formation and evolution of molecules behind shocks george hassel dept. of physics, the ohio state...

17
Formation and Evolution of Molecules Behind Shocks GEORGE HASSEL Dept. of Physics, The Ohio State University [email protected] Eric Herbst (Ohio State), Ted Bergin (U. Michigan) SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 8, 2008 MWAM’08

Upload: makayla-weber

Post on 27-Mar-2015

216 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Formation and Evolution of Molecules Behind Shocks GEORGE HASSEL Dept. of Physics, The Ohio State University ghassel@mps.ohio-state.edu Eric Herbst (Ohio

Formation and Evolution of Molecules Behind Shocks

GEORGE HASSEL Dept. of Physics, The Ohio State University

[email protected]

Eric Herbst (Ohio State), Ted Bergin (U. Michigan)SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 8, 2008 MWAM’08

Page 2: Formation and Evolution of Molecules Behind Shocks GEORGE HASSEL Dept. of Physics, The Ohio State University ghassel@mps.ohio-state.edu Eric Herbst (Ohio

OVERVIEW

• Can shocks form dense clouds from diffuse ISM? (Bergin et al. 2004)

• Replicate molecular observations?

– Ice composition with AV (Whittet et al. 2007, Nummelin et al. 2001)

– Complex gas molecules: L134N, TMC-1 (Ohishi et al 1992, Wakelam, Herbst & Selsis 2007)

Page 3: Formation and Evolution of Molecules Behind Shocks GEORGE HASSEL Dept. of Physics, The Ohio State University ghassel@mps.ohio-state.edu Eric Herbst (Ohio

Modifications:

• Read shock hydro results as input

• Compute dust temperature

• New / modified rates:– Photodesorption

– Eley-Rideal

– CO + O surface barrier

OSU GAS-GRAIN NETWORK

Grain Model: r = 0.1 m Spherical, silicate grains

Rate equations – no stochastic methods

Page 4: Formation and Evolution of Molecules Behind Shocks GEORGE HASSEL Dept. of Physics, The Ohio State University ghassel@mps.ohio-state.edu Eric Herbst (Ohio

Shock Chemistry Model• Hydrodynamical 1 point model (Bergin et al. 2004)

• Diffuse ISM -> Shock -> Dense cloud?

• Formation of H2(g) & CO(g) - ices & complex species?

Photos from NASA-APOD Archive

Page 5: Formation and Evolution of Molecules Behind Shocks GEORGE HASSEL Dept. of Physics, The Ohio State University ghassel@mps.ohio-state.edu Eric Herbst (Ohio

Physical Conditions

• nH, Tg – dense cloud ~105-6 yr

• AV, Td – more gradual change

Page 6: Formation and Evolution of Molecules Behind Shocks GEORGE HASSEL Dept. of Physics, The Ohio State University ghassel@mps.ohio-state.edu Eric Herbst (Ohio

Photodesorption Rates

CO:

Direct photodesorption

Temperature dependent

CO2:

Photodissociation / desorption

Temperature, coverage dependentN2:

Direct photodesorption only with CO

**indicates non-thermal**

H2O:

Photodissociation / desorption

Oberg et al. 2007, in prep.

Page 7: Formation and Evolution of Molecules Behind Shocks GEORGE HASSEL Dept. of Physics, The Ohio State University ghassel@mps.ohio-state.edu Eric Herbst (Ohio

Ice – No Photodesorption

Ices: Whittet et al. 2007, CO(g): Ohishi et al 1992 (TMC-1, L134N)

Page 8: Formation and Evolution of Molecules Behind Shocks GEORGE HASSEL Dept. of Physics, The Ohio State University ghassel@mps.ohio-state.edu Eric Herbst (Ohio

Ice – Photodesorption

Page 9: Formation and Evolution of Molecules Behind Shocks GEORGE HASSEL Dept. of Physics, The Ohio State University ghassel@mps.ohio-state.edu Eric Herbst (Ohio

Ice Composition

• Formation at AV ~ 3-4

OH(s) + H(s) -> H2O(s)

CO(g) -> CO(s)

Page 10: Formation and Evolution of Molecules Behind Shocks GEORGE HASSEL Dept. of Physics, The Ohio State University ghassel@mps.ohio-state.edu Eric Herbst (Ohio

Ice Composition

CO(s) + OH(s) -> CO2(s)

CO2(s) + h -> CO(s) + O(s)

CO(s) + O(s) -> CO2(s)

EA = 290 K (Roser et al. 2001)

= 130 K (Ruffle & Herbst 2001)

Page 11: Formation and Evolution of Molecules Behind Shocks GEORGE HASSEL Dept. of Physics, The Ohio State University ghassel@mps.ohio-state.edu Eric Herbst (Ohio

CO2 Ice

Td0=20 K

EA= 130 K

EA=290 K

Td0=15 K

EA= 130 K

EA=290 K

Page 12: Formation and Evolution of Molecules Behind Shocks GEORGE HASSEL Dept. of Physics, The Ohio State University ghassel@mps.ohio-state.edu Eric Herbst (Ohio

Complex Gas Molecules

H2S NH3

HC3N

14 species

6 species

17-29 species

Page 13: Formation and Evolution of Molecules Behind Shocks GEORGE HASSEL Dept. of Physics, The Ohio State University ghassel@mps.ohio-state.edu Eric Herbst (Ohio

Conclusions• Ice composition:

H2O : CO : CO2 ~ observed abundances

AV Threshold

CH4 minimized

• Governed by photodesorption

• Gas phase molecules – 3 distinct evolution stages

Page 14: Formation and Evolution of Molecules Behind Shocks GEORGE HASSEL Dept. of Physics, The Ohio State University ghassel@mps.ohio-state.edu Eric Herbst (Ohio

Acknowledgements

• Rob Garrod

• Herma Cuppen & Karin Oberg

• MWAM ’08 Organizing Committee

Page 15: Formation and Evolution of Molecules Behind Shocks GEORGE HASSEL Dept. of Physics, The Ohio State University ghassel@mps.ohio-state.edu Eric Herbst (Ohio
Page 16: Formation and Evolution of Molecules Behind Shocks GEORGE HASSEL Dept. of Physics, The Ohio State University ghassel@mps.ohio-state.edu Eric Herbst (Ohio
Page 17: Formation and Evolution of Molecules Behind Shocks GEORGE HASSEL Dept. of Physics, The Ohio State University ghassel@mps.ohio-state.edu Eric Herbst (Ohio