declassified under authority of the … · docid: 2959299 ref id:a2666693~ declassified under...
TRANSCRIPT
DOCID: 2959299 REF ID:A2666693~
DECLASSIFIED UNDER AUTHORITY OF THE INTERGENCY SECURITY CLASSIFICATION APPEALS PANEL, E.0.12958, AS AMENDED, SECTION 5.3(b)(3)
ISCAP NO. '1-00 'i- 00 s--
? Cl_A,Q 0
-- - - - - -- - ·-- - - - - - -
~. A s.er- l - B I ~ ::L.t.
f.<1)1;7
t ,. \.
~ I i -;.,
;-
. _, j ,
r '·~
I
I!· " ;._, (
~ .,_
/, ·.J
--' -
.· . .
I I
•' ~
'. _,.,. ... ~-
' ': '
...
~
"'
, . . ' -___ ., .... r_
ID:A2666693 :_ ~:.:-~-~ -J '
~,,.-\ ~"#>f' .. 1' "' \
!CAL O~ llINtlTES • c I TJ.s': T'l '.
CO.Pr N0.57
\
' ' '
TOP. SECRfi~· .. 5 ·,
,,
'•
_,
r!.. •
v<)
, .... ' \ "' ' ,. J - .......... -~ -- ~..3..-.JA- '----- ....... - ... f
DOCID: 2959299 REF ID:A2666693
\ ....... • l
-,llA-f 7
/"?. I /o .. '7 o.._
--~w ~
;'
}' ,g J 8 B 1'f fl . /'
!!.rig.~ y.P.~
t' .• t ••
' -
'· !he CbaU'lllll7 tho~ oln.sud ~ ~& at thti u.s. -Br1 ti.sh OoRliiii!o&hon rnhll.l.zenoe Jgreerient both 1n e"»W'iJ!g ooopen.Uc~ in tre s~ ,qint r1~1a ar'. lo. lts !Uod lr oei:ientJ.~ ~ .rel11.t10DJ bot;i,;J~"J
the bo cantrl.e.s ~r lly
TM OhalritM u..im-ed ~ U.S.. Del.egatoa thltt t')e Lou'lon Stgl."lt Board woul.datilltU.,a ao Jts utzw&1. to 0"1"l'3' oat tho lett:u- and ap"ti~ ~ tba .Jere~. I"' rLihllia ahaulf !n:uinrl:antJ,r ~ he bcped tl'>at m'AIVIB would acl, heo1ta~OJ to po1nt tbe:!I out tme\U&te.l;J to th& T .o ndon Sigi nt :&.>ti.rd ei. t.e oou'\ l u <1 UI'C' tte U, s. d<ot lef)!. tlo~ wt th!iy W? ,, t'I bo umnt'lmeci and th... eirl ier ~ • ere poit:tell out t.a.e be!i.ei..
4. Be so.l cl tha' ~ :;oht;) £0Vel"'1na tM oooperc1.tic..n o! t1e tr oo\lr\trlea 1n tho fi.e' l ~ C<rmt>.1loa.t1on InV-llice~ hs.d i..e~n settled by the ~'"-" ani! '•l • t tr• pi ~oer.t Co'>fe.c'l:lnoe ~ thcrt.!!' .ire cr.tl.rol, 1.4uhru.cal 1n l. t.e ob .. •• r J
.5. lta tin. .. tl::iJe< .. llu iu 1npt=nt tra .Agreew.nt, "" b-'lJ t... o nsure that be th s1!f. .s o1; t 1.t n ii 1he :O"T1 :llUll ?'ll sLl. ts trail the 11 .,,, ·.l.41> 1 ~
/peaooe ttn.r.. ••••
RLvrz::; .. - - • - .___ _J .' ,;. ' .. , '--=· ....... ~- . . ...
E.O. 12958, as amended Section'"' '"'(b)l (
-'··1
' b)(3), and (b)(6)
DOCID: 2959299 REF ID:A2666693
11 Ee ne.Lt 11XJnt1o:i.:d the Seo•.!rl. t;y question and stated that STArom was fcll.y 8'l'"8.re of 1 ta ovettid1J18 l.lllJOrtance. • .f
12. ~'t.1! 11'~~.i: r.' • .:!ua thz_, Gc?-... rel c~. u t'"~ ~...l. r:<f the U.S. DcJ.ega~ic::. hcf• :- :.J.y G.ll'<'U&:i:;rl tho po.t..n~ <)!" V'"l'"f Ct! the U.S. lla:v W1o f't:lt tha'.: ~ i;:....., r;~".&oi'l1non with ti.e llr!t.1.si; ~~en ~Cll'ul &ild 'b~"ioi~ ~:: ;.ioth t>llrtt'}l!.
1). 'l'h~ Cha"L!"lll.Ul su1'Ported Ger:c:al Corde='• renark51 sb.,.,~oiog on again the impor'&liie of oarrn.ni.oat1c11S, and suggeated that "' ~a G-=i~Al Oordorma.n ahoul.4 di.souse ontaln Securit;r points aeparateJ..y at a later da-r;eb
14-. Th3 OhD.irl'ia.n t~n in-n.ted Gooori.J. Coraer.<AA to be the Chaixmc.a ;f the Ooofeni!lQl!l, Gm1eral Cordon:ian .s.;1d i.,, l!lUCh appreoiated tr~ honol.lI' l.fforaed to hUD aM. the u. s. De~g.;:i;ic.n by the 11uggestl.on. mr. ha felt tb&.t a. Bri tieh Chair:nan would oo more ir11 tab" e, as he would be mvre 1'$11 'ti..1r w:i. th 'l'lhatevel· pi ucc..dure miuld be adopwc1 for the" Con!'erenoe. He //'Ot..J d UlerefoM prefer to de~Hne the offor. The C'hai.J'T:l:!Ul therefore sugg'l:it"!J that C'aptal P lia=hllda ahould taM the Chair a.od t.tlll \l'8.ll seconded by ~nora1 Cord<Jm:m
15. ~ Travi:i a•.iggested thaL the next inee~~ should tNr;e plc.oe at 101.5 on Tuesdey1 12th l!aroh, I.lid thu WIUI e,greed.
16. Th_, 0~1 in OQllClUBiOn. 11e.1.d that he ~ CIQnflndent that & grea-' dea.1 w1.li.c;-aa-o0irij?fuh.ed 1.D. tM norl fortnight a.nd that the oo"lf'erc!l.Oe would
Jllarlt rui imprutant milenor.e tr.. Sigi.n, collaboration b<:lt!leen the two countruo.
- I
DOCID: 2959299 REF ID:A2666693
,·,/,~.· :' • ' j
'.
PRES E ?1 '1'1
' ' ' ~ -, . co--OPl'n-G OF ME:.-lIBRS 'fO ~ CC!l!:ll'TEE ARD TO SUB-COC!IT1'EE3.
'c ;z,t::- Edward ~a v:b lllJ88CS tea tha.t tho Exeout.1 ve Qo=l. ttec anJ the"6u~ittees ehO'il!d bo r~ to Oo~opt a.ddJ.hOJlal. ~O:nl e.a needed. This 1Va3 agree(4
I
,' ;r -~ 'T ( • i _ ~ SUB CMITTTB3 "A•1 '--
4<> The :rtembert.lnp and Agenda "2'e agreoli &3 presented.
SUB COMYJ.'nEC "B ~.
5o Genore.1 Corderlll3l'1. ~ationed the een.se at i tom 2 or tlie ,. .Aeenda and after eo.mo diieu3sion U was agreed ~ a:nend this ~ reaas ''
• (2)
' ·l
~
\0 '.__./
~
..0 '.__./
-0 r
-0 8 Q) ~
"d (r') i::::: '.__./
Q) ~
§ ..0 '.__./
ifJ -clj ~ ..0
~ '.__./
00 (r') If)
f<'1 °' 01 i::::: 0 ·-0 +-' (.) Q)
r.r..1 VJ
DOCID: 2959299 ,., REF ID:A2666693 ..
. ... ...... ~ ....
,I
1 ;
' .. - 2--
SUB CO!Jl!'ZT!Z "g~ , '
6o ~'1£'1"tl c~ requested that )la~r Stone bo ndded to t.'ie po:.ina"lent I?ei!lbe.rehi:p of th~ Sub- (lalillitteo and this wu agreell.
7~ Cll th¢ aasat.:9tion tl1at exehan~a to be considered. by tha St•b-Oonru ttc" mr" te;chnice.l onl.71 Captain Sllledbcr• asked to '!» reka3ed fr'Q!:l ~.:uanent ~erehip.. Jil,e uawaption '1138 cc:rfirmd and his ~Ci.lCl'lt c.ere~. Captaip Coo<bliI- u.'!Oertook to ensure 1.he.t • he be called in 11mn llOQ0&>6at'J'o ~ ~
,. !r ~ i l
SUB Co.tll?'!Er "D".
9o 'r~ Ylmberab.lp 1i8.e ~a, 1U1 preaented,
10.. 'fhe natl.TCC and ~nC:. cf tm.s Sub Ca1111u:l.tce1 boviever1 e7:lk:ld ~rp-J. d)SCU3::iior., 'fhc acme of pare. 2 of the J.gend& .-.a questioned. by Y.r HoC:.d1CEon, e."\d e:ter SClll!e e~ of Vien 1t mus agreed t..lat e.ll dl.eseadne.'o1on problesu '101.l.d be coverod by itOlil 1, pronded t.ae pbraseol')gy of tnis 1tel!l wae suitabl,r obtm£0l. Itett l. wa11 tbere:to1~
charged to rea.41
"X3~bl::;.shma:rt at ,JOlnt u. s. - Jl'f'1tiah Seot.ri ty Pr::.no1;pJes, •
l'..etl 2 'IE.?. then delo~do
. ...
DOCID:
-. ,-
2959299 ,.
' . I ,
REF ID:A2666693 1lgj1'
.. , ...
t • - \" .... -'
• • • • ll30 • •
DOCID:
·':~··:f;;,>(, . ·.·:·~-~/i-~·,.
· ._·_·:~ j:~{:.:_;Y4i--~;>
}.~,._' .. · -,-;\_.;x .. · . .-~ .... ,.._: ·- '-"~;;; ?J~.
2959299 ,. f
REF ID:A266669~
· ;;na.tr"llll!.n of EXi:iouti~ Coor.iHte.,,, Ch.t.i nnll.Jl1 Sub-Comrni ttes A. ·
" .• :£l,.
. .
,. c. D,
. "· ..E;, .' E.>c!-cutive C~ttee,
___. .. _____ ..:._ ______ .
• t L . __ y --'· ...
L .. · Atu:6h~d~ 1 :i th<!> ~1h.~· ~~~~~nt :J ·ttw ·~~rship ~f foe . F.xcr-utive .C0mll1 t+.e" eJid of the Wmibersbip an<l Agenda of tll:i Su~, Coum:l. t-~i'e, ~eu:i. tir.g '{'r(:m t.hie iim-iling•e .. iil<'ri!l?'Y ir."'"-ir.g ··· '.~
2 .' ": _}1ei2~ •... ·. : . <;,_Y>'i;_'~·¥~?f ~'.·;~::·':.\·'.:: 0,;i, :V}(:>.i :_, .. . . . . . .. . (_; OOl!llllit/~tro;ren·t<.> t~&~~ns1~1c.lsona:_uo~d ·~ evnsa_;~~~ bJ · ~'.'/ul-;•
~~?;,.': S"£ ~::;;'::~~r> :· ".· ;,,_ · wbjeQt e:oo:i~= ~~. ~i-at: :~~rt :~ o;e=~e1J~~~ ~- E~~u!:i'~ · .
· T• ·:tP,l~:~~'.;.a,,;;.i,~~f?h~~~~~~~~i.,;,~;.~:~~~;.;;~ ;~::~;~.:··}:.i~.L1; :~-.. 't~'" ~" ·'·.; ·.-;: <:;~ '("; :u ~ .. ; • "ReqUi~nte_ re~il.1,i,g 'l!ct~;;ia.Uci; _of, ,~enplJi~ "~ . ;:-p~--:.~ "" . :,.,
·.·.~· .,,..,,~,,...1.' .:~~-,,;:>';Y::~;;f~;.~ ;r,~,,; ', ;· ~-.t~'':.:.:;,· procedure ehoU.ld l:ic- ,.tionsi~* 'hf' ·each '8i.1b-~.tt~c in oonn.'Jo"t;l,oP.. ll'l:tr' ... : '
\,l{~t(f c;~~;:t~;z, ~1-~~-~,·_;_-.~.-.f~~:_:_1L,~_'_~_··~-;~.<.:_"~_:,_t:;.;°?!·:···'.,··~ .. -· ... ·.'..:.:.f~_.:.:.·~.·.·. =·,o··_;~··.·-.·~.·-·.·~-~n-••.. ·.··.t.·.·• .. ··c4······.· ... ·.·'t.··.~.::.~.· ..... ·.~·::.·~.,tv•._·1 ••. _· ..• ·.~.:.•.~.-~ __ ··.~o·_·.·.-.·_·,·'.··=·~·-.~'-·l'l. .. •~.~ .. ~··.-.·~.:.} ....•. , .. ·.:.~t .. c.·~"··.··-··v'.:_·.·.··.8·~t.·.~·-.·~:·-~.-~'::1.~:l•1·.·~-~ .. · ... -.·~~.i.&,.f.·.:.·.:•'.:.~ .• ~.::_:~_ .. •.·.·.·.r.'.J\ld~r~.u.·,.,.·,·~.:...-.·.·_;:····~.'.-~.'.;·;;~".\.'.'_ ... . l~ff:;f~;- •·#if4;~'<i :~.- . •. ~ ··- .. ,~ .. :;. ...; ~::. , " - ·- ' ···, . ,,/:..
· ::~~"; · ''~T ... l'~~l~i[~i1Ji',.. ·• [~~~ia~~~~~~:t~~tf ~~ . ,_., ·- · '·· '" ...• : ,• «~·"':~s:.'''.\ J ... · ··before hat~d:lng 1.r.. tc ~ ~ter-le3 _of th(; -~._1;:tj.V!I c~-1=~tt(·~,' t>
• ., · .,,_ ,,. ~ ..• ,.. ••• 1 • oepies e.hculd ~ ~~d :i.ri.' · · · . · . . '
);".
. . . .' ~ ~~' ; '.
