hydraulic fracturing in the marcellus shale: water and health, facts vs fiction

5/24/2018 Hydraulic Fracturing In the Marcellus Shale: water and health, facts vs fiction

1/41

#$%&'( )'*+ *, )-. #$%&'()*'+, +- *./

/ ).0 +1 -. &)-2 , ()3 43 ,'()'*+ #$%'()*&++,-#-%(+&%./)(,+ *#0)(*$,) 1


2/41

!"#$%&'() +$%),&$(-.(- ,!/ 0%$)/''&1 1!%'/!"#$% "'( )$"*#+, -".#/ 0/1 -2.#23'

4 567*2."#23' 38 #+$

!"#$$%& ()

9+$3(3%$ -1 9+$:, ;+), -4?@A;


3/41

!"#$%&'() +$%),&$(-. (- ,/0 1%$)0''&2 3/%'0

!

!"#$%&'() +$%),&$(-. (- ,/0 1%$)0''&2 3/%'04 5%,0$ %-# !0%',/6 +%),2 728

+(),(9-8 !"#$%&'() + ,-./ 0$ 123%&456 !"764&8 "6 94&3643 56: ;358)(< 188 %&'()=

%3=3%>3:< ?" #5%) "@ )(&= 0""A 25$ 03 7=3: "% %3#%":743: &6 56$ 25))3% B(5)="3>3%

B&)("7) B%&))36 #3%2&==&"6 3C43#) &6 )(3 45=3 "@ 0%&3@ D7")5)&"6= 320":&3: &6 4%&)&458

5%)&483= 56: %3>&3B=< E"% 2"%3 &6@"%25)&"6F 4"6)54)G

123%&456 !"764&8 "6 94&3643 56: ;358)(

.HHI J%"5:B5$F 97&)3 ,-,?3B K"%AF ?3B K"%A .--,LMINO-

P38< Q,.,R LO,MS-//< E5C Q,.,R LO,M/H.H

TUVG ())#GWWBBB


4/41

!"#$%&'( *+,(&%- +( .&%#( '(/ 0#'-12

"

#$%% '($)*'+, -./0/1=="4&5)3 _&%34)"% "@ )(3 9"7)(B3=)

Z366=$8>56&5 X6>&%"6236)58 ;358)( Z%"`34)

!"!#$$%&' )*

1$2.3)% .4%%350, 10, 6321+, 6324)1,632)-P"C&4"8"'&=) 5) b836 E588= ;"=#&)58

+,-. /%,,0' 12

357.45+ #/ 8($--4, 10, 1-.1=="4&5)3 Z($=&4&56F 934)&"6 "@

c447#5)&"658 [3:&4&63F b7)(%&3

!8&6&4F V):56&5< ;3 '") (&= J


5/41

!"#$%&'() +$%),&$(-. (- ,/0 1%$)0''&2 3/%'0

=


6/41

!"#$%&'( *+,(&%- +( .&%#( '(/ 0#'-12

>

:8 10=)%54)


7/41

!"#$%&'() +$%),&$(-. (- ,/0 1%$)0''&2 3/%'0

?


8/41

!"#$%&'( *+,(&%- +( .&%#( '(/ 0#'-12

@

a64%35=3: 5B5%363== 50"7) 7=&6' 5 (&'(8$ )34(6&458 #%"43== 45883:

($:%578&4 @%54)7%&6' )" %34">3% 65)7%58 '5= )%5##3: :33# B&)(&6 )(3

[5%43887= =(583 (5= 4%35)3: D73=)&"6= 50"7) %385)3: (7256M(358)(

56: 36>&%"6236)58 &2#54)=< 1=="4&5)3: 5%'7236)=F 0")( #%" 56:

#5#3% &= 5&23: 5) 5 =$=)325)&4F "0`34)&>3 %3>&3B "@ :"47236)3:

[5%43887= 9(583 Z85$5=) =)%3)4(3= "@ %7%58F 6"%)(35=)3%6 123%&45< a) &= 3=)&25)3: )" (5%0"% 2"%3 )(56 I--

)%&88&"6 470&4 @33) "@ 65)7%58 '5=F 25&68$ 23)(563F B&)( 56 3=)&25)3: B388(35: >5873 "@

^. )%&88&"6

%3=3%>3= &6 )(3 36)&%3 T3= %3#%3=36) 56 &2#%3==&>3 S3=F

&6 )7%6F 4"78: =7##8$F 5) #%3=36) %5)3=F )(&= 65)&"6e= 65)7%58M'5= 633:= @"% %"7'(8$ HL $35%=3%)&M

458 @%54)7%3= Qf`"&6)=gRF )(3%30$ 47%%36)8$ 6343==&)5)&6' )(3 5##8&45)&"6 "@ ("%&d"6)58F

=70=7%@543 :%&88&6' )34(6&D73=F B&)( 36'&633%&6' #%"43:7%3= )(5) &6>"A3 =70=3D736)F

(&'(M#%3==7%3F (&'(M>"8723 ($:%578&4 @%54)7%&6' Q;];ER 56: %385)3: )34(6&D73= &6

%3D7&%3 @%54)7%&6' 03457=3F 58)("7'( )(3$ 5%3 >3%$ #"%"7=F )("=3 #"%3= 5%3 6") &6)3%4"6M

634)3: 56: 5%3 58=" A6"B6 5= f6") #3%235083g 03457=3 "@ )(&=< P(3 @%54)7%&6' #%"43==

2&'%5)&"6 7#B5%:F )"B5%: )(3 =7%@543&%"6236)58 56: (7256M(358)(&2#54) @%"2 )(3 85))3% 4"2#"636)= "@ )(3 ;];EE=3= )"

3C32#8&@$F &6 '363%58F )(&= #(36"236"6"&: "@ 4%&)&458 5658$=3= 56: :&=47==&"6= "@ :"=3M%3=#"6=3 %385)&"6=(=

=" '3%2563 )" %385)3: )"C&4&)$ 5%'7236)=< ["%3">3%F )" :5)3F %385)&>38$ 8&))83 (5= 0336

#708&=(3: %3'5%:&6' %"@#%,[5%43887=M%385)3: ;];EEM%385)3: &64&:36)=F )(3&% 65)7%3=F

)%73 Q6") &25'&63:F ($#")(3=&d3:F "% )(3"%&d3:R 78)&25)3 &2#54)Q=R 58"6' )(3=3 8&63=36)3%=F #%3==7%3 =36M

="%=F 56: 256$ 4"2#83C =3%&3= "@ 4"6)%"8 >58>3= 56: 256&@"8:=< 1 %385)3: :&5'%52 "@

)(3 ">3%588 =)%74)7%58 =3)7# &6 5 )$#&458 [5%43887= B388 &= =336 &6 +(.&$0 AF 63C) #5'33(&483 #8545%:&6'F 56: 4"6)%"883: >"8723= "@

;];EE 4(32&458=< \388=&)3 =7%@543M=5@3)$ 4"6)%"8= %3D7&%3 4"6)%"883: 5443==W=347%&)$F

4(32&458 &="85)&"6W#%")34)&"6F 56: #3%="658 #%")34)&>3 3D7ì) QZZXR @"% 635%0$B"%A3%= "@ 256$ )%5:3=< 97%@543 4"6)%"8= 5) )(3 B388(35: 58=" &6487:3 #%3==7%3M%5)3:

'%"76: 25)=h 2&C&6' 56: &6`34)&6' 4"6)%"883%=h ("8:&6'WB5=)3 #"6:=h %34">3%&6'W%3M

+(.&$0 @8l952#83 E%54)7%3 E87&: !"2#"=&)&"6 0$ \3&'()&%"6236)58 a2#54) 9)5)3236) "6 65)7%58 '5= :%&88&6' 0$ )(3 ?3B K"%A _3#5%)M

236) "@ X6>&%"6236)58 !"6=3%>5)&"6 _&>&=&"6 "@ [&63%58 U3="7%43= ;


13/41

!"#$%&'() +$%),&$(-. (- ,/0 1%$)0''&2 3/%'0

C!

_"B6M("83 =5@3)$ 235=7%3= 4"643%6&6' ;];EE= 58=" &6487:3 #%3==7%3M%5)3: #8720M

&6' 56: (5%:B5%3h B388 45=&6'= Q)$#&4588$ 6"B )%SM=)338W43236) &6 )(3 5%35 "@

'%"76:B5)3% 5D7&@3%= 56: )(3 >3%)&458 4"2#"636) "@ )(3 B388 =(5@)=Rh 08"B"7) #%3>36M

)(3=3 6723%"7= =5@3'75%:=F )(3%3 %325&6= 5 '%35) :358 "@ #708&4 =A3#)&4&=2 50"7) )(3&%

'%"76:B5)3%F 5&%F 56: =7%@543 B5)3%38$ 4(5%54)3%&d3 56: D756)&@$

56$ 56: 588 =70=7%@543F ;];EM%385)3: &64&:36)= )(5)F )" :5)3F (5>3 54)7588$ 5:>3%=38$ 5@M

@34)3: (7256 (358)( &6 )(3 :&=)%&07)&"6 "@ 65)7%58M'5= :%&88&6' 56: #%":74)&"6 54)&>&)&3=

&6 )(3 [5%43887=< P(&= =)7:$ &= %3=)%&4)3: )" )(3 54)758 ($:%"@%54)7%&6' #%"43== &)=38@F 6")

