idrc survey with prominent dispensationalists
TRANSCRIPT
QUESTIONS CHRISTOPHER CONE
Yes.
Which is the best terminology that describe your view of
Dispensationalism
Normative or Biblical Dispensationalism
Define in a few words what is a Dispensation
A dispensation is a particularly distinctive economy or
administration in and by which God demonstrates or expresses His own
glory. (Cone, Prolegomena on Biblical Hermeneutics and Method,
p. 305)
How many dispensations exist in your view?
4 in a kingdom emphasis, 7 in a soteriological emphasis, 12 in a
doxological emphasis (Cone, Prolegomena on Biblical
Hermeneutics and Method, p. 305-319)
In what sense the Church is presented as a mystery in the NT?
The church was first introduced in Mt 16, elaborated as a mystery in
Eph 2-3
Does Jesus offered the Eschatological Kingdom promised
in the Old Testament to Israel?
Yes
No
Does the rejection of the Jews caused a postponment the
Kingdom offered? If so, was a partial or a total postponnement?
Total postponement of God's eternal spiritual kingdom come to
earth in physical manifestation according to the Davidic Covenant
What is the Meaning of the Mysteries of the Kingdom in
Matthew 13?
Mt 13:11 is a simple statement that the previously unrevealed things of
the kingdom, were now being revealed to the disciples, but were not being revealed to those who
had rejected.
Is there a future for Israel in the Plan of God, according to the
promises of the Old Testament?
Does the fulfillment of physical promises to Israel is limited to the Millennium or it extend throughout
all eternity?
Begin to be fulfiled in the Millennium and continue into
eternity.
There will be animal sacrifices during the Millennium?
Yes. The sacrifices are more than memorial, and most likely have do
with national (rather than individual) atonement or cleanness.
Is Jesus presently reigning at the throne of David?
Is the New Covenant inaugurated in the present dispensation?
It is inaugurated in the sense that it is paid for or ratified, but it is not in
any way being fulfilled.
Are you pre-trib?
In your view, is there a unifying theme for the Bible narrative?
Yes, the glory of God through the making and keeping of His
promises.
What is the relationship between the OT and the NT?
The progress of revelation begins chronologically with Genesis and continues through Revelation. It was given chronologically, and
should be understood chronologically.
Yes, though the term "pre day of the Lord" is more exegetically
grounded (2 Thes 2), as the rapture occurs before the day of the Lord
begins (of which the tribulation is a part).
Are there signs that indicate the Rapture is near? If so, name the
three most important
The rapture is imminent, but the timing is not discernible beyond
speculation.
GLENN KREIDER JAMES E. ALLMAN MICHAEL VLACH
Dispensationalism I'm not sure.
Minimum of 5, prefer 7 8
Yes
Between Revised and Progressive. A New Creationist
Dispensationalist.
A dispensation is a distinguishable period of time
during which God mediates his sovereignty over his creation
A dispensation is a distinguishable economy in the outworking of God's Program.
A noticeable change in how God deals with His creation.
Four to seven, depending on the way you look at them.
church as Jews and Gentiles united together in one new man was unrevealed and unrealized
in OT
The church was not predicted in the OT.
Gentile participation in Israel's covenants was taught in the OT. But the full expressison of New Covenant unity between Jews
and Gentiles and what this means is revealed in the NT
Yes, but there was no postponement. He offered the kingdom which was present
Yes. This is clearly taught in Luke 19:41-44
No
I'm not sure.
Yes Yes Absolutely
Throughout eternity.
No No
Yes
The kingdom as offered was postponed.
Yes. The kingdom will come at the second coming but spiritual blessings of the Abrahamic and
New covenants are being fulfilled today
A stage of the kingdom in which the king is absent, sons of the kingdom and sons of the
evil coexist, and it ends with the day of the Lord and the
return of Christ
Matthew 13 describes kingdom truths concerning the era
between His two comings. It reveals how the kingdom relates
to the interadvent era.
