe

lTed

Hea

lth N

etw

ork

JXI

CX

0526

9C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Pre

felT

ed P

lan

JX I

CX

0527

0C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Pre

felT

ed P

lanS

olo

Cup

Com

pany

JX I

CX

0527

I C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Pre

felT

ed P

lan

JX I

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H/G

lenb

rook

and

Pre

felT

ed P

lanS

olo

Cup

CX

0527

2C

ompa

nyJX

I

CX

0527

3C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd M

etro

polit

an L

ife

Insu

ranc

e C

ompa

nyJX

I

CX

0527

4C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd M

etL

ife

Hea

lthca

re N

etw

ork

of I

linoi

sJX

IC

X05

275

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

Chi

cago

HM

O L

td,

JXI

CX

0527

6C

ontr

act r

elat

ed d

ocum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

Chi

cago

HM

O L

td.

JX I

CX

0527

7C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Chi

cago

HM

O L

td.

JX I

CX

0527

8C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Chi

cago

HM

O L

td.

JX I

CX

0527

9C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Sha

re H

ealth

Pla

n of

Ilin

ois

JX I

CX

0528

0C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

The

Tra

vele

rs M

anag

ed C

are

Syst

emJX

IC

X05

28I

RE

SER

VE

DC

X05

282

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd C

hica

go H

MO

Ltd

.JX

I

CX

0528

3C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

The

Tra

vele

rs M

anag

ed C

are

Syst

emJX

IC

X05

284

RE

SER

VE

DC

X05

285

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd C

hica

go H

MO

Ltd

,JX

I

CX

0528

6C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

The

Tra

vele

rs M

anag

ed C

are

Syst

emJX

IC

X05

287

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd C

hica

go H

MO

Ltd

.JX

IC

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

, Chi

cago

HM

O L

td. a

nd C

hica

go H

ealth

CX

0528

8M

ulti

Opt

ion

Insu

ranc

e, L

td.

JX I

CX

0528

9C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Chi

cago

HM

O L

td.

JX I

CX

0529

0C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

The

Tra

vele

rs M

anag

ed C

are

Syst

emJX

IC

X05

291

Con

trac

t.rel

ated

doc

umen

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Chi

cago

HM

O L

td.

JX I

CX

0529

2C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Men

traH

ealth

JXI

CX

0529

3C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Sha

e H

ealth

Pla

n of

Ilin

ois

JX I

CX

0529

4C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

CC

N, I

nc.

JX I

CX

0529

5C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

CC

N, I

nc.

JX I

CX

0529

6C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

CC

N, I

nc.

JX I

Page 43: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Adm

issi

bilty

Tra

nscr

ipt C

itat

whi

chla

tSu

mm

ary

Num

ber

Doc

umnt

Titl

eO

rdE

xhib

it is

Dis

cuss

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

In Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

CX

OS2

97C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Sha

re H

ealth

Pla

n of

Ilin

ois

JX I

CX

OS2

98C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g H

PH a

nd M

ultiP

lan ,

Inc.

JX I

CX

OS2

99C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g H

PH a

nd M

ultiP

lan

, Inc

.JX

IC

XO

S300

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

HPH

and

Adm

ar C

orpo

ratio

nJX

IC

XO

S30

IC

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g H

PH a

nd P

rinc

ipal

Hea

lth C

are ,

Inc.

JX I

CX

OS3

02C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g H

PH a

nd H

ealth

Net

wor

k, I

nc.

JX I

CX

OS3

03C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g H

PH a

nd W

ellm

ark

Hea

lthN

etw

ork

, Inc

.JX 1

CX

OS3

04C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g H

PH a

nd H

FNJX

IC

XO

S30

S -

CX

OS6

99R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

OS7

00C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Hea

lth M

arke

ting,

Inc

.JX

IC

XO

S70

IC

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

HM

IJX

IC

XO

S702

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

HPH

and

Pri

vate

Hea

lthca

re S

yste

ms

Ltd

.JX

IC

XO

S703

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

HPH

and

Pri

vate

Hea

lthca

re S

yste

ms

Ltd

.JX

IC

XO

S704

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

HPH

and

Pri

vate

Hea

lthca

re S

yste

ms

Ltd

.JX

IC

XO

S70S

Con

b.ac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

HPH

and

Pri

vate

Hea

lthca

re S

yste

ms,

Ltd

.JX

I

CX

OS7

06C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

Ben

efit

Tru

st L

ife

Insu

ranc

e C

ompa

nyJX

I

CX

OS7

07C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NW

Gle

nbro

ok a

nd P

riva

te H

ealth

care

Sys

tem

sJX

IC

XO

S708

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd P

riva

te H

ealth

care

Sys

tem

sJX

IC

XO

S709

Con

trct

-rel

ated

doc

wne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd P

riva

te H

ealth

care

Sys

tem

sJX

IC

XO

S710

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd P

riva

te H

ealth

care

Sys

tem

sJX

IC

XO

S711

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd P

riva

te H

ealth

care

Sys

tem

sJX

IC

XO

S712

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

EN

H a

nd C

IGN

A H

ealth

plan

of

Ilin

ois

JX I

CX

OS7

13C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

CIG

NA

JX I

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

mg

HPH

and

The

Sta

te o

f Il

inoi

s E

mpl

oyee

s G

roup

CX

OS7

14H

ealth

Pla

nJX

IC

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd T

he S

tate

of

Ilin

ois

Em

ploy

ees

Gro

upC

XO

S71S

Hea

lth P

lan

JX I

Ordered 2/9/0S

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

The

Sta

te o

f Il

inoi

s E

mpl

oyee

s G

roup

CX

OS7

16H

ealth

PIa

neac

hers

Ret

irem

ent I

nura

nce

Pla

nJX

I

Con

b.ac

t-re

late

d do

cwne

nt in

volv

ing

HPH

and

The

Sta

te o

f Il

linoi

s an

d L

ocal

CX

OS7

17Governent Employees

' Gro

up H

ealth

Pla

nTea

cher

s' R

etin

aent

Insu

ranc

e P

rogr

amJX

IC

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

The

Sta

te o

f Il

inoi

s E

mpl

oyee

s G

roup

CX

OS7

18H

ealth

Pla

nJX

IC

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

The

Sta

te o

f Il

inoi

s E

mpl

oyee

s G

roup

CX

OS7

19H

ealth

Pla

nJX

IC

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docw

nent

invo

lvin

g E

NH

and

The

Sta

te o

f Il

inoi

s E

mpl

oyee

s G

roup

CX

OS7

20H

ealth

Pla

nJX

I

Page 44: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

tmtie

Adm

issi

bilty

. Tra

nscr

ipt C

ite a

t whi

chR

elat

edSu

mm

ary

Num

ber

Ord

erExhibit is Discussed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

In Camera

Ord

erIn

C

amer

aPag

e(s)

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd T

he S

tate

of

Ilin

ois

Em

ploy

ees

Gro

upCX0572 I

Hea

lth P

lan

JX I

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd T

he S

tate

of

Ilin

ois

Em

ploy

ees

Gro

upC

X05

722

Hea

lth P

lan

JX I

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd T

he S

tate

of

Ilin

ois

Em

ploy

ees

Gro

upC

X05

723

Hea

lth P

lan

JX I

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd T

he S

tate

of

Ilin

ois

Em

ploy

ees

Gro

upC

X05

724

Hea

lth P

lan

JX I

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd T

he S

tate

of

Ilin

ois

Em

ploy

ees

Gro

upC

X05

725

Hea

lth P

lan.