.... . . :;:,,
5, . 'O'li~n i'W 1 ~ m!t;!I~ «::s.n.'1Dt b:> pr.;;~'l.Z'% in t-.i..::·::, e. l.-r'), ~f l'.>l~,g7"' ~.;
. l·=ip6n: 6:1:.ouk. be s ub::rd tted .. · •· · ·
6.:- 1n acld:!.t-..:ou to th~· ~c~ve·:l.l1~en .... ~\.il\-~port.21, a fJ..11~.:.~ .. -::·.>:~·:~r-: '"-' ·;P.
req-.U1·"~ ~ea.cl, sub-:!Ol:Slitteo. B':!.'1:>~. ~-ro:!.;a fzorn ·•<.:b-·:·:~«'•:'·-.-..'c
should be f~a aij r!,c=.<1lld;i.ticns ti:; :th;: E;•~,wt~.v~ ~c:::1H1·e~ 11' '' ::l, a foiir tr.at tl:eycan be inc:tue1:.-d ·I!,('· ~e-l er::p':'nC.4.:::~.o -tc th~· ::r, s Eri ti;'lj,1 Ccm-a-..u:io!'.tiorui Intelli..g0:-.°" e.gr~i."!!:'-'nt. S11b--oc:;iJ'1 tte: o! ~br.;J.u <1.
al'-'o forn-aro if ne:l!:!asa.7, .rep:Mis coo;sr.!..nz ni•.:r :sub,'J.::~r~:;i c~ 1.heir. ·. A&!>llil.D 'Niu® Jl<'.~o f!p!<:i.&.l oa,;r.i~~.~.:~e>r.. by ei tl1e:~· S'.i'Jl;c'I.."'3 Ot" the Lrn:'.'.cn Sictnt lk31.rd C>ut l\"lJ!t;>:h ,..,,t.J.d I'O~ 'te- a•.:.t.t:.1ne- 1).$ ~c.e::;ii·.>;,~s tc t~ · Ar,:re "-!'le••-!: 0 • . • • - .
.--... ..... __,..._ .........
DOCID: 2959299
·,
... •. ~: ..
·-.
.·. :-
:-~ ·> \ ~·- - .
·-: ') .. -
,;/ ..
REF ID:A2666693
I
-•
;!!· ..
. :·c ···.·~ '. ·;);}h:·~·•'J~\·.' .,•,·-,; -:\~ ... ··~;·
.. '.~~~:ri;~.'.~~l'~~t.: • .'L.';;;;;, ~ ·---------- ·' .. ,
f';' .r._ :, • .._.,
:E X i b' ~- T I ~ (·<9~~};':~;;~J,~ ?a:~~~,~i:'.:: . :,,._ i·_.) ~·--~·-:..
<:, .·_.··1i~~~;~,~-." ._;:.~~~4;.'.-::~:~y~.: :.~;~:Q
,._. .·.,_ ...
E.O. 12958, as amended
.. -~·- · .
..•.,.·
\
Section 3.3(b)l, (b)(3), and (b)(6)
. :.:·.~~~---~~:\.~:.:~~\~·{ ~ .-·:i.<~::~~·;.':·:·:.;.\ :·;:.~~~~.
, :J :1 r ~. ·: ·.i. .
:•·.>
::.-· ~. : :~.- ..
DOCID:
·~ J;-1-1'!~ "1-r. :!f., ,'
~ ._: t:" '" ' '. 4l
~~~t~ ~ ~ ... }_ ./' ~ r
2959299 REF ID:A2666693 .,. ....
·-
, -{QQLl.EC'l'lor. A-'lt EX~ Cf RAW ~<.:!U}J, Af!P CQ-{lf'ERATI<F IN fRil.F'F:CG
. ·, • :@iii$%§.) - < - "
,. ., ,
E.0. 12958, as amended ·. Section 3.3(b)1, (b )(3), and (b )( 6)
5c .Exchs.ng_, of report.J1freql:bix:y :u:formanon &.nd ~ Search ;r,,au.l:ta. •
Stel1de.rdieation ot trequen:y Mt.a\10!!. eystem end cL other proceaarea. _,
" - ' '
8., Stanchrdieation or lll!.w J.Uteru.l !'onl6.t..
•
I' ---~ -,_
;,.
-DOCID~ 2959299
~"-;J0.7'o_~-, !
.;);-
-:;:~
«~.:;::_~ .. ,
·: .::t·:.··~\~0:. ·-..--{
r -_.>-J:·' ··r->- '.:_"L~-·
-·~ \.
>!"'
'·· {.,
"' '
t •' ~
i: f' f, ..
' t
REF ID:A2666693
.t •'
-• ..i~ - ,_·~, .,Y~':. ._·
:~.~ti"'.~~-: ~~~; -~·:,_'.~ -~· °'.
E.0. 12958, as amended Section 3 .3(b) l, (b )(3 ), and (b )( 6)
• • • 'l,. l"-t ... :.; . . .. "" ·... ,. . . . . .,,. . . '
~ ~· ...... :.;~ ·.:~ ~ . \
--:"-
··. ·~! , . . ~:·- ~· ··:-=
·_. '.!
,;
DOCID:
~.. .: , .. T ~I ~'
·' ... , -~·-~
.. :
. -~ ~
;.,~
<:· :- , .. ,
2959299
·'
( I
l 'f:· >
I ,,
· .. :-:
REF ID:A2666693~
.. ·. •. --;' ':
..· .. ~;_ .... · ...... ·>.: ,':·· . '~~ >~ . ·.' ·'""' ~ .....
·wer SE~ ~~Ai·>"•:•:'.r-> ...... -_ :\ .-~~f .. ? .. :·r. ;::·_~· ~~.".:.~ ... ~ ... :_-~; ...
1::·· SU;~ CQifr..rr~·rIIB c>
: .. !
. ' Standardiaa t:!.on of . Trans la ti OP!h
··,.: ..•..
".,~-~~~ of Oollate~l Materiel.',
c'•
,.··
. ..,..; _~ ,..;
.·;·
.DOCID: 2959299
"_· ..
. f ,!JJ .
REF •"( .
~fa~i1: .... .. , -~:·:· :r:~ ·:·k·'
ID:A266669~
.·.·.:.··
····:.::.· /': .... ;~;-;)'-.·; '. ;' ,' Jtir :· Hnaale a'oi:i; , -.... ', . .
·.• .. ·,'
.... ;'."• .,
.,· .. .--:..-:.: .• ;: ...
·..:.·.'.:
... -~-r f
•'···
DOCID:
i~~~" . ···-. :·.: . . ,
!;.·
; ~--
·~- . -."1•_:
:--.
2959299 REF ~D ;_.:A2 6 6 6 6 9 ~
-~_-;J' \~·, ' ··:i r;,• ·• :· •.
1. ··~~~~~A;t'.';:-,: ·.
;, :-·
- SW, C:)Mlfl1'l'EB ]~. -~:.Jt·-.--.----
-..... r''11;
''·. ·~:>;;_;/ .. ·. -~· _'.;; ·.-:-
• ,'.:·;_~:l.rnan.!,' ~: ·' · .. ",';\' ·, ..
<~~~:. ___ ; :--.~~-,·. -·..:·· '·•·. ~--· . . -.. · .~,_.": -.'}"--.~.;,,._:-····~.· .• •· .•. ·-, ... ··.·.:.· ..... ··.1·.i ...
- ... : ;,.. ....... ~-.-_?_ ... _r.~.~!-.·.-... -... ·.: , - ... . .. ............ ::,"'.'.If:
i·.'·'i_.
... ;.> }
._;: __ 1·>~:';/: / ' . .'.::~:·':, ~\·.- •·:.
.. !··:·
.. : ;~
't ..
'.,:
. -· ..... -~r;_ .. {
J ... ··'· ·. ,._.
·r. ~: .. >"
t ·.-.7
.. ·:. . ~ .
. ~ -..
~ .. - . ·, :··
··_:.
-·
. '." .. ~ ..
·:: . . ·
" . '
DOCID: 2959299
(''
·~:.•.:..-"'"'" .. f
·. \ ~ . · .....
REF
.>I>:· r~~.
.J . 4•. ~·Captain Weter asked m?ether the Camnitte~ _should eet a ~t data. ) . f'or tlhe .eDd Of coiit'erenco. - . . .
: r '. :;3·,~}ii'ter ~-ane a1.a~a1on~, l t \TBS' agl'eed 'to dtScWis th1~ matter :further ' ... ·, on Pr',483, but meamihUe to consider :that rougbly two we~ke wcULd be taken.
·. :?:~_~ .. ~:~}}.~:·~/.:~.:>_:(··<~=:- ....... -. ~,-... ·.·- ·~·· ··- ·-: ·; .. ,~:.<.:· t': _:. :.;:·· _::_:;:' ... ' • ·.: :· . .. ;· ..... -: .":· .... ·:;·~·· 'o·Ly': Fonna.t.cf Reports f'rom Sub- Ccrmnittees. · ' ·
6. . · It 'liaD &¢:!'.ed thot tt.nal .reports ftom the eub-ooiMi1 ttees should· be. in the form of reoooii'endat1ons to the Executive ecmntttoe whiah shculd be eo _dratted 118 to be oaa111 tronat'oxmed into. e.ppentltocru to th~ bas1o Agl'.:!ell!l3nt.
7. · Sir Ell.rrarit Travis pointed out that not ell tho rcaUl ta of the . Maousdons woiiid ncicioesar1ly be su1 table tor irDlU!llon in the baslo
Agreement aa Appendicet:i and that1 ln aey case, he would 11.ke to ban a · roport dr4wn up tor tho c ons1.derat1on of' the! Londoll Siglnt Board epart fl'all ao,y Jppe_mioea that lfttro written.
. '
DOCID: 2959299 ~ .. · -:-1 .-.··
.REF ID:A2666693 ~. :.·• ;:. .• ,r.' ·.~. \
I
....
. .... ···1"· .··"'·'.
. ... . .'
• r . '
I .~. ·.·•
... ,;
DOCID: 2959299
'"·-~. : .. · .. . .
.. ·".\
E.O. 12958, as amended
:.
Section 3.3(b)l, (b)(3), and (b)(6)
~~ \ .. ~ ~p~;) ~~: ~~i~. ... . . ""~~- .. "<'. .. --~F
-,~·--.·
??---
·.-.
REF ID:A2666693~ '
.EXECUT!V'E ,. ....._ .. ·cm~ -~· .
. , ... :r ,~. ,. • . ._, f .}·!
l? R :!!'. S E H T: ---
C~tiin WoiJicJ;. : · ' .· ' . · p.o.pt~D Blood~. . ·, .r:~= . i . .
. i. • .
~ C~airnwn ..-el~a Ur~ C~X'll!IUI.
2, ~:Co ca.e.tnillUl then t&.bl«td. th~ mnli.to&; ~ t!1e ·r.Lr&t Exocuti"ro Ji: . lioeting cn.~r;pc:D.:.-.. ·rdfii~l3ion. ,:/Ji!
. . Sir ~ ~!!!. :wt th ~erenoe to pllr.l.~ 7. aalred that the · i1 i:hrue "and S-l'-4.l'lC~CWietcd, ~has btt aid not 1n~lldel STA!rolB ~f{I
~1~: ~8!:1 ~\~ae!:onrlw1=~0 apo~f_o~ tOO u.s. on thi~ ;!t1 (~re was \llcn 11ar..e d1r.our;:;1on ~ _to the_ d1otnbutJ.on of __ '1 __ .
11pprovod m:l.nutss ~ Sub~ tteos; !~!ect! to ot:;;ow.t.te th= tc . . -~ •ll Oba.1U!ml)0 . . .
. . : . / .
'nle M'l.nutoa ~! tile Ffrs·~ EUJ<:.'>Jtfr,, Car.Zili t!oo 111.0oting '11'>?'fl tbo:r.: ~•:ssea v.l.thci~t tl.u-thc-r IX>dl.?:tca.t;. '}:lo
3. The Ch:drmo.n ~n object~d t" tbtJ slwrt 1ti~e..1-.cl ht'.'i'¢J}l'! t!r.' reo"1pt at SuC--Co!i::zlittee mir.;utes &nd ~ Jll)rl toUOll:l.n8 ;:s3tpi.g ot th£EJtt;o..:Uw Com:a. tb!ll. ~ ir.~erre'i. c.n this pa.rl1C\ll.a:.:' aq, t':i:r.m noon to 1300, wu <ogethor too br.'.cd lll'l'l bad p1·evolltod t. proper reading a.r.i\ mider•t~ 'by the mi.!'..1-'>cn: t4 t.'r? :&:.:.~outive Crumit~.
i/
(/It l1M •• .••
' ·~ ,.,,_ \ )· . . : ,.
·;:·" '··:-:.
... . .. ,,..
DOCID:
• . "r .. - '~ ..
2959299 REF ID:A2666693~
r
2
'-.,-
.-·,·. -1.
..:'. . .;.:-
4 • With ti:.e concurrence· of ,.·ii the ~re,· the Cll.Urzne.n them ~ to rciad cn.t the m1rrutes of the Firri ~ting of Sub-Co;1t-.2Htee Jl,
J' ,._. '.'. -: -.. ;.- '~ ... · .:.-._. .' ·, ·, · .': .</,-~· .::.;·.::~',;..~~~· ... i."j.t.~r.~.'·~::i.i~~~.i~-;-~~~·~~·\t.",: ;~i .. -··:~t t . .· . . Ge?l()n.\ cliccua::iion broke out oier tho sUbleot d ~vernaaoa, ·; ... i .. 1 ·with Sir E&mrd Travis etating tlui.t adOptioo'of th~ ~te4 U.S. ~ioD . ciovc~D ll'OUid rllBlte °many dit'i:'loultiol) both:nthiii hie organiz(ltion and. · t~ ··11 "J·;·
;, ·~t; :. ;~ 4 '. ·~ .. t1. . __ ._-;:~ii __ . .;• ··.···>.,j.:·ti:. .. _.,. .. ,._-_
. ~ !t'.
