evolution of the thermodynamical and chemical properties ... · surface brightness analysis: csb+t...

14
Paolo Tozzi Trieste Evolution of the Thermodynamical and Chemical properties of the IntraCluster Medium with I. Balestra, S. Ettori, P. Rosati, S. Borgani, J. Santos, A. Bignamini, V. Mainieri, C. Norman Granada, May 2008 The X-ray Universe XMM2235: z=1.39 180 ks with Chandra, PI Chris Mullis

Upload: others

Post on 18-Aug-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Evolution of the Thermodynamical and Chemical properties ... · Surface Brightness analysis: CSB+t cool stacked SB profiles indicate a significant fraction of moderate CC @ z=[0.7-1.4]

Paolo Tozzi Trieste

Evolution of the Thermodynamicaland Chemical properties of the

IntraCluster Medium

with I. Balestra, S. Ettori, P. Rosati, S. Borgani, J. Santos, A. Bignamini,

V. Mainieri, C. Norman

Granada, May 2008The X-ray Universe

XM

M2235: z=

1.39 180 ks w

ith C

han

dra, PI C

hris M

ullis

Page 2: Evolution of the Thermodynamical and Chemical properties ... · Surface Brightness analysis: CSB+t cool stacked SB profiles indicate a significant fraction of moderate CC @ z=[0.7-1.4]

Fe line is detected in most of the z>1 X-ray clusters

P. Rosati et al. 2004

Page 3: Evolution of the Thermodynamical and Chemical properties ... · Surface Brightness analysis: CSB+t cool stacked SB profiles indicate a significant fraction of moderate CC @ z=[0.7-1.4]

We select from the Chandra archive 56 clusters at z>0.3 (among them 7 clusters at z>1)

Distribution of temperature and z of the Chandra high-zsample

Balestra et al. 2007

Page 4: Evolution of the Thermodynamical and Chemical properties ... · Surface Brightness analysis: CSB+t cool stacked SB profiles indicate a significant fraction of moderate CC @ z=[0.7-1.4]

Iron abundance vs redshift

Balestra et al. 2007See also Maughan et al. 2008

Small effect of cooling cores.When does mostof the evolution occur?Use of XMM datafor 0.2<z<0.8

Page 5: Evolution of the Thermodynamical and Chemical properties ... · Surface Brightness analysis: CSB+t cool stacked SB profiles indicate a significant fraction of moderate CC @ z=[0.7-1.4]

Calura Matteucci & Tozzi 2007

Fe abundance evolution and S0 fraction evolution

Page 6: Evolution of the Thermodynamical and Chemical properties ... · Surface Brightness analysis: CSB+t cool stacked SB profiles indicate a significant fraction of moderate CC @ z=[0.7-1.4]

Cora et al. 2008

Dynamical origin of the Fe abundance evolution

Page 7: Evolution of the Thermodynamical and Chemical properties ... · Surface Brightness analysis: CSB+t cool stacked SB profiles indicate a significant fraction of moderate CC @ z=[0.7-1.4]

Santos et al. 2008

Investigating the Cool Core fraction in the distant Cluster population

Page 8: Evolution of the Thermodynamical and Chemical properties ... · Surface Brightness analysis: CSB+t cool stacked SB profiles indicate a significant fraction of moderate CC @ z=[0.7-1.4]

8

Characterization of a CC Cluster

– Central temperature decrease: Tcentral ~ 1/3 Taverage

– Central Surface Brightness (SB) excess

– Cooling time, tcool: shorter than Hubble Time

                                                     

t cool∝C SB−0 .93

Santos et al. 2008

Page 9: Evolution of the Thermodynamical and Chemical properties ... · Surface Brightness analysis: CSB+t cool stacked SB profiles indicate a significant fraction of moderate CC @ z=[0.7-1.4]

Santos et al. 2008

Searching for cool cores in high-z clusters

LOW-z Strong CC

Mod CC - - -

NCC

HIGH-z Mod CC - - -

NCC

Page 10: Evolution of the Thermodynamical and Chemical properties ... · Surface Brightness analysis: CSB+t cool stacked SB profiles indicate a significant fraction of moderate CC @ z=[0.7-1.4]

X-ray properties of distant optically selected clusters (RCS)

Bignamini et al. 2008

Page 11: Evolution of the Thermodynamical and Chemical properties ... · Surface Brightness analysis: CSB+t cool stacked SB profiles indicate a significant fraction of moderate CC @ z=[0.7-1.4]

Santos et al. 2008

No cool cores in RCS (optically selected) Clusters

Page 12: Evolution of the Thermodynamical and Chemical properties ... · Surface Brightness analysis: CSB+t cool stacked SB profiles indicate a significant fraction of moderate CC @ z=[0.7-1.4]

The future of X-ray surveys

Page 13: Evolution of the Thermodynamical and Chemical properties ... · Surface Brightness analysis: CSB+t cool stacked SB profiles indicate a significant fraction of moderate CC @ z=[0.7-1.4]

WFXTpsf 5''FOV 1 sq deg

C. Norman, R. Giacconi, A. Ptak, P. Rosati, R. Gilli, S. Borgani, M. Paolillo, P.T., S. Allen +...

Page 14: Evolution of the Thermodynamical and Chemical properties ... · Surface Brightness analysis: CSB+t cool stacked SB profiles indicate a significant fraction of moderate CC @ z=[0.7-1.4]

Summary

Evidence of evolution in the average Fe abundance, a factor of 2 from z~0.5 to z=0. ICM was already substantially enriched at z>1. This evolution can be explained by the sink of low entropy, high-metallicity gas associated with small halos and/or galaxies.

Surface Brightness analysis: CSB+tcool

stacked SB profiles indicate

a significant fraction of moderate CC @ z=[0.7-1.4] Absence of pronounced CC at high-z Absence of pronounced CC in optical selected high-z cluster.

To capitalize what we have learned so far with Chandra and XMM we must have soon a mission devoted to a wide area deep survey with a good spatial resolution ~ 5'' like WFXT. The technological challenge for the mirrors is crucial.