JX I

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd T

he S

tate

of

Ilin

ois

Em

ploy

ees

Gro

upC

X05

726

Hea

lth P

lan

JX I

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd T

h. S

tate

of

Ilin

ois

Em

ploy

ees

Gro

upC

X05

727

Hea

lth P

lan

JX I

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd T

he S

tate

of

ilino

Is E

mpl

oyee

s G

roup

CX

0572

8H

ealth

Pla

nJX

IC

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

The

Sta

te o

f Il

inoi

s E

mpl

oyee

s G

roup

CX

0572

9H

ealth

Pla

nJX

IC

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

The

Sta

te o

f Il

inoi

s E

mpl

oyee

s G

roup

CX

0573

0H

ealth

Pla

neac

hers

Ret

irem

ent I

nsur

ance

Pla

nJX

I

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

rd T

he S

tate

of

Illin

ois

and

Loc

alC

X05

73I

Governent Employees

' Gro

up H

ealth

Pla

neac

hers

' Ret

irem

ent I

nsur

ance

Pro

gam

JXI

L;o

ntra

ct-r

elat

ed d

ocum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd T

heSt

ate

of I

llinO

ls a

nd L

ocal

Gov

ernm

ent Q

ualty

Hea

lth P

lans

frea

cher

s ' C

hoic

e H

eal

th P

lanC

olle

ge C

hoic

e H

ealth

CX

0573

2Pl

anJX

IO

rder

ed 2

/9/0

5

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd T

he S

tate

of

Illin

ois

Qua

lity

Car

e H

ealth

CX

0573

3Pl

anIo

cal C

are

Hea

lth P

lan/

each

ers '

Cho

ice

Hea

lth P

lanC

olle

ge C

hoic

e H

ealth

Pla

nJX

IO

rder

ed 2

/9/0

5

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd T

he S

tate

of

Ilin

ois

Qua

lity

Car

e H

ealth

CX

0573

4Planocal Care Health Plan/eachers

' Cho

ice

Hea

lth P

lanC

olle

ge C

hoic

e H

ealth

Pla

nJX

IOrdered 2/9/05

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd T

he S

tate

of

Ilin

ois

Qua

lity

Car

e H

ealth

CX

0573

5Planocal Care Health Planeachers

' Cho

ice

Hea

lth P

lanC

olle

ge C

hoic

e H

ealth

Pla

nJX

IOrdered 2/9/05

CX

0573

6C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Aet

na/C

hoic

eJX

IC

X05

737

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

HM

O lI

inoi

.JX

IC

X05

738

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

HM

O I

linoi

sJX

IC

X05

739

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

HM

O I

linoi

sJX

IC

X05

740

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

HM

O I

linoi

sJX

IC

X05

741

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

HM

O I

linoi

sJX

IC

X05

742

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

Man

aged

Car

e N

etw

ork

Pref

errd

JX I

CX

0574

3C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd H

MO

tUin

ois

JX I

CX

0574

4C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Blu

e C

ross

JX I

Page 45: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

tTitl

eA

dmis

sibi

ltyTranscript Cite at which

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yN

umbe

rO

rder

Exhibit is Discussed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

In Camera.

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

CX

0574

5C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

HM

O I

linoi

sJX

IC

X05

746

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd H

MO

Ilin

ois

JX I

CX

0574

7C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

HM

O I

linoi

sJX

IC

X05

748

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd H

MO

Ilin

ois

JX I

CX

0574

9C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

HM

O I

linoi

sJX

IC

X05

750

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd B

lue

Cro

ssJX

IOrdered 2/9/05

CX

0575

I C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

HM

O I

linoi

sJX

IOrdered 2/9/05

CX

0575

2C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Blu

e C

ross

JX I

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0575

3C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

HM

O I

linoi

sJX

IO

rder

ed 2

/9/0

5C

X05

754

Con

trct

-rel

ated

doc

umen

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Blu

e C

ross

JX I

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0575

5C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Blu

e C

ross

JX I

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

CX

0575

6C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd H

ealth

Chi

cago

JX I

Ordered 3/16/05

CX

0575

7.C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd H

ealth

Chi

cago

JX I

Ordered 3/16/05

CX

0575

8C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd H

ealth

Chi

cago

JX I

Ord

ered

3/1

6/05

CX

0575

9C

ontr

ct-r

elat

ed d

ocum

ent i

nvol

ving

HP

H a

nd H

ealth

Chi

cago

JX I

Ord

ered

3/1

6/05

CX

0576

0C

ontr

ct-r

elat

ed d

ocum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

Hea

lthC

hica

goJX

IOrdered 3/16/05

CX

0576

1C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd H

ealth

Chi

cago

JXI

CX

0576

2C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd H

ealth

Chi

cago

JX I

Ordered 3/16/05

CX

0576

3C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd H

ealth

Chi

cago

JX I

Ordered 3/16/05

CX

0576

4C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd H

ealth

Chi

cago

JX I

Ordered 3/16/05

CX

0576

5C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Mic

hael

Ree

se H

ealth

Pla

nJX

IOrdered 3/16/05

CX

0576

6C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Mic

hael

Ree

se H

ealth

Pla

nJX

IO

rder

ed 3

/16/

05C

X05

767

Con

b.ac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd H

uman

aJX

IC

X05

768

Con

b.ac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd H

uman

aJX

IO

rder

ed 3

/16/

05C

X05

769

Con

b.ac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd H

uman

aJX

IO

rder

ed 3

/16/

05C

X05

770

Con

boac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd H

uman

JX I

Ord

ered

3/1

6/05

CX

0577

1C

onbo

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Hum

ana

JX I

Ordered 3/16/05

CX

0577

2C

onb.

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Hum

ana

JX I

CX

0577

3C

onb.