)" )(3 =7%@543 54)&>&)&3= "@ :%&88&6'h )(3 =70=7%@543 54)&>&)&3= "@ :%&88&6'h )(3 07&8:&6' "@

%385)3: %"5:= "% #&&63=h "% )(3 #%"43==3= "@ 45=&6' 5 B388 m 588 "@ B(&4( 5%3 4"22"6

)" :%&88&6' "@ 56$ B388 @"% 56$ #7%#"=3F &6487:&6' 5) 835=) .I 2&88&"6 :"23=)&4 B5)3%

B388=EQ,--S :5)5R 56: 5) 835=) N,IF--- 54)&>3 "&8 56: '5= B388=FQ,--H :5)5R :%&883: &6 )(3T5)&"6 (5= &6:3#36:36)8$ 36:"%=3: )(3 3==36)&58 3D7&>583643 "@ ;];E

56: ")(3% )$#3= "@ :%&88&6'F =)5)&6'F &6 &)= "B6 B"%:=F fXC43#) @"% =#34&58 )""8= 7=3: 76M

:3%'%"76:F ("%&d"6)58 :%&88&6' &= #3%@"%23: 7=&6' )(3 =523 3D7ì) 56: )34(6"8"'$

M

236)F 56: B5=)3 (56:8&6'>P(&= =)7:$ 58=" "68$ 4"643%6= &)=38@ B&)( :"47236)3:F

5:>3%=3 (7256M(358)( &2#54) )" :5)3F 6") @7)7%3 &2#54)Q=R "@ 56$ ="%)56&5F P3663==33F ]&%'&6&5F 56: \3=) ]&%'&6&5R B3%3

D73%&3:F &6 B%&)&6'F 0$ B5$ "@ )(3&% %3=#34)&>3 _3#5%)236)= "@ ;358)( Q_c;RF _3#5%)M

236)= "@ X6>&%"6236)58 Z%")34)&"6W!"6=3%>5)&"6 Q_XZ "% _X!RF "6 [5%4( -SF ,-.LF

5= B388 5= >&5 )(3&% %3=#34)&>3 T&%"6236)58 Z%")34)&"6 1'364$ QT9 XZ1R U3'&"658

%3=#34) )" =3>3%58 A3$ #&343= "@ :5)5< P("=3 %3D73=)=F #8543: B&)( )(3=3 >5%&"7= 5'364&3=

76:3% 5##8&45083 =)5)3 56: @3:3%58 @%33:"2M"@M&6@"%25)&"6 83'&=85)&"6F B3%3 @"% )(3 @"8M

8"B&6' 56: B3%3 %385)3: "68$ )" [5%43887= 9(583 ($:%"@%54)7%&6' 54)&>&)&3=G

*790+ 0)*$85 350 7)2.5$E9)*


15/41

!"#$%&'() +$%),&$(-. (- ,/0 1%$)0''&2 3/%'0

C=

>8

56:W"% )(3&% 4"6=)&)736) 4(32&458= &6 B(&4( (7256 (358)( 56:W"% )(3 8"458 36>&M

%"6236) B5=F "% 25$ (5>3 0336F 5:>3%=38$ &2#54)3:F 8&=)3: 0$ 4"76)$F 4&)$W)"B6W)"B6=(W8"45)&"6F :5)3F 56: )&23&6'

56:W"% )(3 8"458 36>&%"6236) B5=F "% 25$ (5>3 0336F 5:>3%=38$ &2#54)3:F 8&=)3: 0$

4"76)$F 4&)$W)"B6W)"B6=(W8"45)&"6F :5)3F 56: )&23

HI 1J KL KI

JM!

?U[>N56: 6"

54)758 :%&88&6'W

;];E 54)&>&)$ &6

=)5)3

@O?CO>@

?_Z?N56: 6" 54)758

:%&88&6'W;];E

54)&>&)$ &6 =)5)3

@O?DO>@

?_ZF B&)( 6" 54)758

:%&88&6'W;];E

54)&>&)$ &6 =)5)3

@O?CO>@

UPc@NIW,NW.L 56:

?EUAN)(%"7'(

>>OG>O>@

JPQOR

?_ZF B&)( 485&2=

)(5) )(3 [5%43887=

9(583 &= 6") #%3=36)

&6 jK 56: 6" 54)758

:%&88&6'W;];E

54)&>&)$ &6 =)5)3

@O?BO>@

?_Z 56: UPc 56:

6" 54)758 :%&88&6'W

;];E 54)&>&)$

&6 =)5)3

@O?>O>@

?_Z 56: 6" 54)758

:%&88&6'W;];E

54)&>&)$ &6 =)5)3

AOG?O>@

?_Z "6 &)32= .ML

"@ %3D73=) 56: UPc

%3 &)32 / OW.,W.L

56: ?_Z 56: UPc

>O?>O>A

S3 PR:6

T0.(9-%'

?_ZF U3'&"6A

AO?@O>@

U3'&"6 LG

1##%"C /-CN

&64&:36)= &6>"8>&6'

=#&88= &6)" 65>&'5083

B5)3%=C56: ?_Z

:&%34)8$ %3'5%:&6';];E 54)&>&)$

FO>DO>@

U3'&"6 ,G

?" %34"%:= %3835=3

B&)("7) #5&: @33h @33

B5&>3% :36&3: ?1DN

U3'&"6 ,G

?" %34"%:= %3835=3

B&)("7) #5&: @33h @33

B5&>3% :36&3: ?1DN

U%V'0 >=7225%&d3= )(3 %3=78)= %343&>3: @%"2 354( %3=#34)&>3 =)5)3e= _3#5%)236) "@

;358)( Q_c;R 56: _3#5%)236) "@ X6>&%"6236)58 !"6=3%>5)&"6WZ%")34)&"6 Q_X!WZR 56:

*790+ ()*9%7*

*737)38)52+, ()*-45*), 350 037) 46 ()*-45*)


17/41

!"#$%&'() +$%),&$(-. (- ,/0 1%$)0''&2 3/%'0

C?

M! R: UK 7: 57

?_Z 56: UPc

@O?EO>@

?EU

@O?>O>@

Q85=) %3=#"6=3R

?1aBN56: UPc

56: 6" 54)758

:%&88&6'W;];E

54)&>&)$ &6 =)5)3

@O?CO>@

?_Z 56: UPc

@O>FO>@

?_Z 56: UPc

@O>FO>@

?EUF B&)( &6:&%34)

%3=#"6=3 @%"2 c;

_c;

@O?EO>@

P3834"6@3%3643

56: UPc

@O?EO>@

?1a 56: UPcF

B&)( 485&2= )(5) )(3

[5%43887= 9(583 &=

6") #%3=36) &6 P?

@O>CO>@

?_ZF B&)( 6"

54)758 :%&88&6'W

;];E 54)&>&)$ &6

=)5)3

@O?GO>@

?EU 56: UPcF

B&)( &6:&%34)

%3=#"6=3 @%"2 )(3

\] _3#)< "@ X6>4=FO>@

?_Z 56: UPcF

U3'&"6 I

AOG@O>@

U3'&"6 LG

1##%"C /-

&64&:36)= &6>"8>&6'

=#&88= &6)" 65>&'5083

B5)3%=CN56: ?_Z

:&%34)8$ %3'5%:&6';];E 54)&>&)$

FO>DO>@

?_ZF U3'&"6 /

AO?@O>@

U3'&"6 LG

1##%"C /-

&64&:36)= &6>"8>&6'

=#&88= &6)" 65>&'5083

B5)3%=CN56: ?_Z

:&%34)8$ %3'5%:&6';];E 54)&>&)$

FO>DO>@

U3'&"6 LG

1##%"C /-

&64&:36)= &6>"8>&6'

=#&88= &6)" 65>&'5083

B5)3%=CN56: ?_Z

:&%34)8$ %3'5%:&6';];E 54)&>&)$

FO>DO>@

>N?U[ m 6"63 %385)3: )" )(3 [5%43887= 9(583

?N?_Z m 6" :"47236)= #3%)5&6&6'W%3=#"6=&>3 )" )(3 D73=)&"6= #"=3:

@NUPc m %3@3%%3: )" ")(3% :5)505=3 "% &6@"%25)&"6 ="7%43

AN

BN?1a m 6") 5B5%3 "@ 56$ =74( &64&:36)Q=R"8>3236) &6 )(3=3 45=3=F 6"63 B&)( :"47236)3: (7256M(358)( &2#54)< P(3 5##%"C&25)38$ /-

DN?1 m 6") 5##8&45083h 6" [5%43887= :%&88&6' &6 ?i "% ?K

U%V'0 >8Z%&25%$ =)5)3M 56: @3:3%58M05=3: %3=#"6=3= )" B%&))36 &6D7&%&3= 4&)3: 50">3< Q_c; m

_3#5%)236) "@ ;358)(h _X!WZ m _3#5%)236) "@ X6>&%"6236)58 !"6=3%>5)&"6WZ%")34)&"6h T9 XZ1

m T6&)3: 9)5)3= X6>&%"6236)58 Z%")34)&"6 1'364$F 0$ %3'&"6R


18/41

!"#$%&'( *+,(&%- +( .&%#( '(/ 0#'-12

C@

a6 =("%)F 56: 5= =("B6 &6 U%V'0 >

=)5)3= m 65238$F j36)74A$F [5%$856:F ?3B i3%=3$F P3663==33F 56: ]&%'&6&5 m 5= "@ )(&=

