determinants of saving among the zambian middle...
TRANSCRIPT
i
___________________________________________
Determinants of saving among the Zambian middle class:
The banking employees’ perspective
A research report presented to:
The Graduate School of Business
University of Cape Town
In partial fulfillment of the requirements of the
Masters of Business Administration Degree
By John Chundu
February 2017
Supervisor: Dr Abdul Alhassan
Copyright UCT
ii
Plagiarism Declaration
1. I know that plagiarism is wrong. Plagiarism is to use another’s work and pretend that it
is one’s own.
2. I have used the APA convention for citation and referencing. Each contribution to, and
quotation in, this submission from the work(s) of other people has been attributed, cited and
referenced.
3. I certify that this submission is my own work.
4. I have not allowed, and will not allow, anyone to copy my work with the intention of
passing it off as his or her own work.”
Date: February 2017
Student Name: John Chundu
Exam no. 821
Copyright UCT
iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Someone once said, “Life should not be a journey to the grave with the intention of arriving
safely in a pretty and well preserved body. Rather, to skid in broadside in a cloud of smoke
thoroughly used up, totally worn out and loudly proclaiming ‘Wow! What a ride!!’”. This
is how I feel at the end of my MBA journey - thoroughly used up and totally worn out!
However, I leave the MBA a more confident, energised and stronger person than when I
started. I would not have completed this journey (which I have, by the way, thoroughly
enjoyed!) without the help and support of many people.
I would like to express my gratitude to my supervisor, Abdul Latif Alhassan, for sharing his
knowledge and continued input during the course of this research.
I wish to acknowledge my appreciation to my fellow MBA modular class of 2015/2016
especially my syndicate group and to Mary Lister and Michele Snyders at GSB for their
support and assistance in various ways to make my journey a success.
Special thanks go to my beautiful wife Mika and the children: Natasha, Zewelanji and Lusa
including my nephew Bupe for their encouragement, sacrifice and prayers in the last two
years.
Lastly, I am grateful to God for enabling me undertake this journey.
Copyright UCT
iv
ABSTRACT
The purpose of this study was investigate whether financial literacy, availability of credit or
ethnic / cultural background were factors pertinent to sustaining and increasing saving
among the Zambian banking employees or not. This is in recognition of the importance that
saving plays in the economic development of a given country and the apparent sluggish
growth of saving among individuals and households in Zambia. The study employed a
questionnaire as a tool for collection of data from 100 employees within the banking
industry.
In analysing these factors, a statistical analysis software tool called Megastat v11.0 was used
to run regressions and test hypotheses relevant to the study. The study found that financial
literacy was a factor influencing saving behaviour while availability of credit and ethnic /
cultural background were not. The findings will help policy makers, bankers and investment
managers to design interventions that encourage saving through fiscal policy formulation,
introduction of innovative saving products and access to saving and investment information.
Copyright UCT
v
GLOSSARY OF TERMS
Gross national savings (GNS) ratio - an indicator of how much a country saves and is
calculated by deducting the country’s final consumption expenditure from gross national
disposable income (which consists of personal and household savings, business savings and
government savings but excludes foreign saving) expressed as a percent of gross domestic
product (CIA, 2016).
Household – a group of persons who eat and live together and may comprise of several
members or in some cases, only one member (Central Statistical Office, 2016).
Middle class - an ambiguous social classification, broadly reflecting the ability to lead a
comfortable life. The middle class usually enjoy stable housing, healthcare and educational
opportunities (including college) for their children, reasonable retirement and job security,
and discretionary income that can be spent on vacation and leisure pursuits (Kharas, 2010.
p.7).
Saving – residual between income and current consumption (Browning and Lusardi, 1996.
p.1798).
Savings – accumulated value of past saving sometimes referred to as wealth (Blanchard &
Sheen, 2009. p.663)
Copyright UCT
vi
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PLAGIARISM DECLARATION II
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS III
ABSTRACT IV
GLOSSARY OF TERMS V
TABLE OF CONTENTS VI
LIST OF TABLES IX
LIST OF FIGURES IX
CHAPTER ONE 1
1 INTRODUCTION 1
1.1 CONTEXT OF THE STUDY 1
1.1.1 PROBLEM STATEMENT 5
1.2 JUSTIFICATION OF THE RESEARCH 6
1.3 RESEARCH QUESTIONS 8
1.5 LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY 8
1.6 ASSUMPTIONS 9
1.7 ETHICS 10
1.8 ORGANIZATION OF THE THESIS 11
CHAPTER TWO 12
2 LITERATURE REVIEW 12
2.1 INTRODUCTION 12
2.2 DEFINITIONS 12
2.3 THEORETICAL FRAMEWORKS OF SAVING 13
2.4 EVIDENCE OF SAVING FROM LITERATURE 14
2.4.1 INFLUENCE OF CULTURAL FACTORS ON SAVING BEHAVIOUR 14
2.4.2 CULTURAL FACTORS 14
2.4.3 PROPOSITION 1 16
2.4.4 ROLE OF FINANCIAL LITERACY IN SAVING 16
2.4.5 FINANCIAL LITERACY 16
2.4.6 PROPOSITION 2 18
2.4.7 EFFECT OF CREDIT AVAILABILITY 18
2.4.8 CREDIT AVAILABILITY 18
Copyright UCT
vii
2.4.9 PROPOSITION 3 20
2.5 CONCLUSION OF LITERATURE REVIEW 21
2.5.1 PROPOSITION 1: 21
2.5.2 PROPOSITION 2: 21
2.5.3 PROPOSITION 3: 21
CHAPTER THREE 22
3 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY 22
3.1 INTRODUCTION 22
3.2 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY / PARADIGM 22
3.3 RESEARCH DESIGN 24
3.4 STUDY POPULATION AND SAMPLE 26
3.4.1 POPULATION 26
3.4.2 SAMPLE AND SAMPLING METHOD 26
3.5 THE RESEARCH INSTRUMENT 28
3.6 PROCEDURE FOR DATA COLLECTION 29
3.7 DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION 31
3.8 CONSISTENCY MATRIX 32
CHAPTER FOUR 35
4 RESEARCH FINDINGS, DISCUSSION AND INTERPRETATION 35
4.1 INTRODUCTION 35
4.2 OBJECTIVE 1 36
4.3 OBJECTIVE 2 41
4.4 OBJECTIVE 3 48
CHAPTER FIVE 53
5 RESEARCH CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION 53
5.1 INTRODUCTION 53
5.2 CULTURAL FACTORS AND SAVING 53
5.3 FINANCIAL LITERACY AND SAVING 54
5.4 CREDIT AVAILABILITY AND SAVING 54
5.5 RECOMMENDATIONS 54
5.6 PROPOSED FUTURE RESEARCH 55
Copyright UCT
viii
REFERENCES 56
APPENDICES 61
APPENDIX A: ETHICS CLEARANCE 61
APPENDIX B: NOTICE TO RESPONDENTS 62
APPENDIX C: INSTRUCTIONS FOR DISTRIBUTION OF QUESTIONNAIRE 63
APPENDIX D: RESEARCH INSTRUMENT 64
Copyright UCT
ix
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1: Comparative summary of qualitative and quantitative research approaches……23
Table 2: Banking employees per occupational category and by province………………..27
Table 3: Profile of respondents…………………………………………………………....27
Table 4: Results from the pilot test of questionnaire…………………….………………..28
Table 5: Survey delivery platforms……….………………………………………………30
Table 6: Consistency matrix…………..…………..…………………………………….…33
Table 7: Paired observations - saving when growing up and currently save………………39
Table 8: Regression analysis - Discuss money with kids………………………………….40
Table 9: Paired observations for hypothesis 2 under simulation 1……………………..…43
Table 9: Paired observations for hypothesis 2 under simulation 2…………………..……44
Table 11: Mean vs hypothesized value…………………………………………………...51
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1: Gross national savings ratio and gross domestic product movements from 1980
to 2015…………………………………………..………………………………………….3
Figure 2: Relationship between savings, budget deficit or surplus and economic growth ..4
Figure 3: Individual & household savings as a component of total savings ....…….……...6
Figure 4: Household debt and personal saving rate…………………….………………....19
Figure 5: The Survey process……………………………………………………..………25
Figure 6: Province from where respondent comes from…………………………………..36
Figure 7: Regression between province and saving behaviour……………………………37
Figure 8: Regression between growing up and currently save……………………………..38
Figure 9: Regression between last expenditure knowledge and saving……………………41
Figure 10: Regression between budget skills and saving account…………………………42
Figure 11: Q 17 Interest rate - Numeracy………………………………………………….45
Figure 12: Q 18 Inflation…………………………………………………………………..46
Figure 13: Q 19 Risk diversification………………………………………………………47
Figure 14: Regression between credit availability and saving…………………………….48
Figure 15: Regression between high debt service ratio and saving………………………..49
Figure 16: Responses to whether access to credit hinders saving or not…………………..50
Copyright UCT
- 1 -
CHAPTER ONE
1 INTRODUCTION
This chapter sets the context under which the phenomenon being investigated is found. It
discusses the motives and importance of saving. The problem statement, research questions
and objectives including the justification and limitations of the study are also explored. The
chapter concludes by looking at the assumptions made and ethical issues surrounding the
study. The structure of the thesis is also outlined in this chapter.
1.1 Context of the study
The Republic of Zambia is a landlocked, resource rich country in Southern Africa with
massive mineral endowments and agricultural potential. It is geographically large and
sparsely populated with 15.5 million people. It has capitalised on these factors and is now a
lower middle-income country that experienced robust growth in the past decade. It was
among the 10 fastest growing economies in Sub Sahara Africa in 2012 (Central Statistical
Office, 2016; De La Fuente, Murr & Rascon, 2015).
Zambia inherited a free economy and a multi-party political system at the time of its
independence from Britain in October 1964. At the time, it was a relatively wealth country
with gross domestic product per capita of US$238 compared to that of South Korea which
stood at US$120 (World Bank, 2016a; 2016b). However, in 1969, Zambia nationalised or
acquired a major stake in all foreign owned companies in the so-called Mulungushi
economic reforms. This effectively introduced a mixed type of economy where the state and
the private sector were all participants in the economy. While the private sector was free to
be involved in the running of the economy, the State was a major player in the running of
the economy through state owned enterprises. The introduction of a one party state system
of government in 1972 followed the Mulungushi economic reforms. With no opposition
parties or politically active civil society groups to provide checks and balances to
Government’s management of national economic and political affairs, the economic
fortunes began to deteriorate. By 1990, South Korea GDP per capita stood at US$6642
surpassing that of Zambia’s which was at USD$404 clearly indicating the different paths
taken by the two respective countries towards their political and economic development
Copyright UCT
- 2 -
(World Bank, 2016a; 2016b). This deterioration led to increased political activism in the
country culminating in the re-introduction of multiparty politics and free economy in 1991.
The State privatised most of the state owned companies and opened up the economy. After
implementing an austerity economic programme recommended by the International
Monetary Fund (IMF), the country’s economy began to grow. From a negative growth of -
13.1% in 1994, the country has been on an upward growth trajectory save for 1998 when
the country registered a negative economic growth of -0.4 (figure 1). Average annual growth
between 2001 and 2012 was about 6%. The growth has somewhat tempered in light of a
recent slump in the copper prices, Zambia’s main foreign exchange earner with the economy
growing by 3.5% in 2015.
Underpinning this economic performance has been the emergence and growth of the
Zambian middle class. This economic growth has enabled unprecedented public and private
infrastructure development in roads, hospitals, schools, housing and shopping malls to take
place. Up and until 2008, Zambia depended on the Brentwood institutions (IMF and World
Bank) for financing most of her public infrastructure development. However, since the last
programme ended in 2011, the country has been funding a large part of its public
infrastructure from domestic borrowing and lately, in the last 3 years, from issuance of
sovereign bonds. So far, two bonds have been issued amounting to US3 billion. However,
financing of public infrastructure through external borrowing as the case has been by
issuance of sovereign bonds has exposed the country to vagaries of external economic
factors outside the control of the country.
As alluded to earlier, domestic and external borrowing has been financing both private and
public infrastructure. Domestic borrowing has been possible due to the increasing national
savings in the last decade as measured by the GNS ratio. A negative GNS ratio indicates
that the overall economy is spending more income than it earns, thereby drawing down
national wealth (dis-saving) while a positive number is a good indicator of the general
financial wellbeing of the economy in terms of its ability to deal with internal and external
uncertainties without having to borrow for consumption. There was a meteorite increase in
the GNS ratio in Zambia during the period 2001 to 2015. As seen in figure 1, the GNS ratio
increased from about 3.2% in 2001 to 31.1% in 2015 reaching a peak of 41.3% in 2006 just
before the eruption of the 2007/8 financial crisis. GNS ratio dropped to 26.3% in 2008,
Copyright UCT
- 3 -
before returning to around 38.3% in 2011. Since then, the ratio has been fluctuating between
31 – 37% ranges. Compared to many developing countries, Zambia is still among the top
savers. According to Economic Watch (2016), Zambia was 21st on the world rankings in
saving in 2015 at 31.1% while the average world GNS value for the same period was 17.5%.