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Afo

rdab

le H

ealth

Car

e C

once

pts

JX I

CX

0577

4C

ontr

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng E

NH

and

Aff

orda

ble

Hea

lth C

are

Con

cept

sJX

IC

X05

775

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

EN

H a

nd H

uman

aJX

IC

X05

776

-C

X05

899

RE

SER

VE

DC

onb.

act-

rela

ted

docu

men

t inv

olvi

ng H

PH a

nd A

dmar

, For

Mos

t, H

ealth

Mar

ketin

g,C

X05

900

Bee

ch S

tree

tlCA

PP C

are,

Mul

tipla

n, P

refe

rred

Pla

nJX

IC

X05

90 I

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

For

Mos

tJX

IC

X05

902

Con

trac

t-re

late

d do

cum

ent i

nvol

ving

HPH

and

Hea

lthN

etw

ork

JX I

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0590

3 -

CX

0590

4R

ESE

RV

ED

Page 46: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

t Titl

eA

dmis

sibi

ltyT

rans

crip

t Cite

at w

hich

Rela ted

Sum

mar

yIn Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

Num

ber

Ord

erE

xhib

it is

Dis

cuss

edE

xhib

itE

xhib

itC

X05

905

Mas

ter

Lis

t of

Con

trac

ts a

nd A

ctio

ns T

aken

JX 1

Mem

o no

m C

han

to G

ilber

t re:

Est

imat

e of

Anu

al I

ncre

ase

in N

et R

even

ue- U

pdat

ed a

sC

X05

906

of M

ay 1

620

00. A

ttach

ed c

hars

of A

nual Net Revenue In

crea

ses

JX I

Tr.

843

(In

Car

)C

X05

907

Lette

r IT

Om

Pet

ers

to L

evin

e re

: pro

posa

l for

EN

H. A

ttach

ed c

har.

JX 1

Tr.

152

4-15

25; 1

577-

1579

(In

Cam

)O

rder

ed 2

/9/0

5C

X05

908

Rus

h P

rode

nti a

l Cur

rent

Bus

ines

s Fl

ow; S

unar

y of

Exi

stig

Con

trac

ts.

JX I

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0590

9R

ESE

RV

ED

Hig

hlan

d Pa

rk H

ospi

ta a

nd E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

Hea

lthca

re C

ontr

acts

with

var

ous

CX

0591

0pa

yors

JX I

JX6

Tr.

626

1 (P

ub)

CX

0591

1 -

CX

0593

9R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0594

0R

espo

nden

ts' A

nsw

ers

and

Obj

ectio

ns to

Com

plai

nt C

oune

l's

Firs

t Set

of I

nter

roga

torie

s JX

IC

X05

941

-C

X06

136

RE

SER

VE

DC

X06

137

Dep

aren

t of P

atho

logy

and

Lab

orat

ory

Med

icin

e: C

ore

Lab

Exe

cutiv

e S

umm

arJX

IOrdered 2/9/05

CX

0613

8 -

CX

06l3

9R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0614

0E

mai

l IT

om W

eiss

to M

erz

re: R

emot

e A

cces

s to

EN

H c

ompu

ter

syst

ems

JX 1

CX

0614

1R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0614

2FA

Q' s

Abo

ut V

iral

Pri

vate

Net

wor

k at

Eva

nsto

n Nortwestern Healthcare

JX I

CX

06l4

3R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0614

4ID

PH

: Atta

clue

nt B

JX I

CX

0614

5 -

CX

0614

6R

ESE

RV

ED

EN

H J

CA

HO

Com

plia

nce:

Act

ion

Plan

s in

Res

pons

e to

200

2 T

ype

I's

and

CX

0614

7Su

pple

men

tals

JX I

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

CX

0614

8St

atus

of

JCA

HO

Cha

pter

Sco

res

JX 1

CX

0614

9Ili

nois

Dep

aren

t of P

ublic

Hea

lth S

urey

cha

rJX 1

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

CX

0615

0 -

CX

0615

2R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0615

3O

rgan

izat

ion

Dev

elop

men

t Hos

pita

s an

d C

linic

sJX

IC

X06

154

-C

X06

163

RE

SER

VE

DC

X06

164

Em

ail I

T01

1 W

eiss

to B

arrio

s re

: VIP

JX I

CX

0616

5 -

CX

0617

6SE

RV

ED

CX

0617

7E

NH

Inc

ome

Stat

emen

t Yea

r E

nded

Sep

tem

ber

30, 2

002

JX I

CX

0617

8 -

CX

0618

0R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0618

1E

NH

JC

AH

O C

ompl

ianc

e M

aste

r T

rack

ing

Gri

d 20

02JX

IC

X06

182

-C

X06

199

RE

SER

VE

D

Page 47: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Adm

issi

bilty

Transcript Ci

te a

t whi

Ch

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yN

umbe

rD

ocum

cntT

itle

Ord

erExhibit is Discussed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

In Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

CX

0620

0E

NH

Pro

fit H

Wit

Upd

ate

JX I

CX

0620

1 -

CX062 I I

RE

SER

VE

DM

eetin

g R

efer

rng

Phys

icia

n E

xpec

tatio

ns to

Ach

ieve

Cor

pora

te G

row

th, P

rese

ntat

ion

toC

X06

212

Hos

pita

l Adm

inst

ratio

nJX

IC

X06

213

RE

SER

VE

DC

X06

214

Spe

cial

ty R

efer

ral S

urey

Com

men

ts A

ll C

omm

ents

JXI

CX

0621

5 -

CX

0622

5R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0622

6E

NH

Med

ical

Gro

up: E

PIC

' s I

mpa

ctJX

IC

X06

227

-C

X06

228

RE

SER

VE

DC

X06

229

Epi

c C

ost E

stim

ates

for

Aff

liate

Phy

sici

ans

JX I

CX

0623

0 -

CX

0625

3R

ESE

RV

ED

Let

ter

of I

nten

t bet

wee

n Sw

edis

h C

oven

ant H

ospi

tal a

nd E

vans

ton

Nor

twes

tern

CX

0625

4H

ealth

care

and

EN

H F

acul

ty P

ract

ice

Ass

ocia

tes

JX I

CX

0625

5 -

CX

0626

3R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0626

4R

N R

ecru

itmen

t! R

eten

tion

JX I

(Urd

ered

lI

'UN

ote:

Res

pond

ent w

ithdr

ew I

nC

amer

a st

atus

nom

CX

0626

5C

hica

go H

ospi

tal R

isk

Poo

ling

Pro

grar

JX I

Tr.

500

- 512

, 315

6 (I

n C

ar)

RX

0657

EN

HL

PK

029

821

CX

0626

6H

ighl

and

Park

Hos

pita

l Per

form

ance

Im

prov

emen

t Pro

cess

Eva

luat

ion

JX I

Tr.

314

0 (I

n C

ar)

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0626

7In

terv

iew

sJX

IC

X06

268

JCA

HO

web

site

: Sur

ey P

roce

ssJX

IC

X06

269

-C

X06

273

RE

SER

VE

DC

X06

274

Lette

r no

m S

paet

h to

Nea

rJX

IC

X06

275

Let

ter

nom

Dor

sey

to C

han

JX I

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0627

6A

dden

dum

to I

nven

tory

of

Hea

lth C

are

Faci

litie

sJX

IK

raft

: Uni

ted

Hea

lthca

reT

r. 1

085

, 108

8, 1

089

, 109

3, 1

094

CX

0627

7JX

I11

08 (

In C

ar)

Ord

ered

3/1

6/05

Ilino

is D

pear

ent o

f Public Health Center for Health Statistics: Inventory of Health

CX

0627

8C

are

Faci

lties

and

Ser

vice

s an

d N

eed

Det

enni

natio

nsJX

IC

X06

279-

003

Tab

les

nom

Deb

orah

Haa

s-W

ilson

s E

xper

t Rep

ort

Tr.