~',·· '',~?' ~
i'
7"' w~~,._, J > ,,.~~~·~ ~ • t ~ -·-~ ' ~"M :~ ~'
\_ '··
· ·;!··~·r;~;;:·,b,t;: ~l.: .. ~'fo'.:;~1~~~t:~~~~: ~l.;i!~*t:;~~~;:~c= l~~:::~~£~ ... . . . . , . ..... .,._r_._. " .... a "'-1 w . , ·iJ<.-'"'· .... ~.-;_,_,, '•' .. - .,, .•. - ":" ' ..... - -- .. ·=·-- . . -. ·.: · ·/:' .. ~w.-~wD,,&."Q. a.uu. ap \tU. n engor. . r.:ry "'"·-"~, ..... ,. ~ "'"".: ... , ·, ~ - .... ~ • •• • ... • ~-
'.£;;:::~-2::;r~ ~?l ·: .. -~~·i;;~~fi:~~4~;~,~ ~oumea -~~~~~~=~~t1;{~-~t;,;hr'-'.~u~~troe -. · ;_f · <..-.:;, · , • · ~'13. :·.T~'.was ISCllle ~..lderniont expres~ over:-thO ~ ·o:r.oorhin
~· -:·· ~'·.~&,_ ·eapooially ~ .. ·2 ~.~•·:·.It Yu··.sre;a to doleto tho phr~..sc
~,,_\·.·._ .. _'··;'.l· ·.::··· . :.
.·:-~
•g:NQp of oyatomaft t:rte para. 4, •inae the semic ~- ~ phrase was 1mpo15$1ble to define. · ,_;. : ' :
,,_f ,',;:;;. . ... . ·-::;·: ·-.·:).~. '{:_·_\·:'.. r' ~--·
!). Crci;s-refore:acas to the ti.s. 'dni.ft ~ndi~s :,~; ~on turnecl attention Grey trco the Su~Ol!illi"tteo ll mim.-tos to th~ dra!'t /iiipel"..clioeo thealcelvc:i~ .&nd the qt.Wst·l.on lr:a raised u to .-~tbor the .dra.t't .Appendices ahoW.a be tabled. 'l".ai.s produoecl. ge:DG..-li a18Cll8aion. Sir El!mm1 ·p01nt0ii '
.. · ·,·.~~ . ·~ ......
0';.1t t!lat, ill tM f'init place, thc· l!r;\t;~~-_ro at the Executive Collllai.ttco had net had tim>I to stud;r ti:ie/AP'ftfil'di()(ls, .and ho_thora1'oro d1d
. ' . DOt at w·a point tdW to ~e twked ~or opiv.10Jl8 b:alJ$d '.Uj>O?I. the!:!. . . .• G<!iWrsl Cor&nNm et.r~a116d tile.t the l!!;i;eout1ve C~tteo Shoul.d not bo ro~rod to~ ~--~ thai ·;;_,""~ at tb:\s st~', and thAt it was ~he 0.11.ty or the Sub-oeon:ai UC$:> to ,r.ick,!) cl oar 11ta.tei::10nta as to 1ihothez- they
·.·'-N . -~
. ]
:l
wa:i:o f"ounii suit:ible or wei~ not so found} ocl.1 tbo:>~ uhioh·werc cont1·3:.. VG1'8illl llhould bo brougl4~ b!D1'ore tho Executive COllllli"® for '1"1>difiea-Uon, and tho modit1c4t1ons ahocld be embodied ii:: tho Sub--C'cxmitteeG' fin!i.l ro~n&t.!.ons •
~CMim<lll then dircot"d the 5ocrotcnoc: to itlctrue:O th' Sub~ COilallittoo• t elaborate oros3-reforone:n1 1n 1-tor1m 1'8,J>Orts to the· U,S,d-r:aN Jilpendieea woWA_.~ lCaBOl:' b~ aeoepteble to the Exi;eutiTe c~tteoo In
. the Jlle&mlbilCI, WoiAppend.1.oeia 'll'ill be _used onl7 by the S\lb--CQl!lfili ttoes a,!;
A guide tonr4 their filllll re00111110I1d.at2.on9. • · ·
.:.=::_.
:.:·
DOCID: 2959299
· ... ''l- .-
·'·,,-
.·, ..
- 'j..
'• ,_ .... ~
. . . ~:
., -
REF ID:A2666693 e
- 3 -
6.
. ·. ' _: .· . :
•. .· . . C11.ptlf\in Wo~r ad4ed the Objection· that t~ro 'lrOUld be tco Jlll1'lb tor thO E4ocutivo Ccr;m1tte1:1 tci aocasplla:h iR th.a vor,f b.:it ckys and too l1 tUe in tho •ui.ntllle. ·
·. ".;' . . ·:. . . -· ~ . . . ...• . ·.:. ~ --.---:··.:;.;\:/~~:;;. !,·:_;_~ .·.. .. . •
. ' Sir ECl:nu"d &1110 concurrod, cd etated tba.t it WllS tho duty of tho Executive Ccrnl.ttee to holp the SU'IJCO!i:raitt~11 .all along the l13.>,
It ~ t1uall;t: .a.~ed-tha.t tho ·.~ •. s.dratt >.ppenM.ces <m:1~.-'l;o .be :regc 8.ll A b&Q.11 tor dillOWSdOll ;ihc S~ ttooa, and tha.t t!ley JlOed net be consl&rr.lby tho Executho Cc:mQttee until- ouch t:lJr;o ao ·'they ap~ 1n tho tom of f1D'Al SubCc=ittee 1'000!llDICndation&,
8. . Foll~ng thiii, the Chairman read the i:dnutes cr Sub--Co:aui:tt')<J D, ll'biah "WOre approved without d1S<JU11Slon, · _
9o '5$ th.on began to read tho :mi~toe ct Sub-CO!llilittee E. . Sir E<ht:i.rd a.wd thAt para. 3, paa;e 21 11'hich mlgflt be ·JDisuniterstcYA by
. tho Adm1.r&l ty, be deleted. ' !hi.11 'tf0.8 ~od. Geoaral Cordemo.n 0'1:11ervod. that the t1gur1111 in pua. 6fliT9ere prcbl.Y too hig!i, and it was a~~ ~ cut the tota1 a.o.n ~ 100;6oo. . _; · ·. · .
I 9 • tJ.~ 0
·,,
DOCID: 2959299 REF ID:A2666693~
~ ~~~¥.~! .. ;~~.~~:; .. ~}·' ~~::. · ... · - -... _·,·.
· .. ·--.. ~ .•. L,<_· .• "',' .• -· .... ' - -- ''. -t.
;i - I+. ..
.;_ .. ~~r~~~ , -- · ,, _ 4::- 'c · :;; 10. fil.r Edwtlrd. oponod di~cus:don OJ< U.e quest1011 cf whether the
· toccmri:i:aaabo:c.s--en&.cccd to the 1111nutos ~ s~ ttoe B wen to be ', .~;,.),;;:z .:; ' cven~y embodied in ~ J\Ppend1%; he poiJl~ out til&t tho ehamiol•
~~~.·~ · ·· ?2~~tsF:T=:ErEt~:::~~?.::::!~?t,7D8 <:i".r ) ·- ... . .. a::a otho?',.auoll ,nri&blcs. '.The JQor1CAJ1-,Gelcga7ca demurToa, fcel.1118 · - ·
. '. ,,·. tho.1; adequate COilllllUii1oation11 V$X"e bulo to tho tuture esr STAroIB - GCCS •• ! i ~> '.' {.: rolationnhips;. a.no., as . suoh, shOuUl bo. 'epeo1t"ic8ll7 W1 tten into·~ tlMl.
·~~~;~r:_~·:·i:'·i;,~~·~k;~;~~-:~,_-~:::.i:'.:}~:}:: .< :_<, ~A·\lt~ h~·;: f~·if::,_:\~;;:.~(/J.:_: .. :. ~~·\ ';::: ", . --~-
[i~'" "-~::~ '"'.Y': v•;~~~'i;".'"·'"Qener.i corael'll".&Jl 1u1stca. tiiat ~-, atataiicint ~· WUbinstOJro ',, ~~--\-;\f;.l:,~-~~A°l1Dk'.Wlli 't)c; lllllintilinod",·or 110.0 a1mllar ~c~''be imcrtcd..
~:tk~---.?~~~W6~,~-.~iff~~B··:~~ ~~·:~t:~1~:t;~~:··;~·- ;· . · · ·!;:~· .~t., . ""'"•_.,...., ·. ..tr1 ... .,,.fl:.. _, ·:.-.~..: .c.!,.;~,. .._.__._ ."""-.·-·_. .;,_ - .. 1'"- ti. . ···:· '· . ,-. ' ·· · (.::;'f'' ·':~·.~11 011•.Y:~ner ...... "'"'''""'rman ...... ~. _ .... ~~-... co~ ~ra: : _ODS , · ·'< ..
J.-·,:
· ~~4 e~ ®.,.both IJidca, but,~~t ;tho~~ JaUSt:_eaS\JElO ~t ~;;:\;/.': ".:
~~~r-.~~j8ii~~ti~~;1r'~ ,_,at to t110 ·.above 41seuaaionm1 • thO :reoamncnaauou eut~ . < .• " , 1
~
'. ·.·~!fr :~~:~~~~ii ~-::· · ;\'' ' · >' · · •· ···
.. ·'.~
i \ \
··~
...... :
DOCID: 2959299 REF ID:A266669!)
, . .., ' ... <-t··::'.~~·~}"~· .... , .!:·-'·:··
,·
~ .. -.· ·;
,··~··. ~:.~~-;::_ E.O. l2958, as amended .-· ...
: \. · .. :
Section 3.3(b)l, (b)(3), and (b)(6) . :~· ··-~. •.
·~:-:
At~;&- . .:,~-- ·-,;. \:.::,tt{.: rislderotion·'o ea o -J'irst Mcc;ln,g 'ot S~Colmd.ttce Co., .r: .• :
. ~ _,.,~
·=··-: ,..., ..
._ , ·~: .. '::•;.••• .. ·at All.•· Ro ho:Ped th."3.t lid.eon offiodr3.'1Culd always bo in a po:1iti<m" ': ! /'.~.;~;-':/J;J:<V .... i'.::.: .. to appredate the di.fficulties on these occasions and be able to expla~.11
. ,~:-f_/ f tr(u: :~~~-; · ,;~~:'.:\?~~ .. ~O: the age~i~e • oJ;igl~ ~~ the 0%'fJ0~UC~ ta. - : '- : . .·. . · · .. _ - - i .· : • .
- · ..,t ·<; ):, , . . : . }• · . With reference to para 2 of the eeconi:1 seoUon of the Minut~li, .. ·,,. ;:.:,. :·:. oo the.subject of conurents, Sir Ed1!'L."°'13 !rra~ pointed oat that this 11a9'3rit-. : /J ti;.(. , : Ce[;•;i.G, praotlCd ,At pr¢11ent and that e.grcaient on this point would a1mpl.y . ..
..... ·:·•; .. : 1 -{•:·;··:·:_: •• ;.,mean that the u.s. woul-:1 receive the ssme documents e thcS<' een1 ~i>
·~~; ·.... , .. :·:·~~-~r,J·§~1~·~:~<:.:;>:·~t~v;'.~~:~1::~~ncj_cio~~,::;~£~·~:~<~:a~;·~.s~ ~.··:~de cementa -- ·., ... _ ... : ' .. :. ·.on tel~gr-an:·a aliZi in pape::-s loss i'reque::it;ly 1.ilU\ OP•.20-G but ho eair no '..:·
._ ._objection ·to the_ sub~cmmHtee 1e sUggetit1on concemillg cotlll!"...nts • . ·;.
. ··~ .· · ... . -.. ·.-;, . .: ~
.. .:. ·~~ . ·.::·· ·~~ ;'\ ';::.:-::._~;;~ ..... >·.
,, 1.: •
5. Or.. the third para of Se,ction 2 or the Sub Co=ittoe Minutes, b4lth B:.-1gadier General Cordeman end fil!..J@:o.ard Travis conf:tr.msd that the~ lYQuld bo CoRJple~ treed~ ot excha.ngo,, Suoh p.ru.ctical ooruiiderations as the fact that not all traffic is trBMlAGed or tht.t not all translations :need to be exchanged could be Jllet by makillf, ·everything available to the liaison offioer.:s. ·.· _ · . · · · _ · · . '
. ~;,;(i;~,~l~L< i." :·.J;.
. .i.:·. :,_·. ·."' . - · . .:.: .. ;,: .. ' ·,, .........
·'.;,
DOCID: 2959299
.. , r.
~- . ~: '
,-(;_ .,: '
.,. .....
.·.;.
I-
l r-t ' i
-------------------
REF ID:A266669~
2 : -~ ·1·~.:f~\;/~~~i·
:;, ~-: -~~-;;_;'', : ~ .. :~'-•._,,: .. ;_ . . ( ·· ... : ;_.,_'!. · ..... : .,':<
6. Para 4 of Seotiori 2 o! the Minutes -)Vai coria-idered ae.tisf'a.oto?Yo . . . : __ ··... . . ,_ ,.·.· ·.:~:.:.-~)-~+-=,s<::~·~{~~ .. ~ .. > .;r~::· ..... _~-)~."- :1:.~ ·--~- , < . ~ .
7. Para 5 of Section 2 concerning BUll?Jiaries-_ led to ~conaidere.llle discus:::ion, With special reference to collateral material •
. -. ~ ": ,.•
-~~_This iras -~overed by. para 4 of th~ b~ic Agree11:ento
12., Captain l'fenger then descriil<!d. the difficulties that migbt arise in e.xtendir.g to the U.K. kn0'.1ledge of, orthe right to ·uso, techni~1;1e~ developed µnder patent in ~e U.S.· ·~ ·:: . -- ·
13. • sii- Edl'lfil"d Travifl tull,y appreCia.t~ these ai.!'ticulties but so.id that, in his vie-n, they ero-se only Wi&!r ;1.tem (c) of pera 11 abo•re
. _e.na. ~re adequately met by the res'eriations contained in pc'ra 4 of th' basic AgreeJ:lCnt concerning methe>ds ·and techiiiqres. - ·
l4o . Jtrigadi>!r General Corderma",l agreed thllt this point was C<rmrei by para 4- of the Agreeirent. · ·
15. Sir Ed~iard Travi:;. suggested that, to meet such diff'icul ties, an arrsngernent lllight be ma<W by which British non technical. experts wore uu;.de S.'l'Rl.l'C of the purpose and met.hod of operation of a teollniqt<~
which '1'19.8 4eveloped under U.S. patent, -in order to el'l!lUN that the tecbni quei was used to the IDtUimum advan tll.8', without the r.e~ss i ty of releasing technical details to the u.K. .