Fig. 1. Gross national savings ratio and gross domestic product movements from 1980 to2015. Source:
International Monetary Fund, World Economic Outlook Database, April 2016 and Author’s own
computations.
Importance of saving
Saving has been an area of interest to economists since economics was organised and
recognised as a science given the role it plays in the economic development of a nation.
Most literature on saving however, can be traced back to 1950s with work done by Solow
and Swan where they showed the interrelationship between savings, capital formation,
technological progress and economic growth (Blanchard & Sheen, 2009). Other works
include the Life Cycle hypothesis and Permanent Income hypothesis propounded by Franco
Modigliani and Richard Brumberg and Milton Friedman respectively (Browning & Lusardi,
1996; Friedman, 1957). Kazmi and Bilquees (1993) argue that... “Savings provide the most
important economic link between the past, present and future of a country. An adequate rate
of national saving is regarded as an essential condition for achieving targets in the
-20
-10
0
10
20
30
40
50
1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020
%
YEAR
GNS % GDP % growth (at constant prices)Copyright UCT
- 4 -
investment and growth” (p1313). Savings are used for domestic investments, which in turn
impacts economic growth. Posner and Bovbjerg (1995) illustrate this relationship in figure
2 in their study of the impact of USA national budget deficit on savings in which they argued
that deficits in the end affect economic development where such deficits are financed by
private savings thereby negatively affecting private investments, which are key to long-term
economic development.
Figure 2: Relationship between savings, budget deficit or surplus and economic growth
Adapted from “Budget Policy and The Long Run Future” by P.L. Posner and B.D. Bovbjerg,1995,
In Proceedings of the Annual Conference on Taxation Held under the Auspices of the National Tax
Association-Tax Institute of America p. 72
Later studies, such as the one conducted by Cohn and Kolluri (2003), buttress this argument
by stating that…“saving is the ultimate source of physical capital formation and plays a
fundamental role in determining the “wealth of the nation” (p.1199). The importance of
savings in the economic growth / development of a given country, however, remains a hotly
debated issue among economists and scholars. While most of them acknowledge that there
is a positive link between national savings and economic growth, the causality issue is far
for settled (de Laiglesia & Morrison, 2008).
Households are responsible for a substantial part of the saving in both industrial and
developing countries (Schmidt-Hebbel, Webb & Corsetti, 1992). Households play a key role
in capital formation and economic development through savings. Various studies
investigating variables that may affect household savings have been conducted over time.
According to Jongwanich (2010), there is correlation between economic growth and
increase in household savings. As the economy grows, an increase in household savings
rises reflecting better economic conditions that may entail more disposable income.
Non-federal savings
Federal deficit / surplus
Private investment
GDP National savings
Capital (plant & equipment)
Productivity
Labour
Copyright UCT
- 5 -
Without increased savings, the country will resort to external borrowing that will make the
country vulnerable to external financial and economic shocks. For example, an increase in
the lending interest rates in external borrowings may result in an increase in the loan
repayments leading to a reduction in resources available for other investments. The higher
the GNS ratio the less vulnerable the country is to external financial and economic shocks.
Countries that have demonstrated sustained economic growth, as the case is with South
Korea, can also be shown to have relatively high GNS ratios indicating that sustainable GNS
ratio is correlated to sustainable economic growth (Jongwanich, 2010). GNS for South
Korea has averaged 32.5% for the period from 1980 to 2015 (World Bank, 2016a). A
country’s GNS ratio, in relation to other countries, can act as a barometer for measuring
economic growth (Obi, Wafure, & Menson, 2012).
Motives for saving
Individuals and households have different motive for saving. According to Kasilingam &
Jayabal (2011), however, there are four saving motives emphasised by neo-classical
economists. These include “the desire 1) to maintain consumption in the face of income
fluctuations, particularly during retirement; 2) to prepare for income shocks and other
emergencies (precautionary saving); 3) to transfer wealth to future generations (bequest
motive); and 4) to purchase consumer durables and to spend for children education and
vacation (target saving)” (p.68). The ability to save is a function of one’s income and
willingness to save. InterMedia (2016) citing a Zambia 2015 Finscope study on financial
inclusion found that Zambians perceive savings as of critical importance and save to afford
their needs, and as a reserve when in need of emergency funds. Despite the perceived
importance however, the study found that Zambians have difficulties to make ends meet and
may not often have any additional income at the end of a month though they do not fall
completely behind on expenses.
1.1.1 Problem Statement
Personal and household savings are not growing at a rate that would sustain the economic
development the nation aspires to achieve. While the GNS ratio for Zambia has been rising,
personal and household savings, which is part of the components used in the calculation of
GNS ratio, has not been growing in proportionate to the overall growth as seen in figure 3
Copyright UCT
- 6 -
and the underlying causes contributing to this need to investigation. Individual and
household savings as a percentage of total savings stood at 27% in 2005. By the end of 2015,
the contribution of individual and household savings to total savings had plummeted to
19.5%. According to the World Bank (2016b), the GNS ratio for Zambia stood at 31% in
2015 but projected to decline to 26% in 2016 indicating the need for the country to sustain
or increase the GNS ratio. However, in a country where 54.4% of the population lives below
the poverty line (Central Statistical Office, 2016), it is questionable whether the country can
sustain the current levels of GNS ratio.
Figure 3: Individual & household savings as a component of total savings
Source: Bank of Zambia (2016) and Author’s own computations
The middle class of any society plays a key role in the economic development of its society
(Kharas, 2010). With the steady growth of the Zambian economy over the last decade, a
robust middle class has emerged of which banking employees are part. It is critical therefore,
to understand the determinants of saving amongst this segment of the middle class.
1.2 Justification of the Research
This study is significant in two ways. In the first instance, the study would help policy
makers, bankers and investment managers to design interventions that:
0
5000
10000
15000
20000
25000
30000
35000
40000
45000
50000
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
ZM
W' M
illio
ns
Individual & Household Savings Total Savings
Copyright UCT
- 7 -
Can help in sustaining or increasing the GNS ratio through fiscal policy formulation
and introduction of innovative products
Encourage accessibility to savings and investment information.
Change people’s cultural perspectives, customs and behaviours by making savings
and investments desirable.
In order to design policies to promote investments and saving, it is imperative to understand
determinants to saving. The study was aimed at investigating whether or not identified
variables or factors were pertinent to sustaining and increasing savings among the Zambian
middle class for sustained economic growth. In this context, it is investigative research.
In the second instance, this study was meant to contribute to the body of knowledge in the
focus area of this study. While there is abundant literature on the subject for other countries
or groups of countries, there has been a dearth of literature in the case of Zambia. There are
few studies sighted by this researcher on this subject. One report was for the period from
1998 to 2004 that investigated whether interest rates, income and inflation were variables
that influenced national savings or not. This is the period when the country experienced
declining personal and household savings. These studies, however, found that the three
variables were not correlated (Mususu, 2006).
In another study, Maimbo and Mavrotas (2008) identified foreign exchange liberalisation,
HIV/Aids pandemic, absence of rural financial savings institutions, parastatal sector
reforms, poor state of economy, bank closures during the period from 1995 to 1998 and
increase in property for private and commercial purposes as factors affecting savings
mobilisation in Zambia. However, these factors may not apply in the current environment
given the strides recorded in the social, economic and financial spheres of the Zambian
society. For example, the HIV Aids pandemic has largely been contained and HIV Aids
prevalence rates are declining while public sector reforms have abated since the last IMF
program ended in 2011. The Zambian economy has also shown steady growth in the last ten
years.
Copyright UCT
- 8 -
1.3 Research questions
The research sought to answer the following primary question: “What are the determinants
of saving among the Zambian banking employees?” Literature review suggested that
among the various factors that influence individual and household saving was culture,
financial literacy and credit availability. These factors were examined to see if they were
determinants of saving among Zambian banking employees. The following sub questions/
statements were critical in helping to answer the primary question of the research:
1. Is the saving culture (a habit of saving one’s income) a function of one’s cultural
upbringing?
2. Is there a relationship between financial literacy and saving?
3. Is credit availability a hindrance to saving?
1.4 Research objectives
The main objective of the study was to examine the determinants of saving among banking
employees in Zambia. Based on the research questions, the objectives included;
1. To examine the effect of ethnic background on saving behaviour of Zambian
banking employees.
2. To assess the relationship between financial literacy and saving.
3. To examine the effect of credit availability on saving.
1.5 Limitations of the study
Savings is a broad economic activity. Domestic savings comprise of Government, corporate
and personal/household savings. The scope of the research only covered personal and
household savings. Government and corporate savings were not in the scope of the research.
Further, given that the GNS ratio is derived from what is captured in the country’s official
accounting books, the research was restricted to formal savings as in the form of bank
deposits. Informal savings did not form part of the study.
The research focused on the determinants of saving among the Zambian middle class. The
key focus area within the middle class category was the banking employees. Only Zambia
banking employees were included in the study. Non - Zambia banking employees were
excluded. Further, the research was conducted among banking employees working within
Copyright UCT
- 9 -
Lusaka City and as such may not be representative of the entire banking employee
population. However, considering that most studies on saving to some extent is affected by
inaccurate or lack of data, it was apparent that focusing on one specific sub segment of the
population located within a particular geographical area, could be of great help in
understanding the complex relationship between saving rate and its determinants (Ozcan,
Gunay & Ertac, 2003).
Other limitations to this research included the following situations:
1. Limited time within which to complete the research, which may lead to inaccurate or
wrong findings. This was mitigated by limiting the sample size and targeting a
population that has adequate understanding of the phenomenon being investigated.
2. Where there was non-response from some participants or where they were not willing
to participate in the study and therefore not being able to get representative set of data
from which conclusions could be drawn. This limitation was mitigated by targeting a
bigger sample than would have been required for this research.
3. Researcher’s bias. This limitation was mitigated by ensuring that the questionnaire was
tested on a pilot basis before being applied to the study sample.
4. Non-probability sampling approach adopted making the sample to be non-
representative. This limitation was mitigated by :
Taking samples from 14 out of 18 banks operating in the country.
Adopting a stratified approach by taking samples from different categories of
staff. For the purposes of this research, three categories of staff were identified
namely: clerical, managerial and executive staff. Further, the questionnaire was
distributed across a wide spectrum of staff in each category (operations, sales,
finance etc.) to avoid the possibility of having respondents from the same unit
1.6 Assumptions
The following assumptions were made in relation to the research.
1. By focusing on banking employees to study the phenomenon, it was assumed that
the participants had sufficient knowledge and understanding of financial and
economic fundamentals in the market/economy for them to be able to clearly
articulate answers to questions posed to them.
Copyright UCT
- 10 -
2. Since the study was limited to the banking employees within Lusaka City, the sample
was not fully representative of the banking staff population. However, by choosing
a sample from the country’s capital city that interacts and serves a diverse customer
base, they held rich information about the phenomena I was investigating and it was
assumed that their responses to survey questions would be representative of the
population being studied.
3. Ethnic groupings from one province / region of the country were assumed to
culturally homogenous due to their proximity to each other.
1.7 Ethics
University of Cape Town stipulates that all research involving human subjects be evaluated
and approved by Commerce Faculty Ethics in Research Committee prior to collection of
data to ensure that the researcher was in ethical compliance with regard to their study. The
research proposal was evaluated and approved by the University’s committee and an
approval letter can be found under Appendix A. Ethical considerations were looked at from
various angles of responsibility to which the researcher has ethical obligations – society,
environment, subjects and practice of science. One ethical consideration was the danger of
disclosure of subject’s personal and organisational data in the process of collection of data.
The researcher paid close attention to the research instrument and the structure of data
collection methods to ensure that such danger was mitigated. Data was masked so that it did
not reveal who the respondent was.
Another ethical consideration made at the beginning of data collection was on the use of
paper in the production of reports and disseminating the research instrument. It is a known
fact that trees are used to manufacture paper and that trees are critical in the reduction of the
carbon footprint. Consideration was made to cut use of paper to the minimum by utilising
electronic means of data collection and storage of reports. However, due to the slow
response rate experienced in receiving data electronically, about 50% of the data was
collected through physical distribution of the questionnaire which method saw an
improvement in the response rate.
Copyright UCT
- 11 -
Consideration was also made not to use deception or manipulation in conducting the study
or during collection of data. There was a temptation of not informing respondents of their
right to consent or refuse to participate in the study during data collection for fear of not
getting the anticipated sample size. However, respondents were notified through an
introduction letter accompanying the survey instrument as to their rights in relation to this
study. (See Appendix B).
1.8 Organization of the thesis
The research is be structured as follows.