2517

Tr.

251

4-25

15, 2

517

(In

Car

)D

X07

0 11

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0627

9-00

4T

able

s no

m D

ebor

ah H

aas-

Wils

ons

Exp

ert R

epor

tT

r. 2

521

Tr.

252

0-25

21 (

In C

ar)

DX

0700

9O

rder

ed 2

/9/0

5C

X06

279.

005

Tab

les

nom

Deb

orah

Haa

s-W

ilson

s E

xper

t Rep

ort

Tr.

252

5T

r. 2

525

(In

Car

)D

X07

007

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

CX

0627

9-00

7T

able

s no

m D

ebor

ah H

aas-

Wils

ons

Exp

ert R

epor

tT

r. 2

531

Tr.

253

0-25

31 (

In C

ar)

DX

0701

2Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0627

9-00

8T

able

s no

m D

ebor

ah H

aas-

Wils

ons

Exp

ert R

epor

tT

r. 2

555

Tr.

255

4-25

55 (

In C

ar)

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

Page 48: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Adm

issi

bilty

Tra

nscr

ipt C

ite a

t whi

chR

elat

edSu

mnj

ary

Num

ber

Document Title

Ord

erExhibit is Discussed

Exh

ibit

Exh

ibit

In Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

Tr.

255

5-25

56. 2

565

, 256

7, 2

569

(In

DX

070I

3, D

X07

014

CX

0627

9-00

9T

able

s IT

om D

ebor

ah H

aas-

Wils

ons

Exp

ert R

epor

tT

r. 2

556

Cam

)D

X07

020

, DX

0702

2O

rder

ed 2

/9/0

5C

X06

279-

0 10

Tab

les

ITom

Deb

orah

Haa

s-W

ilson

s E

xper

t Rep

ort

Tr.

2581

Tr.

258

0-25

81 (

In C

ar)

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0627

9-0

I I

Tab

les

ITom

Deb

orah

Haa

s-W

ilson

s E

xper

t Rep

ort

Tr.

2581

Tr.

258

0-25

81 (

In C

ar)

DX

0705

0Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0627

9-01

3T

able

s IT

om D

ebor

ah H

aas-

Wils

ons

Exp

ert R

epor

tT

r. 2

593

Tr.

259

0-25

93 (

In C

ar)

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

CX

0627

9-01

4T

able

s IT

om D

ebor

ah H

aas-

Wils

ons

Exp

ert R

epor

tT

r. 2

597

Tr.

259

6-25

97 (

In C

ar)

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

CX

0627

9-0

IST

able

s IT

om D

ebor

ah H

aas-

Wils

ons

Exp

ert R

epor

tT

r.26

01T

r. 2

601

(In

Car

)Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0627

9-0

16T

able

s IT

om D

ebor

ah H

aas-

Wils

ons

Exp

ert R

epor

tT

r. 2

605

Tr.

260

4-26

05 (

In C

am)

Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0627

9-0

17T

able

s IT

om D

ebor

ah H

aas-

Wils

ons

Exp

ert R

epor

tT

r. 2

609

Tr.

260

9 (I

n C

am)

Ordered 2/9/05

DX

0701

6, D

X07

017

CX

062

79- 0

18

Tab

les

ITom

Deb

orah

Haa

s-W

ilson

s E

"Per

t Rep

ort

Tr.

260

9T

r. 2

622

(In

Car

)D

X07

018

Ordered 2/9/05

DX

0701

6, D

X07

017

CX

0627

9-0

I 9T

able

s IT

om D

ebor

ah H

aa- W

ilson

s E

xper

t Rep

ort

Tr.

260

9T

r. 2

622

(In

Car

)D

X07

018

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

CX

0627

9-02

0T

able

s IT

om D

ebor

ah H

aas-

Wils

ons

Exp

ert R

epor

tT

r. 2

609

Tr.

263

2 (I

n C

ar)

DX

0701

9Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0628

0Minutes of Nortwestern Healthcare Executive Committee of the Board of Directors

JX I

CX

0628

IN

ortw

este

rn H

ealth

care

Net

wor

k D

isso

lutio

n A

gree

men

tJX

IC

X06

282-

005

Tab

les

ITom

Deb

orah

Haa

s-W

ilson

s R

ebut

tal R

epor

tT

r. 2

576

Tr.

257

4, 2

576

(In

Cam

)D

X07

021

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

DX

0701

6, D

X07

017

CX

0628

2-00

6T

able

s IT

om D

ebor

all H

aa- W

ilson

s R

ebut

tal R

epor

tT

r. 2

609

Tr.

262

8 (I

n C

ar)

DX

0701

8Ordered 2/9/05

CX

0628

2-00

7T

able

s IT

om D

ebor

ah H

aas-

Wils

ons

Reb

utta

l Rep

ort

Tr.

2610

T..

2703

- 270

5 (I

n C

am)

Ord

ered

2/9

/05

CX

0628

2-00

8T

able

s fi.

om D

ebor

ah H

aas-

Wils

ons

Reb

utt R

epor

tT

r. 2

610

T..

2705

- 270

7 (I

n C

ar)

Ordered 2/9/05

Tr.

916

- 920

, 188

6-18

8920

17. 2

018

2017

- 201

8 (P

ub);

CX

0628

3H

ospi

tal M

arke

t Sha

re: P

atie

nts

Res

idin

g in

50

Zip

Cod

e Se

rvic

e A

rea

Tr.

920

Tr.

192

4-19

26 (

In C

am)

Tr.

922

, 928

(P

ub),

1099

- 110

0C

X06

284

Lette

r IT

om U

nite

d to

Cre

ight

onT

r. 9

2811

2519

28- 1

932

(In

Car

)C

X06

285

Red

acte

d T

rans

crip

t of

Loi

s H

wnn

iak

JX3

Page

3 I

n C

amC

X06

286

Red

acte

d T

rans

crip

t of

Pegg

y K

ing

JX 3

CX

0628

7R

edac

ted

Tra

nscr

ipt o

f Mar O'

Bri

enJX

3C

X06

288

-C

X06

292

RE

SER

VE

DC

X06

293

Rom

ano

Mat

eria

ls R

evie

wed

Tr.

298

0T

r. 2

976

, 297

7 (P

ub)

CX

0629

4Dr. Kenneth Elziga

s R

esum

eT

r. 2

348

Tr.

234

823

49 (

pub)

Tr.

296

4, 2

967

, 296

8, 2

969

, 297

1C

X06

295

Rom

ano

Res

ume

and

Publ

ic S

ervi

ce A

ctiv

ities

Tr.