• .... - ·:. ··-~·.,.I.---~·-·'
DOCID:
'~~r.,., .. :.·· .. :-:;~~"·:··"~~ ·.
.;-..;,. ~ . ·• .
<~Y:; __ :J _:
:;_,,liL ;;r:.-11.J' ,· -::1 .... ,:...-. ... ~:.:.~ J::;:' ... ~~:;... '.'
·•., ,,
< -~ . --
2959299
-.-
--;·/Ef~ -·~~~~~:~~;Ab:~ j~~: ~ ':Q - (•
··:· .·· ·· ..•...
. -.. ~:. :·- ... ;_~·r'> ....
.· : :::-. ~:-,:-~~~i;Ji
·.··r,.,~. ,_.
~y:·1··,_.-.. -.:,. '. -
. . :
t ~·· ...
------------·-------------
REF ID:A266669,)
,, ...
. :. 3 ,. ' ....... ,.;;, .. _ ...
:.·•.,,
-_ 16. ____ · _: [email protected] Gerier:U Cordenna~ li~ed~~t tlris would L>e prac~-ic:ible sohtti,on to the d.ifficult7, · -- '
. :-{ ,,,.,./.
a
17, Sir Efr:;ard Travie ther; reverted to the wints m2.i5.c: in -"- --< _ · ~-para. ·1.t above and caDtiinWens;er, agreeine _wit.ll~:sir Ed,.-.a.r:d 's _ dinsion
,- ~r. f;he pro!Jlem into .three d.if'terent subje~~ suggested tllat" the _fir::>t ;' ' - ps_~ oi' draft Appendix E wdUld be m:>re appropriatelj- j,ncluded ~n _ ·
, , . _ • para~ -- 5 of ~a.ft Appa;IDix B, which _dealt with the-exclnnge of inett:-oos '· >\~ '._,>, -:~~ techniq-ies 11nd -which ampUfied para. ·"4 6f ire: basic Agree:armt, ·
~·-- ·_:; __ .:·;~_1_ .. ~ - -.. -- - ~~' ; -'~·',-... ~_: .. ••.:-, :i:'~·.-<;~-~,.,'.20. '::-~;'~;:-rsir 'E~ 'Travis ·polo· .. out th8.t the word.ins of ~s.. ·2·" - ... ,'; ---.;
'f the~;basio·a: ~nt •-and t~'Ui'8oussior. 'of:this'"sUbject whl.ch Iliac'><· .. '~
. " ·_;: .• ......
-' ,'•·
"'-.:';" .. )• : .... -
-- .
~ . ... : .
Ii I ... _ - -- .. • . .,_
DOCID: 2959299 REF ID:A2666693) ,.,...
'"~ -:~· .;~.:- . ~ ;: ... :: ~°d'? '· 2 ,:· ~~ . / ·.· 41:.ti:.:~ .
-.. ···· .. ·.·.~.·-~.j.~.~.:.~.~ .• ~··.,·;·:.t.c.~,~.~.·.l .. ;.'.-.·.·.·~.:. ; g~:j ··
:,: ...
... _.'- ;,·.
A-rfo -~:;~-i r,~ >: .•.. ~r'. :::~~.~~;._~~~
~tt~~f ,• ' ~.;:::::f '~ .. ' '.
;
' . :'.:·~~~ E.O. 12958, as amend d '~.~ ~~· 'Ll:!. ~ t :.··.· .··.).·. · .... ,. _·.· .. ~L4f:.~.:'k1::1~·f.l Section 3.3(b)I, (b)(3)~ and (b)(6) /,,:~f)/.: /; . ~ •; ,: ·· :·-~l,~~~ ·:;·. ·, - ,, ...
'·· ..;, .
· ... · .. -.. ·
. '"·
.. . · ........
. •.'
- ... '.,: t •.
.... , . ......
''· ·:,,::::Bd.3na1cir- ~nei-o.l Corderman;->;1;;~;fJ.·~!cSir .f»lerd_.Travis. •.\ :: · '·
'•i~;fat\i~J.L_'.~.~~~1_,:sJil:iiii::!t~~.~i~ii~:i.;1lt'.~, ... ·1ic0· ...... -fAbA· ·o .... ,..,.~~., ... lJt •• , ..•. ~;#... d
~:'1!r rI~f-·:.,~~~f~~~f~~f~~"Jl¢ ·.,·.
,·:·,.· .':rn1,,:.
~. , . ~..-::;.·-: ,,'\_·
. .. ·:;_.;_.-~ '-~ .. ~~.: .. ':'<,., •• .. -· .... ... . " · .. ::
.· ;, :")"; '<r -': .. · , . , : ; IfiCLV3Io?, Q."" um:.tClLA!K'.EABLE COLLATERAL ltU'SHIAl. IN st!l!WW§~ ····-·-t ::·;··:.. ''I ·.···~:·:··. -: _. ~.•.· .. •:_:~ ..
. t .. .. 2.. i'li th ~1'erence tp p~·aii ~ end 10 oi.' th:!' Minutes of. the 1'h1rd " . L, (· ,,.. ·. Mcct:l.n£t. Sir Edr.::ird. Tr11vi8 rcporte.d that ~ had c-onsidered this mtter
. ... ,,,~ . . :;eincc the la.:;t Meettnsnnr 1iaS in full ~esrmit nth Generol Cprderun'e C ·· ., -• 11uer.c11tion thnt "ur.ex.:m&.nirAbl:" o()llater&l material ahould not be
1nclud;'d.1n :iurr.;;arieo. !f it w.s iieces3er.y fare. ·oon~ ta refer its
. ! ... ·
L .. fi ·'·
cwn c:uatoirer3 to "1.i.re:i.-chi..ng:i:ible" collateral, this.should be do~ in .' paperis sepAr11t: 'from tr.e GU!lmlriea llild given a more restriated cir:ula.Uon. .· . . . .. . . . . . . ; . ... . . .
~ .. . -'• .. The Sccretnrie_, vie~ 1n8tructed to notify th:: Chairman of · .
• . 5ub•..:o;nr;T1ttee C that tho reCOlllDCndations of his Sub-eomni~ee &ihould be mixhN.e<l in e.ccorcbnoe .witb para 2 e.bm.'- .. · .. ~ . . . . . ~· · ....
.. , .· .
4.. Subje~t to on·e lllinor change, the definition W&.S'<'PPz'tmd a.a table;d, ·It. ia given in it& finc.l f'cr::i aa Appen:Ux l to these J.f:i.nutei>.
5. Captain Srncdbe:a considered tbot it was ~t that thi:I detinition should go dawn on reccrd. !hUl "" agreed and it .,,. let't to later decision 111hether it :should appMr in a lbt or other d.et1ni tioJlll or in the repolllloendationa of' Sub-eoiini ttee c. . · : · · .. • · . · . ,
•.. ·.
DOCID:
·,i
.. \ .
~~- ~.:>.;...
,_,~·T:'.F~:~. , ""' -:: .. ; "" · ....
:.~i>~!f/:~-~~'. .--..
;::,:,)::·.~~;: '.~ .
. ::}~,~~fF •. "i
~,: ·: ... ~; - . --~~~ ';.- ... ... .;... ·.
-·· : ··:~'r·.·, :;t=.~·~·-: :--,'·. ·'· ... : -~-· ...
2959299
·.;.~~------ . .;.,:·
·.···.
-:.;:;, . . ·.,. .... ~· ...... ·.~
. ·< =.··'•
{'.
~ . "''. "!"' :·
. ' '~ ~
'">.:i: ;.'
REF ID:A2666~~~)
.· .... J~i~0:'':l' ;,·{?1Mj; ;:~' ~;;::f~~i~~~~,;;,,,.;. .~;. ~ "~' . . · · _:. 6. ; '~ .. ·~~,!t!~riP.~· !°~ .. ~~.¥.Ul~e.a ... to<,,~·:tif'y t~ ~.a!.n;l<:)J'1 of Stili~
. ··T:'oom-µJ.tt.!=c .9 of. ·,the ~r;pu ti~.'~~;appr~4ii.:1Jl ~~~;:-;.to p&;~il J2_,:r, th_~ · ·· \.• . ..Minute:i' b? th'l -,sc.zor.d J.teet:liis :of :flub cioimlithe~ '-~-';. i ",) _·._ • : , --- ·
~ ?:;:~-:.- .. ~·{>{•: '.::~ ·-~·~:-·<;;;:~·.- ~ ~; '. ,I ~'t: {'- ~ \!~·· ~.r:~:~~;;:.; ~~":_!~;: · .. i'. <t~.,\ ~:·.',.\, ~~--~ -.tf:~"i/ , f ! .. , ~ 1 .;.,"• '.,, , •
/· . . ; . :.: .. ·. . .• . ·. ~' ' ' •· ' .
_ --~~~-.~:~;n u.s~ ~~~·:·:·;~'-\·{~/, .. l,;'.~~.}\'., ",:,:\~;·;/< :; .. ,;.;' .... __ _ . :>_.;J ·- "·. ·:7, : •. :; :._"ArJ.t!in1f o'\.\t of t~.; ai.S~~"eit~¢ertolin''.·i£~\ites';":tilf 's~~reta.rle's'.
,., mro instructed to inform the bbdriWi 'ot all' Sub~Oll'illit+.ees tint refe,rer.ces'
. ' ·!'~ '.
The Secretariea· were imtrUct~d to noti1'y Stlb-co~ittee C of ···.~ ·;.,:·~ ... ,..::·· :·~ ::":":>· .... ~·:··-.·~~:~-~-·~.;::·"=::.\·;··-.. _ ... :j .. ·. :.·. ·.·.:·· ..
13- ·.'._ Standardisntion in Trenslation. ·.- · . ; ~ .
, '" ··'~:\; ilPr~rr~· to ·'p&ral.2 (d)·;·~c~tai~' Wenge~ queiiti~~d whetr.er thfo. aolution Wtruld be adequate, as it did not establish.ltd.ch authority would be 'ul timiltely responsible for the standardisation of trar..31.'lticns in the event of differences of opinion between 'London and Wa.shir.gton. He euge;ested tho.t this ooultl be achieved without ltaking llJ\Y ol'lt:! ~ntre the final arbiter in all )'ield3. · ()le Centre could be established as the
. final authority in one t'ield, and another. in a.no!:Ulr; llCCordir.g. to t~ translators and experience available. ·
' .Ao Genersl Cordel1ll!ID a.croed _that it would b~ advisable ,.to clarify the question of ultimate authority in cD.ses of deo.dlo::k but considered
.·.:that it would be impractice.ble to ilake on~ ~ntro resP<>nsible in all · tielde. He augeestea that the arbiter 1n each lan~us£;e or problmi would
·' . be one or the other Centre· . as Jlllltually agreed. · ·
• 7 I ·.~ ,·
. . . ~ · .. · ... ,'-,
DOCID: 2959299
,··: .... ' ..
..
· .... ' .i?:0~'··· .. >, .. ..... -.·.·:..; - ·-;,,:·
.••• :.._!',·.
.. ( ... ··:...: ...... ~ .. J'.":-'::; ·._,
'i·:· .. ·
. ~ _:~ .. ~\~· ·<~~\:~,;
·.~
I .r" ,, ·'
; E.O. 12958, as amended ····Section 3.3(b)l, (b)(3), and (b)(6)
.. /·i"
-~·:·.~-· .· . .:-~- ' :-·:"; ... 4 ... _ .........
~ ":":.\"'(··.·:-. .. . :·. . -
,·,,\
..... :
~'.;. · .
REF ID:A2666693j
·.·.·
.... 21. . These were disoussed.at ·1~ ~ se~~ modificatio~ agreed · ... wb:i.oh will be included 1n the final vemon. In particular the discussion . covered:-
(a) l'he frequent ref'erenoes t'o P8:!'!!. 2 and .It oe the Bas~ ,AAreement : · ·. ft W'88 decided that such ref'erencea were unnecessary 1n Sub.oonwittee reCOllllllendations, as this point would be covered by a general statement prefacing the ti!Ull. reoaumendationa ot the Com'erenoes 1 to the etteot that notllirlg 1n · tho drstt Appfludioes to the Basia Agreement ahall·~ oonstrued as oontrawnillg miy ol.a.uee11 ~ · i:ha.t .Agreement.
/(b) ••••
. ... ~ ..:. .
.·.: ...
DOCID:
. ·- .. . i.:~~';;t:~ ·.· ; .. :: ···-~--·' .,;;-··
::>·.:·
·- .•·
2959299.
.J .;
.... · ·~ ..
~! •.
REF ID:A266669~
(b)
- 4 -
Whether ~ilation ·or the J&mtbl;r Statue Repo?.-ts · ehould be according to the status of the tasks · · 11.e. aolved, pa.r:tly solved. and §er research) or aocord.i.ns to slphabet;l.cal list by eystem. _ _ ft was ~ that in the first instance the_ OOOlJ?ilat:i.on of these reports should be .'as. reoCllllllellded by Sub- . _. .. Colllnittee l!, except that a notation syst~ Bhould be -introdl.lCed to 10:Uoate' at a g1.enoe the etatwl of ee.ob.. task •
.. 25. Discussion of the rema1Ilder or the paper 'lnU!. polltpOned till 1015 on Thursaa.y, 21st March. · ·
26. Sir Edward Travis said he. Would like to revert to this 13Ubject and made1ffie suggestion that, as it had been agreed that =xche.ngeable oollatera1 material must be emitted from ~nts exohanged, the
. insertion, at d:Lscretion, lof' the comnent :-
"nilil is confinned fx'.an other so\lrOesn
might be valuable to the other Centre as an indication thnt collateral of value existed. The receiving Centre could interpret this COlll!OOnt as a hint to probe no f'urther into the sources.
2.1. This suggestion was agreed •
. .
DOCID: 2959299
.~~ . . -.
. ·-:£->.:-~. ..... ~ . .:;. .. _;. ~. ·· ... "':
-"S:.L.~.:··.o ,:<: ~.b:·:,~.~~-\·:~-;·. : •. ~ ..
._ ·~·.:-;:.:'." - ~ ·, --
.<··
Xt~~~
·'
'. ·~ .