Chapter 1 deals with the introduction or background context within which the study is set.
It will discuss the purpose of the study, the importance and motives of saving and the main
problem the study is trying to address. This chapter will further discuss the research
questions, limitation to the study, assumptions and ethics associated with the study and a
definition of terms used in the study.
Chapter 2 will discuss the theoretical framework of saving and results of the literature
review conducted on the following determinants of saving: availability of credit, cultural
factors and financial literacy.
Chapter 3 discusses methodology adopted to conduct the research. This includes a
discussion of research design, population and sample sampling methods and research
instrument used and procedure for data collection.
Chapter 4 analyses the data collected and the findings. The analysis of data will be
accompanied by a discussion of the findings.
Chapter 5 will conclude, make recommendations and suggest future research. References
and appendices will follow chapter 5.
Copyright UCT
- 12 -
CHAPTER TWO
2 LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Introduction
This chapter surveys literature in individual and household savings to determine whether
cultural factors, financial literacy and availability of credit are determinants of saving
behaviour among Zambian banking employees. It will cover areas such as the definitions
relevant to the topic; determinants of savings and summary of literature review.
2.2 Definitions
Browning and Lusardi (1996) define saving as “simply the residual between income and
current consumption” (p.1798). Blanchard & Sheen (2009) differentiate the various types
of saving by stating that saving is a sum of private and public saving. Private saving is saving
by consumers comprising of individuals, households, corporates or firms and is equal to
income minus taxes and expenditure. Public saving is residual of taxes minus government
expenditure. The main thrust of this study was about private saving and in particular,
individual and household saving. The definition of saving for purposes of this study is that
adopted by Browning and Lusardi (1996): the residual between income and expenditure for
individuals and households. The definition adopted provides an easy and simple
understanding of an otherwise complex topic.
Expanding further on the definition by Browning and Lusardi, Chauke (2012) posits that
saving is a long-term or short-term decision about what to do with residual income after
expenditure and that it is a function of income, expenditure, tax, interest rates, inflation, the
banking system, family structure, investment opportunities and political stability.
F(S) = {Y, E, T, ir, r, Bs, Fs, I, Ps}
Where; Y=Income, E=Expenditure, T=Tax Rate, ir=Interest rate, r=Inflation, Bs=Banking
System, Fs=Family Structure, I=Investment Opportunities and Ps=Political Stability.
Copyright UCT
- 13 -
2.3 Theoretical frameworks of saving
There are two most well-known theories of private saving (Uremadu, 2009). The first one
is the Permanent Income Hypothesis (PIH) propounded by Friedman (1957) where he
explored the relationship between consumption and income. Friedman theorised that income
comprised of two components: permanent and transitory, where permanent income
consisted of factors an individual or household regards as sources of wealth and transitory
income being other income acquired by chance or accident hence not permanent. Similarly,
consumption comprised of permanent and transitory consumption where the permanent
component consisted of factors that were permanent in nature such as rent or food and
transitory component being consumption specific to a particular individual or household
such as an unusual illness or an opportunity to make a specific purchase. He further proposed
that transitory income by its very nature (chance or accidental income) does not have an
impact on consumption. Meghir (2004) sums up the basic hypothesis posited by Friedman
by stating, “Individuals consume a fraction of this permanent income in each period and
thus the average propensity to consume would equal the marginal propensity to consume.
The propensity itself could vary with a number of factors, including the interest rate and
taste shifter variables, or could reflect uncertainty” (p.294). Consumers base their
consumption habits on long-term view of an income measure and may borrow to meet
immediate consumption needs in anticipation of future income (Meghir, 2004).
Understanding income and consumption patterns of individuals or households has
implications on saving.
The second one is Life Cycle Model (LCM). The life cycle model of consumption originally
proposed by Modigliani and Blumberg (1954) and Ando and Modigliani (1963) is the
dominant framework in economics for analysing aggregate consumption and saving
behaviour (Palumbo, 1999). LCM is modelled built around the consumption / savings
behaviour of the householder. According to Ando and Modigliani (1963), householders
spread their lifetime consumption over their lives by accumulating savings during earning
years and maintaining consumption levels during retirement. Age structure is likely to
influence income as during childhood period, the householder earns less money but
consumes relatively large amount of goods thereby saving less in this period. The
householder saving becomes positive as householder grows and reaches a certain age but
Copyright UCT
- 14 -
becomes a dis-saver once he retires and, income drops to a level below consumption. This
implies that over and above income and real interest rates, savings behaviour can vary
systematically from individual to individual according to age structure. In summary,
according to Jongwanich (2010), “the basic LCM model postulates that the savings
behaviour of the householder is determined by current income (Y), income growth (GY),
real interest rates (r) and population structure (P)” (p.968). This is illustrated in the following
equation:
S = f(Y,GY,r,P)
Saving (S) is a function of Y, GY, r and P. An increase in the Y and GY variables tend to
increase private saving while the effect of r is inconclusive (Jongwanich, 2010). The effects
of P have been alluded to above.
2.4 Evidence of saving from literature
2.4.1 Influence of cultural factors on saving behaviour
Literature suggests that cultural factors can affect someone’s saving behaviour. There is
need to investigate whether this phenomenon exists among Zambian banking employees as
a determinant of saving.
2.4.2 Cultural factors
Among several definitions of culture, Telleria (2015) defines culture as “a set of values,
principles and standards shaping and conditioning our behaviour, usually biased towards
the existence of tradition” (p.257). In seeking to understand social phenomena like low
saving rates, Shepherd and Stephens (2010) argue that one needs to pay attention to the role
of culture. They posit that “an integrated cultural approach that considers the ongoing
interdependence between the behaviour and psychological processes of the individuals and
their sociocultural context is essential for social scientists who seek to explain behaviour
like low saving rates and for policy makers who seek to design interventions to change
behaviours” (p.353). Gatina (2014) notes that cultural diversity can play a key role in
Copyright UCT
- 15 -
explaining the level of saving in a country. This is because as people move from place to
place, they carry along with them customs and traditions from their place of origin that may
affect their behaviours including that of saving.
To explain international disparities in saving rates, cultural effects has been one of the
variables that suggested accounting for such disparities (Carroll, Rhee & Rhee, 1994).
However, there are difficulties associated with testing a hypothesis premised on national
culture using cross-country aggregate data, as it (culture) is an unobservable variable
(Carroll et al., 1994).
According to studies conducted by Carroll et al (1994) on immigrants to Canada, they found
no evidence to support the view that cultural effects are a determinant in saving rates across
countries. Their study examined whether cultural factors have any influence on the saving
behaviour by comparing saving habits of migrants to Canada from countries with different
saving rates. However, they admit that their findings may be inconclusive as data used only
reported the immigrants’ place of origin in broad terms and the sample size was small.
Other studies appear to support the view that culture affects saving rates. In a study of
immigrants to United Arab Emirates conducted by Al-Awad and Elhiraika (2003) using
household survey data covering 3206 households, they found that migrants from India and
Pakistan in particular had higher saving rates in comparison to others despite having
relatively low incomes. This finding suggests that saving behaviour may vary across
migrants from different places of origin. Perhaps what could help in understanding this
finding is that Al-Awad and Elhiraika (2003) studies departed from those by Caroll et al
(1994) and others in a number of ways. Firstly, they used a large sample (3206 households);
secondly, migrants come to UAE for finding a job and accumulating savings. Thirdly, there
is little or no assimilation between migrants and nationals. This researcher, however,
disagrees with the conclusion of Al-Awad and Elhiraika. By their own admission that
migrants come to UAE to find a job and accumulate savings, one can argue that the increase
in saving is due to precautionary motives than to cultural factors.
In a recent study conducted in Australia, Gatina (2014) found evidence that cultural effects
affected saving rates. Data from the Household, Income and Labour Dynamics in Australia
(HILDA) Survey to obtain personal characteristics of individuals and country data from the
Copyright UCT
- 16 -
World Development Indicators of the World Bank was used for this study. The study
examined determinants of household saving rates of Australian residents and whether a
difference exists in saving behaviour between Australian-born and foreign-born individuals.
Further, sampling was restricted to immigrants to test whether a home-country effect existed
on their saving habits. The study then compared the saving rates of immigrants to the saving
rate in their respective home country. This examination revealed that immigrants in
Australia save less in comparison to their native-born counterparts.
2.4.3 Proposition 1
Ethnic or cultural background of individuals or households affects saving behaviour.
2.4.4 Role of financial literacy in saving
It is important to examine the role of financial literacy as an enabler or disabler of saving if
action is required to make any interventions necessary to promote a saving culture.
2.4.5 Financial Literacy
The importance of financial literacy in saving or financial behaviour is available in literature
(Huston, 2010; Beckmann, 2013; Klapper, Lusardi & Panos, 2013). The mortgage crisis,
high household bankruptcy rates and consumer over indebtedness experienced in the recent
economic recession have catapulted financial literacy to prominence to a point where it has
the attention of public policy makers (Huston, 2010). After recognising the absence of a
definite definition of financial literacy, Huston (2010) defines it as…. “Measuring how well
an individual can understand and use personal finance-related information” (p.306).
Although financial literacy and financial knowledge is used interchangeably, Huston (2010)
argues that there is a difference stating that “financial knowledge is an integral dimension
of, but not equivalent to, financial literacy” (p.307).
In order to make sound financial decisions, financial literacy is an important component of
this process (Lusardi, Mitchell & Curto, 2010). Knowledge on banking products, interest
rates and other financial instruments can help boost savings. However, knowledge of
savings and investments was low in some studies conducted (Lachance & Cloutier, 2009;
Copyright UCT
- 17 -
Tang & Peter, 2015) hence the need for financial education. To test knowledge of basic but
fundamental financial concepts, there are three questions asked for this purpose (Lusardi et
al., 2010). The first two questions test the knowledge about inflation and interest to see if
one possesses basic financial numeracy while the third evaluates one’s knowledge of risk
diversification, a crucial factor in making an informed investment decision.
Lachance & Cloutier (2009) undertook a study to evaluate young adults’ knowledge,
practices and attitudes towards savings and investments by sampling 966 young adults in
the province of Quebec, Canada. Their findings showed that knowledge about savings and
investments was rather low. Lusardi (2008) postulates that low financial literacy levels and
lack of financial information affect the ability to save and to secure a comfortable retirement.
Beckmann noted that individuals, who are financially literate, are more likely to save using
more than one interest-bearing saving instrument and invest in pension funds. Financially
literate individuals are likely to perform better in terms of saving money, budgeting and
controlling expenditures (Yu, Wu, Chan & Chou, 2015). To the contrary, financial illiteracy
can affect the ability of someone to better financial decisions on savings and investments
(Tang & Peter, 2015).
Examining the impact of saving behaviour in Romania using internationally comparable
indicators, Beckmann (2013) concluded that financial literacy has a positive impact on
saving. The analysis, based on data from the Euro Survey of the Austrian Central Bank,
covered ten countries in Central, Eastern, and South-Eastern Europe (Albania, Bosnia and
Herzegovina, Bulgaria, Croatia, Czech Republic, FYR Macedonia, Hungary, Poland,
Romania, and Serbia). Klapper et al., (2013), however, argue that “correlation between
financial literacy and behaviour does not mean causation and that it is important to find a
causal link” (p.3906). This is due to challenges in obtaining an exogenous source of
variation in financial literacy.
According to Lusardi et al, (2010), there is an association between each of the following
and financial literacy: gender, educational attainment and peers. They found that men were
more financially literate than women while young people with mothers with a college degree
were financially literate compared to their counter parts whose mothers did not have college
degrees. These findings are consistent with other recent studies which found, gender,
financial experience, financial education and parents’ financial experience as some of the
Copyright UCT
- 18 -
variables that have been found to be key to financial knowledge among the young (Yu et al,
2015; Tang & Peter, 2015).
2.4.6 Proposition 2
Financial literacy contributes to sound financial decisions and can affect the individual’s
ability to save and invest.
2.4.7 Effect of credit availability
The easy with which one can access credit may affect saving for precautionary motives.
Credit availability therefore is a variable to study as to whether it is a determinant of saving
or not.
2.4.8 Credit availability
The effect of availability or non-availability of credit on households has been an area of
interest for many researchers. From literature reviewed, credit can affect household saving
in a negative or positive way. Jongwanich (2010), through an in-depth case study of
Thailand during the period 1960 to 2004 examined possible determinants of household and
private savings behaviour. The study found that inflation, an increase in economic growth
and terms of trade, all had a significant positive impact on private and household savings
rates. In contrast, availability of credit tended to reduce private and household saving rates.
The study concluded that when households could borrow freely against future cash flows,
savings rate tended to reduce. The relaxation of consumer borrowing constraints affords
households an alternative source of funds they can use to meet precautionary saving motive
(Glick & Lansing, 2011). Deaton (1991) had earlier put it differently stating that
“precautionary motives interact with liquidity constraints because the inability to borrow
when times are bad provides an additional motive for accumulating assets when times are
good” (p.1222).