298

0(P

ub)

CX

0629

6H

ighl

and

Park

Hos

pita

l Spe

cial

Cas

e R

evie

wT

r. 3

144

Tr.

314

2, 3

144

, 314

5, 3

150

(In

Car

)M

otio

n 5/

12/0

5C

X06

297

Spec

ial C

ase

Rev

iew

Inf

o se

nt to

JC

AH

OT

r.31

44T

r. 3

143

, 314

4, 3

145

(In

Car

)M

otio

n 5/

12/0

5C

X06

298-

CX

0629

9R

ESE

RV

ED

GX

0630

020

02 v

s. 1

999

HP

H Attbute Rating Su

mar

Tr.

3107

Tr.

310

4, 3

106

. 310

7 (I

n C

ar)

Page 49: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Exh

ibit

Doc

umen

t Titl

eA

dmis

sibi

ltyT

rans

crip

t Cite

at w

hich

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yIn Camera

Ord

erIn Camera

Page

(s)

Num

ber

Ord

erE

xhib

it is

Dis

cuss

edE

xhib

itE

xhib

itC

X06

30 1

-C

X06

303

RE

SER

VE

DC

X06

304

Red

acte

d T

rans

crip

t of

Hom

er L

ivin

gsto

nJX

3C

X06

305

Red

acte

d T

rans

crip

t of

Nee

Ie

Stea

ms

JX2

Tr.

416

7 (P

ub)

CX

0630

6R

edac

ted

Tra

ncri

pt o

f G

ar M

eckl

enbu

rgJX

2T

r. 6

261

(Pub

)C

X06

307

Red

acte

d T

rans

crip

t of

Hei

di S

chel

ling

JX2

Tr.

626

1 (P

ub)

CX

0630

8-C

X06

318

RE

SER

VE

D$3

000

000

0 Il

inoi

s H

ealth

Fac

ilitie

s A

utho

rity

Rev

enue

Bon

ds S

erie

s 19

92 (

Hig

hlan

dC

X06

3 19

Park

Hos

pita

)T

r. 5

850

Tr.

584

7-58

51 (

pub)

$61

700

000

Ilin

ois

Hea

lth F

acili

ties

Aut

hori

ty A

djus

tabl

e R

ate

Rev

enue

Bon

dsC

X06

320

(Hig

hlan

d Pa

rk H

ospi

tal)

Tr.

585

0T

r. 5

847-

5851

(Pu

b)$4

000

000

0 Il

inoi

s H

ealth

Fac

ilitie

s A

utho

rity

Rev

enue

Bon

ds, S

erie

s 19

97A

(H

ighl

and

CX

0632

1 Pa

rk H

ospi

ta P

roje

ct)

Tr.

585

1T

r. 5

847-

5851

(Pu

b)

Page 50: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

IN T

HE

MA

TT

ER

OF

EV

AN

STO

N N

OR

TH

WE

STE

RN

HE

AL

TH

CA

RE

- D

ocke

t No.

931

5C

OM

PLA

INT

CO

UN

SEL

'S I

ND

EX

OF

DE

MO

NST

RA

TIV

E E

XH

IBIT

ST

rans

crip

tCite

at

Exh

ibit

Num

ber

Doc

umen

tTite

Adm

issi

bilty

whi

ch

Exhibit is

Rel

ated

Sum

mar

yIn

C

amer

a O

rder

In

Cam

era

Ord

er. E

xhib

itE

xhib

itPa

ge(s

)

. .

...

Dis

cuss

edT

r. 3

34S-

3363

, 543

6-E

xhib

its f

rom

Rom

ano

Exp

ert

(Pub

); T

r. 3

052

3053

3056

All

DX

0044

0R

epor

t63

03, 6

305

(In

Cam

)In

Cam

era-

Exp

ert

Tr.

307

1-30

72, 3

079-

30S3

30S5

- 30S

7, 3

099-

3101

3103

3110

3116

3127

All

Exh

ibits

fro

m R

oman

o R

ebut

tal

3136 (In cai); 3341-33

47D

X00

441

Rep

ort

3356

5554

-55

92 (

Pub

)In

Cam

era-

Exp

ert

DX

0044

2-D

X06

999

RE

SER

VE

D

CX

0506

5-01

7C

X05

067-

015

CX

0506

1-01

SA

llC

X05

064-

017

One

Hea

lth C

ontr

act S

umm

ary

Tr.

60S

(Pu

b); 7

64, 7

65, 7

69C

X05

059-

017

DX

0700

0D

emon

stra

tive

In C

amer

a77

0 (I

n C

am)

CX

0505

S-01

SIn

Cam

era-

Exp

ert.

CX

0506

5-01

7C

X05

061-

01S

All

One

Hea

lth C

ontr

act S

umm

arT

r. 6

27 (

Pub)

; 757

, 764

, 769

CX

0505

9-01

7D

X07

001

Dem

onst

rativ

e In

Cam

era

(In

Cam

)C

X05

05S-

01S

DX

0700

2R

ESE

RV

ED

CX

0506

5, C

X05

059

One

Hea

lth C

ontr

act L

angu

age

Tr.

625

, 627

(Pu

b); 7

69 (

InC

X05

067

, CX

0506

1A

llD

X07

003

Dem

onst

rativ

eC

am)

CX

0505

S, C

X05

064

In C

amer

a-E

xper

tD

X07

004

RE

SER

VE

D

Tr.

601

, 611

, 900

, 930

, 145

S-N

orth

Sho

re H

ospi

tals

Map

1460

, 146

6-14

71 (

Pub)

; 541

-D

X07

005

Dem

onst

rativ

e54

3, 7

6S, 7

69 (

In C

am)

Noe

ther

Hos

pita

l Map

Tr.

621

, 623

, 935

(Pu

b); 7

6SD

X07

006

Dem

onst

rativ

e76

9 (I

n C

am)

Haa

s-W

ilson

dem

onst

rativ

e:Pe

rcen

tage

Cha

nge

in P

rice

per

All

Inpa

tient

Cas

e at

EN

H b

etw

een

Tr.

252

6, 2

536-

2537

, 275

4D

X07

007

FY99

and

FY

0230

34, 3

036

, 304

0 (I

n C

am)

CX

0627

9-00

5In

Cam

era-

Exp

ert

DX

0700

SR

ESE

RV

ED

Haa

s-W

ilson

dem

onst

rativ

e:Pe

rcen

tage

Cha

nge

in P

rice

per

All

Inpa

tient

Cas

e at

EN

H b

etw

een

Tr.