.;
.REF ID:A266669~
-5 -
·: -. :. .
rn_m:D mrELl .Ir.EN"..£ Afro ~\!'ION FROM cmoo sms~
2ta.. Ca,Ptain wen~ D1enti"1Y:d tite d!stin~ticn dra11n' l:n tre-u.s.A. bctT1c~n "infor'l'.tion" o;.r.d "intl!!lli;)H..c<!" eul b~tir.t~n "1nt-:rpretation" an:l. "evaluo.tion", tl"-" fo~r l;w;;:11lfl tile duty .or !;he, CctHNI' ~t,ree·;. and.
. tw J.atkr of. lntelligence 3t(l.f'fa. · He eonllidered. t.iJlt thh Ccmf'ere!loe provided a Sli table o-,:.::od.u.T.i ty to 'irrrent TJe'!I tenta for the prcOuot _; , • · and the !\J.nctionn of Ca.!:UIT ~ntres •. and so _prevetrt con!\J.1Uon on this mttcr in_the 1'1,\ture, · · ,, .. ", .·
·-.
:.-··
!·
...
.•
DOCID: 2959299
.. .I
~ ,.
-,
.J.
(';,_
s/lX:/1
REF ID:A266669l)
.~:
Gros~nor Squa~·
London Vl • 1 • ·--,·
20th March, 191'6·
...
------~---
DOCID: 2959299 REF ID:A26666931Jt
./ ,..,, .J
·" •r
' - .: .. ~¢.:...·~?.;_ ,.
·":"'· ... '·•
~ .. :. APPGHDIX L, ;:~4:\1.~·: q.: --------- y~
";f,.
-~, ~~~·: ;-. · ... ', ~ . ~· ·. ...... i ~- ,· -! ; : ~ • .
('<,
DOCID: 2959299
E.0. 12958, as amended
.-· i' , *' :P
REF ID:A26666931t
,.
··\ - .
'.
PRE SER 'l':
----.... .. ··_ ·., ~.--·.,,,>
Si:' Dlnrd 'l'nvis -
Section 3.3(b)l, (b)(3), and (b)(6) Cs.pt~1n if~l'.l8e.r ·. . . . •.·· I
Briga&or TU tman Conaander Loehnia
_, ,.; .~
·'~ ~. -,.
<. =···
:>
c .·.~ .-..• ;-~ .... ~ ·.
···!··
1,,
, CaptaL'n SnetTuerg_ -
-- -~ (a)
. , . :.::!'.(b) :a~oraing in-para.8
Ari ~ddition to pei-a~12~ to be dis9ussecl at the next . meeti~.
'-
0th.er ll\111or- cho.nSes. 5. : The Secretaries, in ciollaborat1ori w1 th SWl Committee D, were
- instructed to prepare the f1ro.l. version, which ohould inalude !I. security . prS.no1pl.e reconrnended by Sub COIW'llittee E.
Rticorrmendation of Sub Contnittee C on Item 1 of its {$enda
6. This was e.1';1roved, 11uQjeot to minor changes in drafting, arJi the seoretarl.es wore instructed to prepare the final vera1on in oolla-boration ·with Bub 0011111it~e c. · ..
',.
. . . _ 7. ·The Secretaries nrc 1Mtructed to lnclu.de the aubstan.ce of para oae of the Sub Oomu1 tteie• a paper 1n tho genoral J>e.per which would preface the final Appendices dre.wn up by the Conf'erenoc •
. . !' .. . .... :
·.DOCID: 2959299 -.. .,
. -1":-~.
:~?':;i'>}::~~;~~~~;,;~i; /, . { .··
··, ... "
·.'
.. '
.. ·~ .=~:"· ~ ··.;,_
·_.,
. ·~" ..
-;. . r
.... . · ..
·-·. ~~~:~-:
. ~- : _:,. .
. ·~····· 'f
·.r ·1· . ..
·C
r ~. 1 •••• ,., ..
....... ,•·
~~'""'"""'""" ·~--~·--·--·--··:-·-...-~
REF .i.D: A2 6 6 6. 6 9 ~··
: ~-' '·-.2.-.
. ·, -,.~, -~ :;... ·, ·,
'' __ ; '-~ .·- '. '!.· ' -. ~ ~ ; •' ..... ·.;
"~
8. .. ' ' 'It was agreed "that p~a '2(1) of the 'recocrnelldations Bhould . be inserted in the reoomn:eooations' of .Sub CQl!:!littee D and removed : fro~ the Appendix on Coomiin1oat1ons. "· .. ·°'.. :··<'>:;->;;);)I·>·
'•, ·:.·•.;
,1·.·
'·
_:..i; ..
'. .....
I \
·'
}:~~;,!_~·:·. ' , .· ~.• .
. ··:,,i~t~:n
DOCID: REF ID:A2666693e
..
·,
;;_.'./~,i~:~ E.O. 12958, as amended . ' ,., .. ·
q~ ~:·
>·<.id~ Section 3.3(b)l, (b)(3), and (b)(6) . -· .:'. ... · ..... ,,.·
·: ':·. Ez':i.gadie:r Gemril Cordetimn :t.-.r.. ·~·::)~
,_ ...... . ..... , .. -- _;>
.· ... ·
:;:.;
···.'-;_'
. . . '• - . . -. -~: -- - ' ·' .- ·- '.·. ·. ' ~. . - . ·-: ~..:!.;.
i·
,; ........
· 3. · :> ·:.,>'. : ';After 5o:ne G:!.ec1.J.ssion, th=< f'ollow,i.ng·rewo:rditlg of the SuO-Co:r.mi tt<i<i 's qri gill<?.l · reoo:ovlie1X!a.tion !'as ap_;lI"Ov~d:
\··.<'.J:~'..'.;1\;
· "ill CentrQs will be eqUipped to handle iil!arofi.:lin, that; it may bo available waan it. is not practio~bl9 send tl~e crizim.1 i!'.:l.~::-ial, n ·
4.. .. . ··. ·.A revised. wordir.g oi' the Re.:CllllllC:irl2.1;iong. (c.) ar::d (b) of thizi ''. · Sub·.Cc;r.j:t;l:ce =.:: a1:;:o. tal?led Ar::d appra7ef,. ·~·~ !l.'hi:o; relies p.s follo;;s;
.. .. "That, except for eei"tain D/F re~:!Zei:ents, ~on:;ivn .be. ll19.de for excl'~siVO tone-tyPa telecCllJJlU."lications bet'Reen Centres a11d between centres a..-id. ttie:i.r outlying iiltero:!:;rt · · ste.tions. This is considered neces~ in order to 1aa·~
· :f~&sibl~ the rapid fJ.c"J of m?l nc..terial frall the point; of interception to the BE:vc.:ral., centres e.nd. i.11 orc!~r to e.llo\f efficient control of cover with oonl!4~t reduction in \'1'8.St~ful d'-"plic~ticnj as weli as fC1: rapid e7." .. :;_!l.i1~ of raw material a.nd inf'ozr.-.s.ti.cn beti?een. c~ntrea."
5. Captain Wenger said tmt he would like to repot"t on h:i.3 . meeting with D. S,D,, Adr.Ura.1ty1 w.!".ile Sub-C=iittee •.:;• were. p.!"esent. With l"!>ference to the proposal thl:.t Admiralty ehocld ta.:CO over the existing U. S.N, Lonc2cmdercy station, sa»e ci'.annels of 'llb:icll are de~ired ~or Commi_mic:a.tiori Intelligence pui-po:?.es, D.S.D. pad .said that he can d.o nothing until nc receives official support froo thi~ Conference. ·
'.
>'- .. '·-
( -·~
:'',,); . ' . .. 1· ..
. -
DOC ID: 2959299
·, -..
6,
7.
11.
REF ID:A266669~
·1 . . '../"
Sir Ed~1:u-d. ~ra•·is ~id tnis point w~ld ~·cove~ if epe'oi,al attentio::i 'IWr~ i:wi ';.c.:l., in tl~ coveri::ig remr;u; of. tnc tinal. recomoond.<ttions of' tm Coni"erenc;!I, to the importance ~ Conmmics.tions fa::' c:;.UHT pu.r1"cs~n. .!::: >.:c•ild 8ec :tmt ·these re:n:u".:s were brouz,1t before t;1") Lor:ci.on S1GiJ'T Bof<.s-5..
At this point Sub-Allunittee .. 'E' left the iieeti.~ •· • •; - I• •
,· .. _,:
' Mr. Huddleson queried his definition of' cciuNT i~s given in para. 2, on tbe grounds that it took no aceount ¢ Traffic Jntslligence, A revised definition was therefo..-e considered and will be. incl=ed in the tinal reoonrcendation. :.:. :..,. .
12. The Chairtaan reported tba.t the term strr.i.rnr WD.s considered unsa tis'i'actciry-sy-tr..<:! Sub-COIIJlli ttee concerned, as it wculd be easily coilfu~ with other axpresmon::i in cOlmIIOn use, such as CCXUiT, 3IG-!Ill', It 'Ml.:s till!ref.'ore decided to adopt the tcnn OOlill'l'SUU instead.
13, With the above exce2tion, the Minutes of the fifth Meeting ware ap:;iroved,
Pkl.A. 12 OF T:B W.00.~NDATIO!.S OP SUB-col.!i.IT'l"l'EE !>' •.
14. .After considerable discussion, Colonel Heokerrgar -iraa requested to redraft the suggested addition to para. 12 whl.cil been tabled.
At the em of the meeting Colonel Heckemeyer read out a draft w:nich wa:i approved and 11111 be icco:po~ted in the reocrimendatione of Sub-Committee •D')
..
DOCID:
:_:_·_
2959299 REF ID:A2666693~
, ...
3
RECO£,'.YND:\TIOl'IS OF SUE-co:J;.:mr:t •c I ON I'J.SJ,( ? OF ITS A.c;:;NDA
15. General Co4'tler.tn9.n, wi ti:i rereren~e to para. 3 of tile pa.per, CO!lsid~red til.."lt t.~ rec.,.umcr.dation ;;as ina~que.te e.nd that st1n.Jsr<li-sation ~.:ild be effected a$ soon a3 po::sible, It was t:i:o~fore ~ tr'2 followin~ l!hould be substituted;
•To tt~t e~, the London Centre -.tl.ll p~pire a prOt>osed t=nslation style e.trl bJ'out. w!rlc.'1. will be int°i-oduced, with wch modifications as a.re necessary,
• as soon as it ms been considered by t:ae u. S, tec:XUcal specialists concerned,"
:-. .. -' .. '· _.. '
lt was. a.iso agreed that this proposed style .. a.~ ls.yout SiouJ.d .. be drii.wn up before .the de.;e.;-ture of tne u.s. delegates.
\ 17. \ ;Otne(~@,~~1~ ~~ti~ ~e~ uria.;/~-i~~;.•4• •5 1and 6 ,of
.:_ .. ,··
the paper, which -was othernse approved. · .
·"·'fa.; _ ~4. l~C~t~~~~oI~-~,'.~~~rl'rEE -'A' ;6n ITEU ~ ~i/1Ts~~\;~:,: { 'c'. :.~··._::;·'.· /
..... r•.:-·. i-: '1."'. - .. I •',. ' .~. • : • , ~ • • ' :7 ::. 'i\'.:';i;·;~:~.~:·: .. · .. ~:.;:;·;·~'-?~~;· .... ~.i~··-. '.'.-~< .-.: . . . .. ... f>.··. . . 18 •... ;. · 0w.rior che.Iiges'in drafting were .ma.a.e aDi·tlie''pa·· r was appz:oved, ... ,. c.·
4~xf'i~~;fc~~~~!~~~§~~~ft!tii~f~tiiJi : ;-::··"' . .,· . - ·. "'..' ;;•,/the confererioo was being entirely suooess.t'u.1 :in 'establia.IUng .methods -.~: .~f.•. • . ;:,-
·": ._:. ··,
'· · of collabora:tion, but not of integration,' ' ·. Tile lllOtll.Od.s proposed
(>
< .... were not Buch as ,tp reduce the c:amiitmei;t ':of'. ea.eh Cent:z-e;: !Jut 'likely
..... · .. :~;:~, ~~~7f0:\~:~:};~C-:< ·' ·~·-·· .. · · ·•. '.>; ;IiS»~~~\~~$4~&\~j·>.Vf··,~~ 20. · : .-.: .Cenei'al Co.."'dei'm!ln agreed the.t the arrarigei=nts being made were .
· adding to the-bUrdens or each par~ and said be was disturbed ·b;,r this. On the other hand,. he did not feel that a division ot:taciui oould be attempted until communications were 8.d.equnte to ensure that each · Centre receiv'cd results as quickly from tasks dooe at other Centres as it a:1d from its own production co;rmitnents.
21. Sir E6.ward. Travis asreeC. to thi:s but eaid that ti:lis point was ·ilow1'..ere clear],y stated in the fape.r- under discusci.on or in the recoim:endations or. Cryptar.s.l.jrsia. These 1.a·~ter be.d a.lsc a3mm:ed that the division of tas:w was impractics.blc# wit.~.i.t stating t..'-:e reason for the assumption.
22. Ger.-eral Cordernan repeatea. his vie'li that ne..en c=i.nic9.tions were provided., all possible division of tasi:::s, both in int':!roe?tion a?;.d cryptanalysis, should be effocted.
23. The Chairmen t:1en ruggested that prelii::linary s.grce.=:.t ·on the di irision of tas:<S should be attemgted r.ow, in read.inesn fo:.· the ti•:ie when conmmications lll3.de the division possible, Some ind:.c'.l.ticn of the M.ving ot personnel that would be achieved bj division cf 12.bour ·wl".cn cornrr.unicaticns allowed would be a vitluahle ar3~nt in .fav.;our of thi:i early provision of' the necessary _co1:imunicat.ions,
24. Sir EdwB.rd Trov-ls strongly Slpported this point a'.d. Ge r..eral Corderi;ian. agreed that the problem of division of tas.:.s snc:.il<i. be given some attention during tne present conferetlOO.
25. It was then decided that General Coroe:man, Sir id:;rd.rd -Travis, Captain Wenger lllld the Cha.inn.an should hold further disc<.1saions on 'this wbject with the llecessary technicians on or e.fter Tueoday 26th.
" · .. -~. '
·.·.: :--··· .. .,._
" . ~
-; ~:
DOCID:
·.,,\i:.;.-.... :;.. -_;;;::.;;.;~.
- .,.~.' .· -. "·-.. ~- -:· ·:
·~·~/'-'-/'
:- -~.+.::;~~ . 7 .• ..:·
2959299 \ j
,"r.
-j".~ .~·
·.,
·:· , . ...... 1: -~.