Glick & Lansing (2011) studied the relationship between household credit and personal
saving in the US. By studying changes in the saving rate from the mid-1960s to 2010, they
established that changes over time in the availability of credit could explain 90% of the
Copyright UCT
- 19 -
variances in the savings rate. The era of expanding credit availability for individuals and
households that contributed to a dramatic increase in financial leverage as measured by the
household debt to personal disposable income ratio coincided with a period of declining
saving rates. The study found that saving rate is negatively correlated with the household
debt ratio (see figure 4).
Personal saving rate (left scale)
Household debt/ disposable income
(right scale)
14 % %
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
60 65 70 75 80 85 90 95 00 05 10
140
130
120
110
100
90
80
70
60
50
Year
Figure 4: Household debt and personal saving rate
Source: Adapted from Glick & Lansing (2011)
In recent studies conducted in the US by Carroll, Slacalek and Sommer (2013) and using
historical data over a 45-year period, they found strong evidence that credit availability was
one of the factors driving US household saving. They theorised that three factors affect
saving and that these might vary substantially over time. In the first instance, since the
precautionary motive diminishes as wealth rises; the saving rate is a declining function of
market resources. In the second instance, because an expansion in the credit availability
reduces the target level of wealth, looser credit conditions lead to lower saving. Lastly, an
elevated unemployment risk results in greater saving as a precautionary measure. They
conclude by arguing that “the relentless expansion of credit supply between the early-1980s
and 2007 (likely largely reflecting financial innovation and liberalization), along with higher
asset values and consequent increases in net wealth (possibly also partly attributable to the
credit boom) encouraged households to save less out of their disposable income” (p. 25).
Copyright UCT
- 20 -
Easy availability of credit manifests itself in rising household debt. Hence, there is no
incentive for households to save.
In contrast to availability of credit, non-availability of credit can force households to save
more at present in order to make lump sum payments in future. The resultant effect of such
behaviour is an increase in savings. Non-availability of credit are because of imperfect credit
market conditions. Jappelli and Pangano (1994) claim that if household cannot access the
amounts they want to borrow, aggregate saving will be higher than in markets with perfect
credit conditions. Using data from 19 countries (including all the main OECD countries),
they tested whether or not the liquidity constraints helped to explain the international
differences in national saving rates, as articulated in the overlapping generational model and
whether or not the effect of growth on saving is greater where liquidity constraints are more
pervasive. They introduce the concept of forced saving where for example a mortgage credit
provider stipulates that the borrower contribute a certain amount of the loan value before
the mortgage disbursement. This results in an increase in household saving. Jappelli and
Pangano’s findings are supported by Ozcan et al (2003) who state that “borrowing
constraint, if tight, can prevent people from borrowing extensively, thereby possibly
inducing them to save for contingencies and for the purchases of houses, cars, etc” (p.1408).
Deidda (2014) investigated this phenomenon in Italy. Using a 3-year (1989–1993) pooled
cross section of the Bank of Italy Survey of Household Income and Wealth (SHIW) data,
the study found that precautionary savings and non-availability of credit are complementary.
Households that face simultaneously both liquidity constraints and uncertainty have a
stronger precautionary motive to save than unconstrained ones. However, Carroll (2001)
argues contrary to the view that liquidity constraints induce households to save by stating
that “precautionary saving motive can generate behaviour that is virtually indistinguishable
from that generated by a liquidity constraint, because the precautionary saving motive
essentially induces self-imposed reluctance to borrow (or to borrow too much)” (p.32).
2.4.9 Proposition 3
Credit availability reduces the precautionary saving motive thereby affecting the level of
saving.
Copyright UCT
- 21 -
2.5 Conclusion of Literature Review
Culture, financial literacy and credit availability are among determinants of saving
suggested in literature. Below is a presentation of a summary of the review on these three
determinants.
Cultural factors: Studies on the effect of cultural factors on saving have yielded different
results with some suggesting that there is a positive effect while some have been
inconclusive. The fact that some studies have shown a positive effect while others are
inconclusive demonstrates the complexity of measuring cultural factors as a determinant.
Nevertheless, it may still be relevant in explaining differences in saving rates among
different cultural identities.
Financial literacy: The level of an individual’s financial literacy affects their performance
in terms of saving money, investing, budgeting and controlling costs. High financial literacy
affects these behaviours positively while the opposite happens with low financial literacy.
Gender and educational attainment are linked to financial literacy with women showing
lower financial literacy in comparison to men while higher financial literacy increases with
educational attainment.
Credit availability: Where credit is easily available and no credit constraints exist, studies
have shown that there is a negative impact on saving. There is less motivation to save as
saving is easily replaced by debt. Credit is a fall back measure to saving.
2.5.1 Proposition 1:
Ethnic or cultural background of individuals or households affects saving
behaviour.
2.5.2 Proposition 2:
Financial literacy contributes to sound financial decisions and can affect the
individual’s ability to save and invest.
2.5.3 Proposition 3:
Credit availability reduces the precautionary saving motive thereby affecting
the level of saving.
Table 6 also summarises the literature review in form of a consistency matrix.
Copyright UCT
- 22 -
CHAPTER THREE
3 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
3.1 Introduction
This chapter covers the research methodology paradigm and design, study population and
sample, the research instrument, procedure for data collection, analysis and data
interpretation and limitations. The purpose is to provide information in the manner the
research was conducted to arrive at the conclusions made.
3.2 Research methodology / paradigm
There are mainly two domains of research from literature namely quantitative research and
qualitative research (Adams, Khan & Raeside, 2014). Mixed research is a methodology that
combines both qualitative and quantitative approaches to research. In defining quantitative
research, Adams et al. (2014) write, “quantitative research refers to the type of research that
is based on the methodological principles of positivism and neo-positivism, and adheres to
the standards of a strict research design developed prior to the actual research. It is applied
for quantitative measurement and hence statistical analysis is used” (p.6). On the other hand,
they describe qualitative research as the type of research that uses a number of
methodological approaches based on different theoretical principles such as
phenomenology, Social Interactionism and hermeneutics and uses non-statistical methods
of data collection and analysis. It describes reality as lived by the respondents and aims at
exploring social interactions.
One assumption of a quantitative methodology is that the researchers approach the study in
an impersonal way and as a result, their personal views / experience or that of their study
subjects does not affect their expert interpretation of data (Leacock, Warrican & Rose,
2009). For this study, a quantitative approach was used to examine the determinants of
saving. This was based on the underlying assumptions of quantitative traditions (deductive
reasoning) and the research questions that rendered themselves towards a quantitative line
of enquiry.
Copyright UCT
- 23 -
Table 1 illustrates the differences between quantitative and qualitative research and provides
a useful summary to the underlying approach, data collection and analysis of both research
approaches.
Table 1: Comparative Summary of Qualitative and Quantitative Research Approaches
Qualitative Research Quantitative Research
Uses an inductive form of reasoning :
develops concepts, insights and
understanding from patterns in the data
Uses a deductive form of reasoning :
collects data to assess preconceived
models, hypotheses and theories
Uses an emic perspective of inquiry :
derives meaning from the subject’s
perspective
Uses an etic perspective : the meaning
is determined by the researcher
Is idiographic : thus aims to understand
the meaning that people attach to
everyday life
Is nomothetic : aims to objectively
measure the social world, to test
hypotheses, and to predict and control
human behaviour
Regards reality as subjective Sees reality as objective
Captures and discovers meaning once
the researcher becomes immersed in
the data
Tests hypotheses that the researcher
starts off with
Concepts are in the form of themes,
motifs and categories.
Concepts are in the form of distinct
variables
Seeks to understand phenomena Seeks to control phenomena
Observations are determined by
information richness of settings, and
types of observations used are
modified to enrich understanding
Observations are systematically
undertaken in a standardised manner
Data is presented in the form of words,
quotes from documents and transcripts
Data is presented by means of exact
figures gained from precise
measurement
The research design is flexible and
unique and evolves throughout the
research process. There are no fixed
steps that should be followed and
cannot be exactly replicated
The research design is standardised
according to a fixed procedure and
can be replicated
Data is analysed by extracting themes Data analysis is undertaken by means
of standardised statistical procedures
The unit of analysis is holistic,
concentrating on the relationships
between elements, contexts, etc. The
whole is always more than the sum
The unit of analysis is variables which
are anatomistic (elements that form
part of the whole)
Source: Denzin & Lincoln (2000); Neuman (1994) as adapted from April, 2004 (p.77)
Copyright UCT
- 24 -
3.3 Research Design
Leacock et al., (2009) identified the following commonly used research approaches: case
studies; survey studies; correlational studies; causal – comparative studies; historical studies
and; experimental studies. Given the dearth of literature on the subject in the Zambian
context, the research was designed in such way as to obtain data directly from respondents.
As such, a survey study approach was used. In survey studies, data is collected from a select
group of persons in order to answer questions about beliefs, feelings and opinions or test a
hypothesis (Leacock et al., 2009)
One criticism about this approach is the use of a questionnaire that is a self-reporting
instrument as a means of data collection. Leacock et al., (2009) argue that such instrument
“may lead to the collection of data that is distorted by perception, personal experience, and
the passage of time or outright deliberate misrepresentation of the facts” (p 57). It also
suffers from the “garbage in, garbage out” if it is not properly formulated (Adams et al.,
2014).
However, despite the criticism of this approach, the researcher preferred it due to the limited
time the researcher had to undertake the study and the quantitative nature of the study which
meant that data could be compiled and analysed in a shorter period compared to qualitative
approach. Further, by using a questionnaire distributed via email, the researcher facilitated
completion of questionnaire without influencing the outcome.
To address the criticisms of the survey approach alluded to earlier; the survey process as
described in figure 5 was adopted.
Copyright UCT
- 25 -
The Survey Process
Design
Purpose
Support from Literature
Sample Selection
Delivery Method
Write the Questions
Form of Response
Layout
Pilot the survey
Make iterations —
Re-pilot?
Administer the survey
Data Entry
Coding and Storage
Media Missing Data
Analysis
Report
Figure 5: The Survey Process. Source: Adapted from Adams et al., 2014. p.119
Copyright UCT
- 26 -
3.4 Study population and sample
3.4.1 Population
The general study population was the Zambian middle class. However, for the purposes of
this study, the specific study population was the banking employees who within this market
are a sub-segment of the middle class. The specific study population was further limited to
banking employees living in Lusaka City. The country boasts of 19 commercial banks. All
19 commercial banks are represented in Lusaka City. However, one bank was recently
placed under the direct supervision of the Central Bank due to its insolvency and inability
to meet financial obligations as they fell due and was excluded from the population.
As at end of 2015, there were 7999 banking employees across the country of which 5522
were based in the Lusaka area representing 69% of the total banking employees (Bank of
Zambia, 2016). Only Lusaka based bank employees formed a population from which a
sample for study was drawn. This is because the researcher believed that such a sample
contained rich information about the phenomenon being investigated (Leacock et al.,
(2009). Availability and proximity of a large slice of the banking employee population to
the researcher also played a key role in the decision. Table 2 provides an overview of where
the entire banking employee population is located.
3.4.2 Sample and sampling method
The researcher aimed to distribute a total of 270 questionnaires by distributing 15
questionnaires (see Table 3) to each of the 18 banks. In the end, however, the sample was
drawn from bank employees from 14 banks out 18 due time constraints. Non-probability
sampling approach was used for this study. In non-probability sampling, the selection of
sample units or categories depend on the researcher’s personal judgement. According to
Adams et al. (2014), this approach has a weakness of not being representative due to the use
of the researcher’s personal judgement in coming up with a sample. As a result, the findings
of the study may not be valid.
The weakness identified by Adams et al. above were mitigated by:
Taking samples from most of the banks (14 out of 18 banks) operating in the country
Copyright UCT
- 27 -
Adopting a stratified approach by taking samples from a broad spectrum of staff.
For the purposes of this research, three categories of staff were identified namely:
clerical, managerial and executive staff (see Table 3).