252

1, 2

535

, 253

7, 3

035

DX

0700

9FY

99 a

nd F

Y01

303S

- 303

9 (I

n C

am)

CX

0627

9-00

4In

Cam

era-

Exp

ert

Haa

s-W

ilson

dem

onst

rativ

e: P

ayer

All

DX

0701

0D

ata

Tim

elin

eT

r. 2

511

(In

Cam

)In

Cam

era-

Exp

ert

Page 51: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Haa

- Wils

on d

emon

stra

tive:

Perc

enta

ge C

hang

e in

Pri

ce p

er

All

Inpa

tient

Cas

e at

EN

H b

y Pa

yer

and

DX

0701

1Pl

anT

r.25

17(I

nCam

)C

X06

279-

003

In C

amer

a-E

xper

tH

aas-

Wils

on d

emon

stra

tive:

Perc

enta

ge C

hang

e in

Pri

ce p

er

All

Inpa

tient

Cas

e at

EN

H (

Stat

e D

ata

DX

0701

2&

Cos

t Rep

orts

)T

r. 2

533

(In

Cam

)C

X06

279-

007

In C

amer

a-E

xper

tH

aas-

Wils

on d

emon

stra

tive:

Perc

enta

ge C

hang

e in

Pri

ce p

er

All

Inpa

tient

Cas

e at

EN

H a

nd C

ontr

olD

X07

0 13

Gro

ups

for

Aet

naT

r. 2

566

(In

Cam

)C

X06

279-

009

In C

amer

a-E

xper

tH

aas-

Wils

on d

emon

stra

tive:

Perc

enta

ge C

hang

e in

Pri

ce p

er

All

Inpa

tient

Cas

e at

EN

H a

nd C

ontr

olD

X07

014

Gro

ups

for

Tr.

256

8-25

69 (

In C

am)

CX

0627

9-00

9In

Cam

era-

Exp

ert

DX

0701

5R

ESE

RV

ED

Haa

- Wils

on d

emon

stra

tive:

Est

imat

ed R

elat

ive

Pric

e In

crea

se a

t

All

EN

H u

sing

APR

DR

G's

wIL

OS

asC

X06

279-

018

, 019

DX

0701

6M

easu

re o

f R

esou

rce

Inte

nsity

Tr.

262

9 (I

n C

am)

CX

0628

2-00

6In

Cam

era-

Exp

ert

Haa

s-W

ilson

dem

onst

rativ

e:E

stim

ated

Rel

ativ

e Pr

ice

Incr

ease

at

All

EN

H u

sing

DR

G W

eigh

ts w

ILO

S as

CX

0627

9-01

8, 0

19D

X07

017

Mea

sure

of

Res

ourc

e In

tens

ityT

r. 2

629

(In

Cam

)C

X06

282-

006

In C

amer

a-E

xper

tH

aas-

Wils

on d

emon

stra

tive:

Est

imat

ed R

elat

ive

Pric

e In

crea

se a

tE

NH

usi

ng D

RG

Wei

ghts

wIL

OS

as

All

Mea

sure

of

Res

ourc

e In

tens

ity (

with

CX

0627

9-01

8, 0

19D

X07

018

Bak

er d

ata)

Tr.

263

0 (I

n C

am)

CX

0628

2-00

6In

Cam

era-

Exp

ert

Haa

- Wils

on d

emon

stra

tive:

Est

imat

ed R

elat

ive

Pric

e In

crea

se

All

DX

0701

9U

sing

Sta

te D

ata

Tr.

263

5-26

36 (

In C

am)

CX

0627

9-02

0In

Cam

era-

Exp

ert

Haa

s-W

ilson

dem

onst

rativ

e:Pe

rcen

tage

Cha

nge

in P

rice

per

All

Inpa

tient

Cas

e at

EN

H a

nd C

ontr

olT

r. 2

570-

2571

2573

(In

DX

0702

0G

roup

s fo

r H

uman

aC

am)

CX

0627

9-00

9In

Cam

era-

Exp

ert

Haa

s-W

ilson

dem

onst

rativ

e:Pe

rcen

tage

Cha

nge

in P

rice

per

All

Inpa

tient

Cas

e at

EN

H a

nd C

ontr

olD

X07

021

Gro

ups

for

One

Hea

lth.

Tr.

257

7-25

78 (

In C

am)

CX

0628

2-00

5In

Cam

era-

Exp

ert

Page 52: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Haa

s-W

ilson

dem

onst

rativ

e:Pe

rcen

tage

Cha

nge

in P

rice

per

All

Inpa

tient

Cas

e at

EN

H a

nd C

ontr

olD

X07

022

Gro

uDS

for

Uni

ted

Tr.

256

3-25

64 (

In C

am)

CX

0627

9-00

9In

Cam

era-

Exp

ert

Haa

- Wils

on d

emon

stra

tive:

Tr.

245

2, 2

467

, 247

9, 2

489

DX

0702

3F

ram

ewor

k of

Ana

lysi

s26

57 (

Pub)

; 254

0 (I

n C

am)

Tr.

248

1, 2

682-

2683

, 268

7H

aas-

Wils

on d

emon

stra

tive:

(Pub

); 2

541

, 258

6, 2

588

Pote

ntia

l Exp

lana

tions

for

the

Pric

e25

9926

0326

0626

15D

X07

024

Incr

ease

2637

2642

(I

n C

am)

Haa

s-W

ilson

dem

onst

rativ

e: D

ata

DX

0702

5So

urce

sT

r. 2

495

(Pub

)H

aa- W

ilson

dem

onst

rativ

e:In

stitu

tiona

l Rel

atio

nshi

psE

mpl

oyer

- Bas

ed H

ealth

care

Tr.

245

3, 2

456

, 246

0, 2

462

DX

0702

6In

sura

nce

(Pub

)H

aa- W

ilson

dem

onst

rativ

e:T

r. 2

544 ,

254

6, 2

621

(In

DX

0702

7D

iffer

ence

in D

iffer

ence

Car

n)D

X07

028

RE

SER

VE

DSi

mps

on D

emon

stra

tive:

Mai

nD

X07

029

Con

clus

ions

Tr.

169

7-1698 (Pub)

Haa

s-W

ilson

dem

onst

rativ

e: P

aper

sPu

blis

hed

in P

eer-

Rev

iew

edD

X07

030

Eco

nom

ics

Jour

nals

Tr.

247

3, 6

184

(Pub

)H

aas-

Wils

on d

emon

stra

tive:

Fact

ors

in E

valu

atin

g D

r. N

oeth

er's

Aca

dem

ic H

ospi

tals

" C

ontr

olD

X07

031

Gro

uDT

r. 2

929

(Pub

)D

X07

032

RE

SER

VE

DT

r. 3049 3056; JUOb

, JU

n.30

76, 3

078

, 308

6-30

8730

95- 3

096

3107

- 310

931

1131

1231

1431

1731

21-

3122

, 312

312

3131

All

3135

3137

- 313

831

5231

5831

6031

6631

7031

7631

8331

9031

92-

DX

0703

3R

oman

o N

arat

ive

Dem

onst

rativ

e31

96

(In

Cam

); T

r. 5

459-

In C

amer

a-E

xDer

t

Page 53: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

Tr.