26.
REF ID:A2666693j
- 4- •
In viol'f of' tb.e above discucaion it was agreed ttia~ tr1e fi'rst sentence of toe paper from Sub-Ccmmi ttee 'A' should be 111odified to ~~: - . .
"Specific ellocation of ir.terception ts.aka ar.0.,of iseru-ch p:.-ograimr.ea is impracticable until e.dt:quate oo;r.r:ian:i:'~tions are establiab.ea."
•:"1 ••
27. CansiCl..erabl~ discussion also took: place Concerning t;he excha:-.ge of "Intercept Plana", but it wa.o finally agreed•to ina:'<C no oheiige and to approve th.., pa.per, 6Ubject to tile ·modification in Jie.ra. 26. ·
'· . ; • ·. ~-; j •.. ':, ~. '" -
_ , 2a . . · ..... •Tli1s :rec-~ridati~n was-approved..''1
\.~:-.:<~;~~<\·.';[\ ..... · ,.
; L! ;q~~]iE~~~~~~~i:~~~~~~T"J;~~r · · .... : ·,~ ''.ft! C~I ,_ 30.,_''.£' :;. ·.:t~:'l-t ~'ms· then' agreed tha.t'_.no.·1;pec~.l ~~e~.".c~d_be. efr~b- -~;-,,. · •· . . · .,,.;;;:"-; _.,_ · ·- .-.·:·· ~).ished f'?l' lce~ne each other'.icf'ormed Of'. .. tbe-~:etateJOf' ::prl~ties. ;, ,;.-·. ::, ·-:
i, "''" ,. : ·, .-:~{ff<-<•.:'Ji';f~ft;1·•::f:'.·~<;i<'' ~-~'!:<''"'"'··. ·i -'";f.>"-"'.\P'!lfit ,>r-·-~Sit:wt'f-·/!~'f~i;,,.~~~$'1'!.<l:'l.~.:o;: ,- .. ,.-;_"I'"·-.. " !f~·.:::;, ·'·· ~~":.'f-.~i-·~~ .... ·l.~ ... :~~J'~-:-:]!:;·~,\Ji.~ ..... ':''
0
• ... ~·, .'t .. i':.t.···· .. "{(J•\ ..... ~·l:;'.:c~~·:'A1:~·~.;:~~· i"%?::~1F:~1:~ ...... :•0
'J• ·, • .. ,· •• ~>, .. • __ .,1~; .. ~ • 31. :,;\: ·.-,.::;;;:\1~~G-eneral ·coraerinan said,,that,'·.in ·))is yl~, ~-~.o~J.e1'.4!1 __ under-. · ·
,::c;;-;v•.·:.-'. • . : .:~e~nll.ng whic_h .we l:lad :reac~ of _each other~s situation a.Di, capabilities · :JiHf~(::> ;·,:, .;;,'.;:/1Vi1s sup'icient ;tojmirure icUt~ a.ssist&J?Ce. ~n l>tiorlties ~ii,l<:s_., ~:·He. :- ·_. ·
._.,.,-:,:>, '. -_. .,. -;-~~· .,. ': ' · ,.- ~· · · ·:(hoped 'that LOn:l.on Would· eontinue to a.silist the ~ailhington Cent~ in ··. · · ' ~,~~~---)-~ ~?;~~L' · · · . ·:,Y~ i;arficular problem on request, as i~_bafi d.orie in the past, -a_cd · ·
0 -~ - _ --. -..:ft~ .:.;.,·~:_.: ': ,. · --c;)thB.t I.onion would similarly call upo~ :W&ehington:1n· cases of neoe:.>sity. ··
·- .:·; ·'-.:~:. 33, .::{:}:~, -··.· ;i/ .point of vie·11 but considered that no i'urtl'.er discuasion at this··
··."·· ;t.,.
E.0. 12958, as amended . Section 3.3(b)l, (b)(3), and (b)(6)
~-
-~:· .. ' ~
preser.t coni'erence wci.!ld be ct' use. ·
3~-· Sir EdTf!l.rd Travis so.id. tbs.~, disguised 'uric.er whe.te·{er te:ros, _the prcd_uce of. Comlliullications Intelligence was 1ntelligen03.
350 It was th_,refore a.greed ~ot to pursue this subject,
ANY OTI!l~R BUSINl~SS
Captain Sruedberg asked for the inclusion on a future Agenja of ttle qu~stion of whether- might be allowed· the use of oo;.·taiti Speoial Intelligence. It was a~ to ta!<e this a~ the next meeting.
OL'TSTAllDU& ·.rnRK
37. The Secretary gp.ve a re~ of outstanding items to be con_sidered by the Canraittee.
At 1015 on Monday 25th Ma.rah.
..
;-
:I''
··-:.~
~ ·;
-j i
.j ·.j
·DOCID:
.,, . .. :~~d ;jy·
·.'!:· .ll ......... . " ·•' .-.. .;:·
2959299
1,r>·:· ·, .
.~ :.
~··
:1~~; t·;. ~~-::L~_:r ,q, ·~~·~ ~ ..... 1"'"'"4;\r•"f, 1 ·~- .~ ... ~-r- ... ..r.'!'-~ . '.::~~·~,:b~}f ;~· ~. ;.·· .. :~~F~!.~·f.·:f.f:~
":~· ~· _ ... ~ .. '· ~~ .... · : . .-·.·· .• '.:~.~~.~,, .. ·~.·~~-~ .. ~
. , 1.
REF ID:A266~69~
/
.;,·
'cm~ Sub-C~~tl t~~~ :;~ci · \'i;:t~{~>;~··,~~1-~-~~:'-~;f: ·-· .n rt t .B t •.~··.'· · ·
' :'.·~:;T·.; .. :?":·"·:.:, "·"'.: Tl1C Exeatlve Ccim:dtt&e ba:s direc:ted tb:;i.t,
:~~';,~J:'. ~· ";; - -~~
-rf .~.~/ . . . ·: .. · )Ji!~~~-~~·;./J\,.~,jf.r',:·~·f'f f~,~z)_:t_~~~~~;:,:~.i.~:·rJ;~ . ~·~}~ ,''.ll z~;-~~ ;~~~-~?: 1~.(',cj,.:_..-;·:· " ,. :1~1,li'.:>\f1'·''.if]·~·'<'~;;:,~';!.B'if· ,·,·: ... -:~ ., -';.-· -· •f.~
~, · ·· .:'{l1
J. p, . ,{~'<f i;f~~~~~~~ikc·, :.:. , . ". . .·.·<: ;J{?;:.~!Xri~~.J:Wh!i'.:; . ~-;..._ ....... ~.
I ~~ :~,
-~
c • . <-
·..,;
. ' .. ~
' . -....
. ,~ .'t
.•. • .. ·
.:- :.~ .
·: .. : .
.. · !>
1 J \
DOC ID: 2959299
~*~·~~~z, ' ......
·:.·.
E.O. 12958, as amended
REF
··,' ·;.. "
···'•; ,.
·~! 1 .....
.. ~·: .~ . ,., . ~t ~
ID:A2666693~
. . :..:·. . ' . ~
·. :.;. .1 ;~.-. -~ .-:. • . ...... .::;; '.... ... ' • ;. J ,). • ,'
~1J'rl'VE Cl'TJB. ·:~
IITllDT.<;•3 (!;! $F.VE.1lZI . Jcm':iro at . . : -~ ' .. ; •· '·-.-. ~-~.- -~.: ... · .. :~·;;:~(= .
. •::-:: \' :-·
EX?CU'i':CV~ O~
~· ·, .... i- .·• : :· .-,:;;.~·~ ...... :];;~_<\·:~~ ... ~_( ·fil1LD JJ.T 101;> QN HQrIDJ;t, .,~,•--:.•ii«•''·.:.·""
~-.\T-.. '. .. ·: .. ·.;. -~' . ' ,/_:_~-~:';:'.J:f> .. ...... · .. _.,',:" ,;· .. ·,
' .. ' > .. ~2'l't! µAOOH. 19't§. ~ - ., . - .
·~·.'.\:: ~-.~:;}/·;·~·,_. 1?. ;·.~· • ·::--:·.:\?'':".,";-;::/~/ ... '. h''.,~i·:·<~f< .' . . .·~:" v.-~· .. ~.J: »r',"·"'~"'p R@ S J,a ]'., 4!'. .· . ,. ....... 1'' ..... _ .- ~ ·- :·~.·., l!';t.~t • ; - •
;¥.~~<;~L~~{;~~;;~_:;- ;L~:c,~::~~~i,';s~ . ,'_. ;,_-..',;<.:Z;ill>-1~\et C-e~ W!J?,_C$)ri~ •• !},''·"",;:.:_:\·~; •. [.Sir Etmaid ~via. - ·•· ··;-o~.-·'ColoneJ.Eeo1to!r.r.r.t'fl'0"'" .... 1 .. ·• ~. 1·· ,:. 1 ·-"·'·· ,.\ ~-· , ... · .• ~· .; ',"; ;' • • .-:_~· • A. a .. '" .......
1"' ·• ~- , •. : ~-_ :"' _. .. ·~, ~.~, , •, I . i' '
1• _-: :'· ' "_ • "
·. -. .... :·;,Ccp .. aiti J.M.llicr~or.. ., .--.,~· . · ·' ·: - ' .. ~ C.Lcohn1'1o
:)t~:-,,~~i;~ir~w~~~~j1,l,~'2. 1 1.-;r-.• (:::~~:1~--:_ ~:~~~A~ \. ._,_ 4, ~ (f• ~~-,~{ .. ! ~.,..;°"··"·~·;.;/ 'L f·~~--f"(~·:~~~~_:• .. ' •
..... , . . . .. c~f.: "· _,7} -~ - '. :i~~:?·~~~'.;'~'l~":;!,~~:~::;t? ~~lt'1 ~Bent:_ f!?t, ~Qt-, ':bla;ti.M• r--~u· v"\."; . . ;f ,~.-~' "· ,, .,(· .. : -- ";. : · . .,"'·-:'-}
,_
Section 3.3(b)l, (b)(3), and (b)(6)
:~\~±.~ ,' .. ~i ·,<'.·~-. . .. -~: .. :· .
. . ·-~ . .:,_
-~-
. . -.·-." r.--~> ·-~. ·~ . .;:
·~:- T:-f?'i '::.
--)' ~ .. . ·.,.•
. ~·~'.'-. ·-:._j~:.·
. --~-! .,
,:
..... ···r-.•
. !~--~;.
. ~ - ·:·: ,, ·, . .... ,_... ··-~-·
;:\?:.~~~~~-.l-'if~:·~G:.:~:,::,._;;.:;r;;;;r-2:0~-: ... :\:(-:. :.:'..:~. ::; .. ~~ :~. ;~:' ~ .. '' .· · . .' .1 •. :~·';' 'th~ I'eOOll!!iOrJi!'.'!Gi-;m :\n pti.,~Jirtlp."l ' of tho 1t1.riUtee 'SI"'...! ~
·. 'r~.t0N.fil to ro~a:- •. ·· · · ·
'".,\ll· Ccnt1·;;.: 'a:\.U b:i equipplld to h..-md!e ~1.·-'l':·fil,1, ·:th;i.t 1'• Jl;3,J b;$ a.vai.1.ahl~ tor uie ub.~n it 111 M~ t:rn>.c: ~;\nr.~1.J) 1;:> s.o::;Cl th.o orlg:l.iizl r.t!-tc::::-.i.91.;
~ · . c~.toeo7.~ {'4) in par~h 9 "Bil al~ll>r:;id t~ i-..:.W •i:;clveii {'-'!.:...""TOn~v ;r,,aoable)." . , /. . ·: <· · •
5. P-...r~~Z\ )j ll"i~· aJ.terod ,to ~:.; · · • -'.:.'" I . · · ... •". • • • . :··, • t • =':~'.' ... -": - ·• • • -. .· I :' • .·, '• ..... '•. • - ... ·
. : "£.-~:,;~~~-;,~::!. .:..i.14 .r.ir. !l.1:.M:l.eBon ~a. v.!,_t..'1 0'3.ptllin T!'~n&e:t-s s ~:l"-'"t o;. '!}:\.<.;;· .r,ut 00-.1:;..;.ioo~·ed th'il't no f~d.i.e:~.;.on a·c thls F~:r.\'111~ coii:{''!>l'i,r;r.:3 1«1J•11.d bt' ~-r us~·. 'I ' · ·
ti.. &,;bjac·~ to tl:e abo-..-e !OOdif'ioatio~ ·Mild a t-w. mir.cr ~1.3.~~: cl' 'ii?~ni.;, -!:h~ ?linutea -;-;-er.J e;;ipn>T.ld. '
~&~Tu.~
5.. lt.~E'lnu~·r11t..o.r:~a'l ~M.-t ~ia ~tt~o
. . riot nm 'J; ·~~·li: this ..
·' ._ ..... ,·
./
..... . .. _., _,• I . --~' .........
:~- -~· I>,?C ID : ;-~-.:.·."
2959299: -~~~r·:ii_,~. .'~ '· r REF
) :;._,~
/
ID:A2666693
.','•
., ··f~~-.:. ~.:'.-< .
•,.::"
E.O. 12958, as amended
"f{;: .··· . \'I :/_ .... ,
$-'t:·;, . ' .... ;,•;; ,:: .... · -,_ ·: : ' ,. ' ·. ~- '~ . .. ·' '
~,,;t\ ".,: ~~ ~\'-P'".~- 1 -~d;. ..... ··T~·-:,· '~. --:-/!~: :,• :.-.~::~:;, · · .. ~
' f.' '\~~.>,.:,;•::{!/";,• ,~::~·~r--. t-''"'- ~~·;.,. •: :·· I 'i.~i.:,,';!::_,, ";, _'i,• ,,.,··. :,.