Table 2: Banking employees per occupational category and by province
Source: Bank of Zambia (2016). Financial and Other Statistics Booklet
Table 3: Description of respondents
Description of respondents Number to be sampled
Clerical staff (normally unionised) 90
Managerial staff (as per criteria of the specific bank) 90
Executive staff (as per criteria of specific bank) 90
Table 4b: Employment in Banks by Occupational Category and Province, 2015
Occupational Category Lusaka Central Copperbelt Eastern Southern Luapula Western Northern North/W Muchinga Numbers
Executive Management 128 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 128
Senior Managers 454 3 30 3 4 4 1 3 5 2 509
Managers 839 17 125 14 33 5 9 13 15 9 1,079
Credit 389 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 390
Treasury 91 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 91
Finance 117 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 117
Risk and Compliance 56 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 57
Operations 675 12 108 13 28 3 1 4 6 3 853
Others 1,048 46 248 36 76 15 19 22 28 15 1,553
Clerical and general staff 1,725 129 598 141 234 47 66 96 125 61 3,222
Total 5,522 207 1,111 207 375 74 96 138 179 90 7,999 Source: Commercial Banks
Table 5: Annual Employment in Commercial B a n k s by Province, 2006 - 2015
Province 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Lusaka 1,111 927 1,003 3,729 4,052 4,064 4,750 5,078 5,273 5,522 Central 27 40 28 134 133 130 133 152 170 207 Copperbelt 411 521 306 813 843 823 870 931 1,015 1,111 Eastern 51 100 6 135 132 132 147 147 168 207
Southern 125 194 52 289 297 322 335 332 346 375 Luapula 6 8 7 36 48 46 51 51 63 74 Western 9 9 9 71 62 52 57 75 80 96 Nor thern 23 488 28 141 135 146 151 105 124 138 Nor thwestern 7 12 185 89 106 97 106 143 154 179 Muchinga 67 72 90 Total 1,770 2,299 1,624 5,437 5,808 5,812 6,600 7,081 7,465 7,999 Note: Data for Access Bank,African Banking Corporation, Investrust, ZANACO and Finance Bank were not available for 2006 to 2008.
*Muchinga Province was formed in 2011 hence data for earlier periods are not available
Copyright UCT
- 28 -
3.5 The research instrument
A questionnaire was used as a research instrument (see Appendix D). Youngman as cited in
Bell and Waters (2014) listed seven types of questions commonly used by researchers using
this instrument namely: verbal/open, list, ranking, grid, scale, category and quantity. For
this research, a closed questionnaire, one in which a question is asked and a respondent
chooses the answer from a number of options provided, was used to gather data on the
phenomenon studied (Leacock et al., (2009). The questionnaire contained some of the types
of questions identified by Youngman (Bell & Waters, 2014). The advantage of using this
type of questionnaire is the easy to collate and code data while allowing for uniform
measurement thereby providing greater reliability (Leacock et al., (2009).The key, however,
is a proper construction of the questionnaire. The questionnaire included classification and
targeted questions. Classification questions were meant to provide more data with regard to
potential respondents while target questions addressed research questions relevant to the
study. The questions in the questionnaire were derived from the literature review conducted
(see Table 6).
Prior to being administered, the questionnaire was tested among a select group 10 banking
employees. 40% response rate was obtained from questionnaires distributed electronically.
Questions and a summary of the results from the pilot test are contained in Table 4. Feedback
from responses received was used to refine the research instrument.
Table 4: Results from the pilot test of the questionnaire
No. Clarity sought on questionnaire Response from pilot test respondent
1. How long did you take to complete the
questionnaire?
Between 10 – 15 minutes
13 minutes
10 minutes
15 minutes
2. Were the questions in the questionnaire
clear?
Questions were clear
90% clear
Some questions were ambiguous
e.g. one asking about salary per
month: is it gross or net salary?
Copyright UCT
- 29 -
3. Were the questions in the questionnaire
difficult or hard to answer?
Had to thick twice on section D &
E
Some take time to understand, can
be made easier.
Q19 is technical, other the rest are
ok
4. Is there any feedback or comment you
would like to give on the
questionnaire?
send to credit team who see
patterns of borrowing
include religion as a factor to
investigate
provide boxes for ticking instead
of manually making the response
However, Adams et al., (2014) allude to the fact that this type of research instrument has,
among the others, one disadvantage namely that of low response rate which in some cases
may be as low as 20%. The researcher aimed to collect a minimum of 100 responses hence,
a high number of questionnaires was distributed to mitigate the low response rate.
3.6 Procedure for data collection
According to Adams et al., (2014), a researcher can choose between, mail questionnaires,
face to-face interviews, email/web questionnaires, telephone and. peer dissemination as
survey delivery platform. The delivery platform initially preferred by this researcher was
the email platform. To solicit a high response rate, the questionnaire was distributed through
the Human Resource (HR) Directors of respective banks. Instructions on how to distribute
the questionnaire were included to provide guidance to HR Directors in order to mitigate
weaknesses identified with the non-probability sampling approach used (See Appendix C).
However, due to the low response rate experienced in the early stages of data collection
using this approach, peer dissemination was also used which approach was further
augmented with physical distribution of questionnaires. Data was collected using
questionnaires electronically or physically distributed. An introduction letter explaining the
purpose of the research and outlining the rights and responsibilities of the respondents and
the researcher respectively accompanied each questionnaire sent out. The delivery platforms
are compared in Table 5.
Copyright UCT
- 30 -
Table 5: Survey delivery platforms (adapted from Adams et al, 2014. P.122)
Delivery
Platform
Who
Completes—
Surveyor or
Surveyed
Cost Length of
Questionnaire
Response
Rates
Comment
Household Either Expensive Can be long High Not advisable for a student
approach—safety issues
and too time consuming,
no compulsion for
householders to reply
Street Surveyor Medium Short Medium Concern as to the validity
of responses and those
surveyed tend to be self-
selected—so are they
really representative?
Telephone Surveyor Medium Short Depends on
culture
In the UK, student-based
telephone surveys of
individuals do not appear
to illicit a very high
response rate but in Hong
Kong they do. Can work
for company-based
surveys—but little detail is
given and not of a
confidential nature.
Email / web Surveyed Cheap Short Low Reliability concerns—can
be multiple responses.
Copyright UCT
- 31 -
Companies pay little
attention to these
Mail Surveyed Cheap Variable Low For individuals need a
reply paid envelope—not
required for companies.
Customer Either Medium Medium Variable Usually requires
permission of retailer.
Part of an
institution or
organisation
Surveyor Cheap Medium High Can have high response
rates if the surveyed think
that it is advantageous to
them. But can be biased
responses as the
respondents try to portray
their position to their
superiors.
3.7 Data analysis and interpretation
A statistical analysis software tool, Megastat v11.0 was used to run regressions used to
analyse the data collected. Descriptive statistics were also used in conjunction with
regressions. For ethnic / cultural factors questions that indicated willingness to save were
incorporated in the questionnaire. According to Al-Awad & Elhiraika (2003), “willingness
to save is assumed to depend primarily on cultural factors” (p.141). Three questions that
have become standard survey questions for assessing financial literacy (Beckmann, 2013)
were included in the questionnaire. The questionnaire also contains questions that collected
detailed information on the saving behaviour, which were utilized to study whether financial
literacy was correlated with the saving behaviour of Zambian bankers. Credit availability
phenomenon was also analysed using regression and descriptive statistics.
Copyright UCT
- 32 -
3.8 Consistency Matrix
Table 6: Consistency matrix
Research problem: Personal and household savings are not growing at a rate that would sustain the economic development the nation
aspires to achieve.
Sub-problem Literature Review Hypotheses or
Propositions or
Research
questions
Source of data Type of
data
Analysis
The objective of this
sub question is to
examine whether
someone’s cultural
upbringing can
influence saving
behaviour or not.
Zambia is an ethnically
diverse country
comprising of about
seventy-three tribal
groups.
Carroll, C. D.,
Rhee, B. K., &
Rhee, C. (1994).
Al-Awad, M., &
Elhiraika, A.
(2003). Gatina, L.
(2014). Shepherd,
H. R., & Stephens,
N. M. (2010).
Ethnic or cultural
background of
individuals or
households affects
saving behaviour.
I make voluntary contributions on top of
my mandated monthly pension contributions
(7). I currently save or put money away (8).
I always think about life after retirement (9).
How often did your parents / relatives or
friends speak to you about money when you
were growing up? (14), How often do you
discuss money issues with your kids? (15)
How often do you support your siblings or
parents financially? (16).
Ordinal Quantitative:
Descriptive
statistics;
Regression
analysis Copyright UCT
- 33 -
Research problem: Personal and household savings are not growing at a rate that would sustain the economic development the nation
aspires to achieve.
Sub-problem Literature Review Hypotheses or
Propositions or
Research
questions
Source of data Type of
data
Analysis
The objective of this
sub question is examine
whether financial
literacy as a variable
has an impact on
individual and
household saving.
Beckmann, E.
(2013). Tang, N.,
& Peter, P. C.
(2015). Klapper,
L., Lusardi, A., &
Panos, G. A.
(2013. Lachance,
M. J., & Cloutier,
J. (2009). Lusardi,
A., Mitchell, O. S.,
& Curto, V. (2010)
Financial literacy
contributes to
sound financial
decisions and can
affect the
individual’s ability
to save and invest
I know how much money I spent last month
(1). I am happy with my financial /
budgeting skills (2). I own shares / trade on
the stock exchange (3). I have an Investment
/ savings account (4). I know the interest
rate(s) I pay on my loan(s) (5). I have an
insurance life Cover and or retirement
annuity (6). Suppose you had K100 in a
savings account and the interest rate was 2%
per year. After 5 years, how much do you
think you would have in the account if you
left the money to grow? (17). Imagine that
the interest rate on your savings account was
1% per year and inflation was 2% per year.
After 1 year, would you be able to buy more
than, exactly the same as, or less than today
with the money in this account? (18). Do
you think that the following statement is
true or false? Buying a single company
stock usually provides a safer return than a
stock mutual fund (19).
Discrete;
Ordinal Quantitative:
Descriptive
statistics;
Regression
analysis
Copyright UCT
- 34 -
Research problem: Personal and household savings are not growing at a rate that would sustain the economic development the nation
aspires to achieve.
Sub-problem Literature Review Hypotheses or
Propositions or
Research
questions
Source of data Type of
data
Analysis
The objective of this
question is to examine
whether easy access to
credit hinders
individuals and
households from saving
or not.
Glick, R., &
Lansing, K. J.
(2011). Carroll, C.,
Slacalek, J., &
Sommer, M.
(2013). Deaton, A.
(1991). Jappelli,
T., & Pagano, M.
(1994)
Credit availability
reduces the
precautionary
saving motive
thereby affecting
the level of saving.
I do not wait for store sales promotions; I
buy today when I need it (10). I have
borrowed in the last 24 months (11). I have
taken on too much debt (Debt service ratio -
Monthly loan repayments / Monthly income
after tax / NAPSA/ Pension) > 50%) (12). I
think easy access to credit (loans) hinders
saving (13)
Ordinal Quantitative:
Descriptive
statistics;
Regression
analysis
Copyright UCT
- 35 -
CHAPTER FOUR
4 RESEARCH FINDINGS, DISCUSSION AND INTERPRETATION
4.1 Introduction
This chapter presents the findings of the research objectives based on the data collected. The
findings are analysed using statistical analysis software tool (Megastat v11.0) and followed by a
discussion of the analysis.
How and from where was data sourced?
Initially, the researcher aimed to distribute a total of 270 questionnaires by distributing 15
questionnaires (see Table 3) to each of the 18 banks. This target was not achieved however. The
researcher only managed to distribute a total of 203 questionnaires to 14 of the 18 banks
representing a coverage rate of 77.8%. 4 banks were not covered due to time constraints within
which to collect the data. 100 responses were collected from the total number of questionnaires
distributed representing 49.3% response rate. Responses were received from all the 14 banks to
which the questionnaire was distributed to. According to Leacock et al., (2009), a minimum sample
of 100 is acceptable as it is untenable to anticipate a 100% response rate and also given the limited
time available for any particular research.
Research objectives
The main objective of the study was to examine the determinants of saving among banking
employees in Zambia. Based on the research questions, the objectives included;
1. To examine the effect of cultural / ethnic background on saving behaviour of Zambian
banking employees.
2. To assess the relationship between financial literacy and savings.
3. To examine the effect of credit availability on savings.
Copyright UCT
- 36 -
4.2 Objective 1
We have to acknowledge the assumption that the ethnic / cultural background as an independent
variable is measured by province. It is assumed that people of the same province will exhibit
homogeneous saving patterns. These provinces depict the cultural grouping as well as the common
background. Figure 6 shows frequencies of the respondents from the various ethnic groups
categorised into provinces.
Figure 6: Provinces from where respondent come from
As observed from figure 6, the largest number of respondents came from Eastern province making
up 23% while lowest number was from North western and other parts of the world outside Zambia
(3%).
To determine the relationship between the ethic / cultural background and the saving behaviour, a
regression was run between the observed responses on provinces against the observed responses on
whether someone has a savings account or investment account (Q4).
From figure 7 below, we observe that the regression line is almost horizontal or flat. This implies
that there is weak or no significant relationship between the cultural /ethnic background and saving
Province
1. Lusaka
2. Central
3. Southern
4. Western
5. Eastern
6. Muchinga
7. Northern
8. Luapula
9. Copperbelt
10. North
Western
11. Other
Copyright UCT
- 37 -
pattern. The coefficient of determination R² = 0.0139, is too small and almost zero, which suggests
that relationship between the two factors is almost zero.