324

3, 3

371-

33H

5, 3

426-

3429

, 544

5, 5

540

, 627

262

74, 6

280

, 628

2-62

8462

87 (

Pub)

; Tr.

311

9-31

2331

28- 3

129

3138

3191

-A

ll31

9232

0232

0432

16In

Car

era-

Exp

ert N

ote:

3222

3225

3228

- 322

9C

ompl

aint

Cou

nsel

(M

artin

)32

35- 3

236

, 345

7-34

62O

ffer

ed r

evis

ed v

ersi

on, T

r.D

X07

034A

Rom

ano

Dat

a D

emon

stra

tive

5415

6307

6309 6311

3243

Tr.

318

6-31

87, 4

520-

4524

DX

0703

5R

oman

o C

AB

G D

emon

stra

tive

5296

(P

ub)

DX

0703

6R

ESE

RV

ED

DX

0703

7R

oman

o N

PIC

Dem

onst

rativ

eT

r. 3

186

, 541

7 (I

n C

ar)

In C

amer

a-E

xoer

tA

llD

X07

038-

DX

0704

2R

ESE

RV

ED

Haa

s-W

ilson

dem

onst

rativ

e: H

otel

Tr.

249

3 (P

ub);

285

4 (I

nD

X07

043

Pric

esC

am)

Haa

s-W

ilson

dem

onst

rativ

e:Excerpts from the deposition of Mr.

All

DX

0704

4L

ivin

e:st

onT

r. 2

638

(In

Car

)In

Cam

era-

Exp

ert

Haa

- Wils

on d

emon

stra

tive:

-T

able

1 N

umbe

r of

Hos

pita

ls A

ffiia

ted

Tr.

245

8, 5

981-

5983

(P

ub)

DX

0704

5w

ith H

MO

s

Haa

- Wils

on d

emon

stra

tive:

Fiv

eQ

uest

ions

to A

sk B

efor

e A

ccep

ting

Lea

rnin

g A

bout

Dem

and

as a

nD

X07

046

Exo

lana

tion

of th

e Pr

ice

Incr

ease

Tr.

264

4 , 2

648

(In

Car

)H

aa- W

ilson

dem

onst

rativ

e:Evanston and Highland Park 1999

Tr.

264

6, 2

836

, 283

8, 2

839

All

DX

0704

7Pr

ices

(In

Cam

)In

Cam

era-

Exo

ert

Haa

s-W

ilson

dem

onst

rativ

e: T

own

DX

0704

8and Vistnes Quotes

Tr.

247

5, 5

983-

5985

(P

ub)

Haa

s-W

ilson

dem

onst

rativ

e: D

r.B

akers Comments on Learing

Tr.

272

1 (I

n C

ar)

DX

0704

9A

bout

Dem

and

Haa

- Wils

on d

emon

stra

tive:

Perc

enta

ge C

hang

e in

Pri

ce p

erA

llIn

patie

nt C

ase

at E

NH

and

Con

trol

DX

0705

0G

roup

s (S

tate

Dat

a &

Cos

t Rep

orts

)T

r. 2

584-

2585

(In

Car

)C

X06

279-

0 11

In C

arer

a-E

xoer

tH

aas-

Wils

on d

emon

stra

tive:

Num

ber

of S

peci

altie

s in

Top

50

Tr.

270

9 (I

n C

am)

DX

0705

IH

osoi

tals

Haa

- Wils

on b

ook:

Man

aged

Car

ean

d M

onop

oly

Pow

er th

e A

ntitr

ust

Tr.

243

7 (P

ub);

280

1 (I

nD

X07

052

Cha

llenl

!eC

am)

Page 54: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

DX

0705

3R

ESE

RV

ED

Haa

s-W

ilson

dem

onst

rativ

e:E

xam

ple

of M

ultip

le R

egre

ssio

nD

X07

054

Ana

lysi

sT

r. 2

616

, 261

9 (I

n C

am)

DX

0705

5R

ESE

RV

ED

Haa

s-W

ilson

dem

onst

rativ

e: U

se o

fD

X07

056

Mul

tiple

Reg

ress

ion

Ana

lysi

sT

r. 2

619

(In

Cam

)H

aas-

Wils

on d

emon

stra

tive:

Noe

ther

's A

cade

mic

Con

trol

Gro

upA

llD

X07

057

Cas

e M

ix I

ndex

Tr.

269

9 (I

n C

am)

In C

amer

a-E

xper

tH

aa- W

ilson

dem

onst

rativ

e:N

oeth

er's

Aca

dem

ic C

ontr

ol G

roup

All

Dif

fere

nces

in Q

uate

rnar

y Se

rvic

esD

X07

058

Prov

ided

Tr.

270

2 (I

n C

am)

CX

0628

2-00

100

2In

Cam

era-

Exp

ert

DX

0705

9R

ESE

RV

ED

Haa

- Wils

on d

emon

stra

tive:

Noe

ther

's A

cade

mic

Con

trol

Gro

upA

llD

X07

060

Dif

fere

nces

in B

ed S

ize

Tr.

270

8 (I

n C

am)

In C

amer

a-E

xper

tH

as- W

ilson

dem

onst

rativ

e: o

ethe

r'sA

cade

mic

Con

trol

Gro

upA

llD

X07

061

Dif

fere

nces

in T

each

ing

Inte

nsity

Tr.

270

8 (I

n C

am)

In C

amer

a-E

xper

tFi

gure

fro

m B

aker

Exp

ert R

epor

t:B

CB

S Pr

ices

EN

vs.

Com

mun

ityA

llD

X07

062

and

Aca

dem

ic H

ospi

tals

Tr.

272

7-, 3

1 (I

n C

am)

In C

amer

a-E

xper

tB

aker

dem

onst

rativ

e: E

vans

ton

Pric

ing

Prio

r to

Lea

min

g A

bout

DX

0706

3D

eman

dT

r. 4

765

(In

Cam

)B

aker

dem

onst

rativ

e: L

ette

r fr

om

All

DX

0706

4K

lein

to B

rock

Tr.

471

4 (I

n C

am)

In C

amer

a-E

xper

tD

X07

065

RE

SER

VE

DBaker demonstrative: Baker aricle

DX

0706

6on

pro

duct

dif

fere

ntia

tion

Tr.

479

0 (I

n C

am)

Tr.

471

347

15-

4718

Bak

er d

emon

stra

tive:

Bak

er e

xper

t47

2147

33-

4757

(In

All

DX

0706

7re

port

Cam

)In

Cam

era-

Exp

ert

Bak

er d

emon

stra

tive:

Bak

er r

evis

edT

r. 4

739

, 474

4, 4

758

, 478

1A

llD

X07

068

expe

rt r

epor

t48

05- 6

(In

Cam

)In

Cam

era-

Exp

ert

DX

0706

9R

ESE

RV

ED

DX

0707

0B

aker

dem

onst

rativ

e: V

istn

es a

rtic

leT

r. 4

773

, 477

7 (I

n C

am)

DX

0707

1-D

X07

125

RE

SER

VE

DN

oeth

er d

emon

stra

tive:

Noe

ther

DX

0712

6E

xper

t Rep

ort

Tr.