;.:.,.~;'-.! 11"-. ·.:,.~~ i-r··f .. ,-~:.:.;;:._-; 1:.0. o"'\_r!;.,:~~: .. 1' -
·'f. _ _ i '-'· ,RW..2-.:.:l~.l:..!Y~-·~-~e..e..S::~.*'.!....4-- , · ,_ .. ~~.;:~.£~r .. ~~';---·~~-.'" ..... ~~-~:,y:...._.,,~.;· -_ ... ~ -:~ . · ····:· ... ~!"· ·-·:~--~·.).::~:; .. 1·:(··.:_:··!.,,.-~.~,·~:·.:.--··. .. . .<·: ..... _,: :~_.,·: ;.o}.::· ;'. 6,.-,,. ,'.{ )rl ;~~- re:. ~~·:.:-.?c to tr.~. ~~di.~a, 9~.,-~ ,J:'C-.:1'. w.~c:::i q .~ Gener!.l .· .•
- ,- 1~~ '· • ~q~~'.'r:'.:Jl'~Gl:etl 'r.h<:'Gbo!' it wan 'r1Ccesocr; to '~,,ecH".Y .that mr:rce?:"1'9l 1'11).:la -.· o~ ·ttl ii~.i..:slJ J u.::r:·:i~ t~L.:·~:if:.i.cf.~io~.1 to t~e ·ot:1isl.' lJAI ty, i~1• t:1z -~i.l~jec-r; er .
. ·. ... ci ~;c,~1.e:. ;:.;i.:.t'.:-c..;. t:::..i.~.c i.~. :_): ~~~~c~.ti.; ~.9 ~~~io!"'2.l .1-nt.ez-·?z·:;~.. .Ii~ ~Jj.~ t!1e.t .•· J. ·,,: ... <_.lie'chl 1Y,f~:~ir,i,a!~ fo:·~.~.W.1:1 tdl.'<l_.ll:tip\ii.$ted, fl.'3.it.'118,fullJ ccv.,rod·'by ,.
in· ,
~::" ?-~~~:y-;7·~.;~,::· :~~~-/~~ ~·~ . ~..:· . ; .. ·-~ .. t ·:·:.~ :~ .~ ,. . ~ :, ~- ~"._:. . :. ~
t~ ·:reotrictions- · . ' '1'.'\ • ;•
- -":·:;/'• h{U'.is.'~~:J. . .Yi~'4d l:'~ ~not;i,atoo in. the ·MIU' i'uture · and S:i.r E&ira..-d 'l'l"&.via · ... :> · : "-:
~~,,~-f~ii~~i~~~fr:\~?·!~1~11. '~ill)'OuJ.cl'.~,, · -~tai-.."'"1ift1fb•':Pfe.' ,'!~:· ''·'" ~~.(\l'A.f:ws' .\'iCU1 ·;.£e·r11=~· :~~·- '"'1l~c~"&-iW,i e!tL \; "·
. ons 'l_dtP,·-trui ah~Uld :be bu1.h·,.:i:~.; .. _-·;·-1);;·
~iit1i~1~~s1~fi:!f;~J1~~"~:t -,i: .. i~~~.t~ly,'.cover~~ --~~ t.h:: !'in~ papers ):>eir.g Prel'....reil_ c;r au::) .cQ!:1111t·t~_ o. ,
Section 3.3(b)l, (b)(3), and (b)(6) L·,.~f-)>~~~4'.ain~ th~ ~;-~'i:.n;;c cl.' ~r~ items. , ';,; ' • .... ~~\-~·;~:;~:S;~·~<:· ~· .. ::;:;·~) .. :· .. ·:·'~·:_.;:.. ::< .: .· . ·. :·"": · .. _,.., '. .... · .. '. . . . . .
:-··
'-·i·:';:1·1w:, ,· !t~'C 12 fi'ttii S-cl;,-.c',.-,;!lf,..:l.tteu .A~ (.'Oru(.,c"e:roo, i:':t:'f; ~e :!Ui!~a~~ ., •. -
1 ~Lx>rt·f;X:.::cL thc:::-!rl.~! "'?12· . .'l :a:-1::j<}(Jted s!ld th.e ··Ge~:e~~£.n.:· .. 7,~ -i:ln·~.1~ct.:.fl t~ t:~:a
· · -St10-C\~u.~:i;ec .. =L .:;t.~, 11~'!.:t·(; :;.'. scpe:;.?..·~e p~.pe-.c c::a tl.c .s·;J;;;~-.e.:.t'c o~f: oO::..laDc:u.tior.. :'~n Zc:~f.fic A.."iil."!:i e.. · · .,
12 .. · :r·te:~ B ~C:t-c;;J:;.' .. .J.;.-:,!::, S't2.7'll1.n~~~sa~:t:J:i ~ l'U"'":; ~t~.r _al. :2' .lZ.-~.~.:t ~~ a.loo "d;l:w;::r.c<1 ac::'I. :•:,ipr.JY~d.
':. ,·:,; t±~.Sc!{. :.· .. ~13~· ,, l'tth ~tl...~re~ to itetn, at the re~n.:1<'-~~n t'CJ.> S·.1b-.Ccmn!.i;'l;ee A
": p~n8tui;ih (a) it was D.g~ to 4EJ.!t$ th~ eUggea~'iO:lG conc~rar.{; d:l~c',; . · 11!.iit.on bet-lff.Jm: 'rt:.:.&..1:1,,.qton and Jle1oou..-r.ti, M .c~.r.er-~1 G:::r~ . .,1.~a:i,, ·C7!llfo
Wei..p~ v.r.r. 'sir ~Qwa.'C"d T'L·ev:la oouf.'i:c;P.:: ~hi'-li it~~,J'd.-'Seir~:l"!l'1s~Tut" 1tr d.i""ie·.::t' nr~1!a!~-tutl!_~ .. h~ °CrJ·i;~~~ .... Wa~:lr•gt;;-r:.. P:!'l. ~~ ~-i.:.f-~·cc~a-7'?0Z?.lt~1
, ove-r~f.1-B J:aat::-es e:i:c!--:l)t:1.v..g All ·~lC.~i- r....a~t-s:r:; st.r...u:;,a =~ J~'C.·il$d . tm·e<.ltµ lond•'.Jl:, I .' •. ' •
"'14"~· G<?n=.~xQJ. 'Jc;'~~,~:Tn:1n Cl.·.:iu1:rt~~..a ',-f'..J.!.V .. ~·!e1:- l:t~~ :-~.,:~ :y.ff!.cd:.:.~ '"';;~;:a. ;:ie.~!;:..~.:.~, .. . sy~.,:!·lftC.;j:iy r:::t1~,~l .. "'~PU!1Jt),30;:~: Hrl tlJCU!,;h{~ ~i:.9?;:; .:!1:.:. ll.:?:i~·:J;-;
6fticc:=- n;i~t i~e ~.i.~ to h..'1.!dl~ 9!'Y?~&~J.y-t-:J.c.;J 1 7.. /_. ar.J t:::-".:r..~~
l~t;i.c;i JP.:S;tel·,;. I{~ ~.-za sure t~1~t pl:r.>~rmcl Vl'?cld. not bt:1 o.•;.-.ilr.';il;, 1:·. e::r-~"ir.:im· ~ ;-.i;i."obt.'t'.s to er..a'l:-1., l'\a;-1y ll.e.i.Go:i o~.I'ir.~~ to .i;;c "'a-~r,l;a).nzq.
:· ~. ::·. ·~~£ · .... :
IJ~;l,i ~ . .;:...~
";;·-:~~~~'.. ·, - ..
·:<:-·ii~;~~~~------·
:... ...
,_
··~
... . ::-
DOCID:
·:.<: .. :;;.. .. ,. } :7 ~~·fc:f :.-
·.!:-· ~"!;.
--- _, ... -+:
.... : ·{~ .,
;,
... };.' ,,,··t.
REF ID:A266669J~
-._,, _,··,, : ... ;.
15. The eiscussi<J1l the~ pC.1:J3~- to· co;.sideratiol\ Of' too u. s. draft , A;?Ioend.ix G_'. ~'his '1'9.3 iw_.1L"'ied. to 13~ e~"tont t ~a it wtlD ~ed th.&.t the lllOQ.:i.fi.eJ voi·:no:l should 'b~ u:icd I.\!. "tho ·tinal Ji.ppendi.x on the Mject of "I~t.ii.b'.>n ru~d Chnn..'l.els tor :ExChange". ' Rccownemetioris · rrom su'!::-Cor.id .. ·t-~ccs 1\ c::c1 J3 on th:i.11 s\lbjact. mire co.•zidere<l to 1:3 cooo;oi-ed l>y t:r.~ U. s. _dra..."".; .tr;:;ior..li:c G. · . _ . _· : · , . · · . · • · •. - · · _ .
. . , . ; ·>'::·{.;-~~ .~:-·~-: . . ,_I · ..• ;i:·~ .· : : -~- • ..... ;·. ·.· {·\, . .. · . , . . 16_. !;1 con::ieo-ki02? Trith the u.s. ·drett J?peneli.x G, Sir~ 1'rav-is. po:1.ntcd out t!J..'.\t reatr,i.ctions· on lt.-1 tish pel'llonnel in wa.:iliingion woo.ld
-pro'!>ably i:e:'!.1"1 t:"-'li; the .roi:idon ~:tg:lnt ~ 'll'OUl.d have to estebli_sli i'e¢?.!'Oocl. :roo'.a:io'tiQ!lS on v.s. penoll!}Cl _,t.ttachea to the: Lone.on Sigint ce;~Z"C ~ ~ Gc;-~--:.El ~Z'dfil2 8J'ld ~tai.1:1 Smcdher,s _ s~d tJ:'.e.t ti'.& ine>i ~ :Ll.1.ty.o:i:_ t.l'.:t.a Tre!> 1'uJ.ly ca:ipromafed: _ .. ,·.-_, "' c:~~ .'·~ - :·:-. _.-
... :·· ~ .•.. · .. : ._: :· · ·-: ... --_.:_-~- -.~ ... :-· : ... : .... , ... ;.~~ ~:·::; .:~ · .. :~·:,\~1{1:··>.~ .. ;.:f. ~;r:.:·.:: ::.:·: ::~:-: :. · < :. . . "· - .. .. · ~· . , .. 17. ) ;/Jt.i, th ~·~?ereilce to ~ ff. c;it',.:.~!11 ,~ ~eneix, ·ceoora1 .£;1;:~..B ·c:i.":>1~:1£d_ ~t .in ~ ~~_B.'~~ .~r'Y ~~t _should be _ f;i.'.!·et t;c.<10 t:U-:iu,,';11 ~~ by :liaison at'ticers but that tec.'mi.cal detai.ls
•
.. ~, ~~""r~~~~1i~,ii~E=:r~:r ..... __,[~?- - _-_ 0 _ ~sta.bli~~:-as'i gCOOiai p:t~plo _'the.'flllJt'.thiii-.~·roquesir..g party ll'oµla. - _':.--,.:.,:_ __ ,· __ _
• ,--,>::---~ -_- ·-• •. · :·~e·re,sJ?OO:$ib~e fQr preyiding :~he ,i:c_ans .of tra:n"Spori; ,tor ~terinl. St.1?Plied :- •
·t~·itf:l~:~~~~~~:;~,v'"'~'" :~~',%l'~{f;;.~;~l~:-F'. .•. . '' 'W 1
:!?, \...;__~:
· · _- ·:19. ·· ;:;._· :Appena:kes;Jl ~d.-.G .\Ve:i:-e ~cioJi.'!;1.&~...d .arid .it~ ~d that -- • , · _:'i -Jnoy--o6tud -1*': -~ ii$,au:d- in firi8f:·.tom:'~J' ::- :'.)\- _: -•, :_ /;i;· ~} -· "·
-. 20. -_ _ _ " A'.P?erid!.x :o --~ ~s0 -consider~ ana '1 t -~as i,~fli1 tilAt- ~h9 ti::nJ. _ •':!'°Oroll_~J4.d ~}i.C$\;e'l l!ftcr colisidera~on lJY G-enersl c;mr;.rm,an, CA'Dta:l.n "::,: we~ ~d .fil,_~-rd .T:ra.~ •. :,'~ ~_oretsxy _was· in~trm:lied. to. _provide · : "ih'"aw with -copl.ell 0:: ~he re!..-a.."'t a.~ eioon as poo5ible.' .- · _
. ; . 1'AAb"1' COY.!Z!J·JG ~
- -. . ;,· . ~ ' ~·. - ... ; 21 ~ ·,c _ - ,Js. dtt.r:t COV\!1.•l:-:g, p~.per w~s. con£P.1ercd &ml l:!OCif:ted. ir. Jlll4-zy'. -r~tr~ects." ~he ~.r!o::..-e-".;~~~ .. ~~ \.,,"eJ.-c: irAntrueuea to t.!:!:>lC ~~ ~~"'Tin~l &i:u?~; a·i. th~-nsxt nee?.11~!!·
.. " . .
£!r~RE_l'f~~<;S . .:.·
22_.· : ~e &>~--..,,_-~;·..ie"' "<1~;~ n1:zo i~--~C;;d to d;c2<'~ Cl. cc..J-a,-'nrr 'le•'.·+.·--· .... :......!;...;.:'.;.·::.~.:~.'!.!:'-.!:'. . ..... ...... . ~l.l.C\.i >: .... ... • -- ., - .. h .••• ,.
to tl1e Chi>i;:-am ot S'CAN0!3 a,,;l ~.a C.'lairean of fae k-..i'.o::.i Si;:r,lJt_:; ~"'d.i to .'b~ eizn~d ~-.-lib:: <ti:!:i£;~ ct: falo C1Jnf'ere:-ie--~, ~E?z..J. cc;.--C~i:7..an .cml ~t<:S:.~""ffi· -
23. It vr.n then a·g..>"!lcd t!lP..t siANCIB and the Lori<'!o'l S5.gi.nt Ec.G:r:l :aoul& uO"t.~y e~'h .o·~l:ti.\ b;y lott:;r, o:r '4pprO't"1l.l ~in: ~'ien :;o the =e00::..:;e';:\tl.:\ti(JT'IA ~ th~ Cc-:lf'ere-"lc:?~
.!
........ ~-' ... '
;. ·. ~
DOCID: 2959299 REF ID:A2666693
•\;. . .. ;::.
-' / 4i •.
·. :~ .,
..\:~~f',.::
i. CCllti<'Ir:l.rfJ) · ;,;~);)~!!""""= .. !filill!§..]fJl@'j;_y Af!D .FINAJ, ~ _
QE._~.IBiT.~u~~~;-~~~~~!!:- _ ht:l1~ a1: 1C15 ¢n l'leal.1f.!s~r )[arc\1 ';f'al, '194~~""'.~-.._.-~'."''Hc.·~.--....., .. ...,.,.....
. ; .
... ~ . '
- ..... ,.. _ _...,._.._, ____ ,__ _ __._ ...... _, _____ ...,. __ . (
p RE s ENT:.
