enabling awp scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/awpc 2015... · lloyd...

27
Enabling AWP Scalability Dr. Ted Blackmon Lloyd Rankin Lessons Learned from the Field

Upload: others

Post on 26-Sep-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Enabling AWP Scalability

Dr. Ted BlackmonLloyd Rankin

Lessons Learned from the Field

Page 2: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

The benefits of AWP have been documented 

through a number of sources

Vendor Case Studies / Awards

Early ProjectsAdopting AWP

CII Research

COAA Presentations/ Awards

Fiatech Presentations/ Awards

2

Page 3: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Knowing the pitfalls can help you avoid them.

Page 4: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Pitfalls to Avoid in Advanced

Work Packaging on Your Projects

Page 5: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Difficulty in finding experienced Workface Planning Personnel

Page 6: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Lack of adequate training & coaching for newly appointed Workface Planners

Page 7: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Appointment of Workface Planners without requisite field experience

Page 8: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Lack of adequate involvement from EPCM & O-O in the WFP process

Page 9: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Lack of adequate staffing for support of AWP automation systems

Page 10: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Contractual specifications for AWP are overly broad and not specific as to requirements

Page 11: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Processes from support groups (project controls, engineering, etc …) are not aligned to support WFP effort

Page 12: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Level 3 construction schedule is not organized by CWPs

Page 13: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Dogmatic application of AWP principles (as opposed to making it work for your organization)

Page 14: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Lack of effective engagement with GF in building work

Page 15: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Work packages are overloaded with QA/QC

Page 16: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Not enough effort on constraint identification & removal

Page 17: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

IWPs become static –Work packages not being updated as initial plans change

Page 18: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Building CPM schedule of IWPs

Page 19: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Not updating schedule man-hrestimates when reality of IWP development shows schedule is ‘off’

Page 20: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Inability to get data from external stake-holders

Page 21: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Lack of well-defined CWPs / EWPs in engineering data

Page 22: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Model objects / attributes not able to support automation of work steps for IWPs

Page 23: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Contractors lack mature systems for managing materials & tracking progress

Page 24: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Data loaded into Progressing & Materials systems does not match data in WFP tool

Page 25: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Systems not identified on drawings / model components early enough

Page 26: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

Late start means AWP Automation systems were not bench tested prior to field deployment

Page 27: Enabling AWP Scalability - groupasi.netgroupasi.net/conferencelibrary/2015/AWPC 2015... · Lloyd Rankin Dr. Ted Blackmon ... CII Research COAA Presentations / Awards Fiatech Presentations

What are your experiences to

learn from?