This phenomenon can be justified in that people move and merge up in urban areas and their cultural
ties may be broken by close association with other people of different tribal groups hence making
up the whole country a homogeneous grouping.
Figure 7: Regression between province and saving behaviour
Hypothesis 1
H0: Ethnic or cultural background of individuals or households does not affect saving behaviour.
H1: Ethnic or cultural background of individuals or households significantly affect saving behaviour
To test this hypothesis, the following testing questions were evaluated and run into the analysis
software: (the number in bracket indicates the question tag on the questionnaire)
1. I make voluntary contributions on top of my mandated monthly pension contributions (7).
2. I currently save or put money away (8).
3. I always think about life after retirement (9).
4. How often did your parents / relatives or friends speak to you about money when you were
growing up? (14).
y = 0,0671x + 3,2211R² = 0,0139
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
INV
/SA
VIN
GS
Province
REGRESSION BETWEEN PROVINCE AND SAVING BEHAVIOUR
Copyright UCT
- 38 -
5. How often do you discuss money issues with your kids? (15).
6. How often do you support your siblings or parents financially? (16).
The regression was run between dependent variable probe 2 (I currently save or put money
away) and independent variable probe 4 (How often did your parents / relatives or friends speak
to you about money when you were growing up?)
Figure 8: Regression between saving when growing up and currently save
Figure 8 highlights the regression relationship between the exposure to saving at time of growing
up through discussion and an individual’s current savings behaviour. The relationship is weak (flat)
and R² = 0.0057 which is almost zero implying that there is no significant relationship between the
two factors. The individual’s current saving behavior has nothing to do with their upbringing.
Alternatively, how often the parents or relatives or friends speak to an individual about money or
investments when they were growing up has little to do with their saving pattern.
This situation may explain the reason why an individual from a rich family may shockingly lead a
reckless life of abandon when let alone in adulthood, while an individual from irresponsible parents
or families may have good saving habits and prosper economically when they lead their own life
after leaving their families. Furthermore, it also explains the reason why different individuals
brought up from the same identical family will fair differently in saving habits.
y = 0,0783x + 3,1846R² = 0,0057
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
MA
KE
SA
VIN
GS
SAVINGSGROWINGUP
REGRESSION- SAVINGS WHEN GROWING UP AND CURRENT MAKING OF SAVING
Copyright UCT
- 39 -
Hypothesis testing results
When the hypothesis test was run on paired observations between saving when growing up against
current saving, the results yield was as summarised in the table 7.
Please note the following:
- Since the anchoring scale was in ascending order with positive at 5 and negative at 1, the
hypothesised value was set at 5 (5 - always talked to about saving, 5 - strongly agree making saving)
- Decision rule is that if p value is greater than 0.05, accept null, if p value is less than 0.05 reject
null and accept the alternative hypothesis test.
- Since the value of n is large enough, we use z test and not t test.
Table 7: Paired Observations - saving when growing up and currently save
Hypothesis Test: Paired Observations
5.000 hypothesized value
2.750
mean
SAVINGSGROWINGUP
3.400 mean MAKESAVINGS
-0.650 mean difference (SAVINGSGROWINGUP - MAKESAVINGS)
1.866 std. dev.
0.187 std. error
100 n
-30.28 z
1.0000 p-value
-1.016
confidence interval 95.%
lower
-0.284
confidence interval 95.%
upper
0.366 half-width
At 95% level of significant on both upper and lower tails, the p value is greater than the critical
0.05, since p value is 1.00. This means that we fail to reject the null hypothesis, instead we reject
the alternative which states that there is a significant effect of individual cultural background and
the current savings behaviour. Hence we can conclude at 95% certainty that there is no significant
effect of individual’s cultural and ethnic background on their current saving behaviour.
The other regression was run to find out the relation between individual who was brought up in
some cultural pattern and if they continued to impart the same on their children.
Copyright UCT
- 40 -
Independent variable: How often did your parents / relatives or friends speak to you about money
when you were growing up? (14),
Dependent variable: How often do you discuss money issues with your kids? (15)
Table 8: Regression Analysis – discuss money with kids
r² 0.026
Adjusted r² 0.016
r
-
0.162
Std. Error 1.347
n 100
k 1
Dep. Var. Discuss money with kids
ANOVA table
Source SS df MS F p-value
Regression 4.7864 1 4.7864 2.64 .1075
Residual 177.7236 98 1.8135
Total 182.5100 99
At 95% significant level, we still accept the null hypothesis that there is there is no relationship
between an individual being often talked to about money when growing up and them telling their
children about money when grown up.
These findings run contrary to studies conducted in other countries suggesting that there is a
correlation between cultural factors and saving (Carrol et al, 1994; Al-Awad & Elhiraika, 2003;
Gatina, 2014). What is perhaps striking with these studies is that they involved migrants while this
study involved subjects from different parts of Zambia. Migrants from other countries may have
distinct cultural behaviours different from the host countries whereas different ethnic / cultural
groupings within a country may not be distinct in their cultural norms or behaviours due to close
proximity to one another and forging of a national identity.
Copyright UCT
- 41 -
4.3 Objective 2
The objective was to examine whether financial literacy as a variable has an impact on individual
and household saving. To address this objective the following were the probes from the respondents.
The dependent variable was saving habit on bank employees while the independent variables were
measured by a number of variables listed below.
Financial Literacy measures:
- I know how much money I spent last month (1).
- I am happy with my financial / budgeting skills (2).
- I own shares / trade on the stock exchange (3).
- I know the interest rate(s) I pay on my loan(s) (5)
Individual savings measures
- I have an Investment / savings account (4).
- I currently save or put money away (8).
Simulation 1: A regression was run between the probes: “I know how much money I spent last
month” (1) financial literacy measure and “I currently save or put money away” (8). The results
yielded are shown in figure 9.
Figure 9: Regression between last expenditure knowledge and saving
y = 0,2446x + 2,495R² = 0,0429
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
MA
KE
SA
VIN
G
LASTEXPEND
REGRESSION LAST EXPENDITURE KNOWLEDGE AND MAKING SAVING
Copyright UCT
- 42 -
Figure 9 highlights the regression relationship between the last month knowledge and an
individual’s current saving behaviour. The relationship shows some positive upward trend with
slope of 0.2446 and R² = 0.04 which slightly higher away from zero. This implies that there is some
significant relationship between the two factors. The individual’s current saving behavior has
something to do with the financial literacy in terms of accountability of their previous expenses.
Alternatively, the more conscious an individual is to spending the more they become thrift for the
consequence period.
This may explain the reason why individuals who maintain simple book keeping and have some
literacy on financials are likely to be thrifty and invest or save than individuals with no
accountability for periodical expenses. In reality, a person who spends on drinking may not save
partly because they unconsciously spend while drunk and may not remember exactly how much
lump sum was spent.
Simulation 2: A regression was run between probes: “I am happy with my financial / budgeting
skills” (2) and “I have an Investment / savings account” (4). The results yielded are shown in figure
10
Figure 10: Regression between budget skills and saving account
Figure 10 highlights the regression relationship between the individual’s budgeting skills, a measure
of financial literacy an individual’s willingness to maintain an investment or savings account. The
relationship shows a significant positive upward trend with slope of 0.3464 and R² = 0.08 which
y = 0,3464x + 2,4996R² = 0,0827
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
AC
CS
AV
ING
BUDGETSKILL
REGRESSION BUDGET SKILLS AND SAVING
ACCOUNT
Copyright UCT
- 43 -
slightly higher away from zero and R = 28% (explained proportion of the dependent variable as a
result of independent variable). This implies that there is some significant relationship between the
financial literacy measured in terms of budgetary skills and an individual maintain a savings or
investment account. The individual’s financial literacy is positively related to saving. Alternatively,
the higher the budgeting skills an individual has, the more they become thrifty and have investments
Hypothesis 2
We test the second hypothesis based on the variables discussed in Simulation 1 of objective two.
H0: Financial literacy does not contribute to sound financial decisions and cannot affect the
individual’s ability to save and invest.
H1: Financial literacy significantly contributes to sound financial decisions and greatly affect the
individual’s ability to save and invest.
- Since the value of n is large enough, we use z test and not t test.
- We set hypothesis value at 5.00
- Decision rule is that if p value is greater than 0.05, accept null, if p value is less than 0.05
reject null and accept the alternative hypothesis test.
Table 9: Paired observations for Hypothesis 2 under Simulation 1
Since p value (0.00) is less than 0.05 we reject the null hypothesis that financial literacy does not
contribute to sound financial decisions and cannot affect the individual’s ability to save and invest.
Instead, we accept the alternative hypothesis and conclude that financial literacy significantly
contributes to sound financial decisions and greatly affect the individual’s ability to save and invest.
Hypothesis Test: Paired Observations
5.000 hypothesized value
3.090 mean BUDGETSKILL
3.570 mean ACCSAVINGS
-0.480 mean difference (BUDGETSKILL - ACCSAVINGS)
1.567 std. dev.
0.157 std. error
100 n
-34.98 z
0.00 p-value (two-tailed)
Copyright UCT
- 44 -
Hence we deduce that conducting financial literacy programmes to adults and including bank
employees can contribute significantly to saving improvements. People can make decisions if well
informed and appreciate the need to save. This gives the added reason banks or microfinance
lending institutions engaged in administering group loans or small and medium enterprises
financial empowerment may do well to first educate the would be borrowers on budgeting skills
and saving for better investment. This will make the debtors to be financially viable and prudent on
revenues.
Simulation 2 on hypothesis 2
- value of n is large enough, we use z test
- We set hypothesis value at 5.00
- Decision rule is that if p value is greater than 0.05, accept null, if p value is less than 0.05
reject null and accept the alternative hypothesis.
The variables run are last expenditure knowledge and individual making some savings away
Table 10: Paired observations for Hypothesis 2 under Simulation 2
In reference to Table 10, at 95% significant level, we reject the null hypothesis that financial literacy
does not contribute to sound financial decisions and cannot affect the individual’s ability to save
and invest, instead we accept the alternative hypothesis and conclude that financial literacy
significantly contributes to sound financial decisions and greatly affect the individual’s ability to
save and invest.
Hypothesis Test: Paired Observations
5.000 hypothesized value
3.700 mean LASTEXPEND
3.400 mean MAKESAVINGS
0.300 mean difference (LASTEXPEND - MAKESAVINGS)
1.636 std. dev.
0.164 std. error
100 n
-28.73 z
0.00 p-value (two-tailed)
Copyright UCT
- 45 -
Hence we can establish that a person’s knowledge and consciousness of their expenses as well as
other measures of literacy, affect the saving behaviour. The higher the financial accountability, the
higher the saving for an individual.
Descriptive statistics for questions 17, 18 and 19
According to Lursadi et al, (2010), there are three questions that are normally asked to test financial
literacy. These questions were included as Question 17, 18 and 19 in the questionnaire. The results
are depicted in figures 11 to 13 respectively. The results showed that the level of financial literacy
declined with the complexity of the subject being tested indicating perhaps the need for intervention
in such areas.
Figure 11: Q17 - Interest Rate (Numeracy).
Frequency Distribution - Quantitative
ACCAFTER5YRS cumulative
lower upper midpoint width frequency percent frequency percent
0.0 < 1.0 0.5 1.0 0 0.0 0 0.0
1.0 < 2.0 1.5 1.0 82 82.0 82 82.0
2.0 < 3.0 2.5 1.0 6 6.0 88 88.0
3.0 < 4.0 3.5 1.0 6 6.0 94 94.0
4.0 < 5.0 4.5 1.0 0 0.0 94 94.0
5.0 < 6.0 5.5 1.0 6 6.0 100 100.0
100 100.0
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
Perc
ent
ACCAFTER5YRS
Histogram
Series1
1. More than
K102
2. Exactly
K102
3. Less than
K102
4. Do not
know
5. No answer
Copyright UCT
- 46 -
This question tested whether respondents were familiar with interest rate calculation. 82% answered
this question correctly while the other 18% got it wrong, did not know the answer or refused to
answer.
Figure 12: Q18 – Inflation
77% respondents answered correctly to Question 18 which sort to find out if respondents were
familiar with inflation and its effect on savings or investment. 23% answered wrongly, did not know
or did not answer.
Frequency Distribution - Quantitative
1PERCENTINT cumulative
lower upper midpoint width frequency percent frequency percent
0.0 < 1.0 0.5 1.0 0 0.0 0 0.0
1.0 < 2.0 1.5 1.0 7 7.0 7 7.0
2.0 < 3.0 2.5 1.0 2 2.0 9 9.0
3.0 < 4.0 3.5 1.0 77 77.0 86 86.0
4.0 < 5.0 4.5 1.0 6 6.0 92 92.0
5.0 < 6.0 5.5 1.0 8 8.0 100 100.0
100 100.0
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
Per
cent
1PERCENTINT
Histogram
Series1
1. More than
today
2. Exactly the
same
3. Less than today
4. Do not know
5. No answer
Copyright UCT
- 47 -
Figure 13: Q19 – Risk diversification
Only 66% answered question 19 correctly with the rest not knowing the answer, answering wrongly
or ignoring it completely.