615

1, 6

163

(Pub

)D

X07

127-

DX

0712

9R

ESE

RV

ED

Noether demonstrative: Exhibit 12

RX

1912

- 025

All

DX

0713

0fr

om N

oeth

er E

xper

t Rep

ort

Tr.

616

8 (P

ub)

In C

amer

a-E

xper

t

Page 55: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

DX

0713

1-D

X07

133

RE

SER

VE

DR

oman

o de

mon

stra

tive:

Ris

kD

X07

134

Adi

ustm

ent S

tatis

tics

Tr.

627

5, 6

278-

6280

(P

ub)

In C

amer

a-E

xper

t

Rom

ano

dem

onst

rtiv

e: D

iffe

renc

ebe

twee

n JC

AH

O a

nd A

HR

QT

r. 6

315

, 631

7, 6

353

, 635

5D

X07

135

mea

sure

s of

hea

r at

tack

mor

talit

v...

(In

Cam

)In

Cam

era-

Exp

ert

DX

0713

6-D

X07

137

RE

SER

VE

DR

oman

o de

mon

stra

tive:

Pat

ient

Tr.

628

7 (P

ub);

634

7-63

48A

llD

X07

138

Safety Indicators

6352

, 636

0, 6

369

(In

Cam

)In

Cam

era-

Exp

ert

Rom

ano

dem

onst

rativ

e: T

echn

ical

Tr.

636

1, 6

365

6369

(In

All

DX

0713

9R

evie

wC

am)

In C

amer

a-E

xper

t

Page 56: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

IN T

HE

MA

TT

ER

OF

EV

AN

STO

N N

OR

TH

WE

STE

RN

HE

AL

TH

CA

RE

- D

ocke

t No.

931

5E

XH

IT IN

DE

X O

F J

OIN

T E

XH

mIT

ST

rans

crip

t Cite

at

EX

HIB

ITSu

mm

ary

In C

amer

aDOCUMENT DESCRITION

whi

ch. E

xhib

it is

Related Exhibit

Cam

era

NO

.A

dm,it

ted

Exh

ibit

Ord

erPa

ge(s

)

JX 1

Join

t Stip

ulat

ion

Reg

ardi

ng A

dmis

sibi

lty o

f Tria

l Exh

ibits

Tr.

84

JX 2

Join

t Stip

ulat

ions

Reg

ardi

ng A

dmis

sibi

lty o

f Cer

tain

Doc

umen

ts A

nd D

esia

nate

d D

eDos

ition

Tes

timon

yT

r. 4

200

JX 3

Join

t Stip

ulat

ions

Reg

ardi

ng T

estim

ony

of L

ois

Page 3

Hum

inia

k, P

eaav

Kin

a an

d M

arv

O' B

rien

Tr.

420

0JX 4

Join

t Stip

ulat

ion

Reg

ardi

ng T

estim

ony

of K

im O

gden

Tr.

457

0(R

epla

ced

by J

X 7

)

JX 5

Stip

ulat

ion

Reg

ardi

ng A

dmis

sibi

lty o

f Exh

ibits

CX

0001

8,C

X00

144

, CX

0040

5 an

d C

X01

687

Tr.

626

1JX 6

Stip

ulat

ion

Reg

ardi

ng P

rovi

der

Con

trac

tsT

r. 6

261

JX 7

Am

ende

d Jo

int S

tipul

atio

ns R

egar

ding

Tes

timon

y of

Kim

Oad

enT

r. 6

260

Page 57: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

IN T

HE

MA

TT

ER

OF

EV

AN

STO

N N

OR

TH

WE

STE

RN

HE

AL

TH

CA

R -

Docket No. 9315

Re

. ect

ed E

xhib

its

Transcript Cite

at which Exhibit is

Exh

ibit

NU

lDbe

rDocument Tite

stat

us

Dis

cuss

ed

Tr,

291

9, 3

085-

3086

, 308

8-30

90, 3

199

, 320

0,D

X07

034

Rom

ano

Dat

a D

emon

stra

tive

Off

er o

f Pr

oof

- T

r. 3

235-

3202

3216

3222

3224

3226

3235

Exc

erpt

s fr

om E

xper

t Rep

ort o

f D

r, J

onat

han

B. B

aker

:A

dmitt

ed fo

r im

peac

hmen

t pur

oses

onl

yR

X20

38Paragraphs 16, 5

6-, 6

6(O

rder

ed 5

/10/

05)

Tr,

471

5-, 4

727-

34 (

as p

ar o

fDX

706

7)E

xcer

pts

from

Sup

plem

enta

l Exp

ert R

epor

t of

Dr.

Adm

itted

for

impe

achm

ent p

urpo

ses

only

RX

2039

Jonathan B, Baker: Paragraphs 16

56-

(Ord

ered

5/1

0/0

5)T

ames

1 m

roug

h 4

fiom

Sup

plem

enta

l Exp

ert R

epor

tof

Dr.

Jon

atha

n B

, Bak

er r

e C

hang

es in

EN

H's

Pric

eA

dmitt

ed f

or im

peac

hmen

t pur

pose

s on

lyT

r. 4

739-

47; 4

758-

, 478

1-, 4

800,

480

5-R

X20

40Pr

e vs

. Pos

t Mer

ger

(Ord

ered

5/1

0/05

)48

1448

20- 2

1 (a

s pa

r of

DX

706

8)Fi

gue

5 -

Pred

icte

d In

patie

nt P

rice

s fo

r O

vera

ll E

NH

Adm

itted

for

Impe

achm

ent p

uros

es o

nly

RX

2041

vs. C

omm

unity

and

Aca

dem

ic H

ospi

tals

(Ord

ered

5/1

0/05

)

Page 58: COMPLAINT COUNSEL' PURSUANT TO RULE 3.46(c)€¦ · Highland Park, Ilinois Tr. 4882 - 4924 3/23/2005 Chan, Theresa Administrator of Physician Children s Memorial Hospital Tr. 647

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I hereby certifY that on May 20 2005 , I caused copies of the Complaint Counsel's Exhibit Indexto be served on the following persons by electronic mail and first class mail delivery:

Michael L. SibarumWISTON & STRAWN, LLP1400 L Street, NWWashington, DC 20005

Duane M. KelleyWISTON & STRAWN, LLP35 West Wacker DriveChicago, IL 60601-9703

Charles B. KleinWISTON & STRAWN, LLP1400 L Street, NWWashigton, DC 20005

and the delivery ofthree copies and an electronic version to:

The Honorable Stephen J. McGuireFederal Trade Commission600 Pennsylvana AvenueRoom 113Washigton, DC 20580

J.() (0 5(1

Chul PakComplaint Counsel

Date