The promises are eternal so they extend into eternity
Applies to both the millennium and Eternal state.
No, the Lamb of God is the fulfillment of sacrifices
Yes, there will be sacrifices in the Millennium, having civil, theocratic, and ceremonial
significance.
Yes. A temporary act of worship by Israel during the millennium
only. Looks back to the cross like OT sacrifices pointed forward to the cross. Not return to Mosaic
Covenant
depends what you mean by "throne of David." I say, no.
yes, the Spirit which is the locus of NC blessings is here
Yes. The spiritual blessings of the New covenant are in effect today
Yes. Kingdom of God
yes Yes. Yes
No
Yes, the Bible is the history of the work of redemption
Yes, the inbreaking of the Kingdom of God into the earth.
The NT reveals that all Scripture is interpreted in light
of the person and work of Christ in his first and second
comingyes
NT continues the story of the inbreaking of the Kingdom.
NT literally continues the storyline of the OT and adds new details at
times.
No, the rapture is imminent (at any time, without warning, at a time you don't expect it, no one knows except the Father, it will
come like a thief, etc)
Possible stage setting for the Tribulation Period. Israel as a national entity in the land is
significant
NATHAN JONES PAUL M. HENEBURY RICK GRIFFITH
Ryrie Dispensationalist Biblical Covenantalism Revised
7-8 Approx. 8 At least 6
Church unknown to OT people
Yes Yes Yes
In Dispensationalism, God reveals a little more about who He is with each dispensation and governs each period by a different set of rules to live by, ultimately returning man and
God to the 1-and-1 relationship we had with Him in the
beginning.
A descriptive epoch within the Bible story
A dispensation is a distinguishable economy in the outworking of God's Program.
The Church was unrealized in the OT
The Church was not prophesied in the OT but
Gentiles joining with Israel in the kingdom is emphasized
Yes Yes Yes
They continue
No No No
Yes Yes Yes
Yes, the Millennial Kingdom was postponed, but the
spiritual kingdom is already present.
Depends on what 'kingdom' means, but qua Israel it was
total.
Yes, some elements of the Promised Kingdom were postpoed, but others are
already present
The mystery means that the Kingdom prophesied as a
whole in OT would be progressively established.
Relates to the growth of good and evil till the eschaton
The Kingdom will be progressively established
during this "interadvent age" where wickedness will be
allowed to grow
Unknown, but they appear to be limited to the Millennium.
No, they begin to be fulfilled the Millennium and continue in
eternity.
Yes, memorial sacrifices of animal.
Yes, for Israel and the pious of the Nations
Yes, but these are limited to Jews in a theocratic sense akin to confession of sin now (cf. 1
John 1:9)
Yes, the Glory of God Creation
Yes Yes Yes
No
Yes, God is working toward man once again being his co-regent over the Kingdom of
God
The continuing unfolding of the restoration of the relationship
between God and man.
The continuation of the Creation Project
The NT fulfills the OT in many but not all respects as there still exists a future for Israel
Yes: 1) Israel's return in 1948; 2) Moral decay; 3) Converging
of signs
The rapture is imminent, but Israel's return in 1948 is the only "sign" that indicates that
Jesus may return in our generation
RON J. BIGALKE
traditional
at least 3
Yes
A dispensation is a recognizable biblical division within which God evaluates human stewardship, within a particular historic economy, and judges those actions.
The church was not revealed (unexpected and unknown) in
the Old Testament
Absolutely
No
Prophetic postponement (apotelesmatic interpretation)
The mystery kingdom denotes the time from the national rejection of Jesus until all
Israel is saved.
The covenantal promises are fulfilled during the thousand-year millennium, prior to the creation of the eternal state.
Atoning sacrifices are offered ceremonially during the
millennium
New Covenant was ratified by Christ's sacrificial blood
yes
no
both physical and spiritual blessings within a doxological
purpose of history
discontinuity between the Testaments, and
systematizing eschatology from the priority of the Old
Testament, as opposed to the New Testament changing
original meaning