Previous studies (Lusardi, Mitchell & Curto, 2010; Yu, Wu, Chan & Chou, 2015) have shown that
that financial literacy is a determinant of saving and this study goes a long way to argument such
position. However, as Klapper et al., (2013) argue, “correlation between financial literacy and
behaviour does not mean causation and that it is important to find a causal link” (p.3906). For bank
employees, this may be by default given that bank employees have access to financial literacy
information by virtue of their employment the financial industry. Further, many bank employees
have bank accounts opened wherein they receive their salaries and or make savings.
Frequency Distribution - Quantitative
TRUEFALSE cumulative
lower upper midpoint width frequency percent frequency percent
0.0 < 1.0 0.5 1.0 0 0.0 0 0.0
1.0 < 2.0 1.5 1.0 7 7.0 7 7.0
2.0 < 3.0 2.5 1.0 68 68.0 75 75.0
3.0 < 4.0 3.5 1.0 18 18.0 93 93.0
4.0 < 5.0 4.5 1.0 7 7.0 100 100.0
100 100.0
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Perc
ent
TRUEFALSE
Histogram
Series1
1. True
2. False
3. Do not
Know
4. No
answer
Copyright UCT
- 48 -
4.4 Objective 3
The major aim of this objective was to examine whether easy access to credit hinders individuals
and households from saving or not. The major assumption on this objective was that as more
credit facilities are accessed, the individual will have more liability obligations to meet, leaving
them with very little if none for saving.
To address this objective the following were the probes from the respondents. The dependent
variable was saving habit on bank employee while the independent variables were measured by a
number of variables listed below
Credit availability measures
- I have borrowed in the last 24 months (11).
- I have taken on too much debt (Debt service ratio > 50%) (12).
- I think easy access to credit (loans) hinders saving (13)
Savings measures
- I have an Investment / savings account (4).
- I currently save or put money away (8).
Simulation1: A regression was run between the probes: “I have borrowed in the last 24 months”
as measure of credit facility and “I currently save or put money away”. The results yielded are
shown in figure 14.
Figure 14: Regression between credit availability and saving
Copyright UCT
- 49 -
Figure 14 highlights the regression relationship between the individual’s easy access to credit
facility and saving. The relationship shows a significantly weak positive upward trend with slope
of 0.0907 and R² = 0.0095 which is almost zero and R = 10% (explained proportion of the dependent
variable as a result of independent variable). This implies that there is weak or no relationship
between the availability of or easy access to credit facilities and individual’s saving.
In expansion, we will deduce that a person who appreciates saving will continue with the saving
behavior despite the availability of credit, and will be within their debt service ratio. It is a decision
a person willingly makes whether to go for a loan or not.
Simulation2: A regression was run between the probes: “I have taken on too much debt (Debt
service ratio > 50%)” as measure of credit facility and “I currently save or put money away”. The
results yielded are shown in figure 15.
Figure 15: Regression between high debt service ratio and saving
Figure 15 above highlights the regression relationship between the individual’s debt ratio and
saving. The relationship shows a significantly negative upward trend with slope of -0.1834 and R²
= 0.0329 which is further away from zero and R = 57% (explained proportion of the dependent
variable as a result of independent variable). This implies that there is an inverse relationship
Copyright UCT
- 50 -
between an individual’s debt ratio and individual’s saving. The higher the debt ratio, the lower the
saving due to less surplus money for saving.
Hence it is not advisable to let individuals exceed the threshold borrowing ratio. This reduces their
financial viability and the marginal propensity to save (MPS).
When the respondents were asked “I think easy access to credit (loans) hinders saving”, in a five
continuum anchor rating from strongly disagree (1) to strongly agree (5), the results were as shown
in figure 16.
Figure 16: Responses to whether access to credit hinders saving or not
The majority of respondents (33%) said they strongly agree that easy loan access hinders savings,
followed by 24% on agreeing that easy access hinders savings. While 11% were indifferent to the
opinion, a total of 32% categorically felt easy access does not hinder savings. Statistically, this is a
significant value to depict that easy access to loans may not have an effect to dissaving.
Hypothesis 3
We now test the third hypothesis based on the variables discussed in objective three. To recap, the
hypothesis is stated below.
1. strongly
Disagree
2. Disagree
3. Neither
Disagree
nor agree
4. Agree
5. Strongly
agree
Copyright UCT
- 51 -
H0: Credit availability has no effect on the precautionary saving motive thereby affecting the level
of saving
H1: Credit availability has a significant effect on the precautionary saving motive thereby affecting
the level of saving
Note the parameters set below
- value of n is large enough, we use z test
- We set hypothesis value at 3.00, since hinders is from neutral 3 to 1strongly disagree,
- This is one tailed, since it is hinders
- Decision rule is that if p value is greater than 0.05, accept null, if p value is less than 0.05
reject null and accept the alternative hypothesis.
Table 11: Mean vs. Hypothesized Value
Hypothesis Test: Mean vs. Hypothesized Value
3.000 hypothesized value
3.300 mean EASYLOANACCESS
1.418 std. dev.
0.142 std. error
100 n
2.12 z
.9828 p-value (one-tailed, lower)
We notice that p value is greater than the critical 0.05. Hence we accept the null hypothesis and
conclude that credit availability has no effect on the precautionary saving motive thereby affecting
the level of saving at 95% certainty level.
While many studies (Jappelli & Pangano, 1994; Jongwanich, 2010; Carroll, Slacalek & Sommer,
2013) conducted in developed countries have concluded that there is a relationship between
availability of credit and saving, it does not appear to be the case with this study. From the findings,
the results show that credit availability does not discourage saving. It is generally accepted that
availability of credit in a developing country like Zambia, is a source of investment and savings.
Most bank employees borrow to increase their net worth by acquiring landed properties. As
observed in figure 12, the finding however, agree with Glick & Lansing (2011) study that found
Copyright UCT
- 52 -
that saving rate is negatively correlated with the household debt ratio in the US in that there is a
negative relationship between high debt ratio and savings. Hence the way forward is to make the
credit available but be cautious to limit the individual borrowing ratio.
Hence we can establish that a person’s knowledge and consciousness of their expenses as well as
other measures of literacy, affect the saving behaviour. The higher the financial accountability, the
higher the saving for an individual.
Copyright UCT
- 53 -
CHAPTER FIVE
5 RESEARCH CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
5.1 Introduction
The main objective of the study was to examine the determinants of saving among banking
employees in Zambia. There are many determinants of saving but this dissertation investigated three
of these possible determinants namely: availability of credit; financial literacy; and ethnic / cultural
factors. A regression model and descriptive statistics were used to analyse the data to arrive at
conclusions presented in this chapter. The study was designed to help policy makers, bankers and
investment managers to craft interventions that:
Could help in sustaining or increasing the GNS ratio through fiscal policy formulation and
introduction of innovative saving products
Encourage accessibility to saving and investment information.
Change people’s saving cultural perspectives, customs and behaviours by making saving
and investment desirable.
By using Megastat V11.0 software to run regressions and testing hypotheses in chapter four, the
following conclusions have been made.
5.2 Cultural factors and saving
Statistical evidence showed that there was no correlation between ethnic or cultural factors and
saving. This may be attributed to the fact that different ethnic / cultural groupings within a country
even if they come from different provinces may not be distinct in their cultural norms or behaviours
due to close proximity to one another and forging of a national identity. Saving motives appear to
be the driving force to fostering a saving culture. The motives transcend cultural barriers hence the
evidence seen from findings.
Copyright UCT
- 54 -
5.3 Financial literacy and saving
There was evidence to suggest that financial literacy is a determinant of saving among banking
employees and that financial literacy significantly contributes to sound financial decisions and
greatly affect the individual’s ability to save and invest. Information about financial products,
ability to budget and an understanding of risk and reward can help an individual or household to
make informed decisions about their money and investment opportunities.
5.4 Credit availability and saving
Evidence showed that availability of credit did not impact saving in a negative way. Some banking
employees who had access to credit also demonstrated that they were able to save. However,
evidence also showed that there was regression relationship between the individual’s debt ratio and
saving. The relationship shows a significantly negative upward trend implying that an individual
with a high debt service ratio has less funds to invest or save.
5.5 Recommendations
Given the importance of saving in any given economy, it is important that savings are encouraged.
Going by the findings of this study and in the spirit of the design of the study as alluded to in the
introduction section of this chapter, the following are recommended:
5.5.1 Encourage culture of saving by intensifying financial literacy education targeting all sectors
of the economy and different age groups within society. Hitherto, there has been
concentration of financial literacy training / programme to the National Literacy Week.
Financial literacy activities also tend to be skewed to school going children to the exclusion
of other groups within the society.
5.5.2 Zambian Government to consider abolition or reducing withholding tax on interest on
individual or household investments in Govt. bonds and treasury bills.
5.5.3 Lending institutions to cap the debt service ratio to enable individuals or households save
surplus funds.
Copyright UCT
- 55 -
5.5.4 Banks should innovate by coming up with savings products that can encourage and
attract savers.
5.6 Proposed future research
Given the dearth of literature on this subject within the Zambian context, there are many areas yet
to be explored. It is proposed that the following could be examined:
Determine whether saving behaviour is different between males and females
Consider the role of religion in saving and whether religion can influencing saving
investigate whether education is a determinant of saving
Copyright UCT
- 56 -
REFERENCES
Adams, J., Khan, H.T.A., & Raeside, R. (2014). Research Methods for Business and Social Science
Students (2nd Edn.). New Delhi, India: SAGE Publications
Al-Awad, M., & Elhiraika, A. (2003). Cultural effects and savings: Evidence from immigrants to
the United Arab Emirates. The Journal of Development Studies, 39(5), 139-151.
Ando, A., & Modigliani, F. (1963). The" life cycle" hypothesis of saving: Aggregate implications
and tests. The American economic review, 53(1), 55-84.
April, K. (2004). A Resource-Based View of the Firm: Integrating the Role of IT as a Strategic
Resource. Unpublished PhD dissertation, University of Cape Town, August, 1-549.
Bank of Zambia, (2016). Financial and Statistics Booklet retrieved from
http://www.boz.zm/FinAndOtherStatistics/FINANCIAL%20AND%20OTHER%20STAT
ISTICS%20B OOKLET%202015.pdf on 25th November 2016
Beckmann, E. (2013) "Financial Literacy and Household Savings in Romania," Numeracy:
Vol. 6: Iss.2, Article 9. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.5038/1936-4660.6.2.9
Bell, J., & Waters, S., (2014). Doing your research project: A guide for first time reseachers (6th
edn.). Berkshire, England; Open University Press
Blanchard, O., & Sheen, J. (2009). Macroeconomics. Frenchs Forest, N.S.W. Pearson Australia
Browning, M., & Lusardi, A. (1996). Household Saving: Micro Theories and Micro Facts. Journal
of Economic Literature, 34(4), 1797-1855
Carroll, C. D., Rhee, B. K., & Rhee, C. (1994). Are there cultural effects on saving? Some cross-
sectional evidence. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 685-699.
Carroll, C., Slacalek, J., & Sommer, M. (2013). Dissecting Saving Dynamics: Measuring Wealth,
Precautionary, and Credit Effects retrieved from
https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/a28f/b454a6dce301c090ab894f135fe85adee884.pdf on
28th November 2016
Carroll, C. D. (2001). A theory of the consumption function, with and without liquidity
constraints. The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 15(3), 23-45.
Central Statistical Office (2016). Zambia 2015 Living Conditions Monitoring Survey Key Findings.
Lusaka, Zambia
Chauke, H. M., (2011).The determinants of household saving: The South African Black middle
class perspective. MBA Thesis, Gordon School of Business Science. University of Pretoria,
Copyright UCT
- 57 -
South Africa. Retrieved from
http://repository.up.ac.za/bitstream/handle/2263/25807/dissertation.pdf?sequence=1
on 18th November 2016
CIA, (2016). World Fact Book retrieved on 25th November 2016 from
https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world- factbook/rankorder/2260rank.html
Cohn, R. A., & Kolluri, B. R. (2003). Determinants of household saving in the G-7 countries:
recent evidence. Applied Economics, 35(10), 1199-1208.
Deaton, A. (1991). Saving and Liquidity Constraints. Econometrica: Journal of the Econometric
Society, 1221 - 1248.
Deidda, M. (2014). Precautionary saving under liquidity constraints: evidence from Italy. Empirical
Economics, 46(1), 329-360.
De la Fuente, A., Murr, A., & Rascón, E. (2015). Mapping Subnational Poverty in Zambia,
Washington DC: World Bank
de Laiglesia, J. R., & Morrisson, C. (2008). Household Structures and Savings: Evidence from
Household Surveys. Retrieved from
http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.183.130&rep=rep1&type=pdf
on 24th November 2016.