B%&)&6' (5>3 6") 3C#3%&3643: 56$ :%&88&6' 54)&>&)$ "%F )(3%3@"%3F 56$ %385)3: ;];EE

7=3 "% &64&:36)= &6 )(3 [5%43887=< ?3B K"%A Q03@"%3 )(3 47%%36) :%&88&6' 056 "6 ;];EQ=33 #5'3 ,I RF c(&"F Z366=$8>56&5F 56: \3=) ]&%'&6&5F "6 )(3 ")(3% (56:F (5>3 3C#3%&M

(358)( &6 )(3 85))3% )(%33 =)5)3=< T9 XZ1 U3'&"6 ,F 4">3%&6' ?3B K"%A (5=F )" :5)3F 6")

(35:D75%)3%= &6 \5=(&6')"6F _

47%%36) [5%43887= 54)&>&)$F ("B3>3%F :&: %3=#"6: )" )(3 &6D7&%&3=F 56: %3=78)56) :5)5 5%3

8&=)3: 038"B&)$

&6 )("=3 =)5)3=< Q\(36 )(&= P5083 B5= 4%35)3:F &) B5= 6") $3) 3>&:36) )(5) )(3%3 B5= 6"

%385)3: :%&88&6' 54)&>&)$ &6 j36)74A$&=&"6 "@

c&8 56: b5=

?"63

KI ?"63 ?"63 ?"63

M! ?"63 c(&" _3#5%)236) "@

?5)7%58 U3="7%43=

?"63

R:

Z1 _XZ 3E54)=

;5@@CQ??#$K&A@[email protected]>-@58G0AH=HUVHWUP56:

5@@CQ??@5-@6>-0A@$6D#.-="8>?.-3


19/41

!"#$%&'() +$%),&$(-. (- ,/0 1%$)0''&2 3/%'0

CA

U%V'0 @ M

M

3%)&3= )(5) B3%3 3&)(3% =36) 83))3%= "% B3%3 6523: &6 4"6=36) "%:3%= 03)B336 )(3 =)5%) "@

,--N 56: @588 ,-., Q%"7'(8$ 93#)3203%R< T6@"%)765)38$F )(3 83))3%= 5%3 6") 6343==5%&8$

U%V'0 ?Q:5)505=3 4"8834)3: 0$ V57%5 V3'3%3 %3@3%3643RF HOH

45=3=F 56: @"7% Q/R 5::&)&"6588$F %3436)8$ %3#"%)3: 45=3= :3=4%&03: &6 5 #%&>5)3 4"227M

6&45)&"6 "@ 17'7=) .,F ,-.LF B&)( )(3 57)("% "@ )(5) =#%35:=(33)F 76:3% )(3 f457=58&)$

B5)3% ="7%43ZV"

J$(''(-.

M[0$%,(9-2

S-)'0%$ 9$

K9 J$(''(-.\

T0'%,0# W=[%),

.O,?Z OH@Z S/,

U%V'0 @8

45=3= "@ &6)3%3=)Z '%"76:B5)3% =7##8&3=3?

J(=(-&,(9->]

Q9=['%(-,24 >G?

Q9=V(-0#

R9''&,(9-OJ(=(-&,(9-

Q9=['%(-,24A>

R9''&,(9-

Q9=['%(-,24 E@G

:,,$(V&,0# ,9 M(' %-#

^%2 M[0$%,(9-2

I O .I.

K9, :,,$(V&,0# ,9 M('

%-# ^%2 M[0$%,(9-2

HO LI O..

S-#0,0$=(-0# .?] - ON

U%V'0 A< Z366=$8>56&5 _3#5%)236) "@ X6>&%"6236)58 Z%")34)&"6e= QZ1 _XZe=R &6>3=)&'5)&>3

>]

8"458 '%"76:B5)3% =7##8&3=56&5 _3#5%)236) "@ X6>&%"6236)58 Z%")34)&"6e= QZ1 _XZe=R 457=5)&"6 45)3'"%&M

d5)&"6= %3'5%:&6' B5)3%M=7##8$ 4"6)52&65)&"6 %385)3: )" [5%43887= "#3%5)&"6=56&5 _3#5%)236) "@ X6>&%"6236)58 Z%")34)&"6&3B3: 3>3% 6")3: 4"6)52&65)&"6 457=3: 0$

($:%578&4 @%54)7%&6' :&%34)8$g>@Q32#(5=&= 5::3:R&3B "@ 588 &6D7&%$M%385)3: %3=#"6=3= =("B6 &6U%V'0 >

Q50">3R 56: 588 =34"6:5%$ ="7%43= "@ &6@"%25)&"6 =("B6 &6 U%V'0 ?Q50">3R< j36)74A$F[5%$856:F ?3B i3%=3$F P3663==33F 56: ]&%'&6&5 (5>3 0336 3C487:3: @%"2 U%V'0 D:73

)" 854A "@ %385)3: :%&88&6' 54)&>&)$ &6 )("=3 =)5)3=3 56: &6@"%25)&>3 65)7%3 "@ 588 4"2276&45)&"6=F 0")(

B%&))36 56: >3%058F B&)( T9 XZ1 U3'&"6 L &6 )(&= #%"43==h 5==&'63: #3%="6638 )(3%3

B3%3 35'3% )" #%">&:3 5447%5)3 &6@"%25)&"6 56: :&: =" &6 5 =7%#%&=&6'8$ %5#&:F #%"@3=M

=&"658F 56: 4"2#%3(36=&>3 25663%F B&)( 5##%"#%&5)3 @"88"B 7#


23/41

!"#$%&'() +$%),&$(-. (- ,/0 1%$)0''&2 3/%'0

!!

U%V'0 F Q038"BR =("B= )(3 &64&:3643 Q%5)3R "@ 36>&%"6236)58 &64&:36)= 56: 36>&%"6M

236)58 &64&:36)= B&)( :"47236)3: (7256M(358)( &2#54) :&%34)8$ :73 )" ;];E 54)&>M

&)$F #3% .-- B388= :%&883: &6 )(3 [5%43887= 9(583F 7=&6' ;];E )34(6"8"'$F &6 354( =)5)33 @%"2 50">3M4&)3: &6@"%25)&"6 56: %385)3: 4584785)&"6=3 2&==&"6 =)5)3236)= "@ )(3=3 5'364&3=-.@=

_)* 0 C#$C80- 60 @8 -.0#$- @5%@Q

()*+, (%+-$(%.G @5- -.R6$8.>-.@ 6,%$,& "8.06G-$-G 6. -0@%D,6056.7 -.R6$8.>-.@%, C8,6"&a

%,, C%$@0 8E 08"6-@& c "8>>#.6@6-0' 6.G6R6G#%,0' D#06.-00-0' %.G 0@%@-' ,8"%, %.G @$6D%, 78R-$.A

()*+, (%+-$(%.G -.R6$8.>-.@%, $60K0a

-.R6$8.>-.@%, C$8@-"@68. "8.@$6D#@-0 @8 >%K6.7 8#$ "8>>#.6@6-0 %.G -"80&0@->0 G6R-$0-' 0#0@%6.%D,-%.G -"8.8>6"%,,& C$8G#"@6R-a %.G

@5- b.6@-G 3@%@-0 C,%&0 % ,-%G-$056C $8,- 6.


25/41

!"#$%&'() +$%),&$(-. (- ,/0 1%$)0''&2 3/%'0

!=

M

=3$F P3663==33F 56: ]&%'&6&5R (5>3 6") 3C#3%&3643: 56$ %385)3: :%&88&6' )" :5)3< c@ )(3

%325&6&6' @"7% =)5)3=F "68$ )(%33 5:2&) )" 54)&>3 :%&88&6' B&)( ;];EE= &6 )(3 [5%43887=

9(583F 65238$ Z366=$8>56&5F c(&"F 56: \3=) ]&%'&6&5< Q?3B K"%A 4"6)&673= )" #3%2&)8"BM>"8723F 07) 6") (&'(M>"8723F ($:%"@%54)7%&6'h =33 #5'3 ,I&%"6236)58 Z%")34)&"6W!"6=3%>5M

)&"6 @"% )(3 85))3%F )(%33 =)5)3= 5%3 5= @"88"B=56&5 _3#5%)236) "@ ;358)(e= %385)3: =)5)3236) &=G

P(3 2&==&"6 "@ Z1 _c; &= )" #%"2")3 (358)($ 8&@3=)$83=F [$0X0-, (-c&$(02 %-#

#(20%20F 56: )" 36=7%3 )(3 =5@3 :38&>3%$ "@ D758&)$ (358)(45%3 @"% 588 !"22"6B358)(

4&)&d36=>BQ32#(5=&= 5::3:R56&5 _3#5%)236) "@ X6>&%"6236)58 Z%")34)&"6 8&=)= &)= 2&==&"6 =)5)3236) 5=G

S5- L-C%$@>-.@ 8E _.R6$8.>-.@%, )$8@-"@68. 0 >60068. 60 @8 C$8@-"@ )-..0&,R%.6% 0 %6$' ,%.G %.G C8,,#@68. %.G @8!"#./0% 1#" $(% (%+-$( +,0 2+1%$38E 6@0 "[email protected] @5$8#75 % ",-%.-$

-.R6$8.>-.@= T- D;->C5%060 %GG-GB=

16:F )(3 c(&" X6>&%"6236)58 Z%")34)&"6 1'364$e= %385)3: =)5)3236) &=G

e#$ >60068. 60 @8!"#$%&$@5- -.R6$8.>-.@ %.G!)5-/& (%+-$( D& -.0#$6.7 "8>C,6%."- -.@%, ,%8.0@$%@6.7 ,-%G-$056C 6. -.R6$8.>-.@%, 0@-E;->C5%060 %GG-GB=