· : C~ptun Wenger· ... Captain Smetlburg ·. _ ~
. . .. ~-' . . ~·. \
. • . Mro. Huaille3on ·· ·. Mr. C1Izr'~~ .
; ' ~.;. . II , : ' ·,
-~··:'· - .. ~:-.!.t:·~··
· {~c~tarie~) OOlll!llD.tlder Uansoa llro Hinsley.
::. ~ -;· ._-....;..__·~~--- ... • ,..-t"r) . ~ f• ' • • • • . ' .... ·, :-. ~ )'-. : , • :-- , · • • ' ,, . •
, 1;;, •. , J: •... MINUTES OP SE'l.Et.'l'H MEET'nai. '··,-">f.' ·.--.' -., .. · <'~~•'.· ... ~.~ .. ;- '1.1~•; .. . . . : •' • •• ·\,.:..1,~. ~.- ...... _ ,,., ,' . . ....
;µ,: ~·}: ;fi~~i~<:. . ;1 ~ ~i; ... Wi ti1 refci-e~e· .to' par~'f -~.'the' a'.rart '1111nu'l:eS3: NJ;. HUttdlascn J:::.\~::r.;;;)j~g{<':;::;~d wllether the~oOtime~~i()t(ap.fol.d 'i~luae_ a '!'ltafe~.3il·~e
. .;.;:;r.,;«~/:o . ..'. :,,~':.•_;·,,,;:i~:/ .. : ., measu:re.:nen:t of the 1J.~.rQofillli to pe. m~ Wll.;fomly by .both Cent.£-e.,.
....
_,::. : __ .
·_, .. _::/. .. 1·_•.·-.... :_ .. :: .. :;.:~ .. -.· ... ·_ 0.-'.·,_·:~.·-.···; ·.This p. ctnt was discussed and it·W~&l,' ed to~ w o:'l""'.""' ,- o(J;. .......... ., ••'' • ·~ r ---- I -~ ·-":;;J.i.::··· ;<. · · in' tile recq=ndatioO. . It Was. i;icwever7 that both-pa;-ti.es -·
"·: . ·.,.., ;would investigate fti.e e-g,ui~nt at present in u.~ o.m1 oc-rre:;_pond ti; th.-;: .. , .• neax futµrfl with a View·~ _using ·eqµlpm.;nt of. uniform ai.M. , .•. •.. .. ~ ,.-.·: .... ! .::·· : .. ·'·t( .
. •·,: : ·· ..
. . 2n ·. A ·terr minor 'alta.rationa ere Jpade t~.: ~:.d~#t Mkutes~ l.'hi9h 11ere. then app:rt?Ved~ ; . ·: .,, ; : ·. :-.. \ . :
.APPENDIX Eo ... '· ..,:·
. -~~ . -'3. The COI!illi ttee. rext consideied tM ili..o;r pa...~1ilis a::•:\. the ai2:3:i ti.'.1::al Ex!-.~b114 cf Appendix E, ·and ~gadiei..::..1.£?~:. au.d C~o~<?l P.crr:e~ irere called in a.t t.'lis point. ·
4-o General -Ccrei:mn~n expressed the• vieW- that a TI?Ol"C· l'i.ef:'..ntt:;·
E.O. 12958, as amended Section 3.3(b)l, (b)(3), and (b)(6)
e.tll.'i;illl'.ent th'.!.n that gi.-en in EX.l-ii.bit l;. 'w•..ilC. b·~ o.<hi en1)lr,,. ~w.·::>
inietiYe had to .be taken in effecting; a di:1isioi.i c.f te.~k.·l a::1d tll.•: caml'l! Centres ~1112elves were 'best pla!:ecl to t al-:e ti":e f'irst l!tep~'· ~1r Efuio?.rd Travia a~~ed ;nth this vie-;v,.
5o l)rlgedier J'.!ltlll.a:.1 said that ~ :u:oi·e aefln.i..te st~tem!:nt '\rou.J.c1
·-=- · ..
; . < : . ~:
-·- ::.'
~.· ~.···
necesittate th~ omiasion ot para.E. 3 {b) ana (o) of E;::hfo:ii; 4. ooncern1ng divini.oo of ta.Bks on tl";".::-ii.c.; dei'inite oOtild be agreed on, tM8e pointa wi.thcu~ fu:r'br u·lu.;fy,. llo..--ewer, better' fi4'ld.s for tl•e alloc.a1;1.or. of 1:8.:;l;:s m~g.~.t be fo'.lr.d. when thi.s atw:,Y was c&rried out..
60 ~neral Conlemnn e.l!d Sir Erm.rd Tre.rls b.,·":h cor.·.si..dt~!·':(1 th-:d: i~;
1l'aB an urgent req_uir.raient t1it'""the nee;;~ i:W~?::!'::.i.":1.tion rih:::iltl b.:< o=ried ou~ at beth Centres; and. ViemJ e:x:changed e.s to taslro «hic11. should be le!"t to ona or the otl~r Centre,
7o ~adt~r Tilti?ta.~ said there were· resea..rch ta.lb i.n ·Rhich dinsic.n by al ation was riot desirable as t--,.ro hear.Ul u~ better th.Im ere, General Corderman however, sah't that this 'iJOuld. El.Ct 'be t;;-.;.e in oi.l~;.mm+.sr ·
/wh-ec.,. • • ••
DOCID: 2959299
I
I !
' . . __ _,
..
REF ID:A266669~
'£6? c.s:::.::-1 a: -::.1r ]fQrl"i.T\'E l:::..L".!'B
•'. . " \
· when aval.lo.ble pe,raom1el .f.n :et. ther Cent.re were iru..dequate to do all the neoeasary research, al thou,gh he aiireea lha.t the allooe.ti.on of tasl<:s would have to proceed elowl.;. ·
8. Colonel Rowlett ea.id he Yr!ll:l sure that by the tiroe 2 1111mthly status reports had been er.changed, ,n OOI\"•idorable econo.v pf ;>ersonnel would have been effeoted~ · ·
9. . . In view ~r .the above t!i~ous111o~ it na· n'.reed t~t (e.)-tl;le two CentrOSvrould uiiaertake: the. ne<Jesaa:cy lnv,teHga 1on of·~tasks lihioh would be undertaken aolelr by one centre or the other, effecting divilllon of of labour 1n this Tf#JY As early As pracUoo.bleJ but that {b) Eichibi.t 4 shoUld be anitted f'rom the ,Appmlilix. . . .
·' 10. . :A ~Qall' ckafti~ ch~.n,ge ..a.a;· ~d~ ln pa:ra..1' of the Appendix, which ire.a. ~~n. apprOTed. · - . · .. ·. · · . ·: '." • '. .. · . · ... · · • .. ·
COVERING p~;i ' ', ·> .. ',_ ..
·. '· ;;
_::,_.icoV'.ERrNG.LtTT.ER .~":,::;'>· ·· ·
"· > :;'!:~·:~!a~r:X.:~toilsse~ ~~-~~.'aeC::,,~ was 1rustruo~a t~ havci a
~.'.>~;-~ E.0. 12958, as amended .:t:_ff§ Section 3.3(b)l, (b)(3), and (b)(6) :.~ .... -~.::..J
-, ~~~;.!~
:;;. ...... ·-'.··;_,.
,. ;~'' '_·: ..... ..
-~. ; ,.
·:i-· '. "'.-
. . "·
'!'..
·.>
18. With r8!er:m'.:e 'to pe,n,_.2Q b. t:·!<:> p<1pe1•1 co:11:e1 rring t~,~: ·.-0r.~ .. l. exohange of' ro.vr tnat~rlal, lt..!'1-:J t.gr~e4 to 11,\1 th1.ct '\:!ti~ T.'C~•.L:: b~ ., .. ,._ t0 r: a.a· noon Bo toi: CMJ..l<'. be> arrau~C(,"'":°tn orTer to •\~"/.):' tt..i ;o;.nt l·~i:;.;;-·: ":-;;
~ Eo.~wr~~!:?. in fll\l'u., 1.1' abMc •
19 •
:.ry..~~. ' 20. Thio p!i.r~x-, c,oncerni.ng co·:>':dir~,tfon in Tl~•'ic L1B.~y~is_ and~
- was o.p~r.cyed,
. ,.
':DOCID: . ·r~.
'·.c,
i;rf;;-~IF f)-~)i.-li\::
_.,,, -.~.f;;<:tf;:
":·.L>·
''\~:A·'"• ,, . ~~- .
···.~·-· · ....
. ':..
2959299 J
,,
/"; ~·
.. ~_;: . . ' . }. ·.·
.-:: . ···4_ .. ;'.f . ;:~-{: 'i
-:i·_ ....
,.
REF ID:A266669~-
·J
' ··,·. I•; .....
, .... •· .. ~ I
,_1·
·.,,
£...~ . .!! 2~_., App3mll:i: P, oon0ern1na' the !=~ of Oom:nunicat1ons. Intell1genct l".".oC. C.e--ordinat1on 1n_ trarll!lat19~ ~··then. eoca1dere4o'. .. · . -
........ . ~ .
-. . ~· ",.
..
. '
:.~ :
·{ ~ ...
~--'>··
\ '
DOCID: 2959299
·.·~;;.L~:~\.;~:
'~·
-.;
REF ID:A2666693)
··.•.
.. '. . -~,
!I@TES CR PLERARI l!EF.'Tim 1'0 OONJJ.lJDB ,·J .. , .. ' -,l."· •
pm u.s.-mISH Troml!CAL CONJ!'ERENJE~ . . .
SLD AT 1600 cm~. KARoB 27'.1'1I, '19?t6. · '···.
'·
:··>~:; E.O. 12958, as amended . ; PRE s .E l'1 T:
~-,~~~~-~: Section 3.3(b)l (b)(3) and (b)(6) :7,->;:<;: · .. · , , · . :;: - .
,,,,·~~\ , , -'~w ·, •. l~~~""i~:-r·. ·,i{'~:t, ··,··;;;:1;;,~,,. i•·~ :. ; - :':;Captain. L. S.Bowoiih. , .. " ; · • ; . , . · .
......
...
.· .. _·;··
~"l·'
. .... f
·- .. ·· ' .. . : ..
• ; I·- .. ,! ;;,:4 ~;Ipitpt411\ E. S.L.GooclwiJ:l. ' . . . ' . . ; f. ; . ' .._ •• , . ··;,: .. ,,~; ·1';;~-,;..._,.,_;.._ E _._...;_ ., ' , .·· '-·t. ,.i":: c ':· '. . . '-"-1 -·.-r·.·'°". -~.:.-,-•tJVUHUdA:bQ,,l· ·~'"'er! .':. ·;. (:.,. i .. , .;; t(: ~ ·'1. ,,_ !·" 1: ,., - : t.;. ;~}p~ .. ")i.~i.'.i~~,i~;~.~0~-.,,:,;J· .. <\ ·.'' :.::_<::·'-:-~+L'. . . _ _,'.~:,_:'
~'\J'~·,.,.:,3 ?-~,"'l{..; -1\ .... t . . (r 01 ..,-•A"" ;,1;..i.i:r:. •• :., ... r~·-~ <;k:·-r~~ .... -. ~t · t~·
E.E.Bwl!hoiSCn •.
. :·:~).~:~~.·_::~~~.~:.~ ·:~~-~-.::.;:_~· ~(.. :~~-~- E,.~~~. ·. ·~ ;,- <.:!' . r • .'<"' : : : . . . : . . . .2
·,. -.~
•·• ·-;., ••. • I ',:··.::.
·-/;..-:· .. ~;·, .. ,,,,::::. /
.. • ·~ ;
-:•.
~; ,{{ -·
·'
.,_,,_ ..
.-; '
·. 1. ~ Chai~ asked for Wa;y :reaaiks Oil ·the fincl. araf'.1; o~ the ~- Ooverll>g ~ 8lid Jippelldj.oes prepared by th4 Oo.nforencc.
_2. ~ral Co:r&rman, tor this u.s. Il8logation1 and Ca~?:£~E1.~ · ft•, sou 8iid l!ir. ~. for t:he1r ~O'WI ~~i;i;1 e:c~-e-oscd. e;i.z- 8i'Pz::cmil fJf l&i' pa:pora. . . : . . ' . . . '.
,§1..r mwara Travis OQDOU1"t'ed on bchl.llf' ot tM ~ ~izh rep;eoon~at;i. v-.::.;;. ' . . -
4-. · 'file~ k.Pmaod his~. to tb.o·.usembled 111Ceti?l.G, oape~z=,n of Bub-ecm:.1-tteo.s, f'or their IJLWl;l-cJ.;_:iat".._~ll "-'' <1iscu.ssions which had l~ to llUClh il:lportrult ~Ml!!)nte beme11 the ~ oounf;riee.
5. ·Sir~ '!'re.vis thWed his U.S. aoll.,agues for oo:sin:.; te r.::n.i~.'~.'.l.
for the Coiifereme. Jfu-f'elt ~n tllL\t the Cont'ere.-noc had not i;<;;<;-;1 1:c.:<.(> too aoon. · 'Die bisbly aa.tis!'aotory ~nta ~ n:i; e timu whe::t eae.il ~'II 'cJt:m!i,stio Situation ns in a ebto ot tlux '701.il.d er.ell.re th.."'..t; l?i;e;?,1 taken t'rcm llCW 022 1D each OOUDt:ey' 'lllO\ild ~ in liPe with ~ho ZSt".Jt!1J:Cnte n~-:r
fta.ob.ed and 'll'OUld turt;her atrongtl'lell the oolle.born:!d.Oi'l much WM £'.0 i';,.,,.-;il..y eatabliahed. ' •
. '
.DOCID: 2959299
,· ':"".-~~··';::··~.·::-:~-- ·~----
~;.L~~:±J~'!·;Li.·: .. ~~~r._.-.. -. :_ ... # •4~~~~- -; .. r-,~,_. Y.'lo·. >-- ' . • "'.,::;~':"\-~~;.-'· ,,,
..... •:.f :11··r,W.,:,- •:.,. ""••">. ~· -'_,;;•.f'J'
·:.·.· . •!!, •"w,.
......... •_;,_;
. ·.1
/,_· -~' . ,: r J'. ~· • . ~· .
. •· r i
REF ID:A266669~
·,. r (
. ~ ·. , ,,_. '•·' ~. :' -!
2 ·-
.,
•.· .. . ;._
\