Economy Watch (2016). Retrieved from: http://www.economywatch.com/economic-statistics/
Zambia/Gross_National_Savings_Percentage_of_GDP/ on 25th July 2016
Friedman, M. (1957). The permanent income hypothesis. In A theory of the consumption
function (pp. 20-37). Princeton University Press. Retrieved from
http://www.nber.org/chapters/c4405.pdf on 20th November 2016
Gatina, L. (2014). The Saving Behaviour of Immigrants and Home‐Country Characteristics:
Evidence from Australia. Australian Economic Review, 47(2), 157-172.
Glick, R., & Lansing, K. J. (2011). Consumers and the economy, part I: Household credit and
personal saving. FRBSF Economic Letter, 1, 1-5. Retrieved from
http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.204.4445&rep=rep1&type=pdf
on 28th November 2016
Gliem, R. R., & Gliem, J. A. (2003). Calculating, Interpreting, And Reporting Cronbach’s Alpha
Reliability Coefficient For Likert-Type Scales. Midwest Research-to-Practice
Conference in Adult, Continuing, and Community Education. Retrieved from
https://scholarworks.iupui.edu/bitstream/handle/1805/344/Gliem%20%26%20Glie
m.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y on 25th November 2016
Copyright UCT
- 58 -
Jappelli, T., & Pagano, M. (1994). Saving, growth, and liquidity constraints. The Quarterly Journal
of Economics, 83-109.
Jongwanich, J. (2010). The determinants of household and private savings in Thailand. Applied
Economics, 42(8), 965-976.
InterMedia (2016). Consumer Behaviours in Zambia: Analysis and Findings retrieved from
http://www.uncdf.org/sites/default/files/Documents/zambiaintermedia_consumerbehaviou
rs.pdf on 13th July 2016
International Monetary Fund, World Economic Outlook Database, April 2016 retrieved from
https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/weo/2016/01/weodata/weorept.aspx?sy=2014&ey=2
021&scsm=1&ssd=1&sort=country&ds=.&br=1&c=754&s=NGDP_RPCH%2CNGSD_N
GDP&grp=0&a=&pr 1.x=44&pr1.y=9 on 21st November 2016
Kasilingam, R., & Jayabal, G. (2011). Impact of Saving Motives on Household
Savings. Pranjana: The Journal of Management Awareness, 14(1).
Kazmi, A., & Bilquees, F. (1993). National Savings Rates of India and Pakistan: A
Macroeconometric Analysis [with Comments]. The Pakistan Development Review, 32(4),
1313-1324.
Kharas, H. (2010). Emerging middle class in Developing World (no.285). OECD Development
Centre, retrieved from http://unpan1.un.org/intradoc/groups/public/documents/un-
dpadm/unpan044413.pdf on 5th November 2016.
Klapper, L., Lusardi, A., & Panos, G. A. (2013). Financial literacy and its consequences:
Evidence from Russia during the financial crisis. Journal of Banking & Finance, 37(10),
3904-3923.
Lachance, M. J., & Cloutier, J. (2009). Young Adults Knowledge About Savings. Nurture, 3(1),
42.
Leacock, C.J., Warrican, S.J., & Rose, G.S.C., 2009. Research Methods for Unexperienced
Researchers: Guidelines for Investigating the Social World. Kingstone, Jamaica; Ian Randle
Publishers.
Lusardi, A. (2008). Household Saving Behavior: The Role of Financial Literacy, Information, and
Financial Education Programs. Retrieved from
http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.490.1829&rep=rep1&type=pdf
on 21st November 2016
Lusardi, A., Mitchell, O. S., & Curto, V. (2010). Financial literacy among the young. Journal of
Consumer Affairs, 44(2), 358-380.
Copyright UCT
- 59 -
Maimbo, S. M., & Mavrotas, G. (2008). Financial Sector Development in Zambia: Implications
for Domestic Resource Mobilization. In Domestic Resource Mobilization and Financial
Development (pp. 203- 228). Palgrave Macmillan UK.
Meghir, C. (2004). A retrospective on Friedman's theory of permanent income. The Economic
Journal, 114(496), F293-F306.
Mususu, P. (2006). Determinants of individual and household savings in Zambia (MBA Thesis,
School of Business, The Copperbelt University, Zambia). Retrieved from
http://dspace.cbu.ac.zm:8080/jspui/handle/123456789/161 on 20th
November 2016
Obi, B., Wafure, G. O., & Menson, A. E. (2012). Savings, investment and economic growth in
Nigeria: an empirical analysis. IUP Journal of Monetary Economics, 10(1), 16.
Ozcan, K. M., Gunay, A., & Ertac, S. (2003). Determinants of private savings behaviour in
Turkey. Applied Economics, 35(12), 1405-1416.
Palumbo, M. (1999). Uncertain Medical Expenses and Precautionary Saving Near the End of the
Life Cycle. The Review of Economic Studies, 66(2), 395-421. Retrieved from
http://www.jstor.org.ezproxy.uct.ac.za/stable/2566996
Posner, P. L., & Bovbjerg, B. D. (1995). Budget Policy and the Long Run Future. In Proceedings
of the Annual Conference on Taxation Held under the Auspices of the National Tax
Association-Tax Institute of America (Vol. 88, pp. 70-76). National Tax Association.
Schmidt-Hebbel, K., Webb, S. B., & Corsetti, G. (1992). Household saving in developing countries:
first cross-country evidence. The World Bank Economic Review
Shepherd, H. R., & Stephens, N. M. (2010). Using Culture to Explain Behaviour: An Integrative
Cultural Approach. Social Psychology Quarterly, 73(4), 353-354.
Tang, N., & Peter, P. C. (2015). Financial knowledge acquisition among the young: The role of
financial education, financial experience, and parents' financial experience. Financial
Services Review, 24(2), 119.
Telleria, J. (2015). What Does Culture Mean for the UNDP? The implicit cultural logic within the
human development framework. Cultural Studies, 29(2), 255-271.
Uremadu, S. O. (2009). The Impact of Macroeconomic and Demographic Factors on Savings
Mobilisation in Nigeria. African Review of Money Finance and Banking, 23-49.
World Bank, 2016a. Republic of Korea economic data retrieved from
http://data.worldbank.org/country/korea-rep?view=chart on 20th November 2016
Copyright UCT
- 60 -
World Bank, 2016b. Republic of Zambia economic data retrieved from
http://data.worldbank.org/country/zambia?view=chart on 20th November 2016
Yu, K. M., Wu, A. M., Chan, W. S., & Chou, K. L. (2015). Gender differences in financial literacy
among Hong Kong workers. Educational Gerontology, 41(4), 315-326.
Copyright UCT
- 61 -
APPENDICES
Appendix A: Ethics clearance
Graduate School
orBUSINESS UNIVERSITYOF CAPETOWN
GSB/MBA/ETHICS/001
John Chundu
Graduate School of Business, University of Cape Town
Prof Ralph Hamann
GSB Research Director
Research Chair (UCT ACDI)
T: +27 (0)21 406 1503
Cape Town, 19 January 2017
Dear John,
RE: ETHICS APPROVAL
Thank you for submitting your ethical clearance application for your research on “Determinants of saving
among the Zambian middle class: The banking employees’ perspective”.
This is to confirm that your application has been assessed by the GSB’s Ethics in Research Committee according
to the rules and norms of the University and Commerce Faculty, and that it has been approved.
Please note that if you make any substantial change in your research procedure that could affect the experiences
of the participants, you must submit a revised protocol to the Committee for approval.
We wish you all the best for your research.
Kind regards
Copyright UCT
- 62 -
Appendix B: Notice to Respondents
This questionaire is being conducted by an MBA student at the Graduate School of Business,
University of Cape Town. The intention of this study is to contribute to the body of literature by
examining and understand the determinants of saving among the Zambian banking employees.
The research has been approved by the Commerce Faculty Ethics in Research Committee and is
conducted for academic purposes to fulfil the requirements of the Masters in Business
Administration degree programme.
You will not be requested to supply any identifiable information to ensure anonymity of your
responses. All information from this questionaire will be kept confidential, consolidated and not
linked to individual responses. Your participation is voluntary and you have the right to withdraw
from this research at anytime. Further, you have the right to refuse to answer any questions you feel
are not appropriate. Only the researcher will have access to completed questionnaires. The
questionaires will be deleted or shreded upon completion of the research, submission and
acceptance of the report to the University.
The questionaire will take between 10 – 15 minutes to complete and should be returned to the
researcher by xxxxxx using the email address indicated below.
Should you have any questions regarding this research, please feel free to contact the researcher at:
[email protected] or Mobile phone no. +260 xxx xxxxxx
Thank you in anticipation.
John Chundu
Copyright UCT
- 63 -
Appendix C: Instructions for distribution of questionnaire
Please follow the distribution pattern in the table. To avoid the possibility of having respondents
from the same unit, please distribute the questionnaire across a wide spectrum of staff (i.e.
operations, sales, finance etc.). Non-Zambian banking staff do not qualify for this study.
Profile of respondents
Description of respondent type Number to be sampled
Clerical staff (as per criteria of your bank) 5
Managerial staff ( as per criteria of your bank) 5
Executive staff ( as per criteria of your bank) 5
For easy follow up / reminders by the researcher, keep details of staff to whom the questionnaire
will be sent and share the said details with the researcher.
Thank you!
Copyright UCT
- 64 -
Appendix D: Research Instrument
Instructions on how to complete questionnaire
Section A: For each row, please select what is applicable to you.
Section B, C, D & E: Select the choice or answer that suits you the best.
Return questionnaire to [email protected] once completed.
Section A
No. Classification 1 2 3 4 5
a. Gender Male Female Other
b. Age (years) < 25 26 - 35 36 - 45 46 - 55 > 55
c. Marital Status Married Single Divorced Co-habiting
d Number of children 0 1 2 3 >3
e. Educational Level Grade 12
Certificate
Professional
certificates
Diploma Bachelor’s
Degree /
Masters/Phd
Other
f. Monthly Gross Salary
Range (ZMW)
< 10000 10001 - 20000 20001 - 35000 35001 -
50000
> 50000
g. Level in organisation Clerical Managerial Executive
h. Total indebtedness (ZMW
& foreign currency bank
loans - reported in ZMW)
< 100000 100001 -
300000
300001 -
600000
600001 -
900000
>900000
Copyright UCT
- 65 -
i. Province of your tribal grouping
1. Lusaka
2. Central
3. Southern
4. Western
5. Eastern
6. Muchinga
7. Northern
8. Luapula
9. Copperbelt
10. North Western
11. Other
Section B
No. Questions Strongly
Disagree
Disagree Neither
disagree nor
agree
Agree Strongly
agree
1 2 3 4 5
1 I know how much money I
spent last month
2 I am happy with my
financial / budgeting skills
3 I own shares / trade on the
stock exchange
4 I have an Investment /
savings account
Copyright UCT
- 66 -
5 I know the interest rate(s) I
pay on my loan(s)
6 I have an insurance life
Cover and or retirement
annuity
7 I make voluntary
contributions on top of my
mandated monthly pension
contributions
8 I currently save or put
money away
9 I always think about life
after retirement
10 I do not wait for store sales
promotions, I buy today
when I need it
11 I have borrowed in the last
24 months
12 I have taken on too much
debt (Debt service ratio:
Monthly loan repayments /
Monthly income after tax
+ NAPSA + Pension >
50%)
Copyright UCT
- 67 -
13 I think easy access to
credit (loans) hinders
saving
Section C
No. Question Never Once a while Sometimes Often Always
1 2 3 4 5
14 How often did your
parents / relatives or
friends speak to you about
money or investments
when you were growing
up?
15 How often do you discuss
money issues with your
kids? (Skip question if you
have no kids).
16 How often do you support
your siblings or parents
financially?
Section D
No. Questions More than
K102
Exactly K102 Less than
K102
Do not
Know
No
Answer
1 2 3 4 5
Copyright UCT
- 68 -
17 Suppose you had K100 in
a savings account and the
interest rate was 2% per
year. After 5 years, how
much do you think you
would have in the account
if you left the money to
grow?
No Question More than
today
Exactly the
same as today
Less than
today
Do not
know
No answer
1 2 3 4 5
18 Imagine that the interest
rate on your savings
account was 1% per year
and inflation was 2% per
year. After 1 year, would
you be able to buy more
than, exactly the same as,
or less than today with the
money in this account?
More than
today
Exactly the
same as today;
Less than
today
Do not
Know
No Answer
Section E
No. Question True False Do not Know No Answer
1 2 3 4
19 Do you think that the
following statement is true
or false? Buying a single
company stock usually
provides a safer return than
Copyright UCT
- 69 -
a stock mutual fund (i.e. a
collection of stocks and or
bonds).
Copyright UCT