\3=) ]&%'&6&5e= _3#5%)236) "@ ;358)( 56: ;7256 U3="7%43= =)5)3236) &=G

S5- L-C%$@>-.@ 8E f-%,@5 %.G f#>%. O-08#$"-0` >60068. 60 @8 C$8>8@- %.G C$8R6G- +!!"#!"/6

+$% (%+-$( +,0 ()*+, 2%"./&%2E8$ @5- C-8C,- 8E T-0@ h6$76.6% 6. 8$G-$ @8 6>C$8R- @5-6$

g#%,6@& 8E ,6E->F;->C5%060 %GG-GB=

E&6588$F \3=) ]&%'&6&5e= _3#5%)236) "@ X6>&%"6236)58 Z%")34)&"6e= =)5)3236) &=G

S5- T-0@ h6$76.6% L-C%$@>-.@ 8E _.R6$8.>-.@%, )$8@-"@68.`0 >60068. 60 @8 C$8>8@- % (%+-$(3

-.R6$8.>-.@?G

;->C5%060 %GG-GB=

P(3=3 2&==&"6 =)5)3236)= =)%"6'8$ =7''3=) )(5) )(3=3 %3=#34)&>3 5'364&3= B3%3F &6:33:F

)(3 #%"#3% "63= )" 4"6)54) 56: )" D73%$F 5= :3=4%&03: 50">3< \(&83 )(3 %325&6&6'F

%3=#34)&>3 _3#5%)236)= "@ ;358)( 56: _3#5%)236)= "@ X6>&%"6236)58 Z%")34)&"6W

!"6=3%>5)&"6 &6 )(3 =&C QOR =)5)3= Qj36)74A$F [5%$856:F ?3B i3%=3$F ?3B K"%AF P3663=M

=33F 56: ]&%'&6&5R ">3%8$&6' )(3 [5%43887= =(583 #"=) =&2&85% 2&==&"6 =)5)3236)=F B(&4(


26/41

!"#$%&'( *+,(&%- +( .&%#( '(/ 0#'-12

!>

5%3 35=&8$ @"76: "68&63F )(3=3 5%3 %36:3%3: 2"") B&)( %3=#34) )" %385)3: D73%&3= &6 )(3

47%%36) 50=3643 "@ [5%43887= ;];E :%&88&6'W #%":74)&"6 54)&>&)&3= &6 )("=3 =)5)3=&:3: 5

4"22&)236)= @%"2 )(5) 9)5)3 )" :" ="< 144"%:&6'8$F )(3%3 5%3 6" :&%34) :5)5 @%"2 )(3

?3B K"%A _c; )" &6487:3 &6 )(&= =)7:$< P(3%3 &= 47%%36)8$ 5 =)5)3B&:3 056 "6 f];E

QB&)( 32#(5=&= "6 )(3 f;gR &6 ?3B K"%A =&643 ,--NF &2#"=3: 0$ b">3%6"% !7"2"F

B(&4( &= 3=#34&588$ 47%&"7= &6 8&'() "@ )(3 @54) )(5)F 5= #708&=(3: 0$ )(3 ?3B K"%A

_3#5%)236) "@ X6>&%"6236)58 !"6=3%>5)&"6 &)=38@F f;"%&d"6)58 :%&88&6' (5= 0336 7=3:

&6 ?3B K"%A =&643 )(3 .HN-=P(3 85))3% Q("%&d"6)58M:%&88&6' 54)&>&)$ &6 ?3B K"%AR 5#M

#5%36)8$ =#5663: 635%8$ )(%33 :345:3= Q"% 2"%3h =33 038"BR< P(3 57)("% 58=" %3D73=)3:

&6@"%25)&"6 =&2&85% )" )(5) ")(3%B&=3 %3D73=)3:F 5= 4&)3: 50">3F @%"2 )(3 ?3B K"%A

_3#5%)236) "@ ;358)( B&)( %3=#34) )" 56$ :"47236)3: 5:>3%=3 (7256M(358)( 3>36)=

@%"2 )(3 ("%&d"6)58 :%&88&6' )(5) (5: 0336 4"2#83)3: )(3%3 f=&643 )(3 .HN-=Fg 07)F "643

%3D73=) )" :5)3< 16 3C)36=&>3 a6)3%63) =35%4( 0$ )(3 57)("% (5= @5&83: )" $&38: 56$ 4"6M

"@ f("%&d"6)58 :%&88&6'g )(3%3F ="23 "@ B(&4( >#0@(5>3 &6>"8>3: ($:%"@%54)7%&6'< QP(3

57)("% (5= =#"A36 :&%34)8$ B&)( "63 =35="63: B388 :%&883% @%"2 ?3B K"%A B(" #3%="6M

588$ %3>3583: )(5) (3 (5: 0336 f($:%"@%54)7%&6' &6 ?3B K"%A @"% ">3% ,I $35%=F B&)( 6"

#%"0832= 5) 588&%"6236M

)58 !"6=3%>5)&"6 (5= '363%5)3: 5 %5)(3% =)766&6' %3>385)&"6F D7")3: >3%05)&2 038"BC80-G 6. JII[ 60 E8$ 5675 R8,#>- 5&G$%#,6" E$%"@#$6.7;fhf/B %@-0 @5%@ VIN 8E %,, 7%0 - E$%"@#$- 0@6>#A,%@68. 6. %. %@@->C@ @8 "8>>-$"6%,,& C$8G#"- @5- --@ &8#$ .--G0=??

b&>36 )(&=F &) &= 3>&:36) )(5) m :3=#&)3 5 ="M45883: f056g "6 ($:%"@%54)7%&6' &6 ?3BK"%AF 0")( )(3 )34(6&D73= 56: )34(6"8"'&3= "@ ($:%"@%54)7%&6' (5>3 %325&63: "6'"M

&6' )" :5)3F 5803&) B&)( =25883% R8,#>-0Q6") 6343==5%&8$ @&C-0

_3=#&)3 )(&= 57)("%e= 5))32#)= )" =347%3 %385)3: (7256M(358)( :5)5 @%"2 0")( )(3

?3B K"%A _3#5%)236) "@ ;358)( 56: )(3 ?3B K"%A _3#5%)236) "@ X6>&%"6236)58

!"6=3%>5)&"6F 63&)(3% _3#5%)236) 78)&25)38$ #%">&:3: =74( :5)5< b&>36F )("7'(F )(5)

($:%"@%54)7%&6' &6 ?3B K"%A (5= 6") "68$ 0336 "6'"&6' )(3%3 @"% fI- )" O- $35%=Fg??


27/41

!"#$%&'() +$%),&$(-. (- ,/0 1%$)0''&2 3/%'0

!?

56: %325&6= "6'"&6' )" :5)3 QB&)( >"8723= 83== )(56 N-F--- '588"6=RF =74( ("%&d"6)58

:%&88&6' &6 ?3B K"%A ">3% )("=3 =3>3%58 :345:3= 5##35%= )" (5>3 25&6)5&63: B&)("7)

56$ 3>&:36) 56:W"% )%5435083 5:>3%=3 (7256M(358)( &2#54)Q=Rh ")(3%B&=3F "63 B"78:

(5>3 3C#34)3: B388 #708&4&d3: 3#&:32&"8"'&4 %3#"%)= 56: )%5435083 (7256M(358)( :5)5"6 =74( 25))3%=F B&)( 5 274( 35%8&3%M&2#"=3:F 4"2#%3(36=&>3 056 "6 56$W588 )$#3= 56:

0336 ">3%8""A3: 0$ )(5) 9)5)3 B&)( %3=#34) )" &)= #%3=36) 056 "6 )(3 =523 @&C-"@ :%&88M

M

%36)8$ 7=3: )" 544"2#8&=( )(3 =523 36: %3=78)< a) &= 5##5%36)8$ "68$ )(3 50="87)3 R8,#>-0

@-"5.6g#-

"% @-"5.8,87&"@ )(5) #%"43==< P(3 57)("% #($=&4588$ %3=&:3= &6 56 54)&>3 [5%43887=M:%&88&6'

d"63 5:`5436) )" =3>3%58 ?3B K"%A 4"76)&3= )(5) ">3%8&3 )(3 [5%43887= 5= B388F 56: &)

2"=) 43%)5&68$ &= .8@)(3 57)("%e= 3C#3%&3643 "% "#&6&"6 )(5) )(3 56)&M($:%"@%54)7%&6' 54)&>&=)=&6F "% %3=&:36)= "@F )("=3 63&'(0"%&6' ?3B K"%A 4"76)&3= 5%3 @788$ 5B5%3 "@ )(&= 25))3%Q=33 U%V'0 ?F

50">3RF (5= 0336 >3%$ 54)&>38$ &6>3=)&'5)&6' 485&2= "@ 5883'3: :"23=)&4 B5)3%MB388 56:

=7%@543M=#%&6' 4"6)52&65)&"6 @%"2 ;];EM%385)3: :%&88&6'F 5= 4&)3: (3%3&6< c@ )(3

HSL 4"2#85&6)= 58"6' )(3=3 8&63=F .8.-B5= :3)3%2&63: )" 03 G6$-"@,&457=588$ %385)3: )"

;];E 54)&>&)$< [56$ "@ )(3 Z1 _XZe= 4&)3: :5)5 #"&6)= 854A #%34&=3 :5)3= Q%3:54)3:RF

"@ #")36)&58 &6)3%3=)3: ="8&:=RF 4(8"%&:3F

=":&72F 256'563=3F &%"6F 05%&72F =)%"6)&72F )7%0&:&)$ 56:W"% 5872&672g &6 #")36M

%,,#")36)&58 f054A'%"76:Fg "% 65)7M%588$ "447%%&6'F "63=F 4"22"68$ =336 &6 Z366=$8>56&5 '%"76:B5)3%< P(3 50="87)3 56:

%385)&>3 4"6436)%5)&"6= "@ )(3=3 4(32&458 =#34&3= 25$ 03 =70`34) )" =35="658W%5&6@588

#"==&0&8&)&3=< ["%3">3%F &) &= 6") 4835% 5= )" B(3)(3% )(3 Z1 _XZ #3%@"%23: )(3 6343=M

23)(563 @%"2 0&"'36&4 23)(563 B(36 25A&6' &)= %385)3: :3)3%2&65)&"6= "6 457=5)&"63 25)3%&58= %3>&3B3:56&5 _3#5%)236) "@ ;358)( QZ1

="7%43= @"% %385)3: &6@"%25)&"6F 4&)3: 50">3F ("B3>3%F #%">&:3: 52#83 :"47236)5)&"6

"6 =74( 25))3%= &6 Z366=$8>56&5&%"6236)58 Z%")34)&"6W

!"6=3%>5)&"6 &6 )(3 )B" %325&6&6' =)5)3= Qc(&" 56: \3=) ]&%'&6&5R &6 B(&4( )(3%3 &=F "%

(5= 0336F [5%43887=MW ;];EM:%&88&6' 54)&>&)$F =702&))3: 6" :"47236)3: 3>&:3643 "@5:>3%=3 (7256M(358)( &2#54) %3=78)&6' @%"2 ($:%"@%54)7%&6' &)=38@3&)$ &6 j36)74A$F [5%$856:F ?3B

i3%=3$F P3663==33F 56: ]&%'&6&5h )(3%3@"%3F )(3%3 &= 6" %385)3: (7256M(358)( &2#54)3%8&3= )(3 [5%43887=F (5= 5##5%36)8$ 3C#3%&3643: (&=)"%&458W#%3M

056 ;];E 54)&>&)$ =&643 )(3 .HN-=F 07) 63&)(3% "@ ?3B K"%Ae= D73%&3: 5'364&3= Q_c;

(358)( &2#54)= @%"2 )("=3 (&=)"%&4 54)&>&)&3= &6 )(5) =)5)3F 0$ &)= 4&)3: 5'364&3=< _3=#&)3

)(&=F '&>36 )(3 50=3643 "@ #"=)M056 ;];EM)$#3 :%&88&6' &6 ?3B K"%AF "63 B"78: 6")

8"'&4588$ 3C#34) 56$ =74( &2#54)=< Q\(&83 ?3B K"%A 5##5%36)8$ 4"6)&673= )" #3%2&)

8"BM>"8723 ($:%"@%54)7%&6' nV];EoF )(5) &= 6") )(3 )(%7=) "@ )(&= #5#3%3F )%5435083 :5)5 "6 5:>3%=3

(7256M(358)( &2#54)= @%"2 f("%&d"6)58 :%&88&6'g 56:W"% ($:%"@%54)7%&6' &6 3&)(3% )(3

#%3M056 Q;];E %.GV];E #3%2&))3:R 56:W"% #"=)M056 QV];E 8.,&R 3%5= &6 ?3B K"%A3: &6 %3=#"6=3 )" "7% %3D73=)= @%"2 )(3 T91 XZ1 U3'&"6 ,F ?K

_c;F 56:W"% ?K _X!F 56 5##%"#%&5)3 7#:5)3 )" )(&= #708&45)&"6 B&88 03 %3835=3:38= "@ 23)(563 &6 )(5) '3"'%5#(&4 %3'&"6 5%3 6") 5=="4&5)3: B&)( [5%43887=F

;];EM)$#3 :%&88&6'< P(3%3 25$ 03 #5%58838 =&)75)&"6= 38=3B(3%3 &6 )(3 [5%43887= :&=)%&07M

)&"6F 56: )("=3 =&)75)&"6= =("78: 03 "0`34)&>38$ 5::%3==3: &6 )3%2= "@ )(3&% 78)&25)3 ="7%43Q=R3 0336 :%&883:F )(3%3

&= 5 4"8834)&>3 &64&:3643 "@ =)5)3M83>38 36>&%"6236)58 45=3=W485&2= "@ %"7'(8$ .-k

QHOHW.-F---h =33 U%V'0 @F 50">3R &6 Z366=$8>56&5 QB&)( 5 :&%34)8$ ;];EM%385)3: &64&M

:3643 "@ 83== )(56 ,k n.3: %3B5%:M

&6' &6 )3%2= "@ :3)5&83:F %385)3: 4"6)36)56&5F B(&4( :&: 6") %3=#"6: )" )(3 &6D7&%$R

56: _3#5%)236)= "@ X6>&%"6236)58 Z%")34)&"6W!"6=3%>5)&"6 (5>3F )" :5)3F 5##5%36)8$

3C#3%&3643: 5 -k &64&:3643 "@ ;];EM %385)3:F 5:>3%=3 (7256M(358)( &2#54)F 5= (5>3T9 XZ1 U3'&"6= L 56: I< QP(3 6723%"7=F :3)5&83:F 4&)3: =34"6:5%$ ="7%43= "@ %385)3:

&6@"%25)&"6 &6 Z366=$8>56&5 =7##"%) )(&= "0=3%>5)&"6h =33 U%V'0 ?F 50">33 0336 6723%"7= 45=3= "@ 5:>3%=3 36>&%"6236)58 &2#54)F 5##5%36)8$ 25&68$ @%"2

=7%@543 54)&>&)&3=F &6 Z366=$8>56&5 m )(3 %385)&>3 (")03: "@ [5%43887= ;];EM)$#3 :%&88M

&6' m 5= 5 %3=78) "@ [5%43887=M%385)3: 56:W"% f"&8 56: '5= "#3%5)&"6=Fg )(3%3 (5= 0336

56 5##5%36) -k &64&:3643 "@ 5=="4&5)3: :"47236)3:F 5:>3%=3 (7256M(358)( &2#54)3%=3 (7256M(358)( &64&:36)= %385)3: )" ;];E &6 )(3 [5%43887=3%=3 (7256M(358)( &64&:36)= #3%

.-F--- B388=< a6 Z366=$8>56&5F .8.-"@ )(3 50">3M4&)3: &64&:36)= %"=3 )" )(3 83>38 "@ @3:M

3%588$ "% =)5)3M:"47236)3: 5:>3%=3 (7256M(358)( "7)4"23=F #3% #%&25%$ 56: =34"6:M

5%$ ="7%43= "6 )(3 25))3%F =7''3=)&6' )(5) )(3 67203% "@ =74( "7)4"23=F )" :5)3F &= 83==

)(56 )(3 25)(325)&4588$W=)5)&=)&4588$ #%3:&4)3: )")583 56: 5= 2&'() 03 3C#34)3: B(3%3

6") 76&D73 )" ($:%"@%54)7%&6'< 1 %3436) =#&88 "@ 5 4"6436)%5)3:F #")36)&588$ )"C&4 4(32&M

@@

$35%=F (5= #%54)&43: c447#5)&"658 56: X6>&%"6236)58 [3:&4&63 &6 5 %385)&>38$ 85%'3

(358)(45%3 436)3%F &6 56 3C)%3238$ 54)&>3 5%35 "@ [5%43887= ;];EM)$#3 :%&88&6' 56:#%":74)&"6F 56: B(" (5= #%"@3==&"6588$ =336 Q5=&:3 @%"2 (76:%3:= "@ B"%AM%385)3:

&6`7%&3= 56: )%5725 )" [5%43887= B"%A3%= )(32=38>3=R d-$8

%385)3: 5:>3%=3 (7256M(358)( &2#54) &6 8"458 %3=&:36)=W4&)&d36=3%=3

0%"5:M05=3: :36&58 "@ =74(< P(3 57)("%F &6 @54)F 364"7%5'3= "6'"&6' 56: 4"2#%3(36M

"6 %3=&:36)= &6 48"=3F &6)3%23:&5)3F 56: %385)&>38$ :&=)56) #%"C&2&)&3= )" ;];E 54)&>&M

)&3=W5%35= &6 )(3 [5%43887=< 974( 23:&458 =7%>3&885643 &= 5 4"22"6M=36=3 25))3% 56:

B"78: #%">&:3 )(3 f>&:3"g #3%=#34)&>3 &6 )(&= 25))3%F B(&4( 25$ #%">3 =7#3%&"% )" )(3

#%3=36) f=65#=(")g "63< 1 %385)3: :5)505=3 =("78: 03 3=)508&=(3:F )%54A&6' 588 =74(

9)56:5%:&d3:F #708&=(3:F )%5435083 =)56:5%:= 56: 23)(":"8"'&3= @"% =74( 457=58&)$W

457=5)&"6 :3)3%2&65)&"6= =("78: 03 3=)508&=(3: 56: 4"6=&=)36)8$ 5##8&3: &@ 56$ =36=3 &=

)" 03 25:3F "% 4"6487=&"6= :%5B6F @%"2 =74( 5 :5)505=3


33/41

!"#$%&'() +$%),&$(-. (- ,/0 1%$)0''&2 3/%'0

"!

> BBB3=M(&)M %34"%:W:65>W6'W (&=)W6H./-7=,5W#70W"&8r'5=W #3)%"=$=)32W7=r)5083GBBB5)3 4"2276&45)&"6F NW.,W.L

>ABBB,3%


34/41

!"#$%&'( *+,(&%- +( .&%#( '(/ 0#'-12

""

>DBBBW%783=W"207:=256W%3'785)"%$"207:=256EBBB"87)&"6W,W

?C[&883% PVh \"8&6 [iF :3 [545%&" X!F [545%&" 1i Q.HN,R< fa="85)&"6 "@ [3)(56"M

0%3>&054)3% =2&)(&& @%"2 (7256 @343=Fg 1##8< X6>&%"6< [&4%"0&"8< .HN,F /LQ.RG,,SmL,3%=&)$ "@ !58&@"%6&5F V"= 16'383=

U/9= ^9'%V[3:&5 U3=35%4( !36)3%

!0$V0$, W8 i9-#9-6 R/8J8

V"6:"6 !36)3% @"% Z"8&4$ U3=35%4(

3,0[/0- 19#a0'0&43 )" 1!9;G .HSNM,--HR

E5)(3% "@ )(3 fb%336 U3>"87)&"6g

?"038 V57%35)3

+$0#$(); L8 3,%$06 18J86 R/8J8

Q.H.-M,--,R

QK35%= "@ 93%>&43 )" 1!9;G .HSNM,--,R

E"76:3%F ;5%>5%: _3#5%)236) "@ ?7)%&)&"6

L92/ j'99=6 R/8J8_&%34)"% "@ !(32&458 56: Z(5%25437)&M

458 94&3643=

T&,/ H%X%6 R/8J86 T8J8936&"% E388"B &6 ?7)%&)&"6

_&%34)"% "@ !"2276&45)&"6=

:-% 1%$)0'9XC347)&>3 1==&=)56) )" )(3 Z%3=&:36)

Q/0$"' 1%$,(-1=="4&5)3 _&%34)"% 56: _&%34)"%

"@ _3>38"#236)

5(''(%= 1)Q%(-_3>38"#236) 1=="4&5)3

^('V0$, T9226 18J8

XC347)&>3 56: [3:&458 _&%34)"%

:$(0' 3%X$%-2;"1=="4&5)3 _&%34)"% "@ Z708&4 ;358)(

:-% 3(=9X2;%_&%34)"% "@ ]&:3" Z%":74)&"6=

T()/%$# 500;26 QR:

144"76)56)

P'(a%V0,/ 18 5/0'%-6 3)8J86 18R8!8Z%3=&:36)F 1!9;


36/41

JKLMN KO RUVSTPVOVU LTN [KWVU\ LNZVRKMRP$-02, i8 :V0'6 R/8J8

!3)&5F \]

J0--(2 U8 :X0$";7:="6 a6=)&)7)3

T9-%'# j%)/=%-6 18J8

j5&=3% Z3%25636)3 [3:&458 !36)3%

T9V0$, 38 j%$%,a6 J8J8386 R/8J86 18J8a6)3%65)&"658 [3:&458 !"6=78)5)&"6

93%>&43=

3,0[/0- j%$$0,,6 18J8Z&))=0"%"F ?!

U/9=%2 ^8 j%&=.%$,-0$6

R/%$=8J86 18P#8!"6=78)56) Z(5%254&=)= "@ 123%&45

58 i%3%=&)$ "@ b3"%'&5

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ !58&@"%6&5F J3%A383$

^09$.0 18 j&$#(,,6 L8J8

J388F J"$: t V8"$: VV!

P#3%=&)$

+$%-)(2 +8 j&2,%6 R/8J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ [&663=")5

P'3%=&)$ 9$=)32

T9V0$, ^8 Q%220-26 R/8J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ \&=4"6=&6F [5:&="6

P$)9'0 i8 Q%X%'(0$(6 J83)8

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ?30%5=A5 [3:&458 !36)3%

T&220'' K8 :8 Q0)('6 18J86 R/8J818056$ [3:&458 !"883'3

T(-9 Q0$(96 18J8

J5%)= 56: P(3 V"6:"6 ;"=#&)58 a6=)&)7)3

"@ Z5)("8"'$ QT6&)3: j&6':"2R

3%= H8 Q8 Q/%-.6 R/8J8

[&==&==#& 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

j$&)0 18 Q/%22"6 R/8J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ a88&6"&=F T%0565M!(52#5&'6

J%X(# :8 Q/$(2,9[/0$6 R/8J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ;5B5&& 5) [w6"5

P=(' 5(''(%= Q/"--6 18J8

+8 18 Q'"#02#%'06 R/8J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ [5==54(7=3))=

J9-%'# ^8 Q9)/$%-6 R/8J8]&%'&6&5 Z"8$)34(6&4 a6=)&)7)3 56: 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

!"%6388 T6&>3%=&)$

L9/- L8 Q9/$220-6 P2k81%8&6')"6F ]1

^0$%'# +8 Q9=V26 L$86 R/8J8T9_1 b%56: E"%A= ;7256

?7)%&)&"6 !36)3%

^$0.9$" Q9-;96 L8J8!"2#3)&)&>3 X6)3%#%&=3 a6=)&)7)3

1()/%0' J8 Q9$V0,,6 R/8J8

c25(5F ?X

19$,9- Q9$-6 R/8J8i"(6= ;"#A&6= T6&>3%=&)$

K%-)" Q9,&.-%6 J$8R/86 T8J86 Q8J8K8

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ _385B5%3

!8 T&220'' Q$9226 R/8J8P3C5= 1t[ T6&>3%=&)$

5(''(%= L8 Q$956&5

R0,0$ Q8 J0#9-6 18J86 R/8J8[5==54(7=3))= a6=)&)7)3 "@ P34(6"8"'$

U/9=%2 T8 J0^$0.9$(6 R/8J8

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ;"7=)"6

P'X($% ^8 #0 10c(%6 R/8J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ a88&6"&=F T%0565M!(52#5&'6

10$'0 i8 J(%=9-#6 18J8_&52"6: ;35:54(3 !8&6&4

30"=9&$ J(%=9-#6 18J8

_&52"6: ;35:54(3 !8&6&4

J9-%'# Q8 J();29-6 1838P8P8b&803%)F 1x

T%'[/ J(,,=%-6 18J86 18R8!8;"7=)"6F Pu


37/41

L9/- P8 J9#026 J8J838?5)&"658 !"764&8 1'5&6=) ;358)( E%57:

L9/- J9&''6 18J86 R/8J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ j56=5=

U/0$9- 58 J93%=&)$ "@ b3"%'&5

:#%= J$03%&88 Z5%AF ?K

L9/- J%'0 J&--6 18J86 L8J8

!5%8 U< _5%6588 ;"=#&)58F E"%) ;"":F Pu

!0$V0$, i8 J&R9-,6 18J89)< V7A3e= X#&=4"#58 ;"=#&)58

T9V0$, i8 J&R9-,6 18J8a6=)&)7)3 @"% J3(5>&"% 56: ;358)(F a64&883F ?i

5(''(%= !8 +90.06 18J86 18R8!8

935))83F \1

Q/$(2,9[/0$ !8 +9$0=%-6 L$86 R/8J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ [5%$856:

3/%3%=&)$ Q!565:5R

^'0-- 58 +$9-(-.6 R/8J8

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ?30%5=A5F V&64"86

7(-)0-, :8 +&'.(-(,(6 18J8P74="6F 1x

T9V0$, 38 %V'06 P#8J86 R/8J86 L8J8!85%32"6) b%5:75)3 T6&>3%=&)$

3/%"-0 Q8 ^%#6 R/8J86 J8:8j8U86 :8U838

b5: !"6=78)&6' 93%>&43=

5(''(%= 8 ^%(-026 L$86 18J86 18R8!894")) t \(&)3 !8&6&4

L8 j0$-%$# i8 ^006 18J8K583 T6&>3%=&)$ 94(""8 "@ [3:&4&63

H8 !8 ^(-a0'6 18J8

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ 1%A56=5= @"%

[3:&458 94&3643=

5(''(%= R%&' ^'0a0-6 18J8J5$8"% !"883'3 "@ [3:&4&63

L%" :8 ^9'#6 18J86 L8J86 18R8!8

[3:&458 !"883'3 "@ \&=4"6=&6

T9.0$ P8 ^9'#6 R/8J8

P3C5= 1t[ T6&>3%=&)$

T0-0n 18 ^99#$()/6 R/8J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ E8"%&:5

+$0#0$(); H8 ^99#3%=&)$

[3:&458 !36)3%

U(=9,/" K8 9$2;(6 18J86 +8:8Q8M8^8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ?"%)( P3C5=

T9-%'# P8 ^9,26 18J86 R/8J8a6)3%65)&"658 !36)3% @"% P"C&4"8"'$ 56:

[3:&4&63

!0-$" ^8 ^$%V93%=&)$

L%=02 W%- ^$%"6 R/8J8[&4(&'56 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

5(''(%= 58 ^$0%X026 18J86 1838R8!8[3:&458 !"883'3 "@ \&=4"6=&6

i%&$% Q8 ^$00-6 R/8J86 J8:8j8U8!520%&:'3 X6>&%"6236)58F a645643F ?!

R/('([ 38 ^&a0'(%-6 18J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ !"8"%5:"

J%X(# L8 !%-29-6 R/8J8

9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ?3B K"%AF Z")=:52

U0$$"' L8 !%$,=%-6 R/8J86 18R8!86 T8J8Z366=$8>56&5 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

Q'%$0 18 !%2'0$6 R/8J8

P(3 U"03%) ["6:5>& a6=)&)7)3 "@ \&6356: E"": 94&3643F T6&>3%=&)$ "@ !58&@"%M

6&5F _5>&=

7($.(' 58 !%"26 R/8J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ j36)74A$

Q'%$; 58 !0%,/6 L$86 18J8

123%&456 !5643% 9"4&3)$

J3%=&)$F !""A !"883'3

JKLMN KO RUVSTPVOVU LTN [KWVU\ LNZVRKMRGUKTPVTQSNI


38/41


L%=02 J8 !0$V0$,6 R/8J8_%3C38 T6&>3%=&)$

K583 T6&>3%=&)$ 94(""8 "@ [3:&4&63

T9V0$, 18 !9''(-.3%=&)$ "@ P"%"6)" Q!565:5R

T'[/ L8 L%0.0$6 R/8J8X6>&%"6236)58 [3:&4&63F a643%=&)$ "@ !58&@"%6&5F _5>&=

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ a88&6"&=F T%0565M!(52#5&'6

1803%) X&6=)3&6 !"883'3 "@ [3:&4&63

1()/%0' H%=$(-6 R/8J8[&4(&'56 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

L9/- j8 H%-00-06 R/8J86 18R8!86 J87818

[&4(&'56 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

R8 :-#$0< H%$%=6 R/8J86 Q!R[i\ !"%#"%5)&"6

1%$; :8 H%,)/0-6 18386 18j8:86 Q8W8!8

P(3 Z($825% b%"7#

H%,/$"- P8 H0''"6 J$8R8!8_38)5 P"C&4"8"'$

T9V0$, J8 H0$-26 R/8J8K583 T6&>3%=&)$ 94(""8 "@ [3:&4&63

^09$.0 T8 H0$$6 18J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ P3C5=F ;"7=)"6

^09$.0 :8 H0"3%=&)$ "@ Z&))=07%'(

T9-%'# P8 H'0(-=%-6 18J8[5==54(7=3))= b363%58 ;"=#&)58W;5%>5%:

[3:&458 94(""8

i02'(0 18 H'0X%"6 18J86 38J8 (- !".8

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ?"%)( _5A")5 94(""8 "@

[3:&4&63 56: ;358)( 94&3643=

T56&5 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ [&52& 94(""8 "@ [3:&4&63W

;30%3B T6&>3%=&)$ "@ i3%7=5832Q%$9'"- L8 i%);0"6 R/8J86 T8J8

?"%)( !5%"8&65 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

L8 Q'%"V&$- i%+9$)06 R/8J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ !58&@"%6&5F V"= 16'383=

T9V0$, ^8 i%/(,%6 18J86 R/8J8

["76) 9&65& 94(""8 "@ [3:&4&63

L%=02 Q8 i%=V6 W76 R/8J86 L8J8XC#"636)

i%3%=&)$ "@

[3C&4" Q[3C&4"R

U9= j8 i0%=9-6 R/8J8V&03%)$ [7)758 a6=7%5643 !"2#56$

L%" !8 i0/$6 R/8J8X6>&%"6236)58 X:745)&"6 X6)3%#%&=3=F a643%=&)$ "@ \&=4"6=&6F [5:&="6

L9/- i&[(0-6 183)8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ [5==54(7=3))=

!93%=&)$ V5B 94(""8

H%$' 1%$%=9$92)/6 R/8J8

U7)'3%= T6&>3%=&)$F !""A !"883'3

L(,/ :8 1%$'0,,6 R/8J86 T8J8

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ \&=4"6=&6F [5:&="6

i%3%=&)$

L%=02 T8 1%$2/%''6 R/8J8

U"=B388 Z5%A !5643% a6=)&)7)3

T9.0$ M8 1)Q'0''%-6 J878186 1818386J8:8j8U86 J8:8j878U86 +8:8U838

1807D73%D73F ?[

1%$" !8 1)^$%,/6 18J86 18R8!8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ !58&@"%6&5F 956 E%564&=4"

:'%- ^8 1)!&./0-6 J8R/('8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ !58&@"%6&5F U&>3%=&:3


39/41

L%=02 J8 1)H0%-6 J878186 L8J8a"B5 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

L920[/ R8 1)10-%=(-6 18J86 L8J8[4b7&%3\"":=F VVZ

R%,$(); L8 1()/%0'26 R/8J8

!5)" a6=)&)7)3

U/9=%2 !8 1('V"6 18J86 18R8!8J"&=3F a_

L920[/ 18 1(''0$6 18J86 18R8!8_7%(52F ?;

T()/%$# :8 1(''0$6 18J8Z%&64&5 J&"#(5%25F a643%=&)$ "@ U"4(3=)3%

5(''(%= L8 1(''0$6 R/8J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ b3"%'&5

:8 :'%- 19./(22(6 R/8J8

a6=)&)7)3 @"% U3'785)"%$ 94&3643

^$%)0 R8 19-%)96 L8J8[3:&458 !5%3 c207:=256 Z%"'%52

j$(%- P8 19-#0''6 18J8J58)&2"%3 ;35:54(3 a6=)&)7)3

L9/- 58 19$.%-6 J$8R8!8!58&@"%6&5 !5643% U3'&=)%$

3,0[/0- L8 19226 J8J8386 1838?3B K"%A T6&>3%=&)$ !"883'3 "@ _36)&=)%$

j$99;0 U8 1922=%-6 R/8J8

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ]3%2"6) !"883'3 "@

[3:&4&63

:''(29- :8 1&''0$6 R/%$=8J8

a6=)&)7)3 @"% !"6)&67&6'

;358)(45%3 X:745)&"6

!%$$(2 18 K%.'0$6 18J8

J3)( a=%538 [3:&458 !36)3%W1803%) X&6M

=)3&6 !"883'3 "@ [3:&4&63

J%-(0' L8 K)%"("%-%6 18J8

J36'7385 ;358)( Q9"7)( 1@%&45R

R/('([ P8 K0'29-6 R/8J8Z7%:73 T6&>3%=&)$

L9")0 :8 K0,,'0,9-6 J83)86 T8J8

_36>3%F !c

L9/- 38 K0&V0$.0$6 J$8R8!8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ j56=5= 94(""8 "@ [3:&4&63

U/9=%2 K()/9'29-6 R/8J86 18R8!8\3=)3%6 j36)74A$ T6&>3%=&)$

:'V0$, ^8 K();0'V$"6;35%) Q%3)3%=&)$

L9/- R%,$(); MY^$%#"6 18J8P7@)= T6&>3%=&)$ 94(""8 "@ [3:&4&63

c%3'"6 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

3,%-'0" U8 M=%"06 R/8J86 +8:8U8386+8:QK6 Q8K838

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ?3>5:5F U36"

1()/%0' U8 M2,0$/9'=6 R/8J86 18R8!8

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ [&663=")5

1()/%0' 58 R%$(a%6 R/8J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ \&=4"6=&6F [5:&="6

3,&%$, R%,,9-6 R/8J8

Z366=$8>56&5 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

L%=02 1%$) R0$$(-6 18J8[5== b363%58 ;"=#&)58 @"% !(&8:%36

L%" R/0'%-6 18J8\$83 a6)3'%5)3: 94&3643 56:

X6'&633%&6' b%"7#

U(=9,/" J&;02 R/(''([26 R/8J8P3C5= 1t[ T6&>3%=&)$

J%X(# T8 R(;06 R/8J8

!(52#5&'6F aV

3,0X0- R(-;0$6 R/8J8;5%>5%: T6&>3%=&)$

!0-$" Q8 R(,9,6 18J86 R/8J8

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ \&=4"6=&6F [5:&="6

U/9=%2 U8 R9'0=%-6 R/8J8

!"%6388 T6&>3%=&)$

^%$" R8 R92-0$6 18J8Z856) !&)$F EV

L9/- L8 R93%=&)$ "@ b3"%'&5

5(''(%= J8 R93%=&)$ "@ J%&)&=( !"8720&5 Q!565:5R

Q838 R$%;%2/6 R/8J8

P7=A3'33 T6&>3%=&)$

1%$X(- R8 R$(,,26 R/8J8

!"%6388 T6&>3%=&)$

J%-(0' L8 T%(,0-6 R/8J8?5)&"658 a6=)&)7)3= "@ ;358)(

J%X(# 58 T%=0"6 J87818U523$ XD7&63 b%"7#

T8U8 T%X0-/9',6 18J86 18R8!8

Z"#785)&"6 ;358)( a2#3%5)&>3=

T&220' L8 T0(,0$6 R/8J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ P3C5=F 956 16)"6&"

5(''(%= T0X(''06 R/8J8T6&>3%=&)$ !"883'3 !"%A Qa%3856:R

J9-%'# T8 T9V0$,26 R/8J8P(3 T6&@"%23: 93%>&43= T6&>3%=&)$ "@

)(3 ;358)( 94&3643=

L8 J8 T9V(-29-6 18J8

b3"%'3)"B6 T6&>3%=&)$ 94(""8 "@ [3:&4&63

j$%# T9#&6 J8J838T6&>3%=&)$ "@ V"7&=>&883

j('' J8 T90V&);6 R/8J86 J8:8j8U8

_5%)2"7)( [3:&458 94(""8

J%X(# j8 T9''6 R/8J8!"883$>&883F Pu

J%'0 T8 T9=2926 R/8J8[&4(&'56 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

L920[/ J8 T920-6 R/8J8

!""A !"883'3F U7)'3%= T6&>3%=&)$

3,0X0- U8 T920-6 18J8?"%)(B3=)3%6 T6&>3%=&)$ [3:&458 94(""8

3,%-'0" T9,/=%-6 R/8J892&)( !"883'3

P3C5= 1t[ T6&>3%=&)$

5%''%)0 W8 3%=[29-6 18J89)56@"%: T6&>3%=&)$ 94(""8 "@ [3:&4&63

1%$; fL%29-g 3%-#0$26 18J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ P3C5= [3:&458 94(""8

!%$9'# !8 3%-#2,0%#6 18J8

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ P3C5= [3:&458 J%564(

Q/%$'02 T8 3%-,0$$06 R/8J8Z7%:73 T6&>3%=&)$

i9


40/41

P3C5= 1t[ T6&>3%=&)$

1%$X(- L8 3)/(220'6 J8J838U"=8$6 ;3&'()=F ?K

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ [&4(&'56

L90' 18 3)/3%=&)$ "@ ?30%5=A5F V&64"86

1()/%0' j8 3/0$=0$6 R/8J89A3#)&4 [5'5d&63

3%$%/ 3/9$,6 R/8J86 P#8J86 T8J8

9$%547=3 T6&>3%=&)$

:8 L8 3(0#'0$6 R/8J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ a88&6"&=F T%0565M!(52#5&'6

1%$) H8 3(0.0'6 18J8?3B K"%A T6&>3%=&)$ 94(""8 "@ [3:&4&63

1()/%0' 3(0.0'6 18J86 18R8!8J"=)"6 T6&>3%=&)$ 94(""8 "@ Z70&4 ;358)(

i00 18 3('X0$6 R/8J8Z%&643)"6 T6&>3%=&)$

1()/%0' 38 3(=9-6 18J86 18R8!8

\5$63 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

38 +$0# 3(-.0$6 R/8J894&3643 t X6>&%"6236)58 Z"8&4$ Z%"`34)

Z(&85:38#(&5F Z1

:--0 18 3=(,/6 R/8J86 T8J86 i8J8

c(&" 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

^%$" Q8 3=(,/6 R/8J8!"8"%5:" 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

!"8"%5:" 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

i%2a'9 R 39=9."(6 R/8J8

9Ua a6)3%65)&"658 Q%3)3%=&)$ "@ P3C5=F ;"7=)"6

T9V0$, J8 3,00'06 R/8J8Z366=$8>56&5 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

L(,/ 38 3,0$-6 3)8J86 T8J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ !58&@"%6&5F _5>&=

3,0[/0- 38 3,0$-V0$.6 18J8[32"%&58 98"56Mj3))3%&6' !5643% !36)3%

T9-%'# J8 3,03%=&)$

L9- :8 3,9$"6 R/8J8

Z7%:73 T6&>3%=&)$

3(,% T8 U%,(-(6 R/8J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ [&663=")5

J(); U%X0$-0;"7=3 "@ V"%:=F T6&)3: j&6':"2

3,0X0 i8 U%"'9$6 R/8J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ?30%5=A5F V&64"86

i9$$%(-0 U/0'(%-j3)4(72F a643%=&)$

J(=(,$(92 U$()/9[9&'926 18J8

;5%>5%: 94(""8 "@ Z708&4 ;358)(

T9V0$, R8 S[)/&$)/6 R/8J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ 1%&d"65

1%$; L8 S,0''6 18J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ U"4(3=)3% [3:&458 !36)3%

3/%2/( j8 70$=%6 R/8J8

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ?30%5=A5F V&64"86

5(''%$# L8 7(20;6 18J86 R/8J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ a88&6"&= !"883'3 "@ [3:&4&63

i"-- 5%(2/3%=&)$ "@ [3:&4&63 56: _36)&=)%$ "@

?3B i3%=3$F 94(""8 "@ Z708&4 ;358)(

j$(%- 5%-2(-;6 R/8J8!"%6388 T6&>3%=&)$

1('02 50(-V0$.0$6 18J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ a"B5 ;"=#&)58= 56: !8&6&4=

L9/- 50(2V&$.0$6 R/8J8

?3B K"%A [3:&458 !"883'3

L%-0, 38 50(226 18J8

P(3 P"C_"43(=9- 50220'"6 18J86 +TQR

j&6'e= !"883'3 V"6:"6 56: a6=)&)7)3 "@

Z=$4(&5)%$ QT6&)3: j&6':"2R

3,0X0- J8 50d-0$6 18J8!83>3856: !8&6&4 E8"%&:5

L90' P''(9, 5/(,06 18J86 +8:8Q8T8

_56>&883F !1

L9/- 38 5/(,06 R/8J8\(&)3 P34(6&458 U3=35%4(

H0--0,/ i8 5/(,06 R/8J8

T)5( 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

T9V0$, L8 5/(,06 18J86 R/8J89(5A3% ;3&'()=F c;

Q%$9' 5/(,'9);6 R/8J86 T8J8U"4(3=)3% a6=)&)7)3 "@ P34(6"8"'$

Q/$(2,9[/0$ +8 5(';(-29-6 R/8J8

\&82&6')"6F ?!

1%$; i8 5(''0-V$(-.6 18J895&6) Z578< [?

Q%$' H8 5(-,0$6 R/8J8

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ !58&@"%6&5F _5>&=

L%=02 L8 59$=%-6 R/8J8

U"4(3=)3% a6=)&)7)3 "@ P34(6"8"'$

T&220'' 38 59$$%''6 M8J8T6&>3%=&)$ "@ !58&@"%6&5F J3%A383$

38 3,%-'0" I9&-.6 R/8J8

?5)&"658 a6=)&)7)3 "@ 9)5)&=)&458 94&3643

3,0X0- !8 m0(20'6 18J86 R/8J8P(3 T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ?"%)( !5%"8&65

1()/%0' j8 m0=0'6 R/8J8

?7)%&)&"6 a6=)&)7)3F T6&>3%=&)$ "@ P3663==33

P;/%$# P8 m(0.'0$6 18J8

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ a"B5


P(3 "#&6&"6= 3C#%3==3: &6 1!9; #708&45)&"6= :" 6") 6343==5%&8$ %3#%3=36) )(3 >&3B= "@ 588 23203%= "@

B&)("7) 4"2#36=5)&"6


41/41

56.0'( + 7*$+('& *+ 8('.+(. +1 9. &)-:;;< =0* 1/ >2 8$'). ?@?A./ B*0C2 A./ B*0C :@@?DE10 $&'( ,0 ()$0'+U )* 0.(*4.0 + )$0 & U 3 )0 ##.1 1..# /')-'+ )-.X 0(.&&$3 3- &. - 3 (0. ).1 Y$.3)'*+3 %*$) 0.& ).1 -$6 +E-. &)- +1.+4'0*+6.+) & '6# ()3H 533*(' ).1 0U$6.+)32 %*)- #0* +1 (*+2 - 4.*,).+ %..+ 3$%Z.()'4.2 .6*)'*+ &2 +1 $+3('.+)','(H G-'3 #$%&'( )'*+ %> )-.56.0'( + 7*$+('& *+ 8('.+(. +1 9. &)- '3 '6.1 ) 3>3).6 )'(2 *%Z.()'4.0.4'./ *, 1*($6.+).1 )>#.3 +1 0 ).3 *, ->10*,0 ()$0'+UE,&$'1E +1(-.6'( &E0.& ).1 '+('1.+)3 ,,.()'+U -$6 + -. &)-2 )* 1 ).2 '+ )-. 0.U'*+-.6'( &E0.& ).1 '+('1.+)3 ,,.()'+U -$6 + -. &)-2 )* 1 ).2 '+ )-. 0.U'*+*, )-. X 0(.&&$3 8- &. [& >H6./ 7/1'(), 8+$,('& +, 9('/,(/ ),3 :/)&*.'3 (*+3$6.0 .1$( )'*+(*+3*0)'$6 (*+(.0+.1 /')- '33$.3 0.& ).1 )* ,**12 +$)0')'*+2 (-.6'( &32#- 06 (.$)'( &32 &',.3)>&.2 )-. .+4'0*+6.+) +1 -. &)-H \) / 3 ,*$+1.1 '+ :;LF %>U0*$# *, 3('.+)'3)3 (*+(.0+.1 )- ) 6 +> '6#*0) +) #$%&'( #*&'('.3 0.& ).1 )*-. &)- +1 )-. .+4'0*+6.+) 1'1 +*) - 4. 3*$+1 3('.+)','( % 3'3H G-.3. 3('.+)'3)3(0. ).1 )-. *0U +'] )'*+ )* 11 0. 3*+ +1 % & +(. )* 1.% ).3 %*$) #$%&'(-. &)- '33$.3 +1 %0'+U (*66*+ 3.+3. 4'./3 )* )-. #$%&'(H

hydraulic fracturing in the marcellus shale: water and health, facts vs fiction

Documents

f 4654g123e6

marcellus shale

facts vs fiction

j5242018 hydraulic fracturing

a5242018 hydraulic fracturing

ms e5c q

lminop38 q

b6 35c887